C. difficile infection (CDI) is rarely reported in cystic fibrosis (CF) patients despite frequent hospitalisations and antibiotic usage. Conversely, the prevalence of CDI in inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) has received increased attention. We investigated components of the IgG-specific humoral immune response to C. difficile toxins A and B in patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea (CDAD), IBD patients with CDI, CF patients and healthy controls. Serum anti-toxin IgG was determined by ELISA. Circulating antigen-activated B-cells were investigated using Alexa Fluor 488-labelled toxin A and assessed by flow cytometry. Following induction of differentiation of memory B-cells, toxin A- and B-specific antibody secreting cells (ASCs) were quantified using ELISpot. We present the first data showing levels of serum anti-toxin A and B antibodies were significantly higher in patients with CF (without a history of CDI) than in CDAD patients and were stably maintained over time. Notably, the CDAD patients were significantly older than the CF patients. We also show that circulating toxin A-specific memory B-cells (IgD-negative) can be detected in CDAD patients [0.92 (0.09–1.78)%], and were prominent (5.64%, 1.14%) in two CF patients who were asymptomatic carriers of C. difficile. There was correlation between toxin A- and B-specific ASCs, with significantly higher proportions of the latter seen. In some with CDAD, high serum antibody levels were seen to only one of the two toxins. Mucosal secretion of toxin-specific IgG was detected in an additional group of IBD patients with no history of CDI. We conclude that enhanced and stable humoral immune responses to toxins A and B may protect CF and some IBD patients against CDI. The impaired ability to generate strong and/or sustained toxin-specific antibody and memory B-cell responses may increase susceptibility of older patients to CDI and highlight the need to investigate the role of immune senescence in future studies.
Citation: Monaghan TM, Robins A, Knox A, Sewell HF, Mahida YR (2013) Circulating Antibody and Memory B-Cell Responses to C. difficile Toxins A and B in Patients with C. difficile-Associated Diarrhoea, Inflammatory Bowel Disease and Cystic Fibrosis. PLoS ONE 8(9): e74452. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0074452
Editors: Cordula M. Stover (University of Leicester, United Kingdom), and Arun Rishi (Wayne State University, United States of America)
Received: May 10, 2013; Accepted: August 1, 2013; Published: September 10, 2013
Copyright: © 2013 Monaghan et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This research was funded by the Wellcome Trust (Ref 086735/Z/08/Z), via a Research Training Fellowship to Dr Monaghan. Some of the technical assistance and Research Nurse support was funded by the National Institute for Health Research Biomedical Research Units in Gastrointestinal Disease and Respiratory Disease. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
C. difficile infection is a significant clinical problem in patients exposed to the hospital environment. Clinical presentation in those colonised with toxigenic C. difficile can include asymptomatic carriage, mild self-limiting diarrhoea and severe life-threatening pseudomembranous colitis. Exposure to antibiotics is the commonest risk factor, facilitating colonization by C. difficile, via disruption of the protective resident microflora [1,2,3].
Host factors that may determine the development and nature of clinical disease are not fully understood but include age, the use of proton-pump inhibitors or H2 blockers, tube feeding and the host immune response [1,3,4,5,6]. Secreted toxins A and B mediate the intestinal disease [1,7] and serum IgG antibodies against toxin A appear to dominate protective responses in humans; more recently, antitoxin B responses have been correlated with colonization  and prevention of recurrent disease . There are also recent reports of an increase in susceptibility to C. difficile infection in patients with inflammatory bowel disease . By contrast, C. difficile-associated disease is uncommon in patients with cystic fibrosis, despite frequent admissions to hospital for antibiotics for acute pulmonary exacerbations. Asymptomatic carriage of C. difficile has been reported in 22-32% of such patients [10,11], but the mechanism of protection against the development of colonic disease remains to be determined.
The aim of our studies was to investigate, directly for the first time, B lymphocyte anti-toxin A and anti-toxin B antibody production as well as IgG-specific humoral immune responses in patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea, C. difficile infection in patients with inflammatory bowel disease and patients with cystic fibrosis.
Materials & Methods
Blood samples were obtained from adult healthy donors (19) and patients attending two major hospitals in Nottingham, UK between June 2009 and April 2012 (34 months). They included: (i) 53 patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea, (ii) 10 inflammatory bowel disease (7 ulcerative colitis, 3 Crohn’s disease) patients with C. difficile infection and (iii) 18 patients with cystic fibrosis. The diagnosis of cystic fibrosis had previously been made on the basis of a positive sweat test and/or demonstration of 2 known cystic fibrosis mutations and typical clinical features of the disease. Intestinal mucosal samples from an additional 15 patients with inflammatory bowel disease (without a history of C. difficile infection) were also studied.
Written informed consent, specific for each sample type (blood, stool, mucosal tissue), was obtained before collection. These studies were approved by the Nottingham Research Ethics Committee, which also approved the consent procedure for each sample type.
All the patients with C. difficile infection had diarrhoea (defined as a change in bowel habit with 3 or more unformed stools per day for at least 48 hours) and positive stool C. difficile toxin test. Asymptomatic carriers were defined as those without diarrhoea, but had a positive stool culture for C. difficile.
Serum was separated from venous blood samples and aliquots stored at -800C, until use in ELISA assays. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were isolated by centrifugation of EDTA-treated venous blood samples over a Ficoll-Hypaque (Sigma) density gradient. These cells were subsequently used to study memory B cells and toxin A-activated B cells. Frozen stool samples were treated and cultured for C. difficile, as previously described . Mucosal samples were obtained from surgically-resected intestinal tissue of patients with inflammatory bowel disease. Following removal of epithelial cells, mucosal samples were cultured, as previously described . The presence of toxin-specific IgG antibodies in supernatant samples was subsequently investigated by ELISA.
Memory B cell stimulation assay
For induction of differentiation of memory B cells to antibody secreting cells, the peripheral blood mononuclear cells were cultured (0.5 x 106 cells/ml, at 370C, in 5% CO2) for 6 days in RPMI (supplemented with 2 mM L-glutamine), 10% fetal calf serum, 0.1 mg/ml penicillin G (Britannia Pharmaceuticals, UK), 0.1 mg/ml streptomycin (Sigma-Aldrich), and 0.1 mg/ml gentamicin (Mayne Pharma Plc, UK), type B CpG oligonucleotide (ODN 2006; 6 µg/ml; InvivoGen), recombinant human interleukin (IL)-21 (Miltenyi Biotech) and recombinant human CD40 ligand (Miltenyi Biotech). Following centrifugation, aliquots of culture supernatant samples were stored at -800C. After washing, the cells were used in ELISpot assays.
Flow cytometry staining and analysis
Antigen-activated B cells were investigated using Alexa Fluor® 488-labelled toxin A (toxin A488 ). Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (2 x 106) were incubated on ice with 10 µg/ml toxin A488 on a rocker, in the dark, for 1 hour. After washing, the cells were labelled with antibodies to CD19 (Beckman Coulter) and IgD (Southern Biotech). Washed cells were fixed in 0.5ml of 0.5% formaldehyde and subsequently studied by flow cytometry (FACScan FC500, Beckman-Coulter). Data files of up to 1x106 events were collected for each test sample and the resultant dot-plots were opened in Weasel version 3 software (Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of Medical Research) which was used to draw regions encompassing toxin A488 positively labelled events.
Toxin A- and toxin B-specific IgG responses in serum samples were determined by ELISA. Flat-bottom 96-well ELISA plates (F96 CERT Maxisorp NUNC, Thermo Scientific) were coated with 100µl of a 30µg/ml solution of purified toxin A or B in 0.05 M carbonate-bicarbonate buffer (pH 9.6) and incubated overnight at 4°C. After washing six times with PBS-0.05% Tween 20 using an automatic plate washer (ELx50 automated strip washer; Biotek Instruments, Inc.), blocking solution (PBS-0.05% Tween 20 containing 0.05% azide and 1% goat serum) was added to each well and incubated for three hours at 25°C. After further washing, sera diluted (1:100) in PBS-0.05% Tween 20 containing 0.05% azide (or lamina propria cell culture supernatant samples at 1:4 dilution) were added to each well (100 µl) in triplicate and incubated for two hours at 25°C. After washing, positive reactions were detected by successive incubations with 100µl dilution of 5 µg/ml biotinylated anti-human IgG (Vector) in PBS-0.05% Tween 20 containing 1% goat serum for one hour at 25°C and with a streptavidin-horseradish peroxidase substrate (Vector) for 20 minutes at 25°C. The final reaction was visualized by the addition of 2,2’-azino-bis (3-ethylbenzthiazoline-6-sulfonic acid) for 20 minutes in the dark. A405 values were measured in an ELISA plate reader. The A405 values for the negative control wells were averaged and subtracted from toxin-coated wells to give the corrected A405 values for each test sample. ELISA units (EU) in test sera were then calculated from their OD405 values using a standard curve established from serial dilutions (1:25 to 1:1600) of pooled serum samples with high anti-toxin antibody titres. If the corrected OD405 value of a sample fell below that of the lower plateau in the standard curve, it was deemed negative and given an arbitrary value of 0.01 EU.
Ninety six-well ELISpot plates (Millipore Multiscreen MSIPS4510 HTS IP Sterile plate 0.45 µm, hydrophobic, high-protein binding) were pre-treated with 15 µl of 35% ethanol for 1 minute. After three washes with PBS the plates were incubated overnight (at 4°C) with goat anti-human IgG Fc fragment (10 µg/ml, from Bethyl Laboratories, to detect all IgG-secreting cells) and either PBS (control), purified toxin A or purified toxin B (both at a concentration of 30 µg/ml). After washing 4 times with PBS, plates were blocked with 200µl/well of RPMI-1640 supplemented with 10% FCS. To induce differentiation of memory B cells to antibody secreting cells, mitogen-stimulated peripheral blood mononuclear cells were subsequently applied to ELISpot plates (25 x 103 cells/well to detect total IgG ASCs or 2 x 105 cells/well to detect toxin-specific ASCs). Control wells that were incorporated in each plate included those with no cells (media only), and wells to which unstimulated peripheral blood mononuclear cells were added. Following incubation for 18 hours (at 37°C, 5% CO2), the wells were washed 4 times with PBS, followed by PBS-0.05% Tween 20. Diluted (1:1000 in PBS-0.05% Tween 20) horseradish peroxidise-conjugated goat anti-human IgG Fc fragment antibodies (Jackson Immunoresearch) were added to the wells and incubated overnight at 4°C. After removal of the underdrain, plates were washed (3 times with PBS-0.05% Tween 20 and 6 times with PBS) and developed with 3-amino-9-ethylcarbazole (AEC) substrate (BD Biosciences). The plates were washed thoroughly with distilled water and allowed to dry overnight. Spot-forming cells were subsequently enumerated in a blinded fashion using a dissection microscope. The number of toxin A- and B-specific IgG ASCs were expressed as a percentage of the total number of IgG antibody secreting cells. For analysis, the number of background spots from control wells (those containing unstimulated cells or lacking capture antigen) were subtracted from those coated with antigen.
Culture of intestinal mucosa samples
To investigate antibody secretion by intestinal lamina propria cells, fresh mucosal samples (which were surplus to clinical requirements) were obtained from surgically-resected intestinal tissue of patients with ulcerative colitis or Crohn’s disease. Following removal of epithelial cells with EDTA, small pieces of mucosal samples were cultured in RPMI 1640 containing 10% fetal calf serum, 2mM L-glutamine and antibiotics for 24 hours, as previously described . Supernatant samples were subsequently collected (after centrifugation to remove lamina propria cells) and stored at -800C, prior to use in ELISA.
Purification of C. difficile toxins
Groups of patients were compared using two-tailed non-parametric tests (Spearman correlation, Kruskal-Wallis, Wilcoxon matched-pairs signed rank and Mann Whitney tests) and Fisher’s exact test. Data are expressed as median (range). Multiple serum samples were studied from many patients. Fluctuation in serum antibody concentrations in individual subjects over time was assessed using coefficient of variation. For comparative studies between groups, if more than one serum antibody concentration was determined, mean anti-toxin A and anti-toxin B antibody values were used per patient. A significance level of ≤0.05 was considered statistically significant.
The characteristics of the subjects in the four study groups are shown in Table 1, which also demonstrates that patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea were significantly older than those in the other three groups. In 16 of the 18 patients with cystic fibrosis, there was no history of C. difficile infection; 2 had a history of previous C. difficile infection; stool samples from a further 2 patients grew C. difficile and they were therefore deemed to be carriers. During the study period, patients in the cystic fibrosis group had significantly more hospital admissions than those in the other two patient groups (see table 1). At study enrolment, out of 18 of patients in the cystic fibrosis group, 15 and 3 patients were on 2 and 3 concurrent intravenous antibiotics, respectively. The most commonly prescribed antibiotics in descending order were Meropenem, Tobramycin, Amikacin, and Ceftazidime. In the inflammatory bowel disease group, 5 patients had no history of antibiotic usage within the 6 weeks prior to C. difficile infection. In the other 5 patients, two were on 2 types of intravenous antibiotics and one patient was on 3 antibiotics (antibiotics used included Co-amoxiclav, Gentamicin, Trimethoprim, Meropenem and Piperacillin and Tazobactam). In patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea, the most commonly prescribed antibiotics in descending order were Co-amoxiclav, Piperacillin and Tazobactam, Flucloxacillin, and Meropenem.
|Healthy controls (n=19)||Patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea (n=53)||IBD patients with C. difficile infection (n=10)||Cystic fibrosis patients (n=18)|
|Age (yrs)||30 (22-39)||71 (21-98)*||34.5 (21-83)||27.5 (19-49)|
|Immunosuppressive treatment (corticosteroid/other)||0||9/3||6/4||2/2#|
|PPI / H2 blocker||0||31||4||14|
|Pancreatic enzyme supplements||0||0||1||17|
|Number of hospital admissions over study period||0||3 (1-25)a||1 (1-5)b||4.5 (1-10)|
|Serum anti-toxin A Igg (EU)§||10.27 (0.01-59.51)c||17.74 (0.01-161.50)d||47.44 (0.01-182.40)||41.78 (1.62-159.4)†|
|Serum anti-toxin B Igg (EU)§||16.08 (0.01-70.68)e||38.57 (0.01-97.97)f||26.37 (1.62-93.08)||62.7 (12.17-89.12)†|
Serum IgG levels
The majority of serum samples from healthy controls had detectable anti-toxin IgG to toxin A (73.7%) and toxin B (78.9%). Concentrations of anti-toxin -A and -B IgG were significantly higher in patients with cystic fibrosis (with no previous history of C. difficile infection) than in healthy controls and patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea (Table 1 and Figure 1).
Serum anti-toxin A (A) and anti-toxin B (A) IgG levels in healthy controls (n=19), patients with cystic fibrosis (CF; with no previous history of C. difficile infection; n=16), patients with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) and C. difficile infection (n=10) and patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea (CDAD; n=53). If more than one serum sample was studied per subject, the mean antibody concentration was used for the calculation. Anti-toxin A and B levels in patients with cystic fibrosis were significantly higher than those observed in healthy controls and patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea.
Compared with samples from the inflammatory bowel disease patients (n = 22), a significantly greater proportion of serum samples from the cystic fibrosis patients (n = 40) were positive for anti-toxin A IgG (97.5% vs 77.3%, p=0.0183) and anti-toxin B IgG (100% vs 77.3%, p=0.0041).
In paired comparisons, using all the samples collected, there was no correlation between serum anti-toxin A and anti-toxin B antibody levels in any of the patient groups.
Serum anti-toxin IgG concentrations over time
In those patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea from whom 3 or more serum samples were obtained, serum anti-toxin A IgG and anti-toxin B IgG were seen to fluctuate over time. This is illustrated in Figure 2.
(A, B) Serum anti-toxin A and B IgG levels respectively in patients with a single episode of C. difficile infection. (C, D) Anti-toxin A and B IgG levels respectively in patients with recurrent disease. The red line indicates a patient with 8 recurrences.
Data are for patients from whom three or more serum samples were obtained.
Within the patients with C. difficile associated diarrhoea, no significant difference in serum anti-toxin IgG was seen between those patients with single episode or recurrent disease (data not shown). However, in a patient with 8 episodes of C. difficile-associated diarrhoea either very low or undetectable anti-toxin IgG levels were observed (Figure 2). This patient went on to have treatment with intravenous pooled human immunoglobulin and had no further recurrences during the subsequent 12 month follow-up period.
In those patients with cystic fibrosis, serum anti-toxin A and anti-toxin B IgG concentrations remained largely stable over time (Figure 3). A measure of stability over time was made by calculating the coefficient of variation for IgG levels in those patients with 3 or more samples. Significantly greater variation in serum anti-toxin B IgG concentrations were seen in patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea when compared with patients with cystic fibrosis and is shown in Figure 4 [anti-toxin A: 51.61% (0.0-173.0) vs 14.41% (6.31-67.42), p=0.074; anti-toxin B: 55.37% (4.73-172.4) vs 13.82% (2.45-37.78), p=0.017].
(A, B) Serum anti-toxin A and B IgG levels respectively in patients without a history of C. difficile infection. (C, D) Anti-toxin A and B IgG levels respectively in patients with a history of C. difficile infection.
Data are for patients from whom three or more serum samples were obtained.
Coefficient of variation of (A) serum anti-toxin A and (B) anti-toxin B antibody concentrations in patients with non-IBD CDAD and cystic fibrosis (subjects with 3 or more serum antibody values). There is greater stability (ie less fluctuation) in toxin-specific antibody levels in patients with cystic fibrosis than those with non-IBD CDAD; this reaches statistical significance for anti-toxin B (p=0.017), but not anti-toxin A (p=0.074).
Circulating C. difficile toxin A-specific antigen activated B cell responses
Peripheral blood mononuclear cells of cystic fibrosis patients without a history of diarrhoea [n=4; median age 23 yrs (20-26 yrs)] and non-CF patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea [n=20; median age 67 yrs (32-96 yrs), blood samples obtained within 10 days of the onset of diarrhoea] were exposed to fluorescently-labelled toxin A488 and labelled with antibodies to CD19 (pan B cell marker) and IgD (expression lost in switched memory B cells).
In patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea, a significantly greater proportion of events were seen in the CD19-positive, IgD-negative gate in PBMCS exposed to toxin A488 [0.09% (0-0.54) versus 0.92% (0.09-1.78%); p<0.001 Wilcoxon matched-pairs], compared to control buffer. These results suggest that a small proportion of toxin A-specific, antigen-activated B cells can be detected in the peripheral circulation of patients soon after C. difficile infection (table 2; Figure 5). Compared to control buffer, a significantly greater proportion of toxin A488-specific events were seen in the CD19-positive/IgD-positive gates in patients with C. difficile associated diarrhoea.
|Control CD19+ve/IgD-ve events (%)||Tox A488 CD19+ve/IgD-ve events (%)||Control CD19+ve/IgD+ve events (%)||Tox A488 CD19+ve/IgD+ve events (%)|
|Patients with C. difficile- associated diarrhoea (n=18) †||0.10 (0 - 0.54)||0.91* (0.21-1.78)||0.07 (0.01-0.9)||0.90* (0.02-2.60)|
|IBD patients with C. difficile infection (n=2)†||0, 0||1.26, 0.09||0.18, 0.21||1.24, 0.54|
|Cystic fibrosis patients, asymptomatic carriers of C. difficile (n=2)||0.08, 0||5.64, 1.14||0.04, 0.04||3.70, 1.42|
|Cystic fibrosis patients, stool negative for C. difficile (n=2)||0.08, 0.07||0.95, 0.45||0.06, 0.10||1.33, 0.86|
(A) Dot plots of CD19-positive peripheral blood mononuclear cells isolated (within 10 days of onset of symptoms) from a patient with C. difficile infection and incubated with either control buffer or toxin A488. IgD-negative and IgD-positive B cells that bound toxin A488 are represented by events in the right lower and upper quadrants, respectively. (B, C) Toxin A488 labelled events as a percentage of CD19-positive/IgD-negative (B) and CD19-positive/IgD-positive (C) events in patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea. When compared with control buffer, a significantly greater proportion of events were seen in both the CD19-positive/IgD-negative and CD19-positive/IgD-positive gates in peripheral blood mononuclear cells exposed to toxin A488.
In the two cystic fibrosis patients who were asymptomatic carries of C. difficile, >1% (up to 5.64%) of toxin A488-specific events were seen in the above gates (table 2).
Circulating memory B cell responses to C. difficile toxins
Following mitogen-induced differentiation of memory B cells, toxin A- and B-specific antibody secreting cells were enumerated using ELISpot assays and expressed as a percentage of total IgG-secreting cells.
In initial tests of polyclonal activation, the concentration of human IgG secreted into PBMC cell culture supernatant samples (34 samples from 19 patients) was significantly higher following mitogen stimulation compared to cells cultured in control medium [median 0.026 µg/ml (range 0.0-6.454) vs 0.465 µg/ml (0.001-7.172); p <0.0001). Anti-toxin A and B IgG was detectable in 12% and 26.2% of supernatant samples of mitogen-stimulated peripheral blood mononuclear cells, respectively. Toxin A-specific (66.7%) and B-specific (100%) antibody secreting cells were detected in their respective ELISpot assays following polyclonal stimulation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells.
Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were isolated from 39 blood samples, collected at varying time intervals after onset of C. difficile-associated diarrhoea in 16 patients [samples obtained at median 181 (range 81-415) days after the onset of symptoms]. There was significant correlation (p=0.0035) between the frequency of toxin A- and toxin B-specific antibody secreting cells (Figure 6).
Peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 39 blood samples, collected at varying time intervals after onset of C. difficile-associated diarrhoea in 16 patients (median 181 days after onset of diarrhoea, range 81-415). There was significant correlation (p=0.0035) between the frequency of toxin A- and toxin B-specific IgG secreting cells (as percentage of total IgG-secreting antibody secretory cells).
In the same samples, a significantly greater proportion of toxin B-specific, than toxin A-specific memory B cells were detected [0.82% (0 - 4.93) vs 0.33% (0 - 2.12); p<0.0001] (Figure 7).
Peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 39 blood samples, collected at varying time intervals after onset of C. difficile-associated diarrhoea in 16 patients. A significantly higher proportion of toxin B-specific antibody secretory cells (than toxin A-specific antibody secretory cells) was detected [0.82 (0 - 4.93) % vs 0.33 (0 - 2.12) %; p<0.0001].
Similar findings were observed in samples obtained from four patients with inflammatory bowel disease and C. difficile infection and also in samples from patients with cystic fibrosis (without a history of C. difficile infection) [0.67% (0 - 3.57) vs 0.20% (0 - 1.93); p=0.002] (Figure 8).
Peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 24 blood samples, collected at varying time intervals, from 13 patients with cystic fibrosis (with no previous history of C. difficile infection) [samples obtained over median 161.5 (range 42-244) days]. There was significant correlation (p=0.0017) between toxin A- and toxin B-specific IgG antibody secreting cells (A) with significantly higher proportions of the latter [0.67 (0 - 3.57) %) vs 0.20 (0 - 1.93) %; p=0.002] (B).
In circulating cells collected at 6 different time points from 2 patients with cystic fibrosis and a history of C. difficile infection, there were significantly higher toxin A- and toxin B-specific antibody secreting cells, compared to cells isolated from 13 cystic fibrosis patients with no previous history of C. difficile infection [toxin A: 0.20% (0.0-1.93) vs 0.78% (0.06-6.67), p=0.05; and toxin B: 0.675% (0.0-3.57) vs 3.315% (0.32-11.67), p<0.03] (Figure 9). The highest proportion of toxin A-specific (6.67%) and toxin B-specific (11.67%) antibody secreting cells was observed in one of the patients with cystic fibrosis and a history of C. difficile infection, (sample obtained 121 days after the onset of C. difficile-associated diarrhoea).
Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were isolated from a total of 6 and 24 samples collected at varying time intervals from patients with cystic fibrosis with (n=2) and without (n=13) previous history of C. difficile infection, respectively. The frequencies of toxin A- and B-specific antibody secreting cells were significantly higher in those patients with previous C. difficile infection than those without. (A) toxin A-specific ASCs (p=0.05); (B) toxin B-specific ASCs (p=0.026).
Antibody and memory B cell responses to toxins A and B in individual subjects
There was no correlation between serum anti-toxin IgG and memory B cell frequencies in samples obtained from patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea, inflammatory bowel disease (with C. difficile infection) and those with cystic fibrosis.
Illustrative examples are shown in Figures 10 and 11. In some patients in the C. difficile-associated diarrhoea and inflammatory bowel disease (with C. difficile infection) groups, serum IgG responses were not seen to either toxin A or B. In the majority of the cystic fibrosis patients (17 of 18), serum antibody responses were seen to both toxins.
Case studies (A–F) showing toxin A- and toxin B-specific serum antibody levels and memory ASC frequencies in non-IBD CDAD and IBD-CDAD patients. (A) 67 yr female, 1st sample 5d after onset of diarrhoea associated with 1st episode of C. difficile infection. Recurrence of infection after 26d (dashed arrow) with no further episodes over 21mths. (B) 62 yr female, 1st sample 7d after 2nd episode of C. difficile infection (solid arrow). No recurrences over 14mths. (C) 71 yr female, 1st sample 12d after onset of diarrhoea associated with 1st episode of severe C. difficile infection (solid arrow). Second episode of infection (dashed arrow) after 94d but no further episodes over subsequent 15mths. (D) 62 yr female, 1st sample 7d after onset of diarrhoea associated with 1st episode of severe C. difficile infection (solid arrow). Recurrence at 30d (dashed arrow). No further episodes of infection over subsequent 13mths. (E) 32 yr pregnant female, recent diagnosis of ulcerative colitis. Hospital admission for intravenous corticosteroids 17d prior to 1st sample. Two initial stool samples negative for C. difficile toxin. Four days before first blood sample, positive stool C. difficile toxin test (solid arrow). (F) 28 yr female with ulcerative colitis and recurrent C. difficile infection. First sample during 3rd episode of C. difficile infection (1st episode occurred 60d previously – solid arrow). Fourth episode of C. difficile infection (dashed arrow) at 135d. In intervening period, patient was taking corticosteroids, ciclosporin and azathioprine.
Case studies (A–F) showing toxin A- and toxin B-specific serum antibody levels and memory ASC frequencies in patients with cystic fibrosis. (A) 26 yr male with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus, previous fundoplication and gastrostomy. Colonised with C. difficile at recruitment. No history of diarrhoea during study period and subsequent 17mths. (B) 24 yr male with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. Colonised with C. difficile at recruitment. (C) 32 yr male with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. Not colonised with C. difficile at recruitment. No history of diarrhoea during the study or follow-up period. (D) 24 yr male with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus, previous bilateral lung transplantation 3d after first sample. Subsequently taking prednisolone, azathioprine, tacrolimus and cotrimoxazole. (E) 34 yr female with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. Overnight feeding via jejunostomy. C. difficile infection with diarrhoea 10mths prior to first sample. No recurrence of C. difficile infection during the study or subsequent 9 month follow-up period. (F) 28 yr male recruited during episode of clinical C. difficile associated diarrhoea. No recurrence of C. difficile infection during the study period or 14mth follow-up period.
In three patients (Figure 10 A, C, D) with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea, serum anti-toxin IgG levels rose following a second episode of infection and no further clinical recurrence was observed.
Secretion of anti-toxin IgG by intestinal lamina propria cells
In a group of patients with inflammatory bowel disease and no history of C. difficile infection, secretion of toxin-specific IgG antibodies by intestinal lamina propria cells was studied in supernatant samples of cultured pieces of small and large intestinal mucosa obtained from operation resection specimens.
Supernatant samples were diluted 1:4 and ELISA Units (EU) determined from OD405 values using a standard curve established from serial dilutions of pooled serum samples with high anti-toxin antibody titres.
In 2 (of 5) supernatant samples of mucosal tissue from patients with ulcerative colitis and 3 (of 8) with colonic Crohn’s disease, anti-toxin B IgG was detected, but anti-toxin A IgG was undetectable in all.
In cultures of 7 samples of small intestine from patients with Crohn’s disease, anti-toxin A and anti-toxin B IgG were detected in 2 and 7 respectively.
Anti-toxin A and B IgG antibodies were detected in supernatant samples of cultured inflamed colonic mucosa from a patient with C. difficile-associated pseudomembranous colitis undergoing colectomy.
Following initial exposure to a pathogen or its products, protection by the humoral immune system is mediated by long-lived plasma cell-derived antibodies and long-lived memory B cells . Our studies have investigated both types of IgG-mediated humoral immune responses to C. difficile toxins in patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea, IBD patients with C. difficile infection and cystic fibrosis patients, the majority of which had no previous history of C. difficile infection. Serum anti-toxin IgG was also quantified in a separate groups of healthy subjects.
Consistent with previous studies [19,20], the majority of the healthy controls in our studies had detectable anti-toxin A and anti-toxin B antibodies in their serum samples. This implies that asymptomatic exposure to toxigenic C. difficile is common and may be due to transient colonisation. Notably, significantly higher anti-toxin antibody concentrations in patients with cystic fibrosis (with no previous history of C. difficile infection) are likely to be due to more frequent contact with the toxins secreted by C. difficile that colonises the large intestine following antibiotic-mediated disruption of the protective resident microflora, especially following admission to hospital . Indeed, in contrast to patients with inflammatory bowel disease, all the cystic fibrosis patients were on 2 or 3 intravenous antibiotics at the time of recruitment to the study. The cystic fibrosis patients also had additional risk factors for C. difficile colonization/infection including tube feeding, the use of proton pump inhibitors and H2 blockers [3,4]. Frequent exposure to the toxins may also explain maintenance of steady serum anti-toxin antibody concentrations in patients with cystic fibrosis. These circulating antibodies to toxins A and B are believed to provide protection against the development of disease [3,5,6,20], which may be best illustrated in the two asymptomatic carriers of toxigenic C. difficile. The development of C. difficile infection in two cystic fibrosis patients suggest that immune-mediated protection can be overcome and may reflect tilting of the balance in favour of the pathogen. Such “imbalance” may occur due to increased production of toxins A and B, for example following infection with the NAP1 strain , which has recently been reported to be associated more frequently with C. difficile infection (than colonization) . High luminal concentrations of the toxins may overcome IgG and other (IgA, mucus) forms of protection, leading to enhanced susceptibility of host intestinal epithelial and lamina propria cells [15,23]. Whilst firm conclusions cannot be drawn because of the small number of subjects studied, cystic fibrosis patients with previous C. difficile infection appeared to have an enhanced memory B cell response and serum anti-toxin antibody levels above the mean for the rest of the group. Such heightened response may protect against recurrence.
Serum anti-toxin A and anti-toxin B antibody concentrations in patients with C. difficile-associated diarrhoea were significantly lower than in cystic fibrosis patients. Patients in the former group were also significantly older, which may explain the inability of these patients to mount as strong a humoral immune response as those younger patients with cystic fibrosis. Since many patients with C. difficile infection had fluctuating anti-toxin antibody levels, our studies raise the possibility that C. difficile toxin-specific long-lived plasma cell numbers and/or function may not be sustained over time. This could be a general feature of humoral immune responses to bacterial toxins as, in contrast to viral antigens, antibody responses to tetanus and diphtheria toxins have been reported to wane more quickly . Moreover, studies of the aged human immune response (termed ‘immune senescence’) document qualitative and quantitative decline in T and B lymphocyte responses to a range of microbes and antigens. Such changes could be due in part to impaired T cell help for B cell IgG production, diminishing lymphocyte clonal repertoire diversity (polyclonal to oligoclonal) and microenvironmental factors in lymphoid tissue and bone marrow [25,26]. Such information is relevant in efforts to induce and sustain protective immunity against C. difficile infection via improved vaccination strategies.
Whilst concentrations of serum IgG antibodies to toxin A and toxin B did not differ between cystic fibrosis and inflammatory bowel disease patients, greater heterogeneity in antibody levels was seen in the latter group, as illustrated by the absence of detectable antibody in some serum samples. Significantly fewer hospital admissions in the inflammatory bowel disease group suggest that such heterogeneity could be due to less frequent exposure to C. difficile in the hospital environment. Further studies with larger groups of patients are required to determine whether patients with inflammatory bowel disease are at greater risk of C. difficile infection than those with cystic fibrosis. Of note, patients with long-standing diagnoses of ulcerative colitis and Crohn’s disease in clinical remission without recent exposure to antibiotics, immunomodulatory drugs or recent hospitalisation, demonstrate an increased frequency of detectable faecal C. difficile when compared with healthy adults . However, it remains to be seen whether carriage of this bacterium in such patients ultimately translates into increased risk of relapse and will require larger numbers of subjects and longer-term follow-up. Further studies are also required to determine the impact of known risk factors for C. difficile acquisition including antibiotics and immunomodulatory drugs in relation to carriage rates in the IBD population .
Our studies in which cultures of some intestinal mucosal samples affected by inflammatory bowel disease secreted antibodies to C. difficile toxins suggest that exposure to toxigenic C. difficile is not uncommon in such patients. These patients were not thought to have had clinical C. difficile infection, implying asymptomatic exposure to toxigenic C. difficile, with protection mediated by anti-toxin antibodies secreted by plasma cells in the mucosa. It will also be of interest to determine whether the antibody producing cells in the mucosa of patients with inflammatory bowel disease represent long-lived plasma cells.
Impaired mucosal regulatory T cell function has been implicated in the pathogenesis of inflammatory bowel disease  but the effect of C. difficile infection on T cell function in patients with ulcerative colitis and Crohn’s disease remains to be determined. It is possible that C. difficile toxin-induced cytokine expression in macrophages  may lead to resistance of effector T cells to suppression by regulatory T cells and thereby lead to exacerbation of mucosal inflammation in inflammatory bowel disease. Changes in the resident microbial flora associated with C. difficile infection may also adversely influence mucosal regulatory T cells function.
In peripheral blood mononuclear cells, following differentiation of memory B cells, there was significant correlation between toxin A- and toxin B-specific antibody secreting cells (with greater proportions of the latter). However, there was lack of correlation between toxin A- or toxin B-specific serum antibody levels and the relevant memory B cell responses. Such lack of correlation between serum antibody concentrations (derived from long-lived plasma cells) and circulating memory B cell numbers has also been reported for other antigens  and likely reflects independent regulation of the development of the relevant cells in germinal centres .
The findings of toxin A488+ve CD19-positive/IgD-negative and CD19-positive/IgD-positive cells are consistent with the presence of switched (IgD-negative) and unswitched (IgD-positive), toxin A-specific memory B cells. They also reflect heterogeneity in the generation of memory B cell populations . However, the functional contributions of these distinct subpopulations of cells in host protection remains to be determined. More detailed phenotypic studies aimed at characterising human memory B cell subsets in patients with C. difficile infection may help identify B cell signatures associated with disease severity, prognosis and response to treatment.
In conclusion, our studies provide further evidence for the importance of the humoral immune response to toxins A and B in protection against C. difficile infection. The impaired ability to generate strong and sustained toxin-specific humoral immune responses, via long-lived plasma cells and long-lived memory B cells, may increase susceptibility of older individuals to C. difficile infection and warrants further investigation of the role of immune senescence.
Overall, our data suggest that serum anti-toxin antibodies may underestimate the breadth of humoral immunity in relation to C. difficile infection and strongly support the use of toxin-specific B memory cell analyses to complement serological studies. The antigen-specific flow cytometric and ELISpot techniques described in this report could find utility in the development of an effective novel vaccine against C. difficile infection that induces long-lived protection.
We wish to thank Jacqueline Webb, Melanie Lingaya and Rawinder Banwait for technical assistance and Jill Garrett, Mina Patel and Antonella Ghezzi for provision of Research Nurse support. We also wish to thank Dr Andrea Murray (Oncimmune) for advice regarding the establishment of ELISA assays, Dr Victoria Pudney (Academic Department of Clinical Oncology) for technical advice regarding ELISPOT assay development and clinical colleagues in Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust for their support in recruiting patients under their care.
Conceived and designed the experiments: YRM TMM HFS AR AK. Performed the experiments: TMM AR. Analyzed the data: TMM YRM AR. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: AR HFS AK YRM. Wrote the manuscript: YRM HFS TMM AK.
- 1. Monaghan T, Boswell T, Mahida YR (2008) Recent advances in Clostridium difficile-associated disease. Gut 57: 850-860. PubMed: 18252748.
- 2. Borriello SP, Barclay FE (1986) An in-vitro model of colonisation resistance to Clostridium difficile infection. J Med Microbiol 21: 299-309. doi:https://doi.org/10.1099/00222615-21-4-299. PubMed: 3723582.
- 3. Loo VG, Bourgault AM, Poirier L, Lamothe F, Michaud S et al. (2011) Host and pathogen factors for Clostridium difficile infection and colonization. N Engl J Med 365: 1693-1703. doi:https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa1012413. PubMed: 22047560.
- 4. Bignardi GE (1998) Risk factors for Clostridium difficile infection. J Hosp Infect 40: 1-15. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/S0195-6701(98)90182-7. PubMed: 9777516.
- 5. Kyne L, Warny M, Qamar A, Kelly CP (2000) Asymptomatic carriage of Clostridium difficile and serum levels of IgG antibody against toxin A. N Engl J Med 342: 390-397. doi:https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM200002103420604. PubMed: 10666429.
- 6. Kyne L, Warny M, Qamar A, Kelly CP (2001) Association between antibody response to toxin A and protection against recurrent Clostridium difficile diarrhoea. Lancet 357: 189-193. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(00)03592-3. PubMed: 11213096.
- 7. Voth DE, Ballard JD (2005) Clostridium difficile toxins: mechanism of action and role in disease. Clin Microbiol Rev 18: 247-263. doi:https://doi.org/10.1128/CMR.18.2.247-263.2005. PubMed: 15831824.
- 8. Leav BA, Blair B, Leney M, Knauber M, Reilly C et al. (2010) Serum anti-toxin B antibody correlates with protection from recurrent Clostridium difficile infection (CDI). Vaccine 28: 965-969. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.vaccine.2009.10.144. PubMed: 19941990.
- 9. Goodhand JR, Alazawi W, Rampton DS (2011) Systematic review: Clostridium difficile and inflammatory bowel disease. Aliment Pharmacol Ther 33: 428-441. doi:https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2036.2010.04548.x. PubMed: 21198703.
- 10. Peach SL, Borriello SP, Gaya H, Barclay FE, Welch AR (1986) Asymptomatic carriage of Clostridium difficile in patients with cystic fibrosis. J Clin Pathol 39: 1013-1018. doi:https://doi.org/10.1136/jcp.39.9.1013. PubMed: 3093537.
- 11. Welkon CJ, Long SS, Thompson CM Jr, Gilligan PH (1985) Clostridium difficile in patients with cystic fibrosis. Am J Dis Child 139: 805-808. PubMed: 4025261.
- 12. Johal SS, Hammond J, Solomon K, James PD, Mahida YR (2004) Clostridium difficile associated diarrhoea in hospitalised patients: onset in the community and hospital and role of flexible sigmoidoscopy. Gut 53: 673-677. doi:https://doi.org/10.1136/gut.2003.028803. PubMed: 15082585.
- 13. Mahida YR, Galvin AM, Gray T, Makh S, McAlindon ME et al. (1997) Migration of human intestinal lamina propria lymphocytes, macrophages and eosinophils following the loss of surface epithelial cells. Clin Exp Immunol 109: 377-386. doi:https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2249.1997.4481346.x. PubMed: 9276536.
- 14. Modi N, Gulati N, Solomon K, Monaghan T, Robins A et al. (2011) Differential binding and internalization of Clostridium difficile toxin A by human peripheral blood monocytes, neutrophils and lymphocytes. Scand J Immunol 74: 264-271. doi:https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-3083.2011.02578.x. PubMed: 21595735.
- 15. Mahida YR, Galvin A, Makh S, Hyde S, Sanfilippo L et al. (1998) Effect of Clostridium difficile toxin A on human colonic lamina propria cells: early loss of macrophages followed by T-cell apoptosis. Infect Immun 66: 5462-5469. PubMed: 9784558.
- 16. Kamiya S, Reed PJ, Borriello SP (1989) Purification and characterisation of Clostridium difficile toxin A by bovine thyroglobulin affinity chromatography and dissociation in denaturing conditions with or without reduction. J Med Microbiol 30: 69-77. doi:https://doi.org/10.1099/00222615-30-1-69. PubMed: 2778794.
- 17. Mullan N, Hughes KR, Mahida YR (2011) Primary human colonic myofibroblasts are resistant to Clostridium difficile toxin A-induced, but not toxin B-induced, cell death. Infect Immun 79: 1623-1630. doi:https://doi.org/10.1128/IAI.00686-10. PubMed: 21245273.
- 18. Shlomchik MJ, Weisel F (2012) Germinal center selection and the development of memory B and plasma cells. Immunol Rev 247: 52-63. doi:https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-065X.2012.01124.x. PubMed: 22500831.
- 19. Viscidi R, Laughon BE, Yolken R, Bo-Linn P, Moench T et al. (1983) Serum antibody response to toxins A and B of Clostridium difficile. J Infect Dis 148: 93-100. doi:https://doi.org/10.1093/infdis/148.1.93. PubMed: 6886489.
- 20. Warny M, Vaerman JP, Avesani V, Delmée M (1994) Human antibody response to Clostridium difficile toxin A in relation to clinical course of infection. Infect Immun 62: 384-389. PubMed: 8300199.
- 21. McFarland LV, Mulligan ME, Kwok RY, Stamm WE (1989) Nosocomial acquisition of Clostridium difficile infection. N Engl J Med 320: 204-210. doi:https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM198901263200402. PubMed: 2911306.
- 22. Warny M, Pepin J, Fang A, Killgore G, Thompson A et al. (2005) Toxin production by an emerging strain of Clostridium difficile associated with outbreaks of severe disease in North America and Europe. Lancet 366: 1079-1084. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(05)67420-X. PubMed: 16182895.
- 23. Johal SS, Solomon K, Dodson S, Borriello SP, Mahida YR (2004) Differential effects of varying concentrations of clostridium difficile toxin A on epithelial barrier function and expression of cytokines. J Infect Dis 189: 2110-2119. doi:https://doi.org/10.1086/386287. PubMed: 15143480.
- 24. Amanna IJ, Carlson NE, Slifka MK (2007) Duration of humoral immunity to common viral and vaccine antigens. N Engl J Med 357: 1903-1915. doi:https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa066092. PubMed: 17989383.
- 25. Mekker A, Tchang VS, Haeberli L, Oxenius A, Trkola A et al. (2012) Immune senescence: relative contributions of age and cytomegalovirus infection. PLOS Pathog 8: e1002850. PubMed: 22916013.
- 26. Siegrist CA, Aspinall R (2009) B-cell responses to vaccination at the extremes of age. Nat Rev Immunol 9: 185-194. doi:https://doi.org/10.1038/nri2508. PubMed: 19240757.
- 27. Clayton EM, Rea MC, Shanahan F, Quigley EM, Kiely B et al. (2009) The vexed relationship between Clostridium difficile and inflammatory bowel disease: an assessment of carriage in an outpatient setting among patients in remission. Am J Gastroenterol 104: 1162-1169. doi:https://doi.org/10.1038/ajg.2009.4. PubMed: 19319128.
- 28. Mayne CG, Williams CB. (2013) Induced and natural regulatory T cells in the development of inflammatory bowel disease. Inflamm Bowel Dis 19: 1772-1788. PubMed: 23656897.
- 29. Koon HW, Shih DQ, Hing TC, Yoo JH, Ho S et al.. (2013) Human Monoclonal Antibodies against Clostridium difficile Toxins A and B Inhibit Inflammatory and Histologic Responses to the Toxins in Human Colon and Peripheral Blood Monocytes. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 57: 3214-3223. doi:https://doi.org/10.1128/AAC.02633-12. PubMed: 23629713.
- 30. Kurosaki T, Aiba Y, Kometani K, Moriyama S, Takahashi Y (2010) Unique properties of memory B cells of different isotypes. Immunol Rev 237: 104-116. doi:https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-065X.2010.00939.x. PubMed: 20727032.