Reader Comments

Post a new comment on this article

Several issues with the Figures

Posted by knudsonm on 29 Mar 2013 at 19:43 GMT

I just presented this paper to students for a class. We identified several issues that were concerning and/or typo's.
Fig 2A/B- The Arrows should go on the X-axis not the Y.
Fig 2D- the parameter on the X-axis is not indicated.
Fig 3A- The curves for the 2 antibody treatment groups are very near close to one another- does not look like the P = 0.0004 value shown is consistent with this data.
Fig 6- did the authors look at anti-CD8 treatment in mice not treated with CTLA-4 antibodies??? Without this data it is difficult to interpret this result.

No competing interests declared.