Plant epithelia: What is the role of the mortar in the wall?

In a growing plant root, the inner vascular system is sealed off by an epithelium, the endodermis. The space between all of the cells in the endodermal layer is filled with an impermeable mass called the Casparian strip, which closes the spaces between cells in the endodermal layer. The role of the Casparian strip has been proposed to prevent backflow of water and nutrients into the soil, but as mutant plants lacking the Casparian strip only have weak phenotypes, the view that it serves an essential function in plants has been challenged. In an accompanying paper, it is shown that loss of the Casparian strip impacts the ability of the plant to take up ammonium and allocate it to the shoots.

from the leaves to the root and other places of the plant in need of energy. In contrast to the phloem (and arteries and veins), the xylem is made of dead cells with porous cell walls; the vessels are therefore not isolated from their surroundings and their content is free to leak out of them. This explains why, in the absence of an endodermal barrier, pressure would never be able to build up in the vascular cylinder.
If nutrients in the xylem cannot leak out of the vascular cylinder, how are they able enter it initially? Entrance into the vascular cylinder is made possible by the millions of cells of the endodermis that are embedded in the Casparian strip like bricks in a wall. In order to enter the vascular cylinder, a nutrient must actively enter an endodermal cell through a transport protein, diffuse through it, and in doing so, bypass the Casparian strip ( Fig 1B and Fig 2). The whole process is like a car driving through a tunnel in a hill. On the other side of the Casparian strip, the nutrient is transported by another transport protein out of the cell, transported into the xylem, and is then free to move upward toward the shoot. However, this function in permeating nutrients only holds on as long as endodermal cells are young. With progressing maturation, endodermal cells become impregnated by a layer of waxy substances that are A. The 3D tissue layout of a root is a series of concentric annular cylinders made up of the epidermis, cortex, endodermis, and, in the center, the vascular cylinder [22]. B. The Casparian strip is a water-impermeable sealing that fills the space between cells of the root endodermis. The only way for water and solutes to pass this barrier is to enter an endodermal cell. This can happen in one of two ways. Either water or solutes are taken up by transporters at the root epidermis (here, in the case of ammonium, by AMT1;3) and move from cell to cell in a symplastic continuum into an endodermal cell. This symplastic transport pathway predominates when external ammonium is low. Alternatively, water and solutes from the outside medium move through cell walls toward the endodermis and, at this point, are taken up by a transporter in this cell layer (here, in the case of ammonium, by AMT1;2). This apoplastic transport pathway predominates when external ammonium is high. Some solutes can enter the symplast from the apoplast via any cell in the outer root: the epidermal cells, the cortex cells, or the endodermal cells. In both cases, water and solutes pass the Casparian strip by diffusing through an endodermal cell and are subsequently loaded into the xylem by other transporters for long-distance transport to the shoot. AMT, ammonium transporter. deposited at the inner surface of the cell walls. This so-called suberization prohibits nutrients to enter or leak out, thereby sealing the endodermis like the peel of an orange [9,10].
A nutrient in the soil can be transported through an endodermal cell via two transport pathways ( Fig 1B): i) either it is first taken up by transport proteins in the epidermal cells at the root-soil interface from which it diffuses from cell to cell through plasmadesmata, structures that, analogous to gap junctions in animal cells, form bridges between cells and ultimately find their way to endodermal cells; or ii) it diffuses all the way from the soil through the highly permeable cell walls between cells to the Casparian sealing, and during this passage, it is at some point actively taken up by cells, ultimately endodermal cells. The first pathway is called the  [3]. The Casparian strip is seen as a black thickening between endodermal cells. Magnification x 320. G, "Gefässgruppen" (vessel groups; xylem); L, "Leitzellen" (conducting cells; phloem); M, "Mark" (pith); r, "Rindenzellen" (cortical cells); S, "Schutzscheide" (protective sheath; endodermis).
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000073.g002 symplastic pathway because the nutrient moves inside cells in a symplastic continuum; the other is the apoplastic pathway, as the main part of the diffusion occurs outside of cells.
The signaling cascade that triggers the formation of Casparian strips starts with small peptides derived from the vascular cylinder [11,12]. Wherever they leak out of the vascular cylinder, they are recognized by SCHENGEN3 (SGN3), a receptor-like kinase located in the plasma membrane at the distal side of endodermal cells [13]. This sparks an intricate developmental program, in which the transcription factor Myb-related protein 36 (MYB36) plays a central role in the synthesis and deposition of lignin between endodermal cells [14,15]. The function of the Casparian strip becomes more important under stress conditions such as high salt [16]. However, under salt stress, the Casparian strip itself is relatively unmodified, whereas the suberin layer expands dramatically [17]. This shows that the deposition of suberin may be essential to avoid passage of Na + and Cl − through endodermal cells.
The schengen3 mutant of the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana is unable to form a functional Casparian strip and, in contrast to other Casparian strip mutants, possesses no compensatory mechanism to seal off the endodermis [13]. This mutant offers a unique system to understand the role of the endodermal barrier in plants. Surprisingly, studies of this mutant have shown that SGN3 is not essential for plant life. In fact, the phenotype of sgn3 plants is very weak in the sense that the mutant plants take up water and nutrients and apparently grow normally. An exception is the macronutrient potassium, which, in mutant shoots, is lower than in the wild type [13]. This led to the suggestion that the Casparian strip might not be essential for water and nutrient uptake as such but could have more specific roles, such as permitting accumulation of potassium.
A study published today in PLOS Biology has investigated whether loss of SGN3 affects transport from roots to shoots of another important nutrient, namely ammonium [18]. First, it is shown that strontium, an element not required by plants and typically transported along the apoplastic pathway, does not enter the vasculature in wild-type plants but readily does so in the sgn3 mutant plants. This confirms the role of the Casparian strip as a barrier for solute flow from the growth medium into the vascular cylinder. However, no matter whether the Casparian strip was present or not, ammonium was transported from the root to the shoot. There are different transport proteins in roots involved in ammonium uptake and xylem loading [19,20]. By genetically crossing of sgn3 with other lines expressing ammonium transporters only in the epidermis or in the endodermis, the contribution of each transporter in the presence and absence of the Casparian strip could be studied. With a functional Casparian strip and when soil ammonium content is low, uptake at the epidermis followed by symplastic transport was shown to prevail. In contrast, when soil ammonium content is high, transport via the apoplastic route followed by uptake at the endodermis became the dominant route. In the absence of the Casparian strip, the efficiency of the apoplastic transport route decreased. However, unexpectedly, the efficiency of the symplastic pathway increased in the absence of the Casparian strip, which implies that the endodermal bypass caused by the sgn3 mutation has opposing consequences for the symplastic and apoplastic transport pathways. This was a surprising result, as it indicates that the apoplastic route requires Casparian strips to render ammonium uptake at the endodermis more efficient. Moreover, this approach allowed for the first time determining the relative contribution of both pathways and their dependencies on the Casparian strip for any nutrient.
A root pressure develops when mineral nutrients get actively loaded into the xylem and are followed by water. The sgn3 mutant has reduced root pressure and slower flow of water through the xylem most likely because water cannot build up in this structure without endodermal sealing [13]. Water evaporating from the leaves of the shoots creates a low pressure in the shoot xylem that allows its contents to move upward. Under conditions of high transpiration and accompanying suction of xylem sap from the root, nutrient backflow is prevented, and the Casparian strip may therefore not be as important as when transpiration is low. In an earlier study, sunflower plants growing in water baths were fed with nutrients during the day or the night, when transpiration is high and low, respectively [21]. When comparing the plants under the two conditions, no differences in nutrient uptake and growth could be observed. It was thus concluded that convective water transport in the xylem, brought about by root pressure, is in itself sufficient to supply the shoot with nutrients taken up from the soil [21].
Strikingly, in the new study, plants were grown under conditions-liquid medium and strong light-for which transpiration is high and root pressure low. This could explain the weak nutrient-related phenotypes of the mutant plants. It will be interesting in future work to see how mutant plants without a functional Casparian strip behave under conditions for which the root pressure is high and transpiration low.