Proper Microtubule Structure Is Vital for Timely Progression through Meiosis in Fission Yeast

Cells of the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe normally reproduce by mitotic division in the haploid state. When subjected to nutrient starvation, two haploid cells fuse and undergo karyogamy, forming a diploid cell that initiates meiosis to form four haploid spores. Here, we show that deletion of the mal3 gene, which encodes a homolog of microtubule regulator EB1, produces aberrant asci carrying more than four spores. The mal3 deletion mutant cells have a disordered cytoplasmic microtubule structure during karyogamy and initiate meiosis before completion of karyogamy, resulting in twin haploid meiosis in the zygote. Treatment with anti-microtubule drugs mimics this phenotype. Mutants defective in karyogamy or mutants prone to initiate haploid meiosis exaggerate the phenotype of the mal3 deletion mutant. Our results indicate that proper microtubule structure is required for ordered progression through the meiotic cycle. Furthermore, the results of our study suggest that fission yeast do not monitor ploidy during meiosis.


Introduction
Karyogamy, a process in which two haploid nuclei fuse to produce a diploid nucleus, must occur prior to initiation of meiosis in haploid organisms such as the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe. Haploid fission yeast cells display one of two mating types, designated as h + and h 2 . Homothallic strains, designated as h 90 , undergo frequent switching of mating type between h + and h 2 , whereas heterothallic strains are fixed as either h + or h 2 . When starved for nutrients, particularly nitrogen, haploid cells conjugate with cells of the opposite mating type, after which they undergo karyogamy and form diploid zygotes. In conjugated diploid cells, expression of the mei3 gene is induced [1,2]. The mei3 gene encodes an inhibitor of Pat1 kinase [3]. Pat1 kinase negatively regulates the initiation of meiosis [4,5]. Once Pat1 is inactivated by Mei3, dephosphorylated Mei2, which is a critical target of Pat1, accumulates and triggers the initiation of meiosis [6][7][8].
Regulation of the temporal order of conjugation, karyogamy, and the initiation of meiosis is crucial for the generation of proper haploid spores. However, several mutants are known to undergo haploid meiosis in the absence of conjugation. For instance, temperature-sensitive pat1 mutants initiate haploid meiosis at elevated temperatures [4,5]. Expression of an activated form of Mei2 that has alanine substitutions at Pat1 target sites also induces haploid meiosis [6]. It is also known that h + /h + and h 2/ h 2 diploid cells can mate, and the resulting tetraploid cells occasionally produce more than four spores [9]. These spores are derived from ''twin meiosis'', in that two nuclei initiate meiosis separately in the absence of karyogamy [9]. This suggests that fission yeast might not monitor the completion of karyogamy prior to undergoing meiosis. Here, we report that twin meiosis occurs even in diploid zygotes. We examined the meiotic phenotype of cells lacking the mal3 gene that encodes a homolog of EB1, a well-characterized microtubule plus end-tracking protein originally identified as a binding partner of the tumor suppressor protein APC [10]. Mal3 is shown to be a crucial microtubule regulator, both in interphase and during mitotic division [11][12][13]. mal3D cells are characterized by a defective microtubule cytoskeleton, which causes aberrant cell morphology, and by defects in chromosome stability. In the present study, we investigated the meiotic phenotype of the mal3D strain, and found that correct cytoplasmic microtubule organization is crucial for proper meiotic progression.

Materials and Methods
Fission Yeast Strains, Genetic Analysis, and Growth Media Table 1 lists the S. pombe strains used in this study. General genetic analyses of the S. pombe strains followed previously described procedures [14]. Growth media used in the study included complete YE, minimal SD and MM [15], synthetic sporulation SSA [16], and sporulation SPA [14]. A standard protocol was used for gene tagging and deletion [17]. To determine percentage of asci containing 1, 2, 3, 4 or .4 spores, more than 200 asci were examined after incubation on SSA for 3 days (Fig. 1A and 3C) or on SPA for 1 day (Fig. 1D). Standard deviations were calculated from three independent experiments. , and mal3D ssm4D (J853) strains were induced to sporulate by incubating cells for 3 days on SSA medium at 30uC. More than 200 asci were examined for each strain. Error bars indicate standard deviations from three independent experiments. Asterisks indicate significant difference from the wild-type strain (**p,0.01 (Chi-square test)). (C) Viability of spores of the mal3D strain (JW794) from asci carrying 4, 6, or 8 spores. More than 80 spores from each ascus were dissected using a micromanipulator and incubated on rich YE medium at 30uC. (D) Percentage of asci containing 1, 2, 3, 4, or .4 spores generated by the wildtype strain (JY450) on medium containing the anti-microtubule drug thiabendazole. Sporulation was induced by cells at 30uC on SPA medium with or without 100 mg/mL thiabendazole. After incubation for 1 day, more than 200 asci were examined. Error bars indicate standard deviations from three independent experiments. Asterisks indicate significant difference from the wild-type strain (**p,0.01 (Chi-square test)). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0065082.g001

Live Cell Imaging
To induce meiosis, each strain was grown to mid-log phase in MM medium at 30uC, after which cells were collected, washed, and spotted onto plates containing SPA medium. After incubation for 4-6 hours at 30uC, cells were observed using the PersonalDV microscopy imaging system (Applied Precision, Issaquah, WA, USA) or under a fluorescence microscope (AxioPlan 2; Carl Zeiss, Oberkochen, Baden-Württemberg, Germany) equipped with a chilled CCD camera (CoolSNAP HQ2; PHOTOMETRICS, Tucson, AZ, USA) and MetaMorph software (Molecular Devices, Sunnyvale, CA, USA). To determine percentage of zyogotes containing one or two Mei3-GFP-positive nuclei, more than 200 cells were examined after incubation on SPA. Standard deviations were calculated from three independent experiments.

Mal3 is Essential for Proper Spore Production
The sexual differentiation pathway, which involves mating, meiosis, and sporulation, was induced in mal3D cells in order to elucidate the role of Mal3 in meiosis. The mating and sporulation frequencies of the mal3D strain were comparable to those of the wild type; however, 21% of the mal3D cells generated aberrant asci containing more than four (at most eight) spores, a phenomenon that was observed infrequently in wild-type cells (Figs. 1A and 1B). We then determined the viability of spores in the aberrant asci produced by mal3D cells, and found that spore viability declined as the number of spores per ascus increased (45%, 15% and 2% in four-, six-and eight-spore asci, respectively, Fig. 1C). These results suggest that Mal3 plays a significant role in meiosis. Zygotes carrying less than three spores were rarely detected in the wildtype strain, but were observed more frequently in the mal3D strain (0.4% in wt versus 9.5% in mal3D, Fig. 1B). The higher frequency of zygotes carrying less than three spores could be due to a deficiency in microtubule-dependent nuclear movement during meiotic prophase, as has been shown to occur in dynein-dynactin mutants [18][19][20].
Mal3 is a crucial microtubule regulator, and consequently disruption of the mal3 gene compromises the structure of microtubules [11]. We therefore examined whether impairment of the microtubule structure leads to the aberrant spore formation. In wild-type cells cultured in the presence of the microtubuledestabilizing drug thiabendazole, 11% of the spore-containing zygotes contained more than four spores (Fig. 1D), suggesting that disorder in the structure of microtubules is responsible for the extra-spore phenotype of the mal3D strain. Consistent with this observation, the mto1D strain, in which cytoplasmic microtubule nucleation is abolished [21][22][23], also showed the extra-spore phenotype (data not shown).

Meiosis Proceeds without Karyogamy in mal3D Cells
We next investigated how the extra-spore phenotype is elicited in the mal3D strain. Time-lapse observations made throughout the entire meiotic process, from mating to meiosis II, showed that meiotic divisions occurred before the completion of karyogamy in mal3D cells (Fig. 2). We utilized mal3 + and mal3D strains carrying the GFP-atb2 fusion gene encoding GFP-tubulin and the cut11-3mRFP gene encoding a fusion protein consisting of the nuclear envelope marker Cut11 [24] and three copies of mRFP. In wildtype cells, karyogamy occurred prior to meiosis I (Fig. 2, wt). In mal3D cells, cytoplasmic microtubules, which in wild-type cells bridge two approaching nuclei, were severely impaired. During karyogamy in budding yeast, nuclear congression is driven by microtubule dynamics [25,26]. Disruption of the BIM1 gene, which encodes the EB1 homolog in budding yeast, has been shown to lead to a defect in karyogamy [27]. We found that nuclear congression was defective in mal3D cells, as in bim1 mutant budding yeast. In addition, mal3D cells entered meiosis I in the absence of karyogamy, leading to twin haploid meiosis in single zygotes. These observations suggest that formation of extra spores in mal3D cells is caused by the skipping of karyogamy.
We hypothesized that the delay in karyogamy might exacerbate the extra-spore phenotype of mal3D cells. To test this hypothesis, we constructed a mutant strain with deletions of both mal3 and dhc1, which encodes the dynein heavy chain, and a mutant strain with deletions of both mal3 and ssm4, which encodes the p150 glued subunit of the dynactin complex, since nuclear fusion is reportedly delayed in mutants lacking the dynein heavy chain [18]. These double mutant strains showed the exaggerated phenotype, as expected (79% in mal3D dhc1D and 71% in mal3D ssm4D versus 21% in mal3D, Fig. 1B).

Twin Haploid Meiosis Occurs in mal3D Cells
Next, we monitored meiotic initiation by following the expression of Mei3, which is expressed only in cells stimulated to initiate meiosis as a result of nutritional starvation and heterozygosity [1]. Expression of Mei3-GFP was consistently observed in the fused nucleus of most nitrogen-starved wild-type cells (Figs. 3A and 3B). In clear contrast, the frequency of cells containing two Mei3-GFP-positive nuclei was higher in the mal3D mutant. This observation supports the idea that two haploid meioses occur prematurely in the mal3D strain. We then examined the effect produced by accelerating the initiation of meiosis by inhibiting the activity of the Pat1 kinase in mal3D cells. Pat1 kinase is inhibited by Mei3, thereby triggering meiosis [3]. Introduction of a temperature sensitive mutation in the pat1 gene resulted in exaggerated extra-spore formation in mal3D cells cultured at the semipermissive temperature of the pat1 mutation (Fig. 3C, 30uC).

Discussion
In the present study, we demonstrated that fission yeast can initiate meiosis before the completion of karyogamy. Nuclear migration during karyogamy depends entirely upon cytoplasmic microtubules. It has been reported that cytoplasmic dynein plays a role in karyogamy, although nuclear fusion is eventually accomplished even in dynein deletion mutants [18]. In the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, cytoplasmic microtubule plus-end interactions and depolymerization dependent upon the minus-enddirected kinesin Kar3 is thought to generate forces that drive nuclear congression during karyogamy [25]. Recently, it has been shown that Kar3 anchored at a spindle pole body (SPB) could exert the pulling forces on microtubules nucleated from the SPB of the mating partner nucleus and drive nuclear migration [26]. In fission yeast, zygotes lacking both dhc1, which encodes dynein heavy chain, and klp2, which encodes a kinesin-like protein homologous to Kar3, form asci containing more than four spores at a high frequency, suggesting that Klp2 kinesin is involved in karyogamy [28]. An intriguing question for further investigation centers upon how dynein and kinesin are coordinated in this process.
Our results show that even spores that are produced by ''twin haploid meiosis'' retain viability, although at a very low level (Fig. 1C). One potential reason that S. pombe has not developed checkpoint mechanisms to monitor the completion of karyogamy is that it has only three chromosomes. Due to the relatively small number of chromosomes, the complete genome could occasionally be passed to spores produced through haploid meiosis. Schizosaccharomyces japonicus, a species closely related to S. pombe, generates eight spores in each ascus through post-meiotic nuclear division [29,30], which is distinct from our findings in S. pombe mutant zygotes. The meiotic and sporulation phenotypes of karyogamydefective S. japonicus mutants remain elusive. Comparative analyses of the two related species might provide significant information regarding regulation of the initiation and progression of meiosis.