The effect of ocean acidification conditions has been investigated in cultures of the diatom Thalassiosira pseudonana CCMP1335. Expected end-of-the-century pCO2 (aq) concentrations of 760 µatm (equivalent to pH 7.8) were compared with present-day condition (380 µatm CO2, pH 8.1). Batch culture pH changed rapidly because of CO2 (aq) assimilation and pH targets of 7.8 and 8.1 could not be sustained. Long-term (∼100 generation) pH-auxostat, continuous cultures could be maintained at target pH when cell density was kept low (<2×105 cells mL−1). After 3 months continuous culture, the C:N ratio was slightly decreased under high CO2 conditions and red fluorescence per cell was slightly increased. However, no change was detected in photosynthetic efficiency (Fv/Fm) or functional cross section of PS II (σPSII). Elevated pCO2 has been predicted to be beneficial to diatoms due to reduced cost of carbon concentration mechanisms. There was reduced transcription of one putative δ-carbonic anhydrase (CA-4) after 3 months growth at increased CO2 but 3 other δ-CAs and the small subunit of RUBISCO showed no change. There was no evidence of adaptation or clade selection of T. pseudonana after ∼100 generations at elevated CO2. On the basis of this long-term culture, pH change of this magnitude in the future ocean may have little effect on T. pseudonana in the absence of genetic adaption.
Citation: Crawfurd KJ, Raven JA, Wheeler GL, Baxter EJ, Joint I (2011) The Response of Thalassiosira pseudonana to Long-Term Exposure to Increased CO2 and Decreased pH. PLoS ONE 6(10): e26695. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0026695
Editor: Howard Browman, Institute of Marine Research, Norway
Received: June 29, 2011; Accepted: October 2, 2011; Published: October 28, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Crawfurd et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The research was funded by the Natural Environmental Research Council (www.nerc.ac.uk), through the Oceans 2025 programme. Dr. Crawfurd acknowledges a NERC PhD studentship. The Plymouth Marine Laboratory is a registered Charity, No 1091222, the University of Dundee is a registered Scottish Charity, No. SC015096. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Anthropogenic emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2) are leading to rapid changes of ocean pH. This is commonly referred to as ocean acidification  because, as CO2 dissolves in the surface ocean, aqueous carbon dioxide (CO2 (aq)) reacts with water to form carbonic acid (H2CO3), which is a weak acid. This change in the surface ocean is potentially important for phytoplankton not only because the pH of the growing medium (seawater) changes, but also because there will be an increase in the concentration of CO2 (aq) – the substrate for RUBISCO. The implications of these changes for marine phytoplankton are not yet clear and a number of studies to date indicate conflicting responses.
The pH of the surface ocean is expected to decrease from an average present-day pH of ∼8.1, to ∼7.8 by the end of the century . Coccolithophores, as calcifying organisms, are one phytoplankton group that has been a major focus for experiments to investigate the consequences of ocean acidification because they may be particularly vulnerable to pH change. A pH of 7.8 is close to the saturation state (Ω) for calcite, leading to increased dissolution. In one of the first studies on the effects of ocean acidification, Riebesell and colleagues  showed that growth at 780–850 µatm pCO2 resulted in malformed coccoliths of Emiliana huxleyi and Gephyrocapsa oceanica. However, subsequent studies have shown inconsistent effects of reduced pH and Ridgwell and colleagues  concluded that it was difficult to draw consistent conclusions about the effect of pH change on coccolithophores and suggested that inter- and intra-species differences may be responsible for the range of observed effects. More recently, it has been suggested that different nutrient and light regimes may account for the observed variability in these experimental studies . A global study of individual coccolith mass in ocean sediments from the past forty thousand years broadly supports the hypothesis that calcification is likely to decline with a decrease in ocean CO32− concentrations .
The effect of higher pCO2 on other phytoplankton groups is also unclear. From a theoretical point of view, Raven  suggested that increased CO2 (aq) availability should benefit those phytoplankton species that rely on diffusive CO2 entry, or those that are able to suppress carbon concentrating mechanisms (CCMs). Those species that depend on diffusive entry of CO2 may have higher intracellular CO2 (aq) concentrations that are closer to those required to saturate RUBISCO. Higher CO2 (aq) should reduce photorespiration in species with low specificity RUBISCO, since high CO2:O2 concentrations should result in an increased carboxylase:oxygenase ratio . This may be particularly beneficial under low light, growth-limiting conditions. However, most phytoplankton use CCMs and actively take-up both CO2 (aq) and HCO3− , . Therefore, the species that may benefit from a reduction in CCM activity could come from any phytoplankton group. A reduction of CCM mechanisms, i.e. fewer CCM proteins, would reduce the nitrogen requirement for CCM protein synthesis and could result in a concomitant reduction in the energy requirements for protein synthesis .
If there are benefits in terms of energetic costs to the cell, are these of sufficient magnitude to influence growth rate? That is, would higher CO2 (aq) appear to act as a fertilizer? Again, current information is contradictory, although we perhaps should not assume a uniform response in all diatom species. For example, metabolic diversity in diatoms, such as the proposed C4 mechanism for C fixation in certain species , may lead to diverse responses to elevated CO2. Laboratory cultures of Thalassiosira pseudonana exposed to a range of CO2 concentrations showed no increase in specific growth rate when dissolved CO2 exceeded the atmospheric equilibrium concentration of 15 µM CO2 . Saturation at the air-equilibrium CO2 is consistent with the data of Clark and Flynn  and of Roberts et al.  on T. pseudonana and Thalassiosira weissflogii. In an experimental mesocosm bloom, a 40% increase in the specific growth rate of Skeletonema costatum was observed at 750 µatm compared to 250 µatm and 400 µatm pCO2 ; in contrast, there was no effect on growth rate of Nitzschia spp. Also, Beardall and Raven  found a 24% increase in specific growth rate of the diatom Chaetoceros muelleri at 1000 µatm pCO2. In experiments with natural assemblages, increased growth rates were observed at 800 µatm pCO2 compared with 380 µatm pCO2 in three separate incubations of summer assemblage diatoms from the Ross Sea . However, this does not appear to be a consistent response because the same treatment of a Thalassiosira spp.-dominated-community in the Californian upwelling did not alter specific growth rate .
In this study, we investigated the effect of higher CO2 (aq) on the diatom, Thalassiosira pseudonana. Diatoms are very important for the productivity of the oceans, contributing ∼45% of global marine primary production . In addition, the genome of T. pseudonana has been fully sequenced and annotated . A major difficulty with laboratory culturing approaches is to maintain constant pH and CO2 (aq). As phytoplankton photosynthesize and culture cell density increases, CO2 (aq) is removed from the medium, leading to a rapid increase in pH; a change of 1 pH unit in a few days is not unusual. Organic buffers would appear to be an obvious approach to control variations in pH. However, organic buffers can have adverse effects on physiology and, in combination with aeration at different concentrations of CO2, can have a profound effect on the total DIC, acting to increase carbonate at lower seawater pH . Organic buffers may also form complexes with metals, reducing availability to phytoplankton . Organic buffers are not a panacea.
We have used low cell density, continuous cultures to overcome these problems, and to maintain constant growth conditions for a long-term investigation. We have employed a pH auxostat in which pH is constantly monitored and maintained by the influx of fresh media. Auxostats differ from chemostats in that dilution rate is not constant and is self-regulated by metabolic activity within the culture. Cell density in a pH auxostat is therefore determined by the buffering capacity of the input media and the stoichiometry of H+ production/consumption in relation to growth rate and can be defined by the following equation:
where x is cell density, BCR is the buffering capacity of the input media and h is the H+ consumption or generation relative to growth rate . The pH auxostat approach has many advantages over batch culture for maintaining carbonate chemistry for long periods of time.
This approach was capable of maintaining stable pH for a period of 3 months (∼100 generations). The aim was to use long-term cultures, growing under constant conditions, to test if acclimation or adaptation to higher CO2 (aq) might occur. By acclimation, we mean that the organism has sufficient metabolic flexibility to be able to grow under higher CO2 (aq) conditions; adaptation would imply selection of mutant clades that could survive in higher CO2 (aq) but not at air-equilibrium CO2 (aq), or even that have increased fitness during growth at higher CO2 (aq) (–; also see Huertas and colleagues  for results on the related effect of warming). In order for adaptation to present within a population of cells, a mutation which confers a fitness advantage has to become present at a sufficient frequency within a population in order to convey a phenotypic change. In reality this may take many hundreds of generations and many more so for mutations which convey only a very subtle increase in fitness . For ocean acidification experiments using eukaryotes (with generation times ranging from 0.5 to several days) and where carbonate chemistry must be precisely controlled throughout the duration of the study, this clearly represents a formidable challenge. The required number of generations to observe adaptation is dependent on many variables including the number of cells in each population and the fitness advantage conferred by a specific mutation. It is unlikely that 100 generations will be sufficient to examine for adaptation within conventional batch culturing approaches, although in continuous cultures the rapid wash out of slow growing strains may allow adaptation to present more rapidly within a population. Nevertheless, it remains a valid hypothesis to test.
We have investigated a number of cellular characteristics, such as carbon and pigment content, and focused specifically on expression of carbonic anhydrases as components of CCMs and also of diffusive entry of CO2. Carbonic anhydrases catalyze the equilibrium of inorganic carbon species – the reversible hydration of CO2 to HCO3− - and are assumed to ensure a high rate of supply of CO2 to the low affinity active site of RUBISCO within the chloroplast. We selected 4 δ-carbonic anhydrase (δ-CA) from the T. pseudonana genome, since McGinn and Morel  have demonstrated significant changes in δ-CA transcripts in response to changes in carbon availability. In addition, down-regulation of these enzymes in response to higher CO2 (aq) might result in savings in energy and N-resources that might be detectable as a change in cellular physiology. Batch cultures experiments were used to distinguish between adaptation and acclimation after growth for >100 generations at the higher, and the present CO2 (aq) concentrations. Inocula from both long-term CO2 (aq) conditions were used to initiate batch cultures in both CO2 treatments and cell properties were determining. Acclimation was assumed if the properties of cells grown for >100 generations in higher CO2 (aq) reverting to the properties found for the lower CO2 (aq) >100 generation culture, while adaptation would be demonstrated by retention of characteristics shown after 100 generations of growth at high CO2 (aq) when the cells are subsequently cultured at the lower CO2 (aq) (see ).
Materials and Methods
An axenic culture of the diatom Thalassiosira pseudonana CCMP1335 (Coscinodiscophyceae) (Hustedt) Hasle et Heimdal was obtained from the Provasoli-Guillard National Center for Culture of Marine Phytoplankton (CCMP), Maine, USA. Cultures were grown in f/2 + Si media , based on seawater collected from a long-term observatory in the English Channel (; www.westernchannelobservatory.org.uk). Axenic cultures were grown at 14°C with a light:dark cycle of 16∶8 h. Light was cool-white fluorescent, resulting in a photon flux of 60 µmol quanta m−2 s−1 in the centre of each culture vessel.
There were two treatments – higher CO2 (aq) (760 µatm CO2) and present-day CO2 (aq) (380 µatm CO2) conditions. Media and cultures for present-day conditions were bubbled with 0.2 µm filtered air, resulting in a pH of 8.1. Media for the higher CO2 (aq) cultures was equilibrated with a gas mixture of air and CO2, with a certified concentration of 760 µatm CO2 (BOC, Special products, Guildford, UK), resulting in a pH of 7.8. Media were equilibrated with the appropriate 0.2 µm-filtered gas phase immediately after autoclaving for a minimum of three days and equilibration was determined by measuring pH at regular intervals until it remained constant. Three replicate cultures for each treatment were gently aerated with sintered glass diffusers at the bottom of the vessels at a rate of approximately 40 mL min−1. For continuous cultures, medium was pumped into the culture in response to a change in culture pH detected by an Aquatronica, (Aquatronica, Cavriago, Italy) aquarium controller (Figure S1). When the pH deviated by 0.01 pH units from the set value, fresh pre-equilibrated medium was pumped into the culture vessels. Cultures were stirred continuously with magnetic stir bars at low speed. Culture volume was maintained at 350 mL, exit gas carrying media up a waste tube when the culture volume exceeded 350 mL. Exit gas was vented through a port fitted with a 0.2 µm filter.
Determination of cell number and characteristics by flow cytometry
Cells were counted and light scatter and autofluorescence was determined using a Becton Dickinson FACScan benchtop flow cytometer (Becton Dickinson, Oxford, UK), fitted with 15 mW air-cooled lasers exciting at 488 nm and standard filter combinations. Light scattered relates to a particles' refractive index, size and shape; auto-fluorescence is a measure of chlorophyll content . CELLQuest v3.0 software (Becton Dickinson) was used to analyse the data. The flow rate was calibrated using fluorescent microspheres of a known concentration (Beckman Coulter flow set fluorospheres), and means of triplicate analyses were calculated. The specific growth rate per day (µ) was calculated as
where N is the number of cells at time t1 and t0 (in days).
pH was measured using a Mettler Toledo MP220 pH meter Calibrated with pH 4, 7 and 10 standards. It has been suggested  that the high nutrient concentration of culture media complicates the determination of carbon dioxide speciation. Therefore we relied on the certified air/CO2 mixtures, rather than determination of pH, total alkalinity or dissolved inorganic carbon determinations to control the experimental conditions.
Fv/Fm and σPSII, were measured using a SATLANTIC Fluorescence Induction and Relaxation (FIRe) (Satlantic, Halifax, CA). Samples were held in the dark for 30 min, 3 mL samples were loaded in the dark and diluted with fresh f/2 media as necessary. Fluorescent blanks were estimated using 0.2 µm filtered media.
Carbon and nitrogen concentrations were determined using a Thermoquest Flash EA1112, elemental analyser. Samples were filtered through 25 mm GF/C glass fibre filters (Whatman), prepared by ashing for 4 h at 450°C to remove organic contamination. Sample volume was adjusted to yield approximately 7 µg of nitrogen per sample. Filters were dried and stored until analysed.
qPCR analysis of gene expression
The cells were harvested by centrifugation 2 h after the onset of the light period. The cell pellets were ground in a pestle and mortar with liquid nitrogen and RNA was extracted using an RNeasy mini kit with on-column DNAse treatment (both Qiagen). RNA quality was assessed using an Agilent 2100 Bioanalyser and the first strand cDNA was reverse transcribed using oligo d(T)16 primers. The primers used for qPCR are listed in Table S1. The terminology to identify different CA genes follows that used by Tachibana and colleagues . Each qPCR reaction mix contained 10 ng of cDNA, optimised concentrations of the appropriate primers and 25 µL of Power SYBR® Green PCR Master Mix in a total reaction volume of 50 µL. Amplification was performed using an ABI PRISM 7000 (Applied Biosystems, Foster city, USA) with the following thermal cycling conditions: 10 min at 95°C, followed by 40 cycles of 15 s at 95°C and 1 min at 60°C. Duplicate reactions were run for each RNA extraction. Dissociation analysis was performed following the amplification to confirm that a single product was amplified. Data were analysed using Relative Expression Software Tool (REST) 2008 software (www.gene-quantification.info) which enables the use of multiple housekeeping genes for normalisation and incorporates a pair-wise fixed randomisation test . Two housekeeping genes, EF-1α and β-actin demonstrated a consistent level of expression relative to each other in both pH auxostat and batch cultures harvested at different pH and cell densities. The expression of the target genes (δ-carbonic anhydrases CA-4 to CA-7 and RUBISCO small subunit, rbcS) from pH auxostat cultures at 760 µatm CO2 was determined relative to those at 380 µatm CO2. Unfortunately, the RNA samples harvested from pH auxostat 5 (380 µatm CO2) were lost during processing and we were therefore only able to obtain gene expression data from two of the present-day (380 µatm CO2) pH auxostats.
Following growth in continuous culture for 3 months, the effect of treatment was assessed in batch cultures under the same conditions of light and temperature as the continuous cultures. Triplicate flasks containing 900 mL of 760 µatm and 380 µatm CO2 equilibrated media were inoculated from each of the long-term continuous cultures to an initial cell density of 1×105 mL−1. Cell numbers were determined daily by Coulter Multisizer II Coulter Counter and pH was also measured. The experimental design involved inoculating media equilibrated at both 760 µatm and 380 µatm CO2 with cells from both treatments of the long-term cultures, i.e. 100 generation cells acclimated to both higher CO2 (aq) and present-day. That is, cells were transferred from continuous culture both to the same conditions (i.e. 760→760 and 380→380 µatm CO2 (aq)), and to the opposite treatment (e.g. 760→380 and 380→760 µatm CO2 (aq)). Cells were harvested in mid-exponential phase growth and analysed for C:N content, cell size and pigment content (using flow cytometry). As with all batch cultures, and despite aeration of cultures, pH of the batch cultures increased rapidly as the cell density increased. However, a consistent difference in pH was maintained between the two sets of experimental conditions; a permutation-based analysis of variance (PERMANOVA, a routine of the PRIMER statistics package) confirmed a significant difference in pH was maintained between the 760 µatm and 380 µatm CO2 treatments despite changing pH (Pseudo-F = 5.99, p = 0.002).
pH control in aerated batch cultures
The ability of T. pseudonana cultures to change the carbonate system within the culture media was monitored by measuring pH in batch cultures (f/2 medium). In low cell density cultures (<1.8×105 cells mL−1), the pH of cultures bubbled with 760 µatm CO2 remained at around pH 7.8 (Figure 1). However, at higher cell densities, pH was not controlled and increased rapidly to >9. We concluded, in accordance with similar studies of other phytoplankton, that for T. pseudonana, bubbling with CO2 can only control pH at very low cell densities.
Solid lines are the mean pH values from triplicate cultures aerated throughout the experiments with air at 380 µatm pCO2 or air enriched with CO2 at 760 µatm pCO2. Dashed lines are mean cell number from the same experiment. Error bars are ±2SD.
Organic buffers, such as Tris or HEPES, have also been used to control pH in phytoplankton cultures and reduce variability in culture conditions during long-term experiments. Batch cultures were tested for pH control with Tris concentrations of 0, 4, 8, 16.5 and 33 mmol L−1. In all cases, culture pH increased at cell densities >0.7×106 and constant pH was only maintained at initial pH values with the addition of 40 mmol L−1 Tris. However, such high buffer concentrations had adverse effects on growth rate of T. pseudonana and cell densities of buffered cultures were less than half those of unbuffered controls after 5 days. Specific growth rates (µ) were also reduced. For example, in f/2 media buffered with 40 mmol L−1 Tris and aerated with air, cultures had maximum specific growth rates (µmax) of 0.93±0.04 d−1 and in equivalent unbuffered f/2 medium, µmax was 1.34±0.11 d−1. From these findings, we concluded that the addition of organic buffers was not an appropriate methodology to study the long-term effects of ocean acidification on T. pseudonana.
Alternative approaches to achieve long-term control of culture pH and carbonate chemistry within T. pseudonana cultures are continuous or semicontinuous culturing approaches. We evaluated the latter using semicontinuous cultures that were diluted each day with fresh medium equilibrated to the required CO2 concentration. The aim was to maintain low cell numbers (target 2.5×105 cells mL−1) to minimise pH changes that were a consequence of high biomass in the cultures; it was also an aspiration to achieve high growth rates (µ = 1.0 d−1). Over a period of 20 days, there was no significant difference between the growth rate of 3 replicate cultures grown at 760 µatm CO2 with a mean specific growth rate 0.97 d−1 (±2SE 0.11) and 3 cultures bubbled with air (µ = 0.92±0.12). As far as could be ascertained from this short-term experiment, no significant variation in µ as a consequence of pCO2 (aq) was detectable (F = 0.05, p = 0.81). It was clear that much longer growth periods (>100 generations) would be required to answer questions relating to adaptation or acclimation.
Long-term continuous cultures
We developed a continuous culture approach to maintain T. pseudonana at elevated CO2 for several months. The approach used was a pH auxostat, where pH was constantly monitored and maintained by addition of fresh media equilibrated at the required CO2 concentration (Figure S1). In this system, when cell densities approached those at which CO2 utilisation by the phytoplankton exceeded the additional buffering provided by bubbling with air, the addition of fresh media restored target pH, washed out cells and reduced cell density. This approach had the advantage of maintaining a constant cell density and the constant influx of fresh media ensured perturbations in carbonate chemistry were minimised.
The dilution method of pH auxostat continuous culture was successful in maintaining constant values of pH over a 3-month period. Variation in pH between triplicate cultures was generally small but, on occasions, there were short-term variations in individual cultures that required operator intervention to correct, due to for example, a misreading pH sensor. These events can be identified (Figure 2) as transient increases in the standard errors of the mean. In general, the triplicate cultures of the two treatments responded in the same way over the duration of the experiment. Interestingly, the mean cell density of T. pseudonana cultures grown at elevated CO2 (760 µatm) was significantly lower than those grown in air (380 µatm CO2) (1.91×105 cells mL−1 compared to 2.98×105cells mL−1 at the end of the 3-month period of growth). At elevated CO2, the lower seawater pH and lower concentration of carbonate (CO32−) and borate (B(OH)4−) ions, reducing the acid-base buffering capacity, as well as reducing the buffering of increases in CO2 (Revelle Factor) of the seawater , . Reduced buffering capacity resulting in increased dilution is the likely cause of the lower cell densities in the pH auxostat continuous cultures at elevated CO2, although changes in the H+ consumption rate (which is largely due to photosynthetic C uptake) may also contribute.
Effects of long-term culture on cell physiology
After 3 months of continuous culture, a number of physiological variables were measured (Table 1) to assess if there had been any significant change as a consequence of growth at different CO2 (aq) and pH. No differences were detected in the general physical properties of the cells, such as the cellular dimensions and cell-surface properties as assessed by flow cytometry. Mean values for forward and side scatter were identical for the triplicate cultures grown under the two treatments after 100 generations. Side scatter was 41±1 (arbitrary units related to laser detection) for the cultures grown at 380 µatm pCO2, and 41±3 for the cells grown at 760 µatm pCO2. Values of forward scatter were 42±1 for cells grown at 380 µatm pCO2 and 42±2 at 760 µatm pCO2. Although no change in morphological properties of the cells was detected over the time course of the experiment, the carbon and nitrogen ratio did indicate differences between the two treatments. The mean C:N ratio for cells grown at 760 µatm pCO2 was 6.94±0.21, but for cultures grown at 380 µatm pCO2, the C:N ratio was 7.47±0.47 (F = 9.18, p < 0.01). That is, higher pCO2 (aq) appeared to have resulted in lower C:N ratio in cultures maintained under higher pCO2 (aq). However, it should be noted that one of the long-term present-day cultures was more variable than the others and this culture was responsible for the higher SE of the C:N ratio.
Chlorophyll content of each culture, as assessed from red autofluorescence cell−1 was significantly higher and more variable (250±23 arbitrary units) for cells grown at 760 µatm pCO2, compared to (235±4) for cultures grown under present-day conditions of 380 µatm pCO2 (F = 5.23, p = 0.04). Cell density in both treatments and all replicates was low and self-shading was minimal and consistent, so variation in chlorophyll concentration was not due to variation in photon flux density in the 2 cultures treatments. Again, as for C:N ratio, there was some variability in apparently identical continuous cultures and one of the higher CO2 (aq) triplicate cultures did not show any increase in red fluorescence cell−1. An increase in the chlorophyll cell−1 might be expected to change the photosynthetic capacity of the cells. However, no significant differences were detected in measurements of photophysiology. Photosynthetic efficiency (Fv/Fm) was 0.62±0.01 for cultures grown at 380 at µatm pCO2, and 0.60±0.02 for 760 µatm pCO2. No change was observed in the functional absorption cross section of photosystem II (σPSII) (742±52 for 380 µatm pCO2 cultures and 772±65 at 760 µatm pCO2).
The effect of long-term growth at elevated CO2 on components of the CCM was examined by determining the relative expression of four δ-CA homologues (CA-4 to CA-7) and the RUBISCO small subunit, rbcS using qPCR, with normalization to two housekeeping genes (EF-1α and β-actin). Expression of CA-4 was significantly lower in cultures grown at 760 µatm CO2 relative to cultures grown at 380 µatm pCO2 (Figure 3), whilst CA-5, CA-7 and rbcS did not show any significant differences in gene expression. Expression of CA-6 also appeared to be slightly lower in 760 µatm pCO2 cultures, but this was not statistically significant.
qPCR was used to determine the gene expression ratio in cultures grown at 760 µatm pCO2 relative to those grown at 380 µatm pCO2. Boxes represent the inter-quartile range, or the middle 50% of observations. The dotted line represents the median gene expression. Whiskers represent the minimum and maximum observations.
To test for evidence of culture acclimation or adaptation after growth at 760 µatm pCO2 for ∼100 generations, cells from the long-term continuous cultures were used to inoculate batch cultures aerated with either 380 µatm or 760 µatm pCO2. Batch cultures were used in this assay as growth rates can be easily calculated to provide a simple and robust measure of fitness. Following short lag phases, the cultures grew exponentially (Figure 4). Mean specific growth rates (d−1) were 0.88±0.29 in the 380→380 treatment, 0.64±0.13 in the 380→760 treatment, 0.91±0.33 in the 760→380 treatment and 1.02±0.19 in the 760→760 treatment. Since these were batch cultures, the pH of the media increased steadily and after 4 d the 760 µatm pCO2 culture had changed from an initial pH of 7.9 to 8.7±0.1 and the air equilibrated cultures had increased from pH 8.1 to 9.1±0.1. Although there were slight and consistent differences between cell densities in the different treatments, they were not statistically significant. PERMANOVA showed no differences between treatments or between specific growth rates at 3 points on the growth curve or on any interaction between time point and treatment.
Cells from all 6 long-term cultures each inoculated into batch cultures aerated at 760 µatm pCO2 or 380 µatm pCO2. For example, 760→760 represents cells from the long-term culture grown at 760 µatm pCO2 inoculated into a batch culture equilibrated with 760 µatm CO2. 760→380 represents the same cells (from 760 µatm CO2 continuous culture) inoculated into a batch culture equilibrated with 380 µatm CO2. Mean values (±2SE) of triplicate batch cultures from each inoculum.
In contrast to the long-term continuous cultures, there were no significant differences in a number of physiological measures. The C:N ratios of the batch cultures under the 4 treatments (760→760, 760→380, 380→760 & 380→380 µatm) were not significantly different (global test ANOSIM: R = 0.03, P = 19.5%). The mean (±SD) C:N ratios were 6.14±0.15 for 760→760, 6.31±0.52 for 760→380, 5.95±0.25 for 380→760 and 6.17±0.23 for 380→380 cultures. In addition, photosynthetic parameters were uniform in these experiments. A PERMANOVA analysis detected no significant differences between the 4 treatments in either Fv/Fm or σ. Mean Fv/Fm ratios were 0.59±0.02 (760→760), 0.58±0.03 (760→380), 0.60±0.02 (380→760) and 0.59±0.01 (380→380). Values of σ were 856±40 (760→760), 908±98 (760→380), 829±37 (380→760), and 877±19 (380→380). Finally, there were no significant differences in forward scatter, side scatter or chlorophyll fluorescence cell−1 in cultures grown under different CO2 treatments (Table 2).
It is essential to understand how phytoplankton will respond to the higher CO2 (aq)/lower pH conditions that will occur in the surface ocean in the near future as a result of the dissolution of anthropogenic CO2. However, this study highlights the difficulty of investigating the effects of ocean acidification in laboratory culture. Cell densities that are commonly employed in culture rapidly deplete CO2 (aq) from the medium and result in rapid increases in pH. For example, Shi and colleagues  observed that T. weissflogii cells growing to a cell density of 5×103 cells mL−1 from an initial inoculum of 20–100 cells mL−1 caused an increase of 0.1 pH units. Buffers can help to maintain target pH, but there are often unknown effects that make them less than ideal and, in this study, resulted in lower specific growth rates.
As we demonstrate here, dilute cell densities provide one approach that allows long-term maintenance of target pH. The approach adopted here, of dilution with media equilibrated with different pCO2, has advantages over other designs of pH stat that are maintained by the addition of acid or base in response to deviations from the required pH. Although addition of acid or base is very effective at maintaining pH, total alkalinity may be altered, which at high biomass can lead to significant perturbations in carbonate chemistry. However, a disadvantage of the dilution method of the pH auxostat is that it is highly labour-intensive, and large volumes of pre-equilibrated media are required to maintain the cultures.
Overall, there were very few effects on T. pseudonana of long-term culture at different pCO2 and pH (Table 1). Certainly, neither forward nor side scatter measurements were able to detect any difference between cells grown at higher or present-day CO2 (aq). However, there were significant differences in C:N ratio and in red fluorescence cell−1; C:N ratio was significantly lower and red fluorescence cell−1 was elevated in the higher CO2 (aq) cultures (although there was high variability between replicate cultures). In fact, the C:N ratio of the higher CO2 (aq) culture was closer to the Redfield ratio of 6.6 than for the cells from the present-day CO2 (aq) cultures. Changes in C:N ratio and increased production of extracellular organic matter have been reported in other studies of the effect of ocean acidification and the term ‘carbon overconsumption’ has been applied to the uptake of carbon in excess of the expected amount calculated from the nitrate uptake and Redfield ratio –. In the present study, extracellular production was not measured and, although there were significant differences in C:N ratio between treatments, this was largely the result of high variability in one of the replicate cultures. In this study, we have no evidence for consistent increases in C content after >100 generations growth at higher CO2 (aq).
Red fluorescence cell−1 was significantly higher after >100 generations at 760 µatm than at 380 µatm pCO2 (F = 5.23, P<0.05: Table 1). Other studies have also suggested that increased CO2 can lead to higher pigment content per cell in phytoplankton , . However, variation in pigment content is usually associated with photo-acclimation, rather than changes in DIC . Whatever the reason, higher red fluorescence cell−1 did not result in detectible changes to photophysiology. Determinations of Fv/Fm and σPSII were not significantly different in any of the treatments. There is no evidence from our measurements to suggest that photosynthetic rate had changed during the long-term culture period.
We also have no evidence that growth rate varied as a consequence of CO2 treatment. In semicontinuous cultures, growth rates were identical in cultures supplied with 780 or 360 µatm CO2 (aq). Other studies have also failed to find a direct effect of elevated CO2 on cell division of T. pseudonana. Pruder and Bolton  found that growth rate was unaffected by increased CO2 at 760 µatm pCO2, and similar results have been reported for other diatom species , , , .
The most significant effect of culture treatment that we have measured was in expression of CA. There are 13 candidate sequences in the T. pseudonana genome, which are predicted to encode 3 α-, 5 γ-, 4 δ- and 1 ξ-CAs although to date none have been characterized experimentally for CA enzyme activity . McGinn and Morel  demonstrated that, of the four δ-CAs in T. pseudonana, CA-4 and CA-6 transcripts were the most abundant and the most responsive to changes in carbon availability; it should be noted that very high (1% - 10000 µatm) pCO2 (aq) concentrations were used to demonstrate the regulation of δ-CA expression . CA-4 and CA-6 were strongly induced by CO2 depletion (pH 8.9) and highly repressed in the presence of 1% CO2 at pH 7.2 . Tachibana and colleagues  examined the expression of three CAs by RT-PCR and found that transcripts of CA-1, CA-3 and CA-7 (representing α-, ξ- and δ-CAs respectively) were much less abundant in cells grown at 0.16% (1600 µatm pCO2) compared to cells grown in media equilibrated with air. In the present study, which used a much lower pCO2 – 780 or 360 µatm CO2 (aq) in long-term cultures – the effect of treatment on δ-CA transcription was more subtle. Only CA-4 showed any significant change and was substantially repressed at higher CO2. We do not know the subcellular localisation of the δ-CAs in T. pseudonana. Using signal sequence analysis, Tachibana and colleagues  predicted that the δ-CAs would be located in the cytosol, but did not test this experimentally. However, by expressing GFP-fusions, they were able to demonstrate that CA-1 and CA-3 were localized to the stroma and the cytosol respectively. As both of these CAs exhibited reduced transcription in cells grown at high CO2, we might expect that multiple aspects of the CCM in T. pseudonana will respond to future elevations in atmospheric CO2.
The transcriptional responses of CA-4 were measured after ∼100 generations of growth at 780 µatm CO2 (aq); so this was not a transient response to changing pCO2, but persisted throughout a long-term acclimation. Only one component of CCMs was investigated in this study and no doubt there would be many differences in the transcriptome of T. pseudonana between growth at 780 or 360 µatm CO2 (aq). The only other gene investigated in this study, RUBISCO small subunit, showed no variation in rbcS transcription between CO2 treatments. This is consistent with the findings of Granum and colleagues  that RUBISCO transcription is rather invariant, since there were no differences in expression of the large RUBISCO subunit (rbcL) in T. pseudonana cultures grown at 100 or 380 µatm CO2.
So, if higher pCO2 were to be beneficial to phytoplankton in a future high-CO2 ocean, where would significant savings in protein costs occur? That is, would there be significant benefits to the cell by modulating CO2 supply to RUBISCO rather than the regulating the expression levels of the enzyme? RUBISCO comprises a large fraction of total protein in cyanobacteria and microalgae (from 4% to 0.23% of total cell protein , ). CAs are probably a much smaller proportion of total protein – periplasmic CAs are of the order of 0.0012% in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii . A reduction in synthesis of the CO2-responsive CAs in T. pseudonana is unlikely to have much impact on the protein costs of the cell. However, a recent study of the efficiency of the CCM in marine diatoms, which integrates a physiological and a modelling approach, suggests that active transport of HCO3- into the chloroplast constitutes the major energetic cost of the CCM . A model of the Phaeodactylum tricornutum CCM, which ignores the comparatively minor costs relating to the synthesis of CCM components, predicts that a doubling of atmospheric CO2 could result in a 20% reduction in the energetic cost of the CCM, equating to a 3–6% reduction in the total cost of carbon fixation . Thus, the doubling of atmospheric CO2 from present-day levels may yield an energetic benefit to diatoms, but any benefits would be marginal and may not be detectable as a change in specific growth rate. This prediction is in keeping with the results of our long-term experimental study of T. pseudonana at elevated CO2, in which we observed little change in multiple physiological parameters. As this study has shown, standard methods to determine µmax do not have the sensitivity to detect any subtle variations in response to different pCO2 concentrations. The labour-intensive nature of the pH auxostat cultures meant that replication was limited to 3 cultures per treatment and we are aware that this limits the power of our statistical analyses. Performing long-term experiments under carefully controlled conditions, with sufficient replication to allow statistical determination of subtle phenotypes, has been recognised as an important challenge .
In conclusion, growth over 100 generations did not provide evidence for significant adaptation of T. pseudonana CCMP1335 to increased CO2. There were small changes in C:N ratio and reduced expression of one δ-CA when cells were maintained at increased CO2 for 3 months. T. pseudonana appears to be capable of successful acclimation to growth at a wide range of pH. Although data from other diatom species are currently lacking, if all diatoms respond in a similar fashion to T. pseudonana, acidification of this magnitude in the future ocean may have little effect on diatom productivity.
Design of a single vessel for pH auxostat continuous culture. Cultures were bubbled continuously with air at either 760 µatm pCO2 or 380 µatm pCO2. Cultures were also stirred and pH was continuously monitored via a pH meter. An increase in pH triggered the pump, resulting in an influx of f/2 seawater media which was pre-equilibrated via aeration with air at either 760 µatm pCO2 or 380 µatm pCO2. The media influx dilutes the culture, acting to both reduce the cell density and to restore the original pH. Six of these culture vessels were maintained attached to a single control unit.
Primer sequences for qRT-PCR. Forward (F) and reverse (R) primer pairs were designed to amplify regions of 200–300 bases for real-time PCR analysis. The alternative gene identity refers the name used by McGinn & Morel . CA-7 has been previously identified by the protein ID 22619, although protein ID 34094 is used in the genome.
We thank Martin Mühling for helpful discussions and advice during the initial stages of the research.
Conceived and designed the experiments: KJC IJ JAR GLW. Performed the experiments: KJC EJB. Analyzed the data: KJC EJB GLW IJ. Wrote the paper: KJC IJ JAR GLW.
- 1. Doney SC, Fabry VJ, Feely RA, Kleypas JA (2009) Ocean acidification: the other CO2 problem. Annu Rev Mar Sci 1: 169–92.
- 2. Riebesell U, Zondervan I, Rost B, Tortell PD, Zeebe RE, et al. (2000) Reduced calcification of marine plankton in response to increased atmospheric CO2. Nature 407: 364–367.
- 3. Ridgwell A, Schmid DN, Turley C, Brownlee C, Maldonado MT, et al. (2009) From laboratory manipulations to Earth system models: scaling calcification impacts of ocean acidification. Biogeosciences 6: 2611–2623.
- 4. Findlay HS, Calosi P, Crawfurd KJ (2011) Determinants of the PIC:POC response in the coccolithophore Emiliania huxleyi under future ocean acidification scenarios. Limnol Oceanogr 56: 1168–1178.
- 5. Beaufort L, Probert I, de Garidel-Thoron T, Bendif EM, Ruiz-Pino D, et al. (2011) Sensitivity of coccolithophores to carbonate chemistry and ocean acidification. Nature 476: 80–83.
- 6. Raven JA (1991) Physiology of inorganic C acquisition and implications for resource use efficiency by marine phytoplankton: relation to increased CO2 and temperature Plant Cell Environ 14: 779–794.
- 7. Beardall J, Raven JA (2004) The potential effects of global climate change on microalgal photosynthesis, growth and ecology. Phycologia 43: 26–40.
- 8. Giordano M, Beardall J, Raven JA (2005) CO2 concentrating mechanisms in algae: Mechanisms, environmental modulation, and evolution. Ann Rev Plant Biol 56: 99–131.
- 9. Reinfelder JR (2011) Carbon concentrating mechanism in eukaryotic marine phytoplankton. Annu Rev Marine Sciences 3: 291–315.
- 10. Pruder GD, Bolton ET (1979) The role of CO2 enrichment of aerating gas in the growth on an estuarine diatom. Aquaculture 17: 1–15.
- 11. Clark DR, Flynn KJ (2000) The relationship between the dissolved inorganic carbon concentration and growth rate in marine phytoplankton. Proc Roy Soc Lond B 267: 953–957.
- 12. Roberts K, Granum E, Leegood RC, Raven JA (2007) C3 and C4 pathways of photosynthetic carbon assimilation in marine diatoms are under genetic, not environmental, control. Plant Physiol 145: 230–235.
- 13. Kim J-M, Lee K, Shin K, Kang J-H, Lee H-W, et al. (2006) The effect of seawater CO2 concentration on growth of a natural phytoplankton assemblage in a controlled mesocosm experiment. Limnol Oceanogr 51: 1629–1636.
- 14. Tortell PD, Payne C, Guenguen C, Strzepek RF, Boyd PW, et al. (2008) Inorganic carbon uptake by Southern ocean phytoplankton. Limnol Oceanogr 53: 1266–1278.
- 15. Tortell PD, Reinfelder JR, Morel FMM (1997) Active uptake of bicarbonate by diatoms. Nature 390: 243–244.
- 16. Mann DG (1999) The species concept in diatoms. Phycologia 38: 437–495.
- 17. Armbrust EV, Berges JA, Bowler C, Green BR, Martinez D, et al. (2004) The genome of the diatom Thalassiosira pseudonana: ecology, evolution and metabolism. Science 306: 79–86.
- 18. Rost B, Zondervan I, Wolf-Gladrow D (2008) Sensitivity of phytoplankton to future changes in ocean carbonate chemistry: current knowledge, contradictions and research directions. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 373: 227–237.
- 19. Shi D, Xu Y, Morel FMM (2009) Effects of the pH/pCO2 control method on medium chemistry and phytoplankton growth. Biogeosciences 6: 1199–1207.
- 20. Martin GA, Hempfling WP (1976) A method for the regulation of microbial population density during continuous culture at high growth rates. Arch Microbiol 107: 41–47.
- 21. Raven JA, Geider RD (2003) Adaptation, acclimation and regulation of photosynthesis in algae. In Larkum AWD, Douglas SE, Raven JA [Ed.] Photosynthesis in algae. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, the Netherlands, 385-412:
- 22. Collins S, Bell G (2004) Phenotypic consequences of 1000 generations of selection at elevated CO2 in a green alga. Nature 431: 566–569.
- 23. Collins S (2010) Comment on “Effects of long-term high CO2 exposure on two species of coccolithophores: by Müller, et al. 2010. Biogeosciences 7: 2199–2202.
- 24. Huertas IE, Rouco M, López-Rodas V, Costas E (2011) Warming will affect phytoplankton differentially: evidence through a mechanistic approach. Proc Roy Soc B In press. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2011.0160
- 25. Elena SF, Lenski RE (2003) Evolution experiments with microorganisms: the dynamics and genetic bases of adaptation. Nat Rev Genet 4: 457–469.
- 26. McGinn PJ, Morel FMM (2008) Expression and regulation of carbonic anhydrases in the marine diatom Thalassiosira pseudonana and in natural phytoplankton assemblages from Great Bay, New Jersey. Physiol Plant 133: 78–91.
- 27. Guillard RRL, Ryther JH (1962) Studies of marine planktonic diatoms. I. Cyclotella nana Hustedt and Detonula confervacea Cleve. Can J Microbiol 8: 229–239.
- 28. Harris R (2010) The L4 time series: the first 20 years. J Plankton Res 32: 577–583.
- 29. Marie D, Simon N, Vaulot D (2005) Phytoplankton cell counting by flow cytometry. In Andersen, R. A. [Ed] Algal Culturing Techniques, Elsevier Academic Press 253-268:
- 30. Riebesell U, Fabry VJ, Hansson L, Gattuso J-P [Eds] (2010) Guide to best practices for ocean acidification research and data reporting, 260 p. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
- 31. Tachibana M, Allen AE, Kikutani S, Endo Y, Bowler C, et al. (2011) Photosynthesis Res. 109: 205–221.
- 32. Pfaffl MW, Horgan GW, Dempfle L (2002) Relative expression software tool (REST) for group-wise comparison and statistical analysis of relative expression results in real-time PCR. Nucleic Acids Res 30: e36.
- 33. Zeebe RE, Wolf-Gladrow D (2001) CO2 in seawater: equilibration, equilibrium, kinetics, isotopes. Elsevier Oceanographic Series, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands 346:
- 34. Author's committee on the development of an integrated science strategy for ocean science monitoring, research and impacts assessment: National Research Council (2010) Ocean acidification: a national strategy to meet the challenges of a changing world. National Academies Press, 500 Fifth Street NW, Washington DC 20001m USA 175:
- 35. Engel A, DeLille B, Jacquet S, Riebesell U, Rochelle-Newall E, et al. (2004) Transparent exopolymer particles and dissolved organic carbon production by Emiliania huxleyi exposed to different CO2 concentrations: a mesocosm experiment. Aquat Microb Ecol 34: 93–104.
- 36. Engel A, Zondervan I, Aerts K, Beaufort L, Benthien A, et al. (2005) Testing the direct effect of CO2 concentration on a bloom of the coccolithophorid Emiliania huxleyi in mesocosm experiments. Limnol Oceanogr 50: 493–507.
- 37. Riebesell U, Schultz KG, Bellerby RGJ, Botros M, Fritsche P, et al. (2007) Enhanced biological carbon consumption in a high CO2 ocean. Nature 450: 545–548.
- 38. Fu F-X, Warner ME, Zhang Y, Feng Y, Hutchins DA (2007) Effects of increased temperature and CO2 on photosynthesis, growth, and elemental ratios in marine Synechococcus and Prochlorococcus cyanobacteria. J Phycol 43: 485–396.
- 39. Tortell PD (2000) Evolutionary and ecological perspectives on inorganic carbon acquisition in phytoplankton. Limnol Oceanogr 45: 744–750.
- 40. Granum E, Roberts K, Raven JA, Leegood RC (2009) Primary carbon and nitrogen metabolic gene expression in the diatom Thalassiosira pseudonana (Bacillariophyceae): diel periodicity and effects of inorganic carbon and nitrogen. J Phycol 45: 1083–1092.
- 41. Brown CM, MacKinnon JD, Cockshutt AM, Villareal TA, Campbell DA (2008) Flux capacities and acclimation costs in Trichodesmium from the Gulf of Mexico. Mar Biol 154: 413–422.
- 42. Husic MD, Moroney JV, Tolbert NE (1987) The role of carbonic anhydrase in the inorganic carbon concentrating system of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. In J. Biggins [Ed.] Progress in Photosynthesis Research, Nijhoff, Dordrecht, the Netherlands 317-324:
- 43. Hopkinson BM, Dupont CL, Allen AE, Morel FMM (2011) Efficiency of the CO2-concentrating mechanism of diatoms. Proc Natl Acad Sci 108: 3830–3837.