This is an uncorrected proof.
Calmodulin sits at the center of molecular mechanisms underlying learning and memory. Its complex and sometimes opposite influences, mediated via the binding to various proteins, are yet to be fully understood. Calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII) and calcineurin (CaN) both bind open calmodulin, favoring Long-Term Potentiation (LTP) or Depression (LTD) respectively. Neurogranin binds to the closed conformation of calmodulin and its impact on synaptic plasticity is less clear. We set up a mechanistic computational model based on allosteric principles to simulate calmodulin state transitions and its interactions with calcium ions and the three binding partners mentioned above. We simulated calcium spikes at various frequencies and show that neurogranin regulates synaptic plasticity along three modalities. At low spike frequencies, neurogranin inhibits the onset of LTD by limiting CaN activation. At intermediate frequencies, neurogranin facilitates LTD, but limits LTP by precluding binding of CaMKII with calmodulin. Finally, at high spike frequencies, neurogranin promotes LTP by enhancing CaMKII autophosphorylation. While neurogranin might act as a calmodulin buffer, it does not significantly preclude the calmodulin opening by calcium. On the contrary, neurogranin synchronizes the opening of calmodulin’s two lobes and promotes their activation at specific frequencies. Neurogranin suppresses basal CaN activity, thus increasing the chance of CaMKII trans-autophosphorylation at high-frequency calcium spikes. Taken together, our study reveals dynamic regulatory roles played by neurogranin on synaptic plasticity, which provide mechanistic explanations for opposing experimental findings.
How our brains learn and remember things lies in the subtle changes of the strength of the connections between brain cells, the so-called synaptic plasticity. At the level of the recipient neuron, some of the information is encoded into patterns of intracellular calcium spikes. Calmodulin, a small bi-lobed protein whose conformation is regulated by the binding of calcium ions, decodes these signals and modulates the activity of specific binding partners. Two key regulators, calcineurin and calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II, which respectively weakens or strengthens synaptic connections, bind both lobes of calmodulin in its open form, stabilized by calcium. On the contrary, neurogranin binds preferentially to one lobe of calmodulin when in the closed form, destabilized by calcium. It was thus initially suggested that neurogranin would inhibit calmodulin activation and decrease synaptic plasticity. However, past research showed that neurogranin sometimes actually enhances synaptic plasticity, though the mechanism was unclear. Our computational models showed that neurogranin synchronizes the activation of the two lobes of calmodulin, favoring opening at high-frequency calcium spikes. By doing so, neurogranin increases the impact of calmodulin on calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II and reduces its effect on calcineurin, resulting in a strengthening of synaptic connections.
Citation: Li L, Lai M, Cole S, Le Novère N, Edelstein SJ (2020) Neurogranin stimulates Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent kinase II by suppressing calcineurin activity at specific calcium spike frequencies. PLoS Comput Biol 16(2): e1006991. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1006991
Editor: Joanna Jędrzejewska-Szmek, Instytut Biologii Doswiadczalnej im M Nenckiego Polskiej Akademii Nauk, POLAND
Received: March 29, 2019; Accepted: November 18, 2019; Published: February 12, 2020
Copyright: © 2020 Li et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: Computational model has been submitted to BioModels. This model has been assigned the following submission identifier: MODEL1903010001. This model has also been submitted as S1 File.
Funding: LL was supported by the EU Commission grant 305299-AgedBrainSYSBIO (https://cordis.europa.eu/project/rcn/105858/factsheet/en). NL and LL were supported by the BBSRC grants BBS/E/B/000C0419 and BB/P013384/1 (https://bbsrc.ukri.org/). ML was supported by the EU Commission grant 242167-SynSys (http://synsys.eu/). SC was supported by the Amgen Scholars programme (https://amgenscholars.com/). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors declare that their employments to aSciStance Ltd and Scipio bioscience do not bring any competing interest to the findings in this publication. The authors also declare that there is no competing interest associated with their employment, any consultancy they may have carried out, any patents they may hold, any products in development or marketed products they have been involved in, etc.
Calmodulin (CaM) is a small ubiquitous calcium-binding protein whose cellular activity is mediated via the binding of a large array of target proteins. CaM comprises two lobes, each binding two calcium ions, that can undergo transitions between a closed (T) and an open (R) conformation. Calcium binding shifts the transition towards the open form [1, 2]. Some CaM-binding proteins favor the open conformation while others tend to bind to the closed conformation [3–8].
In neurons, CaM plays a crucial role in mediating calcium regulation of synaptic plasticity, a mechanism underlying learning and memory. Among its main binding partners, Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII) and calcineurin (CaN) preferably bind to the open (R) form of CaM, and compete to facilitate long-term potentiation(LTP) or long-term depression (LTD) respectively [2, 9, 10]. On the contrary, neurogranin (Ng), an IQ domain-containing protein, binds preferentially to the closed (T) state, therefore sequestering CaM from its other targets in the absence of calcium [11–13]. Ng’s role in the regulation of synaptic plasticity is still under debate. Ng seems to facilitate LTP induction at high frequency electrical pulses [14–18]. However, it has also been reported to produce the opposite effect . Deciphering the mechanisms underlying Ng’s opposing functions, and how Ng coordinates the activities of CaMKII and CaN in response to calcium signals, are crucial for understanding how CaM regulates brain function and dysfunction.
Although structurally similar, the two CaM lobes display different properties. The carboxy-terminal (C) lobe possesses higher calcium binding affinities but slow kinetics while the amino-terminal (N) lobe has lower calcium binding affinities but faster binding kinetics [6, 20–23]. In addition, the lobes exhibit a significant degree of structural autonomy [24, 25]. CaM lobes undergo constant transitions between the open and closed conformations, transitions regulated by the binding of both calcium ions and target proteins. The key to understanding CaM function lies in the mechanisms underlying the differential activation of its targets and how binding these targets feeds back to its conformational changes.
The two lobes contribute unevenly to target binding. Targets binding preferentially to the closed state, especially Ng, interact predominantly with the C lobe [5, 7, 13, 26–28]. Whereas targets binding preferentially to the open state, such as CaMKII and CaN, contact both domains [4, 6, 8, 29, 30]. Accordingly, binding these targets affects differentially the conformational shifts of both lobes, as indicated by the modification of apparent calcium binding affinities [5, 6, 21, 26]. Targets stabilize the conformation for which they have the highest affinity (i.e. the complexes have the lowest free energy). Reciprocal influences between target binding and calcium binding often exhibit lobe specificity as well [5, 31–33]. Therefore, how CaM regulates the function of its binding partners, including CaMKII, CaN, and Ng, is tightly linked with its structure and the functional differences between its lobes.
A number of computational models have been developed to study the regulation of bidirectional synaptic plasticity [34–39]. While these studies have advanced our understanding of how CaMKII responds to different shapes of calcium signals, they modeled the activation of CaM either using phenomenological descriptions such as the Hill or the Adair-Klotz equations or using sequential bindings of calcium ions. Kubota et al. took one step further by considering CaM’s lobe differences. They modeled the cooperativity between calcium-binding sites on each lobe as consecutive bindings with increased affinities . We previously proposed a mechanistic description of CaM within an allosteric framework [2, 10], but which did not take the role of Ng into account. A few models have advanced our understanding on how Ng facilitates LTP, putting forward Ng’s dynamic regulation of CaM concentration in the post-synaptic density (PSD) and the reshaping of free calcium spikes as proposed mechanisms [40–42]. Using mathematical modeling, Romano et al.  recently showed that Ng facilitates CaMKII activation at a 100 Hz-tetanus stimulation. However, they failed to show why, at the same time, Ng hinders LTP induction, as observed by the same experimental group .
In this paper, we present a detailed mechanistic model of CaM in the context of synaptic plasticity and its interactions with CaMKII, CaN, and Ng, based on the allosteric framework and our previous hemiconcerted CaM model . The four calcium-binding sites were explicitly modeled and each lobe of CaM undergoes independent state transitions. CaM binding to its targets depends on the conformation of CaM rather than the number of calcium ions bound to it, as the status of calcium saturation does not correlate with a specific conformation [44–47]. In addition, we systematically re-estimated the allosteric parameters concerning the two CaM lobes together, as well as the kinetic constants, based on steady states and calcium chelating time course experimental data of full-length CaM. We simulated a wide range of calcium-spike frequencies in a wild type context and for a Ng knock-out situation.
We show differences between CaM’s lobes in response to calcium signals. We show how they contribute to, but also are influenced by, the differential binding of CaM’s targets. We show that Ng is not merely a CaM buffer protein, but it can adjust the activation of CaM at spike frequencies that maximize CaMKII activation. Ng synchronizes the opening of the two CaM lobes. Ng’s regulation of LTP induction depends on the concentration of CaN, and its quantity in relation to CaM.
Materials and methods
We built a mechanistic mathematical model to describe the conformational changes of CaM lobes, calcium bindings, and CaM interaction with binding partners. We expanded and re-parameterized our previous hemiconcerted allosteric model of CaM by Lai et al. . The major differences between our model and other published CaM models are: 1) We do not assume sequential bindings of calcium ions to the four binding sites. Instead, each calcium-binding site on CaM is independent and independent from the binding of protein partners.2) A target binds to CaM that has a specific conformation, other than a specific number of calcium ions bound to it. Similarly, a target binds to CaM that has the preferred conformation, with the same affinity regardless of the number of calcium ions bound. 3) We do not modify intrinsic affinities for CaM binding calcium to mimic the apparent affinity changes exerted by CaM-binding targets. Calcium saturation decreases the free energy of the open state, favoring the association with proteins preferentially binding to that conformation and hindering the association with proteins preferentially binding to the closed state. Symmetrically, protein binding partners shift the conformation equilibrium of CaM towards their preferred state, which results in apparent affinity changes for calcium binding CaM.
On top of the model developed previously by Lai et al. , We explicitly modeled CaM’s interaction with CaMKII, CaN and Ng. We detailed the autophosphorylation of CaMKII monomers. We modeled their dephosphorylation as if directly mediated by CaN, omitting the intermediate reactions involving DARPP-32/Inhibitor-1 and Protein Phosphatase 1. We also implemented reactions to maintain basal calcium concentration, as well as enabling calcium spikes at different frequencies, amplitudes, and duration. Reactions were primarily encoded in mass-action law kinetics except for the reactions depicting the calcium pump and CaMKII dephosphorylation. The model structure is partially illustrated in Fig 1, using no calcium or one calcium ion bound CaM as examples. The full model is written by the Systems Biology Markup Language (SBML)  in the supplementary material and has been deposited in BioModels  (accession number: MODEL1903010001).
Binding interactions and state transitions involving calcium, CaM and CaM-binding proteins. For simplicity, only the binding of the first calcium ion is included. The reactions shown here are applied to all other calcium-bound forms, with any combination of filled calcium-binding sites. a and b represents calcium binding on CaM N lobe; c and d represent calcium binding on the C lobe. R indicates open lobes; T closed lobes. Dissociation coefficients for calcium at specific binding sites are specified, as well as state transition constants (ratios between opposite state transition rates). Identical dissociation constants for protein binding CaM are only written once. Parameter values are included in Table 1.
First, we modified the hemiconcerted CaM model by Lai et al. 2015 , to allow the binding of calcium ions to affect equally, but in opposite directions, both transitions of CaM lobes between open and closed conformations. In other words, calcium binding not only speeds up the T to R state transition but also slows down the R to T state transition. We also removed the assumption that protein partners can bind to all possible conformations of CaM. Rather, we defined these bindings based on the described properties of each specific protein.
CaMKII monomer binds to CaM when both lobes are in open states (namely the “RR” conformation). This binding exposes the kinase domain of CaMKII monomer, allowing it to phosphorylate and to be phosphorylated by its neighbor monomers within the same hexamer ring if they are also in the active conformation . We adapted and improved the approach used by Li et al. 2012  to compute the probability of having an adjacent active monomer, at each time step, based on the proportion of active monomers in the whole system (CaM bound and/or phosphorylated). For more details, see the section CaMKII autophosphorylation below. We then used this probability to adjust the global autophosphorylation rate of CaMKII monomers. Once phosphorylated, CaMKII monomers have a higher affinity for CaM than their non-phosphorylated counterparts and remain active even upon CaM dissociation . CaMKII monomers are dephosphorylated by Protein Phosphatase 1 (PP1). As CaN activates PP1 “linearly” through dephosphorylation of Thr34-phospho-DARPP-32, which then releases PP1 inhibition, we simply modeled a direct dephosphorylation of CaMKII monomers by CaN using Henry-Michaelis-Menten kinetics with total active CaN as the enzyme concentration.
CaN is a heterodimer containing a regulatory subunit (CaNB), and a catalytic subunit (CaNA) . In our model, the sequential binding of four calcium ions to CaNB is required before CaNA can bind CaM, thereafter becoming active [53, 54]. CaNA binds to CaM when both CaM lobes are in the open state (“RR”).
As Ng interacts mostly with the C lobe, in this model we considered that it bound to CaM only when the C lobe was in the closed state, regardless of the N lobe conformation (“RT” and “TT”). As a consequence, the association of CaM with Ng does not prevent the transitions of the N lobe between T and R states. Moreover, due to the lack of relevant experimental data, we assumed that the binding of Ng on the C lobe did not exert any allosteric effect on those transitions.
To create a basal level of calcium (0.08 ⋅ 10−6 M), we implemented reactions to create constant influx and removal of ions, by mimicking a passive calcium input channel and a concentration-dependent calcium pump. Calcium input was encoded as a train of calcium spikes at varied frequencies. Each calcium spike was generated by adding a zero-order calcium creation during 8 ms (mimicking the opening of calcium channels), which elevated the free calcium concentration transiently to 0.8 ⋅ 10−6 M. The spike’s half-life time was about 30 ms, corresponding to the experimental observation . For each free calcium spike, a total of 1926 calcium ions were injected in the model over an 8 ms period. All reactions occur in a single homogeneous compartment with a volume of 10−15 L.
Estimation of equilibrium constants for CaM and calcium
The function of allosteric proteins is characterized by two types of parameters. The thermal equilibrium is quantified by L, the concentration ratio between the different states in the absence of any allosteric effector. In our case, CaM lobes exist under two states, closed (T), and open (R). And for each lobe, we have an allosteric constant L = [T]/[R]. Extremely large or extremely small L indicates a system for which the equilibrium is strongly biased towards a given conformation. In addition, for each allosteric effector, the ratio of their binding affinities for the two conformations of CaM, dubbed c for calcium (cC = KCR/KCT; cN = KNR/KNT) or e for Ng (e = Kd_Ng_RT/Kd_Ng_TT = 1), indicates if a ligand favors one conformation or the other. In addition, the allosteric parameter c reflects the influence of calcium binding on state transitions. A larger c indicates smaller effect, exerted by calcium binding, on state transitions, or vice versa.
We estimated the allosteric parameters for both N and C lobes by using experimental data obtained predominantly from full-length CaM, where intrinsic phenylalanine and tyrosine fluorescence were used for monitoring calcium saturation. We used three sets of steady-state experimental data: 1) CaM titrating CaMKII peptide with a saturating amount of calcium ions , 2) calcium saturation curves of the C lobe in the full-length CaM either without targets or in the presence of CaMKII peptide or full-length Ng [6, 26], 3) calcium saturation curve of the N lobe, in full-length CaM, without targets . As the experimental data concerning the N lobe of CaM is relatively scarce, we also used a calcium titration curve of a truncated N lobe of CaM, that was locked in closed conformation .
To fully characterize the interactions between CaM and calcium, we thus have to estimate: 1) the binding affinities of calcium to the T state of CaM for sites on both lobes. Following Lai et al. , we further hypothesized that within each CaM lobe, the affinities of the two calcium-binding sites were the same and we had only two affinities to estimate (KNT and KCT), 2) the ratio between calcium affinity for the R and T states for both lobes (cN and cC) which we assumed to be equal for the two binding sites within each lobe as in Lai et al. 2015 , 3) the ratio of T state CaM to R state in the absence of calcium for both lobes (LN and LC), and 4) the affinity of CaM to the CaMKII peptide (Kd_CaMKIIpep_RR) and Ng (Kd_Ng_TT and Kd_Ng_RT).
As for the full-length CaMKII, CaMKII peptide used in the published experimental datasets binds to CaM when both lobes are in the R state. Ng only interacts with CaM’s C lobe and, as explained in the model structure section, Kd_Ng_RT = Kd_Ng_TT, i.e. Ng binding does not affect the state transitions of the N lobe and vice versa. The parameters remaining to be estimated are therefore reduced to: KNT, KCT, cN, cC, LN, LC, Kd_CaMKIIpep_RR, and Kd_Ng_TT.
Even with the assumptions described above, the amount of parameters to estimate is large and correlations may arise between them. Moreover, the experimental conditions used in these estimation procedures are highly diverse. Thus, we proceeded in several stages.
First, using calcium titration experiments of truncated N lobe locked in the closed conformation by disulfide crosslinks , we estimated the affinity between calcium and the N lobe in the T state to be KNT = 9.38 ⋅ 10−5 M (S1a and S1b Fig).
Using experimental measurements where CaM titrates CaMKII peptide in the presence of saturating amount of calcium ions , we then estimated the affinity between CaM and CaMKII peptide (Kd_CaMKIIpep_RR). Because of the high calcium concentration, we assumed that almost all CaM molecules were in the R state. This gave a value of Kd_CaMKIIpep_RR = 5.6 ⋅ 10−9 M (S1c and S1d Fig). This only provides an upper bound for the dissociation constant between CaMKII peptide and RR CaM, as not all CaM molecules are in the RR state, even with the highest calcium concentration. In fact, this value was reduced to 3.2 ⋅ 10−10 M during the subsequent stages of parameter estimation.
Estimating parameter values requires sampling values within some given ranges. We calculated the boundary values of KCT and cC by assuming that the observed calcium saturation levels of the C lobe, in the presence either of CaMKII peptide or of Ng [6, 26], reflected the calcium-binding affinities when all C lobes were locked in the R or T state respectively, resulting in cC′ = 0.0011 (cC = KCR/KCT) and KCT′ = 1.3 ⋅ 10−5 M (S1e to S1g Fig). This value of cC′ was used as the upper bound for estimating the real cC, as in reality, the CaMKII peptide is not capable of locking all C lobes in the R state. Similarly, KCT′ was used as the lower bound for KCT, since not all C lobes are locked in the T state by Ng, i.e. the actual affinity of the T state for calcium is lower.
Since KCT had the same order of magnitude as our estimated KNT, and calcium affinity for the C lobe should be higher than for the N lobe, the range for the real KCT value was narrow. Thus, to further reduce the number of parameters to be estimated, we simply assumed that, in the closed state, both C and N lobe shared the same calcium binding affinities, that is KCT = KNT = 9.38 ⋅ 10−5 M.
Finally, we estimated the remaining parameters: cC, cN, LC, LN and Kd_Ng_TT together using the full CaM model with steady state calcium titration curves [6, 26] and the boundary values mentioned above. As shown in S2 Fig, all parameters except cC and LC are identifiable. Fitting results are illustrated in S3 Fig. As Lai et al. , we found cC and LC highly correlated. Fitted their logarithms with a linear regression model provided a slope of -1.9 (S4 Fig). We therefore further refined these two parameters while estimating the rate constants.
Estimations of kinetic rate constants
We estimated the affinity between open CaM (conformation “RR”) and CaN by using the CaN dose-response to CaM, in the presence of saturating calcium concentration . We also estimated the association constant between the two proteins using stopped-flow kinetic data, where mutant CaM was labeled by Acrylodan (CaM(C75)ACR) . The estimated affinity was Kd_CaN_RR = 3.2 ⋅ 10−9 M, with an association constant kon_CaN = 2.3 ⋅ 107 M-1·s-1 (S5 Fig).
We directly used the dissociation constants of CaMKII and phospho-CaMKII from CaM taken from the literature (koff_CaMKII_RR = 1.1 s-1; koff_CaMKIIp_RR = 8.7 ⋅ 10−5 s-1) , and therefore only had to estimate their association rate constants. Based on previously published works [23, 26], we hypothesized that calcium binding to the N lobe was 100 times faster than to the C lobe, (kon_N = 100 × kon_C), and these did not depend on the conformation of the lobes, therefore reducing the estimation of 8 unknown association rates to only 1, kon_CT. Finally, we assumed that the base state-transition rates were the same for the two lobes, k_TtoRC0 = k_TtoRN0. The specific state transition rates, for all liganded populations, depend on the number of calcium bound to the CaM lobe, the protein partner bound, and the allosteric parameters estimated for this lobe. We also made use of the relationship between cC and LC described above, and only had to estimate cC.
We used stopped-flow fluorometry measurements of quin-2 fluorescence increase, after the addition of calcium-saturated CaM mix, in the presence of either CaMKII or phospho-CaMKII , and measurements of native tyrosine fluorescence decrease in the CaM C-terminal in the presence of EGTA, with or without Ng .
Most of the parameters estimated at this stage were identifiable, except the association constant between Ng and CaM kon_Ng, as well as the base state-transition rate k_TtoRC0 (S6 and S7 Figs). Thus, we chose the highest reasonable association constant for Ng and CaM (kon_Ng = 1014 M-1·s-1) and an average value for the transition rate among the range of values that all reached best fit (k_T2RC0 = 316227). The fitted results are illustrated in S8 Fig.
During simulations, we actively adjusted the global autophosphorylation rate of CaMKII monomers based on the total amount of active monomers, that are the phosphorylated and/or CaM bound monomers, and the likelihood of them having adjacent active monomers in pseudo hexamer rings, an updated approach from our previous work .
Briefly speaking, there are 7 types of hexamers, containing 0 to 6 active monomers. For each type, the possibilities of location for the active monomers are limited and we can easily compute the probability for an active monomer to have a neighbor also active. The main aspect of the procedure is to approximate the fraction of the different types of hexamers when the total number of active monomers is updated from the simulation. We achieved this by running, for every 1 percent increase of active monomers, 1000 independent random distributions of the active monomers to hexamers. For every increase of active monomers, we then computed the average occurrences of each type of hexamers and transformed them into the probability for a monomer to be distributed in a specific type of hexamer. We then multiplied the distributions of monomers with their corresponding probability of adjacent active neighbors. Finally, the summation of the above was used as the overall probability and the chance of having an active neighbor monomer for each percent increase in total active monomers. We fitted this data with a 5th order polynomial function and embedded it into the model to adjust the autophosphorylation rate of CaMKII monomer (S9 Fig).
Numerical simulations and analysis of results
All simulations, including timecourses with calcium spikes, were performed with COPASI , using the LSODA solver . Parameter estimations were conducted using the SBPIPE package , combined with the “Particle swarm” optimization method (2000 iterations with a swarm size of 50). Parameters used for simulation of the model are listed in Table 1.
The frequency of calcium spikes was directly encoded in the model together with the number of spikes, to control the total duration of calcium inputs. We ran the simulations on a computing cluster, using Python’s ElementTree package to automatically modify the frequency parameter in CopasiML files.
Each simulation started with a 5000 s equilibrium—with output interval size set at 1 s, followed by the simulation of 300 calcium spikes at frequencies ranging from 0.1 Hz to 100 Hz, with output interval size set at 0.0001 s. We recorded the evolution of all protein active forms during 3000 s.
In order to evaluate CaMKII and CaN’s effects on synaptic plasticity, we measured the “activated area” , which was obtained by integrating, over the 3000 s, the product of their relative activation (concentration of active proteins over total concentration) above basal activities (subtracting basal levels), by their catalytic constants on α-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionic acid (AMPA) receptor GluR1 subunit. The BCM-like curve , useful to characterize bidirectional plasticity, was obtained by subtracting the activated area of CaN from that of CaMKII for each calcium spike frequency.
Ng sequesters closed-state CaM
We first studied how CaM-binding proteins can affect CaM’s apparent affinity for calcium at steady states. As shown in Fig 2, and in accord with previous experiments [6, 26] and modeling , the presence of Ng shifts the calcium-saturation curve of CaM’s C lobe towards higher calcium concentration ranges, reducing the apparent affinity for calcium. This indicates that Ng traps the C lobe in the closed, low-affinity, conformational state, and therefore hinders calcium binding, in particular at low calcium concentrations. Conversely, CaMKII and CaN promote calcium binding to the C lobe, increasing the apparent affinity, through their preferential binding to the open, high-affinity conformation (of both lobes).
Values were obtained by scanning a range of initial calcium concentrations and running simulations until steady-state is reached, using initial conditions described in Hoffman et al. 2014 . a) shows only the saturation of C lobe (within the context of the entire CaM) while b) shows the whole CaM, without any substrates (grey), with Ng (blue), non-phosphorylated CaMKII (orange), CaN (green) or Thr286-phospho-CaMKII (red). The x-axis shows the free concentration of calcium and not the initial concentration used for the scan. [CaM] = 5 μM; [Ng/CaMKII/CaMKIIp/CaN] = 50 μM. Solid line: simulation results; dots: experimental observations.
Calcium saturation curves for full CaM show similar trends as for the C lobe (Fig 2), but they also indicate CaM’s lobe differences in terms of calcium binding. The allosteric parameters we estimated predict that the N lobe is more flexible and has greater potential to undergo spontaneous conformational transitions than the C lobe (LN closer to 1 than LC). However, the binding of calcium has less influence on the conformation of the N lobe, because of the smaller ratio between the affinities for calcium of the two conformations in the N lobe compared with the C lobe (cN closer to 1 than cC). The saturation curve of full CaM in the absence of protein binding partners stretches across a wider range of calcium concentration than the C lobe, showing a larger contribution of the C lobe at lower calcium concentrations. As in our model Ng only interacts with the C lobe, it has little effect on calcium binding to the N lobe. As a consequence, the shift in the saturation curve is mostly seen at lower calcium concentrations. Because both N and C lobes wrap around CaMKII and CaN, the presence of these proteins greatly enhances calcium binding not only to the C lobe but also to the N lobe. However, the N lobe’s calcium affinity is less increased by the conformational change to the open state. Although having the highest affinity towards CaM, phospho-CaMKII cannot shift N lobe’s affinity much compared to non-phospho CaMKII.
In line with the observations above, timecourse simulations show that the presence of Ng speeds up calcium dissociation from CaM’s C lobe (Fig 3), in agreement with stopped-flow fluorometry experimental observations . The steady-state and kinetic results validate our model assumptions and parameters. They also confirm well established functions of Ng: Ng decreases calcium binding to CaM at steady states; Ng increases calcium dissociation from CaM when free calcium concentration is decreased. Both observations arise from the preferential binding of Ng to a conformation of CaM’s C lobe with a low affinity for calcium.
Calcium dissociation from the C lobe of CaM was simulated upon mixing calcium chelator EGTA (10−2 M) after the model simulation reached steady states with pre-mixed CaM (10 μM) and calcium (100 μM) with (cyan) or without (salmon) Ng (50 μM). Solid line: simulation results; dots: experimental observations .
Ng shifts CaM activation towards high-frequency calcium spikes
Post-synaptic stimulation triggers calcium spikes. During one spike, free calcium concentration transiently reaches a near-micromolar level in a few milliseconds, and subsequently declines in about 200 milliseconds, due to calcium pumps and calcium-binding proteins . Therefore, rather than looking at the responses of CaM to steady elevations of calcium concentration, we must look at its responses to calcium spikes at different frequencies (Fig 4).
Intracellular free calcium elevation simulated with a single calcium input (a) or a train of inputs (b) at 1 Hz (red), 5 Hz (blue) and 10 Hz (grey). Each calcium spike represent the addition of 1926 ions over 8 ms.
First we simulated the CaM model without protein partners, using a fixed total calcium input applied at varied spike frequencies. The results are in line with the behavior of our previous fully concerted model , and show that both CaM lobes respond differently to different calcium spike frequencies. At high spike frequencies, both lobes stay in the open state for a duration longer than calcium inputs (red dots in Fig 5 indicate the end of calcium stimulation). However, the N and C lobes display different sensitivities towards calcium spike frequencies. The C lobe opens at lower frequencies, and for a longer duration, whereas the N lobe requires much higher spike frequencies to switch to the open conformation. In both lobes, the stabilization of the open conformation follows the profiles of calcium binding.
Calcium binding CaM was followed during simulations using trains of 300 spikes at different frequencies. Plots show calcium saturation levels at the C and N lobe and the corresponding CaM conformational changes, with CaM on its own, or in the presence of Ng. Red dots represent the end of calcium stimulation. [CaM]tot = 40 μM, [Ng]tot = 40 μM, basal [Ca] = 0.08 μM.
When Ng was added to the model, the range of frequencies able to open most C lobes narrows towards high values (Fig 5). The duration of these openings is also shorter than when Ng is absent. Unsurprisingly, no change was observed for the N lobe (Fig 5). Overall, the opening patterns of the C lobe in presence of Ng resemble those of the N lobe, restricting the opening to high calcium input frequencies.
To better quantify CaM’s responses to the frequencies of calcium input, we calculated the Area Under the Curve (AUC), that is the integral of the increased/decreased fraction of CaM in the open/closed state (above/below basal level), over the entire simulation (see Methods). We calculated these AUCs for all the possible conformations of CaM lobes: RR, RT, TR and TT (where the first letter represents the state of the N lobe and the second represents the state of the C lobe. We then plotted them against calcium spike frequencies (Fig 6).
Conformational changes of CaM (40 μM) without Ng (a) or with Ng ([Ng]tot = 40 μM) (b). Basal activities were subtracted before AUCs were calculated.
In the absence of Ng, CaM’s C lobe is very sensitive to calcium spikes at low frequencies. The TR conformation is increased above its basal level (AUC>0) by calcium stimulation as low as 0.1 Hz (Fig 6a). The TR conformation increases steeply around 3 Hz, peaks at 20 Hz, then declines while the N lobe of the same CaM opens (increase of the RR conformation). The RT conformation does not increase in response to calcium spikes. There is almost one order of magnitude between the frequencies at which the C and N lobe open prominently (Fig 6a).
Ng not only decreases the C lobe opening in response to low frequencies but also shifts it towards higher frequencies. At about 10 Hz, both the TR and RT state start to increase and peak around 25 Hz, indicating the opening of C and N lobes separately within two populations of CaM molecules (Fig 6b). It seems that the N lobe can compete with the C lobe for calcium binding to stabilize its open conformation only in the presence of Ng (Fig 6a). Calcium binding to the N lobe is 100 times faster than its binding to the C lobe. However, the rate of dissociation from the N lobe is also extremely high (corresponding to a lower affinity), which makes the N lobe less efficient than the C lobe for calcium binding. The rates of transition from the closed to open conformation, when no calcium ion is bound, are the same for both lobes. As a result, at these intermediate frequencies, Ng facilitates the opening of the N lobe by decreasing the opening of the C lobe and thus its binding of calcium. At high spike frequencies, the opening of both lobes (RR state) follows almost the same profile as when Ng is absent and reaches the same activity level at 100 Hz regardless of Ng’s presence (Fig 6b).
Therefore, Ng does not prevent CaM activation by calcium spikes. Instead, Ng synchronizes both lobes to respond towards higher calcium spike frequencies, hence narrowing the frequency range at which CaM responses.
Ng facilitates CaMKII activation at high calcium spike frequencies
We then investigated Ng’s role in regulating the activation of CaMKII and CaN by CaM. We first added only CaMKII and CaN in the model (without Ng), as well as the inhibition of CaMKII autophosphorylation by CaN (see Materials and methods). In all the subsequent simulations, the concentration of CaM is smaller than the total concentration of its binding proteins. As above, we simulated trains of calcium spikes at various frequencies but resulting in a fixed additional amount of calcium ions. To compute their activity on phosphorylation of AMPA receptor subunit GluR1, we multiplied the fraction of active CaMKII and CaN by their respective catalytic constants (kcat).
Fig 7 shows example timecourses of protein activity changes following 300 calcium-spike stimulations at 10 Hz or 30 Hz. In the absence of Ng, resting calcium level opens a small proportion of CaM, resulting in higher basal CaN activity than CaMKII. With a 10 Hz calcium stimulation, the opening of CaM leads to a fast and strong elevation of CaN, accompanied by a gentler rise of CaMKII activity, with CaN and CaMKII activities reaching to the same level (Fig 7a). At 30 Hz, the acute elevation of calcium gives rises to sharp and prominent increases of both CaMKII and CaN activities, and the activity of CaMKII overcomes that of CaN. However, the activation of CaMKII decays very quickly to its resting level, potentially due to the slower deactivation and high basal activity of CaN, which prevents the onset of CaMKII autophosphorylation (Fig 7b).
Simulations in absence (a,b) or presence (c,d) of Ng, from equilibrium and during stimulation by 300 calcium spikes at 10 Hz (a,c) and 30 Hz (b,d). The protein activities were defined as follow: fraction of CaMKII monomers bound to CaM and/or phosphorylated multiplied by CaMKII kcat for GluR1, fraction of CaN bound to CaM multiplied by CaNA kcat for GluR1, fraction of Ng bound to CaM. [CaM]tot = 40 μM, [CaMKII]tot = 80 μM, [CaN]tot = 8 μM, and [Ng]tot = 40 μM; kcatCaMKII = 2 s-1, kcatCaN = 0.5 s-1. All the concentrations of perspective CaM binding proteins are assigned according to the proteomic study in the hippocampus CA1 region .
When Ng is present in the model, CaN basal activity is lower at resting calcium concentration, indicating decreased open CaM because of Ng binding. Calcium inputs at both frequencies raise Ca-saturation of CaM, stabilizing open CaM free of any protein partner. This triggers an equilibrium shift (reduced closed CaM free of protein partners) and a release of CaM from Ng. At 10 Hz, a small proportion of CaM is released from Ng, inducing a strong activation of CaN, but a much weaker activation of CaMKII (Fig 7c). At 30 Hz, Ng releases almost all CaM. This transient but strong CaM release robustly increases CaMKII and CaN activity. At both frequencies, the decay of CaN activity is faster than when Ng is absent. The most striking difference is in the way CaMKII activity decays. A significant proportion of CaMKII monomers remain active, and autophosphorylated, for more than 10 minutes, which is far beyond the total duration of calcium stimulation (Fig 7d and S10 Fig). These results indicate an multi-phasic regulation of CaMKII activity by Ng. At an intermediate spike frequency (10 Hz), Ng restrains CaMKII activation; at a high spike frequency (30 Hz), Ng promotes it.
In most LTP-induction protocols, the high-frequency stimulation is not applied continuously but split into discrete bursts. We verified the observation presented above by stimulating the model with three 100 Hz, 100-spike bursts, separated by 10-minute intervals . As shown in Fig 8, we obtained results similar to a setup featuring a continuous 300-spike stimulation (S11 Fig). When Ng is present (Fig 8a), a significant proportion of CaMKII monomers retain their activities for about 10 minutes after the end of each burst. Whereas in the absence of Ng (Fig 8b), the elevated basal CaN prevents such a long-lasting CaMKII activation, resulting in a more transient CaMKII activity. Interestingly, with such a discrete-bursts stimulation, the overall CaMKII activity (integrated over time) is increased by nearly 20% compared with continuous 300-spike stimulation.
Computational models were simulated, with (a) or without (b) Ng, by 300 calcium spikes organized into three 100-spike discrete bursts at 100 Hz each, separated by 10 min intervals. Each calcium input was as described in Fig 3. Both protein activities were normalized to their total concentration, then multiplied by their catalytic constant for GluR1. [CaM] = 40 μM, [Ng] = 40 μM, [CaN] = 8 μM, [CaMKII] = 80 μM; kcatCaMKII = 2 s-1; kcatCaN = 0.5-1.
We systematically explored 30 frequencies, ranging from 0.1 to 100 Hz. To represent the combined effect of CaMKII and CaN on GluR1, thus their impact on synaptic plasticity, we subtracted their “activated area”, following a continuous 300-spike stimulation at each frequency. The “activated area” is an integration of the activity change of an enzyme (above basal level) along time, after the calcium stimulation of a specific frequency. It was calculated based on the timecourse result, such as examples in Fig 7. For each curve in Fig 9a, negative values indicate that CaN activation overcomes CaMKII activation, thus facilitating LTD. Whereas positive values show that CaMKII activation overcomes CaN activation, thus facilitating LTP. Both curves, with (circle) and without (cross) Ng, show triphasic responses, reproducing the classical BCM curve, with predominant CaN activity at low calcium-spike frequencies and overriding CaMKII activity at high spike frequencies. However, the presence of Ng results in an upright shift of the frequency-response curve, indicating the hindered onset of LTD, increased frequency for LTP onset and lifted CaMKII responses at high spike frequencies.
Protein activities, as described in Fig 7, were integrated over time. The effect on synaptic plasticity was calculated by subtracting CaN’s activated area from CaMKII (a). Each protein’s activated area was also plotted as a function of calcium input frequency (b). Models were stimulated either with (grey circle) or without Ng (black cross). All protein concentrations were as described in Fig 7 and in Table 1.
The difference of responses in the presence and the absence of Ng is explained by its different effects on the “activated area” of CaN (green) and CaMKII (red), that vary according to the frequency (Fig 9b). Because of CaN’s relatively low concentration and its higher affinity for CaM than non-phospho CaMKII monomers, CaN becomes active even at low spike frequencies. This strongly inhibits CaMKII autophosphorylation. Despite this constant presence of phosphatase activity, both CaN and CaMKII activity change with frequency, including in the presence of Ng. Thus, Ng regulates the activation of CaMKII and CaN, modulating synaptic plasticity, in three phases: At low spike frequencies, Ng hinders the activation of both proteins, albeit with a stronger effect on CaN, thus inhibiting LTD. As the spike frequency increases, CaN activity rises to induce LTD. The declining phase of CaN activity corresponds to the increasing CaMKII activity, marking the transition from LTD to LTP. The presence of Ng shifts this transition to higher frequencies, therefore increasing the frequency required for LTP induction. At high spike frequencies, Ng predominantly facilitates CaMKII autophosphorylation, thus promoting LTP. As Ng’s regulatory role in synaptic plasticity and CaMKII activation depends on calcium-spike frequencies, and intracellular patterns of calcium elevation vary dependent on the LTP-induction protocols and the specific cellular environment (e.g. the number of receptors), Ng’s non-monotonic regulation might provide a clue to opposing experimental observations in Ng knock-out mice. Ng raises the threshold frequency to activate CaMKII. However, once the threshold is crossed, Ng facilitates its activation.
The fact that sustained CaMKII activity at high calcium spike frequencies was observed only in the presence of Ng was intriguing. To simulate the autophosphorylation of CaMKII monomers, we continuously adjusted the phosphorylation rate based on the total number of active CaMKII monomers (CaM bound and/or phosphorylated), and their random distributions within pseudo hexamer rings. Therefore, to initiate the autophosphorylation of CaMKII, a large number of CaM molecules need to bind to CaMKII, to ensure adjacent neighbor monomers are active within hexamer rings (see Method for more details). If the only function of Ng was to buffer CaM and preclude it from opening, it would not facilitate CaMKII activation, given that the concentration of CaM is already a limiting factor . In the following section, we shed light on the mechanisms underlying Ng’s positive regulation on CaMKII activation at high calcium-spike frequencies.
Ng facilitates CaMKII activation by suppressing the activity of CaN
Ng’s positive impact on CaMKII activation at high-frequency calcium stimulation has been observed experimentally [15, 19]. However, no underlying mechanism was suggested. Sustained CaMKII activation is due to its autophosphorylation, and CaN regulates its dephosphorylation via PP1. We thus hypothesized that CaN might play an important role in mediating Ng’s effect on CaMKII activation.
The frequency-response plot (Fig 9b) shows that the presence of Ng causes a significant change in the plateau activity of CaMKII at high spike frequencies, but a fairly small change of CaN activity. It is therefore difficult to see how such a small change could have an important effect on CaMKII autophosphorylation. However, the phosphorylation of CaMKII is regulated not only by the dynamic elevation of CaN following calcium spikes that is shown in Fig 9b, but also by CaN’s basal activity which is elevated in the absence of Ng (Fig 7a and 7b). This increased basal activity causes a greater change of CaN’s activated area without affecting the CaMKII curve (as shown on S12 Fig, where CaN’s frequency dependent curve is further increased by 54 units). Thus, at high spike frequencies, CaN activity is higher than CaMKII activity in the absence of Ng. However, in the presence of Ng, the activity of CaN is lower than CaMKII. This is reflected in the difference of “activated area” curves in S12 Fig.
To further assess CaN’s role, we removed it from the model and re-simulated the various frequencies of calcium spikes, with and without Ng. As shown in Fig 10a, removing CaN dramatically increases CaMKII activity at high calcium-spike frequencies regardless of Ng’s presence. Moreover, CaMKII reaches similar maximal activity in both situations. As the presence of Ng does not increase CaMKII activity at high calcium-spike frequencies (see grey curve on Fig 10a), the previously observed positive impact of Ng on CaMKII activation (Fig 9) is completely lost. The key impact of removing Ng is a shift of the BCM-like curve towards lower spike frequencies, which indicates a negative effect of Ng on CaMKII in the absence of CaN.
Models were simulated without CaN (a) or without CaN’s phosphatase activity (kcat = 0)(b) or with double amount of CaN (c). The combined response of CaMKII and CaN to calcium spike frequencies were quantified as described in Fig 9: with Ng (grey circle) and without (black cross). Simulation conditions and concentrations are as described in Fig 7. Double amount of CaN equals to 16 μM.
To address whether it is CaN phosphatase activity or its high-affinity binding to CaM which mediates Ng’s effect on CaMKII activation, we simulated the model after removing CaN’s phosphatase activity (kcat = 0), keeping its concentration at the value used to generate Fig 9 (Table 1). Without CaN phosphatase activity, the presence of Ng decreases CaMKII activation at high spike frequencies (Fig 10b), showing that it retain only an inhibitory role. Therefore, Ng facilitates CaMKII activation by suppressing the phosphatase activity of CaN. Furthermore, CaN’s central role on mediating Ng’s effect cannot be replaced by any other high-affinity CaM-binding proteins.
We then doubled CaN concentration, to twice its detected level in the hippocampus CA1 region , while keeping its phosphatase activity (Fig 10c). At low spike frequencies, CaN activity suppresses CaMKII as seen above with normal CaN concentration. However, at high frequencies CaMKII activity can no longer overturn CaN activation, resulting in abolished LTP induction regardless of Ng’s presence. This indicates that high CaN concentration suppresses the positive effect of Ng on CaMKII activation and LTP induction at high frequency stimulations. To summarize, when there is not enough CaN, CaMKII activation is excessive and when there is too much CaN, CaMKII activation is insufficient. In both cases, Ng exerts no positive effect on CaMKII activation.
We tested other CaN concentrations and plotted the differences of CaMKII activation reached at a high calcium spike frequency (100 Hz), in the presence and absence of Ng. Fig 11 shows a nonlinear relationship between the concentration of CaN and the effect of Ng on CaMKII activation. It seems that with those concentrations of Ng, CaM, and CaMKII, Ng displays the highest positive effect on CaMKII activation when CaN concentration is about 4 micromolar. Reducing or increasing CaN concentration weakens Ng’s impact on CaMKII.
Different CaN concentrations were applied in the presence and absence of Ng. The difference between CaMKII’s activated areas reached in response to a 100 Hz calcium spike frequency in presence and absence of Ng were plotted against CaN concentration. The relationship was further fitted into a polynomial function (method loess() from ggplot2) and plotted as the blue line. Red points are the values coming from our simulations. Shaded light grey area represents the 95% confidence interval for the fitting.
These results suggest that a key role for CaN is to control how Ng affects CaMKII activation at higher calcium spike frequencies. The presence of Ng facilitates a prompt release of large quantities of CaM at specific spike frequencies. This facilitates the onset of CaMKII activation and autophosphorylation, allowing it to overcome CaN’s negative feedback. Removal or over-expression of CaN eliminates Ng’s positive regulation on CaMKII, reducing its role to merely a CaM buffer.
The concentration of Ng impacts LTP induction
Previous research showed that Ng constantly moves in and out of the PSD. Its function as a regulator of synaptic plasticity may partly rely on its recruitment of CaM in the PSD . While this is certainly an important aspect of Ng’s function, modeling Ng and CaM translocation in and out the PSD may blur other Ng’s impacts on plasticity. We have already shown that the concentration of CaM is limited in the PSD and increasing it has a positive effect on LTP induction .
The model presented here only incorporated the binding of CaM by Ng in a homogeneous compartment. However, we showed that increasing the concentration of Ng, while keeping the concentration of CaM the same, has a positive effect on LTP induction. As shown in Fig 12, a higher Ng concentration results in a higher response from CaMKII over CaN, with a steeper transition from LTD to LTP. Despite a relative shift toward CaMKII at all frequencies, the transition between CaN and CaMKII (Θm) occurs at higher frequencies when the concentration of Ng increases. Furthermore, the LTD response deepens when the concentration of Ng decreases whereas the LTP response strengthens when the concentration of Ng increases. Therefore, the synaptic response brought forward by Ng’s translocation may lie in between these lines with a broader dynamic range across responses of LTD and LTP.
Computational models with various Ng concentrations were stimulated by 300 calcium spikes at various frequencies. The concentrations of proteins, except Ng, were listed in Table 1 and remain unchanged. In particular, the concentration of CaM is 40 μM. The activated areas of CaMKII and CaN were calculated and their net effects on AMPA receptor phosphorylation were calculated as described in Fig 7, and plotted as a function of calcium spike frequency.
CaM regulates synaptic plasticity via its binding partners [26, 31, 67], some of which have well-known functions while other non-catalytic binding proteins’ roles are less clear. One such protein is Ng, a highly expressed brain protein that carries a CaM-binding IQ domain [68, 69].
Ng primarily interacts with the closed C-lobe of CaM [13, 26], and is considered to buffer CaM [11, 12, 69, 70]. Despite many studies of its function in regulating synaptic plasticity, its precise role is still questioned. Several in vivo experiments showed that Ng facilitates CaMKII activation during LTP induction protocols [16, 19], and it is not a CaM buffer because CaMKII activation requires a significant amount of open CaM. To confuse matters further, the knock-out of Ng in mouse can either facilitate or inhibit LTP induction [14–19].
By setting up a mechanistic model of CaM and incorporating conformational changes of its two lobes, we explored the potential roles Ng plays in regulating bidirectional synaptic plasticity mediated by CaMKII and CaN.
It has been established that the C lobe of CaM has higher affinities but slower binding kinetics for calcium ions than the N lobe [11, 20, 23, 31]. Therefore, it has been proposed that the rate-limiting event for CaM opening is the calcium binding to its C lobe [26, 32, 67]. However, our simulation results showed the contrary. When there is no CaM-binding partner, it is the opening of N lobe requires higher calcium spike frequencies and larger free calcium elevations than the C lobe (Fig 6a). This is because the N lobe has fast calcium-binding rates and low binding affinities, resulting in rapid calcium dissociation. Hence, the calcium binding to the N lobe follows calcium spikes too close to stabilize the open conformation before the decline of free calcium concentration.
We further showed that Ng synchronizes the openings of CaM lobes at a specific calcium spike frequency. This is because Ng preferentially binds to the C lobe of CaM at low-frequency calcium spikes and releases it at high-frequency stimulation when the N lobe is opening (Fig 6b). This synchronization minimizes CaM opening during weak calcium stimulation, reduces basal CaN activity, and enhances CaMKII activation when calcium signal is strong (Figs 7 and 9).
Our findings are in agreement with studies proposing that Ng and other IQ motif proteins act as CaM caches, enhancing the activation of CaM-binding partners when the elevation of free calcium concentration is high [42, 68, 71]. Our study further shows that this increased free calcium concentration is the result of the increased calcium spike frequency, other than total calcium ions. Furthermore, the mechanisms underlying this dynamic regulation can be explained by the allosteric regulation of CaM lobes and the reciprocal influence between CaM and its binding partners.
Our frequency-response curves (Fig 9a) match with experimental observations by Huang et al. , where the absence of Ng facilitates LTD but impairs LTP induction, resulting in a down-shifted BCM curve. Upon Ng’s removal, our BCM-like curve also shifts towards low frequency calcium spikes, indicating a potentially easier onset of LTP at intermediate frequencies. This finding is in partial agreement with what has been published by Krucker et al. , a major experimental study questioning Ng’s positive role on synaptic plasticity. In their work, the mouse brains without Ng expression display lowered CaMKII activation after a high frequency train of electrical stimulation, and an easier onset of LTP under stimulation at intermediate frequencies . Krucker et al. also showed that without Ng, LTP is enhanced at high spike frequencies, which is opposite from what was observed by Huang et al. and by our simulation result. Our research can not explain this discrepancy directly, because of our simplified representation of LTP. Nevertheless, we showed that in the absence of Ng, lowered CaMKII activity does not abolish LTP induction at high-frequency calcium stimulation. We further revealed that the LTP-induction frequency and the amplitude of LTP can be dynamically regulated by the expression levels of CaN and Ng (Figs 11 and 12).
The most intriguing finding from our research is that CaN mediates Ng’s regulatory role in the LTP induction at high frequency calcium spikes. CaN is one of the highly expressed protein phosphatases in the nervous system , and its dysfunction has been associated with many neurological diseases [73–76]. It has been shown that CaN involves in processes weakening synaptic connections [77–82]. And blockage of CaN has shown to encourage learning and memory [83, 84]. Our findings do not contradict these views. In fact, we showed that Ng’s positive impact on CaMKII activation and LTP induction is due to its suppressing of CaN activity, especially at the basal calcium concentration.
When Ng is knocked out, CaM is prone to be activated by the basal level of calcium, therefore elevating the resting level of CaN activity, which in turn decreasing CaMKII autophosphorylation. We further showed that it is CaN’s phosphatase activity, other than its high-affinity binding to CaM, mediates the function of Ng. Therefore, when CaN concentration is very low, the difference of CaN basal activity in the presence and the absence of Ng has little impact on CaMKII activity. On the other hand, when CaN concentration is high, its phosphatase activity obstructs CaMKII autophosphorylation even in the presence of Ng. This sensitivity to CaN concentration may provide a further explanation for conflicting experimental observations where Ng knock out did not always result in reduced LTP induction [15, 19]. Further experimental validations focusing on CaN’s contribution to Ng’s role in synaptic plasticity, will definitely provide new insights about the function of Ng and will broaden our understanding of synaptic plasticity.
One aspect to the regulations of Ng, which we did not include in our model, is the phosphorylation of Ng by the γ isoform of protein kinase C (PKCγ) . Phosphorylated Ng losses its ability to bind CaM [12, 86, 87]. The activation of PKCγ is mediated by metabotropic glutamate receptor (mGluR), therefore being associated with low-frequency stimulation and the resulted slow calcium release. Although our study did not focus on this type of calcium signals, we could still speculate that under the stimulation of low-frequency calcium spikes, combined with the phosphorylation of Ng thereby releasing of CaM, CaN would be predominantly activated and contribute to the LTD induction .
In both repeated and continuous stimulation (Figs 8 and 7), only a small amount of CaMKII monomers retain long-lasting activities after the high-frequency calcium stimulation. Because of the large total number of CaMKII monomers, this corresponds to approximately 700 phosphorylated monomers, or nearly 60 CaMKII dodecamers. The NR2B-containing N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors are responsible for binding Thr286-phospho-CaMKII , and are present in the PSD in a small quantity . These active CaMKII dodecamers are sufficient to saturate C terminal tails of NR2B containing NMDA receptors in the PSD, therefore facilitating AMPA receptor insertion and LTP induction.
This also reveals a limitation in our current approach to approximate CaMKII autophosphorylation rates, which is to estimate the probability for a given monomer to have an active neighbor. Our dendritic-spine model contains a large number of CaMKII monomers, representing a considerable amount of hexamers. Since we assumed a single homogeneous compartment, all monomers possess an equal chance to interact with CaM. Therefore, a substantial amount of active CaM molecules are required to activate two adjacent CaMKII monomers of a hexamer ring, in order to initiate trans-autophosphorylation. An improved approach would be to consider the PSD as a spatially confined compartment that is separated from the rest of the dendritic spine. In such a multi-compartment model, we could incorporate the clustering and translocation of CaMKII dodecamers, which could increase the chance of the PSD-located CaMKII to bind CaM and potentially provide a more accurate estimation of CaMKII autophosphorylation rates. However, the current low estimation of CaMKII autophosphorylation rates does not affect our major findings, which are based on the comparison of CaMKII activation in the presence and absence of Ng, and the rate of CaMKII autophosphorylation is adjusted in the same way for both situations. The only difference could be that the frequencies we found to be able to induce LTP might be higher than reality, albeit for both scenarios.
We have built our model based on a highly simplified concept, in which the effectiveness of the phosphatase and the kinase is directly used as a measure for synaptic plasticity. Although the requirements of CaN and CaMKII for the induction of synaptic plasticity are well established [9, 38], there are more modulators and interactions involved in different stages of memory consolidation . The difficulties of incorporating more molecular interactions in the model are in estimating their relevant equilibrium and kinetic constants systematically and ensuring these parameters are identifiable, which we tried to ensure in this study. Our mathematical model can be expanded and parameters can be reused in future studies to further our understanding of CaM and its binding proteins.
In conclusion, our study revealed complex and dynamic roles Ng plays in regulating bidirectional synaptic plasticity. Ng functions via preferential binding to CaM C lobe at the closed conformation. And by doing so, Ng synchronizes the openings of two CaM lobes, limiting CaMKII activation at intermediate calcium spike frequencies, while facilitating it at high frequencies. Apparently contradictory experimental observations regarding its effect on LTP induction might be all valid. As we already showed before , the exact CaMKII activity required to induce LTP is dependent on conditions and other molecular components inside the postsynaptic dendritic spine. Ng’s positive regulation of CaMKII activity depends on both its concentration and that of CaN. Furthermore, it depends on calcium spike frequencies and the threshold CaMKII activity required to facilitate AMPA receptor insertion and LTP induction.
S1 Fig. Estimations of boundaries for allosteric parameter cC and calcium affinity to a binding site on CaM’s C lobe (KCT) and N lobe (KAT), as well as affinity between CaMKII peptide and open CaM (Kd_CaMKIIpeptide_RR).
S2 Fig. Estimations and correlations of allosteric parameters cC, cN, LC, LN, and affinity between Ng and closed CaM (Kd_Ng_TT).
S3 Fig. Steady state validation of calcium binding CaM.
Comparison of steady state simulation results (solid lines) and published experimental observations (dots) of calcium binding C lobe (a) and N lobe (b) of CaM. To compare with experimental data published by Hoffman et al. , the model was set up with [CaM] = 5 μM and [Ng] = 50 μM. To compare with experiments published by Evans et al. , model initial states were set up as [CaM] = 2 μM and [CaMKII] = 10 μM.
S4 Fig. Linear relationship between log10(cC) and log10(LC).
S5 Fig. Estimations of CaN binding (kon_PP2B_CaM) and releasing open CaM (koff_PP2B_CaM).
S6 Fig. Estimation of allosteric parameter cC and association constants for CaM binding CaMKII (kon_CaMKII), phospho-CaMKII (kon_CaMKIIp) and Ng (kon_Ng), calcium binding C lobe of CaM (kon_CT) and the conformational transition rate of C lobe, when no calcium or protein is bound (k_T2R_C0).
S7 Fig. Correlation analysis of each pair of the parameters estimated above in S6 Fig, based on parameter values searched and their scores for fitting experimental observations.
S8 Fig. Validations of calcium dissociation kinetics from CaM.
Calcium dissociation from C-lobe of CaM (a,b) were measured upon mixing calcium chelator EGTA (10−2 M), and simulated after reaching equilibrium with pre-mixed CaM (10 μM) and calcium (100 μM) with (cyan) or without (salmon) Ng (50 μM). Calcium dissociation from whole CaM (c) were measured upon mixing calcium chelator quin2 (150 μM), and simulated after reaching equilibrium with pre-mixed CaM (2 μM) and calcium (20 μM) with CaMKII (2 μM salmon) or phospho-CaMKII (2 μM cyan). Solid line: simulation results; dots: experimental observations [26, 31].
S9 Fig. Calculation of the rate of CaMKII autophosphorylation.
The procedure for calculating the rate of CaMKII autophosphorylation rate as a function of active CaMKII monomers (for details see Methods section).
S10 Fig. Protein activation after calcium inputs at 30 Hz.
Computational models with (a) or without (b) Ng were stimulated by 300 calcium spikes at 30Hz. Protein activities were normalized by their total concentration, and CaMKII and CaN were further multiplied by their catalytic efficiencies towards GluR1 subunit of AMPAR. [CaM] = 40 μM, [Ng] = 40 μM, [CaN] = 8 μM, [CaMKII] = 80 μM; kcatCaMKII = 2 s-1; kcatCaN = 0.5-1.
S11 Fig. Protein activation after calcium inputs at 100 Hz.
Computational models were simulated with (a) or without (b) Ng, with 300 calcium spikes at 100 Hz. Each calcium input was as described in Fig 3. Both protein activities were normalized to their total concentration, then multiplied by their catalytic constant for GluR1. [CaM] = 40 μM, [Ng] = 40 μM, [CaN] = 8 μM, [CaMKII] = 80 μM; kcatCaMKII = 2 s-1; kcatCaN = 0.5-1.
S12 Fig. Ng affects basal activity of CaN.
Protein activity change, triggered by the train of calcium spikes (as described in Fig 7), and its basal level, were integrated over time (3000 s) and plotted as a function of calcium input frequency. Models were stimulated either with (grey circle) or without Ng (black cross). All protein concentrations were listed in Table 1.
We thank Dr Len Stephens, Dr Simon Andrews, and Dr Michael Wakelam for their support and help.
- 1. Chattopadhyaya R, Meador WE, Means AR, Quiocho FA. Calmodulin structure refined at 1.7 Å resolution. Journal of Molecular Biology. 1992. pmid:1474585
- 2. Stefan MI, Edelstein SJ, Le Novère N. An allosteric model of calmodulin explains differential activation of PP2B and CaMKII. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2008;105(31):10768–10773. pmid:18669651
- 3. Crivici A, Ikura M. Molecular and structural basis of target recognition by calmodulin. Annual Review of Biophysics and Biomolecular Structure. 1995;24:85–116. pmid:7663132
- 4. Rhoads AR, Friedberg F. Sequence motifs for calmodulin recognition. The FASEB journal. 1997;11(5):331–340.
- 5. Theoharis NT, Sorensen BR, Theisen-Toupal J, Shea MA. The neuronal voltage-dependent sodium channel type II IQ motif lowers the calcium affinity of the C-domain of calmodulin. Biochemistry. 2008;47(1):112–123. pmid:18067319
- 6. Evans TIA, Shea MA. Energetics of calmodulin domain interactions with the calmodulin binding domain of CaMKII. Proteins: Structure, Function and Bioinformatics. 2009;76(1):47–61.
- 7. Feldkamp MD, Yu L, Shea MA. Structural and energetic determinants of apo calmodulin binding to the IQ motif of the Na V1.2 voltage-dependent sodium channel. Structure. 2011;19(5):733–747. pmid:21439835
- 8. O’Donnell SE, Yu L, Fowler CA, Shea MA. Recognition of β-calcineurin by the domains of calmodulin: Thermodynamic and structural evidence for distinct roles. Proteins: Structure, Function and Bioinformatics. 2011;79(3):765–786.
- 9. Malenka RC, Bear MF. LTP and LTD: an embarrassment of riches. Neuron. 2004;44(1):5–21. pmid:15450156
- 10. Li L, Stefan MI, Novère NL. Calcium Input Frequency, Duration and Amplitude Differentially Modulate the Relative Activation of Calcineurin and CaMKII. PLoS One. 2012;7(9):e43810. pmid:22962589
- 11. Putkey JA, Kleerekoper Q, Gaertner TR, Waxham MN. A New Role for IQ Motif Proteins in Regulating Calmodulin Function. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 2003;278(50):49667–49670. pmid:14551202
- 12. Huang KP, Huang FL, Chen HC. Characterization of a 7.5-kDa protein kinase C substrate (RC3 protein, neurogranin) from rat brain. Arch Biochem Biophys. 1993;305(2):570–580. pmid:8080473
- 13. Kumar V, Chichili VP, Zhong L, Tang X, Velazquez-Campoy A, Sheu FS, et al. Structural basis for the interaction of unstructured neuron specific substrates neuromodulin and neurogranin with Calmodulin. Sci Rep. 2013;3:1392. pmid:23462742
- 14. Fedorov NB, Pasinelli P, Oestreicher AB, DeGraan PNE, Reymann KG. Antibodies to Postsynaptic PKC Substrate Neurogranin Prevent Long‐term Potentiation in Hippocampal CA1 Neurons. European Journal of Neuroscience. 1995;7(4):819–822. pmid:7620629
- 15. Pak JH, Huang FL, Li J, Balschun D, Reymann KG, Chiang C, et al. Involvement of neurogranin in the modulation of calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II, synaptic plasticity, and spatial learning: a study with knockout mice. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2000;97(21):11232–11237. pmid:11016969
- 16. Huang KP, Huang FL, Jäger T, Li J, Reymann KG, Balschun D. Neurogranin/RC3 enhances long-term potentiation and learning by promoting calcium-mediated signaling. J Neurosci. 2004;24(47):10660–10669. pmid:15564582
- 17. Zhong L, Cherry T, Bies CE, Florence MA, Gerges NZ. Neurogranin enhances synaptic strength through its interaction with calmodulin. EMBO J. 2009;28(19):3027–3039. pmid:19713936
- 18. Zhong L, Gerges NZ. Neurogranin and synaptic plasticity balance. Commun Integr Biol. 2010;3(4):340–342. pmid:20798820
- 19. Krucker T, Siggins GR, McNamara RK, Lindsley KA, Dao A, Allison DW, et al. Targeted disruption of RC3 reveals a calmodulin-based mechanism for regulating metaplasticity in the hippocampus. J Neurosci. 2002;22(13):5525–5535. pmid:12097504
- 20. Linse S, Helmersson A, Forsén S. Calcium binding to calmodulin and its globular domains. J Biol Chem. 1991;266(13):8050–8054. pmid:1902469
- 21. Bayley PM, Findlay WA, Martin SR. Target recognition by calmodulin: dissecting the kinetics and affinity of interaction using short peptide sequences. Protein Sci. 1996;5(7):1215–1228. pmid:8819155
- 22. VanScyoc WS, Sorensen BR, Rusinova E, Laws WR, Alexander Ross JB, Shea MA. Calcium binding to calmodulin mutants monitored by domain-specific intrinsic phenylalanine and tyrosine fluorescence. Biophysical Journal. 2002;83(5):2767–2780. pmid:12414709
- 23. Faas GC, Raghavachari S, Lisman JE, Mody I. Calmodulin as a direct detector of Ca2+ signals. Nat Neurosci. 2011;14(3):301–304. pmid:21258328
- 24. Finn BE, Evenàs J, Drakenberg T, Waltho JP, Thulin E, Forsén S. Calcium-induced structural changes and domain autonomy in calmodulin. Nature Structural Biology. 1995;2(9):777–783. pmid:7552749
- 25. Lai M, Brun D, Edelstein SJ, Le Novère N. Modulation of Calmodulin Lobes by Different Targets: An Allosteric Model with Hemiconcerted Conformational Transitions. PLoS Computational Biology. 2015;11(1).
- 26. Hoffman L, Chandrasekar A, Wang X, Putkey JA, Waxham MN. Neurogranin alters the structure and calcium binding properties of calmodulin. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 2014;289(21):14644–14655. pmid:24713697
- 27. Chichili VPR, Xiao Y, Seetharaman J, Cummins TR, Sivaraman J. Structural Basis for the Modulation of the Neuronal Voltage-Gated Sodium Channel NaV1.6 by Calmodulin. Scientific Reports. 2013;3(1):2435.
- 28. Cui Y, Wen J, Sze KH, Man D, Lin D, Liu M, et al. Interaction between calcium-free calmodulin and IQ motif of neurogranin studied by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Anal Biochem. 2003;315(2):175–182. pmid:12689827
- 29. Ikura M, Clore G, Gronenborn A, Zhu G, Klee C, Bax A. Solution structure of a calmodulin-target peptide complex by multidimensional NMR. Science. 1992;256(5057):632–638.
- 30. Meador W, Means A, Quiocho F. Target enzyme recognition by calmodulin: 2.4 A structure of a calmodulin-peptide complex. Science. 1992;257(5074):1251–1255.
- 31. Gaertner TR, Putkey JA, Waxham MN. RC3/Neurogranin and Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II produce opposing effects on the affinity of calmodulin for calcium. J Biol Chem. 2004;279(38):39374–39382. pmid:15262982
- 32. Kubota Y, Waxham MN. Lobe specific Ca2+-calmodulin nano-domain in neuronal spines: A single molecule level analysis. PLoS Computational Biology. 2010;6(11). pmid:21085618
- 33. Putkey JA, Waxham MN, Gaertner TR, Brewer KJ, Goldsmith M, Kubota Y, et al. Acidic/IQ motif regulator of calmodulin. J Biol Chem. 2008;283(3):1401–1410. pmid:17991744
- 34. D’Alcantara P, Schiffmann SN, Swillens S. Bidirectional synaptic plasticity as a consequence of interdependent Ca2+-controlled phosphorylation and dephosphorylation pathways. Eur J Neurosci. 2003;17(12):2521–2528. pmid:12823459
- 35. Holmes WR. Models of calmodulin trapping and CaM kinase II activation in a dendritic spine. J Comput Neurosci. 2000;8(1):65–85. pmid:10798500
- 36. Zhabotinsky AM. Bistability in the Ca(2+)/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase-phosphatase system. Biophys J. 2000;79(5):2211–2221. pmid:11053103
- 37. Kubota Y, Bower JM. Transient versus asymptotic dynamics of CaM kinase II: possible roles of phosphatase. J Comput Neurosci. 2001;11(3):263–279. pmid:11796942
- 38. Lisman JE, Zhabotinsky AM. A model of synaptic memory: a CaMKII/PP1 switch that potentiates transmission by organizing an AMPA receptor anchoring assembly. Neuron. 2001;31(2):191–201. pmid:11502252
- 39. Hayer A, Bhalla US. Molecular switches at the synapse emerge from receptor and kinase traffic. PLoS Comput Biol. 2005;1(2):137–154. pmid:16110334
- 40. Kubota Y, Putkey JA, Neal Waxham M. Neurogranin controls the spatiotemporal pattern of postsynaptic Ca 2+/CaM signaling. Biophysical Journal. 2007.
- 41. Kubota Y, Putkey JA, Shouval HZ, Waxham MN. IQ-motif proteins influence intracellular free Ca2+ in hippocampal neurons through their interactions with calmodulin. J Neurophysiol. 2008;99(1):264–276. pmid:17959737
- 42. Zhabotinsky AM, Camp RN, Epstein IR, Lisman JE. Role of the neurogranin concentrated in spines in the induction of long-term potentiation. J Neurosci. 2006;26(28):7337–7347. pmid:16837580
- 43. Romano DR, Pharris MC, Patel NM, Kinzer-Ursem TL. Competitive tuning: Competition’s role in setting the frequency-dependence of Ca2+-dependent proteins. PLoS Computational Biology. 2017;13(11).
- 44. Shifman JM, Choi MH, Mihalas S, Mayo SL, Kennedy MB. Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII) is activated by calmodulin with two bound calciums. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2006;103(38):13968–13973. pmid:16966599
- 45. Tjandra N, Kuboniwa H, Ren H, Bax A. Rotational Dynamics of Calcium‐Free Calmodulin Studied by 15N‐NMR Relaxation Measurements. European Journal of Biochemistry. 1995. pmid:7601131
- 46. Malmendal A, Evenäs J, Forsén S, Akke M. Structural dynamics in the C-terminal domain of calmodulin at low calcium levels. Journal of Molecular Biology. 1999.
- 47. Schumacher MA, Rivard AF, Bächinger HP, Adelman JP. Structure of the gating domain of a Ca2+-activated K+ channel complexed with Ca2+/calmodulin. Nature. 2001;410(6832):1120–1124. pmid:11323678
- 48. Hucka M, Finney A, Sauro HM, Bolouri H, Doyle JC, Kitano H, et al. The systems biology markup language (SBML): A medium for representation and exchange of biochemical network models. Bioinformatics. 2003. pmid:12611808
- 49. Chelliah V, Juty N, Ajmera I, Ali R, Dumousseau M, Glont M, et al. BioModels: Ten-year anniversary. Nucleic Acids Research. 2015. pmid:25414348
- 50. Rosenberg OS, Deindl S, Sung RJ, Nairn AC, Kuriyan J. Structure of the autoinhibited kinase domain of CaMKII and SAXS analysis of the holoenzyme. Cell. 2005;123(5):849–860. pmid:16325579
- 51. Waxham MN, Aronowski J, Westgate Sa, Kelly PT. Mutagenesis of Thr-286 in monomeric Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II eliminates Ca2+/calmodulin-independent activity. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 1990;87(4):1273–7. pmid:2154738
- 52. Klee CB, Crouch TH, Krinks MH. Calcineurin: a calcium- and calmodulin-binding protein of the nervous system. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 1979;76(12):6270–3. pmid:293720
- 53. Perrino BA, Ng LY, Soderling TR. Calcium regulation of calcineurin phosphatase activity by its B subunit and calmodulin: Role of the autoinhibition domain. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 1995;270(1):340–346. pmid:7814394
- 54. Kissinger CR, Parge HE, Knighton DR, Lewis CT, Pelletier LA, Tempczyk A, et al. Crystal structures of human calcineurin and the human FKBP12-FK506-calcineurin complex. Nature. 1995;378(6557):641–644. pmid:8524402
- 55. Sabatini BL, Oertner TG, Svoboda K. The life cycle of Ca(2+) ions in dendritic spines. Neuron. 2002;33(3):439–452. pmid:11832230
- 56. Grabarek Z. Structure of a trapped intermediate of calmodulin: Calcium regulation of EF-hand proteins from a new perspective; 2005.
- 57. Quintana AR, Wang D, Forbes JE, Waxham MN. Kinetics of calmodulin binding to calcineurin. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2005;334(2):674–680. pmid:16009337
- 58. Putkey JA, Waxham MN. A peptide model for calmodulin trapping by calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 1996;271(47):29619–29623. pmid:8939892
- 59. Hoops S, Sahle S, Gauges R, Lee C, Pahle J, Simus N, et al. COPASI–a COmplex PAthway SImulator. Bioinformatics. 2006;22:3067–74. pmid:17032683
- 60. Petzold L. Automatic Selection of Methods for Solving Stiff and Nonstiff Systems of Ordinary Differential Equations. SIAM Journal on Scientific and Statistical Computing. 1983.
- 61. Dalle Pezze P, Le Novère N. SBpipe: A collection of pipelines for automating repetitive simulation and analysis tasks. BMC Systems Biology. 2017. pmid:28395655
- 62. Lucić V, Greif GJ, Kennedy MB. Detailed state model of CaMKII activation and autophosphorylation. Eur Biophys J. 2008;38(1):83–98. pmid:18769913
- 63. Allbritton NL, Meyer T, Stryer L. Range of messenger action of calcium ion and inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate. Science. 1992;258(5089):1812–1815.
- 64. Sharma K, Schmitt S, Bergner CG, Tyanova S, Kannaiyan N, Manrique-Hoyos N, et al. Cell type– and brain region–resolved mouse brain proteome. Nature Neuroscience. 2015;18(12):1819–1831. pmid:26523646
- 65. Bienenstock EL, Cooper LN, Munro PW. Theory for the development of neuron selectivity: orientation specificity and binocular interaction in visual cortex. J Neurosci. 1982;2(1):32–48. pmid:7054394
- 66. Petersen A, Gerges NZ. Neurogranin regulates CaM dynamics at dendritic spines. Scientific Reports. 2015;5:1–10.
- 67. Peersen OB, Madsen TS, Falke JJ. Intermolecular tuning of calmodulin by target peptides and proteins: differential effects on Ca2+ binding and implications for kinase activation. Protein Sci. 1997;6(4):794–807. pmid:9098889
- 68. Gerendasy DD, Sutcliffe JG. RC3/neurogranin, a postsynaptic calpacitin for setting the response threshold to calcium influxes. Molecular Neurobiology. 1997. pmid:9396008
- 69. Baudier J, Deloulme JC, Van Dorsselaer A, Black D, Matthes HWD. Purification and characterization of a brain-specific protein kinase C substrate, neurogranin (p17). Identification of a consensus amino acid sequence between neurogranin and neuromodulin (GAP43) that corresponds to the protein kinase C phosphorylation si. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 1991.
- 70. Gerendasy D. Homeostatic tuning of Ca2+ signal transduction by members of the calpacitin protein family. Journal of Neuroscience Research. 1999. pmid:10491576
- 71. Prichard L, Deloulme JC, Storm DR. Interactions between neurogranin and calmodulin in vivo. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 1999. pmid:10075657
- 72. Baumgärtel K, Mansuy IM. Neural functions of calcineurin in synaptic plasticity and memory; 2012.
- 73. Dineley KT, Kayed R, Neugebauer V, Fu Y, Zhang W, Reese LC, et al. Amyloid-β oligomers impair fear conditioned memory in a calcineurin-dependent fashion in mice. Journal of Neuroscience Research. 2010. pmid:20544830
- 74. Rachidi M, Lopes C. Molecular and cellular mechanisms elucidating neurocognitive basis of functional impairments associated with intellectual disability in Down syndrome. American Journal on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities. 2010. pmid:20441388
- 75. Berridge MJ. Calcium signalling and Alzheimer’s disease; 2011.
- 76. Mohmmad Abdul H, Baig I, LeVine H, Guttmann RP, Norris CM. Proteolysis of calcineurin is increased in human hippocampus during mild cognitive impairment and is stimulated by oligomeric Abeta in primary cell culture. Aging Cell. 2011. pmid:20969723
- 77. Ikegami S, Inokuchi K. Antisense DNA against calcineurin facilitates memory in contextual fear conditioning by lowering the threshold for hippocampal long-term potentiation induction. Neuroscience. 2000. pmid:10891607
- 78. Malleret G, Haditsch U, Genoux D, Jones MW, Bliss TVP, Vanhoose AM, et al. Inducible and reversible enhancement of learning, memory, and long-term potentiation by genetic inhibition of calcineurin. Cell. 2001. pmid:11257222
- 79. Zeng H, Chattarji S, Barbarosie M, Rondi-Reig L, Philpot BD, Miyakawa T, et al. Forebrain-specific calcineurin knockout selectively impairs bidirectional synaptic plasticity and working/episodic-like memory. Cell. 2001. pmid:11733061
- 80. Jouvenceau A, Billard JM, Haditsch U, Mansuy IM, Dutar P. Different phosphatase-dependent mechanisms mediate long-term depression and depotentiation of long-term potentiation in mouse hippocampal CA1 area. European Journal of Neuroscience. 2003. pmid:12956726
- 81. Kang-Park MH, Sarda MA, Moore SD, Shenolikar S, Wilson WA, Clark S, et al. Protein Phosphatases Mediate Depotentiation Induced by High-Intensity Theta-Burst Stimulation. Journal of Neurophysiology. 2006.
- 82. Jouvenceau A, Dutar P. A role for the protein phosphatase 2B in altered hippocampal synaptic plasticity in the aged rat. Journal of Physiology Paris. 2006;99:154–161.
- 83. Christie-Fougere MM, Darby-King A, Harley CW, McLean JH. Calcineurin inhibition eliminates the normal inverted U curve, enhances acquisition and prolongs memory in a mammalian 3′-5′-cyclic AMP-dependent learning paradigm. Neuroscience. 2009. pmid:19041926
- 84. Baumgärtel K, Genoux D, Welzl H, Tweedie-Cullen RY, Koshibu K, Livingstone-Zatchej M, et al. Control of the establishment of aversive memory by calcineurin and Zif268. Nature Neuroscience. 2008. pmid:18425121
- 85. Ramakers GMJ, Gerendasy DD, De Graan PNE. Substrate phosphorylation in the protein kinase Cγ knockout mouse. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 1999. pmid:9890937
- 86. Gerendasy DD, Herron SR, Watson JB, Sutcliffe JG. Mutational and biophysical studies suggest RC3/neurogranin regulates calmodulin availability. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 1994. pmid:8071370
- 87. Gerendasy DD, Herron SR, Jennings PA, Sutcliffe JG. Calmodulin stabilizes an amphiphilic α-helix within RC3/neurogranin and GAP-43/neuromodulin only when Ca2+is absent. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 1995. pmid:7896819
- 88. Volk LJ, Daly CA, Huber KM. Differential Roles for Group 1 mGluR Subtypes in Induction and Expression of Chemically Induced Hippocampal Long-Term Depression. Journal of Neurophysiology. 2006. pmid:16421200
- 89. Strack S, Colbran RJ. Autophosphorylation-dependent targeting of calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II by the NR2B subunit of the N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 1998. pmid:9694809
- 90. Okabe S. Molecular anatomy of the postsynaptic density; 2007.