5 Apr 2012: Dalmasso M, Aubert J, Briard-Bion V, Chuat V, Deutsch SM, et al. (2012) Correction: A Temporal -omic Study of Propionibacterium freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T Adaptation Strategies in Conditions Mimicking Cheese Ripening in the Cold. PLOS ONE 7(4): 10.1371/annotation/e0ff065d-a52d-44f2-8727-328393ed60b6. https://doi.org/10.1371/annotation/e0ff065d-a52d-44f2-8727-328393ed60b6 View correction
Propionibacterium freudenreichii is used as a ripening culture in Swiss cheese manufacture. It grows when cheeses are ripened in a warm room (about 24°C). Cheeses with an acceptable eye formation level are transferred to a cold room (about 4°C), inducing a marked slowdown of propionic fermentation, but P. freudenreichii remains active in the cold. To investigate the P. freudenreichii strategies of adaptation and survival in the cold, we performed the first global gene expression profile for this species. The time-course transcriptomic response of P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T strain was analyzed at five times of incubation, during growth at 30°C then for 9 days at 4°C, under conditions preventing nutrient starvation. Gene expression was also confirmed by RT-qPCR for 28 genes. In addition, proteomic experiments were carried out and the main metabolites were quantified. Microarray analysis revealed that 565 genes (25% of the protein-coding sequences of P. freudenreichii genome) were differentially expressed during transition from 30°C to 4°C (P<0.05 and |fold change|>1). At 4°C, a general slowing down was observed for genes implicated in the cell machinery. On the contrary, P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T strain over-expressed genes involved in lactate, alanine and serine conversion to pyruvate, in gluconeogenesis, and in glycogen synthesis. Interestingly, the expression of different genes involved in the formation of important cheese flavor compounds, remained unchanged at 4°C. This could explain the contribution of P. freudenreichii to cheese ripening even in the cold. In conclusion, P. freudenreichii remains metabolically active at 4°C and induces pathways to maintain its long-term survival.
Citation: Dalmasso M, Aubert J, Briard-Bion V, Chuat V, Deutsch S-M, Even S, et al. (2012) A Temporal -omic Study of Propionibacterium freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T Adaptation Strategies in Conditions Mimicking Cheese Ripening in the Cold. PLoS ONE 7(1): e29083. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0029083
Editor: Jack Anthony Gilbert, Argonne National Laboratory, United States of America
Received: August 2, 2011; Accepted: November 21, 2011; Published: January 13, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Dalmasso et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Along with Tekes, INRA (French National Institute for Agricultural Research) and Valio Ltd supported this study. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. No additional external funding was received for this study.
Competing interests: The authors have the following competing interest to declare. Jarna Tanskanen is an employee of Valio Ltd. There are no patents, products in development or marketed products to declare. This does not alter the authors' adherence to all the PLoS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Micro-organisms have a determining contribution to the formation of the typical flavor and texture characteristics of each cheese variety. The metabolism of lactic starters and of adjunct ripening cultures has mainly been studied in conditions mimicking their growth in milk and in cheese. More recently, studies have specifically focused on the metabolism of non-growing bacteria under the sub-optimal conditions prevailing in cheese. They showed that bacterial metabolism is markedly modified by cheese conditions, like starvation and low temperatures. Bacteria expressed genes associated with specific metabolic pathways that could also contribute to the ripening process –.
Propionibacterium freudenreichii is widely used in Swiss cheese manufacture for its key contribution to the formation of the characteristic holes (or “eyes”) and flavor during the ripening of this cheese variety . Different combinations of time and temperature are applied during the ripening of Swiss cheeses, according to the manufacturers' practices. Typically, cheeses are ripened for 2–3 weeks at 10–14°C, then in a warm room (20–24°C) until the cheeses have enough holes, and are finally transferred to a cold room (4–6°C). P. freudenreichii grows during the ripening in the warm room with populations reaching stable levels over 109 colony-forming units (cfu)/g . It converts the lactate produced by lactic acid bacteria into propionate, acetate and CO2. Propionic fermentation mainly occurs in the warm room and is markedly slowed down in the cold room. However, P. freudenreichii is known to remain active during the storage of cheese at 4°C, as recently shown by real time reverse transcription PCR . In particular, it goes on producing some flavor compounds in the cold, like short branched-chain acids from branched-chain amino acids catabolism, and free fatty acids from milk fat hydrolysis . The aim of the present study was to better understand how P. freudenreichii copes with cold-induced stress and remains active when cheeses are transferred to the cold room. This study was performed under conditions mimicking Swiss cheese ripening, by applying for the first time a whole genome transcriptomic approach to P. freudenreichii. Transcriptomics and other -omic approaches have increasingly been used over the last few years to provide a comprehensive view of microorganism physiology in various research areas. For example, the transcriptomic response of the starter bacterium Lactococcus lactis has recently been studied in conditions mimicking cheese manufacture .
The time-course transcriptomic response of P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T strain was analyzed during its growth at 30°C, then during a further 9 days at 4°C. In addition, temporal changes in the proteome and extracellular metabolome were monitored. Our results show that P. freudenreichii under-expresses many genes involved in cell machinery in the cold, but remains active, redirecting its carbon metabolism towards glycogen accumulation. Interestingly, some genes involved in the formation of important flavor compounds of cheese were not significantly affected in the cold. These results highlight the contribution of P. freudenreichii to the formation of flavor compounds even at low ripening temperatures. Thus, our data provides insights into the strategies used by P. freudenreichii to adapt to a low temperature and to maintain its long-term survival.
Results and Discussion
Experimental conditions mimicking cheese ripening
In cheeses stored at cold temperatures, P. freudenreichii stops growing, slows down propionic fermentation, but it remains active  and continues to produce some metabolites . To better understand how P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T copes with cold-induced stress when cheeses are transferred to the cold room, an -omic approach was applied. The culture conditions were chosen to mimic the medium and the temperature-shift withstood by P. freudenreichii during Swiss cheese ripening.
During Swiss cheese ripening, P. freudenreichii grows in the absence of carbohydrates since all the lactose of milk is converted to lactate by lactic starters within the first day of cheesemaking . Lactate is used as the main carbon source by P. freudenreichii and is available until the end of ripening , , . The Swiss cheese aqueous phase is a rich medium, in which the soluble nitrogen matter increases during ripening from about 20 g/kg to 50–150 g/kg, with a proportion of free amino acids reaching up to 50% . To mimic cheese conditions, bacteria were grown in a rich medium (YEL ) containing lactate (130 mM) as carbon source and high amounts of soluble nitrogen matter (Table S1), and as follows: at 30°C for 40 h, lactate was then added to prevent its exhaustion, and the cultures were further incubated for 9 days at 4°C (Fig. 1A). Preliminary experiments showed that, in YEL medium, either containing twice as much initial lactate content (260 mM instead of 130 mM), or supplemented with 130 mM lactate during incubation, P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T continued, or started growing again at the same rate if the temperature was maintained at 30°C, and consumed all the available lactate (Fig.S1). These results showed that low temperature, and not nutrient starvation, was the main factor inducing changes in CIRM-BIA1T metabolism under our experimental conditions, like in Swiss cheese.
Lactate was added at 64 h (↓) to mimic cheese ripening conditions. A, growth monitored by optical density (650 nm) measurements (black circle), lactate consumption (cross), production of acetate (white triangle) and propionate (black triangle); B, production of pyruvate (white rhombus) and succinate (black rhombus), consumption of aspartate (white triangle) and asparagine (black triangle); C, production of methylbutanoate (sum of 2-methyl- and 3-methylbutanoate acids). ¥: sampling times for microarray experiments.
The time-course of growth, lactate consumption and propionic fermentation are shown in Figure 1A. Cells grew at 30°C with a generation time of 5.4±0.2 h. They consumed lactate and concomitantly produced propionate and acetate, with a ratio of 2.2±0.1 moles of propionate per mole of acetate, in agreement with literature data , , . Pyruvate was excreted during exponential growth when lactate was abundant, and then reused when the lactate concentration was low, at the end of incubation at 30°C (40 h) (Fig. 1B). As previously observed under similar conditions, P. freudenreichii can excrete pyruvate in order to maintain its concentration in the cell under its toxicity threshold .
Succinate and NH3 were also produced, concomitantly with aspartate (Asp) and asparagine (Asn) consumption (Fig. 1B, Table S1). The molar ratio of succinate, NH3, and Asp/Asn was close to the expected ratio of 1. P. freudenreichii is known to deaminate Asp to fumarate which is, in turn, converted to succinate, with a generation of additional energy. Previous studies performed under similar conditions showed that, when extra Asp was added to a complex medium containing lactate, up to 40 mM of Asp were converted to succinate concomitantly with lactate fermentation . In Swiss cheese, Asp and Asn are also metabolized by P. freudenreichii and, consequently, their final content is much lower than in similar cheese varieties without propionic fermentation . In the present study, the concentration of six other free amino acids, glutamate (Glu), glycine (Gly), serine (Ser), arginine (Arg), lysine (Lys) and alanine (Ala) also exhibited a decrease ranging from 0.22 to 1.06 mM during the incubation at 30°C (Table S1). Short chain acids (acetate, propionate and methylbutanoic acids) are considered as flavor compounds in Swiss cheese . Beside acetate and propionate, CIRM-BIA1T also produced 46.8±5.2 µM of methylbutanoic acids during its growth at 30°C (Fig. 1C).
All these results showed that the metabolites produced by P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T during growth in cultures at 30°C were in close agreement with that produced during its growth in Swiss cheese.
Time-course of gene expression over the incubation period
A whole-genome transcriptomic approach was used to investigate the gene expression of P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T at five sampling times. Overall, 565 genes were detected as differentially expressed (DE genes) with P<0.05 and |(fold change)|>1, at least at one sampling time in comparison with the reference time 20 h. The DE genes represented 25% of the protein-coding genes of CIRM-BIA1T genome targeted in the microarray. The complete microarray expression data for these genes is presented in Table S2.
To get information on the time-course of gene expression, the temporal expression profiles of the DE genes were classified using a quadratic regression method, convenient to analyze time-course microarray data . A large majority (80%) of genes exhibited two patterns characterized by i) a marked increase or decrease in expression occurring between the incubation periods at 30°C and at 4°C, and ii) a limited change in expression over the period at 4°C (Fig.S2). In addition, 19% of genes exhibited a linear decrease or increase, and 1% showed a transient up- or down-regulation at 40 h that could not be fitted by this quadratic regression model at P<0.05.
According to these temporal expression patterns, the results will be further discussed by comparing gene expression at two main sampling times, i.e. at the reference time 20 h, corresponding to the exponential phase of growth at 30°C, and after 3 days at 4°C. In agreement, RT-qPCR validation experiments were solely performed at these two sampling times. RT-qPCR was applied to 28 genes observed as differentially expressed in microarray experiments, preferentially chosen (19/28) among the up-regulated genes at 4°C. Overall, the confirmation of microarray data by RT-qPCR showed an excellent agreement between the fold-change values obtained from the two approaches (RT-qPCR fold change = 1.17×microarray fold change, R2 = 0.91), thus validating the results of microarray experiments (Tables 1, 2, 3 and 4). Moreover, the changes in protein expression between 30°C and 4°C were analyzed by using a proteomic approach combining 2D electrophoresis and protein identification by mass spectrometry (Fig. 2, Table S4).
Two-dimensional analysis of proteins produced during P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T growth (A) at 30°C (reference time 20 h) and then (B) at 4°C (3 days). Numbers identify spots which volume decreased at 4°C (A), or increased at 4°C (B). The identification by MS/MS of each spot can be found in Table S4.
Changes in expression according to gene functional category
Genes were classified in 19 functional categories (Table S3). The number of up- or down-regulated DE genes in each category is illustrated in Figure 3. Only 24 genes (1% of the whole genome) were differentially expressed at the end of incubation at 30°C (40 h), in comparison to the reference time (Fig. 3A), whereas 413 genes were differentially expressed at 4°C (3 days) (Fig. 3B).
Number of differentially expressed genes (P<0.05 and |fold change|>1) after 40 h at 30°C (A, 24 genes) and after 3 days at 4°C (B, 413 genes), in comparison with genes expressed at the reference time 20 h. Down-regulated (white histogram) or up-regulated (black histogram) genes with known functions are presented according to their metabolic category: A, adaptation to atypical conditions; AA, transport and metabolism of amino acids; C, metabolism of coenzymes and prosthetic groups; CD, cell division; CE, cell envelop; CH, transport and metabolism of carbohydrates; DNA, DNA metabolism; E, energy metabolism; L, lipid metabolism; Mi, miscellaneous; Nt, transport and metabolism of nucleotides; P, protein synthesis; PD, protein degradation; Ph, metabolism of phosphate; PM, protein modification and folding; PS, protein secretion; ST, signal transduction; T, transport of peptides and inorganic ions; TS, transcription.
At 4°C, most of the DE genes implicated in functions related to the general cell machinery were down-regulated, including those related to the metabolism of nucleotides (Nt), co-enzymes and prosthetic groups (C), energy (E), and proteins (PD, P, PM) (Fig. 3B). In contrast, similar numbers of down and up-regulated genes were observed in some gene categories, like adaptation to atypical conditions (A), DNA metabolism (D), transcription (TS) and transport and metabolism of amino acids (AA), carbohydrates (CH), and inorganic ions (T). Lastly, the category dedicated to phosphate metabolism exhibited exclusively up-regulated genes at 4°C (Fig. 3B). These general trends summarize the strategies of adaptation and survival of P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T at 4°C, which are discussed in detail in the following sections.
General cell machinery slowing down
At 4°C, CIRM-BIA1T growth and general metabolism slowed down. The growth curve flattened out at an OD of 3, i.e. 1.9±0.5.109 colony forming unit/ml (cfu/ml). Accordingly, expression of the ftsX gene involved in cell-division was reduced at 4°C, as revealed by both microarray and RT-qPCR results (fold change of −4.2 and −4.3, respectively) (Table 1). Lactate consumption and acetate and propionate production rates also decreased by a factor of 19, 29 and 25, respectively (Table 5). However, cells did not show any sign of carbon starvation since cstA, coding for a carbon-starvation protein which was transiently up-regulated at 40 h in response to the low lactate content, was then down-regulated after lactate addition at 4°C (Table 2).
More than 60% of the DE genes were down-regulated at 4°C. At cold temperatures, many bacteria also exhibit a general slowing down, like for example Lc. lactis in model cheeses when placed at 12°C for seven days . In particular, in the present study, P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T down-regulated most of the DE genes involved in energetic metabolism (29/34). This included genes encoding ATP synthases (atpABCDEFGH) and several oxidoreductases of the electron transport chain (nuoABCDEFG, nuoJKL, nuoM, cydAB, and sdhAC, Table S2). Genes encoding the elongation factor (tuf) and ribosomal proteins were also down-regulated at 4°C, as previously observed in L. lactis . Proteomics also partly confirmed CIRM-BIA1T metabolism slowing down. For example, NuoD and the elongation factor were some of the identified proteins which volume decreased at 4°C (Table 1, Table S4 and Fig. 2). Cells also diminished protein synthesis at 4°C, since 87% (33/38) of the DE genes for this category were down-regulated (Table S2).
Concerning amino acid synthesis pathways, all the DE genes were down-regulated at 4°C, except for Arg synthesis (Table S2). For example, genes coding for proteins of the branched-chain amino acid ABC transporter (livFG, brae, brad, ydaO, fold change ranging from −1.3 to −3.3), and for Met, Glu, Trp, Lys Ile, and Val synthesis were down-regulated at 4°C (Table S2).
Concerning carbohydrate metabolism, genes coding for enzymes of the TCA cycle (icd and acn) and components of the pyruvate dehydrogenase (aceE and lpd) were also down-regulated at 4°C.
General cold stress response
When cultures were placed at 4°C, P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T had to face a cold stress and significantly up- or down-regulated stress protein-coding genes. Cells up-regulated genes coding for one stress-response transcriptional regulator protein and two cold shock proteins (pspC, cspA and cspB, fold change of +2.6, +2.2 and +2.6, respectively) (Table 2, Table S2). Cold shock proteins are essential for the cells to resume growth in the cold and are synthesized in many bacteria . These proteins, usually transiently expressed and detected during the acclimation phase, act as chaperones  and could constitute an asset for P. freudenreichii to maintain its metabolic activity in the cold. P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T also down-regulated several chaperone and heat shock protein-coding genes (groSL and dnaKJ operons, hsp20, clpB, grpB), with fold change values ranging from −1.3 to −5.2 over the whole period at 4°C (Table 3, Table S2). The spot volumes of DnaK2, GroS1, ClpB2 and Hsp20 1 proteins also decreased at 4°C (Table 3, Table S4 and Fig. 2). These proteins are known to be induced by several other stresses in P. freudenreichii , , and, in contrast, to be repressed upon cold shock in different bacterial species , , as observed for CIRM-BIA1T.
The up-regulation of two genes encoding DEAD-box RNA helicases, PFREUD_04260 and PFREUD_13460, with fold change values of +1.0 and +1.9 respectively (Table S2), were other indicators of the cold stress response in P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T. The up-regulation of these helicases has previously been observed in L. monocytogenes  and many other microorganisms in the cold . They help to relieve secondary structures formed by RNA at low temperatures, thus facilitating translation, and could contribute to the ability of P. freudenreichii cells to withstand cheese ripening conditions .
The maintenance of membrane fluidity is another absolute priority for bacterial survival in the cold . P. freudenreichii membrane contains a large majority of odd numbered, iso- and anteiso-form branched-chain fatty acids , . In the cold, P. freudenreichii changes its membrane fatty acid profiles in reducing the presence of iso-form fatty acids in favor of anteiso-form fatty acids . Branched-chain fatty acids are synthesized thanks to the activity of a branched-chain alpha-keto acid dehydrogenase, encoded by the bkd operon. In the present study, the genes of the bkd operon were either non-differentially expressed or were down-regulated (bkdA2, fold change = −3.2, Table 2). Similarly, in L. monocytogenes, another bacterial species containing branched-chain fatty acids, the transcription of the bkd operon is not affected at 4°C . This suggests that the major cold regulation point in CIRM-BIA1T is found downstream of the bkd operon in the branched-chain fatty acid synthesis pathway, as in L. monocytogenes.
In addition, the genes involved in Arg transport and synthesis (argBCDEFG, argJK) were up-regulated at 4°C (Table 2, Table S2). This result was unexpected because more than 2 mM of free Arg were still present in the culture medium at the end of incubation (Table S1). Whether the up-regulation of these genes resulted or not in the accumulation of intracellular Arg, and its role for P. freudenreichii remains hypothetic. In many bacteria, Arg can be used as an alternative energy source and to control intracellular pH .
Long-term survival mechanism and rerouting of carbon metabolism
P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T kept a high viability over the whole period at 4°C, with 90% of the viable cells enumerated at 3 days being still cultivable at 9 days (1.7±0.3.109 cfu/ml). Cells had to find other ways to get energetic supplies, since genes of the electron transport chain and ATP synthesis were down-regulated at 4°C. P. freudenreichii is known to accumulate inorganic polyphosphates (polyP) as an energy reserve during its growth on lactate , which are degraded by inorganic pyrophosphatases . In the present study, an inorganic pyrophosphatase-coding gene, ppa, was especially up-regulated at 4°C (RT-qPCR fold change = +3.3, Table 3). PolyP could thus be used to regenerate ATP from ADP in CIRM-BIA1T, as previously described in other bacteria .
A rerouting of carbon metabolism in P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T in the cold was also observed, as summarized in Figure 4 and discussed below. The formation of pyruvate from various sources was actively up-regulated. The expression of lactate dehydrogenases, catalyzing the oxidation of lactate into pyruvate, was either maintained at 4°C (ldh1 and dld genes), or significantly up-regulated (ldh2 gene, RT-qPCR fold change = +1.9) (Table 4). In agreement, lactate was constantly consumed at 4°C, with a total of 55.3±3.8 mM consumed over the period at 4°C (Fig. 1A). Moreover, the reactions of Ala and Ser conversion into pyruvate were up-regulated. Indeed, the transport of Ala and Ser into the cell, encoded by cycA2, was up-regulated, as well as the conversion of Ala and Ser into pyruvate, encoded by ald and sdaA genes respectively (fold change of +7.3 and +3.5, respectively) (Table 2, Table S2, Fig. 4). The Ald protein was also induced at 4°C (Table 2). However, the concentration of free Ala and Ser in culture supernatant decreased by only 0.15±0.06 and 0.18±0.04 mM, respectively, over the incubation period in the cold (Table S1). Intracellular Ala and Ser stocks may have also been converted into pyruvate. Propionate and acetate continued to be produced with the same propionate/acetate ratio compared to that observed at 30°C (Fig. 1A, Table 5). However, the yield of propionate and acetate produced per mole of lactate consumed tended to decrease at 4°C, compared to 30°C (Table 5). This result suggests that a fraction of the pyruvate produced from lactate was redirected towards other metabolic pathways at 4°C.
Protein and gene names are written in plain and in italic fonts, respectively. The color indicates the change in expression at 4°C, compared to reference time (exponential growth at 30°C, 20 h): in red, genes up-regulated at 4°C using microarray and RT-qPCR data and protein present at larger amounts; in pink, genes up-regulated at 4°C using microarray results only; in blue, genes down-regulated at 4°C using microarray and RT-qPCR data; in green, genes up-regulated at 4°C using microarray data only; in black, genes not being differentially expressed at 4°C using microarray data. * genes up-regulated using RT-qPCR data, but not significantly affected using microarray experiments. Red lines emphasize the metabolic pathways that seem to be favored at 4°C in P. freudenreichii considering the proteomic and transcriptomic results. Plain lines are used to symbolize one reaction, dotted lines several reactions (intermediary products not detailed). Gene and protein abbreviations are as follow: acn (aconitase), Ald/ald (alanine dehydrogenase), AspA2/aspA2 (aspartate ammonia-lyase), Cat/cat (coenzyme A transferase), dld (D-lactate dehydrogenase), Eno1/eno1 (enolase 1), fba2 (fructose-bisphosphate aldolase class I), FumC/fumC (fumarate hydratase class-II), glgA (glycosyltransferase), glgC (glucose-1-P adenylyltransferase), gltA1,2 (citrate synthases), icd (putative isocitrate/isopropylmalate dehydrogenase), ldh (L-lactate dehydrogenase), mdh (malate dehydrogenase), MmdA/mmdA (methylmalonyl-CoA carboxytransferase 12S subunit), MutA/mutA (methylmalonyl-CoA mutase small subunit), MutB/mutB (methylmalonyl-CoA mutase large subunit), pccB (propionyl-CoA carboxylase β-chain), Pgi/pgi (glucose-6-P isomerase), Pgm1/pgm1 (phosphoglucomutase), PpdK/ppdk (pyruvate phosphate dikinase), ptsI (PTS enzyme I), sdaA (L-serine dehydratase), sdhA (succinate dehydrogenase, subunit A), sdhA3 (succinate dehydrogenase, flavoprotein subunit), sdhB (succinate dehydrogenase, subunit B), sdhB3 (succinate dehydrogenase), sdhC1 (succinate dehydrogenase, subunit C), sdhC2 (succinate dehydrogenase, cytochrome B-558 subunit), ?: undefined protein (probable phosphoenolpyruvic carboxylase).
Our transcriptomic and proteomic data suggest that P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T metabolism was redirected towards glycogen synthesis through gluconeogenesis (Fig. 4). Hence, pyruvate phosphate dikinase, catalyzing the conversion of pyruvate into phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP), was over-expressed at 4°C (Table 4). PEP could have been converted to α-D-glucose-6-P via gluconeogenesis, as suggested by the up-regulation at 4°C of eno1, fba2, pgi genes and some of the corresponding proteins (Eno1 and Pgi) (Fig. 4, Table 4). Gluconeogenesis was previously reported in resting cells of the same P. freudenreichii strain incubated in the presence of labeled pyruvate . In our study, the final product of gluconeogenesis, α-D-glucose-6-P, could have been converted into glycogen, as suggested by the up-regulation of glgC (fold change = +2.6) encoding ADP-glucose synthase, the main regulation enzyme of glycogen synthesis , and of two other enzymes of glycogen synthesis pathway, at gene and/or protein level (Fig. 4, Table 4). Glycogen is an α-1,4 linked, α-1,6 branched glucose polymer used for long-term energy storage. Its metabolism is highly interconnected with a wide range of cellular processes and tightly adjusted to the nutritional and energetic status of the cell . P. freudenreichii is able to synthesize and accumulate intracellular glycogen, although it is not able to degrade extracellular glycogen . Storing glycogen should then be an asset for P. freudenreichii contributing to its aptitude to adapt, resist and survive to stressful conditions such as the low temperature during cheese ripening.
In the present study, Asp may also have been used as an additional carbon source for glycogen synthesis. The aspartate ammonia-lyase (AspA2), catalyzing the conversion of aspartate into fumarate, was over-expressed at 4°C at both transcriptomic and proteomic levels (Table 2). Succinate was no more excreted at 4°C (Fig. 1B), and, in agreement, the two copies of the succinate dehydrogenase-coding genes were down-regulated. In contrast, fumarate hydratase was over-expressed at gene (fumC, RT-qPCR fold change of +2.6) and protein levels (Table 4, Fig. 4). Altogether, these results suggest that Asp could have been converted to fumarate, malate, and then to pyruvate and/or PEP to be used as an additional substrate for gluconeogenesis. Only intracellular Asp would have been used for glycogen synthesis, since the culture medium was depleted in free Asp and Asn at 4°C and that the total Asp content in the medium did not significantly decrease during incubation at 4°C (Fig. 1B, Table S1).
Aroma compound production in the cold
P. freudenreichii has a key role in the formation of Swiss cheese flavor by producing a variety of flavor compounds from three main origins: propionate from lactate fermentation, methylbutanoic acids from the conversion of Ile and Leu, and free fatty acids from milk fat hydrolysis by lipolytic carboxylic ester hydrolases .
Most of the genes involved in Wood-Werkman cycle converting pyruvate to propionate were not differentially expressed in conditions mimicking cold room ripening of cheeses. The Wood-Werkman cycle seemed to be maintained at 4°C, as indicated by the increase in spot volume at 4°C of FumC, Cat, MmdA, MutA and MutB proteins (Table 4, Fig. 4 and Table S4). Accordingly, propionate continued to be produced, as stated above, but its formation rate decreased by a factor of 25 (Table 5).
The production of methylbutanoic acids, in contrast, decreased by a factor of only 3 at 4°C (Fig. 1C, Table 5). The formation of methylbutanoic acids from Leu and Ile is catalyzed by genes encoding branched-chain amino acid aminotransferases (pabC and ilvE) and genes of the bkd operon . As already mentioned, these genes were not differentially expressed at 4°C, except for the bkdA2 gene.
Ten genes coding for (putative) carboxylic ester hydrolases were previously identified in CIRM-BIA1T genome  and could be involved in fat hydrolysis or ester synthesis. Interestingly, nine of these 10 genes were not differently expressed at 4°C, whereas the remaining one (pf379) was significantly up-regulated (fold change = +1, Table S2). These results coincide with the observation that milk fat hydrolysis and ester synthesis are maintained in cheese at cold temperatures .
This study brought new insights into the metabolism of P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T in conditions mimicking cheese transfer from the warm room to the cold room. It highlights in particular how this strain re-directs some metabolic pathways to accumulate carbon storage compounds and to use alternative energy storage compounds like polyP, contributing to its long-term survival. Further work is in progress to determine if other P. freudenreichii strains exhibit similar metabolic adaptations in the cold, compared to CIRM-BIA1T, or if they use additional adaptive strategies. Since some strains of P. freudenreichii are now considered for their probiotic properties , our results could also be of interest to develop dairy products containing probiotic strains keeping high viable populations during their storage at a low temperature.
Materials and Methods
Strain and culture conditions
The sequenced P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T strain  was grown in YEL broth  under air atmosphere without agitation. Growth was monitored by optical density measurements at 650 nm (OD650). Cultures were incubated at 30°C until they reached an OD650 of about 2±0.11 (at 40 h), i.e. before the exhaustion of the main carbon source (lactate). Then, cultures were incubated for a further 9 days at 4°C. Lactate (132 mM/ml, Panreac, Lyon, France) was added after 24 h incubation at 4°C in order to mimic the lactate availability during cheese ripening, thus preventing carbon starvation. Cultures were harvested at five stages: in the middle of the exponential growth phase at 30°C (20 h, OD650≈0.5), at the end of exponential growth phase at 30°C (40 h, OD650≈2), and after 3, 6 and 9 days of incubation at 4°C. After 3 and 9 days at 4°C, the bacterial concentrations were determined by CFU counting on YEL agar incubated at 30°C for 5 days, in anaerobic conditions.
Experiments were performed in triplicate as independent cultures.
Total RNA extraction was adapted from Deutsch et al . Briefly, at each sampling time, cells were harvested (8000×g, 10 min, room temperature or 4°C regarding the sampling time). Cell pellets were suspended in 100 µl of TE buffer 1× (Qiagen, Courtaboeuf, France) containing lysozyme (20 mg/ml), and incubated for 15 min at 24 °C before addition of 350 µl RLT buffer (from the Qiagen RNeasy minikit). 50 mg of zirconium beads and 100 µl of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS, 20%) were then added and cells were disrupted for 2×90 seconds at 30 Hz by using a Retsch MM301 high-speed mixer mill (Grosseron, France). RNA was extracted according to the instructions of the RNeasy kit. Then DNase treatments of the RNA samples were performed using a DNA-free kit (Ambion, Texas, USA) according to the manufacturer's instructions. RNA quantification and contamination by proteins were assessed using a NanoDrop ND-1000 spectrophotometer (NanoDrop Technologies, Inc., Rockland, DE). RNA quality was evaluated using an Agilent 2100 bioanalyzer (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA) and the RIN value was calculated as previously described . All of the RNA samples had a RIN value greater than 8.4, indicating a good RNA integrity. The absence of genomic DNA was confirmed by quantitative PCR (qPCR).
Transcriptomic analyses and statistical analysis
Microarray design, manufacture, synthesis and image scanning were provided by Source BioScience imaGenes (Berlin, Germany). Briefly, P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T microarrays were designed as 8×15K (i.e. 8 samples per slide with 15000 oligos targeting each sample) custom microarrays including all ORFs and intergenic regions from the whole genome of P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T strain. So, the number of oligos targeting CIRM-BIA1T strain genome ranged from 1 to 5, with a mean of 4 oligos per gene or intergenic region. The complete microarray design is available in NCBIs GEO platform under accession number GPL13959. At each sampling time, hybridizations consisted in three biological replicates. A technical replicate was also performed for the reference time at 20 h. Cyanine-3 (Cy3) labeled cRNA was prepared from (50–100 ng) RNA using the Low Input Quick Amp Labeling Kit (Agilent Technologies) according to the manufacturer's instructions, followed by RNAeasy column purification (Qiagen). Dye incorporation and cRNA yield were checked with the NanoDrop ND-1000 Spectrophotometer. 600 ng of Cy3-labelled cRNA (specific activity >10.0 pmol Cy3/ug cRNA) was fragmented (60°C, 30 min) in a reaction volume of 25 µl containing 1× Agilent fragmentation buffer and 2× Agilent blocking agent following the manufacturer's instructions. On completion of the fragmentation reaction, 25 µl of 2× Hi-RPM hybridization buffer (Agilent Technologies) was added to the fragmentation mixture and hybridized to Agilent specific 8×15 K microarray for 17 h at 65°C in a rotating Agilent hybridization oven. After hybridization, microarrays were washed for 1 min at room temperature with GE Wash Buffer 1 (Agilent Technologies), then for 1 min with 37°C GE Wash buffer 2 (Agilent Technologies), and finally for 1 min at room temperature with acetonitrile. Slides were scanned immediately after washing on the Agilent DNA Microarray Scanner (G2565CA) using one color scan setting for 8×15 K array slides (Scan Area 61×21.6 mm, Scan resolution 5 µM, Dye channel set to Green and Green PMT set to 100%). The scanned images were analyzed with Feature Extraction Software 9.1 (Agilent Technologies) using default parameters. Normalization and microarray analysis were performed using limma package  of the R software (www.R-project.org). All intensities were expressed as log2 of the normalized signal intensities. Differential analysis was performed using empirical Bayes fitting in limma. Raw P-values were adjusted for multiple comparisons by the Benjamini-Hochberg procedure  which controls the False Discovery Rate. We considered genes with an adjusted P-value<0.05 to be DE. Moreover, expression ratios, indicating the fold change in expression between two samples, were calculated using 20 h sample as a reference. Only genes with a |fold change (log2)| greater than 1 (standing for an increase or decrease in expression of at least 2 times) were considered as biologically significant. Genes fitting both P-value and fold change criteria were retained. The data presented in this publication have been deposited in NCBIs Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/) and are accessible though GEO Series accession number GSE30841.
The DE genes were also classified according to their temporal expression profiles using the quadratic regression method proposed by Liu et al. .
Reverse transcription quantitative PCR
In order to confirm the results from the transcriptomic analyses, reverse transcription quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) experiments were carried out. Transcripts were quantified at two specific times, at the exponential phase of growth (reference time 20 h) and after a 3-day incubation at 4°C. Twenty-eight genes observed as DE using microarray experiments were chosen. Primers were designed using Primer3Plus software  with default parameters except for the difference of melting temperature between the forward and reverse primers set to less than 1°C. The primer sequences for the tested genes are detailed in Table 6. cDNA synthesis, quantitative PCR, and cycle thresholds (Ct) were performed according to Falentin et al. . Briefly, cDNA was synthesized using a qScript™ cDNA synthesis kit (Quanta BioSciences, Maryland, USA). Amplification by qPCR was performed with a 15 µl final volume mixture containing 5 µl of a cDNA template dilution of 1 in 40, 0.5 µM of each primer and 1× IQ™ SYBR Green Supermix (BioRad, California, USA), in an Opticon 2 real-time PCR detector (Biorad). Amplification cycles consisted in an initial step at 95°C for 5 min followed by 40 cycles of 95°C for 30 s, 60°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 1 min. Amplicon denaturation step of 0.5°C/min from 65°C to 90°C was performed to verify amplification specificity and determine amplicon melting temperature. Five genes that were not DE in microarray experiments (PFREUD_18870, gyrB1, 16S, pf279, gtfF) were chosen as possible internal standards for RT-qPCR normalization. The stability of mRNA expression of these genes was checked by using the geNorm VBA applet for Microsoft Excel . Thus, PFREUD_18870, pf279 and gtfF genes were chosen as internal standard for normalization. The delta-delta-Ct method of geNorm was used to determine the normalized expression level of genes of interest (http://medgen.ugent.be/genorm/). An ANOVA was performed and changes in gene expression between the two conditions with a P-value<0.05 were considered as significant. To facilitate comparison with transcriptomic data, the results of RT-qPCR were expressed as fold change in log2.
Protein extraction was performed as described by Jan et al. , with modifications. In brief, cells were harvested at four sampling times (20 h and 3, 6 and 9 days) by centrifugating 50 ml of culture (7000×g, 10 min, room temperature or 4°C regarding the sampling time) and washed in a wash buffer (50 mM Tris-HCl [pH 7.5], 150 mM NaCl, Panreac). Washed cells were then recovered in a protoplastization solution (25 mM Tris-HCl [pH 7.5], 0.5 M sucrose, 0.1 mg of lysozyme per ml, 1 mg of chloramphenicol per ml, 0.4 mM phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride [PMSF]) and incubated for 30 min at 37°C prior to centrifugation (7000×g, room temperature, 10 min). The cell pellet was recovered in a lysis solution (50 mM Tris-HCl [pH 7.5], 0.3% SDS, 200 mM dithiothreitol (DTT), 0.4 mM PMSF, 1 mg/ml chloramphenicol) and sonicated on ice with a Vibra Cell sonicator (Bioblock Scientific, Illkirch, France) equipped with a tapered microtip (three bursts of 1 min at 1-min intervals, output of 2.5). The lysates were centrifuged (10000×g, 10 min, room temperature) and the supernatants were stored at −20°C until electrophoresis.
Two-dimensional electrophoresis (2D electrophoresis) and image analysis
Proteins were precipitated (2D clean up kit, GE Healthcare) and rehydrated in 100 µl of Destreak rehydratation solution (GE Healthcare) containing 20% IPG buffer (pH 4/7, GE Healthcare). Isoelectric focusing was carried out using pH 4 to 7 Immobiline Dry Strips (18 cm, GE Healthcare) on a Multiphor II electrophoresis system (Amersham Biosciences). Second dimension SDS PAGE (14% monomers) was performed on an Ethan Dalt Twelve (GE Healthcare) according to a procedure previously described . Analysis of the gel images was undertaken using Progenesis SameSpots software version 3.3 (Nonlinear Dynamics, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom). The gel images were aligned by automated calculation of alignment vectors after assigning 30–35 landmark vectors . An ANOVA was performed and a threshold of P<0.05 was chosen to identify significant changes in spot volumes. Differentially expressed proteins also have to match a fold change criterion, expressed in log2, of at least 0.6.
Protein identification was performed using tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) as previously described . All mass spectrometry data were submitted to MASCOT v.2.2 software for search into two concatenated databases: (i) Swiss-Prot database (http://www.expasy.org) and (ii) a portion of the UniProtKB database corresponding to the P. freudenreichii taxonomic group. Fifty protein spots were excised and submitted to an in-gel tryptic digestion as previously described . The alkylation of cysteine by iodoacetamide was specified as a fixed modification while the two following modifications were set as variable modifications: oxidation of methionine and deamidation of asparagine and glutamine residues. The peptide mass tolerance was set to 0.2 Da for MS 0.15 Da for MS/MS. For each peptide identified, a minimum of four peptides with MASCOT score corresponding to a P-value<0.05 or an Exponentially Modified Protein Abundance Index (emPAI)  greater than 0.4 were necessary for validation with a high degree of confidence. For the validation of peptides from the MASCOT search results, the 1.19.2 version of the IRMa software was used .
Analysis of metabolites in culture supernatants
Free and total amino acids were analyzed with an amino acid analyzer (AlphaPlus series 2; Pharmacia, Uppsala, Sweden). Lactic, propionic, acetic, succinic, and pyruvic acids were quantified in culture supernatants by HPLC on an Aminex A-6 ion exchange column (Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA) at 55°C with 0.005 M H2SO4 as eluent at a flow rate of 0.4 ml.min−1. Both UV (210 nm) and refractometric detectors were used. Methylbutyric acid (sum of 2-methylbutyric and 3-methylbutyric acids) concentration was determined in culture supernatants after acidification by oxalic acid (final concentration: 0.03 mM) by gas chromatography, as previously described . The rate of metabolites consumption or production was calculated i) at 30°C, between 20 h and 40 h, ii) at 4°C, by linear regression of values at lactate addition time point (64 h), at 3, 6 and 9 days. The differences between means from independent triplicate cultures for concentrations, ratios, and rates of metabolite consumption or production at the different sampling times were assessed by Student tests.
Growth of P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T strain at 30°C monitored by optical density measurements (650 nm) in YEL medium containing 130 mM (plain line) or 260 mM of lactate (dotted line).
An illustration of the two main temporal expression patterns of P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T strain genes identified by the quadratic regression method proposed by Liu et al. . The black dots are the hybridization signals. The curve is the fitted regression pattern. Pattern and genes given as an example of the pattern are as follows A: example of a quadratic linear concave up regulated regression pattern (for PFREUD_06720 gene) displayed by 178 differentially expressed genes; B: example of a quadratic linear convex down regulated regression pattern (for groEL1 gene) displayed by 272 differentially expressed genes.
Concentrations of total and free amino acids, and NH3 in P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T strain supernatant samples over time.
P. freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T strain 565 differentially expressed genes according to microarray experiments ( P <0.05, |fold-change|>1).
Description of the metabolic function of genes grouped in each category.
We thank Valentin Loux (INRA, Jouy-en-Josas) for his help regarding the microarray design and Pascal Pachot for his support concerning statistical analysis.
Conceived and designed the experiments: AT. Performed the experiments: MD SP JJ M-BM MP VB-B VC. Analyzed the data: MD AT JA HF GJ S-MD. Wrote the paper: MD AT. Assisted in the design of the study: SE JT.
- 1. Falentin H, Postollec F, Parayre S, Henaff N, Le Bivic P, et al. (2010) Specific metabolic activity of ripening bacteria quantified by real-time reverse transcription PCR throughout Emmental cheese manufacture. Int J Food Microbiol 144: 10–19.
- 2. Ganesan B, Stuart MR, Weimer BC (2007) Carbohydrate starvation causes a metabolically active but nonculturable state in Lactococcus lactis. Appl Environ Microbiol 73: 2498–2512.
- 3. Taïbi A, Dabour N, Lamoureux M, Roy D, LaPointe G (2011) Comparative transcriptome analysis of Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris strains under conditions simulating Cheddar cheese manufacture. Int J Food Microbiol 146: 263–275.
- 4. Yvon M, Gitton C, Chambellon E, Bergot G, Monnet V (2011) The initial efficiency of the proteolytic system of Lactococcus lactis strains determines their responses to a cheese environment. Int Dairy J 21: 335–345.
- 5. Langsrud T, Reinbold GW (1973) Flavor development and microbiology of Swiss cheese- A review. III. Ripening and flavor production. J Milk Food Technol 36: 593–609.
- 6. Thierry A, Maillard MB, Richoux R, Kerjean JR, Lortal S (2005) Propionibacterium freudenreichii strains quantitatively affect production of volatile compounds in Swiss cheese. Lait 85: 57–74.
- 7. Cretenet M, Laroute V, Ulve V, Jeanson S, Nouaille S, et al. (2011) Dynamic analysis of the Lactococcus lactis transcriptome in cheeses made from milk concentrated by ultrafiltration reveals multiple strategies of adaptation to stresses. Appl Environ Microbiol 77: 247–257.
- 8. Fröhlich-Wyder MT, Bachmann HP (2004) Cheeses with propionic acid fermentation. In: Fox PF, McSweeney PLH, Cogan TM, Guinee TP, editors. Cheese. Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology. London: Elsevier. pp. 141–156.
- 9. Thierry A, Salvat-Brunaud D, Madec MN, Michel F, Maubois JL (1998) Affinage de l'emmental: dynamique des populations bactériennes et évolution de la composition de la phase aqueuse. Lait 78: 521–542.
- 10. Malik AC, Reinbold GW, Vedamuthu ER (1968) An evaluation of the taxonomy of Propionibacterium. Can J Microbiol 14: 1185–1191.
- 11. Crow VL (1986) Metabolism of aspartate by Propionibacterium freudenreichii subsp. shermanii: Effect on lactate fermentation. Appl Environ Microbiol 52: 359–365.
- 12. Thierry A, Maillard MB, Yvon M (2002) Conversion of L-leucine to isovaleric acid by Propionibacterium freudenreichii TL 34 and ITGP23. Appl Environ Microbiol 68: 608–615.
- 13. Crow VL (1986) Utilization of lactate isomers by Propionibacterium freudenreichii subsp. shermanii: regulatory role for intracellular pyruvate. Appl Environ Microbiol 52: 352–358.
- 14. Liu H, Tarima S, Borders A, Getchell T, Getchell M, et al. (2005) Quadratic regression analysis for gene discovery and pattern recognition for non-cyclic short time-course microarray experiments. BMC Bioinformatics 6: 106.
- 15. Thieringer HA, Jones PG, Inouye M (1998) Cold shock and adaptation. Bioessays 20: 49–57.
- 16. Chan YC, Wiedmann M (2009) Physiology and genetics of Listeria monocytogenes survival and growth at cold temperatures. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 49:
- 17. Anastasiou R, Leverrier P, Krestas I, Rouault A, Kalantzopoulos G, et al. (2006) Changes in protein synthesis during thermal adaptation of Propionibacterium freudenreichii subsp. shermanii. Int J Food Microbiol 108: 301–314.
- 18. Leverrier P, Vissers JPC, Rouault A, Boyaval P, Jan G (2004) Mass spectrometry proteomic analysis of stress adaptation reveals both common and distinct response pathways in Propionibacterium freudenreichii. Arch Microbiol 181: 215–230.
- 19. Li SK, Xiao X, Sun P, Wang FP (2008) Screening of genes regulated by cold shock in Shewanella piezotolerans WP3 and time course expression of cold-regulated genes. Arch Microbiol 189: 549–556.
- 20. Piette F, D'Amico S, Mazzucchelli G, Danchin A, Leprince P, et al. (2011) Life in the cold: a proteomic study of cold-repressed proteins in the Antarctic bacterium Pseudoalteromonas haloplanktis TAC125. Appl Environ Microbiol 77: 3881–3883.
- 21. Rodrigues DF, Tiedje JM (2008) Coping with our cold planet. Appl Environ Microbiol 74: 1677–1686.
- 22. Shivaji S, Prakash JSS (2010) How do bacteria sense and respond to low temperature? Arch Microbiol 192: 85–95.
- 23. Dherbécourt J, Maillard MB, Catheline D, Thierry A (2008) Production of branched-chain aroma compounds by Propionibacterium freudenreichii: links with the biosynthesis of membrane fatty acids. J Appl Microbiol 105: 977–985.
- 24. Hofherr LA, Hammond EG, Glatz BA, Ross PF (1983) Relation of growth temperature to fatty acid composition of Propionibacterium strains. J Dairy Sci 66: 1622–1629.
- 25. Pessione A, Lamberti C, Pessione E (2010) Proteomics as a tool for studying energy metabolism in lactic acid bacteria. Mol Biosyst 6: 1419–1430.
- 26. Clark JE, Beegen H, Wood HG (1987) Isolation of intact chains of polyphosphate from Propionibacterium shermanii grown on glucose or lactate. J Bacteriol 168: 1212–1219.
- 27. Gomez-Garcia MR, Losada M, Serrano A (2003) Concurrent transcriptional activation of ppa and ppx genes by phosphate deprivation in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. strain PCC 6803. Biochem Bioph Res Co 302: 601–609.
- 28. Seufferheld MJ, Alvarez HM, Farias ME (2008) Role of polyphosphates in microbial adaptation to extreme environments. Appl Environ Microbiol 74: 5867–5874.
- 29. Deborde C, Rolin DB, Boyaval P (1999) In vivo 13C NMR study of the bidirectional reactions of the wood-werkman cycle and around the pyruvate node in Propionibacterium freudenreichii subsp. shermanii and Propionibacterium acidipropionici. Metab Eng 1: 309–319.
- 30. Ballicora MA, Iglesias AA, Preiss J (2003) ADP-Glucose pyrophosphorylase, a regulatory enzyme for bacterial glycogen synthesis. Microbiol Mol Biol R 67: 213–225.
- 31. Eydallin G, Montero M, Almagro G, Sesma MT, Viale AM, et al. (2010) Genome-wide screening of genes whose enhanced expression affects glycogen accumulation in Escherichia coli. DNA Res 17: 61–71.
- 32. Thierry A, Deutsch SM, Falentin H, Dalmasso M, Cousin FJ, et al. (2011) New insights into physiology and metabolism of Propionibacterium freudenreichii. Int J Food Microbiol 149: 19–27.
- 33. Dherbécourt J, Falentin H, Canaan S, Thierry A (2008) A genomic search approach to identify esterases in Propionibacterium freudenreichii involved in the formation of flavour in Emmental cheese. Microb Cell Fact 7:
- 34. Cousin FJ, Mater DDG, Foligné B, Jan G (2011) Dairy propionibacteria as human probiotics: a review of recent evidence. Dairy Sci Technol 91: 1–26.
- 35. Falentin H, Deutsch SM, Jan G, Loux V, Thierry A, et al. (2010) The complete genome of Propionibacterium freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T, a hardy Actinobacterium with food and probiotic applications. PLoS ONE 5: e11748.
- 36. Deutsch SM, Le Bivic P, Herve C, Madec MN, LaPointe G, et al. (2010) Correlation of the capsular phenotype in Propionibacterium freudenreichii with the level of expression of gtf, a unique polysaccharide synthase-encoding gene. Appl Environ Microbiol 76: 2740–2746.
- 37. Schroeder A, Mueller O, Stocker S, Salowsky R, Leiber M, et al. (2006) The RIN: an RNA integrity number for assigning integrity values to RNA measurements. BMC Mol Biol 7:
- 38. Smyth GK (2005) Limma: linear models for microarray data. In: Gentleman R, Carey V, Dudoit S, Irizarry R, Huber W, editors. Bioinformatics and computational biology solutions using R and Bioconductor. New York: Springer. pp. 397–420.
- 39. Benjamini Y, Hochberg Y (1995) Controlling the false discovery rate - A practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. J Roy Stat Soc B Met 57: 289–300.
- 40. Untergasser A, Nijveen H, Rao X, Bisseling T, Geurts R, et al. (2007) Primer3Plus, an enhanced web interface to Primer3. Nucleic Acids Res 35: W71–W74.
- 41. Vandesompele J, De Preter K, Pattyn F, Poppe B, Van Roy N, et al. (2002) Accurate normalization of real-time quantitative RT-PCR data by geometric averaging of multiple internal control genes. Genome Biol 3: RESEARCH0034.
- 42. Jan G, Leverrier P, Pichereau V, Boyaval P (2001) Changes in protein synthesis and morphology during acid adaptation of Propionibacterium freudenreichii. Appl Environ Microbiol 67: 2029–2036.
- 43. Gilad O, Jacobsen S, Stuer-Lauridsen B, Pedersen MB, Garrigues C, et al. (2010) Combined transcriptome and proteome analysis of Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis BB-12 grown on xylo-oligosaccharides and a model of their utilization. Appl Environ Microbiol 76: 7285–7291.
- 44. Le Marechal C, Jardin J, Jan G, Even S, Pulido C, et al. (2011) Staphylococcus aureus seroproteomes discriminate ruminant isolates causing mild or severe mastitis. Vet Res 42: 35.
- 45. Ishihama Y, Oda Y, Tabata T, Sato T, Nagasu T, et al. (2005) Exponentially modified protein abundance index (emPAI) for estimation of absolute protein amount in proteomics by the number of sequenced peptides per protein. Mol Cel Proteomics 4: 1265–1272.
- 46. Dupierris V, Masselon C, Court M, Kieffer-Jaquinod S, Bruley C (2009) A toolbox for validation of mass spectrometry peptides identification and generation of database: IRMa. Bioinformatics 25: 1980–1981.