In the United States, serogroup Y, ST-23 clonal complex Neisseria meningitidis was responsible for an increase in meningococcal disease incidence during the 1990s. This increase was accompanied by antigenic shift of three outer membrane proteins, with a decrease in the population that predominated in the early 1990s as a different population emerged later in that decade. To understand factors that may have been responsible for the emergence of serogroup Y disease, we used whole genome pyrosequencing to investigate genetic differences between isolates from early and late N. meningitidis populations, obtained from meningococcal disease cases in Maryland in the 1990s. The genomes of isolates from the early and late populations were highly similar, with 1231 of 1776 shared genes exhibiting 100% amino acid identity and an average πN = 0.0033 and average πS = 0.0216. However, differences were found in predicted proteins that affect pilin structure and antigen profile and in predicted proteins involved in iron acquisition and uptake. The observed changes are consistent with acquisition of new alleles through horizontal gene transfer. Changes in antigen profile due to the genetic differences found in this study likely allowed the late population to emerge due to escape from population immunity. These findings may predict which antigenic factors are important in the cyclic epidemiology of meningococcal disease.
Citation: Krauland MG, Hotopp JCD, Riley DR, Daugherty SC, Marsh JW, Messonnier NE, et al. (2012) Whole Genome Sequencing to Investigate the Emergence of Clonal Complex 23 Neisseria meningitidis Serogroup Y Disease in the United States. PLoS ONE 7(4): e35699. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0035699
Editor: Ray Borrow, Health Protection Agency, United Kingdom
Received: October 14, 2011; Accepted: March 20, 2012; Published: April 27, 2012
This is an open-access article, free of all copyright, and may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose. The work is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication.
Funding: This study was supported by a cooperative agreement from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and a grant from Sanofi Pasteur. Sanofi Pasteur had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: Dr. Harrison receives research support from Sanofi Pasteur and has served as a consultant to GlaxoSmithKline, Novartis Vaccines, Merck, Sanofi Pasteur, and Pfizer. Dr. Krauland and Dr. Marsh receive research support from Sanofi Pasteur. There are no patents, products in development or marketed products to declare. This does not alter the authors' adherence to all the PLoS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Neisseria meningitidis is a leading cause of bacterial meningitis world-wide . The most common disease-causing serogroups are A, B, C, X, W-135, and Y. In the United States, serogroup Y N. meningitidis was responsible for an increasing proportion of all meningococcal disease during the 1990s and also for an increased incidence of disease. For example, during 1989–1991, ∼ 2% of invasive meningococcal strains in the U.S. were serogroup Y, whereas by the mid 1990s, over a third of cases were caused by this serogroup. The predominant genetic lineage of serogroup Y isolates from this time period was the ST-23 clonal complex , , .
In a previous study, we demonstrated that the emergence and maintenance of ST-23 complex serogroup Y meningococcal disease in Maryland was associated with antigenic shift in three key meningococcal outer membrane proteins (OMPs), PorA, FetA, and PorB. A change in the pulsed field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) profile was also described, indicating that the strain that predominated in the early 1990s (early strain type) was replaced by another serogroup Y ST-23 complex strain that emerged later in the same decade (late strain type) through clonal replacement , .
In clonal replacement, one circulating strain is supplanted by another. This phenomenon has been observed in disease-causing strains of N. meningitidis , in N. meningitidis carriage isolates , , and other bacteria . Clonal replacement may be the result of introduction of new genetic lineages that are more fit, more virulent, more transmissible or allow escape from population immunity due to differences in antigenic proteins. Alternatively, mutation or recombination within a population may result in the development of a sub-population that has distinct genetic features with enhanced fitness or with antigens that have changed enough to allow escape from population immunity. A modeling approach has demonstrated that infectious pathogens may develop stable co-existing populations which have non-overlapping repertoires of dominant antigens even when recombination is a common feature, as a result of selection due to immunity in the host population . This concept would explain the existence of two populations of antigenically different but otherwise genetically similar strains causing disease in the same host population at the same time.
We used whole genome sequencing to more extensively investigate the genetic differences in early and late strain type serogroup Y ST-23 complex N. meningitidis isolates obtained from meningococcal disease cases in Maryland during the 1990s. We hypothesized that an accumulation of antigenic differences within an otherwise stable genome was responsible for the emergence of the late ST-23 complex strain type. The increase in serogroup Y meningococcal disease during this period presented the opportunity to investigate differences in disease-causing isolates in a relatively stable human population, thereby minimizing the confounding effects caused by population differences. The goal of this study was to identify differences that may explain clonal emergence and the cyclical nature of meningococcal disease. In addition, this study identified conserved antigens that could be investigated as potential vaccine candidates. To be responsible for the emergence of the late strain type, the differences found between the sequenced genomes of the early and late strain type must be found in the population of isolates from the time period of emergence, not just in the sequenced genomes. Therefore, we investigated target genes in isolates selected from early and late strain type populations. While some genes showed consistent allelic differences between early and late strain type population isolates, some did not. These results contribute to our understanding of which genes may be important in clonal emergence in N. meningitidis.
Materials and Methods
Selection and Characterization of Study Isolates
The study isolates were obtained from the Maryland Active Bacterial Core surveillance (ABCs) site, which conducts active, population- and laboratory-based surveillance for meningococcal infection throughout Maryland and is a component of the multistate Emerging Infections Program Network . Early and late strain type ST-23 complex serogroup Y isolates were characterized by PFGE, MLST, and OMP genotyping as previously described , . The early and late populations both contained one predominant PFGE type, so a representative isolate from each PFGE type was selected for whole genome sequencing. The date of isolation for the early strain type isolate (NM220) was June 1999 and for the late strain type isolate (NM233) was October 1999; dates of isolation were proximate by design. Both early and late profile isolates caused disease throughout the 1990s. Isolates for sequencing were chosen from the period with a peak in incidence. The proportion of disease caused by late profile isolates relative to early profile isolates was steady at this time but the incidence of disease caused by early strain type isolates was decreasing. NM220 (ST-23) and NM233 (ST-1621) are both from clonal complex 23 (ST-1621 is a single locus variant of ST-23).
To determine if gene differences between NM220 and NM233 were representative of the wider populations of disease-causing isolates, we selected 8 early strain type isolates and 8 late strain type isolates. Strains were chosen to be temporally similar between the early and late populations.
DNA was prepared by phenol-chloroform extraction from overnight cultures of isolated colonies grown on chocolate agar. Pyrosequencing using a GS-20 sequencer followed by assembly using the Newbler program (Roche) were accomplished by 454 Life Sciences and resulted in draft genomes. The average depth of coverage for all contigs was 22 for the early strain type and 27 for the late strain type (see Table 1). Other general features of the genomes are summarized in Table 1. A second round of pyrosequencing was accomplished using a 3kb paired end protocol. ORFs from the second sequencing were not manually curated, except for verification of selected differences. Genomes were compared between new and old sequences to identify regions missed in initial sequencing and to verify SNP differences. Missing regions were predominantly located in transposases and repeat regions.
PCR and Sanger sequencing were used as needed for resolution of homopolymer differences and verification of relevant insertions, deletions and point mutations, using primers designed from the whole genome sequences. Primers for amplification and sequencing of gene targets in the early and late strain type populations were obtained from the literature or were designed from whole genome sequences.
Prediction and annotation of open reading frames (ORFs) was accomplished using a suite of automated tools combining Glimmer gene prediction ,  and ORF and non-ORF feature identification (e.g. protein motifs) using tRNAscan-SE , RNAmmer , hmmpfam , , blastp , SignalP , prosite , LipoP , and tmhmm . Automated functional annotation based on database matches was followed by automated annotation improvement through mummer-based  mapping from the published MC58 genome . When a frameshift/point mutation was identified, the start and stop site coordinates were adjusted to encompass the entire gene. Since 454 sequencing causes frameshifts, many of the frameshifts are unlikely to be real. Therefore, where possible for the construction of orthologous clusters, the genes were translated excluding the frameshifted base(s) using a blast based algorithm implemented in Manatee [manatee.sourceforge.net]. ORFs of <50 aa in length and lacking functional evidence were removed from the genome if they were overlapping genes with functional annotation or known repeats (e.g. Correia repeats) or if they lacked an appropriate third position skew. Annotations were improved by using MugsyAnnotator  and manual curation using Manatee on the ortholog clusters.
Two methods were used to predict orthologous genes across the two serogroup Y genomes and all published N. meningitidis genomes , , , , . First, Jaccard ortholog clusters (JOCs) were obtained from bi-directional best blastp matches . JOCs are based solely on protein homology and do not utilize available information about gene synteny. Therefore, MugsyAnnotator was used to identify a second set of orthologs using whole genome alignment to better identify orthologs with conserved synteny . The conservation of ortholog clusters across the various genomes analyzed was determined using Sybil, a web-based software package for comparative genomics , as described previously , , . Since 454 draft genomes are prone to errors in homopolymers and many neisserial genes are known to be phase-variable, ORFs were not considered to be different if their amino acid sequences differed only because of a frameshift in a homopolymer or phase-variable region. With phase-variation, such differences would be characteristic of the individual isolates in culture and would not reflect differences in the population of strains. Due to the draft nature of the early and late strain type genomes, some repeat regions and genes such as transposases which occur in multiple copies within a genome were not resolved and were excluded from analysis. All well-resolved ORFs were compared between early and late strain type genomes, including, but not limited to, known antigens and potential antigens, which were defined as ORFs having lipoprotein attachment sites and/or signal sequences.
ClustalW2  (http://www.ebi.ac.uk/Tools/msa/clustalw2/) was used for further investigation of nucleotide and amino acid sequence alignments. An unrooted phylogenetic network was created by aligning the genomes with Mugsy, using all of the positions present in all 22 available N. meningitidis genomes (1,535,077 bp) to determine the phylogenetic network with the NeighborNet algorithm using SplitsTree4 .
πS (number of synonymous changes per synonymous site) and πN (number of non-synonymous changes per non-synonymous site) for all ORFs were calculated using codeml in the PAML package  from within IDEA . Input nucleotide alignments were generated by using the EMBOSS tranalign tool  on the protein alignments of the clusters as generated by Muscle . Average πS and πN was calculated for the set of all genes, not just those with differences.
ORFs from 20 other available sequenced genomes  were compared to predicted ORFS of NM220 and NM233 genomes. Available genomes were grouped by clonal complex for comparison (Table S1). Absence of ORFs not meeting the previously described limits for orthologs was validated using Standalone BLAST against the nucleotide sequence of NM220 and NM233. Only ORFs not identified as orthologs and not found by Standalone BLAST analysis, with criteria of ≥80% nucleotide identity and ≥50% coverage were considered to be absent from the serogroup Y genomes.
Nucleotide Sequence Accession Numbers
This Whole Genome Shotgun project has been deposited at DDBJ/EMBL/GenBank under the accession AGRQ00000000, AGRR00000000. The version described in this paper is the first version, AGRQ01000000, AGRR01000000. The following additional sequences for these genomes have also been deposited in GenBank: NM220 pilC1 (JN681261), pilC2 (JN681262), pilE/pilS (JN681263); NM233 hpuA (JN681260), pilE/pilS (JN681264).
General Features of Sequenced Genomes
The two study serogroup Y genomes were similar in size and G+C content to previously sequenced neisserial genomes (Table 1). Differences in gene content between the serogroup Y genomes and the aggregate for each clonal complex ranged from 60 to 130 ORFs. The majority of gene differences were found in genes annotated as encoding hypothetical proteins, conserved hypothetical proteins, putative proteins, restriction modification systems, and phage-related proteins. Some genes were found in a majority of non-serogroup Y genomes. These include the genes nadA, tspB, and the hemoglobin receptor gene hmbR. Some representative genes found in a majority of other genomes but missing in the serogroup Y genomes are listed in Table 2. Both serogroup Y genomes lack the islands of horizontal transfer PNM1 (20 ORFs), IHT-C (30 ORFs) and IHT-E (19 ORFs), which contain genes encoding mainly hypothetical proteins, phage related proteins, and a transposon , . Only five genes were found in the serogroup Y genomes but not in any other sequenced genomes (Table 3).
Genetic Similarity between Early and Late Strain Types
Overall, the two genomes were highly related (Figure 1). Of 1776 shared ORFs, 1231 showed 100% amino acid identity, with a further 319 having between 99% and 100% identity. In contrast, a comparison including the genomes MC58, Z2491, 053442, FAM18, alpha14, and N1568 yielded 1490 shared ORFs, with 80 exhibiting 100% identity and an additional 538 having between 99 and 100% amino acid identity. Overall, NM220 (early strain type) and NM223 (late strain type) had 13,950 SNPs, excluding insertions and deletions that cannot be systematically examined as these are draft genomes with sequencing gaps in different locations. Repeat pyrosequencing resulted in confirmation of 10,317 SNP differences between NM220 and NM233. Not all SNPs were resolved, including regions present in one genome but missing from the other. Alignment of nucleotide sequences of the early strain type, the late strain type and a subset of other available sequenced genomes showed a high level of nucleotide conservation between the early and late strains (Figure S1). A phylogenetic network showed the early strain type and late strain type as most closely related among all currently available sequenced meningococcal genomes (Figure 2), with the serogroup Y genomes clustering in a branch not closely related to other genomes. Values for πN and πS were low over a majority of the genomes (Figures 1 and 3) with average πN = 0.0033 and average πS = 0.0216. No non-synonymous changes were found in 1238 shared ORFs and no synonymous changes were found in 1195 shared ORFs. ORFs with the highest πN and πS included antigens, predicted membrane proteins, hypothetical proteins and housekeeping genes (Table 4).
Ordered from outermost to innermost, the rims show: rim 1 (plus strand) and rim 2 (minus strand), predicted coding regions, colored by role category; rim 3, SNP density; rim 4, πN, plotted from 0 (base of rim) to 0.1; rim 5, πS, plotted 0 (base of rim) to 0.5. Role category colors are: amino acid biosynthesis, violet; biosynthesis of cofactors, prosthetic groups and carriers, light blue; cell envelope, light green; cellular processes, red; central intermediary metabolism, brown; disrupted reading frame, black; DNA metabolism, gold; energy metabolism, light gray; fatty acid and phospholipid metabolism, magenta; hypothetical proteins, black; mobile and extrachromosomal element functions, cyan; protein fate, pink; protein synthesis, pink; purines, pyrimidines, nucleosides and nucleotides, orange; regulatory functions, olive; signal transduction, olive; transcription, dark green; transport and binding proteins, blue-green; unknown function, gray; viral functions, gray. SNP density: pink, 0 SNPs per kbp; yellow, 1–25 SNPs per kbp; red, 26–50 SNPs per kbp; green, 51–75 SNPs per kbp; blue, 76–155 SNPs per kbp.
Tree produced using SplitsTree. Other genomes include: GB013, 053442, 961–5945, NZ05/33, CU385, M01-240355, M01-240149, M13399, M04-240196, H44/76, N1568, M6190, Z2491, G2136, M0579, FAM18, MC58, OX99-30304, alpha14, and ES14902.
Vaccine Candidates and Conserved Antigens
Three proteins, factor H binding protein (FHbp), neisserial heparin binding antigen (NhbA), and NadA have been investigated as targets for vaccines against serogroup B disease , . The genes encoding FHbp are identical in the early and late strain types (Table S2) while the genes for NhbA exhibited 99.8% predicted amino acid identity, with only 2 predicted amino acid changes (Table S3). In both genomes the gene encoding the protein product NadA is missing and that section of the genome contains the sequence 5′-TTTCCATTCCAAACGC-3′. This situation has been described in other NadA deficient strains . Lipoprotein prediction based on sequence identified a total of 73 shared lipoprotein ORFs in the early and late strain types. Forty-three of the shared predicted lipoprotein ORFs had 100% nucleotide and amino acid identity between the early and late strain types (Table S2) and three others had only synonymous nucleotide changes (Table S3). Comparison of the amino acid identity of the conserved lipoproteins with 100% nucleotide identity, across the twenty additional genomes which have been completely sequenced, showed that the majority were highly conserved across those genomes. These highly conserved lipoproteins may be of interest as further vaccine candidates should they be found to elicit an appropriate immune response.
The gene encoding the antigenic outer membrane protein PorB had the highest πN and πS in the early strain type/late strain type comparison (πN = 0.2789, πS = 1.2413). Other antigens with relatively high πN and/or πS included lactoferrin binding protein B (LbpB) and PilV (Table 4).
PorA, PorB, FetA
In a previous study, we demonstrated differences in deduced PorA variable regions (VR1 and VR2), PorB loops V and VII, and FetA VR . Comparison of entire sequences of these proteins showed additional changes. The predicted amino acid sequence of late strain type PorA contained 6 amino acid changes relative to the early strain type sequence, in addition to those previously reported. PorB sequences exhibited more extensive differences, with the predicted amino acid sequence containing 5 amino acid insertions and 93 amino acid substitutions in addition to those previously reported in loops V and VII (Figure S2). Late strain type FetA contained 1 amino acid deletion and 20 amino acid substitutions in addition to those previously reported in the variable region .
Lipoproteins and Proteins with Signal Sequences
The early and late strain type genomes contained 456 shared ORFs which are potential antigens based upon predicted lipoprotein attachment sites and/or predicted signal sequences. Of 73 shared lipoproteins, 27 exhibited amino acid differences (Table S3). Of the 383 ORFs with signal sequences but no lipoprotein attachment sites, only 68 had ≤99% amino acid identity. The majority of these ORFs were associated with the cell envelope (22) or with transport and binding (17), based on their gene role category. Differences were found in the iron acquisition and uptake lipoproteins LbpB (Figure S3) and hemoglobin-haptoglobin utilization protein A (HpuA) (Figure S4). The putative lipoprotein and suggested vaccine target Ag473  contains a 21 nt tandem repeat with a 2 repeat difference between early and late strain type, resulting in a 14 aa insertion in the late strain type predicted protein. Differences were also noted in the non-lipoprotein iron acquisition and uptake proteins transferrin binding protein A (TbpA), transferrin binding protein B (TbpB), and lactoferrin binding protein A (LbpA) (Table S3).
Pilus Structure and Assembly
N. meningitidis has type IV pili (Tfp) which are polymers whose major subunit is the protein product of the highly variable pilE gene , . Due to the highly repetitive nature of this section of the genomes, initial sequences were fragmentary. Further 454 sequencing of this region indicated that the pilS regions of the early strain type and the late strain type were nearly identical over part of the sequence. However, the early strain type contained fewer pilS cassettes (3 cassettes, the late strain type contains 5 cassettes) and the pilS region of the late strain type contained a putative IS1160-like transposase between the fourth and fifth pilS cassettes (GenBank accession numbers JN681263, JN681264). The sequence of the pilE gene was similar between the early and late strain types over the C-terminal half but highly dissimilar at the N-terminus. The late strain type transposase was only partially resolved and further sequencing was not undertaken.
The predicted pilus adhesin, PilC1 (GenBank accession number JN681261and NMY233_1622) exhibited 84% amino acid similarity between the early strain type and the late strain type (Figure S5). Minor pilin PilV is encoded in the early and late population strains by the genes NMY220_0548 and NMY233_0521, respectively. The predicted PilV amino acid identity between the early strain type and the late strain type is 91.5%, with differences in 22 of the total 130 amino acids. The genes bounding the pilV locus have ≥ 98% nucleotide identity and ≥ 99% amino acid identity between the two strain types, indicating that this gene may have participated in horizontal gene transfer.
The early strain type contained the PglB form of the pilin glycosylation B locus (NMY220_1618) while the late strain type contained PglB2 (NMY233_1594). In the late strain type, PglB2 was immediately followed by a conserved hypothetical protein (NMY233_1595) of unknown function  not found in the early strain type.
Genes Found Exclusively in Early or Late Strain Type
The early strain type and late strain type each contained genes not found in the other genome (Table S4). The majority of these genes encoded hypothetical proteins, putative lipoproteins or putative membrane proteins. The late strain type contained two genes encoding proteins with significant similarity to proteins with experimentally verified functions: zitB (NMY233_0596), which encodes a predicted cation-efflux facilitator family protein, and a gene encoding a rubredoxin (NMY233_0921).
Serogroup Y Clonal Complex 23 Population Results
To determine whether the differences identified in the single sequenced early and late strain type isolates were characteristic of the larger population of isolates, ten gene targets were investigated in eight early strain type and eight late strain type population isolates. The early strain type and late strain type population isolates were consistent with NM220 and NM233 in gene content for pglB and pglB2, zitB, and rubredoxin (Table 5, presence or absence by PCR). The sequenced alleles of hpuA in the population strains were also identical to the NM220 and NM233 alleles by strain type (all early strain type matched NM220, all late strain type matched NM233), as were the alleles for pilV. Tandem repeat differences in ag473 were maintained in population isolates, except for one early strain type isolate that had a single tandem repeat, and thus did not match either the early or late strain type. Late strain type population lbpB alleles were identical to the NM233 allele. Among the early strain type isolates, five lbpB alleles were identical to the NM220 allele but NM109, NM115 and NM206 had an allele that differed from both NM220 and NM233. All late strain type tbpB alleles were identical. Early strain type isolates contained three alleles for tbpB, all of which differed from the alleles found in either NM220 or NM233, and two isolates failed to amplify that locus.
NM220 and NM233 contained different alleles for three pilin-associated genes pilH, pilI, and pilJ. The population of early strain type isolates contained the late strain type allele except for 2 isolates (isolated in 1998 and 2001), which contained the early strain type alleles.
Some studies have compared whole neisserial genomes in an attempt to elucidate the basis for differences in invasiveness and pathogenicity , . Other than the presence of a capsule and the production of endotoxin, no definitive requirements for virulence and pathogenicity have been found. All sequenced genomes differ in gene content from each other; the absolute number of differences is understandably greater in strains from different clonal complexes. Even within a clonal complex, some genes are present in some strains but not in all. Some of these variably present genes are phage-related and their presence/absence may reflect evolutionary distance since the time of phage acquisition. Many other variably present genes are annotated as encoding hypothetical proteins, with insufficient similarity to well-characterized genes to allow prediction of function.
A phylogenetic tree of genetic relatedness of early strain type, late strain type and 20 available sequenced meningococcal genomes indicates that the serogroup Y strains are most closely related to each other and they cluster in a branch not closely related to other sequenced genomes. The serogroup Y strains in this study differ in gene content from other sequenced genomes in the same way as other sequenced genomes differ from each other, that is, mainly in phage-related genes and in gene encoding hypothetical proteins. Most notably, the serogroup Y genomes are missing the genes located in the putative islands of horizontal transfer PNM1, IHT-C and IHT-E, all of which appear to be of phage origin. It has been suggested that these genes contribute to virulence and pathogenicity, but their actual roles are currently unknown , .
Closely related strains that differ in their ability to cause disease are ideal for investigating the genetic factors that contribute to that ability to cause disease . An analogous situation is presented in the case of replacement of one invasive strain by another over time, where the analysis involves determination of factors responsible for the decrease in incidence of the earlier strain and increase in incidence of the later strain. In this study, we used pyrosequencing to obtain draft genomes of two closely related clonal complex 23 meningococcal strains from Maryland: one whose ST, OMP profile and PFGE profile were representative of a strain causing disease in the early 1990s and one with a different OMP and PFGE profile which was responsible for disease later in that decade . The early and late strains exhibited antigenic differences which can be postulated to have contributed to the decline of the early strain type and the emergence of the late strain type.
The majority of ORFs in the two genomes had few or no mutations, leading to an overall low level of πN and πS. The highest value of both πN and πS was found in the gene encoding PorB, which is known to be both immunogenic and highly variable. Other genes with relatively high πN and πS included those encoding PorA, FetA, PilV, LbpB, and HpuA. A number of housekeeping genes were represented among those with high πN and πS, including shikimate 5-dehydrogenase (aroE), one of the seven genes used for MLST. The late strain type is a single locus variant of ST-23; single locus variants are considered to have arisen by horizontal gene transfer if the variant allele exhibits extensive differences from the allele found in the parent sequence type. Therefore, the πN and πS values for shikimate 5-dehydrogenase can be used as a marker for horizontal gene transfer. Genes in the early and late genomes whose πN and πS are similar to that of aroE have likely been involved in horizontal gene transfer.
In addition to the overall low values of πN and πS, loci which differed between the early and late strain type genomes exhibited a surplus of πS over πN. This phenomenon has been documented in methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus and Clostridium difficile . Recent mutations show an excess of non-synonymous changes, which will be modified over time by the effects of selection. Alleles which result from horizontal gene transfer have a relative surplus of synonymous changes because in them, selection has already purged deleterious non-synonymous changes. The relative abundance of synonymous over non-synonymous changes in genes which differ between the early and late strains is another indication that these genes have been involved in horizontal gene transfer.
Given that both strain types caused similar rates of disease in the same population during different periods of the same decade, we did not expect major differences in virulence between them. Accordingly, our principal hypothesis was that emergence of the late strain type was primarily due to antigenic changes that allowed escape from population immunity. A number of proteins are known to be immunogenic in N. meningitidis and many others can be predicted to be immunogenic based upon their structure or their function. Our comparison of whole genomes found a preponderance of antigens unchanged but also found differences in a number of loci that contribute to the antigenic profile and these differences may have been instrumental in disease emergence. Genes exhibiting differences include antigenic outer membrane proteins, genes involved in pilus structure, function and glycosylation, and genes involved in iron acquisition and uptake. Differences in the genes encoding the antigens PorA, PorB, and FetA are more extensive than previously described . Additional antigens differing between the early and late strain types included putative lipoproteins and the vaccine target Ag473. Neisserial type IV pili (Tfp) are necessary for adhesion of bacterial cells to human mucosal cells and are major antigens . Differences were found in genes that can be expected to affect the Tfp antigen profile, including the major structural subunit PilE and in the pilus tip adhesin PilC . The pilH/I/J loci differed between early and late strains but most strains within the population tested contained the late strain type alleles. These loci may not have been involved in emergence of the late strain type. Alternatively, the late strain type alleles may have been acquired early in the genetic transformation of the early to late strain type. The presence of the early strain type alleles in isolates obtained in three different years (1998, 1999, and 2001) may imply persistence of a sub-population possessing those alleles or multiple instances of horizontal transfer. Pilin glycosylation is believed to be an important mechanism for decreasing immunogenicity of the pilin subunits by masking exposed areas of the protein. In N. meningitidis, the gene encoding pilin glycosylation protein B (PglB) has been documented to exist in 2 forms, pglB and pglB2 , , . The early strain type contains pglB, while the late strain type contains pglB2. Based upon the number and extent of differences in genes affecting the structure and function of the pilus, it can be theorized that these differences contributed to the change in disease epidemiology.
Iron acquisition and uptake are necessary for survival of N. meningitidis in the human host and iron is sequestered in a variety of forms, including lactoferrin, transferrin, and hemoglobin/haptoglobin. N. meningitidis has evolved mechanisms for obtaining iron from these sources using several two component systems. These systems are antigenic, as they require surface exposure to bind their substrates. In addition, they are highly variable, with different alleles found in otherwise similar strains during epidemics, invoking the concept of a “genocloud”, a combination of a dominant strain and its close relatives . The early and late strain type differed at genes encoding the main iron acquisition systems for lactoferrin, transferrin, and hemoglobin/haptoglobin. The alleles for these genes were consistent in a population of late strain type isolates. However, some early strain type isolates contained the late strain type allele for lbpB and the early strain type isolates contained multiple variants of tbpB, which did not match either the early or late allele. These results may indicate selection for recombinants at these loci in a population of isolates against which human immunity has developed.
We also identified genes encoding known and predicted lipoproteins that were highly similar or identical in the two genomes. Factor H binding protein (fHbp), neisserial heparin binding antigen (nhbA) and nadA have been identified as encoding possible targets for vaccines for prevention of serogroup B meningococcal disease as well as that caused by other serogroups , . The gene nadA was absent in the early and late strain type genomes, but fHbp and nhbA were highly conserved. This study found 46 other genes encoding predicted lipoproteins that were identical in amino acid sequence between the early and late strain types and an additional 20 with greater than 99% amino acid identity. The majority of the identical lipoproteins were also highly conserved across 20 sequenced genomes, suggesting that some of them may be appropriate for investigation as vaccine targets. Conservation of antigens may indicate that structural constraints based upon function limit variation in those proteins. Conserved antigens are superior vaccine candidates, since highly variable vaccine targets complicate vaccine formulation, requiring the inclusion of many variants. However, highly conserved antigens may be a disadvantage to the bacteria, since their conservation predicts that any immunity they engender will be broad and will therefore limit spread of many strains.
Only a few genes were found in one of the genomes sequenced in this study but not the other. The majority of these were hypothetical proteins, but some are predicted to be membrane associated and therefore possibly antigenic. The exact function and importance of these genes will require further investigation.
Sequencing of a single genome provides a complete picture of that particular genome but does not provide information on variations among a population of closely related strains. While some studies have sequenced multiple strains, the relationship of a sequenced genome to a wider population of similar strains is still relatively unexplored. Our results indicate that some genes differ even within isolates from a closely related population. The identity of these genes gives important insights into the ways in which N. meningitidis adapts to the immune response. Allelic variation of known antigens has been demonstrated by targeted Sanger sequencing, but this method requires prior knowledge of the targeted genes. The whole genome approach allows investigation of known targets but also facilitates identification of novel genes whose importance and even function has not previously been determined.
The existence of two strains that are close temporally and geographically, with a majority of genes identical but still some genes highly variant, accentuates the mosaic nature of the meningococcal genome and the ability of this bacterium to acquire new gene variants through horizontal gene transfer and to continue to cause invasive disease. The results of this study suggest that specific genes, mostly encoding antigens, were associated with and were potentially responsible for the expansion of serogroup Y disease. However, this study represents an ecological analysis which makes causality difficult to prove. Additional studies involving multiple examples of clonal emergence of N. meningitidis are needed to determine whether there are consistent antigenic features associated with meningococcal disease emergence.
Percent identity plots from Mugsy alignments of early strain type, late strain type, MC58, Z2491, 053442, FAM18, and alpha14 visualized using the GMAJ alignment viewer, with the early strain type genome as the reference. The horizontal axis shows nucleotide positions in the sequence. The vertical axis shows percentage of matching nucleotides at each position. Percent identity ranges from 50 (bottom) to 100 (top) percent in each row.
Alignment of predicted amino acid sequence of early strain type (upper sequence) and late strain type (lower sequence) PorB (NMY220_1828 and NMY233_1807) showing non-conserved amino acids. Boxes outline loops V (*) and VII (+), which were previously reported.
Alignment of predicted protein lactoferrin binding protein B (LbpB) showing non-conserved amino acids. Upper sequence early clone (NM220), lower sequence late strain type (NM233).
Alignment of predicted protein hemoglobin-haptoglobin utilization protein A (hpuA) showing non-conserved amino acids. Upper sequence early strain type (NM220), lower sequence late strain type (NM233).
Alignment of predicted protein PilC1, showing non-conserved amino acids. Upper sequence early strain type (NM220), lower sequence late strain type (NM233).
Lipoproteins exhibiting identical nucleotide and amino acid sequence in early and late clones and their amino acid identity across sequenced genomes.
Early clone (NM220) and late clone (NM233) differences in predicted outer membrane proteins, lipoproteins, proteins involved in pilus biogenesis and non-lipoproteins involved in iron acquisition and uptake.
We thank Samuel V. Angiuoli for the pre-publication use of MugsyAnnotator and Joana C. Silva for valuable advice and comments. We thank David Blythe, Rosemary Hollick, and the staff of the Maryland Active Bacterial Core surveillance (ABCs) site for assistance with meningococcal disease surveillance.
Conceived and designed the experiments: MGK JCDH JWM HT LHH. Performed the experiments: MGK JCDH. Analyzed the data: MGK JCDH. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: MK JCDH DRR SCD NEM LWM. Wrote the paper: MGK JCDH JWM LHH. Reviewed the manuscript: MGK JCDH DRR SCD JWM NEM LWM HT LHH.
- 1. Harrison LH, Trotter CL, Ramsay ME (2009) Global epidemiology of meningococcal disease. Vaccine 27: Suppl 2B51–63.
- 2. Harrison LH, Jolley KA, Shutt KA, Marsh JW, O'Leary M, et al. (2006) Antigenic shift and increased incidence of meningococcal disease. J Infect Dis 193: 1266–1274.
- 3. Jackson LA, Wenger JD (1993) Laboratory-based surveillance for meningococcal disease in selected areas, United States, 1989–1991. MMWR CDC Surveill Summ 42: 21–30.
- 4. Rosenstein NE, Perkins BA, Stephens DS, Lefkowitz L, Cartter ML, et al. (1999) The changing epidemiology of meningococcal disease in the United States, 1992–1996. J Infect Dis 180: 1894–1901.
- 5. McEllistrem MC, Kolano JA, Pass MA, Caugant DA, Mendelsohn AB, et al. (2004) Correlating epidemiologic trends with the genotypes causing meningococcal disease, Maryland. Emerg Infect Dis 10: 451–456.
- 6. Achtman M (1995) Epidemic spread and antigenic variability of Neisseria meningitidis. Trends Microbiol 3: 186–192.
- 7. Leimkugel J, Hodgson A, Forgor AA, Pfluger V, Dangy JP, et al. (2007) Clonal waves of Neisseria colonisation and disease in the African meningitis belt: eight- year longitudinal study in northern Ghana. PLoS Med 4: e101.
- 8. Moore PS (1992) Meningococcal meningitis in sub-Saharan Africa: a model for the epidemic process. Clin Infect Dis 14: 515–525.
- 9. Chiou AC, Andrade SS, Almeida SC, Zanella RC, Andrade AL, et al. (2008) Molecular assessment of invasive Streptococcus pneumoniae serotype 1 in Brazil: evidence of clonal replacement. J Med Microbiol 57: 839–844.
- 10. Gupta S, Maiden MC, Feavers IM, Nee S, May RM, et al. (1996) The maintenance of strain structure in populations of recombining infectious agents. Nat Med 2: 437–442.
- 11. Schuchat A, Hilger T, Zell E, Farley MM, Reingold A, et al. (2001) Active bacterial core surveillance of the emerging infections program network. Emerg Infect Dis 7: 92–99.
- 12. Salzberg S, Delcher AL, Fasman KH, Henderson J (1998) A decision tree system for finding genes in DNA. J Comput Biol 5: 667–680.
- 13. Delcher AL, Harmon D, Kasif S, White O, Salzberg SL (1999) Improved microbial gene identification with GLIMMER. Nucleic Acids Res 27: 4636–4641.
- 14. Lowe TM, Eddy SR (1997) tRNAscan-SE: a program for improved detection of transfer RNA genes in genomic sequence. Nucleic Acids Res 25: 955–964.
- 15. Lagesen K, Hallin P, Rodland EA, Staerfeldt HH, Rognes T, et al. (2007) RNAmmer: consistent and rapid annotation of ribosomal RNA genes. Nucleic Acids Res 35: 3100–3108.
- 16. Eddy SR (1998) Profile hidden Markov models. Bioinformatics 14: 755–763.
- 17. Krogh A, Mian IS, Haussler D (1994) A hidden Markov model that finds genes in E. coli DNA. Nucleic Acids Res 22: 4768–4778.
- 18. Altschul SF, Gish W, Miller W, Myers EW, Lipman DJ (1990) Basic local alignment search tool. J Mol Biol 215: 403–410.
- 19. Bendtsen JD, Nielsen H, von Heijne G, Brunak S (2004) Improved prediction of signal peptides: SignalP 3.0. J Mol Biol 340: 783–795.
- 20. Falquet L, Pagni M, Bucher P, Hulo N, Sigrist CJ, et al. (2002) The PROSITE database, its status in 2002. Nucleic Acids Res 30: 235–238.
- 21. Juncker AS, Willenbrock H, Von Heijne G, Brunak S, Nielsen H, et al. (2003) Prediction of lipoprotein signal peptides in Gram-negative bacteria. Protein Sci 12: 1652–1662.
- 22. Krogh A, Larsson B, von Heijne G, Sonnhammer EL (2001) Predicting transmembrane protein topology with a hidden Markov model: application to complete genomes. J Mol Biol 305: 567–580.
- 23. Delcher AL, Salzberg SL, Phillippy AM (2003) Using MUMmer to identify similar regions in large sequence sets. Curr Protoc Bioinformatics Chapter 10: Unit 10 13:
- 24. Tettelin H, Saunders NJ, Heidelberg J, Jeffries AC, Nelson KE, et al. (2000) Complete genome sequence of Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B strain MC58. Science 287: 1809–1815.
- 25. Angiuoli SV, Dunning Hotopp JC, Salzberg SL, Tettelin H (2011) Improving pan-genome annotation using whole genome multiple alignment. BMC Bioinformatics 12: 272.
- 26. Schoen C, Blom J, Claus H, Schramm-Gluck A, Brandt P, et al. (2008) Whole-genome comparison of disease and carriage strains provides insights into virulence evolution in Neisseria meningitidis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 105: 3473–3478.
- 27. Parkhill J, Achtman M, James KD, Bentley SD, Churcher C, et al. (2000) Complete DNA sequence of a serogroup A strain of Neisseria meningitidis Z2491. Nature 404: 502–506.
- 28. Peng J, Yang L, Yang F, Yang J, Yan Y, et al. (2008) Characterization of ST-4821 complex, a unique Neisseria meningitidis clone. Genomics 91: 78–87.
- 29. Budroni S, Siena E, Hotopp JC, Seib KL, Serruto D, et al. (2011) Neisseria meningitidis is structured in clades associated with restriction modification systems that modulate homologous recombination. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 108: 4494–4499.
- 30. Crabtree J, Angiuoli SV, Wortman JR, White OR (2007) Sybil: methods and software for multiple genome comparison and visualization. Methods Mol Biol 408: 93–108.
- 31. Riley DR, Angiuoli SV, Crabtree J, Dunning Hotopp JC, Tettelin H (2011) Using Sybil for interactive comparative genomics of microbes on the web. Bioinformatics.
- 32. Dunning Hotopp JC, Lin M, Madupu R, Crabtree J, Angiuoli SV, et al. (2006) Comparative genomics of emerging human ehrlichiosis agents. PLoS Genet 2: e21.
- 33. Tettelin H, Masignani V, Cieslewicz MJ, Donati C, Medini D, et al. (2005) Genome analysis of multiple pathogenic isolates of Streptococcus agalactiae: implications for the microbial "pan-genome". Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 102: 13950–13955.
- 34. Chenna R, Sugawara H, Koike T, Lopez R, Gibson TJ, et al. (2003) Multiple sequence alignment with the Clustal series of programs. Nucleic Acids Res 31: 3497–3500.
- 35. Huson DH, Bryant D (2006) Application of phylogenetic networks in evolutionary studies. Mol Biol Evol 23: 254–267.
- 36. Yang Z (2007) PAML 4: phylogenetic analysis by maximum likelihood. Mol Biol Evol 24: 1586–1591.
- 37. Egan A, Mahurkar A, Crabtree J, Badger JH, Carlton JM, et al. (2008) IDEA: Interactive Display for Evolutionary Analyses. BMC Bioinformatics 9: 524.
- 38. Rice P, Longden I, Bleasby A (2000) EMBOSS: the European Molecular Biology Open Software Suite. Trends Genet 16: 276–277.
- 39. Edgar RC (2004) MUSCLE: multiple sequence alignment with high accuracy and high throughput. Nucleic Acids Res 32: 1792–1797.
- 40. Dunning Hotopp JC, Grifantini R, Kumar N, Tzeng YL, Fouts D, et al. (2006) Comparative genomics of Neisseria meningitidis: core genome, islands of horizontal transfer and pathogen-specific genes. Microbiology 152: 3733–3749.
- 41. Pizza M, Scarlato V, Masignani V, Giuliani MM, Arico B, et al. (2000) Identification of vaccine candidates against serogroup B meningococcus by whole-genome sequencing. Science 287: 1816–1820.
- 42. Jiang HQ, Hoiseth SK, Harris SL, McNeil LK, Zhu D, et al. (2010) Broad vaccine coverage predicted for a bivalent recombinant factor H binding protein based vaccine to prevent serogroup B meningococcal disease. Vaccine 28: 6086–6093.
- 43. Comanducci M, Bambini S, Brunelli B, Adu-Bobie J, Arico B, et al. (2002) NadA, a novel vaccine candidate of Neisseria meningitidis. J Exp Med 195: 1445–1454.
- 44. Hsu CA, Lin WR, Li JC, Liu YL, Tseng YT, et al. (2008) Immunoproteomic identification of the hypothetical protein NMB1468 as a novel lipoprotein ubiquitous in Neisseria meningitidis with vaccine potential. Proteomics 8: 2115–2125.
- 45. Cehovin A, Winterbotham M, Lucidarme J, Borrow R, Tang CM, et al. (2010) Sequence conservation of pilus subunits in Neisseria meningitidis. Vaccine 28: 4817–4826.
- 46. Carbonnelle E, Helaine S, Nassif X, Pelicic V (2006) A systematic genetic analysis in Neisseria meningitidis defines the Pil proteins required for assembly, functionality, stabilization and export of type IV pili. Mol Microbiol 61: 1510–1522.
- 47. Kahler CM, Blum E, Miller YK, Ryan D, Popovic T, et al. (2001) exl, an exchangeable genetic island in Neisseria meningitidis. Infect Immun 69: 1687–1696.
- 48. Bennett JS, Bentley SD, Vernikos GS, Quail MA, Cherevach I, et al. (2010) Independent evolution of the core and accessory gene sets in the genus Neisseria: insights gained from the genome of Neisseria lactamica isolate 020–06. BMC Genomics 11: 652.
- 49. Joseph B, Schwarz RF, Linke B, Blom J, Becker A, et al. (2011) Virulence evolution of the human pathogen Neisseria meningitidis by recombination in the core and accessory genome. PLoS One 6: e18441.
- 50. Didelot X, Urwin R, Maiden MC, Falush D (2009) Genealogical typing of Neisseria meningitidis. Microbiology 155: 3176–3186.
- 51. Castillo-Ramirez S, Harris SR, Holden MT, He M, Parkhill J, et al. (2011) The Impact of Recombination on dN/dS within Recently Emerged Bacterial Clones. PLoS Pathog 7: e1002129.
- 52. Nassif X, Lowy J, Stenberg P, O'Gaora P, Ganji A, et al. (1993) Antigenic variation of pilin regulates adhesion of Neisseria meningitidis to human epithelial cells. Mol Microbiol 8: 719–725.
- 53. Rudel T, Scheurerpflug I, Meyer TF (1995) Neisseria PilC protein identified as type-4 pilus tip-located adhesin. Nature 373: 357–359.
- 54. Power PM, Roddam LF, Dieckelmann M, Srikhanta YN, Tan YC, et al. (2000) Genetic characterization of pilin glycosylation in Neisseria meningitidis. Microbiology 146 ( Pt 4): 967–979.
- 55. Power PM, Roddam LF, Rutter K, Fitzpatrick SZ, Srikhanta YN, et al. (2003) Genetic characterization of pilin glycosylation and phase variation in Neisseria meningitidis. Mol Microbiol 49: 833–847.
- 56. Zhu P, van der Ende A, Falush D, Brieske N, Morelli G, et al. (2001) Fit genotypes and escape variants of subgroup III Neisseria meningitidis during three pandemics of epidemic meningitis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 98: 5234–5239.