Recently, we described that ATP induces changes in YFP/CFP fluorescence intensities of Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) sensors based on CFP-YFP. To get insight into this phenomenon, we employed fluorescence lifetime spectroscopy to analyze the influence of ATP on these fluorescent proteins in more detail. Using different donor and acceptor pairs we found that ATP only affected the CFP-YFP based versions. Subsequent analysis of purified monomers of the used proteins showed that ATP has a direct effect on the fluorescence lifetime properties of CFP. Since the fluorescence lifetime analysis of CFP is rather complicated by the existence of different lifetimes, we tested a variant of CFP, i.e. Cerulean, as a monomer and in our FRET constructs. Surprisingly, this CFP variant shows no ATP concentration dependent changes in the fluorescence lifetime. The most important difference between CFP and Cerulean is a histidine residue at position 148. Indeed, changing this histidine in CFP into an aspartic acid results in identical fluorescence properties as observed for the Cerulean fluorescent based FRET sensor. We therefore conclude that the changes in fluorescence lifetime of CFP are affected specifically by possible electrostatic interactions of the negative charge of ATP with the positively charged histidine at position 148. Clearly, further physicochemical characterization is needed to explain the sensitivity of CFP fluorescence properties to changes in environmental (i.e. ATP concentrations) conditions.
Citation: Borst JW, Willemse M, Slijkhuis R, van der Krogt G, Laptenok SP, Jalink K, et al. (2010) ATP Changes the Fluorescence Lifetime of Cyan Fluorescent Protein via an Interaction with His148. PLoS ONE 5(11): e13862. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0013862
Editor: Vadim E. Degtyar, University of California, United States of America
Received: July 22, 2010; Accepted: October 19, 2010; Published: November 5, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Borst et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by ZonMw HORIZON Breakthrough Grant 050-71-019 and NKB-KWF grants KUN-2004-3125 and KUN-2005-3333. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
In a recent paper  we described that ATP induces changes in YFP/CFP fluorescence intensities in YFP/CFP based Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) sensors. Although we presented this finding as a cautionary note, we also pointed out that this ability can possibly serve as basis for development of a new range of genetically encoded biosensors for monitoring ATP concentrations. ATP is the primary energy source in every living cell and knowledge about its temporal and spatial behavior is of great importance. Based on early observations , ,  and recent own work ,  a model of compartmentalized production and consumption of ATP is now emerging. Therefore, tools to monitor dynamic changes in the intracellular distribution of ATP at near physiological concentrations in living cells are now urgently needed. Recently, the development of Perceval, a new reporter for ATP:ADP ratios in cells was described . Perceval is a circular permuted GFP variant, which upon binding of ATP to a domain derived from bacterial regulatory protein GlnK1, changes its fluorescence intensity. As the authors of this work point out, this sensor has its limitations and a ratiometric sensor based on FRET would still be welcome.
In our previous work we postulated that the ATP effect on CFP-YFP based FRET sensors occurred most likely via a direct quenching of the energy transfer step, possibly coupled to energy-induced charge displacement in the phosphate groups. We have applied fluorescence lifetime spectroscopy, which is generally accepted as one of the most reliable quantitative tools for this type of studies , , to get more insight into the physical basis and sequence of events involved. In this paper, we employed fluorescence lifetime spectroscopy to analyze effects of ATP on different fluorescent proteins in more detail.
Expression constructs and purification of proteins
For the bacterial expression of proteins the open reading frames of eCFP (CFP), Cerulean (CrFP), eYFP (YFP) and our previously described CFP-xa-YFP control construct , in which a Xa protease sensitive cleavage site is placed between the CFP-YFP chromophores, were amplified by a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) from the full-length cDNAs and appropriate segments were cloned into the pTYB11 vector (New England Biolabs, Impact vector system). The purification of the protein was performed as described in the manual of New England Biolabs, Impact vector system. The protein solutions were kept in 50 mM Hepes (pH 7.5) and stored in aliquots in −80 degrees.
For experiments in mammalian cells we used the same 6xHis-Tag containing vector designated CFP-xa-YFP as described before . In addition a version in which the CFP part was exchanged with Cerulean, designated as CrFP-xa-YFP, was used.
For purification of the mammalian expressed proteins we used the Ni-NTA Qiagen kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany) according to the manufacturer's instructions.
COS-1 (ATCC CRL-1650) cells expressing CFP-xa-YFP or CrFP-xa-YFP proteins were lysed in a buffer containing 50 mM NaH2PO4, 300 mM NaCl, 10 mM Imidazole, 0,05% Tween 20, pH 8,0, by repeated freeze/thawing. Steady-state spectral fluorescence emission recordings of cleared extracts or purified protein in a Tris/NaCl buffer of pH 7.4 were obtained using a Shimadzu RF-5301 spectrofluorimeter (Shimadzu Corporation, Kyoto, Japan) using an excitation wavelength of 425 nm and a bandwidth of 10 nm.
Fluorescence Lifetime Spectroscopy
Time-resolved fluorescence measurements were carried out using a mode-locked continuous wave laser for excitation and time-correlated single photon counting (TCSPC) as detection technique as described previously . The samples were prepared either in Tris/NaCl buffer, pH 7.4 or in 50 mM Hepes, pH 7.5. ATP or MgATP were prepared in same buffer before addition to protein samples. The samples were excited with plane polarized light pulses (0.2 ps FWHM) at an excitation frequency of 3.8 MHz and both parallel- and perpendicular-polarized fluorescence intensities were detected. At 430-nm excitation, CFP fluorescence was detected with a 480.5-nm interference filter (Schott, Mainz, Germany; half-bandwidth of 5.4 nm). The sensitized emission of YFP fluorescence was detected with an OG 530 cut-off filter (Schott) and 557.6-nm interference filter (Schott; half-bandwidth 5.9 nm). The dynamic instrumental response function of the setup (40 ps FWHM) was obtained at the CFP or YFP emission wavelengths by using a solution of xanthione in ethanol as reference compound having an ultrashort fluorescence lifetime of 14 ps , . The use of the reference convolution method  together with the current instrumentation enables determining fluorescence lifetimes with high accuracy and picosecond precision. Data analysis was performed using a model of discrete exponential terms. Global analysis of the experimental data was performed using the TRFA Data Processing Package of the Scientific Software Technologies Center (Belarusian State University, Minsk, Belarus) .
Previously, we demonstrated that the effect of ATP on FRET signals appeared to be independent of the linker sequence between the CFP and YFP moieties in all biosensors studied . Although we did observe a decrease in energy transfer with increasing linker lengths (Data not shown, see also previous work ) no effect of the linker length was observed on the ATP-induced changes in YFP/CFP ratio. Interestingly, when we subsequently analyzed a range of constructs encoding sensors composed of different donor and acceptor fluorescent proteins  we found that the effect of ATP on the fluorescence intensity ratio's was only observed in constructs composed of CFP-YFP based versions. In Figure 1 the effects of ATP on a GFP-tdTomato  construct is shown as an example.
Steady state fluorescence emission spectrum of a GFP-tdTomato construct () in the presence or absence of 10 mM ATP. Excitation of the GFP was at 480 nm excitation.
To exclude the possibility that still other cellular factors, besides ATP, affect the FRET efficiency, we analyzed the effect ATP has on the FRET efficiency of bacterial expressed and purified CFP and YFP alone, and compared it with the effects it has on the dual-colored CFP-xa-YFP control construct. As can be seen in Figure 2A, the effects of ATP could be nicely reproduced for the CFP-xa-YFP construct but ATP did not influence the spectral properties of CFP (Fig. 2B) or YFP alone (data not shown).
Steady state fluorescence emission spectra of CFP-xa-YFP (A) and CFP alone (B) at different ATP concentrations. Excitation of the CFP was at 420 nm excitation.
To answer the question whether the effect of ATP is the result of direct quenching of the energy transfer step or whether it is affecting the fluorescence characteristics of either one or both of the fluorescent moieties in the FRET sensor, we employed a more sensitive and quantitative method; time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy . Steady-state fluorescence spectroscopy of fluorescent sensors provides only information on average fluorescence properties of donor and acceptor molecules. The advantage of time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy over steady-state fluorescence spectroscopy is that more detailed information on protein dynamics can be obtained. A fluorescent lifetime can be described as the average time a fluorescent molecule spends in the excited state. This is an intrinsic property of every fluorescent molecule, which is dependent on its environment but probe concentration independent. We have performed fluorescence lifetime measurements on individual fluorescent proteins; CFP, Cerulean (CrFP), YFP and the different CFP based sensors. Generally, in FRET constructs the fluorescence lifetime of the donor (in our case CFP or CrFP) is measured. Fluorescence lifetime measurements of the CFP-xa-YFP control construct showed a clear effect at increasing ATP concentrations on the fluorescence lifetime of the CFP (see table 1). The fluorescence decay curves of this sensor in the absence and presence of ATP and MgATP are depicted in figure 3. The calculated average fluorescence lifetime changed from 1.37 ns to 1.83 ns upon addition of 10 mM ATP. Fluorescence lifetime measurements of the purified samples of CFP and YFP alone showed no effect on the fluorescence decay kinetics of YFP (Table 2) but, interestingly, we observed an increase of the fluorescence lifetime of CFP. As shown in table 2 and figure 4, the fluorescence lifetime of CFP changes from 2.86 ns to 3.04 ns at 10 mM ATP. An increase of the fluorescence lifetime was already evident at 2 mM ATP. The data of monomeric CFP were analyzed using a bi-exponential decay model; the data of the CFP-xa-YFP and CrFP-xa-YFP constructs were analyzed using a 3-component decay model , . Since previous experiments were performed by addition of MgATP, we tested also different concentrations of MgSO4. Interestingly, we again found a quenched fluorescence lifetime of CFP. The fluorescence lifetime of CFP decreased to almost the original value (2.90 ns). All the fluorescence lifetimes and the effects of ATP and MgATP are summarized in table 1 and 2.
Normalized experimental (dotted line) and fitted (solid line) fluorescence decay curves of CFP-xa-YFP (curve 1), CFP-xa-YFP in the presence of 10 mM MgATP (curve 2) or 10 mM ATP (curve 3). The excitation wavelength was 430 nm and the detection wavelength of CFP emission was 480 nm. Weighted residuals are shown in the bottom panel and the recovered parameters (α, τ) are collected in Table 1.
Normalized experimental (dotted line) and fitted (solid line) fluorescence decay curves of CFP (curve 1), CFP in the presence of 10 mM MgATP (curve 2) or 10 mM ATP (curve 3). The excitation wavelength was 430 nm and the detection wavelength of CFP emission was 480 nm. Weighted residuals are shown in the bottom panel and the recovered parameters (α, τ) are collected in Table 2.
The fluorescence lifetime properties of CFP are rather complicated due to the existence of two different conformations exhibiting two different lifetimes , . For this reason a CFP variant , Cerulean (CrFP), was generated exhibiting mono-exponentially decay. The main difference of this variant compared to CFP is the change of histidine148 into an aspartic acid. Surprisingly, analysis of purified monomeric Cerulean showed no effect on the fluorescence lifetime at increasing amounts of ATP. In figure 5 the fluorescence decay curves are shown and the calculated fluorescence lifetimes are summarized in table 2.
Normalized experimental (dotted line) and fitted (solid line) fluorescence decay curves of CrFP (curve 1; no ATP, curve 2; 10 mM MgATP, curve 3; 10 mM ATP), and CrFP-xa-YFP (curve 4; no ATP, curve 5; 10 mM MgATP, curve 6; 10 mM ATP). The excitation wavelength was 430 nm and the detection wavelength of CFP emission was 480 nm. The recovered parameters (α, τ) are collected in Table 1 and 2.
Next, we assessed Cerulean's properties in the context of FRET in mammalian cells, by changing CFP for Cerulean in our CFP-xa-YFP constructs. Again, we compared directly the effects of increasing amounts of ATP on the CFP and Cerulean-based constructs by spectral analysis in cell lysates (Fig. 6A, C and E) and on the purified monomeric proteins (Fig. 6B, D and F). In the spectral analysis, the effect of ATP on YFP/CFP ratios (Fig. 6E and F and table 3) was again only observed in the construct containing CFP and absent in the CrFP containing construct. Also, fluorescence lifetime measurements showed changes on donor lifetimes only in constructs containing CFP moieties (Fig. 5 and table 2). Finally, by specifically mutating the histidine at position 148 into an aspartic acid in the CFP-xa-YFP construct we could reproduce the lifetime results obtained by the CrFP-xa-YFP construct (See table 1).
Steady state fluorescence emission spectra of Cos-1 cells expressing CFP-xa-YFP (A, C) and CrFP-xa-YFP (B, D) in cell lysates (A, B) and of Ni-NTA purified protein (C, D) at different ATP concentrations. Under both conditions the YFP/CFP ratio shows a clear ATP dependent change in the CFP-xa-YFP construct whereas hardly any change was observed in the CrFP-xa-YFP construct (E, F). Excitation of the CFP was at 425 nm excitation.
Taken together, our observations lead us to conclude that the effect of ATP on the fluorescence characteristics of CFP occurs specifically via possible electrostatic interactions of the negative charge of ATP to the positively charged histidine residue at position 148 within the CFP molecule.
Previously, we postulated that ATP could have an effect on FRET signals in CFP-YFP based sensors by quenching of the energy transfer between the two fluorophores. Here, we show by time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy that the effect of ATP is not via quenching of the energy transfer step but via a direct interaction of ATP with the histidine residue at position 148 of CFP. The advantage of fluorescence lifetime measurements over steady-state fluorescence is that fluorescence lifetimes are concentration independent but can be influenced by the local environment of the fluorophore and can therefore be used to map this environment (pH etc.). It is known that the pH can change the protonation of the chromophore, thereby affecting the absorption characteristics and consequently the fluorescence lifetime of visible fluorescent proteins . In our experiments we can exclude pH effects as most samples were prepared with and without ATP/MgSO4 at identical pH-values.
It is known that the presence of multiple fluorescence lifetimes in CFP is due to conformational adaptation, where two different conformations of CFP result from the alternate displacement of two hydrophobic residues (Tyr145 and His148) ,  to the surface of the protein. Mutation of His148 to aspartic acid results in an almost completely single exponential fluorescence decay, a feature that was rationally engineered in Cerulean . The recent described X-ray structure of Cerulean  now provides a structural explanation for the described change in the fluorescence decay compared to the CFP variant. It has been shown recently that the fluorescence decay of Cerulean is also not exactly monoexponential . As shown here, the His148 residue in CFP is involved in binding ATP, thereby effecting the fluorescence lifetime properties upon ATP application.
In the two conformations of the original CFP, the side chain of His148 is either oriented towards the chromophore or positioned at the outside of the protein. Since the effect of ATP is seen on all lifetime components of CFP, we now speculate that ATP dynamically associates with this residue via π-π or cation-π interactions ,  or indirectly by influencing the conformation of the side chain. However, a direct electrostatic interaction with the negatively charged ATP molecule is also possible since the pKa of the side chain of histidine is about 6 . Our experiments have been performed at pH 7.5, which results in a partially positive charge of the histidine residue. The fluorescence lifetimes of purified monomeric CFP were calculated using a two-component fit model. A closer look at the data showed that it is the long component that is mainly affected upon ATP addition. In principle two effects are mixed during these analyses. First, the minor or major conformation of CFP determines the binding of ATP to the histidine. Secondly, at lower pH the side chains of histidine becomes more positively charged. Using lower pH has a direct influence on the chromophore of CFP causing a change in fluorescence lifetime properties. A third explanation may be the stacking of ATP to the histidine thereby changing the local conformation of CFP. As a result, flipping of the side chain can open up a pore, thereby giving access for quenching molecules to the chromophore (see ).
Either way, since His148 is one of the amino acid residues closest to CFP's chromophore, we can easily explain that changing the conformation of CFP or charge of the chromophore can have an effect on the CFP fluorescence properties. These effects become even more drastic in CFP/YFP FRET biosensors because distance and/or orientation may affect the fluorescence characteristics and thereby change the FRET readout of CFP/YFP based biosensors.
During the course of our studies, Imamura et al.  published a FRET based sensor for the visualization of ATP levels inside single living cells, which is also based on CFP and YFP but contains the epsilon subunit of the bacterial F(o)F(1)-ATP synthase as ATP sensing domain. However, in their control studies they do not see a direct effect of ATP on their sensor. We can explain this observation by the fact that these authors study changes in FRET ratios using micromolar concentrations of ATP, while we use millimolar ATP concentrations. We therefore conclude that the sensitivity of their ATP binding linker for ATP is much higher than an electrostatic interaction of ATP with the histidine at position 148, making their sensor better suited for the analysis of the intracellular distribution of ATP concentrations in living cells. In cells or conditions with large and sudden fluctuations in local or global ATP concentration however, we still conclude that findings should be interpreted with caution if genetically encoded CFP-YFP based biosensors are used.
Finally, combining recent spectroscopic work of Villoing et al. , showing that both CFP and its H148D mutant exhibit highly complex temperature and pH dependent fluorescence decays, and our work presented here, illustrates that we still have only limited understanding of the complex and heterogeneous fluorescence properties of CFP and the H148D variant Cerulean or the effects thereon of small molecules in its environment. Therefore, further physicochemical characterization is needed to explain the sensitivity of CFP fluorescence to changes in solute conditions, including changes in ATP-Mg concentration. Ultimately, better understanding of the emissive properties of fluorescent proteins may lead to a more rational design of FRET sensors.
Conceived and designed the experiments: JWB KJ BW JAMF. Performed the experiments: JWB MW RS GNMvdK. Analyzed the data: JWB MW SL JAMF. Wrote the paper: JWB KJ BW JAMF.
- 1. Willemse M, Janssen E, de Lange F, Wieringa B, Fransen J (2007) ATP and FRET--a cautionary note. Nat Biotechnol 25: 170–172.
- 2. Hoffman JF (1997) ATP compartmentation in human erythrocytes. Curr Opin Hematol 4: 112–115.
- 3. Ueda T, Mori Y, Kobatake Y (1987) Patterns in the distribution of intracellular ATP concentration in relation to coordination of amoeboid cell behavior in Physarum polycephalum. Exp Cell Res 169: 191–201.
- 4. Weiss JN, Lamp ST (1989) Cardiac ATP-sensitive K+ channels. Evidence for preferential regulation by glycolysis. J Gen Physiol 94: 911–935.
- 5. Kuiper JW, Pluk H, Oerlemans F, van Leeuwen FN, de Lange F, et al. (2008) Creatine kinase-mediated ATP supply fuels actin-based events in phagocytosis. PLoS Biol 6: e51.
- 6. van Horssen R, Janssen E, Peters W, van de Pasch L, Lindert MM, et al. (2009) Modulation of cell motility by spatial repositioning of enzymatic ATP/ADP exchange capacity. J Biol Chem 284: 1620–1627.
- 7. Berg J, Hung YP, Yellen G (2009) A genetically encoded fluorescent reporter of ATP:ADP ratio. Nat Methods 6: 161–166.
- 8. Borst JW, Laptenok SP, Westphal AH, Kuhnemuth R, Hornen H, et al. (2008) Structural changes of yellow Cameleon domains observed by quantitative FRET analysis and polarized fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. Biophys J 95: 5399–5411.
- 9. Suhling K, French PM, Phillips D (2005) Time-resolved fluorescence microscopy. Photochem Photobiol Sci 4: 13–22.
- 10. Borst JW, Hink MA, van Hoek A, Visser AJ (2005) Effects of refractive index and viscosity on fluorescence and anisotropy decays of enhanced cyan and yellow fluorescent proteins. J Fluoresc 15: 153–160.
- 11. Boens NN, Tamai N, Yamazaki I, Yamazaki T (1990) Picosecond single photon timing measurements with a proximity type microchannel plate photomultiplier and global analysis with reference convolution. Photochem Photobiol Sci 52: 911–917.
- 12. Ho CJ, Motyka AL, Topp MR (1989) Picosecond time-resolved S2-S0 fluorescence of xanthione in different fluid solvents. Chem Phys Lett 158: 51–59.
- 13. Digris AV, Skakoun VV, Novikov EG, van Hoek A, Claiborne A, et al. (1999) Thermal stability of a flavoprotein assessed from associative analysis of polarized time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy. Eur Biophys J 28: 526–531.
- 14. Evers TH, van Dongen EM, Faesen AC, Meijer EW, Merkx M (2006) Quantitative understanding of the energy transfer between fluorescent proteins connected via flexible peptide linkers. Biochemistry 45: 13183–13192.
- 15. van der Krogt GN, Ogink J, Ponsioen B, Jalink K (2008) A comparison of donor-acceptor pairs for genetically encoded FRET sensors: application to the Epac cAMP sensor as an example. PLoS ONE 3: e1916.
- 16. Grailhe R, Merola F, Ridard J, Couvignou S, Le Poupon C, et al. (2006) Monitoring protein interactions in the living cell through the fluorescence decays of the cyan fluorescent protein. Chemphyschem 7: 1442–1454.
- 17. Kim J, Kwon D, Lee J, Pasquier H, Grailhe R (2009) The use of Cyan Fluorescent Protein variants with a distinctive lifetime signature. Mol Biosyst 5: 151–153.
- 18. Bae JH, Rubini M, Jung G, Wiegand G, Seifert MH, et al. (2003) Expansion of the genetic code enables design of a novel “gold” class of green fluorescent proteins. J Mol Biol 328: 1071–1081.
- 19. Seifert MH, Ksiazek D, Azim MK, Smialowski P, Budisa N, et al. (2002) Slow exchange in the chromophore of a green fluorescent protein variant. J Am Chem Soc 124: 7932–7942.
- 20. Rizzo MA, Springer GH, Granada B, Piston DW (2004) An improved cyan fluorescent protein variant useful for FRET. Nat Biotechnol 22: 445–449.
- 21. Kneen M, Farinas J, Li Y, Verkman AS (1998) Green fluorescent protein as a noninvasive intracellular pH indicator. Biophys J 74: 1591–1599.
- 22. Malo GD, Pouwels LJ, Wang M, Weichsel A, Montfort WR, et al. (2007) X-ray structure of Cerulean GFP: a tryptophan-based chromophore useful for fluorescence lifetime imaging. Biochemistry 46: 9865–9873.
- 23. Goedhart J, van Weeren L, Hink MA, Vischer NO, Jalink K, et al. (2010) Bright cyan fluorescent protein variants identified by fluorescence lifetime screening. Nat Methods 7: 137–139.
- 24. Mao L, Wang Y, Liu Y, Hu X (2004) Molecular determinants for ATP-binding in proteins: a data mining and quantum chemical analysis. J Mol Biol 336: 787–807.
- 25. Pyrkov TV, Kosinsky YA, Arseniev AS, Priestle JP, Jacoby E, et al. (2007) Complementarity of hydrophobic properties in ATP-protein binding: a new criterion to rank docking solutions. Proteins 66: 388–398.
- 26. Berg JM, Tymoczko JL, Stryer JL (2002) Biochemistry, fifth edition. New York: W.H. Freeman and Company.
- 27. Imamura H, Nhat KP, Togawa H, Saito K, Iino R, et al. (2009) Visualization of ATP levels inside single living cells with fluorescence resonance energy transfer-based genetically encoded indicators. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 106: 15651–15656.
- 28. Villoing A, Ridhoir M, Cinquin B, Erard M, Alvarez L, et al. (2008) Complex fluorescence of the cyan fluorescent protein: comparisons with the H148D variant and consequences for quantitative cell imaging. Biochemistry 47: 12483–12492.