In many eukaryotes, messenger RNAs with premature termination codons are destroyed by a process called “nonsense-mediated decay”, which requires the RNA helicase Upf1 and also, usually, an interacting factor, Upf2. Recognition of premature termination codons may rely on their distance from either a splice site or the polyadenylation site, and long 3′-untranslated regions can trigger mRNA decay. The protist Trypanosoma brucei relies heavily on mRNA degradation to determine mRNA levels, and 3′-untranslated regions play a major role in control of mRNA decay. We show here that trypanosomes have a homologue of Upf1, TbUPF1, which interacts with TbUPF2 and (in an RNA-dependent fashion) with poly(A) binding protein 1, PABP1. Introduction of a premature termination codon in either an endogenous gene or a reporter gene decreased mRNA abundance, as expected for nonsense-mediated decay, but a dependence of this effect on TbUPF1 could not be demonstrated, and depletion of TbUPF1 by over 95% had no effect on parasite growth or the mRNA transcriptome. Further investigations of the reporter mRNA revealed that increases in open reading frame length tended to increase mRNA abundance. In contrast, inhibition of translation, either using 5′-secondary structures or by lengthening the 5′-untranslated region, usually decreased reporter mRNA abundance. Meanwhile, changing the length of the 3′-untranslated region had no consistent effect on mRNA abundance. We suggest that in trypanosomes, translation per se may inhibit mRNA decay, and interactions with multiple RNA-binding proteins preclude degradation based on 3′-untranslated region length alone.
Citation: Delhi P, Queiroz R, Inchaustegui D, Carrington M, Clayton C (2011) Is There a Classical Nonsense-Mediated Decay Pathway in Trypanosomes? PLoS ONE 6(9): e25112. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0025112
Editor: Najib M. El-Sayed, The University of Maryland, United States of America
Received: July 7, 2011; Accepted: August 24, 2011; Published: September 21, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Delhi et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was funded by the Land of Baden Württemberg (core funding to CC), by a Wellcome Trust grant to CC and MC, and by the Deutsche Forschunggemeinshaft (TM). Rafael Queiroz was supported by a fellowship from the Deutsches Akademisches Austauschdienst. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The eukaryotic nonsense mediated decay (NMD) pathway degrades mRNAs with mutations that result in premature termination of translation , , . Premature termination codons (PTC) can occur through frame-shift or point mutations, or as a consequence of splicing defects. NMD requires translation in order to recognise a PTC, and occurs in the cytoplasm , . An ATP-dependent RNA helicase called Upf1 is essential for NMD , , , , . The helicase activity is required : over-expression of a helicase-dead Upf1 mutant had a dominant-negative effect . Some forms of NMD also require Upf2, which interacts with Upf1. Upf1 sequences have been found in all eukaryotic groups tested so far , . In contrast some organisms have no obvious Upf2, and its loss is correlated with mutations in the Upf2-interaction domain of Upf1 , . NMD in mammals involves phosphorylation of Upf1 by the Smg-1 kinase; it is not clear if the phosphorylation is necessary in yeast and Smg-1 is not conserved .
A nonsense codon can be recognised as a PTC by various mechanisms, depending on both the gene and the species. In several organisms, the nature of the 3′-UTR is important: NMD can be triggered by the presence of an abnormally long 3′-UTR, or by specific sequences in the 3′-UTR or around the termination codon . In a recent study of human cells, Upf1 loading on several mRNAs was shown to be directly proportional to UTR length, suggesting that UPF1 was able to bind non-specifically to the parts of the mRNA that were not being actively translated and thereby “measure” the 3′-UTR length . Most Saccharomyces cerevisiae 3′UTRs are less than 300 bases long  and the presence of a 3′-UTR that is longer than usual can trigger NMD . Similarly, the distance from the PTC to the poly(A) tail has been shown to determine NMD in Drosophila melanogaster , , and long 3′-UTRs are associated with NMD in Arabidopsis thaliana . This type of NMD depends on ribosome release factors, which can complex either with Upf1 or with poly(A) binding protein (PABP). A current model suggests that when a 3′-UTR is abnormally long, interactions with Upf1 predominate, resulting in recruitment of the mRNA decay machinery , , , . Upf2 is not obligatory for this type of NMD in yeast  or human cells . In S. pombe the determinants for NMD are uncertain, the main criterion appearing to be the ORF length . Giardia, too, exhibits NMD-like mRNA decay, but the precise signals are unknown and dependence on UPF1 has not been demonstrated .
Mammalian cells have a splicing-dependent NMD pathway, which depends on the proteins of the exon junction complex (EJC), which are deposited −20 to −24 nucleotides upstream of the splice junction , , . The EJC contains the NMD factor Upf3; this recruits Upf2 which in turn recruits Upf1. In contrast, in Schizosaccharomyces pombe, unspliced mRNAs were subject to weak NMD: the abundance of a reporter mRNA decreased concordantly with coding region length, and 3′-UTR length had little influence . The presence of a nearby intron, either upstream or downstream of the PTC, enhanced NMD and the EJC was not required .
NMD targets mRNAs that have short open reading frames (ORFs) upstream of the start codon , , , suppresses splicing defects , , ,  and disposes of non-coding polyadenylated RNAs . To investigate the overall role of NMD in regulation of gene expression, transcriptome profiles have been obtained for cells depleted of NMD factors. In S. cerevisiae, nearly a tenth of all mRNAs showed increased abundance in Δupf1 cells, , , . The identified transcript set was markedly skewed towards mRNAs that had relatively low abundances, and about half of the affected mRNAs were bound to Upf1, suggesting that they were direct NMD targets . Depletion of Upf1 in animals caused 2–10 fold increases in many mRNAs, a substantial proportion of which are likely to be direct NMD substrates , , . In Caenorhabditis elegans, for example, depletion of Upf1 increased the abundance of mRNAs that arose from splicing errors, or had upstream open reading frames .
Despite all this, the full physiological importance of NMD is not yet clear. Notably, Upf1, Upf2 and Upf3 are not essential for viability in yeast or Caenorhabditis elegans. Upf1 is essential for shoot development in Arabidopsis , mammalian embryonic viability  and Drosophila development ; but it is not known whether NMD-specific or non-NMD-specific function(s) of Upf1 are implicated. So far, the only protist in which NMD has been investigated is Giardia lamblia. In Giardia, introductions of PTCs into a luciferase reporter mRNA reduced mRNA abundance by up to 70% . The dependence of the PTC-induced mRNA decrease on Upf1 was not tested, but extra expression of tagged Upf1 reduced the abundance of the truncated luciferase mRNA further and influenced a small number of native mRNAs .
Kinetoplastids are protists that diverged from animals and plants early in eukaryotic evolution. In Kinetoplastids, transcription is polycistronic. Individual mRNAs are cleaved from the precursor by trans splicing of a 39 nt capped leader to the 5′ end of the RNA, and by polyadenylation at the 3′-end; only one cis-spliced mRNA has been experimentally demonstrated . The abundances of mRNAs are determined post-transcriptionally and variations in mRNA half-lives have been extensively documented. In most cases examined, mRNA abundances were shown to be determined by sequences in the 3′-UTR and regulatory RNA-binding proteins , , . The mRNA decay machinery is overall similar to that in yeast, plants, and animals , , , , and RNA interference is present , but the existence of NMD has hitherto not been documented. In this paper we investigate the function of Upf1 and the possible existence of NMD in the Kinetoplastid Trypanosoma brucei.
Sequence analysis and domain organisation of TbUPF1 and TbUPF2
The trypanosome genome has single loci encoding TbUPF1 (Tb927.5.2140)  and TbUPF2 (Tb11.02.4270). The TbUPF1 homolog encodes a protein of predicted molecular weight of 93.3 kDa which shares 42.77% and 43.58% identity with human and S. cerevisiae Upf1, respectively (see Figure S1). It has a highly conserved N-terminal Cysteine-Histidine-rich domain (CH domain) which includes the amino acid residues needed for interacting with Upf2  – present in all other sequences analysed except that from Giardia intestinalis. The amino acid sequence from residue 368 to 608 of TbUPF1 contains the ATPase and DEAD-like helicase domains that are known to be essential for NMD.
TbUPF2 is a protein of 162.5 kDa. The N-terminal part contains two MIF4G-like domains with very low scores (InterPro) followed by a single consensus MIF4G domain (SMART score 0.0013), analogous to the third MIF4G domain of human Upf2. There is then a Glu/Asp-rich acidic region. We identified no matches for Upf3, Smg-6 or Smg-7. BLASTp using Smg-1 revealed a variety of kinase domains but no clear homologue.
Effect of TbUPF1 and TbUPF2 depletion on trypanosome growth
To find out whether TbUPF1 and TbUPF2 were required for trypanosome growth, we created bloodstream and procyclic trypanosome cell lines with tetracycline-inducible RNAi. We failed to generate an appropriate anti-UPF1 antibody, so to assess the effect of the RNAi on the protein, we tagged one copy of UPF1 in situ, so that the expressed protein had an N-terminal V5 tag. Two procyclic form clones with up to 88% reduction in the mRNA (Figure 1A) showed slightly prolonged division times but this was independent of the presence of tetracycline (Figure 1B), so might be due to clonal variation. A procyclic line in which dsRNA against TbUPF1 was made by synthesising the entire ORF as a double strand, using opposing T7 polymerase promoters, grew slowly in the absence of tetracycline and almost completely stopped dividing upon tetracycline addition (Figure 1C). This could have been a consequence of extremely effective depletion, but off-target effects cannot be ruled out. In bloodstream trypanosomes with one V5-tagged UPF1 allele, RNAi targeting UPF1 resulted in over 95% depletion of V5-UPF1 without any effect on growth (not shown). Inducible RNAi against TbUPF2 did not affect procyclic trypanosome growth or morphology up to 7 days post-tetracycline addition (Figure 1B) although the transcript was 80% reduced after 3 days (not shown). In a recently published high-throughput RNAi screen, cells with UPF1 or UPF2 RNAi even appeared to have a selective advantage in bloodstream forms, but not procyclic forms : although high-throughput results must always be viewed with caution, in this case they were consistent with the results of our focussed experiments. All evidence so far therefore indicates that neither UPF1 nor UPF2 is required for bloodstream trypanosome growth and division, but there were hints that some UPF1 might be needed for optimal growth of procyclic forms. We do not know whether either protein is completely dispensable because a knockout was not attempted.
(A) Procyclic trypanosomes with or without tetracycline-inducible TbUPF1-FLAG or Tbupf1-1-FLAG transgenes (induced for 48 h), or inducible RNAi hp-hairpin (induced for 72 h), p2T7 – opposing T7 promoters (induced for 24 h) were grown with (+) or without (−) tetracycline (200 ng/ml) for the indicated time and then harvested for RNA preparation. Northern blots were probed for TbUPF1 or tubulin (TUB) RNA. The extra band in lane 6 is the dsRNA synthesised from TbUPF1 RNAi plasmid and the extra bands in lanes 8 and 10 are the exogenous expressed TbUPF1/Tbupf1-1 transcripts. (B) Procyclic cells containing hp RNAi or over-expression plasmids were grown in presence and absence of tetracycline (0.1 ug/ml) and the cell count taken every 24 hours for at least 7 days. Cells were diluted to 5×105 cells/ml to maintain exponential growth. Cumulative growth curves were plotted using Kaleidograph, and the doubling times for each line in the presence and absence of tetracycline were estimated using the computer-fitted growth curves. (C) Growth curve of procyclic trypanosome containing the p2T7 UPF1 RNAi construct. Details of the growth conditions and induction are as in (B). (D) Western blot analysis on 2×107 cells of bloodstream or procyclic trypanosomes expressing flag-tagged wild-type TbUPF1 or the helicase mutant Tbupf1-1, using anti-flag antibody. The control antibody was anti-aldolase for bloodstream forms; for procyclics a cross-reacting band is shown. (E) Interaction of tagged TbUPF1 with TbUPF2. TbUPF2-myc (lanes 7–12) was expressed in trypanosomes with a V5-tagged TbUPF1 gene. Cells with no myc-tagged protein (lanes 1–6) served as a control. Extracts were immunoprecipitated with anti-myc, in the presence or absence of RNase. 2.5% of the input (lanes 1, 2, 7, 8) and unbound (lanes 3, 4, 9, 10,) fractions, and the whole eluates (lanes 5, 6, 11, 12,) were separated by SDS-PAGE, blotted, and probed with antibodies to myc, V5 and PABP. *IgG heavy chain. (F) TbUPF1-flag is in the cytoplasm. Fixed procyclic trypanosomes expressing UPF1-FLAG were stained for the flag tag and counterstained for DNA with DAPI. Cells with no FLAG construct showed only much fainter background fluorescence.
For over-expression analysis, we created bloodstream and procyclic trypanosomes with tetracycline-inducible expression of FLAG-tagged wild type TbUPF1. We also inducibly expressed an R747C mutant version, Tbupf1-1. This is equivalent to the yeast R779C and human R844C Upf1 mutants, expression of which abrogated NMD in a dominant-negative fashion , . Expression of either protein in bloodstream forms had no effect on growth. In procyclic forms, the TbUPF1-flag and Tbupf1-1-flag transcripts were, respectively, <2-fold and 13-fold more abundant than the endogenous TbUPF1 transcript (Figure 1A). Correspondingly, Tbupf1-1-flag protein was considerably more abundant than TbUPF1-flag (Figure 1D). Expression of TbUPF1-flag marginally inhibited cell growth; expression of Tbupf1-1-flag resulted in some slightly abnormal parasite morphology (not shown) but did not change the division time (Figure 1B). The inducibly-expressed TbUPF1-flag was readily detectable by immunofluorescence and located predominantly in the cytoplasm (Figure 1F).
TbUPF1 interacts with TbUPF2
To find out whether TbUPF1 and TbUPF2 interact, we co-expressed TbUPF2-myc in cells with in situ V5-tagged TbUPF1 (Figure 1E). Immunoprecipitation with anti-myc antibody resulted in co-precipitation of both V5-TbUPF1 and PABP (lane 11). The interaction between V5-TbUPF1 and TbUPF2-myc was not affected by RNase treatment, whereas PABP was released (lane 12). Comparison of the band intensities in lanes 7 and 8 (2.5% of input) and pull down (100%) indicated that only a small proportion of V5-TbUPF1 was bound to TbUPF2-myc, but the myc pull-down also showed poor efficiency (compare lanes 9 & 10 with lanes 7 & 8). The control immunoprecipitation (using cells that did not express a myc-tagged protein) pulled down very little V5-TbUPF1 and no detectable PABP (lanes 5 & 6). These results confirmed that Tb11.02.4270 is indeed likely to be TbUPF2, as predicted in . The results also indicated that tagged TbUPF2 and TbUPF1 were bound to PABP in an RNA-dependent fashion.
So far, our results were consistent with a role of TbUPF1 in cytoplasmic mRNA metabolism.
The abundance of a PTC-containing trypanosome mRNA decreases with ORF length
To find out whether trypanosomes degrade mRNAs containing premature termination codons (PTCs) we inserted PTCs into a trypanosome ORF. We started with bloodstream trypanosomes lacking the non-essential gene (Tb927.2.6000) encoding glycosyl phosphatidylinositol phospholipase C (GPI-PLC) . We took plasmids containing either the wild-type GPI-PLC gene or a PTC-containing version, with an associated selectable marker. These plasmids were transfected into trypanosomes so that they would integrated into the original locus  (Figure S2). The wild-type open reading frame contains 342 codons; the modified transgenes contained PTCs at codon 17, codon 102 or codon 237. We had previously reported that the PTC at position 17 (51 nt ORF) had little effect on the amount of mRNA, but the abundance had not been quantified . More careful analysis revealed that this PTC reduced the steady state level of the GPI-PLC mRNA to 35% of normal (Figure 2). PTCs at codons 102 or 237 reduced the levels marginally, to ∼80% of normal. These cells lines contain most of the drug resistance markers available in trypanosomes. To determine the role of TbUPF1 in the GPI-PLC mRNA decay, we attempted to deplete TbUPF1 mRNA by transient transfection of morpholino oligonucleotides; this had little effect but the depletion was insufficiently effective to draw any conclusions.
(A) Northern blots of RNA extracted from two independent clones containing GPI-PLC transgenes, wild type (342 codons, lanes 2,3) or with PTCs at codons 17 (lanes 4,5) or 102 (lanes 6,7) or 237 (lanes 8,9). RNA extracted from a GPI-PLC +/− cell line is shown for comparison in lane 1. (B) Quantitation of GPI-PLC mRNA by phosphorimager, plotted onto a map of the open reading frame. The values are averages of measurements from the two clones and are shown relative to the wild type transgene, after normalization for loading using rRNA. The GPI-PLC +/− cells gave a relative mRNA abundance of 0.91.
The abundance of a PTC-containing reporter mRNA decreases concordantly with ORF length
To test for NMD in procyclic-form T. brucei, we used a reporter containing the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) ORF followed by the 3′-UTR of the actin gene (CAT-ACT construct). Downstream of this was the neomycin phosphotransferase (NEO) gene, with 5′ and 3′-UTRs (Figure 3A). We transfected linearized plasmid into procyclic trypanosomes, and selected for G418 resistance. The plasmid was designed to integrate into the silent rDNA spacer, with an rRNA promoter driving transcription by RNA polymerase I. Using this system, the level of CAT mRNA could be measured using NEO RNA as an internal control for both transcription rate and plasmid copy number. Use of pol I gave us sufficient RNA for quantification and detection on Northern blots, enabling us to confirm that mRNAs had the correct size (shown later). We note that in trypanosomes, any effect of trans splicing on mRNA decay should be seen equally in mRNAs made by RNA polymerase I or RNA polymerase II, since the evidence so far indicates that transcripts made by either polymerase are processed with equal efficiency . All measurements were made in cells that had been growing for at least 2 days without G418.
(A) Map of the CAT-NEO reporter plasmid used to analyse requirements for NMD. spRRNA: non-transcribed portion of rRNA spacer, used for integration into the genome; PRRNA – rRNA promoter; 5′: 5′-UTR; 3′: 3′-UTR; TER – symbol for termination codon. This plasmid was used in procyclic forms. For bloodstream forms, spRRNA and PRRNA were replaced with a segment from the tubulin locus. (B) Effect of the position of the termination codon on the CAT/NPT ratio in procyclic trypanosomes, with pol I transcription of the reporter. The cartoons on the left illustrate the CAT mRNAs investigated. SL: spliced leader; GFP: complete or partial GFP coding region. The 5′-UTR of the WT mRNA is 70 nt, the CAT ORF 660 nt and the 3′-UTR 326 nt. The graphs on the right show the ratio of CAT to NPT mRNA, normalised to wild-type, expressed as a percentage. Results are arithmetic mean and standard deviation for at least three biological replicates. Asterisks indicate cloned cell lines, the rest of the results are for populations. (C) Effect of ORF length and UPF1 RNAi on CAT/NPT mRNA ratio in bloodstream trypanosomes, with pol II transcription of the reporter. Results are for 3–4 independent cloned lines, each measured once or twice, and are expressed as arithmetic mean ± standard deviation. The arithmetic mean CAT/NPT ratio for WT-CAT was set to 100%. Columns 2,3 and 5,6 are for cell lines containing a hairpin UPF1 RNAi plasmid, without (2, 5) or with (3, 6) tetracycline. (D) Results are the same as in (C), but each cell line was considered individually, with the CAT/NPT value minus tetracycline set to 100%. (E) Effect of TbUPF1 RNAi on levels of CAT mRNAs in procyclic forms. Trypanosomes with in situ V5-tagged UPF1 were transfected with reporter plasmids and the hpTbUPF1 RNAi plasmid. Tetracycline was added where indicated, for 48 h. The ratio of CAT to NPT mRNA was measured by real-time PCR, and expressed as a percentage of wild-type. Results are arithmetic mean and standard deviation for at least three biological replicates. The Western blots beneath the graph show expression of V5-UPF1, with aldolase (ALD) as loading control. The V5 signals were normalised using the aldolase band, and expressed as a percentage relative to lane 1. The high V5 signal in the LPTC RNAi line might be due to tagging of both alleles. The double band of V5-TbUPF1 was rarely seen; it might be caused by phosphorylation .
The CAT ORF is of prokaryotic origin. To find out if a nonsense-mediated decay effect could be seen, we inserted PTCs at various positions. The CAT termination codon is at nt 660 (WT-CAT, WT660 in Figure 3B). Insertion of 4 nt at position 218 resulted in a frame shift, giving a TGA termination codon at position 243 and a second TAG 5 codons downstream. This construct was named “early PTC” (EPTC-CAT) and yielded no detectable CAT protein (judged by Western blotting, not shown). Translation reinititation is unlilkely with this construct since the next ATG after the PTC is 45 nt downstream. A similar insertion at position 519 gave a TGA at position 591 (late PTC, LPTC-CAT) (Figure 3B); in this case two more in-frame termination codons are 9 and 10 codons downstream, with two ATGs within 18 nt of the PTC; should any translation re-initiation occur, the longest possible ORF would extend only 54 nt beyond the WT-CAT termination codon.
In addition to the EPTC-CAT and LPTC-CAT ORFs, we inserted segments of the GFP gene at various positions to give ORF lengths of 393, 963 and 1380 nt. Cell lines were generated and we confirmed that the mRNA sizes were as expected (not shown). We then measured the level of CAT mRNA by reverse transcription and real-time PCR (Figure 3B). ORFs of 243–393 nt (EPTC243, EPTC249, EPTC393 in the Figure) all yielded 30–40% of wild-type RNA, while the 1380 nt CAT-GFP ORF doubled the amount of mRNA relative to WT-CAT. Taken together these results were consistent with three hypotheses: either the introduction of a PTC per se decreased mRNA abundance, or the length of the ORF or the 3′-UTR was the determining factor. To follow this up, we made a construct with a 963 nt CAT-GFP ORF, but the same 3′-UTR as the EPTC-CAT mRNA. The resulting EPTC-CAT-GFP mRNA level was (65% of WT) intermediate between that of EPTC and WT-CAT. This suggests that long ORFs favour mRNA abundance, while the presence of the untranslated CAT segment has a negative influence. The results do not show whether the effect of the untranslated CAT segment is sequence-specific, or is related to the overall length of the 3′-UTR.
To measure mRNA half-lives, we treated the cells with Sinefungin and Actinomycin D to halt transcription, and then measured mRNA levels by Northern blot. We consistently observed, as seen previously for experiments using Actinomycin D alone , that the apparent mRNA levels either stayed constant, or increased over the first 2 h after inhibitor addition (Figure S3A), so in general we calculated half-lives starting from the 2 h time-point. Pooling results for all cell lines with normal levels of UPF1 and UPF2 (including RNAi lines with no tetracycline induction, a total of at least 8 measurements for each CAT construct), we found that the half-lives of the WT-CAT and EPTC-CAT mRNAs were 2.4±0.2 h and 1.8±0.5 h respectively. The result for WT-CAT agrees with the previous estimate made using Actinomycin D alone . The half-life numbers were, however, so strongly dependent on which time points were used to plot the decay curves that it was impossible to make any quantitative judgements from the results.
To make sure that the results with the reporter were not artefacts of pol I transcription, and to find out whether PTC introduction affected mRNA abundance in bloodstream forms, we integrated the WT-CAT and EPTC-CAT ORFs into the tubulin locus in bloodstream-form trypanosomes. Results from four independent cell lines yielded EPTC-CAT mRNA levels of between 8% and 59% relative to full-length CAT (Figure 3D, compare bars 1 and 4). This shows that the effect of the PTC was independent of both the transcribing polymerase and the trypanosome life-cycle stage.
Effect of RNAi targeting TbUPF1 on reporter mRNAs
We now investigated whether TbUPF1 was required for the relatively low abundance of the EPTC-CAT mRNA. We made cell lines that expressed WT-CAT, LPTC-CAT or EPTC-CAT mRNA and had inducible TbUPF1 RNAi. The levels of CAT mRNA were measured with or without induction of RNAi. For bloodstream forms, expressing WT-CAT, using RNA polymerase II, we assayed 3 independent cloned lines. The CAT mRNA levels in the RNAi lines showed considerable variation between clones (Figure 3C, lanes 2,3,5,6). To measure the effect of RNAi, we therefore compared individual clones with and without tetracycline. For three EPTC-CAT lines, the increase in CAT mRNA was 1.3–1.7 fold; however similar increases were seen in 3 out of 4 WT-CAT lines (RNA levels changed 0.5–1.9 fold) (Figure 3D). Thus depletion of UPF1 did not specifically reverse the effect of the PTC on reporter mRNA abundance. Preliminary results for UPF2 RNAi revealed no effect at all on either mRNA (not shown).
In the procyclic cell line with the WT-CAT gene (polymerase I transcription) and the TbUPF1 RNAi plasmid, TbUPF1 RNAi caused a 30–40% decrease in WT-CAT mRNA abundance (Figure 3E, lanes 3 & 4). With the LPTC-CAT transgene, results were similar (lanes 7 & 8). Addition of tetracycline to cells with no RNAi construct had no effect (Figure 3E, lanes 2, 6 and 10). In the cell line with the EPTC-CAT transgene, the increase in CAT mRNA was unaffected by RNAi induction (Figure 3D lanes 11 &12). From all experiments, so far we therefore concluded that introduction of PTCs – or decreasing the ORF length - reduced the abundances of the CAT and GPI-PLC mRNAs in trypanosomes, but there was no convincing evidence for a role of UPF1 in destruction of EPTC-CAT mRNA.
The length of the 3′-UTR does not reproducibly affect reporter mRNA abundance
Our results in Figure 2 and 3B were consistent with the prediction that mRNA degradation increases with the distance of the termination codon from the poly(A) tail. To find out whether 3′-UTR length really was important, we extended the 3′UTR of the WT-CAT mRNA and measured the relative mRNA abundance, using procyclic trypanosomes. Inserting 190 nt of GFP sequence (3′+WT), or even a complete GFP ORF (720 nt, 3′++WTs) had no effect on WT-CAT mRNA levels (Figure 4A). Correct processing of the mRNA was confirmed by Northern blotting (Figure 4B).
(A) Effect of the 3′-UTR length on the CAT/NPT ratio. The cartoons on the left illustrate the CAT mRNAs investigated. gfpNS: GFP coding region with no start codons. Details as in Figure 3. The sizes of the mRNAs were verified by Northern blotting (not shown). (B) Northern blot showing the sizes of selected reporter mRNAs. (C) Effect of UPF1 RNAi on the steady-state level of the 3′++WT mRNA. Results are mean and standard deviation of 3 independent experiments. (D) Relationship between 3′-UTR length (or termination codon – PABP distance) and mRNA abundance using data from (A) and (E). Results are mean ± standard deviation. (E) Tethering of PABP1 and PABP2. Six copies of BoxB were inserted either between the EPTC CAT cassette and the 3′-UTR in the EPTC 243 construct (Figure 3B), or after the AUG-less GFP coding sequence in the 3′-UTR of the 3′++WT construct (Figure 4A). Cell lines containing the various CAT mRNAs (as indicated to the left of the bar graph) were also transfected with tetracycline inducible plasmids expressing proteins bearing an N-terminal lambda-N peptide, and a C-terminal myc tag. Proteins were GFP, PABP1 (Tb09.211.0930) or PABP2 (Tb09.211.2150), shown to the left of the mRNA cartoons. Expression of the tagged proteins was induced for 48 h using 100 ng/ml tetracycline. The Western panels on the right, which were probed with antibody to the myc tag and to aldolase (control) come from a single experiment and exposed film. The amounts of CAT mRNA relative to NEO, measured by qPCR, are shown as mean and standard deviation for three independent experiments.
Since the 3′-UTR GFP insertion was immediately downstream of the WT-CAT termination codon, potentially allowing reinitiation, we created a new plasmid in which the 720 nt GFP ORF had been mutated so that it lacked initiation codons (GFPns, GFP-no-start). The abundance of mRNA (3′++WT) from this plasmid was 55% of WT, and the effect was reversed to 82% by RNAi against TbUPF1 (Figure 4C). This was consistent with 3′-UTR-dependent and UPF1-dependent NMD. We were, however, unable to confirm this result with the LPTC-CAT and EPTC-CAT ORFs. Lengthening their 3′UTRs by 720 nt, using the ATG-less GFP (from 393 to 1112 nt in LPTC-CAT and 743 to 1463 nt in EPTC-CAT) did not decrease CAT mRNA levels (Figure 4A); for EPTC-CAT, results stayed between 35% and 40% even with the longest extension. When we put together the results of all these reporter experiments, the length of the 3′-UTR, over a 330 nt–1.2 kb range, had no consistent effect on trypanosome mRNA abundance (Figure 4D). If there is a 3′-UTR length effect at all, it must be overridden even by minor differences in the 3′-UTR sequence.
Tethering of poly(A)-binding protein inhibits trypanosome mRNA decay
In mammals, budding yeast and Drosophila, tethering of cytoplasmic poly(A)-binding protein (PABP) downstream of a PTC inhibits NMD , . It was thought that the tethered PABP specifically antagonised NMD by effectively shortening the 3′-UTR , but recently the effect has been shown to be more general and not dependent on PTC recognition . To find out whether the PABP effect was seen in trypanosomes, we inserted six “B” boxes downstream of EPTC-CAT, or downstream of GFPns in the 3′++WT construct (Figure 4E). This lengthened each 3′-UTR by 270 nt but had no effect on mRNA abundance (compare Figures 4A and 4E). Proteins bearing a lambda N peptide at the N-terminus, and a myc tag at the C-terminus, were inducibly expressed in cell lines expressing the new mRNAs and the effect on CAT mRNA was measured. All three proteins were expressed at comparable levels. There are two PABPs in trypanosomes, PABP1 (Tb09.211.0930) and PABP2 (Tb09.211.2150). Tethering of either GFP or PABP2 to the EPTC-CAT-box B mRNA had no effect on mRNA abundance. In contrast, tethering of PABP1 to either 3′++WT or EPTC-CAT mRNA – decreasing the stop codon -PABP distances to 720 and 100 nt respectively - indeed increased mRNA levels. PABP1 tethering caused complete stabilization of the mRNAs (Figure 4E and Figure S3G, H).
Changing the 5′-UTR length decreases mRNA abundance and inhibits translation
We next wanted to check whether the physical length of the ORF or the distance from the 5′-end to the stop codon, influenced mRNA abundance. We therefore extended the 5′-UTRs of WT-CAT, LPTC-CAT and EPTC-CAT by inserting ATG-less GFP sequences of 190 nt (5′+), 720 nt (5′++) or 1440 nt (5′+++). Results are shown in Figure 5A and Northern blots to verify RNA sizes are in Figure 4B. Lengthening the 5′-UTR in front of the WT-CAT or LPTC-CAT ORFs decreased the mRNA levels by 20–50%. In contrast, the amount of CAT mRNA from the EPTC-CAT constructs increased steadily as the length of the 5′-UTR increased; with the longest 5′-UTR, rescue was complete, since the 5′++EPTC mRNA level was the same as that of the 5′++WT mRNA. Thus the level of mRNA was not consistently increased in parallel with the distance of the termination codon from the 5′-end.
(A) Effect of the 5′-UTR length on the CAT/NPT ratio. Stars indicate where paired values are different at the P = 0.05 level or below (Students t-test, two-tailed, unpaired). The sizes of the mRNAs were verified by Northern blotting (not shown). Details as in Figure 3. (B) Effect of the 5′-UTR length on the amount of CAT protein. The amount of CAT protein was measured relative to aldolase (loading control). Results are the average of duplicate measurements, variation was very low. (C) Effect of the translation inhibition length on the CAT/NPT ratio. The double ovals in the 5′-UTRs represent hairpins which completely inhibit translation. Other details are as for Figure 4A.
NMD depends on the recognition of the nonsense mutations by the translation machinery. It was therefore important to examine the effects of 5′-UTR extension on translation. To do this, using WT-CAT cell lines, we measured amounts of CAT protein by Western blotting, then normalised them to the amount of CAT mRNA from Figure 5A. Insertion of GFPns in the 5′-UTR strongly inhibited translation whereas the same sequence in the 3′-UTR did not (Figure 5B). Thus we could not see whether the effects we had seen were due to 5′-UTR length per se, or to translation inhibition.
To distinguish the effects of translation inhibition from those related to 5′-UTR length, we sought a method to inhibit translation alone. Treatment of trypanosomes with protein synthesis inhibitors increases the levels of many mRNAs – including the WT-CAT mRNA used in this study (not shown). The reasons have not been defined, but a requirement for unstable protein factors for mRNA decay (e.g. ), or effects on mRNA processing  have been suggested (reviewed in ). To analyse translation alone, we therefore inserted a translation-inhibitory hairpin into the 5′-UTRs of the reporter plasmids (control data for translation shown later). This decreased the abundances of the WT-CAT and LPTC-CAT mRNAs (Figure 5C) in the same way as lengthening the 5′-UTR (Figure 5A). This indicates that translation favours mRNA maintenance. In contrast, the amount of hp-EPTC-CAT mRNA was similar to that of EPTC-CAT mRNA (Figure 5C). The simplest interpretation of this result is that EPTC-CAT mRNA has low abundance because of NMD, while the hp-EPTC-CAT and hp-CAT mRNAs have low abundance because they have no ribosomes on the ORF.
Tethering of UPF1 to a 3′-UTR can decrease mRNA abundance
To find out whether UPF1 was capable of affecting mRNA levels at all, we used a tethering approach. As reporter, we used the CAT-ACT mRNA, with either 6 copies of the B box sequence, or two copies of MS2 stem-loop downstream of the stop codon (Figure 6A). Stable clonal cell lines were obtained that expressed the reporter mRNAs constitutively from the T7 promoter. These reporter lines were transfected with the plasmids giving inducible expression of lambdaN-tagged protein constructs: lambdaN-UPF1-flag (UPF1 with a C-terminal FLAG tag), lambdaN-GFP-TAP (Green fluorescent protein with a TAP tag) or UPF1-flag without the lambdaN (Figure 6B). A representative set of results obtained with the CAT-ACT 3′UTR mRNA is shown in Figure 6C and quantitation for 3 biological replicates in Figure 6D. A reproducible decrease of the reporter mRNA was seen upon induction of lambdaN-UPF1-FLAG in the CAT-B-ACT cell line (Figure 6C&D, lanes 5,6). This decrease was dependent on the RNA-protein interaction because expression of lambdaN-UPF1-FLAG (Figure 6C&D, lanes 9,10) did not decrease the amount of CAT-MS2-ACT mRNA, Expression of UPF1-FLAG (Figure 6C&D, lanes 7,8) and tethering of lambdaN-GFP-TAP (Figure 6C&D, lanes 3,4) also did not decrease CAT-B-ACT mRNA. Results suggested that the UPF1 tethering was indeed affecting mRNA degradation (see Figure S4). Tethering of lambdaN-UPF1-FLAG to a target mRNA with a translation-inhibitory hairpin also caused a decrease in target mRNA (Figure 6E, lanes 5–8). Preliminary results (not shown) indicated that tethering of mutant upf1-1 also caused degradation. Overall, this would imply that TbUPF1 may be capable of recruiting the degradation machinery directly via protein-protein interactions.
(A) Reporter mRNAs with ACT 3′-UTRs. used for tethering experiments, not to scale. For details see text and Table 1. The mRNAs were produced from a T7 promoter, in cells expressing T7 polymerase. (B) Fusion proteins used for tethering. For details see text and Table 1. (C) Northern blot showing CAT-ACT mRNAs in cells inducibly expressing GFP and TbUPF1 fusion proteins. Appropriate Western blots are beneath. Expression of tagged TbUPF1 or GFP was induced with 1 µg/ml tetracycline for 2 days. A portion of the cells was used for western analysis and the rest was used for total RNA isolation. Northern blots were probed with full length CAT probe and SRP was used as loading control. For western analysis, cell lines expressing the TbUPF1 with a flag tag were probed with anti-flag antibody and those with the TAP tag were probed with PAP antibody. The same blots were probed with anti-aldolase antibody as a loading control. (D) Quantitation of the data in (C). CAT mRNA amounts are expressed as the percentage of the appropriate control - lane 1 in (C). Results are the arithmetic mean of and standard deviation for at least three biological replicates or cell lines. (E) As for (C), but including cells expressing hp-CAT-B-ACT.
Effects of ORF and UTR lengths across the transcriptome
To find out whether depletion of TbUPF1 had any effect on the steady-state transcriptome, we did microarray experiments using procyclic trypanosomes with TbUPF1 RNAi (full-length RNAi construct). No changes above two-fold were found, so the results have not been submitted to a database. Since a few probes showed up-regulation of 1.3–1.6-fold, we chose one - Tb927.10.12900 (up 1.54-fold) - for further analysis. Northern blotting revealed two bands:, one was the expected monocistronic RNA of 0.9 kb (increased 1.3-fold by UPF1 RNAi) and another of 4.5 kb that was increased 2.4-fold by UPF1 RNAi (Figure S5 A,B, average of two independent measurements). The origin of the 4.5 kb band is not clear (see Figure S5, legend); it may be a dicistronic transcript. We also examined the EP procyclin locus. This produces two RNAs which should be targeted by classical NMD, and one of these accumulated 1.3–1.5-fold upon UPF1 depletion (Figure S5C, D). Thus although UPF1 might play some role in control of aberrantly processed mRNAs, the only effects detected were marginal.
This paper includes some results that support the existence of a classical NMD pathway in T. brucei. There are genes encoding UPF1 and UPF2, and the two proteins interact; also, tethering of UPF1 to an mRNA decreased its abundance and stability. The abundances of an endogenous mRNA and a reporter mRNA were decreased by introduction of a PTC. In a reporter mRNA with a full-length CAT ORF, extension of the 3′-untranslated region caused a decrease in reporter mRNA abundance which was abrogated by RNAi targeting UPF1. Many other results, however, do not support the existence of classical NMD – notably, several failures to specifically reverse apparent NMD effects by UPF1 RNAi.
The decreases in mRNAs upon introduction of PTCs were analogous to those that have been seen in other organisms. For GPI-PLC, a termination codon at codon 17 reduced RNA to 35% of normal, but one at codon 102 only to 80%. For CAT, in contrast, a PTC at codon 81 reduced mRNA to about 35%, and again, early PTCs depressed mRNA levels more than later ones. These values are consistent with NMD in Opisthokonts. For example, PTCs at codon 83 in the Drosophila ADH gene reduced mRNA to 25–30%  and mammalian intron-dependent NMD (codon 46) depressed mRNA to 9% . In S. pombe, intron-independent decay reduced mRNA to 43% at codon 27 and 83% at codon 140, while intron-dependent decay resulted in levels around 20% .
In Opisthokonts, mechanisms for PTC recognition are predominantly based on (1) the termination codon sequence context; (2) the positions of cis splicing junctions (marked by the EJC); and (3) the length of the 3′-UTR (as judged by the distance between the termination codon and poly(A) binding protein). In trypanosomes, option (1) seems unlikely to be important for the CAT reporters: the relevant region was of prokaryotic origin. Any mechanism depending on recognition of the splice junction via the EJC is unlikely. Some of the EJC proteins are present, and form a complex, in trypanosomes , though neither binding to the exon junction nor a role in trans splicing have been confirmed. Even assuming that the EJC is deposited at the trans splice junction, it would be stripped off by the scanning small ribosomal subunit complex before translation initiation. An involvement of the trans splice site per se cannot, however, be ruled out. Splicing-dependent, EJC-independent NMD was shown in S. pombe : notably, NMD was stimulated by the presence of an intron upstream of a PTC – as would occur in trypanosomes. S. pombe splicing-dependent NMD was however stronger than the NMD-like effects that we saw in trypanosomes.
In a recent study of mRNP composition, UPF1 was found in all mRNPs examined, but the amount was greater in mRNAs that are susceptible to NMD, and also correlated positively with the length of the 3′-UTR . In addition, even low amounts of translational read-through or reinitiation reduced NMD. Our experiments with reporters yielded very mixed evidence concerning a role of the 3′-UTR length in determining trypanosome mRNA abundance. For the WT-CAT ORF, we saw a clear decrease in CAT mRNA abundance after insertion of an ATG-less GFP sequence in the 3′-UTR. The result was, however, contradicted using the LPTC-CAT ORF, where the same insertion had no effect (Figure 4D). The most recent evidence suggests that at a global level, 3′-UTR length negatively affects mRNA half-lives in mouse cells , but the effect is both variable and weak. In trypanosomes, deep sequencing data reveals no such correlation (T. Manful, A Fadda and C. Clayton, ZMBH, manuscript submitted). This is not surprising. Trypanosome (and mouse) 3′-UTRs are somewhat longer than those of yeast: for trypansoomes, the median length is 400 nt, and 3′-UTRs over 1 kb are by no means unusual . The heavy reliance of trypanosomes on regulation of mRNA stability to control gene expression may have driven the evolution of long 3′-UTRs: these will have space for multiple elements which can be recognized by regulatory sequence- or secondary-structure-specific RNA-binding proteins.
Tethering of PABP to reporter mRNAs had a very strong stabilizing effect. This is may well be unrelated to NMD - in yeast, even a non-translated mRNA can be stabilized by tethering of PABP ; 5′ decapping is inhibited. It was intriguing that we saw effects of PABP1, but not PABP2. In the related parasite Leishmania, both proteins are cytoplasmic and can associate with eIF4G in vitro, but using cytoplasmic extracts, only PABP1 was shown to copurify with eIF4G . It is therefore quite possible that in trypanosomes, also, tethered PABP1 inhibits 5′-3′ degradation by binding to the cap-bound translation initiation complex. Whether this also stimulates translation, as in yeast  remains to be determined.
Our results leave open the question of the function of UPF1 in trypanosomes. It is likely to play some role in Kinetoplastids since the gene is well conserved throughout Kinetoplastids. TbUPF1 must also be bound to some RNAs, since it was found to interact not only with UPF2, but also, in an RNA-dependent fashion, with PABP. In addition, tethering of UPF1 to an mRNA did increase the degradation rate, and there were various RNAi effects on reporters that appeared to be independent of the presence of a PTC. Depletion of TbUPF1 did not affect the T. brucei steady-state mRNA transcriptome as judged by microarray analysis; preliminary results from an RNA-Seq study confirm this (T. Manful, ZMBH, unpublished). There was also little evidence for a requirement of either UPF1 or UPF2 in trypanosome growth and division. It is therefore possible that UPF1 affects mRNA in conditions or life-cycle stages that were not examined in our study, or has other functions.
Overall it is not clear that classical NMD exists in trypanosomes. It would not be required for disposal of pseudogene mRNAs: most trypanosome pseudogenes are either located in telomeric regions that are not transcribed, or produce transposon-related RNAs that are disposed of by the RNAi machinery , . Alternative trans splicing can definitely create short upstream ORFs and bicistronic mRNAs, but their low abundance could easily be caused simply by low utilization of the alternative processing sites.
One more set of observations is worthy of comment: inhibition of translation, either by adding a secondary structure, or increasing the length of the 5′-UTR, decreased the amount of reporter mRNAs. Although recent results from yeast have shown that loss of ribosomes is not an obligatory prerequisite for mRNA decay , translation initiation certainly must stop before 5′-3′ degradation can begin. Both our results, and those from S. pombe  would be consistent with a link between the average number of ribosomes on an mRNA and its stability. Assuming that initiation is to some degree stochastic, the lower the average number of ribosomes on an ORF is, the higher the proportion of mRNAs with no ribosomes at all. Our observations therefore fit with the idea that release of an mRNA from polysomes can render it more susceptible to degradation.
Trypanosomes, cell culture, and plasmid construction
Procyclic and bloodstream trypanosomes of the Lister 427 strain, and bloodstream-form parasites of the AnTat 1.1 strain, were cultured according to standard protocols. Procyclic trypanosomes were diluted to a density of 5×105/ml before the density reached 8×106/ml; bloodstream cells were diluted to 1×105/ml before the density reached 1×106/ml. Unless noted, experiments were done using cells expressing the Tet repressor from pHD1313 . In some cases the cells also expressed T7 polymerase. Tetracycline-dependent transcription by RNA polymerase 1 or the T7 polymerase was induced by addition of 0.1–1 µg/ml tetracycline. Selecting antibiotics were always removed at least one day before experiments were initiated.
All plasmid constructs are described in Table S1 and the oligonucleotides in Table S2. For RNA interference, dsRNA was either expressed as a stem-loop, transfected into the standard line, or using opposing T7 promoters with a line expressing T7 polymerase in addition to the tet repressor . Plasmids were linearized, transfected into the parasites by electroporation, and permanent cloned cell lines were obtained by limiting dilution .
Cells (5×106 to 2×107) were harvested by centrifugation and the pellets boiled in reducing SDS sample buffer before separation by SDS-PAGE. After Western blotting, tags were detected with the following primary antibodies at 1∶2000 dilution∶ mouse M2 (anti-Flag, Sigma), mouse anti-V5 (Invitrogen), mouse anti-myc (Santa Cruz Laboratories) and, for the TAP tag, peroxidase anti-peroxidase (PAP, Sigma). Detection was done using the ECL kit (GE Healthcare). In order to visualise TbUPF1 in trypanosomes, we raised antibody against N-terminally truncated TbUPF1 (residues 396–842), but the serum failed to detect the protein on Western blots.
Approximately 106 cells were collected by centrifugation and resuspended in 50 µl of PBS. Cells were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde in PBS for 20 min, washed twice in PBS and allowed to settle onto poly-lysine-coated slides. Cells were permeabilised in 0.2% Triton-X100 in PBS, washed twice and blocked in 0.5% gelatine in PBS for 1 hour. Primary antibody was added at the manufacturer-recommended dilution, incubated for 1 hour and the slides washed 3 times in PBS before addition of Alexa -594-conjugated secondary antibody (1 hour). Slides were washed, stained with DAPI (10 min), and washed twice more before drying the slide and mounting with Vectorshield.
Northern blotting and RNA half-life assay
Parasites were harvested at room temperature and RNA isolated by Trizol extraction. RNA was denatured with formamide and formaldehyde, separated on a denaturing formaldehyde gel, blotted onto Nytran and hybridized. The DNA probes were made from plasmids or PCR products, by random priming with 32P label dCTP.
For RNA half-life assays, synthesis and maturation of mRNA were inhibited by addition to the growth medium of 2.0 µg/mL Sinefungin then, 5 min later, 10 µg/mL Actinomycin D , . The time of Actinomycin D addition to the cell was taken as time 0. Cells were collected at various times and RNA isolated by Trizol extraction. RNA levels were estimated by Northern blotting using [32P]-labelled probes, and quantitated by phosphorimaging. The 7SLRNA, or mRNAs encoding histone H4 (HISH4) or beta-tubulin (TUB) were used as loading controls. To obtain half-lives, we used the phosphorimaging results starting 2 h after Actinomycin D addition. Half-lives were measured for each individual experiment and, if there were at least three experiments, expressed as arithmetic mean ± standard deviation. For two experiments an average is given.
Microarray analyses to compare the RNA of wild-type and TbUPF1-depleted procyclic forms (cell line with RNAi targeting the entire TbUPF1 ORF) were done using 6 slides, with two biological replicates, as described in . Almost no differences were found, so the results have not been uploaded into a public database.
Real time PCR was performed using the SYBR green I kit (Roche Applied Science). RNA was isolated using Trizol. About 1 µg total RNA was DNase treated, then cDNA was synthesised using SuperScript III (Invitrogen). After RNaseH digestion of the DNA-RNA hybrid, the cDNA was diluted and used for real time PCR in the LightCyclerR 480 system. Standard curves for each primer set - CZ 3634 and CZ 3633 for CAT and CZ 3636 and CZ 3635 for the reference neomycin phosphotransferase (NEO) gene were included during each run to calculate the in-run PCR efficiency. Primers were designed using Primer3 software . Relative quantification was done according to the E (efficiency) method using the LightCyclerR 480 software (Roche Applied Science).
Procyclic cell lines carrying V5-tagged TbUPF1, either alone or with co-expressed TbUPF2-myc, were induced with 100 ng/ml tetracycline for 48 hours in medium lacking selective antibiotics. For each sample, 6×108 cells were harvested and suspended in 2 ml of lysis buffer containing 20 mM Tris-HCl pH 7.4, 10 mM NaCl, 0.1% IGEPAL, 100 nM okadaic acid and Complete protease Inhibitor without EDTA (Roche). The cells were lysed by passing through a 21-gauge syringe several times on ice. Cell lysis was monitored under the microscope. The salt concentration was adjusted to 150 mM NaCl, and the lysate clarified by centrifugation at 13,000 rpm, 20 min at 4°C (microfuge). The cleared lysates (1 ml each) were treated with to RNase A (200 µg/mL) or 4 mM Vanadyl Ribonucleoside complexes (VRCs, Sigma). About 800 µL of each lysate (± RNase A) was incubated with 50 µL of Myc-agarose (Sigma) for 2 h at 4°C with rotation. Immune complexes were washed 3 times with 500 µL of 20 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.4), 150 mM NaCl, 0.1% IGEPAL, and 100 nM okadaic acid, boiled in 80 µL of 2× SDS sample buffer, then analyzed by Western blotting. For the input and flow-through fractions, 2.5% of the total (equivalent to 6×106 cells) was loaded. The Western blot was probed with anti-V5, anti-myc or anti-PABP antibodies (gift from Dr. Laurie Read).
Sequence alignment of TbUPF1 with UPF1s from other species. Residues that are100% conserved are in solid red boxes, while those in which at least 70% are similar are outlined in red. The arginine residue at position 747 in the trypanosome sequence was mutated to make upf1-1. Other arginines in this region that were shown to be essential in yeast or human UPF1 are indicated by asterisks. The Figure was generated by Clustalw2 and ESPript. Sequences used were: Tb: Trypanosoma brucei CP000068.1. Sc: Saccharomyces cerevisiae NC_001145.2. At: Arabidopsis thaliana AF484122.1. Tv: Trichomonas vaginalis DS113229.1. Dd: Dictyostelium discoideum XM_631398.1. Gi: Giardia intestinalis DQ861427.1. Tg: Toxoplasma gondii XM_002368483.1. Pf: Plasmodium falciparum AE014185.2. Hs: Homo sapiens NM_002911.3.
The strategy for replacement of the GPI-PLC gene with a mutant copy. In wild-type cells the GPI-PLC gene (pink) is flanked by HSP100 (green) and ß′-COP genes. The poly(A) site is marked as “a” and the two alternative spliced learder addition sites as black dots (“SL” for “spliced leader”). The panel below shows the loci in the double knockout line, and below that the construct that was used to return the full-length or PTC versions of GPI-PLC. The bottom panel shows the loci in cells containing the integrated return construct.
RNA degradation kinetics for selected CAT constructs, including the effects of UPF1 RNAi, UPF2 RNAi, or tethering of PABP. Results are shown as arithmetic mean ± standard deviation for 3 or more experiments, with all values at +2 h set as 100%. When two experiments were done, each is shown individually. The curves were fitted for time points from +2 h onwards. The half-lives shown were calculated separately for each individual experiment and – if there were three experiments - are presented as arithmetic mean ± standard deviation. The constructs used are indicated above the graphs; the presence of a tethered protein or induction of RNAi are also indicated.
Tethering of UPF1 to T7-transcribed CAT-B-ACT mRNA increases the mRNA degradation rate. The Figure show the results for two inependent experiments, done using the clones shown in Figure 5C, and as described for Figure S4. Expression of lambdaN-UPF1-flag was induced with tetracycline. In the absence of lambdaN-UPF1-FLAG induction, the half-life of the CAT-B-ACT mRNA was 15–20 min. This was surprisingly short. We do not understand why, but one possible explanation is that the mRNAs were made by T7 polymerase. Instability of a T7-produced CAT reporter with a different 3′-UTR has been previously observed; the reasons are unknown (Colasante et al., Mol Biochem Parasitol 151, 193–204.) Upon induction of lambdaN-UPF1-FLAG expression the half-life decreased further.
RNAi targeting TbUPF1 has minor effects on the abundances of mRNAs from two loci. (A) shows a map of the region around Tb927.10.12900. The direction of transcription and the positions of various probes (a–d, dotted lines) used to identify the various RNAs is indicated. Estimated sizes and location of monocistronic RNAs, based on our own mapping and on RNASeq tag abundances shown at tritrypDB, are also shown. (B) Shows a Northern blot of RNA with and without RNAi targeting either XRNA or UPF1, using probe (a) (made using CZ3585, CZ3586). A Histone H4 probe (HISH4) serves as a control. Probe ‘c’ (made using oligonucleotides CZ3695, CZ3696) detected a single RNA migrating at 3.7 kb and probe ‘d’ (made using CZ3707, CZ3708) detected two RNAs of similar abundance, migrating at 2.6 kb and 1.8 kb. The band of 4.5 kb was detected only by probes (a) and (b). There is a tag gap in the middle of Tb10.389.0620, but no mapped spliced leader addition site. (C) The procyclin locus containing EP1 and EP2, with predicted transcripts based on mapped splicing sites. Alternative splicing of the procyclin EP2 RNA precursor is known to result in two transcripts. The dominant one, at 0.9 kb, has a short 5′-UTR preceding the EP2 initiation codon. The minor one, of 1.4 kb, has various very short ORFs upstream of the EP2 ORF while the 0.4 kb RNA contains these short ORFs alone: either of these might be a substrate for NMD. The location of the EP2 upstream probe used in (D) is indicated as a dotted line. (D) RNA was prepared from three independent bloodstream-form trypanosome clones (AnTat1.1. strain) with TbUPF1 hpRNAi, incubated with 100 ng/ml tetracycline for 2 days. The blot was probed with the EP2 upstream region indicated in (A). We detected the 0.9 kb EP mRNAs and three additional bands at 0.4, 1.4 and 2.3 kb. The 2.3 kb signal comigrates with rRNA so could either be a cross-hybridisation or a dicistronic precursor. The bands were all of approximately equal intensity: the mature EP mRNA is very unstable in bloodstream forms. The level of the 1.4 kb EP mRNA increased 1.3–1.4 fold after TbUPF1 depletion, whereas the levels of the monocistronic 0.9 kb mRNA and the 0.4 kb RNA were unaffected. The uORF-EP2 RNA probe was made by in vitro transcription using 32P-UTP and T7 RNA polymerase, from a PCR template carrying the T7 polymerase promoter sequence. (The primers were CZ3391 and CZ3392.).
We thank Ana Robles (ZMBH) for making pHDs 1520, 1522, and 1519. The microarrays were supplied by NIAID. We thank Laurie Read (State University of New York, Buffalo) for the anti-PABP and Andreas Kolozik (University of Heidelberg) for the LambdaN-BoxB plasmids. We also thank Bhaskar Jha for help with Figure S1 and are grateful to Ute Liebfried for technical assistance.
Conceived and designed the experiments: PD MC CC. Performed the experiments: PD RQ MC DI. Analyzed the data: PD RQ MC CC DI. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: PD MC. Wrote the paper: PD MC CC.
- 1. Chang Y-F, Imam J, Wilkinson M (2007) The Nonsense-Mediated Decay RNA surveillance pathway. Ann Rev Biochem 76: 51–74.
- 2. Maquat LE (2005) Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay in mammals. J Cell Sci 118: 1773–1776.
- 3. Stalder L, Mühlemann O (2008) The meaning of nonsense. Trends Cell Biol 18: 315–321.
- 4. Kuperwasser N, Brogna S, Dower K, Rosbash M (2004) Nonsense-mediated decay does not occur within the yeast nucleus. Rna 10: 1907–1915.
- 5. Singh G, Jakob S, Kleedehn M, Lykke-Andersen J (2007) Communication with the exon-junction complex and activation of nonsense-mediated decay by human Upf proteins occur in the cytoplasm. Molecualr Cell 27: 780–792.
- 6. He F, Brown A, Jacobson A (1996) Interaction between Nmd2p and Upf1p is required for activity but not for dominant-negative inhibition of the nonsense-mediated mRNA decay pathway in yeast. RNA 2: 153–170.
- 7. Arciga-Reyes L, Wootton L, Kieffer M, Davies B (2006) UPF1 is required for nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) and RNAi in Arabidopsis. Plant J 47: 480–489.
- 8. Schell T, Köcher T, Wilm M, Seraphin B, Kulozik A, et al. (2003) Complexes between the nonsense-mediated mRNA decay pathway factor human upf1 (up-frameshift protein 1) and essential nonsense-mediated mRNA decay factors in HeLa cells. Biochem J 373: 775–783.
- 9. Johns L, Grimson A, Kuchma S, Newman C, Anderson P (2007) Caenorhabditis elegans SMG-2 selectively marks mRNAs containing premature translation termination codons. Mol Cell Biol 27: 5630–5638.
- 10. He F, Brown A, Jacobson A (1997) Upf1p, Nmd2p, and Upf3p are interacting components of the yeast nonsense-mediated mRNA decay pathway. Mol Cell Biol 17: 1580–1594.
- 11. Weng Y, Czaplinski K, Peltz S (1996) Genetic and biochemical characterization of mutations in the ATPase and helicase regions of the Upf1 protein. Mol Cell Biol 16: 5477–5490.
- 12. Sun X, Perlick H, Dietz H, Maquat L (1998) A mutated human homologue to yeast Upf1 protein has a dominant-negative effect on the decay of nonsense-containing mRNAs in mammalian cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 95: 10009–10014.
- 13. Chen Y-H, Su L-H, Sun C-H (2008) Incomplete nonsense-mediated mRNA decay in Giardia lamblia. Int J Parasitol 38: 1305–1317.
- 14. Kadlec J, Guilligay D, Ravelli R, Cusack S (2006) Crystal structure of the UPF2-interacting domain of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay factor UPF1. RNA 12: 1817–1824.
- 15. Ivanov P, Gehring N, Kunz J, Hentze M, Kulozik A (2008) Interactions between UPF1, eRFs, PABP and the exon junction complex suggest an integrated model for mammalian NMD pathways. EMBO J 27: 736–747.
- 16. de Pinto B, Lippolis R, Castaldo R, Altamura N (2004) Overexpression of Upf1p compensates for mitochondrial splicing deficiency independently of its role in mRNA surveillance. Mol Microbiol 51: 1129–1142.
- 17. Ruiz-Echevarría M, González C, Peltz S (1998) Identifying the right stop: determining how the surveillance complex recognizes and degrades an aberrant mRNA. EMBO J 17: 575–589.
- 18. Hogg J, Goff S (2010) Upf1 senses 3′UTR length to potentiate mRNA decay. Cell 143: 379–389.
- 19. Tuller T, Ruppin E, Kupiec M (2009) Properties of untranslated regions of the S. cerevisiae genome. BMC Genomics 10: 391.
- 20. Kebaara B, Atkin A (2009) Long 3′-UTRs target wild-type mRNAs for nonsense-mediated mRNA decay in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Nucelic Acids Res 37: 2771–2778.
- 21. Behm-Ansmant I, Gatfield D, Rehwinkel J, Hilgers V, Izaurralde E (2007) A conserved role for cytoplasmic poly(A)-binding protein 1 (PABPC1) in nonsense-mediated mRNA decay. EMBO J 26: 1591–1601.
- 22. Hansen K, Lareau L, Blanchette M, Green R, Meng Q, et al. (2009) Genome-wide identification of alternative splice forms down-regulated by nonsense-mediated mRNA decay in Drosophila. PLoS Genet 5: e1000525.
- 23. Kertész S, Kerényi Z, Mérai Z, Bartos I, Pálfy T, et al. (2006) Both introns and long 3′-UTRs operate as cis-acting elements to trigger nonsense-mediated decay in plants. Nucleic Acids Res 34: 6147–6157.
- 24. Silva A, Ribeiro P, Inácio A, Liebhaber S, Romão L (2008) Proximity of the poly(A)-binding protein to a premature termination codon inhibits mammalian nonsense-mediated mRNA decay. RNA 14: 563–576.
- 25. Amrani N, Ganesan R, Kervestin S, Mangus DA, Ghosh S, et al. (2004) A faux 3′-UTR promotes aberrant termination and triggers nonsense-mediated mRNA decay. Nature 432: 112–118.
- 26. Weng Y, Czaplinski K, Peltz S (1996) Identification and characterization of mutations in the UPF1 gene that affect nonsense suppression and the formation of the Upf protein complex but not mRNA turnover. Mol Cell Biol 16: 5491–5506.
- 27. Wen J, Brogna S (2010) Splicing-dependent NMD does not require the EJC in Schizosaccharomyces pombe. EMBO J 29: 1537–1551.
- 28. Ramani A, Nelson A, Kapranov P, Bell I, Gingeras T, et al. (2009) High resolution transcriptome maps for wild-type and nonsense-mediated decay-defective Caenorhabditis elegans. Genome Biol 10: R101.
- 29. Nyikó T, Sonkoly B, Mérai Z, Benkovics A, Silhavy D (2009) Plant upstream ORFs can trigger nonsense-mediated mRNA decay in a size-dependent manner. Plant Mol Biol 71: 367–378.
- 30. Saul H, Elharrar E, Gaash R, Eliaz D, Valenci M, et al. (2009) The upstream open reading frame of the Arabidopsis AtMHX gene has a strong impact on transcript accumulation through the nonsense-mediated mRNA decay pathway. Plant J 60: 1031–1042.
- 31. Mendell J, Sharifi N, Meyers J, Martinez-Murillo F, Dietz H (2004) Nonsense surveillance regulates expression of diverse classes of mammalian transcripts and mutes genomic noise. Nat Genet 36: 1073–1078.
- 32. Sayani S, Janis M, Lee C, Toesca I, Chanfreau G (2008) Widespread impact of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay on the yeast intronome. Mol Cell 31: 360–370.
- 33. Kawashima T, Pellegrini M, Chanfreau G (2009) Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay mutes the splicing defects of spliceosome component mutations. RNA 15: 2236–2247.
- 34. Kurihara Y, Matsui A, Hanada K, Kawashima M, Ishida J, et al. (2009) Genome-wide suppression of aberrant mRNA-like noncoding RNAs by NMD in Arabidopsis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 106: 2453–2458.
- 35. He F, Li X, Spatrick P, Casillo R, Dong S, et al. (2003) Genome-wide analysis of mRNAs regulated by the nonsense-mediated and 5′ to 3′ mRNA decay pathways in yeast. Mol Cell 12: 1439–1452.
- 36. Guan Q, Zheng W, Tang S, Liu X, Zinkel R, et al. (2006) Impact of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay on the global expression profile of budding yeast. PLoS Genet 2: e203.
- 37. Dahlseid J, Lew-Smith J, Lelivelt M, Enomoto S, Ford A, et al. (2003) mRNAs encoding telomerase components and regulators are controlled by UPF genes in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Eukaryotic Cell 2: 134–142.
- 38. Johansson M, He F, Spatrick P, Li C, Jacobson A (2007) Association of yeast Upf1p with direct substrates of the NMD pathway. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 20872.
- 39. Rehwinkel J, Letunic I, Raes J, Bork P, Izaurralde E (2005) Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay factors act in concert to regulate common mRNA targets. Rna 11: 1530–1544.
- 40. Yoine M, Nishii T, Nakamura K (2006) Arabidopsis UPF1 RNA Helicase for Nonsense-Mediated mRNA Decay Is Involved in Seed Size Control and Is Essential for Growth. Plant Cell Physiol.
- 41. Medghalchi S, Frischmeyer P, Mendell J, Kelly A, Lawler A, et al. (2001) Rent1, a trans-effector of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay, is essential for mammalian embryonic viability. Hum Mol Genet 10: 99–105.
- 42. Metzstein M, Krasnow M (2006) Functions of the nonsense-mediated mRNA decay pathway in Drosophila development. PLoS Genet 2: e180.
- 43. Chen Y-H, Su L-H, Huang Y-C, Wang Y-T, Kao Y-Y, et al. (2009) UPF1, a conserved nonsense-mediated mRNA decay factor, regulates cyst wall protein transcripts in Giardia lamblia. PLOS one 3: e3609.
- 44. Mair G, Shi H, Li H, Djikeng A, Aviles HO, et al. (2000) A new twist in trypanosome RNA metabolism: cis-splicing of pre-mRNA. RNA 6: 163–169.
- 45. Estévez A (2008) The RNA-binding protein TbDRBD3 regulates the stability of a specific subset of mRNAs in trypanosomes. Nucleic Acids Res 36: 4573–4586.
- 46. Archer SK, van Luu D, de Queiroz R, Brems S, Clayton CE (2009) Trypanosoma brucei PUF9 regulates mRNAs for proteins involved in replicative processes over the cell cycle. PLoS Pathog 5: e1000565.
- 47. Stern M, Gupta S, Salmon-Divon M, Haham T, Barda O, et al. (2009) Multiple roles for polypyrimidine tract binding (PTB) proteins in trypanosome RNA metabolism. RNA 15: 648–665.
- 48. Clayton C, Shapira M (2007) Post-transcriptional regulation of gene expression in trypanosomes and leishmanias. Mol Biochem Parasitol 156: 93–101.
- 49. Schwede A, Ellis L, Luther J, Carrington M, Stoecklin G, et al. (2008) A role for Caf1 in mRNA deadenylation and decay in trypanosomes and human cells. Nucleic Acids Res 36: 3374–3388.
- 50. Kramer S, Queiroz R, Ellis L, Webb H, Hoheisel J, et al. (2008) Stress granules and the heat shock response in Trypanosoma brucei. J Cell Sci 121: 3002–3014.
- 51. Schwede A, Manful T, Jha B, Helbig C, Bercovich N, et al. (2009) The role of deadenylation in the degradation of unstable mRNAs in trypanosomes. Nucleic Acids Res 37: 5511–5528.
- 52. Shi H, Djikeng A, Mark T, Wirtz E, Tschudi C, et al. (2000) Genetic interference in Trypanosoma brucei by heritable and inducible double-stranded RNA. RNA 6: 1069–1076.
- 53. Alsford S, Turner D, Obado S, Sanchez-Flores A, Glover L, et al. (2011) High throughput phenotyping using parallel sequencing of RNA interference targets in the African trypanosome. Genome Res . in press.
- 54. Leeds P, Wood J, Lee B, Culbertson M (1992) Gene products that promote mRNA turnover in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Mol Cell Biol 12: 2165–2177.
- 55. Clerici M, Mourão A, Gutsche I, Gehring N, Hentze M, et al. (2009) Unusual bipartite mode of interaction between the nonsense-mediated decay factors, UPF1 and UPF2. EMBO J 28: 2293–2306.
- 56. Webb H, Carnall N, Vanhamme L, Rolin S, Van Den Abbeele J, et al. (1997) The GPI-phospholipase C of Trypanosoma brucei is nonessential but influences parasitemia in mice. J Cell Biol 139: 103–114.
- 57. Webb H, Burns R, Ellis L, Kimblin N, Carrington M (2005) Developmentally regulated instability of the GPI-PLC mRNA is dependent on a short-lived protein factor. Nucleic Acids Res 33: 1503–1512.
- 58. Stewart M, Haile S, Jha B, Cristodero M, Li C-H, et al. (2010) Processing of a reporter mRNA in trypanosomes is not coupled to transcription by RNA polymerase II. Mol Biochem Parasitol 172: 99–106.
- 59. Colasante C, Robles A, Li C-H, Schwede A, Benz C, et al. (2007) Regulated expression of glycosomal phosphoglycerate kinase in Trypanosoma brucei. Mol Biochem Parasitol 151: 193–204.
- 60. Hotz H-R, Hartmann C, Huober K, Hug M, Clayton CE (1997) Mechanisms of developmental regulation in Trypanosoma brucei: A polypyrimidine tract in the 3′-untranslated region of a trypanosome surface protein mRNA affects RNA abundance and translation. Nucleic Acids Res 25: 3017–3025.
- 61. Rebbapragada I, Lykke-Andersen J (2009) Execution of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay: what defines a substrate? Curr Opin Cell Biol 21: 394–402.
- 62. Tsuboi T, Inada T (2010) Tethering of poly(A) binding protein interferes with non-translated mRNA decay from 5′ end in yeast. J Biol Chem . in press.
- 63. Fluck C, Salomone J, Kurath U, Roditi I (2003) Cycloheximide-mediated accumulation of transcripts from a procyclin expression site depends on the intergenic region. Mol Biochem Parasitol 127: 93–97.
- 64. Gatfield D, Unterholzner L, Ciccarelli F, Bork P, Izaurralde E (2003) Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay in Drosophila: at the intersection of the yeast and mammalian pathways. EMBO J 22: 3960–3970.
- 65. Lejeune F, Li X, Maquat LE (2003) Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay in mammalian cells involves decapping, deadenylating, and exonucleolytic activities. Mol Cell 12: 675–687.
- 66. Bercovich N, Clayton C, Levin M, Vazquez M (2009) Identification of core components of the exon junction complex in trypanosomes. Mol Biochem Parasitol 166: 190–193.
- 67. Schwanhäusser B, Busse D, Li N, Dittmar G, Schuchhardt J, et al. (2011) Global quantification of mammalian gene expression control. Nature 473: 337–342.
- 68. Siegel T, Hekstra D, Wang X, Dewell S, Cross G (2010) Genome-wide analysis of mRNA abundance in two life-cycle stages of Trypanosoma brucei and identification of splicing and polyadenylation sites. Nucleic Acids Res 38: 4946–4957.
- 69. da Costa Lima T, Moura D, Reis C, Vasconcelos J, Ellis L, et al. (2010) Functional characterization of three leishmania poly(A) binding protein homologues with distinct binding properties to RNA and protein partners. Eukaryot Cell 9: 1484–1494.
- 70. Gray N, Coller J, Dickson K, Wickens M (2000) Multiple portions of poly(A)-binding protein stimulate translation in vivo. EMBO J 19: 4723–4733.
- 71. Shi H, Djikeng A, Tschudi C, Ullu E (2004) Argonaute protein in the early divergent eukaryote Trypanosoma brucei: control of small interfering RNA accumulation and retroposon transcript abundance. Mol Cell Biol 24: 420–427.
- 72. Patrick K, Luz P, Ruan J, Shi H, Ullu E, et al. (2008) Genomic rearrangements and transcriptional analysis of the spliced leader-associated retrotransposon in RNA interference-deficient Trypanosoma brucei. Mol Microbiol 67: 435–447.
- 73. Hu W, Petzold C, Coller J, Baker K (2010) Nonsense-mediated mRNA decapping occurs on polyribosomes in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Nat Struct Mol Biol 17: 244–247.
- 74. Alibu VP, Storm L, Haile S, Clayton C, Horn D (2004) A doubly inducible system for RNA interference and rapid RNAi plasmid construction in Trypanosoma brucei. Mol Biochem Parasitol 139: 75–82.
- 75. Clayton CE, Estévez AM, Hartmann C, Alibu VP, Field M, et al. (2005) Down-regulating gene expression by RNA interference in Trypanosoma brucei. In: Carmichael G, editor. RNA interference:. Humana Press.
- 76. Li C-H, Irmer H, Gudjonsdottir-Planck D, Freese S, Salm H, et al. (2006) Roles of a Trypanosoma brucei 5′→3′ exoribonuclease homologue in mRNA degradation. RNA 12: 2171–2186.
- 77. Queiroz R, Benz C, Fellenberg K, V S, Hoheisel J, et al. (2009) Transcriptome analysis of differentiating trypanosomes reveals the existence of multiple post-transcriptional regulons. BMC Genomics 10: 495.
- 78. Rozen S, Skaletsky H (2000) Primer3 on the WWW for general users and for biologist programmers. Methods Mol Biol 132: 365–386.
- 79. Nett I, Martin D, Miranda-Saavedra D, Lamont D, Barber J, et al. (2009) The phosphoproteome of bloodstream form Trypanonosoma brucei, causative agent of African sleeping sickness. Mol Cell Proteomics 8: 1527–1538.