Noroviruses are the most common cause of acute gastroenteritis across all ages worldwide. These pathogens are generally understood to exhibit a wintertime seasonality, though a systematic assessment of seasonal patterns has not been conducted in the era of modern diagnostics.
We conducted a systematic review of the Pubmed Medline database for articles published between 1997 and 2011 to identify and extract data from articles reporting on monthly counts of norovirus. We conducted a descriptive analysis to document seasonal patterns of norovirus disease, and we also constructed multivariate linear models to identify factors associated with the strength of norovirus seasonality.
The searched identified 293 unique articles, yielding 38 case and 29 outbreak data series. Within these data series, 52.7% of cases and 41.2% of outbreaks occurred in winter months, and 78.9% of cases and 71.0% of outbreaks occurred in cool months. Both case and outbreak studies showed an earlier peak in season-year 2002-03, but not in season-year 2006-07, years when new genogroup II type 4 variants emerged. For outbreaks, norovirus season strength was positively associated with average rainfall in the wettest month, and inversely associated with crude birth rate in both bivariate and multivariate analyses. For cases, none of the covariates examined was associated with season strength. When case and outbreaks were combined, average rainfall in the wettest month was positively associated with season strength.
Citation: Ahmed SM, Lopman BA, Levy K (2013) A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of the Global Seasonality of Norovirus. PLoS ONE 8(10): e75922. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0075922
Editor: Alessandro Vespignani, Northeastern University, United States of America
Received: April 17, 2013; Accepted: August 21, 2013; Published: October 2, 2013
This is an open-access article, free of all copyright, and may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose. The work is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication.
Funding: Support was received from the Fogarty International Center (http://www.fic.nih.gov/) at the National Institutes of Health [FIC R21TW009032]. This work was also supported in part by an appointment to the Research Participation Program at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention administered by the Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education through an interagency agreement between the U.S. Department of Energy and CDC. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: Ben A. Lopman has previously served as a PLOS Academic Editor. This does not alter the authors' adherence to all the PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Noroviruses are the most common cause of sporadic cases and outbreaks of gastroenteritis across all age groups worldwide –. In the United States, norovirus is estimated to cause 21 million illnesses , 71,000 hospitalizations , and 800 deaths annually , . In developed countries, outbreaks frequently occur in healthcare, long-term care, daycare, and school settings , and are associated with deaths among the elderly .
The winter seasonality of norovirus has long been recognized, and norovirus has been referred to as ‘winter vomiting disease’. Understanding the relationship between climate and infectious diseases can help evaluate the impact of environmental drivers of infection risk and anticipate how global climate change will affect the distribution and spread of infectious diseases. For norovirus, climate change has the potential to impact seasonality by influencing transmissibility, host susceptibility, and the resistance of norovirus to environmental conditions .
Some studies have found associations between norovirus seasonality and climatic/weather phenomena. Rainfall has been highlighted as an important factor for norovirus seasonality, probably due to waterborne transmission of the virus . Likewise, cool temperatures, low population immunity, and the emergence of new variants are associated with increased norovirus activity . Of these predictors, changes in temperature had the greatest attributable risk for norovirus incidence in a long-term study of England and Wales . Seasonal patterns of rotavirus, another gastrointestinal virus that peaks during winter months, have also been associated with weather factors such as temperature, relative humidity, and rainfall –.
Factors related to human behavior, demographics, and host immunity have been put forth to explain increased incidence of norovirus in colder months. In particular, crowding and more time spent indoors are possible factors in increasing human-to-human transmission of respiratory viruses during winter . For rotavirus, birth rates and local exposure rates (force of infection) have been suggested as key factors driving seasonal patterns of disease .
The periodic emergence of new strains of norovirus may also interact with host immunity in the population to mediate seasonal patterns of disease. Noroviruses are RNA viruses of the family Caliciviridae , and are classified into one of five genogroups (GI-GV), with human infections principally caused by GI and GII . Genogroup II genotype 4 (GGII.4) viruses predominate and rapidly evolve in response to human population immunity, with new GII.4 variants emerging every two to four years. The emergence of a novel GII.4 virus in 2002/03 was associated with unusual spring/summer seasonality, as well as overall wintertime increase of disease, presumably due to an initial lack of effective population immunity to the emergent variant .
The most recent review of global seasonality of norovirus was published over a decade ago , before PCR diagnostics were widely available. To update our understanding of the global seasonality of norovirus in the age of modern diagnostics, we conducted a systematic review of the literature and carried out an ecological analysis to identify factors associated with the strength of norovirus seasonality.
Search Strategy and Selection Criteria
We carried out a systematic review of the PubMed Medline database through Endnote X4 software (Carlsbad, CA) in August, 2011 using the search terms “norovirus” and each of the following terms: “ambient temperature,” “climate,” “rain,” “relative humidity,” “season,” and “weather”. Titles and abstracts were screened for relevance by two independent reviewers and original articles were obtained and screened for inclusion according to the following criteria: (i) conducted continuously for one year or more; (ii) monthly data reported on human norovirus counts (cases or outbreaks); and (iii) conducted after 1997 (when modern PCR-based diagnostics for norovirus began widespread use). Non-human and laboratory studies were excluded, as were studies presenting monthly percentages without reporting total numbers of cases or outbreaks. No exclusions were made for language of publication.
Reported monthly norovirus burden measures were extracted using Plot Digitizer (SourceForge.net). If published figures/tables were not available in high enough resolution for digital extraction, we contacted the authors to request their original dataset. If authors did not respond, or if the researchers were unable to provide data in the monthly format, the article was excluded (n = 8). Two datasets (Johansen et al. , Hulth et al. ) were expanded when authors replied with more inclusive data. If data were reported for several years but aggregated by month, the dataset was included without a specific season-year, and only used in the analysis not requiring monthly data.
We classified studies by outcome according to whether they reported counts of monthly cases or outbreaks. Case datasets included records of norovirus-positive laboratory samples or individual cases reported through studies of regional/national reporting systems. Outbreak definitions varied among papers, but outbreak data included reports of cases clustered in time and place.
Several data processing steps were carried out to ensure comparability of data. For articles presenting data stratified by genotype/genogroup, counts of cases or outbreaks across all the subgroups were summed for each month. If the study reported results as percentages but included monthly totals, results were converted to monthly counts. Weekly counts were summed over months, and only single instances of redundant datasets (i.e., multiple publications using the same data) were used. If an article reported norovirus burden separately for more than one country, multiple datasets were created, one for each national population.
Descriptive Analysis: Timing of Seasonal Patterns
We generated three metrics for analysis: (1) Average Seasonality: normalized proportion of cases/outbreaks by month summed over all years; (2) Long-term Seasonal Patterns: normalized proportion of cases/outbreaks by calendar month of study period; and (3) Season Strength: peak to mean ratio of normalized proportion of cases/outbreaks by month. The derivation of these metrics can be found in the Supplemental Material.
Regression Analysis: Predictors of Seasonal Patterns
For each study location we assembled information on latitude, average winter temperature (°C) (with winter defined as December/January/February and June/July/August for Northern and Southern hemispheres, respectively), peak-to-trough ratio of monthly average temperature (per season year), and average monthly precipitation in the wettest month (cm) using publicly available information for the city in which the study occurred (42% of case and 21% of outbreak datasets) , . If three or fewer cities were included in a single study, values were averaged for those cities (one case dataset). If the study included data from greater than three cities or for a region or country as a whole, data for the largest city (by population) was used (53% of case and 69% of outbreak datasets). Weather data were excluded for studies that covered large, nonhomogeneous locations (two cruise ship outbreak studies, one case dataset from China, one case dataset from Brazil, and one outbreak dataset from the USA).
Country-level data included gross-domestic product (GDP in 2011 international dollars) , crude birth rate (births/1000 population) , and population density (population per square km) . The crude birth rate value was only available in five-year intervals, and was applied accordingly. Population density was the yearly estimate for the first calendar year of a season year (e.g., 1998 estimate used for season year 1998-99).
We also included a binary variable to indicate season-years when new pandemic strains emerged. A new strain year was defined as a season-year with an antigenic shift and reports of heightened activity, which occurred in the 2002–2003 and 2006–2007 seasons , .
We modeled norovirus season strength as a function of the climatic and socio-demographic variables described above. Norovirus season strength was log-transformed in order to normalize its distribution. Separate linear regression models were fitted for cases, outbreaks, and the combined dataset of cases and outbreaks. Bivariate linear analyses were initially performed, with each variable individually predicting the outcome. Multivariate linear models were constructed using forward selection; variables with p-values <0·2 in the bivariate analyses were added, with the next most significant variables being added one at a time. Once in the model, variables were not dropped. For the case dataset, no variable had a p-value <0·2 in the bivariate models, so we started the multivariate modeling with the most significant variable from the outbreak dataset. We did not include latitude, average winter temperature, and peak to trough temperature ratio in the same model because of collinearity of these three variables.
Our original search yielded 458 articles, 171 of which were duplicates, and 149 of which were deemed irrelevant based on review of their title/abstract. Of the remaining 138 articles, 29 did not report data, six did not span an entire year, 11 did not report monthly outcomes, and two could not be located. Fourteen others were excluded for miscellaneous reasons (outcome measures that could not be compared to other studies). Six relevant articles not identified in the search but known to the authors were also included in the review, two datasets were added/removed based on clarifying correspondence with authors, and multiple articles using the same dataset were condensed into a single dataset. We included papers published in all languages including English, Mandarin Chinese, Portuguese, and Polish by translating relevant sections (captions and data presented in tables and/or graphs). The final dataset included 38 case and 29 outbreak series (Figure 1, Table S1).
Note that final numbers refer to total number of data series included in analyses, whereas other numbers refer to numbers of articles reviewed.
Norovirus cases and outbreaks exhibited a clear seasonality across most of the locations in this study (Figure 2), with a peak in winter months and a trough in summer months. Among the 68 studies analyzed, 52·7% of cases and 41·2% of outbreaks occurred in winter months (December-February in the Northern Hemisphere, June-August in the Southern Hemisphere), and 78·9% of cases and 71·0% of outbreaks occurred in cool months (October-March in the Northern Hemisphere, April-September in the Southern Hemisphere). The average season strength (peak to mean ratio of cases/outbreaks by month) was 3·0 in Europe and 3·6 in Asia; there was not enough data to summarize season strength by region for the Americas, Africa or Australia.
Presented by month summed over all years for each study, by location. Within continents, studies are displayed from top to bottom in order of latitude, North to South.
In the 12 season-year span of northern hemisphere data for cases, seven seasons peaked in December-February (winter), and five peaked in March. For outbreaks, eight seasons peaked in December-February and three peaked in March (Figure 3). There were no studies that reported outbreak data for the 2008–2009 season. Outbreak reports had a somewhat weaker seasonality than case reports (average peak to mean ratio of 2·06 versus 2·35, respectively).
New strain years highlighted (Blue = 2002-03; Green = 2006-07). Dotted line indicates studies where monthly datasets were reported as averages over several years.
In terms of new strain years, both case and outbreak studies showed an earlier seasonality in 2002-03, but not in season-year 2006-07 (Figure 3).
Determinants of season strength
For outbreaks, norovirus season strength was positively associated with average rainfall in the wettest month, and inversely associated with crude birth rate in both bivariate (rainfall: R2 = 0·0564, p = 0·0096; crude birth rate: R2 = 0·0941, p = 0·0011) and multivariate analyses (R2 = 0·1848, rainfall: p = 0·0005, crude birth rate: p<0·0001) (Table 1). None of the covariates examined was associated with season strength from cases studies in either bivariate or multivariate analyses.
In the combined case and outbreak analysis, no covariates were individually associated with season strength, but in the multivariate model, average rainfall in the wettest month was positively associated (R2 = 0·0321, rainfall: p = 0·0065, avg winter temp: p = 0·0177).
This systematic review and meta-analysis of the seasonality of norovirus highlights a pattern of distinct but variable global seasonality, with a peak in winter months (December-February in the Northern Hemisphere, June-August in the Southern Hemisphere) in most settings. Approximately half of all the cases and outbreaks occurred in winter months while approximately three-quarters occurred in cool months (October-March in the Northern Hemisphere, April-September in the Southern Hemisphere).
Our findings are broadly consistent with the notion that norovirus incidence peaks in the winter, at least in temperate climates. In Europe, where there were more data over a range of years and climates, the relative strength of the norovirus peak was clearly observed during winter months (Figure 2). We did not detect strong, consistent associations between socio-demographic or weather variables with the strength of the norovirus season.
This review substantially expands a previous study on the global seasonality of norovirus by Mounts et al. , published over a decade ago. In the intervening years, a relative abundance of surveillance data have become available, largely due to the expanded availability of sensitive diagnostic assays and their widespread use by public health agencies. Mounts et al. reviewed 14 studies, evenly split between case-based and outbreak-based studies. Our study started where the previous review left off, in 1997, and included over four times as many data series. In addition to the large number of studies from Europe, our review included a considerable number of studies from Asia, representing the range of wealth in the region. However, there remains little published data from Africa or South America, or for tropical regions in general. The data that are available from these locations are from highly diverse settings and generally of short duration, limiting our ability to differentiate between the effects of meteorological and demographic characteristics on norovirus seasonality in these areas (see Figure S1).
Based on two papers from Victoria, Australia, it has been posited that norovirus incidence in the southern hemisphere contrasts with the northern hemisphere by peaking in warmer months . In our review, neither these data from Australia nor other southern hemisphere settings (Brazil, Malawi, Madagascar) exhibited a consistent summer or winter peak once normalized across years (Figure 2). It is unclear if this lack of observed seasonality in southern hemisphere settings is a result of different epidemiological patterns, or a lack of robust data.
The majority of studies included in our review were from regional or national surveillance systems, capturing outbreaks from schools, nursing homes, hospitals, and the general community, among other settings. Other studies that depart from the general pattern of wintertime seasonality are those reporting outbreaks on cruise ships. These show an inverted seasonal pattern, which likely reflects the seasonality of cruise voyages in their respective geographic areas (Caribbean, Mediterranean).
Somewhat unexpectedly, outbreak studies exhibited weaker seasonality than case studies. Outbreaks may exhibit different seasonal patterns than cases since population sizes in settings at risk of outbreaks may vary throughout the course of the year (e.g. elevated in summer for cruise ships and in winter for healthcare facilities). In addition, case datasets include active surveillance for sporadic cases (e.g., collecting and testing stool from diarrhea patients in emergency departments) as well as passive laboratory surveillance (all stools sent for testing). The stools sent to laboratories for testing might originate from outbreak investigations. If so, multiple norovirus positive stools reported in these situations could inflate the observed seasonality in studies that we classified as case data series. Regardless, the proportion of illnesses that get recorded may differ between case surveillance and outbreak surveillance, which could lead to differences in estimates of observed seasonal strengths.
The emergence of a new GII.4 variant in 2002 precipitated a break with typical seasonality, presumably due to faster transmission resulting from this virus's escape from population immunity . However, this pattern was not observed in 2006/07, where, if anything, a later-than-usual peak was observed, possibly implying that the new strain emerged later in the season. Thus, we speculate that escaping population immunity may result in a departure from typical seasonality, but the occurrence of this phenomenon might depend on when in the norovirus season the new strain first appears.
It is important to note that we do not propose our predictor variables, including latitude, average winter temperature, and peak-to-trough temperature ratio, as part of the causal mechanism of norovirus gastroenteritis. Rather, we attempted to use them as possible indicators of temperature-mediated transmission. On a broad ecological scale, our results point to a possible association between season strength and both rain in the wettest month and crude birth rate. These results are in agreement with some local studies, including that of Marshall and Bruggink , which suggested that rainfall may be a more important predictor of norovirus seasonality than temperature in Australia. Interestingly, lower birth rates have also been associated with stronger seasonality of rotavirus, at least in some settings , , . Birth rates, which were inversely associated with norovirus in some of our models, are thought to influence seasonality via replenishment of susceptible individuals in the population. However, in general, caution should be taken in interpreting our results: most of the variability observed in the data was not explained by variables included in our models.
It is also important to note that our study did not directly assess factors that may lead to higher numbers of norovirus cases. Instead, we examined meteorological characteristics of a location and demographic characteristics of that location's population that could potentially influence transmission rates and in turn, the degree of the seasonal variation in human illness. Weather and demographic characteristics may or may not have a directly causal relationship with norovirus transmissibility, but even if they do, it can be exceedingly difficult to detect such an association since epidemiological data represent case/outbreak events, not transmission events per se . Moreover, we used monthly averages of meteorological characteristics as potential predictors of seasonality, instead of records of the actual meteorological conditions matched in time, which is an oversimplification of the actual climatic conditions at the time of the case/outbreak. Country-level demographic descriptors may also be too broad to capture the influence of these factors at the local level. Ideally, both epidemiological (outcome) and weather/demographic (exposure) would be specific to areas that are large enough to capture general disease patterns but small enough to have homogenous meteorological and populations characteristics, and would also be matched in time.
In order to better understand the global seasonality of norovirus disease and the factors influencing that seasonality, there is a need for additional studies in developing and southern hemisphere countries. There was limited variability in the data from our review, since the majority of data were from Europe and North America - temperate regions with similar levels of income and health/sanitation infrastructure. Regardless, this review makes it clear that norovirus is a wintertime phenomenon, at least in the temperate northern hemisphere. Understanding the seasonality of norovirus offers insight into the factors that promote its transmission.
Scatterplots of a) latitude, b) average winter temperature, c) summer to winter temperature ratio, d) peak monthly rainfall, e) crude birth rate, f) population density, and g) GDP against norovirus season strength with regression line.
The authors wish to acknowledge Samantha B. Dolan for her service as a second reviewer for the article screening process.
Conceived and designed the experiments: KL. Performed the experiments: SMA. Analyzed the data: SMA BAL KL. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: SMA BAL KL. Wrote the paper: SMA BAL KL.
- 1. de Wit MA, Koopmans MP, Kortbeek LM, Wannet WJ, Vinje J, et al. (2001) Sensor, a population-based cohort study on gastroenteritis in the Netherlands: incidence and etiology. Am J Epidemiol 154: 666–674.
- 2. Scallan E, Hoekstra RM, Angulo FJ, Tauxe RV, Widdowson MA, et al. (2011) Foodborne illness acquired in the United States—major pathogens. Emerg Infect Dis 17: 7–15.
- 3. Patel MM, Widdowson MA, Glass RI, Akazawa K, Vinje J, et al. (2008) Systematic literature review of role of noroviruses in sporadic gastroenteritis. Emerg Infect Dis 14: 1224–1231.
- 4. Lopman BA, Hall AJ, Curns AT, Parashar UD (2011) Increasing rates of gastroenteritis hospital discharges in US adults and the contribution of norovirus, 1996–2007. Clin Infect Dis 52: 466–474.
- 5. Hall AJ, Curns AT, McDonald LC, Parashar UD, Lopman BA (2012) The roles of Clostridium difficile and norovirus among gastroenteritis-associated deaths in the United States, 1999–2007. Clin Infect Dis 55: 216–223.
- 6. Lopman BA, Adak GK, Reacher MH, Brown DW (2003) Two epidemiologic patterns of norovirus outbreaks: surveillance in England and wales, 1992–2000. Emerg Infect Dis 9: 71–77.
- 7. Harris JP, Edmunds WJ, Pebody R, Brown DW, Lopman BA (2008) Deaths from norovirus among the elderly, England and Wales. Emerg Infect Dis 14: 1546–1552.
- 8. Patel MM, Hall AJ, Vinje J, Parashar UD (2009) Noroviruses: a comprehensive review. J Clin Virol 44: 1–8.
- 9. Rohayem J (2009) Norovirus seasonality and the potential impact of climate change. Clin Microbiol Infect 15: 524–527.
- 10. Marshall JA, Bruggink LD (2011) The dynamics of norovirus outbreak epidemics: recent insights. Int J Environ Res Public Health 8: 1141–1149.
- 11. Lopman B, Armstrong B, Atchison C, Gray JJ (2009) Host, weather and virological factors drive norovirus epidemiology: time-series analysis of laboratory surveillance data in England and Wales. PLoS One 4: e6671.
- 12. Purohit SG, Kelkar SD, Simha V (1998) Time series analysis of patients with rotavirus diarrhoea in Pune, India. Journal of Diarrhoeal Diseases Research 16: 74–83.
- 13. Jagai JS, Sarkar R, Castronovo D, Kattula D, McEntee J, et al. (2012) Seasonality of rotavirus in South Asia: a meta-analysis approach assessing associations with temperature, precipitation, and vegetation index. PLoS One 7: e38168.
- 14. Atchison CJ, Tam CC, Hajat S, van Pelt W, Cowden JM, et al. (2010) Temperature-dependent transmission of rotavirus in Great Britain and The Netherlands. Proc Biol Sci 277: 933–942.
- 15. D'Souza RM, Hall G, Becker NG (2008) Climatic factors associated with hospitalizations for rotavirus diarrhoea in children under 5 years of age. Epidemiol Infect 136: 56–64.
- 16. Hashizume M, Armstrong B, Wagatsuma Y, Faruque AS, Hayashi T, et al. (2008) Rotavirus infections and climate variability in Dhaka, Bangladesh: a time-series analysis. Epidemiol Infect 136: 1281–1289.
- 17. Levy K, Hubbard AE, Eisenberg JN (2009) Seasonality of rotavirus disease in the tropics: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Epidemiol 38: 1487–1496.
- 18. Cardoso MR, Cousens SN, de Goes Siqueira LF, Alves FM, D'Angelo LA (2004) Crowding: risk factor or protective factor for lower respiratory disease in young children? BMC Public Health 4: 19.
- 19. Pitzer VE, Viboud C, Lopman BA, Patel MM, Parashar UD, et al. (2011) Influence of birth rates and transmission rates on the global seasonality of rotavirus incidence. J R Soc Interface 8: 1584–1593.
- 20. Caul EO (1996) Viral gastroenteritis: small round structured viruses, caliciviruses and astroviruses. Part I. The clinical and diagnostic perspective. J Clin Pathol 49: 874–880.
- 21. Zheng DP, Ando T, Fankhauser RL, Beard RS, Glass RI, et al. (2006) Norovirus classification and proposed strain nomenclature. Virology 346: 312–323.
- 22. Lopman B, Vennema H, Kohli E, Pothier P, Sanchez A, et al. (2004) Increase in viral gastroenteritis outbreaks in Europe and epidemic spread of new norovirus variant. Lancet 363: 682–688.
- 23. Mounts AW, Ando T, Koopmans M, Bresee JS, Noel J, et al. (2000) Cold weather seasonality of gastroenteritis associated with Norwalk-like viruses. J Infect Dis 181 Suppl 2S284–287.
- 24. Johansen K, Mannerqvist K, Allard A, Andersson Y, Burman LG, et al. (2008) Norovirus strains belonging to the GII.4 genotype dominate as a cause of nosocomial outbreaks of viral gastroenteritis in Sweden 1997—2005. Arrival of new variants is associated with large nation-wide epidemics. J Clin Virol 42: 129–134.
- 25. Hulth A, Andersson Y, Hedlund KO, Andersson M (2010) Eye-opening approach to norovirus surveillance. Emerg Infect Dis 16: 1319–1321.
- 26. weatherbase weatherbase.
- 27. Services WMOWWI: World Weather Information Service World Meteorological Organization.
- 28. Fund IM.World Economic and Financial Surveys: World Economic Outlook Database: International Monetary Fund.
- 29. United Nations DoEaSAPD, Population Estimates and Projections Section World Population Prospects, the 2010 Revision. United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division, Population Estimates and Projections Section.
- 30. Siebenga JJ, Vennema H, Zheng DP, Vinje J, Lee BE, et al. (2009) Norovirus illness is a global problem: emergence and spread of norovirus GII.4 variants, 2001–2007. J Infect Dis 200: 802–812.
- 31. Pitzer VE, Viboud C, Simonsen L, Steiner C, Panozzo CA, et al. (2009) Demographic variability, vaccination, and the spatiotemporal dynamics of rotavirus epidemics. Science 325: 290–294.
- 32. Dushoff J, Plotkin JB, Levin SA, Earn DJ (2004) Dynamical resonance can account for seasonality of influenza epidemics. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 101: 16915–16916.