Mass mortalities of marine mammals due to infectious agents are increasingly reported. However, in contrast to previous die-offs, which were indiscriminate with respect to sex and age, here we report a land-based mass mortality of Subantarctic fur seals with apparent exclusivity to adult males. An infectious agent with a male-predilection is the most plausible explanation for this die-off. Although pathogens with gender-biased transmission and pathologies are unusual, rodents are known sources of male-biased infectious agents and the invasive Mus musculus house mouse, occurs in seal rookeries.
Methodology/ Principal Findings
Molecular screening for male-biased pathogens in this potential rodent reservoir host revealed the absence of Cardiovirus and Leptospirosis genomes in heart and kidney samples, respectively, but identified a novel Streptococcus species with 30% prevalence in mouse kidneys.
Inter-species transmission through environmental contamination with this novel bacterium, whose congenerics display male-bias and have links to infirmity in seals and terrestrial mammals (including humans), highlights the need to further evaluate disease risks posed by alien invasive mice to native species, on this and other islands.
Citation: de Bruyn PJN, Bastos ADS, Eadie C, Tosh CA, Bester MN (2008) Mass Mortality of Adult Male Subantarctic Fur Seals: Are Alien Mice the Culprits? PLoS ONE 3(11): e3757. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0003757
Editor: Dennis Marinus Hansen, Stanford University, United States of America
Received: June 25, 2008; Accepted: October 31, 2008; Published: November 19, 2008
Copyright: © 2008 de Bruyn et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The Department of Science and Technology, through the National Research Foundation (South Africa), provided financial support.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Mass mortality events in marine mammals have increasingly been observed in the last two decades and have been ascribed to infectious agents, such as a bacteria or viruses, or to poisoning , , . The mass mortality of around 20 000 harbour seals (Phoca vitulina) which occurred in 1988 during the seal haul-out in the North Sea was, for example, shown to be due to phocine distemper virus (PDV), a morbillivirus with a significant mortality rate . In 1998, another mass mortality event affecting an estimated 1600 New Zealand sea lions (Phocarctos hookeri) occurred, with two bacterial genera being implicated as possible causal agents . No overt gender or age bias was recorded for these or for other subsequent marine mammal die-offs. In contrast, the land-based mass mortality event reported here, was observed in adult, male Subantarctic fur seals Arctocephalus tropicalis at Fur Seal Peninsula on Subantarctic Marion Island (46°52′S, 37°51′E) (Fig. 1) in January 2007.
Photo taken three weeks after the die-off event by PJN de Bruyn.
At least 250–300 individual adult males succumbed within a period of two weeks (02–15 Jan 2007) between observer visits to this area. No additional atypical mortalities were observed at this beach following the mass die-off. Approximately 50 male carcasses were however encountered around the remainder of the island in smaller rookeries and always in pools of water, at sites spaced 1–5 km apart, prior to the die-off. The nearest of these affected rookeries was approximately 2 km from Fur Seal Peninsula. However, it was only after the observed Fur Seal Peninsula die-off that these noticeable, but not markedly anomalous, deaths were considered to have possibly been linked. The mass mortality coincided with the end of the Marion Island A. tropicalis pupping season, a time when dominant adult males had already been ashore for 3–4 weeks, securing and defending territories to gain exclusive breeding rights to harems of females . Given an estimated pup production of 5387  for the Fur Seal Peninsula rookery on Marion Island, and the use of a conversion factor of 1 to 2.4, adult males to pups , this die-off represents 11–13% of the adult males within this one rookery. An estimated 95% of the carcasses were found in pools of water (Fig. 1). No dead adult females or atypical pup mortality (of either sex  was noted during this period. Had a similar proportion of adult females (as adult males) succumbed at sea during their foraging trips , a higher than usual pup mortality  would have ensued, but was not observed. This, together with the fact that adult females spend 24% of their time ashore to nurse their pups at this time of the year , indicates offshore female mortalities were neither overt, nor overlooked. The inaccessibility of the rookeries due to steep, rocky terrain, the peak breeding season aggression and the sheer density of seals on this most densely populated seal rookery , together with the presence of the carcasses in pools of water, precluded tissue sample collection or post-mortem analyses. Careful surveillance of the entire area with the use of binoculars from vantage points was however undertaken which readily confirmed, on the basis of the extreme sexual dimorphism in fur seals, that only adult males had succumbed on beaches.
To our knowledge no documented cases of such severe gender-biased natural mass mortality exist for seals, or other marine mammals. A variety of infectious and non-infectious diseases (such as toxins and stress) were considered as a potential cause for the die-off. As no marine mammal deaths in the wild have conclusively been shown to result from organochloride or toxic element exposure, even in heavily polluted waters , and as the observed male biased mortality occurred in the far less polluted waters of the Southern Ocean , it is unlikely that toxins released from stored fat in adult males would have precipitated a mass die-off within a 14-day period. The possibility of heightened stress due to elevated population density was judged improbable since the population of Fur Seal Peninsula, the largest fur seal rookery, has seen little growth (1.4%) from 1998 to the present . Population densities over the last eight years have also remained stable within this rookery, making it unlikely that unusual density dependent stress-related mortality was the driver for the die-off in this worse-affected rookery. Although annual post-breeding mortality occurs at 30–50% for some fur seal species , mortality rates for adult male Subantarctic fur seals at Marion Island, during the breeding season, whilst not known precisely, are presumed to be very low (<1%; MNB, PJNdB & CAT personal obs.). The short period within which the A. tropicalis mortalities occurred (<2 weeks), the relative absence of obvious physical injuries on carcasses, the low levels of physical contact during territorial disputes resulting in the virtual absence of fatal confrontations [e.g. 13], , and the fact that male-to-male aggression is a usual stressor at this time of the year, rule out the possibility of male-male fighting as a cause for the deaths. Analyses of the mean maximum (T2007 = 10.8°C) temperatures for this period showed no marked variation exceeding the standard deviations of the means for the last 10 years (Maximum Average±SD = 11.56±0.71). Subantarctic fur seals are more susceptible to higher-than-ordinary temperatures compared to lower temperatures  and, furthermore, extraordinary temperature fluctuations would presumably not cause gender-biased mortality. Even a combination of these factors is unlikely to have caused the observed male-biased mortality. Instead, the observed age and gender-bias points to an infectious agent with a male predilection being the most plausible explanation. Such male-bias has been reported for members of the family Picornaviridae. In particular, Encephalomyocarditis (EMC) virus, a member of the Cardiovirus genus which is classified within the Picornaviridae, shows a marked bias towards adult male mice Mus musculus  and was identified as the causative agent in a mass gender-biased mortality of free-ranging African elephants, Loxodonta africana . In that elephant die-off, 83% of fatalities occurred in adult bulls, despite there being no observed gender or age differences with respect to EMC seropositivity .
Members of the Cardiovirus genus have a worldwide distribution and an extremely wide host range, with rodents being implicated as the reservoir host and source of infection for other species . The virus is transmitted orally; by internasal, intertracheal and aerosol infection of the respiratory tract . Friedman et al.  showed male-biased mortality in an EMC study conducted on mice, Mus musculus, linking higher testosterone levels to increased susceptibility. As the mass seal die-off occurred in the breeding season when testosterone levels are significantly higher in adult male Subantarctic fur seals , and as a potential reservoir host, the invasive house mouse occurs on the island, EMC virus was considered to be the prime infectious agent candidate.
Alien mice, Mus musculus domesticus, were accidentally introduced to Marion Island by sealers during the early 1800's  and have recently been the subject of numerous studies concerned with the effect that this invader may have on indigenous species (e.g.  and references therein). Mice are found in high densities on beaches at Marion Island  and rodents in general are readily infected with Cardioviruses . The continuous onshore presence of adult male seals for at least three weeks , prior to the mass mortality which ensued over a 14-day period, points to the likelihood of an onshore acquired infection, and is in keeping with the short incubation period, rapid transmission rate and male-biased mortality documented for cardioviruses .
The large seal and mouse populations on Marion Island ,  are likely to facilitate transmission of this virus and other infectious agents, for which Mus are reservoir hosts. Mice are abundant on beaches due to the greater availability of seal and seabird faeces, carcasses and related detritus as food items and as centers of high productivity . In addition, mice are partial to areas with adequate shelter , making boulder-strewn beaches (also the favoured breeding colony beach type of Arctocephalus tropicalis, ) attractive to mice. Arctocephalus seals are known to investigate objects such as rocks, by smelling them and through tactile response elicited by facial vibrissae (e.g. Arctocephalus forsteri, ), and A. tropicalis are often observed vigorously rubbing their muzzles/faces against rocks . This behaviour, in combination with the urine and faecal contamination of environments frequented by mice, provides a possible route of transmission from rodents to other susceptible hosts. The hypothesis that mice may have been the source of the pathogen causing the male-biased seal die-off was investigated by molecular screening of mice for the presence of rodent-borne, gender-biased pathogen genomes.
In order to determine whether mice may harbour the EMC virus and/or be shedding bacteria via the urinary route, 46 mice were trapped at four localities, approximately 8 months after the seal mortalities. RNA was extracted from homogenized heart tissue, using a modified GuSCN-silica method and reverse transcribed using random hexanucleotides (IDT) and 10U of AMV-RT (SBS Genetech) as described previously for another picornavirus . The cDNA was then used as template for viral gene amplification, with two Cardiovirus-specific primer sets, one targeting the 3D viral replicase gene  and the other the 5'non-coding region . Positive and negative controls were included to confirm primer specificity and sensitivity, and to preclude false positives due to reagent contamination, respectively. Whilst the cDNA prepared from positive control EMC virus RNA, amplified with both primer sets, the cDNA prepared from RNA extracted from mouse heart samples failed to amplify with either of the Cardiovirus primer sets.
In contrast to the gut which contains multiple bacterial species, kidneys generally have markedly lower levels of bacterial species diversity, making them amenable to identification of unknown bacteria using broad-range bacterial PCR primers . Leptospirosis, a spirochete which is shed in the urine of a wide range of small rodents has recently been found in seals where it was linked to recent, significant die-offs . Rocks in seal rookeries contaminated with Mus urine thus provide a likely route of transmission of mouse-borne diseases. To determine whether Leptospirosis or any other bacterial species may be shed in mouse urine, total genomic DNA was extracted from kidney samples of the same 46 mice, using the Roche High Pure PCR Template Preparation Kit, according to supplier specifications. Leptospira PCR primers targeting the 16S rDNA bacterial gene  and the rpoB gene  were used to assess genomic presence of this agent in kidneys, whilst broad-range bacterial primers  permitted identification of other bacterial genera possibly being shed in urine. Leptospirosis-presence could not be confirmed through amplification and nucleotide sequencing, with either of the primers sets, indicating the absence of this bacterial genus in the Marion Island mice sampled. However, the broad-range bacterial primers amplified a 16S gene fragment in 18 samples. All positive amplicons were purified with the Roche High Pure PCR Template Purification kit (according to manufacturer specifications), and sequenced with each of the PCR primers in separate reactions. Sequences were viewed, edited and aligned in Mega4 . Of the 18 positive PCRs, 14 produced unambiguous sequence data, and were identical to each other across the homologous 943 nucleotide (nt) region sequenced, with the remaining four being bacterial mixtures of indiscernible species composition. This corresponds to a Streptococcus bacterial prevalence of at least 30.4 % in the M. musculus kidney samples screened. A Blast nucleotide search (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/blast) of the Marion Island mouse kidney sequence (which has been submitted to Genbank under accession number EU626397) revealed the closest cultured bacterial match to be S. sanguinis (Genbank entry EU189961), a bacterial agent associated with infective endocarditis in humans  and for which male-bias has been reported , . Nucleotide sequence identity to this S. sanguinis 16S gene sequence was 95.6%, and ranged from 91.6% to 95.2% in pairwise comparisons with other species within the Streptococcus genus. To assess phylogenetic affinities among the presently-documented Streptococcus species and the bacterium identified in Marion Island mouse kidneys, a 16S gene dataset was compiled comprising 37 Streptococcus type specimen sequences, the Mus kidney Streptococcus sequence generated in this study, and four Enterococcus sister-taxon sequences. Following sequence alignment in Mega4 , a gene phylogeny was inferred using the neighbor-joining algorithm and Tamura-Nei model of sequence evolution (Fig. 2), with nodal support being assessed by 1000 bootstrap replications. The phylogeny confirms the monophyly of the Marion Island mouse kidney bacterium and representative species within the Streptococcus genus (100% bootstrap support). However, the bacterial species in Marion Island mice is distinct from all other congenerics, including those previously isolated from murid rodents and pinnipeds (Fig. 2) and therefore represents a new bacterial species. The shedding of Streptococcus in mouse urine is significant for a number of reasons. Firstly, this was the most prevalent bacterial genus occurring in mixed Arcanobacterium infections linked to male-biased mortalities of antlered white-tailed deer Odocoileus virginianus . Secondly, three Streptococcus bacterial species have thus far been identified from seals (Fig. 2) suffering from respiratory infections, and perhaps of greatest significance is that adult, male-biased Streptococcus susceptibility has been documented for inbred mice .
Invasive mice have direct and indirect adverse effects on invertebrates, birds and plants [e.g. 21 and references therein] on Marion Island and numerous other islands worldwide  but have hitherto not been suspected of having adverse effects on marine mammals, particularly seals. Harvell et al.  argues that “host shifts” by known infectious agents are responsible for new disease outbreaks rather than by transmission of new agents. This is evidenced by the plethora of morbilliviral diseases in various marine mammal species. Such shifts are thought to be favoured by changing environmental conditions brought about by climatic and anthropogenic factors , both of which have long been recognized as having an impact on Marion Island . Mice on Marion Island may be an example of such anthropogenic favouring of disease transmission. Our results indicate that the most likely viral candidate previously associated with a mass gender-biased, large mammal die-off was not present in the mice sampled. However, these invasive rodents were shown to harbour a novel bacterial species belonging to the genus Streptococcus, members of which have documented adult, male bias in the Mus rodent host . This genus has also been recovered from diseased pinnipeds. Identification of the new bacterial species in kidneys confirms that excretion and transmission via urine to other species is possible. However, in the absence of seal samples from the adult males that succumbed, this hypothesis that mice were the source of the infectious agent remains tenuous. The indirect evidence presented here, indicating that mice may harbour a bacterium with a potential predilection for male mammals, whilst preliminary, highlights the generally overlooked threat that alien invasive mice may pose to the health of island endemics. We propose several future lines of study that would be useful for providing more definitive answers in the event of a future seal die-off:
- Collection of blood samples from healthy seals to obtain baseline blood profiles as well as obtaining biopsy samples on a routine basis from dead animals.
- Demographic studies of the increasing Subantarctic-and Antarctic fur seal populations , to estimate age and sex-specific survival and mortality, and provide benchmarks against which temporal trends and anomalous years can be identified.
- Assessing sex-specific survival and mortality rates of mice on Marion Island, at both spatial and temporal scales in conjunction with monitoring rodent density and reproductive output in relation to changing climatic conditions.
- Longitudinal monitoring of Streptococcus infection dynamics in mice populations, which may assist with modeling and predicting inter-species transmission.
- Investigate in vitro and in vivo whether susceptibility to the novel Streptococcus bacterium identified from Marion Island mice displays gender-bias in this rodent host.
We thank Santjie du Toit for assistance with field observations, Truuske Gerdes of the ARC-OVI for providing the EMC virus used for positive control purposes, Daniel Haydon for review of the draft manuscript, Cromwell Purchase for assisting with dissections, and Chris Oosthuizen and Mashudu Phalanndwa for field trapping. The Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism provided logistic support within the South African National Antarctic Programme. We thank the academic editor, Dennis Hansen, Ian Wilkinson and an anonymous reviewer for their comments and suggestions for improvement of the manuscript.
All the above procedures have ethics clearance from the Animal Use and Care Committee (AUCC) of the Faculty of Natural and Agricultural Sciences, University of Pretoria, South Africa, under AUCC 040827-023.
Conceived and designed the experiments: ADSB. Performed the experiments: ADSB CE. Analyzed the data: ADSB. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: ADSB MB. Wrote the paper: PJNdB ADSB CT MB. Recorded the seal die-off/fieldwork: PJNDB. Conceived the seal/mouse link: ADSB. Fieldwork: CT.
- 1. Harwood J (1998) What killed the monk seals? Nature 393: 17–19.
- 2. Kennedy S, Kuiken T, Jepson PD, Deaville R, Forsyth M, et al. (2000) Mass die-off of Caspian seals caused by canine distemper virus. Emerg Infect Dis 6: 637–639.
- 3. Heide-Jørgensen M-P, Härkönen T (1992) Epizootiology of the seal disease in the Eastern North Sea. J Appl Ecol 29: 99–107.
- 4. Fenwick SG, Duignan PJ, Nicol CM, Leyland MJ, Hunter JEB (2004) A comparison of Salmonella serotypes isolated from New Zealand sea lions and feral pigs on the Auckland Islands by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis. J Wildl Dis 40: 566–570.
- 5. Kerley GIH (1983) Comparison of seasonal haul-out patterns of fur seals Arctocephalus tropicalis and A. gazella on Subantarctic Marion Island. S Afr J Wildl Res 13: 71–77.
- 6. Hofmeyr GJG, Bester MN, Makhado AB, Pistorius PA (2006) Population changes in Subantarctic and Antarctic fur seals at Marion Island. S Afr J Wildl Res 36: 55–68.
- 7. Kerley GIH (1987) Arctocephalus tropicalis on the Prince Edward Islands. In Croxall JP, Gentry RL, editors. Status, Biology and Ecology of Fur Seals. Proceedings of an international symposium and workshop, Cambridge, England April 1984. NOAA technical report NMFS 51: 61–64.
- 8. Hofmeyr GJG, Bester MN, Pistorius PA, Mulaudzi TW, de Bruyn PJN, et al. (2008) Median pupping date, pup mortality and sex ratio of fur seals at Marion Island. S Afr J Wildl Res 37: 1–8.
- 9. Kirkman SP, Bester MN, Hofmeyr GJG, Pistorius PA, Makhado AB (2002) Pup growth and maternal attendance patterns in Subantarctic fur seals. Afr Zool 37: 13–19.
- 10. O'Shea TJ (1999) Environmental contaminants and marine mammals. In: Reynolds JE III, Rommel SA, editors. Biology of Marine Mammals. USA: Smithsonian Institution.
- 11. Knox GA (2007) Biology of the Southern Ocean. CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group.
- 12. Wickens P, York AE (1997) Comparative population dynamics of fur seals. Mar Mamm Sci 13: 241–292.
- 13. Miller EH (1975a) Social and evolutionary implications of territoriality in adult male New Zealand fur seals, Arctocephalus fosteri (Lesson, 1828), during the breeding season. Rapp Proc-verb Reun Cons Int Expl Mer 169: 170–187.
- 14. Bester MN (1977) Habitat selection, seasonal population changes and behaviour of the Amsterdam Island fur seal Arctocephalus tropicalis on Gough Island. University of Pretoria. D.Sc. Thesis.
- 15. Bester MN, Rossouw GJ (1994) Time budgets and activity patterns of sub-Antarctic fur seals at Gough Island. S Afr J Zool 29: 168–174.
- 16. Friedman SB, Grota LJ, Glasgow LA (1972) Differential susceptibility of male and female mice to encephalomyocarditis virus: effects of castration, adrenolectomy, and the administration of sex hormones. Infect Immun 5: 637–644.
- 17. Grobler DG, Raath JP, Braack LEO, Keet DF, Gerdes GH, et al. (1995) An outbreak of encephalomyocarditis-virus infection in free-ranging African elephants in the Kruger National Park. Onderstepoort J Vet Res 62: 97–108.
- 18. Thomson GR, Bengis RG, Brown CC (2001) Picornavirus infections: encephalomyocarditis. In: Williams ES, Barker IK, editors. Infectious diseases of wild mammals, 3rd Edition. USA: Iowa State Press, Blackwell Publishing. pp. 124–130.
- 19. Bester MN (1990) Reproduction in the male Subantarctic fur seal Arctocephalus tropicalis. J Zool Lond 222: 177–185.
- 20. Jansen van Vuuren B, Chown SL (2007) Genetic evidence confirms the origin of the house mouse on sub-Antarctic Marion Island. Polar Biol 30: 327–332.
- 21. Smith VR, Avenant NL, Chown SL (2002) The diet and impact of house mice on a Subantarctic island. Polar Biol 25: 703–715.
- 22. Matthewson DC, Van Aarde RJ, Skinner JD (1994) Population biology of house mice (Mus musculus L.) on Subantarctic Marion Island. S Afr J Zool 29: 99–106.
- 23. Hunter P, Swanepoel SP, Esterhuysen JJ, Raath JP, Bengis RG, et al. (1998) The efficacy of an experimental oil-adjuvanted encephalomyocarditis vaccine in elephants, mice and pigs. Vaccine 16: 55–61.
- 24. Avenant NL, Smith VR (2003) The microenvironment of house mice on Marion Island (sub-Antarctic). Polar Biol 26: 129–141.
- 25. Condy PR (1978) Distribution, abundance, and annual cycle of fur seals (Arctocephalus spp.) on the Prince Edward Islands. S Afr J Wildl Res 8: 159–168.
- 26. Miller EH (1975b) A comparative study of facial expressions of two species of pinnipeds. Behaviour LIII: 268–284.
- 27. Bastos ADS (1998) Detection and characterization of foot-and-mouth disease virus in sub-Saharan Africa. Onderstepoort J Vet Res 65: 37–47.
- 28. Vanderhallen H, Koenen F (1998) Identification of encephalomyocarditis virus in clinical samples by reverse transcription-PCR followed by genetic typing using sequence analysis. J Clin Microbiol 36: 3463–3467.
- 29. Kyu B, Matsumori A, Sato Y, Okada I, Chapman NM, et al. (1992) Cardiac persistence of cardioviral RNA detected by polymerase chain reaction in a murine model of dilated cardiomyopathy. Circulation 86: 522–530.
- 30. Nikkari S, Lopez FA, Lepp PW, Cieslak PR, Ladd-Wilson S, et al. (2002) Broad range bacterial detection and analysis of unexplained death and critical illness. Emerg Infect Dis 8: 188–194.
- 31. Cameron CE, Zuerner RL, Raverty S, Colegrove KM, Norman SA, et al. (2008) Detection of pathogenic Leptospira bacteria in pinniped populations via PCR and identification of a source of transmission for zoonotic Leptospirosis in the marine environment. J Clin Microbiol 46: 1728–1733.
- 32. Matthias MA, Díaz M, Campos KJ, Calderon M, Willig MR, et al. (2005) Diversity of bato-associated Leptospira in the Peruvian Amazon inferred by Bayesian phylogenetic analysis of 16S ribosomal DNA sequences. Am J Trop Med Hyg 73: 964–974.
- 33. La Scola B, Buil LTM, Baranton G, Khamis A, Raoult D (2006) Partial rpoB gene sequencing for identification of Leptospira species. FEMS Microbiol Lett 263: 142–147.
- 34. Tamura K, Dudley J, Nei M, Kumar S (2007) MEGA4: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis (MEGA) software version 4.0. Mol Biol Evol 24: 1596–1599.
- 35. Shin GY, Manuel RJ, Ghori S, Brecker S, Breathnach AS (2005) Molecular technique identifies the pathogen responsible for culture negative infective endocarditis. Heart 91: e47.
- 36. Baumann CD, Davidson WR, Roscoe DE, Beheler-Amass K (2001) Intracranial abscessation in white-tailed deer of North America. J Wildl Dis 37: 661–670.
- 37. Willoughby DS, Watson DW (1964) Host-parasite relationships among group A Streptococci: Influence of sex on the susceptibility of inbred mice toward Streptococcal infection. J Bacteriol 87: 1457–1461.
- 38. Howald G, Donlan CJ, Galván JP, Russel JC, Parkes J, et al. (2007) Invasive rodent eradications on islands. Cons Biol 21: 1258–1268.
- 39. Harvell CD, Kim K, Burkholder JM, Colwell RR, Epstein PR, et al. (1999) Emerging marine diseases-Climate links and anthropogenic factors. Science 285: 1505–1510.
- 40. Smith VR (2002) Climate change in the Subantarctic: an illustration from Marion Island. Clim Change 52: 345–357.