Citation: Molla Herman A, Brasset E (2021) Rhino breaks the deadlock in Drosophila testis. PLoS Genet 17(9): e1009702. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1009702
Editor: Jean-René Huynh, College de France CNRS, FRANCE
Published: September 2, 2021
Copyright: © 2021 Molla Herman, Brasset. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: AMH was supported by CNRS, Inserm, Collège de France, FRM (Equipe FRM DEQ20160334884), ANR (ANR-13-BSV2-0007-02 PlasTiSiPi; ANR-15-CE13-0001-01, AbsCyStem), and Bettencourt-Schueller Foundations. EB was supported by the Foundation pour la Recherche médicale and foundation ARC pour la recherche sur le cancer (PJA20171206129), IDEX-ISITE initiative 16-IDEX-0001 (CAP20-25), ANR (ANR-17-CE12-0030-03 EpiTET and ANR-20-CE12-0005-01 CHApiTRE projects). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
In the early 2000s, Aravin and colleagues discovered, in the Drosophila melanogaster testis, a new class of small regulatory RNAs initially named repeat-associated small interfering RNA (rasiRNAs). rasiRNAs were first described as regulating a protein-coding gene. They are derived from the Suppressor of Stellate [Su(Ste)] locus located on the Y chromosome and were shown to target the X-linked Stellate repeated genes by sequence complementarity. Stellate genes encode proteins with homology to the regulatory β subunit of the protein kinase CK2. Stellate repression occurs during male gametogenesis and is essential for male fertility. These small RNAs were renamed as PIWI-interacting RNAs (piRNAs); they are 23 to 29 nucleotides (nt) long and bind to proteins of the PIWI family. Accordingly, piRNA pathway mutants are sterile, and they contain crystalline aggregates of Stellate-coded protein .
piRNAs were then discovered in mammals and in most other animal germ cells . Nowadays, we know that piRNAs are mainly devoted to protecting the genome from active mobile genetic elements in the metazoan germline. In D. melanogaster, both sexes depend on a functional piRNA pathway for their fertility. Our understanding of piRNA biogenesis and function comes predominantly from studies of the female Drosophila germline, but the male’s piRNA pathway remains poorly understood. Previously, studies reported that many proteins involved in the female piRNA pathway are also required for male fertility and Stellate silencing in the testis, supporting the conservation of piRNA pathway machinery in both sexes . While Aub is expressed broadly from germline stem cells (GSCs) to primary spermatocytes, Ago3 and PIWI were detected only in mitotically dividing germline cells (GSCs and spermatogonia), indicating stage-specific modulations of the piRNA pathway [4–6] (Fig 1A). The 2 most active piRNA clusters in the testis are dual strand: Su(Ste) genes and AT-chX [5,7,8]. Interestingly, Aravin’s team have recently defined novel piRNA clusters in D. melanogaster spermatogenesis and show piRNAs adaptation, dependent on sex-specific expression of transposons . Dual-strand piRNA clusters generally lack promoters, and their expression depends on the Rhino–Deadlock–Cutoff (RDC) complex that licenses noncanonical transcription. The RDC is anchored to H3K9me3-marked chromatin via Rhino’s chromodomain. This process involves 5′-end protection of nascent RNAs and suppression of transcription termination . Importantly, since fertility in male Rhino mutants was not compromised and stellate crystals were absent, RDC function in spermatogenesis was neglected .
(A) Developmental impact of RDC in spermatogenesis. Left: The Drosophila melanogaster testis is depicted with the germline in green and the somatic cells in violet (CySCs). In the mitotic region, GSCs divide to form GBs and cysts of 2-, 4-, 8-, or 16-cell spermatogonia. Then, spermatogonia grow and mature to form spermatocytes that enter meiosis. After spermatid elongation and individualization, sperm will accumulate in the seminal vesicle. RDC, PIWI, Ago3, and Aub levels of expression are depicted in orange, yellow, and gray. Right: GSC and spermatocyte magnifications. In GSC, Rhino protein is localized in several foci, decorating the 38C and AT-chX piRNA dual-strand clusters, among others. In spermatocytes, 38C is not expressed anymore, and AT-chX loci is highly expressed and colocalizes with a single RDC foci. Su(Ste) dual-strand transcription is RDC independent. Su(Ste) piRNAs together with piRNA pathway proteins silence Stellate genes to avoid crystal formation. (B) Evolutionary impact of RDC in spermatogenesis. Top: D. melanogaster female and male are depicted. Su(Ste) piRNAs produced from the Y chromosome avoid Stellate expression and crystal formation. AT-chX piRNAs do not have enough homology with vasa to silence it in D. melanogaster. Bottom: A cross of a D. melanogaster female with another species produces interspecies sterile hybrids, since Stellate genes form crystalline aggregates in their spermatocytes when expressed, and AT-chX could silence “alien vasa,” altering the germline. cc, cell cyst; CySC, cyst stem cell; GB, gonioblast; GSC, germline stem cell; piRNA, PIWI-interacting RNA; RDC, Rhino–Deadlock–Cutoff; TE, transposable element.
In this issue of PLOS Genetics, Chen and colleagues explored whether piRNA loci in the D. melanogaster testis use the same RDC noncanonical transcription mechanism as in the female germline . Unexpectedly, a detailed examination of male fertility by sperm exhaustion assays revealed germline defects and subfertility in RDC mutant males. A careful spatiotemporal analysis showed that the RDC complex is not ovary specific. RDC assembled also in early spermatogenesis to regulate piRNA cluster expression required for an efficient transposable element (TE) silencing in the testis. Like in ovaries, they observed that RDC marks all dual-strand piRNA clusters, except Su(Ste). Furthermore, Moonshiner (a paralog of transcription initiation factor TFIIA-L) then links the RDC to RNA polymerase II to initiate a promoterless noncanonical transcription.
One striking result from Chen and colleagues is that transcription of the Su(Ste) dual-strand cluster is Rhino independent, and Stellate genes are properly silenced in Rhino mutants . Similarly to piRNAs found in some arthropods and mammals, the Su(Ste) locus may be canonically transcribed by RNA polymerase II, with initiation occurring from convergent promoters. Sense transcripts of Su(Ste) are spliced and polyadenylated . This is consistent with the Su(Ste) locus lacking RDC, which would actually suppress splicing and polyadenylation if present. Importantly, when Su(Ste) repeats start to be expressed in spermatocytes during the mitosis-to-meiosis transition, the general transcription machinery is replaced by testis-specific machinery, like testis-specific TBP-associated factor (tTAF), testis-specific meiotic arrest complex (tMAC), and the coactivator mediator . It remains to be addressed whether this testis-specific machinery is required for Su(Ste) expression.
In this new study, Chen and colleagues showed that RDC first forms multiple nuclear foci in GSCs and spermatogonia due to its association with multiple dual-strand piRNA clusters and then concentrates in spermatocytes in a single dot corresponding to a unique piRNA cluster, the X-linked AT-chX locus . Importantly, the spermatocyte stage is known to have some unique features. (1) Chromosomes get organized in 3 distinct chromosome territories (2; 3; X, Y, 4) . (2) The X chromosome is transcriptionally down-regulated, while the heterochromatin-rich and gene-poor Y chromosome is highly expressed due to Y-loop formation [15,16]. (3) Pericentromeric satellite sequences within the X, Y, and fourth chromosomes get together and are decorated with D1 (a multi-AT-hook satellite DNA-binding protein involved in chromocenter formation) . Thus, 2 intriguing key questions arise from this study: (i) Why does the X-linked pericentromeric AT-chX locus not colocalize with pericentromeric D1? (ii) How does AT-chX become highly expressed at this stage? One possibility might be that AT-chX loops out to be excluded from the down-regulated X chromosome, similarly to the Y chromosome. Also, we cannot exclude that the single Rhino foci results from the concentration of multiple piRNA clusters, similarly to rDNA that cluster in the nucleolus to be transcribed by RNA-pol-I in many organisms . Future single-cell transcriptomics and high-throughput chromosome conformation capture (HiC) experiments performed in the testis should help to better understand AT-chX and other piRNA cluster expression and nuclear organization during spermatogenesis.
Finally, even if AT-chX is the second most expressed piRNA cluster in the testis after Su(Ste), its function still remains poorly understood. One possibility is that AT-chX could be a master locus required for the piNG-body formation, as flamenco is necessary for the Yb body formation in ovarian somatic cells . Indeed, the piNG-body emerges at the spermatocyte stage and contains proteins similar to the female nuage . It has also been proposed that AT-ChX piRNAs could participate together with the Su(Ste) system to assist the emergence of reproductive isolation and speciation of D. melanogaster during evolution (Fig 1B). Indeed, only D. melanogaster has Su(Ste) and AT-chX repeats [7,21]. When D. melanogaster females mate with other Drosophila species males, Stellate genes cannot be repressed, and the hybrids flies are sterile. Intriguingly, AT-chX piRNAs have 76% homology to vasa transcripts within D. melanogaster but do not have the ability to repress vasa in the testis or ovaries. However, vasa sequences from related species that diverged from a Drosophila common ancestor several million years ago have more than 90% complementarity with piRNAs from AT-chX repeats of D. melanogaster. AT-chX piRNAs are more similar to “alien vasa” than endogenous vasa, suggesting that those piRNAs could help to preserve reproductive isolation and speciation through the repression of “alien vasa” when crossed to other species, since vasa is crucial for the piRNA pathway, germline formation, and fertility.
Thanks to their discovery, Chen and colleagues open the possibility to reconsider many other proteins of the piRNA pathway thought to be futile in males, which will help to better understand the global piRNA mechanisms and piRNA sexual dimorphism.
We thank Neuza Reis Matias (Stanford Medicine, USA) and Silke Jensen (GReD, Université Clermont Auvergne) for discussions and manuscript reading.
- 1. Aravin AA, Klenov MS, Vagin VV, Bantignies F, Cavalli G, Gvozdev VA. Dissection of a natural RNA silencing process in the Drosophila melanogaster germ line. Mol Cell Biol. 2004;24:6742–50. pmid:15254241.
- 2. Gainetdinov I, Colpan C, Arif A, Cecchini K, Zamore PD. A Single Mechanism of Biogenesis, Initiated and Directed by PIWI Proteins, Explains piRNA Production in Most Animals. Mol Cell. 2018;71:775, e5–90. pmid:30193099.
- 3. Quénerch’du E, Anand A, Kai T. The piRNA pathway is developmentally regulated during spermatogenesis in Drosophila. RNA. 2016;22:1044–54. pmid:27208314.
- 4. Cox DN, Chao A, Lin H. Piwi encodes a nucleoplasmic factor whose activity modulates the number and division rate of germline stem cells. Development. 2000;127:503–14. pmid:10631171.
- 5. Nishida KM, Saito K, Mori T, Kawamura Y, Nagami-Okada T, Inagaki S, et al. Gene silencing mechanisms mediated by Aubergine piRNA complexes in Drosophila male gonad. RNA. 2007;13:1911–22. pmid:17872506.
- 6. Nagao A, Mituyama T, Huang H, Chen D, Siomi MC, Siomi H. Biogenesis pathways of piRNAs loaded onto AGO3 in the Drosophila testis. RNA. 2010;16:2503–15. pmid:20980675.
- 7. Kotov AA, Adashev VE, Godneeva BK, Ninova M, Shatskikh AS, Bazylev SS, et al. piRNA silencing contributes to interspecies hybrid sterility and reproductive isolation in Drosophila melanogaster. Nucleic Acids Res. 2019;47:4255–71. pmid:30788506.
- 8. Chen P, Kotov AA, Godneeva BK, Bazylev SS, Olenina LV, Aravin AA. piRNA-mediated gene regulation and adaptation to sex-specific transposon expression in D. melanogaster male germline. Genes Dev. 2021;35(11–12):914–35. pmid:33985970.
- 9. Mohn F, Sienski G, Handler D, Brennecke J. The Rhino-Deadlock-Cutoff Complex Licenses Noncanonical Transcription of Dual-Strand piRNA Clusters in Drosophila. Cell. 2014;157:1364–79. pmid:24906153.
- 10. Volpe AM, Horowitz H, Grafer CM, Jackson SM, Berg CA. Drosophila rhino encodes a female-specific chromo-domain protein that affects chromosome structure and egg polarity. Genetics. 2001;159:1117–34. pmid:11729157.
- 11. Chen P, Luo Y, Aravin AA. RDC complex executes a Dynamic piRNA program during Drosophila spermatogenesis to safeguard male fertility. PLoS Genet. 2021.
- 12. Aravin AA, Naumova NM, Tulin AV, Vagin VV, Rozovsky YM, Gvozdev VA. Double-stranded RNA-mediated silencing of genomic tandem repeats and transposable elements in the D. melanogaster germline. Curr Biol. 2001 Jul 10;11(13):1017–27. pmid:11470406.
- 13. Gleason RJ, Anand A, Kai T, Chen X. Protecting and Diversifying the Germline. Genetics. 2018;208:435–71. pmid:29378808.
- 14. McKee BD, Yan R, Tsai J-H. Meiosis in male Drosophila. Spermatogenesis. 2012;2:167–84. pmid:23087836
- 15. Landeen EL, Muirhead CA, Wright L, Meiklejohn CD, Presgraves DC. Sex Chromosome-wide Transcriptional Suppression and Compensatory Cis-Regulatory Evolution Mediate Gene Expression in the Drosophila Male Germline. PLoS Biol. 2016;14:e1002499. pmid:27404402.
- 16. Mahadevaraju S, Fear JM, Akeju M, Galletta BJ, Pinheiro MMLS, Avelino CC, et al. Dynamic sex chromosome expression in Drosophila male germ cells. Nat Commun. 2021;12:892–16. pmid:33563972.
- 17. Jagannathan M, Cummings R, Yamashita YM. The modular mechanism of chromocenter formation in Drosophila. Elife. 2019 Feb 11;8:e43938. pmid:30741633.
- 18. Maiser A, Dillinger S, Längst G, Schermelleh L, Leonhardt H, Németh A. Super-resolution in situ analysis of active ribosomal DNA chromatin organization in the nucleolus. Sci Rep. 2020;10:7462–11. pmid:32366902.
- 19. Dennis C, Zanni V, Brasset E, Zhang L, Eymery A, Jensen S, et al. “Dot COM,” a nuclear transit center for the primary piRNA pathway in Drosophila. PLoS ONE. 2013;8:e72752. pmid:24039799.
- 20. Kibanov MV, Egorova KS, Ryazansky SS, Sokolova OA, Kotov AA, Olenkina OM, et al. A novel organelle, the piNG-body, in the nuage of Drosophila male germ cells is associated with piRNA-mediated gene silencing. Mol Biol Cell. 2011;22:3410–9. pmid:21775629.
- 21. Adashev VE, Kotov AA, Bazylev SS, Shatskikh AS, Aravin AA, Olenina LV. Stellate Genes and the piRNA Pathway in Speciation and Reproductive Isolation of Drosophila melanogaster. Front Genet. 2020;11:610665. pmid:33584811.