Self-association is an important biological phenomenon that is associated with many cellular processes. NMR relaxation measurements provide data about protein molecular dynamics at the atomic level and are sensitive to changes induced by self-association. Thus, measurements and analysis of NMR relaxation data can provide structurally resolved information on self-association that would not be accessible otherwise. Here, we present a computer program, NMRdyn, which analyses relaxation data to provide parameters defining protein self-association. Unlike existing relaxation analysis software, NMRdyn can explicitly model the monomer-oligomer equilibrium while fitting measured relaxation data. Additionally, the program is packaged with a user-friendly interface, which is important because relaxation data can often be large and complex. NMRdyn is available from http://research1t.imb.uq.edu.au/nmr/NMRdyn.
Citation: Wang CK, Schirra HJ, Craik DJ (2008) NMRDyn: A Program for NMR Relaxation Studies of Protein Association. PLoS ONE 3(11): e3820. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0003820
Editor: Bostjan Kobe, University of Queensland, Australia
Received: June 30, 2008; Accepted: November 7, 2008; Published: November 26, 2008
Copyright: © 2008 Wang et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Australian Research Council. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) relaxation is a powerful tool for understanding the structure and dynamics of proteins. In the most common approach to the analysis of protein dynamics, relaxation data – in the form of longitudinal relaxation rates (R1), transverse relaxation rates (R2), and heteronuclear NOEs (Nuclear Overhauser Effects) – are used to derive microdynamic parameters that describe both the overall tumbling and the internal motions of a macromolecule. In the ‘model-free’ approach , , the internal dynamics are quantified using a generalized order parameter, S2, which characterizes the amplitude of motion, and an internal correlation time τi. Additional parameters can be introduced to account for internal motions on fast and slow timescales . Several computer programs have been developed to analyze relaxation data and generate the parameters that describe the rates and amplitudes of protein motions, including Modelfree , relax  and MOLDYN .
An important phenomenon that can affect dynamics of a protein is self-association. The formation of oligomers is a key factor in the activity of many proteins, including enzymes, ion channels, receptors and transcription factors. HIV protease is a well-known example of an enzyme that operates as a dimer . Neuropeptide Y, a polypeptide hormone and neurotransmitter that is involved in the control of food intake, also forms dimers . Another example is kalata B1, a member of the cyclotides , a novel family of circular plant peptides that act in plant defense , which have been shown to form tetramers in solution .
Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) relaxation measurements have the potential to provide atomic scale information about protein self-association , . If the lifetimes of the monomer and aggregates are short on the NMR relaxation timescale, observed relaxation rates are a weighted average of the different species present . Even a small amount of high molecular weight species, from a tetramer for example, can cause a significant change in the observed relaxation rates, which in an oligomerization equilibrium are strongly dependent on the protein concentration as well as the molecular volume and shape of the species being measured.
This paper describes a computer program, NMRDyn, which analyses NMR relaxation data to allow the deduction of motional parameters. Unlike existing programs, NMRdyn was designed to deal with the self-association of proteins, i.e. it is able to explicitly optimize a monomer-oligomer association model for any type of oligomer while optimizing microdynamic parameters that describe protein dynamics, and presents a user-friendly interface to facilitate the examination of data and results. NMRdyn was designed for 15N NMR relaxation measurements and can also deal with 13Cα NMR relaxation data but is not appropriate for C = O relaxation, which can be complicated by chemical shift anisotropy contributions. NMRdyn is open-source and licensed under the GNU General Public License (GPL), and the code, as well as a manual describing the use of NMRdyn, is available from http://research1t.imb.uq.edu.au/nmr/NMRdyn.
Materials and Methods
Nuclear spin relaxation is induced mainly by dipolar and chemical shift anisotropy interactions, which are modulated by molecular tumbling. When a protein does not self-associate, the observed relaxation data, R1, R2 and NOE, can be expressed mathematically as shown in equations 1–3 .(1)(2)(3)Here γX and γH are the gyromagnetic ratios for X ( = 13C or 15N) and 1H respectively, rXH is the internuclear distance, and c represents the chemical shift anisotropy contribution. In the ‘model-free’ approach, the precise definition of the spectral density function, J(ω), and the inclusion/exclusion of the chemical exchange contribution, Rex, depends on the choice of model. There are eight basic models as summarized in table 1 , , , ; models 1 and 3 use equation 4, models 2 and 4 use equation 5, models 5 and 7 use equation 6, and models 6 and 8 use equation 7. Models 1, 2, 5, and 6 differ from the other models, collectively, in that they omit the Rex term when evaluating R2 according to equation 2. Equations 4 and 5 represent the original equations for spectral density derived by Lipari and Szabo , while equations 6 and 7 are extensions to the equations proposed by Clore et al .(4)(5)(6)(7)Here τc is the overall correlation time, S2 is the generalized order parameter, and τi is the internal correlation time. Potential fast internal motions are accounted for by the order parameter and the fast correlation time τf.
When a protein does self-associate, the observed relaxation data are a weighted average of the individual relaxation data of all species present in the association equilibrium. For example, in a system containing monomers (M) and dimers (D), the observed relaxation data would be given by equations 8–10 , , .(8)(9)(10)where M and D, as superscripts, refer to relaxation data of the monomer and dimer, respectively, and where pM and pD, which sum to 1, are the populations of protein in the monomeric and dimeric states, respectively. The populations pM and pD can be calculated once the association constant for the dimer formation is known. 〈Rex〉 signifies contributions to R2 from intramolecular exchange processes within the monomer and dimer, as well as from exchange processes between both species. If we focus on the 15N nucleus, contributions from monomer-dimer exchange to the R2 rates can occur only for those residues that differ in 15N chemical shift between the monomer and dimer . In the case of pure monomer-dimer exchange, the 〈Rex〉 term should increase with concentration, but if a change in concentration leads to the dominance of one conformer, then the 〈Rex〉 term may decrease with increasing concentration . In general, the contributions to 〈Rex〉 are not straightforward, because the timescales for conformational exchange motions and for exchange between monomer and dimer are generally similar (ms-µs). Thus, we assume 〈Rex〉 to be independent of the monomer-dimer interconversion, as has been done previously .
Thus, if the contributions to 〈Rex〉 are small, the general relaxation equations for a system containing different oligomeric species can be specified by equations 11–13.(11)(12)(13)where s iterates over all species present. The population of each species can be determined from the relevant association constant(s). If the stoichiometry of the oligomer and/or association constant is unknown, NMRdyn can extract these self-association parameters from the given relaxation data by optimizing a target function described below.
Once the form of the relaxation equations for R1, R2 and NOE has been established, theoretical calculations can be compared to experimental measurements. In a standard NMR relaxation study, NMR relaxation data is usually measured only at one concentration. Study of protein self-association requires sets of data measured at multiple concentrations. A special feature of NMRdyn is the ability to handle multiple sets of NMR relaxation data at different protein concentrations. Using the experimental data, the internal motional parameters for a given residue can be optimized according to a selected model. For residue i, this is often achieved by minimizing an error function, as defined in equation 14.(14)Here, j and k iterate over the concentrations and frequencies of the measured data, respectively.
Since there are eight basic models in a ‘model-free’ analysis, with different numbers of microdynamic parameters in each model, one has to balance precision with bias in selecting the best dynamic model describing the behavior of a given residue . Akaike's Information Criteria (AIC)  has been shown to be a highly reliable way of choosing the best model by selecting the model with the minimum AIC score . For residue i, the AIC score for model m is given by equation 15 , .(15)where km is the number of parameters in the model m. Model selection, based on AIC, has been implemented in NMRdyn.
It should be noted that we have so far discussed NMR relaxation in terms of isotropic diffusion, which applies broadly to the main intended applications, and is an assumption made in earlier studies . However, NMRdyn can also deal with anisotropic motion that may for example result from the formation of an anisotropic oligomer. In many such cases, the oligomer can be described as an axially symmetric ellipsoid, requiring only slight modifications of the spectral density function . To provide an example of the required modifications for the case of anisotropic overall motion, the spectral density function in equation 4 would become:(16)
In this equation, the principal components of the axially symmetric diffusion tensor are Dx = Dy = D⊥ and Dz = D∥, and the time constants are τ1 = (6D⊥)−1, τ2 = (D∥+5D⊥)−1, τ3 = (4D∥+2D⊥)−1. The coefficients Ak depend on the specific orientation of the respective XH bond vector. In NMRdyn, we adopt a ‘random oligomer’ approach, which assumes that the nature of the monomer-oligomer exchange is fast and non-specific, and is based on the ‘random dimer’ approach of Fushman et al.  that was used to analyze the anisotropy of the dimeric state of the dynamin plackstrin homology domain in solution. In this approach, the coefficients Ak can be replaced with their averaged values. For example, in the case of a dimer formed from two spherical monomers joined side-to-side, the values A1 = 1/5, A2 = 2/5 and A3 = 2/5 are used .
Algorithm and Implementation
The core functionality of NMRdyn is the ability to perform a standard model-free analysis of experimental data from 13C or 15N relaxation experiments to provide motional parameters describing the molecular dynamics of a protein. NMRdyn uses an iterative approach to derive the optimal τc for a protein of interest and selects the model along with a set of motional parameters for each residue that best fits the relaxation data. The process of model parameter optimization and model selection forms the basis for the extraction of self-association information from relaxation data, which is achieved using a grid search approach. A flowchart of describing the operation of NMRdyn is shown in Figure 1.
Panel A shows that the system being studied may be a monomeric protein or may include oligomers. The types of parameters that describe the dynamics of the system are labeled. In the monomeric case, relaxation data are usually measured at different magnetic field strengths and at one concentration, for a series of n nuclei (typically the backbone amide nitrogen for each amino acid, or backbone/sidechain 13C labeled sites) as shown in panel B. To study self-association, data at multiple concentrations are required. Relaxation data, molecular parameters, and physical constants are used as input into NMRdyn. Panel C (left side) shows that in the case of a monomeric protein, NMRdyn performs a ‘classical’ analysis, where the AIC value is minimized until it and all microdynamic parameters converge with model optimization and model selection performed at each minimization step. For studies of protein self-association (Panel C, right side), a grid-search approach can be applied, resulting in a set of microdynamic parameters describing the monomeric protein and the oligomer.
Parameter optimization in NMRdyn is iterative in nature, and stops when pre-defined convergence criteria have been met. Each iteration initiates a nested simplex search strategy. The approach is a non-derivative-based optimization method, which uses a non-degenerate simplex to guide its function sampling. In NMRdyn, a global simplex search is employed to optimize the AIC value, while at each exploratory step in the global simplex search, the selected models are first fitted to the relaxation data for each residue using separate simplex search instances, then tested for validity , and finally selected based on their AIC score. To derive protein self-association related parameters, the complete model parameter optimization and model selection procedure is essentially repeated for each grid point in a grid search.
NMRdyn is written in object-orientated C++. Object-orientated programming promotes reusability and extensibility of the code. At the top-level the code is organized into two modules, one dealing with the relaxation analysis algorithm and the other with the implementation of the general user interface. Publicly available libraries were employed in the program. Simplex routines from the publicly available GNU scientific library (GSL) were used to implement optimization routines of the motional parameters. The Qt libraries from Trolltech were used to program the general user interface (GUI). Although NMRdyn was initially developed on a linux operating system, both the GSL and Qt libraries are cross-platform, meaning that NMRdyn can be compiled and run on multiple architectures.
Description and Usage
Although NMRdyn can be run via the command line or incorporated into a script to expand the core functionality, the program also presents a user-friendly graphical interface to facilitate analysis. Such an interface is important because it helps the user visualize the motional parameters and relaxation data, which are often large and complex. For a given protein, data for each residue can be measured at multiple field strengths and multiple concentrations, creating an abundance of data. The main design principle of the interface was to allow the user to easily modify the parameters and data, analyze the data, and interpret the results.
As shown in Figure 2, the interface is split into two sections – one to display the motional parameters (parameter section) and another to display the experimental and calculated data (data section). Each section comprises a number of spreadsheets, allowing the user to easily modify input information. When the user changes the motional parameters in the parameter section, the program dynamically calculates the theoretical data and highlights regions in the calculated data that show significant deviation from the experimental data. This allows the user to interactively determine the effects of the motional parameters.
The interface is split into two sections. The top section displays the motional microdynamic parameters and the lower section displays both the observed and calculated data from the relaxation analysis. Both sections are displayed as worksheets so that individual data cells can be easily edited. Above the parameter section is a menu bar, which provides convenient access to the core functions of NMRdyn, including an iterative search to identify the best overall correlation time and set of models for the given relaxation data.
NMRdyn can automatically optimize the microdynamic parameters for a set of experimental data in a routine relaxation analysis using an iterative protocol or study protein self-association using a grid-search approach. An iterative search can be started after the user has defined project-specific parameters (i.e. the number of residues in the protein) and entered the experimental data in the data section. The optimized parameters and selected models from the analysis are displayed in the parameter section, while the calculated data are updated in the data section. To perform a grid-search, the user first specifies the desired range of values for the parameters involved in the grid search, and then the program searches for the optimal values while reporting a summary of the results for each point in the grid. The results for each grid point can be opened as a separate NMRdyn project so that the selected models and optimized parameters can be examined in more detail.
Understanding the dynamics of a protein is often key to understanding its biological function. Some example applications of NMRdyn are reported in this section. One of the most informative motional parameters is S2, which describes the internal flexibility of a given amino acid in a protein. In Figure 3, we show the S2 values resulting from a relaxation analysis on a neuropeptide Y dataset , assuming isotropic tumbling and a monomeric species, and compare it to the output from relax , the most recent program for analyzing NMR relaxation data. The excellent agreement between NMRdyn and relax for both experimental and simulated relaxation data was used to validate NMRdyn's implementation.
The original set of relaxation data used was downloaded from the Biological Magnetic Resonance Bank . S2 describes the flexibility of a given residue, with a value close to 1 indicative of high local order, and is one of the most informative parameters from a relaxation analysis. The agreement between the results from NMRdyn and relax validates NMRdyn's implementation.
The grid-search function in NMRdyn can be used to study protein self-association. For example, a floating-stoichiometry analysis can be performed to determine the form of the aggregate (i.e. whether the oligomer is a dimer, tetramer, etc.) by searching over a grid with various values for the association constant, Ka, and the size of the oligomer, which can be manipulated in NMRdyn through an interactive input panel. Floating-stoichiometry analysis has been used previously to determine the stoichiometry of oligomers, e.g. a floating-stoichiometry analysis of tyrosine phosphatase suggested that it can form tetramers in solution . In the case of the prototypical cyclotide, kalata B1, where the stoichiometry of the oligomer is known to be a tetramer from analytical ultra-centrifugation , the value of Ka can be refined by searching over different values for Ka and selecting the value that gives the best fit of the experimental data as illustrated in Figure 4.
NMRdyn was used to perform a search over different association constants. The overall Akaike's Information Criteria (AIC) score was used to judge the goodness of the fit, with the aim of obtaining the minimum AIC score. The results indicate that an association constant of approximately 3×107 M−3 can be used to describe the formation of the kalata B1 tetramer in solution.
NMRdyn is a new interactive tool for the analysis of NMR relaxation data. Apart from providing the standard functions to optimize motional parameters according to the ‘model-free’ approach, NMRdyn also features tools to handle protein self-association. NMRdyn is available from http://research1t.imb.uq.edu.au/nmr/NMRdyn.
Conceived and designed the experiments: CKLW HJS DJC. Performed the experiments: CKLW HJS. Analyzed the data: CKLW HJS. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: DJC. Wrote the paper: CKLW.
- 1. Lipari G, Szabo A (1982) Model-free approach to the interpretation of nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation in macromolecules. 1. Theory and range of validity. J Am Chem Soc 104: 4546–4559.
- 2. Lipari G, Szabo A (1982) Model-free apporach to the interpretation of nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation in macromolecules. 2. Analysis of experimental results. J Am Chem Soc 104: 4559–4570.
- 3. Clore GM, Szabo A, Bax A, Kay LE, Driscoll PC, et al. (1990) Deviations from the simple two-parameter model-free approach to the interpretation of 15N nuclear magnetic relaxation of proteins. J Am Chem Soc 112: 4989–4991.
- 4. Palmer AG, Rance M, Wright PE (1991) Intramolecular motions of a zince finger DNA-binding domain from Xfin characterized by proton-detected natural abundance carbon-13 heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy. J Am Chem Soc 113: 4371–4380.
- 5. d'Auvergne EJ, Gooley PR (2008) Optimisation of NMR dynamic models I. Minimisation algorithms and their performance within the model-free and Brownian rotational diffusion spaces. J Biomol NMR 40: 107–119.
- 6. Craik DJ, Kumar A, Levy GC (1983) MOLDYN: A Generalized Program for the Evaluation of Molecular Dynamics Models Using Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spin-Relaxation Data. J Chem Inf Comput Sci 23: 30–38.
- 7. McPhee F, Good AC, Kuntz ID, Craik CS (1996) Engineering human immunodeficiency virus 1 protease heterodimers as macromolecular inhibitors of viral maturation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 83: 11477–11481.
- 8. Bader R, Bettio A, Beck-Sickinger AG, Zerbe O (2001) Structure and Dynamics of Micelle-bound Neuropeptide Y: Comparison with Unligated NPY and Implications for Receptor Selection. J Mol Biol 305: 307–329.
- 9. Craik DJ, Daly NL, Bond T, Waine C (1999) Plant cyclotides: A unique family of cyclic and knotted proteins that defines the cyclic cystine knot structural motif. J Mol Biol 294: 1327–1336.
- 10. Jennings C, West J, Waine C, Craik D, Anderson M (2001) Biosynthesis and insecticidal properties of plant cyclotides: the cyclic knotted proteins from Oldenlandia affinis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 98: 10614–10619.
- 11. Nourse A, Trabi M, Daly NL, Craik DJ (2004) A comparison of the self-association behavior of the plant cyclotides kalata B1 and kalata B2 via analytical ultracentrifugation. J Biol Chem 279: 562–570.
- 12. Fushman D, Cahill S, Cowburn D (1997) The Main-chain Dynamics of the Dynamin Pleckstrin Homology (PH) Domain in Solution: Analysis of 15N Relaxation with Monomer/Dimer Equilibration. J Mol Biol 266: 173–194.
- 13. Bernadó P, Åkerud T, García de la Torre J, Akke M, Pons M (2003) Combined use of NMR relaxation measurements and hydrodynamic calculations to study protein association. Evidence for Tetramers of Low Molecular Weight Protein Tyrosine Phosphatase in Solution. J Am Chem Soc 125: 916–923.
- 14. d'Auvergne EJ, Gooley PR (2003) The use of model selection in the model-free analysis of protein dynamics. J Biomol NMR 25: 25–39.
- 15. Akerud T, Thulin E, Van Etten RL, Akke M (2002) Intramolecular dynamics of low molecular weight protein tyrosine phosphatase in monomer-dimer equilibrium studied by NMR: a model for changes in dynamics upon target binding. J Mol Biol 322: 137–152.
- 16. Wennerström H (1972) Nuclear magnetic relaxation induced by chemical exchange. Mol Phys 24: 69–80.
- 17. Akaike H (1973) Information Theory and an Extension of the Maximum Likelihood Principle. In: Petrov BN, Csaki F, editors. Budapest: Academiai Kiado. pp. 267–281.
- 18. Woessner D (1962) Nuclear Spin Relaxation in Ellipsoids Undergoing Rotational Brownian Motion. J Chem Phys 37: 647–654.
- 19. d'Auvergne EJ, Gooley PR (2006) Model-free model elimination: A new step in the model-free dynamic analysis of NMR relaxation data. J Biomol NMR 35: 117–135.
- 20. Ulrich EL, Akutsu H, Doreleijers JF, Harano Y, Ioannidis YE, et al. (2008) BioMagResBank. Nucleic Acids Res 36: D402–408.