The compound genotype KIR3DS1/HLA-B Bw4-80I, which presumably favors natural killer cell activation, has been implicated in protection against HIV disease. We show that this genotype confers dual protection over the course of HIV disease; early direct containment of HIV viral load, and late specific defense against opportunistic infections, but not AIDS-related malignancies. The double protection of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I in an etiologically complex disease such as AIDS, along with the disease specificity of its effects is conceptually novel and underscores the intricacy of host immunogenetics against HIV/AIDS.
Natural killer (NK) cells are part of the innate immune response which provides the first line of defense against viral infections such as HIV by production of cytokines and direct killing of infected cells. NK cells possess a variety of inhibitory and activating receptors that upon binding to their HLA class I ligands on target cells, regulate activation and inhibition of NK cell responses. A protective effect of the specific combination of the activating receptor KIR3DS1 with HLA-Bw4 alleles that have isoleucine at position 80 (HLA-B Bw4-80I) against AIDS progression was reported previously. Based on this genetic association, KIR3DS1 on NK cells was proposed to bind to HLA-B Bw4-80I on HIV-1 infected target cells, thereby signaling the NK cell to kill the target. Here we present data showing that this compound genotype also confers protection against the development of AIDS defining opportunistic infections. Interestingly, no protection against the development of AIDS defining malignancies was observed. The double protection of this compound genotype in AIDS, along with the specificity of its effects is a novel finding and underscores the complex role of host immunogenetics against HIV/AIDS.
Citation: Qi Y, Martin MP, Gao X, Jacobson L, Goedert JJ, Buchbinder S, et al. (2006) KIR/HLA Pleiotropism: Protection against Both HIV and Opportunistic Infections. PLoS Pathog 2(8): e79. doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.0020079
Editor: Richard A. Koup, National Institutes of Health, United States of America
Received: April 17, 2006; Accepted: June 29, 2006; Published: August 18, 2006
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Public Domain declaration which stipulates that, once placed in the public domain, this work may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose.
Funding: This project has been funded in whole or in part with federal funds from the National Cancer Institute, National Institutes of Health, under contract NO1-CO-12400. This research was supported in part by the Intramural Research Program of the NIH, National Cancer Institute, Center for Cancer Research. Data collected as part of the ALIVE study were supported through NIDA DA04334.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Abbreviations: CMV, cytomegalovirus; CMVR, cytomegalovirus retinitis; HAART, highly active antiretroviral therapy; HLA, human leukocyte antigen; KIR, killer immunoglobulin-like receptor; KS, Kaposi sarcoma; LTNP, long-term nonprogressor; MAC, mycobacterium avium complex; MACS, the Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study; NK, natural killer; OI, opportunistic infection; PCP, pnuemocystis carinii pneumonia; RH, relative hazard
Natural killer (NK) cells are central components of the innate immune response, providing early defense against viral infections and tumor cells by production of cytokines and direct cytotoxicity [1,2]. Regulation of their activity is under the control of a range of activating and inhibitory receptors that work in concert to identify and destroy aberrant target cells, while recognizing and sparing unblemished self [3,4]. The group of killer immunoglobulin-like receptors (KIR) on NK cells, which contains allotypes that are either activating or inhibitory, participate in the complex regulation of NK cell responses through recognition of specific human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I molecules on target cells . KIR and HLA loci are both highly polymorphic and they map to distinct human chromosomes (Chromosomes 19 and 6, respectively), and therefore, they segregate independently. Both the KIR receptor and its specific HLA ligand must be present in order to regulate NK cell activity, such that one without the other is functionally inert. The specific combination of the activating KIR allele KIR3DS1 with HLA-B alleles that encode molecules having isoleucine at position 80 (HLA-B Bw4-80I) was previously observed to exert a protective effect against AIDS progression after HIV infection based upon a genetic association analysis of AIDS cohorts . We proposed that KIR3DS1 might bind HLA-B Bw4-80I allotypes on target cells, thereby signaling the NK cell to kill the HIV infected target, although direct evidence for a KIR3DS1: HLA-B Bw4-80I interaction has not been reported. The synergistic protection of KIR3DS1 + HLA-B Bw4-80I (termed “KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I” hereafter) was observed against progression to CD4 T cell depletion and development of AIDS-defining illnesses collectively. Thus, KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I may confer protection against HIV directly by killing HIV-infected target cells, and/or indirectly by preventing/delaying onset of specific AIDS-defining illnesses.
AIDS-defining illnesses include two basic types of diseases, opportunistic infections and certain malignancies. Given the protective effect of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I on progression to CD4 T cell decline and AIDS in general, we tested the specificity of this genotype in defense against individual AIDS-defining illnesses and against HIV directly. The most common AIDS outcomes in our cohorts include two malignancies, Kaposi sarcoma (KS) and AIDS lymphoma, and three diseases caused by opportunistic infections (OI): pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP), cytomegalovirus retinitis (CMVR), and mycobacterium avium complex (MAC). The other OI observed in our cohort of patients were grouped together in this study because their individual frequencies were too low to consider individually (termed “other OI”; see Table 1 footnote). The combined group of all OI and combined AIDS-related malignancies occurred at similarly advanced stages of HIV-related immune suppression (mean time to CD4 <200: 5.8 vs. 6.5 y; p >0.1).
Effect of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I across Distinct Disease Outcomes in HIV-1 Infection
Disease-free survival and categorical analyses were performed on a group of 1,184 study participants whose date of HIV seroconversion was known within a 6-mo period on average (seroconverters). All clinical data used in this study was collected before the advent of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) in order to avoid confounding of our results by efficacious antiretroviral therapy. In categorical analyses, the frequency of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I in each of six individual disease groups (KS, lymphoma, PCP, CMVR, MAC, other OI) and combinations of these groups (malignancies combined and all OI combined) were compared to the frequency of this compound genotype in a control group of 88 HIV+ long-term nonprogressors (LTNP) who had participated in their respective studies for at least 15 y and had never presented with disease symptoms. Since the control group was consistent for all categorical analyses, effects of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I across distinct disease outcomes could be compared directly. In the primary analysis, individuals were included in a disease group only if that disease was the first AIDS outcome diagnosed since HIV seroconversion, regardless of subsequent diagnoses (termed “1st outcome only”). This analysis eliminates confounding by the possibility that developing an initial disease may increase the risk of developing a second one. In the secondary analysis, individuals were included in a disease group if they had ever developed the disease (“anytime outcome”), regardless of whether it was the first or a subsequent disease diagnosis (thus, a single individual may be counted in multiple disease groups). This analysis is less rigorous than the first, but involves more events and was used to support or refute the primary analysis.
Of the six individual disease groups, significant (p <0.05) KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I protection against PCP, other OI, and MAC was observed in analyses considering 1st outcome only, anytime outcome, or both (Table 1). Notably, there was no significant effect of this genotype against KS or AIDS lymphoma. These data indicated that KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I confers defense against opportunistic infections, but not against AIDS malignancies in general. Substantiating these findings, KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I was associated with strong protection against all OI outcomes combined (OR = 0.36–0.4, p = 0.003–0.005), but not against the combined AIDS malignancies (OR = 0.75–1.0, p = 0.5–0.9). Similar results were observed after increasing the control group from 88 to a total of 197 LTNP by the addition of 109 seroprevalent LTNP (those patients who were HIV+ at study entry, and remained free of AIDS for at least 13 y following entry into the study; for OI, OR = 0.4, p = 0.001; for malignancies, OR = 1.1, p = 0.8). The apparent lack of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I protection against CMV retinitis, the only OI tested individually for which KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I showed no significant effect, could have to do with the immune privileged status of the retina where NK cell accessibility may be restricted regardless of the receptors they express. Indeed, there is little or no infiltration of inflammatory cells into the retina in association with CMV retinits .
The Bw4-80I group includes two alleles, B*57 and B*27, that are known to be highly protective in the acquired immune response against HIV based on both functional and genetic epidemiological data . In contrast, B*35-Px associates with rapid progression to AIDS [7,8] and carries the Bw6 motif (i.e. not Bw4-80I). These three alleles show the strongest effects on progression to AIDS relative to all other individual HLA alleles in analyses of the cohorts used herein [7,9]. Thus, KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I protection could be artificially strengthened by the presence of the protective B*57 and B*27 in the Bw4-80I group and the absence of the susceptible B*35-Px from this group. However, removing patients with these alleles (n = 345) from the analysis did not alter the strength of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I protection against OI (OR = 0.35, p = 0.019), indicating that the protection conferred by KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I is separate from the individual effects of these three alleles on the acquired immune response. Further, in a model adjusting for the effects of these three alleles as well as time to CD4 <200, the strength and significance of the KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I protection remained (OR = 0.34, p = 0.03). The lack of an effect of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I on AIDS malignancy was not altered by removing or adjusting for these same variables.
The categorical analyses indicated that KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I protects against ever developing an OI, but not AIDS malignancy after HIV infection. Some patients with KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I do, however, develop OI even as a first AIDS outcome. We therefore tested whether KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I delayed progression to OI as a first AIDS outcome using 1,126 seroconverters in survival analysis (i.e. time since seroconversion to the first AIDS outcome diagnosed; Figure 1, Table 1). KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I was shown to delay progression to OI as a first outcome only [unadjusted: Relative Hazard (RH) = 0.56, p = 0.004; adjusted for time to CD4 <200 as a time-dependent covariate and HLA-B*57, -B*27, and -B*35-Px as fixed covariates in a Cox proportional hazards model: RH = 0.58, p = 0.007]. Further, delayed progression to OI was observed regardless of whether it was the first or a subsequent AIDS diagnosis (unadjusted: RH = 0.61, p = 0.008; adjusted: RH = 0.64, p = 0.016; unpublished data). This genotype showed no protection in survival analysis against progression to AIDS malignancy, whether it was the first outcome only or not (RH = 1.1–1.4, p = 0.3–0.8). Adjusting for race in the Cox model did not affect the results (RH = 1.34, p = 0.34 for malignancy; RH = 0.56, p = 0.004 for OI), which concurs with our previously observed effect of this compound genotype on AIDS progression in both European and African Americans . Thus, the survival analysis confirmed and extended the observations of the categorical analyses with regard to both OI and AIDS malignancies.
Kaplan-Meier survival analyses illustrating the effect of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I on progression to A) AIDS-defining opportunistic infections and B) AIDS-defining malignancies among seroconverters. Patients with KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I (red curve) were compared with patients missing this genotype (blue curve). RH and p-values from corresponding Cox models are given.
These data raised the possibility that the protective effect of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I on AIDS progression that was reported previously may be completely due to protection against OI, rather than HIV directly. Viral load set point measurements (the mean of all viral load measurements determined between 6 mo to 3 y after infection) were available for 391 European American seroconverters from the MACS. The mean (natural log) viral load set point for patients with KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I (n = 47, mean = 9.4) was significantly lower than that for individuals without this genotype (n = 344, mean = 10.1; p = 0.01; Table 2), supporting a direct protective effect of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I against HIV replication early after infection, and well before the development of AIDS-defining illnesses in all of the 391 patients studied here. This difference in viral load set points between the KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I positive vs. negative groups is likely to have clinical significance based on the correlation between viral load set point levels and time to AIDS that has been reported previously .
Summary of Mean HIV-1 RNA Load among 391 Seroconverters during the First 3 y after Seroconversion
These data indicate pleiotropic protective effects of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I over the course of HIV disease, including relatively early control of viral load after infection and subsequently against developing OI (Figure 2). While these two protective effects are not completely independent of one another, adjusting for time to CD4 <200, a measurement linked to viral load set point , did not alter the protection conferred by KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I against OI. Notably, this genotype does not protect against AIDS malignancy. The conserved, activating NK cell receptor NKG2D has been implicated in surveillance against and elimination of tumor cells  and this receptor may also play a role in control of AIDS malignancies, beyond that of any activating KIR. To date, only a single genetic epidemiological study has implicated an activating KIR in tumor pathogenesis . In this case, KIR3DS1 was associated with increased risk of cervical neoplasia, possibly due to enhancement of chronic inflammation of the cervix, a likely precursor of cervical neoplasia . Thus, environmental factors, variation in the HIV genome, or host genetic variants other than KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I may determine the risk of developing AIDS malignancies.
Flow chart illustrating the dual protection conferred by KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I in the natural history of HIV-1 infection: early control of HIV-1 viral load, and late specific defense against opportunistic infections. There is no effect of this genotype on the development of AIDS-related malignancies.
It is not clear whether the protective effect of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I is mediated through NK cells, CD8+ T cells, or both. NK cell activation through KIR3DS1 binding to ligand on HIV infected target cells may confer rapid protection against the virus very soon after infection and before the acquired immune response ensues. This does not preclude the possibility of KIR3DS1-mediated NK and/or T cell responses during chronic infection, however, and indeed the data presented here indicates protection against OI during the chronic phase of HIV infection. Functional studies will be necessary to define the stage(s) and effector cell type(s) responsible for the association of KIR3DS1/Bw4-80I with protection against AIDS that has been described previously  and herein.
The HLA class I loci show the strongest and most consistent effects (across studies) on HIV disease relative to any other single genetic locus. Of the three HLA class I loci, HLA-B is the most rapidly evolving  and it also appears to be the most consequential in the acquired immune response against HIV from both functional and genetic epidemiological perspectives [9,15]. On a population level, control of a rapidly evolving pathogen such as HIV likely requires host genetic factors that are highly polymorphic and evolving rapidly themselves, characteristics of both the HLA class I and KIR loci [9,15,16]. Thus, it may not be coincidental that allotypes of the HLA-B locus in combination with a KIR locus would be central to the innate immune response against both HIV and the opportunistic infections stemming from HIV-mediated immune suppression. It is now clear that HLA class I contributes heavily to both the acquired and the innate immune responses, and decoding the complexity of its effects in HIV disease may prove essential for conquering this virus.
Materials and Methods
Individuals infected with HIV-1 for whom dates of seroconversion were known were derived from four cohorts: the Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study (MACS) , the Multicenter Hemophilia Cohort Study (MHCS) , the San Francisco City Clinic Cohort (SFCCC)  and the AIDS Linked to Intravenous Experience (ALIVE)  (N = 1,184; European American = 799, African American = 332, Other = 53). There were several seroconverters for whom the date (after seroconversion) of first disease outcome was not known with regard to OI (n = 58) and malignancy (n = 64). Thus, we were unable to use these individuals in the survival analyses, but we were able to use them in categorical analyses, which do not take time to disease outcome after seroconversion into account. The categorical analyses employed a control group of 88 HIV+ LTNPs who had participated in their respective studies for at least 15 y and had never presented with disease symptoms (79 European Americans, five African Americans, five Other). Samples from long term nonprogressing seroprevalent individuals (individuals who entered the study HIV positive, were followed for at least 13 y, and never developed AIDS; n = 109) were used as additional controls in one set of categorical analyses in order to boost the sample size in the control group (99 European Americans, six African Americans, four Other). European American seroconverters with known viral load set point data were derived from the MACS (N = 391). This study was approved by the Protocol Review Office of the NCI institutional review board. Informed consent was obtained at the study sites from all individuals.
HLA and KIR genotyping.
Genotyping of the HLA and KIR loci were performed as previously described .
Viral load set point measurements.
Viral load measurements determined previously from 391 European American seroconverters were available for analysis from the MACS cohort. Prior to 1997, HIV-1 RNA copies/mL was measured retrospectively on stored samples using reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (Amplicor; Roche Diagnostics, Nutley, New Jersey) with an assay quantification limit of 400 copies/mL . Samples below the quantification limit were subsequently tested with the Roche Ultrasensitive Assay with an assay detection limit of 50 copies/ml. Prospectively, HIV-1 RNA copies/mL are measured initially with Roche Ultrasensitive Assay whose detection limit is 50 copies/mL. All HIV RNA measurements obtained during the first 3 y after the first HIV-seropositive visit were used to calculate viral load set point values for each individual. Viral load measurements were first transformed to natural logarithm, and then averaged to determine the mean viral load set point for each individual. The average number of measurements per patient was 4.8 with a range of 1–10.
Analyses were carried out on seroconverters from all of the cohorts combined. Although our previous study of HLA and KIR in these patients showed consistent effects in African Americans and European Americans , we performed the Cox model analysis adjusted and unadjusted for race. The two models yielded virtually identical results. Data management and statistical analyses were performed with SAS 9.1 (SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina). PROC LOGISTIC was used for categorical analyses and PROC LIFETEST and PHREG were used for Kaplan-Meier and Cox model analyses. Statistical significance refers to two-sided p-values <0.05.
The content of this publication does not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the Department of Health and Human Services, nor does mention of trade names, commercial products, or organizations imply endorsement by the U.S. Government. We thank Drs. George Nelson and Jim Lautenberger for helpful comments.
MPM, XG, and MC conceived and designed the experiments. MPM and XG performed the experiments. YQ analyzed the data. LJ, JJG, SB, GDK, SJO, and JT contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools. MC wrote the paper.
- 1. Biron CA, Brossay L (2001) NK cells and NKT cells in innate defense against viral infections. Curr Opin Immunol 13: 458–464.
- 2. Trinchieri G (1989) Biology of natural killer cells. Adv Immunol 47: 187–376.
- 3. Lanier LL (2005) NK cell recognition. Annu Rev Immunol 23: 225–274.
- 4. Moretta L, Moretta A (2004) Unravelling natural killer cell function: Triggering and inhibitory human NK receptors. Embo J 23: 255–259.
- 5. Martin MP, Gao X, Lee JH, Nelson GW, Detels R, et al. (2002) Epistatic interaction between KIR3DS1 and HLA-B delays the progression to AIDS. Nat Genet 31: 429–434.
- 6. Wiegand TW, Young LH (2006) Cytomegalovirus retinitis. Int Ophthalmol Clin 46: 91–110.
- 7. Carrington M, O'Brien SJ (2003) The influence of HLA genotype on AIDS. Annu Rev Med 54: 535–551.
- 8. Gao X, Nelson GW, Karacki P, Martin MP, Phair J, et al. (2001) Effect of a single amino acid change in MHC class I molecules on the rate of progression to AIDS. N Engl J Med 344: 1668–1675.
- 9. Gao X, Bashirova A, Iversen AK, Phair J, Goedert JJ, et al. (2005) AIDS restriction HLA allotypes target distinct intervals of HIV-1 pathogenesis. Nat Med 11: 1290–1292.
- 10. Lyles RH, Munoz A, Yamashita TE, Bazmi H, Detels R, et al. (2000) Natural history of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 viremia after seroconversion and proximal to AIDS in a large cohort of homosexual men. Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study. J Infect Dis 181: 872–880.
- 11. Raulet DH (2003) Roles of the NKG2D immunoreceptor and its ligands. Nat Rev Immunol 3: 781–790.
- 12. Carrington M, Wang S, Martin MP, Gao X, Schiffman M, et al. (2005) Hierarchy of resistance to cervical neoplasia mediated by combinations of killer immunoglobulin-like receptor and human leukocyte antigen loci. J Exp Med 201: 1069–1075.
- 13. Hawes SE, Kiviat NB (2002) Are genital infections and inflammation cofactors in the pathogenesis of invasive cervical cancer? J Natl Cancer Inst 94: 1592–1593.
- 14. Klein J, Satta Y, O'hUigin C, Takahata N (1993) The molecular descent of the major histocompatibility complex. Annu Rev Immunol 11: 269–295.
- 15. Kiepiela P, Leslie AJ, Honeyborne I, Ramduth D, Thobakgale C, et al. (2004) Dominant influence of HLA-B in mediating the potential co-evolution of HIV and HLA. Nature 432: 769–775.
- 16. Abi-Rached L, Parham P (2005) Natural selection drives recurrent formation of activating killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptor and Ly49 from inhibitory homologues. J Exp Med 201: 1319–1332.
- 17. Phair J, Jacobson L, Detels R, Rinaldo C, Saah A, et al. (1992) Acquired immune deficiency syndrome occurring within 5 years of infection with human immunodeficiency virus type-1: The Multicenter AIDS Cohort Study. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 5: 490–496.
- 18. Goedert JJ, Kessler CM, Aledort LM, Biggar RJ, Andes WA, et al. (1989) A prospective study of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 infection and the development of AIDS in subjects with hemophilia. N Engl J Med 321: 1141–1148.
- 19. Buchbinder SP, Katz MH, Hessol NA, O'Malley PM, Holmberg SD (1994) Long-term HIV-1 infection without immunologic progression. Aids 8: 1123–1128.
- 20. Vlahov D, Graham N, Hoover D, Flynn C, Bartlett JG, et al. (1998) Prognostic indicators for AIDS and infectious disease death in HIV-infected injection drug users: plasma viral load and CD4+ cell count. JAMA 279: 35–40.