Many bacterial pathogens produce extracellular proteases that degrade the extracellular matrix of the host and therefore are involved in disease pathogenesis. Dichelobacter nodosus is the causative agent of ovine footrot, a highly contagious disease that is characterized by the separation of the hoof from the underlying tissue. D. nodosus secretes three subtilisin-like proteases whose analysis forms the basis of diagnostic tests that differentiate between virulent and benign strains and have been postulated to play a role in virulence. We have constructed protease mutants of D. nodosus; their analysis in a sheep virulence model revealed that one of these enzymes, AprV2, was required for virulence. These studies challenge the previous hypothesis that the elastase activity of AprV2 is important for disease progression, since aprV2 mutants were virulent when complemented with aprB2, which encodes a variant that has impaired elastase activity. We have determined the crystal structures of both AprV2 and AprB2 and characterized the biological activity of these enzymes. These data reveal that an unusual extended disulphide-tethered loop functions as an exosite, mediating effective enzyme-substrate interactions. The disulphide bond and Tyr92, which was located at the exposed end of the loop, were functionally important. Bioinformatic analyses suggested that other pathogenic bacteria may have proteases that utilize a similar mechanism. In conclusion, we have used an integrated multidisciplinary combination of bacterial genetics, whole animal virulence trials in the original host, biochemical studies, and comprehensive analysis of crystal structures to provide the first definitive evidence that the extracellular secreted proteases produced by D. nodosus are required for virulence and to elucidate the molecular mechanism by which these proteases bind to their natural substrates. We postulate that this exosite mechanism may be used by proteases produced by other bacterial pathogens of both humans and animals.
Extracellular proteases are produced by many bacterial pathogens and are commonly involved in the degradation of the host extracellular matrix, facilitating invasion and colonization. One such pathogen is Dichelobacter nodosus, the causative agent of ovine footrot, a disease of major economic significance to the international sheep industry. D. nodosus secretes a number of serine proteases, which are thought to cause the tissue damage associated with virulent footrot. Our study showed that a D. nodosus mutant lacking one of the three secreted proteases, AprV2, failed to cause virulent disease in sheep. We used x-ray crystallography to solve the structure of AprV2 and the closely related protease AprB2. Our structures revealed an unusual extended disulphide-tethered loop that is located next to, but does not form part of, the primary substrate binding site. Through targeted mutagenesis studies we were able to show that this loop functions as an exosite, mediating effective enzyme-substrate interactions. Bioinformatic analyses suggest that subtilases from other pathogenic bacteria may contain this loop and may therefore utilize a similar mechanism. Our multidisciplinary research approach has provided a comprehensive understanding of the functional role of extracellular proteases in the pathogenesis of ovine footrot.
Citation: Kennan RM, Wong W, Dhungyel OP, Han X, Wong D, Parker D, et al. (2010) The Subtilisin-Like Protease AprV2 Is Required for Virulence and Uses a Novel Disulphide-Tethered Exosite to Bind Substrates. PLoS Pathog 6(11): e1001210. doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1001210
Editor: C. Erec Stebbins, The Rockefeller University, United States of America
Received: April 5, 2010; Accepted: October 26, 2010; Published: November 24, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Kennan et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This research was supported by the Australian Research Council (ARC) through funding to the ARC Centre of Excellence in Structural and Functional Microbial Genomics. JCW is an ARC Federation Fellow and honorary National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia (NHMRC) Principal Research Fellow. CJP is an NHMRC Training Fellow. SPB is an NHMRC Senior Research Fellow. AIS acknowledges the support of an NHMRC Principal Research Fellowship during the course of this work. WW was supported by scholarships from the Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Faculty and the ARC Centre of Excellence in Structural and Functional Microbial Genomics. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Dichelobacter nodosus is a Gram negative, anaerobic rod that is the principal causative agent of ovine footrot, a debilitating disease of the hoof of ruminants. The disease results in significant costs to the worldwide sheep industry due to a reduction in meat and wool production and the expenditure associated with prevention and treatment programs , , . Footrot is characterized by the separation of the keratinous hoof from the underlying tissue, resulting in severe lameness and loss of body condition , . The severity of the disease can vary from benign footrot, which presents as an interdigital dermatitis that does not progress, to virulent footrot, which results in severe under-running of the horn of the hoof and the separation of the hoof from the underlying tissue . Type IV fimbriae are an essential virulence factor , ; it also has been suggested that three closely-related secreted subtilisin-like proteases produced by D. nodosus may be required for virulence , . In strains that cause virulent footrot these proteases are called acidic protease isoenzymes 2 and 5 from virulent strains (AprV2 and AprV5) and basic protease from virulent strains (BprV). In benign strains the comparable proteases are termed AprB2, AprB5 and BprB. All of these proteases are synthesised as inactive precursors with an N-terminal pre-pro-region, a serine protease domain and a C-terminal domain of unknown function. The active protease is produced by cleavage of the N-terminal pre-pro region and the C-terminal domain , , . The protease domains have significant sequence identity to members of the subtilase family of serine proteases (54% identity with closest homologue from Dehalococcoides sp. VS), but sequence alignments indicate several insertions in the D. nodosus proteases .
Previous studies suggested that these proteases may represent the key difference between virulent and benign strains of D. nodosus; proteases secreted by virulent isolates have a greater thermostability and elastase activity (as monitored on elastin agar plates) than those of benign strains and it is postulated that this difference may relate to their in vivo activity against host tissue. These features are utilized in diagnostic tests to distinguish between virulent and benign footrot , , . Comparison of the protease sequences from the virulent strain A198 with the benign strain C305 revealed that within the mature protease domain there is a single amino acid difference between AprV2 and AprB2 , and between AprV5 and AprB5 , and 96% sequence identity between BprV and BprB .
In this multidisciplinary study we set out to determine the role of these proteases in virulence and to determine the molecular basis for their function. We constructed isogenic protease mutants and characterized their protease activity and virulence. We showed that AprV2 was required for a virulent D. nodosus isolate to cause disease. Determination of the crystal structure of AprV2 revealed the presence of a novel exosite loop. This combined genetic and structural approach has permitted a comprehensive investigation of the secreted protease component of a pathogenic organism, and furthermore provided novel insight into how subtilisin-like proteases may have been hijacked by pathogenic microorganisms to degrade extracellular matrix components.
Protease activity of D. nodosus
To assess the contribution of each of the three extracellular proteases to the overall protease activity of the virulent D. nodosus isolate VCS1703A, separate chromosomal mutants of each protease gene were constructed by allelic exchange events that involved double crossovers. To confirm that the observed phenotypes resulted from these mutations, the mutants were complemented by insertion of the wild-type protease genes into the chromosome. Quantitative protease assays of culture supernatants, using azocasein as the substrate, showed that mutation of the aprV5 and aprV2 genes reduced total protease activity by 71% and 39%, respectively (Figure 1A). Complementation with the respective wild-type genes returned total protease activity to wild-type levels; however, it was also observed that the complemented aprV5 strain tended to lose protease activity upon repeated subculture. Since only a 12% reduction (P<0.05) was observed in the bprV mutant, BprV does not appear to make a major contribution to total protease activity. These results indicate that AprV5, either directly or indirectly, makes the major contribution to total extracellular protease activity.
Total protease activity of 40 h culture supernatants was measured using azocasein as the substrate. The protease activity is expressed relative to the wild-type activity. Means and standard error of the mean (s.e.m.) are shown. (A) Total protease activity of the protease mutants and their complemented derivatives. Each of the mutants had significantly reduced (P<0.05, n = 3, t-test) protease activity compared to the wild-type strain VCS1703A, while the complemented strains, except for the bprV complemented strain, were not significantly different to wild-type. WT: Wild-type VCS1703A, Benign: the benign isolate CS101. (B) Total protease activity of double and triple protease mutants. WT: Wild-type VCS1703A, Triple: the aprV2 aprV5 bprV triple mutant. The designation (1) and (2) represents independently derived mutants. Other genotypes are as indicated. The protease activity of each of these mutants was significantly different to wild-type (P<0.05, n = 3, t-test).
To confirm the individual contribution of each protease gene to the overall protease activity of VCS1703A, double and triple mutants were also constructed. Only very low levels of protease activity were observed in the aprV2bprV and aprV5bprV double mutants (Figure 1B). Negligible protease activity was detected in the triple mutant and the aprV2aprV5 double mutant. The reduction in total protease activity for the double mutants was greater than the combined reduction in the total protease activity for the single mutants suggesting that the secreted proteases either act synergistically to degrade target substrates or that one or more of the proteases may be involved in the activation of the other proteases, or both.
The ability of D. nodosus to digest insoluble elastin in an agar medium has been used as a diagnostic test to distinguish virulent and benign strains. Virulent isolates digest elastin within seven to ten days, while benign strains show no digestion after >21 days incubation . Analysis of the wild type, the protease mutants and the complemented strains on elastin agar showed that the aprV2 mutant was unable to digest elastin, even after 30 days incubation, whereas both the aprV5 and bprV mutants were able to digest elastin at wild-type levels, showing clearing after 10 days (Figure S1A). Complementation of the aprV2 mutation restored the ability to digest elastin. In addition, the aprV5bprV mutants still had elastase activity. These results provided evidence that the AprV2 protease was responsible for the elastase activity. Note that the levels of elastase activity in culture supernatants were not high enough for detection in quantitative elastase assays.
Sequence analysis of the aprV2 and aprB2 genes has shown there is only one amino acid difference (Y92R) between the two mature proteases . To see what effect complementing the aprV2 mutant with the aprB2 gene would have on the protease phenotype of the resultant strain we inserted the aprB2 gene from the benign strain CS101 into the site of the disrupted aprV2 gene. Analysis of this strain in the azocasein assay showed that its total protease activity was not significantly different to the wild type (Figure 1A). However, this complemented strain had the in vitro phenotype of a benign strain since it had no elastase activity (Figure S1A), and its protease thermostability profile (Figure S1B) was that expected of a benign isolate .
The apparent difference in elastase activity between AprV2 and AprB2 was assessed in vitro using an Elastin-Congo Red substrate and purified recombinant proteins. Under these conditions, the ability of AprB2 to degrade the substrate was significantly less than AprV2 (p<0.05, Figure 2). Both proteases displayed similar activity against the soluble chromogenic elastase substrate, N-Methoxysuccinyl-Ala-Ala-Pro-Val p-nitroanilide (AAPVn), with kinetic parameters that were of the same order of magnitude (Table 1). These results suggest that the Y92R substitution does not contribute directly to catalysis at the active site of the enzyme.
For quantitative measurement of elastase activity of recombinant AprV2, AprB2 (AprV2.Y92R) and protease mutants, purified protease was incubated with Elastin-Congo Red at 25°C for 19 h. Elastin degradation was detected spectroscopically at 490 nm. The mean and s.e.m are shown (* p<0.001, n = 3, one-way ANOVA compared to AprV2).
AprV2 is essential for virulence in sheep
To determine the role in disease of each of the proteases, virulence testing in sheep was carried out on the wild type, the aprV2, aprV5 and bprV mutants and their corresponding complemented strains, using our standard procedure , . These experiments represented a rigorous test of the ability of these bacteria to cause disease since such pen-based trials often magnify the ability of less virulent isolates to cause disease. Comparative analysis of the footrot scores of sheep infected with the wild-type strain and the aprV2 mutant revealed a significant difference (P<0.0001); the aprV2 mutant was effectively avirulent (Figure 3). Complementation of the aprV2 mutant with the wild-type aprV2 gene restored the wild-type virulence profile, fulfilling molecular Koch's postulates. To our surprise, complementation of the aprV2 mutant with aprB2 also restored a virulent phenotype, indicating that AprV2-mediated elastase activity was not required for virulence. Analysis of isolates obtained from infected lesions confirmed that they had the expected phenotypic and genotypic properties.
Sheep were challenged with the wild type, the three protease mutants and their complemented derivatives in a blind pen trial. The total weighted foot score (TWFS) for individual sheep at week three is shown. The mean and the s.e.m. for each group are shown. Each mutant is significantly different to the wild-type, while the aprV2/aprV2+ and aprV2/aprB2+ complemented strains are not significantly different to wild-type (P<0.05, n = 8, one-way ANOVA). NC: negative control, not infected with bacteria.
The aprV5 and bprV mutants were also avirulent (Figure 3), but complementation of these strains with the respective wild-type genes did not restore virulence, which was unexpected. Extensive sequencing of each of the protease genes in these strains showed them to be intact. However, upon subculture, protease secretion and/or elastin digestion by the aprV5 and bprV complemented strains were variable, as was their ability to undergo twitching motility, a property that is essential for virulence . Therefore, we suggest that the complemented derivatives were genetically unstable and that secondary mutations were being selected in these strains. Consequently, no meaningful conclusions can be drawn from the aprV5 and bprV sheep virulence experiments.
Identification of the native substrates of AprV2
Since the elastase activity of AprV2 was not required for virulence it was of interest to determine which hoof proteins were degraded by Aprv2 and AprB2. Fragments of hoof from a disease-free sheep were exposed to recombinant AprV2 and AprB2 and solubilised proteins were identified. AprV2 degraded type I keratin, serum albumin and the beta subunit of haemoglobin (Figure 4). Importantly, the hoof digestion pattern produced by AprB2 was similar to that produced by AprV2 (Figure 4), which is consistent with results of the virulence trials.
The activity of AprV2, AprB2 and AprV2.C141S on fragments of hoof isolated from a disease free sheep. C141S is a substitution derivative of AprV2 in which one disulphide bond has been removed. The degradation products were visualised by SDS-PAGE. Degraded proteins were identified by in-gel tryptic digest followed by LCMS. I: intact proteins; D: degraded proteins; NP: no protease added.
AprV2 contains a novel disulfide tethered extended loop
To investigate how the single amino acid difference (Y92R) between the active forms of AprV2 and AprB2 alters the substrate specificity of AprB2 we determined the crystal structures of AprV2 and AprB2 to 2.0 Å and 1.7 Å, respectively (Table 2; Figure 5A,B). The two structures were very similar (RMSD of 0.28 Å for 339 Cα) (Figure 5C) and therefore we will describe the structure with reference to AprV2.
(A) and (B) Cartoon representation of AprV2. Two views differing by 90° are shown. Disulphide bonds are shown in yellow stick representation. Calcium ions found in the crystal structure are shown as pink spheres. (C) An overlay of the crystal structures of AprV2 (blue) and AprB2 (yellow). The structures are shown as a Cα trace. The I2 loop is labelled. Tyr 92 in AprV2 and Arg 92 in AprB2 are shown in stick representation and labelled. (D) Electrostatic potential surface of AprV2 generated using CCP4mg . Positively charged electrostatic potential is coloured blue and negatively charged electrostatic potential is coloured red. The location of the active site residues is indicated. The location of the S1 binding pocket is indicated. (A), (B) and (C) were prepared using PyMol . The structural alignment in (C) was prepared using MUSTANG . Secondary structure elements were calculated using stride .
AprV2 adopts a subtilisin-like fold consisting of a curved six-stranded parallel beta sheet sandwiched between two and five alpha helices (Figure 5A, B). A two stranded anti-parallel beta hairpin runs perpendicular to the plane of the central beta sheet. The proteases have two disulphide bonds, Cys89-Cys141 and Cys183-Cys220 and three calcium binding sites (Figure S2). The proposed catalytic triad (Asp41, His105 and Ser277) of AprV2 is located at the C-terminal edge of the beta sheet. The most striking feature of the substrate binding site is a large, elongated S1 binding pocket, which is lined by residues 177–180, 204–208, 215 and 218, and appears capable of accommodating bulky side-chains such as phenylalanine (Figure 5D). This finding is consistent with previous studies, which have shown that AprV2 preferentially cleaves after phenylalanine or leucine residues .
Comparison with other subtilisin-like proteases reveals several major insertions (termed I1-I4) in the loops that surround the active site cleft (Figure 6A, B; Figure S3). Most notable is the large well ordered I2 loop (residues 82–102) that is tethered to the subtilisin-like fold by a disulphide bond between Cys141 and Cys89 (Figure 6). The loop is well defined in the electron density, with low B-factors, suggesting that it has limited mobility in the crystal structure (Figure 6C). However, the apparent stability of the I2 loop is likely to arise from crystal packing and it is uncertain if this conformation would be favoured in solution. Surprisingly, the single amino acid difference between AprV2 and AprB2 (Y92R) is located at the tip of this extended loop, ∼27 Å from the active site serine (S277). A PSI-BLAST search revealed that the additional loops present in AprV2 may be conserved in other extracellular proteases (Figure S3B).
(A) Overlay of the crystal structures of AkP (magenta; 1DBI), thermitase (green; 1THM), Carlsburg subtilisn (yellow; 1AF4), BPN' (orange; 1SUP) and savinase (blue; 1SVN). (B) Overlay of the crystal structures of AprV2 (red) with AkP, thermitase, Carlsburg subtilisn, BPN' and savinase (coloured as in (a)). The structures were superimposed using the A chains only and are shown as a Cα trace. The I1, I2, I3 and I4 loops are labelled. Tyr 92 in AprV2 and Arg 92 are shown in stick representation and labelled. (C) Stereo view of a 2|Fo|−|Fc| electron density map depicting the disulfide tethered I2 loop of the AprV2 protease. The map is contoured at 1.2 σ. Water molecules have been removed for clarity. The conformation of this loop (cyan) is stabilised by inter and intramolecular contacts with molecules generated by symmetry coloured blue. The alignments in (A) and (B) were generated using MUSTANG . Secondary structure elements were calculated using stride . The figure was prepared using PyMol .
We constructed an I2 loop truncation mutant, AprV2Δ83–99, but the resultant protein was not functional, therefore we investigated the role of the I2 loop using site-directed mutagenesis. We targeted residue 92 as the Y92R substitution reduced the ability of AprB2 to degrade Elastin-Congo Red (Figure 2), while maintaining its ability to degrade the elastin-like peptide AAPVn (Table 1). We used site-directed mutagenesis to convert Tyr92 to Asp, Ala, Leu or Phe and examined the ability of the resultant proteins to degrade insoluble Elastin-Congo Red. While the presence of a negative charge (Asp), positive charge (Arg) or smaller hydrophobic (Ala and Leu) side-chain decreased elastin degradation, the Phe substitution increased the elastase activity of the enzyme (Figure 2). We also examined the ability of these mutants to degrade AAPVn (Table 1), fibronectin (Figure S4) or hoof material (Figure S5). No major differences were discernable. Based on these data we conclude that an aromatic ring is required at position 92 for maximal activity against insoluble elastin, but that this activity is not related to the hoof digestion observed in a footrot lesion.
The Cys89-Cys141 disulphide bond is required for optimal activity
To test the importance of the Cys89-Cys141 disulfide bond for proteolytic activity, we also used site-directed mutagenesis to convert Cys141 to Ser141. Although this AprV2.C141S derivative was still active against small peptide substrates (Table 1), we noted that the ability of this enzyme to degrade fibronectin, insoluble elastin and proteins from sheep hoof was reduced. Notably, wild-type AprV2 was able to break down fibronectin in 48 h, whereas at the corresponding time point AprV2.C141S-treated fibronectin was still intact (Figure 7A). The elastinolytic activity of the C141S protease was also approximately two-fold lower than wild type (Figure 2). Finally, the ability of AprV2.C141S to degrade sheep hoof material was significantly reduced compared to AprV2 and AprB2 (Figure 4). Together these data suggest that the integrity of the I2 loop and the Cys89-Cys141 disulfide bond is important for maximal AprV2 protease activity.
(A) Degradation of fibronectin by purified AprV2 and AprV2.C141S at 25°C. The degradation of fibronectin over time was assessed by SDS-PAGE analysis. (B) Stern-Volmer plot for iodide quenching of tryptophan in AprV2 and AprV2.C141S. Purified protease was incubated with increasing amounts of KI, and the fluorescence emission intensity was recorded. The lines represent a least squares fit of the experimental data as described previously . The mean and s.e.m from three independent experiments are shown. Note that in these figures AprV2.C141S is shown as C141S.
To determine whether the C141S substitution affects the conformation/mobility of the I2 loop we determined the crystal structure of AprV2.C141S to 2.1 Å (structure refinement statistics in Table 2). The structure of AprV2.C141S was very similar to that of AprV2, overlaying with an RMSD of 0.21 Å for 339 Cα. The structure confirmed the absence of the Cys89-Cys141 disulfide bond and revealed that while the I2 loop had a slightly different structure to that of AprV2 there were no significant differences in the structure of the active site or primary substrate binding site (Figure 8A and S6). The average B factors for the I2 loops in AprV2 and AprV2.C141S were 14.6 Å2 and 28.4 Å2, respectively, indicating that the I2 loop is more mobile in the substituted protease (Figure 8B,C). Given that the conformation of the I2 loop is stabilized by crystal packing in all three structures we investigated whether the I2 loop was more mobile in solution in AprV2.C141S using intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence spectroscopy; the I2 loop contains two tryptophans. Steady state fluorescence quenching data showed that the wild-type protease was more protected from quenching by potassium iodide than the C141S enzyme (Figure 7B), confirming that the conformation of the I2 loop in AprV2.C141S is different to that in the wild type.
(A) Overlay of AprV2 (orange) with AprV2.C141S (cyan) shown in stereo. The structures are shown as a Cα trace. (B) and (C) Ribbon representation of AprV2.C141S (B) and AprV2 (C) coloured and sized according to B-factor. High B-factors are coloured red and shown as thicker ribbon. Low B-factors are coloured blue and shown as thinner ribbon. The alignment was generated using the program MUSTANG . The figure was prepared using Pymol .
Although the extracellular proteases of D. nodosus have been considered for many years to be potential virulence factors , their importance in the pathogenesis of disease had not been established. The analysis of their role in disease has always been complicated by the fact each isolate produces three very closely related proteases. The genetic approach utilized here has now provided clear evidence that the AprV2 protease is essential for virulence. This conclusion is based on data that showed that an aprV2 mutant was unable to cause footrot in sheep, unlike the isogenic wild-type strain, and that the ability to cause disease was restored to wild-type levels in the complemented derivative. No definitive conclusions could be drawn from the virulence testing of the aprV5 and bprV mutants. However, it is likely that the AprV5 and BprV proteases also play a role in disease, especially since the three secreted proteases appear to act synergistically, with the double protease mutants, aprV2aprV5, aprV2bprV, and aprV5bprV, showing lower secreted protease activity than that expected based on the secreted protease activity of the individual mutants (Figure 1B). It remains to be elucidated how this synergism arises, although it could occur at the processing, secretion or substrate level.
Benign and virulent strains of D. nodosus can be differentiated by phenotypic analysis of their extracellular proteases, including analysis of their elastase activity and thermostability , , , . We now have established that AprV2 is responsible for the elastase activity of the virulent isolate VCS1703A. Purified AprB2, which differs in sequence from AprV2 only at residue 92, is less efficient at degrading elastin. Therefore, it was important to examine the effect on virulence of complementing the aprV2 mutant with aprB2. This AprV2−AprB2+ strain was benign by the standard laboratory tests used to differentiate virulent and benign strains. Unexpectedly, it was virulent in the sheep footrot trial, producing disease that was indistinguishable in footrot severity from that caused by the isogenic wild-type strain. Since this strain still produces both AprV5 and BprV we conclude that the presence of one benign protease (AprB2) in combination with two virulent proteases (AprV5 and BprV) is not sufficient to make a strain benign even though in a laboratory diagnostic context the strain would be designated as benign. Therefore, although it appears that the properties of AprV2 and AprB2 are responsible for the differentiation of benign and virulent strains in laboratory tests, there clearly are other virulence factors, such as the other virulent proteases, that contribute to virulent disease.
We have shown that AprV2 mediates the degradation of keratin (Figure 4), a component of the ovine hoof that confers physical protection and tissue integrity. This finding suggests that AprV2 has a direct role in destroying the keratin layer of the ovine hoof, a characteristic feature of virulent footrot. The initial site of D. nodosus attachment during infection is at the epidermal layer of the interdigital skin and degradation of keratin in this area by AprV2 is likely to be required to break through the skin horn junction, allowing the subsequent under-running of the horn by D. nodosus.
An intriguing feature identified in the structures of AprV2 and AprB2 is the disulphide-tethered I2 loop. This loop is located next to, and partially occludes, the substrate binding site of the enzyme (Figure 6). The single amino acid difference between AprV2 and AprB2 is located at the tip of the loop. We have shown that residue 92 is a key determinant of elastase activity. Although, substitution of Tyr92 with Arg reduced the degradation of insoluble elastin, no significant differences in either KM or Vmax were observed for hydrolysis of the elastin-like peptide, AAPVn. This result suggests that residue 92 does not contribute to catalysis at the active site of the enzyme. Instead, the reduced elastinolytic activity of AprB2 is likely to arise from impaired enzyme-substrate interactions at a site distal to the active site. We therefore propose that the I2 loop functions as an exosite, mediating the formation of a stable enzyme-substrate complex. The disulphide bond tethering the I2 loop appears to be important for this function since its disruption alters the mobility of the loop, which significantly reduces the ability of the protease to degrade fibronectin, insoluble elastin and other proteins from the sheep hoof.
We have identified several serine proteases that like AprV2 also appear to contain large insertions between the β1 strand and α2 helix (the location of the I1 and I2 loops) (Figure S3). These enzymes include MprA, from Burkholderia pseudomallei (the causative agent of melioidosis), TgSUB1 and TgSUB2, from Toxoplasma gondii (the causative agent of toxoplasmosis) and PfSUB1 from the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum. MprA degrades physiologically relevant proteins and may play a role in causing the lung damage associated with melioidosis , , however, it has only a minor role in virulence . PfSUB1 and TgSUB2 appear to be critical for parasite survival , . The presence of the I2-like insertions in these proteins suggests that the mechanism of exosite loop-mediated proteolysis used by the D. nodosus secreted proteases may represent a mechanism of substrate recognition that is utilized by other bacterial proteases. Studies investigating the structure of these proteins along with the function of their I2-like insertions will shed some light on this hypothesis and may lead to the development of improved diagnostic reagents and the identification of novel vaccine and drug targets.
Materials and Methods
Construction and characterization of D. nodosus mutants and complemented strains
To construct the single mutants, suicide plasmids were inserted into D. nodosus strain VCS1703A by natural transformation . The aprV2 and bprV mutants were complemented by transforming the mutants with the relevant plasmids, which reconstituted the disrupted gene and inserted a different resistance marker. The aprV5 mutant was complemented by inserting an intact copy of aprV5 and a kanamycin resistance marker into one of the three rrnA operons. The aprV2bprV double mutant was constructed by inserting the bprV suicide plasmid into an aprV2 mutant, and the aprV2aprV5 double mutant constructed by inserting the aprV2 suicide plasmid into an aprV5 mutant. An aprV5bprV double mutant was constructed by inserting a suicide plasmid into the wild-type strain, which disrupted both genes when a double crossover event occurred. Finally, a triple aprV2aprV5bprV mutant was constructed by inserting the aprV5bprV suicide plasmid into the aprV2 mutant.
All mutants and complemented strains were confirmed by PCR and Southern hybridizations. PCR-RFLP analysis of the omp gene family was used to confirm that mutants were derived from the wild-type strain . Elastase activity and protease thermostability assays for the differentiation of benign and virulent strains of D. nodosus were as described previously , , .
Virulence testing in sheep
Virulence testing in sheep was performed as before , . The sheep were randomly allocated into nine groups of eight sheep and challenged blind with the various strains. A plain agar challenge was used as the negative control. The feet of all animals were examined and scored for footrot lesions at the start of the trial and then at weekly intervals using a standard lesion scoring method , . The total weighted foot score (TWFS) was used to provide an unambiguous overall footrot score for each animal . The trial was carried out in a PC2 containment facility at Elizabeth Macarthur Agricultural Institute in accordance with the guidelines of the Australian Government Office of the Gene Technology Regulator and the Elizabeth Macarthur Agricultural Institute Animal Ethics Committee.
Measurement of protease activity
All assays were performed in 20 mM Tris-HCl pH 8 and 5 mM CaCl2 (buffer A) with the exception of the Elastin-Congo Red elastase assay, which was performed in 25 mM Bis-Tris pH6.5, 150 mM NaCl, 5 mM CaCl2 and 5% glycerol. Quantitative determination of total protease activity or elastase activity was carried out using azocasein  or Elastin-Congo Red  assays, respectively. Degradation of AAPVn by recombinant protease (1 µM) was measured at 25°C as described . KM and Vmax were determined by plotting initial velocities against AAPVn concentration and fitted by non-linear regression (Prism). Fibronectin degradation was measured by incubating human fibronectin (1 µM, BD Biosciences) with recombinant protease (0.1 µM) at 25°C. Cleavage products were visualised by SDS-PAGE. Proteolytic degradation of hoof was determined by incubating dissected hoof material (2.2% (w/v) in buffer A) from a disease-free sheep with recombinant protease (110 µg/ml) at 25°C. Samples were taken over a 16 hour period and degradation products were visualised by SDS-PAGE.
Proteolytic digestion of hoof and substrate identification by in-gel tryptic digestion and LCMS
Hoof material (14% (w/v) in buffer A) from a disease-free sheep was incubated with 100 µg of recombinant protease at 25°C for 18 h. Degradation products were separated by SDS-PAGE. The bands were excised and subjected to in-gel tryptic digestion and the digests analysed by LC-MS/MS using a HCT ULTRA ion trap mass spectrometer (BrukerDaltonics) coupled online with a 1200 series capillary HPLC (Agilent technologies). Proteins were identified by searching the LC-MS/MS data against the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) non-redundant and Swiss-Prot databases using the MASCOT search engine (version 2.1, Matrix Science Inc.) with all taxonomy selected.
Protein production, crystallisation and data collection
AprV2 and AprB2 were purified and crystallised as before . Data collection statistics have been reported . The expression construct for AprV2.C141S was generated using the Quikchange site-directed mutagenesis kit (Stratagene) and pET22b.AprV2 as the template. Expression, purification and crystallisation of AprV2.C141S were as for AprV2. Data collection statistics for AprV2.C141S are in Table S1.
Structure determination and refinement
Unless stated otherwise, all programs used for structural and crystallographic analysis were located within the CCP4 interface  to the CCP4 suite . Manual building and maximum likelihood refinement were carried out using COOT  and REFMAC5 , respectively. The protease structures were solved by molecular replacement using PHASER . A search model for AprB2 was derived from the coordinates of Bacillus Ak.1 protease (PDB code 1DBI ), identified using the FFAS server . The search model was generated using the SCRWL server and consisted of all conserved side-chains with the remaining non-alanine/glycine residues truncated at the Cγ atom . The initial model of AprB2 was subject to several iterations of manual building and refinement. The model was then subjected to automatic building using ARP/wARP  before the structure was completed by more cycles of manual building and refinement. The refined AprB2 structure with the I2 loop deleted was used as the MR search model for AprV2 and AprV2.C141S. The initial models were subjected to simulated annealing using PHENIX , . Successive rounds of manual building and refinement incorporating TLS  generated the final models. Water molecules were added to all models using ARP/warp v 5.0 , . Structure validation was carried out using MolProbity  and COOT . Refinement statistics for the structures determined are presented in Table 2. The coordinates and structure factors are available from the Protein Data Bank (2LPA; 2LPC; 2LPC). Raw data and images are available from TARDIS (www.tardis.edu.au) .
Fluorescence quenching experiments
Recombinant protease (0.5 µM in buffer A) was incubated with increasing amounts of quenching solution (2 M KI and 1 mM Na2S2O3) and the change in the fluorescence emission intensity of the tryptophan residues (λex290 nm/λem340 nm) was measured using a Perkin-Elmer LS50B spectrofluorometer. The data were analysed as before .
The sheep virulence experiments were carried out in a PC2 containment facility at the Elizabeth Macarthur Agricultural Institute in accordance with the guidelines of the Australian Government Office of the Gene Technology Regulator and the Elizabeth Macarthur Agricultural Institute Animal Ethics Committee. These experiments were approved by the Elizabeth Macarthur Agricultural Institute Animal Ethics Committee.
Characterisation of the D. nodosus wild-type and protease mutants. (A) Elastase activity of protease mutants and the complemented strains. Elastase activity was determined by growing the strains indicated on TAS agar containing 0.3% elastin for 28 days. A zone of clearing of the insoluble elastin around the growth streak indicates elastase activity. (B) Protease thermostability of protease mutants and complemented strains. Culture supernatants were diluted 1:5 in Hepes Buffer (5.6 mM Hepes acid, 113.6 mM Hepes sodium salt, 10 mM CaCl2, 0.1 mM Zwittergent 3–14, pH 8.5 at 40°C) and 20 μl aliquots placed into wells in a gelatin-agarose gel after heating at 67°C for 0, 8 and 16 min . Gels were then incubated at 37°C in a moist chamber overnight and then immersed in hot saturated ammonium sulphate to precipitate undigested protein. Zones of clearing around wells indicate protease activity.
(5.02 MB TIF)
Calcium binding sites in AprV2. Stereo diagrams showing the calcium binding sites in AprV2. Calcium ions are indicated as blue spheres, water molecules are indicated as red spheres. (A) The Ca-I binding site. This site corresponds to the high affinity A-site in the archetypal subtilisin BPN′ . The Ca2+ ion is coordinated to the side chain oxygen atoms of Asp5 (Oδ1), Asp49 (Oδ1 and Oδ2) and Asn119 (Oδ1) and the carbonyl oxygen atoms from Val116, Ile121 and Val123. (B) The Ca-II binding site. The Ca2+ ion coordinates to four side chain oxygen atoms from Asp69 (Oδ1 and Oδ2), Asp71 (Oδ1) and Asp74 (Oδ1), two main chain carbonyl oxygen atoms from Asp71 and Gly72 and a water molecule. This site is unique to AprV2 and AprB2. (C) The Ca-III binding site. The Ca2+ ion is more solvent exposed than the other bound Ca ions and coordinates to the side chain oxygen atoms of Asp59 (Oδ2), Asp69 (Oδ2) and Asp74 (Oδ1 and Oδ2) along with the carbonyl oxygen atom of Asp76 and two water molecules. All calcium ions form a distorted pentagonal, bipyrimidal coordination geometry. The figure was prepared using PyMol .
(1.47 MB TIF)
The I2 loop. (A) AprV2 contains a novel disulfide tethered extended loop. Structure based sequence alignment of AkP (1DBI), thermitase (TM, 1THM), Carlsburg subtilisin (CBG, 1AF4), BPN′ (1SUP) and savinase (SAV, 1SVN) with AprV2 and AprB2. Secondary structure elements present in AprV2 are shown above the alignment. Residue numbering is for AprV2. The filled arrows indicate active site residues. The open arrow indicates the oxyanion hole. The I1, I2, I3 and I4 loops are labeled. Residues highlighted in red indicate strictly conserved residues. Residues in red text indicate those with similar physiochemical properties. The alignment was generated using the program MUSTANG  and ESPript . Secondary structure elements were calculated using stride . (B) Subtilisin-like proteases from pathogens that contain an I2-like insertion. Sequence alignment of AprV2 (D. nodosus), MprA (B. pseudomallei), PfSUB1 (P. falciparum), TgSUB1 (T. gondii), TgSUB2 (T. gondii), XC (X. campestris), PP (P. piscicida) and BPN′ (B. amyloliquefaciens). Secondary structure elements present in AprV2 are shown above the alignment. Residue numbering is for AprV2. Residues highlighted in red indicate strictly conserved residues. Residues written in red indicate those with similar physiochemical properties. The alignment was generated using the program Clustal W  and ESPript . Secondary structure elements were calculated using stride .
(1.42 MB TIF)
Degradation of fibronectin by AprV2 and mutants. Purified protease was incubated with fibronectin at 25°C. The degradation of fibronectin over time was monitored by SDS-PAGE analysis. Intact fibronectin (FN) is >250 kDa. Degradation products are observed at molecular weight <250 kDa.
(5.02 MB TIF)
Degradation of sheep hoof by AprV2 and mutants. Purified protease was incubated with hoof material from a disease free sheep at 25°C. The degradation over time was monitored by SDS-PAGE analysis. Degradation products were observed between 5–15 kDa. RP: recombinant protease; HDP: hoof degradation products.
(5.95 MB TIF)
AprV2.C141S is structurally similar to AprV2. The crystal structure of AprV2.C141S and AprV2 were superimposed using LSQKAB in CCP4 , . The Cα RMSD for each residue is plotted. The secondary structure of each residue is indicated with α-helices shown in dark grey and β-strands shown in black. The loop insertions are shown in grey and labelled. The location of the catalytic triad (Asp41, His105 and Ser277) and the disrupted disulphide bond (Cys89 and Cys141) is labelled. Secondary structure elements were calculated using stride .
(2.89 MB TIF)
Data collection statistics for AprV2.C141S.
(0.05 MB DOC)
We thank Craig Kristo of the Faculty of Veterinary Science, University of Sydney, and the technical staff of the Elizabeth Macarthur Agricultural Institute, for invaluable assistance with the sheep virulence trials. We thank the Monash University protein production unit for purification of the recombinant proteases and Dr John Price of the Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Monash University, who provided purified fibronectin.
Conceived and designed the experiments: RMK WW OPD XH DW DP CJR RHPL SM SBR VL GAP RNP SPB AIS IM RJW JCW CJP JIR. Performed the experiments: RMK WW OPD XH DW DP CJR RHPL SM SBR VL GAP IM RJW CJP. Analyzed the data: RMK WW OPD XH DW DP CJR RHPL SM SBR VL GAP RNP SPB AIS IM RJW JCW CJP JIR. Wrote the paper: RMK WW OPD RJW JCW CJP JIR.
- 1. Stewart DJ (1989) Footrot of sheep. In: Egerton JR, Yong WK, Riffkin GG, editors. Footrot and foot abscess of ruminants. Boca Raton: CRC Press. pp. 5–45.
- 2. Green LE, George TR (2008) Assessment of current knowledge of footrot in sheep with particular reference to Dichelobacter nodosus and implications for elimination or control strategies for sheep in Great Britain. Vet J 175: 173–180.
- 3. Wani SA, Samanta I (2006) Current understanding of the aetiology and laboratory diagnosis of footrot. Vet J 171: 421–428.
- 4. Egerton JR, Roberts DS, Parsonson IM (1969) The aetiology and pathogenesis of ovine footrot. I. A histological study of the bacterial invasion. J Comp Pathol 81: 179–185.
- 5. Stewart DJ, Clark BL, Jarret RG (1984) Differences between strains of Bacteroides nodosus in their effects on the severity of footrot, bodyweight and wool growth on Merino sheep. Aust Vet J 61: 349–352.
- 6. Kennan RM, Dhungyel OP, Whittington RJ, Egerton JR, Rood JI (2001) The type IV fimbrial subunit gene (fimA) of Dichelobacter nodosus is essential for virulence, protease secretion, and natural competence. J Bacteriol 183: 4451–4458.
- 7. Han X, Kennan RM, Davies JK, Reddacliff LA, Dhungyel OP, et al. (2008) Twitching motility is essential for virulence in Dichelobacter nodosus. J Bacteriol 190: 3323–3335.
- 8. Kortt AA, Riffkin MC, Focareta A, Stewart DJ (1993) Amino acid sequence of extracellular acidic protease V5 of Dichelobacter nodosus, the causative organism of ovine footrot. Biochem Mol Biol Int 29: 989–998.
- 9. Billington SJ, Johnston JL, Rood JI (1996) Virulence regions and virulence factors of the ovine footrot pathogen, Dichelobacter nodosus. FEMS Microbiol Lett 145: 147–156.
- 10. Lilley GG, Stewart DJ, Kortt AA (1992) Amino acid and DNA sequences of an extracellular basic protease of Dichelobacter nodosus show that it is a member of the subtilisin family of proteases. Eur J Biochem 210: 13–21.
- 11. Riffkin MC, Focareta A, Edwards RD, Stewart DJ, Kortt AA (1993) Cloning, sequence and expression of the gene (aprV5) encoding extracellular serine acidic protease V5 from Dichelobacter nodosus. Gene 137: 259–264.
- 12. Riffkin MC, Wang LF, Kortt AA, Stewart DJ (1995) A single amino-acid change between the antigenically different extracellular serine proteases V2 and B2 from Dichelobacter nodosus. Gene 167: 279–283.
- 13. Siezen RJ, Leunissen JA (1997) Subtilases: the superfamily of subtilisin-like serine proteases. Protein Sci 6: 501–523.
- 14. Stewart DJ (1979) The role of elastase in the differentiation of Bacteroides nodosus infections in sheep and cattle. Res Vet Sci 27: 99–105.
- 15. Depiazzi LJ, Henderson J, Penhale WJ (1990) Measurement of protease thermostability, twitching motility and colony size of Bacteroides nodosus. Vet Microbiol 22: 353–363.
- 16. Palmer MA (1993) A gelatin test to detect activity and stability of proteases produced by Dichelobacter nodosus. Vet Microbiol 36: 113–122.
- 17. Lilley GG, Riffkin MC, Stewart DJ, Kortt AA (1995) Nucleotide and deduced protein sequence of the extracellular, serine basic protease gene (bprB) from Dichelobacter nodosus strain 305: comparison with the basic protease gene (bprV) from virulent strain 198. Biochem Mol Biol Int 36: 101–111.
- 18. Kortt AA, Stewart DJ (1994) Properties of the extracellular acidic proteases of Dichelobacter nodosus. Stability and specificity of peptide bond cleavage. Biochem Mol Biol Int 34: 1167–1176.
- 19. Depiazzi LJ, Richards RB (1979) A degrading proteinase test to distinguish benign and virulent ovine isolates of Bacteroides nodosus. Aust Vet J 55: 25–28.
- 20. Liu D, Yong WK (1993) Use of elastase test, gelatin gel test and electrophoretic zymogram to determine virulence of Dichelobacter nodosus isolated from ovine foot rot. Res Vet Sci 55: 124–129.
- 21. Lee MA, Liu Y (2000) Sequencing and characterization of a novel serine metalloprotease from Burkholderia pseudomallei. FEMS Microbiol Lett 192: 67–72.
- 22. Chin C-Y, Othman R, Nathan S (2007) The Burkholderia pseudomallei serine protease MprA is autoproteolytically activated to produce a highly stable enzyme. Enzyme Microb Technol 40: 370–377.
- 23. Valade E, Thibault FM, Gauthier YP, Palencia M, Popoff MY, et al. (2004) The PmlI-PmlR quorum-sensing system in Burkholderia pseudomallei plays a key role in virulence and modulates production of the MprA protease. J Bacteriol 186: 2288–2294.
- 24. Yeoh S, O'Donnell RA, Koussis K, Dluzewski AR, Ansell KH, et al. (2007) Subcellular discharge of a serine protease mediates release of invasive malaria parasites from host erythrocytes. Cell 131: 1072–1083.
- 25. Miller SA, Thathy V, Ajioka JW, Blackman MJ, Kim K (2003) TgSUB2 is a Toxoplasma gondii rhoptry organelle processing proteinase. Mol Microbiol 49: 883–894.
- 26. Kennan RM, Dhungyel OP, Whittington RJ, Egerton JR, Rood JI (2003) Transformation-mediated serogroup conversion of Dichelobacter nodosus. Vet Microbiol 92: 169–178.
- 27. Kortt AA, Burns JE, Stewart DJ (1983) Detection of the extracellular proteases of Bacteroides nodosus in polyacrylamide gels: a rapid method of distinguishing virulent and benign ovine isolates. Res Vet Sci 35: 171–174.
- 28. Egerton JR, Roberts DS (1971) Vaccination against ovine foot-rot. J Comp Pathol 81: 179–185.
- 29. Whittington RJ, Nicholls PJ (1995) Grading the lesions of ovine footrot. Res Vet Sci 58: 26–34.
- 30. Ohman DE, Cryz SJ, Iglewski BH (1980) Isolation and characterization of Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO mutant that produces altered elastase. J Bacteriol 142: 836–842.
- 31. Betsuyaku T, Nishimura M, Yoshioka A, Takeyabu K, Miyamoto K, et al. (1996) Elastin-derived peptides and neutrophil elastase in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 154: 720–724.
- 32. Wong W, Kennan R, Rosaldo CJ, Rood JI, Whisstock J, et al. (2010) Crystallization of the virulent and benign subtilisin-like proteases from the ovine foot-rot pathogen, Dichelobacter nodosus. Acta Crystallogr F 66: 289–293.
- 33. Potterton E, Briggs P, Turkenburg M, Dodson E (2003) A graphical user interface to the CCP4 program suite. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr 59: 1131–1137.
- 34. Collaborative Computational Project N (1994) The CCP4 suite: programs for protein crystallography. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr 50: 760–763.
- 35. Emsley P, Cowtan K (2004) Coot: model-building tools for molecular graphics. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr 60: 2126–2132.
- 36. Murshudov GN, Vagin AA, Dodson EJ (1997) Refinement of macromolecular structures by the maximum-likelihood method. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr 53: 240–255.
- 37. McCoy AJ, Grosse-Kunstleve RW, Storoni LC, Read RJ (2005) Likelihood-enhanced fast translation functions. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr 61: 458–464.
- 38. Smith CA, Toogood HS, Baker HM, Daniel RM, Baker EN (1999) Calcium-mediated thermostability in the subtilisin superfamily: the crystal structure of Bacillus Ak.1 protease at 1.8 A resolution. J Mol Biol 294: 1027–1040.
- 39. Jaroszewski L, Rychlewski L, Li Z, Li W, Godzik A (2005) FFAS03: a server for profile--profile sequence alignments. Nucleic Acids Res 33: W284–288.
- 40. Canutescu AA, Shelenkov AA, Dunbrack RL Jr (2003) A graph-theory algorithm for rapid protein side-chain prediction. Protein Sci 12: 2001–2014.
- 41. Langer G, Cohen SX, Lamzin VS, Perrakis A (2008) Automated macromolecular model building for X-ray crystallography using ARP/wARP version 7. Nat Protoc 3: 1171–1179.
- 42. Afonine PV, Grosse-Kunstleve , Adams RW (2005) The Phenix refinement framework. CCP4 Newsletter 42: Contribution 8.
- 43. Brunger AT, Kuriyan J, Karplus M (1987) Crystallographic R Factor Refinement by Molecular Dynamics. Science 235: 458–460.
- 44. Painter J, Merritt EA (2006) Optimal description of a protein structure in terms of multiple groups undergoing TLS motion. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr 62: 439–450.
- 45. Perrakis A, Sixma TK, Wilson KS, Lamzin VS (1997) wARP: improvement and extension of crystallographic phases by weighted averaging of multiple-refined dummy atomic models. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr 53: 448–455.
- 46. Lamzin VS, Wilson KS (1993) Automated refinement of protein models. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr 49: 129–147.
- 47. Davis IW, Leaver-Fay A, Chen VB, Block JN, Kapral GJ, et al. (2007) MolProbity: all-atom contacts and structure validation for proteins and nucleic acids. Nucleic Acids Res 35: W375–383.
- 48. Androulakis S, Schmidberger J, Bate MA, DeGori R, Beitz A, et al. (2008) Federated repositories of X-ray diffraction images. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr D64: 810–814.
- 49. Lehrer SS (1971) Solute perturbation of protein fluorescence. The quenching of the tryptophyl fluorescence of model compounds and of lysozyme by iodide ion. Biochemistry 10: 3254–3263.
- 50. Potterton L, McNicholas S, Krissinel E, Gruber J, Cowtan K, et al. (2004) Developments in the CCP4 molecular-graphics project. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr 60: 2288–2294.
- 51. DeLano WL (2002) The PyMOL User's Manual Scientific D, editor. San Carlos, CA, USA .
- 52. Konagurthu AS, Whisstock JC, Stuckey PJ, Lesk AMPS (2006) MUSTANG: A multiple structural alignment algorithim. Proteins: Structure, Function and Bioinformatics 64: 559–574.
- 53. Frishman D, Argos P (1995) Knowledge-based protein secondary structure assignment. Proteins 23: 566–579.
- 54. Vieira J, Messing J (1982) The pUC plasmids, an M13mp7-derived system for insertion mutagenesis and sequencing with synthetic universal primers. Gene 19: 259–268.
- 55. Wang RF, Kushner SR (1991) Construction of versatile low-copy-number vectors for cloning, sequencing and gene expression in Escherichia coli. Gene 100: 195–199.
- 56. Gallagher T, Oliver J, Bott R, Betzel C, Gilliland GL (1996) Subtilisin BPN' at 1.6 A resolution: analysis for discrete disorder and comparison of crystal forms. Acta Crystallogr 52: 1125–1135.
- 57. Gouet P, Courcelle E, Stuart DI, Metoz F (1999) ESPript: analysis of multiple sequence alignments in PostScript. Bioinformatics 15: 305–308.
- 58. Thompson JD, Higgins DG, Gibson TJ (1994) Clustal W: improving the sensitivity of progressive multiple sequence alignments through sequence weighing, positions-specific gap penalties and weight matrix choice. Nucleic Acids Res 22: 4673–4680.