Anthelmintic resistance is a major problem in livestock farming, especially of small ruminants, but our understanding of it has been limited by the difficulty in carrying out functional genetic studies on parasitic nematodes. An important nematode infecting sheep and goats is Haemonchus contortus; in many parts of the world this species is resistant to almost all the currently available drugs, including ivermectin. It is extremely polymorphic and to date it has proved impossible to relate any sequence polymorphisms to its ivermectin resistance status. Expression of candidate drug-resistance genes in Caenorhabditis elegans could provide a convenient means to study the effects of polymorphisms found in resistant parasites, but may be complicated by differences between the gene families of target and model organisms. We tested this using the glutamate-gated chloride channel (GluCl) gene family, which forms the ivermectin drug target and are candidate resistance genes. We expressed GluCl subunits from C. elegans and H. contortus in a highly resistant triple mutant C. elegans strain (DA1316) under the control of the avr-14 promoter; expression of GFP behind this promoter recapitulated the pattern previously reported for avr-14. Expression of ivermectin-sensitive subunits from both species restored drug sensitivity to transgenic worms, though some quantitative differences were noted between lines. Expression of an ivermectin-insensitive subunit, Hco-GLC-2, had no effect on drug sensitivity. Expression of a previously uncharacterised parasite-specific subunit, Hco-GLC-6, caused the transgenic worms to become ivermectin sensitive, suggesting that this subunit also encodes a GluCl that responds to the drug. These results demonstrate that both orthologous and paralogous subunits from C. elegans and H. contortus are able to rescue the ivermectin sensitivity of mutant C. elegans, though some quantitative differences were observed between transgenic lines in some assays. C. elegans is a suitable system for studying parasitic nematode genes that may be involved in drug resistance.
Citation: Glendinning SK, Buckingham SD, Sattelle DB, Wonnacott S, Wolstenholme AJ (2011) Glutamate-Gated Chloride Channels of Haemonchus contortus Restore Drug Sensitivity to Ivermectin Resistant Caenorhabditis elegans. PLoS ONE 6(7): e22390. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0022390
Editor: Clotilde K. S. Carlow, New England Biolabs, United States of America
Received: March 30, 2011; Accepted: June 20, 2011; Published: July 26, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Glendinning et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by an award from the Wellcome Trust, Reference 083921 (www.wellcome.ac.uk). Some nematode strains used in this work were provided by the Caenorhabditis Genetics Center, which is funded by the NIH National Center for Research Resources. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Infections with parasitic nematodes are a major problem in animal health, and for human health in less-developed parts of the world . Currently, the only effective means of control is by treatment with chemical anthelmintics . One of the major classes of anthelmintic is the macrocyclic lactones (MLs), which include ivermectin and moxidectin, and these have been widely used in agriculture  and, in the case of ivermectin, human medicine , . However, some species of parasite, especially those infecting small ruminants, have become resistant to the MLs, and this is threatening sustainable worm control in those animals , . There have also been suggestions of the emergence of ML resistance in human parasites , , so there is an urgent need to understand the genetic basis of this resistance. Unfortunately, many informative genetic experiments in parasitic nematodes are extremely difficult, so for some time there has been an interest in exploiting the free-living species, Caenorhabditis elegans, for such studies, taking advantage of the powerful genetic and behavioural tools that can be applied to this organism. Haemonchus contortus is an economically important parasite of small ruminants which has developed widespread resistance to anthelmintic drugs, including the MLs . The major targets of the MLs are the glutamate-gated chloride channel (GluCl) receptors; activation or potentiation of these channels in GI nematodes by the drugs produces paralysis and inhibition of feeding , and in filarial nematodes inhibits protein secretion . An improved understanding of the contribution of GluCl receptors to anthelmintic actions and resistance would aid in developing new pharmacological strategies against parasitic nematodes.
Investigation of the behavioural and drug target roles of individual GluCl subunits in parasitic nematodes is hampered by several limitations. The requirement for a host to complete the lifecycle of the parasite is a major obstacle in producing mutant strains of parasitic nematode required for a detailed analysis of GluCl subunit function. Transgenesis of parasitic nematodes is possible , , and some parasitic nematodes are more amenable to this strategy than others. For example Strongyloides stercoralis has been successfully transformed , ,  although this parasite is unusual in that it has free-living generations which alternate with parasitic generations. H. contortus has not been successfully used in studies of transgenesis so far, although RNAi may be useful in the future for studying genes in H. contortus by gene knockdown , . Due to the powerful genetic techniques available when working with the free living model organism C. elegans, our aim was to exploit C. elegans for the study of H. contortus GluCl subunit function in vivo. Successful expression of subunits from the parasite in C. elegans would enable us to interrogate the function of particular GluCl subunits.
Several other investigators have looked at the ability of parasite gene products to express successfully in C. elegans. Gillan et al., studying hsp-90, found that the H. contortus orthologue produced only a partial rescue of the C. elegans mutation, whereas the orthologue from Brugia pahangi, a more distantly related parasite, failed to produce any rescue . Other H. contortus genes that have been successfully expressed in C. elegans include cathepsin L , the transcription factor elt-2  and β-tubulin, where Kwa et al  showed that polymorphisms associated with benzimidazole resistance would cause the transgenic C. elegans to become drug resistant. Genes from other parasites have also been expressed; Kampkotter et al  showed that a glutathione-S-transferase from Onchocerca volvulus would make C. elegans more resistant to oxidative stress and Massey et al.  showed that a forkhead transcription factor from Strongyloides stercoralis would rescue daf-16 associated defects. In contrast, Crook et al.  found that a putative daf-7 orthologue from Parastrongyloides trichosuri (Ptr-daf-7 – genetic nomenclature as proposed by Beech et al. ) did not complement C. elegans daf-7 mutants. Very recently, Welz et al  showed that expression of the Ancylostoma caninum SLO-1 channel could completely rescue the emodepside sensitivity of a slo-1 null mutant of C. elegans, demonstrating the utility of the free-living nematode for the expression of parasite drug targets.
Studying genes that may be involved in macrocyclic lactone action and resistance in this manner has the potential to be challenging as there are multiple genes encoding ivermectin-sensitive GluCl subunits in nematodes. C. elegans has six GluCl genes, with at least two of these being alternatively spliced ; in H. contortus there are also six known GluCl genes coding for at least seven subunits, however the composition of the two gene families is not the same (Table 1). The gene family from C. elegans contains two genes, Cel-glc-1 and Cel-avr-15, for which structural orthologues have not been described in H. contortus and the parasite has two genes, Hco-glc-5 and Hco-glc-6, which are not present in C. elegans . The subunits are, by analogy with nicotinic and GABAA receptors, assumed to combine to form pentameric receptors, however the subunit composition and stoichiometry of the functional receptors in vivo in either species is unknown. Many, but not all, GluCl subunits form ivermectin-sensitive channels when expressed in vitro (Table 1). An important similarity between the two nematodes is the presence of the avr-14 gene, which has structural orthologues not only in these two species, but in all nematode genomes examined so far , , . This gene is alternatively spliced to produce AVR-14A and AVR-14B subunits; the alternatively spliced subunits share 81% and 82% amino acid sequence similarity between each other in H. contortus and C. elegans respectively . The AVR-14B subunits have 87% amino acid sequence identity between the two worm species, while for AVR-14A the identity is 88%. The AVR-14 subunits share a common N-terminal ligand-binding domain but diverge thereafter in the sequence that forms the ion channel and intracellular domain. Previously we have shown that expression of Hco-AVR-14A and –AVR-14B in avr-14 mutant C. elegans can rescue the behavioural abnormality, increased reversal frequency, associated with the mutation . However, mutations in avr-14 alone are not sufficient to make C. elegans resistant to ivermectin , so it was not possible to test the effects of the parasite subunits on drug resistance in those studies.
In the experiments reported here we make use of the triple GluCl mutant C. elegans line DA1316, which has 4,000 fold resistance to ivermectin in a growth assay compared to wild-type . The three GluCl genes with mutations in DA1316 are avr-14, avr-15 and glc-1, with the mutations in the former two genes producing null-function subunits for both splice variants. DA1316 was selected as the background mutant to test the hypothesis that GluCl subunits from H. contortus could rescue the ivermectin sensitivity of mutant C. elegans. In addition, we wished to examine whether other members of the GluCl gene family could also rescue an avr-14 defect; whether only orthologous genes were capable of accurately rescuing the C. elegans phenotype or whether paralogous genes were also capable of restoring drug sensitivity. Overall, these experiments test the usefulness of C. elegans as an expression system for studying drug resistance and other genes from a parasitic species.
avr-14 Expression Pattern
The expression pattern of wild type C. elegans transformed with a transcriptional reporter construct incorporating a 1,700 bp avr-14 promoter fragment showed GFP expression in the nerve ring, ventral nerve cord and sensory neurones in the body (Fig. 1). This construct accurately reproduced the pattern shown previously using a similar avr-14 promoter . Expression was also clear in the amphidial neurones of the head and the phasmid neurones of the tail (Fig. 1).
The avr-14 promoter fragment used was a section 1.7 kb upstream of the initiation codon. A) Whole adult wild type C. elegans transformed with a Cel-avr-14::gfp construct. vnc = ventral nerve cord; nr = nerve ring. B) Head section. an = amphidial neurones; vnc = ventral nerve cord. C) Body section between vulva and tail. pds = posterior deirid sensilla neurone cell bodies; vnc = ventral nerve cord. D) Tail section. phn = PHA, PHB and PHC neurone cell bodies. vnc = ventral nerve cord.
Rescue of ivermectin sensitivity of DA1316 with C. elegans and H. contortus avr-14 cDNAs
The movement of the triple GluCl mutant strain, DA1316, was not affected by exposure to 1 µM ivermectin after 1 hour, in contrast to the total paralysis of 100% of wild type C. elegans that was observed under the same conditions (Fig. 2). In order to confirm that this resistance could be reversed by expression of one of the genes mutated in DA1316, avr-14, we transformed DA1316 with three subunit cDNAs (Cel-avr-14a, Cel-avr-14b or Hco-avr-14b) under the control of the avr-14 promoter. Transformation with any of these cDNAs resulted in rescue of ivermectin sensitivity to varying degrees (Fig. 2A and B), with statistically significantly greater numbers of worms paralysed by exposure to 1 µM ivermectin in all the transgenic worm lines tested, compared to the parent DA1316. In particular, the avr-14b cDNA of both nematode species resulted in a robust rescue, with at least 79% of the tested worms becoming immotile in the presence of ivermectin. This result was obtained with two different lines expressing the C. elegans subunit, where 93±3.4% and 95±5.0% of the worms were paralysed, and four lines expressing the H. contortus subunit, where the proportion that were paralysed varied from 79±12.1% to 92±4.5%. The results with the lines transformed with both the C. elegans and H. contortus avr-14b cDNAs were similar to both wild-type worms and to DA1370, a double mutant strain (avr-15; glc-1) that is only weakly resistant to ivermectin . The three lines containing Cel-avr-14a cDNA in DA1316 showed different levels of ivermectin sensitivity, from 33±8.6% of line 2 paralysed to 78±11.8% of line 1; the differences between avr-14A lines 2 & 3, and the avr-14B lines were significant (p = <0.01).
N = 3. Asterisks indicate a significant difference (p = <0.05) between the transgenic lines and the parent DA1316 triple mutant (avr-14; avr-15; glc-1). A) Ivermectin sensitivity, assessed by counting the number of stationary worms after exposure to 1 µM ivermectin for 1 hr, of DA1316 transformed with either Cel-avr-14a (3 lines) or Cel-avr-14b (2 lines) cDNA. B) Ivermectin sensitivity of DA1316 transformed with Hco-avr-14b cDNA (4 lines), assessed as in panel A). For panels A & B, data are presented as mean ± SEM and a one-way ANOVA and Tukey's post-hoc test were performed on the two data sets separately using Minitab. Wild-type N2 worms and the DA1370 double mutant (avr-15; glc-1) are included for comparison. C) The effect of ivermectin on nematode swimming measured as “thrashes” per minute (as % of vehicle control) for wild type and transgenic C. elegans lines. Hco-avr-14b in DA1316 line 2 and Cel-avr-14b in DA1316 line 1 were chosen as representative lines from the motility assay for use in the thrashing assays. The experiment was repeated 3 times, with 8 worms per strain per concentration. D) An automated thrashing assay on the same lines as in panel C. The experiment was repeated between 1 and 4 times for each data point. Curves were fitted using the variable slope sigmoidal equation in GraphPad Prism (San Diego). The data are presented as mean ± SEM with N = 3. Symbols as in panel C).
In an attempt to obtain more quantitative data on the level of drug sensitivity of the transgenic lines, we carried out thrashing assays in varying concentrations of ivermectin, and compared the results obtained by counting manually with those obtained with an automated system . In summary, the thrashing rates of the transformed worms were similar to those of wild type, showing a greater sensitivity to ivermectin than the untransformed triple mutant, DA1316. There was no significant difference between the thrashing rates (75±16 to 95±4 thrashes/min) of any of the lines when placed in 0.1% (v/v) DMSO as a vehicle only control. The dose-response curve of DA1316 indicated that these worms become susceptible to the paralytic effects of ivermectin at concentrations above 10 µM (Fig. 2C). Even at 10 µM ivermectin, C. elegans with mutations in the three GluCl subunit genes reduced their thrashing rate by only 50%. In contrast, the transformation of DA1316 with avr-14b cDNA from either C. elegans or H. contortus resulted in an increase in the sensitivity of these worms to ivermectin to such an extent that they had a thrashing rate of only 2±1 and 2±2 thrashes/min respectively at 10 µM drug, and their thrashing rate was reduced by more than 50% at 1 µM ivermectin. The results from transgenic worms expressing Cel-AVR-14A were more variable, with two out of three lines retaining some activity in 1 µM ivermectin (Fig 2A).
The automated thrashing assay produced very similar results to those obtained by the more laborious manual thrashing assay, with rescue of the ivermectin sensitivity observed for DA1316 expressing all of the avr-14 cDNAs (Fig. 2D). The nature of the assay allowed us to measure more ivermectin concentrations, and also more C. elegans strains simultaneously than was possible with the manual thrashing assay. Importantly, very similar thrashing rates and dose-response curves were produced using the two different methods.
Chronic Ivermectin Sensitivity Assay
The previous assays both measured the sensitivity of the worms to an acute exposure to ivermectin. However in vivo drug exposure would be much longer-term, with potential effects at lower concentrations than were used in the motility assays. The chronic ivermectin sensitivity assay, or growth assay, involved placing eggs onto nematode growth medium containing different concentrations of ivermectin and is a useful measure of the combined effects of ivermectin on foraging (locomotion) and pharyngeal pumping activity in different lines of C. elegans. Control plates containing 0.1% (v/v) DMSO were also set up during each experiment to account for any non-ivermectin related effects. The triple mutant line was resistant to ivermectin throughout the concentration range used, whereas no wild type adults were observed at concentrations above 1 nM ivermectin (Fig 3A). All the avr-14 cDNAs conferred ivermectin sensitivity onto DA1316, and no adults were observed at concentrations of 3nM and above.
A). The number of eggs that developed to adulthood on different concentrations of ivermectin. There is rescue of ivermectin sensitivity by Cel-avr-14a, Cel-avr-14b and Hco-avr-14b cDNA in the resistant DA1316 mutant. Data are presented as mean ± SEM. B) The DA1316 triple mutant transformed with Hco-avr-14b cDNA carried out fewer reversals per minute than the other lines. Reversals per minute were counted to compare WT, DA1316 (glc-1; avr-14; avr-15) and DA1316 containing either Cel-avr-14b or Hco-avr-14b cDNA behind the Cel-avr-14 promoter. The double mutant, DA1370 (avr-15; glc-1), which has mutations in glc-1 and avr-15 was also used as a comparison. * Indicates that the reversals of the line containing the cDNA from the parasite were significantly reduced compared to DA1316, WT and DA1316 containing Cel-avr-14b cDNA. No difference was detected between the reversal frequencies of WT, DA1316, DA1370 or Cel-avr-14b in DA1316, using a one-way ANOVA (Minitab). Data are presented as mean ± SEM with N = 10 worms for each line.
Our previous study had indicated that mutations in GluCl subunits affected the reversal frequency of C. elegans, with avr-14 mutants reversing more frequently than wild-type, and also that expression of the H. contortus AVR-14B could rescue this abnormality in an avr-14 mutant strain ; indeed, expression of H. contortus AVR-14B caused the worms to reverse less frequently than wild-type. However, the experiments in that study had not included DA1316, which has an additional mutation in glc-1 , so we tested whether DA1316 also reversed more frequently, and to identify whether any altered number of reversals could again be rescued using Hco-avr-14b or Cel-avr-14b cDNA (Fig. 3B). The reversal frequency of DA1316 was not significantly elevated compared with wild-type, indicating that loss of a functional glc-1 offset the increase caused by mutations in avr-14 and avr-15 . DA1370, the double mutant (avr-15;glc-1) also reversed at the same frequency as the wild-type worms, adding additional support for this suggestion. The expression of Cel-AVR-14B had no effect on the reversal frequency of DA1316, but transforming the triple mutant with Hco-avr-14b cDNA produced worms with a severely reduced ability to reverse at normal frequencies.
Rescue by other C. elegans and H. contortus GluCl subunits
The GluCl are pentameric channels, there are multiple GluCl subunit genes in both C. elegans and H. contortus and the subunit composition of the native channels is not known. In vitro, Cel-GLC-1 and -GLC-2 can co-assemble to form functional channels ; in vivo, Cel-glc-2 is expressed only in the pharynx , where Cel-avr-15 is also expressed , and the expression pattern of Cel-glc-1 has not yet been determined. In H. contortus, the expression patterns of Hco-AVR-14 and Hco-GLC-5 overlap , though whether the two subunits co-assemble is not known. If, in vivo, AVR-14 subunits co-assemble with others to form ivermectin-sensitive heteromeric channels, this might mean that expression of non-orthologous GluCl genes would not rescue the ivermectin-resistance phenotype effectively, perhaps limiting the usefulness of this approach for studying genes from other species. We therefore transfected DA1316 with cDNAs encoding other ivermectin-sensitive subunits from C. elegans (glc-1, glc-3, avr-15) and H. contortus (Hco-glc-5). We also used cDNA encoding an ivermectin-insensitive subunit, Hco-GLC-2  and an uncharacterised subunit, Hco-GLC-6 , from H. contortus. All of the cDNAs were sub-cloned behind the same avr-14 promoter used previously. The results, shown in Figure 4, show that of the C. elegans subunits, all three lines expressing Cel-AVR-15 were almost completely sensitive to 1 µM ivermectin, whereas those expressing Cel-GLC-3 or Cel-GLC-1 were only partially sensitive to this concentration of the drug. Expression of the H. contortus GLC-5 subunit also caused a partial rescue of the sensitivity to 1 µM ivermectin, and complete sensitivity to 10 µM, whereas expression of Hco-GLC-2 did not produce any significant changes to DA1316, which is consistent with the insensitivity of GLC-2 channels to ivermectin , . The uncharacterised Hco-GLC-6 subunit produced an almost complete rescue of drug sensitivity, indicating that it either produces ivermectin-sensitive channels, or can combine with pre-existing subunits to form such channels.
A) Paralysis assay on lines transformed with cDNA expressing other C. elegans GluCl subunits. The proportion of worms that were paralysed by immersion in 1 µM ivermectin for 1 hr is shown. B) Thrashing assay of the lines from panel A. The number of thrashes/minute of the worms following a 1 hr exposure to 1 µM ivermectin is indicated. C) Paralysis assay on worms transformed with cDNAs expressing H. contortus GluCl subunits. D) Thrashing assay at three different concentrations of ivermectin, carried out on some of the lines shown in C). For panels A, B & C, * = statistically significant difference from DA1316 (p≤0.05).
The study of polymorphisms and mutations potentially involved in anthelmintic resistance of parasitic nematodes is complicated by the difficulty of carrying genetic experiments on these organisms. Though in vitro studies are useful, especially in the case of those drugs which affect ion channels, in vivo confirmation that a particular sequence change does alter the organism's response to drug application is always desirable. C. elegans has been used as an expression system for many parasite genes, including those involved in resistance to the benzimidazole anthelmintics , and so it seemed an obvious question to ask if it is a suitable system for studying genes which encode targets of the MLs, and are thus candidate resistance genes . The MLs act on glutamate-gated channels, either directly activating them or potentiating their response to glutamate . The GluCls are expressed widely in the nematode nervous system, and are encoded by a small gene family; this family differs in size and composition between species, with some genes, such as avr-14, being widely conserved and others seeming to be present in much fewer species , , . The presence of multiple potential targets in parasitic species, some of which do not have orthologues in C. elegans, as is the case for H. contortus, raises some interesting problems, especially if they are required to assemble with other subunits to form heteromeric receptors in order to be fully functional.
We addressed some of these issues by expressing multiple GluCl subunits from both C. elegans and H. contortus in a C. elegans strain (DA1316) that is very resistant to ivermectin, and by testing the sensitivity of the transgenic worms to the drug. DA1316 is a triple mutant strain (avr-14, avr-15, glc-1) but the double mutant (avr-15, glc-1) has a very low-level of resistance , so that even partial rescue of the avr-14 mutation would produce a clear shift in response to the drug. A rescue of ivermectin sensitivity implies that the recombinant subunit forms, either by itself or by assembling with other endogenous polypeptides, a functional drug-sensitive channel. We chose H. contortus as the source of the parasite cDNAs for this study because it is a member of clade V like C. elegans, and is therefore not too phylogenetically distant , and because it encodes a number of ivermectin-sensitive GluCl subunits, not all of which have orthologues in the C. elegans genome (Table 1). The expression of GFP under the control of the avr-14 promoter fragment showed that any recombinant subunits would be expressed in the same cells as the C. elegans avr-14 gene products and, as predicted by our previous results , expression of both Cel-AVR-14B and Hco-AVR-14B restored the worms to almost complete drug sensitivity. A caveat to that statement is that we do not know which of the splice variants, AVR-14A or AVR-14B, are normally expressed in these cells, nor should it be assumed that the expression of this gene in parasitic species would be the same as in C. elegans. Indeed, for both H. contortus and Brugia malayi, there is evidence that it is not , . Despite this, expression of Hco-AVR-14B not only rescued a behavioural defect associated with avr-14, an increased reversal frequency, but caused the worms to reverse less frequently than wild-type, as previously reported . This unexpected result may be related to the much greater potency of L-glutamate on the Hco-AVR-14B receptor (EC50 = 27.6 µM) than on Cel-AVR-14B (EC50 = 2.2 mM) that we observed in vitro . If one of the roles of AVR-14 is to suppress the initiation of reversals , then activation of Hco-AVR-14B by lower concentrations of glutamate may cause this suppression to last longer than in wild-type worms. The observation that DA1316 reversed with a similar frequency to wild-type is presumably due to the mutation in glc-1, which must be able to suppress the increase in reversal frequency caused by the avr-14 and avr-15 mutations. We have previously shown that not all mutation in GluCl genes cause an increase in reversal frequency; a deletion in glc-3 causes a marked decrease in reversal frequency . This is supported by the result with DA1370, which carries mutations in avr-15 and glc-1. This strain showed no abnormality in reversal frequency (Figure 3B), unlike avr-15 single mutants  which strongly suggests that the glc-1 allele is suppressing this effect of the avr-15 mutation The ivermectin resistance of the transgenic lines was measured in a variety of assays, and all gave essentially the same result, that the resistance of DA1316, whether to acute or chronic exposure, was reversed by expression of the AVR-14 subunits (Figures 2 & 3).
Mutations in the GluCl of ivermectin-resistant isolates of parasitic nematodes have been observed, in particular in Cooperia oncophora , and these mutations affect the sensitivity of the channels to ivermectin in vitro , . In addition, mutations in the have been made in both the mammalian glycine receptor and the nematode GluCl that reduce or abolish the effect of ivermectin . These amino-acid residues are found in M3 and contribute to the recently described binding site of ivermectin in the membrane domain of the GluCl . It would be interesting to test such mutants of AVR-14B in transgenic C. elegans, to confirm that they do not rescue drug sensitivity and to examine whether the decreased reversal frequency shown in Figure 3B is still observed, and correlates with the in vitro potency of glutamate at these receptors.
These experiments showed that orthologous gene products from a parasitic nematode were functionally expressed in C. elegans, so we then looked at some paralogous gene products from both species. Figure 4 shows that those subunits that formed ivermectin-sensitive subunits in vitro also rescued the drug resistance phenotype, at least to some extent, though there were some quantitative and qualitative differences between some of the lines expressing paralogues and orthologues. Such a rescue could have come about in one of two ways; either the paralogous subunits were able to assemble with the normal partners of the endogenous AVR-14 subunits to form a functional GluCl, or they formed novel ivermectin-sensitive channels that silenced avr-14 expressing neurones on exposure to the drug. The ivermectin insensitive subunit, Hco-GLC-2 , was not able to rescue ivermectin sensitivity but interestingly Hco-GLC-6 , which has not yet been studied by in vitro expression in Xenopus oocytes or in cell culture, was able to rescue the avr-14 defect, suggesting that this subunit also contributes to an ivermectin-sensitive channel.
Taken together, the data show that C. elegans is a good system for the expression of parasite ion channels that act as drug targets, and is likely to be a reliable way of assessing the contributions of sequence polymorphisms within these subunits to a drug resistance phenotype. If this is true for ivermectin and the GluCl, then similar assays should be useful for the many drugs that act at nicotinic acetylcholine receptors, especially those that cause paralysis. The use of the model organism may help to overcome the formidable barriers to carrying out genetic experimentation on parasites.
C. elegans wild-type and mutant strains were cultured according to standard techniques, and were maintained at 19°C on nematode growth medium (NGM) agar plates seeded with OP50 bacteria.
Transformation of C. elegans
The C. elegans and H. contortus GluCl cDNA fragments were cloned behind a Cel-avr-14 promoter fragment, as described previously . The avr-14 promoter was a 1700 bp fragment from immediately upstream of the avr-14 translational start site. To test the expression pattern of this promoter fragment, a transcriptional GFP reporter construct was made by cloning the avr-14 promoter fragment into a vector containing GFP (pPD95.75 Fire Vector Kit 1995, Addgene plasmid 1494) . The reporter construct was used to transform N2 (wild type) C. elegans and the expression pattern examined (MZ16 F Fluorescence Stereomicroscope, Leica) (Fig. 1). The sequence of the Hco-glc-6 cDNA is deposited under Accession number EU006789.
Transformation of C. elegans was carried out using DNA-coated gold particle bombardment (Bio-Rad PDS-1000 with hepta adaptor for increased transformation efficiency). For the rescue experiments, the DA1316 strain (avr-14; avr-15; glc-1 triple mutant: ) was bombarded using a total of approximately 3 µg of DNA. The co-transformation marker (myo-3::gfp, pPD118.20 Fire Lab Vector Kit 1997, Addgene plasmid 1592) and the test DNA were on separate plasmids, which were linearized by digestion with ApaI or KpnI in standard buffers (NEB) in a total reaction volume of 50 µl for each plasmid. The DNA solutions were then mixed together and precipitated onto gold particles. Transformation was carried out under 1500 psi of helium gas pressure and a chamber vacuum of 21 mmHg. Subsequently, transformants expressing GFP in the body wall muscle were picked and successful lines were maintained. The presence of the test DNA was verified for each line using single worm PCR, with primers either specific to the start and end of the cDNA sequence (for H. contortus cDNA) or by designing primers that spanned exon-exon junctions (for C. elegans cDNA). In practise, 100% of lines expressing the myo-3::gfp construct contained the test DNA. At least two separate lines were produced for each GluCl cDNA tested. A control line was produced by transforming DA1316 with the myo-3::gfp construct only, and this line is used in place of untransformed DA1316 throughout the rest of the assays.
Acute ivermectin sensitivity assays
A survey of the ivermectin sensitivity of the multiple lines was carried out for all worm strains produced. Ten individual worms were picked from each line/strain into 96-well plates with wells containing 50 µl M9 salts, two wells per line. 50 µl of 2 µM ivermectin solution was added to each well to produce a final concentration of 1 µM. The worms were left at 19°C for 1 h, after which time the number of stationary worms in each well was counted. The experiments were carried out in triplicate and using the data from this assay, one representative line containing each construct was chosen for use in the thrashing assay, chronic ivermectin sensitivity assay and behavioural assay.
Thrashing assays were carried out at different concentrations of ivermectin to characterise the drug sensitivity of the avr-14B transgenic lines more fully. The thrashing assay was carried out using two different methods: manual thrashing assay and automated thrashing assay. The two methods were used to verify the measurements thoroughly.
For the manual thrashing assay, individual young adult C. elegans were placed in 100 µl of ivermectin solution (made up in M9 buffer) in a 96-well microtitre plate. After 30 minutes in the drug at 19°C, the number of thrashes (bends of the body from one side to the other and back) were counted for 1 minute. A preliminary time-course investigation (data not shown) indicated that 30 minutes would be the appropriate duration in the drug at the ivermectin concentrations used (0.03 to 8.75 µg/ml). The experiment was carried out for 8 worms per strain, per ivermectin concentration and was repeated on two further days. The GluCl-transformed lines were chosen as representative lines, after inspection of the motility assay data. One thrash was counted as a movement of the head to one side e.g. a thrash was counted every time the head of the worm moved to the left.
The automated thrashing assay was carried out as for manual thrashing, except that the thrashing rates for all worms could be measured simultaneously. Movies were taken of the whole 96-well plate, and thrashing rates calculated for each well by the co-variance method as described previously .
Chronic ivermectin sensitivity assay
NGM was made, allowed to cool, and spiked to contain a final concentration of either 0.01% DMSO or ivermectin at 100 pM or 1, 3.2, 10, or 100 nM. The NGM was transferred to 12-well plates, allowed to set and seeded with 50 µl OP50. After 2 days at room temperature, egg preparations of the different C. elegans lines were made, and eggs were transferred onto the ivermectin/DMSO plates. The number of adult worms in each well was counted six days later. Three replicate wells per ivermectin/DMSO concentration per worm strain were set-up, and the whole experiment was repeated on two subsequent occasions.
Behavioural assay – reversal frequency
The frequency of reversals was as described by Cook et al . Individual worms were picked onto an unseeded NGM plate (to remove traces of bacteria), and then transferred to the measurement NGM plate (also unseeded) where they were left to acclimatise for 5 min. The number of reversals (initiations of backward movement) in 5 min was counted.
Conceived and designed the experiments: SKG DBS SW AJW. Performed the experiments: SKG SDB. Analyzed the data: SKG SDB AJW. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: DBS SDB. Wrote the paper: SKG SW AJW.
- 1. Brooker S, Hotez PJ, Bundy DAP (2010) The global atlas of helminth infection: mapping the way forward in neglected tropical disease control. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 4: e779.
- 2. Geary TG, Woo K, McCarthy JS, Mackenzie CD, Horton J, et al. (2010) Unresolved issues in anthelmintic pharmacology for helminthiases of humans. Int J Parasitol 40: 1–13.
- 3. Vercruysse J, Rew RS (2002) Macrocyclic lactones in antiparasitic therapy. Wallingford, U.K.: CABI Publishing.
- 4. Fox LM (2006) Ivermectin: uses and impact 20 years on. Curr Op Infect Dis 19: 588–593.
- 5. Omura S (2008) Ivermectin: 25 years and still going strong. Int J Antimicrob Agents 31: 91–98.
- 6. Kaplan RM (2004) Drug resistance in nematodes of veterinary importance: a status report. Trends Parasitol 20: 477–481.
- 7. Wolstenholme AJ, Fairweather I, Prichard RK, von Samson-Himmelstjerna G, Sangster N (2004) Drug resistance in veterinary helminths. Trends Parasitol 20: 469–476.
- 8. Churcher TS, Pion SDS, Osei-Atweneboana MY, Prichard RK, Awadzi K, et al. (2009) Identifying sub-optimal responses to ivermectin in the treatment of River Blindness. Proc Nat'l Acad Sci US A 106: 16716–16721.
- 9. Osei-Atweneboana MY, Eng JKL, Boakye DA, Gyapong JO, Prichard RK (2007) Prevalence and intensity of Onchocerca volvulus infection and efficacy of ivermectin in endemic communities in Ghana: a two-phase epidemiological study. Lancet 369: 2021–2029.
- 10. Britton C, Murray L (2006) Using Caenorhabditis elegans for functional analysis of genes of parasitic nematodes. Int J Parasitol 36: 651–659.
- 11. Wolstenholme AJ, Rogers AT (2005) Glutamate-gated chloride channels and the mode of action of the avermectin/milbemycin anthelmintics. Parasitology 131: S85–S95.
- 12. Moreno Y, Nabhan JF, Solomon J, Mackenzie CD, Geary TG (2010) Ivermectin disrupts the function of the excretory-secretory apparatus in microfilariae of Brugia malayi. Pro Nat'l Acad Sci US A 107: 20120–20125.
- 13. Lok JB, Artis D (2008) Transgenesis and neuronal ablation in parasitic nematodes: revolutionary new tools to dissect host-parasite interactions. Parasite Immunol 30: 203–214.
- 14. Liu CH, de Oliveira A, Higazi TB, Ghedin E, DePasse J, et al. (2007) Sequences necessary for trans-splicing in transiently transfected Brugia malayi. Mol Biochem Parasitol 156: 62–73.
- 15. Lok JB, Massey HC (2002) Transgene expression in Strongyloides stercoralis following gonadal microinjection of DNA constructs. Mol Biochem Parasitol119: 279–284.
- 16. Castelletto ML, Massey HC, Lok JB (2009) Morphogenesis of Strongyloides stercoralis infective larvae requires the DAF-16 ortholog FKTF-1. PLoS Pathogens 5: e1000370.
- 17. Junio AB, Li XS, Massey HC, Nolan TJ, Lamitina ST, et al. (2008) Strongyloides stercoralis: Cell- and tissue-specific transgene expression and co-transformation with. vector constructs incorporating a common multifunctional 3 ′ UTR. Exp Parasitol 118: 253–265.
- 18. Geldhof P, Visser A, Clark D, Saunders G, Britton C, et al. (2007) RNA interference in parasitic helminths: current situation, potential pitfalls and future prospects. Parasitology 134: 609–619.
- 19. Samarasinghe B, Knox DP, Britton C (2011) Factors affecting susceptibility to RNA interference in Haemonchus contortus and in vivo silencing of an H11 aminopeptidase gene. Int J Parasitology 41: 51–59.
- 20. Gillan V, Maitland K, McCormack G, Him N, Devaney E (2009) Functional genomics of hsp-90 in parasitic and free-living nematodes. Int J Parasitol 39: 1071–1081.
- 21. Britton C, Murray L (2002) A cathepsin L protease essential for Caenorhabditis elegans embryogenesis is functionally conserved in parasitic nematodes. Mol Biochem Parasitol 122: 21–33.
- 22. Couthier A, Smith J, McGarr P, Craig B, Gilleard JS (2004) Ectopic expression of a Haemonchus contortus GATA transcription factor in Caenorhabditis elegans reveals conserved function in spite of extensive sequence divergence. Mol Biochem Parasitol 133: 241–253.
- 23. Kwa MSG, Veenstra JG, van Dujk M, Roos MH (1995) Beta-tubulin genes from the parasitic nematode Haemonchus contortus modulate drug resistance in Caenorhabditis elegans. J Mol Biol 246: 500–510.
- 24. Kampkotter A, Volkmann TE, de Castro SH, Leiers B, Klotz LO, et al. (2003) Functional analysis of the glutathione S-transferase 3 from Onchocerca volvulus (Ov-GST-3): A parasite GST confers increased resistance to oxidative stress in Caenorhabditis elegans. J Mol Biol 325: 25–37.
- 25. Massey HC, Bhopale MK, Li XS, Castelletto M, Lok JB (2006) The fork head transcription factor FKTF-1b from Strongyloides stercoralis restores DAF-16 developmental function to mutant Caenorhabditis elegans. Int J Parasitol 36: 347–352.
- 26. Crook M, Grant K, Grant WN (2010) Failure of Parastrongyloides trichosuri daf-7 to complement a Caenorhabditis elegans daf-7 (e1372) mutant: implications for the evolution of parasitism. Int J Parasitol 40: 1675–1683.
- 27. Beech RN, Wolstenholme AJ, Neveu C, Dent JA (2010) Nematode parasite genes: what's in a name? Trends Parasitol 26: 334–340.
- 28. Welz C, Kruger N, Schniederjans M, Miltsch SM, Krucken J, et al. (2011) SLO-1-channels of parasitic nematodes reconstitute locomotor behaviour and emodepside sensitivity in Caenorhabditis elegans slo-1 loss of function mutants. PLoS Pathogens 7: e1001330.
- 29. Yates DM, Portillo V, Wolstenholme AJ (2003) The avermectin receptors of Haemonchus contortus and Caenorhabditis elegans. Int J Parasitol 33: 1183–1193.
- 30. Jagannathan S, Laughton DL, Critten CL, Skinner TM, Horoszok L, et al. (1999) Ligand-gated chloride channel subunits encoded by the Haemonchus contortus and Ascaris suum orthologues of the Caenorhabditis elegans gbr-2 (avr-14) gene. Mol Biochem Parasitol 103: 129–140.
- 31. Laughton DL, Lunt GG, Wolstenholme AJ (1997) Alternative splicing of a Caenorhabditis elegans gene produces two novel inhibitory amino acid receptor subunits with identical ligand-binding domains but different ion channels. Gene 201: 119–125.
- 32. Williamson SM, Walsh TK, Wolstenholme AJ (2007) The cys-loop ligand-gated ion channel gene family of Brugia malayi and Trichinella spiralis: a comparison with Caenorhabditis elegans. Invert Neurosci 7: 219–226.
- 33. Cook A, Aptel N, Portillo V, Siney E, Sihota R, et al. (2006) Caenorhabditis elegans ivermectin receptors regulate locomotor behaviour and are functional orthologues of Haemonchus contortus receptors. Mol Biochem Parasitol 147: 118–125.
- 34. Dent JA, Smith MM, Vassilatis DK, Avery L (2000) The genetics of ivermectin resistance in Caenorhabditis elegans. Proc Nat'l Acad Sci USA 97: 2674–2679.
- 35. Buckingham SD, Sattelle DB (2009) Fast, automated measurement of nematode swimming (thrashing) without morphometry. Bmc Neuroscience 10: 84.
- 36. Cully DF, Vassilatis DK, Liu KK, Paress P, Van der Ploeg LHT, et al. (1994) Cloning of an avermectin-sensitive glutamate-gated chloride channel from Caenorhabditis elegans. Nature 371: 707–711.
- 37. Laughton DL, Lunt GG, Wolstenholme AJ (1997) Reporter gene constructs suggest the Caenorhabditis elegans avermectin receptor β-subunit is expressed solely in the pharynx. J Exp Biol 200: 1509–1514.
- 38. Pemberton DJ, Franks CJ, Walker RJ, Holden-Dye L (2001) Characterization of glutamate-gated chloride channels in the pharynx of wild-type and mutant Caenorhabditis elegans delineates the role of the subunit GluClα2 in the function of the native receptor. Mol Pharmacol 59: 1037–1043.
- 39. Portillo V, Jagannathan S, Wolstenholme AJ (2003) Distribution of glutamate-gated chloride channel subunits in the parasitic nematode Haemonchus contortus. J Comp Neurol 462: 213–222.
- 40. Cheeseman CL, Delany NS, Woods DJ, Wolstenholme AJ (2001) High-affinity ivermectin binding to recombinant subunits of the Haemonchus contortus glutamate-gated chloride channel. Mol Biochem Parasitol 114: 161–168.
- 41. McCavera S, Walsh TK, Wolstenholme AJ (2007) Nematode ligand-gated chloride channels: an appraisal of their involvement in macrocyclic lactone resistance and prospects for developing molecular markers. Parasitology 134: 1111–1121.
- 42. Blaxter ML, De Ley P, Garey JR, Liu LX, Scheldeman P, et al. (1998) A molecular evolution framework for the phylum Nematoda. Nature 392: 71–75.
- 43. McCavera S, Rogers AT, Yates DM, Woods DJ, Wolstenholme AJ (2009) An ivermectin-sensitive glutamate-gated chloride channel from the parasitic nematode, Haemonchus contortus. Mol Pharmacol 75: 1347–1355.
- 44. Njue AI, Hayashi J, Kinne L, Feng X-P, Prichard RK (2004) Mutations in the extracellular domain of glutamate-gated chloride channel α3 and β subunits from ivermectin-resistant Cooperia oncophora affect agonist sensitivity. J Neurochem 89: 1137–1147.
- 45. Lynagh T, Lynch JW (2010) A glycine residue essential for high ivermectin sensitivity in Cys-loop ion channel receptors. Int J Parasitol 40: 1477–1481.
- 46. Hibbs RE, Gouaux E (2011) Principles of activation and permeation in an anion-selective Cys-loop receptor. Nature 474: 54–60.
- 47. Fire A, Harrison SW, Dixon D (1990) A modular set of lacz fusion vectors for studying gene-expression in Caenorhabditis elegans. Gene 93: 189–198.
- 48. Dent JA, Davis MW, Avery L (1997) avr-15 encodes a chloride channel subunit that mediates inhibitory glutamatergic neurotransmission and ivermectin sensitivity in Caenorhabditis elegans. EMBO J 16: 5867–5879.
- 49. Vassilatis DK, Arena JP, Plasterk RHA, Wilkinson H, Schaeffer JM, et al. (1997) Genetic and biochemical evidence for a novel avermectin sensitive chloride channel in C. elegans; isolation and characterisation. J Biol Chem 272: 33167–33174.
- 50. Horoszok L, Raymond V, Sattelle DB, Wolstenholme AJ (2001) GLC-3: a novel fipronil and BIDN-sensitive, but picrotoxinin-insensitive, L-glutamate-gated chloride channel subunit from Caenorhabditis elegans. Brit J Pharmacol 132: 1247–1254.
- 51. Cully DF, Wilkinson H, Vassilatis DK (1996) Molecular biology and electrophysiology of glutamate-gated chloride channels of invertebrates. Parasitology 113: S191–S200.
- 52. Forrester SG, Beech RN, Prichard RK (2004) Agonist enhancement of macrocyclic lactone activity at a glutamate-gated chloride channel subunit from Haemonchus contortus. Biochem Pharmacol 67: 1019–1024.