Skip to main content
Advertisement
  • Loading metrics

What comes after social tipping? Perspectives from transitions towards net-zero

  • Claudia R. Binder ,

    Roles Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Methodology, Supervision, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    claudia.binder@epfl.ch

    Affiliation Laboratory for Human-Environment Relations in Urban Systems, IIE, ENAC, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland

    ⨯
  • Alejandro Gomez,

    Roles Conceptualization, Methodology, Formal analysis, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliations Laboratory for Human-Environment Relations in Urban Systems, IIE, ENAC, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland, Laboratory of Landscape Development, IA, ENAC, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland

    ⨯
  • Jair Campfens,

    Roles Formal analysis, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Laboratory for Human-Environment Relations in Urban Systems, IIE, ENAC, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland

    ⨯
  • Maria Anna Hecher,

    Roles Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Validation, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Laboratory for Human-Environment Relations in Urban Systems, IIE, ENAC, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland

    ⨯
  • Simón Ladino Cano,

    Roles Formal analysis, Validation, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Laboratory for Human-Environment Relations in Urban Systems, IIE, ENAC, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland

    ⨯
  • Léonard Léchot,

    Roles Writing – original draft

    Affiliation Laboratory for Human-Environment Relations in Urban Systems, IIE, ENAC, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland

    ⨯
  • Hanbit Lee,

    Roles Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Laboratory for Human-Environment Relations in Urban Systems, IIE, ENAC, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland

    ⨯
  • Simon Montfort

    Roles Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Laboratory for Human-Environment Relations in Urban Systems, IIE, ENAC, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland

    ⨯

Abstract

The world is on track to exceed 1.5 °C of warming. To avoid further temperature increase, accelerated action to decarbonize our societies is needed. Scholars claim that this transition requires surpassing social tipping points (STPs). STPs are defined as non-linear processes of transformative change in social systems, where a small perturbation triggers a response that generates self-amplifying changes in behaviors. While research efforts have focused on analyzing triggers to tipping, we have little understanding of the structures and mechanisms that stabilize a new state after the tipping phase. We argue that post-tipping trajectories rarely converge to a single stable state. Instead, they converge to multiple coexisting (including reversed) states that can exist as spatial patterns and need to be designed-in for stability. Combining insights from ecological systems, where phenomena that occur after tipping have been researched, with empirical evidence on social tipping in transitions towards net zero, we shed light on states after tipping and on how they may be stabilized. Four phenomena shape post-tipping trajectories: (i) lock-in through co-adoption of technologies or feedback loops; (ii) the co-existence of states; (iii) the reversibility of sustainable behaviors; and (iv) infrastructure as a stabilizer of co-existing or new states. We found that a systemic approach that combines technological and social levers to create positive feedback is needed to stabilize a future state. We propose three policy design principles to achieve this: (1) prioritize infrastructure that creates positive lock-ins to new technologies; (2) combine deep (social norms) and shallow (co-adoption of technologies) levers; and (3) target network brokers to bridge adopter and non-adopter groups and establish diffusion structures.

1. Introduction

Global warming will soon exceed 1.5 °C [1]. To avoid further temperature increase, accelerated action to decarbonize our societies is needed. Current policies and governance models have not been sufficient to meet the political goals of renewable technology adoption and behavioral change [2]. One approach to accelerating the transition involves fostering social tipping points [1]. STPs are defined as “non-linear processes of transformative change in social systems” [3]. After surpassing an STP, both the structure and the dynamics of the system change, leading to a new state of limited reversibility [4–6]. Thus, to identify adequate policy levers, an understanding of what triggers STPs, what supports their acceleration, and how the stabilization of the new state occurs is necessary [1,7].

Research has focused primarily on identifying what mechanisms trigger STPs [8–11]. In so doing, tools have been developed for the early identification of STPs [12–14]. Lenton et al., [7] recently developed a methodology to identify STPs, assess how close we are to tipping, identify factors that can influence them, and actions that may trigger them. However, there is still little knowledge on what future states could look like and which structures and mechanisms – and consequently, which policies – could stabilize them [1,7].

Ayoub and Geels [15] first attempted to address this question by empirically studying solar PV diffusion in Germany and the UK. They claim that after the tipping point was surpassed, both countries experienced a deceleration in adoption dynamics, rather than the expected acceleration: (Negative) socio-political feedback counteracted (positive) techno-economic ones (e.g., cost decreases). The study showed how the relative strength of the feedback loops changed, and no new reinforcing loops emerged. Their framework also did not indicate how future states stabilize. Using a toy model of opinion dynamics, [16] developed a typology of the dynamics and new states that may arise after an STP is reached. The authors suggest that we might encounter accelerated transition, hysteresis implying reversible behaviors, and the coexistence of different states. However, for the urgently needed transition towards net-zero, there is little empirical or conceptual evidence regarding (i) which mechanisms and self-reinforcing processes could stabilize the new system after tipping has occurred, and (ii) which policy levers may foster that stability.

We argue that post-tipping trajectories rarely converge to a single stable state. Instead, they converge to multiple coexisting states that can exist as spatial patterns and need to be designed-in for stability. This essay provides empirically based insights into states that emerge after social tipping and the mechanisms, feedbacks, and policy levers that could support their stabilization. We base our findings on phenomena identified in research on ecological systems, where evidence of what happens after tipping exists. Combining these insights with empirical evidence on social tipping in transitions towards net zero, we address the following questions:

  • Which phenomena do we encounter after the social tipping phase?
  • Under which conditions are the new states likely to be stable?
  • Which policy levers can be used to stabilize a desired new system state?

The essay is structured as follows: we first analyze four phenomena encountered after the tipping phase in ecological systems (stabilization, coexistence, hysteresis, and spatial embeddedness). Second, we scrutinize which of these phenomena are also present in socio-technical systems, including in the transition towards net zero. In the main text, we present key theses and conclude by identifying policy levers and directions for future research.

2. Learning from ecosystems: post-tipping phenomena

We start by analyzing ecosystems, where tipping dynamics have been widely studied [17–20]. Because ecosystems display nonlinear dynamics including thresholds, feedback loops, time lags, and heterogeneous responses to disturbance [20], they offer an empirical basis for examining what happens once a system crosses a tipping point. Across cases, four recurrent features can be identified in the stabilization phase: stabilization around new feedback architectures, the coexistence of contrasting stable states, hysteresis (reversibility), and spatially embedded feedback networks. [21]

BOX: Methodological approach

Our approach relies on the comparative analysis provided by [21], who specify ontological similarities among ecological, climate, and social tipping points. They four main principles that apply to both systems: (i) multiple after-tipping states can be encountered, implying varying magnitudes of change; (ii) nonlinearity exists, i.e., disproportionality between cause and effect; (iii) feedbacks act as either internal drivers of change between two systems or as stabilizers; and (iv) the irreversibility or limited reversibility (hysteresis) of the new state.

We used this ontological similarity to compare phenomena observed in ecological systems with those observed in social systems. Specifically, we proceeded in three steps:

1. Analyze ecological phenomena after tipping and understand the theorized mechanisms

2. Study phenomena in the net-zero transition and identify analogies with the ecological system

3. Analyze the mechanisms present in the social system that link back to theoretical groundings

While the ontology and our phenomena-oriented analysis reveal some common features across the social and ecological systems, we are aware that the two systems differ. In social systems, we need to (i) distinguish agency across individual, group, and national levels; (ii) account for norms, power, and inequality; and (iii) study the different drivers of behavioral change [11,21]. These key differences are accounted for in the examples we present.

Stabilization after tipping

By stabilization, we mean the process by which a system that has crossed a threshold is maintained in a new regime by self-reinforcing processes. In shallow lakes, for example, nutrient enrichment can drive the system from a clear, macrophyte-dominated state to a turbid regime dominated by phytoplankton [17,22]. Algal blooms reduce light penetration, vegetation declines, and benthic-feeding fish resuspend sediments while suppressing grazers such as Daphnia, creating a reinforcing loop that sustains turbidity and nutrient recycling. In this sense, the turbid lake is a reorganized regime maintained by its own reinforcing feedback loops. Following Beisner et al. [18], this can be understood as an interaction between environmental drivers, such as nutrient loading, and ecosystem state variables, such as algal biomass. In the stability-basin heuristic (Fig 1.1), environmental drivers reshape the landscape, while state variables indicate where the system, represented by the ball, sits within it. As nutrient loading increases, the clear-water basin becomes shallower, meaning that the system’s regime resilience declines and is less likely to return to the clear-water state after disturbance. A perturbation can then push the ball into the turbid basin, where reinforcing feedbacks maintain the system in that regime.

thumbnail
Fig 1. Four ecological phenomena that structure system dynamics in ecological systems after crossing a tipping point.

(1.1) Stabilization: Tipping reorganizes feedbacks, allowing new reinforcing loops to consolidate an alternative ecological regime, illustrated here for the clear- to turbid-water transition in shallow lakes. (1.2) Coexistence: Limited connectivity and spatial heterogeneity isolate local feedbacks, enabling contrasting regimes to persist side-by-side under similar conditions. (1.3) Hysteresis: Because feedbacks reconfigure during the transition, recovery requires stronger forcing than collapse, producing asymmetry and ecological memory. (1.4) Spatial coupling: Spatial structures and connectivity shape how feedbacks propagate or remain locally anchored, mediating whether stabilization stays localized or spreads through cascading.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pclm.0000982.g001

Co-existence of different states

The coexistence of different states represents the spatio-temporal unfolding of tipping across connected yet uneven ecosystems. With this phenomenon, we observe that threshold crossing can unfold unevenly across a spatially extended ecosystem, so that patches may temporarily or persistently occupy different regimes. This describes asynchronous local shifts, prolonged transient co-occurrence, or stabilized spatial mosaics in heterogeneous landscapes over ecologically relevant periods [23,24]. In Lake Taihu, for example, lake size, spatial heterogeneity, and weak exchange between compartments shape how light penetration, sediment resuspension, nutrient cycling, and macrophyte or phytoplankton dominance vary across lacustrine sub-basins [25]. As a result, some regions remain clear while others are turbid, forming a spatial mosaic of equilibria that respond asynchronously to environmental forcing (Fig 1.2). This pattern is consistent with spatial regime-shift theory: spatial heterogeneity can cause patches to cross thresholds at different values of the control variable [24], while slow traveling waves, mild spatial barriers, or heterogeneous diffusion can allow alternative states to co-occur for long periods or become pinned in space [23].

Hysteresis

By hysteresis, we mean limited or path-dependent reversibility: after a threshold has been crossed, reducing the initial driver to its former level may not be sufficient to restore the previous regime. In ecosystems with alternative stable states, forward and backward shifts can occur at different values of a control variable because feedbacks maintain the system within its current stability basin [17,18]. Recovery then requires stronger forcing than the initial disturbance because the system must overcome the stability generated by its own reconfigured feedback loops (Fig 1.3). In shallow lakes, for example, reducing nutrient loading may not immediately restore a clear-water state, because sediment suspension and altered food-web interactions can continue to stabilize the turbid regime. In this sense, hysteresis reflects ecological memory: past shifts shape present dynamics and make return trajectories asymmetric [26].

Spatial embeddedness of feedbacks

Finally, studies across ecosystems show that the propagation and stabilization of feedbacks during and after a tipping event depend strongly on spatial structure and network topology. The level of connectivity and the heterogeneity of ecosystem components regulate whether feedbacks remain locally contained or become synchronized across landscapes, a distinction central to the theory of critical transitions [27]. This is related to, but distinct from, the previous phenomenon: coexistence describes the spatiotemporal heterogeneity of states, whereas spatial embeddedness explains how spatial structure supports the system’s structural stability. In patterned savannas, for example, this can include local facilitation, where nearby plants improve soil moisture and microclimatic conditions, and longer-distance competition for water and nutrients can give rise to self-organized patterns that influence where transitions begin and stabilize [28]. Low connectivity may confine such feedback to specific patches, whereas higher connectivity can synchronize them across patches. Consequently, root systems, coral skeletons, and sediment structures can channel water, nutrients, and energy along specific pathways [29]. These structures also act as spatial memory, meaning that past ecological organization helps determine where feedbacks take hold, remain contained, or cascade into wider regime shifts (Fig 1.4).

3. Relating ecological insights to social tipping

Based on the insights from tipping in ecological systems, we now reflect on how this relates to socio-technical tipping in the transition towards net-zero. Following the methodological approach presented in BOX 1, we present empirical examples at the individual, group, and municipal levels and examine renewable energy (co-)adoption, infrastructure development, and behavioral change, while considering equity issues.

3.1 How new states become stable

3.1.1 Lock-ins through co-adoption of technologies at the individual level.

As illustrated above for ecological systems, the stabilization of a new system state requires mechanisms that reinforce the new behavior and make reversal to the old state difficult. In socio-technical systems, while the tipping event itself may be triggered by external factors such as policy changes or price drops, co-adoption can provide an internal mechanism for system stabilization, creating positive lock-in across technological and social systems.

Studies focusing on technology adoption and diffusion have shown that the adoption of one technology often acts as a precursor or trigger for the adoption of another, creating a reinforcing cascade. This is evident at the household scale, where the transition requires integrating multiple low-carbon technologies. For example, photovoltaics (PV) can provide renewable energy that powers electric vehicles (EV) or heat pumps [30–32]. Energy management systems can tie these components together, optimizing energy flows, balancing the grid, and significantly increasing energy self-consumption, thus supporting the stabilization of the new system state [33,34].

Co-adoption of energy technologies creates lock-in through functional and economic interdependence and thus stabilizes the technology (non)adoption state.

The core of this stabilization lies in the systems’ functional and economic complementarity, which inherently reduces households’ perceived risk and purchasing effort [31,35,36]. The co-adopted technologies enhance the utility and economic viability of the entire system. A household that installs PV then has an economic incentive to purchase an EV or heat pump to maximize the return on the initial investment through self-consumed electricity, creating a reinforcing technical feedback loop. Thus, interdependent technologies ultimately create a form of systemic lock-in that is less vulnerable to external pressure or policy shifts. Co-dependence means that if one technology fails (e.g., the heat pump breaks down), the most economically rational choice is to replace it with a low-carbon technology rather than revert to the old fossil-fuel alternative (e.g., install a new gas boiler). The co-dependence of the components becomes a systemic barrier to reversion, stabilizing the new, lower-carbon system state.

While technology co-adoption can create beneficial lock-in at the household level, the same dynamics can lead to a less desirable form of lock-in, stabilizing a suboptimal system state and undermining the transition’s depth [37]. This can occur through mechanisms such as “innovation myopia,” which prioritizes short-term speed over structural depth, and “complexity paralysis,” where horizontal complementarities introduce complexity that restricts adoption. Therefore, achieving net-zero requires guiding technology co-adoption to ensure the new stable state avoids becoming locked into a technologically and environmentally insufficient or socially undesired intermediate system.

3.1.2 Stabilizing the new system: The emergence of new feedback loops after tipping.

As already shown for ecological systems, self-reinforcing processes play a central role in shaping the stability of the new system following tipping. This is also true for socio-technical systems, particularly when they undergo tipping processes that shift them from one stable state to another. As shown above, at the level of individual technology adoption, co-adoption can create lock-in and stabilize the new system. Similar dynamics can also emerge at the municipal level, where local governments can incentivize and leverage individual adoption behaviors to support the transition towards renewables.

We illustrate how dominant feedback loops evolve across stable states before and after tipping using the case of the energy transition in the municipality of Pully [38].

As shown in Fig 2, a pre-tipping state comprises a dominant feedback loop that is primarily technical in nature and reinforces a low-adoption equilibrium. This loop, the “Technology Adoption Trap,” creates a reinforcing cycle that stabilizes a low-uptake equilibrium. Specifically, low levels of solar PV deployment lead to low adoption of battery energy storage systems (BESS), which weakens local grid stability and, in turn, hinders EV adoption. This indirectly restricts EV uptake, reinforcing low solar PV deployment. As shown in [38], such less desirable lock-in dynamics have been identified in earlier work [34,39], demonstrating that the limited adoption of renewable energy technologies can mutually inhibit decarbonization progress [15].

thumbnail
Fig 2. Dominant reinforcing feedback loops before and after tipping.

Before tipping, the system is stabilized in a low-adoption equilibrium by a technically constrained reinforcing loop, where limited co-adoption and weak complementarities between technologies inhibit synergies and lock the system into a low-uptake state. After tipping, an alternative reinforcing loop emerges, sustaining high residential solar PV adoption through peer effects, awareness, and perceived viability. Reproduced from [38].

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pclm.0000982.g002

After surpassing a tipping point, the dominant feedback loop changes from a technical one that reinforces the low adoption of renewable energies to a socio-technical one that stabilizes social norms and the adoption of energy technologies.

After tipping, a dominant feedback loop rooted in social and cognitive mechanisms rather than technical ones emerges. This loop, the “Spiral of Behavioral Acceleration,” illustrates how high solar PV deployment stimulates an active peer effect, where early adoption increases visibility and encourages broader uptake. This social visibility heightens public awareness, strongly enhancing the perceived viability of solar PV and creating a reinforcing loop that accelerates deployment. Compared to the first loop, this one exhibits stronger promotional effects and no negative relationships, thereby stabilizing the system in a high-adoption state of solar PV deployment. In contrast to [15], the post-tipping feedback loop is indeed new, not only newly dominant. The reason is that the reinforcing social dynamics (peer effects, awareness, perceived viability) only become self-sustaining once solar PV deployment reaches a sufficiently high level. Before tipping, these interactions are either absent or too weak to constitute a reinforcing loop at the system level.

This shift in dominance from techno-economic traps to behavioral acceleration highlights the necessity for policymakers to deliberately sequence short-term technological incentives with long-term normative approaches to ensure structural stability.

3.2 Co-existence of different states: the case of renewable energy technology adoption

Mirroring the ecological system in which contrasting states can coexist within a single lake, studies of technological adoption suggest that social tipping may convert and stabilize only within a specific segment of the population, leading to a permanent split in the social system.

A granular analysis of residential solar PV non-adopters in Switzerland [40] provides a clear illustration of this phenomenon, revealing two coexisting stable states within the non-adopting majority. The study shows that the non-adopting majority (82% of surveyed residents) is clearly segmented into two groups, defining the co-existence of two states. The potential solar PV adopter group (39% of the sample) intends to adopt within five years, representing the part of the population closer to adoption. This group is largely characterized by an enabling structural context, typically comprising homeowners living in single-family homes and those who have already co-adopted other low-carbon technologies. For this group, positive self-reinforcing processes such as local policy incentives and social influence are already active. This makes them the “low-hanging fruit” whose action will accelerate the overall transition. In contrast, members of the unlikely solar PV adopter group (43% of the sample) state that they are unlikely to adopt. The factors differentiating them from potential adopters are deeply structural. Members are significantly less likely to be homeowners, report a lower co-adoption rate for EVs, and have lower perceived economic stability. This segmentation reveals that the social tipping point is heterogeneous and non-inclusive, thus does not convert all individuals. Instead, the transition appears to stabilize in a state of coexistence characterized by one group of adopters (early and potential adopters) and a persistent, structurally excluded group of non-adopters (unlikely adopters).

The social system is likely to stabilize in two co-existing states with different degrees of technology adoption.

This empirical evidence supports the theoretical concept of coexistence after tipping, as observed in ecosystems, demonstrating that the transition is likely to stabilize well below 100% adoption without fundamental structural interventions. In a polarized system, the ultimate success of the transition is not determined by converting the last non-adopter, but by maximizing the overall adoption pool, ensuring the overall rate of change is sufficient. Therefore, policies should not assume full market convergence. Instead, they must navigate permanent co-existence through targeted structural changes to actively integrate excluded groups into the transition. Crucially, these targeted approaches are not merely a matter of market efficiency, but of critical climate justice [41,42]. Under current adoption patterns, benefits remain concentrated among affluent population segments, while low-income renters and multi-family residents are systematically locked out by split incentives and a lack of property control. Failing to deploy inclusive approaches, such as regulated tenant-landlord schemes, therefore risks anchoring deep socio-economic inequalities as a permanent feature of the post-tipping state.

3.3 Hysteresis: The reversibility of sustainable behaviors

In ecological systems, changes that occur after tipping may be reversible, but this reversibility is limited by hysteresis. Once a system crosses a critical threshold and settles into a new stable state, stronger forcing is usually required to push it back to the previous attractor than was originally needed to drive it across the tipping point [17,43,44]. This asymmetry arises because the tipping process reconfigures the system’s internal feedback architecture, establishing a new regime with its own reinforcing dynamics. Social systems exhibit similar logic, though with greater complexity [21].

When a social system tips, the transition process reconfigures the feedback structure that sustains it: in other words, actors change their behavior to adapt to new system conditions [9,21]; infrastructures and institutions reorganize themselves around the shifted pattern of behavior [15,45]; and interactions within the system are stabilized by new social norms [46]. As a result, two stable states of a social system may appear similar on the surface that rest on different stabilizing mechanisms [21]. Therefore, when changes after tipping are reversed, this rarely implies a return to the original equilibrium due to hysteresis [16]. Even when system behaviors revert, the underlying feedback architecture may have shifted in ways that make the “reversed” state qualitatively different from the pre-tipping one.

The trajectory of global air travel during and after the COVID-19 pandemic illustrates this. The collapse of air travel during the pandemic, driven by stringent mobility restrictions, led scholars to speculate that a shift toward low-carbon travel behaviors might be attainable [47,48]. Yet once restrictions were lifted, air travel rebounded rapidly, reaching pre-pandemic levels by the end of 2023 and attaining an all-time high in 2024 [49]. The speed and scale of this rebound indicate that the core stabilizing feedbacks underpinning high-carbon mobility – aviation cost structures, infrastructures of global connectivity, established travel-related social norms, and habitual practices, among others [50] – were not disrupted, even though mobility patterns for some segments (e.g., business travelers) changed significantly [51]. New motivations for leisure travel also emerged, further reinforcing aviation demand – for example, stronger intentions to fly due to the awareness of having saved money during the pandemic [52]. The temporary ban introduced through government intervention never translated into a new stable state because other system elements did not simultaneously evolve toward sustainable mobility.

After social tipping, the reversibility of sustainable behaviors rarely restores the original system state because the underlying feedbacks have been reconfigured.

Backward change dynamics are therefore highly uncertain and can lead to unintended consequences, such as the rebound in global air travel. This poses a challenge for future attempts to stabilize positive tipping dynamics, since social tipping processes involve distributed agency and limited manageability, and also because interventions interact with infrastructures, institutions, and norms in ways that cannot be fully controlled once non-linear change has been triggered [3]. From a policy perspective, this means that positive tipping should not only be triggered but also stabilized through enabling conditions and reinforcing feedbacks that make the desired state less vulnerable to reversion [5].

3.4 Spatial networks: Infrastructure as driver and stabilizer

As shown for ecosystems, spatiality matters in triggering change and stabilizing the new or the old system. In socio-technical systems, neighborhood or city-scale infrastructural changes are an additional element (to co-adoption) required for stability in the transition towards net-zero. Historically, large-scale transitions have been driven by infrastructure, which physically embeds a particular system logic into the landscape. The existing fossil-fuel-based energy system is a prime example of this negative lock-in. Energy infrastructures, technologies, and institutions form an interlocked system that directly hinders decarbonization through entrenched standards, vested interests, and the sheer longevity of assets with a 40-year lifespan [53–55]. This lock-in is not only technological but also behavioral: cheap energy has stimulated demand for energy-intensive goods and services, while urban forms that spatially separate housing, economic centers, and services have locked households into car-dependent lifestyles [56,57].

The same principle can be harnessed to stabilize a sufficiency-oriented system after tipping by creating reinforcing feedback loops between infrastructure investment and behavioral change. Two cases from cycling transitions illustrate this dynamic. [58] show that the composition of affordances in a socio-ecological system, such as infrastructures that leverage pro-environmental behaviors, plays an essential role in shaping collective behavioral patterns using a case study of cycling uptake in Copenhagen. Their model results showed that tipping points associated with collective pro-environmental behaviors might be most efficiently triggered and stabilized by changes in the physical form of environments, where urban designers and policymakers have most control [58]. A second case study, based on semi-structured interviews conducted in three major Swiss cities, illustrates this dynamic at the level of everyday practice. [59] shows that modal shifts arise from interconnected dynamics, including the conditions of use of different transport modes, the allocation of time and resources, and the coordination of daily practices. For example, one interviewee shifted from driving to cycling after a change in workplace parking availability, and cycling subsequently also became a way to integrate exercise into the daily commute [59]. More broadly, the study found that some modal shifts required a period of learning and adaptation through which new mobility routines were established, while shifts embedded in wider lifestyle changes could become difficult to reverse [59].

Infrastructure facilitates and supports tipping dynamics and can stabilize the system after tipping

Together, these findings illustrate a potential mechanism of positive lock-in: changes in material conditions can facilitate or trigger behavioral shifts, while the subsequent formation of routines, competences, and meanings can stabilize the new mode against reversion. This reinforcing dynamic is consistent with the multi-level perspective, emphasizing that for a new system to become stable, niche innovations must reconfigure the incumbent regime [45]. Understanding the interlinkage between infrastructure and social practice is essential for designing systemic interventions that ultimately stabilize new behaviors. These intersections dictate the scope and long-term consequences of policy actions, shaping socio-material and political arrangements for years [45]. To stabilize a system after tipping, infrastructure must be proactively designed to create positive lock-in. By physically shaping the environment to facilitate sustainable choices by default, infrastructure can tip social practices towards sufficiency and create a new, stable state that is resilient to reversion [60].

4. Policy design principles for post-tipping stabilization

We argue that post-tipping trajectories rarely converge to a single stable state. Instead, they converge to multiple coexisting states that can exist as spatial patterns and need to be designed-in for stability.

The policy challenge is therefore not to engineer a single universal transition pathway but to ensure that co-existing states together are all consistent with net-zero trajectories. Addressing this requires an integrated perspective across four domains: technology and infrastructure, social norms, institutions, and social networks, operating at the individual, group, municipal, and national levels (Fig 3; [61]).

thumbnail
Fig 3. Multi-level interactions shaping post-tipping stabilization (Source: authors).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pclm.0000982.g003

Conventional climate policy often operates on a domain-by-domain basis, subsidizing specific technologies or pricing emissions in defined sectors. As shown in Section 3.2, such policies can trigger change but do not ensure that a new state is sustained once reached. Post-tipping stabilization requires the new system to develop positive feedbacks: technologies, institutions, norms, and networks must lock into their new states and reinforce one another across domains because challenges to the new stable state in one domain can trigger reversion in another (infrastructure investments without corresponding norm change leave the system vulnerable to behavioral rebound when financial incentives are withdrawn; coalition entrenchment without distributional legitimacy generates counter coalitions; norm shifts without complementary infrastructure may fail to sustain new behaviors when the physical environment continues to favor the current state). No single domain is self-sufficient, and the stability of the new state is only as robust as its weakest cross-domain link. In the following, we discuss policy design principles for technology and infrastructure, deep and shallow levers, and social networks.

Prioritize infrastructure that creates positive lock-ins into new technologies

Policies should prioritize infrastructures that stabilize positive reinforcing feedbacks across domains: examples include EV charging networks that increase the utility of electric vehicles, heat pump supply chains embedded in building codes, and local energy communities that couple PV generation to collective consumption, creating switching costs that make reversion increasingly impractical independent of continued policy support [62,63]. In particular, for the parts of the population who have not yet reached a tipping point, the critical sequencing principle is that infrastructure investment that supports technologies and behavior that stabilize the envisioned state should precede or accompany instruments that displace the current one, so that the physical alternative exists before the old system is rendered non-viable [63,64]. These measures can be supported by fostering co-adoption and thus, the lock-in of technologies.

Combine deep levers (norm change) and shallow levers

Our findings suggest that, to stabilize a new state, a combination of changes in technical and social systems is necessary [61], requiring alignment across the individual, group, municipal, and national levels (see Fig 3). Policies should aim to combine different levers to induce change [9,65,66]. Deep leverage points include entrenched social norms and long-lived infrastructures that provide durable stability but are challenging to shift. Municipal and state-level change, therefore, requires the reconfiguration of norms and attitudes [38], as reflected in socio-technical transition theory [15]. Policies should accelerate norm cascades by making the new behavior visible and socially rewarded: examples include mandatory energy performance labeling, public carbon benchmarking of municipalities and firms, and the spatial provision of low-carbon infrastructure that embeds clean options into everyday practice [46]. At the same time, destabilizing preexisting norms should be aimed at: as the new norm consolidates, practices associated with the earlier state progressively should lose institutional and social standing, raising the costs of defending them publicly [45,67]. Disclosure requirements and the explicit framing of the new state as the social standard, rather than as an incentivized deviation, may accelerate this process. However, as our findings show, normative change is spatially uneven (Section 3.2): norm-targeted instruments must, therefore, be spatially differentiated and tailored to diverse socioeconomic profiles rather than assuming uniform diffusion. Shallow leverage points, including efficiency gains and the co-adoption of technologies (e.g., PV, heat pumps, and EVs), can further stabilize the new state by creating technological lock-ins through functional and economic interdependencies.

Target network brokers to bridge adopter and non-adopter groups and establish diffusion structures

As our findings show, co-existing states are not a transient phase but a potentially permanent configuration, driven by imbalances in diversity and connectivity within and between networks (Section 3.2; [68]. Centola and Macy [69] show that complex contagion, defined as behavior change requiring reinforcement from multiple contacts, can arrest at partial adoption when bridging ties between subpopulations are absent. Policy can respond through two types of bridge-targeting instruments. First, policies can promote the installation of actors who bridge subpopulations by funding trusted intermediary roles (such as energy advisors embedded in housing associations or community institutions that already have legitimacy in non-adopter communities), deliberately placing bridging actors in network positions that the transition would otherwise not reach. Second, policies can activate existing network members as brokers: peer referral schemes that reward adopters for recruiting neighbors may mobilize the network’s own structure [70], while co-adoption bundling schemes (that is, subsidies conditional on joint adoption within a housing association or neighborhood) force bridging interactions endogenously. Structural barriers that prevent these dynamics, including split incentives between tenants and landlords and the financial exclusion of low-income households, must be addressed through regulated tenure schemes and targeted subsidies; otherwise, non-adopter clusters risk becoming permanently stabilized [68,71]. Thus, policies should specifically target different material and value systems and leverage the potential across the three axes of social influence (social and spatial proximity), co-adoption, and financial concerns [40,71,72].

Consider institutional entrenchment

While we have so far examined the individual elements that contribute to post-tipping system stabilization, we now take a slightly broader view: two feedback mechanisms are relevant when considering stabilization after tipping. First, resource feedback arises when policies create new economic interests that subsequently support the policy’s continuation: green industrial policy, domestic content requirements, and community ownership schemes concentrate clean energy employment and assets in ways that build durable pro-transition constituencies [63]. Second, interpretive feedback through the perception of policies: subsidies and ownership-broadening schemes that allow low-carbon behavior to be personally experienced as effective can change how voters, including conservative ones, evaluate subsequent cost-imposing instruments such as carbon pricing [64,73]. Montfort et al. [64] show that the perceived effectiveness of prior benefit-inducing policies increases support for higher carbon prices. This is particularly true among right-leaning voters – precisely the segment whose support is most needed to build political feasibility. To displace the old, still co-existing system, distinctly political instruments may target organizational and regulatory power rather than financial position alone. Examples include the removal of fossil fuel subsidies and preferential regulatory access, market structure reform that breaks incumbent control over grid access and retail markets, and shifting the burden of proof in permitting so that new fossil investments must justify themselves against a net-zero baseline [74].

5. Further research

The results presented above suggest new research avenues. We group these into three main questions:

  1. Coexistence or convergence: What outcome is good enough? Many socio-technical systems exhibit multiple stable equilibria, meaning that pre-existing practices or norms can persist indefinitely unless a critical threshold is passed [75]. Given that the coexistence of states, i.e., different degrees of depth and type of adoption, is possible [76] and might be stable over time, the question arises: how can we achieve transition if such stable states persist? Understanding the exact conditions under which stable coexistence can be disrupted or maintained will be crucial.
  2. Who connects the dots? Rethinking networks for social norm change. The co-existence of different stable states might be closely related to co-existing social networks [72,77] with their distinct “nodes” and low connectivity. Accordingly, research needs to address different types of social networks and the role of brokers in fostering information and “value” flows [78,79]. The structure of these social networks is critical, and the reach and persuasiveness of communication depend heavily on the quality of connections between nodes [68,80].
  3. What are the causalities? Tipping phenomena involve complex self-reinforcing processes, and current models often combine many influences (economic, social, technological) without clear causal attribution. [7], as well as this essay, rely on causal inferences derived from empirical evidence and theoretical knowledge. However, it is not clear how these potential causal effects relate to one another. In simulation models, sensitivity analysis is used to identify the strengths of different influence factors, whereas in complex models, it is still not clear what the causalities underlying the mechanisms are [81]. Algorithms should be developed that identify causal relationships within tipping dynamics and provide evidence to inform policy design.

6. Conclusion

We propose a new way to think about what happens after social tipping points have been surpassed. We posit that post-tipping trajectories rarely converge to a single stable state. Instead, they converge to multiple coexisting states that can exist as spatial patterns and need to be designed-in for stability. We studied phenomena in ecological systems and related them to empirical evidence from socio-technical systems in their transition towards net zero. While social systems differ from ecological ones, their study allows us to move beyond the traditional thinking in transition and innovation studies, providing insights into the future states we might encounter and how stabilization might occur. We found that the phenomena encountered in ecological systems can be mirrored in socio-technical ones, namely (1) new feedback loops stabilizing the new state; (2) the co-existence of different states after the transition; (3) hysteresis leading to difficult, but possible reversibility; and (4) spatiality, e.g., infrastructure, as driver and stabilizer.

These findings have implications for research and policy. They suggest we need to think in terms of heterogeneity rather than homogeneity – that is, consider multiple pathways and tipping points rather than a single one. We need to think across scales – from individual to national. Finally, we need to design integrative policies that account for the need to stabilize the new state while destabilizing still-existing old ones. The challenge is no longer how to trigger tipping points: It is how to make the outcomes last.

In summary, paraphrasing a remark often attributed to Albert Einstein, solving today’s interconnected environmental challenges may require a shift in thinking rather than simply more of the same.

Acknowledgments

The authors wish to thank two anonymous reviewers for their excellent comments, Matthias Heinrich for valuable inputs and Simon Holley for English review.

References

  1. 1. Lenton TM, Milkoreit M, Willcock S, Abrams JF, McKay DI, Buxton JE, et al. The global tipping points report.
  2. 2. United Nations Environment Programme. Emissions Gap Report 2024: No more hot air … please! With a massive gap between rhetoric and reality, countries draft new climate commitments. 2024. https://wedocs.unep.org/20.500.11822/46404
  3. 3. Milkoreit M. Social tipping points everywhere?—Patterns and risks of overuse. WIREs Climate Change. 2022;14(2).
  4. 4. Everall JP, Tschofenig F, Donges JF, Otto IM. The Pareto effect in tipping social networks: from minority to majority. Earth Syst Dynam. 2025;16(1):189–214.
  5. 5. Lenton TM, Benson S, Smith T, Ewer T, Lanel V, Petykowski E, et al. Operationalising positive tipping points towards global sustainability. Global Sustain. 2022;5:e1.
  6. 6. Spaiser V, Juhola S, Constantino SM, Guo W, Watson T, Sillmann J. Negative social tipping dynamics resulting from and reinforcing earth system destabilisation. Climate change/Human/Earth system interactions/Other methods. 2023.
  7. 7. Lenton TM, Powell TWR, Smith SR, Geels FW, Alkemade F, Ayoub M, et al. A method to identify positive tipping points to accelerate low-carbon transitions and actions to trigger them. Sustain Sci. 2026;21(1):201–20. pmid:41573230
  8. 8. Alkemade F, de Bruin B, El-Feiaz A, Pasimeni F, Niamir L, Wade R. Social tipping dynamics in the energy system. Earth Syst Dynam. 2024;15(2):485–500.
  9. 9. Eker S, Wilson C, Höhne N, McCaffrey MS, Monasterolo I, Niamir L, et al. Harnessing social tipping dynamics: A systems approach for accelerating decarbonization. One Earth. 2024;7(6):976–88.
  10. 10. Otto IM, Donges JF, Cremades R, Bhowmik A, Hewitt RJ, Lucht W. Social tipping dynamics for stabilizing Earth’s climate by 2050. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2020;117(5):2354–65.
  11. 11. Winkelmann R, Donges JF, Smith EK, Milkoreit M, Eder C, Heitzig J. Social tipping processes towards climate action: A conceptual framework. Ecol Econ. 2022;192:107242.
  12. 12. Bauch CT, Sigdel R, Pharaon J, Anand M. Early warning signals of regime shifts in coupled human–environment systems. Proceed National Acad Sci. 2016;113(51):14560–7.
  13. 13. Boulton CA. Urgency under uncertainty: Acting on negative and positive tipping points. Dialogues on Climate Change. 2025;2(2–3):139–44.
  14. 14. Dakos V, Boulton CA, Buxton JE, Abrams JF, Arellano-Nava B, Armstrong McKay DI, et al. Tipping point detection and early warnings in climate, ecological, and human systems. Earth Syst Dynam. 2024;15(4):1117–35.
  15. 15. Ayoub M, Geels FW. What happens after positive tipping points? A socio-technical analysis of acceleration and deceleration in solar-PV diffusion in Germany and the UK. Technol Forecast Soc Change. 2024;207:123642.
  16. 16. Macy MW, Ma M, Tabin DR, Gao J, Szymanski BK. Polarization and tipping points. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2021;118(50):e2102144118.
  17. 17. Scheffer M, Carpenter S, Foley JA, Folke C, Walker B. Catastrophic shifts in ecosystems. Nature. 2001;413(6856):591–6.
  18. 18. Beisner B, Haydon D, Cuddington K. Alternative stable states in ecology. Front Ecol Environ. 2003;1(7):376–82.
  19. 19. Rietkerk M, Dekker SC, De Ruiter PC, Van De Koppel J. Self-organized patchiness and catastrophic shifts in ecosystems. Science. 2004;305(5692):1926–9.
  20. 20. Rocha JC, Schil C, Lindkvist EAL, Biggs R, Blenckner T, Crépin AS, et al. Regime shifts and transformations in social-ecological systems: advancing critical frontiers for safe and just futures. arXiv. 2025.
  21. 21. Milkoreit M, Hodbod J, Baggio J, Benessaiah K, Calderón-Contreras R, Donges JF. Defining tipping points for social-ecological systems scholarship—an interdisciplinary literature review. Environ Res Lett. 2018;13(3):033005.
  22. 22. Folke C, Carpenter S, Walker B, Scheffer M, Elmqvist T, Gunderson L. Regime shifts, resilience, and biodiversity in ecosystem management. Annu Rev Ecol Evol Syst. 2004;35(1):557–81.
  23. 23. van de Leemput IA, van Nes EH, Scheffer M. Resilience of alternative states in spatially extended ecosystems. PLoS One. 2015;10(2):e0116859. pmid:25714342
  24. 24. Van Nes EH, Scheffer M. Implications of spatial heterogeneity for catastrophic regime shifts in ecosystems. Ecology. 2005;86(7):1797–807.
  25. 25. Janssen ABG, Teurlincx S, An S, Janse JH, Paerl HW, Mooij WM. Alternative stable states in large shallow lakes?. J Great Lakes Res. 2014;40(4):813–26.
  26. 26. Beisner BE, Haydon D, Cuddington KL. Encyclopedia of Ecology. Elsevier; 2008. 930–5.
  27. 27. Scheffer M, Carpenter SR, Lenton TM, Bascompte J, Brock W, Dakos V, et al. Anticipating critical transitions. Science. 2012;338(6105):344–8.
  28. 28. Van Der Voort J, Baudena M, Meron E, Rietkerk M, Doelman A. Vegetation patterning can both impede and trigger critical transitions from savanna to grassland. Environ Res Lett. 2025;20(9):094052.
  29. 29. Banerjee S, Baudena M, Carter P, Bastiaansen R, Doelman A, Rietkerk M. Rethinking tipping points in spatial ecosystems. arXiv. 2023.
  30. 30. Agnew S, Dargusch P. Consumer preferences for household-level battery energy storage. Renew Sustain Energy Rev. 2017;75:609–17.
  31. 31. Priessner A, Hampl N. Can product bundling increase the joint adoption of electric vehicles, solar panels and battery storage? Explorative evidence from a choice-based conjoint study in Austria. Ecol Econ. 2020;167:106381.
  32. 32. Stauch A. Does solar power add value to electric vehicles? An investigation of car-buyers’ willingness to buy product-bundles in Germany. Energy Res Soc Sci. 2021;75:102006.
  33. 33. Liang J, Qiu Y (Lucy), Xing B. Impacts of the co-adoption of electric vehicles and solar panel systems: Empirical evidence of changes in electricity demand and consumer behaviors from household smart meter data. Energy Economics. 2022;112:106170.
  34. 34. Shen X, Qiu YL, Bo X, Patwardhan A, Hultman N, Dong B. The impact of co-adopting electric vehicles, solar photovoltaics, and battery storage on electricity consumption patterns: empirical evidence from Arizona. Resour Conserv Recycl. 2023;192:106914.
  35. 35. Plananska J, Gamma K. Product bundling for accelerating electric vehicle adoption: A mixed-method empirical analysis of Swiss customers. Renew Sustain Energy Rev. 2022;154:111760.
  36. 36. Stremersch S, Tellis GJ. Strategic bundling of products and prices: A new synthesis for marketing. J Mark. 2002;66(1):55–72.
  37. 37. van Wijk J, Fischhendler I. When solutions become problems: How low-carbon innovations can undermine sustainability transitions. Energy Res Soc Sci. 2025;130:104421.
  38. 38. Campfens JKEK, Duygan M, Binder CR. Initiating social tipping dynamics in energy transitions: A novel analytical approach for exploring feedback loops and intervention points. Environ Innov Soc Transit. 2025;56:100973.
  39. 39. Unruh GC. Understanding carbon lock-in. Energy Policy. 2000;28(12):817–30.
  40. 40. Duygan M, Hecher MA, Binder CR. What determines the uptake of solar PV? – A survey of early, potential and unlikely adopters of residential PV systems and participants of community PV projects. Energy Policy. 2026;213:115193.
  41. 41. Torné A, Trutnevyte E. Policy mixes for a just, effective, and public budget-conscious household energy transition in Switzerland. Energy Policy. 2026;208:114872.
  42. 42. Zimm C, Mintz-Woo K, Brutschin E, Hanger-Kopp S, Hoffmann R, Kikstra JS. Justice considerations in climate research. Nature Climate Change. 2024;14(1):22–30.
  43. 43. Kéfi S, Saade C, Berlow EL, Cabral JS, Fronhofer EA. Scaling up our understanding of tipping points. Philos Trans R Soc B Biol Sci. 2022;377(1857):20210386.
  44. 44. Scheffer M, Bascompte J, Brock WA, Brovkin V, Carpenter SR, Dakos V, et al. Early-warning signals for critical transitions. Nature. 2009;461(7260):53–9. pmid:19727193
  45. 45. Geels FW, Schot J. Typology of sociotechnical transition pathways. Research Policy. 2007;36(3):399–417.
  46. 46. Nyborg K, Anderies JM, Dannenberg A, Lindahl T, Schill C, Schlüter M. Social norms as solutions. Science. 2016;354(6308):42–3.
  47. 47. Gössling S, Humpe A. The global scale, distribution and growth of aviation: Implications for climate change. Glob Environ Change. 2020;65:102194. pmid:36777089
  48. 48. Sovacool BK, Furszyfer Del Rio D, Griffiths S. Contextualizing the Covid-19 pandemic for a carbon-constrained world: insights for sustainability transitions, energy justice, and research methodology. Energy Res Soc Sci. 2020;68:101701.
  49. 49. IATA. Global air passenger demand reaches record high in 2024. 2025. Accessed 2025 November 14. https://www.iata.org/en/pressroom/2025-releases/2025-01-30-01/
  50. 50. Hansmann R, Binder CR. Reducing personal air-travel: Restrictions, options and the role of justifications. Transp Res Part D: Transp Environ. 2021;96:102859.
  51. 51. Julsrud TE, Kallbekken S. Has international business travel reached a turning point? Exploring the long-term effects of COVID-19 on air-travel practices in knowledge-intensive organizations. Sustain Sci Pract Policy. 2025;21(1).
  52. 52. Hoffmann S, Lang N, Lasarov W, Reimers H. Flying rebound: consequences of the imposed flying sufficiency during the COVID-19 pandemic. J Sustain Tour. 2023;31(8):1983–2002.
  53. 53. Dablander F, Hickey C, Sandberg M, Zell-Ziegler C, Grin J. Embracing sufficiency to accelerate the energy transition. Energy Res Soc Sci. 2025;120:103907.
  54. 54. Hughes TP. Networks of power: electrification in Western society, 1880-1930. Softshell Books ed. ed. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press; 1993.
  55. 55. Seto KC, Davis SJ, Mitchell RB, Stokes EC, Unruh G, Ürge-Vorsatz D. Carbon lock-in: types, causes, and policy implications. Ann Rev Environ Res. 2016;41(1):425–52.
  56. 56. Creutzig F, Agoston P, Minx JC, Canadell JG, Andrew RM, Quéré CL, et al. Urban infrastructure choices structure climate solutions. Nature Clim Change. 2016;6(12):1054–6.
  57. 57. Wiedenhofer D, Lenzen M, Steinberger JK. Energy requirements of consumption: Urban form, climatic and socio-economic factors, rebounds and their policy implications. Energy Policy. 2013;63:696–707.
  58. 58. Kaaronen RO, Strelkovskii N. Cultural evolution of sustainable behaviors: pro-environmental tipping points in an agent-based model. One Earth. 2020;2(1):85–97.
  59. 59. Meinherz F, Binder CR. The dynamics of modal shifts in (sub)urban commuting: An empirical analysis based on practice theories. J Transp Geogr. 2020;86:102763.
  60. 60. Arnz M, Göke L, Thema J, Wiese F, Wulff N, Kendziorski M, et al. Avoid, shift or improve passenger transport? Impacts on the energy system. Energy Strategy Reviews. 2024;52:101302.
  61. 61. Binder CR, Athanassiadis A, Bristow D, Haberl H, Kennedy C. Tipping points toward sustainability: The role of industrial ecology. J Ind Ecol. 2025;29(3):622–33. pmid:42052579
  62. 62. Arthur WB. Competing technologies, increasing returns, and lock-in by historical events. Econ J. 1989;99(394):116–31.
  63. 63. Meckling J, Sterner T, Wagner G. Policy sequencing toward decarbonization. Nat Energy. 2017;2(12):918–22.
  64. 64. Montfort S, Fesenfeld L, Stadelmann-Steffen I, Ingold K. Policy sequencing can increase public support for ambitious climate policy. Policy Soc. 2023 Dec 23;42(4):454–77.
  65. 65. Farmer JD, Hepburn C, Ives MC, Hale T, Wetzer T, Mealy P. Sensitive intervention points in the post-carbon transition. Science. 2019;364(6436):132–4.
  66. 66. Meadows D. Leverage points: places to intervene in a system. Acad Syst Change. 1999;19:28.
  67. 67. Bicchieri C. The grammar of society: The nature and dynamics of social norms. Cambridge University Press; 2005.
  68. 68. Abrahamse W, Steg L. Social influence approaches to encourage resource conservation: A meta-analysis. Global Environ Change. 2013;23(6):1773–85.
  69. 69. Centola D, Macy M. Complex contagions and the weakness of long ties. Am J Sociol. 2007;113(3):702–34.
  70. 70. Hecher MA, Duygan M, Kirklies P-C, Chatelain G, Neumann O. Tracing residential PV adoption journeys: A process-oriented understanding of technology adoption and the role of peer-based initiatives. Environ Res: Energy. 2026;3(2):025020.
  71. 71. Martinez-Alcaraz P, Serra-Coch G, Hecher M, Binder CR. Photovoltaic panels diffusion in Switzerland: understanding adopters profiles using clustering methods. Environ Innov Soc Transit. 2025;56:100995.
  72. 72. Serra-Coch G, Wyss R, Binder CR. Geographic network effects to engage people in the energy transition: The case of PV in Switzerland. Heliyon. 2023;9(7):e17800.
  73. 73. Campbell AL. Policy makes mass politics. Annual Rev Polit Sci. 2012;15(1):333–51.
  74. 74. Mildenberger M. Carbon captured: How business and labor control climate politics. MiT Press; 2020.
  75. 75. Markard J, Rosenbloom D. Phases of the net-zero energy transition and stategies to achieve it. Routledge handbook of energy transitions. Routledge; 2022. 102–23.
  76. 76. Heinrich M, del Campo F, Ladino Cano S, Binder CR. Exploring the co-adoption of low-carbon solutions: A household segmentation approach.
  77. 77. Alexander M, Forastiere L, Gupta S, Christakis NA. Algorithms for seeding social networks can enhance the adoption of a public health intervention in urban India. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2022;119(30):e2120742119.
  78. 78. Montfort S, Fesenfeld L, Ingold K, Lamb WF, Andrijevic M. Political enablers of ambitious climate policies: a framework and thematic review. NPJ Clim Action. 2025;4(1):14. pmid:39959135
  79. 79. Nita A, Zamorano M, Caro-Gonzalez AL, Rozylowicz L. Driving climate action: brokers as catalysts in EU policy networks. Appl Netw Sci. 2025;10(1):41.
  80. 80. Wolske KS, Gillingham KT, Schultz PW. Peer influence on household energy behaviours. Nat Energy. 2020;5(3):202–12.
  81. 81. Bian S, Wang Z, Leng S, Lin W, Shi J. Utilizing causal network markers to identify tipping points ahead of critical transition. Adv Sci (Weinh). 2025;12(42):e15732. pmid:40911335