The Fukushima nuclear disaster has generated worldwide concern on the risk of exposure to nuclear radiations. In Europe, health authorities had to issue statements about the lack of usefulness of iodine based preventive treatments within their borders. However a lack of confidence in official messages has developed in various European countries due to recent perceived failures in managing public health crises. The lay population preventive behaviors in this context are largely unknown. Consequently, to examine the effects of public health crisis on lay behaviors leading to pharmaceuticals purchases, we studied the sales of iodine-based products in France before, during and after the crisis.
We focused our study on 58 iodine-based drugs available with and without a physician prescription. Our data came from a stratified sample of 3004 pharmacies in metropolitan France. Our study period was from January 2010 to April 2012, with a focus on March-April 2011. We differentiated sales of drugs prescribed by physicians from sales of drugs obtained without a prescription. We used a CUSUM method to detect abnormal increases in sales activity and cross-correlations to assess shifts in sales timing.
Sales of iodine-based nutritional complements, and later sales of iodine-based homeopathic remedies, substantially increased (up to 3-fold) during a period of 20 days. Their temporal patterns were correlated to specific events during the crisis. Prescriptions for iodine-based homeopathy increased (up to 35% of all sales). Iodine pills, strictly regulated by health authorities, have also been sold but on a very small scale.
These results indicate uncontrolled preventive behaviors resulting in the potentially unjustifiable consumption of available drugs. They have implications in public policy, and demonstrate the usefulness of drug sales surveillance for instantaneous evaluation of population behavior during a global crisis.
Citation: Crépey P, Pivette M, Bar-Hen A (2013) Quantitative Assessment of Preventive Behaviors in France during the Fukushima Nuclear Crisis. PLoS ONE 8(3): e58385. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0058385
Editor: Suminori Akiba, Kagoshima University Graduate School of Medical and Dental Sciences, Japan
Received: September 20, 2012; Accepted: February 4, 2013; Published: March 7, 2013
Copyright: © 2013 Crépey et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The authors have no support or funding to report.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
On March 11, 2011, a magnitude 9 earthquake followed by a 15-m tsunami wave damaged the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant (NPP) in Japan . The disaster provoked the meltdown of three reactors leading to a level-7 nuclear incident . In the aftermath, Japan had to face the worst nuclear disaster since the destruction of Chernobyl’s reactor number four in 1986. Nuclear disasters have global consequences, and populations are now highly aware of the potential public health consequences of radioactive discharges , .
In France, a severe loss of confidence in political authorities has been observed in matters concerning nuclear risk following the Chernobyl event. A study on a sample of the general population in France by Carlé and colleagues  showed that 75% of the respondents believed they had not been told the truth about the Chernobyl fallout. The same study showed that neither government representatives nor journalists were considered by a large majority of respondents to be technically competent and likely to tell the truth about nuclear issues. In addition, 68% of the respondents had no confidence in the abilities of the authorities to protect them in case of a major nuclear disaster.
This lack of confidence in health authorities was also observed during the last influenza pandemic. However, the reluctance to comply with official recommendations seems to be more related to differences in risk perception , , which resulted in a lower than usual pandemic influenza vaccination uptake .
During the Fukushima crisis, contrary to multiple unofficial and nonmedical sources, all French official communications indicated that using iodine was not useful as a preventive measure in France . Potassium iodide (KI) pills are only used in case of risk of direct exposure to radioactive iodine isotopes to saturate the thyroid glands with nonradioactive iodine. In France, KI pills are army-regulated and only available in military controlled pharmacies or in pharmacies located in a 10-km radius from one of the 19 French NPPs . However, several drugs, such as antiseptics, nutritional supplements and homeopathic remedies, containing relatively low concentrations of iodine, can be purchased in pharmacies with or without prescriptions.
Our study focuses on sales of the previously described drugs, on their timing, and on correlations with the timing of events that may have impacted those sales. Implications in terms of public health campaigns are discussed.
Materials and Methods
We studied the changes in pharmaceutical sales of iodine-based drugs in France through a stratified random sample of 3004 pharmacies set up by the company Celtipharm . Through their participation in the Xpr-So© system, the pharmacies have automatically reported their sales several times a day since 2007. Thanks to a regularly updated exhaustive database of the 22,458 active French pharmacies, a stratification to improve representativeness is performed on sales revenue (6 levels for global revenue and 4 levels per type of sales: prescribed drugs, OTC, and other type of sales), localization (5 geographic areas) and sales area (5 types, from rural to densely urban). Each stratum has a minimum of 30 pharmacies or is merged with neighboring strata. Sampling rates per strata are computed with the Neyman optimal allocation algorithm . Extrapolations from the sample have been validated with data from drug manufacturers who distribute their products directly (and only) to pharmacies. We study sales data from January 2010 to April 2012 in order to include a reference period (the year 2010) and the period surrounding the Fukushima crisis. We compiled a list of 92 products containing or claiming to contain iodine based on a search for the pattern “iod*” in their name or principal ingredients. From that list, a total of 58 had been sold at least once in pharmacies from our sample during the study periods. We analyzed separately sales made with a physician prescription and those made without prescriptions. Sales were observed at the national and regional levels. The number of pharmacies selling the listed products was also analyzed. The list of products is given in Table S1. We computed cross-correlations of sales time series to quantify potential lags between types of sales. To detect unexpected increases in sales and assess durations of this kind of event we used a negative binomial CUSUM algorithm. We parameterized the CUSUM to compute its score from the difference between the cumulative sum of the sequence of observations and the maximum of variations observed the preceding month. We used a lag of a few days between the current observation and the preceding month to avoid tainting the “variation baseline” with the observed event. The same method, developed for real-time detection of a parameter’s deviation, is also classically used to detect disease outbreaks , . Positive CUSUM score can occur during a normal year; consequently, to maximize the specificity of our indicator we set the detection threshold to the maximum value of the score obtained during an a priori “normal” year, i.e. the year 2010, preceding the Fukushima crisis.
We defined four categories of iodine-based products: antiseptics, nutritional complements, homeopathic remedies, and KI pills. Figure 1 shows increases in sales in all product categories except iodine-based antiseptics during the period of the Fukushima crisis (February to mid-April 2011). In addition, although KI pills were only available to people living in a 10 km-radius from a NPP and were not released to the rest of the population for preventive purpose during the period, sales were registered in our sample specifically during the crisis. To confirm these increases, we computed a negative binomial CUSUM score  on the sales time series (Figure 2). We define the threshold for “sales outbreak” detection as the maximum CUSUM score obtained for the year 2010. Antiseptics (prescribed or not) do not cross the threshold in 2011, while iodine-based homeopathic remedies cross it during 22 days for all sales and 7 days for prescribed sales. Lastly, nutritional complements cross it during 19 days for all type of sales. Prescribed nutritional complements also slightly cross the threshold in 2011 but a few days prior to the Fukushima crisis. Sales of KI pills were almost nil outside of the Fukushima period making the CUSUM computation irrelevant. Comparisons between sales in 2010 and 2011 are given in Table 1. In particular, we notice a 144% increase of iodine-based nutritional complement sales in March 2011, but the largest sales increase concerns iodine-based homeopathic remedies, with a threefold increase compared to March 2010. We assessed the scale of the phenomenon by analyzing the number of pharmacies per day selling the identified products. In 2010, on a given day only 210 pharmacies on average sold iodine-based homeopathic remedies. During the 1-month period starting on March 11th, this number rose to 740 selling pharmacies per day on average and to 2,046 between the 21st and 25th of March 2011, representing 10% of the total number of stores.
Dashed lines show the weekly sliding average.
The straight lines on the plots illustrate the threshold for the CUSUM score, defined as the maximum value of the CUSUM score in 2010. An increase in the CUSUM score indicates a strong positive deviation from the normal trend. Light gray lines represent unit sales volumes. Panel A shows results for all type of sales while panel B only shows sales with a physician prescription.
To explore the timing of the purchases, we computed cross-correlations between the different sales time-series displaying an increase between February and April 2011 (all categories except iodine-based antiseptics). The cross-correlograms (Fig. 3) show that nutritional complements were purchased first, then homeopathic remedies sales peaked one day later, followed two days later by a peak of KI pills sales. No regional patterns were evidenced in the data.
The Fukushima crisis was a good model to study the public’s reaction to a major public health crisis. Whether the risk was real or not, we show that a part of the population chose to ignore official recommendations, seeking protection with what they perceived as preventive drugs. Table 2 allows us to hypothesize temporal links between these peaks and specific events related to the Fukushima crisis. The two main peaks of nutritional complement and homeopathic remedies sales occurred on the 18th and 24th of March, respectively, when a large-scale radioactive discharge was confirmed and just prior to the arrival of the radioactive cloud over France. The sequence of events, causing increasing concern, could explain the trend of purchase of different categories of products, which could be perceived of incremental efficiency: first iodine-based nutritional complements, then iodine-based homeopathic remedies, and finally KI pills.
Adverse events related to iodine consumption are limited since available studies do not reveal an association between KI and severe adverse events in the general population. Only newborns, the elderly and people with a history of thyroid dysfunction are at higher risk of developing complications . However our results raise questions about behaviors that could be adopted in the context of a public health crisis. The recent influenza A/H1N1 pandemic crisis in France showed that a part of the population chose to avoid protective measures. We now show that during the Fukushima crisis a part of the population looked for its own protective measures. It is also interesting to note that, despite the absence of any official indication or biological rationale, physicians have prescribed homeopathic remedies to protect their patients’ thyroidal glands. The generally admitted absence of adverse events on account of homeopathic drugs may have played a role in physicians’ decision to prescribe them to demanding patients. This absence of adverse events could explain the rationale for such protective behavior, at no perceived cost in terms of health risk.
Our approach has some limitations: (i) Pharmacy sales are only a proxy for self-medication since we cannot quantify practices such as traditional medicines, internet drug sales, etc… (ii) The act of purchasing a drug does not imply that it has been consumed. It is possible that purchased drugs have been stockpiled in order to be available in case of a real threat. The strict regulation surrounding the delivery of KI pills favors this hypothesis, at least for KI pills. The Fukushima crisis may have acted as a reminder to people authorized to stockpile to renew their stock. But it is clear that the control surrounding KI delivery in France prevented a wider unnecessary and potentially dangerous use. In the US where KI is available without prescriptions, several media sources reported that KI manufacturers and retailers were out of stock in the days following the disaster. However no study has described the extent of the phenomena and its public health impact yet.
Habits of self-medication are deeply rooted in the population of many countries. Combined with misinformation and distrust for official recommendations, it may lead, in time of public health crisis, to dramatic consequences. In the future, public health authorities may have to adapt their reaction accordingly to account for behaviors documented in this study. Consequently, it is crucial for public health decision makers to understand how and when populations resort to self-medication in order to design more efficient public health campaigns in times of public health crisis. Our study seems to show that real-time monitoring of drug sales could be an appropriate tool in that context.
Our study reports, describes, and quantifies some preventive lay behaviors during an international public health crisis. Those reactions have implications in terms of public health policy because they consist of uncontrolled use of drugs outside of their original purpose. Consequently we advocate the use of real time drug sales monitoring for instantaneous evaluation of population behavior during a global public health crisis.
Conceived and designed the experiments: PC MP AB. Performed the experiments: PC. Analyzed the data: PC MP AB. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: PC. Wrote the paper: PC AB.
- 1. Nuclear Emergency Response Headquarters Government of Japan (2011) Report of Japanese Government to the IAEA Ministerial Conference on Nuclear Safety - The Accident at TEPCO’s Fukushima Nuclear Power Stations.
- 2. Nuclear and Industrial Safety Agency (2011) INES (the International Nuclear and Radiological Event Scale) Rating on the Events in Fukushima Dai-ichi Nuclear Power Station by the Tohoku District - off the Pacific Ocean Earthquake.
- 3. Yablokov AV, Nesterenko VB (2009) Chapter I. Chernobyl Contamination?: An Overview 1. Chernobyl Contamination through Time and Space. Power 30: 4–30.
- 4. Carlé B, Charron S, Milochevitch A, Hardeman F (2004) An inquiry of the opinions of the French and Belgian populations as regards risk. Journal of hazardous materials 111: 21–27.
- 5. Raude J, Caille-Brillet A-L, Setbon M (2010) The 2009 pandemic H1N1 influenza vaccination in France: who accepted to receive the vaccine and why? PLoS currents 2: RRN1188.
- 6. Setbon M, Le Pape M-C, Létroublon C, Caille-Brillet A-L, Raude J (2011) The public’s preventive strategies in response to the pandemic influenza A/H1N1 in France: Distribution and determinants. Preventive medicine 52: 178–181.
- 7. Vaux S, Van Cauteren D, Guthmann J-P, Le Strat Y, Vaillant V, et al. (2011) Influenza vaccination coverage against seasonal and pandemic influenza and their determinants in France: a cross-sectional survey. BMC public health 11: 30.
- 8. Institut de Radioprotection et de Sûreté Nucléaire (n.d.). Available: http://www.irsn.fr/EN/news/Pages/news.aspx. Accessed 3 March 2012.
- 9. Autorité de Sureté Nucléaire (ASN) (n.d.) La distribution d’iode stable autour des centrales nucléaires françaises. Available: http://www.distribution-iode.com. Accessed 8 January 2013.
- 10. Celtipharm (n.d.) Panel Xpr-SO (c). Available: http://www.xpr-so.com/pages/Public/Accueil.aspx. Accessed 1 November 2011.
- 11. Kish JL (1965) Survey Sampling. Wiley & Sons.
- 12. Watkins RE, Eagleson S, Veenendaal B, Wright G, Plant AJ (2008) Applying cusum-based methods for the detection of outbreaks of Ross River virus disease in Western Australia. BMC medical informatics and decision making 8: 37.
- 13. Astagneau P, Ancelle T, editors (2011) Surveillance épidémiologique. Paris: Lavoisier.
- 14. Spallek L, Krille L, Reiners C, Schneider R, Yamashita S, et al.. (2011) Adverse Effects of Iodine Thyroid Blocking: a Systematic Review. Radiation protection dosimetry: 1–11.