• Loading metrics

Biophysical attributes that affect CaMKII activation deduced with a novel spatial stochastic simulation approach

Biophysical attributes that affect CaMKII activation deduced with a novel spatial stochastic simulation approach

  • Ximing Li, 
  • William R. Holmes


Calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII) holoenzymes play a critical role in decoding Ca2+ signals in neurons. Understanding how this occurs has been the focus of numerous studies including many that use models. However, CaMKII is notoriously difficult to simulate in detail because of its multi-subunit nature, which causes a combinatorial explosion in the number of species that must be modeled. To study the Ca2+-calmodulin-CaMKII reaction network with detailed kinetics while including the effect of diffusion, we have customized an existing stochastic particle-based simulator, Smoldyn, to manage the problem of combinatorial explosion. With this new method, spatial and temporal aspects of the signaling network can be studied without compromising biochemical details. We used this new method to examine how calmodulin molecules, both partially loaded and fully loaded with Ca2+, choose pathways to interact with and activate CaMKII under various Ca2+ input conditions. We found that the dependence of CaMKII phosphorylation on Ca2+ signal frequency is intrinsic to the network kinetics and the activation pattern can be modulated by the relative amount of Ca2+ to calmodulin and by the rate of Ca2+ diffusion. Depending on whether Ca2+ influx is saturating or not, calmodulin molecules could choose different routes within the network to activate CaMKII subunits, resulting in different frequency dependence patterns. In addition, the size of the holoenzyme produces a subtle effect on CaMKII activation. The more extended the subunits are organized, the easier for calmodulin molecules to access and activate the subunits. The findings suggest that particular intracellular environmental factors such as crowding and calmodulin availability can play an important role in decoding Ca2+ signals and can give rise to distinct CaMKII activation patterns in dendritic spines, Ca2+ channel nanodomains and cytoplasm.

Author summary

Ca2+ signals are commonly used by cells for various types of activities. In neurons, Ca2+ can regulate gene expression and dendritic spine enlargement, strengthen synaptic connectivity, and promote neural growth or even death. One important Ca2+ binding protein is calmodulin, which has a wide range of downstream effectors that relay and interpret Ca2+ signals. These downstream proteins have different calmodulin binding kinetics and can interact with calmodulin differently depending on Ca2+ signaling patterns and in particular, on signaling frequencies. In this study, we focus on one particular pathway that is thought to be important for learning and memory and involves calmodulin and the effector protein, Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII). We have developed a novel computational method that avoids the problem of combinatorial explosion inherent with modeling this pathway, and the method allows us to study the pathway in more detail than conventional methods. Experiments have shown that CaMKII activity is sensitive to Ca2+ signal frequency and our models demonstrate how this frequency dependence relies on the amount of Ca2+ input, calmodulin availability and the Ca2+ diffusion rate.


Calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII) is an important enzyme widely distributed in the central nervous system and other tissues including cardiac muscle [13]. In intracellular Ca2+ signaling, the Ca2+ sensor protein calmodulin (CaM) binds to and activates CaMKII [46]. Importantly CaM binding to CaMKII produces an allosteric change in CaM that increases its binding affinities for Ca2+ [7] (Fig 1). In neurons, CaMKII molecules play an essential role in long-term potentiation (LTP), our best model for the molecular basis of learning and memory [8]. In spines, activated CaMKII molecules interact with postsynaptic density proteins, facilitating actins to reorganize, leading to spine enlargement and upregulation of α-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionic acid (AMPA) receptor numbers [4]. CaMKII molecules can also phosphorylate AMPA receptors to regulate channel conductance [4, 6] or form complexes with NMDA receptors [5]. In addition to synaptic functions, recent studies suggest that CaMKII in the soma can act as carriers to shuttle Ca2+-CaM into the nucleus [9, 10]. Ca2+-CaM molecules are then unloaded in the nucleus, and participate in the calcium/calmodulin dependent protein kinase IV (CaMKIV) cascade to activate nuclear transcription factors. Therefore, CaMKII molecules play a key role in excitation-transcription coupling.

Fig 1. Types of Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII interactions modeled.

(A) Ca2+ binds to a CaM molecule that already has 3 Ca2+ bound, making the CaM fully loaded. Each CaM has two lobes, an N lobe and a C lobe. Each lobe has 2 Ca2+ binding sites. (B) A CaM molecule binds to a CaMKII subunit, activating the subunit. Each subunit of the CaMKII holoenzyme can interact with CaM independently. (C) CaMKII autophosphorylation is neighbor sensitive and follows one direction (arbitrarily chosen as left to right here). When both a subunit and its neighbor to the left are activated, the subunit can be phosphorylated. (D) CaM bound to a CaMKII subunit interacts with Ca2+ at an increased affinity. (E) CaM bound to a phosphorylated CaMKII subunit also interacts with Ca2+ at a further increased affinity. Notation: K represents an unphosphorylated CaMKII subunit; Kp is a phosphorylated subunit; NiCj is CaM with i Ca2+ ions bound at the N lobe and j Ca2+ ions bound at the C lobe.

The CaMKII molecule is a holoenzyme that consists of 12 subunits grouped in 2 rings [2, 5, 6, 11]. Each subunit contains an association domain allowing the formation of multimers, a regulatory domain with a CaM binding site and phosphorylation sites, and a catalytic domain to act as a kinase [2, 5, 6, 11]. Activities such as CaM binding and auto-phosphorylation result in various subunit states. For example, in the presence of Ca2+-CaM complexes, each subunit can bind a CaM molecule and expose its catalytic domain to phosphorylate the direct neighbor subunit at its Thr286 site (for αCaMKII) [12]. Once phosphorylated, the CaM unbinding rate decreases dramatically, leading to a prolonged activation of the subunit; we say, the CaM molecule is “trapped” by the CaMKII subunit [13]. Even when the CaM molecule unbinds, the CaMKII subunit stays activated, entering an autonomous state. Finally, Thr305/Thr306 can also be phosphorylated. There the threonine sites overlap with the CaM binding site and their phosphorylation blocks the binding of CaM molecules. In this case, the subunit becomes “capped”.

Researchers have long been interested in modeling and simulating CaMKII [1423]. However, the structural complexity and multi-state nature of CaMKII present a technical challenge. A major problem is combinatorial explosion [24]. One CaMKII subunit has only a moderate number of states to consider, but with 6 or 12 subunits on a holoenzyme, the number of combinations of states for a holoenzyme becomes extremely large. This is a common problem in systems biology since large proteins usually consist of multiple subunits. Software that adopts a rule-based approach such as BioNetGen [25] can be used to expand the network based on a set of given reaction rules. Nevertheless, for a CaMKII holoenzyme, using BioNetGen to generate the network is still computationally intensive. After expansion with BioNetGen, a 6-subunit holoenzyme with four states for each subunit has 700 unique species and 12,192 unique reactions (See S2 File for detailed calculations).

The size of the network and the problem of combinatorial explosion grow substantially when more detailed kinetics are considered. For example, each CaM has 2 lobes and in total 4 Ca2+-binding sites. This can introduce 5, 9, 16 or more binding states depending on assumptions made [7, 1921, 23, 26, 27]. Here we follow the experimental work of Linse et al. [28] and assume that each lobe binds Ca2+ independently and within each lobe, Ca2+ binding is cooperative. This gives rise to 9 distinct binding states. In addition, it is known that Ca2+ binding kinetics to CaM is different whether CaM is free, bound to CaMKII or bound to phosphorylated CaMKII [2932]. Therefore, we allow each CaM state to have distinct kinetics to interact with a CaMKII subunit. Also, each CaMKII subunit exhibits a distinct phosphorylation rate depending on the state of the bound CaM [21, 29]. Consequentially, each subunit would potentially have 20 states. For simplicity, consider a 6-subunit CaMKII holoenzyme. Then for the holoenzyme, the total number of unique species alone reaches 10,668,140 (computed with the necklace function [33] see S2 File). It would be extremely time-consuming and not practical for BioNetGen to generate this network. To overcome this problem, most previous modeling studies of CaMKII have simplified the Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII reaction network by either modeling CaMKII as monomers [18, 21] or allowing only CaM fully-loaded with Ca2+ to interact with CaMKII subunits [14, 16, 17, 22]. However, Pepke et al. [21] has shown that a reaction network without sufficient kinetic resolution has limited predictive power for intracellular signaling events.

The intracellular environment presents another complication. Conventionally, biochemical reactions are modeled in a deterministic manner using Ordinary Differential Equations (ODEs). The underlying assumptions are that reactions occur in a spatially homogenous environment, reactants are abundant and not subject to stochasticity, and molecules diffuse sufficiently fast. The majority of previous modeling studies belong to this category except for a few that are stochastic or hybrid models [15, 18, 20, 27]. However, intracellular space is highly heterogeneous and compartmentalized [34, 35]. Reactions are often restricted to a small space. Structures such as the cytoskeleton, scaffold proteins or endoplasmic reticulum often act as diffusion barriers to slow down molecules. In addition, most previous modeling studies focus on the dendritic spine, where NMDA receptor-channels are the main Ca2+ providers.

In the present work, we focus on the soma where voltage-dependent Ca2+ channels (CaV) provide the Ca2+ influx. Specifically, we examined Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII network activity near L-type Ca2+ channels, which constitute the major Ca2+ source in the soma. This is an area less studied in previous models, but plays a critical role in excitation-transcription coupling [10, 36]. To study this Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII signaling network and deal with the problem of combinatorial explosion, we modified the published and freely available simulator Smoldyn [37, 38]. Smoldyn is a particle-based stochastic simulator and has been used for simulating reaction and diffusion processes in cells. It works well for relatively simple reaction networks but not for holoenzymes such as CaMKII. We added new data structures to Smoldyn to describe the reaction network in a compact way. CaMKII holoenzymes are modeled as a collection of subunits. Each subunit has a set of binding sites. Subunits react independently and diffuse collectively. Reactions are defined between binding sites. The reaction network is stored in a hash table to allow for lookup during simulations when reactants collide. Therefore, expanding and loading a complete network is not required. We tested and verified these modifications and then created a detailed Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII network to examine factors that affect the frequency dependence of CaMKII activation. We found that the total Ca2+ influx amount, as well as Ca2+ diffusion rate and CaM availability, can change the dependence of CaMKII phosphorylation on Ca2+ input frequencies. Meanwhile, driven by Ca2+ input with a given frequency, CaM species travel through an altered pathway along with the change of CaMKII phosphorylation pattern.


Testing of the simulator modifications

We first tested the modifications to Smoldyn used in this paper (see Methods). The reaction and diffusion kinetics of Smoldyn have been thoroughly validated in the past [37], but we still needed to validate that our modifications for molecular complex management were working properly. Our first test used a Ca2+-CaM network (Fig 2) (Model 1). The 4 Ca2+ binding sites on CaM give rise to a total of 9 different binding states of a CaM molecule. For the reaction volume, we use a 500 nm × 500 nm × 500 nm cube with all sides being reflective. The size of this volume is what might be used to study a Ca2+ channel nanodomain (the region up to 100nm from the channel pore) or a small dendritic spine head. Initially, the cube contains 3000 Ca2+ ions and 700 apoCaM molecules, equivalent to 39.867 μm and 9.302 μm respectively. The concentrations are chosen to produce an observable amount of 4-Ca2+ bound CaM at the steady state. All molecules are initially uniformly distributed. We tested reactions using two different Ca2+ diffusion constants, 2.2 × 10−6 cm2 s−1 [39, 40] and half of this 1.1 × 10−6 cm2 s−1. A detailed description of the model and other testing models is in S1 File and S1 Table.

Fig 2. Ca2+-CaM interaction network.

(A) Ca2+ and CaM interactions can produce 9 different states of CaM. CaM has two lobes, an N lobe and a C lobe, each of which has 2 Ca2+ binding sites. Binding sites on the lobes are designated N1, N2, C1 and C2. The N lobe and C lobe bind Ca2+ independently of each other, but Ca2+ binding within a lobe is cooperative. Thus, site N2 cannot bind Ca2+ unless N1 has already bound Ca2+ and a similar rule applies to sites C2 and C1. In the figure N0C0 represents apoCaM (no Ca2+ bound), “N2” represents binding sites N1 and N2 both bound with Ca2+ and “C2” represents similarly that both C1 and C2 have Ca2+ bound, “N1” and “C1” represent only the “N1” site and only the “C1” site have Ca2+ bound. Edges are labeled to indicate bidirectional interactions, including both bindings and unbindings. For example, “N1∼ca” means interactions between a Ca2+ ion and a CaM at the N1 site. Likewise, “C1∼ca” means interactions between a Ca2+ ion and a CaM at the C1 site. (B) The same reactions between Ca2+ and CaM as shown in A are represented using the syntax of the modified simulator. The binding and unbinding rate constants are labeled on the left. “+” represents a binding reaction; “∼” represents molecules that are bound. “{}” on the left-hand side of the reaction specifies the states of the reactant binding sites or the conditions for a reaction to occur. On the right-hand side, binding sites involved in the reaction are assigned new values. Notice the “==” sign is used on the left-hand side, but the “=” sign is used on the right-hand side. The “==” represents True (==1) or False (==0), whereas the “=” denotes an assigning operation. (C) The time course of each CaM state simulated using the original Smoldyn (blue), modified Smoldyn at default Ca2+ diffusion (red), half Ca2+ diffusion (yellow line) and COPASI (black lines).

We first characterized the reactions in the network to see if results of our stochastic model could reasonably be compared to results with standard ODE methods. A second order chemical reaction in the solvent phase consists of two steps: molecules encountering each other by diffusion followed by the molecules reacting with each other. If the encountering step takes a much longer time to occur than the reacting step, the reaction is diffusion-limited; otherwise, the reaction is activation-limited. Conventionally, an experimentally measured binding kinetic rate, kon, can be decomposed into an encounter rate, kenc, and an intrinsic activation rate, ka, using the following equation [41], (1) For diffusion-limited reactions, kakenc and konkenc; for activation-limited reactions, konka as diffusion is sufficiently fast. Given the diffusion coefficients for Ca2+ and CaM and the parameter values for Ca2+ and CaM reaction kinetics in S1 Table, we calculated the ratios and concluded that the reactions in the network belong to the activation-limited regime. This was also true if diffusion constants were reduced by half. Thus, this simple model resembles a well-mixed system and an ODE model will provide a good test standard.

We coded a deterministic ODE system in COPASI [42] and compared results with our stochastic model using the same kinetics. We found that the stochastic model and the ODE COPASI model exhibited similar time courses for all CaM binding state species. Slowing down Ca2+ diffusion did not significantly alter the time courses for the parameter values used (Fig 2C).

As another verification, we tested the steady state fraction of phosphorylation of CaMKII holoenzymes when they are modeled as multi-subunit complexes (Model 2, in S1 File). Michalski and Loew [22] derived an expression for the steady state fraction of phosphorylated subunits as a function of the number of subunits in a holoenzyme. This expression assumes a closed system where CaMKII holoenzymes are exposed to a saturating amount of fully loaded CaM molecules and subunit phosphorylation is allowed from a neighbor that has CaM bound but not from one that is also phosphorylated. With these conditions, the steady state fraction of phosphorylated subunits is for holoenzymes as dimers, for trimers, and approaches 1−e−1 for large subunit numbers. We built a model using a closed system with 1 μm × 1 μm × 1 μm geometry. The model contained 6000 CaM bound CaMKII subunits. CaMKII holoenzymes all had either 2, 3, 6 or 12 subunits. Consistent with the Michalski and Loew formula assumptions, an already phosphorylated subunit could not act as a kinase to phosphorylate its neighbor. As expected, we obtained steady state phosphorylation levels that depended on the number of the subunits in a holoenzyme as per the Michalski and Loew formula (S2 Fig).

Finally, using the same closed system, we tested the complete network and compared results with those obtained from a simulation implemented with a spatial Gillespie algorithm [20] (Model 3, S1 File). The two methods showed comparable results (S3 Fig). The results of all these tests suggest that our modifications of Smoldyn are working properly.

Analysis of the Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII network with physiologically relevant Ca2+ influx

To investigate how various CaM species contribute to the activation of CaMKII holoenzymes, we set up a prototype Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII network model. We were particularly interested in studying how network transitions involving partially loaded CaM species contribute to CaMKII activations, as this is not clearly understood. The prototype model comprises Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII interactions as shown in Fig 3A. In this network diagram, molecule species are represented as vertices and reactions are represented as edges.

Fig 3. The complete Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII network.

(A) Species are represented by vertices. Green edges mark the preferred pathway. The back layer (Layer 1, blue) represents interactions between Ca2+ and CaM. The front layer (Layer 2, yellow) represents interactions between Ca2+ and CaM attached to a CaMKII subunit. Note these interactions are bidirectional. (B) Molecule numbers of various CaM states with 5 Hz Ca2+ influx. Plots of Layer 1 and Layer 2 are displayed to provide a view of the preferred path. The species marked with green triangles constitute part of the preferred pathway. Note that only panel N0C0 in Layer 1 is on a scale from 0 to 6000. All the other panels have a scale from 0 to 1500.

CaM molecules and CaMKII holoenzymes with 6-subunit rings were initially uniformly distributed in a 1 μm × 1 μm × 2 μm box. As an initial condition, the box contained 6020 CaM molecules (5 μm) and 12036 CaMKII subunits (10 μm), within which 195 CaM molecules are bound to CaMKII. The initial state is at an equilibrium, which we carefully computed by running 5 simulation trials starting with the same numbers of CaM and CaMKII molecules. For simplicity, we did not consider resting intracellular Ca2+ as part of the steady state initial condition, as calculations showed its effect to be minor. Ca2+ influx was modeled as an entry from a single source at the top center of the box. A previously generated input file having a total of 5 Ca2+ bursts delivered at 5 Hz was used to provide Ca2+ influx during the simulation (see Methods).

We ran the simulation up to 2.2s, recorded the molecule numbers at every 1 ms (Fig 3B) and logged all reaction events. Using the events log, we counted the accumulated occurrences of each reaction type at every 10 ms, starting from the initial state until the Ca2+ bursts were finished. For a particular reaction, the number of occurrences during a time span is considered to be the net number of molecule state changes along the corresponding edge, i.e., the number of unbinding events is subtracted from the number of binding events. A negative number means that unbinding occurs more often than binding within the given time span.

We analyzed the edges of the Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII network (Fig 3A). We decomposed the network to 2 layers. The back layer (Layer 1) describes interactions between Ca2+ and the 9 states of CaM (NxCy, x,y = 0,1,2). The front layer (Layer 2) is for reactions of Ca2+ with CaM attached to unphosphorylated CaMKII (KNxCy). Starting in Layer 1, there are up to 4 possible binding reactions for each CaM species to change state (Fig 4A): binding a Ca2+ at a C site (denoted as Cx∼ca), binding Ca2+ at an N site (denoted as Nx∼ca), binding to an unphosphorylated CaMKII subunit (denoted as K∼NxCy) or binding to a phosphorylated CaMKII subunit (denoted as Kp∼NxCy). Likewise, in Layer 2, there are up to 3 possible binding reactions for each CaMKII bound CaM species to change state (Fig 5A): binding a Ca2+ at a C site (denoted as KCx∼ca), binding a Ca2+ at an N site (denoted as KNx∼ca), and the CaMKII bound with the CaM becoming phosphorylated (denoted as KNxCy∼p).

Fig 4. Layer 1 reactions.

(A) Kinetic diagram illustrating possible reactions starting from Layer 1. For a CaM binding state, 4 types of bidirectional reactions are shown: interacting with a Ca2+ at an N site, with a Ca2+ at a C site, with an unphosphorylated CaMKII subunit and with a phosphorylated CaMKII subunit. Triangles indicate reactions involved in the preferred pathway starting from N0C0. (B) Accumulated reaction occurrences over time. Color code corresponds with the edge color in A. Colored triangles match plot lines with particular edges in A.

Fig 5. Layer 2 reactions.

(A) Kinetic diagram illustrating possible reactions starting from Layer 2. For a CaM binding state, 3 types of reactions are shown: interacting with a Ca2+ at an N site, with a Ca2+ at a C site, and the bound CaMKII subunit becoming phosphorylated. Triangles indicate reactions involved in the preferred pathway. (B) Accumulated reaction occurrences over time. Color code corresponds with the edge color in A. Colored triangles match lines with particular edges in A.

For each CaM state, we counted the accumulated occurrences of the possible reaction types. Results are shown in Fig 4B. The plot reveals a preferred pathway for CaM and CaMKII state transitions as labeled in Fig 3A. Starting as apoCaM, a CaM molecule tends to bind a Ca2+ ion on the C1 site and then on the C2 site, entering the N0C2 state. CaM in the N0C2 state has a strong preference to enter Layer 2 by binding to a CaMKII subunit (Fig 4B, the black line in panel N0C2), likely followed by the phosphorylation of the bound CaMKII subunit (Fig 5B, the black line in panel KN0C2). Once bound to a CaMKII subunit, additional Ca2+ ions bind to CaM more quickly. In this scenario, it is rare for CaM to become fully bound with Ca2+ ions before binding with a CaMKII subunit. Nevertheless, phosphorylation of CaMKII subunits occurs most often when subunits are bound with fully loaded CaM, but still often occurs with CaM having C sites loaded, KN0C2 and KN1C2, as shown in Fig 5B. We note that the way the preferred pathway is chosen at each vertex is a consequence of reaction affinities as given in S1 Table and these were chosen to be consistent with experimental studies and values in the previous modeling work [1921]. For example, even though N sites bind Ca2+ faster, the C sites have higher affinity making Ca2+ binding to C sites preferred.

To confirm the critical role of NxC2 (x = 0,1,2) CaM in activation and phosphorylation of CaMKII, we set up two modified reaction schemes (Fig 6A). In Scheme 1, only CaMKII subunits bound with NxC2 are allowed to become phosphorylated. In Scheme 2, phosphorylation is allowed only for subunits bound with N2Cx. Note that the phosphorylation rates in the two schemes are equivalent, i.e., kon of reaction KN2C0∼p is the same as that of KN0C2∼p, and the kon of KN2C1∼p equals that of KN1C2∼p. Not surprisingly, the two schemes give rise to different phosphorylation levels as shown in Fig 6B. Scheme 1 performs slightly worse than the whole network, whereas Scheme 2 produces a much lower phosphorylation level. Therefore, edges of the network are not equally involved in CaMKII phosphorylation.

Fig 6. Reaction scheme 1 and 2 adapted from the complete network.

(A) In reaction scheme 1, phosphorylation was allowed only from CaMKII bound with NxC2 (blue edges). In reaction scheme 2, phosphorylation was allowed only from CaMKII bound with N2Cx (green edges). (B) Comparison of phosphorylation levels in the complete network (10 individual trials), scheme 1 and scheme 2.

Changes in CaMKII activation frequency dependence and physiologically relevant factors

A classic experiment by DeKoninck and Schulman [43] showed that in vitro, CaMKII holoenzyme activation is sensitive to the frequency of Ca2+-CaM pulses. A recent study [44] also showed that in vivo glutamate uncaging frequency affects CaMKII activation in dendritic spines. Numerous modeling studies have also reported a dependence of CaMKII activation on the frequency of Ca2+ signals [16, 17, 21, 22]. To confirm this CaMKII activation pattern, we tested our 6-subunit CaMKII model using previously generated 10 Hz and 5 Hz Ca2+ influx files. The total number of Ca2+ ions entering was comparable in the two cases (40433 ions with 5 Hz vs. 40435 ions with 10 Hz).

We examined the reaction occurrences over time and noticed that, compared to 5 Hz input, the 10 Hz input results in more rapid and more overall bindings between N0C2 CaM and CaMKII (Fig 7A and 7B, also see S6 Fig), and consequently, more autophosphorylation. More bindings between N0C2 CaM and CaMKII is to be expected because higher frequency means more intensive Ca2+ input which drives CaM to travel through the preferred pathway (Fig 3A). This leads to more N0C2 available to bind to CaMKII. More autophosphorylation is primarily due to increasing occurrences of KN2C2∼p reactions (Fig 7C and 7D) because the additional KN0C2 binds Ca2+ at higher affinity leading to state KN2C2 that has the highest rate of autophosphorylation. Therefore, the frequency effect is inherent in the binding properties among Ca2+, CaM and CaMKII.

Fig 7. Effects of 10 Hz and 5 Hz Ca2+ input on reaction occurrences.

(A) Accumulated reaction occurrences generated from 6 trials for CaM CaMKII binding reactions in the presence of 5 Hz Ca2+ input. (B) The same as in A but for 10 Hz Ca2+ input. (C) Accumulated reaction occurrences for CaMKII phosphorylation reactions in the presence of 5 Hz Ca2+ input. Phosphorylation reactions other than KNxC2∼p are shown in grey and are not individually labeled. (D) The same as in C but for 10 Hz Ca2+ input. For a different view of these data, see S6 Fig.

Interestingly, the effect of frequency is not the same for all CaMKII CaM binding interactions. For example, the net bindings between N0C1 CaM and CaMKII increased with 10 Hz input while bindings between apoCaM and CaMKII decreased. To understand this note that with high frequency Ca2+ input, [Ca2+] is higher and more N0C1 forms. With more N0C1 available, there will be more binding of N0C1 with CaMKII. Hence the yellow line (K∼N0C1) is higher in Fig 7B (10Hz) than in Fig 7A (5Hz). In addition, there will be more Ca2+ binding to KN0C0, forming KN0C1, and this means that mass action kinetics will drive N0C0 to bind with CaMKII to replace the KN0C0 that transitioned to KN0C1. However, more N0C1 formed from N0C0 with high frequency input means that there is less N0C0 available to drive the K∼N0C0 reaction. As a result, the green line (K∼N0C0) is lower in Fig 7B (10Hz) than in Fig 7A (5 Hz).

However, the frequency effect can be reversed by providing a saturating amount of Ca2+. In Fig 8, we increased the Ca2+ channel number to allow more Ca2+ influx per action potential pulse. The total Ca2+ influx was again comparable for 5 Hz and 10 Hz input. As Ca2+ influx was increased, the network produced more phosphorylated CaMKII subunits for both input frequencies, but the difference in phosphorylation level between 5 Hz and 10 Hz input diminished. Eventually, the 10 Hz input became saturating and the network generated less phosphorylation with 10 Hz than with 5 Hz input (Fig 8F).

Fig 8. Effects of increased Ca2+ influx on frequency dependence.

(A-E) Accumulated reaction occurrences for phosphorylation of CaMKII subunits bound with N2C2 CaM (black lines) and all other NxCy CaM summed together (blue lines) are shown for 5 Hz (thin lines) and 10 Hz (thick lines) input with different levels of Ca2+ influx. (F) Summary of phosphorylation levels in the presence of increasing amounts of Ca2+ delivered at 5 Hz and 10 Hz. The advantage of 10 Hz input for phosphorylation is reversed as Ca2+ influx increases.

This reversal in frequency preference occurs at lower levels of Ca2+ input when available CaM is limited or Ca2+ diffusion is slowed (Fig 9). Notice that in the model Ca2+ can diffuse out of the reaction volume. As a result, a lower diffusion constant effectively means a higher level of Ca2+. To demonstrate, we first compared simulations where the amount of CaM in the system was reduced from the default concentration of 5 μm to 2.5 μm. Limiting CaM reduces phosphorylation for a given Ca2+ input at both frequencies (compare Fig 9A and 9B), but the difference in phosphorylation levels between the two frequency conditions is smaller. We see slightly more phosphorylation with 5 Hz input than 10 Hz input with the 3× Ca2+ input condition. With less CaM present, the Ca2+ influx has a better chance to saturate the available CaM allowing the frequency dependence to reverse at a lower influx level. We then compared simulations with default (2.2 × 10−6 cm2 s−1) and slowed (1.1 × 10−6 cm2 s−1) Ca2+ diffusion coefficients, noting that the slowed diffusion condition does not change the activation-limited regime of the network. Slowed diffusion results in a dramatic increase of CaMKII phosphorylation regardless of Ca2+ influx level and input frequency (compare Fig 9A and 9C). Here the frequency preference for 10 Hz input also reverses at the 3× Ca2+ input condition. This occurs because slow Ca2+ diffusion allows the input to become sufficiently saturating at a lower level of Ca2+ influx and this leads to the frequency preference change. Finally, frequency dependence reverses dramatically with merely twice the baseline amount of Ca2+ influx when slow diffusion and limited CaM are combined (Fig 9D–9F).

Fig 9. Effects of CaM availability and Ca2+ diffusion on frequency dependence.

(A) With 3× Ca2+ influx, phosphorylated CaMKII subunits in the presence of 5 Hz (blue) and 10 Hz (black) Ca2+ input. (B) The same as in A except that the total CaM available in the system is reduced from 5 μm to 2.5 μm. (C) The same as in A except that Ca2+ diffusion is slowed to 1.1 × 10−6 cm2 s−1. (D) The same as in A except that 2× Ca2+ influx is provided. (E) The same as in D except that the total CaM available in the system is reduced from 5 μm to 2.5 μm. (F) The same as in D except with both slowed Ca2+ diffusion and reduced the amount of CaM.

To understand why frequency dependence changes, we examined what was happening in the full Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII network starting with Ca2+ binding to apoCaM and apoCaM availability. It is important to note that simulations with 10 Hz input and 5 Hz input had virtually the same total Ca2+ entering the volume. With 3× Ca2+ influx, 10 Hz bursts deplete apoCaM, but 5 Hz bursts do not (Fig 10B). With 4× Ca2+ influx, it takes 4 bursts of influx to deplete apoCaM in the 5 Hz condition but only 3 with 10 Hz (Fig 10C). When apoCaM molecules are depleted, Ca2+ must bind elsewhere in the network and this causes deviations from the preferred path as described below. One consequence is that the number of KN0C2 molecules formed is higher with 5 Hz input (Fig 10E and 10F, red lines) than with 10 Hz input (Fig 10E and 10F, blue lines). This leads to more phosphorylation with 5 Hz than 10 Hz input for the 4× Ca2+ influx case because of the longer inter-burst interval, which allows more relief from apoCaM depletion. Thus Ca2+ can bind to apoCaM and subsequent reactions along the preferred path can occur. The frequency dependence reversal for reduced CaM availability and slowed Ca2+ diffusion can also be explained in terms of CaM saturation. For a given Ca2+ input apoCaM depletion will occur faster if there is less to begin with and also if Ca2+ diffusion is slowed, which will allow more chances for Ca2+ and CaM to interact before Ca2+ leaves the system.

Fig 10. ApoCaM depletion and KN0C2 number as Ca2+ influx increases.

(A) With 2× Ca2+ input, time courses of the amount of apoCaM (N0C0). Red lines are for 5 Hz input, and blue lines are for 10 Hz input. (B) The same as in A except that 3× Ca2+ influx is given. (C) The same as in A except that 4× Ca2+ influx is given. (D-F) The same as in A-C except that KN0C2 molecule numbers are plotted.

We found that there were deviations from the previously observed preferred pathway when saturating Ca2+ input is provided, particularly when CaM molecules are in the N0C2 state. In the presence of moderate Ca2+ influx (Fig 11A and 11B) CaM molecules follow the preferred pathway: the net bindings between N0C2 and CaMKII (K∼N0C2) occur more often than the bindings of Ca2+ ions to the N1 site of N0C2 molecules (N1∼ca). CaMKII binding with N0C2 dominates all types of CaMKII CaM interactions (Fig 11D, 11E and 11G). However, when Ca2+ influx becomes saturating, bindings of Ca2+ ions on the N1 site of N0C2 molecules start to dominate over the bindings between N0C2 and CaMKII (Fig 11C). CaM molecules tend to stay in Layer 1 until they get fully loaded with Ca2+. As a result, CaMKII binding with N2C2 increases and becomes dominant over all other CaMKII CaM interactions (Fig 11F, 11H and 11I). This gives rise to an altered preferred pathway (Fig 12 solid green triangles). It is worth noting that the net bindings between CaMKII and N1C2 and N2C1 also rise as Ca2+ input becomes saturating (Fig 11D–11I, blue lines and pink lines). Interestingly, when we examined the accumulated reaction occurrences with 5× Ca2+ influx at 10 Hz, we noticed that K∼N2C1 constitutes a second preferred pathway (Fig 12 yellow triangles), which starts with N1∼ca reactions from apoCaM followed by N2∼ca, C1∼ca, and K∼N2C1 in Layer 1, and KC2∼ca and KN2C2∼p in Layer 2. In short, a saturating amount of Ca2+ forces CaM species to traverse states in a way that deviates from the preferred pathway observed with a moderate amount of Ca2+. These deviations are driven by different amounts of reactants.

Fig 11. Change of pathway choice as Ca2+ influx increases.

(A) With 2× Ca2+ input, reaction occurrences of CaM N0C2 binding Ca2+ at the N1 site (blue) and directly binding with CaMKII (black). Thick lines are for 10 Hz input, and thin lines are for 5 Hz input. (B) The same as in A except that 3× Ca2+ influx is given. (C) The same as in A except that 4× Ca2+ influx is given. (D-F) Accumulated reaction occurrences for major CaM CaMKII binding reactions with varying amount of total Ca2+ influx from 2×, 3× to 4×, with Ca2+ input delivered at 5 Hz. (G-I) The same as in D-F except that Ca2+ input is delivered at 10 Hz.

Fig 12. Deviations in the preferred pathway with 5× Ca2+ influx at 10 Hz.

Accumulated reaction occurrences for CaM species in Layer1 and Layer 2 are shown. The new preferred pathway (marked by solid green triangles) is different from the one previously observed with a non-saturating Ca2+ influx in Figs 4 and 5 (marked by hollow green triangles). Also note a second preferred pathway that travels through N2C1 (marked by yellow triangles).

To validate our conclusion about the pathway decision change, we used a reduced reaction network to capture the observed frequency preference reversal (Fig 13). The reduced network is derived from the initial steps in the whole Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII network. We used the original Smoldyn to simulate the simple network, to demonstrate that the reversal of frequency preference is not an artifact of our modified simulator but is inherent to the network itself. We used 5 pulses of instantaneous Ca2+ release as the input and varied the amount of Ca2+ influx per pulse. The CaMKII molecules are modeled as monomers with an arbitrary phosphorylation rate of 1 s−1. As expected, the reversal of frequency preference can be qualitatively captured by the simple reaction scheme (Fig 13A). The 10 Hz stimulus becomes saturating and fails to generate more phosphorylation than 5 Hz when Ca2+ influx reaches 50,000 ions per pulse (Fig 13B).

Fig 13. The effect of saturating Ca2+ on reversing frequency dependence demonstrated using a reduced network.

(A) The reduced reaction network derived from the complete network. CaMKII is modeled as a monomer and undergoes phosphorylation at an arbitrary rate 1 s−1 as long as it is bound with a CaM N1C2. (B) Summary of phosphorylation levels in the presence of varying Ca2+ ions per pulse from 20,000 ions/pulse to 50,000 ions/pulse delivered at 5 Hz and 10 Hz.

The structural organization of CaMKII subunits may affect the activation level

Recent work on CaMKII holoenzyme structure suggests that how subunits are organized can affect the activation of the holoenzyme. In particular, whether subunits are arranged in a compact or an extended way can change the accessibility of CaM to CaMKII. It is known that the structural arrangement is related to a linker region between a subunit’s kinase domain and the holoenzyme central hub. Bayer et al. [45] examined splice variants of β-CaMKII, which have identical kinase domains yet different linker lengths. These variants responded to Ca2+ oscillations differently, even though they showed no response difference to prolonged Ca2+-CaM input. In particular, for Ca2+ pulse input, the variants with longer linker length exhibited a higher autophosphorylation rate. Another study by Chao et al. [46] also indicated that the linker length affects the capability of a subunit’s kinase domain to undock from the central hub. Undocking helps the subunit to be released from an autoinhibited state. Thus a longer linker is expected to keep the kinase domain further away from the central hub, allowing a better chance for Ca2+-CaM to access the binding site.

In our prototype model, each holoenzyme subunit has a distinct physical location and is separated by 8 nm from its neighbors. Studies suggest that a typical one-ring holoenzyme radius is 5 nm to 8 nm [46, 47]. To examine the effect of a longer linker length on CaMKII activation, we varied the radius of a one-ring 6-subunit holoenzyme from 5 nm to 15 nm. Neighbor subunits are equally spaced at the same distance as the holoenzyme radius. For each radius condition, we ran 15 simulation trials using the default Ca2+ influx delivered at 5 Hz and 10 Hz respectively. As shown in Fig 14, the effects of holoenzyme radius on phosphorylation level are related to the Ca2+ input frequencies. With 10 Hz pulses, phosphorylation increases steadily as the holoenzyme radius grows from 5 nm to 15 nm. This result suggests that linker length may affect Ca2+-CaM binding to CaMKII and subsequently affect phosphorylation levels, depending on the Ca2+ input conditions.

Fig 14. Effects of holoenzyme size on CaMKII phosphorylation.

Phosphorylation levels from individual trials as a function of the holoenzyme radius and Ca2+ input frequency. Each radius condition contains 15 trials. For the trials with 10 Hz input, a one-way ANOVA test (F = 1.806, p = 0.157) was performed. Despite no statistically significant difference among radius conditions, a regression analysis shows a steady upward trend (slope = 4.359, p = 0.025) with statistical significance in phosphorylation level as the holoenzyme radius increases.


In this study, we present an efficient approach to simulate multi-subunit molecules with detailed kinetics in reaction-diffusion networks. Our approach is an adaptation of Smoldyn [37, 38], a particle-based stochastic simulator that allows reaction and diffusion to be simulated in spatially heterogeneous environments. Our adaptation adds new data structures to Smoldyn to describe reactions at the binding site level, leading to an efficient solution of the problem of combinatorial explosion inherent in models with multi-subunit molecules [24]. We also introduced an intuitive approach to analyze the pathway choices of a network based on the reaction history of a simulation, allowing us to grasp insights quickly about how reactions proceed in a large network. In traditional analyses, the numbers of each molecular species are examined to resolve the dynamics of the network. However, this procedure is indirect at best when it comes to drawing insights about network behavior. Furthermore, being able to track reaction history of a system is not possible in deterministic simulations. Here we were able to count the number of times a reaction occurs easily and we demonstrated that this reaction history can be highly informative and can allow us to see clearly how the favored network pathway may change with different input conditions.

Insights from the detailed Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII network model

We used the modified Smoldyn simulator and reaction history information to obtain several insights into the Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII reaction network. First, under physiological conditions when Ca2+ influx is low to moderate, CaM molecules partially loaded with Ca2+ are important for CaMKII activation. In particular, reaction history shows that CaM molecules that have 2 Ca2+ ions attached on the C lobe (in particular species N0C2, but also N1C2 and N2C2) preferentially bind to CaMKII subunits before adding additional Ca2+ ions to the N lobe. This is consistent with the predominant pathway hypothesis suggested by Pepke et al. [21] as well as with experimental work by Shifman et al. [29]. Nevertheless, phosphorylation was found to occur primarily from CaMKII bound with CaM fully loaded with Ca2+(KN2C2) and higher frequencies of low to moderate Ca2+ input resulted in more CaMKII phosphorylation.

Second, while CaMKII activation is known to be sensitive to the frequency of Ca2+ signals [43], we found that the frequency dependence is reversed with strong Ca2+ signals, with more CaMKII subunit phosphorylation seen at 5 Hz input than at 10 Hz. Reaction history shows that this occurs because of a depletion of apoCaM, resulting in a change in the preferred pathway for CaMKII activation. Specifically, CaM with 2 Ca2+ ions on the C lobe now becomes more likely to bind Ca2+ on the N lobe than to bind with CaMKII. The change of pathway choice affects how the network is tuned to a particular Ca2+ input frequency. The fact that the strength of the Ca2+ signal matters is important because many experiments that study frequency dependence are done in conditions where CaM is saturated with Ca2+ and this is not the typical situation encountered by the cell.

Third, we found that factors such as CaM availability and Ca2+ diffusion can also affect the frequency dependence of CaMKII activation by Ca2+ signals, also by changing the preferred pathway for CaMKII activation. A limited amount of CaM makes the given Ca2+ input more likely to saturate available CaM on both lobes before binding to CaMKII. Similarly, slow Ca2+ diffusion allows more extensive interactions between Ca2+ and CaM thus making it more likely for a given amount of Ca2+ input to become saturating. Experimental studies suggest that the number of freely diffusible CaM molecules is highly limited in vivo [4850] and limited CaM further implies a regulatory role for the many endogenous CaM-binding proteins [51]. A limited amount of CaM or a slowed Ca2+ diffusion may permit enough Ca2+ to bind to available CaM and allow CaMKII activation to occur at a lower frequency or a lower strength Ca2+ signal.

Fourth, it is known that intracellular crowding and spatial homogeneity can slow down molecule diffusion. For example, a recent biophysical study [52] suggests that the diffusion of Ca2+ ions can be reduced by ten times in a nanodomain around the Ca2+ channel mouth. We believe that such a restriction in Ca2+ diffusion may have substantial effects on CaMKII phosphorylation and the frequency dependence. For example, depending on the size of the nanodomain, slow Ca2+ diffusion in a nanodomain can potentially result in a localized Ca2+ signal with sufficient strength to activate CaMKII and downstream cascading proteins.

Finally, we demonstrated that holoenzyme size is a possible means to affect the level of phosphorylation, depending on the Ca2+ influx. We increased the size of the holoenzyme by changing the distance between neighboring subunits and found that with 10 Hz pulses the corresponding phosphorylation levels of the network increased. This is consistent with the idea that the configuration of a holoenzyme, whether compact or extended, can affect the ability of CaM molecules to access CaMKII subunits [11]. The extension may allow a subunit to sample a volume that is both larger and further away from other subunits, increasing the possibility of a reaction and subsequently leading to more phosphorylated subunits. We did not implement volume exclusion for CaMKII holoenzymes. It is possible that volume exclusion could make the effects of holoenzyme size more apparent.

Modeling considerations

Our model does not contain Thr305/Thr306 phosphorylation (few subunits would have become phosphorylated there during the time period simulated) and also lacks some newly discovered CaMKII structural feature mechanisms, which may lead to a more complicated activation pattern of CaMKII holoenzyme subunits. For example, it has been found that there exists a compact autoinhibition state, which occurs through dimerization of adjacent subunits from top and bottom rings [53]. Once Ca2+-CaM is bound to a dimerized subunit, the dimer disassembles and the two subunits swing away from the center of the holoenzyme. Another recent study indicated that phosphorylated CaMKII subunits can undergo subunit exchange to facilitate propagating activation triggered by Ca2+-CaM [54]. The significance of these additional features of CaMKII activation awaits future study. In addition we have not included other Ca2+ buffers or CaM-binding proteins in our models (e.g., calbindin, calcineurin, neurogranin, F-actin). Including additional reactions involving these molecules could affect Ca2+ concentration, CaM availability and effective Ca2+ diffusion, factors that we already analyze separately with the current simulations (Figs 812).

One technical challenge for particle-based simulation is to handle diffusion-limited reactions, especially in the presence of highly concentrated molecules. One recent experimental study [26] estimated that the N sites of CaM act very fast to bind Ca2+, much faster than previously cited for CaM-N lobe binding kinetics in experimental or modeling studies (although see [55] for a critique of these estimates). If accurate, these fast binding kinetics would place these reactions in the diffusion-limited regime, rendering traditional mass action based methods inaccurate. However, for kinetics this fast, adequate simulation options are limited and not efficient. If using the original Smoldyn algorithm, the simulation time step would have to be considerably reduced to obtain the correct steady state [56]; alternatively, one might increase the geminate recombination probability [37]. Another software package using an enhanced Green’s Function Algorithm [57] can handle the high concentration diffusion-limited reactions accurately, but it takes an impractically long time to run a simulation. If diffusion is slowed considerably in local nanodomains such that Ca2+-CaM-CaMKII interactions become diffusion-limited, it will be necessary to develop different algorithms with improved efficiencies to handle these interactions accurately.


Simulator modifications

The modification is based on Smoldyn (V2.37). The reaction and diffusion kinetics of Smoldyn have been thoroughly validated in the past [37]. Since our modification has progressed independently, an additional check is necessary regarding compatibility or integration with updated versions of Smoldyn [38] and its future development.

We expanded the molecule data structure in Smoldyn to include complexes, molecules and binding sites. A complex may contain multiple molecules and a molecule may contain multiple binding sites. Reactions are specified between binding sites. Each binding site has binary states. For example, bound is coded as 1 and unbound as 0; phosphorylated as 1 and unphosphorylated as 0. Each molecule has a vector to store the states of binding sites. All reactions are stored in a hash table with reactants and their binding states as entry keys. A hash table is a data structure that stores association arrays and allows rapid lookup. In our case, the reaction network can be considered as associations between reactants, and therefore is ideal to be implemented using a hash table. CaM is an example of a molecule with multiple binding sites. The binding reactions involving the N and C lobes of CaM can be coded as in Fig 1B. A CaMKII holoenzyme is an example of a complex composed of two 6-subunit rings. Each subunit is a molecule containing binding sites for CaM and phosphorylation. Each ring has a radius of 8 nm and is separated from its direct neighbors at a fixed distance of 8 nm (estimated from [47]). For simplicity, we usually modeled CaMKII holoenzymes as one ring of 6 subunits. A link to the sample reaction configuration files to be run with the modified Smoldyn is included in S1 File. A link to the modified Smoldyn source code is provided in S4 File.

In the original version of Smoldyn, each reaction generates new molecules and reactant molecules are removed. In our case, since one molecule can have multiple binding sites and is potentially associated with multiple partners, entirely removing a molecule is not practical because other attached molecules would also be affected. In addition, removing and generating new molecules makes it difficult to track the reaction history of a molecule. Therefore, during reactions we do not remove molecules but merely change molecule binding states and positions. Molecules bound together physically overlap, synchronize their locations automatically and diffuse together. The diffusion coefficient is determined by the larger molecule. For example, when Ca2+ and CaM are bound, the attached Ca2+ molecule diffuses with the CaM diffusion rate; similarly, CaM bound to a CaMKII subunit will diffuse with the CaMKII holoenzyme.

Macromolecules usually have multiple binding sites, and sometimes these sites compete for the same ligand. For example, CaM has 4 Ca2+ binding sites. Since the N and C sites act independently, the N1 and C1 sites compete for Ca2+ and an apoCaM N0C0 can become either N1C0 or N0C1, resulting in a branching reaction scheme. Thus a decision process is needed to choose a reaction path when such a binding event occurs.

To do this, consider the following two reactions

  1. rxn1: camN0C0 + ca <-> camN1C0
  2. rxn2: camN0C0 + ca <-> camN0C1

Rxn1 has a forward rate constant kf1 in μm−1 s−1 and a backward rate constant kb1 in s−1. Rxn2 has similar rate constants kf2 and kb2. The two reactions can be viewed together as an equivalent rxn3, which has overall kinetic rates kf3 and kb3. According to the law of mass action, the reactions can be written as differential equations and we can obtain (2)

Smoldyn uses binding radii to implement second order reactions. If two molecules are spatially separated by a distance smaller than the corresponding binding radius, then the reaction proceeds. In Smoldyn, a special algorithm is used to calculate the binding radius, which depends on the kinetic rate constant, simulation time step and total diffusion rate of reactants. In the case of a branched binding scheme sharing common reactants, we first calculate a binding radius r3 based on kf3. If the distance between a molecule pair is smaller than r3, binding happens. To make a reaction choice, we generate a uniformly distributed random number from 0 to 1. If the number falls in the range , then rxn1 is chosen; instead if the number falls in the range , we pick rxn2. Following this approach, the network can be kept consistent with the prediction by the mass action law.

Reaction network

We focus on the interactions among Ca2+, CaM, and CaMKII. We first used a Ca2+-CaM network for testing to confirm that modifications to the simulator were working properly. Then we added CaMKII holoenzymes to study the reaction network in detail. We set up a box-shaped model to represent a portion of a cell body. The box has dimensions of 1 μm in width and length, as well as 2 μm in depth. The top surface of the box represents the cell membrane, reflective to all molecules. The four sides are also reflective (effectively not different from using periodic boundaries S1 Fig). The bottom surface is partially absorbing to Ca2+ ions but reflective to CaM and CaMKII. This conservation of CaM molecules and CaMKII subunits guarantees a steady state initial condition. This partial absorption is a built-in feature in the original Smoldyn to resemble unbounded diffusion [58].

Voltage-gated Ca2+ channels (presumably L-type) are located on the top surface to provide Ca2+ influx. For simplicity, these channels are placed together at the center of the membrane. The channels open and close depending on a time-varying membrane voltage file generated from a NEURON model (described below). CaMKII subunits are uniformly present at a concentration of 10 μm. They are also immobilized, presumably attached to actin [10]. Freely diffusible CaM molecules are uniformly distributed at a concentration of 5 μm. This is consistent with the notion that at the resting level, freely diffusible CaM molecules are considerably limited in number compared to their binding proteins [48, 50, 59]. S1 Table lists all the reactions with corresponding kinetic parameters involved in the network. Kinetic parameters are integrated from various sources as noted in S1 Table and are adjusted to satisfy microscopic reversibility.

Ca2+ input conditions

A model was constructed using NEURON [60] with a detailed morphology of a CA1 pyramidal cell and ion channel conductances to generate a voltage response at the soma to various stimulation conditions. Theta-burst stimulation (5 pulses at 100 Hz, repeated 5 times at 5 Hz or 10 Hz intervals) was applied to synapses on spines taking into account a probability of release measured in experiments [61]. This stimulation activated AMPA and NMDA receptor-channels on dendritic spines causing depolarization in the dendritic tree, which propagated to the soma and initiated action potentials. Soma voltage profiles for 5 Hz and 10 Hz interval stimulation are shown in Fig 15A and 15C.

Fig 15. Patterns of membrane voltage and Ca2+ influx.

(A) A 5 Hz action potential burst voltage file generated from the NEURON model. (B) Ca2+ influx generated using the 5 Hz voltage file with 16 Ca2+ channels. Ca2+ influx is stochastic. There are spontaneous influxes in the absence of action potentials. (C) 10 Hz action potential burst voltage file generated from the NEURON model. (D) Ca2+ influx generated using the 10 Hz voltage file with 16 Ca2+ channels. (E) Accumulated Ca2+ influx for 5 Hz and 10 Hz input with 16 channels. The total Ca2+ amount is matched between Ca2+ input files.

This membrane voltage output from the NEURON model was used to determine Ca2+ influx through L-type Ca2+ channels in our reaction network model. Since the kinetics of L-type Ca2+ channels are relatively fast and their density is low, the membrane potential is little affected by their activity. Thus the NEURON model and the reaction network model can be safely decoupled. L-type Ca2+ channels are modeled stochastically. They open and close in response to the voltage input.

  1. CaL{gate==0} <-> CaL[gate=1].

The voltage-dependent opening and closing of these channels are modeled with the Hodgkin-Huxley formalism [62]. The rates of channel opening and closing are functions of membrane voltage and are calculated using variables ninf and τn, where ninf describes the steady-state voltage-dependent activation and τn is the time constant (Fig 16A).

Fig 16. Ca2+ channel parameters.

(A) ninf(V) and τn(V) used to simulate the voltage-gated Ca2+ channels. (B) The number of channels N was determined by fitting the single channel current to the Goldman—Hodgkin—Katz (GHK) current equation. N was found to be 16.

Then the following set of equations are used to describe voltage-gated Ca2+ channel kinetics: (3) (4) (5) (6) where V1/2 and slope together describe the channel activation in response to voltage. In our model, V1/2 equals -15 mV and slope equals 8 mV.

The rateopen and rateclose are used to calculate conditional probabilities to determine the state of a channel for the next time step in the following way (7) (8) (9) For each channel, at a given time, a probability is calculated based on the membrane voltage to decide whether a channel opens. If it opens, a varying number of Ca2+ ions enter. To calculate how many ions, we used the following equation [52] to obtain the unitary current for a single channel (10) where g is chosen as 5 pS and RT/zF equals 12 mV, and Vs is determined as described below. A current density is calculated using Goldman—Hodgkin—Katz current equation as follows, (11) where extracellular [Ca2+]o equals 2 mM, intracellular [Ca2+]i equals 50 nm and a maximum membrane permeability to Ca2+ P is 0.241 × 10−3 cm s−1. Since the membrane surface is 1 μm2, the current density is converted to a total current Ighk for this area. If a total of N channels are present, in this membrane surface, the single channel current ica equals . By fitting the total current Ighk with N × ica, we obtained an N of 16 and a Vs of −1.91 mV (Fig 16B). From ica, the number of ions entering each open channel during one time step is calculated as (Fig 15B and 15D), where 2 is the valence of Ca2+ and e is the elementary charge. To guarantee a consistent amount of total Ca2+ for a given set of 5 Hz and 10 Hz voltage files, we generated 40 trials of Ca2+ influx files for each frequency and then selected the ones with equivalent total Ca2+ influx (Fig 15E).

Supporting information

S1 File. Descriptions of all models used in the study.


S2 File. How the combinatorics numbers are calculated.


S3 File. Neighbor sensitivity of CaMKII autophosphorylation.


S4 File. Source code of the modified Smoldyn.

Please follow the GitHub link ( to the source code repository for future updates. More links to the relevant online repositories are in S1 File.


S1 Fig. Comparison of CaMKII subunits phosphorylated and CaM bound simulated with reflective and periodic side surfaces.

We see that because geometry is a box, reflective and periodic boundary conditions give comparable results. (A) Phosphorylated CaMKII subunits from 10 trials with reflective boundary conditions and periodic boundary conditions (B) The same as in A but for CaM-bound CaMKII subunits.


S2 Fig. The modified Smoldyn produces results consistent with the formula [22].

Holoenzymes has 2, 3, 6, or 12 subunits. Fully loaded CaM saturated CaMKII. The percentage of phosphorylated subunits are plotted over time.


S3 Fig. The modified Smoldyn produces results consistent with those computed with a spatial Gillespie algorithm.

(A) Bound CaMKII subunits simulated separately using the spatial Gillespie algorithm (red line) and modified Smoldyn (blue line) (B) The same as in A but for phosphorylated CaMKII subunits.


S4 Fig. Probability of release at synapses used in the NEURON model.

(A) Probability of release measured experimentally [61] using high frequency stimulation (100 Hz) as a function of stimulation pulse number. (B) Probability of release profile used to generate theta-burst stimulation at various frequencies. Long interval can be adjusted to give rise to 5 Hz or 10 Hz action potential patterns.


S5 Fig. Morphology of the pyramidal neuron used in the NEURON model.

Soma is colored in blue and dendritic spines are marked in black. Probabilistic synaptic input as in S4 Fig is given at spines. Action potentials are recorded in the soma and used to generate Ca2+ influx.


S6 Fig. Accumulated reaction occurrences generated from 6 trials for CaM CaMKII binding reactions in the presence of 5 Hz and 10 Hz Ca2+ input.

This is a rearrangement of the same data shown in Fig 7A and 7B.


S1 Table. Kinetic parameters of all reactions.



We thank David C. Sterratt for alerting us to the necklace function in the numbers package of the statistics program R which we used to compute the number of possible states in the network.


  1. 1. Wayman GA, Lee YS, Tokumitsu H, Silva AJ, Silva A, Soderling TR. Calmodulin-kinases: modulators of neuronal development and plasticity. Neuron. 2008;59(6):914–931. pmid:18817731
  2. 2. Lisman J, Schulman H, Cline H. The molecular basis of CaMKII function in synaptic and behavioural memory. Nat Rev Neurosci. 2002;3(3):175–190. pmid:11994750
  3. 3. Erickson JR. Mechanisms of CaMKII activation in the heart. Front Pharmacol. 2014;5(e1000583):289.
  4. 4. Herring BE, Nicoll RA. Long-term potentiation: from CaMKII to AMPA receptor trafficking. Annu Rev Physiol. 2016;78(1):351–365. pmid:26863325
  5. 5. Hell JW. CaMKII: claiming center stage in postsynaptic function and organization. Neuron. 2014;81(2):249–265. pmid:24462093
  6. 6. Coultrap SJ, Bayer KU. CaMKII regulation in information processing and storage. Trends Neurosci. 2012;35(10):607–618. pmid:22717267
  7. 7. Stefan MI, Edelstein SJ, Le Novere N. An allosteric model of calmodulin explains differential activation of PP2B and CaMKII. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2008;105(31):10768–10773. pmid:18669651
  8. 8. Bliss TVP, Lømo T. Long-lasting potentiation of synaptic transmission in the dentate area of the anaesthetized rabbit following stimulation of the perforant path. J Physiol. 1973;232(2):331–356. pmid:4727084
  9. 9. Ma H, Groth RD, Cohen SM, Emery JF, Li B, Hoedt E, et al. γCaMKII shuttles Ca2+/CaM to the nucleus to trigger CREB phosphorylation and gene expression. Cell. 2014;159(2):281–294. pmid:25303525
  10. 10. Li B, Tadross MR, Tsien RW. Sequential ionic and conformational signaling by calcium channels drives neuronal gene expression. Science. 2016;351(6275):863–867. pmid:26912895
  11. 11. Stratton MM, Chao LH, Schulman H, Kuriyan J. Structural studies on the regulation of Ca2+/Calmodulin-Dependent Protein Kinase II. Current Opinion in Structural Biology. 2013;23(2):292–301. pmid:23632248
  12. 12. Bradshaw JM, Hudmon A, Schulman H. Chemical quenched flow kinetic studies indicate an intraholoenzyme autophosphorylation mechanism for Ca2+/Calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II. J Biol Chem. 2002;277(23):20991–20998. pmid:11925447
  13. 13. Meyer T, Hanson PI, Stryer L, Schulman H. Calmodulin trapping by Ca2+-calmodulin-dependent protein kinase. Science. 1992;256(5060):1199–1202. pmid:1317063
  14. 14. Zhabotinsky AM. Bistability in the Ca2+/Calmodulin-Dependent Protein Kinase-Phosphatase system. Biophys J. 2000;79(5):2211–2221. pmid:11053103
  15. 15. Holmes WR. Models of calmodulin trapping and CaM kinase II activation in a dendritic spine. J Comput Neurosci. 2000;8(1):65–85. pmid:10798500
  16. 16. Kubota Y, Bower JM. Transient versus asymptotic dynamics of CaM kinase II: possible roles of phosphatase. J Comput Neurosci. 2001;11(3):263–279. pmid:11796942
  17. 17. Dupont G, Houart G, De Koninck P. Sensitivity of CaM kinase II to the frequency of Ca2+ oscillations: a simple model. Cell Calcium. 2003;34(6):485–497. pmid:14572807
  18. 18. Bhalla US. Signaling in small subcellular volumes. I. stochastic and diffusion effects on individual pathways. Biophys J. 2004;87(2):733–744. pmid:15298882
  19. 19. Lucić V, Greif GJ, Kennedy MB. Detailed state model of CaMKII activation and autophosphorylation. Eur Biophys J. 2008;38(1):83–98. pmid:18769913
  20. 20. Zeng S, Holmes WR. The effect of noise on CaMKII activation in a dendritic spine during LTP induction. J Neurophysiol. 2010;103(4):1798–1808. pmid:20107130
  21. 21. Pepke S, Kinzer-Ursem T, Mihalas S, Kennedy MB. A dynamic model of interactions of Ca2+, calmodulin, and catalytic subunits of Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II. PLoS Comput Biol. 2010;6(2):e1000675–15. pmid:20168991
  22. 22. Michalski PJ, Loew LM. CaMKII activation and dynamics are independent of the holoenzyme structure: an infinite subunit holoenzyme approximation. Phys Biol. 2012;9(3):036010. pmid:22683827
  23. 23. Stefan MI, Marshall DP, Le Novere N. Structural analysis and stochastic modelling suggest a mechanism for calmodulin trapping by CaMKII. PLoS ONE. 2012;7(1):e29406–14. pmid:22279535
  24. 24. Stefan MI, Bartol TM, Sejnowski TJ, Kennedy MB. Multi-state modeling of biomolecules. PLoS Comput Biol. 2014;10(9):e1003844. pmid:25254957
  25. 25. Hlavacek WS, Faeder JR, Blinov ML, Posner RG, Hucka M, Fontana W. Rules for modeling signal-transduction systems. Sci STKE. 2006;2006(344):re6–re6. pmid:16849649
  26. 26. Faas GC, Raghavachari S, Lisman JE, Mody I. Calmodulin as a direct detector of Ca2+ signals. Nat Neurosci. 2011;14(3):301–304. pmid:21258328
  27. 27. Byrne MJ, Putkey JA, Waxham MN, Kubota Y. Dissecting cooperative calmodulin binding to CaM kinase II: a detailed stochastic model. J Comput Neurosci. 2009;27(3):621–638. pmid:19609660
  28. 28. Linse S, Helmersson A, Forsén S. Calcium binding to calmodulin and its globular domains. J Biol Chem. 1991;266(13):8050–8054. pmid:1902469
  29. 29. Shifman JM, Choi MH, Mihalas S, Mayo SL, Kennedy MB. Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII) is activated by calmodulin with two bound calciums. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2006;103(38):13968–13973 pmid:16966599
  30. 30. Forest A, Swulius MT, Tse JKY, Bradshaw JM, Gaertner T, Waxham MN. Role of the N- and C-Lobes of Calmodulin in the Activation of Ca2+/Calmodulin-Dependent Protein Kinase II †. Biochemistry. 2008;47(40):10587–10599. pmid:18795794
  31. 31. Lai M, Brun D, Edelstein SJ, Le Novere N. Modulation of Calmodulin Lobes by Different Targets: An Allosteric Model with Hemiconcerted Conformational Transitions. PLoS Comput Biol. 2015;11(1):e1004063–28. pmid:25611683
  32. 32. Gaertner TR, Putkey JA, Waxham MN. RC3/Neurogranin and Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II produce opposing effects on the affinity of calmodulin for calcium. J Biol Chem. 2004;279(38):39374–39382. pmid:15262982
  33. 33. Tucker A. Applied Combinatorics, 6th Edition. Wiley; 2012.
  34. 34. Luby-Phelps K. Cytoarchitecture and physical properties of cytoplasm: volume, viscosity, diffusion, intracellular surface area. Int Rev Cytol. 2000;192:189–221. pmid:10553280
  35. 35. Dix JA, Verkman AS. Crowding Effects on Diffusion in Solutions and Cells. Annu Rev Biophys. 2008;37(1):247–263. pmid:18573081
  36. 36. Ma H, Li B, Tsien RW. Distinct roles of multiple isoforms of CaMKII in signaling to the nucleus. Biochim Biophys Acta. 2015;1853(9):1953–1957. pmid:25700840
  37. 37. Andrews SS, Bray D. Stochastic simulation of chemical reactions with spatial resolution and single molecule detail. Phys Biol. 2004;1(3-4):137–151. pmid:16204833
  38. 38. Andrews SS. Smoldyn: particle-based simulation with rule-based modeling, improved molecular interaction and a library interface. Bioinformatics (Oxford, England). 2017;33(5):710–717.
  39. 39. Allbritton NL, Meyer T, Stryer L. Range of messenger action of calcium ion and inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate. Science (New York, NY). 1992;258(5089):1812–1815.
  40. 40. Keller DX, Franks KM, Bartol TM, Sejnowski TJ. Calmodulin activation by calcium transients in the postsynaptic density of dendritic spines. PLoS One. 2008;3(4):e2045. pmid:18446197
  41. 41. Rice SA. Comprehensive Chemical Kinetics: Diffusion-Limited Reactions. vol. 25. Elsevier Science Ltd; 1985.
  42. 42. Hoops S, Sahle S, Gauges R, Lee C, Pahle J, Simus N, et al. COPASI—a COmplex PAthway SImulator. Bioinformatics. 2006;22(24):3067–3074. pmid:17032683
  43. 43. De Koninck P, Schulman H. Sensitivity of CaM kinase II to the frequency of Ca2+ oscillations. Science. 1998;279(5348):227–230. pmid:9422695
  44. 44. Fujii H, Inoue M, Okuno H, Sano Y, Takemoto-Kimura S, Kitamura K, et al. Nonlinear decoding and asymmetric representation of neuronal input information by CaMKIIα and calcineurin. Cell Rep. 2013;3(4):978–987. pmid:23602566
  45. 45. Bayer KU, De Koninck P, Schulman H. Alternative splicing modulates the frequency- dependent response of CaMKII to Ca2+ oscillations. The EMBO journal. 2002;21(14):3590–3597. pmid:12110572
  46. 46. Chao LH, Stratton MM, Lee IH, Rosenberg OS, Levitz J, Mandell DJ, et al. A Mechanism for tunable autoinhibition in the structure of a human Ca2+/Calmodulin-Dependent Kinase II holoenzyme. Cell. 2011;146(5):732–745. pmid:21884935
  47. 47. Gaertner TR, Kolodziej SJ, Wang D, Kobayashi R, Koomen JM, Stoops JK, et al. Comparative analyses of the three-dimensional structures and enzymatic properties of alpha, beta, gamma and delta isoforms of Ca2+-Calmodulin-Dependent Protein Kinase II. J Biol Chem. 2004;279(13):12484–12494. pmid:14722083
  48. 48. Sanabria H, Digman MA, Gratton E, Waxham MN. Spatial diffusivity and availability of intracellular calmodulin. Biophys J. 2008;95(12):6002–6015. pmid:18820232
  49. 49. Persechini A, Stemmer PM. Calmodulin is a limiting factor in the cell. Trends Cardiovasc Med. 2002;12(1):32–37. pmid:11796242
  50. 50. Luby-Phelps K, Hori M, Phelps JM, Won D. Ca2+-regulated dynamic compartmentalization of calmodulin in living smooth muscle cells. J Biol Chem. 1995;270(37):21532–21538. pmid:7665565
  51. 51. Skene J. GAP-43 as a ’calmodulin sponge’ and some implications for calcium signalling in axon terminals. Neurosci Res Suppl. 1990;13:S112–S125. pmid:1979675
  52. 52. Tadross MR, Tsien RW, Yue DT. Ca2+ channel nanodomains boost local Ca2+ amplitude. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2013;110(39):15794–15799 pmid:24019485
  53. 53. Chao LH, Pellicena P, Deindl S, Barclay LA, Schulman H, Kuriyan J. Intersubunit capture of regulatory segments is a component of cooperative CaMKII activation. Nat Struct Mol Biol. 2010;17(3):264–272. pmid:20139983
  54. 54. Stratton M, Lee IH, Bhattacharyya M, Christensen SM, Chao LH, Schulman H, et al. Activation-triggered subunit exchange between CaMKII holoenzymes facilitates the spread of kinase activity. eLife. 2014;3:2342–28.
  55. 55. Mironov S. Maxwell’s demon for calcium binding to calmodulin? eprint arXiv:13053553. 2013;.
  56. 56. Andrews S, Vel Arjunan SN, Balbo G, Liu F. Simulating macromolecular crowding with particle and lattice-based methods (Team 3). In: Gilbert David, Heiner Monika, Takahashi Koichi, and Uhrmacher Koichi, eds. Multiscale Spatial Computational Systems Biology; 2015. p. 170–187.
  57. 57. van Zon JS, ten Wolde PR. Simulating biochemical networks at the particle level and in time and space: Green’s function reaction dynamics. Phys Rev Lett. 2005;94(12):128103. pmid:15903966
  58. 58. Andrews SS. Accurate particle-based simulation of adsorption, desorption and partial transmission. Phys Biol. 2009;6(4):046015. pmid:19910670
  59. 59. Tran QK, Black DJ, Persechini A. Intracellular coupling via limiting calmodulin. J Biol Chem. 2003;278(27):24247–24250. pmid:12738782
  60. 60. Carnevale NT, Hines ML. The NEURON Book. Cambridge University Press; 2006.
  61. 61. Grover LM, Kim E, Cooke JD, Holmes WR. LTP in hippocampal area CA1 is induced by burst stimulation over a broad frequency range centered around delta. Learn Mem. 2009;16(1):69–81. pmid:19144965
  62. 62. Tuckwell HC. Quantitative aspects of L-type Ca2+ currents. Prog Neurobiol. 2012;96(1):1–31. pmid:22008116