Glucose is the main energy substrate in the adult brain under normal conditions. Accumulating evidence, however, indicates that lactate produced in astrocytes (a type of glial cell) can also fuel neuronal activity. The quantitative aspects of this so-called astrocyte-neuron lactate shuttle (ANLS) are still debated. To address this question, we developed a detailed biophysical model of the brain’s metabolic interactions. Our model integrates three modeling approaches, the Buxton-Wang model of vascular dynamics, the Hodgkin-Huxley formulation of neuronal membrane excitability and a biophysical model of metabolic pathways. This approach provides a template for large-scale simulations of the neuron-glia-vasculature (NGV) ensemble, and for the first time integrates the respective timescales at which energy metabolism and neuronal excitability occur. The model is constrained by relative neuronal and astrocytic oxygen and glucose utilization, by the concentration of metabolites at rest and by the temporal dynamics of NADH upon activation. These constraints produced four observations. First, a transfer of lactate from astrocytes to neurons emerged in response to activity. Second, constrained by activity-dependent NADH transients, neuronal oxidative metabolism increased first upon activation with a subsequent delayed astrocytic glycolysis increase. Third, the model correctly predicted the dynamics of extracellular lactate and oxygen as observed in vivo in rats. Fourth, the model correctly predicted the temporal dynamics of tissue lactate, of tissue glucose and oxygen consumption, and of the BOLD signal as reported in human studies. These findings not only support the ANLS hypothesis but also provide a quantitative mathematical description of the metabolic activation in neurons and glial cells, as well as of the macroscopic measurements obtained during brain imaging.
The brain has remarkable information processing capacity, yet is also very energy efficient. How this metabolic efficiency is achieved given the spatial and metabolic constraints inherent to the designs and energy requirements of brain cells is a fundamental question in neurobiology. The major cell classes in mammalian nervous systems include neurons, glia and the microvasculature that supplies the molecular substrates of energy and metabolism. Together, this neuron-glia-vasculature (NGV) ensemble constitutes the functional unit that underlies the cost infrastructure of computation. In spite of its importance, a comprehensive understanding of this dynamic system remains elusive. While it is well established that glucose feeds the brain, few of the details regarding the destiny of glucose intermediates in metabolic pathways are known. Controversy remains regarding the degree of cooperativity between glia and neurons in sharing lactate, the product of aerobic glycolysis (Warburg effect) and one of the substrates for further energy extraction by oxidative processes. Specifically, while experimental data support the occurrence of a flow of lactate from glia to neurons, the astrocyte-neuron lactate shuttle (ANLS), some theoretical considerations have been proposed to support the occurrence of lactate transport in the other direction (NALS). Our computational model is the first to integrate multiple timescales of the NGV unit. It provides a quantitative mathematical description of metabolic activation in neurons and astrocytes, and of the macroscopic measurements obtained during brain imaging that uses metabolism as a proxy for neuronal activity.
Citation: Jolivet R, Coggan JS, Allaman I, Magistretti PJ (2015) Multi-timescale Modeling of Activity-Dependent Metabolic Coupling in the Neuron-Glia-Vasculature Ensemble. PLoS Comput Biol 11(2): e1004036. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1004036
Editor: Lyle Graham, UFR Biomédicale de l’Université René Descart, France
Received: January 17, 2014; Accepted: November 13, 2014; Published: February 26, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Jolivet et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Funding: This work was supported by a grant from King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST) for a collaboration between the Blue Brain Project at EPFL and the KAUST-EPFL Alliance for Neuro-inspired High Performance Computing. RJ was funded by a Marie Curie fellowship (FP7-PEOPLE-2010-IEF BrainEnergyControl). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The mammalian brain exhibits remarkable processing power. It is at the same time energy efficient. The design features that allow such efficient computation are mapped in cellular and molecular components and their roles in information processing. Concurrently, these features are anchored in, and constrained by, the universal metabolic chains that provide energy to cells. Deciphering the metabolic code and the neural code are thus tandem requirements for a comprehensive understanding of brain function. Understanding the metabolic underpinnings of information processing is also of added value to understanding the etiology and progression of neuropsychiatric and neurodegenerative disorders [1, 2]. The picture that emerges from this dynamical system will reflect the cooperative function of neurons, glia and the vascular system.
Glutamate, the brain’s major neurotransmitter, effects numerous cascades and processes in brain cells [3, 4]. Among them, astrocytes couple synaptic activity to energy metabolism via a sodium-dependent uptake of glutamate . The ensuing cascade of molecular events leads to the glycolytic processing of glucose and the release of lactate by astrocytes. A comprehensive model of brain energy metabolism must consider oxidative and non-oxidative glucose consumption, intracellular and extracellular compartmentalization and transport of choke-point metabolic intermediates such as lactate and pyruvate, as well as feedback mechanisms that report local synaptic and intrinsic neuronal activity [6, 7]. These pathways are in turn complicit in the molecular and cellular mechanisms that contribute to the still poorly understood read-out of functional brain imaging .
The role of astrocytes and how they metabolically interact with neurons is well supported experimentally; some mostly theoretical considerations, however, have challenged this view. Magistretti and colleagues proposed that clearance of glutamate from the synaptic cleft by astrocytes could be coupled to glycolysis and subsequent lactate production . Lactate produced in this way would then be transported to the extracellular space. Controversy remains surrounding directionality and timing of lactate flow in the brain; while a neuron-to-astrocyte lactate system (NALS) is proposed by some [9, 10], an astrocyte-to-neuron direction (ANLS) is supported by a large set of experimental evidence . Biophysical models also weigh-in on the conditions and sequences of events required for lactate production and consumption [12–15].
The existence of an extracellular pool of lactate likely used as an energy reservoir at the onset of stimulation has been observed in rats and humans [16, 17]. The distribution of monocarboxylate transporters at the membrane of neurons and astrocytes supports the hypothesis of a net transfer of lactate from astrocytes to neurons through the extracellular space . Glial cells have been observed to take up most glucose [19, 20], while neurons are responsible for the largest part of brain oxygen consumption [21, 22]. Additional evidence comes from the direct measure of NADH transients in brain slices, showing that neurons display early oxidative metabolism following presynaptic activity, while astrocytes display a delayed activation of glycolysis but no detectable oxidative response . Nevertheless, the ANLS-hypothesis is still debated and challenged with arguments focusing now on the exact interpretation of the above observations [24, 25].
Nicotine adenine dinucleotide, either oxidized or reduced (NAD+, or NADH), is a workhorse cofactor that acts as a central electron broker for metabolic redox cycles including glycolysis, the citric acid cycle (Krebs, TCA) and oxidative phosphorylation. Owing to its high UV wavelength absorption, it is also responsible for cellular auto-florescence. This coincidence makes it a useful indicator of metabolic activity. NADH is an important metabolic signal because it is produced or used during both mitochondrial activity and activation of the glycolytic pathway, and because it cannot diffuse freely through the mitochondrial membrane but needs to be transported by appropriate shuttles. Fluctuations of the NADH concentration measured in the appropriate cellular compartments can then indicate increased or decreased oxidative and glycolytic metabolism. A critical previous finding in this regard was the observation of early and late activity-dependent phases of metabolic activity with the early phase taking the form of a NADH “dip” and the late phase appearing as a NADH “overshoot” with a longer time constant of decay . Interestingly, these phases also correlate with the fluctuations of the extracellular lactate concentration as determined in animals  and humans [26, 27].
The emerging consensus is that the early phase represents NADH depletion in the dendrites of active neurons and that the overshoot represents glycolytic activity that results in the accumulation of NADH. This activity results in the high production of lactate in astrocytes as rapid glycolysis overtakes the subsequent consumption by oxidative pathways [23, 26, 27]. The accumulation and transportation of lactate between glial cells and neurons may in turn serve as an activity-dependent buffer that is informed by the neuronal release and glial uptake of glutamate . It might also act as a signaling molecule to the vasculature  or to brain cells via binding to the G-protein coupled receptor GPR81 .
The preference for lactate over glucose as an energy substrate in neurons has been demonstrated in vivo as well as in vitro [30, 31], as has a neuroprotective role for lactate in the case of insulin-dependent hypoglycemia  and other conditions [33, 34]. The role of the ANLS in homeostatic maintenance involves the regulation of blood glucose  and sodium . While the ANLS hypothesis, since its initial formulation , does not preclude the use of glucose by neurons as an energy substrate, it has been challenged by some studies defending the view that glucose, rather than lactate, is the sole energy substrate for oxidative metabolism in neurons [37, 38].
Previous modeling efforts have advanced our knowledge of this functional metabolic network by demonstrating that lactate consumption by neurons occurs early in the stimulus regimen and that the early and late lactate transients correspond to the activity of two distinct populations of cells, neurons and glia. The current study builds on and complements those and other models [9, 10, 12–15, 39–42] and addresses unresolved mechanisms of neuron-glial metabolic and vascular coupling. The model is based on several previous studies [13, 40] with five significant improvements: 1) the compartmentalization of NADH between cytosolic and mitochondrial compartments; 2) the linking of metabolic and Hodgkin-Huxley formalisms; 3) the input to the neuronal and astrocytic compartments formulated as a presynaptic glutamatergic stimulation; 4) the model explicitly and continuously updates reversal potentials; and 5) the model was constrained using in vitro data and correctly predicts in vivo results without the need of invoking glycogen (which is deliberately excluded from the model).
In this paper, we will show that a biophysical model of astrocyte-neuron metabolic interactions designed following these principles leads to the presence of an activity-dependent lactate shuttle from astrocytes to neurons and that this model can reproduce the evoked response of NADH in its various compartments as reported by Kasischke and colleagues . We will subsequently show that our biophysical model correctly predicts qualitatively—and to some extent quantitatively—the evoked responses of tissue lactate and tissue oxygen as observed in the rat brain in vivo . Finally, our biophysical model predicts the evoked responses of tissue lactate, of the BOLD signal and the glucose and oxygen consumption as observed in the human brain in vivo.
This in silico model represents a dynamic and integrative analysis of compartmentalized metabolism and its relation to neuronal signaling in the central nervous system. The model was designed based on knowledge of the underlying biophysics and required input parameters and equations from multiple species, time and spatial scales. The model is inspired by previous work from Aubert and colleagues [13, 40] and consists of four compartments: neuron, astrocyte, capillary and extracellular space (see Fig. 1). These compartments are referred to by the subscripts n, g (for glia/astrocyte), c and e respectively. In addition, the neuronal and astrocytic compartments are further divided between cytosolic and mitochondrial sub-compartments to account for the compartmentalization of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH). These are referred to by the superscripts cyto and mito. Transport between compartments is noted with the subscripts of both compartments; for instance, transport from the neuronal compartment to the extracellular space is labeled with ne or, conversely, en.
The model is divided in four main compartments: a neuronal compartment, an astrocytic compartment, the extracellular space and a vascular compartment. Neurons and astrocytes are further divided between a cytosolic sub-compartment and a mitochondrial sub-compartment to account for the compartmentalization of oxidative and glycolytic metabolisms. Both neurons and astrocytes contain a metabolic network including glycolytic enzymes, lactate dehydrogenase, glucose and lactate transporters, NADH shuttles, oxidative metabolism, phosphocreatine and the Na, K-ATPase electrogenic pump. Additionally, the neuronal compartment contains voltage- and calcium-gated ion channels following the Hodgkin-Huxley formalism. The system as a whole is driven by two independent inputs (red). First, a glutamatergic presynaptic population activates AMPA receptors on the neuronal membrane and excitatory amino-acid transporters (EAATs) on the astrocytic membrane. The activation of both AMPA receptors and EAATs leads to an increase of the intracellular sodium concentration which activates the energy consuming Na, K-ATPase pump and subsequent metabolic processes. Activation of AMPA receptors also depolarizes neurons and might lead to the generation of action potentials, which will also lead to an increase in intracellular sodium in the neuronal compartment via opening of voltage-gated sodium channels. Second, the cerebral blood flow (CBF) is modulated as a separate input. For comparison to in vitro experiments using acute brain slices, the only input is the presynaptic neuronal population while the supply of oxygen and glucose that normally comes from the CBF is held constant as a proxy for the laminar flow of a controlled perfusing solution. Finally, the extracellular space is the place where cells and capillaries exchange metabolites
The model is formulated as a series of 33 differential equations adapted from previous work [13, 40] with the following improvements: the compartmentalization of (mostly) NADH between the cytosolic and mitochondrial compartments; the model was joined to a Hodgkin-Huxley-type model [43, 44]; the input to the neuronal and astrocytic compartments is formulated as a glutamatergic input and not anymore as an abstract stimulation; the model explicitly models sodium entry and extrusion in both the neuronal and astrocytic compartments, continuously updating the corresponding reversal potentials. The model, which for the first time bridges mathematical descriptions of energy metabolism and Hodgkin-Huxley equations, was constrained on in vitro data and correctly predicts in vivo results.
Parameters that were difficult to determine experimentally such as transport constants were left free to vary [10, 42]. Free parameters were then optimized so that the model reproduces the experimental results presented in . The number of free parameters was maintained as small as possible by enforcing constraints on the value of metabolites at steady state. Simulations with randomized fluctuations in parameter values (up to plus or minus 10% of reported values) did not reveal significant changes in behavior of the model. This approach successfully predicts qualitatively and quantitatively in vivo measurements in rodents and in humans (see Results, Fig. 5 and 6).
The pooling together of equations from various sources is unfortunately necessary for construction of such a broad and multi-dimensional model. There is no single source of equations that can be tapped for this model. Note however that most equations come from only two published sources. The variables, their steady-state values and the corresponding governing equations are given in Table 1. Equations (A.1)-(A.8), (A.13) and (A.16)-(A.22) are taken from Aubert and Costalat  and were originally introduced in ref.  for the equations describing metabolism and by Buxton and colleagues  for the equations describing the vascular dynamics. Equations (A.9)-(A.12), (A.14) and (A.15) are original. Equations (A.23)-(A.26) describe the neuronal membrane excitability following the Hodgkin-Huxley formalism and the neuronal calcium dynamics. They are adapted from .
All the fluxes and currents appearing in Table 1, as well the equations describing the dynamics of the gating variables, are given in Table 2. Like for Table 1, these equations are taken from [40, 44–46] except equations (A.35)-(A.37) which are original. All rates and state variables are given per unit cell volume (neuron or astrocyte) or per unit capillary volume to the exception of JGLCce, JLACec, LACe and GLCe that are given per unit extracellular volume. Mitochondrial and cytosolic NADH levels are given per unit mitochondrial or cytosolic volume respectively.
ADPx is given as a function of the ATP concentration (x stands for n or g). It reads: (1) with A = AMPx+ADPx+ATPx = 2.212 mM the total adenine nucleotide concentration and qAK = 0.92 the adenylate kinase equilibrium constant [40, 45]. As a consequence: (2) with ux = q2AK+4·qAK·(A/ATPx-1).
Input to the model
The model receives input from a presynaptic excitatory population. Glutamate released by excitatory presynaptic neurons drives the intracellular sodium concentration in neurons and astrocytes and activates AMPA receptors on neurons, thus inducing a synaptic current Isyn. The presynaptic population contains Nexc excitatory neurons discharging at frequency fexc(t). This presynaptic population thus generates an excitatory conductance gexc(t) given by: (3) with g = 7.8·10-6 mS·cm-2·sec the total surface under the conductance evoked by one excitatory event [47, 48]. The corresponding synaptic current is then given by: (4) with ψn the neuronal membrane voltage and EAMPA = 0 mV the reversal potential of AMPA ionotropic receptors. It is estimated that about two thirds of the current generated at AMPA receptors is due to a flow of sodium ions . Sodium also flows through voltage-dependent sodium channels when the neuron is active (INa). As a consequence, the sodium drive to the neuron is approximated by: (5) with Sm·Vn = 2.5·104 cm-1 the ratio between neuronal membrane surface and neuronal volume and F = 9.64853·104 C·mol-1 the Faraday constant. Finally, the glutamate is cleared from the synaptic cleft by excitatory amino acid transporters located on the astrocyte membrane. Those transporters use the electrochemical sodium gradient to transport glutamate with a stoichiometry of three sodium ions for one glutamate molecule. We thus write the sodium drive to the astrocyte as follows: (6) with ∆glut = 2.25·10-5 mM a constant, which corresponds to the total amount of glutamate released in the synaptic cleft by each presynaptic action potential multiplied by the ratio between synaptic and astrocytic fractional volumes. For the sake of simplicity, we assume that fexc(t) always follows the same temporal dynamics exponentially decaying from f0 = 3.2 Hz to f∞ = 0.5 Hz with a time constant tf = 2.5 sec and Nexc = 1500.
Cerebral blood flow
Following in vivo measurements in rodents [50, 51], the cerebral blood flow is modeled as a piecewise double exponential function delayed in time by t1 relatively to the onset of stimulation t0. It reads: (7) with F0 = 0.012 sec-1 . Typical values are t0 = 0 sec and t0 = 1 sec, tend being the time at which stimulation ends. Two distinct simulation scenarios are considered to mimic in vitro and in vivo conditions. In the in vivo scenario, Equation (7) is used while in the in vitro scenario, the capillary state variables remain constant at their steady-state while the rest of the variables are left free to vary. Our simulations have shown that this is almost equivalent to taking a constant blood flow F(t) = F0.
The blood-oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD) signal is computed following . It is written as a function of the deoxyhemoglobin concentration (dHb) and of the venous volume (Vv): (8) with dimensionless parameters k1 = 2.22, k2 = 0.46 and k3 = 0.43 . The steady-state values of deoxyhemoglobin (dHb0) and venous volume (Vv,0) are given in Table A1.
As noted already by Aubert and colleagues , most models of energy metabolism concentrate on erythrocytes, muscles or other organs such as the liver. It is also not clear whether or not parameters drawn from experiments could be directly injected as such into a model without spatial dimensions and without diffusion processes like ours. To circumvent this problem, we proceeded as follows:
First, we chose target steady-state values for the concentration of metabolites following measures reported in the literature. Specifically, we chose the concentration of intracellular sodium following , the concentration of intracellular glucose, phosphoenolpyruvate, pyruvate, adenosine triphosphate and phosphocreatine following , and glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate following . Finally, the NADH concentration in all four compartments where it appears in the model was chosen following  and calculations based on results by Kasischke and colleagues .
We then optimized a subset of model parameters (see Table 3) by fitting its predictions to the temporal dynamics of NADH fluorescence as measured by Kasischke et al. . Namely, the dynamics of the NADH concentration in various compartments was extracted empirically from Fig. 4D in . Data points were then fitted with sums of exponentials in order to obtain continuous curves. We then optimized the model by minimizing the distance between the temporal dynamics of NADH in the model and the one in the smoothed curve obtained from  using least-square distance as the error measure and using the downhill simplex algorithm. After the optimization converged, we rounded the value of the optimal parameter set and recomputed the steady-state value. All along optimization, we checked that the steady-state was stable by computing its Jacobian matrix (first order approximation) . The parameter set in Table 3 is the set resulting from this procedure.
The simulations were run in MATLAB (The Mathworks, Natick MA, USA). The model was integrated with the ordinary differential equation solver with fixed and optimized parameters (ode15s) that is adapted to stiff systems. We used a time step ∂t = 10-4 sec when the neuron is spiking and ∂t = 1 sec starting one second after the end of presynaptic stimulation. ∂t = 10-4 sec is smaller than the fastest time constant appearing in the Hodgkin-Huxley equations [tauh(-80 mV) = 6.4·10-4 sec]. The second time step (∂t = 1 sec) is small enough for the slow metabolic processes and maintains simulation time and memory usage to reasonable values for an average desktop PC. Simulations take a couple of minutes to execute on a recent laptop.
We developed a model of the coupling between neuronal activity and metabolic response in neurons and astrocytes. The model employed to simulate the neural-glial-vascular (NGV) functional system is composed of four distinct computational units representing a neuron, an astrocyte, a capillary and the extracellular space (Fig. 1). The core of our model is composed of the compartmentalized model of brain energy metabolism recently proposed by Aubert and Costalat [13, 40]. This model connects a model of erythrocyte glycolytic metabolism [45, 56] together with the so-called “Balloon model” of blood flow dynamics . From this starting point, we added a precise description of neuronal membrane excitability formulated within the Hodgkin-Huxley framework . Channels dynamics is drawn from a model proposed by Wang . It includes all the standard Hodgkin-Huxley currents plus a high-threshold calcium current and a calcium-gated potassium current inducing spike-frequency adaptation. The Hodgkin-Huxley model is connected to the metabolic pathways through the electrogenic Na, K-ATPase pump which is responsible for a net outward current and concomitant ATP consumption. We modified the metabolic pathways to include compartmentalization of NADH between the cytosol and mitochondria. To do so, we developed a very simple model of mitochondrial respiration and added NADH malate-aspartate shuttles between the cytosol and mitochondria, drawing inspiration from a model by . Finally, the model is driven by external input modeled as a global excitatory presynaptic activity and coordinated increase of the cerebral blood flow. The presynaptic population is coarsely described through a time-dependent excitatory conductance. This conductance drives sodium flow in neurons through AMPA receptors and action potential-generating voltage-gated sodium channels, and in astrocytes through excitatory amino acid transporters which co-transport glutamate using the sodium gradient. The model is illustrated in Fig. 1 and extensively described in the Methods section.
We first tested the model for its responsiveness to an excitatory stimulus (Fig. 2A) and recorded its voltage response (Fig. 2B). In response to this stimulus, the model generated action potentials within the initial 7 sec of the stimulation. Because of spike-frequency adaptation and of the time course of the excitatory stimulus, the frequency of elicited action potentials quickly decreased until the neuron eventually ceased to fire (Fig. 2B inset). Response trajectories of intracellular sodium, in both the astrocyte (red) and neuron (blue), showed significant differences in both amplitude and duration, with astrocytes exhibiting a smaller but more sustained response and a delayed recovery (Fig. 2C).
A. Time course of the global excitatory conductance simulating the activation of AMPA receptors by the presynaptic population. The gray area denotes the stimulation period. B. Neuronal membrane voltage recorded in response to the excitatory stimulation plotted in A and instantaneous firing rate (inset). C. Sodium concentration in the neuronal cytosol (blue) and in the astrocytic cytosol (red) recorded in response to the excitatory stimulation plotted in A
We then examined the time course of critical intermediates in energy metabolism in response to the same excitatory stimulus. We first focused on the concentration changes of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and phosphocreatine (PCr) in the glial and neuronal compartments (Fig. 3). In both cases, the response to the excitatory stimulation, evidenced as a consumption of these energy rich metabolites, was slower in the astrocytic (red) than in the neuronal compartment (blue) (Fig. 3A). And while the decrease in glial ATP surpassed that seen in the neuron (Fig. 3C), the consumption of PCr predominated in the neuron (Fig. 3B). In both compartments, the resulting decrease in ATP concentration was very limited.
A. Concentration of phosphocreatine (PCr; upper lines at ~5.0 mM) and adenosine triphosphate (ATP; lower lines at ~2.2 mM) in the neuronal (blue) and astrocytic compartments (red) during a 20 sec in vitro stimulation episode (same simulation as in Fig. 2). B. Zoom-in re-scaling of the area of interest in panel A for PCr in neuronal (blue) and astrocytic compartments (red). C. Zoom-in re-scaling of the area of interest in panel A for ATP in neuronal (blue) and astrocytic compartments (red). In panels A, B and C, the gray area denotes the stimulation period
NADH responses evoked in vitro are consistent with the ANLS hypothesis
Next, we examined the trajectories of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) in response to the stimulation in the astrocytic, neuronal and mitochondrial compartments (Fig. 4A). The dashed lines represent experimental data from Kasischke et al. . Fig. 4A shows the temporal evolution of the concentration of NADH in the astrocytic cytosol, in the neuronal mitochondria and averaged over the whole tissue as evoked by a 20 sec stimulation episode (see Methods). All three curves are in excellent quantitative agreement with the results reported by Kasischke et al. . In particular, the NADH concentration in the neuronal mitochondria displays an initial dip of about-10% indicating a strong increase of the oxidative metabolism in neurons (Fig. 4B). It then returns towards its baseline before the presynaptic bombardment has finished and finally slightly overshoots in the poststimulus period. On the contrary, the NADH concentration in the astrocytic cytosol increases significantly only about 10 sec after the onset of the stimulation and displays a long-lasting monophasic behavior. This corresponds to a strong and sustained increase of the glycolysis in this compartment (Fig. 4B).
A. Relative fluctuations of the NADH concentration in the astrocytic cytosol (red), in the neuronal mitochondria (blue) and averaged over the whole tissue (black) as evoked by a 20 sec stimulation episode in vitro (grey area; same simulation as in Fig. 2 and 3). The dotted lines indicate corresponding in vitro data reproduced from Kasischke et al. . B. Oxygen utilization (thick lines) and glucose utilization (thin lines) by neurons (blue) and astrocytes (red) as evoked by the same 20 sec stimulation episode as in A. Glucose utilization is multiplied by 6 to allow a direct comparison to oxygen utilization. C. Net transport of lactate between the four compartments of the model during the same 20 sec stimulation episode as in A. Lactate is exported by the astrocyte to the extracellular space (thick red line) and imported by the neuron from the extracellular space (thick blue line; net import is negative by convention in this model). The thin red line denotes the activity of the lactate dehydrogenase converting pyruvate into lactate in the astrocytic cytosol while the thin blue line denotes the activity of the lactate dehydrogenase converting lactate into pyruvate in the neuronal cytosol (again, the negative sign is a convention). Note how increase in lactate-to-pyruvate conversion precedes the increase in net lactate import by neurons, while pyruvate-to-lactate conversion follows the increase in net lactate export by astrocytes. D. Relative fluctuations of tissue lactate (pink) and of extracellular lactate (black) during the same 20 sec stimulation episode as in A to C. Both lines are superimposed and barely distinguishable
The initial dip in the neuronal mitochondria is the result of consumption of NADH to produce ATP. A recovery and rebound results when NADH is produced from the consumption of lactate imported into the neuronal cytosol from the extracellular space (Fig. 4C). In both Fig. 4B and C, it can be seen that the astrocytic response is slower than the neuronal response. In particular, both oxygen and glucose consumption increase immediately at the beginning of the stimulation in the neuronal compartment. Partially supporting this metabolic activity, neurons immediately start to import lactate from the extracellular space (Fig. 4C). On the contrary, the increase in glucose consumption by astrocytes (Fig. 4B) is more gradual and the increase in lactate export by astrocytes to the extracellular space is slightly delayed (Fig. 4C). The initial release of presynaptic glutamate with subsequent neuronal activity and reuptake into astrocytes lead to the increase in intracellular sodium concentration and activation of the Na, K-ATPase imposing, along with the conversion of glutamate to glutamine in astrocytes, an increased metabolic demand. However, as can be seen in Fig. 2C, the increase in intracellular sodium is slower and more gradual in the astrocytic compartment leading to the 10 second delay in the glial cell metabolic response to the stimulation. Finally, the dynamics of tissue NADH (Fig. 4A) is mirrored in the predicted tissue and extracellular lactate concentrations (Fig. 4D).
The utilization of glucose and oxygen by neurons and astrocytes during this 20 sec stimulation episode is shown in Fig. 4B. For model optimization, we imposed that the largest fraction of glucose goes to astrocytes while the largest fraction of oxygen goes to neurons . We observed that this bias is further increased during stimulation. The neuronal oxygen utilization immediately increased at the onset of stimulation in register with the initial dip of the NADH in the neuronal mitochondria. This is consistent with reports that the astrocytic fraction of glucose utilization increases during stimulation .
The biophysical model correctly predicts rodent in vivo oxygen and lactate evoked responses
One of the hallmarks of a successful model is its ability to reproduce and explain empirical observations. We thus now turn to an in vivo situation and compare the predictions of the mathematical model we designed in the precedent sections to two experiments carried out in rats. Tissue oxygen and lactate during stimulus (Fig. 5B and C), and lactate transfer between compartments were compared (Fig. 5D).
A. Temporal evolution of the cerebral blood flow chosen as an input to the model during a simulated 60 sec stimulation episode in vivo (grey area). This specific time course closely matches measurements in rodents during functional forepaw or whisker stimulation [50, 51]. Note that the blood flow only significantly increases approximately 1 sec after the onset of activation (inset). B. Relative fluctuations of the intra-parenchymal oxygen concentration as evoked by a 60 sec stimulation episode with the blood flow as in A. These results closely match the experimental results of Ances et al.  (their Fig. 1). C. Relative fluctuations of tissue lactate (pink line) and of extracellular lactate (black line) during the same 60 sec stimulation episode as in A to B. These results closely match the experimental results of Hu and Wilson  (their Fig. 1). D. Net transport of lactate between the four compartments of the model during the same 60 sec stimulation episode as in A to C. Like in the in vitro case (Fig. 4), lactate is exported by the astrocyte to the extracellular space (thick red line) and imported by the neuron from the extracellular space (thick blue line; net import is negative by convention in this model). A small amount of lactate is exported from the extracellular space to the capillary at baseline and this export increases by 69% after the end of the stimulation (pink line). The thin red line denotes the activity of the lactate dehydrogenase converting pyruvate into lactate in the astrocytic cytosol while the thin blue line denotes the activity of the lactate dehydrogenase converting lactate into pyruvate in the neuronal cytosol (again, the negative sign is a convention)
Upon stimulation, CBF increases after a delay of ~1 sec (see Equation 7), quickly peaks before relaxing to an elevated plateau. This pattern matches neurovascular responses observed in rodents in response to sustained sensory stimulation (for instance by mechanical activation of the whiskers [50, 51] (Fig. 5A)). The 1 sec delay seen in panel A is hardcoded in the model (see Equation 7). This matches our own observations that CBF only starts to increase above its baseline ~0.5–1 sec after the onset of stimulation [51, 59].
Because neuronal activity slightly precedes functional hyperemia, the oxygen concentration initially dips below its resting value before rising as cerebral blood flow finally increases after the 1 sec delay (Fig. 5B inset). The dip in oxygen below baseline levels after stimulation has ceased reflects the rapid decrease in the replenishment rate by blood at a time when oxygen is still consumed to replenish the ATP that is used to fuel the Na, K-ATPase pump.
Extracellular lactate is consumed throughout the stimulation. Its concentration initially dips until the cerebral blood flow increases and leads to a sustained overproduction of lactate (Fig. 5C). At rest, the astrocytic compartment exports lactate to the extracellular space, part of which is taken up by the neuronal compartment for energy production (Fig. 5D), the rest being exported to the circulation. Upon stimulation, export of extracellular lactate to the circulation is reduced while import into neurons is increased. Export of lactate to the extracellular space by the astrocytic compartment is also increased but with a delay and explains the initial dip in concentration. In the recovery period, all transports slowly return back to their baseline values explaining the long lasting overshoot of extracellular and tissue lactate. Export of extracellular lactate to the circulation is durably increased in the recovery period (Fig. 5D; pink line).
Fig. 5 shows results of simulations independent from the simulations that yielded Fig. 2 to 4 where the model was constrained to reproduce the experimental results from ref. . In these new simulations, not only is the temporal course of tissue oxygen qualitatively predicted, but the amplitude of fluctuations is, to some extent, quantitatively predicted as well. Our model predicts that the oxygen pressure first drops by -1.7% (inset), then overshoots at +17.7% before stabilizing 2.4% above its baseline in the last 20 sec of the stimulation. Finally, it undershoots to -2.6% in the post-stimulus period. These figures are to be compared with the values reported by , namely, an initial drop at -1.8%, an overshoot at +19.9%, a stabilization 1.7% above the baseline and a final undershoot at -3.1%.
The consumption of lactate closely tracks the stimulation dependent oxygen consumption but lacks the inflections corresponding to CBF changes as it is less affected by the blood flow (Fig. 5D). Lactate is exported by the astrocyte to the extracellular space (thick red line) and imported by the neuron from the extracellular space (thick blue line; net import is negative by convention in this model). A small amount of lactate is exported from the extracellular space to the capillary at baseline and this export increases by 69% after the end of the stimulation (pink line). The thin red line denotes the activity of the lactate dehydrogenase converting pyruvate into lactate in the astrocytic cytosol while the thin blue line denotes the activity of the lactate dehydrogenase converting lactate into pyruvate in the neuronal cytosol (again, the negative sign is a convention). These net transfers all contribute to the evolution of the tissue and extracellular lactate concentrations (Fig. 5C). This prediction closely matches the experimental results of Hu and Wilson  (their Fig. 1).
The biophysical model correctly predicts human glucose and oxygen utilization during brain activation
We then compared new simulations to measurements from human subjects [26, 52, 60]. As in Fig. 5, the neurovascular response was adapted from experimental measurements (Fig. 6A). Simulated levels of lactate (Fig. 6B), the cerebral metabolic rate for glucose (Fig. 6C), the cerebral metabolic rate for oxygen (Fig. 6D), the ratio of cerebral uptake of O2 to cerebral uptake of glucose (Oxygen-Glucose Index or OGI) (Fig. 6E), as well as the blood-oxygen-level dependent signal (Fig. 6F) all supported a validation of the model.
A. Temporal evolution of the cerebral blood flow chosen as an input to the model during a simulated 900 sec stimulation episode in vivo (grey area). This specific time course closely matches in vivo measurements in humans during imaging experiments [52, 60]. B. Relative fluctuations of tissue lactate concentration during the same stimulation episode as in A. The model predicts an initial lactate dip followed by a 60% increase sustained till the end of the stimulation. The presence of a dip matches experimental data from Mangia et al. . C and D. Cerebral metabolic rate of glucose consumption (CMRglc) and cerebral metabolic rate of oxygen consumption (CMRO2) during the same 900 sec stimulation episode as in A to B. In both cases, the light area corresponds to the contribution of the astrocytic compartment towards the total tissue consumption, while the dark area corresponds to the contribution of the neuronal compartment. While glucose consumption increases by about 40%, the increase is mostly due to the astrocytic compartment (light red) with the neuronal glucose utilization even slightly decreasing at the onset of activation (dark red). On the contrary, while oxygen utilization increases by about 10%, most of this increase is due to the neuronal compartment (dark blue) with the astrocytic oxygen utilization being almost constant (light blue). E. The predicted ratio of CMRO2 to CMRglc or oxygen-glucose index (OGI) during the same 900 sec stimulation episode as in A to D. F. Predicted BOLD signal for the same 900 sec stimulation episode as in A to E. Like the tissue lactate concentration (B), the BOLD shows a clear dip at the onset of activation
The model qualitatively and to some extent quantitatively predicted well-known features of these various macroscopic observables, including the BOLD signal [52, 60], despite extrapolation from multiple sources. For instance, after an initial dip , the tissue lactate concentration reached a plateau that last until the end of the stimulation . The initial dip in extracellular lactate (Fig. 6B inset) is representative of a surge in lactate consumption at the beginning of neural activity, and a symptom of the intrinsic latency in the start-up of the ANLS and of functional hyperaemia. The time lag between the onset and offset of neuronal activation and the onset and offset of CBF also explain other transients such as the slow recovery of the lactate concentration after the cessation of neural activity . Relative increase in glucose and oxygen consumption also matched experimental results and led to a decreased OGI during stimulation .
There is mounting evidence in support of a metabolic link between neurons and glial cells. The most prominent experimentally-based conceptual model of neuron-glia metabolic coupling, the astrocyte-neuron lactate shuttle (ANLS), has raised controversies, not so much for the proposed energy-dependent link between the two cell types, but because certain details and mechanisms are debated [11, 62]. Although experimental evidence gathered over the last two decades largely supports it , experimentally untangling this system is challenging.
Our detailed biophysical model of the NGV ensemble expands on previous models in four distinct ways. First, a shuttling of lactate from astrocytes to neurons emerged in response to activation. Second, the model is consistent with increased neuronal oxidative metabolism and delayed increased astrocytic glycolysis for generating the activity-dependent NADH transients. Third, the model correctly predicts the dynamics of tissue lactate and oxygen as observed in vivo in rats. Fourth, the model correctly predicts with good quantitative precision the temporal dynamics of tissue lactate, CMRglc, CMRO2 and of the BOLD signal as reported in human studies. These findings not only support the ANLS hypothesis but also provide a quantitative mathematical description of the metabolic activation in neurons and astrocytes, as well as the macroscopic measurements obtained with brain imaging techniques.
The blood oxygen-level dependent (BOLD) signal which forms the basis of the functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) technology reports fluctuations in brain activity, the molecular and cellular mechanisms of which are still incompletely understood [8, 63]. Although somewhat limited in representing detailed processes, our use of the Buxton model was sufficient to correctly predict known features of the BOLD signal (Fig. 6F). Ultimately, modeling efforts that build on our work will have to include more detailed descriptions of blood flow regulation. For instance, blood flow regulation in the brain was recently suggested to happen in the microvasculature at the capillary level by active dilation of pericytes . Subsequent efforts will need to focus on the daunting task of modeling the numerous pathways that relate neuronal activity to functional hyperaemia .
Recent modeling of the neuron-astrocyte cross-talk during oscillations linked to blood oxygenation levels verified the possibility that the slow fMRI BOLD signals might reflect the spontaneous ongoing activity of neuroglial networks . Our results support this view by accurately modeling results from human imaging experiments [52, 60]. A course for future modeling will be to examine and model data from multi-modal imaging experiments .
As noted in the introduction, controversy surrounds the directionality of lactate flow in the brain with a neuron-to-astrocyte direction proposed by some. Here, following the arguments delineated in Jolivet et al. , we imposed that the largest fraction of glucose should go to astrocytes (there is no controversy that neurons are responsible for the vast majority of oxygen consumption). We derive confidence in our model from the fact that it correctly predicts a vast array of in vivo experimental findings while being only loosely constrained by in vitro experimental findings and by the imposed compartmentalization of glucose uptake between neurons and astrocytes. As argued in Jolivet et al. , metabolic shuttling between the astrocytic and neuronal compartments originates from the imbalance between the high oxygen consumption of neurons and their limited glucose utilization for ATP production purposes. Unlike astrocytes, neurons are unable to up-regulate their rate of glycolysis in response to increased activity due to constitutive inhibition of the rate limiting glycolytic enzyme Pfkfb3 (6-phosphofructo-2-kinase/fructose-2, 6-bisphosphatase 3) . This mechanism is crucial to neuronal defenses against reactive oxygen species. Additional in vitro mechanisms support that compartmentalization includes the existence of glutamate-induced glycolysis in astrocytes [5, 69], glutamate-induced inhibition of glucose transport in neurons  and the involvement of extracellular increases in potassium inducing an Na, K-ATPase-dependent activation of glycolysis in astrocytes . However, it is to be noted that if the proportion of glucose directly taken up by neurons was to be increased, the astrocyte-to-neuron lactate shuttle would be reduced in amplitude, and its direction eventually reversed if neurons were consuming glucose in excess of what they oxidize (see  for further discussion of this question).
Metabolic phenotypes have been suggested that convey a metabolic identity depending on how they utilize the various oxidative and non-oxidative pathways . The re-equilibration of the constituents of extracellular space, a process involving physical flushing mediated by astrocytes, is also now thought to be one of the key housekeeping functions of sleep  and the disruption of normal metabolic processes is suggested to underlie the progression of neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer’s . Lactate, whether sourced from glia or plasma, is associated with neuroprotection [32–34]. Assuming the ANLS is indeed taking place, we are left to question: What is it good for?
Neurons do not appear to suffer functional consequences as a result of their metabolic peculiarities. Lactate can sustain prolonged firing in neurons more efficiently than glucose in culture and can preferentially support activity in both resting and active states in vitro and in vivo [30, 31, 74]. Recently, it was shown in the subfornical organ that this pathway can also affect the dynamics of the local neural network by modulating the excitability of GABAergic neurons through the regulation of ATP-dependent potassium channels . It is not necessary perhaps to preclude the use of glucose by both neurons and glia under certain circumstances as has been suggested by a computational model studying the ATP supply to neurons under hypoxic conditions , and as is indeed suggested by our own results (see Fig. 4B, 5D and 6C). Finally, extracellular lactate might also act as a messenger to the vasculature  and it is thus possible that the ANLS plays a role as one of the pathways regulating functional hyperaemia.
Astrocytes also support memory formation by supplying neurons with lactate . So central is the ANLS to the normal function of the brain that learning, as measured by LTP and long term memory formation in the hippocampus of rats, is abolished by interfering with the transport of lactate from astrocytes to neurons . Consistent with those findings, lactate, but not glucose, has been show to induce the expression of plasticity genes such as Arc, Zif 268 and BDNF in vitro in neurons and in vivo . Further, the mechanism by which glucose enhances memory storage has been shown to involve the neuronal consumption of lactate .
We present here the first temporal multi-scale model of the NGV that accurately reflects experimental observations in multiple settings and organisms. These findings not only support the ANLS hypothesis but also provide a quantitative mathematical description of the metabolic activation in neurons and astrocytes, as well as of the macroscopic measurements obtained with functional brain imaging techniques.
We thank Daniel Keller, Heikki Lehväslaiho, Corrado Cali and Felix Schürmann for comments on earlier versions of this manuscript.
Conceived and designed the experiments: RJ IA PJM. Performed the experiments: RJ. Analyzed the data: RJ IA. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: PJM. Wrote the paper: RJ JSC.
- 1. Mlynárik V, McKenna MC (2013) Early impairment in brain metabolism detected by MR spectroscopy antedates structural changes in mouse models of spinocerebellar ataxias. J Neurochem 127(5): 578–9.
- 2. Harris JJ, Jolivet R, Attwell D (2012) Synaptic energy use and supply. Neuron 75: 762–777. pmid:22958818
- 3. Anderson CM, Swanson RA (2000) Astrocyte glutamate transport: review of properties, regulation, and physiological functions. Glia 32: 1–14. pmid:10975906
- 4. Cornell-Bell AH, Finkbeiner SM, Cooper MS, Smith SJ (1990) Glutamate induces calcium waves in cultured astrocytes: long-range glial signaling. Science 247: 470–473. pmid:1967852
- 5. Pellerin L, Magistretti PJ (1994) Glutamate uptake into astrocytes stimulates aerobic glycolysis: a mechanism coupling neuronal activity to glucose utilization. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 91: 10625–10629. pmid:7938003
- 6. Bergersen LH (2007) Is lactate food for neurons? Comparison of monocarboxylate transporter subtypes in brain and muscle. Neuroscience 145: 11–19. pmid:17218064
- 7. Barros LF (2013) Metabolic signaling by lactate in the brain. Trends Neurosci 36: 396–404. pmid:23639382
- 8. Magistretti PJ, Pellerin L (1999) Cellular mechanisms of brain energy metabolism and their relevance to functional brain imaging. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 354: 1155–1163. pmid:10466143
- 9. Mangia S, Simpson IA, Vannucci SJ, Carruthers A (2009) The in vivo neuron-to-astrocyte lactate shuttle in human brain: evidence from modeling of measured lactate levels during visual stimulation. J Neurochem 109 Suppl 1: 55–62.
- 10. Simpson IA, Carruthers A, Vannucci SJ (2007) Supply and demand in cerebral energy metabolism: the role of nutrient transporters. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 27: 1766–1791. pmid:17579656
- 11. Pellerin L, Magistretti PJ (2012) Sweet sixteen for ANLS. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 32: 1152–1166. pmid:22027938
- 12. Aubert A, Costalat R, Magistretti PJ, Pellerin L (2005) Brain lactate kinetics: Modeling evidence for neuronal lactate uptake upon activation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 102: 16448–16453. pmid:16260743
- 13. Aubert A, Pellerin L, Magistretti PJ, Costalat R (2007) A coherent neurobiological framework for functional neuroimaging provided by a model integrating compartmentalized energy metabolism. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 4188–4193. pmid:17360498
- 14. Neves A, Costalat R, Pellerin L (2012) Determinants of brain cell metabolic phenotypes and energy substrate utilization unraveled with a modeling approach. PLoS Comput Biol 8: e1002686. pmid:23028284
- 15. Cloutier M, Bolger FB, Lowry JP, Wellstead P (2009) An integrative dynamic model of brain energy metabolism using in vivo neurochemical measurements. J Comput Neurosci 27: 391–414. pmid:19396534
- 16. Hu Y, Wilson GS (1997) A temporary local energy pool coupled to neuronal activity: fluctuations of extracellular lactate levels in rat brain monitored with rapid-response enzyme-based sensor. J Neurochem 69: 1484–1490. pmid:9326277
- 17. Mangia S, Garreffa G, Bianciardi M, Giove F, Di Salle F, et al. (2003) The aerobic brain: lactate decrease at the onset of neural activity. Neuroscience 118: 7–10. pmid:12676131
- 18. Pierre K, Pellerin L (2005) Monocarboxylate transporters in the central nervous system: distribution, regulation and function. J Neurochem 94: 1–14. pmid:15953344
- 19. Chuquet J, Quilichini P, Nimchinsky EA, Buzsáki G (2010) Predominant enhancement of glucose uptake in astrocytes versus neurons during activation of the somatosensory cortex. J Neurosci 30: 15298–15303. pmid:21068334
- 20. Véga C, Martiel J-L, Drouhault D, Burckhart M-F, Coles JA (2003) Uptake of locally applied deoxyglucose, glucose and lactate by axons and Schwann cells of rat vagus nerve. J Physiol 546: 551–564. pmid:12527741
- 21. Thompson JK, Peterson MR, Freeman RD (2003) Single-neuron activity and tissue oxygenation in the cerebral cortex. Science 299: 1070–1072. pmid:12586942
- 22. Malonek D, Grinvald A (1996) Interactions between electrical activity and cortical microcirculation revealed by imaging spectroscopy: implications for functional brain mapping. Science 272: 551–554. pmid:8614805
- 23. Kasischke KA, Vishwasrao HD, Fisher PJ, Zipfel WR, Webb WW (2004) Neural activity triggers neuronal oxidative metabolism followed by astrocytic glycolysis. Science 305: 99–103. pmid:15232110
- 24. Brennan AM, Connor JA, Shuttleworth CW (2006) NAD(P)H fluorescence transients after synaptic activity in brain slices: predominant role of mitochondrial function. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 26: 1389–1406. pmid:16538234
- 25. Hertz L, Peng L, Dienel GA (2007) Energy metabolism in astrocytes: high rate of oxidative metabolism and spatiotemporal dependence on glycolysis/glycogenolysis. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 27: 219–249. pmid:16835632
- 26. Fox PT, Raichle ME, Mintun MA, Dence C (1988) Nonoxidative glucose consumption during focal physiologic neural activity. Science 241: 462–464. pmid:3260686
- 27. Prichard J, Rothman D, Novotny E, Petroff O, Kuwabara T, et al. (1991) Lactate rise detected by 1H NMR in human visual cortex during physiologic stimulation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 88: 5829–5831. pmid:2062861
- 28. Gordon GRJ, Choi HB, Rungta RL, Ellis-Davies GCR, MacVicar BA (2008) Brain metabolism dictates the polarity of astrocyte control over arterioles. Nature 456: 745–749. pmid:18971930
- 29. Lauritzen KH, Morland C, Puchades M, Holm-Hansen S, Hagelin EM, et al. (2014) Lactate receptor sites link neurotransmission, neurovascular coupling, and brain energy metabolism. Cereb Cortex 24: 2784–2795.
- 30. Bouzier-Sore A-K, Voisin P, Canioni P, Magistretti PJ, Pellerin L (2003) Lactate is a preferential oxidative energy substrate over glucose for neurons in culture. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 23: 1298–1306. pmid:14600437
- 31. Bouzier-Sore A-K, Voisin P, Bouchaud V, Bezancon E, Franconi J-M, et al. (2006) Competition between glucose and lactate as oxidative energy substrates in both neurons and astrocytes: a comparative NMR study. Eur J Neurosci 24: 1687–1694. pmid:17004932
- 32. Wyss MT, Jolivet R, Buck A, Magistretti PJ, Weber B (2011) In vivo evidence for lactate as a neuronal energy source. J Neurosci 31: 7477–7485. pmid:21593331
- 33. Berthet C, Lei H, Thevenet J, Gruetter R, Magistretti PJ, et al. (2009) Neuroprotective role of lactate after cerebral ischemia. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 29: 1780–1789. pmid:19675565
- 34. Ros J, Pecinska N, Alessandri B, Landolt H, Fillenz M (2001) Lactate reduces glutamate-induced neurotoxicity in rat cortex. J Neurosci Res 66: 790–794. pmid:11746403
- 35. Lam TKT, Gutierrez-Juarez R, Pocai A, Rossetti L (2005) Regulation of blood glucose by hypothalamic pyruvate metabolism. Science 309: 943–947. pmid:16081739
- 36. Shimizu H, Watanabe E, Hiyama TY, Nagakura A, Fujikawa A, et al. (2007) Glial Nax channels control lactate signaling to neurons for brain [Na+] sensing. Neuron 54: 59–72. pmid:17408578
- 37. Chih CP, Lipton P, Roberts EL Jr (2001) Do active cerebral neurons really use lactate rather than glucose? Trends Neurosci 24: 573–578. pmid:11576670
- 38. Dienel GA, Cruz NF (2003) Neighborly interactions of metabolically-activated astrocytes in vivo. Neurochem Int 43: 339–354. pmid:12742078
- 39. Jolivet R, Magistretti PJ, Weber B (2009) Deciphering neuron-glia compartmentalization in cortical energy metabolism. Front Neuroenergetics 1: 4. pmid:19636395
- 40. Aubert A, Costalat R (2005) Interaction between astrocytes and neurons studied using a mathematical model of compartmentalized energy metabolism. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 25: 1476–1490. pmid:15931164
- 41. DiNuzzo M, Mangia S, Maraviglia B, Giove F (2010) Changes in glucose uptake rather than lactate shuttle take center stage in subserving neuroenergetics: evidence from mathematical modeling. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 30: 586–602. pmid:19888285
- 42. Jolivet R, Allaman I, Pellerin L, Magistretti PJ, Weber B (2010) Comment on recent modeling studies of astrocyte-neuron metabolic interactions. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 30: 1982–1986. pmid:20700131
- 43. Jolivet R, Lewis TJ, Gerstner W (2004) Generalized integrate-and-fire models of neuronal activity approximate spike trains of a detailed model to a high degree of accuracy. J Neurophysiol 92: 959–976. pmid:15277599
- 44. Wang XJ (1998) Calcium coding and adaptive temporal computation in cortical pyramidal neurons. J Neurophysiol 79: 1549–1566. pmid:9497431
- 45. Heinrich R (1996) The regulation of cellular systems. New York: Chapman & Hall. 372 p.
- 46. Buxton RB, Wong EC, Frank LR (1998) Dynamics of blood flow and oxygenation changes during brain activation: the balloon model. Magn Reson Med Med 39: 855–864.
- 47. Destexhe A, Paré D (1999) Impact of network activity on the integrative properties of neocortical pyramidal neurons in vivo. J Neurophysiol 81: 1531–1547. pmid:10200189
- 48. Häusser M, Roth A (1997) Estimating the time course of the excitatory synaptic conductance in neocortical pyramidal cells using a novel voltage jump method. J Neurosci 17: 7606–7625. pmid:9315883
- 49. Attwell D, Laughlin SB (2001) An energy budget for signaling in the grey matter of the brain. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 21: 1133–1145. pmid:11598490
- 50. Ances BM, Buerk DG, Greenberg JH, Detre JA (2001) Temporal dynamics of the partial pressure of brain tissue oxygen during functional forepaw stimulation in rats. Neurosci Lett 306: 106–110. pmid:11403969
- 51. Calcinaghi N, Jolivet R, Wyss MT, Ametamey SM, Gasparini F, et al. (2011) Metabotropic glutamate receptor mGluR5 is not involved in the early hemodynamic response. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 31: e1–e10. pmid:21731033
- 52. Obata T, Liu TT, Miller KL, Luh WM, Wong EC, et al. (2004) Discrepancies between BOLD and flow dynamics in primary and supplementary motor areas: application of the balloon model to the interpretation of BOLD transients. NeuroImage 21: 144–153. pmid:14741651
- 53. Aubert A, Costalat R, Valabrègue R (2001) Modelling of the coupling between brain electrical activity and metabolism. Acta Biotheor 49: 301–326. pmid:11804241
- 54. Rose CR, Ransom BR (1997) Regulation of intracellular sodium in cultured rat hippocampal neurones. J Physiol 499 (Pt 3): 573–587. pmid:9130155
- 55. Gjedde A (2007) 4.5 Coupling of Brain Function to Metabolism: Evaluation of Energy Requirements. In: Lajtha A, Gibson GE, Dienel GA, editors. Handbook of Neurochemistry and Molecular Neurobiology. Boston, MA: Springer US. pp. 343–400. Available: http://link.springer.com/10.1007/978–0–387–30411–3_14. Accessed 20 October 2014.
- 56. Joshi A, Palsson BO (1990) Metabolic dynamics in the human red cell. Part IV--Data prediction and some model computations. J Theor Biol 142: 69–85.
- 57. Hodgkin AL, Huxley AF (1952) Propagation of electrical signals along giant nerve fibers. Proc R Soc Lond Ser B Contain Pap Biol Character R Soc G B 140: 177–183.
- 58. Gadea A, López-Colomé AM (2001) Glial transporters for glutamate, glycine, and GABA III. Glycine transporters. J Neurosci Res 64: 218–222.
- 59. Calcinaghi N, Wyss MT, Jolivet R, Singh A, Keller AL, et al. (2013) Multimodal imaging in rats reveals impaired neurovascular coupling in sustained hypertension. Stroke J Cereb Circ 44: 1957–1964.
- 60. Nakai T, Matsuo K, Kato C, Takehara Y, Isoda H, et al. (2000) Post-stimulus response in hemodynamics observed by functional magnetic resonance imaging--difference between the primary sensorimotor area and the supplementary motor area. Magn Reson Imaging 18: 1215–1219. pmid:11167041
- 61. Mangia S, Tkác I, Gruetter R, Van de Moortele P-F, Maraviglia B, et al. (2007) Sustained neuronal activation raises oxidative metabolism to a new steady-state level: evidence from 1H NMR spectroscopy in the human visual cortex. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 27: 1055–1063. pmid:17033694
- 62. Pellerin L, Bouzier-Sore A-K, Aubert A, Serres S, Merle M, et al. (2007) Activity-dependent regulation of energy metabolism by astrocytes: an update. Glia 55: 1251–1262. pmid:17659524
- 63. Fox MD, Raichle ME (2007) Spontaneous fluctuations in brain activity observed with functional magnetic resonance imaging. Nat Rev Neurosci 8: 700–711. pmid:17704812
- 64. Hall CN, Reynell C, Gesslein B, Hamilton NB, Mishra A, et al. (2014) Capillary pericytes regulate cerebral blood flow in health and disease. Nature 508: 55–60. pmid:24670647
- 65. Attwell D, Buchan AM, Charpak S, Lauritzen M, Macvicar BA, et al. (2010) Glial and neuronal control of brain blood flow. Nature 468: 232–243. pmid:21068832
- 66. DiNuzzo M, Gili T, Maraviglia B, Giove F (2011) Modeling the contribution of neuron-astrocyte cross talk to slow blood oxygenation level-dependent signal oscillations. J Neurophysiol 106: 3010–3018. pmid:21917999
- 67. Hyder F, Renken R, Kennan RP, Rothman DL (2000) Quantitative multi-modal functional MRI with blood oxygenation level dependent exponential decays adjusted for flow attenuated inversion recovery (BOLDED AFFAIR). Magn Reson Imaging 18: 227–235. pmid:10745130
- 68. Herrero-Mendez A, Almeida A, Fernández E, Maestre C, Moncada S, et al. (2009) The bioenergetic and antioxidant status of neurons is controlled by continuous degradation of a key glycolytic enzyme by APC/C-Cdh1. Nat Cell Biol 11: 747–752. pmid:19448625
- 69. Pellerin L, Magistretti PJ (1997) Glutamate uptake stimulates Na+, K+-ATPase activity in astrocytes via activation of a distinct subunit highly sensitive to ouabain. J Neurochem 69: 2132–2137. pmid:9349559
- 70. Porras OH, Loaiza A, Barros LF (2004) Glutamate mediates acute glucose transport inhibition in hippocampal neurons. J Neurosci 24: 9669–9673. pmid:15509754
- 71. Ruminot I, Gutiérrez R, Peña-Münzenmayer G, Añazco C, Sotelo-Hitschfeld T, et al. (2011) NBCe1 mediates the acute stimulation of astrocytic glycolysis by extracellular K+. J Neurosci 31: 14264–14271. pmid:21976511
- 72. Xie L, Kang H, Xu Q, Chen MJ, Liao Y, et al. (2013) Sleep Drives Metabolite Clearance from the Adult Brain. Science 342: 373–377. pmid:24136970
- 73. Demetrius LA, Simon DK (2012) An inverse-Warburg effect and the origin of Alzheimer’s disease. Biogerontology 13: 583–594. pmid:23086530
- 74. Bouzier-Sore A-K, Merle M, Magistretti PJ, Pellerin L (2002) Feeding active neurons: (re)emergence of a nursing role for astrocytes. J Physiol Paris 96: 273–282. pmid:12445906
- 75. Genc S, Kurnaz IA, Ozilgen M (2011) Astrocyte-neuron lactate shuttle may boost more ATP supply to the neuron under hypoxic conditions--in silico study supported by in vitro expression data. BMC Syst Biol 5: 162. pmid:21995951
- 76. Suzuki A, Stern SA, Bozdagi O, Huntley GW, Walker RH, et al. (2011) Astrocyte-neuron lactate transport is required for long-term memory formation. Cell 144: 810–823. pmid:21376239
- 77. Yang J, Ruchti E, Petit J-M, Jourdain P, Grenningloh G, et al. (2014) Lactate promotes plasticity gene expression by potentiating NMDA signaling in neurons. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 111: 12228–12233. pmid:25071212
- 78. Newman LA, Korol DL, Gold PE (2011) Lactate produced by glycogenolysis in astrocytes regulates memory processing. PloS One 6: e28427. pmid:22180782