An Adaptive Allelic Series Featuring Complex Gene Rearrangements

An intriguing observation from somestudies of adaptive change is allelicseries, where adaptive alleles successive-ly replace each other at a single locus.For instance, at the Cyp6g1 locus ofDrosophila melanogaster, transposable ele-ment insertions and a gene duplicationevent have combined to create at leasttwo adaptive alleles in which the morederived the allele, the greater theinsecticide resistance of its bearer [1].Similarly, insecticide-resistant alleles inCulex mosquitoes have been observedreplacing each other within the periodof a decade [2].Another case of an allelic series ispresented in the paper by Magwire et al.[3], which identifies a new locus affect-ing sigma virus resistance inD. melano-gaster. Multiple alleles exist at this locusand they differ in their extent of genecopy number polymorphism and featurea transposable element thought to gen-erate novel transcripts. Thus, this studycontributes to an emerging picture thatthe mutations associated with recentadaptive events may not involve regula-tory SNPs or coding SNPs, but complexgene rearrangements [1,4,5]. Further-more, the nested nature of these rear-rangements means that the order inwhich they arose can be deduced.The genes featured in the particularrearrangement described by Magwireetal. [3] were originally identified via anovel genome-wide screen to identifytransposable element insertions at highfrequencies in natural populations [6].Unlike the situation in humans andmany other vertebrates, particular trans-posable element insertions are rarely athigh frequencies in Drosophila popula-tions. A survey of insertion site occu-pancy led Aminetzach and colleagues[6] to a gene, which they dubbedCHKov1,thathasaDOC transposableelement inserted into the coding region.This gene is one of a large cluster of 27paralogs that encode proteins withdistant similarity to choline kinases.The pattern of polymorphism aroundthe DOC insertion suggests it was at thecenter of a very recent and strongselective sweep dating to between 25and 240 years ago. What selective agentcould result in such strong selection onan insect species, so recently? The link to‘‘choline’’ motivated Aminetzach et al.[6] to test whether a commonly usedclass of insecticides, the organophos-phates (OPs), which target the insectnervous system by inhibiting the enzymeacetylcholine esterase, could be theselective agent driving this selectivesweep at a locus implied in cholinemetabolism. They found that a linebearing the DOC allele had greaterresistance to an OP than a control linewith a similar genetic background.The new study of Magwire et al. [3]links another adaptive phenotype, viralresistance, to the CHKov genes. Thesigma virus has been found to infect upto 20% of D. melanogaster flies in fieldpopulations. At least six separate genesthat reduce infection rates have beenmapped in D. melanogaster [7]. Sigma-resistant alleles of theref(2)P locus of D.melanogaster have previously been char-acterized and display patterns of poly-morphism consistent with a selectivesweep[8].Magwireetal.[3]usedapositional cloning approach involvingsome of the genetic tools available forD. melanogaster to molecularly character-izethesecondofthesixgenes,ref(3)D.The resistant mutation involves a com-plex rearrangement of the CHKov1 andCHKov2 genes, with gene duplicationsderived from the allele originally char-acterized by Aminetzach et al. [6]. Thusthe naturally occurring allelic seriesinvolves three alleles: the ancestral allelethat is purportedly susceptible to an OPinsecticide and the sigma virus, theDOCinsertion allele characterized as resistantto an OP and moderately resistant tosigma viruses, and a derived, highlyvirus-resistant allele (alleles A, B, andC, respectively, in Figure 1).As in the case of Cyp6g1, it appearsthat the next step in an allelic series hasarisen before the previous step has sweptto fixation. What is the significance ofthis? We might expect that in a specieswith high population substructure, inde-pendent alleles may arise and competeagainst each other depending on thedegree of gene flow. However, D.melanogaster populations are not thoughtof as highly structured and the fact thealleles in an allelic series are notindependent, but are nested, indicatesthat D. melanogaster populations are largeenough to increase the probability ofsubsequent mutation, even while theprevious allele is at a low to moderatefrequency.On the other hand, these results suggestmutation may still be limiting. The mostadaptive allele at a gene may be two,three, or more mutational steps away.This may be because the initial adaptiveallele is negatively correlated with otherimportant traits, while the subsequentalleles ameliorate these trade offs or costs.Alternatively, the allelic series may reflecta ‘‘Red Queen’’ phenomenon, where amolecular arms race between host andpathogen means that new alleles mustarise in the host species, to counter thenew alleles in the pathogen species. In

An intriguing observation from some studies of adaptive change is allelic series, where adaptive alleles successively replace each other at a single locus. For instance, at the Cyp6g1 locus of Drosophila melanogaster, transposable element insertions and a gene duplication event have combined to create at least two adaptive alleles in which the more derived the allele, the greater the insecticide resistance of its bearer [1]. Similarly, insecticide-resistant alleles in Culex mosquitoes have been observed replacing each other within the period of a decade [2].
Another case of an allelic series is presented in the paper by Magwire et al. [3], which identifies a new locus affecting sigma virus resistance in D. melanogaster. Multiple alleles exist at this locus and they differ in their extent of gene copy number polymorphism and feature a transposable element thought to generate novel transcripts. Thus, this study contributes to an emerging picture that the mutations associated with recent adaptive events may not involve regulatory SNPs or coding SNPs, but complex gene rearrangements [1,4,5]. Furthermore, the nested nature of these rearrangements means that the order in which they arose can be deduced.
The genes featured in the particular rearrangement described by Magwire etal. [3] were originally identified via a novel genome-wide screen to identify transposable element insertions at high frequencies in natural populations [6]. Unlike the situation in humans and many other vertebrates, particular transposable element insertions are rarely at high frequencies in Drosophila populations. A survey of insertion site occupancy led Aminetzach and colleagues [6] to a gene, which they dubbed CHKov1, that has a DOC transposable element inserted into the coding region. This gene is one of a large cluster of 27 paralogs that encode proteins with distant similarity to choline kinases. The pattern of polymorphism around the DOC insertion suggests it was at the center of a very recent and strong selective sweep dating to between 25 and 240 years ago. What selective agent could result in such strong selection on an insect species, so recently? The link to ''choline'' motivated Aminetzach et al. [6] to test whether a commonly used class of insecticides, the organophosphates (OPs), which target the insect nervous system by inhibiting the enzyme acetylcholine esterase, could be the selective agent driving this selective sweep at a locus implied in choline metabolism. They found that a line bearing the DOC allele had greater resistance to an OP than a control line with a similar genetic background.
The new study of Magwire et al. [3] links another adaptive phenotype, viral resistance, to the CHKov genes. The sigma virus has been found to infect up to 20% of D. melanogaster flies in field populations. At least six separate genes that reduce infection rates have been mapped in D. melanogaster [7]. Sigmaresistant alleles of the ref(2)P locus of D. melanogaster have previously been characterized and display patterns of polymorphism consistent with a selective sweep [8]. Magwire et al. [3] used a positional cloning approach involving some of the genetic tools available for D. melanogaster to molecularly characterize the second of the six genes, ref(3)D.
The resistant mutation involves a complex rearrangement of the CHKov1 and CHKov2 genes, with gene duplications derived from the allele originally characterized by Aminetzach et al. [6]. Thus the naturally occurring allelic series involves three alleles: the ancestral allele that is purportedly susceptible to an OP insecticide and the sigma virus, the DOC insertion allele characterized as resistant to an OP and moderately resistant to sigma viruses, and a derived, highly virus-resistant allele (alleles A, B, and C, respectively, in Figure 1).
As in the case of Cyp6g1, it appears that the next step in an allelic series has arisen before the previous step has swept to fixation. What is the significance of this? We might expect that in a species with high population substructure, independent alleles may arise and compete against each other depending on the degree of gene flow. However, D. melanogaster populations are not thought of as highly structured and the fact the alleles in an allelic series are not independent, but are nested, indicates that D. melanogaster populations are large enough to increase the probability of subsequent mutation, even while the previous allele is at a low to moderate frequency.
On the other hand, these results suggest mutation may still be limiting. The most adaptive allele at a gene may be two, three, or more mutational steps away. This may be because the initial adaptive allele is negatively correlated with other important traits, while the subsequent alleles ameliorate these trade offs or costs. Alternatively, the allelic series may reflect a ''Red Queen'' phenomenon, where a molecular arms race between host and pathogen means that new alleles must arise in the host species, to counter the new alleles in the pathogen species. In that case, it is not that the organism starts multiple steps away from the ''adaptive peak'', but that after each step, the ''adaptive landscape'' changes.
Magwire et al. [3] suggest that the adaptive response to the sigma virus has pre-adapted D. melanogaster to OP insecticides. However, it is now unclear how important OPs have been to selection at this locus. One of the mysteries about the DOC element insertion into the CHKov1 gene is that the age of the allele (estimated to be ,90,000 years), as determined by its divergence from the ancestral allele, is much older than the use of insecticides and the age of the selective sweep, which was determined from the patterns in nearby polymorphisms. The presence/ absence of the DOC insertion is also correlated with the presence/absence of seven amino acid changes affecting a predicted protein that is substantially shortened and altered relative to that encoded by the ancestral allele. Now we know of another selective agent, namely the sigma virus, that is thought to have been infecting D. melanogaster for at least 200 years, but probably longer [9]. A highly virulent variant of the sigma virus is thought to have spread through European Drosophila populations in the 1980s, and that is possibly responsible for the recent sweep [10].
Magwire et al.'s [3] findings should motivate molecular and biochemical investigations of the various alleles of CHKov1 and 2, and of the somewhat mysterious group of paralogous proteins currently dubbed ''choline kinase-like''. Finally, such examples of allelic series not only tell us about population size and structure, but also provide important empirical examples of how fast adaptive evolution at a single locus can be, and should motivate the search for other ''adaptive allelic series'' that will help us understand the limits and dynamics of adaptation.