Phagocytosis of bacteria by innate immune cells is a primary method of bacterial clearance during infection. However, the mechanisms by which the host cell recognizes bacteria and consequentially initiates phagocytosis are largely unclear. Previous studies of the bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa have indicated that bacterial flagella and flagellar motility play an important role in colonization of the host and, importantly, that loss of flagellar motility enables phagocytic evasion. Here we use molecular, cellular, and genetic methods to provide the first formal evidence that phagocytic cells recognize bacterial motility rather than flagella and initiate phagocytosis in response to this motility. We demonstrate that deletion of genes coding for the flagellar stator complex, which results in non-swimming bacteria that retain an initial flagellar structure, confers resistance to phagocytic binding and ingestion in several species of the gamma proteobacterial group of Gram-negative bacteria, indicative of a shared strategy for phagocytic evasion. Furthermore, we show for the first time that susceptibility to phagocytosis in swimming bacteria is proportional to mot gene function and, consequently, flagellar rotation since complementary genetically- and biochemically-modulated incremental decreases in flagellar motility result in corresponding and proportional phagocytic evasion. These findings identify that phagocytic cells respond to flagellar movement, which represents a novel mechanism for non-opsonized phagocytic recognition of pathogenic bacteria.
Flagella-driven bacterial motility, referred to as swimming, has been recognized for over 20 years to affect the ability of bacteria to infect and colonize a host. The common theme is that bacteria must be motile to colonize the host but must become non-motile to chronically persist; this has been observed in many pathogenic bacteria including species of Vibrio and Pseudomonas. Therefore it makes sense that the immune system would evolve mechanisms to exploit this virulence determinant of pathogenic bacteria. Here we present evidence that flagellar motility is recognized by innate immune cells as a phagocytic activation signal. We show that step-wise loss of flagellar motility confers a proportional ability to evade phagocytic engulfment, independent of the flagellum itself acting as a phagocytic activator. This is not due to motility- co-regulated secretions or compensatory genetic changes by the bacteria, but instead is due to a mechano-sensory response whereby phagocytic cells respond directly to flagellar motility. This represents a novel mechanism by which the innate immune system facilitates clearance of bacterial pathogens, and provides an explanation for how selective pressure may result in bacteria with down-regulated flagellar gene expression and motility as is observed in isolates taken from chronic infections.
Citation: Lovewell RR, Collins RM, Acker JL, O'Toole GA, Wargo MJ, Berwin B (2011) Step-Wise Loss of Bacterial Flagellar Torsion Confers Progressive Phagocytic Evasion. PLoS Pathog 7(9): e1002253. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.ppat.1002253
Editor: Craig R. Roy, Yale University School of Medicine, United States of America
Received: March 14, 2011; Accepted: August 1, 2011; Published: September 15, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Lovewell et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This research was supported by RO1 AI067405 and a CF Foundation RDP training grant (B.B.) and NIH training grant NIGMS GM008704 (RRL). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Pathogen recognition by the innate immune system is one of the first lines of defense in cellular immunity to infection . However, how bacteria establish chronic infections, as observed in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF), and the reasons that these infective agents cannot be eliminated by the immune system are still largely unclear , . A relevant example of this is Pseudomonas aeruginosa, a Gram-negative opportunistic pathogen which establishes infection in the lung tissue of CF patients and effectively evades immune clearance , ; CF disease severity correlates with chronic infection of the pulmonary compartment by P. aeruginosa , . One contributing factor that enables immune evasion is the loss of bacterial flagellar motility during colonization –. P. aeruginosa has a single, polar, monotrichous flagellum which provides force for swimming locomotion in aqueous environments . Multiple studies have found that the majority of P. aeruginosa isolates taken from chronically infected CF patients have down-regulated flagellar gene expression and are phenotypically deficient in the ability to swim , . The previous paradigm suggested that the loss of flagellin as a phagocytic ligand facilitates evasion of innate immune cells and results in increased bacterial burden in the CF lung , . Recently, with the use of flagellated and non-flagellated swimming-defective P. aeruginosa genetic mutants, we demonstrated that it is not the loss of the flagellum itself, but rather the loss of flagellar-based swimming motility that allows P. aeruginosa to avoid phagocytic clearance . However, it is currently unclear how the loss of bacterial swimming motility enables phagocytic evasion from innate immune cells and, to date, no published reports have examined in detail the dynamics of non-opsonized P. aeruginosa-phagocyte association and subsequent fate as a function of bacterial swimming motility.
In order to delineate how bacterial swimming contributes to phagocytic recognition and uptake, we take advantage of isogenic bacterial mutations that affect flagellar swimming motility and we identify the individual components that comprise the phagocytic process as it relates to swimming and non-swimming bacteria. Swimming motility in Gram-negative bacteria is powered by generation of an ion gradient to turn a flagellar rotor against a stationary stator complex . The resultant force provides the necessary torque to turn the flagellar filament and thus propel the bacteria . In these studies we utilize genetic mutants which lack structural and functional flagella due to mutations in either the flagellin monomer or the flagellar hook protein and are therefore non-swimming, and also mutants which do not produce all or part of the flagellar stator complex. These mot stator mutants all have fully assembled flagella, since loss of the Mot stator proteins does not impede construction of the flagellar filament, and are instead partially or fully defective in the ability to rotate the flagellum depending on which stator components are omitted , , . Our previous work with these mutants found that the phagocytic response to P. aeruginosa infection depends on flagellar motility, but does not depend on the flagellum itself as an activating ligand .
Since loss of flagellar motility confers phagocytic resistance, these data suggest that innate immune cells have the ability to recognize bacterial movement and that swimming bacteria provide an important sensory input for phagocytic engulfment . However, an alternative explanation is that bacteria change the expression of unknown secreted and/or cell-surface ligands in response to the loss of swimming motility and therefore alter their phagocytic recognition and uptake. Here we test these hypotheses and provide the first evidence that phagocytic cells utilize bacterial swimming motility as a global mechanism for bacterial recognition. Significantly, we show that alterations in swimming motility allow multiple bacterial species to evade phagocytic recognition. This is not due to measurable changes in the expression of common outer membrane proteins (OMPs) or known regulators of pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs). Rather, we provide evidence that phagocytic cells are able to respond to bacterial swimming as a function of flagellar rotation after initial contact and, importantly, that phagocytosis is directly proportional to the flagellar torque of the bacteria. We therefore propose a model in which the step-wise loss of flagellar function confers a progressive increase in the ability of the bacteria to evade the phagocytic response of the innate immune system, which promotes an environmentally beneficial niche during infection. This selective pressure provides an explanation for the down-regulation of motility genes and phenotypic loss of swimming that is observed in isolates procured from chronic infections –.
Loss of flagellar motility is a widespread mechanism amongst Gram-negative bacteria for resistance to phagocytic uptake
To determine whether phagocytic evasion through loss of swimming motility is specific to P. aeruginosa or is a mechanism shared amongst flagellated Gram-negative pathogens, we used genetically modified motility mutants in multiple bacterial backgrounds (Table 1). P. aeruginosa PA14 is a non-mucoid clinical isolate and is considered the wild-type (WT) in this study. All P. aeruginosa genetic mutants used in this study are on the PA14 background. All Vibrio cholerae mutants are constructed using the classical biotype O395 strain and all Escherichia coli mutants are in the K12 background. All non-flagellated strains (which lack swimming motility) have a mutation in either the flagellar hook gene (flgK), or in the gene coding for the flagellin monomer (flaA and fliC for V. cholerae and E. coli, respectively) , , .
The two stator complexes (MotAB and MotCD) in P. aeruginosa are each composed of two proteins and are functionally partially-redundant. Importantly, deletion of all four genes (motABmotCD) inhibits flagellar rotation, but not flagellar assembly, resulting in a mutant that is flagellated but incapable of swimming . The motAB mutant, and to a lesser extent the motCD mutant, are swimming competent, though not to the same degree as the parental WT , . The stator complexes in V. cholerae and E. coli are analogous to those of P. aeruginosa, though not identical in composition. The stator of V. cholerae is also composed of at least four proteins, termed PomA, PomB, MotX, and MotY . The contribution of each protein to stator functionality in V. cholerae is still unclear, however loss of the motX gene results in a flagellated, but non-swimming mutant that is phenotypically similar to the P. aeruginosa motABmotCD mutant , . In E. coli, the stator is composed of only two proteins, MotA and MotB . Loss of either gene product (MotA in this study) results in a similar flagellated, but non-swimming mutant . We previously reported that the genetic loss of the stator complexes in P. aeruginosa PA14 confers resistance to phagocytosis in vitro and in vivo in comparison to the swimming-competent parental strain . Phagocytic evasion is not dependent on flagellar assembly, as both flagellated and non-flagellated mutants were equally capable of avoiding phagocytic ingestion . In order to better understand the dynamics of phagocytic resistance by strains incapable of swimming motility, we first verified that strains competent in swimming motility were as equally susceptible to gentamicin as non-swimming strains and remained equally viable during incubation (Figure S1 and data not shown), and then performed gentamicin protection assays with bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (BMDCs) and increasing concentrations of non-swimming P. aeruginosa relative to the WT concentration. We were not able to identify a resistance threshold in either the flgK or the motABmotCD mutants where phagocytic susceptibility approximated WT levels (Figure 1A). In assays where the concentration of non-swimming bacteria was increased to 100-times that of WT, we observed only a ∼30% increase in recovery relative to WT (Figure 1A), indicating that the mechanism facilitating phagocytic resistance of non-swimming P. aeruginosa can only partially be overcome even in the presence of increased non-swimming bacterial concentrations. This degree of phagocytic resistance conferred by loss of bacterial motility is highlighted by the comparison to other phenotypes that have been reported to alter bacterial clearance. For example, alginate production (mucoidy) by P. aeruginosa has been reported to alter bacterial phagocytic susceptibility , however the swimming mucoid P. aeruginosa strain FRD1  exhibited only a ∼2-fold change in phagocytosis compared to non-mucoid PA14 WT (Figure 1A).
Gentamicin protection assays were used to assess: (A) C57BL/6 BMDC phagocytosis of WT P. aeruginosa strain PA14, the independent mucoid clinical isolate FRD1, and increasing concentrations of non-flagellated mutant flgK and flagellated but non-swimming mutant motABmotCD (in PA14 background). (B) Murine BMDC phagocytosis of WT V. cholerae strain O395, and the flaA, motX, tcpA, and toxT mutants. (C) Murine BMDC phagocytosis of WT E. coli strain K12, and the flgK, fliC, and motA mutants. (D) Human THP-1 leukocyte phagocytosis of P. aeruginosa WT, flgK, and motABmotCD (left); or V. cholerae WT, flaA, and motX (right). Where indicated throughout this and the other figures, phagocytosis of WT strains (PA14, K12 and 0395 in this figure) has been normalized to 100% and the relative phagocytosis of the mutant strains shown as the percent of WT. N≥6, *p<0.05 compared to WT.
To test whether motility-based phagocytic recognition is specific to P. aeruginosa, or if this mechanism extends to other bacterial pathogens as well, we performed similar assays using flagellated and non-flagellated V. cholerae and E. coli genetic mutants that contain analogous mutations to the P. aeruginosa mutants described previously. In assays using V. cholerae, both the non-flagellated flaA mutant and the flagellated but non-swimming motX mutant were ∼100-fold more resistant to phagocytosis than the isogenic WT (Figure 1B). In comparison, the swimming-competent tcpA and toxT mutants, which instead lack toxin co-regulated pili (TCP) which facilitate attachment –, were ingested to a similar degree as WT V. cholerae (Figure 1B). In experiments using E. coli, the non-flagellated flgK and fliC strains and the flagellated but non-swimming motA strain were all significantly more resistant to phagocytosis compared to the swimming WT, although to a lesser degree than observed with P. aeruginosa and V. cholerae (Figure 1C). To test if these findings also applied to human phagocytes, we tested human THP-1 cells for their preferential ability to phagocytose swimming bacteria. The human THP-1 phagocytic cell line recapitulated our observations using murine BMDCs (Figure 1D) which supports a general mechanism by which non-opsonized Gram-negative bacterial recognition by phagocytic cells is swimming motility-dependent and is not species-specific.
P. aeruginosa lacking swimming motility have decreased overall association with innate immune cells independent of flagellar assembly
In order to visualize the host-pathogen interactions that occur between P. aeruginosa and innate immune cells, and to confirm the assays presented in Figure 1, murine peritoneal macrophages were incubated at 37°C with equal numbers of either GFP-transformed P. aeruginosa PA14 WT or motABmotCD, or V. cholerae O395 WT or motX bacteria and the non-adherent bacteria were washed away prior to counter-staining exposed cell-surfaces with Alexa-647-labeled wheat germ agglutinin (WGA). Multiple images per co-incubation were generated by randomly choosing a viewing field and counting the internalized bacteria along the Z-axis of all visible cells. Representative images of co-incubations using O395 WT (Figure 2A, left) or motX (Figure 2A, right) demonstrate that bacteria with swimming motility associate with macrophages to a much higher extent than do non-swimming bacteria. In co-incubations using O395 WT or PA14 WT bacteria (as in Figure 2A) the quantified internalization, as assessed by bacteria within the phagocytes that do not co-localize with the WGA, is increased >10-fold over motX or motABmotCD, respectively (Figure 2B). These data both further support our gentamicin protection assays and the hypothesis that loss of flagellar motility inhibits the ability of phagocytic cells to engulf bacteria.
(A) Confocal fluorescence microscopy of untreated murine peritoneal macrophages co-incubated at 37°C for 45 minutes with GFP-transformed V. cholerae O395 WT (left) or motX (right), washed, and subsequently stained on ice with Alexa647-conjugated wheat germ agglutinin (WGA). (B) Internalized bacteria, as in (A), were quantified on the basis of being within a contiguous WGA-decorated phagocyte plasma membrane and not co-localizing with WGA (co-localization seen as yellow, as at the plasma membrane or being external to a phagocytic cell). N≥6 images, *p<0.05.
Increased phagocytic resistance by P. aeruginosa motABmotCD is not due to compensatory changes in bacterial secretions, extracellular protein expression, or PAMP presentation
One possible explanation for our current observations is that motility or loss of motility elicits the release of an unknown soluble factor, and that this hypothetical ligand is acting to either induce phagocytosis (if elicited in the motile bacteria) or to impair phagocytosis (if elicited in the non-motile bacteria) by affecting either the neighboring bacteria or the phagocyte itself. In either scenario, we hypothesized that one bacterial strain may affect the phagocytosis of the other strain in trans. We tested this hypothesis with mixed cultures of PA14 WT and motABmotCD. Carbinicillin-resistant (Carbr) WT or the motABmotCD mutant were mixed in equal numbers with the Carbinicillin-sensitive (Carbs) version of the other strain and introduced to murine BMDCs in a standard gentamicin protection assay, after which lysates were plated on Carbinicillin-selective plates. The number of recovered Carbr-motABmotCD CFUs after co-incubation with Carbs-WT and BMDCs was not significantly different than when motABmotCD alone was incubated with BMDCs (Figure 3A). Likewise, recovered CFUs of Carbr-WT when mixed with Carbs-motABmotCD did not change from what is observed when WT alone is assayed by gentamicin protection assay (Figure 3A). This indicates that a swimming competent strain is not able to confer phagocytic susceptibility to a non-swimming strain, nor can a non-swimming mutant confer resistance to a swimming WT. Therefore, differences in phagocytic response as elicited by swimming verses non-swimming P. aeruginosa are not due to any soluble factor being secreted into the extracellular environment or altering the phagocytic activity of the BMDCs.
(A) BMDCs were co-incubated with a mixture of equal numbers of carbinicillin-resistant PA14 WT and carb-sensitive motABmotCD or, conversely, carb-resistant motABmotCD and carb-sensitive WT. Phagocytic susceptibility was assayed by gentamicin protection assay and plating on carbinicillin-treated LB agar. (B) Volcano plot of WT gene expression versus motABmotCD mutant gene expression. Red points indicate genes corresponding to likely immunogenic molecules (see Table S1). N≥7, *p<0.05.
Many of the regulatory pathways controlling synthesis of outer membrane proteins and peripheral structures on P. aeruginosa are still being elucidated; however phagocytosis assays with P. aeruginosa swarming mutants, type-III secretion mutants, and mucoid strains did not result in significantly increased phagocytic resistance relative to controls (data not shown). Nonetheless, it is still possible that flagellar rotation is co-regulated with gain or loss of expression of an unknown extracellular PAMP or ligand that is recognized by innate immune cells. To identify if deletion of the mot genes correlates with changes in peripheral gene expression levels, we performed genome-wide microarray analysis of the WT and motABmotCD strains. Comparison of gene expression levels between WT and motABmotCD showed no significant change in any recognizable PAMP regulators, OMP genes, lipopolysaccharide synthesis elements, or known immune activating factors (Figure 3B and Table S1). Genes which did change expression more than 2-fold with loss of the mot operons are listed in Table 2. However, swimming motility assays and preliminary phagocytic assays with PA14 strains containing transposon insertions in each of those genes identified in Table 2 did not recapitulate the phenotypes observed with motABmotCD (data not shown). These data support the hypothesis that phagocytic cells are able to directly respond to swimming motility by bacteria.
Inherent microbiocidal activity and limited bacteria-cell contact does not provide for phagocytic resistance in non-swimming bacteria
An alternative hypothesis to the cellular sensing of bacterial motility is that instead of non-swimming strains evading phagocytic uptake, the loss of flagellar motility renders the bacteria more susceptible to killing within the phagolysosome. While there is no prior evidence of this, we rigorously tested relative bacterial association and recovery over time by co-incubating WT or motABmotCD with adherent macrophages and then separating the cell-unassociated bacteria in the media from the macrophage-associated bacteria and plating both fractions to quantitatively assess relative CFUs in each. At all time points tested, greater CFU recovery was observed in the unassociated fraction when using motABmotCD, while in the associated fraction, significantly higher CFUs were recovered with WT (Figure 4A). If intracellular killing were increased for motABmotCD, extracellular CFUs would decrease below that of WT as bacteria were removed from the system at a higher rate. We therefore conclude that microbiocidal vulnerability and bacterial death does not measurably account for the differences observed between swimming and non-swimming strains. These data support previous observations that intracellular killing of non-opsonized P. aeruginosa is <5% of available bacteria within a 45-min co-incubation time period . Another alternative explanation for the current observations is that non-swimming bacterial mutants do not come into contact with phagocytes to the same degree as swimming-capable WT. To test this hypothesis we performed multiple, complementary assays. First, we performed gentamicin protection assays with WT or motABmotCD in the presence of surfactant in order to decrease surface tension that may inhibit contact between bacteria and phagocytes. In co-incubations performed with either the non-ionic detergents Tween80 or beta-octyl glucoside (used as a biofilm inhibitor ), or the artificial lung surfactant Survanta, we did not observe any increase in motABmotCD uptake (Figure 4B). Secondly, we tested whether forced contact between bacteria and phagocytes would overcome the phagocytic deficit of the non-swimming bacteria. To do so, we centrifuged bacteria onto BMDCs or macrophages and then subsequently assayed for phagocytosis. The degree of initial contact of WT or motABmotCD bacteria with the phagocytes following centrifugation was analyzed by FACS and was not different between strains (Figure 4C, inset). We observed a slight increase in CFU recovery of the non-swimming P. aeruginosa flgK and motABmotCD mutants (Figure 4C) as well as the non-swimming V. cholerae flaA and motX mutants (Figure 4D) relative to the respective swimming bacterial strains when contact was artificially initiated. However, the increased internalization did not recapitulate WT levels of phagocytosis, since non-swimming strains were still at least 10-fold more resistant to uptake as compared to their respective parental strains. These data demonstrate that phagocytic recognition is not solely dependent on contact between bacteria and phagocyte and supports a role for flagellar motion in pathogen recognition and ingestion.
(A) Adherent murine peritoneal macrophages were co-incubated with PA14 WT or motABmotCD and cellular associated bacteria and non-associated bacteria were quantitatively assessed at the indicated time points. (B) BMDCs were co-incubated with WT or motABmotCD in the presence or absence of 0.01% Tween80, 0.01% beta-octyl glucoside, or 2% Survanta, and assayed by gentamicin protection assay for relative bacterial phagocytosis. (C, inset) GFP-expressing PA14 WT or motABmotCD were centrifuged onto BMDCs and immediately fixed and analyzed by FACs for cellular association. Phagocytic cells in the absence of bacteria are shown as background. (C) P. aeruginosa PA14 WT, flgK, or motABmotCD, or (D) V. cholerae O395 WT, flaA, or motX were centrifuged onto BMDCs or peritoneal macrophages, respectively, and assayed by gentamicin protection assay. N≥5, *p<0.05 as compared to WT.
Flagellar motility enhances both the association and the uptake of bacteria by phagocytes
The relative contributions of binding verses phagocytic uptake and engulfment are not well understood in non-opsonized phagocytosis. To further elucidate the individual components that promote the phagocytosis of swimming bacteria, we quantitatively assessed bacterial association with macrophages under 3 sequential conditions. We first co-incubated swimming or non-swimming P. aeruginosa with adherent murine macrophages at 4°C, which is permissive for binding but prevents both bacterial motility and phagocytic uptake, and then washed away non-associated bacteria and plated the cellular lysates. In parallel, we warmed cells and bacteria to 37° after the initial binding and washing at 4°C, thus initiating both bacterial movement and phagocytosis of bound bacteria, and then plated lysates directly, or treated with gentamicin and then plated. In co-incubations held at 4°C, recovered CFUs between WT, flgK, and motABmotCD were similar, as was expected since all bacteria were immobilized (Figure 5A). Of note, this also supports that it is not an unknown bacterial cell-surface ligand, with expression altered by changes in motility, that affects bacterial binding to phagocytes. However, the difference in relative bacterial association with macrophages increased dramatically when bound-bacteria and cells were warmed to 37°C, demonstrating that binding of bacteria is a necessary but insufficient component to the differential phagocytic recognition (Figure 5A). Even once associated with phagocytic cells, non-swimming P. aeruginosa evade uptake and, as evidenced by the progressively decreasing number of CFUs recovered after successive washes (Figure 5A left), disassociate at a higher efficiency than WT bacteria. Treatment with gentamicin demonstrated that the remaining associated bacteria, after washing, are further differentially ingested dependent on swimming-capability (Figure 5A). However, it is possible that co-incubation at 4°C distorts initial receptor-ligand interactions that nominally occur at physiological temperature. To confirm that non-swimming P. aeruginosa is impaired in its ability to bind innate immune cells, we pre-treated macrophages with cytochalasin D to inhibit phagocytic uptake and subsequently incubated WT or non-swimming mutants with these macrophages at 37o. We then washed and plated cellular lysates to quantitatively assess the bacteria that bound to the outside of the cells. In support of the previous assays, we recovered significantly fewer flgK and motABmotCD CFUs than WT (Figure 5B). Visualization of these co-incubations using GFP-expressing strains and Alexa-647-stained macrophages confirmed that bacterial association is decreased in non-swimming P. aeruginosa strains (Figure 5C).
(A) P. aeruginosa PA14 WT, flgK, or motABmotCD that were incubated in parallel with adherent macrophages at 4°C exhibited similar binding (assessed by CFUs following washing and lysis of the macrophages) (left). However, the difference in relative bacterial association with macrophages dramatically changed when, following washing, the bound bacteria and cells were warmed to 37°C (middle); and this differential was even more substantial when assessed on the basis of phagocytosed (gentamicin-resistant) bacteria (right). Plots show total mean recovered CFUs accounting for input bacteria (left panel) and the number of recovered CFUs plotted relative to WT (right panel). (B) Murine peritoneal macrophages were treated with cytochalasin D prior to co-incubation with PA14 WT, flgK, or motABmotCD and were assayed for bacterial association and protection from gentamicin. (C) Fluorescence microscopy of cytochalasin D-treated macrophages co-incubated with GFP-expressing PA14 WT, GFP-expressing flgK, or GFP-expressing motABmotCD and subsequently stained with wheat germ agglutinin-conjugated Alexa647. 65x magnification. N≥5, *p<0.05.
Live cell imaging of P. aeruginosa interactions with murine peritoneal macrophages
In order to better understand and visualize how phagocytic cells bind swimming verses non-swimming bacteria we performed live cell microscopy of adherent macrophages interacting with P. aeruginosa. Equal concentrations of either GFP-expressing WT or GFP-expressing motABmotCD were flowed across adherent macrophages at a constant rate and visualized under fluorescence and DIC. WT readily accumulated on macrophage cell surfaces with prolonged associations and visible and substantial adherence events (Figure 6 top, Video S1). The motABmotCD mutant displayed little or no accumulation on the cells, visually flowing past macrophages with appreciably shorter adherent associations (Figure 6 bottom, Video S2). These images support the previous data which show that phagocytic evasion by non-swimming bacteria is achieved through multi-faceted resistance to binding accompanied by phagocytic unresponsiveness even with contact.
Representative images of adherent macrophages treated with liquid culture of GFP-expressing PA14 WT (top) or GFP-expressing motABmotCD (bottom) under constant flow at Time = 1 min, Time = 15 min, and Time = 30 min. Bacterial concentrations were equalized prior to imaging for comparative visualization of bacterial accumulation and retention (arrows) on phagocytes. Macrophages viewed by DIC, bacteria by fluorescence. See Videos S1 and S2.
Step-wise loss of flagellar torsion progressively increases phagocytic resistance
Our data indicate that flagellar rotation confers phagocytic recognition by innate immune cells. As a formal test of this, we hypothesized that bacterial flagellar motility would be proportional to phagocytic uptake. Motility studies with P. aeruginosa grown in media of increasing viscosity have shown that successive genetic deletions of the partially-redundant mot flagellar stator complexes result in decreases in swimming capability , . Specifically, swimming and flagellar-based motility in P. aeruginosa is tied to the degree of flagellar stator function, since loss of rotation from deleting motAB decreases flagellar-based motility below that of WT, while loss of motCD further decreases flagellar-based motility below that of the motAB mutant , , and loss of all four mot genes (both complexes) renders P. aeruginosa completely unable to swim or swarm (maximal expansion of colonies of WT, motAB, motCD and motABmotD in 0.6% agar were previously assessed as 29.5, 21.9, 7.3, and 6.3 mm, respectively , ). Therefore, we used isogenic mot mutants to test if decreases in swimming ability confer proportional increases in phagocytic evasion. Total bacterial association between GFP-expressing motAB and BMDCs was significantly decreased as compared to GFP-expressing WT as measured by fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS), while association was further decreased in GFP-expressing motCD and GFP-expressing motABmotCD (Figure 7A). To more rigorously and quantitatively assess relative phagocytosis of these mutants we returned to the gentamicin protection assay. Phagocytosis of motAB was slightly but significantly decreased compared to WT (Figure 7B). Further phagocytic resistance was observed in motCD, with non-swimming motABmotCD mutant being the most resistant (Figure 7B). This was not due to measurable differences in binding between the mot mutants, since these all bound to cytochalasin D-treated BMDCs similarly, though binding was impaired relative to GFP-expressing WT and better than GFP-expressing flgK (Figure 7C). Importantly, microarray analysis comparing gene expression profiles between WT, motAB, motCD and motABmotCD did not reveal any genetic changes that progressively correlate amongst these four strains with motility and therefore there were also no changes amongst the bacterial strains that correlated with phagocytosis (Table S2). Using methodology similar to that in Figure 5A, we next used the mot mutants to compare relative swimming ability with phagocytosis by adherent macrophages. Assessment of retained association and subsequent engulfment after initial binding revealed that all 3 mot mutants were slightly, but comparably, deficient in binding to adherent macrophages at 4°C (Figure 7D). However, upon warming of cells and bound bacteria to 37°C, followed by treatment with gentamicin, a progressive loss of association relative to WT was observed where association and engulfment of WT > motAB > motCD > motABmotCD (Figure 7D). This is the first evidence that the MotAB and MotCD proteins regulate phagocytic susceptibility in P. aeruginosa and that sequential loss of the Mot complexes confers increasing phagocytic evasion.
(A) FACS analysis and (B) gentamicin protection assay of BMDCs co-incubated with PA14 WT, motAB, motCD, or motABmotCD. (C) FACS analysis of cytochalasin D treated BMDCs co-incubated with GFP-expressing PA14 WT, flgK, motAB, motCD, or motABmotCD. (D) Adherent macrophage assay of cells co-incubated with PA14 WT, motAB, motCD, or motABmotCD bacteria at 4°C, warmed to 37 °C, or treated with gentamicin after warming to 37 °C. (E) Gentamicin protection assay of murine peritoneal macrophages co-incubated as indicated with P. aeruginosa PA14 WT or V. cholerae O395 WT in 70 mM, 18 mM, 9 mM, or 4.5 mM NaCl buffers, or in 15 mM NaCl buffer with 135 mM choline chloride. Recovered CFUs are normalized against recovery in HBSS (138 mM NaCl). N≥5, *p<0.05.
Since we observed increasingly dramatic phagocytic evasion phenotypes through genetic manipulation of the bacterial stator complexes, we turned to V. cholerae for biochemical proof-of-principle in support of our genetic evidence. Flagellar torque in Pseudomonas is believed to be generated through active transport of protons across the outer and inner membranes , . In V. cholerae, however, flagellar torque is generated through transport of sodium ions , . Progressively limiting the concentration of sodium in the media leads to proportional inhibition of V. cholerae flagellar rotation, and thus its ability to swim . We performed gentamicin protection assays in serum-free buffers containing successively titrated concentrations of NaCl, while maintaining a constant osmolarity by substituting choline chloride. As expected, decreasing the availability of sodium did not significantly change the degree of uptake of WT P. aeruginosa, which does not depend on sodium for flagellar motility (Figure 7E). However, loss of sodium availability correlated with increased phagocytic resistance by WT V. cholerae (Figure 7E). Treatment of V. cholerae or P. aeruginosa alone with sodium-limited buffers did not significantly decrease recovery of colony forming units (data not shown). Importantly, reconstitution of the lowest sodium-containing buffer with 15mM NaCl, while maintaining the choline chloride concentration constant, elicited a recovery in phagocytic susceptibility of V. cholerae, thereby confirming that choline chloride itself is not responsible for increased phagocytic resistance or for death of the V. cholerae (Figure 7E). Taken together, these data indicate that the step-wise loss of flagellar torsion and swimming ability, whether through genetic deletion of the stator complex or limiting ion motive force, provides for an increasing ability to evade recognition and phagocytosis by innate immune cells.
In this work, we define the steps that comprise phagocytic recognition of non-opsonized bacterial pathogens and identify that changes in flagellar swimming motility can titrate the phagocytic clearance of bacteria. In support of previous results, phagocytosis is independent of flagellar assembly, since both flagellated and non-flagellated non-swimming strains are equally resistant to uptake . While the majority of these studies focus on P. aeruginosa, we show that this immune resistance phenotype in swimming-defective strains is not specific to a single species, but represents a potentially widespread mechanism of immune evasion by Gram-negative bacteria. This phenotype is not due to motility-regulated secreted factors or compensatory changes in expression of bacterial genes. Likewise, phagocytic evasion is not due to avoidance of contact with phagocytic cells. Instead, as shown with P. aeruginosa, non-swimming strains avoid phagocytic recognition by disassociation after initial contact and remain resistant to phagocytosis even after being bound at the cell surface.
In comparing resistance across multiple bacterial species, it is interesting that non-swimming V. cholerae mimicked P. aeruginosa in terms of scope and magnitude of phagocytic resistance, while the degree of non-swimming E. coli resistance was much less dramatic. Since loss of motility in the V. cholerae and E. coli isogenic mutants was confirmed by swimming motility assays in 0.3% agar (data not shown), it is not immediately clear why swimming deficiency in E. coli conferred resistance to a lesser degree. Of note, both P. aeruginosa and V. cholerae have a single, polar, monotrichous flagellum under standard conditions, whereas E. coli swim via multiple peritrichous flagella , , . However, non-flagellated flgK and fliC strains of E. coli were not significantly different than the flagellated, non-swimming motA mutant in terms of phagocytic uptake. It is therefore unlikely that multiple flagella are causative of the discrepancy; more plausible is that the recognition of alternative structures, specific to E. coli, are able to partially compensate for the resistance phenotype of non-swimming strains. The small decrease in uptake observed with a mucoid strain of swimming-capable P. aeruginosa, as well as the trending decrease in recovered V. cholerae CFUs when TCP is eliminated, suggest that such compensatory mechanisms are feasible. Even so, the significant drop in phagocytic susceptibility when E. coli loses flagellar motility, independent of flagellar assembly, supports our hypothesis of a widespread mechanism utilized by innate immune cells for phagocytosis of motile, non-opsonized pathogens. Moreover, we demonstrate that this response to motility is shared amongst phagocytic cell types, anatomical locations, and cells of human or mouse origin (Figure 1 and ).
To delineate the phagocytic process, we examined bacterial engulfment in a step-wise manner. Our data indicate that for an uptake event to occur, contact must be made between the pathogen and the phagocyte, followed by adhesion and recognition, which culminates in a stimulus to ingest. In assessing P. aeruginosa binding and association with cytochalasin D-treated BMDCs, both the non-flagellated flgK mutant and the flagellated mot mutants were modestly but significantly decreased in binding to BMDCs compared to WT, though the degree of flgK association was well below that of all three mot mutants, which were not different from each other. This is of interest since multiple reports have identified bacterial flagella as potent adhesins in physiological systems –. Taken together, these data point to the flagellum in P. aeruginosa as indeed having adhesive properties, but calls into question the role of flagella as direct ligands for phagocytosis since all non-swimming mutants, regardless of flagellar expression, were indistinguishable in phagocytic assays. Furthermore, artificial enforcement of contact between non-swimming P. aeruginosa or V. cholerae and phagocytes did not recapitulate WT levels of uptake. In the experiments where pathogen-host cell contact was induced, and therefore initially equal between strains, we recovered significantly fewer CFUs using non-swimming strains relative to controls and the presence of the flagellum did not change phagocytic uptake among strains that were non-swimming. Therefore, the presence of a non-rotating flagellum can only partially recover WT levels of binding to phagocytic cells, and contact alone, regardless of flagellar assembly, is necessary but insufficient for full phagocytic activation. Importantly, among those bacteria that bound to the cell-surface, we discovered that their subsequent phagocytic fate is dependent on their swimming capability. Overall dissociation after contact, and therefore also evasion of engulfment, was increased in non-swimming P. aeruginosa compared to WT. These data support an overall model where loss of flagellar rotation enables the evasion of both phagocyte binding and, importantly, recognition and response after initial contact.
The evidence that the flagellum itself is not contributing to phagocytic susceptibility, but that flagellar rotation is, raises the question of how the cells preferentially recognize swimming bacteria. We previously demonstrated that loss of the MyD88 adaptor protein did not alter phagocytic uptake of P. aeruginosa . Therefore, none of the MyD88-dependent toll-like receptors (TLRs), specifically TLR5 which recognizes bacterial flagellin, are required for phagocytosis of P. aeruginosa. The two likely possibilities, not mutually exclusive, are that bacterial motility alters the expression of an unknown bacterially-produced factor or ligand that alters the ability of the phagocyte to recognize or ingest the bacteria; or that the phagocyte can sense the motility and that this drives the phagocytic event. Our data demonstrate that it is unlikely that phagocytic cells are sensing a motility co-regulated secreted molecule or extracellular ligand, since the mixed-culture assay did not indicate that WT could confer phagocytic susceptibility to the motABmotCD mutant in trans, nor could motABmotCD confer phagocytic resistance to WT. This inability to physiologically complement the phagocytic phenotype suggests that the extracellular environment of cells co-incubated with WT is not different than when cells are co-incubated with motABmotCD. In support of the complementation data, microarray analysis of bacterial gene expression when the mot complexes were successively deleted from WT indicate that no known immunogenic effectors are significantly altered. Most importantly, there was no significant change in gene expression pattern that correlated with successive deletion of the mot complexes and therefore no compensatory bacterial genetic changes that correlated with phagocytic susceptibility. Those genes that do change expression more than 2-fold in response to deletion of mot genes are likely bystander effects, as we could not identify phagocytic or motility phenotypes in corresponding transposon mutants. Thus, we believe it is unlikely that phagocytic evasion by motABmotCD is due to indirect effects of mot gene deletion. The alternative explanation is that leukocytes possess a mechanism that recognizes and responds to flagellar torsion as a phagocytic initiation signal. We hypothesized that, if this were the case, then step-wise decreases in flagellar torsion would result in proportional increases in phagocytic resistance. Deleting MotAB from the stator complex of P. aeruginosa results in decreased swimming speed, as it partially contributes to flagellar torque generation , . Our data show that this decrease in swimming capability confers a small but significant degree of resistance to phagocytosis. Further loss of flagellar motility, due to deletion of MotCD, which is a larger contributor to stator functionality than MotAB , , conferred a greater degree of phagocytic resistance. Complete loss of flagellar function, the phenotypic result of deletion of all four mot genes , , conferred the greatest degree of phagocytic resistance, equal to that of non-flagellated mutants. Once bacteria are cell-bound, subsequent dissociation and phagocytic evasion follow the same pattern, with resistance in motABmotCD > motCD > motAB > WT. This is the first demonstration of titrated phagocytic resistance in P. aeruginosa being regulated through mot gene function, and fits an infection model where the sensory mechanisms of the innate immune system provide a selective pressure for P. aeruginosa to down-regulate flagellar motility. Since the partial loss of the stator does not completely inhibit swimming capability, selective pressure to lose stator functionality would not necessarily impede P. aeruginosa colonization, but provide increasing degrees of resistance to phagocytic recognition. Indeed, the partial redundancy in the P. aeruginosa stator proteins may have evolved to provide such an advantage during infection.
While a functional stator complex is required for flagellar rotation, additional requirements, such as the electro-chemical gradient that provides rotational force, are necessary for full flagellar motility . Limiting the availability of ions required for flagellar rotation can selectively impede flagellar motility . We found that progressively decreasing sodium availability to V. cholerae, which depends specifically on sodium ions for flagellar rotation, conferred step-wise increases in phagocytic resistance, analogous to our observations with the P. aeruginosa genetic mutants. Limiting sodium availability to P. aeruginosa did not alter phagocytic susceptibility, which fits with P. aeruginosa use of a proton motive force and not sodium for flagellar motility , . These data are in agreement with our results using genetically modified bacteria, indicating that loss of flagellar motility, regardless of the means, confers resistance to phagocytic uptake.
While the down-regulation of flagellar motility in P. aeruginosa isolates from persistent infections has been previously documented –, these results provide an explanation for the observed loss of motility in clinical strains recovered from CF patients over the course of chronic infection, but which is not limited to just P. aeruginosa. Consistent with a pleiotropic mechano-sensory system, both non-swimming V. cholerae and E. coli also demonstrate phagocytic resistance. We believe it is therefore likely that innate immune cells are able sense bacterial motility, possibly through membrane depression or activation of an unknown tension receptor(s), and that this mechanical perturbation, analogous to a “fish on a hook”, provides the necessary sensory stimulant for the cell to “set the hook” and initiate phagocytic uptake. Examples of cellular mechano-sensory systems exist in other physiological systems, such as cellular stretch detection in muscle sarcoma cells  and shear-enhanced adhesive catch bonds in rolling leukocytes , but to date no reports have identified such a mechanism contributing to pathogen recognition. Since flagellar motility is a necessary virulence factor for many pathogens to effectively colonize a host –, it makes evolutionary sense that the innate immune system, as a first line of defense, would develop strategies to exploit this phenotype. Concomitantly, loss of flagellar motility in isolates taken from established infections corresponds to selective pressure to bypass this immune strategy.
In conclusion, in this work we demonstrate that bacterial flagellar rotation is recognized as a phagocytic activator by innate immune cells. We show that this mechanism responds to at least three different species of bacteria, P. aeruginosa, V. cholerae, and E. coli, and thus likely represents a common and widespread immune strategy for bacterial recognition by direct sensing of flagellar torsion. In the P. aeruginosa model, swimming-deficient strains avoid phagocytic uptake through a combinatorial strategy of limiting prolonged association after initial contact with phagocytic cells and not eliciting uptake when bound to the cell surface. We show for the first time that phagocytic recognition is directly proportional to mot gene function as it relates to phenotypic flagellar torsion. These results provide a basis for the reported observations of non-motility in clinical strains isolated from established infections, and provide evidence of a novel strategy utilized by the innate immune system to fight bacterial infection.
Materials and Methods
This study was carried out in strict accordance with the recommendations in the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals of the National Institutes of Health. The protocol was approved by the Dartmouth IACUC Committee (Permit Number: A3259-01). No surgery was performed, and all efforts were made to minimize suffering.
Mice and cells
Bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (BMDCs) were cultured from C57BL/6 WT mice obtained from NCI using a modification of Inaba et al. as previously described . For isolation of murine macrophages, naïve C57BL/6 mice were injected i.p. with 1 ml of 4% thioglycolate and subsequently sacrificed 4 days later. The peritoneal cavity was lavaged with 6 ml of serum-free Hank's Balanced Salt Solution (HBSS). The lavage fluid was centrifuged and pelleted cells were washed twice in serum-free HBSS before being resuspended in 2 ml serum-free HBSS. For these studies, the Pseudomonas aeruginosa strain FRD1 is a mucoid clinical isolate, while the non-mucoid clinical isolate PA14, Vibrio cholerae strain O395 (generously provided by Dr. Ron Taylor, Dartmouth), and Escherichia coli strain K12 (obtained from Yale CGSC) are the parental bacterial strains and wild type controls for all of the respective mutants studied.
Bacterial binding assays and FACS-based bacterial association
Bacterial strains expressing green-fluorescence protein (GFP) were generated by transformation of the indicated strains with a multi-copy plasmid (pSMC21 Ampr Kanr Carbr GFP+) that constitutively expresses GFP under control of a derivative of the Ptac promoter , . FACS-based bacterial association was assayed as a modified version previous protocols . Briefly, 2.5×105 C57BL/6 BMDCs or macrophages were incubated with the indicated non-transformed or GFP-expressing bacterial strains at an MOI of ∼10 in serum-free HBSS for 45 minutes at 37°C or 4°C as indicated in the text. Cells were washed in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) and mean fluorescence intensity of the phagocyte populations were assessed and graphed to obtain relative efficiency of cellular association with the indicated bacterial strains. For bacterial binding assays, BMDCs or macrophages were pre-incubated in 10 uM cytochalasin D (Sigma) in serum-free HBSS for 60 minutes at 37°C. Co-incubation between phagocytes and the indicated bacterial strains took place in the presence of 10 uM cytochalasin D in serum-free HBSS or in HBSS alone for 45 minutes at 37°C. Cells were subsequently washed in serum-free HBSS or PBS and then analyzed by plating cellular lysates and counting recovered CFUs, or by FACS for the acquisition of fluorescence as a function of GFP+ bacterial association.
Gentamicin protection assays
Phagocytosis of live bacteria was performed as a modified version of published protocols  and as previously described . Briefly, overnight cultures of P. aeruginosa, V. cholerae, or E. coli were washed and resuspended in serum-free HBSS or the indicated buffer and bacteria concentrations were determined. 2.5×105 BMDCs or the indicated cell type were incubated with bacteria at an MOI of ∼10 for 45 minutes at 37°C, followed by incubation in 100 µg/ml gentamicin for 20 minutes at 37°C. Recovered CFUs are normalized to input bacteria to account for variability in initial strain concentration. Where indicated, recovered CFUs are presented as a percent of the isogenic WT to compare relative degrees of phagocytosis. In experiments utilizing sodium-limited buffers, solutions were made with 0.9 mM CaCl, 4 mM KCl, 0.5 mM MgCl, 5 mM HEPES and the indicated amount of NaCl and reconstituted with choline chloride for a combined concentration of 140 mM (pH 7.5). For phagocytic threshold experiments, the concentration of non-swimming P. aeruginosa was successively increased 10-fold relative to the concentration of WT. For forced-contact experiments, BMDCs or macrophages were centrifuged for 5 min at 400 g. Bacteria were then layered onto pelleted cells followed by centrifugation at 4°C for 10 min at 715 g. An equal degree of cell-to-bacteria contact after centrifugation in swimming verses non-swimming strains was verified by immediately fixing cells and GFP-transformed bacteria with 4% paraformeldahyde and measuring the accumulated cellular GFP signal via FACS. For bacteria-phagocyte cell surface tension experiments, gentamicin protection assays were performed in the presence of the indicated concentrations of surfactant.
RNA from P. aeruginosa strains was prepared with TRI Reagent (Sigma) followed by the RNeasy kit (Qiagen), following manufacturer's instructions. Microarray analysis was performed on a Pseudomonas aeruginosa PA01 gene chip using raw oligonucleotide probes generated from wild-type PA14, the motAB mutant, the motCD mutant, or the motABmotCD mutant. Each sample was analyzed in triplicate (N = 3), and summarized in one probe intensity by the Vermont Genetics Network Microarray Facility using Affymetrix GCOS software. Data analysis was performed using R  / BioConductor tools , . Probe set sample matrix expression statistics were calculated using the Robust Multichip Average (RMA) method of Speed and coworkers , , implemented in the aroma.affymetrix package of Bengtsson . Quality statistics were calculated using the Simpleaffy  and AffyQCReport packages . The linear mixed effects model was fit using the lme4 package .
For static imaging, BMDCs were washed twice in 400 uL of serum-free HBSS prior to a 10 minute cytospin onto glass slides at 89.5 g. Alternatively, primary macrophages were allowed to adhere to glass slides for 1 hour at 37°C. Cells were co-incubated with GFP-expressing P. aeruginosa or GFP-expressing V. cholerae strains as indicated for 45 minutes at 37°C at a MOI∼10. Cells were stained with Alexa647-labeled wheat germ agglutinin (Molecular Probes) to delineate the cell surfaces. Cells were visualized via fluorescence microscopy on a Zeiss LSM510 Meta microscope using a 40X or 63X lens, followed by image analysis with LSM5 Image Browser software. For live cell imaging, GFP-expressing P. aeruginosa in phosphate buffer saline (PBS) were flowed over a monolayer of adherent macrophages at 50 mL/h for 20 min at an MOI∼10, followed by fresh media for 10 min. Bacterial accumulation was monitored at 5 sec intervals at 60X magnification using fluorescence and DIC. Imaging was performed using a Nikon TE2000 swept field confocal microscope with 0.17 mm Delta TPG dishes and analysis was performed with NIS-Elements viewing software.
Adherent macrophage assays
Macrophages were allowed to adhere to the bottom of 24- or 48-well plates in serum-free HBSS for 60 min at 37°C. Adherent cells were washed twice in serum-free HBSS followed by co-incubation with P. aeruginosa strains at 4°C for 30 min. Non-associated bacteria were removed by washing with serum-free HBSS. Cell-associated bacteria were quantified by lysing cells in 0.1% Triton-X 100, plating lysate on LB media for >12 hours at 37°C, and counting recovered CFUs. Alternatively, following co-incubation at 4°C and removal of non-associated bacteria, cells and associated P. aeruginosa were warmed to 37°C for 30 min and quantified as above or warmed for 30 min, washed with serum-free HBSS, treated with 100 ug/mL gentamicin, and then quantified as above.
Bacterial viability assays
P. aeruginosa or V. cholerae cultures were grown to mid-log phase in LB broth and diluted to O.D. 600<0.1 in serum-free HBSS. To measure susceptibility to gentamicin, samples were treated with 100 ug/mL for 15 minutes at 37°C and then directly plated on LB agar or, alternatively, untreated samples were further diluted 1∶200 (P.a.) or 1∶555 (V.c.) and plated on LB agar and resultant CFUs were counted. To measure bacterial replication and death in HBSS, bacterial cultures were prepared as above and then plated directly, or incubated at 37°C for 60 min and quantified as above.
Loss of the flagellum or flagellar motility does not confer changes in bacterial viability or gentamicin susceptibility. Recovered CFUs of (A) P. aeruginosa or (B) V. cholerae before and after 15 minute incubation with 100 ug/mL gentamicin in serum-free HBSS at 37°C. (C) Recovered CFUs of P. aeruginosa WT, flgK, or motABmotCD or (D) V. cholerae WT, flaA, or motX before and after 60 minute incubation at 37°C in serum-free Hank's balanced salt solution (HBSS).
Change in gene expression of bacterial immunogens with loss of motABmotCD. Selected genes detected in bacterial microarray that correspond to known or proposed immunogenic molecule expression by P. aeruginosa, compared to gene expression with loss of motABmotCD.
P. aeruginosa genes detected in bacterial microarray. List of genes identified in bacterial microarray analyses with comparative expression levels and statistical analysis relative to loss of motAB, motCD, or motABmotCD.
Live cell microscopy of macrophage interactions with PA14 Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Adherent macrophages (viewed in DIC) were treated with liquid culture of GFP-expressing PA14 WT under constant flow. Images are recorded every 5 seconds over a 30 minute time period and compressed for playback. Bacterial concentrations were equalized prior to imaging for comparative visualization of bacterial accumulation and retention on phagocytes.
Live cell microscopy of macrophage interactions with motABmotCD Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Using the same methodology and bacterial concentrations as in Video S1, the accumulation of GFP-expressing motABmotCD PA14 bacteria by adherent macrophages was visualized.
We thank John Jack Hammond, Qianru Yu, and Bruce Stanton and the COBRE microscopy core facility for technical assistance; Deborah Hogan for technical advice; Raquel Martinez, Christina Megli, and Ron Taylor for providing the Vibrio cholerae strains; the Englehart Cell Lab at Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center; and the VGN Flow Cytometry and MicroArrray core facility.
Conceived and designed the experiments: RRL MJW GAO BB. Performed the experiments: RRL RMC JLA BB. Analyzed the data: RRL GAO MJW BB. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: MJW GAO BB. Wrote the paper: RRL BB.
- 1. Akira S, Uematsu S, Takeuchi O (2006) Pathogen recognition and innate immunity. Cell 124: 783–801.S. AkiraS. UematsuO. Takeuchi2006Pathogen recognition and innate immunity.Cell124783801
- 2. Lyczak JB, Cannon CL, Pier GB (2000) Establishment of Pseudomonas aeruginosa infection: lessons from a versatile opportunist. Microbes Infect 2: 1051–1060.JB LyczakCL CannonGB Pier2000Establishment of Pseudomonas aeruginosa infection: lessons from a versatile opportunist.Microbes Infect210511060
- 3. Lyczak JB, Cannon CL, Pier GB (2002) Lung infections associated with cystic fibrosis. Clin Microbiol Rev 15: 194–222.JB LyczakCL CannonGB Pier2002Lung infections associated with cystic fibrosis.Clin Microbiol Rev15194222
- 4. Amiel E, Lovewell RR, O'Toole GA, Hogan DA, Berwin B (2010) Pseudomonas aeruginosa evasion of phagocytosis is mediated by loss of swimming motility and is independent of flagellum expression. Infect Immun 78: 2937–2945.E. AmielRR LovewellGA O'TooleDA HoganB. Berwin2010Pseudomonas aeruginosa evasion of phagocytosis is mediated by loss of swimming motility and is independent of flagellum expression.Infect Immun7829372945
- 5. Balloy V, Verma A, Kuravi S, Si-Tahar M, Chignard M, et al. (2007) The role of flagellin versus motility in acute lung disease caused by Pseudomonas aeruginosa. J Infect Dis 196: 289–296.V. BalloyA. VermaS. KuraviM. Si-TaharM. Chignard2007The role of flagellin versus motility in acute lung disease caused by Pseudomonas aeruginosa.J Infect Dis196289296
- 6. Luzar MA, Thomassen MJ, Montie TC (1985) Flagella and motility alterations in Pseudomonas aeruginosa strains from patients with cystic fibrosis: relationship to patient clinical condition. Infect Immun 50: 577–582.MA LuzarMJ ThomassenTC Montie1985Flagella and motility alterations in Pseudomonas aeruginosa strains from patients with cystic fibrosis: relationship to patient clinical condition.Infect Immun50577582
- 7. Mahenthiralingam E, Campbell ME, Speert DP (1994) Nonmotility and phagocytic resistance of Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates from chronically colonized patients with cystic fibrosis. Infect Immun 62: 596–605.E. MahenthiralingamME CampbellDP Speert1994Nonmotility and phagocytic resistance of Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates from chronically colonized patients with cystic fibrosis.Infect Immun62596605
- 8. Mahenthiralingam E, Speert DP (1995) Nonopsonic phagocytosis of Pseudomonas aeruginosa by macrophages and polymorphonuclear leukocytes requires the presence of the bacterial flagellum. Infect Immun 63: 4519–4523.E. MahenthiralingamDP Speert1995Nonopsonic phagocytosis of Pseudomonas aeruginosa by macrophages and polymorphonuclear leukocytes requires the presence of the bacterial flagellum.Infect Immun6345194523
- 9. Toutain CM, Zegans ME, O'Toole GA (2005) Evidence for two flagellar stators and their role in the motility of Pseudomonas aeruginosa. J. Bacteriol 187: 771–777.CM ToutainME ZegansGA O'Toole2005Evidence for two flagellar stators and their role in the motility of Pseudomonas aeruginosa.J. Bacteriol187771777
- 10. Terashima H, Kojima S, Homma M (2008) Flagellar motility in bacteria structure and function of flagellar motor. Int Rev Cell Mol Biol 270: 39–85.H. TerashimaS. KojimaM. Homma2008Flagellar motility in bacteria structure and function of flagellar motor.Int Rev Cell Mol Biol2703985
- 11. DeRosier DJ (1998) The turn of the screw: the bacterial flagellar motor. Cell 93: 17–20.DJ DeRosier1998The turn of the screw: the bacterial flagellar motor.Cell931720
- 12. Martinez RM, Dharmasena MN, Kirn TJ, Taylor RK (2009) Characterization of two outer membrane proteins, FlgO and FlgP, that influence vibrio cholerae motility. J Bacteriol 191: 5669–5679.RM MartinezMN DharmasenaTJ KirnRK Taylor2009Characterization of two outer membrane proteins, FlgO and FlgP, that influence vibrio cholerae motility.J Bacteriol19156695679
- 13. Braun TFPS, Gully JB, Empey JC, Van Way S, Putnam A, et al. (1999) Function of proline residues of MotA in torque generation by the flagellar motor of Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol 181: 3542–3551.TFPS BraunJB GullyJC EmpeyS. Van WayA. Putnam1999Function of proline residues of MotA in torque generation by the flagellar motor of Escherichia coli.J Bacteriol18135423551
- 14. Doyle TB, Hawkins AC, McCarter LL (2004) The complex flagellar torque generator of Pseudomonas aeruginosa. J Bacteriol 186: 6341–6350.TB DoyleAC HawkinsLL McCarter2004The complex flagellar torque generator of Pseudomonas aeruginosa.J Bacteriol18663416350
- 15. Gosink KK, Hase CC (2000) Requirements for conversion of the Na(+)-driven flagellar motor of Vibrio cholerae to the H(+)-driven motor of Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol 182: 4234–4240.KK GosinkCC Hase2000Requirements for conversion of the Na(+)-driven flagellar motor of Vibrio cholerae to the H(+)-driven motor of Escherichia coli.J Bacteriol18242344240
- 16. Pritt , B , O'Brien L, Winn W (2007) Mucoid Pseudomonas in cystic fibrosis. Am J Clin Pathol 128: 32–34.PrittBL. O'BrienW. Winn2007Mucoid Pseudomonas in cystic fibrosis.Am J Clin Pathol1283234
- 17. Ohman DE, Chakrabarty AM (1981) Genetic mapping of chromosomal determinants for the production of the exopolysaccharide alginate in a Pseudomonas aeruginosa cystic fibrosis isolate. Infect Immun 33: 142–148.DE OhmanAM Chakrabarty1981Genetic mapping of chromosomal determinants for the production of the exopolysaccharide alginate in a Pseudomonas aeruginosa cystic fibrosis isolate.Infect Immun33142148
- 18. Hulbert RR, Taylor RK (2002) Mechanism of ToxT-dependent transcriptional activation at the Vibrio cholerae tcpA promoter. J Bacteriol 184: 5533–5544.RR HulbertRK Taylor2002Mechanism of ToxT-dependent transcriptional activation at the Vibrio cholerae tcpA promoter.J Bacteriol18455335544
- 19. Stonehouse E, Kovacikova G, Taylor RK, Skorupski K (2008) Integration host factor positively regulates virulence gene expression in Vibrio cholerae. J Bacteriol 190: 4736–4748.E. StonehouseG. KovacikovaRK TaylorK. Skorupski2008Integration host factor positively regulates virulence gene expression in Vibrio cholerae.J Bacteriol19047364748
- 20. Sun DX, Mekalanos JJ, Taylor RK (1990) Antibodies directed against the toxin-coregulated pilus isolated from Vibrio cholerae provide protection in the infant mouse experimental cholera model. J Infect Dis 161: 1231–1236.DX SunJJ MekalanosRK Taylor1990Antibodies directed against the toxin-coregulated pilus isolated from Vibrio cholerae provide protection in the infant mouse experimental cholera model.J Infect Dis16112311236
- 21. Santos L, Rodrigues D, Lira M, Oliveira R, Real Oliveira ME, et al. (2007) The effect of octylglucoside and sodium cholate in Staphylococcus epidermidis and Pseudomonas aeruginosa adhesion to soft contact lenses. Optom Vis Sci 84: 429–434.L. SantosD. RodriguesM. LiraR. OliveiraME Real Oliveira2007The effect of octylglucoside and sodium cholate in Staphylococcus epidermidis and Pseudomonas aeruginosa adhesion to soft contact lenses.Optom Vis Sci84429434
- 22. Kanda E, Tatsuta T, Suzuki T, Taguchi F, Naito K, et al. (2010) Two flagellar stators and their roles in motility and virulence in Pseudomonas syringae pv. tabaci 6605. Mol Genet Genomics. E. KandaT. TatsutaT. SuzukiF. TaguchiK. Naito2010Two flagellar stators and their roles in motility and virulence in Pseudomonas syringae pv.tabaci 6605. Mol Genet Genomics
- 23. Kojima S, Yamamoto K, Kawagishi I, Homma M (1999) The polar flagellar motor of Vibrio cholerae is driven by an Na+ motive force. J Bacteriol 181: 1927–1930.S. KojimaK. YamamotoI. KawagishiM. Homma1999The polar flagellar motor of Vibrio cholerae is driven by an Na+ motive force.J Bacteriol18119271930
- 24. Arora SK, Ritchings BW, Almira EC, Lory S, Ramphal R (1998) The Pseudomonas aeruginosa flagellar cap protein, FliD, is responsible for mucin adhesion. Infect Immun 66: 1000–1007.SK AroraBW RitchingsEC AlmiraS. LoryR. Ramphal1998The Pseudomonas aeruginosa flagellar cap protein, FliD, is responsible for mucin adhesion.Infect Immun6610001007
- 25. Attridge SR, Rowley D (1983) The role of the flagellum in the adherence of Vibrio cholerae. J Infect Dis 147: 864–872.SR AttridgeD. Rowley1983The role of the flagellum in the adherence of Vibrio cholerae.J Infect Dis147864872
- 26. Giron JA, Torres AG, Freer E, Kaper JB (2002) The flagella of enteropathogenic Escherichia coli mediate adherence to epithelial cells. Mol Microbiol 44: 361–379.JA GironAG TorresE. FreerJB Kaper2002The flagella of enteropathogenic Escherichia coli mediate adherence to epithelial cells.Mol Microbiol44361379
- 27. Birukov KG, Shirinsky VP, Stepanova OV, Tkachuk VA, Hahn AW, et al. (1995) Stretch affects phenotype and proliferation of vascular smooth muscle cells. Mol Cell Biochem 144: 131–139.KG BirukovVP ShirinskyOV StepanovaVA TkachukAW Hahn1995Stretch affects phenotype and proliferation of vascular smooth muscle cells.Mol Cell Biochem144131139
- 28. Finger EB, Puri KD, Alon R, Lawrence MB, von Andrian UH, et al. (1996) Adhesion through L-selectin requires a threshold hydrodynamic shear. Nature 379: 266–269.EB FingerKD PuriR. AlonMB LawrenceUH von Andrian1996Adhesion through L-selectin requires a threshold hydrodynamic shear.Nature379266269
- 29. Drake D, Montie TC (1988) Flagella, motility and invasive virulence of Pseudomonas aeruginosa. J Gen Microbiol 134: 43–52.D. DrakeTC Montie1988Flagella, motility and invasive virulence of Pseudomonas aeruginosa.J Gen Microbiol1344352
- 30. Freter R, Jones GW (1976) Adhesive properties of Vibrio cholerae: nature of the interaction with intact mucosal surfaces. Infect Immun 14: 246–256.R. FreterGW Jones1976Adhesive properties of Vibrio cholerae: nature of the interaction with intact mucosal surfaces.Infect Immun14246256
- 31. Pier GB, Meluleni G, Goldberg JB (1995) Clearance of Pseudomonas aeruginosa from the murine gastrointestinal tract is effectively mediated by O-antigen-specific circulating antibodies. Infect Immun 63: 2818–2825.GB PierG. MeluleniJB Goldberg1995Clearance of Pseudomonas aeruginosa from the murine gastrointestinal tract is effectively mediated by O-antigen-specific circulating antibodies.Infect Immun6328182825
- 32. Siitonen A, Nurminen M (1992) Bacterial motility is a colonization factor in experimental urinary tract infection. Infect Immun 60: 3918–3920.A. SiitonenM. Nurminen1992Bacterial motility is a colonization factor in experimental urinary tract infection.Infect Immun6039183920
- 33. Inaba K, Inaba M, Deguchi M, Hagi K, Yasumizu R, et al. (1993) Granulocytes, macrophages, and dendritic cells arise from a common major histocompatibility complex class II-negative progenitor in mouse bone marrow. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 90: 3038–3042.K. InabaM. InabaM. DeguchiK. HagiR. Yasumizu1993Granulocytes, macrophages, and dendritic cells arise from a common major histocompatibility complex class II-negative progenitor in mouse bone marrow.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A9030383042
- 34. Bloemberg GV, O'Toole GA, Lugtenberg BJJ, Kolter R (1997) Green fluorescent protein as a marker for Pseudomonas spp. Appl Environ Microbiol 63: 4543–4551.GV BloembergGA O'TooleBJJ LugtenbergR. Kolter1997Green fluorescent protein as a marker for Pseudomonas spp.Appl Environ Microbiol6345434551
- 35. MacFerrin KD, Terranova MP, Schreiber SL, Verdine GL (1990) Overproduction and dissection of proteins by the expression-cassette polymerase chain reaction. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 87: 1937–1941.KD MacFerrinMP TerranovaSL SchreiberGL Verdine1990Overproduction and dissection of proteins by the expression-cassette polymerase chain reaction.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A8719371941
- 36. Duncan MJ, Li G, Shin JS, Carson JL, Abraham SN (2004) Bacterial penetration of bladder epithelium through lipid rafts. J Biol Chem 279: 18944–18951.MJ DuncanG. LiJS ShinJL CarsonSN Abraham2004Bacterial penetration of bladder epithelium through lipid rafts.J Biol Chem2791894418951
- 37. R Development Core Team (2009) R Development Core Team2009R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. http://www.R-project.org. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. http://www.R-project.org.
- 38. Gentleman R (2005) Bioinformatics and computational biology solutions using R and Bioconductor, in Statistics for biology and health. Vol. xix: New york: Springer Science+Business Media. 473.R. Gentleman2005Bioinformatics and computational biology solutions using R and Bioconductor, in Statistics for biology and health.Vol. xixNew yorkSpringer Science+Business Media473
- 39. Gentleman RC, Carey VJ, Bates DM, Bolstad B, Dettling M, et al. (2004) Bioconductor: open software development for computational biology and bioinformatics. Genome Biol 5: R80.RC GentlemanVJ CareyDM BatesB. BolstadM. Dettling2004Bioconductor: open software development for computational biology and bioinformatics.Genome Biol5R80
- 40. Bolstad BM, Irizarry RA, Astrand M, Speed TP (2003) A comparison of normalization methods for high density oligonucleotide array data based on variance and bias. Bioinformatics 19: 185–193.BM BolstadRA IrizarryM. AstrandTP Speed2003A comparison of normalization methods for high density oligonucleotide array data based on variance and bias.Bioinformatics19185193
- 41. Irizarry RA, Bolstad BM, Collin F, Cope LM, BHobbs , et al. (2003) Summaries of Affymetrix GeneChip probe level data. Nucleic Acids Res 31: e15.RA IrizarryBM BolstadF. CollinLM CopeBHobbs2003Summaries of Affymetrix GeneChip probe level data.Nucleic Acids Res31e15
- 42. Bengtsson H, Simpson K, Bullard J, Hansen K (2008) aroma.affymetrix: A generic framework in R for analyzing small to very large Affymetrix data sets in bounded memory, in Technical Report #745, Department of Statistics, University of California, Berkeley. H. BengtssonK. SimpsonJ. BullardK. Hansen2008aroma.affymetrix: A generic framework in R for analyzing small to very large Affymetrix data sets in bounded memory, in Technical Report #745, Department of Statistics, University of California, Berkeley
- 43. Wilson CL, Miller CJ (2005) Simpleaffy: a BioConductor package for Affymetrix Quality Control and data analysis. Bioinformatics 21: 3683–3685.CL WilsonCJ Miller2005Simpleaffy: a BioConductor package for Affymetrix Quality Control and data analysis.Bioinformatics2136833685
- 44. Parman C, Halling C, Gentleman R (2005) affyQCReport: QC Report Generation for affyBatch objects. C. ParmanC. HallingR. Gentleman2005affyQCReport: QC Report Generation for affyBatch objects
- 45. Bates D, Moechler M, Dai B (2008) lme4: Linear mixed-effects models using S4 classes. D. BatesM. MoechlerB. Dai2008lme4: Linear mixed-effects models using S4 classes