Individuals with asymptomatic infection due to Plasmodium vivax are posited to be important reservoirs of malaria transmission in endemic regions. Here we studied a cohort of P. vivax malaria patients in a suburban area in the Brazilian Amazon. Overall 1,120 individuals were screened for P. vivax infection and 108 (9.6%) had parasitemia detected by qPCR but not by microscopy. Asymptomatic individuals had higher levels of antibodies against P. vivax and similar hematological and biochemical parameters compared to uninfected controls. Blood from asymptomatic individuals with very low parasitemia transmitted P. vivax to the main local vector, Nyssorhynchus darlingi. Lower mosquito infectivity rates were observed when blood from asymptomatic individuals was used in the membrane feeding assay. While blood from symptomatic patients infected 43.4% (199/458) of the mosquitoes, blood from asymptomatic infected 2.5% (43/1,719). However, several asymptomatic individuals maintained parasitemia for several weeks indicating their potential role as an infectious reservoir. These results suggest that asymptomatic individuals are an important source of malaria parasites and Science and Technology for Vaccines granted by Conselho Nacional de may contribute to the transmission of P. vivax in low-endemicity areas of malaria.
Malaria still poses as one of the most important parasitic diseases in the world. The advance of molecular diagnosis brought to light the existence of asymptomatic infections, which may represent most of the infections in some areas. Importantly, the role of asymptomatic carriers in the natural history of malaria is not completely understood. Herein we describe the general characteristics of asymptomatic individuals infected with Plasmodium vivax, and provide evidence of their potential as parasitic reservoirs, even when molecular methods fail to detect the infection. Our findings reinforce the need for better diagnostic tests and open a new window of complexity to be considered in control programs.
Citation: Almeida GG, Costa PAC, Araujo MdS, Gomes GR, Carvalho AF, Figueiredo MM, et al. (2021) Asymptomatic Plasmodium vivax malaria in the Brazilian Amazon: Submicroscopic parasitemic blood infects Nyssorhynchus darlingi. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 15(10): e0009077. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009077
Editor: Photini Sinnis, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, UNITED STATES
Received: January 6, 2021; Accepted: August 30, 2021; Published: October 29, 2021
Copyright: © 2021 Almeida et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the manuscript.
Funding: RG was supported by the National Institutes of Health (R01AI079293, and U19 AI089681—Amazonian Center of Excellence in Malaria Research); Fundação de Amparo a Pesquisa de São Paulo (Fapesp, 2016/23618-8), Rede Mineira de Biomoléculas from Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa de Minas Gerais (Fapemig, RED-00012-14), Brazilian National Institute of Science and Technology for Vaccines granted by Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq)/Fapemig/Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Ensino Superior (CAPES) (465293/2014-0), and CNPq/MS-SCTIE-Decit/ Fundação Bill & Melinda Gates (442570/2019-8). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Plasmodium vivax is spread worldwide and although it is frequently considered to be low pathogenic, it is an important cause of morbidity and mortality in endemic areas in central and south America, and in regions of Asia and Oceania [1,2]. The annual incidence of vivax malaria has reduced since the last century in Brazil, but to achieve elimination new strategies are needed to optimize diagnostic and early treatment, and to block transmission from humans to mosquitoes . Control of P. vivax is challenging due to the unique biology of this species, including the early emergence of infectious gametocytes within 3 days after the detection of asexual forms, the development of hypnozoites in the liver, a potential source of later relapses, and the preferential infection of reticulocytes, which represents 0.5–2.5% of the red blood cells, which limits the parasite density [4,5].
Patients with symptomatic malaria actively seek diagnosis and treatment. In contrast, asymptomatic (ASY) cases of P. vivax infection are mostly undetectable, neglected, and remain untreated. For this reason, asymptomatic malaria require active surveillance and poses as one of the most challenging obstacles for the control of Plasmodium infections worldwide [6,7]. Evidence has shown that asymptomatic individuals commonly have very low parasite density, usually undetectable by field tests, such as microscopy or rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) . Although the role of these submicroscopic infections in the maintenance of endemicity is not well understood, it is generally thought that they may serve as parasitic reservoirs sustaining endemicity and causing new outbreaks [9–11].
In the Brazilian Amazon, the incidence of malaria dropped from near 600,000 cases/year in the late 1990s to near 144,000 in 2014 , mostly due to the implementation of the control measures established by the National Malaria Control Programme. Despite these recent declines, malaria is still hypoendemic in the Amazon and asymptomatic cases are thought to be one of the obstacles to the elimination of P. vivax transmission in the Amazon basin in Brazil . Hence, considering the global effort to eliminate malaria, it is crucial to characterize the asymptomatic population and to better understand if and how submicroscopic infections impact the transmission and impair the control of the disease. Herein we verified the frequency and the spatial distribution of asymptomatic infection in a low endemic setting of malaria caused by P. vivax in the Brazilian Amazon and explore their characteristics, which will be relevant for future studies in this population.
This study was performed under protocols reviewed and approved by the Ethical Committees on Human Experimentation from Instituto René Rachou, Fiocruz, and National Ethical Council (CAAE: 59902816.7.0000.5091). All participants were informed about the objectives and procedures of the study, with voluntary participation through written informed consent.
Surveys and inclusions criteria
Screening for asymptomatic infection.
Candeias do Jamari (8°47’41.6"S 63°42’10.9"W) is a municipality localized in the south-western Amazon region in Brazil, where malaria is endemic and the annual parasite index usually exceeds 50 cases per 1,000 inhabitants. Between 2018 and 2019, 2,394 cases of P. vivax and 287 cases of P. falciparum were notified in this town .
From December 2018 to October 2019, four cross-sectional surveys were done in 3 areas from this municipality to identify asymptomatic infections. Candeias do Jamari has two main seasons: a wet season between October and April and a dry season between May to September. Transmission of P. vivax occurs during the entire year, although peaks of transmission occur during the dry season. Areas 1 and 2 had the most reported symptomatic cases in the past years, while area 3 has reported fewer cases of symptomatic malaria . Screenings were done in a household-based sampling comprising adult individuals (18 years or older) manifesting interest in being enrolled in the study, reporting or having no symptomatic malaria in the last two months and at the time of enrollment. Exclusion criteria included: pregnancy, breastfeeding, and current diagnostic of chronic inflammatory or infectious diseases.
After informed consent, 200μL of blood were collected by finger puncture and Giemsa-stained thick blood smears were performed. Blood was centrifuged, and DNA was extracted from compacted cells using a commercial kit (QIAmp DNA blood mini kit, Qiagen). Extracted DNA was resuspended in 200μL of Elution Buffer to reproduce the original concentration of parasites/μL. Samples were tested at least in triplicate by qPCR and individuals with positive results for P. vivax in at least one replicate were included in the Baseline study. No template controls (NTC) were included in all reactions to ensure the reliability of the results.
Baseline and longitudinal arm.
Four to seven days after the first positive qPCR for P. vivax at Screening, 47 from 108 ASY donated a new blood sample, were interviewed, and clinically examined by a physician. This date of clinical examination was considered as the Baseline in our analysis. Thirty-eight symptomatic (SY) individuals with positive thick blood smears for P. vivax performed at the Centro de Pesquisas em Medicina Tropical (CEPEM) were also enrolled in this study. Twenty healthy individuals from Porto Velho with negative parasitemia by thick blood smear and PCR, and reporting no malaria symptoms for more than two years were enrolled as controls (CTL).
Blood was collected by venipuncture, and samples were used for routine blood counting and clinical biochemistry, DNA extraction, and thick smears for parasite detection. Interviews were done using a web-based tool for research data curatorship (REDCap). Heparinized blood samples from 32 ASY (17 from the Baseline and 15 of the last time point of the longitudinal arm, described below) and 9 SY were used in the membrane feeding assay. In this case, volunteers were included according to the availability of mosquitoes to perform the experiment. Treatment was offered to all ASY and those who chose to be treated received 3 days of chloroquine (600 mg on day 1, and 450 mg on days 2 and 3) and primaquine 7 days (total dose 3–4.2 mg/kg).
Forty-nine individuals were followed weekly for six weeks to assess the development of symptoms and for parasite detection (longitudinal arm). Among those, 36 subjects were from the Baseline, and additional 13 subjects were from Screening. The study design is depicted in Fig 1.
From 1,120 randomly tested individuals 108 tested positive in qPCR for P. vivax from which interviews and blood sampling were done in 47 at the Baseline. Longitudinal arm included 36 and 13 ASY individuals from Baseline and Screening, respectively. Membrane feeding assay was performed in 17 ASY from the Baseline and 15 from the last timepoint of the longitudinal arm.
Molecular diagnoses of Plasmodium vivax infections
A qPCR addressed to a sub-telomeric non-ribosomal multicopy target (Pvr47) was done as described by Amaral et al. , with modifications. Briefly, 2 μL of extracted DNA was mixed with 0.5 μM of primers (Pvr47-Forward 5’-TCCGCAGCTCACAAATGTTC3-3’, Pvr47-Reverse 5’-ACATGGGGATTCTAAGCCAATTTA-3’), 0.25 μM of probe (fam-5’-TCCGCGAGGGCTGCAA-3’-MGB), 5 μL master mix (CTVacinas, Brazil) and 1 μL of PCR-grade water. Reactions were done in an Applied Biosystems 7500 Real-Time PCR System with the following steps: 2 minutes of initial denaturation at 95°C followed by 45 cycles of denaturation (95°C/3s), annealing (54°C/30s) and extension (60°C/30s). Positive, negative, and blank controls were added to each plate. The same positive control was added to each plate to ensure the parasite quantification comparability inter-assay. A standard curve was built using a TOPO-2.1 plasmid with the amplified fragment inserted to calculate the number of copies of the target in a sample.
The PCR for P. falciparum was performed only in samples that were PCR positive for P. vivax to avoid the inclusion of patients co-infected with both species . When blood samples were PCR negative for P. vivax, but infected mosquitoes during membrane feeding assay (MFA), we also employed a nested PCR to confirm the result . Briefly, 2 μL DNA samples were mixed with 0.4 μM each SSUrRNA universal primers (P1:5’- ACGATCAGATACCGTCGTAATCTT-3’ and P2: 5’-GAACCCAAAGACTTTGATTTCTCAT- 3’), 125 μM each of dNTPs, 2.5 mM MgCl2, 1x Taq buffer (Promega), and 0.75 units of Taq polymerase (Promega), in a 20 μL final volume. Amplification was done as follows: 92°C/2m, followed by 35 cycles of 92°C/30s and 60°C/90s and a final extension of 60°C/5m. The product was diluted 1:50 in TE buffer (Qiagen) and 2 μL were applied in 8 μL mix containing 1 μM of primer P1 and a P. vivax primer (Vi, 5’-CAATCTAAGAATAAACTCCGAAGAGAAA-3’), 312.5 μM of each dNTP, 1x Taq buffer (Promega), 1.5 mM MgCl2, and 0.75 units of Taq polymerase (Promega). Amplification was as follows: 92°C/2m, followed by 18 cycles of 92°C/30s and 60°C/60s and a final extension of 60°C/5m. Products were electrophoresed and seen as ~110 bp bands in a 2% Agarose gel in a UV transilluminator.
Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay
Plasma from 47 ASY, 38 SY, and 20 healthy donors that reported never had malaria before was used to assess the levels of IgG against the P. vivax blood-stage antigens PvMSP-119 , PvAMA-166  and PvDBP-IIBrz-2 by ELISA as described . The results were expressed as reactivity index (RI = the ratio between the OD 450nm values obtained from the sample and the cut-off value). Cut-off value was set at 3 standard deviations above the mean OD 450nm of plasma from 34 individuals from the south-east of Brazil, a non-endemic area for malaria, and 12 individuals who reported never having had malaria before, from Porto Velho, the capital of Rondônia located 20km from Candeias do Jamari. Values of RI higher than 1.1 were considered positive.
Human-to-Mosquito transmission experiments
Nyssorhynchus darlingi mosquitoes from an established colony (F8-F18 generations) were reared under standard laboratory conditions as described . N. darlingi is the main vector of P. vivax in the area we studied. Mosquitoes were maintained on cotton soaked with 15% honey solution ad libitum one day before and after the infection blood meal. Heparinized blood was kept at 37°C, for approximately 10 minutes, until the membrane feeding assay. Blood sample (2mL) was loaded into a glass feeder closed with parafilm membrane and maintained at 37°C by a connected heated water source. One mesh-covered 650 mL plastic cup containing 80 females 3- to 5- days old N. darlingi (F8 to F18 generations) that had been starved for 24 h, were placed under the feeder for 30 min to allow feeding. Fully engorged females were transferred into 20cm3 cages and maintained in the same conditions of insectarium for 2 weeks.
One-third to one-half of each group of mosquitoes were dissected on day 7 and the remaining mosquitoes on day 14 post-feeding. Mosquitoes were freeze-killed and their midguts were dissected out in phosphate-buffered saline and stained with 0.2% w/v mercurochrome (in ddH2O) for 5 min. The percentage of mosquitoes infected and the number of oocysts/mosquito were determined by examination at 40x objective on a light microscope.
Differences between proportions were calculated by Fisher’s exact test. Odds ratios and confidence intervals (95%) were calculated by the Baptista-Pike method. Maps were edited using the software Q-GIS 3.12 and employing the SIRGAS 2000 UTM 22s coordinate system. Base-layer was from the ArcGIS (source: Esri, Maxar, GeoEye, Earthstar Geographics, CNES/Airbus DS, USDA, USGS, AeroGRID, IGN, and the GIS User Community. Available on https://arcg.is/1H5GjP). Variables were tested for Gaussian distribution using the Shapiro-Wilk test and variables were tested according to their distribution. Mann-Whitney U test and t-student test were used for comparisons between two groups. ANOVA or Kruskal-Wallis tests were used for multiple comparisons. The Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient was used to test correlations. These analyses were performed using GraphPad Prism 8 (GraphPad Software, San Diego, CA, USA). Longitudinal spot-matrix were done using R and ggplot2 package. The statistical significance threshold was P < 0.05, with 95% confidence intervals for all hypotheses tested.
Occurrence of asymptomatic cases of P. vivax infection are associated with the distribution of symptomatic malaria
An overall 1,120 individuals were tested for P. vivax infection by qPCR during the 4 Screenings from which a total of 108 (9.6%) were PCR positive (Table 1). All ASY were negative in blood thick smear. The male/female ratio was 0.93 (540/580). There was a higher prevalence of ASY infection among males in December compared to females (OR 3.244, CI: 1.552–6.604, p = 0.002, Table 1). The prevalence of asymptomatic infection was higher in females in September when compared to December in the same area (OR 2.218, CI: 1.027–4.568, p = 0.046, Table 1).
To test the distribution of ASY according to SY cases, the surveys conducted in December, January, and September were focused on the two areas with higher number of reported SY infection (areas 1 and 2), while in October the Screening was conducted in an area with fewer notified cases of SY malaria (area 3). We visited all houses of area 1 in both surveys, and only 64 individuals out of 669 were sampled in more than one survey. Although all houses were visited in both surveys we could not interview or sample all the residents due to the absence of people at the time of visit or sampling refusal. There was no significant difference between the percentages of ASY from areas 1 (December) and area 2 (January), but a marginally significant difference was observed between the proportions of areas 1 and 2 when September and January were compared (OR 1.8, CI 1.026–3.112, p = 0.0459). In contrast, area 3 had a lower prevalence of ASY compared to the other areas (Table 1), following the same trend found for SY cases. Interestingly, the distribution of ASY is associated with the average of annual notified cases in each studied area (Fig 2A). The spatial distribution of individuals at a household level is shown in Fig 2B.
(a) Mean and standard deviation of officially notified symptomatic cases between the studied areas from 2015 to 2019. (b) Spatial distribution of asymptomatic infections between the 3 areas studied in Candeias do Jamari, RO. Map was built using QGIS using base layers from USGS source: Esri, Maxar, GeoEye, Earthstar Geographics, CNES/Airbus DS, USDA, USGS, AeroGRID, IGN, and the GIS User Community. (Available on https://arcg.is/1H5GjP).
The parasitemia in SY was higher than in ASY (Fig 3A). The median of the estimated parasite density of SY patients was 39,279 copies/μL (IQR 3,247–178,458), while for ASY individuals was 14.2 copies/μL (IQR 2.44–76.5). High variability inter- and intra-assay in the mean Cq value were observed in ASY at the higher Cqs. Moreover, no amplification was observed in one or more replicates of the same ASY sample. To test whether this finding was due to the very low parasitemia we evaluated the correlation of each mean value with the respective standard deviation of the Cq. There was a positive correlation between the standard deviation of the replicates and the cycle threshold, indicating that the lower the number of copies in the sample, the higher the variability between replicates (Fig 3B). Estimated parasitemia of ASY with conflicting results (ASYconf) was lower than the ASY with non-conflicting results (ASYnon-conf) whose all replicates had detected amplification (Fig 3C).
(a) Estimated parasitemia determined by qPCR. Asymptomatic infections are characterized by very low parasitemia. Each dot represents the average number of copies/μL of an individual in at least 3 replicates. (b) Correlation between mean Cq value and correspondent standard deviation. High Cq values correlate with higher variation in the measurement. (c) Several asymptomatic infections had conflicting PCR results (ASYconf); 1 or more negative results in qPCR. Asymptomatic non-conflicting (ASYnon-conf) individuals had all qPCR replicates positive. Each dot represents the average number of copies/μL estimated from the Ct of the positive replicates of a subject, in at least 3 replicates. Bars amid dot plots represent the respective means. ****p<0.0001. t-Student test. SY–Symptomatic patients. ASY–Asymptomatic individuals.
Most asymptomatic individuals report a previous symptomatic infection
Of the 47 ASY enrolled at Baseline, most (93%, 44/47) reported a previous episode of SY malaria, with 77% (34/44) and 61% (27/44) reporting respectively more than 2 and 5 or more symptomatic episodes in their lives. The time since the last SY malaria was higher than 12 months for 75% (33/44) of participants. The average age of ASY was 40 years old, and the male/female ratio was 0.8 (21/26). The average ages for SY and CTL were 39.2 and 28.9 years old, and the male/female ratios were 2.3 and 1.1, respectively. In addition, 49% (23/47) of the ASY had become PCR negative in about one week. No ASY had fever during clinical examination, while 41% (14/34) of the SY had an axillary temperature above 37.5°C. From the 47 ASY included, 34 (72%) were re-assessed 30 to 45 days after the Baseline enrollment, and none of them reported seeking or receiving malaria treatment in the previous month.
Hematological and biochemical parameters are not altered during asymptomatic malaria caused by P. vivax
No relevant routine hematological abnormality was observed in ASY. Most SY had marked lymphopenia and low counts of platelets (Fig 4). Biochemical parameters were analyzed, and levels were comparable between ASY and CTL. Symptomatic patients had higher levels of C reactive protein (CRP) and bilirubin, and lower levels of cholesterol compared to ASY and CTL (Fig 4).
Each dot represents individual values of each analyte by group. Gray background and dotted lines represent range of expected values in healthy individuals. Only significant differences were shown. *p<0.05. **p<0.01. ***p<0.001. ****p<0.0001. Dunn’s test. SY–symptomatic patients. AS–Asymptomatic individuals. CTL—healthy controls. CRP–C-reactive protein. ALT–alanine transferase. AST–Aspartate transferase.
Most of the asymptomatic individuals have IgG anti-P. vivax antigens
Levels of IgG against the recombinant antigens PvMSP-119, PvAMA166, and PvDBPIIBrz-2 were significantly higher in ASY than in CTL. Despite the levels observed in SY showed to be higher than those observed in ASY, 78% of the latter produced IgG anti-PvMSP-119 above the cutoff. Also, 63.8% and 53.2% of ASY displayed IgG levels against PvAMA166 and PvDBPII-Brz-2 above the cutoff (Fig 5A). Interestingly, 4 individuals had no detectable IgG against the antigens, while 16 (37.2%) among IgG positive individuals had antibodies against all three antigens (Fig 5B). Noteworthy, except for PvMSP-119, levels of IgG were similar between ASY and SY.
a) Reactivity index for each individual by group for the three antigens. Each dot represents individual values of each analyte by group. Gray background represents the cut-off threshold. Data above the background is positive, and bellow, negative. Data upon the gray line is considered inconclusive. Y-axis is Log2 transformed to better show the distribution of negative individuals. Only significant differences were shown. **p<0.01. ****p<0.0001. Dunn’s test. b) Venn’s Diagram depicting the distribution of IgG positive ASY for the three antigens. RI–reactivity index. SY–symptomatic patients. ASY–Asymptomatic individuals. CTL—healthy controls.
Peripheral blood infection by P. vivax can be detected for several weeks in symptomless individuals
A group of 49 ASY was followed by 6 weeks with weekly blood sampling to verify changes in parasitemia. From the 49 subjects, 27 (55%) became PCR negative as soon as one week after the sampling and 15 were negative in all samplings throughout the study. ASY that become negative in the following week, have a higher probability of bearing parasite density below the median (14.2 copies/μL) (Fisher’s exact test, p<0.0001, OR = 21.4, CI 6.03–60.82). Also, 6 subjects had at least one positive PCR after the 3rd week. Twenty individuals were PCR positive in at least two consecutive weeks, and 4 were positive in all weeks tested. Parasite densities did not vary substantially in the individuals with detectable parasitemia across the weeks. While some individuals showed detectable parasitemia for several weeks, some became negative for P. vivax, showing positivity later during the longitudinal arm (Fig 6), suggesting either reinfection or oscillating parasitemia. No individual included in the longitudinal arm became symptomatic during the study.
Blood from asymptomatic P. vivax-infected individuals infect N. darlingi
Finally, we verified the potential of blood from ASY to infect colony-raised N. darlingi. From 2,823 engorged mosquitoes, 2,177 were dissected with a mean of 77.2% surviving until midgut dissection. Blood from all 9 SY were able to infect mosquitoes, with a rate of infection of 43.4% (199/458). The numbers of oocysts varied from 1–108 per midgut. Blood from 50% (16/32) of ASY was able to infect mosquitoes, with significantly lower infection rates compared to SY (Fig 7A). Blood from ASY infected 2.5% (43/1,719) of the mosquitoes with the numbers of oocysts varying from 1–8 per midgut (Fig 7C).
Eighty to one-hundred colony raised females of N. darlingi were fed in fresh blood collected from symptomatic patients (SY) and asymptomatic individuals (ASY), with current (PCR+/+) or past (PCR+/-) detected low parasitemia by qPCR. Each dot represents individual values of the frequency of infected mosquitoes by person. **p<0.01. ns- not significant. two-tailed Mann-Whitney U test. c) Photomicrographs showing several oocysts in midguts from mosquitoes fed in symptomatic or asymptomatic individuals (arrows).
From 15 ASY with positive PCR in the same blood sample used for MFA, 8 were able to infect mosquitoes, as evidenced by the oocysts found in their midgut ranging from 1 to 7 per midgut. Interestingly, among 17 ASY who were PCR positive at Screening but became negative at the time of sampling for MFA (PCR+/-), blood samples from 8 ASY infected mosquitoes. The average number of infected mosquitoes was similar between both groups (Fig 7B). Most importantly, 5 out of those 8 ASY, whose blood infected mosquitoes, were PCR negative in the same samples used for MFA (Fig 6, individuals 23, 27, 29, 42 and 45 at sampling week 6). To exclude the possibility that these findings were due to DNA polymorphisms or intrinsic PCR failures, a nested-PCR addressing the 18S ribosomal gene  was employed in the same samples and confirmed the results.
Here, we found that in areas with a higher frequency of symptomatic cases, a considerable proportion of the population currently present P. vivax subpatent infections. These areas are characterized by their proximity to rivers and the riparian forest, which provides environmental conditions to maintain the life cycle of anophelines. Importantly, we found that blood from ASY with subpatent parasitemia effectively infected the vector N. darling with P. vivax.
During the rainy season (October to April), most of the riparian forest is submerged due to the flooding of Jamari river. In this period, the number of SY cases is lower when compared to the dry season (May to September) [14,22]. After the flood, infection rates rise due to the increase of the anophelines breeding habitats and numbers . Historically, more SY cases are reported in September than in December [13,14]. However, our data suggest that the proportion of ASY infections does not follow the seasonality observed for SY infection, as also found by others .
The fact that ASY individuals have lower parasite densities compared to SY is well known . The conflicting results for some of the individuals were inversely correlated with parasitemia, suggesting subsampling error or stochastic amplification (Monte-Carlo effect) [26,27]. In those cases, several replicates were necessary to conclude whether the individual was infected or not. The fact that 50% of samples tested by MFA with negative PCR were able to infect mosquitoes reinforces that these results are due to very low parasitemia and not due to sample cross-contamination . The limit of detection (LOD) calculated for our qPCR was 154.2 copies/μL, detecting as low as 23.5 copies/μL by the 95%CI. Values below the LOD were extrapolated from the standard curve and therefore subjected to higher variability. Besides the intrinsic limitations of this approach, our results are compatible with those found by others for P. falciparum  and P. vivax [15,27,30].
Defining ASY infection is not trivial . The first concern to be considered is the occurrence of pre-symptomatic patients, since the incubation period might be remarkably long . To avoid this bias, we monitored ASY up to 45 days after the enrollment to ensure they remained ASY. Moreover, in the longitudinal study, no ASY received treatment or developed classical symptoms of malaria or others that made them seek medical care. No relevant alterations were found in parameters from ASY that are usually observed in SY, such as lymphopenia and thrombocytopenia, along with high levels of CRP and bilirubin and lower levels of cholesterol . This finding reinforces that, along with the very low parasitemia, which might be undetectable at times, asymptomatic infections are also undetectable by routine exams or clinical evaluation.
Almost 80% of the ASY had detectable levels of IgG anti-MSP-119, as previously described . It has been shown that serum levels of IgG against PvMSP-119 slightly decline in SY 2 months after treatment . Likewise, IgG against PvMSP-119 is also short-lived in ASY [36,37]. It is not clear if the persistence of low parasite density is enough to sustain high levels of IgG for longer periods. These results might be relevant for the development of serological tests for the diagnosis of ASY infection.
As reported by others [29,38], our data show that parasitemia can oscillate when close to the detectable limits of molecular methods. The infection status of the subjects included in this study was assessed weekly for 6 weeks. Others evaluate the infection persistance of P. vivax monthly for longer periods . In both cases, no approach was used to verify if the presence of parasitemia in two different time points represents persistance or new infections. While the duration of a submicroscopic infection may be as long as five consecutive months, incubation periods of vivax malaria may be as long as one year [32,39]. The presence of the dormant phase of P. vivax (hypnozoites), may have an impact on the maintenance of low parasitemia in ASY, since a high proportion of recurrent infections evolve to ASY infections [5,40,41]. A recent study suggests that bone-marrow is an important reservoir of P. vivax in monkeys, but evidence in humans is still absent . Thus, up to now, these data are not able to determine whether the current ASY infection has been maintained for a long time or if individuals have been frequently re-infected with P. vivax, sustaining the low parasitemia and boosting the antibody levels.
In this study, we used 80–100 female N. darlingi to fed on blood of each subject. Assuming an average of 2–3μL of blood ingested by mosquito  and with an average of 77% of engorged mosquitoes, a total of 154–231μL of blood was tested by MFA, while only an equivalent of 6–20μL of blood was tested by PCR, which might explain the discrepancies with the qPCR and the mosquito infection in individuals with negative PCR results. All SY infected mosquitoes with a load of oocyst per midgut ranging from 1–108. Another study found 50% of infectivity with a range of 1–175 oocysts per midgut using similar methodologies and the same species of Anopheline (F1). Although SY were on average more infective to mosquitoes, almost half of the ASY were infective to N. darlingi in infection rates varying from 2.2–10.8%, as previously reported for N. darlingi  and for other species [25,45]. Importantly, half of the individuals with a current negative PCR, but with a previous infection detected less than one week before (PCR+/-), were able to infect mosquitoes with the same efficiency as the currently PCR positive (PCR+/+) ASY. Kiattibutr et al  found a similar result in 9 samples with negative PCR results, with a rate of infection lower than the one shown here. The lack of the detection of P. vivax in some samples is likely due to the very low parasite density or the sensitivity of the molecular assays , but enough to allow transmission when a large number of mosquitoes are fed.
It has been shown that in P. falciparum malaria, the contribution of ASY for the transmission is higher in low transmission settings, and increases with the relative proportions of subpatent infections . Another elegant study assessed the relative contribution of ASY and SY malaria for both species, P. falciparum and P. vivax, to the infectious reservoir in low-endemic settings in Ethiopia. The ASY infection by P. vivax had a greater impact on the transmission compared to SY, being responsible for the majority of the infectious reservoir . Such studies were still not performed in our study area in Brazil, and thus the relative contribution of ASY P. vivax infection in our settings remains elusive. Also, it is important to notice that only adults were included in this study, and the contribution of asymptomatic malaria in children (below 18 years old) to transmission is unknown in this setting.
Very low numbers of parasites circulating may strongly impair the probability of detection by PCR, while in a real transmission scenario, high densities of mosquitoes might increase the chance of infection and maintain the endemicity. Thus, these data suggest that mass treatment might be a valuable tool for disease control, although field studies are still needed to test its efficacy compared to other control measures currently employed .
In conclusion, we confirmed a significant proportion of asymptomatic infections in a low transmission area from the Brazilian Amazon. The distribution of asymptomatic cases in different areas is heterogeneous and is associated with a larger number of symptomatic cases in areas near the riparian forest. Low oscillating parasitemia can give false-negative results in epidemiological inquiries and the persisting silent infection fosters the conditions to turn ASY as potential reservoirs for P. vivax. Finally, using an artificial feeding assay, we show that blood from ASY infects colony-raised N. darlingi. Importantly, even with undetectable parasitemia by qPCR, ASY contribute with low rates of transmission to anophelines, suggesting their potential role in sustaining the P. vivax cycle in hypoendemic areas.
We are grateful to all the participants enrolled in the present study for their consent and cooperation. We would like to thank the the of Platform of Production and Infection of Malaria Vectors (PIVEM) from Fiocruz Rondonia, the field group (René de Moura Fé, João Dantas, and Maria Lourdes dos Santos), the microscopists (Franklin Barbosa, Valdines Santos and Antônio Gurgel), the Malaria Ambulatory Care team (Marcela de Oliveira, Vagno de Lima, Caroline Pereira, Eduardo Garbin and Rosilene Ruffato) and the project management team (Cristiane Gomes, Patrícia Palhares and Alessandra Araújo) for the invaluable support. We acknowledge the Program for Technological Development in Tools for Health–PDTIS-FIOCRUZ for the use of its facilities.
- 1. Battle KE, Lucas TCD, Nguyen M, Howes RE, Nandi AK, Twohig KA, et al. Mapping the global endemicity and clinical burden of Plasmodium vivax, 2000–17: a spatial and temporal modelling study. Lancet. 2019;394: 332–343. pmid:31229233
- 2. Guerra CA, Howes RE, Patil AP, Gething PW, van Boeckel TP, Temperley WH, et al. The international limits and population at risk of Plasmodium vivax transmission in 2009. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2010;4. pmid:20689816
- 3. Ferreira MU, Castro MC. Challenges for malaria elimination in Brazil. Malar J. BioMed Central; 2016;15: 1–18. pmid:26729363
- 4. Bousema T, Drakeley C. Epidemiology and infectivity of Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium vivax gametocytes in relation to malaria control and elimination. Clin Microbiol Rev. 2011;24: 377–410. pmid:21482730
- 5. Martin TCS, Vinetz JM. Asymptomatic Plasmodium vivax parasitaemia in the low-transmission setting: The role for a population-based transmission-blocking vaccine for malaria elimination. Malar J. 2018;17: 1–7. pmid:29291736
- 6. Bousema T, Okell L, Felger I, Drakeley C. Asymptomatic malaria infections: Detectability, transmissibility and public health relevance. Nat Rev Microbiol. 2014;12: 833–840. pmid:25329408
- 7. Cotter C, Sturrock HJW, Hsiang MS, Liu J, Phillips AA, Hwang J, et al. The changing epidemiology of malaria elimination: New strategies for new challenges. Lancet. 2013;382: 900–911. pmid:23594387
- 8. Recht J, Siqueira AM, Monteiro WM, Herrera SM, Herrera S, Lacerda MVG. Malaria in Brazil, Colombia, Peru and Venezuela: Current challenges in malaria control and elimination. Malar J. BioMed Central; 2017;16: 1–18. pmid:28049519
- 9. Okell LC, Bousema T, Griffin JT, Ouédraogo AL, Ghani AC, Drakeley CJ. Factors determining the occurrence of submicroscopic malaria infections and their relevance for control. Nat Commun. 2012;3: 1–9. pmid:23212366
- 10. Nguyen TN, von Seidlein L, Nguyen TV, Truong PN, Hung S Do, Pham HT, et al. The persistence and oscillations of submicroscopic Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium vivax infections over time in Vietnam: an open cohort study. Lancet Infect Dis. 2018;18: 565–572. pmid:29398388
- 11. Alves FP, Gil LHS, Marrelli MT, Ribolla PEM, Camargo EP, Pereira Da Silva LH. Asymptomatic Carriers of Plasmodium spp. as Infection Source for Malaria Vector Mosquitoes in the Brazilian Amazon. J Med Entomol. 2005;42: 777–779. pmid:16363160
- 12. Coura JR, Suárez-Mutis M, Ladeia-Andrade S. A new challenge for malaria control in Brazil: Asymptomatic Plasmodium infection—A Review. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz. 2006;101: 229–237. pmid:16862314
- 13. Brasil. Ministério da Saúde. Sistema de Informação de Vigilância Epidemiológica–SIVEP–Malária. [Internet]. 2020 [cited 6 May 2020]. Available: http:www.saude.gov.br/sivepmalaria
- 14. Teixeira do Nascimento Filha M. Análise espacial e epidemiológica da malária no município de Candeias do Jamari no Estado de Rondônia. 2015; Available: http://www.pgbioexp.unir.br/downloads/4586_analise_espacial_e_epidemiologica_da_malaria_(maria_do_nascimento_filha_&_dr._tony_katsuragawa).pdf
- 15. Amaral LC, Robortella DR, Guimarães LFF, Limongi JE, Fontes CJF, Pereira DB, et al. Ribosomal and non-ribosomal PCR targets for the detection of low-density and mixed malaria infections. Malar J. 2019;18: 154. pmid:31039781
- 16. Kimura M, Kanoek O, Liu Q, Zhou M, Kawamoto F, Wataya Y, et al. Identification of the four species of human malaria parasites by nested PCR that targets variant sequences in the small subunit rRNA gene. Parasitol Int. 1997;46: 91–95.
- 17. Cunha MG, Rodrigues MM, Soares IS. Comparison of the immunogenic properties of recombinant proteins representing the Plasmodium vivax vaccine candidate MSP119 expressed in distinct bacterial vectors. Vaccine. 2001;20: 385–396. pmid:11672901
- 18. Vicentin EC, Françoso KS, Rocha M V., Iourtov D, dos Santos FL, Kubrusly FS, et al. Invasion-inhibitory antibodies elicited by immunization with Plasmodium vivax apical membrane antigen-1 expressed in Pichia pastoris yeast. Infect Immun. 2014;82(3): 1296–307. pmid:24379279
- 19. Sousa TN, Tarazona-Santos EM, Wilson DJ, Madureira AP, Falco PR, Fontes CJ, et al. Genetic variability and natural selection at the ligand domain of the Duffy binding protein in brazilian Plasmodium vivax populations. Malar J. BioMed Central Ltd; 2010;9: 334. pmid:21092207
- 20. Figueiredo MM, Costa PAC, Diniz SQ, Henriques PM, Kano FS, Tada MS, et al. T follicular helper cells regulate the activation of B lymphocytes and antibody production during Plasmodium vivax infection. PLoS Pathog. 2017;13: 1–23. pmid:28700710
- 21. Araujo M da S, Andrade AO, Dos Santos NAC, Pereira DB, Costa G da S, de Paulo PFM, et al. Brazil’s first free-mating laboratory colony of Nyssorhynchus darlingi. Rev Soc Bras Med Trop. 2019;52: 10–12. pmid:31340377
- 22. Aranha Camargo LM, Duccini Dal Colletto GM, Ferreira MU, De Mello Gurgel S, Escobar AL, Marques A, et al. Hypoendemic malaria in rondonia (Brazil, Western Amazon Region): Seasonal variation and risk groups in an urban locality. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1996;55: 32–38. pmid:8702019
- 23. Gil LHS, Tada MS, Katsuragawa TH, Ribolla PEM, Da Silva LHP. Urban and suburban malaria in Rondônia (Brazilian Western Amazon) II. Perennial transmissions with high anopheline densities are associated with human environmental changes. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz. 2007;102: 271–276. pmid:17568931
- 24. Tada MS, Marques RP, Mesquita E, Martha RCD, Rodrigues JA, Costa JDAN, et al. Urban malaria in the Brazilian Western Amazon Region I. High prevalence of asymptomatic carriers in an urban riverside district is associated with a high level of clinical malaria. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz. 2007;102: 263–269. pmid:17568930
- 25. Tadesse FG, Slater HC, Chali W, Teelen K, Lanke K, Belachew M, et al. The Relative Contribution of Symptomatic and Asymptomatic Plasmodium vivax and Plasmodium falciparum Infections to the Infectious Reservoir in a Low-Endemic Setting in Ethiopia. Clin Infect Dis. 2018;66: 1883–1891. pmid:29304258
- 26. Taylor SC, Nadeau K, Abbasi M, Lachance C, Nguyen M, Fenrich J. The Ultimate qPCR Experiment: Producing Publication Quality, Reproducible Data the First Time. Trends Biotechnol. 2019;37: 761–774. pmid:30654913
- 27. Costa DC, Madureira AP, Amaral LC, Sanchez BAM, Gomes LT, Fernandes Fontes CJ, et al. Submicroscopic malaria parasite carriage: How reproducible are polymerase chain reaction-based methods? Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz. 2014;109: 21–28. pmid:24626306
- 28. Gruenberg M, Moniz CA, Hofmann NE, Wampfler R, Koepfli C, Mueller I, et al. Plasmodium vivax molecular diagnostics in community surveys: Pitfalls and solutions. Malar J. 2018;17: 1–10. pmid:29291736
- 29. Slater HC, Ross A, Felger I, Hofmann NE, Robinson L, Cook J, et al. The temporal dynamics and infectiousness of subpatent Plasmodium falciparum infections in relation to parasite density. Nat Commun. 2019;10. pmid:30926893
- 30. Martins-Campos KM, Kuehn A, Almeida A, Duarte APM, Sampaio VS, Rodriguez ÍC, et al. Infection of Anopheles aquasalis from symptomatic and asymptomatic Plasmodium vivax infections in Manaus, western Brazilian Amazon. Parasites and Vectors. Parasites & Vectors; 2018;11: 1–11. pmid:29728152
- 31. Laishram DD, Sutton PL, Nanda N, Sharma VL, Sobti RC, Carlton JM, et al. The complexities of malaria disease manifestations with a focus on asymptomatic malaria. Malar J. 2012;11: 1–15. pmid:22212246
- 32. Warwick R, Swimer GJ, Britt RP. Prolonged incubation period of imported P.vivax malaria in London. J R Soc Med. 1980;73: 333–336. pmid:7017128
- 33. Kim JS, Oh JS, Chang EA, Bae SY, Nam DH, Lee CH, et al. Alteration of platelet counts and lipid profiles after treatment of acute Plasmodium vivax. Acta Trop. 2008;106: 39–43. pmid:18304498
- 34. Morais CG, Soares IS, Carvalho LH, Fontes CJF, Krettli AU, Braga ÉM. IgG isotype to C-terminal 19 kDa of Plasmodium vivax merozoite surface protein 1 among subjects with different levels of exposure to malaria in Brazil. Parasitol Res. 2005;95: 420–426. pmid:15759156
- 35. Soares IS, Da Cunha MG, Silva MN, Souza JM, Del Portillo HA, Rodrigues MM. Longevity of naturally acquired antibody responses to the N- and C- terminal regions of Plasmodium vivax merozoite surface protein 1. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1999;60: 357–363. pmid:10466961
- 36. Longley RJ, White MT, Takashima E, Morita M, Kanoi BN, Li Wai Suen CSN, et al. Naturally acquired antibody responses to more than 300 Plasmodium vivax proteins in three geographic regions. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2017;11: 1–15. pmid:28892517
- 37. Longley RJ, França CT, White MT, Kumpitak C, Sa-Angchai P, Gruszczyk J, et al. Asymptomatic Plasmodium vivax infections induce robust IgG responses to multiple blood-stage proteins in a low-transmission region of western Thailand. Malar J. BioMed Central; 2017;16: 1–13. pmid:28454546
- 38. Camargo EP, Alves F, Pereira Da Silva LH. Symptomless Plasmodium vivax infections in native Amazonians. Lancet. 1999;353: 1415–1416. pmid:10227233
- 39. Tripura R, Peto TJ, Chalk J, Lee SJ, Sirithiranont P, Nguon C, et al. Persistent Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium vivax infections in a western Cambodian population: Implications for prevention, treatment and elimination strategies. Malar J. BioMed Central; 2016;15: 1–12. pmid:26729363
- 40. van den Eede P, Soto-Calle VE, Delgado C, Gamboa D, Grande T, Rodriguez H, et al. Plasmodium vivax sub-patent infections after radical treatment are common in peruvian patients: Results of a 1-year prospective cohort study. PLoS One. 2011;6. pmid:21297986
- 41. White NJ. Determinants of relapse periodicity in Plasmodium vivax malaria. Malar J. 2011;10. pmid:21989376
- 42. Obaldia N, Meibalan E, Sa JM, Ma S, Clark MA, Mejia P, et al. Bone marrow is a major parasite reservoir in plasmodium vivax infection. MBio. 2018;9: 1–16. pmid:29739900
- 43. Pichon G, Awono-Ambene HP, Robert V. High heterogeneity in the number of Plasmodium falciparum gametocytes in the bloodmeal of mosquitoes fed on the same host. Parasitology. 2000;121: 115–120. pmid:11085230
- 44. Bharti AR, Chuquiyauri R, Brouwer KC, Stancil J, Lin J, Llanos-Cuentas A, et al. Experimental infection of the neotropical malaria vector Anopheles darlingi by human patient-derived Plasmodium vivax in the Peruvian Amazon. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2006;75: 610–616. pmid:17038681
- 45. Coleman RE, Kumpitak C, Ponlawat A, Maneechai N, Phunkitchar V, Rachapaew N, et al. Infectivity of asymptomatic Plasmodium-infected human populations to Anopheles dirus mosquitoes in western Thailand. J Med Entomol. 2004;41: 201–208. pmid:15061279
- 46. Kiattibutr K, Roobsoong W, Sriwichai P, Saeseu T, Rachaphaew N, Suansomjit C, et al. Infectivity of symptomatic and asymptomatic Plasmodium vivax infections to a Southeast Asian vector, Anopheles dirus. Int J Parasitol. 2017;47: 163–170. pmid:28043858
- 47. Tadesse FG, Van Den Hoogen L, Lanke K, Schildkraut J, Tetteh K, Aseffa A, et al. The shape of the iceberg: Quantification of submicroscopic Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium vivax parasitaemia and gametocytaemia in five low endemic settings in Ethiopia. Malar J. BioMed Central; 2017;16: 1–11. pmid:28049519
- 48. World Health Organization. Mass drug administration, mass screening and treatment and focal screening and treatment for malaria. Malar Policy Advis Comm Meet. 2015; 1–27. Available: http://www.who.int/malaria/mpac/mpac-sept2015-erg-mda-report.pdf