26 Feb 2011: Hennig BJ, Fielding K, Broxholme J, Diatta M, Mendy M, et al. (2011) Correction: Host Genetic Factors and Vaccine-Induced Immunity to Hepatitis B Virus Infection. PLOS ONE 6(2): 10.1371/annotation/0d903d46-1104-43b8-ae6b-4f2343bb3357. https://doi.org/10.1371/annotation/0d903d46-1104-43b8-ae6b-4f2343bb3357 View correction
Vaccination against hepatitis B virus infection (HBV) is safe and effective; however, vaccine-induced antibody level wanes over time. Peak vaccine-induced anti-HBs level is directly related to antibody decay, as well as risk of infection and persistent carriage despite vaccination. We investigated the role of host genetic factors in long-term immunity against HBV infection based on peak anti-HBs level and seroconversion to anti-HBc.
We analyzed 715 SNP across 133 candidate genes in 662 infant vaccinees from The Gambia, assessing peak vaccine-induced anti-HBs level and core antibody (anti-HBc) status, whilst adjusting for covariates. A replication study comprised 43 SNPs in a further 393 individuals.
In our initial screen we found variation in IFNG, MAPK8, and IL10RA to affect peak anti-HBs level (GMTratio of <0.6 or >1.5 and P≤0.001) and lesser associations in other genes. Odds of core-conversion was associated with variation in CD163. A coding change in ITGAL (R719V) with likely functional relevance showed evidence of association with increased peak anti-HBs level in both screens (1st screen: s595_22 GMTratio 1.71, P = 0.013; 2nd screen: s595_22 GMTratio 2.15, P = 0.011).
This is to our knowledge the largest study to date assessing genetic determinants of HBV vaccine-induced immunity. We report on associations with anti-HBs level, which is directly related to durability of antibody level and predictive of vaccine efficacy long-term. A coding change in ITGAL, which plays a central role in immune cell interaction, was shown to exert beneficial effects on induction of peak antibody level in response to HBV vaccination. Variation in this gene does not appear to have been studied in relation to immune responses to viral or vaccine challenges previously. Our findings suggest that genetic variation in loci other than the HLA region affect immunity induced by HBV vaccination.
Citation: Hennig BJ, Fielding K, Broxholme J, Diatta M, Mendy M, Moore C, et al. (2008) Host Genetic Factors and Vaccine-Induced Immunity to Hepatitis B Virus Infection. PLoS ONE 3(3): e1898. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0001898
Editor: Etienne Joly, Université de Toulouse, France
Received: December 7, 2007; Accepted: February 26, 2008; Published: March 26, 2008
Copyright: © 2008 Hennig et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: B.J.H. was supported by a Wellcome Trust Advanced Training Fellowship. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Persistent hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection affects 350 million people world-wide, with highest endemicity in Sub-Saharan Africa and China. It is estimated that around half a million die every year from end stage complications of persistent infection . Long-term studies in The Gambia aim to answer the question as to whether prevention of (early) HBV infection through infant vaccination reduces the incidence of persistent carriage and of subsequent hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) in later life –. In The Gambia vaccination was introduced in the mid 1980s and has been demonstrated to be safe and effective, however, the level of HBV vaccine-induced antibody decays exponentially over time, and this is irrespectively of the population immunised . The peak antibody level attained after vaccination is directly related to this uniform decay, as shown experimentally and through modelling , . Hence we have used peak anti-HBs as a surrogate for durability since we can predict from it the antibody level at any time point afterwards. High peak anti-HBs level correlates directly with protection against infection and persistent carriage . So whilst the anti-HBs level wanes with time since vaccination, the proportion of core-antibody (anti-HBc) positive individuals, i.e. those infected despite vaccination, increases and was shown to be >15% in the most recent surveys carried out (with up to 19 years of follow-up) , . This happens at a time when the risk of exposure is increasing due to the onset of sexual activity.
Little is known about host genetic determinants of immunity induced by infant HBV vaccination per se, and even less about the role of genetic variation in determining the duration of vaccine-induced immunity. Family and twin studies have established that genetic variability influences vaccine immunogenicity –. Höhler et al concluded from a twin study assessing the heritability of HBsAg vaccine response that genetic factors have a strong influence, with variation in the MHC playing an important role, but suggesting that more than half the heritability is determined by non-MHC genes . In The Gambia Newport and colleagues assessed the heritability of immune responses to several infant vaccines in twins and showed that the genetic contribution to antibody responses varied depending on the vaccine; for anti-HBs response the observed heritability was relatively high (77%) .
A number of studies have linked HLA class I, II and III variation to non-response or low response to hepatitis B vaccine –. The most consistent findings regarding high response are associations with DRB1*01 (DR1), DRB1*11 (DR5), DRB1*15 (DR2), DQB1*0501, DPB1*0401; non-response has been shown repeatedly to correlate with DRB1*03, DRB1*07, DQB1*02, DPB1*1101 , . However, very little indeed is published on HBV vaccine-induced immunogenicity regarding variation in non-HLA genes . Most of these studies are hampered by small sample sizes and a limited number of markers/genes screened, so we only have a snapshot understanding of what genetic factors are implicated in the control of HBV vaccine immunogenicity. Furthermore, different populations have been studied making comparisons difficult, and virtually none of these associations have been confirmed. Finally, although we know that peak anti-HBs level predicts long-term vaccine efficacy, what genetic factors may influence duration of protection has hardly been investigated and we do not know whether the genetic control of short-term immune responses as measured in most studies translate into durable immunity – it is likely that different genetic mechanisms underlie the control of immune memory.
This current study is, to our knowledge, the first project assessing this large a number of (non-HLA based) candidate genes and their possible effect on HBV vaccine-induced immunity. We obtained results on a total of 715 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) across 133 genes, and tested for association with peak anti-HBs level (directly correlated with durability of anti-HBs response, i.e. long-term vaccine efficacy, protection against infection and persistent carriage) and anti-HBc status (indication of infection despite vaccination) in a study sample of 662 infant vaccinees from The Gambia who have been followed-up for close to two decades. We report here on the findings from this study, together with a replication study comprising 43 SNPs in 393 further individuals from the same population.
Materials and Methods
Recruitment was carried out in 2003 in the West Kiang region in The Gambia as part of the survey to determine HBV vaccine efficacy 19 years post vaccination, and in particular to evaluate of the magnitude and duration of protective antibody responses induced by infant HBV vaccination . Findings from earlier studies in the same region (1985, 1989, 1993, and 1998) including information on demographics, medical background and epidemiological data have been published previously , –. Briefly, children born within the area covered by the MRC Unit in Keneba (West-Kiang, The Gambia) vaccinated within the HBV vaccination programme were considered eligible for the present study. The recruitment was restricted to non-infected individuals, only confirmed non-immune children <5 years old had been recruited prior to 1985 and from there onwards all study participants were vaccinated at birth, i.e. are deemed anti-HBc negative (perinatal transmission of HBV infection is very rare in this population).
This genetic study was carried out in two stages: The first screen study participants comprised all individuals identified as anti-HBc positive on at least one survey (i.e. ever positive) and, where possible, two randomly selected age-group matched consistently anti-HBc negative individuals. All other individuals, who by definition were anti-HBc negative, were included in the second stage, which was designed with the aim to replicate the ‘top’ results from the first screen. Exclusion criteria were: no information on peak anti-HBs level or date, peak anti-HBs measurement time less than one month after the last vaccination (anti-HBs is thought to peak at 1 month after the last dose), no information on number of doses of vaccine and age >5 yrs at time of last vaccination. Study participants originated from three main villages Keneba, Manduar and Kantonkunda and a small number of individuals from other villages or visitors to the region, all of whom had been included in the vaccine programme. Vaccination groups up to 2002 reflect type of vaccine, administration route and time period during which a regime was used (see Table 1); accordingly there is a direct relationship between vaccine group and date of birth (i.e. age of vaccinee). The number of individual belonging to vaccine group 6 was small (n = 2) and these were thus excluded from the analysis. The number of vaccine doses received was grouped into ≤3 (containing a small number of two and one dose recipients) versus 4 doses. An overview of selection/exclusion criteria is given in Supplementary Figure S1.
We studied two outcome measures in the 1st screen (i) peak anti-HBs level as quantitative variable and (ii) anti-HBs status as binary variable, and for the 2nd screen peak anti-HBs level only. Additional screen specific exclusion of samples and covariate frequency distribution with corresponding geometric mean titer (GMT) of peak anti-HBs for each of the two sample sets are described below and are summarized in Table 1.
This project was approved by the joint Gambia Government/MRC Ethics Committee, as well as LSHTM and Oxford University (OXTREC) Ethics Committees. All subjects and/or legal guardians provided written, informed consent.
1st screen study participants.
The total available sample for the first screen with complete data on covariates was 662, these were included in the assessment of peak anti-HBs level. The number of individuals included in the analysis of anti-HBc status was reduced to 594, because we decided to confine the analysis to a clear-cut binary outcome of consistently anti-HBc positive versus consistently negative individuals. Thus, we excluded individuals who were reconverters (n = 61; 9.3%), i.e. those shown to have lost core-antibody positivity over the course of follow-up, and those who presented with variable anti-HBc status over time (n = 7). The group of individuals with less than 3 doses of vaccine included two individuals with two doses only. The mean age of the whole 1st screen sample was 13.4 years (range 1.2 to 22.9 years) and consisted of 377 sibships with up to seven siblings, 27.1% of these sibships comprised just one individual; relatedness was accounted for in the analysis.
2nd screen study participants.
The sample available for analysis for the 2nd screen was 393 individuals with complete data on covariates, the mean age was 7.4 years (range 1.1 to 16.2 years). These individuals tended to be younger and all were consistently anti-HBc negative, due to the initial selection procedure applied for the 1st screen (see above). The group of individuals with less than 3 doses of vaccine included six with two doses and one with one dose. The 2nd screen sample consisted of 277 sibships with up to five siblings, 42.2% of these contained only one individual. There were no individuals representative of vaccine group 1 and 2 in this sample (due to the younger mean age) and because groups 3 and 6 consisted of very few individuals, the five participants belonging to these vaccine groups were excluded.
Vaccinations and serological assessment
Vaccination types and regimes changed over time (as shown in Table 1). The median measurement time between last vaccination and peak antibody level assessment was 9 weeks (range 5.0 to 57.2 weeks). At each survey time point, concentrations of core antibody (anti-HBc) and, if found to be positive, hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) and HBeAg were assessed, as described previously .
Infection was defined as the presence of anti-HBc with at least 30% inhibition, as stipulated by the manufacturer (Sorin Biochemica or DiaSorin). If infection was found only during a single follow-up time point and was not confirmed subsequently, the person was considered to have had a transient infection. Carriage was defined as the detection of HBsAg on two separate occasions at least six months apart. Primary vaccine failure was defined as a peak anti-HBs response of <10 mIU/mL; a responder was defined as a vaccinee with a peak anti-HBs response of ≥10 mIU/mL. The proportion of HBsAg positive (n = 21), anti-HBeAg positive (n = 7) and persistent carriers (n = 7) in the total sample was too small for a subgroup analysis of these parameters.
DNA extraction from whole blood or PBMCs was carried out using a standard salting-out method . Genotyping assays for the initial screen were run on the Illumina BeadArray platform (www.illumina.com). Our candidate gene selection criteria were based on literature searches, previous reported genetic associations with vaccine-induced antibody level (in particular with anti-HBs), possible biological implication in immune-regulatory processes, inclusion of gene families and coverage of regulatory pathways. The selection of 768 single nucleotide polymorphism (SNPs) for genotyping was based on HapMap frequency data, validation, anticipated success rate on the Illumina platform, gene size, distribution across loci, enrichment in coding changes, inclusion of sequence 500 bp up- and down-stream of each gene. Just over 95% of our candidate polymorphisms were SNPs genotyped in both Yoruba (YRI) and Caucasians (CEU) as part of the HapMap project (http://www.hapmap.org/), many of these variants are tag SNPs in either or both of these populations.
Linkage disequilibrium (LD) and haplotype blocks were assessed using the Haploview programme (http://www.broad.mit.edu/mpg/haploview/) applying default parameters according to Gabriel et al . To account for markers with low minor allele frequency (MAF) we employed r2 as measure of LD throughout and considered an r2 value of 0 to 0.5 as low, 0.5 to 0.75 as intermediate and >0.75 as strong LD. The FASTSNP programme (http://fastsnp.ibms.sinica.edu.tw/pages/input_CandidateGeneSearch.jsp) was employed to establish whether SNPs were of functional relevance .
The 2nd screen genotyping was carried out using the Sequenom platform (iPlex and hME; http://www.sequenom.de/). The aim was to replicate the results from the first screen by concentrating on the ‘top’ markers in the remainder of the sample set.
Validated demographic and serological data was available as an Access 2000 database from the MRC's long-term hepatitis B vaccination programme . All statistical analysis was conducted using Stata software (version 9; StataCorp) and employed forward regression models to determine the role of genetic markers on outcomes, with inclusion of individual SNPs into the (multi-marker) gene/locus models according to LD structure. No adjustment for multiple comparisons was made. Almost 95% of individuals were Mandinka, ethnicity was thus not considered informative enough for stratification of the study cohort by ethnic groups.
This society is polygamous, thus resulting in a complex pedigree structure, e.g. presence of a large proportion of half-sibs. Consequently, clustering by sibship was determined by maternal ID in order to account for relatedness. For polymorphisms with a low MAF heterozygotes and homozygotes were grouped for the analysis if there were less than 10 individuals in the latter genotype category by outcome measure. Genetic variation was entered in the analysis as categorical genotype data with 11 representing ancestral homozygotes, 12 representing heterozygotes and 22 representing variant homozygotes. Two outcome measures were assessed: (i) peak anti-HBs level and (ii) anti-HBc status.
i) Peak anti-HBs.
From the peak anti-HBs level we can predict the persistence of antibody level at any time point afterwards, peak anti-HBs is also a predictor of risk of infection and persistent carriage. Peak anti-HBs was not normally distributed and thus log-transformed for the analysis. Multiple linear regression, including robust standard errors to account for relatedness by sibship, was used to identify covariates associated with log peak anti-HBs level. The model included as covariates the logarithm of measurement time (i.e. duration of time between last vaccination and peak anti-HBs measurement to account for the exponential decay of anti-HBs over time), vaccine group (i.e. type, regime, administration route, year), number of doses (≤3 versus 4), age group at recruitment (5 year intervals), village (Keneba, Manduar, Kantonkunda+others), gender and relatedness. Results are summarized as the ratio of the geometric mean titer (GMT), associated 95% confidence intervals (CI) and P-values.
ii) Anti-HBc status.
Consistent core antibody positive individuals were defined as those who had been identified as anti-HBc positive at any time point and remained positive at subsequent surveys and compared to subjects who were consistently negative for anti-HBc over the course of time; reconverters and variables were excluded (see above). Multiple conditional logistic regression, including robust standard errors to account for relatedness by sibship, was used to identify covariates associated with being core antibody positive. The model for anti-HBc status accounted for peak anti-HBs level (as surrogate measure for vaccine group, anti-HBs measurement time, number of vaccine doses), age group at recruitment (5 year intervals), village (Keneba, Manduar, Kantonkunda+others), and gender as covariates. Results are reported as odds ratios (OR), with associated 95% CI and P-values.
The statistical analysis for the 2nd screen was carried out in an identical manner to that of the 1st screen for anti-HBs level as the outcome. The distribution of covariates for the 2nd screen was slightly different in terms of age and vaccine group distribution (see below).
Genetic analysis of 1st screen data
Overall 739/768 SNP assays produced good quality data (failure rate 3.8%). Twenty SNPs were monomorphic or had a MAF of <1% and were excluded from the analysis. The remaining SNPs were distributed across 133 candidate genes with a varying number of markers per gene (shown in supplementary Table S1), covering all chromosomes except 15 and 18. The average genotyping success rate across all markers was 99.5% (ranging from 71.2–100.0%). Four SNPs had a failure rate >10% and were excluded leaving a total of 715 SNPs for analysis.
Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (HWE) calculation was based on one randomly selected individual from each sibship. Of the 715 SNPs available for the statistical analysis 40 (5.6%) were shown to diverge from HWE (P range 1.5E-27 to 0.5). At the P<0.05 level we expect to find approximately 36 SNPs to be out of HWE, the observed number of markers diverging from HWE is therefore comparable to the expected number. There was no obvious clustering of SNPs out of HWE, or a trend for excess presence of one particular genotype across these polymorphisms. Markers not in HWE are only discussed further if a positive association with either outcome measure was found.
Statistical analysis of 1st screen data
i) peak anti-HBs level.
Basic model for peak anti-HBs level for 1st screen
In all models, including the basic model (i.e. excluding genetic factors, see Table 2A), a strong effect of vaccine group and measurement time was seen on peak anti-HBs as quantitative outcome measure. Overall, the adjusted GMT was between 60–94% lower in all vaccination groups compared to the reference group 4 (P≤0.001). This was expected and previously described as part of the HBV vaccine efficacy studies in this population . The adjusted correlation coefficient for the decline of anti-HBs level with time since last vaccination (measurement time) was −0.99 (95%CI: −1.51 to −0.47). No effect was seen with number of vaccine doses (≤3 vs 4) upon inclusion or exclusion of the few individuals with only two doses of vaccine (data not shown). Village seemed to show a trend towards association, with individuals born in Kantonkunda presenting with a slightly decreased vaccine-induced antibody level. This result did not change upon exclusion of the 33 individuals from other villages or visitors to the region, who had been grouped with Kantonkunda for the analysis (data not shown). Neither gender nor age at recruitment (range 1.2 to 22.9 years) showed an effect on peak anti-HBs level.
Adjusted genetic models for peak anti-HBs for 1st screen
Out of a total of 133 screened genes we identified host genetic variation in three candidate genes to affect peak vaccine-induced antibody level using a cut-off of size of effect (ratio of GMT) of <0.6 or >1.5 and P≤0.001 in the multi-marker models adjusted for covariates, namely: MAPK8, IL10RA, and IFNG (see Table 3). For these three genes the multi-marker models indicated a similar modification of GMT, but with reduced significance compared to single SNP models (data not shown).
Carriage of the variant allele for s523, which is located just outside the 3′UTR, was associated with a two times increase in anti-HBs level (P = 0.0001), FastSNP predicts this polymorphism to be of functional relevance. The two screened markers in IFNG showed low pairwise LD (r2 = 0.27), and the associated SNP (s523) was not in LD with markers in neighbouring genes, i.e. IRAK3 upstream, or IL26 and IL22 downstream. We therefore suspect this to be an independent association within the IFNG locus.
A SNPs in MAPK8, s419 (intronic), demonstrated a linear trend of carriage of the variant allele with 40–60% reduction in anti-HBs level (P = 0.0003). A second marker, s421, which is in almost complete LD with s419 (r2 = 0.99) gave the same results (data not shown). Both these SNPs showed low to intermediate LD (r2≤0.5) with four neighboring markers genotyped, but the possibility that another functional variant lies upstream or downstream and is in LD with SNP s419 or s421 cannot be excluded.
In IL10RA only s481 (intron 6) was associated with increased GMT of anti-HBs level and this appeared to be heterozygote protection effect (GMTratio of 1.75, P = 0.001). We observed low LD across the whole length of this gene covered with our set of four SNPs and no LD with neighboring genes tested, so if s481 is in LD with a functional variant it is likely to be very nearby.
Associations of single SNPs in several other genes that had a lesser effect on anti-HBs level, and those taken forward to the 2nd screen are shown in supplementary Table S2; this includes ITGAL (see below and Table 3).
ii) anti-HBc status.
Basic model for anti-HBc status for 1st screen
In the basic model employing the binary outcome measure of core antibody status (see Table 2B) peak anti-HBs level (surrogate for vaccine group and measurement time) clearly affected the risk of core-conversion, with an about 30% increase in being core antibody positive per log decrease of peak anti-HBs level (P = 4.83E-13). The older age groups (>15 years) were more likely to present as anti-HBc positive. A trend towards risk of core-conversion was seen in individuals born in Kantonkunda (excluding the ‘others’ did not change this significantly, data not shown) and to an even lesser extent in males compared with females.
Adjusted genetic models for anti-HBc positivity for 1st screen
We identified CD163 as gene to play a role in determining anti-HBc status although polymorphisms in several other genes were also associated with an increased/decreased risk of core-conversion with a reduced size of effect or significance level (see Table 3). The single SNP analysis showed a dose-dependent risk of core-conversion with carriage of the minor allele for CD163 s503 (intron 12); in the multi-SNP analysis this effect seems to be enhanced in the presence of s504 (Ile to Val change at codon 342, r2 = 0.56 with s503) with an up to 7- or 4-fold higher risk of core-conversion for those homozygous for the minor allele of s503 and s504, respectively (Table 3). There was no to low LD with markers further upstream in the same gene and its neighbor GNB3, however, there may be further SNPs correlated with s503 and/or s504 downstream in a region not covered in this study.
Inclusion/exclusion of the seven persistent carriers from the anti-HBc positives did not alter the findings for the basic or adjusted genetic models significantly (data not shown).
Genetic analysis of 2nd screen data
For the second round of genotyping we concentrated on those SNPs that had been shown to increase/decrease the GMT of anti-HBs level in the 1st screen by a factor of 1.5 and/or be associated at the level of P<0.005. Alternative SNPs were genotyped if technical difficulties using the 2nd screen Sequenom genotyping platform were encountered. We also re-screened a few polymorphisms that had shown an effect on anti-HBc status (although the remainder of our samples did not comprise any anti-HBc positive individuals). A total of 50 ‘top’ SNPs were selected, as listed in Supplementary Table S3, of these three failed at the design stage and four failed outright for technical reasons. We obtained good genotyping data for 43 of the ‘top’ SNPs with an average genotyping success rate of 94.8% (ranging from 74.9–99.7%). One SNPs out of these 43 diverged from HWE at the P = 0.05 level.
Basic model for peak anti-HBs level for 2nd screen.
For the 2nd screen all models including the basic model (i.e. excluding genetic factors, see Table 2A) showed an effect of vaccine group and measurement time on anti-HBs level, as expected and as seen in the 1st screen. Age group, number of doses, gender and village did not appear to influence the vaccine-induced antibody level.
Adjusted genetic models for peak anti-HBs for 2nd screen.
A summary of the results for the single SNP analysis for the replication study is shown in supplementary Table S4. Out of the total of 43 ‘top’ SNP re-screened we identified one SNP (s595) in ITGAL that appeared to influence peak anti-HBs level. The results for the s595 SNP are comparable in both screens (1st screen: s595_22 GMTratio of 1.71, P = 0.013; 2nd screen: s595_22 GMTratio of 2.15, P = 0.011; Table 3). The s595 polymorphism is a non-synonymous coding change in exon 21 (R791T) and is predicted to affect splicing regulation (FASTSNP prediction). R791T is not in LD with any of the other four screened SNPs in ITGAL (r2≤0.1), we thus hypothesize that this is an independent association of a genetic variant that is likely to be functionally relevant.
Other markers screened in the 2nd sample set appeared to increase/decrease the GMT level by more than 1.5-fold, but only showed a trend for association (see supplementary Table S4).
An assessment vaccine non-response (anti-HBs <10IU/ml, primary vaccine failure) was not possible due to lack of power given the small number of non-responders present (N = 47 in 1st and 2nd screen combined). The great majority of study participants were of Mandinka origin and ethnicity was not adjusted for in the analysis. However, inclusion/exclusion of the 26 individuals of other ethnicity from the analysis did not alter significantly the results for the basic or adjusted models for peak anti-HBs level or anti-HBc status (data not shown).
Hepatitis B vaccine-induced immunity is promoted by the presentation of HBsAg via HLA class II molecules on antigen-presenting cells to CD4 T helper cells, thereby triggering HBsAg-specific B cells to proliferate and differentiate into anti-HBs producing cells (primary immune response). Longer term both memory T and B cells are generated, which are responsible for subsequent anti-HBs release in response to later infections (secondary immune responses). Immune memory to HBV is crucially dependent on this rapid antibody release to neutralize the challenge posed by circulating virus. Very little is known about how durable immune memory is maintained, especially in the absence of often undetectable primary vaccine-induced anti-HBs level several years post immunization. However, peak anti-HBs level induced by vaccination is directly related to a uniform decay of antibody level over time irrespectively of population, and predictive of vaccine efficacy long-term. In The Gambia protection against infection was reported to be 83.4% and against persistent carriage to be 96.5% 19 years post vaccination . The present study aimed to investigate whether host genetic factors affect durable vaccine-induced immunity (as predicted by peak anti-HBs level) to HBV infection in The Gambia. An initial screen obtained results on 715 SNPs in 133 genes in 662 infant vaccinees and the replication screen comprised data on 43 SNPs in 393 individuals from the same population.
Based on our basic models, without genetic factors, our overall findings regarding the effect of vaccine group, measurement time, vaccine dose, age group, village and gender were as expected for both our outcome measures and are in line with previous surveys in the West-Kiang region . We saw a strong effect of vaccine group (reflecting vaccine type, regime, route and year of administration) and time elapsed between last vaccine dose and measurement of peak anti-HBs (measurement time) on peak anti-HBs level (Table 2A). None of the other covariates influenced vaccine-induced antibody level substantially.
Individuals positive for anti-HBc despite vaccination in infancy are considered to be core-converters or to have had a ‘breakthrough’ infection. Because all individuals included in our study were considered anti-HBc negative at the time of recruitment, we believe that bias due to infection prior to immunization is not an issue in our analysis. We assessed anti-HBc status in the initial screen only and observed that anti-HBs level (employed as surrogate for vaccine group and measurement time) had the strongest effect on anti-HBc status, whilst gender and village only showed weak associations (Table 2B), as expected. Older individuals appeared more prone to core-conversion, and this higher risk in older age groups could be due to either decreased level of vaccine-induced anti-HBs level or an increased level of exposure through sexual transmission (especially through contact with unvaccinated individuals) or both. Unfortunately we do not have any measure of exposure, other than age as potential indicator of onset of sexual activity, and this could have biased our findings. Due to small numbers present we excluded individuals who had re-converted or presented with variable anti-HBc results, although these would be an interesting sub-group for further investigation.
The HLA region is the most extensively studied area to date with regard to HBV vaccine-induced immunity and relatively consistent data has been reported –. However, reports on other candidate loci are very limited. Polymorphisms in members of the IL1 gene family, IL2, IL4, IL6, IL10, IL12β, TNFα, GNB3, and haptoglobin have all been implicated in affecting the magnitude or kinetics of HBV vaccine-induced antibody response or lymphocyte proliferation –. We concentrated our focus mostly on novel candidate genes outside the MHC region, although our 133 screened genes did include the above mentioned previously screened genes with exception of TNFα and IL2 (see Supplementary Table S1). Our candidate gene selection was based on molecules that are known or likely to influence the regulation of HBV vaccine-induced immune responses such as those involved in pathogen uptake and recognition, antigen processing and presentation, as well as effector and memory T and B cell function (for full list see supplementary Table S1). We hypothesize that host genetic variation could affect increased/decreased peak anti-HBs level, thus indirectly influencing the risk of core conversion, or directly affect susceptibility to infection despite vaccination (as well as potentially re-conversion) and there may be interaction between genes affecting these outcomes (for further details see supplementary Figure S2).
In addition to vaccine group and measurement time (and to a lesser degree village) we found genetic factors to affect our outcomes. Through our 1st screen we identified variation in three candidates (MAPK8, IFNG and IL10RA) that play a role in HBV vaccine-induced immunity by affecting the peak anti-HBs level and polymorphisms in CD163 appeared to affect anti-HBc status (all analyses adjusted for covariates, GMTratio or OR of <0.6 or >1.5 and P≤0.001; Table 3). These and further SNPs in other genes showing reduced size of effect or significance level we followed-up in a 2nd screen (see supplementary Table S2). We did not confirm any previously reported associations in our native African population.
IFNγ is produced by activated T lymphocytes in response to intracellular pathogen challenge. It plays a central role in immune-regulatory processes, e.g. by activating macrophages and potentiating antiviral effects of type I IFNs, and thus is crucial in the cell-mediated immunity. A recent study by Yang et al showed that persistent HBV carriers mounted a detectable HBV-specific IFNγ response to a HBV-derived DNA vaccine and this response was observed for at least 40 weeks as a function of CD4+ memory T-cells . Our result suggests that genetically determined differences in IFNγ activity could impact on the magnitude of immune responses to HBV vaccination.
MAPK8 (JNK1) is a kinase which functions within the TLR pathway by promoting the phosphorylation of transcription factors such as c-Jun and ATF2, following stimulation with pro-inflammatory cytokines. A study by Vanlandschoot and colleagues reported reduced phosphorylation of MAPK8 kinase in response to rHBsAg in LPS-stimulated PBMCs . It appears that MAPK8 is primarily involved in the differentiation of T helper into Th1 cells and maintaining their survival during antiviral immune responses . This Th1 mediated favoring of cell-mediated immune responses could be a possible mechanism underlying the association MAPK8 variation with reduced antibody generation following HBV vaccination.
The involvement of IL10RA in immune responses induced by HBV vaccination is also plausible, given that IL10RA is a receptor which mediates the effects of IL10, and IL10 was shown to correlate with immune responses to HBV vaccination . We observed IL10RA variation to have a beneficial effect by leading to increased vaccine-induced anti-HBs level.
The risk of core-conversion despite vaccination was substantially increased in a dose-dependent manner by SNPs in CD163 in our study population. CD163 is a macrophage hemoglobin scavenger receptor involved in acute phase response regulation; it can be induced by IL6, IL10, TLR2 and TLR5, and is suppressed by pro-inflammatory mediators including IFNγ and TNFα. . Reduced levels of IFNγ and TLRs may therefore lead to increased level of CD163 and raised level of CD163 have been reported in patients with persistent hepatitis infection . Our dataset contained seven carriers, but our findings did not change significantly upon inclusion or exclusion of these individuals.
Overall the findings from the replication study did not provide support for the three strongest associations identified in the first screen, perhaps in part as a result of the smaller sample size in the replication study. However, the 2nd screen replicated an association with host genetic variation in ITGAL, a gene which did show association in the 1st screen albeit at a reduced significance level; evidence of correlation with vaccine-induced antibody level was seen for s595. This SNP is a common non-synonymous coding change (R719T; rs2230433; MAF = 38%) and a similar effect size, i.e. an about 2-fold increase in anti-HBs level, was observed in both screens in individuals homozygote for the variant allele encoding for Threonine (1st screen: s595_22 GMTratio of 1.71, P = 0.013; 2nd screen s595_22 GMTratio of 2.15, P = 0.011, see Table 3). Our result for this polymorphism is thus the only true replication in the present study. However, we cannot exclude the possibility of this being a chance finding given the number of tests carried out. Lymphocyte function-associated antigen-1 (LFA1) consists of two subunits ITGAL (also known as LFA1A or CD11a) and ITGB2. ITGAL binds to ICAMs and regulates processes such as leukocyte-endothelial cell interaction, cytotoxic T-cell mediated killing, and antibody dependent killing by granulocytes and monocytes. Despite its central role in immune cell interaction no study assessing responses to viral or vaccine challenges prior to this appears to have assessed host genetic variation in ITGAL. The R791T variant lies within the integrin-alpha-2 domain of the gene, which forms interactions with EGF2, FG-GAP and Integrin_B_tail domains and this SNP is predicted to be involved in splicing regulation, i.e. to play an important role functionally. It would now be of interest to assess this R791T variant for association in an independent sample set of HBV vaccinees or with responses to other vaccines or other diseases that are immunologically mediated.
Lack of power due to small sample numbers prevented us from assessing possible genetic effects on vaccine non-response (primary vaccine failure). Almost 95% of our study population was Mandinka. Ethnicity was not adjusted in our analysis, but inclusion/exclusion of individuals of other ethnic origin did not change any of our results significantly.
There are some limitations to our study: The number of polymorphisms tested in the second sample is small and for technical reasons we could not obtain data for all ‘top’ SNPs identified through the 1st screen. The sample size was about 40% smaller and only one out of our two outcome measures, peak anti-HBs level, could be assessed. The reduced power may explain why our findings from the 2nd screen showed reduced level of significance, although the effect size was comparable for a number of markers followed-up. It is possible that natural boosting through exposure to HBV is a determinant of anti-HBs persistence and we had no means of addressing this specifically in our study. However, a recent vaccine boost study in The Gambia reported on low pre-boost anti-HBs levels suggesting that natural boosting is likely to play a limited role .
The strength of our study lies primarily in the availability of good serological and demographic data from infant HBV vaccinees followed up long-term. There is no comparable sample cohort in Africa as far as we are aware. The sole similar study of HBV vaccine efficacy long-term is the Qidong HBV vaccine trial in China, for which data has only been published based on the 5-year follow-up so far . A novel aspect of this present project is the reasonably large number of polymorphisms (715) genotyped across a total of 133 genes located outside the MHC region, the great majority of which have never before been tested as candidate genes in HBV vaccine-induced immunity. We believe it is important to concentrate on novel candidate genes, given that the heritability of non-HLA genes has been estimated to range between 35–50% for immunity induced by HBV vaccination , .
Findings from studies such as this will help us to increase our understanding of mechanisms underlying vaccine-induced immunity and possible natural immunity to infection. This could lead to the development of genetic markers as correlates of protection. More importantly this type of investigation could help the development of new and improved vaccines, e.g. through use of adjuvants targeting pathways identified through genetic studies, that could eventually lead to life-long protection and reduce the proportion of vaccine failures.
Schematic representation of role of host genetic factors in vaccine-induced immunity to HBV. This figure is a schematic diagram of HBV vaccine-induced immunity assessment employing peak anti-HBs level and anti-HBc status as outcome measures. Assuming host genetic variation (here SNP1) correlates with increased/decreased peak anti-HBs level, this in turn indirectly and inversely affects increased/decreased risk of core conversion. To determine whether SNP1 also directly affects anti-HBc status we test for association with anti-HBc status whilst adjusting for anti-HBs level. Simultaneously, there may be other polymorphisms (here SNP2), exerting a direct effect on the risk of core-conversion. There may or may not be interaction between the genes in which these SNPs are located. Additionally, genetic variants modulating the immune-response to HBV vaccination may also affect susceptibility to infection, or other polymorphisms (SNP3) or confounders may lead to a counter effect by increasing the likelihood of infection in the presence of protective vaccine-induced antibody, thus further complicating this scenario. Finally, core antibody positive individuals may over time re-convert, which could be controlled directly or indirectly through genetic factors. In our study only vaccinated individuals with no indication of infection prior to immunization were included, as such there was no scope to assess susceptibility to infection, but simultaneously we believe there was no bias due to infection at the time of recruitment. Furthermore, we excluded individuals who lost anti-HBc positivity or had presented with variable anti-HBc status over the course of follow-up in order to work with a clear-cut distinction of those consistently positive versus consistently negative for anti-HBc.
(0.06 MB TIF)
Outline of study set-up with sample selection and exclusion criteria. For further details see Materials and Methods (study participants).
(0.06 MB TIF)
Details for SNPs in 1st screen
(0.16 MB XLS)
Single SNP analysis results for 1nd screen for markers taken forward to 2nd screen
(0.04 MB XLS)
Details for SNPs in 2nd screen
(0.03 MB XLS)
In memoriam: Steve Bennett (1950–2003). We are most grateful to the population of the West-Kiang region in The Gambia who participated in this study. Special thanks to all fieldworkers, drivers, data and laboratory staff in The Gambia, particularly Alieu Mendy, who made this project possible. We also thank Ruhul Amin, Aveika Akum, Denise Brocklebank, Tony Fulford, Jahid Hassan, Andrew Morris and Sanyan Sankung for their advice and help with database and analytical aspects of the work. Thanks also goes to Chris Allan and Julie Alipaz for their support in the coordination of genotyping.
Conceived and designed the experiments: AH Mv BH AH CM. Performed the experiments: BH MM PR. Analyzed the data: BH PW. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: AH GS HW BH AH CM JB KF AP. Wrote the paper: AH Mv BH AH. Other: Advised on analysis: KF. Assisted with bioinformatics aspects of analysis: JB. Coordination of DNA extractions and storage: MD. Sample shipment: MD. DNA database management: MD. HBV serology: MM. Sample collection: PR. Management of DNA bank: GS. Epidemiologist on study: Mv. Database management: PW. Epidemiologist: SZ. Principal investigator of study: BH.
- 1. WHO (2000) Hepatitis B fact sheet.
- 2. Whittle HC, Inskip H, Hall AJ, Mendy M, Downes R, et al. (1991) Vaccination against hepatitis B and protection against chronic viral carriage in The Gambia. Lancet 337: 747–750.
- 3. Chotard J, Inskip HM, Hall AJ, Loik F, Mendy M, et al. (1992) The Gambia Hepatitis Intervention Study: follow-up of a cohort of children vaccinated against hepatitis B. J Infect Dis 166: 764–768.
- 4. Fortuin M, Chotard J, Jack AD, Maine NP, Mendy M, et al. (1993) Efficacy of hepatitis B vaccine in the Gambian expanded programme on immunisation. Lancet 341: 1129–1131.
- 5. Fortuin M, Karthigesu V, Allison L, Howard C, Hoare S, et al. (1994) Breakthrough infections and identification of a viral variant in Gambian children immunized with hepatitis B vaccine. J Infect Dis 169: 1374–1376.
- 6. Whittle HC, Maine N, Pilkington J, Mendy M, Fortuin M, et al. (1995) Long-term efficacy of continuing hepatitis B vaccination in infancy in two Gambian villages. Lancet 345: 1089–1092.
- 7. Viviani S, Jack A, Hall AJ, Maine N, Mendy M, et al. (1999) Hepatitis B vaccination in infancy in The Gambia: protection against carriage at 9 years of age. Vaccine 17: 2946–2950.
- 8. Whittle H, Jaffar S, Wansbrough M, Mendy M, Dumpis U, et al. (2002) Observational study of vaccine efficacy 14 years after trial of hepatitis B vaccination in Gambian children. Bmj 325: 569.
- 9. van der Sande MA, Waight P, Mendy M, Rayco-Solon P, Hutt P, et al. (2006) Long-term protection against carriage of hepatitis B virus after infant vaccination. J Infect Dis 193: 1528–1535.
- 10. Jack AD, Hall AJ, Maine N, Mendy M, Whittle HC (1999) What level of hepatitis B antibody is protective? J Infect Dis 179: 489–492.
- 11. Inskip HM, Hall AJ, Chotard J, Loik F, Whittle H (1991) Hepatitis B vaccine in the Gambian Expanded Programme on Immunization: factors influencing antibody response. Int J Epidemiol 20: 764–769.
- 12. van der Sande MA, Waight PA, Mendy M, Zaman S, Kaye S, et al. (2007) Long-term protection against HBV chronic carriage of Gambian adolescents vaccinated in infancy and immune response in HBV booster trial in adolescence. PLoS ONE 2: e753.
- 13. Lin TM, Chen CJ, Wu MM, Yang CS, Chen JS, et al. (1989) Hepatitis B virus markers in Chinese twins. Anticancer Res 9: 737–741.
- 14. Alper CA (1995) The human immune response to hepatitis B surface antigen. Exp Clin Immunogenet 12: 171–181.
- 15. Kruger A, Adams P, Hammer J, Bocher WO, Schneider PM, et al. (2005) Hepatitis B surface antigen presentation and HLA-DRB1*- lessons from twins and peptide binding studies. Clin Exp Immunol 140: 325–332.
- 16. Hohler T, Reuss E, Evers N, Dietrich E, Rittner C, et al. (2002) Differential genetic determination of immune responsiveness to hepatitis B surface antigen and to hepatitis A virus: a vaccination study in twins. Lancet 360: 991–995.
- 17. Newport MJ, Goetghebuer T, Weiss HA, Whittle H, Siegrist CA, et al. (2004) Genetic regulation of immune responses to vaccines in early life. Genes Immun 5: 122–129.
- 18. Ovsyannikova IG, Jacobson RM, Poland GA (2004) Variation in vaccine response in normal populations. Pharmacogenomics 5: 417–427.
- 19. De Silvestri A, Pasi A, Martinetti M, Belloni C, Tinelli C, et al. (2001) Family study of non-responsiveness to hepatitis B vaccine confirms the importance of HLA class III C4A locus. Genes Immun 2: 367–372.
- 20. Desombere I, Cao T, Gijbels Y, Leroux-Roels G (2005) Non-responsiveness to hepatitis B surface antigen vaccines is not caused by defective antigen presentation or a lack of B7 co-stimulation. Clin Exp Immunol 140: 126–137.
- 21. Desombere I, Hauser P, Rossau R, Paradijs J, Leroux-Roels G (1995) Nonresponders to hepatitis B vaccine can present envelope particles to T lymphocytes. J Immunol 154: 520–529.
- 22. Hatae K, Kimura A, Okubo R, Watanabe H, Erlich HA, et al. (1992) Genetic control of nonresponsiveness to hepatitis B virus vaccine by an extended HLA haplotype. Eur J Immunol 22: 1899–1905.
- 23. Hohler T, Meyer CU, Notghi A, Stradmann-Bellinghausen B, Schneider PM, et al. (1998) The influence of major histocompatibility complex class II genes and T-cell Vbeta repertoire on response to immunization with HBsAg. Hum Immunol 59: 212–218.
- 24. Hohler T, Stradmann-Bellinghausen B, Starke R, Sanger R, Victor A, et al. (2002) C4A deficiency and nonresponse to hepatitis B vaccination. J Hepatol 37: 387–392.
- 25. Martinetti M, De Silvestri A, Belloni C, Pasi A, Tinelli C, et al. (2000) Humoral response to recombinant hepatitis B virus vaccine at birth: role of HLA and beyond. Clin Immunol 97: 234–240.
- 26. McDermott AB, Zuckerman JN, Sabin CA, Marsh SG, Madrigal JA (1997) Contribution of human leukocyte antigens to the antibody response to hepatitis B vaccination. Tissue Antigens 50: 8–14.
- 27. Sullivan JS, Hanna JN (1999) A genetic marker associated with non-response to recombinant hepatitis B vaccine by indigenous Australian children. J Paediatr Child Health 35: 412–413.
- 28. Vidan-Jeras B, Brinovec V, Jurca B, Levicnik Steyinar S, Jeras M, et al. (2000) The contribution of HLA-Class II antigens in humoral non-response and delayed response to HBsAG vaccination. Pflugers Arch 440: R188–189.
- 29. Milich DR, Leroux-Roels GG (2003) Immunogenetics of the response to HBsAg vaccination. Autoimmun Rev 2: 248–257.
- 30. Thursz M (2001) MHC and the viral hepatitides. Qjm 94: 287–291.
- 31. Kimman TG, Vandebriel RJ, Hoebee B (2007) Genetic variation in the response to vaccination. Community Genet 10: 201–217.
- 32. Whittle HC, Bradley AK, McLauchlan K, Ajdukiewicz AB, Howard CR, et al. (1983) Hepatitis B virus infection in two Gambian villages. Lancet 1: 1203–1206.
- 33. Miller SA, Dykes DD, Polesky HF (1988) A simple salting out procedure for extracting DNA from human nucleated cells. Nucleic Acids Res 16: 1215.
- 34. Gabriel SB, Schaffner SF, Nguyen H, Moore JM, Roy J, et al. (2002) The structure of haplotype blocks in the human genome. Science 296: 2225–2229.
- 35. Tabor HK, Risch NJ, Myers RM (2002) Candidate-gene approaches for studying complex genetic traits: practical considerations. Nat Rev Genet 3: 391–397.
- 36. Hohler T, Reuss E, Freitag CM, Schneider PM (2005) A functional polymorphism in the IL-10 promoter influences the response after vaccination with HBsAg and hepatitis A. Hepatology 42: 72–76.
- 37. Lindemann M, Barsegian V, Siffert W, Ferencik S, Roggendorf M, et al. (2002) Role of G protein beta3 subunit C825T and HLA class II polymorphisms in the immune response after HBV vaccination. Virology 297: 245–252.
- 38. Lindemann M, Virchow S, Ramann F, Barsegian V, Kreuzfelder E, et al. (2001) The G protein beta3 subunit 825T allele is a genetic marker for enhanced T cell response. FEBS Lett 495: 82–86.
- 39. Louagie H, Delanghe J, Desombere I, De Buyzere M, Hauser P, et al. (1993) Haptoglobin polymorphism and the immune response after hepatitis B vaccination. Vaccine 11: 1188–1190.
- 40. Sleijffers A, Yucesoy B, Kashon M, Garssen J, De Gruijl FR, et al. (2003) Cytokine polymorphisms play a role in susceptibility to ultraviolet B-induced modulation of immune responses after hepatitis B vaccination. J Immunol 170: 3423–3428.
- 41. Wang C, Tang J, Song W, Lobashevsky E, Wilson CM, et al. (2004) HLA and cytokine gene polymorphisms are independently associated with responses to hepatitis B vaccination. Hepatology 39: 978–988.
- 42. Yucesoy B, Sleijffers A, Kashon M, Garssen J, de Gruijl FR, et al. (2002) IL-1beta gene polymorphisms influence hepatitis B vaccination. Vaccine 20: 3193–3196.
- 43. Yang SH, Lee CG, Park SH, Im SJ, Kim YM, et al. (2006) Correlation of antiviral T-cell responses with suppression of viral rebound in chronic hepatitis B carriers: a proof-of-concept study. Gene Ther 13: 1110–1117.
- 44. Vanlandschoot P, Roobrouck A, Van Houtte F, Leroux-Roels G (2002) Recombinant HBsAg, an apoptotic-like lipoprotein, interferes with the LPS-induced activation of ERK-1/2 and JNK-1/2 in monocytes. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 297: 486–491.
- 45. Arbour N, Naniche D, Homann D, Davis RJ, Flavell RA, et al. (2002) c-Jun NH(2)-terminal kinase (JNK)1 and JNK2 signaling pathways have divergent roles in CD8(+) T cell-mediated antiviral immunity. J Exp Med 195: 801–810.
- 46. Weaver LK, Pioli PA, Wardwell K, Vogel SN, Guyre PM (2007) Up-regulation of human monocyte CD163 upon activation of cell-surface Toll-like receptors. J Leukoc Biol 81: 663–671.
- 47. Hiraoka A, Horiike N, Akbar SM, Michitaka K, Matsuyama T, et al. (2005) Expression of CD163 in the liver of patients with viral hepatitis. Pathol Res Pract 201: 379–384.
- 48. Sun Z, Zhu Y, Stjernsward J, Hilleman M, Collins R, et al. (1991) Design and compliance of HBV vaccination trial on newborns to prevent hepatocellular carcinoma and 5-year results of its pilot study. Cancer Detect Prev 15: 313–318.