Molecular Effects of Doxycycline Treatment on Pterygium as Revealed by Massive Transcriptome Sequencing

Pterygium is a lesion of the eye surface which involves cell proliferation, migration, angiogenesis, fibrosis, and extracellular matrix remodelling. Surgery is the only approved method to treat this disorder, but high recurrence rates are common. Recently, it has been shown in a mouse model that treatment with doxycycline resulted in reduction of the pterygium lesions. Here we study the mechanism(s) of action by which doxycycline achieves these results, using massive sequencing techniques. Surgically removed pterygia from 10 consecutive patients were set in short term culture and exposed to 0 (control), 50, 200, and 500 µg/ml doxycycline for 24 h, their mRNA was purified, reverse transcribed and sequenced through Illumina’s massive sequencing protocols. Acquired data were subjected to quantile normalization and analyzed using cytoscape plugin software to explore the pathways involved. False discovery rate (FDR) methods were used to identify 332 genes which modified their expression in a dose-dependent manner upon exposure to doxycycline. The more represented cellular pathways included all mitochondrial genes, the endoplasmic reticulum stress response, integrins and extracellular matrix components, and growth factors. A high correlation was obtained when comparing ultrasequencing data with qRT-PCR and ELISA results. Doxycycline significantly modified the expression of important cellular pathways in pterygium cells, in a way which is consistent with the observed efficacy of this antibiotic to reduce pterygium lesions in a mouse model. Clinical trials are under way to demonstrate whether there is a benefit for human patients.


Introduction
Pterygium is a very common ocular surface lesion attributed to chronic ultraviolet light exposure which typically afflicts a younger population, adding tremendous burden, both human and financial, in many countries [1]. At the cellular level, pterygium is characterized by proliferation of limbal cells, inflammatory infiltrates, fibrosis, angiogenesis, and extracellular matrix breakdown [2][3][4]. Traditionally regarded as a degenerative condition, pterygia also display tumor-like features, such as propensity to invade normal tissue and high recurrence rates following resection [5]. The mechanism of pterygium formation is not completely understood but several processes have been suggested as part of the pathogenesis of this disease, including genetic predisposition, anti-apoptotic mechanisms, cytokines, growth factors, extracellular matrix remodelling, immunological mechanisms, and viral infections [6].
Currently, the only approved treatment for pterygium is surgery [7], a group of different procedures that, in some cases, result in high recurrence rates [8]. Recently, based on the profuse irrigation of the pterygium lesion, bevacizumab-mediated antiangiogenic therapies have been tested, but these protocols have produced inconclusive results [9,10].
In a recent article, it was shown that doxycycline, a common oral antibiotic, was able to dramatically reduce pterygium-like lesions in a mouse model [11]. The same antibiotic was responsible for reducing neovascularisation in a burn model of the rat cornea [12]. Apparently, doxycycline and other tetracyclines posses numerous properties which are independent of their antibiotic activity [13]. Specifically, the antiangiogenic effects of doxycycline seem to be related with the inhibition of matrix metalloproteinases [14,15], although alternative and/or synergistic mechanisms cannot be excluded.
In the present study we decided to investigate the molecular effects of doxycycline on short-term primary cultures of pterygium cells, using ultrasequencing techniques, to better understand all the pathways affected by the antibiotic in pterygium.

Results
Primary cultures were established from pterygia surgically removed from 10 patients. To identify the cell population present in these cultures, immunofluorescence for different markers was performed. Confocal microscopy of these samples showed that the predominant cell population is composed of vimentin-positive cells, with a fibroblast-compatible morphology (Fig. 1).
The cultures were treated with doxycycline and RNA from these samples was analyzed through massive sequencing. Due to the characteristics of the multiplexing protocol and other technical reasons, there was a broad variability on the number of sequence readings per sample, ranging from 82,040 to more than 7.5 million reads (Fig. 2). To deal with this variability, ultrasequencing data were normalized in all samples. To test the efficacy of our normalization protocol, several predictions were made and checked on the data pool. One of the tests consisted in the prediction of the patient's gender by analyzing expression of genes coded by the Y chromosome (Fig. 3A,B) or other genes whose expression is linked to the sex of the individual, such as XIST or RPS4Y1 (not shown). The gender of all patients was correctly predicted. A second test consisted in the analysis of genes whose expression was not modified by doxycycline treatment. In these cases, the genetic background of each patient was very homogeneous in comparison with the expression in other patients, which was more variable (Fig. 3C-H).
Following normalization, the first observation was a confirmation of the predominant cell type in the cultures. Several fibroblast markers, including fibronectin 1, collagen type1 a and b, vimentin, and collagen type 3, were found among the 10 most represented transcripts of the study, whereas markers for endothelial and epithelial cells were very scarce.
Then, gene expression of samples treated with doxycycline was compared with untreated controls. A Manhattan-type heatmap for the 332 genes whose expression experimented the largest variation after antibiotic treatment shows that treatments tend to group together, indicating that for these genes variations due to the treatment are larger than those due to individual idiosyncrasies (Fig. 4).
To investigate which cellular pathways are involved in the response of pterygium cells to doxycycline, ultrasequencing results were analyzed with specialized software. The group of genes that experiment larger variations after treatment with the antibiotic are the ones expressed by the mitochondrial genome. Eukaryotic mitochondrial DNA codes for 15 major genes; of these, a single gene (MT-ATP8) did not change, expression for the 2 genes coding for ribosomal RNA was highly upregulated in a dosedependent manner after treatment, whereas expression for the other 12 genes was downregulated, also in a dose-dependent fashion (Table 1).
Another pathway whose expression was deeply modified (all genes in this pathway were upregulated) upon doxycycline treatment includes almost all the proteins involved in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress response (Fig. 5). This pathway is implicated at all levels, from the docking of the ribosome to the ER (SSR2, RRBP1, SEC61A1), to proteins involved in protein folding (PPIB, PDIA1 to 6, etc), quality control proteins (BiP, SIL1, HSP47), members of the unfolded protein response (ATF6, IRE1, PERK), and the ER-associated protein degradation (ERAD) process (EDEM1, SEC61, ubiquitin ligase complex, etc). When the unfolded protein response (UPR) is activated, several mediator signals are sent to the nucleus to activate UPR responsive genes and to promote apoptosis. One of these is CHOP, which is also upregulated in doxycycline treated cells.
Another set of genes affected by doxycycline treatment includes several integrins, integrin-interacting proteins, collagens, and other extracellular matrix components ( Table 2), indicating that doxycycline has a significant impact on matrix remodelling. In addition, several growth factors including VEGF and MANF, cytokines such as IL-6, and cell cycle related factors (TP53, CDKN1A, CDK2AP2) had also modified expression in the doxycycline treated cells.
Sequencing results were confirmed through quantitative real time PCR (qRT-PCR) for those pathways with higher degrees of variation upon treatment. In all cases, the direction and magnitude of the change in expression was confirmed by the amplification technique (Fig. 6). For all the chosen genes, there was a tight correlation between data obtained through ultrasequencing and those collected by real time PCR (Fig. 7), indicating the efficiency of our normalization method.
For some genes that generate secretory proteins, such as MANF, IL-6, and VEGFA, a further confirmation was performed through ELISA protein determination in the supernatant of the treated and untreated cultures. Again, a high correlation was observed among sequencing data, qRT-PCR quantification, and ELISA protein levels (Fig. 8).

Discussion
In this study we have shown through ultrasequencing analysis that pterygium cells respond to doxycycline treatment by modifying the expression levels of a broad number of genes responsible for important cellular functions. Among the pathways that were modified the most, we found the mitochondrial genes, the ER stress cascade, growth factors, interleukins, cell cycle regulators, integrins, and components of the extracellular matrix.

Data Normalization
Massive transcriptome sequencing is a relatively new technique and, as such, needs some time and a series of additional developments before its complete potential can be achieved. In this regard, data normalization is one of the most relevant problems in current papers dealing with ultrasequencing data. Initially it was presumed that RNA-seq techniques were free of the nonlinear distortions that plagued hybridization techniques. Hence expression values were derived directly from the total number of alignments for a particular exon divided by its length [16]. Later on, that measurement was improved by the Reads Per Kilobase of exon model per Million mapped reads (RPKM) method [17]. Still, these and similar methods were affected by an important sequencing depth bias. Nowadays, novel normalization methods are appearing to deal with all these problems [18].
Our normalization protocol uses the broad experience accrued in the last years from microarray analysis, where quantile normalization has been the gold standard [19]. This approach does not introduce substantial biases in either genes with low expression nor in those with high expression levels. Confirmation of the quality of our approach is provided by a series of biological evidences. First, our data predicted correctly the gender of all the patients based on the expression of genes coded by the Y chromosome. Second, genes whose expression is bound to the sample genetic background were clearly differentiated with this method. In addition, expression data obtained by addition of sequencing alignments presented a high correlation with data obtained from the same samples by qRT-PCR. An outstanding advantage of this methodology is that samples with very different sequencing depth (from 80,000 to more than 7,000,000 reads, Fig. 1) can be used for the analysis whereas in other methodologies they need to be discarded in order to avoid biases [20].

Previous High-throughput Studies in Pterygium
A few previous studies had applied high-throughput techniques to study the transcriptomics of pterygium. For instance, the gene expression of pterygium was compared to that of normal autologous conjuntiva, finding a significant increase of fibronectin, CD24, MIP-4, and NGAL in the pterygium lesions [21,22]. Another study compared the gene expression pattern of pterygium with pre-existing data on human cornea, limbus, and conjunctiva, finding that pterygium markers closely resemble those of conjunctival and limbal cells [23]. A recent paper has shown that pterygium presents aberrant DNA methylation patterns in regions close to matrix remodelling genes such as TGM-2, MMP-2 and CD24 [24]. Our study is the first to analyze mRNA and protein changes produced by a drug treatment on pterygium cells.
Our cultured cells were positive for vimentin and negative for epithelial and endothelial markers. Therefore our first impulse was to classify them as fibroblasts. Nevertheless, Dushku and Reid showed that pterygium originates from altered limbal epithelial basal cells which express vimentin but do not stain for keratins [25], so our primary cultures seem to represent the characteristic cells of pterygium.

Doxycycline Action on the Mitochondria
Doxycycline has been used in the past as a reversible inhibitor of mitochondrial translation [26][27][28]. Doxycycline occupies an important tRNA binding site on the 30S ribosome subunit, thus preventing the attachment of amino acyl tRNAs and terminating the translation process. Depending on the cell type, different mechanisms are activated [29]. This translation inhibition has been associated with cell arrest, apoptosis/necrosis, and cell detachment due to activation of caspase 3, 8, and 9, but also to caspase-independent mechanisms [29][30][31][32]. Interestingly, doxycycline concentrations achievable in serum seem to be more toxic for tumors than for normal cells [33]. To the best of our knowledge, our study provides the first evidence of doxycycline acting as a selective inhibitor of mitochondrial genes' transcription. The inhibition is potent and raises the question of whether the recognized effect of doxycycline as an inhibitor of mitochondrial protein synthesis is due, at least in part, to the inhibition of the transcription of mitochondrial encoded genes rather than to its binding to the ribosomes' active site.
Nonetheless, doxycycline pretreatment has been shown to counteract the apoptosis and ER stress responses induced by doxorubicin in mouse heart and testis [34,35], probably through a preconditioning mechanism. This is in agreement with our data showing and increase in prosurvival molecules such as IL6, VEGFA, p21, or RelA. A short time exposure to doxycycline would provoke a transient mitochondrial damage and ER stress that would stimulate those survival factors that may protect the cells from the following doxorubicin insult. However in our experimental paradigm those survival factors seem to be overwhelmed by the production of proapoptotic factors such as CHOP, BAX, and caspase activation.

Endoplasmic Reticulum Stress Response Pathway
ER stress is a cellular response to disturbances in the normal function of the ER which is conserved in all mammalian species, as well as in yeast and worms [36]. Accumulation of unfolded proteins in the ER lumen results in activation of a common response to this stress situation called the unfolded protein response (UPR), which is aimed initially at compensating for damage trying to restore normal function of the cell by halting protein translation and activating the signaling pathways that lead to increasing production of molecular chaperones involved in protein folding, but can eventually trigger cell death if ER stress is severe or prolonged [37]. There are three main signaling systems initiated by UPR through ER stress sensors, including Eukaryotic translation initiation factor 2-alpha kinase 3 (eIF2AK3), Activating transcription factor 6 (ATF-6 alpha), and Endoplasmic reticulum to nucleus signaling 1 (IRE1) [36]. In normal conditions these proteins are inactivated by Heat shock 70 kDa protein 5 (GRP78). Accumulation of unfolded proteins leads to GRP78 binding to them, resulting in release and activation of eIF2AK3, ATF-6 alpha and IRE1 [37][38][39][40].
In agreement with the results shown above, we also found an increase in the transcription of GADD34 and DNAJC3, which promote negative feed-back loops leading to restoration of protein translation. However, when the restoration of homeo-stasis is not achieved within a certain time lapse the UPR switches to apoptosis promotion. Despite the translational block produced by PERK activation, certain genes can bypass this block. An example is the proapoptotic protein CHOP (CCAAT/2enhancer-binding protein homologous protein) which is upregulated by ATF4 (activating transcription factor 4). CHOP causes downregulation of the anti-apoptotic mitochondrial protein Bcl-2 [41], favoring a pro-apoptotic drive at the mitochondria by proteins that cause mitochondrial damage, cytochrome c release, and caspase 3 activation. The doxycycline-mediated increase on the transcription of CHOP suggests that the proapoptotic switch has been produced. Moreover, C/ EBP zeta, which is activated by IRE1 and leads to decreased Bcl-2 transcription [42], is also upregulated by doxycycline. Consistently, the expression of the pro-apoptotic molecule BAX is also increased, supporting the idea of activation of apoptosis in pterygium cells by doxycycline.

Extracellular Matrix and Integrins
Integrins and integrin receptors regulate many aspects of cell physiology, being of particular importance in cell adhesion and migration. These two processes depend on packing of actin cytoskeleton into adhesive and protrusive organelles in response to extracellular signals. In normal epithelia, alpha/beta integrins function as receptors for the laminin family of extracellular matrix proteins (such as laminin 1 and laminin 5) and mediate the stable attachment of epithelial cells to the underlying basement membrane [43].
The function of some integrins, such as alpha-6/beta-4 integrin, is altered substantially as normal epithelia undergo malignant transformation and progress to invasive carcinoma [44]. Cooperative signaling between integrins and v-Erb-b2 erythroblastic leukemia viral oncogene homologs 2 and 3 (ErbB2 and ErbB3) is required to promote PI3K activation. This activation is mediated through GAB1 [45]. Alpha-6/beta-4 integrin can also form signaling complexes with specific growth factor receptors that act synergistically to activate PI3K [44,46]. A signaling pathway involving EGFR, ErbB2, ErbB3, phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K), Akt, glycogen synthase kinase 3-b (GSK3-b), and cyclin D1 is essential for the maintenance of survival, mitosis, and invasiveness of human lung adenocarcinoma cell lines as well as to evade apoptosis [47].
In our experiments, doxycycline treatment decreased the expression of multiple members involved in the interaction between the cell and the extracellular membrane, including ligands such as laminin 1, laminin 5, and THBS1, integrins such as b1 and ErbB3, intracellular mediators such as vinculin, GAB1, PI3K p85, and EIF4E3, suggesting that anoikis may be another mechanism by which doxycycline exerts its actions on pterygium cells. Figure 5. Schematic cartoon of the main pathways involved in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress response. Proteins are translocated directly from the ribosome into the ER and protein folding takes place with the help of specific chaperones. If folding is correct, the proteins follow their path to the Golgi complex and the secretory pathway. If misfolded proteins accumulate in the ER lumen, the UPR can be triggered and signals will be sent to the nucleus and apoptosis could be induced through CHOP. All the proteins represented in the cartoon are significantly upregulated by doxycycline treatment. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0039359.g005

Growth Factors and Interleukins
Several growth factors such as VEGF and MANF and interleukins such as IL-6 were elevated in pterygium cells exposed to doxycycline.
VEGF has attracted much attention in the study of pterygium lesions since they are highly vascularised and upregulation of VEGF has been reported in pterygia when compared to normal conjunctiva [48]. In addition, women with a polymorphism in the VEGF gene (VEGF-460) have a 2.5-fold increased risk of developing pterygium [49]. These observations were instrumental in designing clinical trials where bevacizumab, the humanized blocking antibody against VEGF, was applied to pterygium lesions [9,10]. The fact that doxycycline treatment results in a higher expression of VEGF suggests that this may be a compensatory reaction of the cells whose survival is compromised by the decrease in mitochondrial protein synthesis and elevated ER stress.
In the same line of thought, MANF acts as a growth factor for astrocytes and other neural cells but also as a protective factor against ER stress [50]. Since we have reported a huge increase in genes related to the ER stress response upon doxycycline treatment, MANF expression may be increased to try to compensate for these deleterious circumstances.
IL-6 is a proinflammatory cytokine which is upregulated in pterygium by UV light exposure and might be part of the pathological pathway leading to the formation of the lesion [51]. Elevation of this cytokine is related to increases in angiogenesis, cell proliferation, invasion potential, and inflammation. The upregulation of IL-6 after treatment with doxycycline may be also part of the survival program of the pterygium cells faced by the harsh conditions created by the antibiotic.

Cell Cycle Arrest
Doxycycline has been shown to induce cell cycle arrest, although this effect is dependent on the cell line studied [29,52]. Likewise, induction of p53 gene expression in cancer cells can lead to both cell cycle arrest and apoptosis. In addition, the expression of the proapoptotic molecule Bax is up-regulated following an increase on p53 levels [53]. In our hands, doxycycline treatment on pterygium culture increased the expression of p53 and several others CDKs (CDKN1A, CDK2AP2), as well as the proapoptotic protein Bax, providing an additional mechanism to the observed changes.
In conclusion, we have shown that doxycycline elicits a strong dose-dependent response in pterygium cells inducing a number of intracellular pathways such as mitochondrial gene expression, the ER stress pathway, genes related to the extracellular matrix environment, growth factors, interleukins, and cell cycle related proteins. These changes can explain the reduction in pterygium growth previously reported in a mouse model for this antibiotic [11] and provide the theoretical basis to pursue treatment of pterygium patients with doxycycline. Current clinical trials are under way to test whether this treatment is efficient in humans.

Patients and Primary Culture
Use of pterygium specimens was approved by our Institutional Review Board (Comité É tico de Investigación Clínica de La Rioja, CEICLAR). All patients provided written informed consent and the specimens were handled in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki. Ten consecutive patients that underwent surgical removal of their primary pterygium were recruited. These included 6 males and 4 females with a medium age of 44.367.8  years (range . Of these, 2 patients were Spanish citizens (both women) and 8 were immigrants from South America. The excised pterygia were transferred to the laboratory for establishing cell cultures as previously described [11]. Briefly, the pterygium specimen was minced into small pieces and cultured for 3 days in DMEM/F-12 medium supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum, 200 mM L-glutamine, 0.5% DMSO, and 1% penicillin/streptomycin/amphotericin (all culture reagents are from Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA). Once the cells had migrated from the explants and attached to the dish surface, the explant fragments were removed and the medium changed to keratinocyte-serum free medium with 5% fetal calf serum, and 1% penicillin/streptomycin/amphotericin. When the cells reached 80% confluency, they were passed to fresh dishes using 0.25% trypsin. Medium was renewed every 2-3 days and replaced with fresh medium 24 h before adding the antibiotic. All experiments were performed with cells on passages 3 to 5. For each patient, cells were subjected to 4 treatments: 0 (control), 50, 200, and 500 mg/ml doxycycline (Vibravenosa, Pfizer, Alcobendas, Spain) for 24 h.

Immunofluorescence and Confocal Microscopy
Prior to doxycycline treatment, some cells were cultured in glass coverslips overnight, fixed with 10% buffered formalin for 10 min, permeabilized with 0.1% triton X-100 in PBS for 10 min, and exposed to a mix of 3 primary antibodies overnight at 4uC. These primary antibodies included mouse anti-vimentin (1:40, Sigma, Madrid, Spain), rabbit anti-cytokeratin 4 (1:100, Abcam, Cambridge, UK), and goat anti-CD31 (1:50, Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Santa Cruz, CA). Following vigorous washes, the second layer was added for 2 h at room temperature. Conjugated antibodies in this second layer included Alexa 633 donkey anti-goat, Alexa 546 donkey anti-rabbit, and Alexa 488 donkey anti-mouse (1:200, Invitrogen). After another series of washes, the coverslips were mounted with DAPI-containing ProLong mounting medium (Invitrogen). Paraffin sections of human uterus and appendix were processed in parallel as positive controls. A confocal microscope (Leica TCS SP5, Leica, Badalona, Spain) was used to visualize the slides.

RNA Extraction
Total RNA was isolated from pterygium cell cultures using TRIzol (Invitrogen), purified using an RNeasy Mini kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA), and treated with DNase I (Qiagen) following manufacturer's instructions.

cDNA Library Preparation and Ultrasequencing
Library preparation and ultrasequencing were performed following Illumina's (San Diego, CA) protocols. Most reagents were also from Illumina.
First, the integrity and quality of total RNA were assessed with the Experion Automated Electrophoresis system (BioRad, Hercules, CA). Then, mRNA was isolated from 1 mg of total RNA using poly-T oligo-attached magnetic beads. This mRNA was fragmented into pieces of approximately 200 bp using divalent cations under elevated temperature. The cleaved RNA fragments were reverse transcribed into first strand cDNA using reverse transcriptase and random primers. Next, the second strand was synthesized using DNA polymerase I and RNAse H. These double-stranded cDNA fragments were end-repaired by T4 DNA polymerase and Klenow DNA polymerase, and phosphorylated by T4 polynucleotide kinase. The cDNA products were incubated with Klenow DNA polymerase to generate 39 Adenine overhangs, therefore allowing ligation to Illumina indexing adapters to the double stranded cDNA ends. The adapter-ligated products were purified with Ampure XP magnetic beads (Agencourt Bioscience Corporation, Beverly, MA, USA) and libraries were amplified by 15 cycles of PCR with Phusion DNA polymerase (Finnzymes Reagents, Vantaa, Finland). Constructed libraries were validated and quantified using BioRad's automated electrophoresis system Experion and qPCR respectively. Pools of 6 indexed libraries were mixed (multiplexed) at equimolar ratios to yield a total oligonucleotide mix concentration of 10 nM. Finally the resulting libraries were sequenced on the Genome Analyzer IIx platform (Illumina) to generate 150 bp single reads. Six pooled indexed libraries were sequenced in each flow cell lane.

Data Treatment
Raw sequence data in fastq format were processed through a number of sequential steps: 1. Aggressive adapter removal: adapter sequences were removed from the raw sequences with an ad-hoc script using a nonconservative approach. Thus, even the shortest representations (one nucleotide) were eliminated. 2. mRNA alignment to DNA: alignment was performed by Tophat (an intron aware wrapper of Bowtie DNA aligner). Results were sorted and indexed using Samtools. 3. Coverage vectors for each sample were extracted under R statistical environment using Rsamtools library. Human GTF annotation from Ensembl was applied as reference for the exon genomic ranges, parsed into R data structures. Exon expression was calculated as the median coverage for every exon genomic range as stated by annotation. Exon expression data from our 40 different samples were normalized by quantile normalization and locus expression was calculated by simple addition of all the expression hits from distinct exons annotated to a single locus. 4. Samples were grouped by patient and every locus expression in the group was scaled in the interval [0,1] in order to correct for the different response ranges observed for the same gene in different genetic backgrounds. 5. Library siggenes in R was applied to select the differentially expressed loci using the FDR-based SAM method.
Resulting data were submitted to GEO (http://www.ncbi.nlm. nih.gov/geo) and are available with accession number GSE34736.

Heatmaps
The 332 genes whose expression was most regulated by doxycycline, with a FDR lower than 0.005, were represented as a heatmap by using a Manhattan method for dissimilarity and a ward method for hierarchical clustering, calculated in an R environment.

Pathway/Network Analysis
The Reactome FI cytoscape plugin (www.reactome.org) and the Genemania cytoscape plugin (www.genemania.org) [54] were used to identify enriched pathways and networks regulated by doxycycline treatment.

Statistics
GraphPad Prism v5 was used for all statistics. Two-way ANOVA was used to analyze qRT-PCR and ultrasequencing data. Correlation analysis was used to compare ultrasequencing and qRT-PCR data. Differences were considered statistically significant when p,0.05.

Confirmation of the Sequencing Results
Gene products whose expression was significantly changed upon application of doxycycline were chosen for further confirmation. cDNA was synthesized by reverse transcription of 1 mg of total RNA using the SuperScript III First-Strand Synthesis kit (Invitrogen) in a total volume of 20 ml according to the manufacturer's instructions and was amplified by qRT-PCR using Taqman probes (Table 3) in a 7300 Real Time PCR System (Applied Biosystems, Carlsbad, CA) and their gene expression calculated using absolute quantification by interpolation into a standard curve [55]. All values were divided by the expression of the house keeping gene, GAPDH, to avoid potential pipetting errors. Some secreted proteins such as IL-6, MANF and VEGF-A were quantified in the supernatant of the cultures by commercially available ELISA kits (Uscn, Life Science, Inc. Wuhan, China). Figure 8. Correlation among values obtained through ultrasequencing, qRT-PCR, and ELISA for 3 secretory proteins whose expression varies with doxycycline treatment. These include MANF (A,D), IL-6 (B,E), and VEGFA (C,F). For mRNA quantification (A,B,C), all bars represent fold increase with respect to untreated controls 6 SEM for 10 independent samples. For protein quantification (D,E,F), bars represent the mean 6 SEM for 10 independent samples. Statistically significant differences with untreated controls are represented by asterisks (for ultrasequencing and protein data) or the pound sign (for qRT-PCR). *: p,0.05; **: p,0.01; ***: p,0.001; #: p,0.05; ##: p,0.01; ###: p,0.001. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0039359.g008 Table 3. TaqMan probes used for the quantification of gene expression by qRT-PCR.