Normal Hematopoietic Progenitor Subsets Have Distinct Reactive Oxygen Species, BCL2 and Cell-Cycle Profiles That Are Decoupled from Maturation in Acute Myeloid Leukemia

In acute myeloid leukemia (AML) quiescence and low oxidative state, linked to BCL2 mitochondrial regulation, endow leukemic stem cells (LSC) with treatment-resistance. LSC in CD34+ and more mature CD34− AML have heterogeneous immunophenotypes overlapping with normal stem/progenitor cells (SPC) but may be differentiated by functional markers. We therefore investigated the oxidative/reactive oxygen species (ROS) profile, its relationship with cell-cycle/BCL2 for normal SPC, and whether altered in AML and myelodysplasia (MDS). In control BM (n = 24), ROS levels were highest in granulocyte-macrophage progenitors (GMP) and CD34− myeloid precursors but megakaryocyte-erythroid progenitors had equivalent levels to CD34+CD38low immature-SPC although they were ki67high. BCL2 upregulation was specific to GMPs. This profile was also observed for CD34+SPC in MDS-without-excess-blasts (MDS-noEB, n = 12). Erythroid CD34− precursors were, however, abnormally ROS-high in MDS-noEB, potentially linking oxidative stress to cell loss. In pre-treatment AML (n = 93) and MDS-with-excess-blasts (MDS-RAEB) (n = 14), immunophenotypic mature-SPC had similar ROS levels to co-existing immature-SPC. However ROS levels varied between AMLs; Flt3ITD+/NPM1wild-type CD34+SPC had higher ROS than NPM1mutated CD34+ or CD34− SPC. An aberrant ki67lowBCL2high immunophenotype was observed in CD34+AML (most prominent in Flt3ITD AMLs) but also in CD34− AMLs and MDS-RAEB, suggesting a shared redox/pro-survival adaptation. Some patients had BCL2 overexpression in CD34+ ROS-high as well as ROS-low fractions which may be indicative of poor early response to standard chemotherapy. Thus normal SPC subsets have distinct ROS, cell-cycle, BCL2 profiles that in AML /MDS-RAEB are decoupled from maturation. The combined profile of these functional properties in AML subpopulations may be relevant to differential treatment resistance.


Introduction
Recent years have witnessed accelerated interest in the role of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in both normal hematopoietic development and leukemogenesis and in how redox modulation may impact on therapeutic strategies for acute myeloid leukemia (AML) [1,2].
ROS serve as mediators in proliferation and differentiation of hematopoietic cells, either via a paracrine mechanism [3], or by intracellular ROS production induced by cytokine receptor engagement on hematopoietic cells [4][5][6][7]. Normal hematopoietic stem cells (HSC) however require fine-tuning of low intracellular ROS levels in order to maintain quiescence, limit oxidative stress damage and sustain lifelong haematopoiesis. The metabolic adjustment of HSCs to reliance on glycolysis with resulting low ROS levels is due to the local conditions of hypoxic bone marrow (BM) niches, and also transcription/signalling pathways that alter ROS homeostasis and are critical for HSC function [8]. Gene targeting of regulatory molecules such as FoxO and Atm leads to higher ROS in HSC and loss of quiescence and self-renewal [9,10]. Conversely, manipulations that decrease ROS levels cause increased HSC quiescence and loss of effective differentiation into downstream progenitors [11]. Inefficient ROS homeostasis resulting in oxidative stress and genetic instability in HSCs and myeloid progenitors has been linked to myeloid malignancy; [12][13][14] for example high ROS levels have been correlated with greater DNA damage in AML with Flt3-internal-tandem-duplication (ITD) [15] and may explain the poor prognosis [16]. Furthermore overproduction of ROS in AML drives growth factor independent proliferation of AML blasts [17,18].
Flow cytometric analyses with fluorescent ROS-indicator dyes show that quiescent drugresistant cancer and AML leukemic stem cells (LSC) are enriched in the ROS-low fraction of total tumour cells [2,19] similarly to normal slow-cycling HSC being enriched in the ROS-low population [20]. Unlike HSC and most cancer cells [21], AML LSC have increased dependence on oxidative phosphorylation despite maintaining protective low ROS levels [2]. This mitochondrial respiration appears to require BCL2, the overexpression of which has previously been established to have other roles in functional chemo-resistance through anti-apoptosis [22] and potentially by inducing quiescence [23]. These and other mechanisms for BCL2 dependence suggest that chemo-resistant AML LSC may be targeted by the novel BCL2 inhibitor ABT199 /venetoclax [24,25]. However identifying and tracking chemo-resistant LSCs in patients to evaluate the effectiveness of such new therapies or indeed standard treatments is problematic since xenotransplantation assays are not applicable to routine clinical practice and LSC immunophenotypic profiles are heterogeneous. LSC have been identified within the lineage-negative CD34 + CD38 -/low compartment that contains HSC in normal haematopoiesis [26,27] but also in 'more mature' CD34 + CD38 + [28] and CD34 − progenitor/precursor compartments [29,30]. Potentially, low intracellular ROS levels could be used as a differential functional marker of chemo-resistant leukemic stem/progenitor cells (SPC) within immunophenotypic subsets pre-and post-treatment, particularly if combined with quiescence and BCL2 expression. It remains unclear, however, how ROS levels are modulated in the various normal human progenitors downstream from normal HSC compared to their immunophenotypic leukemic counterparts in AML [28] or at the intermediate/pre-leukemic stage of MDS. In addition the relationship between ROS, BCL2 and cell-cycle status for the different normal and leukemic SPC subsets requires further clarification in order to understand the relationship between emergence of SPCs with potential chemo-resistant functional properties and maturation stage in both CD34 + and more mature CD34 − AML subtypes. We sought to investigate this, developing a novel combined flow cytometry assay to measure ROS, cell-cycle (ki67) and the anti-apoptotic marker BCL2 in blast populations from normal, MDS and AML patients.

Patient samples
All experiments with human clinical material were performed after receiving approval from the University of Birmingham Research Governance office and the North West-Greater Manchester East Research Ethics Committee (12/NW/0742) and were conducted according to the principles expressed in the Declaration of Helsinki. Human BM and peripheral blood (PB) specimens were residual material from clinical samples for which institutional/ethical approvals were obtained. Control samples were adult (ages 43-84yrs, median 64yrs) lymphoma patient staging BM (n = 24) with no evidence of haematological malignant cells (confirmed by morphology and flow cytometry), and umbilical cord blood (UCB) samples (n = 4). Pre-treatment BM/PB samples from AML patients (n = 93, details in S1 File and S1 Table) and BM samples from myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS)/myeloproliferative disease (MPD) patients were also studied (n = 26, age 32-89yrs, median 76yrs). All samples were between 24-36 hours old.

Colony forming unit (CFU) assays
To determine lineage potential FACS-sorted immunophenotypic subsets were seeded into methylcellulose media (Methocult, StemCell Technologies) at 100-1000 cells per dish. CFUdishes were incubated at 37°C, 5%CO 2 for 14-days and then scored for colonies using an inverted light microscope. Specific colony types (CFU-GEMM, CFU-GM, CFU-M, CFU-G and CFU-E) were expressed as percentage of total colony yield under each experimental condition.

Drug sensitivity assays
Freshly isolated (by Ficoll-based density gradient centrifugation) pre-treatment AML patient cells were incubated at 37°C 5%CO 2 with or without ABT199 (Caltag Medsystems) for 16 hours at a range of concentrations in duplicate. Sensitivity to ara-C (Sigma-Aldrich) was measured after incubation with drug for 48 hours. After washing, cells were stained for surface markers and then with Annexin-V and 7AAD. Live/dead cells were then visualized by flow cytometry with toxicity calculated using the formula: %specific apoptosis = (test-control)×100 / (100-control)

ROS levels in control stem/progenitor cells (SPC)
We first asked whether low ROS levels measured with the redox-sensitive probe DCF were restricted to, and could thus differentiate HSC from, other immunophenotypic normal human hematopoietic progenitor populations (S1 Fig). In control BM samples (n = 24) total CD34 +-CD38 high cells (fraction containing committed progenitors) had higher DCF staining than total CD34 + CD38 low cells (fraction containing more immature SPC) as expected. Further analysis within these two immunophenotypic compartments (representative examples in Fig 1A) confirmed that HSC had low DCF staining (median standardised-DCF-MFI = 2.05), as did the MPP population (median 1.98). The infrequent LMPP subset (<5% of CD34 + CD38 low ) had relatively higher DCF staining (median 2.48), compared to both HSC and MPP. Interestingly there was a differential ROS profile within the CD34 + CD38 high fraction: GMP had highest DCF staining (median 6.64), followed by CMP (median 3.41) and then MEP (median 2.88) (complete summarised data in Fig 2A and 2B). The hierarchy in DCF staining with GMP>CMP>MEP and LMPP>HSC/MPP was also observed in umbilical cord blood (UCB) samples (n = 4) (example in Fig 1B), suggesting that this ROS profile is representative of normal non-malignant human SPC and not specific to the BM microenvironment.

Lineage fate and viability of CD34 + CD38 high cells with different ROS levels
The relationship between ROS levels and immunophenotypic normal progenitors (CD34 +-CD38 high fraction) was further assessed by colony assays using purified progenitor subsets from control BM (n = 3). CD34 + CD38 high CD45RA + cells (GMP-enriched) and CD34 +-CD38 high CD45RA − cells (CMP/MEP-enriched), were sorted into four populations denoted DCF low , DCF int1 , DCF int2 and DCF high ( Fig 3A) and assayed for colony output after 14 days culture in vitro. Results from CD45RA − cells showed that mixed (CFU-GEMM) and erythroid (CFU-E) potential was limited to DCF low /DCF int1 fractions and was lost in DCF int2 /DCF high fractions. Only granulocyte/macrophage colonies were generated in DCF int2 and DCF high fractions ( Fig 3B). CD45RA + cells exclusively generated granulocyte (CFU-G) and macrophage (CFU-M) or mixed GM colonies (CFU-GM) with a relative reduction in CFU-GM and increase in CFU-M observed with increasing DCF (DCF int2 /DCF high fraction) ( Fig 3C). Thus, higher ROS in the CD45RA − (CMP/MEP-enriched) compartment correlates with reduced multipotency, loss of erythroid potential and commitment towards GMP while higher ROS in the CD45RA + (GMP-enriched) compartment correlates with loss of mixed GM potential and higher macrophage potential.
High intracellular ROS levels may predispose GMP to greater risk of apoptosis. In CFU assays, total colony yields were progressively lower with increasing ROS levels ( Fig 3D), suggesting that higher ROS impedes cell proliferation and survival during cell culture. We  . ROS levels in CD34 − CD117 + cells were also compared between control BM and CD34 − AML (n = 10) and MDS patient BM samples, using the same colour scheme as above (C). CD34 − CD117 + cells were subdivided into CD45RA + and CD45RA − cells to enrich for myeloid and erythroid precursors respectively. Median expression and interquartile range is shown on each plot. P values are shown for data-sets where significant differences were observed (p<0.05, Mann Whitney test with 95% confidence intervals).

Fig 3. Influence of ROS levels on lineage fate and viability in normal progenitors.
Sorting scheme of normal BM CD34 + CD38 high cells separated into CD45RA + and CD45RA − subsets, followed by gating into 4 different populations based on differential DCF staining (A). Sorted cells were seeded onto methylcellulose media supplemented with cytokines. After 2 week culture at 37˚C in vitro, colonies were scored using an inverted light microscope and recorded as a percentage of the total colony yield for FACS-sorted control CD34 + CD38 high CD45RA − (B) and CD34 + CD38 high CD45RA + (C) progenitors with different levels of DCF staining. Total colony yield as percentage of input cell number was also determined (D). Colony forming unit assay data is from three evaluated cell viability in control BM cells (n = 7) (Fig 3E). Total CD34 + CD38 low cells and MEP, which are both low for ROS, had the highest viability (>96.5%) while CMP and GMP, which are high in ROS, both had lower frequencies of viable Annexin-V − /7AAD − cells (86% and 84% respectively). We investigated whether SPCs with higher ROS might be more sensitive to apoptosis by further oxidative insult (such as that generated by chemotherapy) by overnight treatment with the pro-oxidant BSO. This caused increased DCF staining but did not alter the number of apoptotic cells within CMP/GMP subsets (Fig 3F and 3G), suggesting that these cells have a relative protection against rapid induction of apoptosis from higher ROS levels. DCF staining was significantly lower in GMP-like (median 3.83) leukemic subsets when compared to the equivalent control SPC (Fig 2A and 2B, p<0.0001).

Altered ROS levels in AML and MDS CD34 + cells
AML blasts also circulate in peripheral blood (PB) but it is unclear whether ROS profiles of leukemic-SPC are modulated by dissociation from hypoxic BM niches. We compared DCFmeasured ROS levels of CD34 + subsets in unpaired PB (n = 43) and BM (n = 27) presentation samples and in 8 paired BM/PB AML samples. Abnormally expanded SPC observed in AML BM samples were also present in AML PB diagnosis samples. The unpaired PB vs.  Fig 1D), as observed in AML samples, while one sample had low DCF staining in all CD34 + CD38 low subsets but retained high DCF levels in CD34 + CD38 high GMP (examples in S1G Fig). In contrast, MDS without excess blasts (MDS-noEB) samples (n = 12), mostly showed higher DCF staining across CD34 + subsets, particularly in GMP fractions (examples in Fig 1E and S1H Fig, summarised data in Fig 2A and  2B). Thus, the transition of myeloid-committed CD34 + CD38 high SPCs to lower ROS appears to occur later in pre-leukemic progression. independent experiments. Colonies were scored as erythroid (e), macrophage (m), granulocyte (g), granulocytemacrophage (gm), or granulocyte-erythroid-macrophage mixed (gemm). Viability was determined by Annexin V and 7-AAD staining of normal BM labelled with HSPC-specific mAb. Initial gating was performed on SSC low CD45 int CD117 + cells. The pooled viability data from 7 control BM sample are shown (E). The effects of redox modification on DCF staining and cell viability in CD34 + CD38 high progenitors, is shown from two independent experiments (F). BM cells were treated overnight with the pro-oxidant BSO (100μM) or left untreated (control).

Combined analyses of BCL2 / ki67 with ROS in control and AML/MDS SPCs
Although ROS, BCL2 expression and cell-cycle status have previously been functionally linked [2,23,33,34] there are as yet no data assessing these therapeutically relevant parameters in parallel for normal or leukemic SPC subsets. We therefore developed and performed a combined assay on control BM (n = 16), AML diagnosis samples (n = 40) and MDS samples (n = 12). In control BMs CD34 + CD38 high cells expressed higher levels of both ki67 and BCL2 than CD34 + CD38 low cells (example in Fig 5A). Closer inspection (in 11 cases) showed that although there was no significant difference in ki67 between CMP, GMP and MEP subsets, BCL2 expression followed a GMP>CMP>MEP hierarchy (S3A and   Functional Profiles of Normal and AML Stem/Progenitor Cells CD34 − cells (mixed myeloid/erythroid) in controls were as proliferative as CD34 + CD38 high SPCs but had low BCL2 at levels similar to CD34 + CD38 low SPCs and MEP (Fig 6A and 6B). The observed BCL2 upregulation in the GMP subset suggests that at this myeloid maturation stage when higher ROS levels prime for proliferation/maturation, BCL2 might be transiently expressed for protection against further oxidative stress.
Although MDS-noEB (n = 6) had a normal profile, MDS-RAEB CD34 + SPCs (n = 6) were similar to AMLs with a major aberrant ki67 low BCL2 high population in both CD34 + CD38 low and CD34 + CD38 high compartments in all samples, and for some patients (4/6) also in the CD34 − compartment (Fig 6C). We therefore identified ki67 low BCL2 high phenotype as an aberrant blast profile in both CD34 + and CD34 − AMLs and MDS-RAEB but not at the pre-leukemic stage of MDS-noEB.
There was heterogeneity in the ki67 low BCL2 high population frequency between AML samples, both for total blasts and for the immunophenotypic blast subsets (S4A and S4B Fig). The high frequency in the Flt3ITD + /NPM1wt immature CD34 + CD38 low (LMPP) SPCs was consistent with ki67 low BCL2 high as a putative treatment-resistant 'LSC-type' subpopulation. The Flt3ITD − /NPM1mutated CD34 − AMLs, however, also all had a high ki67 low BCL2 high blast frequency ( Fig 6C). Since the Flt3ITD − /NPM1mutated subgroup is associated with treatment sensitivity it is likely that other functional properties attenuate any relative chemo-resistance from the ki67 low BCL2 high phenotype, at least for this more mature CD34 − AML.
We hypothesised that BCL2 over-expression (with downstream effects on apoptosis, metabolic regulation and cell-cycle) might be maintained in ROS-high blasts of some AMLs to counteract further oxidative stress similar to the observed BCL2 upregulation at the GM maturation stage. We gated on blasts with 20% highest DCF fluorescence and 20% lowest DCF fluorescence to allow a comparison between ROS highest and ROS lowest blasts (AML n = 40, MDS n = 12). There was a relative enrichment of the more immature immunophenotypic SPC (hierarchy LMPP/MPP >CMP/GMP) in the ROS lowest vs ROS highest fractions for most of the CD34 + AMLs (n = 24) (S5A Fig) but no SPC correlation with a specific ki67/BCL2 profile or overall high ROS levels. Interestingly ROS lowest /ROS highest gating of CD34 + SPCs in MDS-noEB revealed an aberrant relative expansion of CD34 + CD38 low and MEP/CMP SPCs in the ROS lowest and ROS highest fractions respectively (S5B Fig). Although some patients had lower ki67 in ROS lowest fractions as observed for normal BM and MDS-noEB (Fig 7A-7C), the majority did not have ROS low enrichment of the LSC-like ki67 low BCL2 high phenotype (S6 Fig). Similar ki67 and BCL2 levels were, however, maintained between ROS lowest and ROS highest blasts in a number of AML/MDS-RAEB patients. From available clinical data of early post-treatment outcome for CD34 + AMLs, high BCL2 over-expression (>6.9-fold above isotype) in ROS highest as well as ROS lowest fractions seemed to be most associated with initial treatment resistance (Fig 7D) although numbers were limited. A correlation between BCL2 overexpression in ROS lowest /ROS highest and early treatment response was not apparent in CD34 − AMLs including the Flt3ITD + /NPM1mutated patients (Fig 7E).
BCL2 inhibition experiments were performed using ABT199 in a subgroup of pre-treatment AMLs (n = 9). High levels of ABT199 sensitivity (EC50 at or below 100nM) was observed in both CD34 + and CD34 − AMLs, irrespective of differences in intracellular ROS, BCL2 and cellcycle status. ABT199-induced cell death was greater than that observed using ara-C for 5 of 6 samples (4/4 CD34 + AMLs and 1/2 CD34 − AMLs) where the drug assays were performed in parallel (S7A and S7B Fig). In the 2 samples tested, the potentially LSC-enriched, immature CD34 + CD38 low blast fractions showed equivalent or greater ABT199 sensitivity than more mature CD34 + CD38 high blasts (S7C Fig) and had a similar profile of differential sensitivity to ABT199 compared to ara-C (S7D Fig).

Discussion
This study provides a phenotypic profile for normal and leukemic SPC-subsets of functional cell properties that may, by dysregulation downstream of genetic abnormalities, promote survival and propagation in AML. Our results show decoupling of the relationship between normal myeloid maturation and cellular ROS/ BCL-2/ cell-cycle profiles in AML and MDS-RAEB with certain leukemic blast subpopulations displaying a chimeric functional phenotype of both 'stem-cell-like' and 'GM-like' properties. Normal human CD34 + and CD34 − CD117 + SPC subsets exhibit distinct patterns of ROS, cell-cycle activity with BCL2 expression upregulation at the GM stage. These ROS/ cell-cycle patterns are lost in AML and MDS-RAEB with an aberrant ki67 low BCL2 high phenotype observed in both CD34 + and CD34 − blast subpopulations at disease presentation.
By combining immunophenotypic characterisation of normal human SPC subsets with a ROS assay we show that although the DCF-low/ROS-low state has been associated with greater quiescence and the DCF-high/ROS-high state with proliferation and differentiation in primitive hematopoietic cells [20], the more mature (CD34 + CD38 high ) progenitors actually contain a combination of ROS-low and ROS-high cells with MEP consistently ROS-low, and GMP being ROS-high while CMP are a mixture of ROS-high / low cells. Colony assay data support a model whereby ROS-high CMP are pre-committed to become GMP while ROS-low CMP are either less committed and/or pre-committed to MEP. This ROS-based separation of human CMP is consistent with ROS being a driver of myeloid differentiation [6,7,35]. Extending our analysis by evaluation of the combined ROS/cell-cycle/BCL2 profile showed that all subsets (GMP/ CMP/MEP) of CD34 + CD38 high cells had high levels of cell-cycle activity despite variation in ROS levels but BCL2 upregulation correlated with increasing ROS levels and was thus myeloid-specific. BCL2 protein upregulation may be a survival cue to counteract oxidative stressinduced apoptosis in GMPs when higher ROS levels are required to prime for proliferation/ maturation. It could also be speculated, however, to predispose GMP to accumulating more DNA damage [36] and explain the relative expansion of GMP rather than CMP as observed in most MDS-RAEB and AML patients [28,37].
All normal CD34 + CD38 low SPCs were BCL2 low and, as expected, HSC and MPP were ROSlow ki67 low (quiescent) but interestingly the infrequent LMPP population appeared less 'stemcell-like' with higher ROS and greater cell-cycle activity. The immunophenotypically immature SPCs of AML and MDS-RAEB samples had the lowest ROS levels but the overall ROS profile was less heterogeneous compared to normal; the CD34 + CD38 high (GMP-like in particular) and CD34 − AML 'mature' blasts were both lower in ROS than the immunophenotypic equivalent control SPCs. This shift towards immature SPC ROS levels may contribute to the differentiation block in AML, consistent with data showing that agents increasing ROS can induce maturation of AML blasts [38,39]. The ROS-low pattern was observed, often more distinctly, in AML cells in PB and may represent an adaptation of AML sub-clones in BM that traffic to the PB [40] akin to that of HSPC preserving their hypoxic status while circulating in the normoxic blood environment [41].
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0163291.g007 methods of ROS detection [18]. It is plausible that extracellular ROS production is also high in our patients while intracellular ROS is kept under control by an enhanced anti-oxidant response [42,43], which may be targetable for inhibition [44][45]. Our data partially support the link between Flt3ITD + mutation and higher ROS levels [15] but also show that ROS levels were lower in most NPM1-mutated/ Flt3ITD + cases (all CD34 − AML in our cohort). Though patient numbers are low, this could suggest that the NPM1-mutated phenotype mitigates the effect of Flt3ITD + on intracellular ROS levels, resulting in a lower risk of DNA damage and progression as suggested by clinical data [46]. Higher ROS levels were also observed in some CBF-AMLs which is interesting as ROS signalling is crucial for maintaining AML1-ETO fusion protein-induced aberrant progenitor cells in a drosophila model [31]. The elevated ROS of CBF-AMLs may be related to both granulocytic maturation and enhanced sensitivity to chemotherapy by the mechanism of ROS-induced apoptosis.
We also detected higher ROS than controls in SPCs of MDS-noEB, most marked in the erythroid precursor-enriched subset (CD117 + CD34 − CD45RA − ). This may be linked with the reported higher apoptosis and cytopenias observed in MDS patients [37] from increased oxidative stress particularly of the erythroid lineage. Reduced ki67 expression, high BCL2 expression and most significantly an expanded ki67 low BCL2 high phenotype were observed in AML and MDS-RAEB but not MDS-noEB. While the ki67 low BCL2 high aberrant phenotype was highly expanded in Flt3ITD + cases including in the LSC-enriched LMMP-like subpopulation [28], it was also present in other AML subtypes. The in vivo LSC frequency of identified ki67 low BCL2 high cells could not be investigated by xenografting experiments due non-viability following intracellular staining but ki67 and BCL2 expression, either as single parameters or when combined as ki67 low BCL2 high , did not correlate with early outcome to standard treatment in our small patient group. This is not unexpected as chemo-resistance is also dependent on the balance between activities of different pro-/anti-apoptotic BCL2 family proteins [47][48][49] as well as drug efflux activity [50]. Further sub-analysis of ROS highest and ROS lowest cells within the blast population of each patient showed that, although aberrant BCL2 overexpression has been reported as an adaptation of LSC-enriched ROS lowest AML cells [2], ROS highest cells were also BCL2 high for some CD34 + AMLs (8/24) and CD34 − AMLs (7/9). Intriguingly, aberrant overexpression of BCL2 in ROS highest as well as ROS lowest blasts was the profile most associated with early chemotherapy resistance from limited available data in the 24 CD34 + AMLs with outcome data. However, sensitivity to BCL2 inhibition in vitro using ABT199 in a small number of tested patients was high across both CD34 + and CD34 -AML blast types with different ROS, ki67 and BCL2 levels. Furthermore AML blasts including potentially LSC-enriched fractions, showed greater sensitivity to ABT199 than ara-C. Thus BCL2 dependence was shared by phenotypically different AML blasts. This in vitro data is supportive of greater clinical efficacy of BCL2-inhibition therapy across different AML subtypes compared to standard chemotherapy.
It may also be postulated from our results that BCL2 over-expression (with downstream effects on apoptosis, metabolic regulation and cell-cycle) is an adapted 'GM-like' property (to intrinsic or extrinsic dysregulation) that in some AMLs modulates the apoptotic threshold to additional oxidative stress as well as metabolic adjustments. This could contribute to relative chemo-resistance by protecting leukemic blasts with higher ROS from apoptosis triggered by chemotherapy-induced oxidative damage.