Polyploidy has played an important role in evolution across the tree of life but it is still unclear how polyploid lineages may persist after their initial formation. While both common and well-studied in plants, polyploidy is rare in animals and generally less understood. The Australian burrowing frog genus Neobatrachus is comprised of six diploid and three polyploid species and offers a powerful animal polyploid model system. We generated exome-capture sequence data from 87 individuals representing all nine species of Neobatrachus to investigate species-level relationships, the origin and inheritance mode of polyploid species, and the population genomic effects of polyploidy on genus-wide demography. We describe rapid speciation of diploid Neobatrachus species and show that the three independently originated polyploid species have tetrasomic or mixed inheritance. We document higher genetic diversity in tetraploids, resulting from widespread gene flow between the tetraploids, asymmetric inter-ploidy gene flow directed from sympatric diploids to tetraploids, and isolation of diploid species from each other. We also constructed models of ecologically suitable areas for each species to investigate the impact of climate on differing ploidy levels. These models suggest substantial change in suitable areas compared to past climate, which correspond to population genomic estimates of demographic histories. We propose that Neobatrachus diploids may be suffering the early genomic impacts of climate-induced habitat loss, while tetraploids appear to be avoiding this fate, possibly due to widespread gene flow. Finally, we demonstrate that Neobatrachus is an attractive model to study the effects of ploidy on the evolution of adaptation in animals.
Polyploidy or whole genome duplication is rare in animals and usually polyploid animals reproduce asexually. The Australian burrowing frogs of the genus Neobatrachus form an interesting exception amongst vertebrates with multiple independently originated autotetraploid sexual species. We generated population genomic data from 87 animals representing all six diploid and three tetraploid species of Neobatrachus. We show that, while diploid Neobatrachus species seem to be isolated from each other, their sister tetraploid species experience substantial levels of gene flow, and have wider distributions. Furthermore, we observe asymmetric gene flow from diploids to tetraploids. Based on our genomic and climate analyses we suggest that such inter-specific hybridization mediated by whole genome duplication rescues species diversity and allows tetraploids to more easily avoid impacts of climate-induced habitat loss.
Citation: Novikova PY, Brennan IG, Booker W, Mahony M, Doughty P, Lemmon AR, et al. (2020) Polyploidy breaks speciation barriers in Australian burrowing frogs Neobatrachus. PLoS Genet 16(5): e1008769. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1008769
Editor: Rodney Mauricio, University of Georgia, UNITED STATES
Received: October 3, 2019; Accepted: April 8, 2020; Published: May 11, 2020
Copyright: © 2020 Novikova et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: The raw genomic reads generated in this study were deposited in the NCBI SRA under the BioProject PRJNA507583. BioSample SRA number for each of the individual can be found in the Supplementary Data. Multispecies alignments of phased sequences for each locus can be found at https://bioinformatics.psb.ugent.be/gdb/Neobatrachus_AHE/.
Funding: The Australian Research Council Discovery grant DP120104146 awarded to JSK and SCD supported the sequencing work. P.Y.N acknowledges postdoctoral fellowship from The Research Foundation – Flanders (FWO), 12S9618N. This work was also supported by the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme [grant number ERC-StG 679056 HOTSPOT], via a grant to L.Y. YVdP acknowledges funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program (grant agreement No 833522). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Polyploidy or whole genome duplications (WGDs) play important roles in ecology and evolution [1, 2]. Although polyploidization predominantly occurs in plants, polyploidy has also played an important role in animal evolution. For instance, two ancient WGDs occurred early in the vertebrate lineage , while more recent WGDs occurred in several animal groups, including insects, molluscs, crustaceans, fishes, amphibians and reptiles [4–6]. The majority of polyploid animals switch to diverse modes of asexual reproduction after polyploid formation [4, 7, 8]. Amphibians, and more specifically anurans, are among very few exceptions exhibiting multiple independent occurrences of diploid and sexually reproducing polyploid sister species . The most famous example is probably the clade of model frogs Xenopus which is enriched with allopolyploids [10, 11]. Overall, polyploid occurrences in amphibia have been described in at least 15 different families , which makes it the most frequent among sexually reproducing vertebrates, possibly due to homomorphic (undifferentiated) sex chromosomes  which do not require dosage compensation .
Here, we focus on a group of widely distributed, endemic, Australian burrowing frogs: Neobatrachus. This genus comprises six diploid (N. albipes, N. fulvus, N. pelobatoides, N. pictus, N. sutor, N. wilsmorei; 2n = 24) and three tetraploid (N. aquilonius, N. kunapalari, N. sudellae; 4n = 48) species [15, 16], all characterised by bisexual reproduction . Taxonomic status of a previously described tetraploid species N. centralis has been redefined and synonymized with N. sudelli , which was later changed to a version with fenimine termination N. sudellae, as the species was named after a woman, Miss J. Sudell of Warwick . Tetraploid species of Neobatrachus were suggested to have independent origins based on mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) . At least one of the tetraploid species—N. sudellae—was suggested to have originated through autotetraploidy rather than allotetraploidy, as they exhibit tetrasomic inheritance and show a prevalence of tetravalent over bivalent formations during meiosis . Neobatrachus species are well defined based on external morphology, male advertisement calls and divergence at allozyme loci [20–22]. Generally, frog call structure differs among ploidies with higher ploidy species having lower pulse rates, a trait linked to nuclear volume increase with increasing ploidy . Indeed, tetraploid Neobatrachus species have lower pulse number and rate in their advertisement calls compared to diploids with multiple pulses in their calls (however N. sutor (2n) and N. wilsmorei (2n) have calls with a single pulse). However, each of the Neobatrachus species retain distinct calls [24, 25]. This differs from the more extensively studied gray treefrog, Hyla versicolor [26, 27], where tetraploids may have also originated from multiple independent origins but have calls that are largely similar across lineages . The primary aim of our study is to resolve the phylogenetic relationships and reticulation of the Neobatrachus species and describe the evolutionary origin of the tetraploid Neobatrachus lineages.
While polyploidization has occurred frequently across the tree of life, the evolutionary benefits of WGDs remain elusive. Polyploidy has been associated with greater tolerance to harsher conditions, but it is not clear whether WGDs broadly provide a fitness advantage or are simply a consequence of elevated rates of unreduced gamete formation [2, 29–31], which might be more prone to occur in extreme environments. Polyploids of hybrid origin (allopolyploids) may benefit from heterosis due to increased genetic variation, instantaneous shifts into intermediate or new ecological niches, and the redundancy of independently segregating gene copies [2, 29]. However, newly formed polyploids are simultaneously subject to several disadvantages perhaps most prominent of which is their low abundance compared to the established non-polyploids . Polyploids face strong frequency dependent selection because they are unlikely to produce viable or fertile offspring if crossed with a diploid. Therefore, rare polyploid types are at a disadvantage. Conversely, while autopolyploids retain many of the same disadvantages as allopolyploids, the advantages of autopolyploidy are much less clear . Recent example of possible advantage of autopolyploidy in frogs comes from Odontophrynus species [12, 33–35], where polyploids exhibited higher stress response and lower nuclear abnormalities compared to the sister diploids coexisting in the same agroecosystems . In Neobatrachus, while tetraploid species are distributed sympatrically with some of the diploid species, they are also able to occupy more arid areas across Australia [2, 19]. Here, using a combination of climate, occurrence and genomic data, we test whether Neobatrachus polyploids occupy larger or different niches and whether they may have a greater genetic adaptive potential in changing environments. The latter becomes critically important, since changing environments drive amphibian extinction rates, which continue to increase and are comprised of many interdependent factors such as habitat loss, emergence and spread of diseases, invasive species and pollution [37–40].
In the current study, we use an anchored hybrid enrichment approach (AHE) [41–44] to resolve the phylogenetic relationships among Neobatrachus species, and to assess fine-scale intra-specific genetic population structure. We also quantify the extent of hybridization between the nine Neobatrachus species with a particular focus on taxa with contrasting ploidies. Finally, we combine population dynamics assessments with changes in ecologically suitable areas for each species to describe population responses to climate changes.
Evolutionary history of Neobatrachus
We generated sequence data and alignments for 439 targeted orthologous nuclear loci of 87 Neobatrachus individuals spanning the entire genus as well as nine Heleioporus individuals as outgroups (see Methods). We filtered out six individuals which did not meet our missing data threshold and six individuals where estimated ploidy did not correspond to the expected (see Methods and S1 Table). Our further analysis includes 75 Neobatrachus individuals: 8 N. albipes (2n), 8 N. fulvus (2n), 7 N. pelobatoides (2n), 5 N. pictus (2n), 9 N. sutor (2n), 5 N. wilsmorei (2n), 14 N. sudellae (4n), 11 N. aquilonuis (4n), 8 N. kunapalari (4n). We then built a species tree and gene trees from the sequenced loci with ASTRAL-II  using RaxML  (Fig 1A). This revealed extensive conflict between gene genealogies and the species tree (Fig 1A, S1 Fig and S2 Fig). Multidimensional scaling (MDS) of gene tree topologies suggested that nuclear loci constitute either two or four topology clusters (S3 Fig), indicating competing signal. To investigate the population structure of Neobatrachus further we assessed it by ADMIXTURE  on extracted polymorphism data (66,789 sites in total; see Methods; Fig 1B, Fig 2, S1 Fig, S4 Fig). Overall, admixture clustering corresponded with the phylogenetic placement of the individuals on the species tree (Fig 1 and S1 Fig).
(A) Gene trees, colored by clade, for 361 nuclear loci based on 2 individuals per species show considerable incongruence and differ from the species trees (bold black topology). Conflict between gene tree clusters (S3 Fig) and the nuclear species tree suggest non-bifurcating relationships between the species. (B) Pie charts represent summarised admixture proportions for each species (summing assignments for each individual, S1 Fig, Fig 2) at optimal clustering with K = 7. Tetraploids (N. sudellae, N. aquilonius and N. kunapalari) show highly admixed ancestries. (C) Dated diploid-only species tree. Colors represent consistency levels between gene genealogies with red being most conflicted and blue most consistent. Grey bars represent 95% confidence intervals on the ages of nodes, noted in millions of years before present.
According to the geographical locations of the sampled individuals, pie charts show the probability of the assignment of the individual to one of the 7 individually colored clusters. Overlapping pie charts on the map have been moved just enough to appear separate. Diploid Neobatrachus species (top 6: N. pelobatoides, N. albipes, N. wilsmorei, N. sutor, N. pictus, N. fulvus) are each assigned to separate clusters, while all three tetraploid species (bottom 3: N. kunapalari, N. sudellae, N. aquilonius) show inter-species admixture.
We first focus on the evolutionary history of the diploid Neobatrachus species. Diploids were clearly split at K = 7 and did not show admixed individuals (Fig 1, Fig 2 and S1 Fig). However, the gene genealogies from diploid species only also show inconsistency among each other (Fig 1C and S5 Fig). To distinguish between the scenarios of (1) rapid speciation and (2) possible incomplete lineage sorting (ILS) and/or gene flow between the diploid species we estimated genealogies conflict within loci by randomly sampling individuals representing each species. If there has been rapid speciation we expect to see consistent genealogies within each locus regardless of individual chosen to represent each species, but in case of ILS and/or gene flow gene genealogies within one locus should remain in conflict with each other. We found that within locus genealogies are consistent with each other and conflict remains only between loci genealogies (S6 Fig), which supports the scenario of rapid speciation of the diploid species without secondary contacts or persistent incomplete lineage sorting. This is also consistent with clear ADMIXTURE clustering of the diploids (Fig 1B). In the absence of informative fossil material, we estimated the approximate evolutionary timescale of the Neobatrachus diploid species divergence (Fig 1C) using secondary calibrations . Interspecific divergence times provided support for a relatively old (older than 4 Mya) origin of Neobatrachus species (Fig 1C), which also argues in favor of rapid speciation rather than ILS explaining gene tree inconsistencies.
The evolutionary history of the tetraploid Neobatrachus species is more obscure. However, despite the conflict between gene genealogies and the species tree, they all demonstrate that the three tetraploid species do not form a monophyletic group (Fig 1A). All three tetraploid species showed admixture with each other and with local diploid species (Fig 1B, Fig 2 and S1 Fig). The differential assignment of each tetraploid individual within the species (the discrepancies between the pie-charts on Fig 2) argues in favour of an autopolyploid (non-hybrid) origin with sequential unequal gene flow rather than an allopolyploid (hybrid) origin (in this case admixture assignments would show consistent mixed assignment of the tetraploid individuals to both parental species).
In order to distinguish more clearly between allo- and autopolyploid origin of the tetraploids we modeled expected allele frequency distributions for allo- and autotetraploids to estimate the inheritance mode (see Methods). As previously shown [49, 50] allotetraploid individuals with disomic inheritance mode are expected to have an excess of intermediate frequency alleles (AABB) rather than rare alleles (ABBB or AAAB). We simulate expectation of the biallelic allele frequencies for autotetraploids by combining in a pairwise manner the alignments of the diploid individuals within the species, when combination of the diploids between the species simulates expectations for allotetraploids. The allele frequencies distributions for N.sudellae (4n) and N. aquilonius (4n) did not have the excess of intermediate alleles expected for allotetraploids and seem to correspond to an autotetraploid origin (S8 Fig, see Methods). N. kunapalari showed a mixed inheritance pattern, so we could not reject either allo- or autopolyploid origins for this species. However, the most parsimonious explanation of such a pattern is an autotetraploid origin with later extensive gene flow from a different (non-parental diploid) or a different autotetraploid species. Overall, our results seem to support the previously suggested autotetraploid origin of Neobatrachus tetraploid species [17, 19].
To further assess the complex demographic history of Neobatrachus, we performed TreeMix  modeling where species relationships are represented through a graph of ancestral populations (Fig 3A). The structure of the graph was inferred from allele-frequency data and Gaussian approximations of genetic drift such that the branch lengths in the graph are proportional to the amount of drift since populations split. We sequentially added up to 15 migration events, showing saturation of the model likelihood at five additional migration edges on average for 30 runs of Treemix, each with a different seed for random number generation (Fig 3E). We show an example of the inferred introgression events and the bifurcating graph for the model with five migration events for the run that resulted in the highest maximum likelihood (Fig 3A–3D). Inferred migration events (Fig 3B) indicate widespread directional introgression and interploidy gene flow between the polyploid species, however, only two introgression events had p-values lower than 0.05 in this particular run: from N. sudellae (4n) to N. kunapalari (4n) and from N. sutor (2n) to N. kunapalari (4n). Since there was some variability in inferred migration edges from run to run, to estimate the most frequently inferred migration events we summed the significant inferred migration edges among 30 TreeMix runs with five events allowed (Fig 3F). Migration events were found most frequently from N. sudellae (4n) to N. kunapalari (4n) (19 of 30 runs) and from N. sutor (2n) to N. kunapalari (4n) (12 of 30 runs). Interploidy introgression events were mostly asymmetric and from diploids to tetraploids, which corresponds with our ADMIXTURE cluster assignment results (Fig 1 and Fig 2). Inferred introgression events are broadly congruent with clusters of conflicting gene-tree topologies (S3 Fig). Each tetraploid Neobatrachus species (N. aquilonius, N. kunapalari, N. sudellae) is sister to a diploid species in the TreeMix graphs (Fig 3A and 3B, tips highlighted in bold) as well as in the species trees (Fig 1), which is consistent with previously suggested independent origins for the tetraploid species .
(A) Bifurcating maximum likelihood tree produced by TreeMix. (B) Example of a graph produced by TreeMix with 5 allowed migration events. (C) Scaled residual fit between observed data and predicted model in (A). Plot shows half of the residual covariance between each pair of populations divided by the average standard error across all pairs. Positive residuals represent populations where the model underestimates the observed covariance, meaning that populations are more closely related to each other in the data than in the modeled tree. Such population pairs are candidates for admixture events. Similarly, negative residuals indicate pairs of populations where the model overestimates the observed covariance. Overall, the residual plot of the model suggested that model fit could be improved by additional edges (migration events). (D) Scaled residual fit between observed data and predicted model in (B). Compared to Fig 3C this suggests that, although the complexity of the species relatedness is not fully represented by the model, major gene flow events and their direction were probably captured. (E) Box plots of 30 runs of TreeMix (each started with a different seed for random number generation) likelihood at different numbers of allowed migration events; saturation starts after 3 additional migration edges. (F) Bar plot showing the number of times a particular directional migration event was inferred in 30 TreeMix runs with 5 migration events allowed. We show only the events which were inferred more than twice.
As an additional test for determining historical hybridizations, we estimated the network phylogeny of Neobatrachus using SNaQ  implemented in PhyloNetworks (version 0.11.0) . We found that the scenario with two hybridization events allowed supported the data the best (see Methods, S9 Fig). The first inferred hybridization event suggests gene flow from the N. aquilonius, N. fulvus, and N. sudellae ancestral branch into N. kunapalari (minor hybrid edge γ = 0.343) (S9A Fig). The second inferred hybridization suggests gene flow from N. sudellae into N. aquilonius (minor hybrid edge γ = 0.192) (S9A Fig).
Estimation of suitable distribution areas and demographic patterns
Tetraploid species have the highest nucleotide diversity among Neobatrachus species (Fig 4D and S2 Table), which is likely due to gene flow directed to tetraploid taxa and introgression between tetraploids of different origin. This is supported also by Fst distances (S10 Fig), where Fst distances between tetraploid species are the lowest, while Fst distances between tetraploids and diploid are larger, and Fst distances between the diploid lineages are the highest, suggesting stronger isolation.
(A) Example of the estimation of the suitable distribution area for N. sutor, based on occurrence data and current climate. (B) Example of the projection of the suitable distribution area for N. sutor based on the past climate at around 20Kya at LGM (last glacial maximum). Note that the scales in A and B are the same; Australian continent here is larger due to lower sea levels at LGM. (C) Scatter plot showing relative change of the predicted suitable area at the LGM and current conditions for each species as a function of Tajima’s D estimator. Diploid species show high correlation between Tajima’s D and distribution area change (blue line, Pearson’s correlation -0.88 (R2 = 0.72, p-value = 0.02); (D) Hierarchical clustering of Neobatrachus species based on mean nucleotide diversity within and between the species.
To estimate the dynamics in population abundance over recent times, we measured Tajima’s D, a summary statistic that measures the lack or excess of rare alleles in a population compared to the neutral model. All of the Neobatrachus species have negative median values of Tajima’s D, which suggests that none of the species are experiencing dramatic population diversity decline (Fig 4C). We used the observed Tajima’s D values as a proxy for each species’ demographic patterns and compared them with estimated change in the suitable geographic area (Fig 4A–4C). In order to describe the ecological areas occupied by the different Neobatrachus species, as well as changes in those areas since the last glacial maximum (LGM) at around 20 Kya, we made use of occurrence data  (S11 Fig) and climate datasets . We first performed a PCA of reduced bioclimatic variables concentrating on one of the highly correlated variables (r>0.85, Pearson correlation coefficient; see Methods) for individuals from the Neobatrachus occurrence data (S12 Fig). Using this substantially increased geographic sampling compared to our sequenced sample set, we could see moderate clustering of the individuals by species, which demonstrates that Neobatrachus species differ in their ecological (climatic) occupancies.
We then modelled suitable distribution areas for each species separately with MaxEnt , which applies machine learning maximum entropy modeling on the climate data at the geographical locations of the species occurrence data. Bioclimatic variables had different impacts on the model for each species (S13 Fig), however, appeared to be more similar for sympatric species (for example, N. sutor and N. wilsmorei) than for allopatric species (for example, N. pictus compared to any other diploid species). By projecting the models built on the current climate data on the past climate data (at the last glacial maximum, LGM) we could estimate the changes in the suitable habitat area since the LGM relative to the current suitable area for different species (Fig 4A–4C, S14 Fig and S15 Fig). We observed a correlation between the change in the suitable habitat area and median Tajima’s D for the diploid Neobatrachus species (Fig 4C). As shrinkage in suitable habitat areas increases for a given diploid species, Tajima’s D values also increase. This suggests that climate change since LGM to current days may have already had a negative effect on diploid Neobatrachus’ genetic diversity via loss of suitable habitat even if populations are not obviously already getting smaller. Interestingly, tetraploid species appear to be the outliers to this trend, which we suggest may be due to their highly admixed genetic structure.
We have investigated the evolutionary history of the Australian burrowing frogs Neobatrachus genus and the population genomic consequences of genome duplication in a vertebrate model by generating and analysing nucleotide sequence data for 439 loci in 87 Neobatrachus individuals, covering the entire genus, including the three currently recognized tetraploids. The observation of non-bifurcating relationships between closely related species (Fig 1) is now common [57–67], and is understood to be caused by either rapid speciation, or shared variation between species due to incomplete lineage sorting (ILS) or gene flow. Population structure analysis revealed that each of the diploid species forms discrete clusters (Fig 1B and Fig 2), consistent with their status as phylogenetically distinct species. However, topology inconsistencies remained in the diploid only phylogenetic analysis (Fig 1C and S5 Fig). We show that random sets of individuals representing each species does not change the topology of a single locus and that inconsistency remains only between loci (S6 Fig). This suggests that diploid Neobatrachus species experienced rapid speciation and currently do not share variation between the species (no ILS or gene flow).
The tetraploids were assigned to a mixed set of clusters by population structure analysis, suggesting gene flow between each other and with the diploid species from overlapping geographical areas (Figs 1, 2 and S1 Fig). Comparing allele frequency distributions at the biallelic sites of the tetraploid individuals to the modelled expected distributions of autopolyploids with tetrasomic inheritance and allopolyploids with disomic inheritance, we rejected the hypothesis of the hybrid or allotetraploid origin of the two out of tree Neobatrachus tetraploid species–N. sudellae and N. aquilonius (S8 Fig). However, extensive gene flow between the autotetraploids of the different origin and from ‘non-parental’ diploids to the autotetraploids can lead to mixed inheritance, signs of which we see on N. kunapalari (4n) species (S8 Fig), for which we could not reject either of the inheritance modes.
Further extended analysis of the population structure and potential gene flow with TreeMix uncovered migration (gene flow) events from N. sudellae (4n) to N. kunapalari (4n) and from N. sutor (2n) to N. aquilonius (4n) (Fig 3). In several analyses, we inferred migration from N. sudellae (4n) to N. aquilonius (4n), reverse migration between N. sutor and N. aquilonius, migration from N. albipes (2n) to N. kunapalari (4n) and even N. pelobatoides (2n) to N. albipes (2n). The latter, if true, may be attributed to ancient migration events, since we do not see any evidence for recent mixing between the diploids (Figs 1 and 2, S6 Fig). As a complementary analysis we estimated a network phylogeny which recovered two hybridization events (S9 Fig): one between N. sudellae (4n) and N. aquilonius (4n), and a more ancient one between N. kunapalari (4n) and the ancestral branch of N. aquilonius (4n), N. sudellae (4n) and N. pictus (2n). This provided added support for gene flow between the tetraploid species. There are several possible scenarios of unidirectional gene flow from diploids to tetraploids which the TreeMix analysis suggested, for example, (1) through an unreduced gamete of a diploid crossing with a tetraploid or (2) through a triploid individual formed in a cross between diploid and a tetraploid, which could produce unreduced 3n gametes and backcross to a diploid. We describe these scenarios and potential mechanisms of unreduced gamete formation in more detail providing evidence based on literature [21, 25, 30, 31, 68–73], cytology and field observations in the S1 Text. Extensive gene flow between Neobatrachus species, especially between the tetraploid species, makes it difficult to estimate the true ancestral diploid population(s) for the tetraploids. Previously, it has been suggested that tetraploid Neobatrachus species might have independent origins . Our results are well aligned with this suggestion and place tetraploid species in a polyphyletic arrangement on the species tree and on the TreeMix graphs, and suggest at least two independent origins of polyploidy: genetically closest diploid lineages to N. aquilonius and N. sudellae are N. fulvus and N. pictus respectively while the closest diploid lineage to N. kunapalari is N. albipes.
An important question that remains is what allows admixture between Neobatrachus tetraploids of potentially different origin and admixture of tetraploids with the local diploids, while the diploids seem to be currently isolated from each other? Similar to Neobatrachus, the tetraploid tree frogs Hyla versicolor of multiple origins show high levels of interbreeding in overlapping geographical distribution, however the levels of divergence between the ancestral diploid species in this case are shallower . Another example of a similar pattern was shown in plants, where polyploidy is more frequent: diploid Arabidopsis lyrata and A. arenosa do not hybridize, while tetraploidy seems to overcome the endosperm-based hybridization barrier enabling gene flow between the two species [74–76]. One hypothesis that can explain polyploidy mediated gene flow in Neobatrachus is that potentially incompatible loci in the diploids are masked in the tetraploids, however this requires a whole-genome sequencing analysis of introgression.
Neobatrachus species are widely distributed in Australia with tetraploid species occurring more in the central (drier) area compared to diploids, which is reflected in the principal component analysis of the climatic data for species occurrences (S12 Fig). Areas occupied by different Neobatrachus species differ only slightly in their environmental characteristics (S13 Fig). Worth mentioning is that climatic variables do not entirely describe ecological niches, which could differ in other characteristics such as timing of breeding and foraging, food source preference, or soil types etc. Nevertheless, ecological niche modelling based on climate data may provide additional insights into population dynamic trends. Here, we applied the MaxEnt modelling approach to the publicly available climate and occurrence data for all nine Neobatrachus species, comparing the present and past suitable geographical areas. Most of the Neobatrachus species showed substantial changes of the suitable areas comparing current and past presence probabilities (S14 Fig, S15 Fig). Interestingly, the estimated change in suitable habitat areas and population genetics estimator of demographic trends (Tajima’s D), obtained from independent datasets, were correlated (Fig 4C). Tetraploid species appear to be outliers from the general trend, probably due to their mixed population structure: in this case, emergence of rare alleles in the population due to migration events will affect Tajima’s D estimator. Overall, it appears that the species with greater shrinkage of suitable area since the last glacial maximum had less negative median Tajima’s D values, which suggests an ongoing shift from population expansion to population contraction.
Conclusion and Outlook
Neobatrachus frogs represent a group of diploid and tetraploid species with a complex ancestry. By analysing sequence data of 439 targeted orthologous nuclear loci across the entire Neobatrachus genus we show rapid diversification of the diploid Neobatrachus species and multiple independent derivations of the tetraploid species. This work also revealed that the diploid Neobatrachus species are currently isolated, when autotetraploids of a different origin are able to hybridise with each other and with the local diploids in a unidirectional manner with gene flow from the diploids to the tetraploids. Tetraploid Neobatrachus species are able to occupy harsher environments and are distributed more widely across Australia. We suggest that polyploidy-mediated gene flow and hybridisation promote the adaptive advantage of the tetraploids in the face of climate change. These results, revealing gene flow between tetraploids and asymmetric inter-ploidy gene flow, pose a number of important questions concerning the evolution of sexual polyploid animals. Whole-genome sequencing data for Neobatrachus species would not only help to refine the population structure and introgressive mixing in the genus, but also provide information on potential adaptive values of the introgressed regions. One could hypothesize that a wide and potentially rapid spread of the tetraploids into new territories was facilitated by introgression from the locally adapted diploids , and that more detailed sampling of the tetraploids from parts of their distribution ranges remote from sympatry with diploids may reveal evidence of early versus ongoing gene flow. Moreover, population-level genomic resequencing of multiple diploid and tetraploid sister species could provide insight into the unique biology of autotetraploid sexual animals and effects of the tetraploidization on their evolution. The results on the changing suitable habitat areas for the Neobatrachus species highlight the importance of continuous observation of their population dynamics. Monitoring the current status of biodiversity through collection of species occurrence data and population genetic data allows the prediction of population dynamics and hopefully timely responses in conservation efforts in the face of rapidly changing environments [78, 79]. Emerging methods of public engagement to collect occurrence and other data (video and audio; www.frogid.net.au, [80, 81]) have potential to provide essential information on the state of frog species.
Anchored Hybrid Enrichment (AHE) phylogenomics
All the samples examined were obtained from the Australian Biological Tissue Collection at the South Australian Museum. Details of all samples examined are presented in the S1 Table. We collected AHE data at Florida State University’s Center for Anchored Phylogenomics (www.anchoredphylogeny.com), following the methods described in Lemmon et al.  and Prum et al. . Briefly, after quantifying the extracted DNA using Qubit, we sonicated the DNA to a size range of 150-500bp using a Covaris Ultrasonicator. We then prepared indexed libraries using a Beckman Coulter FXp liquid-handling robot. After library QC using Qubit, we pooled the libraries in groups of 16 and enriched the library pools using an hybrid enrichment kit developed for use in Anurans [42, 43]. Finally, we sequenced the enriched library pools on two lanes of an Illumina 2500 sequencer with a PE150 protocol at the Translational Laboratory at Florida State University.
Following sequencing, we quality filtered the reads using the Casava high-chastity filter, then demultiplexed the reads using the 8bp indexes with no mismatches tolerated. To increase read length and correct for sequencing errors, we merged read pairs that overlapped by at least 18bp using the method of Rokyta et al. . This process also removed sequencing adapters. We then performed a quasi ‘de novo’ assembly of the reads following Hamilton et al. , with Pseudacris nigrita, and Gastrophryne carolinensis as references. In order to reduce the potential effects of low level sample contamination, we retained only the assembly clusters containing more than 61 reads. In order to produce phased haplotypes from the assembly clusters, we applied the Bayesian approach developed by Pyron et al. , in which reads overlapping polymorphic sites are used to identify the likely phase of allelic variants within each locus. Because this approach was developed to accommodate any ploidy level, we were able to isolate two or four haplotypes for diploid and tetraploid individuals, respectively. We determined orthology for each locus using a neighbor-joining approach based on pairwise sequence distances, as described in Hamilton et al. . We aligned homologous haplotypes using MAFFT v7.023b , then auto-trimmed/masked the alignments following the approach of Hamilton et al. , but with MINGOODSITES = 12, MINPROPSAME = 0.3, and MISSINGALLOWED = 48. Final alignments were visually inspected in Geneious R9 (Biomatters Ltd., ) to ensure that gappy regions were removed and misaligned sequences were masked.
Misidentifications in the dataset
Both phylogenetic and admixture assignments suggested that several individuals had been misidentified in the field, which is expected for morphologically similar species and in particular for some of the diploid-tetraploid species pairs, e.g. N. fulvus and N. aquilonius . Field sampling can be accompanied by a certain level of honest mistakes in species identification, especially for sympatric species. However, a high level of incompletely sorted polymorphisms in recently split lineages or recent hybridization events could also result in uncertain positioning of an individual. We carefully curated the dataset and made a decision to rename some of the misidentified samples or completely exclude them from the analyses based on the amount of the missing data in the assembly, ploidy estimations from the sequencing data, and on the clear placement in a different clade. Below we describe our workflow for manual curation of the dataset to exclude or rename uncertain individuals without compromising too much on the potentially real shared variation.
The multiple sequence alignment resulting from the AHE workflow contains different amounts of informative sequence and gaps for each individual. First, we calculated the informative sequence fraction (no gaps) for each individual compared to the multiple sequence alignment length and applied a threshold of at least 0.2 of informative fraction for each individual to qualify for the subsequent analysis. Based on these criteria we excluded 6 samples (S1 Table).
Second, we estimated the ploidy of each sample using the nQuire software  on the next generation sequencing data mapped to one of the outgroup species Heleioporus australiacus (I5549) AHE assembly as a reference. As a preparation step for nQuire, we mapped reads to the reference using the BWA-MEM algorithm from BWA  (version 0.7.17), used Samtools  (version 1.6) to sort and index the mapping and removed potential duplicates from the PCR amplification step of library preparation with picard-tools (http://broadinstitute.github.io/picard/). We used the denoised input of base frequencies generated with default parameters for the Gaussian Mixture Model utilized in nQuire to estimate ploidy levels on the basis of frequency distributions at biallelic sites. The resulted estimations can be found in S1 Table. We excluded 5 samples placed in a different clade compared to the rest of the samples in the corresponding lineage, where ploidy estimation confirmed their misidentification. Finally, we renamed 2 samples to a different species name with which it clustered, in cases when initial ploidy and estimated ploidy corresponded to each other (S1 Table).
We have also excluded from further analysis sample I5442, initially identified as N. kunapalari, which was estimated to be a triploid and showed high levels of admixture between a diploid N. wilsmorei and potentially N. kunapalari or N. sudellae. In fact, triploid individuals are known in natural populations of Neobatrachus [22, 24, 25, 91, 92], (S1 Text), and could provide an explanation for the gene flow between species of different ploidy through a “triploid bridge”. A 3n individual formed in a cross between 2n and 4n individuals could produce a haploid, diploid or triploid gametes. Diploid gametes can cross to a tetraploid and produce 4n individuals that can backcross into the sympatric 4n population [71, 93, 94].
To generate a molecular species tree, we started by reconstructing individual genealogies for each of the 439 recovered loci. We analyzed two datasets, of which the first included all samples (except triploids discussed in the Results section), while the second was trimmed down to just two individuals per species. Results from the full sampling can be found in the Supplementary Material (S2 Fig), and the finer sampling in the main text (Fig 1A). We used RaxML  to simultaneously search for the best tree and apply 100 rapid bootstraps, implementing the GTRGAMMA model of nucleotide evolution for each locus. In generating species trees, coalescent methods have been shown to be more accurate than concatenation in cases of extensive incomplete lineage sorting, so we used the shortcut coalescent method ASTRAL III. Shortcut coalescent methods like ASTRAL take individual gene trees as input, and are much more computationally efficient than full coalescent analyses. We used our RAxML-generated gene trees as input for ASTRAL, allowing us to make use of all our molecular data.
To address gene-tree incongruence in a diploid-only phylogeny and investigate possible conflicting signals in our data as a result of (1) rapid radiation or (2) introgression and/or incomplete lineage sorting (ILS), we took a two-fold approach. We started by randomly selecting loci with complete species-level sampling for Neobatrachus, and visualized these gene trees with a single representative per species, varying the sampled individuals among plots to visualize the consistency of interspecific relationships (S6 Fig). Following this exercise we used multidimensional scaling (MDS) to approximate the relative distances between gene tree topologies . To prepare the data, we again trimmed down gene trees to one sample per species of Neobatrachus, and discarded loci missing any taxa, leaving us with 361 loci. We started by simply visualizing gene-tree incongruence overlaying the topologies of all 361 loci in DensiTree (Fig 1, S5 Fig). We then calculated the pairwise distances between all gene trees using the Robinson-Foulds metric, in the R package APE . We projected the tree distances into two and three dimensions (representing tree topology space) using MDS, as visualizing and interpreting more dimensions is difficult. To test if gene trees are uniformly distributed throughout tree space, or clustered, we used the partitioning around the medoids algorithm as implemented in the R package CLUSTER . We chose the optimum number of clusters (k), using the gap statistic, calculated for each k = 1–10. Clusters of gene trees represent similar topologies, and so we then summarized each cluster using ASTRAL, to identify consistent differences in topology.
The inclusion of tetraploid taxa with admixed genetic material has the potential to negatively influence bifurcating species tree inference. To address this, we removed tetraploid taxa from all alignments to jointly estimate a species tree and divergence dates for diploid Neobatrachus species using StarBEAST2 . We chose two individuals per diploid Neobatrachus and Heleioporus species, as well as five microhylid outgroup taxa (Cophixalus cheesmanae, Liophryne rhododactyla, Microhyla achatina, Kalophrynus interlineatus) for calibration purposes. Full coalescent species tree inference can be computationally prohibitive with large data matrices, and so we chose 25 loci selected for sampling completeness, locus length, and number of variable sites informed by AMAS  (S7 Fig). We used a single strict molecular clock linked across the 25 partitions, independent GTR site models, and ran four independent chains for 1x109 generations, sampled each 5x105 generations. Because no valuable fossil information for Neobatrachus is available, we used two secondary calibrations from the most extensive anuran time-tree to date . The first on the root of the tree (split between Microhylidae and Myobatrachidae; normal distribution, mean = 128, sigma = 4), and the second between Neobatrachus and Heleioporus (normal distribution, mean = 32.5, sigma = 4). Each run was inspected for stationarity with TRACER , and summarized to a maximum clade credibility tree with mean heights to check for consistency in topology and divergence times.
While bootstrapping and posterior probabilities are commonly used to investigate topological confidence, individual gene trees arguably provide a better estimate of concordance in branching events found in the species tree. We estimated gene concordance factors (GCF) in IQTREE , and plotted them along the species tree to visualize support for branching patterns in the Neobatrachus species tree (Fig 1C and S5 Fig).
Maximum likelihoods of individual ancestries were estimated with ADMIXTURE  for 66,789 biallelic sites combining all 439 loci and allowing for maximum 20 out of 87 Neobatrachus individuals (excluding the outgroup species) to have missing data at each site. In order to include tetraploid samples in ancestry assignment we randomly chose two alleles for each site. We also applied minor allele frequency threshold of two percent. Ancestral population assignment showed three local minima of cross-validation errors at K equals 3, 7 and 9 (S4 Fig), with K = 7 being the lowest, which we chose for the subsequent analysis as the optimal solution.
In order to check the inheritance mode of the three tetraploid Neobatrachus species we compared allele frequencies distributions at biallelic sites within each individual for each species with modeled expected distributions for auto and allo tetraploids. Autotetraploids were modelled combining bam files within each diploid species from the mapping described above; allotetraploids were modelled combining bam files between each diploid species (S8A Fig). Base frequencies distributions of biallelic sites were produced using the denoised algorithm from nQuire  for each individual separately. The base frequencies for each individual have a continuous rather than discrete (AAAB 0.25, AABB 0.5, ABBB 0.75) distribution since they are calculated from read counts at a biallelic site. As it was previously shown [49, 50] allotetraploids with disomic inheritance mode are expected to have an excess of intermediate frequency alleles, which is supported by our models as well (S8A Fig). Performing Wilcoxon tests for the ratios between intermediate (40–60%) and rare (<30%) allele frequencies we rejected allotetraploid origins for N. sudellae and N. aquilonius. N. kunapalari showed intermediate distributions, suggesting mixed chromosomal inheritance. A mixed chromosomal inheritance pattern can be explained under several scenarios including being newly formed allopolyploid hybrids of close relation, the presence of continued gene-flow with diploids or other autopolyploid species, or the process of diploidization in an autopolyploid with tetrasomic inheritance . Other analyses in this study suggest extensive gene flow between N kunapalari and diploids as well as tetraploids (Fig 2, Fig 3B and 3F). While we cannot rule out the possibility that N. kunapalari was initially formed from the hybridization of two closely related lineages, we believe extensive gene flow and the older lineage age of N. kunapalari is a sufficient and more likely cause for its elevated intermediate allele frequencies when compared to the other tetraploids.
The graphs representing ancestral bifurcations and migration events were produced using Treemix V.1.12 . Input data contained 5092 biallelic sites called at 439 loci among 9 Neobatrachus species with at least 20% of the data to be present at each species at each site. Position of the root was set to N. pelobatoides as the nuclear species tree suggested (Fig 1A, black). To account for linkage disequilibrium we grouped SNPs in windows of size 10 using -k flag. We also generated bootstrap replicates using -bootstrap flag and subsequently allowed up to 15 migration events with flag -m. We ran TreeMix software with 30 different random number generated seeds. For graph and residuals visualisation we used R script plotting_funcs.R from the Treemix package.
The network phylogeny of Neobatrachus was estimated using SNaQ  implemented in PhyloNetworks (version 0.11.0) . We used a single individual for each species, and estimated gene tree phylogenies in RAxML , as described in the phylogenetic analysis section above, using Heleioporus australiacus as the outgroup taxon, but pruned Heleioporus from all trees for our PhyloNetworks analysis so as not to infer spurious ingroup-outgroup hybridizations as can occur in network analyses. We used a species tree estimated by ASTRAL as the starting tree for our analysis, allowing for between 0 and 10 hybridizations. We conducted 10 replicates for each hybridization value. Final trees were re-rooted with Neobatrachus pelobatoides as the root to match the network tree with the major tree. Pseudolikelihood values reported from PhyloNetworks demonstrate a sharp increase in support when allowing 1 (-Ploglik = 55.06) hybridization event as opposed to 0 (-Ploglik = 188.17). We also found a considerable change when allowing for 2 hybridization events (-Ploglik = 48.22). With more than two hybridizations allowed, however, PhyloNetworks only recovered two hybridization events or additional hybridizations resulted in suboptimal pseudolikelihoods (S9 Fig).
Summary statistics and demographic tendencies
We calculated summary statistics (Fig 4A–4C) with the R package “PopGenome”  for all the loci with more than 100 aligned sites (filtering for only non-variable and biallelic sites and filtering out sites with more than two alleles) separately for each species for within-species statistics (nucleotide diversity, Tajima’s D, S2 Table) and in a pairwise mode for between-species statistics (Fst).
Species distribution modelling
Bioclimatic variables were obtained from worldclim project  with 2.5 minutes resolution for reconstructed climate data at Last Glacial Maximum around 20Kya, averaged conditions across 1960–1990 and the most recent available conditions averaged across 1970–2000. Software DIVA-GIS 7.5 was used to trim the data to area longitude from 110 to 155 and latitude from -40 to -9. Bioclimatic variables were excluded if they were highly correlated (r>0.85, Pearson correlation coefficient) in all 3 climatic data sets, leaving for further analysis 6 bioclimatic variables in total: BIO9 = Mean Temperature of Driest Quarter, BIO10 = Mean Temperature of Warmest Quarter, BIO12 = Annual Precipitation, BIO17 = Precipitation of Driest Quarter, BIO18 = Precipitation of Warmest Quarter, BIO19 = Precipitation of Coldest Quarter.
To model the species suitable area we used software MaxEnt (v. 3.4.1.), which predicts species distribution from climate data using the species occurrences employing a machine learning technique called maximum entropy modeling . Here we used Neobatrachus species occurrence data from amphibiaweb.org , which includes 189 entries for N. albipes, 282 for N. aquilonius, 87 for N. fulvus, 588 for N. kunapalari, 802 for N. pelobatoides, 699 for N. pictus, 707 for N. sudellae, 639 for N. sutor and 282 for N. wilsmorei (S11 Fig). We used 75% of occurrence points for each species for model training and 25% for model testing with 1,000,000 background points and 10 replicates. We have trained the model on bioclimatic variables (reduced to 6 in total, described earlier) averaged across conditions 1960–1990; and then projected that model to the same set of environmental variables from the Last Glacial Maximum. The average test AUC (area under the Receiving Operator Curve) for the replicate runs for all the species was more than 0.9 (S3 Table), indicating a high performance of the models. In order to estimate which bioclimatic variable is the most important in the models we performed a jackknife test, where model performance was estimated without a particular variable and only with this particular variable in turn (S13 Fig).
We used cloglog output format of MaxEnt, which gives an estimate between 0 and 1 of probability of presence of the species in the area. In order to determine the relative change of the suitable area we used the point-wise mean values from the 10 replicates for model predictions on current and past climate (S14 Fig and S15 Fig). We extracted the suitable area for both climate conditions with R library ‘raster’  with 0.8 presence probability threshold and estimated change in the suitable area relative to the current suitable area as (current-past)/current.
S1 Text. Summary of cytogenetic observations and mechanisms for unidirectional introgression.
S1 Table. Sample information, BioSample IDs, metadata, ploidy inference and filtering.
S2 Table. Summary statistics for each of the species calculated with R package “PopGenome”.
S3 Table. The average test AUC (area under the Receiving Operator Curve) for the replicate runs for all the species in MaxEnt modeling for predicting species distribution from climate data at the species occurrences.
S4 Table. Instances of polyploid Neobatrachus.
S1 Fig. Species tree and admixture results for optimal clustering at K equals 3, 7 and 9 (see S4 Fig. for optimal number of clusters).
Vertical colored bars to the left of the tips of the tree correspond to our final species assignments (S1 Table); colors of the bars are species-specific and correspond to the branch colors from Fig 1A; filtered out samples are marked with black bars.
S2 Fig. Nuclear species tree as inferred using ASTRAL, all nuclear loci, and complete taxon sampling.
Figure extends across four parts (A, B, C, D) and is color coded by species identity.
S3 Fig. Two dimensional representations of MDS gene tree space, colored by optimal clustering scheme for two dimensions (k = 2) and three dimensions (k = 4), and their associated topologies inferred using ASTRAL.
Each point represents a single gene tree, colored clusters match colored trees displayed to the right. Nodes at values indicate bootstrap support.
S4 Fig. Cross-validation plot showing three local optimal solutions for ADMIXTURE clustering at K equals 3, 7 and 9.
(A) Gene trees, colored by clade, for 361 nuclear loci based on 2 individuals per species show considerable incongruence and differ from the species trees (bold black topology). (B) Gene trees for diploid individuals only also show considerable incongruence and differ from the species trees (bold black topology). (C,D) Species tree colored by topological consistency as measured by gene concordance factors—gCF%, the percentage of loci which decisively favor a given bipartition. Warmer colors indicate high discordance, cooler colors indicate strong concordance.
S6 Fig. Genealogies for six randomly sampled nuclear loci (y-axis) with different diploid individuals chosen as representatives for each species (different sample sets, x-axis) are consistent with each other.
Genealogical conflict remains only among loci. This supports a scenario of rapid speciation of the diploid species without secondary contact or persistent incomplete lineage sorting.
S7 Fig. Sequenced loci statistics on alignment length and number of variable sites inferred by AMAS (11).
S8 Fig. Distribution of allele frequencies of biallelic sites in Neobatrachus tetraploids supports tetrasomic inheritance mode in N. sudellae and N. aquilonius and mixed inheritance mode in N. kunapalari.
(A) Pairwise combination of individuals within the diploid species model the expected allele frequencies in autotetraploids with tetrasomic inheritance (blue line), when pairwise combination of individuals between the diploid Neobatrachus species model the expected distribution for allotetraploids with disomic inheritance mode (purple line). Modeled allotetraploids show excess of intermediate allele frequencies compared to autotetraploids. Gray area shows 95% confidence interval. (B) Comparing the ratio between intermediate (40–60%) and rare (<30%) allele frequencies we reject allotetraploid origin for N. sudellae and N. aquilonius, when N. kunapalari shows intermediate distribution, suggesting mixed inheritance. Comparisons performed with Wilcoxon tests adjusted for multiple testing.
S9 Fig. SnaQ analysis.
A. The optimum phylogenetic network includes two hybridization events. B. Network score has the best support at minumum 2 hybridization events, additional allowed hybridizations do not increase the network score.
S10 Fig. Heatmap and hierarchical clustering of the Neobatrachus lineages based on the distance matrix from pairwise median Fst values.
Tetraploid species (N. sudellae, N. aquilonius and N. kunapalari; highlighted with black left bar) cluster together and are characterised by the lowest Fst values between each other. This, together with low Fst values between tetraploid and diploid lineages, can probably be explained by the gene flow within the tetraploids and between the diploids and the tetraploids. Diploid lineages (highlighted with grey left bar) appear to be more isolated from each other compared to tetraploids, which is in agreement with ADMIXTURE assignment results and TreeMix estimations of possible migration events.
S11 Fig. Occurrence data locations registered at the AmphibiaWeb database for Neobatrachus species: A—tetraploids, B—diploids.
S12 Fig. PCA analysis of bioclimatic variables for Neobatrachus entries in the occurrence AmphibiaWeb database.
A) Barplot showing the percentage of variances explained by each principal component. The first three principal components are labeled with the top three contributions of variables. BIO10 = Mean Temperature of Warmest Quarter, BIO12 = Annual Precipitation, BIO17 = Precipitation of Driest Quarter, BIO18 = Precipitation of Warmest Quarter, BIO19 = Precipitation of Coldest Quarter. B-D) Pairwise combinations of the first three principal components, where individuals with a similar profile of bioclimatic data are grouped together. Points represent each individual and colored according to the species assignment, ellipses represent 95% confidence area.
S13 Fig. The results of the jackknife test of variable importance for models on each species.
BIO19 (Precipitation of Coldest Quarter) was the most informative variable for the models of N. pelobatoides and N. albipes distributions; BIO18 (Precipitation of Warmest Quarter) was the most informative variable for the models of N. wilsmorei, N. sutor and N. kunapalari; BIO17 (Precipitation of Driest Quarter) was the most informative variable for the model of N. fulvus; BIO10 (Mean Temperature of Warmest Quarter) for N. pictus; and BIO9 (Mean Temperature of Driest Quarter) for N. sudellae and N. aquilonius.
S14 Fig. The point-wise mean of the 10 models for each of the diploid species build on environmental layers from the current climate data and applied to the environmental layers from the Last Glacial Maximum climate data.
S15 Fig. The point-wise mean of the 10 models for each of the tetraploid species build on environmental layers from the current climate data and applied to the environmental layers from the Last Glacial Maximum climate data.
S16 Fig. Karyotypes of Neobatrachus.
A) N. sutor [2n], B) N. pictus x N. sudellae triploid [3n] hybrid from Moyston, east of the Grampians, Victoria, C) N. fulvus x N. sutor triploid [3n] hybrid from Learmonth, Western Australia, D) N. sudellae [4n], E) tetraploid x tetraploid hybrid from north of Menzies, Western Australia, F) N. pictus x N. sudellae pentaploid [5n] hybrid from Moyston, east of the Grampians, Victoria. Arrowheads indicate nucleolar organiser regions (NORs).
We thank Sarah Catalano and Steven Myers for DNA extraction and shipping samples, Mitzy Pepper for laboratory assistance, the Western Australian Museum and Stephen Mahony for some of the frog images. We thank Sean Holland and Michelle Kortyna at Florida State University’s Center for Anchored Phylogenomics for assistance with data collection and analysis.
- 1. Soltis DE, Visger CJ, Soltis PS. The polyploidy revolution then. . .and now: Stebbins revisited. Am J Bot. 2014;101(7):1057–78. pmid:25049267
- 2. Van de Peer Y, Mizrachi E, Marchal K. The evolutionary significance of polyploidy. Nat Rev Genet. 2017;18(7):411–24. pmid:28502977
- 3. Dehal P, Boore JL. Two rounds of whole genome duplication in the ancestral vertebrate. PLoS Biol. 2005;3(10):e314. pmid:16128622
- 4. Otto SP, Whitton J. Polyploid incidence and evolution. Annu Rev Genet. 2000;34:401–37. pmid:11092833
- 5. Li Z, Tiley GP, Galuska SR, Reardon CR, Kidder TI, Rundell RJ, et al. Multiple large-scale gene and genome duplications during the evolution of hexapods. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2018;115(18):4713–8. pmid:29674453
- 6. Berthelot C, Brunet F, Chalopin D, Juanchich A, Bernard M, Noel B, et al. The rainbow trout genome provides novel insights into evolution after whole-genome duplication in vertebrates. Nat Commun. 2014;5:3657. pmid:24755649
- 7. Stenberg P, Saura A. Meiosis and its deviations in polyploid animals. Cytogenet Genome Res. 2013;140(2–4):185–203. pmid:23796636
- 8. Neiman M, Sharbel TF, Schwander T. Genetic causes of transitions from sexual reproduction to asexuality in plants and animals. J Evol Biol. 2014;27(7):1346–59. pmid:24666600
- 9. Mable BK, Alexandrou MA, Taylor MI. Genome duplication in amphibians and fish: an extended synthesis: Polyploidy in amphibians and fish. Journal of Zoology. 2011;284:151–82.
- 10. Evans BJ. Genome evolution and speciation genetics of clawed frogs (Xenopus and Silurana). Front Biosci. 2008;13:4687–706. pmid:18508539
- 11. Session AM, Uno Y, Kwon T, Chapman JA, Toyoda A, Takahashi S, et al. Genome evolution in the allotetraploid frog Xenopus laevis. Nature. 2016;538(7625):336–43. pmid:27762356
- 12. Schmid M, Evans BJ, Bogart JP. Polyploidy in Amphibia. Cytogenetic and Genome Research. 2015;145:315–30. pmid:26112701
- 13. Miura I. Sex Determination and Sex Chromosomes in Amphibia. Sex Dev. 2017;11(5–6):298–306. pmid:29241181
- 14. Schmid M, Steinlein C. Sex chromosomes, sex-linked genes, and sex determination in the vertebrate class amphibia. EXS. 2001(91):143–76. pmid:11301597
- 15. Roberts JD. Taxonomic status of the Australian burrowing frogs Neobatrachus sudelli, N. centralis and Neoruinosus and clarification of the type specimen of N. albipes. Records of the Western Australian Museum. 2010;25: 455–8.
Frost DR. Amphibian Species of the World: an Online Reference. Version 6.0 (Date of access). Electronic Database accessible at http://research.amnh.org/herpetology/amphibia/index.html. American Museum of Natural History, New York, USA. 2016.
- 17. Mahony MJ, Robinson ES. Polyploidy in the australian leptodactylid frog genus Neobatrachus. Chromosoma. 1980;81(2):199–212. pmid:7192202
- 18. Shea GM. Emendation of the specific name of the frog Neobatrachus sudelli (Lamb, 1911) (Anura:Myobatrachidae). Memoirs of the Queensland Museum. 2012;56(1):116–7.
- 19. Mable BKR, Roberts J.D. Mitochondrial DNA evolution of tetraploids in the genus Neobatrachus (Anura: Myobatrachidae). Copeia. 1997;4:680–9.
- 20. Mahony M, Roberts JD. Two new species of desert burrowing frogs of the genus Neobatrachus (Anura:Myobatrachidae) from Western Australia. Records of the Western Australian Museum. 1986;13:155–70.
- 21. Roberts JD, Mahony M, Kendrick P, Majors CM. A new species of burrowing frog, Neobatrachus (Anura:Myobatrachidae), from the eastern wheatbelt of Western Australia. Records of the Western Australian Museum. 1991;15:23–32.
- 22. Mahony M, Donnellan SC, Roberts JD. An Electrophoretic Investigation of Relationships of Diploid and Tetraploid Species of Australian Desert Frogs Neobatrachus (Anura: Myobatrachidae). Australian Journal of Zoology. 1996;44:639–50.
- 23. Keller MJ, Gerhardt HC. Polyploidy alters advertisement call structure in gray treefrogs. Proc Biol Sci. 2001;268(1465):341–5. pmid:11270429
- 24. Roberts JD. Call Evolution in Neobatrachus (Anura: Myobatrachidae): Speculations on Tetraploid Origins. Copeia. 1997;1997(4):791–801.
- 25. Roberts JD, Edwards D. The Evolution, Physiology and Ecology of the Australian Arid-Zone Frog Fauna. On the Ecology of Australia’s Arid Zone 2018. p. 149–80.
- 26. Wasserman AO. Polyploidy in the common tree toad Hyla versicolor Le Conte. Science. 1970;167(3917):385–6. pmid:5409740
Bogart J. Evolutionary implications of polyploidy in amphibians and reptiles. In: Lewis WH ed Polyploidy: Biological relevance. Plenum Press: New York. pp 341–378. 1980.
- 28. Holloway AK, Cannatella DC, Gerhardt HC, Hillis DM. Polyploids with different origins and ancestors form a single sexual polyploid species. Am Nat. 2006;167(4):E88–101. pmid:16670990
- 29. Comai L. The advantages and disadvantages of being polyploid. Nat Rev Genet. 2005;6(11):836–46. pmid:16304599
- 30. Mason AS, Pires JC. Unreduced gametes: meiotic mishap or evolutionary mechanism? Trends Genet. 2015;31(1):5–10. pmid:25445549
- 31. Pandian TJK, R. Ploidy induction and sex control in fish. Hydrobiologia. 1998;384(1–3):167–243.
- 32. Parisod C, Holderegger R, Brochmann C. Evolutionary consequences of autopolyploidy. New Phytol. 2010;186(1):5–17. pmid:20070540
- 33. Becak ML, Becak W, Rabello MN. Cytological evidence of constant tetraploidy in the bisexual South American frog Odontophrynus americanus. Chromosoma. 1966;19(2):188–93. pmid:5959682
- 34. Bogart JP. Chromosomes of the South American amphibian family Ceratophridae with a reconsideration of the taxonomic status of Odontophrynus americanus. Can J Genet Cytol. 1967;9(3):531–42. pmid:6079738
- 35. Martino AL, Sinsch U. Speciation by polyploidy in Odontophrynus americanus. Journal of Zoology. 2002;257(1):67–81.
- 36. Pollo FE, Grenat PR, Otero MA, Babini S, Salas NE, Martino AL. Evaluation in situ of genotoxic and cytotoxic response in the diploid/polyploid complex Odontophrynus (Anura: Odontophrynidae) inhabiting agroecosystems. Chemosphere. 2019;216:306–12. pmid:30384299
- 37. Stuart SN, Chanson JS, Cox NA, Young BE, Rodrigues AS, Fischman DL, et al. Status and trends of amphibian declines and extinctions worldwide. Science. 2004;306(5702):1783–6. pmid:15486254
- 38. Collins JP. Amphibian decline and extinction: what we know and what we need to learn. Dis Aquat Organ. 2010;92(2–3):93–9. pmid:21268970
- 39. Hudson MA, Young RP, D'Urban Jackson J, Orozco-terWengel P, Martin L, James A, et al. Dynamics and genetics of a disease-driven species decline to near extinction: lessons for conservation. Sci Rep. 2016;6:30772. pmid:27485994
- 40. O'Hanlon SJ, Rieux A, Farrer RA, Rosa GM, Waldman B, Bataille A, et al. Recent Asian origin of chytrid fungi causing global amphibian declines. Science. 2018;360(6389):621–7. pmid:29748278
- 41. Lemmon AR, Emme SA, Lemmon EM. Anchored hybrid enrichment for massively high-throughput phylogenomics. Syst Biol. 2012;61(5):727–44. pmid:22605266
- 42. Barrow LN, Lemmon AR, Lemmon EM. Targeted Sampling and Target Capture: Assessing Phylogeographic Concordance with Genome-wide Data. Syst Biol. 2018;67(6):979–96. pmid:30339251
- 43. Heinicke MP, Lemmon AR, Lemmon EM, McGrath K, Hedges SB. Phylogenomic support for evolutionary relationships of New World direct-developing frogs (Anura: Terraranae). Mol Phylogenet Evol. 2018;118:145–55. pmid:28963082
- 44. Yuan Z-Y, Zhang B-L, Raxworthy CJ, Weisrock DW, Hime PM, Jin J-Q, et al. Natatanuran frogs used the Indian Plate to step-stone disperse and radiate across the Indian Ocean. National Science Review. 2018:nwy092–nwy.
- 45. Mirarab S, Warnow T. ASTRAL-II: coalescent-based species tree estimation with many hundreds of taxa and thousands of genes. Bioinformatics. 2015;31(12):i44–52. pmid:26072508
- 46. Stamatakis A. RAxML version 8: a tool for phylogenetic analysis and post-analysis of large phylogenies. Bioinformatics. 2014;30(9):1312–3. pmid:24451623
- 47. Alexander DH, Novembre J, Lange K. Fast model-based estimation of ancestry in unrelated individuals. Genome Research. 2009;19:1655–64. pmid:19648217
- 48. Feng YJ, Blackburn DC, Liang D, Hillis DM, Wake DB, Cannatella DC, et al. Phylogenomics reveals rapid, simultaneous diversification of three major clades of Gondwanan frogs at the Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2017;114(29):E5864–E70. pmid:28673970
- 49. Hollister JD, Arnold BJ, Svedin E, Xue KS, Dilkes BP, Bomblies K. Genetic adaptation associated with genome-doubling in autotetraploid Arabidopsis arenosa. PLoS Genet. 2012;8(12):e1003093. pmid:23284289
- 50. Arnold B, Kim ST, Bomblies K. Single Geographic Origin of a Widespread Autotetraploid Arabidopsis arenosa Lineage Followed by Interploidy Admixture. Mol Biol Evol. 2015;32(6):1382–95. pmid:25862142
- 51. Pickrell JK, Pritchard JK. Inference of population splits and mixtures from genome-wide allele frequency data. PLoS Genet. 2012;8(11):e1002967. pmid:23166502
- 52. Solis-Lemus C, Ane C. Inferring Phylogenetic Networks with Maximum Pseudolikelihood under Incomplete Lineage Sorting. PLoS Genet. 2016;12(3):e1005896. pmid:26950302
- 53. Solis-Lemus C, Bastide P, Ane C. PhyloNetworks: A Package for Phylogenetic Networks. Mol Biol Evol. 2017;34(12):3292–8. pmid:28961984
AmphibiaWeb. Information on amphibian biology and conservation. Berkeley, California: AmphibiaWeb Available: http://amphibiaweborg/. 2016.
- 55. Hijmans RJ, Cameron S. E., Parra J. L., Jones P. G. and Jarvis A. Very high resolution interpolated climate surfaces for global land areas. Int J Climatol. 2005;25:1965–78.
- 56. Phillips SJ, Anderson RP, Schapire RE. Maximum entropy modeling of species geographic distributions. Ecological Modelling. 2006;190(3):231–59.
- 57. Novikova PY, Hohmann N, Nizhynska V, Tsuchimatsu T, Ali J, Muir G, et al. Sequencing of the genus Arabidopsis identifies a complex history of nonbifurcating speciation and abundant trans-specific polymorphism. Nat Genet. 2016;48(9):1077–82. pmid:27428747
- 58. Green RE, Krause J, Briggs AW, Maricic T, Stenzel U, Kircher M, et al. A Draft Sequence of the Neandertal Genome. Science. 2010;328:710–22. pmid:20448178
- 59. Nishihara H, Maruyama S, Okada N. Retroposon analysis and recent geological data suggest near-simultaneous divergence of the three superorders of mammals. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009;106(13):5235–40. pmid:19286970
- 60. Hallstrom BM, Janke A. Mammalian evolution may not be strictly bifurcating. Mol Biol Evol. 2010;27(12):2804–16. pmid:20591845
- 61. Garrigan D, Kingan SB, Geneva AJ, Andolfatto P, Clark AG, Thornton KR, et al. Genome sequencing reveals complex speciation in the Drosophila simulans clade. Genome Res. 2012;22(8):1499–511. pmid:22534282
- 62. Martin SH, Dasmahapatra KK, Nadeau NJ, Salazar C, Walters JR, Simpson F, et al. Genome-wide evidence for speciation with gene flow in Heliconius butterflies. Genome Research. 2013;23:1817–28. pmid:24045163
- 63. Jonsson H, Schubert M, Seguin-Orlando A, Ginolhac A, Petersen L, Fumagalli M, et al. Speciation with gene flow in equids despite extensive chromosomal plasticity. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2014;111(52):18655–60. pmid:25453089
- 64. Fontaine MC, Pease JB, Steele A, Waterhouse RM, Neafsey DE, Sharakhov IV, et al. Mosquito genomics. Extensive introgression in a malaria vector species complex revealed by phylogenomics. Science. 2015;347(6217):1258524. pmid:25431491
- 65. Lamichhaney S, Berglund J, Almen MS, Maqbool K, Grabherr M, Martinez-Barrio A, et al. Evolution of Darwin's finches and their beaks revealed by genome sequencing. Nature. 2015;518(7539):371–5. pmid:25686609
- 66. Suh A, Smeds L, Ellegren H. The Dynamics of Incomplete Lineage Sorting across the Ancient Adaptive Radiation of Neoavian Birds. PLoS Biol. 2015;13(8):e1002224. pmid:26284513
- 67. Pease JB, Haak DC, Hahn MW, Moyle LC. Phylogenomics Reveals Three Sources of Adaptive Variation during a Rapid Radiation. PLoS Biol. 2016;14(2):e1002379. pmid:26871574
- 68. Becak ML, Becak W. Further studies on polyploid amphibians (Ceratophrydidae). 3. Meiotic aspects of the interspecific triploid hybrid: Odontophrynus cultripes (2n = 22) x O. americanus (4n = 44). Chromosoma. 1970;31(4):377–85. pmid:5490304
Main AR. Comparisons of breeding biology and isolating mechanisms in Western Australian frogs. (ed.) G WL, editor. Melbourne, Victoria, Australia: Melbourne Univ. Press 1962. 370–9 p.
- 70. Nishioka M, Ueda H. Studies on polyploidy in Japanese frogs. Sci Rep Lab Amphibian Biol Hiroshima Univ. 1983;6:207–52.
- 71. Bogart JP, Bi K. Genetic and genomic interactions of animals with different ploidy levels. Cytogenet Genome Res. 2013;140(2–4):117–36. pmid:23751376
- 72. Shimada M, Hase K. Female polyandry and size-assortative mating in isolated local populations of the Japanese common toad Bufo japonicus. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society. 2014;113(1):236–42.
- 73. Geach TJ, Stemple DL, Zimmerman LB. Genetic analysis of Xenopus tropicalis. Methods Mol Biol. 2012;917:69–110. pmid:22956083
- 74. Lafon-Placette C, Johannessen IM, Hornslien KS, Ali MF, Bjerkan KN, Bramsiepe J, et al. Endosperm-based hybridization barriers explain the pattern of gene flow between Arabidopsis lyrata and Arabidopsis arenosa in Central Europe. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2017;114(6):E1027–E35. pmid:28115687
- 75. Lafon-Placette C, Kohler C. Endosperm-based postzygotic hybridization barriers: developmental mechanisms and evolutionary drivers. Mol Ecol. 2016;25(11):2620–9. pmid:26818717
- 76. Marburger S, Monnahan P, Seear PJ, Martin SH, Koch J, Paajanen P, et al. Interspecific introgression mediates adaptation to whole genome duplication. Nature Communications. 2019;10(1):5218. pmid:31740675
- 77. Schmickl R, Marburger S, Bray S, Yant L. Hybrids and horizontal transfer: introgression allows adaptive allele discovery. J Exp Bot. 2017;68(20):5453–70. pmid:29096001
- 78. McCartney-Melstad E, Shaffer HB. Amphibian molecular ecology and how it has informed conservation. Mol Ecol. 2015;24(20):5084–109. pmid:26437125
- 79. McCartney-Melstad E, Gidis M, Shaffer HB. Population genomic data reveal extreme geographic subdivision and novel conservation actions for the declining foothill yellow-legged frog. Heredity (Edinb). 2018;121(2):112–25. pmid:29941996
- 80. Callaghan CT, Rowley JJL, Cornwell WK, Poore AGB, Major RE. Improving big citizen science data: Moving beyond haphazard sampling. PLoS Biol. 2019;17(6):e3000357. pmid:31246950
- 81. Rowley JJL, Callaghan CT, Cutajar T, Portway C, Potter K, Mahony S, et al. FrogID: Citizen scientists provide validated biodiversity data on frogs of Australia. Herpetological Conservation and Biology. 2019;14(1):155–70.
- 82. Prum RO, Berv JS, Dornburg A, Field DJ, Townsend JP, Lemmon EM, et al. A comprehensive phylogeny of birds (Aves) using targeted next-generation DNA sequencing. Nature. 2015;526:569. pmid:26444237
- 83. Rokyta DR, Lemmon AR, Margres MJ, Aronow K. The venom-gland transcriptome of the eastern diamondback rattlesnake (Crotalus adamanteus). BMC Genomics. 2012;13:312. pmid:23025625
- 84. Hamilton CA, Lemmon AR, Lemmon EM, Bond JE. Expanding anchored hybrid enrichment to resolve both deep and shallow relationships within the spider tree of life. BMC Evol Biol. 2016;16(1):212. pmid:27733110
- 85. Pyron RA, Hsieh FW, Lemmon AR, Lemmon EM, Hendry CR. Integrating phylogenomic and morphological data to assess candidate species-delimitation models in brown and red-bellied snakes (Storeria). Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society. 2016;177(4):937–49.
- 86. Katoh K, Standley DM. MAFFT multiple sequence alignment software version 7: improvements in performance and usability. Mol Biol Evol. 2013;30(4):772–80. pmid:23329690
- 87. Kearse M, Moir R, Wilson A, Stones-Havas S, Cheung M, Sturrock S, et al. Geneious Basic: an integrated and extendable desktop software platform for the organization and analysis of sequence data. Bioinformatics. 2012;28(12):1647–9. pmid:22543367
- 88. Weiss CL, Pais M, Cano LM, Kamoun S, Burbano HA. nQuire: a statistical framework for ploidy estimation using next generation sequencing. BMC Bioinformatics. 2018;19(1):122. pmid:29618319
- 89. Li H, Durbin R. Fast and accurate short read alignment with Burrows-Wheeler transform. Bioinformatics (Oxford, England). 2009;25:1754–60.
- 90. Li H, Handsaker B, Wysoker A, Fennell T, Ruan J, Homer N, et al. The Sequence Alignment/Map format and SAMtools. Bioinformatics (Oxford, England). 2009;25:2078–9.
- 91. Roberts JD. Geographic Variation in Calls of Males and Determination of Species Boundaries in Tetraploid Frogs of the Australian Genus Neobatrachus (Myobatrachidae). Australian Journal of Zoology 1997;45(2):95–112.
Mahony M. Cytogenetic studies on Australian frogs of the family Myobatrachidae. Ph.D. thesis, Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia. 1986.
- 93. Choleva L, Janko K. Rise and persistence of animal polyploidy: evolutionary constraints and potential. Cytogenet Genome Res. 2013;140(2–4):151–70. pmid:23838539
- 94. Okamoto T, Ohnishi Y, Toda E. Development of polyspermic zygote and possible contribution of polyspermy to polyploid formation in angiosperms. J Plant Res. 2017;130(3):485–90. pmid:28275885
- 95. Hillis DM, Heath TA, St John K. Analysis and visualization of tree space. Syst Biol. 2005;54(3):471–82. pmid:16012112
- 96. Paradis E, Claude J, Strimmer K. APE: Analyses of Phylogenetics and Evolution in R language. Bioinformatics (Oxford, England). 2004;20:289–90.
- 97. Maechler M, Rousseeuw P, Struyf A, Hubert M. cluster: Cluster Analysis Basics and Extension. 2018.
- 98. Ogilvie HA, Bouckaert RR, Drummond AJ. StarBEAST2 Brings Faster Species Tree Inference and Accurate Estimates of Substitution Rates. Mol Biol Evol. 2017;34(8):2101–14. pmid:28431121
- 99. Borowiec ML. AMAS: a fast tool for alignment manipulation and computing of summary statistics. PeerJ. 2016;4:e1660. pmid:26835189
- 100. Rambaut A, Drummond AJ, Xie D, Baele G, Suchard MA. Posterior Summarization in Bayesian Phylogenetics Using Tracer 1.7. Syst Biol. 2018;67(5):901–4. pmid:29718447
- 101. Nguyen LT, Schmidt HA, von Haeseler A, Minh BQ. IQ-TREE: a fast and effective stochastic algorithm for estimating maximum-likelihood phylogenies. Mol Biol Evol. 2015;32(1):268–74. pmid:25371430
- 102. Ramsey J, Schemske DW. Neopolyploidy in Flowering Plants. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics. 2002;33(1):589–639.
- 103. Pfeifer B, Wittelsburger U, Ramos-Onsins SE, Lercher MJ. PopGenome: an efficient Swiss army knife for population genomic analyses in R. Mol Biol Evol. 2014;31(7):1929–36. pmid:24739305
- 104. Hijmans RJ, van Etten J. raster: Geographic analysis and modeling with raster data. R package version 2.0–12. 2012.