We have previously described a new family of mutant adenoviruses carrying different combinations of attB/attP sequences from bacteriophage PhiC31 flanking the Ad5 packaging domain. These novel helper viruses have a significantly delayed viral life cycle and a severe packaging impairment, regardless of the presence of PhiC31 recombinase. Their infectious viral titers are significantly lower (100–1000 fold) than those of control adenovirus at 36 hours post-infection, but allow for efficient packaging of helper-dependent adenovirus. In the present work, we have analyzed which steps of the adenovirus life cycle are altered in attB-helper adenoviruses and investigated whether these viruses can provide the necessary viral proteins in trans. The entry of attB-adenoviral genomes into the cell nucleus early at early timepoints post-infection was not impaired and viral protein expression levels were found to be similar to those of control adenovirus. However, electron microscopy and capsid protein composition analyses revealed that attB-adenoviruses remain at an intermediate state of maturation 36 hours post-infection in comparison to control adenovirus which were fully mature and infective at this time point. Therefore, an additional 20–24 hours were found to be required for the appearance of mature attB-adenovirus. Interestingly, attB-adenovirus assembly and infectivity was restored by inserting a second packaging signal close to the right-end ITR, thus discarding the possibility that the attB-adenovirus genome was retained in a nuclear compartment deleterious for virus assembly. The present study may have substantive implications for helper-dependent adenovirus technology since helper attB-adenovirus allows for preferential packaging of helper-dependent adenovirus genomes.
Citation: Alba R, Cots D, Ostapchuk P, Bosch A, Hearing P, Chillon M (2011) Altering the Ad5 Packaging Domain Affects the Maturation of the Ad Particles. PLoS ONE 6(5): e19564. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0019564
Editor: David Harrich, Queensland Institute of Medical Research, Australia
Received: November 5, 2010; Accepted: April 11, 2011; Published: May 18, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Alba et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by Instituto Salud Carlos III (PI081162)(MC); Agència de Gestió d'Ajuts Universitaris i de Recerca (SGR-2009-1300)(MC); the Association Française contre les Myopathies (AFM#12277) (MC); BrainCAV an EC-FP7 project (FP7-222992)(AB); CAV-4-MPS an E-Rare project (ISCIII PS09/02674)(AB); and NIH AI041636 (PH). RA was a recipient of a FI-Generalitat fellowship #2003-0367. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Adenovirus (Ad) is one of the most studied vectors in gene therapy and the most widely used vector in human clinical trials (http://www.wiley.co.uk/genmed/clinical). Helper-Dependent Ad (HD-Ad) alternatively referred to as Gutted, Gutless or High Capacity Ad, are promising vectors for gene delivery. The lack of any viral coding region in these vectors allows prolonged transgene expression due to a minimization of cellular immune responses , , . In addition, they are able to incorporate genes up to 36 Kb in size. A helper virus is required in order to produce HD-Ad to provide all viral proteins in trans. Nevertheless, the production of infectious helper virus using this system must be inhibited. The use of recombinases to specifically excise the packaging domain (ψ) in the helper Ad genome represented an important advancement in HD-Ad production technology , . At present, the most successful HD-Ad production system is based on excision of ψ from the helper virus genome mediated by Cre recombinase in combination with the physical separation of helper and HD-Ad virions by ultracentrifugation. Using this optimized system, levels of helper Ad contamination can, at best, be reduced to 0.1% 0.01%  (routinely about 1% -0.1%), the main limitation being the incomplete excision of ψ due to relatively low levels of Cre in adenovirus producing cells . Of note, alternative packaging domain excision-based methods using recombinases such as FLPe has not resolved this issue , .
To address the limitations of the existing systems, we had previously reported a non-excision method based on the differential packaging efficiency between helper Ad and HD-Ad genomes mediated by the attB sequence of bacteriophage PhiC31 inserted between the inverted terminal repeat (ITR) and the packaging domain in the helper Ad genome . The helper Ad packaging process is impaired 36 hours post-infection (hpi) rendering 100–1000 times lower attB-Ad titers due to a significant delay in the viral life cycle. This delay is extended up to 56–60 hpi. Interestingly, attB-FC31 technology is not dependent on the action of recombinases and, therefore, the generation of new recombinase-based cell lines can be avoided.
Ad has a strictly regulated infection cycle where multiple viral and cellular proteins interact to complete the viral replication program to generate infectious virus particles. In vitro, initiation of infection for Ad5 typically occurs when the fiber knob binds to the coxsackie and adenovirus receptor (CAR) in the cell membrane (or other receptors depending on the Ad5 protein  or the Ad serotype ), and penton base binds to alphavbeta3 or aλπηαvbeta5 integrins leading to clathrin-mediated endocytosis . After internalization, Ad5 escapes from the endosome following pH-acidification leading to viral capsid disassembly. Adenovirus particles traffick through the cell along the microtubule network  and reach the nucleus through nuclear pores . Finally, adenovirus expresses the proteins required for viral genome replication and subsequent processes of the viral life cycle. Of note, genome replication and capsid assembling events occur in different nuclear compartments .
Packaging of the adenoviral genome is a complex process where different viral proteins, (e.g. L1-52/55K, IVa2 and L4-22K), interact with ψ to encapsidate the viral genome in a polar process to form a mature viral particle . Interestingly, the packaging domain can be located at either end of the viral genome allowing for viral genome packaging. The distance of ψ from the 5′ or 3′ ends of the genome is crucial for optimal packaging activity, although some flexibility in its location is tolerated. For example, when the distance between the ITR and ψ is 655 nucleotides or more, virus viability is severely compromised. However, when the distance between the ITR and ψ is increased up to 271 nucleotides, fully viable viruses are produced . During the Ad assembly process, the density of the viral particle varies from 1.29 to 1.35 g/cc which appears to reflect the insertion of viral DNA into an empty capsid, the subsequent packaging process, followed by final virion maturation . The Ad protease, also called adenain, is transported into the capsid and mediates the final steps of mature particle formation via the cleavage of a number of virion proteins including pIIIa, pVI, pVII, pVIII, pTP, X and L1-52/55K .
For final application of attB-helper adenoviruses in HD-Ad production, an extensive characterization of these vectors is required. Here, we have investigated which processes of the attB-helper Ad viral life cycle are affected.
Adenovirus generation, production and purification
Ad5/attP, Ad5/RFP, Ad5/βgal and attB-helper Ads (Ad5/FC31.1 or Ad5/FC31.2) were produced at the Vector Production Unit in the Center of Animal Biotechnology and Gene Therapy at the Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona (Bellaterra, Spain) as previously described . Briefly, PacI-linearized plasmids were transfected into HEK293 cells (ATCC, CRL-1573) and virus recovered 8–10 days post-transfection. Then, viruses were amplified through successive 56–60 hour infection cycles until a total of 4×108 HEK293 cells were infected. Ad5/FC31.1[ψ] was generated using Stow's method , by cotransfecting PacI-linearized pAd5/FC31.1 plasmid and in340 virus complete genome (with the exception of the left terminus). Plaques were isolated and different clones were amplified to generate Ad5/FC31.1[ψ] as previously described. Viral mutant Ad5/ts369 was produced in HEK293 cells grown at 32.5°C. Viruses were purified using two consecutive CsCl gradients (a step gradient followed by an equilibrium gradient ) followed by elution on a Sephadex PD-10 desalting column (Amersham Biosciences, Uppsala, Sweden). For attB-helper Ads, both, mature and immature particles from the first gradient were purified in the second cesium chloride gradient. Final purified viral stocks were titered by determining their concentration (particles/ml) by optical density at 260 nm (1 OD260 unit = 1×1012 particles/ml), and their infectivity (infectious units/ml) was measured by endpoint dilution assay. Briefly, end-point dilution assays were performed in triplicate by infecting 293 cells with serially diluted vectors, and then counting the number of transgene (GFP, RFP or βgal) expressing cells. Viral titers ranged between 0.7×1010 to 3×1010 IU/ml with an average ratio of physical particles to infectious units of 40∶1.
Viral production assay
HEK-293 cells were infected with control Ad and attB-helper Ad at 5 IU/cell in a 6-well format. Fresh DMEM medium was added 6 hpi. Pellet and supernatant were harvested at 36 and 56 hpi and three rounds of freeze/thawing performed to liberate viral particles. Finally, infectious titer was calculated at each time point by end-point dilution assay in three independent analysis.
Southern Blot analysis of viral genomes
High molecular weight DNA was extracted following Hirt's Method . For packaged genomes, DNA was extracted from 10 µl of purified virus or from 200 µl of crude viral lysate. Fourteen µl of 10% SDS, 6 µl of 0.5 M EDTA and 40 µl of 20 mg/mL proteinase K (Roche,) were added. Samples were incubated for 3 hours at 55°C and later heated for 5 min at 95°C to liberate viral genomes. Samples were then diluted to 200 µl with deionized water and 100 µl of 7.5 M ammonium acetate added. Viral DNA was extracted using 300 µl of Phenol/CHCl3/isoamyl alcohol (25∶24∶1) and absolute ethanol, then precipitated by washing twice with ethanol 70%. Pellets were then dissolved in 50 µl of sterile deionized water. SpeI-digested viral genomes were separated by gel electrophoresis, and then incubated in: a) 200 mM HCl (15 min); b) 5 N NaOH, 1.5 M NaCl (45 min); c) 20× SSC buffer (NaCl 3 M, Sodium Citrate 0.3 M pH = 7.4) (45 min). DNA was transferred to a positively-charged membrane (Roche Diagnostics Corp, Indianapolis) in 10× SSC buffer for 18 hours, fixed via exposure to UV light with a UV-stratalinker 1800 (Stratagene, La Jolla, CA) and detected using Alkphos Direct Labelling kit (Amersham Biosciesces) according to manufacturer's instructions.
Viral replication assay
Both Ad5/attP and Ad5/FC31.1 were used to infect HEK-293 cells at 5 IU/cell in a 6 well plate for 6 hours, in two independent experiments. Cell were washed and fresh medium added. Cell pellets/supernatants were recovered at 24, 28, 32 and 36 hpi. Viral DNA was extracted from one tenth of the crude lysate and transferred to a Hybond-XL membrane (Amershan Biosciences) and detected using a GFP probe (at concentrations ranging from 50 to 0.01 ng). The GFP probe was obtained by isolating a 1597 bp product corresponding to the GFP expression cassette of pKS/RSV (kindly provided by Eric Kremer, Montpellier, France) using a SpeI+SalI restriction digest. The product was then labelled with AlkPhos Direct Labeling Kit and used to probe viral DNA using the DP-Star detection kit according to the manufacturer's instructions. In parallel, crude lysates from infected cells were analyzed in triplicate by end-point dilution assay to calculate the number of IU/cell at each time point.
HEK-293 cells were infected with Ad5/attP, Ad5/FC31.1 and Ad5/FC31.2 (all carrying a GFP cassette) or Ad5/βgal Ad (carrying a βgal cassette) in a 6-well plate at 5 IU/cell for single infection. For co-infection experiments attB/attP-modified Ads (Ad5/attP, Ad5/FC31.1 and Ad5/FC31.2) were co-infected with control Ad5/βgal at 5 IU/cell per virus. At 36 hpi, viruses were harvested and further titered by end-point dilution assay using fluorescence microscope and X-gal staining for GFP or βγαλ ϖιρυσεσ ρespectively.
4×106 HEK293 cells were infected (n = 5) with different control and helper Ad (MOI = 2). Infected cells were recovered at 12, 24, 30 and 36 hpi. Medium was recovered and saline buffer was added to harvest the cells. After centrifugation, cells were first resuspended in PBS buffer (1×) and then in 4% paraformaldehyde buffer. Finally, GFP expression by infected cells was analyzed by flow cytometry at Servei de Citometria of IBB-UAB (Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona).
Electron Microscopy assay
Viral particles were analyzed by the Uranyl Acetate method as previously described . The samples were viewed with a FEI Tecnai 12 BioTwinG2 transmission electron microscope at 80 kV and the digital images were obtained with an AMT XR-60 CCD Digital Camera System. Services were provided by the TEM Facility, Central Microscopy Imaging Center at Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, New York, USA.
Silver Stain SDS-PAGE protein analysis
Viral proteins from virions purified by CsCl equilibrium gradient centrifugation were separated by electrophoresis on a SDS-10% polyacrylamide gel and silver stained as previously described . Gels of viral proteins were incubated with 50% methanol/10% acetic acid followed by 10% methanol/5% acetic acid incubation, dithiothreitol, and 12 mM silver nitrate. Signal was developed by incubation in 2% potassium carbonate containing 0.044% formaldehyde, and development stopped by incubation in 1% acetic acid. Finally, the gel was washed with distilled water.
Western Blot and immunodetection analysis
Viral proteins were separated by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and transferred to a Hybond-P membrane (Amersham-Pharmacia) by standard methods, in at least two independent experiments. Membranes were probed with antibodies directed against penton base and hexon (generous gifts of Carl Anderson, Brookhaven National laboratory, USA), L1-52/55K , pVII/VII  and β-actin (ref. a2066, Sigma). Proteins were visualized using AlkPhos-coupled secondary antibody (Zymed) and a fluorescent substrate (AttoPhos Substrate, Promega). Signals were analyzed using a phosphorimager (Molecular Dynamics Storm 860).
Nuclear extracts prepared from HEK293 and DKzeo cells  were in HEPES 20 mM at pH 7.5, glycerol 20%, NaCl 450 mM MgCl2 1.5 mM, EDTA 0.2 mM in sterile deionized water and protease inhibitors, following the protocol described by Zhang et al , and stored at −80°C. Protein extracts were quantified using BCA following the manufacturer's protocol (Pierce). Three µg of nuclear extract were incubated for 30 minutes at 37°C with 2.6 µl 5× Binding buffer (LightShift Chemiluminescent EMSA Kit, 20148X, Pierce), 1 µl poly-deoxyinosic-deoxycytidylic, and 1 µl of biotin-labeled wild type-attB or mutant attB. The samples were then separated in a non-denaturing polyacrylamide gel for 90 minutes at 120 V, and transferred to a positively charged membrane (Roche Diagnostics Corp, Indianapolis,). Subsequently the membrane was incubated with a peroxidase-streptavidin conjugate, followed by washing and incubation with luminol (PIERCE) following the protocol provided by the manufacturer. To confirm observations, the experiment was repeated in three independent analysis. attBwt sequence (wild type): 5′ACCGGTCCGCGGTGCGGGTGC CAGGGCGTGCCCTTGGGCTCCCCGGGCGCGTACTCCAC3′. attB* sequence (mutant): 5′ACCGGTGGGCACGCGCGCACCTGGCGCACCGCGTCGGCGCACCTGCGCACCTG GCACCA3′.
attB/attP sequences flanking the packaging signal do not affect the entry of the adenoviral genome into the nucleus
The recombinant viruses used in this study include viruses with RFP (Ad5/RFP) or GFP (Ad5/attP, Ad5/FC31.1, Ad5/FC31.2) expression cassettes in place of the E1 region. Ad5/attP contains a PhiC31 attP site located to the right of the GFP gene. Ad5/FC31.1 and Ad/FC31.2 contain the same attP insertion as well as an additional PhiC31 attB site inserted to the left of the Ad5 packaging domain and differ only by the additional insertion of a 65-bp spacer between attB and ψ in Ad5/FC31.2 (Fig. 1). We previously reported that the attB insertion, but not the attP insertion, reduced viral DNA packaging, delayed the production of infectious virus and decreased overall infectious virus yield . Here, we characterize this defect in further detail. Entry of attB-Ad genomes (adenovirus vectors carrying the attB sequence 5′ of the packaging signal) into the nucleus was compared to control first generation Ad5/RFP by infecting HEK293 cells at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 5 infectious units per cell (Figure 2A). Viral genomes were isolated by Hirt's method from the nucleus at 6 hpi. Southern blot densitometry showed that both viral genomes of control and attB-Ad vectors reached the nucleus at similar levels, indicating that viral proteins involved in virion trafficking must be present and fully active in attB-Ad.
Viral genomes schemes are not to scale.
(A) Equal amounts (30 µg) of high molecular weight DNA were loaded. Probe used contains the first 194 nt of adenovirus genome. (B) Viral genome replication of Ad5/attP and attB-Ad. Viral DNA produced at 24, 28, 32 and 36 hpi in HEK-293 cells (MOI = 5) were quantified by Dot-Blot in triplicate and titers measured in nanograms (ng) of DNA. (C) Virus yield of Ad5/attP and attB-Ad. Infectivities of vectors were analyzed in triplicate, and further quantified in IU/cell (in bars) by fluorescent microscopy after a secondary infection in HEK-293 cells. Statistics were performed with natural log values using one way ANOVA (** p<0,01; *** p<0,001).
Viral DNA replication and protein production of attB-adenovirus are not affected
To analyze whether viral DNA replication was altered, viral genome replication was quantified at 24, 28, 32 and 36 hours post infection (hpi) and correlated with infectious virus yields at the same time points. HEK-293 cells were infected with attB-Ad and Ad5/attP (control Ad) at a MOI of 5, and viral DNAs purified and quantified by dot-blot analysis. We found that for both attB-Ads, the kinetics and level of genome replication were similar to Ad5/attP at all time points (Ad5/FC31.1, Figures 2B and 2C; Ad5/FC31.2, data not shown). However, the amount of infectious attB-Ad (in IU/cell) was markedly reduced (>99%) at all times compared to control Ad, and statistically significant (p<0.01 at 24, 28 and 36 hpi; and p<0.001 at 32 hpi). These results showed that the delayed life cycle of attB-Ads must be due to alterations in subsequent steps to replication. Moreover, since Ad5/FC31.1 and Ad5/FC31.2 vectors are identical (except for an extra 65-bp spacer between attB and ψ in Ad5/FC31.2) and have a similarly delayed viral life cycle (Reference 8, Figure 3), as well as similar viral infectivity and DNA replication, they were used interchangeably throughout the experiments.
HEK-293 cells were infected with Ad5/βgal, Ad5/attP or attB-Ad at MOI of 5, and samples were analyzed at 24, 30 and 36 hpi. Non-viral marker GFP protein was quantified by measuring relative mean fluorescence intensity per cell (RFU/cell) by Flow Cytometry (A). Late viral hexon protein was detected from protein extracts by Western Blot analysis at 24 hpi (B). Equal amount of proteins were loaded and β-actin protein was used as control. Mock are uninfected HEK-293 cells.
In addition to viral replication, the levels of expression of several viral proteins from the Ad5/βgal, Ad5/attP or attB-Ad genomes were also analyzed. Both the GFP-marker protein (driven by a constitutive promoter and analyzed at 24, 30 and 36 hpi; Figure 3A) and Ad5 hexon protein (driven by the endogenous adenoviral MLP promoter and analyzed at 24 hpi; Figure 3B) were expressed at similar levels from the attB-Ads compared to the control Ads. These results support our notion that the delayed maturation of attB-Ad is due to effects on life cycle steps following viral genome replication.
Adenovirus proteins provided in trans do not normalize the viral life cycle of attB-Ad vectors
Previous results showed that attB-Ads could rescue HD-Ad vectors  and are in agreement with results here suggesting that the defect in attB-Ads is a cis-acting effect. We examined this issue by testing whether the delay in the accumulation of infectious attB-Ad could be rescued by co-infection with a control adenovirus. attB-Ads and Ad5/attP (carrying a GFP cassette) were co-infected with a first generation adenovirus (Ad5/βgal) and analyzed at 36 hpi. As expected, single infections of control Ad5/attP or control Ad5/βgal (MOI of 5) generated titers 100–200-fold higher than those from attB-Ad vectors (Figure 4). Similarly, in co-infection experiments using Ad5/βgal (MOI of 5) either with attB-Ad (MOI of 5) or with control Ad5/attP (MOI of 5), only modest changes in viral titers (either of Ad5/βgal, Ad5/attP or attB-Ad) compared to the single virus infection were observed. These data show that the delay in accumulation of infectious attB-Ad cannot be rescued (or rescued only in a minor fraction) to levels of control Ad5/attP (p<0.05 for both attB-Ad vectors) by the presence of viral proteins provided in trans by an Ad vector with a normal life cycle.
HEK-293 cells were infected at 5 IU/cell for each adenovirus vector (“single infection”), or co-infected with Ad5/βgal and different attB/attP-containing vectors (5 IU/cell each vector). (a) Refers to Ad5/βgal coinfected with Ad5/attP; (b) to Ad5/βgal coinfected with Ad5/FC31.1; and (c) to Ad5/βgal coinfected with Ad5/FC31.2. At 36 hpi, virus were harvested and further titered by end-point dilution and analyzed in triplicate by βgal or GFP expression in two independent experiments. Asterisks refers to statistical significance: * p<0,05; ** p<0,01.
Altered viral capsid formation of attB-Ad vectors at 36 hpi
Since the delay in the accumulation of mature attB-Ad was independent of replication and expression of the structural proteins, we examined the integrity and formation of adenoviral capsids by electron microscopy (Figure 5). As controls, Ad5/RFP and Ad5/ts369 were analyzed at 36 hpi and attB-virus was analyzed at 36 and 56 hpi. Ad5/ts369 is an L1-52/55K temperature-sensitive mutant virus that is blocked at an intermediate stage when grown at the non-permissive temperature of 39.5°C . It accumulates light intermediate particles and was used as a control for intermediate virus assembly. Interestingly, at 36 hpi attB-Ad appeared to be in an intermediate state of assembly which resembled Ad5/ts369 grown at the non-permissive temperature. Protein aggregates were observed along with relatively few virus-like particles. The particles appeared to lack DNA since they accumulated uranyl acetate in the interiors. However, at 56 hpi, most attB-Ad capsids appeared mature and resembled those observed for control Ad5/RFP at 36 hpi (Figure 5).
Maturation of attB-Ad particles is severely impaired at 36 hpi
Inefficient virus maturation was also evident during the purification process on cesium choride gradients. Ad5/FC31.2 (36 hpi) produced mainly immature particles compared to control Ad5/RFP (36 hpi) or Ad5/FC31.2 at 56 hpi (Figure 6A). Results of a second isopycnic cesium chloride gradient centrifugation of Ad5/FC31.2 (56 hpi) revealed the presence of at least three immature intermediates of maturation, termed Band 1, Band 2 and Band 3, (Figure 6B) which were individually isolated for further characterization. Of note, density of the purified Ad5/FC31.2 (36 hpi) particles was significantly lower with respect to Ad5/RFP (36 hpi) and Ad5/FC31.2 (56 hpi) particles densities (Figure 6C).
Shown are images for Ad5/RFP and Ad5/FC31.2 at 56 hpi and Ad5/FC31.2 at 36 hpi. Arrows indicate (a) mature particles, and (b) immature particles. (B) Second cesium chloride gradient for Ad5/FC31.2 at 56 hpi, 1, 2 and 3 indicates three low density bands. (C) Density in (g/cm3) of purified particles of Ad5/RFP, Ad5/ts369, Ad5/FC31.2 at 36 hpi and Ad5/FC31.2 at 56 hpi. (D) Silver stained polyacrylamide gel of CsCl purified particles of Ad5/ts369 and Ad5/RFP at 36 hpi. and attB-Ad at 36 and 56 hpi. Asterisks refers to statistical significance: * p<0,05; ** p<0,01.
The virus maturation process was analyzed in detail by silver staining of viral proteins of purified particles of Ad5/RFP (36 hpi), Ad5/ts369 (36 hpi) grown at the nonpermissive temperature and attB-Ad (36 and 56 hpi) (Figure 6D). The protein banding pattern of attB-Ad at 36 hpi was similar to that of the Ad5/ts369 light intermediate particle protein pattern. Both showed the presence of precursor proteins including pVI, pVIII and 50K. In contrast, at 56 hpi attB-Ad presented a similar protein pattern to Ad5/RFP (e.g., the loss of the 50K protein). However, not all attB-Ad particles were fully mature since pVI and pVIII precursors were still detected.
L1-52/55K has been shown to be cleaved during the assembly process; likely by adenain . Intermediate and empty particles contain intact L1-52/55K as well as cleaved products of approximately 40 KDa, while the mature virus lacks intact L1-52/55K and is markedly reduced for the 40K product. Western blot analysis for L1 52/55K of Ad/RFP, Adt5/ts369 and attB-Ad5 indicated that at 36 hpi, particles of Ad/RFP did not contain intact L1-52/55K (although the 40K cleavage products were observed); while light intermediate particles of Ad5/ts369 grown at the non-permissive temperature contained both the intact and cleaved product(s) of L1-52/55K (Figure 7A). However, at 36 hpi attB-Ad produced very low levels of L1-52/55K, suggesting that only few capsids had incorporated this protein. At 56 hpi, the level of cleaved L1-52/55K proteins increased, though a significant percentage remained uncleaved (54%) indicating that part of the attB-Ad viral population was still at an intermediate step of maturation. Analysis of pVII showed that at 36 hpi attB-particles had similar levels of precursor and mature protein VII (60% to 40%, respectively), while at 56 hpi protein VII was mature (Figure 7B). As expected, protein VII was unprocessed in the immature particles isolated from Band 2 and 3 (Figure 6B) and not present in Band 1, indicating that these putative intermediates corresponded to capsids at the very early steps of maturation (Figure S1). In addition, material from these bands did not contain viral DNA and were not infectious.
(A) Western Blot analysis of penton base (control for protein content) and L1-52/55K viral proteins from CsCl gradients of Ad5/RFP and Ad5/ts369 at 36 hpi and attB-Ad at 36 and 56 hpi (cleaved and uncleaved L1-52/55K protein are indicated by arrows). Densitometric analysis of the Western-blot for the L1-52/55K cleaved and uncleaved proteins after normalization to penton base. (B) Western blot analysis of adenoviral protein pVII from CsCl gradients of Ad5/RFP at 36 hpi and attB-Ad at 36 and 56 hpi.
A second packaging signal cloned at 3′-ITR normalizes infectivity levels of attB-Ad
To determine whether the defect in virus assembly observed with attB-Ad was due to a dominant effect mediated by the attB sequence we generated a new Ad construct named Ad5/FC31.1[ψ] with a second packaging domain inserted at the right-end of the genome (Figure 1). Results of infections showed that at 36 hpi similar levels of infectious viral particles of Ad5/FC31.1[ψ] as compared to the control Ad (Ad5/βgal) were obtained (Figure 8) indicating that Ad5/FC31.1[ψ] capsids were fully matured at that time. This result show Ad5/FC31.1[ψ] viral genomes allow for normal genome replication and viral protein expression at 36 hpi, suggesting that the delayed attB-helper genome life cycle is not due to irreversible trapping in a nuclear compartment that inhibits virus assembly.
Viral production in IU/cell of Ad5/FC31.1, Ad5/FC31.1[ψ] and Ad5/βgal at 36 hpi. in HEK293 cells. Titering was performed in triplicate in HEK-293 cells. Asterisks refers to statistical significance: ** p<0,01; *** p<0,001; NS = not significant).
A nuclear protein interacts with the attB sequence in vitro
Taken together the results, with Ad-helper vectors with the attB sequence 5′ of the packaging signal having a delayed viral cycle leads to the hypothesis that a cellular factor could be interacting with the attB sequence, impairing the formation of the packaging complex with ψ. In order to test this hypothesis an electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) was performed to detect specific interactions mediated by nuclear protein(s). In addition to the wild type attB sequence, we also tested a mutant attB sequence encoding the same nucleotide composition as the wild type attB but in a different order. Results clearly show that in vitro, the wild type attB sequence (but not the mutant attB) interacts with a nuclear protein from HEK293 cells (Figure 9). In order to test whether this interaction was specific for the HEK293 cell line, we also tested the interaction between the attB sequence and protein extracts from canine DKZeo cells. The band-shift also observed in DKzeo cells (data not shown), indicating that this interaction was not specific for HEK293 cells. The band-shift in HEK-293 cells appeared to be more intense than in DKzeo cells, suggesting different levels of expression for this nuclear factor between both cell types.
Competitor: HEK293 cell nuclear extracts incubated with the attBwt sequence together with poly-dIdC and unlabeled attBwt as specific competitor. NNE: attBwt sequence without nuclear extracts. attBwt: Nuclear extracts from HEK293 cells incubated with a wild type attB sequence and poly-dIdC. attB*: Nuclear extracts from HEK293 cells incubated with a mutant attB sequence and poly-dIdC.
Helper-dependent adenovirus vectors are important candidates for gene therapy due to their reduced capacity to induce cellular immune responses and their ability to direct stable transgene expression of up to 2 years . Despite these advantages, their production presents two important problems: (1) contamination with helper Ad and (2) low titer preparations. During the last decade, optimization of the Cre-loxP system has been done by combining the excision of ψ (using a Cre expressing cell line) with the physical separation of helper and HD-Ad virions by density in CsCl ultracentrifugation. This has improved the reduction of helper Ad contamination levels from 10% down to 0.1%-0,01% . Additional strategies for optimizin the excision of ψ mediated by Cre recombinase must consider the compromise required between recombination activity and cell toxicity, i.e. low Cre levels limit efficient excision of ψ, while high Cre levels become cytotoxic and affect proliferation of adenovirus producing Cre-cell lines . Moreover, the need for large amounts of HD-Ad vectors for clinical assays in human patients prevents the use of non-scalable downstream processes such as ultracentrifugation. Therefore, to improve production and purification of HD vectors beyond the limits of current systems, other strategies must be developed.
We have recently generated a new system based on preferential packaging of the HD-Ad genome compared to the helper Ad genome. We constructed a family of helper Adenovirus by flanking the packaging signal with PhiC31 attB/attP sites . At 36 hpi production yield of attB/attP Ads (in IU/cell) is significantly reduced (>99%). Surprisingly, though attB and attP sites are sequences recognized by FC31 recombinase, differential packaging takes place in the absence of recombinase indicating that mechanism(s) other than recombination are involved.
Here, we have analyzed the mechanism underlying the delayed viral cycle of attB-Ad by studying the steps in adenovirus particle generation. We have observed that attB-Ad can reach the cell nucleus at the same time (6 hpi) and at the same level (genome copies) as a control Ad (Ad5/RFP). Since at this time replication has not yet started, thus the observed viral genomes are derived from the incoming virus. This indicates that attB-Ad viral capsids allow appropiate cell trafficking and uncoating, and therefore viral capsid proteins (like adenain and pVII) must be fully active. When compared to control Ad5, viral DNA replication from attB-Ad and attP-Ad vectors is slighty reduced (between 0% and 50%, data not shown). However, this does not affect the kinetics and level of virus production since Ad5/attP behaves exactly as control Ad5. Moreover, quantification of viral DNA replication up to 36 hpi showed that although attB-Ad infectious titers were 2 to 3 logs lower than those for control attP-Ad, attB-Ad replicated to the same level as attP-Ad at all time points. Therefore, viral genome replication is not causing the delay in the attB-Ad viral life cycle.
Analysis of adenoviral gene expression showed that protein expression levels from attB-Ad were equivalent to controls (Ad5/attP or Ad5/βgal). Consistent with this result, coinfection of attB-adenoviral particles with Ad5/βgal, which does not show any delay in viral life cycle, did not rescue the delay in the attB-Ad5 life cycle. Furthermore, as previously shown, attB-Ad viruses function efficiently as helper virus for the production of HD-Ad vectors . Therefore, the cause of the delayed viral cycle must reside in the genome sequence or the viral genome structure of attB-Ad.
The delay in packaging and accumulation of infectious attB-Ad genomes was rescued by the incorporation of a packaging domain at the right end of the attB-Ad genome. Therefore, the cis-acting defect is recessive to the presence of a wild type packaging domain. This result indicates first, that the attB-helper genome is not irreversibly retained in a nuclear compartment inhibitory to virus assembly, and second, that packaging impairment was not caused by spontaneous and deleterious mutations in the attB-Ad genomes.
We have previously reported that less than 5% of the attB-Ad genomes are packaged at 36 hpi in coinfection experiments compared to control viral genomes . Furthermore, only a minimal fraction of the packaged attB-genomes were able to form infectious particles at 36 hpi . To test if differences in attB-Ad infectivity correlated with differences in capsid morphology, adenoviral capsids were analyzed by electron microscopy. As observed for the control Ad5/βgal at 36 hpi, the majority of attB-Ad vectors consisted of full capsids at 56 hpi. In contrast, at 36 hpi, attB-particles were present in an immature state consisting of protein aggregates and some empty particles; similar to that observed for the light assembly intermediate mutant Ad5/ts369 grown at the nonpermissive temperature. Since viral proteins provided by attB-Ad allow normal packaging of HD-Ad at 36 hpi  then, according to the classical theory of adenovirus assembly , pre-formed empty capsids should be also available for the packaging of attB-Ad genomes at this time. However, instead of empty capsids, electron microscopy images showed an accumulation of unstructured protein aggregates with few empty capsids. These results are suggestive of a modified theory; that is, that the packaging complex on the viral DNA acts as an initiator of the formation of a procapsid/DNA assemblage followed by the incorporation of the DNA into the procapsid. Since the attB-Ad infectious cycle is delayed without mutating any viral proteins of the packaging complex, these vectors could also be used to study basic aspects of adenovirus assembly.
The protein content of attB-Ad particles isolated at 36 and 56 hpi was examined. At 36 hpi attB-Ad presented a viral protein pattern similar to Ad5/ts369 at the restrictive temperature indicating an intermediate state of virus maturation. In contrast, the protein pattern of attB-Ad at 56 hpi was similar to control Ad5/RFP, though a band likely corresponding to pVI/pVIII precursors was also observed, suggesting that the viral life cycle of attB-Ad must be slightly longer than 56 hours. Detailed analysis of two key maturation proteins at 36 hpi showed low amounts of L1-52/55K (either cleaved or uncleaved), and that only ∼50% of pVII protein was cleaved, consistent with the formation of only a few attB-helper Ad capsids. However, at 56 hpi, almost all pVII protein was cleaved, while L1-52/55K levels in attB-Ad particles were much higher than at 36 hpi. Furthermore, an important proportion of L1-52/55K was still uncleaved, confirming once more that attB-Ad had not completed the maturation process at 56 hpi, and that this process may take closer to 60 hours, as observed from the analysis of their life cycle. Collectively, these results demonstrate that the insertion of an attB site between the Ad5 ITR and ψ hinders viral DNA packaging and consequently the virion maturation process.
This finding could reflect the altered spacing between ψ and the ITR, but there is considerable flexibility allowed in the location of the packaging signal relative to the genomic terminus, as demonstrated by Hearing and al. , so a spacing effect appears unlikely. Rather, results from the EMSA experiment suggest a mechanism by which the attB sequence interferes with virus assembly and could be related to the binding of a nuclear protein to this sequence. Due to the proximity of attB site to ψ, efficient interaction between packaging complex proteins and ψ would be affected by the binding of the unknown nuclear factor to attB. Indeed further analyses are required to identify the unknown nuclear factor.
In conclusion, we have demonstrated that the severe delay in the viral life cycle of attB-Ad helper virus is not caused by abnormal viral DNA replication nor by altered levels or availability of viral proteins. However, the packaging process is clearly impaired and it affects the timing of subsequent processes such as maturation of the Ad particles. Thus, at 36 hpi we observed protein aggregates and few unassembled capsids instead of fully matured particles. Only when production times were prolonged to 56 hours was it possible to detect a high percentage of mature and infectious attB-Ad virions. Therefore, these results may have important implications for HD-Ad vector technology since this is a novel method based on preferential packaging to produce infectious HD-Ad particles in the absence of helper Ad . Most importantly, it avoids the current limitations associated with standard methods based on recombination-mediated excision of the packaging signal, since it does not require physical removal of contaminating helper virions by ultracentrifugation, and allows the use of scalable downstream methods, such as HPLC purification. Finally, the impairment on genome packaging and capsid maturation processes also makes attB-Ad useful vectors for future studies to better understand the adenovirus life cycle.
Western blot analysis of adenoviral protein pVII from CsCl gradients. Ad5/RFP and Ad5/ts369 were harvested at 36 hpi. Ad5/FC31.2 was harvested at 56 hpi. Samples from Ad5/FC31.2 are the intermediate steps of maturation observed in figure 6B.
We would like to acknowledge Dr. Mercè Monfar, Dr. Maria de las Mercedes Segura, Dr. Stuart A. Nicklin, and Professsor Andrew H. Baker for critically reading the manuscript. We thank Carl Anderson and Dan Engel for the gift of antibodies. We thank Eric Kremer for providing pKS/RSVGFP plasmid. We also thank Susan Van Horn for her technical assistance with the electron microscopy provided by the TEM Facility, Central Microscopy Imaging Center at Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, New York, USA. We would also like to tnak Mary Anderson and Sofia Tsiropoulou for technical help, and the Vector Production Unit of CBATEG at the Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona.
Conceived and designed the experiments: RA PH MC. Performed the experiments: RA DC PO. Analyzed the data: RA AB PH MC. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: AB PH MC. Wrote the paper: RA MC.
- 1. Schiedner G, Morral N, Parks RJ, Wu Y, Koopmans SC, et al. (1998) Genomic DNA transfer with a high-capacity adenovirus vector results in improved in vivo gene expression and decreased toxicity. Nat Genet 18: 180–183.
- 2. Morsy MA, Gu M, Motzel S, Zhao J, Lin J, et al. (1998) An adenoviral vector deleted for all viral coding sequences results in enhanced safety and extended expression of a leptin transgene. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 95: 7866–7871.
- 3. Alba R, Bosch A, Chillon M (2005) Gutless adenovirus: last-generation adenovirus for gene therapy. Gene Ther 12: Suppl 1S18–27.
- 4. Parks RJ, Chen L, Anton M, Sankar U, Rudnicki MA, et al. (1996) A helper-dependent adenovirus vector system: removal of helper virus by Cre-mediated excision of the viral packaging signal. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 93: 13565–13570.
- 5. Hardy S, Kitamura M, Harris-Stansil T, Dai Y, Phipps ML (1997) Construction of adenovirus vectors through Cre-lox recombination. J Virol 71: 1842–1849.
- 6. Palmer D, Ng P (2003) Improved system for helper-dependent adenoviral vector production. Mol Ther 8: 846–852.
- 7. Ng P, Evelegh C, Cummings D, Graham FL (2002) Cre levels limit packaging signal excision efficiency in the Cre/loxP helper-dependent adenoviral vector system. J Virol 76: 4181–4189.
- 8. Ng P, Beauchamp C, Evelegh C, Parks R, Graham FL (2001) Development of a FLP/frt system for generating helper-dependent adenoviral vectors. Mol Ther 3: 809–815.
- 9. Umana P, Gerdes CA, Stone D, Davis JR, Ward D, et al. (2001) Efficient FLPe recombinase enables scalable production of helper-dependent adenoviral vectors with negligible helper-virus contamination. Nat Biotechnol 19: 582–585.
- 10. Alba R, Hearing P, Bosch A, Chillon M (2007) Differential amplification of adenovirus vectors by flanking the packaging signal with attB/attP-PhiC31 sequences: implications for helper-dependent adenovirus production. Virology 367: 51–58.
- 11. Waddington SN, McVey JH, Bhella D, Parker AL, Barker K, et al. (2008) Adenovirus serotype 5 hexon mediates liver gene transfer. Cell 132: 397–409.
- 12. Bergelson JM, Cunningham JA, Droguett G, Kurt-Jones EA, Krithivas A, et al. (1997) Isolation of a common receptor for Coxsackie B viruses and adenoviruses 2 and 5. Science 275: 1320–1323.
- 13. Meier O, Greber UF (2004) Adenovirus endocytosis. J Gene Med 6: Suppl 1S152–163.
- 14. Suomalainen M, Nakano MY, Keller S, Boucke K, Stidwill RP, et al. (1999) Microtubule-dependent plus- and minus end-directed motilities are competing processes for nuclear targeting of adenovirus. J Cell Biol 144: 657–672.
- 15. Chardonnet Y, Dales S (1970) Early events in the interaction of adenoviruses with HeLa cells. I. Penetration of type 5 and intracellular release of the DNA genome. Virology 40: 462–477.
- 16. Hasson TB, Ornelles DA, Shenk T (1992) Adenovirus L1 52- and 55-kilodalton proteins are present within assembling virions and colocalize with nuclear structures distinct from replication centers. J Virol 66: 6133–6142.
- 17. Ostapchuk P, Hearing P (2005) Control of adenovirus packaging. J Cell Biochem 96: 25–35.
- 18. Hearing P, Samulski RJ, Wishart WL, Shenk T (1987) Identification of a repeated sequence element required for efficient encapsidation of the adenovirus type 5 chromosome. J Virol 61: 2555–2558.
- 19. Weber JM (2003) Adenain, the adenovirus endoprotease (a review). Acta Microbiol Immunol Hung 50: 95–101.
- 20. Stow ND (1981) Cloning of a DNA fragment from the left-hand terminus of the adenovirus type 2 genome and its use in site-directed mutagenesis. J Virol 37: 171–180.
- 21. Palmer DJ, Ng P (2008) Methods for the production of helper-dependent adenoviral vectors. Methods Mol Biol 433: 33–53.
- 22. Hirt B (1967) Selective extraction of polyoma DNA from infected mouse cell cultures. J Mol Biol 26: 365–369.
- 23. Sandalon Z, Gnatenko DV, Bahou WF, Hearing P (2000) Adeno-associated virus (AAV) Rep protein enhances the generation of a recombinant mini-adenovirus (Ad) utilizing an Ad/AAV hybrid virus. J Virol 74: 10381–10389.
- 24. Sarnow P, Hearing P, Anderson CW, Reich N, Levine AJ (1982) Identification and characterization of an immunologically conserved adenovirus early region 11,000 Mr protein and its association with the nuclear matrix. J Mol Biol 162: 565–583.
- 25. Ostapchuk P, Yang J, Auffarth E, Hearing P (2005) Functional interaction of the adenovirus IVa2 protein with adenovirus type 5 packaging sequences. J Virol 79: 2831–2838.
- 26. Xue Y, Johnson JS, Ornelles DA, Lieberman J, Engel DA (2005) Adenovirus protein VII functions throughout early phase and interacts with cellular proteins SET and pp32. J Virol 79: 2474–2483.
- 27. Soudais C, Boutin S, Kremer EJ (2001) Characterization of cis-acting sequences involved in canine adenovirus packaging. Mol Ther 3: 631–640.
- 28. Zhang W, Imperiale MJ (2003) Requirement of the adenovirus IVa2 protein for virus assembly. J Virol 77: 3586–3594.
- 29. Hasson TB, Soloway PD, Ornelles DA, Doerfler W, Shenk T (1989) Adenovirus L1 52- and 55-kilodalton proteins are required for assembly of virions. J Virol 63: 3612–3621.
- 30. Morral N, O'Neal W, Rice K, Leland M, Kaplan J, et al. (1999) Administration of helper-dependent adenoviral vectors and sequential delivery of different vector serotype for long-term liver-directed gene transfer in baboons. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 96: 12816–12821.