Historical records suggest that multiple burial sites from the 14th–16th centuries in Venice, Italy, were used during the Black Death and subsequent plague epidemics.
High throughput, multiplexed real-time PCR detected DNA of seven highly transmissible pathogens in 173 dental pulp specimens collected from 46 graves. Bartonella quintana DNA was identified in five (2.9%) samples, including three from the 16th century and two from the 15th century, and Yersinia pestis DNA was detected in three (1.7%) samples, including two from the 14th century and one from the 16th century. Partial glpD gene sequencing indicated that the detected Y. pestis was the Orientalis biotype.
Citation: Tran T-N-N, Signoli M, Fozzati L, Aboudharam G, Raoult D, Drancourt M (2011) High Throughput, Multiplexed Pathogen Detection Authenticates Plague Waves in Medieval Venice, Italy. PLoS ONE 6(3): e16735. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0016735
Editor: Tara Smith, University of Iowa, United States of America
Received: October 19, 2010; Accepted: December 26, 2010; Published: March 10, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Tran et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: These authors have no support or funding to report.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The history of Venice, Italy is tightly linked to the ancient plague and particularly to the Second Pandemic, which originated in Europe with the Black Death in the mid-14th century. The commercial activity of the Venetian Republic facilitated trade and interactions with the Southern and Oriental regions of the Mediterranean Sea, where the plague was endemic. Starting in 1348, Venice suffered several plague epidemics, most notably the Black Death . Historical records indicate that a massive epidemic swept through the city during the 14th century , which is thought to have killed thousands of people and profoundly affected the history of this prosperous city. Following the initial wave, additional and more detrimental epidemics occurred in 1462, 1485, 1506, 1575–1577 and 1630–1632. In Venice, the number of deaths was first recorded during the 1575–1577 epidemic, with a mortality rate of 27.8%; the 1630–1632 epidemic had a mortality rate of 32.5% of the Venetian population , .
The cause of these disasters is a matter of debate, and it has not been universally agreed upon that these epidemics were due to Yersinia pestis . Alternative hypotheses including influenza , anthrax  and hemorrhagic fever  have been proposed. Using suicide PCR and a recently developed multiplex molecular approach to identify pathogens in ancient human remains , we demonstrate here that the Venetian epidemics were indeed plague outbreaks caused by the bacterial species Y. pestis.
During 2004 and 2005, the renovation of the buildings of Lazzaretto Vecchio in Venice revealed several burial sites containing victims of the plague epidemics (Figure 1). Skeletons from this site were collected by Michel Signoli and Luigi Fozzati. A total of 92 burial locations including graves and trenches were discovered at this site, each containing 5–184 individuals. Pottery fragments found in the sediment were used to determine the age of each site , . Sites 21, 24, 26, 34, 90, 91 and 92 dated to the second half of the 14th century and were organized in regular, narrow, parallel graves approximately 50 cm apart. The graves had an east–west or a west–east orientation and were mainly located in the western part of the Prato al Morti. The corpses were deposited in a supine position on the same level. In sites 26 and 34, the bodies were deposited on ceramic (graffita arcaica) dating to the mid-14th century. Burial sites dating to the 15th century could be divided into two major groups. The first consisted of regular, parallel trenches that intersected and often partially or totally destroyed earlier trenches. This suggested that the locations of the previous burial sites were not recorded. The second group consisted of several levels of large graves. Burials dating to the 16th century were in equally large and long trenches. The burials from the early 17th century epidemic were more dispersed and characterized by regular trenches in an east–west orientation or by rectangular graves with varying numbers of corpses.
Prevention of contamination
Ancient teeth were collected separately from different skeletons in burial sites by archaeologists and transported to the laboratory in individual bags. The dental pulp, which is protected from external contamination in the central cavity and the root canal of the tooth, was used for molecular experiments . The teeth used in this study had closed apexes and were free of caries and trauma. All instruments used to collect dental pulp were sterilized for each tooth to prevent cross contamination, and all reagents were from new kits. The laboratory followed general procedures for decontamination including the use of decontamination solutions and sterilization by ultraviolet light before experiments. PCR experiments were performed according to the suicide PCR protocol previously used for glpD by our research team . The experiments were done in a laboratory where Y. pestis and Y. pestis DNA have not been previously handled. Ancient teeth collected from corpses devoid of any anthropological evidence of infection were collected from a cemetery in Moirans, France (16th–18th) in agreement with French regulations and with appropriate permission of French authorities; they were used as negative controls in the PCR analyses.
High throughput detection of pathogens
Dental pulp was recovered as previously described  and incubated overnight at 56°C with 600 µL of ATL buffer and 50 µL of proteinase K. The total DNA was extracted using the QIAamp Media MDx Kit and pulverized on the BioRobot® MDx workstation in a final volume of 100 µL (Qiagen GmbH, Hilden, Germany). The high throughput detection of seven pathogens was performed as previously described . Briefly, DNA of Y. pestis, Bacillus anthracis (anthrax agent), Borrelia recurrentis (louse-borne relapsing fever agent), Bartonella quintana (trench fever agent), Rickettsia prowazekii (epidemic typhus agent), Salmonella enterica Typhi (typhoid fever agent) and poxvirus (smallpox agent) (Table) was detected with high throughput multiplexed real-time PCR. Two wells containing sterile water and two containing DNA extracted from dental pulp collected from negative control corpses served as standards.
Y. pestis DNA genotyping
Further genotyping of Y. pestis was based on suicide PCR of the glpD gene . A previously reported glpD primer pair  was used and the PCR was conducted in a laboratory in which Y. pestis and Y. pestis DNA were not previously handled. The PCR products were separated by electrophoresis at 100 V in a 2% agarose gel and sequenced using the Big Dye Terminator Kit. Sequencing products were resolved with the ABI PRISM 3130 Genetic Analyzer (Applied BioSystems, Courtaboeuf, France) and analyzed with the ABI PRISM DNA Sequencing Analysis Software version 3.0 (Applied BioSystems). Sequences were compared with those available in the GenBank database by BLAST (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/blast/Blast.cgi).
High throughput detection of pathogens
A total of 173 dental pulp specimens from Venice were analyzed including 37 specimens dating to the 14th century, 45 from the 15th century, 48 from the 16th century and 43 from the 17th century. Negative controls were negative in all experiments. High throughput real-time PCR detected B. quintana DNA in five (2.9%) dental pulp specimens, including three from the 16th century and two from the 15th century, and Y. pestis DNA was detected in three (1.7%) specimens, including two from the 14th century and one from the 16th century. The other five tested pathogens were not detected in this study.
Y. pestis DNA genotyping
The presence of Y. pestis DNA was confirmed by amplifying 165 bp of the glpD gene in two specimens, including one specimen positive by real-time PCR (from grave 35) for Y. pestis and another specimen negative by real-time PCR. The sequence of the PCR product derived from the specimen of grave 35 was most closely related to that of the Y. pestis biotype Orientalis glpD gene (GenBank accession number AL59082) with 98% sequence similarity. This sequence is characterized by a 93-bp deletion compared with the glpD gene sequence of Y. pestis Antiqua (GenBank accession number NC008150).
The results reported here are authentic; the negative controls remained negative in the two rounds of PCR-based experiments, and Y. pestis was specifically detected using two independent PCR-based experiments including suicide PCR. The specificity of the PCR products was further confirmed by sequencing .
The innovative approach used in this study was based on high throughput, multiplexed detection of seven pathogens that have been implicated in several epidemics with high mortality rates . Previous studies reported the detection of bacteria in the dental pulp of buried individuals , . This multiplexed approach allowed the detection of two organisms in individuals recovered from the same grave. B. quintana is a blood-borne organism and the etiological agent of trench fever resulting from bacteremia . However, asymptomatic bacteremia has also been reported  indicating that only the detection of B. quintana DNA in the dental pulp does not definitively identify the cause of death in ancient, buried individuals. However, the same is not true for Y. pestis; untreated septicemia always results in death , . Therefore, we interpreted the detection of Y. pestis DNA as indicative that these individuals died of septicemic plague. This approach eliminated five pathogens previously implicated without any experimental evidence as being responsible for the Black Death . Only B. quintana and Y. pestis were detected in these Venetian individuals.
B. quintana has previously been detected in human remains including a Neolithic individual  and in Napoleon Great Army soldiers from 1815 who also had typhus . We recently detected a B. quintana and Y. pestis co-infection in individuals excavated from a burial site near Paris dating to the 11th–15th centuries (Drancourt and Le Forestier, unpublished data). B. quintana is transmitted by the human body louse Pediculus humanus , which has been experimentally demonstrated to carry Y. pestis ,  and was observed during familial plague outbreaks –. Medieval populations are known to have been largely infested by body lice and the observation here of a co-infection with B. quintana and Y. pestis is compatible with the hypothesis that the body louse was a vector driving the Black Death epidemics in Europe , .
Our results detail the start of the Black Death in Europe in the mid-14th century. Several works previously documented Y. pestis in human remains from the Black Death (Figure 2) including Y. pestis DNA in one individual in Vilarnau, France from the 13th–15th centuries , one individual from the second half of the 14th century in the Saint Come and Saint Damien sites in Montpellier, France , three individuals in Dreux, France from the 12th–14th centuries , one individual in Saint-Laurent-de-la-Cabreisse, France from the AD 1348 or 1374 , two individuals in Bondy, France from the 11th–15th centuries (Drancourt and Le Forestier, unpublished data), two individuals in Stuttgart, Germany from the 14th–17th centuries , five late medieval individuals in Manching-Pichl, Germany , seven individuals in Bergen op Zoom, the Netherlands from the mid-14th century (AD 1349-50) and two individuals in Hereford, England from the AD 1335±54 . In addition, immunological detection of the F1 antigen has been reported in seven individuals in Saint-Laurent-de-la-Cabreisse, France , one individual in Genoa, Italy from the 14th century , ten individuals of Stuttgart, Germany from the 14th–17th centuries , three individuals in Bergen op Zoom, the Netherlands and four individuals in Hereford, England . Y. pestis has been documented in ten Black Death burial sites scattered over five countries by using different methodological approaches, and therefore the Black Death undoubtedly was due to the plague agent Y. pestis . In the present study, ancient Y. pestis DNA has been detected in only a small proportion of buried individuals in agreement with previous studies, indicating that detection of aDNA lacked sensitivity, in contrast to the immunological detection of the Y. pestis F1 antigen , , –. One Black Death site yielded 10/12 (83.3%) positives in the F1 dipstick assay and only 2/12 (16.7%) positives with PCR techniques . Another recent study yielded only 10/72 (14%) positives with PCR and 24/47 (51%) positives by the F1 dipstick assay . Molecular techniques allowed for genotyping ancient plague and yielded Y. pestis Orientalis on the basis of multiple spacer sequencing  and a characteristic deletion in the glpD gene as in Venice . A recent analysis of single nucleotide polymorphisms yielded two previously unknown, non-Orientalis clades of Y. pestis in South France, in the Netherlands and in England . In latter study, plague in 17th century Parma, another North Italy city was ascertained by immunological detection of the F1 antigen but aDNA detection failed and genotyping was not done.
References are indicated in brackets. France: 1. Marseille (18th) , , ; 2. Martigues (18th) , ; 3. Berre l'Etang (18th) ; 4. La Chaize-le-Vicomte (17th–18th) ; 5. Poitiers (16th–18th)  (Drancourt, unpublished data); 6. Draguignan (17th)  (Drancourt, unpublished data); 7. Saint-Maurice (17th) ; 8. Briançon (17th) ; 9. Lariey (17th)  (Drancourt, unpublished data); 10. Lambesc (16th) , ; 11. Vilarnau (13th–15th) ; 12. Bondy (11th–15th) [Drancourt, unpublished data]; 13. Montpellier (13th–14th) , ; 14. Dreux (12th–14th) ; 15. Vienne (7th–9th) ; 16. Sens (5th–6th) ; 17. Saint-Laurent-de-la-Cabrerisse (AD 1348 or 1374) . Italy: 18. Venice (14th–17th) [present study]; 19. Genoa (Bastione dell'Acquasola) (14th) ; 20. Parma (16th/17th) . Germany: 21. Stuttgart (14th–17th) ; 22. Aschheim (6th) ; 23. Manching-Pichl (Late medieval) ; 24. Augsburg (16th/17th) ; The Netherlands: 25. Bergen op Zoom (Mid-14th) . England: 26. Hereford (AD 1335±54) .
The originality in the organization of the Lazzaretto Vecchio site is owed to the fact that, unlike other plague burial sites investigated to date; this location was utilized during the Venetian plague waves for four centuries rather than only a single epidemic. This site contains multiple, simultaneous burial sites from different periods of major demographic crises that reflect the unique management of an epidemic. In Venice, the island of Santa Maria di Nazareth appears to have been used since the beginning of the Second Pandemic, if not for the care, at least for the burial of victims.
While the Black Death significantly affected Venice, this medieval city imposed the most efficient prevention measures of the time by increasing the 30-day isolation decreed in Ragusa (currently Dubrovnik) to a 40-day isolation known as quarantine . Shortly, all of the port cities in medieval Europe set up quarantine areas that persisted until the 20th century .
Conceived and designed the experiments: DR MD GA. Performed the experiments: TT LF MS. Analyzed the data: MS LF GA DR MD. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: LF DR. Wrote the paper: TT MS MD GA.
- 1. Biraben JN (1975) Les hommes et la peste en France et dans les pays européens et méditerranéens. Paris: Mouton, E.H.E.S.S. Centre de Recherches Historiques.
- 2. Signoli M, Gambaro L, Rigeade C, Drusini A (2009) Les fouilles du Lazzareto Vecchio (Venise, Italie) 333–346.
- 3. Ell SR (1989) Three days in October of 1630: detailed examination of mortality during an early modern plague epidemic in Venice. Rev Infect Dis 11: 128–141.
- 4. Wood J, Witte-Avina S (2003) Was the Black Death yersinial plague? Lancet Infect Dis 3: 327–328.
- 5. Teh WL, Chun JW, Pollitzer R (1923) Clinical Observations upon the Manchurian Plague Epidemic, 1920–21. J Hyg (Lond) 21: 289–306.
- 6. Twigg G (1985) The Black Death: a biological reappraisal. New York: Schocken.
- 7. Duncan CJ, Scott S (2005) What caused the Black Death? Postgrad Med J 81: 315–320.
- 8. Raoult D, Aboudharam G, Crubezy E, Larrouy G, Ludes B, et al. (2000) Molecular identification by “suicide PCR” of Yersinia pestis as the agent of medieval black death. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 97: 12800–12803.
- 9. Gambaro L, Rigaede C, De Piero M, Ardagna Y, Gobbo V, et al. (2007) La fouille de l'ile du Lazzareto Vecchio de Venise: premières données. In: Signli M, Chevé D, Adalian P, Boetsch G, Dutour O, editors. Plague: Epidemics and Societies. Frizenze University Press. pp. 97–101.
- 10. Drancourt M, Raoult D (2005) Palaeomicrobiology: current issues and perspectives. Nat Rev Microbiol 3: 23–35.
- 11. Drancourt M, Signoli M, Dang LV, Bizot B, Roux V, et al. (2007) Yersinia pestis Orientalis in remains of ancient plague patients. Emerg Infect Dis 13: 332–333.
- 12. Drancourt M, Aboudharam G, Signoli M, Dutour O, Raoult D (1998) Detection of 400-year-old Yersinia pestis DNA in human dental pulp: an approach to the diagnosis of ancient septicemia. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 95: 12637–12640.
- 13. Nguyen-Hieu T, Aboudharam G, Signoli M, Rigeade C, Drancourt M, et al. (2010) Evidence of a louse-borne outbreak involving typhus in Douai, 1710–1712 during the war of Spanish succession. PLoS One 5: e15405.
- 14. Anderson B, Firedman H, Bendinelli M (2006) Microorganisms and Bioterrorism. First edition ed. New York: Springer Science and Business Media.
- 15. Aboudharam G, Lascola B, Raoult D, Drancourt M (2000) Detection of Coxiella burnetii DNA in dental pulp during experimental bacteremia. Microb Pathog 28: 249–254.
- 16. Stein A, Raoult D (1995) Return of trench fever. Lancet 345: 450–451.
- 17. Brouqui P, Lascola B, Roux V, Raoult D (1999) Chronic Bartonella quintana bacteremia in homeless patients. N Engl J Med 340: 184–189.
- 18. Gage KL, Kosoy MY (2005) Natural history of plague: perspectives from more than a century of research. Annu Rev Entomol 50: 505–528.
- 19. Perry RD, Fetherston JD (1997) Yersinia pestis–etiologic agent of plague. Clin Microbiol Rev 10: 35–66.
- 20. Drancourt M, Tran-Hung L, Courtin J, Lumley H, Raoult D (2005) Bartonella quintana in a 4000-year-old human tooth. J Infect Dis 191: 607–611.
- 21. Raoult D, Dutour O, Houhamdi L, Jankauskas R, Fournier PE, et al. (2006) Evidence for louse-transmitted diseases in soldiers of Napoleon's Grand Army in Vilnius. J Infect Dis 193: 112–120.
- 22. Raoult D, Roux V (1999) The body louse as a vector of reemerging human diseases. Clin Infect Dis 29: 888–911.
- 23. Ayyadurai S, Sebbane F, Raoult D, Drancourt M (2010) Body lice, Yersinia pestis orientalis, and black death. Emerg Infect Dis 16: 892–893.
- 24. Houhamdi L, Lepidi H, Drancourt M, Raoult D (2006) Experimental model to evaluate the human body louse as a vector of plague. J Infect Dis 194: 1589–1596.
- 25. Blanc G, Balthazard M (1941) Recherches expérimentales sur la peste. L'infection du pou de l'homme: Pediculus corporis de Geer. Comptes Rendus des Séances de l'Academie des Sciences 213: 849–851.
- 26. Blanc G, Baltazard M (1942) Rôle des ectoparasites humains dans la transmission de la peste. Bulletin de l'Académie de Médecine 126: 446–448.
- 27. Blanc G, Baltazard M (1945) Documents sur la peste. Archieves de l'Institut Pasteur du Maroc 5: 349–354.
- 28. Drancourt M, Houhamdi L, Raoult D (2006) Yersinia pestis as a telluric, human ectoparasite-borne organism. Lancet Infect Dis 6: 234–241.
- 29. Drancourt M, Raoult D (2010) The body louse as a vector of the Black Death. Emerg Infect Dis. In-press.
- 30. Donat R, Passarius O, Aboudharam G, Drancourt M (2008) Les sépultures simultanées et l'impact de la peste. In: Passarius O, Donat R, Catafau A, editors. Vilarnau, un village du Moyen-Âge en Roussillon. Trabucaire, Canet-en-Roussillon.
- 31. Drancourt M, Roux V, Dang LV, Tran-Hung L, Castex D, et al. (2004) Genotyping, Orientalis-like Yersinia pestis, and plague pandemics. Emerg Infect Dis 10: 1585–1592.
- 32. Haensch S, Bianucci R, Signoli M, Rajerison M, Schultz M, et al. (2010) Distinct clones of Yersinia pestis caused the Black Death. PLoS Pathog 6: e1001134.
- 33. Pusch CM, Rahalison L, Blin N, Nicholson GJ, Czarnetzki A (2004) Yersinial F1 antigen and the cause of Black Death. Lancet Infect Dis 4: 484–485.
- 34. Wiechmann I, Harbeck M, Grupe G (2010) Yersinia pestis DNA sequences in late medieval skeletal finds, Bavaria. Emerg Infect Dis 16: 1806–1807.
- 35. Cerutti N, Marin A, Rabino Massa E (2007) Plague in ancient remains: an immunological approach. In: Signoli M, Chevé D, Adalian P, Boetsch G, Dutour O, editors. Plague: Epidemics and Societies. Frizenze University Press. pp. 238–241.
- 36. Bianucci R, Rahalison L, Ferroglio E, Massa ER, Signoli M (2007) A rapid diagnostic test for plague detects Yersinia pestis F1 antigen in ancient human remains. C R Biol 330: 747–754.
- 37. Bianucci R, Rahalison L, Massa ER, Peluso A, Ferroglio E, et al. (2008) Technical note: a rapid diagnostic test detects plague in ancient human remains: an example of the interaction between archeological and biological approaches (southeastern France, 16th–18th centuries). Am J Phys Anthropol 136: 361–367.
- 38. Bianucci R, Rahalison L, Peluso A, Massa ER, Ferroglio E, et al. (2009) Plague immunodetection in remains of religious exhumed from burial sites in central France. Journal of Archaeological Science 36: 616–621.
- 39. Gensini GF, Yacoub MH, Conti AA (2004) The concept of quarantine in history: from plague to SARS. J Infect 49: 257–261.
- 40. Brachet JL (1847) Mémoire sur la peste et les quarantaines
- 41. Hadjouis D, La VD, Aboudharam G, Drancourt M, Andrieux P (2008) Thomas Craven, noble anglais mort de la peste en 1636 à Saint-Maurice (Val-De-Marne, France). Identification et détermination de la cause de la mort par l'ADN. Biométrie humaine et anthropologie 26: 69–76.
- 42. Wiechmann I, Grupe G (2005) Detection of Yersinia pestis DNA in two early medieval skeletal finds from Aschheim (Upper Bavaria, 6th century A.D.). Am J Phys Anthropol 126: 48–55.