• Loading metrics

GLI3 resides at the intersection of hedgehog and androgen action to promote male sex differentiation

  • Anbarasi Kothandapani,

    Roles Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Supervision, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Department of Comparative Biosciences, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, United States of America

  • Samantha R. Lewis,

    Roles Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Supervision, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Department of Comparative Biosciences, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, United States of America

  • Jessica L. Noel,

    Roles Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Supervision, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Department of Comparative Biosciences, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, United States of America

  • Abbey Zacharski ,

    Contributed equally to this work with: Abbey Zacharski, Kyle Krellwitz, Anna Baines

    Roles Data curation, Investigation, Methodology

    ‡ Undergraduate Researchers

    Affiliation Department of Comparative Biosciences, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, United States of America

  • Kyle Krellwitz ,

    Contributed equally to this work with: Abbey Zacharski, Kyle Krellwitz, Anna Baines

    Roles Data curation, Investigation, Methodology, Visualization

    ‡ Undergraduate Researchers

    Affiliation Department of Comparative Biosciences, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, United States of America

  • Anna Baines ,

    Contributed equally to this work with: Abbey Zacharski, Kyle Krellwitz, Anna Baines

    Roles Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Visualization, Writing – review & editing

    ‡ Undergraduate Researchers

    Affiliation Department of Comparative Biosciences, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, United States of America

  • Stephanie Winske ,

    Roles Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Visualization, Writing – review & editing

    ‡ Undergraduate Researchers

    Affiliation Department of Comparative Biosciences, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, United States of America

  • Chad M. Vezina,

    Roles Data curation, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Investigation, Methodology, Resources, Visualization, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Department of Comparative Biosciences, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, United States of America

  • Elena M. Kaftanovskaya,

    Roles Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Visualization

    Affiliation Department of Human and Molecular Genetics, Florida International University, Miami, Florida, United States of America

  • Alexander I. Agoulnik,

    Roles Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Investigation, Methodology, Project administration, Resources, Supervision, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Department of Human and Molecular Genetics, Florida International University, Miami, Florida, United States of America

  • Emily M. Merton,

    Roles Data curation, Investigation, Methodology, Visualization

    Affiliation Molecular Genetics and Microbiology, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, United States of America

  • Martin J. Cohn,

    Roles Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Investigation, Methodology, Project administration, Resources, Supervision, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Molecular Genetics and Microbiology, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, United States of America

  • Joan S. Jorgensen

    Roles Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Investigation, Methodology, Project administration, Resources, Supervision, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Department of Comparative Biosciences, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, United States of America

GLI3 resides at the intersection of hedgehog and androgen action to promote male sex differentiation

  • Anbarasi Kothandapani, 
  • Samantha R. Lewis, 
  • Jessica L. Noel, 
  • Abbey Zacharski, 
  • Kyle Krellwitz, 
  • Anna Baines, 
  • Stephanie Winske, 
  • Chad M. Vezina, 
  • Elena M. Kaftanovskaya, 
  • Alexander I. Agoulnik


Urogenital tract abnormalities are among the most common congenital defects in humans. Male urogenital development requires Hedgehog-GLI signaling and testicular hormones, but how these pathways interact is unclear. We found that Gli3XtJ mutant mice exhibit cryptorchidism and hypospadias due to local effects of GLI3 loss and systemic effects of testicular hormone deficiency. Fetal Leydig cells, the sole source of these hormones in developing testis, were reduced in numbers in Gli3XtJ testes, and their functional identity diminished over time. Androgen supplementation partially rescued testicular descent but not hypospadias in Gli3XtJ mutants, decoupling local effects of GLI3 loss from systemic effects of androgen insufficiency. Reintroduction of GLI3 activator (GLI3A) into Gli3XtJ testes restored expression of Hedgehog pathway and steroidogenic genes. Together, our results show a novel function for the activated form of GLI3 that translates Hedgehog signals to reinforce fetal Leydig cell identity and stimulate timely INSL3 and testosterone synthesis in the developing testis. In turn, exquisite timing and concentrations of testosterone are required to work alongside local GLI3 activity to control development of a functionally integrated male urogenital tract.

Author summary

Disorders in male sex differentiation (DSD) are among the most common defects in all live births, yet in many cases, pediatric patient families are reluctant to address the issue and endure lifelong consequences. Urogenital tract development, as in many organ systems, depends on exquisite timing among layers of a number of signaling pathways. Here, we show that interactions between the hedgehog and androgen signaling pathways are required for the development of internal and external male sex characteristics, but results for each tissue is distinct. This new knowledge will aid in discovering the means by which congenital malformations might occur, identify potential developmental targets that might be vulnerable to environmental exposures, and promote new ideas for how they might be prevented.


Congenital anomalies within the male urogenital tract, including cryptorchidism (failure of the testes to descend) and hypospadias (mislocalization of the urethral meatus), are among the most frequently documented abnormalities in all live births and their incidence is increasing [1]. These defects in male sex differentiation can occur separately or together with additional male-specific disorders suggesting a common or overlapping etiology. It has long been established that male sex differentiation requires androgen activity that must occur within a critical timeframe of fetal development [2]. Indeed, there is concern that the overall increase in the incidence of disorders of male sex differentiation that has been observed in developed industrial countries is related to endocrine disruptors that impact androgen activity [3]. Notably, a number of other molecular pathways, including hedgehog morphogens, are also known to control aspects of development that define male primary and secondary sex organ phenotypes [46].

Sonic Hedgehog (SHH) directs patterning and development of external genitalia and secondary sex organs while Desert Hedgehog (DHH) stimulates differentiation of a critical population of cells within the developing testis, the fetal Leydig cells, that are the sole source for fetal androgen production [5,7,8]. All hedgehog ligands signal via Smoothened receptor to activate GLI1, GLI2 and GLI3 transcription factors. Each factor has been shown to contribute to male sex differentiation in distinct ways. For example, while mutations in Gli2 alone caused external genitalia defects, compound mutation with Gli1 showed no additional defects, but its combination with Gli3 exhibited more severe defects [5,911]. Further, some studies showed that Gli3 is not essential for the development of external genitalia but others found that Gli3 disruption causes significant genital malformations [5,10,11]. Meanwhile, within the fetal testis, elimination of Gli1 or Gli2 individually is not sufficient to reproduce the failure in fetal Leydig cell differentiation seen in Dhh knockout mice; Gli3 has not been tested [12]. Together, these studies support the concept that hedgehog and androgen pathways collaborate to orchestrate male sex differentiation and highlight Gli3 in particular as a potentially important intermediary between the two. In humans, there is a subset of male patients with mutations in GLI3, including autosomal dominant GLI3 anomalies categorized as Greig cephalopolysyndactyly syndrome (GCPS) and Pallister-Hall syndrome (PHS), that exhibit differences in male sex differentiation [13,14]. Despite these reports, the role for GLI3 in urogenital development remains unknown.

In this report, we used the Gli3 extra toes Jackson (XtJ) mouse model that harbors a loss-of-function mutation and is an established model for human GCPS [15]. Our results show that, similar to GCPS patients, the Gli3XtJ mutation causes differences in male sex differentiation including cryptorchidism and hypospadias. Notably, testicular hormones, INSL3 and testosterone, were significantly lower in Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos, which contributed to a range of mutant phenotypes in primary and secondary organs of the male reproductive tract. While testis development, including testis cord formation, progressed normally, expression of genes associated with androgen and INSL3 production in addition to members of the DHH pathway were disrupted within Gli3XtJ mutant testes, indicating a failure in fetal Leydig cell differentiation or maintenance. Reintroduction of a constitutively active Gli3-full length expression plasmid (GLI3A) into Gli3XtJ mutant testes significantly increased fetal Leydig cell-specific gene expression providing evidence that GLI3A maintains fetal Leydig cell identity. Together, our results suggest that fetal Leydig cell function depends on activated GLI3 for optimal expression of genes critical to INSL3 and androgen synthesis, the timing and concentration of which is critical to define optimal male sex differentiation.


The Gli3XtJ mutation disrupts male sex differentiation

GLI3 mutations have been associated with the urogenital phenotypes exhibited by GCPS and PHS patients [13,14]. Thus, we used Gli3XtJ mutant mice, which serve as a robust model of GCPS [15], to investigate the interplay between Gli3 and androgen production and action. While mice heterozygous for the Gli3XtJ mutation were viable and fertile, the homozygous mutation resulted in embryonic lethality, thus confining our analysis to fetal development up to embryonic day (E) E17.5 [15]. Similar to some GCPS patients, Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos exhibited cryptorchidism and external genitalia defects, including hypospadias. While wild type testes were present near the bladder by E16.5, all Gli3XtJ mutant males examined exhibited cryptorchidism with placement of the testes near the kidney (Fig 1A and 1B). This difference was quantified by measuring the distance from the kidney hilum to the center of the testis on the ipsilateral side. Mutant testes were significantly closer to the kidneys than wild type testes, indicating a failure to descend. As a control for generalized developmental delays, caudal kidney to cranial bladder distances were measured and revealed no differences between wild type and mutant animals (Fig 1C). By E17.5 however, testes were located near the bladder in most Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos examined, indicating that the transabdominal phase of testis descent may be variable and delayed by ~24 hours.

Fig 1. Gli3XtJ mutation disrupts male sex differentiation.

Wild type and Gli3XtJ urogenital tracts were evaluated at E16.5 or E17.5 for testis placement (A,B), external genitalia (D-G), prostate bud formation (H, I) and anogenital distance (J). A,B) Wild type testes (n = 7) appear near the bladder (A) and Gli3XtJ testes (n = 5) are located near the kidney showing bilateral cryptorchidism (B). Arrows denote testes (outlined with dashed line or T), kidney (K) and bladder (B). C) Distances from kidney hilum to gonad on ipsilateral side, and from the caudal kidney to the cranial bladder were measured. D-G) External genitalia in wild type (D,F) (n = 6) and Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos (E,G) (n = 6) imaged in whole-mount using light microscopy (D,E) or nanoscale computed tomography (F,G). Single arrows mark the position of the urethral duct; multiple arrows indicate ectopic opening of hypospadiac urethra. H, I) Whole-mount male urogenital sinus was stained by ISH to detect Nkx3-1 mRNA to visualize prostate buds in wild type (H) (n = 3) and Gli3XtJ embryos (I) (n = 3). Seminal vesicles (SV), urethra (Ur), bladder (B), arrow denotes prostate buds. J) Gli3XtJ embryos (n = 7) showed reduced anogenital distance (AGD) compared to wild type embryos (n = 7). For C and J, results are represented as mean ± SEM. Student’s t-test, **: p<0.01, ***: p<0.001, ns: non-significant.

Next, examination of external genitalia using light microscopy (Fig 1D and 1E) and nanoscale computed tomography (Fig 1F and 1G) revealed abnormal penile morphology with varying degrees of hypospadias in Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos (Fig 1E and 1G). External genitalia were examined in 6 litters of mice collected at E16.5–17.5 from which 6 male homozygous Gli3XtJ mutants were recovered. Hypospadias was detected in half of the male mutants (n = 3/6), all of which showed ectopic opening of the urethral duct at the base of the penis (Fig 1E and 1G). In one case, the hypospadiac urethral opening extended from the base of the penis into the scrotum, similar to human penoscrotal hypospadias. Development of the penile glans and prepuce was generally normal except at the site of the ectopic opening.

Additional male sex phenotype characteristics arise starting around E16 and are related to hedgehog and androgen activity, including prostate bud formation and expansion of the anogenital distance (AGD) [16,17]. To investigate prostate bud initiation, we performed whole mount in situ hybridization on urogenital sinuses at E16.5 with a RNA probe for Nkx3-1, a prostate epithelium selective marker. Results showed no difference in bud patterns between wild type and Gli3XtJ mutant urogenital tracts (Fig 1H and 1I). At the same time, however, Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos showed a significantly reduced AGD compared to wild type littermates (Fig 1J). Altogether, the spectrum of phenotypes in male reproductive organs in Gli3XtJ mutant embryos ranged from unaffected prostate bud formation to varying degrees of severity of AGD expansion, hypospadias, and cryptorchidism.

Insufficient hormone production from fetal testes in Gli3XtJ mutant embryos causes a subset of differences in male sex differentiation

The fetal testis is known to be the sole source of the two hormones that are critical for male sex differentiation: insulin-like 3 peptide (INSL3) and testosterone. To test whether the Gli3XtJ mutation altered fetal testis hormone production, we measured Insl3 transcript levels, which function as a readout for the INSL3 peptide [18], and testicular testosterone concentrations (Fig 2). Insl3 transcripts in Gli3XtJ mutant testes were significantly decreased by 64% at E13.5 and by 60% at E16.5 compared to wild type values; however, expression of Insl3 increased by ~3-fold between E13.5–16.5 in both wild type and Gli3XtJ mutant testes (Fig 2A). In addition, testicular testosterone levels were ~60% and over 70% lower in Gli3XtJ testes compared to that of wild type testes at E13.5 and E16.5, respectively. Notably, in contrast to Insl3, Gli3XtJ mutant testes failed to produce any additional testosterone while there was a ~2-fold increase in wild type testes between E13.5–16.5 (Fig 2B).

Fig 2. Gli3XtJ mutant testes produce insufficient hormones.

A) RT-qPCR comparing expression of Insl3 transcripts in wild type (n = 3) and Gli3XtJ (n = 3) testes at E13.5 and E16.5. Results are reported relative to E13.5 wild type testis. B) Testicular testosterone levels as measured by ELISA at E13.5 and E16.5 (WT n = 6; Gli3XtJ n = 4). Results are represented as mean ± SEM. (A, B) One-way ANOVA followed by post-hoc Tukey’s test, #: p<0.1, *: p<0.05, **: p<0.01, ****: p<0.0001, ns: non-significant.

Early development of mouse external genitalia is controlled by locally acting signals, including SHH, in the absence of hormonal signaling [6,19,20], followed by androgen mediated virilization of the penis [21]. To test whether defects in Gli3XtJ mutant male external genitalia were caused by the deficiency in androgens, we administered 1mg/kg DHT to pregnant dams daily starting at E12.5 and harvested embryos at E16.5 and E17.5. Proximal hypospadias was observed in 8 of 10 Gli3XtJ mutant males treated with DHT, and the range of severity was similar to that observed in untreated and vehicle (sesame oil) treated Gli3XtJ mutants (S1 Fig; compare S1B Fig with Fig 1E and 1G). Thus, androgen supplementation is not sufficient to restore normal urethral tube development in the absence of Gli3.

Testis descent is completed in two phases: transabdominal and inguinoscrotal, which occur pre- and postnatally, respectively, in the mouse [22]. During fetal stages, the urogenital ridges are held in their abdominal position by two ligamentous structures, the cranial suspensory ligament (CSL) and caudal gubernaculum. Because Gli3XtJ mutant embryos are embryonic lethal, we were restricted to analysis of the transabdominal phase of testis descent that requires both INSL3 and testosterone, which promote outgrowth of the gubernaculum and regression of the CSL, respectively [23,24]. Both ligaments were evaluated by serial section histology at E16.5. Results show that there is no difference in morphology of the gubernaculum between wild type and mutant animals (Fig 3A). To test whether the hedgehog pathway has a direct impact on gubernaculum outgrowth, we stained Gli1-LacZ embryos that were collected at birth as a readout of active hedgehog signaling (S1 Methods). Results show positive β-galactosidase activity within the testes, bladder, and vas deferens as expected [25]. In contrast, staining in the gubernaculum was absent, suggesting that its development is independent of hedgehog activity (S2A Fig). INSL3 signaling is mediated through its cognate Relaxin Family Peptide Receptor type 2 (RXFP2) expressed in the gubernaculum [2628]. qPCR results indicated that Rxfp2 transcripts were not different between wild type and Gli3XtJ mutant gubernacula (S2B Fig). Together, these data suggest that although the gubernaculum structure is normal, insufficient INSL3 exposure may contribute to delayed testicular descent in Gli3XtJ mutants.

Fig 3. Cranial suspensory ligaments (CSL) persist in Gli3XtJ embryos and degrade in response to exogenous DHT.

A) H&E stain of serial sagittal sections from wild type (n = 5) and Gli3XtJ mutant (n = 5) embryos at E16.5. Arrows denote cranial suspensory ligaments (CSL), epididymis (E), intestine (Int), kidney (K), testis (T) and gubernaculum (G). B) Pregnant dams were treated daily with sesame oil or DHT (1 mg/kg body weight), starting on E12.5 until the embryos were harvested at E16.5. Oil treated (a,b) (n = 4) and DHT treated (c,d) (n = 4) Gli3XtJ urogenital sections were stained with picrosirius red to detect mature collagen fibers. The enlarged images (b,d) are taken from boxed regions in low magnification image (a,c). Scale bar: (a,c) = 100 μm and (b,d) = 25 μm. C) Total collagen density was determined by measuring the number of collagen fibers within a region of interest representing the total cross-sectional area of the CSL. Results are represented as mean ± SEM. Student’s t-test, **: p<0.01.

Additional evaluation of histological serial sections in wild type animals show typical regression of the CSL; however, the ligament remained intact and appeared shorter and thicker in Gli3XtJ mutant animals (Fig 3A). Regression of the CSL depends on androgen/androgen receptor (AR) interactions [24,26,27,29]; therefore, we tested whether abnormal AR expression contributed to impaired CSL degradation (S1 Methods). Immunohistochemistry results showed no difference in AR expression in the CSL, epididymis, or testis between wild type and Gli3XtJ mutant embryos (S2C Fig). Next, we evaluated testis descent following gestational exposure to DHT or sesame oil control. Although prenatal DHT treatment did not hasten descent compared to vehicle treated mutant embryos, fluorescent imaging of picrosirius red staining did reveal that the collagen content of the CSL was affected (Fig 3B). CT-FIRE software was used to quantify individual collagen fiber metrics and total collagen density [30,31]. Collagen density per area was significantly decreased within the CSL of DHT treated compared to oil treated Gli3XtJ mutant embryos (Fig 3C). In summary, these data suggest that insufficient production of testicular INSL3 and testosterone caused the delayed testis descent in Gli3XtJ mutants.

Inadequate testis hormone production is caused by differentiation of fewer fetal Leydig cells within an otherwise normal testis in Gli3XtJ mutant embryos

Insufficient production of testicular hormones by Gli3XtJ mutant testes imply that GLI3 functions as a mediator for DHH-induced fetal Leydig cell differentiation. To localize GLI3 presence in fetal testis, we performed double label immunohistochemistry for β-galactosidase and 3-βhydroxysteroid dehydrogenase (3βHSD), a fetal Leydig cell specific marker, on E16.5 testis sections from Gli3-LacZ reporter mice. As expected, Gli3 expression was confined to the testis interstitium, specifically within peritubular myoid and fetal Leydig cells (Fig 4A).

Fig 4. Gli3XtJ mutant embryos have normal testicular morphology.

A) Double stain immunohistochemistry was used to detect β-galactosidase (red, marked GLI3) along with 3βHSD (Leydig cell marker, green) in E16.5 testes of Gli3-LacZ embryos. DAPI marks cell nuclei in blue. Yellow denotes co-localization in fetal Leydig cells. Arrows denote peritubular myoid cells; testis cords are outlined by dotted lines. B-M) Representative images of testis sections at E13.5 and E16.5 comparing wild type and Gli3XtJ mutant embryos—H&E staining (B-E), immunostaining for germ cell marker, TRA98 (red) and Sertoli cell marker, AMH (green) (DAPI nuclear counterstain, blue; F-I), and immunostaining for laminin (green) (DAPI nuclear counterstain, blue; J-M) to highlight intact basement membranes.

We next considered the impact of the Gli3XtJ mutation on testis development. Histological analysis of E13.5 and E16.5 testes showed intact testicular morphogenesis in both wild type and Gli3XtJ mutant animals (Fig 4B–4E). Wild type and Gli3XtJ mutant testes exhibited similar anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) and Tra98 staining patterns suggesting no difference in number of Sertoli or germ cells, respectively (Fig 4F–4I). Laminin staining of the basement membrane, a product of Sertoli and peritubular myoid cells, was intact in Gli3XtJ mutants indicating no impairment in function of either cell type (Fig 4J–4M). Together, these results suggest that the Gli3XtJ mutation does not impact Sertoli, germ cell, or peritubular myoid cells, which together promote normal testis cord development. Given the decreased levels of fetal Leydig cell derived hormones, we next performed immunohistochemistry for 3βHSD, a fetal Leydig cell marker, to evaluate and quantify differentiated cells. Results show that fetal Leydig cells were present but fewer in number at both E13.5 and E16.5 in Gli3XtJ mutant testes; however, fetal Leydig cell number/area increased at the same rate for both groups between the time points (Fig 5A–5F).

Fig 5. Gli3XtJ mutant embryos have fewer fetal Leydig cells.

Representative images of 3βHSD immunostained fetal Leydig cells (green) with DAPI nuclear counterstain (blue) at E13.5 and E16.5 in wild type (A,D) and Gli3XtJ mutant (B,E) testes. C, F) Cells positive for 3βHSD were quantified from stained sections and results are represented as mean ± SEM. Biological replicates are as follows: E13.5 WT n = 5, Gli3XtJ n = 5; E16.5 WT n = 5, Gli3XtJ n = 3. Student’s t-test, #: p<0.1, *: p<0.05. Scale bar: 100 μm.

Fetal Leydig cells are mitotically inactive and rarely proliferate [32]; therefore, the decrease in fetal Leydig cell numbers could be due to an increase in Leydig cell death or increased accumulation of progenitor cells that fail to differentiate [33]. Expression of cleaved caspase-3 was absent in both wild type and Gli3XtJ mutant testes ruling out caspase 3-mediated fetal Leydig cell apoptosis (S3A Fig). To test for impaired fetal Leydig cell differentiation, we investigated expression of progenitor population markers and evaluated the integrity of signaling pathways that collaborate with DHH. Immunofluorescence and qPCR results show that the expression patterns for fetal somatic cell progenitor, WT1 [34,35] and adult Leydig cell progenitor, NR2F2 (COUPTF2) [36] are not different between wild type and Gli3XtJ mutant testes (S3B and S3C Fig). Finally, it has been reported that future fetal Leydig cells differentiate in response to coordinated events between active DHH and PDGFA signals and a loss of the NOTCH pathway [37,38]. Transcript levels of PDGFA pathway genes and NOTCH family members were not different between wild type and Gli3XtJ mutant testes at both E13.5 and E16.5 (S3D and S3E Fig). Altogether, these data suggest that deficient hormone production in Gli3XtJ mutant testes is caused by an insufficient number of steroidogenic cells as defined by expression of 3βHSD.

Fetal Leydig cells in Gli3XtJ mutant embryos are dysfunctional

We next investigated deficits of the fetal Leydig cell population in the context of the developing testis. First, we evaluated whether the Gli3XtJ mutation affected the genes within the hedgehog signaling pathway itself. Testicular transcripts of Dhh increased at E13.5 and remained unchanged at E16.5 (Fig 6A). Gli1 and Ptch1, both downstream targets of hedgehog signaling, were significantly decreased by E16.5. In addition, there was a stepwise decrease in Gli2 from E13.5 and E16.5 (Fig 6A). These results suggest that the loss of Gli3 perturbs hedgehog signaling over time. One critical feature to hedgehog signaling is its dependency on the primary cilium for its function and GLI processing [39]; therefore, we evaluated features of primary cilia within wild type versus Gli3XtJ mutant fetal testes. Results showed similar staining patterns of cilia among interstitial cells in general and on marked fetal Leydig cells (S4A Fig). Next, we investigated transcript profiles of Foxj1 and Rxp3, genes that are involved in cilia biogenesis and responsive to hedgehog signals [40] and found no change in expression of either gene (S4B Fig). Collectively, these data suggest that ciliopathy is not the cause for disrupted hedgehog transcript profiles in Gli3XtJ mutant testes.

Fig 6. Hedgehog and steroidogenic pathway genes are decreased in Gli3XtJ testes.

RT-qPCR comparing wild type (white bars) and Gli3XtJ mutant (gray bars) testis mRNA expression for hedgehog (A) and steroidogenic (B) pathway genes at E13.5 and E16.5 and expressed as fold change from wild type control at each time point and reported as the average ± SEM from n = 3–4 biological replicates. Student’s t-test, *: p<0.05, **: p<0.01, ns: non-significant.

Gli3XtJ mutant testes produce less Insl3 and testosterone indicating dysfunctional fetal Leydig cells; therefore, we performed qRT-PCR to examine production of genes related to steroid synthesis. In the fetal testis, Sertoli cell-derived DHH signals stimulate differentiation of SF1-positive progenitor cells into fetal Leydig cells, which is heralded by upregulation of Sf1 and then SF1-dependent steroidogenic enzymes [8,41]. Our results show that transcript levels of Sf1, Star, Cyp11a1 and Cyp17a1 were significantly decreased in mutant testes at both E13.5 and E16.5 (Fig 6B). This result could be interpreted as a true decrease in gene expression or it could reflect a decrease in fetal Leydig cell number, or both. To adjust, transcript levels reported in Fig 6B were normalized to Leydig cell numbers as quantified by 3βHSD staining (Fig 5C and 5F). Raw values without normalization indicated that the transcript levels were largely reflected by the decrease in cell numbers (S5 Fig); however, normalized data indicated an additional 25–40% decrease, especially at E16.5. Altogether, these data suggest that although fewer fetal Leydig cells can be identified in Gli3XtJ mutant testes, their function is affected and worsens over time.

Exogenous Gli3 restores the fetal Leydig cell transcript profile in Gli3XtJ mutant testes

SF1 is known as the master regulator of genes within the steroidogenic pathway [42,43]; of interest, both GLI2 and GLI3 have been reported to stimulate distinct steroidogenic genes to promote steroid synthesis [44]. To test whether replacement of GLI3 could restore expression of Sf1 and other steroidogenic genes, we transfected Gli3XtJ mutant testes using microinjection followed by electroporation [45] with CMV driven expression vectors encoding either EGFP (negative control), or Gli3FL, a constitutively active form of GLI3 [46]. Testes were harvested and transfected at E14.5 followed by 48 hours culture and then processed for RNA and copy number qPCR to quantify transcript numbers of each gene. Reintroduction of Gli3FL increased Gli3 transcript levels from 0% to 40% of wild type control (Fig 7A). The remainder of transfection data was focused on results within Gli3XtJ testes. As expected, transfection of Gli3FL plasmids increased expression of hedgehog-responsive gene, Gli1, and had no effect on the negative control, Sox9. In addition, Gli3FL expression had no impact on Gli2 or Insl3 (Fig 7B). Reintroduction of Gli3 expression stimulated a significant increase for each fetal Leydig cell gene associated with steroidogenesis (Fig 7C). Based on these data, we conclude that hormone dependent male sex differentiation requires activated GLI3 to promote fetal Leydig cell differentiation, maintenance, and testosterone synthesis.

Fig 7. Reintroduction of pGli3FL plasmid DNA restored expression of steroidogenic genes.

A) Wild type and Gli3XtJ mutant testes were transiently transfected with pEGFP-C2 or pEGFP-Gli3FL plasmids and transfection efficiency was analyzed by quantifying the transcript numbers of Gli3 using copy number qPCR. Results are represented as mean ± SEM from n = 3–4 biological replicates. One-way ANOVA followed by post-hoc Tukey’s test, **: p<0.01, ****: p<0.0001. B,C) Gli3XtJ mutant testes were transiently transfected with pEGFP-N1 (gray bars) or pEGFP-Gli3FL (black bars) plasmids. Transcript numbers of Gli2 and Sox9 (negative controls), Gli1 (positive control), Insl3 (B), and steroidogenic genes (C) were measured in the transfected testes. Results are represented as mean ± SEM from n = 3–4 biological replicates. Student’s t-test, *: p<0.05, **: p<0.01.


Results from this study showed that Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos exhibit several characteristics associated with differences in male sex differentiation including decreased anogenital distance, delayed testicular descent, and urethral tube defects, including hypospadias. Differences in sex development, especially those related to male sex differentiation, have significantly increased in incidence over the last decade and few explanations have emerged [47]. Each of these sex characteristics requires activated androgen receptor activity along with other signaling pathways, including hedgehog, within critical developmental windows. For example, independent studies have shown that perturbation of androgen receptor activity or locally acting signals, such as hedgehog and wnt, within defined developmental stages, can cause disrupted genital tubercle and phallus growth [21,48]. These and other studies illustrate the interconnectedness of androgen activity and other pathways in male sex differentiation [49]. While there are some clear examples related to specific genetic defects, the most likely explanation includes complex interactions between genetic defects and environmental factors, which together, also impact epigenetic codes. For example, only 5–29% of GCPS and PHS patients exhibit male disorders of sex differentiation (Genetic and Rare Disease Information Center, US Department of Health & Human Services). While these mutations have been described as completely penetrant with variable severity, our data suggest that variation in presentation of these specific phenotypes might also be explained by a sensitivity of the GLI3 mutation in certain patients to another layer of vulnerability imposed by androgen action.

Each of the disorders identified in Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos have been associated with both androgen and hedgehog signaling deficiencies [25,5052]; therefore, we hypothesized that the hedgehog and androgen pathways work together to promote male sex differentiation. Our results confirm this hypothesis, but also show that the pathway interactions are unique to each tissue in question. We modeled androgen and hedgehog contributions to fetal Leydig cell differentiation, testis descent, prostate and external genitalia formation (Fig 8). Besides testis descent, which we found to be independent of hedgehog signaling, all other male sex differentiation requires the androgen-activated androgen receptor (AR) along with GLI-mediated hedgehog (HH; Sonic, Desert, or Indian) activity. The fetal Leydig cell requires DHH to stimulate androgen synthesis and GLI3A must be present for optimal productivity. These circulating androgens will then bind AR to stimulate IHH to promote male genital tubercle development and cooperate with SHH in prostate bud formation. Timing of these events is crucial.

Fig 8. GLI3A and androgens cooperate to promote male reproductive tract maturation.

Sertoli cells produce DHH, which diffuses to the testis interstitium where it interacts with PTCH1 receptors to stimulate fetal Leydig cell differentiation. Bound PTCH1 releases SMO to stabilize the activated GLI3 transcription factor (GLI3A), likely along with GLI2A, which indirectly (dashed arrow) stimulates Sf1 (Nr5a1) and other steroidogenic genes to initiate androgen production. Fetal Leydig cells produce androstenedione, which is converted to testosterone in Sertoli cells. GLI3A is necessary to maintain fetal Leydig cell identity by promoting the fidelity of both the hedgehog and steroidogenic enzyme pathways (green loop arrow). Testosterone is released into fetal circulation to promote testis descent, prostate and external genitalia formation (detailed descriptions in Box). Each downstream developmental event needs discrete levels of testosterone at specific times. While both abdominal and scrotal phases of testis descent are independent of HH signaling, prostate and external genitalia development both require HH. Prenatal prostate buds can form with minimal androgen exposure and without HH; although, elevated levels of each are likely important for later developmental stages. Male genital tubercle development is initiated by activated AR, which in turn, stimulates an increase in production of HH and other signaling factors. Gli3XtJ mutant embryos are embryonic lethal precluding analysis of postnatal development; however, our analysis of male sex characteristics during prenatal development highlight cooperation and interactions between androgen/AR and HH signaling pathways.

External genitalia and AGD defects within Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos varied in severity, ranging from indistinguishable from wild type to severe penoscrotal hypospadias. In addition, prenatal administration of DHT did not rescue external genitalia defects in Gli3XtJ mutants. One explanation for this outcome could be insufficient delivery of DHT to embryos; however, this is unlikely because we detected retained Wolffian duct structures in female embryos from litters of each treated dam, validating excess androgen exposure (S6 Fig). Previous studies have established that androgens promote male genital tubercle differentiation with the critical prenatal window defined as E13.5 –E16.5 in mice [21]. These studies were achieved with conditional deletion of the Ar gene and with the use of an androgen receptor antagonist. Sex steroid receptors are known to stimulate both Sonic and Indian hedgehog in numerous cell types, including those in the developing genital tubercle. Further, evidence that the hedgehog pathway is downstream of the androgen receptor is supported by findings that Gli2 and Gli3 mutant mouse models, in addition to temporally controlled deletion of Shh between E13.5 and E15.5, cause hypospadias and a urethral phenotype that is strikingly similar to the hypospadias observed in Gli3XtJ mutants [10,11,52]. It is currently not known whether exogenous androgens could alleviate or bypass these hedgehog-mediated defects. Although we did not evaluate transcripts of other factors downstream of hedgehog, our finding that external genital defects in the Gli3XtJ mutants could not be rescued by exogenous DHT suggests that this would not be the case. Nonetheless, because our animals did have some circulating androgens, albeit very low, we acknowledge the possibility that low levels of androgens could be sufficient to promote expression of hedgehog pathway genes in the face of the Gli3XtJ mutation. Supplementation with DHT however, failed to alleviate those with the phenotype indicating that the Gli3XtJ mutation is sufficient to impede proper development. Thus, we conclude that the variability in urogenital and AGD defects is caused by the unpredictable circulating concentrations of androgens layered upon the Gli3XtJ mutation. Taken together with the inability of DHT to rescue the hypospadias in Gli3XtJ mutants, our data support the hypothesis that the urethral defect is a direct result of disrupted hedgehog signaling in the genital tubercle.

The impact of varying concentrations of circulating androgens is further supported by our observation that prostate bud emergence was not different between Gli3XtJ mutant and wild type male embryos, suggesting sufficient androgen exposure specific to prostate bud development by E16.5. Prostate bud formation is complete by E18.5 and is sensitive to low levels of androgens, but independent of Gli3 [5356]. Mouse urogenital morphogenesis has been separated into pre- and postnatal phases with distinct sensitivity to both androgens and estrogens [19,21]. Urethral tube defects in particular are exquisitely sensitive to androgen/AR activity during prenatal development within a critical window between E13.5–16.5 [21]. Future experiments designed to correlate testicular testosterone concentrations to specific gradations of defects within individual Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos would be helpful to validate these conclusions.

Testicular descent is a critical event in male sexual differentiation and like urogenital morphogenesis, occurs in two distinct stages separated by the time of birth in mice [57]. The inguinoscrotal phase of the testicular migration occurs after birth in mice [22] and hence cannot be evaluated in Gli3XtJ mutants. Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos exhibited a failure in the transabdominal phase of descent by E16.5. Prenatal descent relies on a coordinated regression of the CSL, which is degraded in response to androgens, and the pull of the gubernaculum as it differentiates in response to INSL3 [23,27]. The sole source for both INSL3 and androgens is the fetal testis, and both were significantly diminished in Gli3XtJ mutant testes. We did not detect structural defects within the CSL or gubernaculum or find evidence that the ligaments were dependent on the hedgehog pathway for morphogenesis at early stages of embryonic development. We observed that exogenous DHT exposure had a significant impact on the integrity of collagen content within the androgen-dependent CSL although enhanced collagen degradation was insufficient to promote timely descent. The essential role of androgens in the regression of the CSL comes from animal studies that show that disturbances in androgen synthesis or action result in retained CSL [23,58]. Although it is reported that the CSL is a fibromuscular structure composed of smooth muscle fibers and abundant collagen [59], there are few details regarding the collagen content of the CSL. To our knowledge, very few studies have administered exogenous DHT to rescue failure of CSL regression [60]; our studies show that DHT was able to reduce the collagen content of the CSL suggesting an AR-mediated program in collagen degradation. Testis descent was observed in most Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos by E17.5; therefore, it is likely that co-supplementation of DHT and INSL3 would be required to fully rescue the defective phenotype. Based on these results, we conclude that the hedgehog and androgen pathways do not converge directly within the ligamentous structures that mediate testis descent and that this process requires relatively higher concentrations of androgens along with sufficient INSL3 for an optimal outcome. Thus, the failure in the transabdominal phase of testis descent in Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos suggests that the hedgehog/androgen interface must occur at the level of the fetal testis.

It has long been established that DHH mediated Smoothened activity stimulates fetal Leydig cell differentiation [8,61]. Further, inhibition of all three GLI transcription factors downstream of Smoothened causes impaired fetal Leydig cell differentiation, but individual elimination of Gli1 or Gli2 had no obvious impact [12]. These data prompted our investigation into the impact of Gli3 on fetal testis development. Given the impact of the Gli3XtJ mutation on fetal Leydig cell hormone production, we were not surprised to find fewer cells positive for the steroidogenic enzyme, 3βHSD, or decreased expression of Insl3, Sf1, and other steroidogenic enzyme genes. We have identified putative GLI binding sites in enhancer regions in loci of Sf1 including the putative fetal Leydig cell enhancer reported by Shima et al. [62]; however, transfection analysis in fetal testes (as in Fig 7) and other Leydig cell lines have not supported their specificity. Our data suggest that GLI3 contributes to stabilization of the fetal Leydig cell identity likely through indirect means (Fig 8). At least the cells that were present produced enough INSL3 and androgens to allow prostate bud formation, eventual testis descent, and some success in external genitalia formation. We were, however, surprised to discover evidence to suggest that the hedgehog pathway was significantly impaired. At E13.5, transcripts for Sertoli cell-derived Dhh were increased 2-fold in an apparent response to deficient downstream effects on hedgehog responsive cells as indicated by diminishing Ptch1 and Gli1 target gene transcripts. In addition, Gli2 expression decreased significantly over time, but we did not detect evidence for ciliopathy. These results, taken together with the fading expression of hormone-related genes, suggested that the fetal Leydig cell population was losing its identity over time.

Fetal testes were evaluated by immunofluorescence and qPCR for evidence that would suggest a shift from the fetal Leydig cell identity to a progenitor or other cell type. We did not observe any changes that would indicate accumulation of progenitor cells or defects in other cell types that are associated with fetal Leydig cell differentiation. Other studies with altered hedgehog/GLI signaling activity have shown evidence for target cell dedifferentiation. We found that reintroduction of a plasmid encoding the GLI3 active form into the Gli3XtJ mutant testis had no impact on Insl3, but significantly increased transcripts required for androgen production. This result was reflected in the functional output of fetal Leydig cells over time. Although both Insl3 and testosterone were substantially decreased at E13.5 and E16.5 in Gli3XtJ mutant compared to wild type testes, Insl3 levels increased at the same rate over time in testes of both genotypes. In contrast, testosterone production remained stagnant in mutant compared to wild type testes, suggesting fundamental differences in regulation of each hormone. Notably, the addition of GLI3A did not impact expression of Gli2; however, Gli1 increased as expected. Results suggest that appropriate expression of GLI3A is critical for maintenance of hedgehog signaling capacity and fetal Leydig cell identity. Thus, the fetal Leydig cell within the developing testis represents the foundation for hedgehog/androgen interactions in mediating male sex differentiation.

In summary, our detailed analysis of the differences in male sex differentiation caused by the Gli3XtJ mutation highlights the unique requirements for the interface between hedgehog and androgen action for each tissue. Ultimately, the fetal testis must initiate the program. At a critical time point in fetal testis development, paracrine DHH signals initiate Smoothened activity and hence, GLI3A, likely in concert with GLI1 and GLI2, to stimulate transcription of Insl3, Sf1 and the steroidogenic enzyme pathway genes that provide the foundation for INSL3 and androgen synthesis within fetal Leydig cells. GLI3A is required to maintain this activity. Ultimately, these hormones must reach specific threshold levels for each tissue and in some cases, such as external genitalia and the anogenital region, testis-derived androgens and local hedgehog, among other signals, must coordinate with exquisite timing for appropriate male reproductive tract development.

Materials and methods


Gli3XtJ mice were originally obtained from Jackson Laboratories and have been maintained at the University of Wisconsin for >10 years by breeding into the C57BL/6J background. Genotyping for the wild type and mutant alleles was performed by PCR as published [15,63]. Embryonic testes were differentiated from ovaries by visualization of the characteristic coelomic vessel in the testis. Heterozygous mice were bred for timed pregnancies, and the presence of a vaginal plug the next morning was considered 0.5 day of gestation (E0.5). Embryos were harvested at the stated days and gonads were processed as described. Embryonic males were distinguished by the presence of classic testicular structures including testis cords and the coelomic vessel. In the event that tissues were processed without gonad visualization, tail snips were collected to harvest genomic DNA and perform PCR for Sry (see S1 Table for primers) and the Gli3XtJ mutation. All the procedures described were reviewed and approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at the University of Wisconsin and were performed in accordance with the NIH Guiding Principles for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals.

Morphological measurements

The urogenital system with the gonad and the external genitalia were examined at the indicated time points with a Leica M165FC stereo microscope and images were taken with a Leica DFC295 camera (Leica Microsystems) to enable gross morphological evaluation. Images were coded and anogenital distance was measured by a different investigator that was blinded to genotype from the image. Anogenital distance (AGD) was quantified by measuring the length from the caudal base of the genital tubercle to the anterior aspect of the anus. Wild type and Gli3XtJ male fetuses were analyzed on E16.5.

External Genitalia

Embryos were fixed overnight in 4% paraformaldehyde and dissected to remove limbs and tail in order to provide unobstructed views of anogenital region. Topographic anatomy was examined under a Leica MZFLIII stereo dissecting microscope and images were recorded using a ProgRes C14 Plus CCD camera (Jenoptik). Specimens were then contrast stained in 2.5% aqueous Lugol's Iodine (IKI) for high resolution x-ray nanoscale computed tomography (nanoCT). Scanning was performed at the University of Florida’s Nanoscale Research Facility on a Phoenix V|tome|X M scanner (General Electric) with a 180 kv nanofocus x-ray tube. Radiographs were imported into Phoenix DatosOS|X reconstruction software to produce tomograms, and CT datasets were analyzed, and images produced using VGStudioMax 3.3 software (VolumeGraphics).

In situ hybridization (ISH)

Samples were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde overnight at 4°C and whole-mount in situ hybridization was performed according to standard procedures [64]. ISH and genotyping were conducted by separate labs to ensure that phenotypic analysis was blind to genotypes. Nkx3-1 riboprobes were generated as described previously [64]. The digoxigenin-labeled probe was detected by using an alkaline phosphatase conjugated anti-digoxigenin antibody.


Testes and embryos were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde overnight at 4°C. Tissues were either embedded in paraffin or in OCT freezing media (Tissue-Tek). Paraffin sections were stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) for histological analysis. Sections from at least 4 animals from different litters for each genotype were examined, representative images are shown.

For immunohistochemical analysis, paraffin or frozen sections were stained with appropriate antibodies (S2 Table) according to standard procedures. Briefly, sections were incubated at 4°C overnight with primary antibodies followed by incubation at room temperature with secondary antibodies for 1 hr. Slides were counterstained with DAPI and mounted on glass coverslips.

For collagen staining, paraffin sections were stained with picro-sirius red and mounted with Richard-Allan mounting media as described previously [30]. All images were captured on a Leica SP8 confocal microscope or a Keyence BZ-X700 microscope and processed with ImageJ or Adobe Photoshop. Collagen fiber metrics were measured using CT-FIRE fiber detection software (LOCI; Madison, WI) [31].


Testes were dissociated with Tissue Protein Extraction Reagent (Pierce) using a rotary homogenizer. Testosterone ELISA was performed as previously published [65]. Briefly, Immunosorb 96-well plates (Nunc) were coated with goat anti-mouse immunoglobulin followed by a mouse antibody against testosterone (Biostride). Sample lysates were then added to plates and allowed to bind for 1.5 hr after which HRP-conjugated testosterone was added and allowed to compete for antibody binding. Following a wash, 3,3′,5,5′-tetramethylbenzidine was added to develop color and quenched with 0.5M sulfuric acid. HRP-conjugated testosterone was a kind gift of Dr. Milo Wiltbank, University of Wisconsin-Madison.

RT-qPCR and Copy number qPCR

Total RNA was extracted using the RNeasy mini kit (QIAGEN) and 500ng RNA was used for cDNA synthesis by SuperScript II cDNA First-Strand Synthesis System (Invitrogen) using random primers. The cDNA was amplified by real-time quantitative PCR using SYBR Green (Bio-Rad) as fluorophore in a CFX96 real-time thermal cycler (Bio-Rad). A 10 μl qRT-PCR reaction volume was used with 2 μl of 1:4 diluted cDNA and 300 nM primer. Results were calculated using comparative CT method and normalized to 36B4 (Rplpo) from at least three separate biological replicates. All reactions were performed in duplicates. Primer sequences can be found in S1 Table.

Copy number qPCR was performed to determine the absolute copy number of target gene by relating the CT value to a standard curve. The composite gBlock (IDT Technologies) is used as the quantification standard, which includes all the target gene sequences (PCR products) synthesized on the same genomic block (S3 Table) [66]. Total RNA was extracted using the RNeasy mini kit (QIAGEN) and 500ng RNA was used for multi-primed cDNA synthesis with a cocktail mix of 1 μM each of gene specific reverse primer. A standard curve was generated from tenfold serial dilution series of gBlock fragments ranging from 102 copies/μL to 106 copies/μL. The exact copy number of the unknown samples was calculated from the standard curve using the formula: Absolute transcript copy number = 10^[(CT−(y-intercept))/slope].

5α-dihydrotestosterone treatment

Pregnant dams were treated daily with sesame oil or DHT (1 mg/kg body weight), starting on E12.5 and the embryos were examined at E16.5. Appropriate embryonic absorption of DHT was validated by examining female embryos for the presence of a retained Wolffian duct. The Wolffian duct is precursor of the male-associated reproductive tract and its maintenance is dependent on the presence of androgens. Female embryos from DHT treated dams were harvested and their reproductive tract was examined under phase contrast microscopy for the presence of both the Müllerian and Wolffian ducts (S6 Fig).

Fetal testis transfection analysis

Fetal testis transfection assays were performed as previously described [45]. Testes were harvested from embryos at E14.5 and transfected with pEGFP-C2 (Clontech) or pEGFP-Gli3FL constructs. Gli3FL plasmid was a kind gift from Dr. Leslie Biesecker, NIH. Approximately 0.2 μl of the plasmids (4 μg/μl) was injected into the gonad at three different sites. An aliquot of 20 μl of sterile PBS was placed on the testes for electroporation. Immediately thereafter, five square electrical pulses of 65 V, 50 msec each at 100-msec intervals, were delivered through platinum electrodes from an electroporator (BTX Electro Square Porator, ECM830). After electroporation, testes were placed into 500 μl of Dulbecco minimal Eagle medium (DMEM) supplemented with 10% FBS and 1% Penicillin-Streptomycin, and cultured at 37°C with 5% CO2/95% air for 48 hr and then rinsed with PBS and processed for copy number qPCR analysis.

Statistical analyses

Statistical differences were assessed using a two-tailed Student’s t-test assuming unequal variances. Results were considered statistically different if p-values were ≤ 0.05. Results of p < 0.1 are also reported. One-way ANOVA Post-hoc Tukey was performed where appropriate.

Supporting information

S1 Fig. Prenatal DHT administration did not rescue the external genitalia phenotype in Gli3XtJ mutant male embryos.

External genitalia of Gli3XtJ males harvested from pregnant dams that were treated daily with sesame oil (A) (n = 7) or DHT (1 mg/kg body weight) (B) (n = 8) beginning at E12.5. Arrows indicate ectopic opening of hypospadiac urethra. Embryos were harvested at E16.5 or E17.5 and imaged using whole-mount light microscopy.


S2 Fig. Gubernaculum development is independent of hedgehog signaling; Rxfp2 expression in the gubernaculum and androgen receptor expression in the CSL were unaffected in Gli3XtJ mutants.

A) β-galactosidase (blue) expression in urogenital tracts of a Gli1-LacZ P0 male. The white arrow highlights positive LacZ stain in the vas deferens and the black arrow points out the lack of staining in the gubernaculum B) Expression of INSL3 receptor, Rxfp2, is unaffected in Gli3XtJ gubernaculum at E16.5 compared to the wild type. Results are normalized to wild type control and are represented as mean ± SEM from three biological replicates. Student’s t-test, ns: non-significant. C) IHC with anti-androgen receptor (AR) antibody shows similar expression pattern in wild type and Gli3XtJ mutant embryos. Arrows denote cranial suspensory ligaments (CSL); epididymis (E), intestine (Int), kidney (K), testis (T).


S3 Fig. Gli3XtJmutation does not affect survival of fetal Leydig cells or fate of progenitors.

A) Expression of cleaved caspase 3 with DAPI nuclear counterstain at E16.5 in wild type and Gli3XtJ testes. P0 ovary is included as a positive control, arrows highlight positive staining for cleaved caspase 3. B,C) Expression levels of Wt1 and Nr2f2 were analyzed by IHC (B, Scale bar: 100 μm) and RT-qPCR (C). D, E) Transcript levels of Notch signaling pathway genes (D) and PDGF signaling pathway genes (E) were analyzed by RT-qPCR. Results are normalized to wild type controls at each age and are represented as mean ± SEM from three biological replicates. Student’s t-test, #: p<0.1, ns: non-significant.


S4 Fig. Gli3XtJ mutant testes have normal cilia morphology.

A) Representative images of acetylated γ-tubulin (green) and 3βHSD immunostained (red, counterstained with DAPI) wild type and Gli3XtJ testes at E16.5 showing similar appearance of cilia. Scale bar: 100 μm. B) Transcript levels of genes involved in ciliary biogenesis, Foxj1 and Rxp3 are unaffected in Gli3XtJ testes at E13.5 and E16.5 compared to wild type. Results are reported as compared to wild type controls at each age and represented as mean ± SEM from three biological replicates. Student’s t-test, ns: non-significant.


S5 Fig. Expression of steroidogenic genes not normalized to fetal Leydig cell numbers.

RT-qPCR comparing wild type and Gli3XtJ testes mRNA expression of steroidogenic genes at E13.5 and E16.5 normalized to 36b4 (Rplpo) and expressed as fold change from wild type testes ± SEM, from n = 3–4 biological replicates. Student’s t-test, **: p<0.01, ***: p<0.001.


S6 Fig. Prenatal DHT administration results in retained Wolffian ducts in Gli3XtJ mutant female embryos.

A,B) Pregnant dams (n = 5) were treated daily with sesame oil or DHT (1 mg/kg body weight), starting on E12.5 and harvested at E16.5. Female reproductive tracts were examined under phase contrast microscopy. Arrows indicate epididymis head (A) and the presence of both the Müllerian and Wolffian ducts (B).


S1 Methods. Description of methods used for supplemental figures.



Kyle Wegner for his help with picrosirius red staining and CT-FIRE software. Jorgensen Lab Members and the Developmental Endocrinology Research Group, especially Rob Lipinski, for critical commentary and support. Nicole Franks and Dr. Benjamin Allen (University of Michigan) for Gli3-LacZ gonads.


  1. 1. Thorup J, McLachlan R, Cortes D, Nation TR, Balic A, Southwell BR, et al. What is new in cryptorchidism and hypospadias—a critical review on the testicular dysgenesis hypothesis. J Pediatr Surg. 2010;45(10):2074–86. pmid:20920735
  2. 2. Welsh M, Suzuki H, Yamada G. The masculinization programming window. Endocr Dev. 2014;27:17–27. pmid:25247641
  3. 3. Chul Kim S, Kyoung Kwon S, Pyo Hong Y. Trends in the incidence of cryptorchidism and hypospadias of registry-based data in Korea: a comparison between industrialized areas of petrochemical estates and a non-industrialized area. Asian J Androl. 2011;13(5):715–8. pmid:20729869
  4. 4. Yamada G, Satoh Y, Baskin LS, Cunha GR. Cellular and molecular mechanisms of development of the external genitalia. Differentiation. 2003;71(8):445–60. pmid:14641326
  5. 5. Haraguchi R, Mo R, Hui C, Motoyama J, Makino S, Shiroishi T, et al. Unique functions of Sonic hedgehog signaling during external genitalia development. Development. 2001;128(21):4241–50. pmid:11684660
  6. 6. Perriton CL, Powles N, Chiang C, Maconochie MK, Cohn MJ. Sonic hedgehog signaling from the urethral epithelium controls external genital development. Dev Biol. 2002;247(1):26–46. pmid:12074550
  7. 7. Clark AM, Garland KK, Russell LD. Desert hedgehog (Dhh) gene is required in the mouse testis for formation of adult-type Leydig cells and normal development of peritubular cells and seminiferous tubules. Biol Reprod. 2000;63(6):1825–38. pmid:11090455
  8. 8. Yao HH, Whoriskey W, Capel B. Desert Hedgehog/Patched 1 signaling specifies fetal Leydig cell fate in testis organogenesis. Genes Dev. 2002;16(11):1433–40. pmid:12050120
  9. 9. Haraguchi R, Motoyama J, Sasaki H, Satoh Y, Miyagawa S, Nakagata N, et al. Molecular analysis of coordinated bladder and urogenital organ formation by Hedgehog signaling. Development. 2007;134(3):525–33. pmid:17202190
  10. 10. Miyagawa S, Matsumaru D, Murashima A, Omori A, Satoh Y, Haraguchi R, et al. The role of sonic hedgehog-Gli2 pathway in the masculinization of external genitalia. Endocrinology. 2011;152(7):2894–903. pmid:21586556
  11. 11. He F, Akbari P, Mo R, Zhang JJ, Hui CC, Kim PC, et al. Adult Gli2+/-;Gli3Delta699/+ Male and Female Mice Display a Spectrum of Genital Malformation. PLoS One. 2016;11(11):e0165958. pmid:27814383
  12. 12. Barsoum I, Yao HH. Redundant and Differential Roles of Transcription Factors Gli1 and Gli2 in the Development of Mouse Fetal Leydig Cells1. Biol Reprod. 2011;84(5):894–9. pmid:21209421
  13. 13. Narumi Y, Kosho T, Tsuruta G, Shiohara M, Shimazaki E, Mori T, et al. Genital abnormalities in Pallister-Hall syndrome: Report of two patients and review of the literature. Am J Med Genet A. 2010;152a(12):3143–7. pmid:21108399
  14. 14. Ito S, Kitazawa R, Haraguchi R, Kondo T, Ouchi A, Ueda Y, et al. Novel GLI3 variant causing overlapped Greig cephalopolysyndactyly syndrome (GCPS) and Pallister-Hall syndrome (PHS) phenotype with agenesis of gallbladder and pancreas. Diagn Pathol. 2018;13(1):1. pmid:29368652
  15. 15. Hui CC, Joyner AL. A mouse model of greig cephalopolysyndactyly syndrome: the extra-toesJ mutation contains an intragenic deletion of the Gli3 gene. Nat Genet. 1993;3(3):241–6. pmid:8387379
  16. 16. Zheng Z, Cohn MJ. Developmental basis of sexually dimorphic digit ratios. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011;108(39):16289–94. pmid:21896736
  17. 17. Bushman W. Hedgehog Signaling in Prostate Development, Regeneration and Cancer. J Dev Biol. 2016;4(4). pmid:29615593
  18. 18. Sadeghian H, Anand-Ivell R, Balvers M, Relan V, Ivell R. Constitutive regulation of the Insl3 gene in rat Leydig cells. Mol Cell Endocrinol. 2005;241(1–2):10–20. pmid:16006031
  19. 19. Suzuki H, Suzuki K, Yamada G. Systematic analyses of murine masculinization processes based on genital sex differentiation parameters. Dev Growth Differ. 2015;57(9):639–47. pmid:26660623
  20. 20. Haraguchi R, Suzuki K, Murakami R, Sakai M, Kamikawa M, Kengaku M, et al. Molecular analysis of external genitalia formation: the role of fibroblast growth factor (Fgf) genes during genital tubercle formation. Development. 2000;127(11):2471–9. pmid:10804187
  21. 21. Zheng Z, Armfield BA, Cohn MJ. Timing of androgen receptor disruption and estrogen exposure underlies a spectrum of congenital penile anomalies. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2015;112(52):E7194–203. pmid:26598695
  22. 22. Hutson JM, Hasthorpe S, Heyns CF. Anatomical and functional aspects of testicular descent and cryptorchidism. Endocr Rev. 1997;18(2):259–80. pmid:9101140
  23. 23. Emmen JM, McLuskey A, Grootegoed JA, Brinkmann AO. Androgen action during male sex differentiation includes suppression of cranial suspensory ligament development. Hum Reprod. 1998;13(5):1272–80. pmid:9647559
  24. 24. Hughes IA, Acerini CL. Factors controlling testis descent. Eur J Endocrinol. 2008;159 Suppl 1:S75–82.
  25. 25. Franco HL, Yao HH. Sex and hedgehog: roles of genes in the hedgehog signaling pathway in mammalian sexual differentiation. Chromosome Res. 2012;20(1):247–58. pmid:22105695
  26. 26. Adham IM, Emmen JM, Engel W. The role of the testicular factor INSL3 in establishing the gonadal position. Mol Cell Endocrinol. 2000;160(1–2):11–6. pmid:10715534
  27. 27. Emmen JM, McLuskey A, Adham IM, Engel W, Grootegoed JA, Brinkmann AO. Hormonal control of gubernaculum development during testis descent: gubernaculum outgrowth in vitro requires both insulin-like factor and androgen. Endocrinology. 2000;141(12):4720–7. pmid:11108287
  28. 28. Bogatcheva NV, Truong A, Feng S, Engel W, Adham IM, Agoulnik AI. GREAT/LGR8 is the only receptor for insulin-like 3 peptide. Mol Endocrinol. 2003;17(12):2639–46. pmid:12933905
  29. 29. van der Schoot P, Emmen JM. Development, structure and function of the cranial suspensory ligaments of the mammalian gonads in a cross-species perspective; their possible role in effecting disturbed testicular descent. Hum Reprod Update. 1996;2(5):399–418. pmid:15717439
  30. 30. Wegner KA, Keikhosravi A, Eliceiri KW, Vezina CM. Fluorescence of Picrosirius Red Multiplexed With Immunohistochemistry for the Quantitative Assessment of Collagen in Tissue Sections. J Histochem Cytochem. 2017;65(8):479–90. pmid:28692327
  31. 31. Bredfeldt JS, Liu Y, Pehlke CA, Conklin MW, Szulczewski JM, Inman DR, et al. Computational segmentation of collagen fibers from second-harmonic generation images of breast cancer. J Biomed Opt. 2014;19(1):16007. pmid:24407500
  32. 32. Lejeune H, Habert R, Saez JM. Origin, proliferation and differentiation of Leydig cells. J Mol Endocrinol. 1998;20(1):1–25. pmid:9513078
  33. 33. Kaftanovskaya EM, Lopez C, Ferguson L, Myhr C, Agoulnik AI. Genetic ablation of androgen receptor signaling in fetal Leydig cell lineage affects Leydig cell functions in adult testis. Faseb j. 2015;29(6):2327–37. pmid:25713029
  34. 34. Wen Q, Zheng QS, Li XX, Hu ZY, Gao F, Cheng CY, et al. Wt1 dictates the fate of fetal and adult Leydig cells during development in the mouse testis. Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab. 2014;307(12):E1131–43. pmid:25336526
  35. 35. Chen M, Zhang L, Cui X, Lin X, Li Y, Wang Y, et al. Wt1 directs the lineage specification of sertoli and granulosa cells by repressing Sf1 expression. Development. 2017;144(1):44–53. pmid:27888191
  36. 36. Qin J, Tsai MJ, Tsai SY. Essential roles of COUP-TFII in Leydig cell differentiation and male fertility. PLoS One. 2008;3(9):e3285. pmid:18818749
  37. 37. Tang H, Brennan J, Karl J, Hamada Y, Raetzman L, Capel B. Notch signaling maintains Leydig progenitor cells in the mouse testis. Development. 2008;135(22):3745–53. pmid:18927153
  38. 38. Brennan J, Tilmann C, Capel B. Pdgfr-alpha mediates testis cord organization and fetal Leydig cell development in the XY gonad. Genes Dev. 2003;17(6):800–10. pmid:12651897
  39. 39. Gerhardt C, Wiegering A, Leu T, Ruther U. Control of Hedgehog Signalling by the Cilia-Regulated Proteasome. J Dev Biol. 2016;4(3).
  40. 40. Choksi SP, Lauter G, Swoboda P, Roy S. Switching on cilia: transcriptional networks regulating ciliogenesis. Development. 2014;141(7):1427–41. pmid:24644260
  41. 41. Park SY, Tong M, Jameson JL. Distinct roles for steroidogenic factor 1 and desert hedgehog pathways in fetal and adult Leydig cell development. Endocrinology. 2007;148(8):3704–10. pmid:17495005
  42. 42. Baba T, Otake H, Inoue M, Sato T, Ishihara Y, Moon JY, et al. Ad4BP/SF-1 regulates cholesterol synthesis to boost the production of steroids. Commun Biol. 2018;1:18. pmid:30271905
  43. 43. Morohashi KI, Omura T. Ad4BP/SF-1, a transcription factor essential for the transcription of steroidogenic cytochrome P450 genes and for the establishment of the reproductive function. Faseb j. 1996;10(14):1569–77. pmid:9002548
  44. 44. Tang C, Pan Y, Luo H, Xiong W, Zhu H, Ruan H, et al. Hedgehog signaling stimulates the conversion of cholesterol to steroids. Cell Signal. 2015;27(3):487–97. pmid:25582983
  45. 45. Gao L, Kim Y, Kim B, Lofgren SM, Schultz-Norton JR, Nardulli AM, et al. Two regions within the proximal steroidogenic factor 1 promoter drive somatic cell-specific activity in developing gonads of the female mouse. Biol Reprod. 2011;84(3):422–34. pmid:20962249
  46. 46. Shin SH, Kogerman P, Lindstrom E, Toftgard R, Biesecker LG. GLI3 mutations in human disorders mimic Drosophila cubitus interruptus protein functions and localization. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1999;96(6):2880–4. pmid:10077605
  47. 47. Skakkebaek NE, Rajpert-De Meyts E, Main KM. Testicular dysgenesis syndrome: an increasingly common developmental disorder with environmental aspects. Hum Reprod. 2001;16(5):972–8. pmid:11331648
  48. 48. Chen Y, Yu H, Pask AJ, Fujiyama A, Suzuki Y, Sugano S, et al. Hormone-responsive genes in the SHH and WNT/beta-catenin signaling pathways influence urethral closure and phallus growth. Biol Reprod. 2018;99(4):806–16. pmid:29767687
  49. 49. Miyagawa S, Satoh Y, Haraguchi R, Suzuki K, Iguchi T, Taketo MM, et al. Genetic interactions of the androgen and Wnt/beta-catenin pathways for the masculinization of external genitalia. Mol Endocrinol. 2009;23(6):871–80. pmid:19282366
  50. 50. Murashima A, Kishigami S, Thomson A, Yamada G. Androgens and mammalian male reproductive tract development. Biochim Biophys Acta. 2015;1849(2):163–70. pmid:24875095
  51. 51. Lin C, Yin Y, Veith GM, Fisher AV, Long F, Ma L. Temporal and spatial dissection of Shh signaling in genital tubercle development. Development. 2009;136(23):3959–67. pmid:19906863
  52. 52. Seifert AW, Bouldin CM, Choi KS, Harfe BD, Cohn MJ. Multiphasic and tissue-specific roles of sonic hedgehog in cloacal septation and external genitalia development. Development. 2009;136(23):3949–57. pmid:19906862
  53. 53. Cunha GR, Baskin L. Development of human male and female urogenital tracts. Differentiation. 2018;103:1–4. pmid:30262219
  54. 54. Doles J, Cook C, Shi X, Valosky J, Lipinski R, Bushman W. Functional compensation in Hedgehog signaling during mouse prostate development. Dev Biol. 2006;295(1):13–25. pmid:16707121
  55. 55. Toivanen R, Shen MM. Prostate organogenesis: tissue induction, hormonal regulation and cell type specification. Development. 2017;144(8):1382–98. pmid:28400434
  56. 56. Allgeier SH, Lin TM, Moore RW, Vezina CM, Abler LL, Peterson RE. Androgenic regulation of ventral epithelial bud number and pattern in mouse urogenital sinus. Dev Dyn. 2010;239(2):373–85. pmid:19941349
  57. 57. Tremblay JJ. What signals testis descent? Biol Reprod. 2010;83(5):687–9. pmid:20668256
  58. 58. van der Schoot P, Elger W. Androgen-induced prevention of the outgrowth of cranial gonadal suspensory ligaments in fetal rats. J Androl. 1992;13(6):534–42. pmid:1293133
  59. 59. Kassim NM, Russell DA, Payne AP. Does the cranial suspensory ligament have a role in cryptorchidism? Cells Tissues Organs. 2010;191(4):307–15. pmid:19940435
  60. 60. Hammes A, Andreassen TK, Spoelgen R, Raila J, Hubner N, Schulz H, et al. Role of endocytosis in cellular uptake of sex steroids. Cell. 2005;122(5):751–62. pmid:16143106
  61. 61. Yao HH, Capel B. Disruption of testis cords by cyclopamine or forskolin reveals independent cellular pathways in testis organogenesis. Dev Biol. 2002;246(2):356–65. pmid:12051821
  62. 62. Shima Y, Miyabayashi K, Baba T, Otake H, Katsura Y, Oka S, et al. Identification of an enhancer in the Ad4BP/SF-1 gene specific for fetal Leydig cells. Endocrinology. 2012;153(1):417–25. pmid:22128023
  63. 63. Buscher D, Grotewold L, Ruther U. The XtJ allele generates a Gli3 fusion transcript. Mamm Genome. 1998;9(8):676–8. pmid:9680393
  64. 64. Keil KP, Mehta V, Abler LL, Joshi PS, Schmitz CT, Vezina CM. Visualization and quantification of mouse prostate development by in situ hybridization. Differentiation. 2012;84(3):232–9. pmid:22898663
  65. 65. Rasmussen FE, Wiltbank MC, Christensen JO, Grummer RR. Effects of fenprostalene and estradiol-17 beta benzoate on parturition and retained placenta in dairy cows and heifers. J Dairy Sci. 1996;79(2):227–34. pmid:8708084
  66. 66. Lee J, Foong YH, Musaitif I, Tong T, Jefcoate C. Analysis of specific RNA in cultured cells through quantitative integration of q-PCR and N-SIM single cell FISH images: Application to hormonal stimulation of StAR transcription. Mol Cell Endocrinol. 2016;429:93–105. pmid:27091298