The cardiac muscarinic receptor (M2R) regulates heart rate, in part, by modulating the acetylcholine (ACh) activated K+ current IK,ACh through dissociation of G-proteins, that in turn activate KACh channels. Recently, M2Rs were noted to exhibit intrinsic voltage sensitivity, i.e. their affinity for ligands varies in a voltage dependent manner. The voltage sensitivity of M2R implies that the affinity for ACh (and thus the ACh effect) varies throughout the time course of a cardiac electrical cycle. The aim of this study was to investigate the contribution of M2R voltage sensitivity to the rate and shape of the human sinus node action potentials in physiological and pathophysiological conditions. We developed a Markovian model of the IK,ACh modulation by voltage and integrated it into a computational model of human sinus node. We performed simulations with the integrated model varying ACh concentration and voltage sensitivity. Low ACh exerted a larger effect on IK,ACh at hyperpolarized versus depolarized membrane voltages. This led to a slowing of the pacemaker rate due to an attenuated slope of phase 4 depolarization with only marginal effect on action potential duration and amplitude. We also simulated the theoretical effects of genetic variants that alter the voltage sensitivity of M2R. Modest negative shifts in voltage sensitivity, predicted to increase the affinity of the receptor for ACh, slowed the rate of phase 4 depolarization and slowed heart rate, while modest positive shifts increased heart rate. These simulations support our hypothesis that altered M2R voltage sensitivity contributes to disease and provide a novel mechanistic foundation to study clinical disorders such as atrial fibrillation and inappropriate sinus tachycardia.
Heart rate regulation is dependent upon a delicate interplay between parasympathetic and sympathetic nerve activity at the level of the sinus node. Acetylcholine slows the heart rate by activating the M2 muscarinic receptor (M2R) that, in turn, opens the acetylcholine-activated potassium channel (IK,ACh) to slow the firing of the sinus node. Surprisingly, the M2R is sensitive to membrane potential and undergoes conformational changes throughout the cardiac action potential that alter the affinity for acetylcholine, with secondary consequences for IK,ACh activity. Here, we investigated the contribution of M2R voltage sensitivity to the rate and shape of the human sinus node action potential in physiological and pathophysiological conditions, using a Markovian model of the IK,ACh channel integrated into a computational model of human sinus node. The computational model allowed us to assess the effects of potential genetic variants that alter specific properties of voltage sensitivity. Our results indicate that alterations in the M2R voltage sensitivity play a significant role in the physiology and pathophysiology of the human sinus node and atria. Our computational model is relevant for future studies aimed at the design and development of anti-arrhythmic agents that specifically target the unique voltage-sensitive properties of M2R.
Citation: Moss R, Sachse FB, Moreno-Galindo EG, Navarro-Polanco RA, Tristani-Firouzi M, Seemann G (2018) Modeling effects of voltage dependent properties of the cardiac muscarinic receptor on human sinus node function. PLoS Comput Biol 14(10): e1006438. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1006438
Editor: Alison L. Marsden, Stanford University, UNITED STATES
Received: November 14, 2017; Accepted: August 15, 2018; Published: October 10, 2018
Copyright: © 2018 Moss et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: FBS and MT-F are supported by the Nora Eccles Treadwell Foundation. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. EGM-G and RAN-P are supported by the Caonsejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnologia - SEP-CONACYT (CB-2011-01-167109 to EGM-G and CB-2013-01-220742 to RAN-P). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The cardiac muscarinic receptor (M2R) plays a crucial role in regulating heart rate variability and vulnerability to atrial arrhythmia by modulating the acetylcholine (ACh) activated K+ current IK,ACh. Cardiac KACh channels are heteromultimers composed of two G-protein-coupled inward rectifier K+ channel subunits, Kir 3.1 and Kir 3.4 . ACh activation of M2R triggers dissociation of the G beta-gamma subunits (Gβɣ) that in turn directly activate Kir 3.x subunits to conduct IK,ACh. Unexpectedly, M2Rs were discovered to possess an intrinsic ability to sense transmembrane voltage  and the affinity of the receptor for ligands was noted to vary in response to changes in membrane voltage . In particular, the affinity of the receptor for ACh is increased at hyperpolarized membrane potentials and decreased at depolarized potentials. The changes in affinity exert a downstream effect on the KACh channel such that the channel is more active (more current) at hyperpolarized potentials and less active (less current) at depolarized potentials. The observation that M2Rs are intrinsically voltage sensitive has profound implications for cellular signaling in excitable tissues, such as heart. For example, voltage sensitive behavior provides a mechanistic explanation for a decades-old enigmatic process called IK,ACh “relaxation” gating. Relaxation gating refers to a time-dependent change in current magnitude following a depolarizing or hyperpolarizing voltage step  and has important consequences for shaping the cardiac action potentials (AP), especially in the sinus node. We recently proposed that relaxation gating represents a voltage dependent change in ACh affinity induced by voltage dependent conformational changes within M2R . Our experimental data provide a mechanistic basis to explain the participation of IK,ACh in the modest chronotropic effects induced by resting vagal tone. As a result of conformational changes in the M2R, the affinity for ACh varies throughout the cardiac electrical cycle such that low (subsaturating) ACh concentrations preferentially activate IK,ACh during diastolic membrane voltages thereby slowing the spontaneous firing rate without appreciably altering AP duration (APD).
Alterations in the voltage sensitivity of M2R could theoretically contribute to cardiovascular diseases that clinically present with apparent changes in vagal tone. For example, genetic variants in M2R that shift the receptor occupancy into the hyperpolarized state would be expected to increase the affinity of the receptor for ACh and thus activate more KACh channels at a given ACh concentration (or degree of vagal tone). Accordingly, genetic variants in M2R that shift the receptor occupancy into the hyperpolarized state might explain the clinical phenotype of vagally-mediated atrial fibrillation (AF), patients who present with bradycardia in the setting of physiological (basal) ACh concentrations. Alternatively, genetic variants in M2R that shift the receptor occupancy into the depolarized state would be expected to decrease the affinity of the receptor for ACh and thus fewer KACh channels activate at a given ACh concentration (or given degree of vagal tone). This would decrease the effects of vagal modulation of heart rate, thereby increasing basal heart rate, as observed in the syndrome of inappropriate sinus tachycardia (IST).
To provide insights into the contribution of M2R voltage sensitivity to cardiac electrophysiology in physiological and pathophysiological conditions, we extended our previous Markovian model of M2R  to incorporate Gβɣ-mediated activation of the KACh channel and integrated the revised Markovian model into a human model of the sinus node (SN) cell model . Based on experimental data from isolated human SN cells [7, 8], Fabbri and colleagues recently published a comprehensive model of the human SN pacemaker cell that faithfully recapitulated the effects of autonomic modulation as well as mutations associated with SN dysfunction . In the Fabbri model and its parent model , IK,ACh is described by a voltage- and [ACh]-dependent gate, but the intrinsic voltage sensitivity of M2R is not incorporated. Here, we introduce a model reproducing the effects of M2R voltage sensitivity on human SN cell function under physiological and pathophysiological conditions. These simulations support our hypothesis that altered M2R voltage sensitivity contributes to disease and provide a novel mechanistic foundation to study clinical disorders such as AF and IST.
Effects of low concentrations of ACh on sinus node action potentials
For decades, the contribution of IK,ACh to the modest chronotropic effects of ‘physiological’ or low-dose ACh has been debated [10–12]. Based on the M2R voltage-dependent properties, we predict that subsaturating ACh concentrations exert a larger effect during diastolic (hyperpolarized) membrane voltages, compared to the voltages during the cardiac AP (depolarized) [3, 5]; thus preferentially slowing the pacemaker rate with minimal effect on APD. To test this hypothesis, we simulated the effects of varying low, sub-saturating concentrations (e.g., 20–100 nM) of ACh on sinus node AP properties (Fig 1). The most striking effect of increasing ACh concentration was reduced slope of phase 4 depolarization and the corresponding increase in basic cycle length (Fig 1A, Table 1, Vshift = 0), with minimal shortening of APD90 (Table 2, Vshift = 0). Thus, the basic cycle length (BCL) increased from 827 ms in the absence of ACh, to 1585 ms in the presence of 0.1 μM ACh. The AP amplitude decreased steadily by up to 4.7 mV at the highest tested concentration of 0.1 μM ACh (inset of Fig 1A). Simulated open probability O and IK,ACh for different ACh concentrations are shown in Fig 1B and 1C. Taken together, these simulations indicate that subsaturating concentrations of ACh slow spontaneous excitation of the SN cell by inhibiting the rise of phase 4 depolarization, without appreciably shortening APD90 or reducing the amplitude of the AP.
(A) Resulting transmembrane voltage (Vm) showing the increase in BCL from 827 ms to 1585 ms with a reduction of APD90 by roughly 10%. (B) Open probability O of the channel and (C) the corresponding activated IK,ACh.
Modeling perturbations in M2R voltage sensitivity
In our previous experimental studies using isolated feline left atrial myocytes, the voltage dependence of M2R was explored by measuring the ACh concentration-IK,ACh response relationship at hyperpolarized (-100 mV) and depolarized membrane voltages (+50 mV) [3, 5]. These experiments indicated that the affinity of the receptor for ACh was greater at hyperpolarized membrane voltages, compared to depolarized voltages. We reasoned that, similar to voltage-gated ion channels, putative disease-associated mutations in M2R might alter the voltage sensitivity of the M2R, with unique consequences for sinus node AP properties and heart rate responses. We modified rate parameters (Eqs 5 and 6) to shift the receptor occupancy towards a hyperpolarized state (higher affinity) or a depolarized state (lower affinity) (S1A Fig). Thus, we simulated the effects of shifting the M2R voltage sensitivity (Fig 2, S3C Fig). S1B Fig highlights the effects of voltage shifts on the state O. Negative shifts (e.g., Vshift of -30 mV and -150 mV), which caused a more hyperpolarized state of the receptor, increased the occupancy of the U1 and B1 states, as well as the state O. Negative voltage shifts resulted in a slight leftward shift in the concentration-response curve when the cell was held at +50 mV (Fig 3E). Likewise, positive shifts in M2R voltage sensitive parameters caused a slight rightward shift in the concentration-response curve for a holding potential of Vh = -100 mV (Fig 3A). To avoid local minima during the parameter fitting, the model was forced to favor the open state (state O equal to 1), at the maximum concentration of 10 μM ACh and to favor the closed state (O equal to 0), with no ACh present. Further, U1 was forced to be as high as possible at a holding potential of -100mV and U2 at +50 mV, in the absence of ACh. Thus, negative and positive voltage shifts did not move the steady-state concentration-response relationships outside of these ranges. Notwithstanding, the voltages experienced by the single cell model vary between -60 and +30 mV (Fig 1A), within the minimum and maximum ranges defined by the parameter fitting.
The left sub-model describes the M2R, with states U1 and B1 for high ACh affinity and hyperpolarized voltages, and states U2 and B2 for low ACh affinity and depolarized voltages. The right sub-model represents the KACh channel with the open state O and the closed state C. For further details, see the method section.
Concentration-response curves at a holding potential of (A) -100 mV and (E) +50 mV. Relaxation gating features derived from the mono-exponential fitting of activation and deactivation traces (B,C,F,G). The associated relaxation kinetic time constants are shown in (D,H). Measured data is represented as mean ± std. Respectively the squared fit error for each feature is; Con: 0.06, Coff: 0.025, Aon: 0.11, Aoff: 0.014, τon: 0.04, τoff: 0.18, IKACh,norm,-100mV: 0.003, IKACh,norm,50mV: 0.03. The total error of the features is equal to the square root of the sum of the respective squared fit errors (Eq 11 and Methods).
We previously described the kinetics of “relaxation” gating of IK,ACh in terms of activation and deactivation of KACh channels in the setting of subsaturating ACh concentrations . Activation kinetics were measured by first stepping to a depolarized voltage (+60 mV) to close a large portion of KACh channels at a physiological voltage, followed by stepping through a range of voltages to measure activation of IK,ACh. Deactivation kinetics were assessed by a pre-pulse to a hyperpolarized voltage (-100 mV) to open channels, followed by variable test voltage steps to measure the rate of KACh channel closure. Accordingly, simulated IK,ACh evoked by 0.1 μM ACh using the activation and deactivation voltage protocols are presented in S1 Fig and the kinetic parameters are described in Table 3. The simulations recapitulate the experimental features of IK,ACh relaxation gating , as shown in S1 Fig. The effects of voltage shifts in M2R voltage sensitive parameters on IK,ACh relaxation gating parameters are shown in Fig 3.
Next, we simulated the effects of negative and positive voltage shifts in M2R voltage-sensitive parameters on sinus node APs, together with the corresponding effects on state O and IK,ACh (Fig 4). Negative shifts (e.g., Vshift of -10 mV and -30 mV), which would be predicted to increase ACh affinity, reduced the slope of phase 4 depolarization in a concentration-dependent manner, with minimal effects on AP amplitude or APD90 (Fig 4A versus 4D, Tables 1 and 2). The reduction in the slope of phase 4 depolarization induced by a negative Vshift was due to an increase in the open probability of KACh channels relative to the control condition, thereby increasing the magnitude of IK,ACh. These results indicate that shifts in the M2R voltage sensitivity impact the rate of spontaneous depolarization of sinus node APs.
In the presence of (A,B,C) 0.05 μM ACh and (D,E,F) 0.1 μM ACh. (A,D) present the resulting sinus node APs, (B,E) the open probability O of the KACh channel and (C,F) the resulting IK,ACh.
To further characterize the physiological consequences of positive and negative voltage shifts, we studied the effects of variable M2R voltage sensitivity on the ACh concentration-heart rate response relationship (Fig 5A). Our model recapitulates experimental data  indicating that ACh concentrations ranging from 0.01 to 0.1 μM induce slowing of the spontaneous activity by 10% and 45%, respectively. Hyperpolarizing shifts in the M2R voltage dependent parameters shifted the relationship toward progressive spontaneous activity slowing. By contrast, depolarizing shifts in these parameters antagonized the spontaneous activity slowing induced by ACh. Taken together, these results suggest that shifts in M2R voltage sensitive parameters exert significant physiological effects on SN firing rate and AP parameters.
(A) Concentration-heart rate response to the effect of variable M2R voltage sensitivity. Negative voltage shifts accentuate the response of ACh, while positive shifts blunt the heart rate slowing induced by ACh. (B), The individual contributions of ACh-sensitive currents to the measured concentration-heart rate response. Our current model that incorporates the voltage-sensitivity of the M2R into IK,ACh (new), together with formulations for the ACh-sensitive currents ICa,L and If from Fabbri et al  provides the best fit to the measured data. IK,ACh contributes to about 50% of the heart rate response at 0.03 μM ACh and contributes a greater proportion to heart rate slowing at higher ACh concentrations.
Next, we quantified the effects of the individual ACh-influenced cardiac currents on heart rate slowing. Fig 5B illustrates the relative contributions of ACh-sensitive currents, including our new model of IK,ACh, together with formulations of the L-type Ca2+ current (ICa,L) and the hyperpolarized-activated ‘funny current’ (If) from Fabbri et al. . Inspection of the individual contributions of the ACh-sensitive currents reveals that our model of IK,ACh (incorporating the voltage-sensitivity of M2R) accounts for roughly 50% of the slowing at ~30nM and more for higher concentrations. These results highlight the important contribution of M2R voltage sensitivity to heart rate slowing induced by ACh.
The observation that M2Rs are intrinsically voltage sensitive has profound implications for cellular signaling in excitable tissues, such as heart. This could have important consequences for cardiovascular drug development in that the affinity for ligands may vary in a voltage- and ligand-specific manner. The properties of M2R voltage dependence provide a novel molecular basis to explain the previously perplexing “relaxation” gating of IK,ACh, originally described in the 1970s . Precisely how the receptor’s voltage dependent properties influence the firing rate and shape of sinus node APs under physiological conditions, or in the presence of a M2R genetic defect, remains unknown. In order to address this question, we enhanced our previous Markovian model of M2R  by a 2-state Markovian model to incorporate G-protein activation of the KACh channel. The parameters of this revised model were adapted to experimental data from isolated feline left atrial myocytes, see Methods. We integrated the revised model into a human SN single cell model and used computational simulations to gain insights into effects of voltage sensitivity of M2Rs.
While there is no controversy as to the cardiac effects of strong vagal stimulation, the participation of IK,ACh in mediating the purely chronotropic effects of low (or “physiologic”) ACh concentrations has been debated over the past thirty years. Low concentrations of ACh (e.g., below 100 nM) and weak vagal stimulation reduce spontaneous pacemaker rate without altering APD or increasing the maximal diastolic potential . DiFrancesco et al. proposed that weak vagal stimulation primarily inhibited If with little to no contribution from IK,ACh. Indeed, the EC50 for ACh modulation of If is an order of magnitude lower than that required for IK,ACh activation . However, subsequent studies have corroborated an important role for IK,ACh in mediating the chronotropic effects of weak vagal stimulation and externally applied low ACh concentrations . Perhaps the strongest evidence for IK,ACh contribution to basal chronotropy comes from the Kir3.4 knock-out mouse which displays a specific deficit in heart rate variability at rest [13, 14]. These studies confirm that low ACh concentrations (basal vagal tone) activate IK,ACh to slow heart rate. Our experimental and simulated data provide a mechanistic basis to explain the participation of IK,ACh in the modest chronotropic effects induced by resting vagal tone. Our experimental data predict that the affinity of M2R for ACh varies throughout the AP. The simulations performed here corroborate that subsaturating ACh concentrations preferentially open the KACh channel during diastolic membrane voltages and thereby slow the spontaneous firing rate. As seen in Fig 5B, IK,ACh accounts for roughly half of the heart rate slowing at concentrations around 30 nM, and more for higher concentrations.
In silico modeling is valuable for understanding fundamental features of physiology and pathophysiology [15–17]. This is especially relevant for modeling of IK,ACh in disease states. For example, numerous disease-causing mutations in ion channel genes alter the voltage sensitivity of the channel [18, 19]. In light of these observations, we simulated effects of hypothetical mutation-induced positive and negative shifts in M2R voltage sensitivity to ACh on sinus node AP properties and spontaneous firing. Modest voltage shifts (Vshift of ±10 mV) exerted significant effects on the slope of phase 4 depolarization and thus on spontaneous activity responses to subsaturating ACh concentrations, such as those elicited by vagal resting tone. Moderate voltage shifts (Vshift of ± 30 mV) caused more profound changes in spontaneous activity. These simulations provide a proof-of-principle for a theoretical contribution of altered M2R voltage sensitivity to cardiovascular disease states associated with changes in vagal tone. For example, parasympathetic induction and maintenance of atrial arrhythmias is a well-described phenomenon, first reported in 1930 . Moreover, increased parasympathetic tone is an initiating factor in a subset of AF patients . Our simulations suggest that genetic variants in M2R that shift the receptor occupancy towards hyperpolarized states (U1/B1) associated with increased ACh affinity of the receptor increase IKACh at a given ACh concentration (or degree of vagal tone). These genetic variants might explain, in part, the clinical phenotype of vagally-mediated AF patients who present with bradycardia in the setting of physiological (basal) ACh concentrations. Also, our simulations suggest that genetic variants in M2R that shift receptor occupancy towards depolarized states (U2/B2) associated with decreased ACh affinity of the receptor reduce IKACh at a given ACh concentration (or degree of vagal tone). Thus, positive shifts in M2R voltage sensitivity would decrease the effects of vagal modulation of heart rate, thereby increasing basal heart rate, as observed in the syndrome of IST. Indeed, a recent study confirmed decreased parasympathetic tone in IST patients . While speculative, the hypothesis that altered M2R voltage sensitivity is relevant for cardiac diseases provides a novel mechanistic foundation to study disorders such as AF and IST.
Limitations of the model
There are several limitations inherent in the application of the model to describe the kinetics and behavior of IK,ACh. First, the receptor-channel model was fit and optimized to recreate the kinetics of IK,ACh occurring at a concentration of 0.1 μM ACh. While this is within the range of measured concentrations of ACh, measurements at lower concentrations could enable a more accurate reconstruction of the behavior of IK,ACh and a direct comparison to the effect of If at such concentrations. Furthermore, we acknowledge that the description of the process of dissociation of Gβɣ from the M2R to the activation of the KACh channel is highly simplified. We used a simple channel opening description with a 2-state Markovian model neglecting different binding properties of different Kir subunits or cooperativity mechanisms in binding of Gβɣ. This simplification was necessary as parameters for more complex models are not identifiable with the existent experimental data. Also, the model is not able to reproduce the distinct characteristics of the deactivation protocol time constants. The experimental data indicate that the deactivation time constant is nearly voltage-independent (Fig 3H), the model predicts an increase with membrane depolarization. Nonetheless, because the other simulated features have a very high similarity to the measured values (Fig 3B, 3C, 3F and 3G) and the time constants are in the range of less than half the length of an action potential, we believe that any error introduced does not significantly influence our findings. Additionally, dissociation or binding of Gβɣ in our model does not account for changes in the process due to other influences or any binding to sites other than the KACh channel.
The SN cell model recapitulates the experimental findings that ACh inhibits If and ICa,L, which also contribute to slowing of spontaneous pacing rate . We argue that unlike IK,ACh, the M2R voltage dependent effects do not influence If and ICa,L on the time scale of the AP. If and ICa,L inhibition are mediated by inhibition of the cAMP-dependent protein kinase A cascade that functions on a much slower time scale than the APD. By contrast, our simulations demonstrate that voltage dependent conformational changes in M2R influence IK,ACh throughout the cardiac AP, modulating both firing rate and APD. Finally, because our model does not fully integrate all the components of the autonomic nervous system, it is possible that the effects of the putative genetic mutations might be mitigated by compensatory changes in the autonomous nervous system’s response to changes in heart rate.
The recent observation that M2Rs are intrinsically voltage sensitive has important implications for understanding the physiology and pathophysiology of parasympathetic regulation of heart rate and APD. By optimizing and integrating a new Markovian model into a human SN model, we show that low ACh concentrations preferentially slow beating rate, without shortening APD, and thereby provide additional support that IK,ACh participates in the purely chronotropic effects of basal vagal tone. Moreover, we explore the effects of altered M2R voltage sensitivity and provide a proof-of-principle foundation that altered sensitivity could result in clinical manifestations of disease states such as vagally-mediated atrial fibrillation and syndrome of inappropriate sinus tachycardia. Given the importance of parasympathetic regulation of atrial vulnerability, M2Rs represent an important therapeutic target to control or prevent atrial arrhythmias.
Model of M2R and KACh channels
We developed a Markovian model to reconstruct the behavior of KACh channels at different ACh concentrations and varying transmembrane voltages (Fig 2). The model comprises 3 sub-models: (1) A Markovian model describing the kinetics of the M2R depending on different concentrations of ACh at different voltages (M2R model), (2) a Markovian model describing the activation of the KACh channel based on dispersion of Gβɣ protein from the receptor to the channel (KACh channel model), and (3) a model of potassium current through KACh channels.
Markovian model of M2R.
This sub-model describes biophysical properties of the M2R and comprises 4 distinct states, U1, B1, U2 and B2, whose interaction describes the affinity of M2R to changes in ACh concentration [L] and transmembrane voltage Vm (Fig 2, left side). The sub-model was published previously  and is a simplification of a more complex model of receptor systems . Time-dependent changes of states were defined as: (1) (2) (3) (4) with the transition rate coefficients α(Vm), β(Vm), and γ0[L], and the constant parameters δ0 and K. Each of the 4 distinct states represents the M2R under specific conditions. The state U1 represents the M2R at hyperpolarized Vm without bound ACh, U2 the M2R at a depolarized Vm without bound ACh, B1 the M2R at a hyperpolarized Vm with bound ACh, and B2 the M2R at depolarized Vm with bound ACh.
The transition rate coefficients between these states are dependent on Vm or [L]. The transition rate coefficients α and β between U1 and U2 are dependent on Vm: (5) (6) with the rates α0 and β0, the charges zα and zβ, the Faraday constant F, gas constant R and temperature T, see S3B and S3C Fig for the respective traces. Additionally to the original formulation, we introduced a voltage shift Vshift to describe effects of mutations on voltage sensitivity of the receptor. The shift solely affects the voltage dependent transition rate coefficients of the M2R and thus indirectly influences the states of the KACh channel model and the resulting IK,ACh. We defined negative Vshift as hyperpolarizing shifts. Negative Vshift lead to an increased occupancy of the states U1 and B1, i.e. to a more hyperpolarized state of the receptor model. Likewise, positive Vshift were defined as depolarizing shifts as they lead to increased occupancy of the states U2 and B2, i.e. to a more depolarized state of the receptor model.
A total removal of voltage sensitivity was achieved for large shifts locking the M2R in its hyperpolarized state (Vshift ≦ -150 mV) and its depolarized state (Vshift ≧ +150 mV) (S3A Fig).
A change in voltage affinity due to the presence of ACh was represented as a change in the transition rate. The transition rate coefficient α was multiplied with the constant K in the voltage dependent transition between B1 and B2. Similarly, the ACh affinity of the M2R was represented by the transition rate coefficients δ0 and γ0.
Markovian model of KACh channels.
Simulating physiological mechanisms, the KACh channel model was coupled to the M2R model via a description of Gβɣ protein. The normalized concentration of Gβɣ was represented as the sum of the states B1 and B2 of the M2R model. The KACh channel model comprised an open (O) and closed (C) state (Fig 2, right side). The model described the channel kinetics based on the dispersion of Gβɣ causing opening of the KACh channel: (7) with forward rate f and the backward rate b.
Modeling of IK,ACh.
A previously developed description for IK,ACh was used to calculate this current . The description of IK,ACh includes its dependency on extracellular K+ concentration [K+]o and rectification: (8) with the Nernst potential EK. We calculated the conductance of KACh channels as the maximum conductance gK,ACh,max multiplied with the open probability O from the KACh channel sub-model: (9)
Measured data and model parameterization
The parameters of the model were determined by iterative stochastic optimization as previously described . Model parameterization was implemented in Matlab R2017a (The Mathworks Inc., Natick, MA) and the Matlab Parallel Computing Toolbox. An error function based on the root mean squared differences of the measured versus simulated features of the activation protocol, deactivation protocol, and concentration response curve from  was minimized.
Measured features were based on whole-cell voltage-clamp experiments . IK,ACh for the activation and deactivation clamp protocols was recorded in the presence of 0.1 μM ACh. The 3 best measured currents, see S1 Fig, from  of each protocol were then fitted to a mono-exponential equation, averaged and then normalized to Coff at -10 mV: (10) with the constants A and C, and the time-constant τ of activation (on) and deactivation (off). We choose this strategy, as extracting mono-exponential features and then averaging them introduces less error in the overall reconstructed behavior than averaging the signals themselves. The same fitting approach was used during the model parameterization.
Concentration response curves were measured as the resulting IK,ACh at either a holding potential of -100 mV or +50 mV at different ACh concentrations (Fig 5A and 5E). The currents were then normalized to the current measured at maximal ACh concentration for each holding potential.
A total of 8 simulated features fs,i, consisting of six features for the voltage clamp protocols (i.e. Con, Coff, Aon, Aoff, τon, and τoff) and two for the concentration response curves (i.e. IKACh,norm,50mV and IKACh,norm,-100mV), were compared to their corresponding measured features fm,i (Fig 5B–5D and 5F–5H): (11)
Other components of the cost function were used to constrain the behavior of the model at specific ACh concentration and Vm, and to ensure high open probability of the channel. Without bound ACh and Vm of +50 mV, the state U2 was forced to be maximal. Respectively, U1 was forced to be maximal without bound ACh and a transmembrane voltage of -100 mV. Equivalently, with bound ACh, state B2 and B1 were forced to be maximal at -100 mV and 50 mV, respectively. Further, the sum of B1 and B2 was forced to be maximal with bound ACh.
Single cell simulations
For simulations of single cell electrophysiology, the new receptor-channel model was integrated in the publically available model of human SN cells . The formulations for the effect of ACh on ICaL and If were left unaltered throughout the experiments. The model was first exported to Matlab using OpenCOR (www.opencor.ws) and then modified accordingly. Numerical integration was performed by using the integrated ode15s formulation provided by Matlab. We measured BCL to characterize the rate of spontaneous activation of the simulated SN cell at varying concentration of ACh and Vshift. The maximum conductivity gK,ACh,max was set 0.0022 μS to reproduce previously published heart rate slowing in the presence of 0−0.1 μM ACh . Furthermore, we measured the APD at 90% repolarization (APD90) to characterize the cardiac AP.
The stochastic parameterization yielded the model parameters (Table 3). In comparison to the parameterization of our previous model , the fit error of the features from the activation and deactivation protocols was reduced from 1.5 to 0.68 despite the additional error terms. Respectively the squared fit error for each feature is; Con: 0.06, Coff: 0.025, Aon: 0.11, Aoff: 0.014, ton: 0.04, toff: 0.18, IKACh,norm,50mV: 0.03, IKACh,norm,-100mV: 0.003. The total error of the features is equal to the square root of the sum of the respective squared fit errors. The corresponding modeled and measured current traces of the voltage protocols are shown in S2 Fig.
S1 Fig. Simulated concentration response at different holding potentials and effects of voltage shifts on the open state of the model.
(A) Simulated ACh concentration-IKACh response curves for voltages at indicated holding potentials. The concentration-response curves are voltage-dependent, whereby negative holding potentials are associated with greater ACh binding affinity, while depolarized holding potentials decrease binding affinity. Thus, hyperpolarizing voltage shifts in the concentration-response curve increase ACh affinity of the M2R, while depolarizing shifts decrease affinity. (B) The effects of voltage shifts (Vshift) on the steady state of the open state of the KACh channel at 0.1μM ACh. A -30mV shift increases the O state at all voltages as a consequence of increased receptor affinity, while a +30 mV shift decreases the O state as a consequence of decreased affinity.
S2 Fig. IK,ACh current evoked by 0.1 μM ACh.
Normalized simulated (A,E) and measured (B-D,F-H)  currents, using the activation and deactivation voltage protocols from . Artifacts in the measured traces, which were cropped for the monoexponential fitting, are shown in grey.
S3 Fig. Effect of Vshift on the open-state occupancy at a concentration of 0.08 μM ACh as well as on α and β.
(A) Impact of different Vshift on the open-state occupancy, with the model being shifted in its complete depolarized/hyperpolarized state for large shifts. (B) Corresponding traces of the seperate model states over the time course of one AP. (C) Transition rates between U1 and U2 for different voltages.
We thank Prof. Olaf Dössel as the initial part of his work was done at the Institute of Biomedical Engineering, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology.
- 1. Krapivinsky G, Gordon EA, Wickman K, Velimirovic B, Krapivinsky L, Clapham DE. The G-protein-gated atrial K+ channel IKACh is a heteromultimer of two inwardly rectifying K+-channel proteins. Nature. 1995;374:135–41. pmid:7877685
- 2. Ben-Chaim Y, Chanda B, Dascal N, Bezanilla F, Parnas I, Parnas H. Movement of 'gating charge' is coupled to ligand binding in a G-protein-coupled receptor. Nature. 2006;444(7115):106–9. pmid:17065983.
- 3. Navarro-Polanco RA, Moreno Galindo EG, Ferrer-Villada T, Arias M, Rigby JR, Sanchez-Chapula JA, et al. Conformational changes in the M2 muscarinic receptor induced by membrane voltage and agonist binding. J Physiol. 2011;589(Pt 7):1741–53. pmid:21282291.
- 4. Noma A, Trautwein W. Relaxation of the ACh-induced potassium current in the rabbit sinoatrial node cell. Pflugers Arch. 1978;377(3):193–200. pmid:569814.
- 5. Moreno-Galindo EG, Sanchez-Chapula JA, Sachse FB, Rodriguez-Paredes JA, Tristani-Firouzi M, Navarro-Polanco RA. Relaxation gating of the acetylcholine-activated inward rectifier K+ current is mediated by intrinsic voltage sensitivity of the muscarinic receptor. J Physiol. 2011;589(Pt 7):1755–67. pmid:21282289.
- 6. Fabbri A, Fantini M, Wilders R, Severi S. Computational analysis of the human sinus node action potential: model development and effects of mutations. J Physiol. 2017;595(7):2365–96. pmid:28185290.
- 7. Verkerk AO, van Borren MM, Wilders R. Calcium transient and sodium-calcium exchange current in human versus rabbit sinoatrial node pacemaker cells. ScientificWorldJournal. 2013;2013:507872. Epub 2013/02/24. pmid:23606816.
- 8. Verkerk AO, Wilders R, van Borren MM, Peters RJ, Broekhuis E, Lam K, et al. Pacemaker current (I(f)) in the human sinoatrial node. Eur Heart J. 2007;28(20):2472–8. Epub 2007/09/06. pmid:17823213.
- 9. Severi S, Fantini M, Charawi LA, DiFrancesco D. An updated computational model of rabbit sinoatrial action potential to investigate the mechanisms of heart rate modulation. J Physiol. 2012;590(Pt 18):4483–99. pmid:22711956.
- 10. Shibata EF, Giles W, Pollack GH. Threshold effects of acetylcholine on primary pacemaker cells of the rabbit sino-atrial node. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B, Containing papers of a Biological character. 1985;223(1232):355–78. pmid:2858102.
- 11. DiFrancesco D, Ducouret P, Robinson RB. Muscarinic modulation of cardiac rate at low acetylcholine concentrations. Science. 1989;243(4891):669–71. pmid:2916119.
- 12. Boyett MR, Kodama I, Honjo H, Arai A, Suzuki R, Toyama J. Ionic basis of the chronotropic effect of acetylcholine on the rabbit sinoatrial node. Cardiovasc Res. 1995;29(6):867–78. pmid:7656291.
- 13. Mesirca P, Marger L, Toyoda F, Rizzetto R, Audoubert M, Dubel S, et al. The G-protein-gated K+ channel, IKACh, is required for regulation of pacemaker activity and recovery of resting heart rate after sympathetic stimulation. J Gen Physiol. 2013;142(2):113–26. Epub 2013/07/15. pmid:23858001.
- 14. Wickman K, Nemec J, Gendler SJ, Clapham DE. Abnormal heart rate regulation in GIRK4 knockout mice. Neuron. 1998;20(1):103–14. pmid:9459446.
- 15. Sachse FB. Computational Cardiology: Modeling Of Anatomy, Electrophysiology, And Mechanics. Heidelberg: Springer; 2004. 322 p.
- 16. Fink M, Niederer SA, Cherry EM, Fenton FH, Koivumaki JT, Seemann G, et al. Cardiac cell modelling: observations from the heart of the cardiac physiome project. Progress in Biophysics and Molecular Biology. 2011;104(1–3):2–21. Epub 2010/03/23. pmid:20303361.
- 17. Clayton RH, Bernus O, Cherry EM, Dierckx H, Fenton FH, Mirabella L, et al. Models of cardiac tissue electrophysiology: progress, challenges and open questions. Progress in Biophysics and Molecular Biology. 2011;104(1–3):22–48. Epub 2010/06/18. pmid:20553746.
- 18. Franqueza L, Lin M, Splawski I, Keating MT, Sanguinetti MC. Long QT syndrome-associated mutations in the S4-S5 linker of KvLQT1 potassium channels modify gating and interaction with minK subunits. J Biol Chem. 1999;274(30):21063–70. pmid:10409658
- 19. Splawski I, Tristani-Firouzi M, Lehmann MH, Sanguinetti MC, Keating MT. Mutations in the hminK gene cause long QT syndrome and suppress IKs function. Nature Genetics. 1997;17:338–40. pmid:9354802
- 20. Andrus EC, Carter EP. The refractory period of the normally-beating dog's auricle; with a note on the occurrence of auricular fibrillation following a single stimulus. J Exp Med. 1930;51:357–67. pmid:19869696
- 21. Coumel P. Autonomic influences in atrial tachyarrhythmias. J Cardiovasc Electrophysiol. 1996;7(10):999–1007. pmid:8894942.
- 22. Nwazue VC, Paranjape SY, Black BK, Biaggioni I, Diedrich A, Dupont WD, et al. Postural tachycardia syndrome and inappropriate sinus tachycardia: role of autonomic modulation and sinus node automaticity. Journal of the American Heart Association. 2014;3(2):e000700. pmid:24721800.
- 23. Zhang H, Holden AV, Noble D, Boyett MR. Analysis of the chronotropic effect of acetylcholine on sinoatrial node cells. J Cardiovasc Electrophysiol. 2002;13(5):465–74. pmid:12030529.
- 24. Weiss JM, Morgan PH, Lutz MW, Kenakin TP. The cubic ternary complex receptor-occupancy model. III. resurrecting efficacy. Journal of theoretical biology. 1996;181(4):381–97. pmid:8949584.