Oral Vaccination with Lipid-Formulated BCG Induces a Long-lived, Multifunctional CD4+ T Cell Memory Immune Response

Oral delivery of BCG in a lipid formulation (Liporale™-BCG) targets delivery of viable bacilli to the mesenteric lymph nodes and confers protection against an aerosol Mycobacterium tuberculosis challenge. The magnitude, quality and duration of the effector and memory immune response induced by Liporale™-BCG vaccination is unknown. Therefore, we compared the effector and memory CD4+ T cell response in the spleen and lungs of mice vaccinated with Liporale™-BCG to the response induced by subcutaneous BCG vaccination. Liporale™-BCG vaccination induced a long-lived CD4+ T cell response, evident by the detection of effector CD4+ T cells in the lungs and a significant increase in the number of Ag85B tetramer-specific CD4+ T cells in the spleen up to 30 weeks post vaccination. Moreover, following polyclonal stimulation, Liporale™-BCG vaccination, but not s.c. BCG vaccination, induced a significant increase in both the percentage of CD4+ T cells in the lungs capable of producing IFNγ and the number of multifunctional CD4+ T cells in the lungs at 30 weeks post vaccination. These results demonstrate that orally delivered Liporale™-BCG vaccine induces a long-lived multifunctional immune response, and could therefore represent a practical and effective means of delivering novel BCG-based TB vaccines.


Introduction
Bacille Calmette-Guérin (BCG) is the only available vaccine for the prevention of tuberculosis [1] and has been given to over 3 billion individuals, making it the most widely administered vaccine to date. BCG is typically administered soon after birth, and while it is effective at preventing TB during childhood, its effectiveness wanes over time [2,3]. To that end, the efficacy of BCG against adult pulmonary TB is highly variable, ranging from 0-80% [4,5,6]. Due to the success of BCG in reducing childhood TB, and its proven safety record, strategies to develop a more effective TB vaccine have focused on improving the efficacy of BCG, either through the development of recombinant BCG strains and attenuated Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) vaccine strains or through the development of subunit and virus-vectored vaccines that can be used as a boost for BCG [7]. In that regard, most of the novel TB vaccines currently in the vaccine pipeline are designed to incorporate BCG or attenuated Mtb [8].
Optimizing the delivery of this live bacterial vaccine is a further way in which the efficacy of BCG could be improved. Oral delivery of BCG has many advantages over the standard intradermal method of BCG vaccination, including reduced cost, ease of administration, avoidance of needles and the associated risk of disease transfer. More importantly, it has been shown that oral delivery more effectively targets the mucosal immune response than intradermal vaccination [9]. This is critical, given that the primary site of TB infection is the lungs.
BCG is most effective when delivered as a live vaccine [10,11]. We have previously reported that oral delivery of BCG in a lipid formulation protects the bacilli from degradation in the stomach and provides immunity against an aerosol Mtb or Mycobacterium bovis challenge in mice and guinea pigs [12,13,14,15]. Moreover, oral BCG vaccination has been shown to boost antigen-specific immune responses in human volunteers [16,17] and reduce the incidence of virulent M. bovis in livestock and wildlife [18,19,20,21].
Immunity to TB is highly dependent upon CD4 + T cells and the acquisition of a T helper cell type 1 (Th1) immune response [22]. Control of a primary TB infection is reliant on the production of IFNc and TNFa in the lungs by CD4 + effector T cells [23,24,25,26,27]. These cytokines activate infected macrophages, enabling them to kill or restrict the growth of the invading mycobacteria [22]. The requirements for a protective memory response to TB are less clear [28]. Lung-resident CD4 + T cells appear to be the principal mediators of protection, since following BCG vaccination lung-resident memory T cells have been shown to be sufficient for protection against a mycobacterial challenge [29]. However, the level of IFNc produced by CD4 + T cells is not a reliable predictor of vaccine efficacy [30,31]. More recently, efforts have focused on measuring the quality of the vaccineinduced immune response by assessing the proportion of multifunctional Th1 CD4 + T cells, which are capable of simultaneously producing high levels of IFNc, TNFa and IL-2 [32]. The increased presence of these cells in the spleens, [33,34] and perhaps more importantly the lungs, of vaccinated mice has been shown to correlate with protection against TB [35].
Although the vaccine-elicited immune response to parenteral BCG vaccination is well characterized, the CD4 + T cell immune response to lipid-formulated oral BCG vaccination is unknown. In this study, we compare the magnitude and quality of the CD4 + T cell response in the spleen and lungs of mice induced by orally delivered lipid-formulated BCG to the response induced by subcutaneous (s.c.) BCG vaccination. We report that lipidformulated oral BCG vaccination (Liporale TM -BCG) induced a long-lived CD4 + T cell response, demonstrated by the persistence of activated, antigen-specific CD4 + T cells in the spleens and a greater number of multifunctional CD4 + T cells in the lungs than s.c. vaccinated mice at 30 weeks post immunization. These findings suggest that Liporale TM -BCG vaccination could present an effective means of delivering novel BCG-based vaccines for the prevention of TB.

Ethics Statement
This project was undertaken within the provisions of the Animal Welfare Act (1999) of New Zealand and was approved by the Victoria University of Wellington Animal Ethics Committee.

Mice
Inbred C57BL/6 mice were purchased from The Jackson Laboratory and bred and housed under SPF conditions at the Malaghan Institute of Medical Research Biomedical Research Unit in Wellington, New Zealand. Groups of 5 age-and sexmatched mice were used at each time point for each experimental group.

BCG Preparation and Vaccination
Mice were vaccinated per oral or subcutaneous route, as indicated, with M. bovis BCG Danish strain 1331. BCG was grown to mid log-phase in 175 ml flasks (Falcon, NJ, USA) containing Middlebrook 7H9 medium (Difco, Detroit, MI, USA) supplemented with albumin-dextrose-catalase (BBL, Becton Dickinson, MD, USA) and 0.01% Tween 80. BCG in vaccine preparations was enumerated by plating onto modified Middlebrook 7H11 agar (Difco, Detroit, MI, USA) containing oleic acid-albumin-dextrosecatalase ((BBL, Becton Dickinson, MD, USA) and glycerol and counting retrospectively after incubation for 2-3 weeks. For formulating the oral vaccine, broth-grown BCG bacilli were pelleted by centrifugation and encapsulated into Liporale TM as previously described (13). For subcutaneous vaccination, 50 uL of 7H9 medium, containing approximately 1610 6 CFU BCG, was injected into the right flank. For oral BCG administration, mice were temporarily separated into individual cages and offered 0.3mL chocolate-flavored Liporale TM containing 1-2610 7 CFU BCG. After 12 hours, the oral vaccine had been entirely consumed and mice were placed back in their original cages.

Tissue Preparation
At times indicated, mice were culled by cervical dislocation. Single lymphocyte suspensions were prepared from spleens of mice by passing them through a 70 mm cell strainer and subjecting them to red blood cell lysis (Red Blood Cell Lysing Buffer, Sigma, St. Lois, MO). Lung lymphocytes were isolated by enzymatic digestion of lung tissue (2.4 mg/mL Collagenase Type I (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA), 0.12 mg/mL DNase 1 (Roche, Mannheim, Germany) in Iscove's Modified Dulbecco's Medium (IMDM) without additives), and CD45 + cells were isolated using magnetic bead enrichment with CD45 MicroBeads (MACS, Miltenyi Biotec, Germany). Total cell counts per organ were determined using a haemocytometer following red blood cell lysis of spleens or following CD45 MicroBead isolation from lungs.

Identification of Tetramer-specific Cells
Single cell suspensions from spleens were stained with I-A(b) Mtb antigen 85B precursor 280-294 (FQDAYNAAGGHNAVF) tetramer-APC or with I-A(b) human class II-associated invariantchain peptide (PVSKMR MARPLLMQA) tetramer-APC as a negative control (NIH MHC Tetramer Core Facility at Emory University, Atlanta, GA), and enriched by positive magnetic bead isolation using the AutoMACS cell sorter (Miltenyi Biotec) following staining with anti-APC MicroBeads (MACS, Miltenyi Biotec) and were identified by flow cytometry. For phenotype analysis we used a minimum number of 50 events in the tetramer gate, with a mean of 180 events.

Statistical Analysis
Statistical significance was determined by one-way ANOVA followed by the Tukey post-test, two way ANOVA followed by the Bonferroni post test, or by the Mann Whitney test, as indicated in figure legends, using Prism software.

Liporale TM -BCG Significantly Increases the Number of Ag85B-specific CD4 + T Cells in the Spleen
To compare the immune response elicited by Liporale TM -BCG to the response induced by s.c. BCG vaccination, we isolated CD4 + T Cell Response to Lipid-Formulated Oral BCG PLOS ONE | www.plosone.org lymphocytes from the spleens of vaccinated C57Bl/6 mice at 4, 8 and 30 weeks post immunization. Naïve mice served as unvaccinated controls. Splenic CD4 + T cells specific for the immunogenic BCG and Mtb antigen Ag85B were identified using an MHCII-Ag85B tetramer (Fig. 1a). Importantly, only mice that received Liporale TM -BCG had a significant increase in the  number of Ag85B-specific cells in the spleen compared to naïve controls at 8 and 30 weeks following immunization (Fig. 1b).
Liporale TM -BCG Induces an Ag85B-specific CD4 + Effector T Cell Phenotype in the Spleen To distinguish between naïve, effector (T EFF )/effector-memory (T EM ) and central memory (T CM ) CD4 + T cell populations, total CD4 + lymphocytes from naïve mice or Ag85B-specific CD4 + T cells from vaccinated mice, were stained for the expression of CD62L, a lymphoid homing receptor that is downregulated shortly following T cell activation, and the activation marker CD44. CD4 + T cell subsets were categorized as follows: naïve cells as CD62L hi , CD44 lo ; T CM as CD62L hi , CD44 hi and T EM /T EFF as CD62L lo , CD44 hi [36,37].
At 4 weeks post immunization, the Ag85B-specific CD4 + T cells from the spleens of mice vaccinated with Liporale TM -BCG or s.c. BCG displayed a predominantly T EM /T EFF phenotype (Fig. 2 a  and b). The antigen-specific CD4 + effector immune response was maintained up to 8 weeks post immunization, illustrating that Liporale TM -BCG can induce an antigen-specific CD4 + effector T cell response in the spleen that is equivalent to s.c. BCG vaccination.
By 30 weeks post immunization, .50% of the Ag85B-specific CD4 + T cells in the spleens of vaccinated mice were T CM , consistent with reports demonstrating that central memory cells are capable of long term survival [38]. Interestingly, there was a significant increase in the proportion of T CM cells in mice that received BCG orally compared to mice that received a s.c. BCG immunization (p,0.05), suggesting that Liporale TM -BCG vaccination can induce a long-lived antigen specific memory immune response.

Liporale TM -BCG Induces a Long-lived CD4 + Effector T Cell Phenotype in the Lungs
To investigate the immune response to lipid-formulated oral BCG vaccination in the lung, we isolated lymphocytes from the lungs of mice 4, 8 and 30 weeks post oral or subcutaneous BCG vaccination. We determined the phenotype of the total CD4 + T cell population using antibodies against CD62L and CD44 to distinguish between naïve, T EM /T EFF and T CM subsets (Fig. 3a). Similar to the antigen-specific response in the spleen, at 4 and 8 weeks post immunization, Liporale TM -BCG induced a T EM /T EFF CD4 + T cell phenotype in the lungs that was equivalent to the immune response observed when BCG was administered subcutaneously (Fig. 3b). Importantly, by 30 weeks following immunization, only mice that received Liporale TM -BCG maintained a CD4 + T EM /T EFF phenotype relative to naïve controls. The maintenance of a CD4 + T EM /T EFF cell population in the lungs of orally vaccinated mice 7 months after immunization suggests that oral BCG vaccination induces a prolonged effector response in the lungs compared to subcutaneous vaccination.

Cytokine Production by CD4 + T Cells from the Lungs of Liporale TM -BCG Vaccinated Mice
To assess the quality of the immune response in the lung following Liporale TM -BCG vaccination, lymphocytes were isolat-ed from the lungs of naïve or BCG-vaccinated mice and restimulated for 6 hours in vitro in the presence of Brefeldin A and monensin. Cytokine producing CD4 + T cells were identified by intracellular staining and flow cytometry. At 4 and 8 weeks after vaccination, there was a significant increase in the proportion of CD4 + T cells producing IFNc or TNFa, but not IL-2, in the lungs of mice that received either Liporale TM -BCG or s.c. BCG vaccines compared to naïve controls (Fig. 4 a and b). Of note, by 30 weeks post immunization, there was a significant increase in the proportion of IFNc-producing CD4 + T cells from the lungs of mice that received Liporale TM -BCG vaccination relative to cells from s.c. BCG vaccinated mice and naïve controls (Fig. 4 a and b).
The frequency of multifunctional CD4 + T cells in the lungs of vaccinated and naïve mice was determined using Boolean gating. At 4 and 8 weeks after vaccination with either Liporale TM -BCG or s.c. BCG there was a significant increase in the percentage and number of multifunctional CD4 + T cells in the lungs of mice compared to cells from naïve controls (Fig. 5 a, b and c). The proportion of IFNc + TNFa + IL-2 2 double positive CD4 + T cells also was also significantly increased in the lungs of Liporale TM -BCG or s.c. BCG vaccinated mice compared to naïve controls (Fig. 5 b and c). Interestingly, at 30 weeks after immunization, there was a significant increase in the frequency of multifunctional CD4 + T cells in the lungs of mice that received Liporale TM -BCG compared to s.c. vaccinated or naïve controls (Fig. 5d).

Discussion
Oral delivery of live BCG using a lipid formulation has been shown to be effective at protecting animals against a virulent mycobacterial challenge [12,14,15,39]; however, the immune response elicited by this vaccine had not been fully investigated. Therefore we compared the CD4 + T cell response in mice vaccinated with Liporale TM -BCG to mice vaccinated with BCG through the conventional s.c. route. We observed a significantly increased number of Ag85B tetramer-specific CD4 + T cells in the spleens of mice vaccinated with Liporale TM -BCG and found that oral vaccination induced T EFF /T EM and T CM CD4 + T cell populations in the spleen that were similar to s.c. BCG vaccinated mice. Moreover, following polyclonal stimulation, we found that mice vaccinated with Liporale TM -BCG had significantly more IFNc-producing, and multifunctional CD4 + T cells in the lungs, the primary site of TB infection, than s.c. BCG vaccinated or control mice .6 months after vaccination.
The earlier control of bacterial growth observed following pulmonary mycobacterial challenge of memory immune mice has been shown to coincide with the early arrival of antigen-specific Th1 CD4 + T cells in the lungs [40]. Supporting this, it has been demonstrated that adoptively transferred activated, transgenic Th1 ESAT-6-specific cells traffic to the lungs and protect from an Mtb challenge in a frequency dependent manner [41]. Moreover, using FTY720 to block egress of lymphocytes from the lymph nodes, it has been shown that T cells in the lungs of BCG vaccinated mice are sufficient to protect against a mycobacterial challenge [29]. Together, these studies suggest that the presence of Th1 CD4 + T cells in the lungs is critical for the immune protection afforded by vaccination. We found that both Liporale TM -BCG vaccination and s.c. BCG vaccination led to a statistically significant increase in the frequency of IFNc-producing CD4 + T cells in the lungs at 4 and 8 weeks after immunization, which coincided with the presence of a predominantly effector phenotype of the CD4 + T cells in the lungs. By 30 weeks post vaccination, a significant population of T EFF /T EM CD4 + T cells capable of producing IFNc was identified only in the lungs of mice that were vaccinated with Liporale TM -BCG, suggesting that the oral route of vaccination produces a more sustained immune response in the lungs than traditional s.c. vaccination.
Although IFNc is necessary to control an Mtb infection, the IFNc response induced by TB vaccination is an unreliable correlate of vaccine-elicited protection [30,31]. For this reason we also assessed the frequency of multifunctional cells in the spleens and lungs of vaccinated mice, since these cells have been shown to correlate with vaccine-elicited protection from Mtb in mice [32,33,35]. We found an increase in the proportion and frequency of triple cytokine producing cells in the lung at 4 and 8 weeks in mice vaccinated with BCG orally or s.c., but interestingly, only Liporale TM -BCG maintained a significant population of multifunctional CD4 + T cells in the lungs of mice by 30 weeks post vaccination. Therefore, the oral, mucosal vaccination route maintains the multifunctional CD4 + T cell population in the lung for longer than the traditional s.c. route of immunization.
By contrast, Kaveh et al. recently reported that intradermal BCG vaccination induces a long-lived population of multifunctional CD4 + T cells in the lungs [42]. In this study an increase in the proportion of multifunctional cells in vaccinated mice compared to naïve controls was detected at 6 weeks post immunization, however, it is unclear whether the percentage of multifunctional cells in BCG vaccinated mice were above that found in naïve mice at 6, 12 and 18 months after vaccination because unvaccinated controls were not included at later time points. The phenotype of the multifunctional cells in the spleens of intradermally BCG vaccinated mice was reported as T EM -like (CD44 hi , CD62L lo ); however, it is important to note that this phenotype was assessed after an 18 hour in vitro restimulation, and it is likely that the phenotype of these cells was altered by the restimulation [43]. In our study we found that Ag85B tetramer-specific CD4 + T cells in the spleen maintained an effector phenotype up to 8 weeks following either s.c. or Liporale TM -BCG vaccination. By contrast, at 30 weeks post vaccination, over 50% of the antigen-specific CD4 + T cells in the spleens of vaccinated mice had a T CM phenotype, with a significantly higher proportion of T CM in the orally vaccinated mice. Similar to the early response in the spleen, we observed a pool of CD4 + T EFF /T EM cells at 4 and 8 weeks in the lungs of mice that received BCG either orally or subcutaneously. This population of CD4 + T EFF /T EM cells was maintained up to 30 weeks post Liporale TM -BCG vaccination. It is possible that the low level of persisting antigen in the lungs following oral BCG vaccination contributed to the maintenance of T EFF /T EM cells in the lung up to 6 months after vaccination; however it should be noted that an earlier study demonstrated that viable bacteria could not be recovered from the lungs by 8 weeks following oral BCG vaccination [44].
A further possible mechanism for the extended presence of T EFF /T EM lymphocytes following oral BCG vaccination is tissuespecific homing, in which T cells preferentially migrate to the tissues in which they were primed [45]. There is evidence that T cells primed in mucosal lymphoid sites, such as the mesenteric lymph nodes and Peyer's patches, express homing markers and chemokines specific for the major mucosal sites in the body, the lung and the intestine [46,47,48]. Following Liporale TM -BCG vaccination, live mycobacteria are predominantly found in mucosal lymphatic tissues, such as the mesenteric lymph nodes, cervical lymph nodes and the Peyer's patches, and is therefore thought to be where T cell priming occurs [44,49]. Interestingly, lymphocytes isolated from the spleen of mice vaccinated with Liporale TM -BCG did not express the mucosal homing molecules CD103 or a4b7, but differentially expressed b1 integrin, which has been shown to be involved in T cell homing to the lung epithelium [49,50,51]. Whether the antigen-specific CD4 + T cells recovered from the spleens of Liporale TM -BCG vaccinated mice express b1 integrin remains to be determined.
We have shown previously that Liporale TM -BCG vaccination effectively protects against Mtb infection and in this present study we have provided evidence that orally delivered, Liporale TM -BCG vaccination induces a strong antigen-specific CD4 + T EFF /T EM and T CM response, which appears superior to s.c. BCG vaccination. Due to the ability of BCG to protect against childhood TB, most TB vaccines currently in clinical trial incorporate either recombinant BCG, attenuated Mtb strains or boosting regimes to maintain this protection [8]. Given the longlived immune response we see in the lungs of mice following Liporale TM -BCG vaccination, we speculate that the delivery of novel live TB vaccines via the oral route may more effectively target the mucosal immune response than traditional immunization routes, enhancing protection against aerosol Mtb infection. Figure 5. Increased multifunctional CD4 + T cells in the lungs of Liporale TM -BCG vaccinated mice. Lymphocytes from the lungs of naïve, Liporale TM -BCG vaccinated (BCG oral) or subcutaneous vaccinated (BCG s.c.) mice were stimulated for 6 hours in the presence of Brefeldin A and monensin then analyzed by flow cytometry. (A) Representative dot plots of CD4 + T cells from the lungs of naïve or BCG vaccinated mice expressing IFNc, TNFa or IL-2 cytokines. Multifunctional cells were identified by first gating on IFNc+ cells, and then on cells positive for both TNFa and IL-2. (B) Bar graph showing the percentage of CD4 + T cells from naïve or BCG vaccinated mice producing 1, 2 or 3 cytokines simultaneously, and bar graph of the frequency of multifunctional CD4 + T cells in the lungs of naïve or vaccinated mice at 4 weeks post immunization. (C,D) Bar graphs as in (B), but showing results for 8 and 30 weeks post vaccination, respectively. Results are displayed as mean + SEM of n = 5 for each group, significance expressed relative to naïve: *p,0.05, **p,0.01, ***p,0.001 (two way ANOVA with Bonferroni post test (Figure 5a, b and c, left graphs), one way ANOVA with Tukey post test (Figure 5a, b and c, right graphs)). Eight and 30 weeks results are representative of 2 independent experiments. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0045888.g005