http://orcid.org/0000-0001-8126-6377
Figures
Abstract
Rationale
Plasma low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (plasma LDL-C), vascular endothelial cells and peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs), particularly monocytes, play key roles in initiating atherosclerosis, the primary cause of cardiovascular disease (CVD). Although the mechanisms underlying development of atherosclerosis are not well understood, LDL-C is known to influence expression of endothelial microRNAs (miRNAs) and gene-targets of miRNAs to promote cell senescence. However, the impact of LDL-C on expression of PBMC miRNAs and miRNA targeted genes in response to an atherogenic diet is not known. In this study, we used unbiased methods to identify coordinately responsive PBMC miRNA- gene networks that differ between low and high LDL-C baboons when fed a high-cholesterol, high-fat (HCHF) diet.
Methods and results
Using RNA Seq, we quantified PBMC mRNAs and miRNAs from half-sib baboons discordant for LDL-C plasma concentrations (low LDL-C, n = 3; high LDL-C, n = 3) before and after a 7-week HCHF diet challenge. For low LDL-C baboons, 626 genes exhibited significant change in expression (255 down-regulated, 371 up-regulated) in response to the HCHF diet, and for high LDL-C baboons 379 genes exhibited significant change in expression (162 down-regulated, 217 up-regulated) in response to the HCHF diet. We identified 494 miRNAs identical to human miRNAs and 47 novel miRNAs. Fifty miRNAs were differentially expressed in low LDL-C baboons (21 up- and 29 down-regulated) and 20 in high LDL-C baboons (11 up- and 9 down-regulated) in response to the HCHF diet. Among the differentially expressed miRNAs were miR-221/222 and miR-34a-3p, which were down-regulated, and miR-148a/b-5p, which was up-regulated. In addition, gene-targets of these miRNAs, VEGFA, MAML3, SPARC, and DMGDH, were inversely expressed and are central hub genes in networks and signaling pathways that differ between low and high LDL-C baboon HCHF diet response.
Conclusions
We have identified coordinately regulated HCHF diet-responsive PBMC miRNA-gene networks that differ between baboons discordant for LDL-C concentrations. Our findings provide potential insights into molecular mechanisms underlying initiation of atherosclerosis where LDL-C concentrations influence expression of specific miRNAs, which in turn regulate expression of genes that play roles in initiation of lesions.
Citation: Karere GM, Glenn JP, Birnbaum S, Garcia R, VandeBerg JL, Cox LA (2019) Identification of coordinately regulated microRNA-gene networks that differ in baboons discordant for LDL-cholesterol. PLoS ONE 14(3): e0213494. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0213494
Editor: Peng Yu, Texas A&M University, UNITED STATES
Received: December 20, 2017; Accepted: February 24, 2019; Published: March 15, 2019
Copyright: © 2019 Karere et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: MicroRNA and gene expression files are available, respectively, from the SRA database (accession number SRP148696) and GEO database (accession number GSE114722).
Funding: This study received support from the following: National Institutes of Health (Grant number: P01 HL028972) received by JLV; NIH Office of the Director (Grant number: P51 OD011133) received by JLV; NIH Office of the Director (Grant number: P51 RR013986) received by JLV; (Grant number: C06 RR14578; C06 RR15456; C06 RR013556; C06 RR017515). The funder supported the infrastructure that was used during the investigation of the work reported in the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Cardiovascular disease (CVD), the leading cause of morbidity and mortality in developed countries [1,2], is commonly associated with development of atherosclerosis. The pathophysiological characteristics of atherosclerosis are a consequence of interactions between genetic and environmental factors including diet. Clinical and epidemiological studies indicate that atherosclerotic burden is positively correlated with plasma LDL-C concentrations [3–6], and high LDL-C concentration is a major risk factor or atherosclerosis [7].
High LDL-C concentrations contribute greatly to the initiation of atherosclerosis, whereby LDL particles and associated cholesterol activate adhesion molecules on vascular endothelial cells (EC), reduce synthesis of EC-derived relaxing factor, and promote EC apoptosis [7, 8]. It is posited that upon activation of adhesion molecules, PBMCs, particularly monocytes, adhere to the endothelium, infiltrate the neointima through the endothelial layer, phagocytize LDL-C and transform to macrophages, triggering inflammation-signaling cascades. Previous in vitro studies demonstrated that LDL-C, particularly oxidized LDL-C (ox-LDL-C), induces EC apoptosis by regulating the expression of genes and miRNAs. For example, ox-LDL-C induces EC apoptosis by down-regulating BCL2 [9, 10] and the miR-222/221 family [11], while up-regulating miR-365 [12].
Previously we showed that hepatic miR-222/221 was down-regulated in response to feeding a HCHF diet to baboons with high LDL-C concentrations [13]. In the current study, we hypothesized that PBMC miRNAs and miRNA gene-targets are differentially expressed in response to changes in LDL-C concentrations, and that miRNA-gene networks are concomitantly modulated. To test this hypothesis, half-sib adult baboons (Papio hamadryas) exhibiting discordant LDL-C plasma concentrations (low and high LDL-C) were challenged for 7 weeks with a HCHF diet. Blood samples were collected before and after the diet challenge. We quantified all PBMC-expressed genes and miRNAs by unbiased RNA Seq.
We identified differentially expressed genes and miRNAs, inversely expressed miRNA gene-targets and their integrated networks, and gene ontologies and biological pathways modulated in response to changes in LDL-C concentrations. By analyzing half-sib baboons discordant for the LDL-C plasma concentrations (> 2 S.D. difference), we minimized genetic variation due to genetic background and increased the likelihood that we would discover miRNAs and miRNA gene-targets that are LDL-C responsive.
The baboon is a well-characterized model for dyslipidemia and atherosclerosis [6, 14] and is very similar to humans both physiologically and genetically [15], suggesting that findings in baboons will translate to humans. In addition to genetic background, we are able to control diet and environment in baboons, which is very difficult in humans. To our knowledge, the influence of LDL-C concentrations on PBMC miRNA and miRNA gene-target expression has not been investigated in primates. Identification of baboon PBMC miRNAs and miRNA gene-targets that are differentially expressed in response to changes in LDL-C concentrations may provide insights into understanding mechanisms by which early atherosclerosis is initiated, potentiating discovery of novel therapeutic targets and biomarkers for dyslipidemia.
Materials and methods
Animals
Baboons were bred and maintained at the Southwest National Primate Research Center (SNPRC), Texas Biomedical Research Institute (Texas Biomed), which is accredited by the Association for Assessment and Accreditation of Laboratory Animal Care International. The animals were maintained in outdoor group housing, which provided full social environment and physical activity, and food and drink ad libitum. The Texas Biomedical Research Institute’s Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee approved experimental protocols, and SNPRC veterinarians and veterinary staff conducted all procedures, and all efforts were made to minimize suffering. The animals were not euthanized after the experiments.
Selection of baboon half-sib-pairs discordant for LDL-C
Based on phenotypic and genotypic analysis of 951 pedigreed baboons, we identified three half-sib-pairs with contrasting phenotypes for LDL-C concentrations as described. The members of each half-sib-pair differed by at least two standard deviations for LDL-C concentrations [16].
Diet challenge
Half-sib baboons were maintained on a chow diet that is low in fat (4% of calories) and cholesterol (0.03 mg/kcal) and challenged for 7 weeks with HCHF diet, which is high in fat (40% of calories) and cholesterol (1.7 mg/kcal). The dietary components and the dietary challenge protocols have been described [17].
Sample collection
Prior to sample collection, baboons were sedated with ketamine (10 mg/kg), given atropine (0.025 mg/kg) and intubated. Blood pressure was measured by automated arm cuff (Collin), and oxygen saturation, heart and respiration rates were monitored by pulse oximetry. Blood samples (10 ml) were collected by venipuncture in EDTA tubes, before (n = 6) and after the HCHF challenge diet (n = 6). Whole blood was centrifuged at 10,000g for 10 min, and buffy coats were aspirated and stored at -80°C.
RNA isolation
Total RNA was isolated and purified from buffy coats of 12 samples using TRIzol Reagent and miRNeasy Mini Kit (Qiagen) as described previously [18]. RNA quantity was assessed spectrophotometrically using a NanoDrop 8000 (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Wilmington, DE), and quality was assessed using an Agilent Bioanalyzer 2100 (Agilent, Santa Clara, CA). RNA integrity was assessed by electrophoresis in a denaturing 1% agarose gel and stored at −80°C until further use.
RNA sequencing and data analysis
Complementary DNA (cDNA) was generated for RNA Seq using Illumina’s mRNA Seq Sample Preparation Kit according to the manufacturer’s protocol and as described previously [18]. Briefly, we enriched for mRNAs using poly-A selection and fragmented the mRNA by chemical fragmentation. We generated the first strand of cDNA using reverse transcription and Illumina’s random hexamer primers, and the second strand using DNA Polymerase I and RNase H. We multiplexed all samples in one pool and hybridized the pool to an individual lane of a flow cell for cluster generation using the Illumina Paired End Cluster Generation Kitv4 (2x100bp) and Cluster Station. Sequencing was performed using the Illumina v4 Sequencing Kit and HiSeq 2500 Sequencer.
The sequencing output FASTQ files (GEO accession number: GSE114722) were analyzed using default settings of Partek Flow (Partek Inc., MO). Briefly, paired sequence reads for each sample were trimmed bases from the 5’ end, followed by trimming of bases from both ends for sequence reads with a Phred score of less than 30.The sequence reads were aligned with STAR aligner v2.3.1j to baboon transcriptome (Ensembl PapAnu2 release 76). To quantify the expression levels of transcripts, the mapped reads were normalized using transcripts per kilobase million (TPM), whereby read counts were divided by the length of a gene in kilobase to compute reads per kilobase (RPK). The sum of all RPK values in a sample were divided by 106 to compute ‘per million scaling factor’. Finally, each RPK was divided by the ‘per million scaling factor’ to obtain TPM. The reads were quantified using Partek’ expectation maximization (EM) algorithm. Differential expression of genes was evaluated using Partek’s gene specific analysis (GSA). The goal of GSA is to identify a statistical model that is the best for a specific gene, and then to use the best model to test for differential expression.
Using GSA, p values and fold-change for each gene, calculated as normalized ratio of mapped reads before and after diet challenge, were outputted. Finally, using Partek Genomic Suite we generated unsupervised hierarchical clustering of profiles of differentially expressed genes.
Functional enrichment analysis
To enhance the understanding of the biological relevance of all differentially expressed genes before and after HCHF diet challenge in low and high LDL-C baboons, we performed functional enrichment analysis using ClueGO, a plug-in app for Cytoscape [19]. ClueGo facilitates generation of functionally grouped gene ontology and pathway networks and charts to decipher the biological relevance of expressed genes. The statistical test used for the enrichment was based on the both-sided hypergeometric option with a Benjamini-Hoschberg correction and kappa score of 0.4. In addition, we invoked the GO Term Fusion option as well as biological, functional, molecular and immunity GO terms.
To further understand the biological relevance of the genes that were common and inversely expressed in both low and high LDL baboons, we performed network analysis using ConsensusPathDB-human (http://cpdb.molgen.mpg.de/), a web-based analysis tool. The significance of GO terms and pathways was tested with p value set at <0.01, a minimum overlap with input genes set at 2 and a GO level 5 category option.
Small RNA sequencing and data analysis
We used protocols and procedures described previously [13] and used the same RNA samples that were used for RNA Seq above. After isolating RNA, we enriched the sample with sncRNAs by using mirVana miRNA Isolation Kit (Ambion). We used 2μg of sncRNAs to synthesis cDNA. After purification, the ibraries were quantified using QuBit fluorometry and Nanodrop 8000 spectrometry. Library clones were generated using cBot, and sequenced using Illumina’s Genome Analyzer (GAIIx). Sequence reads analysis and identification of differentially expressed miRNAs were done using mirTools [20]. For the miRNAs, sequence reads (SRA accession number: SRP148696) were normalized using reads per million mapped to miRNA (RPMM), whereby the sum of miRNA specific read counts per sample was divided by 106 to compute ‘per million scaling factor’. Finally, read counts were divided by the ‘per million scaling factor’ to compute RPMM.
Identification of gene-miRNA integrated networks
To identify miRNA-gene integrated networks, we used MiRNA Target Filter in IPA. Briefly, we uploaded both differentially expressed miRNAs and differentially expressed genes and identified miRNA targets using TargetScanHuman v6.2/Tar-Base/MiRecords software embedded in IPA. TargetScanHuman considers matches to human 3’ UTRs and their orthologs. We used the Build function to connect inversely expressed miRNA-mRNA molecules and generate networks. The low LDL-C network was overlaid on a miRNA-gene list for high LDL baboons to generate a high LDL-C network.
Statistical analysis
Statistical analysis was performed using algorithms embedded in miRTool for miRNA expression profiles and Partek Genomic Suite for gene expression profiles. Arithmetic means derived from three samples for baboons fed chow or HCHF diet per baboon phenotype were used to identify differentially expressed miRNAs and genes, and analyzed by a two-tailed paired t- test. One sample two-tailed t-test was used to test the mean difference in LDL-C concentrations of the animals before and after diet challenge. Statistical significant threshold was set at p < 0.05. Where appropriate multiple testing analysis was performed to correct p values using Benjamini-Hochberg method described by McDonald JH. (2014) [21].
For the miRNA analysis, we used 5% False Discovery Rate (FDR) and 20% for the gene analysis; meaning that we accepted the possibility that 20% of the genes with p values less than 0.05 are likely false positive. Statistically significant pathways and GO terms were determined using algorithms embedded in IPA, ClueGo, or ConsensusPathDP-human software. P-values <0.05 were considered statistically significant.
Results
LDL-C concentrations in low and high LDL-C baboon baboons
Table 1 illustrates changes of LDL-C concentrations after the HCHF diet challenge. For both low and high LDL-C baboons, LDL-C concentrations increased significantly after diet challenge (low, p = 0.01; high, p = 0.03). For the high LDL-C baboons, LDL-C concentrations increased 2-fold compared to low LDL-C baboons after the HCHF diet challenge (p = 0.02).
Differential expression of PBMC genes responsive to HCHF diet
We identified genes that were differentially expressed in response to LDL-C concentration changes by analyzing the expression levels before and after HCHF diet challenge. For low LDL-C baboons, 626 genes (255 down-regulated, 371 up-regulated) exhibited significant change in expression, while 272 genes (114 down-regulated, 158 up-regulated) remained significantly differentially expressed in high LDL-C baboons after p-value correction (S1 Table). Tables 2 and 3 show the top 35 genes with highest change in response to HCHF diet. Fig 1 shows unsupervised hierarchical clustering of gene expressionprofiles in low and high LDL-C baboons.
Columns and rows, respectively, denote genes and time points.
Moreover, we used ClueGO (http://apps.cytoscape.org/apps/cluego), an application for Cytoscape, to identify networks of both gene ontology (GO) and pathways influenced by genes differentially expressedin low and high LDL-C baboons. Fig 2 shows functionally grouped networks of GO terms and pathways associated with expressed genes in low LDL-C baboons, including VLDL particle remodeling, regulation of cholesterol transport, endothelial cell apoptotic process, and negative regulation of blood vessel morphogenesis. For high LDL-C baboons, GO terms and pathways included coronary vasculature development, heart valve morphogenesis, kidney epithelium development, distal tubule and collecting duct development (Fig 3).
Terms are represented as nodes linked based on their kappa score 0.4, where only the label of the most significant term per group is shown. The node size represents the term enrichment significance. The node color denotes different GO terms, and color gradient shows the gene proportion of each cluster associated with the term.
Terms are represented as nodes linked based on their kappa score 0.4, where only the label of the most significant term per group is shown. The node size represents the term enrichment significance. The node color denotes different GO terms, and color gradient shows the gene proportion of each cluster associated with the term.
Genes expressed in both low and high LDL-C baboons
Eighteen differentially expressed genes were common in both low and high LDL-C baboons (Table 4). After p-value correction, 14 genes remained significantly differentially expressed in both groups. Among the 14 genes, 3 genes (VEGFA, SPARC and DMGDH) were inversely expressed between the two groups. MAML3, PKD1L3 and LIN9 were inversely expressed between the phenotypes but their differential expression was nominal in low LDL-C baboons. Fig 4 shows a network of GO and pathways associated with the differentially expressed genes. The top GO terms that were statistically significant included regulation of angiogenesis, regulation vascular development, regulation of hematopoietic progenitor cell differentiation, and kidney endothelial angiogenesis.
Terms are represented as nodes linked based on their kappa score 0.4, where only the label of the most significant term per group is shown. The node size represents the term enrichment significance. The color gradient shows the proportion of the number of genes for each cluster associated with the term.
Annotation of small RNAs and identification of novel miRNAs
The proportion of expressed sncRNAs for each type of annotated sncRNA is shown in Fig 5. Fig 5A shows combined data for low and high LDL-C baboons. miRNAs were the most abundantly expresse of the annotated sncRNAs (93%). Other sncRNAs, such as small interfering RNAs (siRNAs), small nucleolar RNAs (snoRNAs), small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs), and transfer RNAs (tRNAs), comprised 4% of the total expressed sncRNAs. Repeat-associated RNAs accounted for only 1% of the sncRNAs.
Proportion of sncRNAs in a) both low and high LDL-C, b) high LDL-C only and c) low LDL-C only PBMC samples. Segments in the donut diagram represent the proportions of different categories of small RNAs. Notably, “other non-coding RNAs” include snoRNAs, tRNAs, siRNAs,and snRNAs.
Unique sncRNAs that did not map (“unclassified”) to any sncRNA databases or to the human genome comprised approximately 2% of the sncRNAs expressed in all baboon PBMC libraries. Fig 5B and 5 show the data, respectively, for low LDL-C baboons and high LDL-C baboons. A higher proportion of miRNAs were expressed in low LDL-C baboons (96%) compared with high LDL-C baboons (90%).However, the difference was not statistically significant. Other non-coding RNAs accounted for only 2% of the total expressed sncRNAs in low LDL-C baboons and 6% for high LDL-C baboons (Fig 4B and 4C).
We identified 541 distinct miRNAs in baboon PBMCs: 494 were identical to human miRNAs, herein referred to as known miRNAs, and 47 were novel baboon miRNAs (Table 5). A greater number of known and novel miRNAs were expressed in low LDL-C than high LDL-C baboons. All known and novel miRNAs are shown in S2 and S3 Tables.
Differential expression of PBMC miRNAs in response to a HCHF diet
MiRNAs that were differentially expressed in response to a HCHF diet in low and high LDL-C baboons are shown in Fig 6. Fifty miRNAs were differentially expressed in low LDL-C baboons (21 up- and 29 down-regulated). For high LDL-C baboons, 20 miRNAs were differentially expressed in response to LDL- C level change (11 up- and 9 down-regulated). The miR-30 family was down-regulated in both low and high LDL-C baboons. Notable miRNAs up-regulated in low LDL-C PBMCs but not significantly differentially expressed in high LDL-C baboons included miR-33b, 29b, 16, 155 and 26b. The miR- 221/222 family was down-regulated in high LDL-C baboons but not significantly differentially expressed in low LDL-C samples. Table 6 shows the miRNA nucleotide sequences, p values and fold changes of these miRNAs.
We identified star miRNAs (complementary sequence to mature miRNA) that were differentially expressed and exhibited discordant expression in low and high LDL-C baboons. MiR-34a* and 374a* (miR-34a-3p and 374a-3p) were up-regulated in low LDL-C baboons and down-regulated in high LDL-C baboons. Interestingly, miR-148a and miR-148b were up-regulated in low LDL-C baboons while complementary sequences, miR-148a* (miR-148a-5p) and miR-148b* (miR-148b-5p), were up-regulated in high LDL-C baboons.
Targets of differentially expressed miRNAs
We used IPA to identify miRNA gene-targets that are differentially expressed and inversely correlated with differentially expressed miRNAs. Table 7 shows that the total number of targeted genes for low LDL- C baboons was significantly greater than for high LDL-C baboons, z-score = 24.6, p<0.001. These miRNA targets included genes involved in lipid exchange and transport, angiogenesis and glucose homeostasis such as APOL1, VEGFA, IGFBP5, and MAMAL3. S4 Table shows all genes that were differentially expressed and inversely correlated with differentially expressed miRNAs in low and high LDL-C baboons.
Expression of miRNAs and miRNA-targets is coordinated in response to LDL-C levels
We integrated differentially expressed genes and differentially expressed miRNAs in response to HCHF diet in low and high LDL-C baboons. Notably, the genes and miRNAs were identified from the same samples. Figs 7 and 8 show networks of miRNAs and miRNA targets that were inversely expressed in low and in high LDL-C baboons, respectively. We found out that VEGFA, MAML3, and LRP2 are major hubs that are differentially expressed between low and high LDL-C baboons and inversely expressed in respect to miRNAs that are differentially expressed in low and high LDL–C baboons.
Genes and miRNAs are represented as nodes. Red nodes indicate up-regulated genes, and green nodes denote down-regulated miRNAs. The intensity of the color indicates the degree of differential expression. Numerals below each colored node represent expression fold-change and P-values. The molecular relationship between nodes is represented as a line (edge); arrows indicate the direction of interaction.
Genes and miRNAs are represented as nodes. Rednodes indicate up-regulated genes, and green nodes denote down-regulated miRNAs. The intensity of the color indicates the degree of differential expression. Numerals below each colored node represent expression fold-change and P-values. The molecular relationship between nodes is represented as a line (edge); arrows indicate the direction of interaction.
Discussion
Plasma high LDL-C concentration is a major risk factor for atherosclerosis, the leading cause of CVD. LDL-C contributes greatly to the development and progression of atherosclerosis by inducing the expression of EC adhesion molecules and ameliorating endothelial cell apoptosis. Various studies have shown that LDL-C particles, particularly when oxidized, induce EC apoptosis by altering the expression of miRNAs or miRNA target genes in vitro [11, 12]. In addition, PBMCs, particularly monocytes play a key role during initiation of atherogenesis, where they infiltrate vascular intima and differentiate to macrophages, triggering a cascade of inflammatory signals. Further, recent studies have demonstrated that monocyte-derived exosomes transport miRNAs that activate adhesion molecules of EC in vitro [22, 23]. Previously, we showed that LDL-C concentrations influence the expression of hepatic miRNAs in response to a HCHF diet [13]. In the current study, we aimed to assess differential expression of PBMC miRNAs and miRNA gene-targets in baboons differing in LDL-C response to a HFHC diet, together with identification of coordinately expressed miRNAs and miRNA gene-targets using unbiased methods. To address these aims we combined high throughput RNA sequencing together with bioinformatics, including TargetScan software embedded in IPA, EM algorithm in Partek package, GO and KEGG pathway analysis. To our knowledge this is the first study to interrogate the expression of miRNAs and miRNA targets in PBMCs in response to a HCHF diet challenge in nonhuman primates discordant forLDL-C response to a dietary challenge.
We observed that 626 genes were differentially expressed in response to a HCHF diet challenge in low LDL baboons and 272 genes in high LDL baboons multiple testing correction. The top 35 gens with highest fold change in low LDL-C baboons includes CPS, which catalyzes synthesis of carbamoyl phosphate and mutation in the gene leads to susceptibility to persistent hypertension, and PLG, the precursor for plasmin and angiotensin. Mutation in PLG leads to thrombophilia. The top 35 genes in high LDL-C baboons includes ALDOB, which is a glycolytic enzyme, and a lipoprotein receptor (LRP2).
Eighteen genes were differentially expressed in response to HCHF diet in both low LDL-C baboons and high LDL-C baboons. Among the 18 genes, 3 (VEGFA, DMGDH and SPARC) were inversely expressed between the baboon phenotypes. These PBMC candidate genes whose expression is influenced by dyslipidemia in baboons are potential therapeutic targets. Future studies will validate their expressionand decipher the molecular mechanisms associated with dyslipidemia.
For miRNAs, 70 were differentially expressed; 50 in low LDL-C and 20 in high LDL-C baboons. Notable miRNAs include miR545-3, which exhibited 322-fold change in high LDL-C baboons, miR-221\222, miR- 34a, and 148a/b. Integration of differentially expressed miRNAs, and, inversely, differentially expressed genes targeted by these miRNAs, revealed that the major hubs are regulated by multiple miRNAs. Forexample, in high LDL-C baboons, VEGFA is targeted by miR-34a-5p and miR-344d-3p, and MAML3 is putatively targeted by miR-499, miR-148a-3p, miR-423-5p, miR-101-3p and miR-411-5p. These observations are consistent with previous knowledge that miRNAs coordinately regulate major gene hubs in a complex network by binding at multiple sites to fine tune their expression.
Importantly, we observed differing integrated GO terms and pathways in low and high LDL-C baboon groups. For low LDL-C baboons, the major G0 terms and pathways associated with expressed genes in response to HCHF diet are linked to lipid metabolism. In contrast, GO terms and pathways associated with vascular development, apoptosis and kidney development are enriched for genes expressed in high LDL-C baboons. Genes expressed in both groups are associated with angiogenesis and vascular development. The high plasma cholesterol in high LDL-C baboons is associated with attenuated lipid metabolism pathways and activated epithelial development pathways, possibly in response to endothelium injury modulated by LDL-C.
Candidate genes and signaling pathways
VEGFA and VEGF signaling pathway.
VEGFA is a major ligand for the VEGFR1 receptor that is involved in VEGF signaling pathway, implicated in many pathophysiological conditions, including CVD. In our study, the VEGFA was down-regulated inlow LDL-C baboons, and up-regulated in high LDL-C baboons. Our findings indicate that the high LDL-C plasma concentrations correlated with increased expression of VEGFA in PBMCs.
LDL-C plays a major role initiating atherosclerosis, and one possible mechanism involves up-regulation of VEGFA. It’s plausible that PBMC-secreted VEGFA may interact with monocyte VEGFA receptor to induce atherogenesis-related inflammatory cytokines. In mice, cholesterol loaded in macrophagesinfluenced the up-regulation of VEGFA [24]. In humans, VEGFA was up-regulated in neointimal lesions compared to control [25]. Future studies will investigate the mechanistic role of VEGFA expressed in PBMCs in response to HCHF diet, in relation to atherogenesis, and whether VEGFA is a potential biomarker for dyslipidemia.
DMGDH and choline oxidative pathway.
DMGDH encodes an enzyme that catalyzes the demethylation of dimethylglycine (DMG), leading to the subsequent formation of sarcosine and glycine in a canonical choline oxidative pathway in the mitochondria [26]. In our study, DMGDH was up-regulated in high LDL-C baboons while it was down- regulated in low LDL-C baboons in response to HCHF diet. Our findings suggest that the concentrationof plasma cholesterol influences the expression of DMGDH, likely in response to accumulated DMG levels.
Aberrant plasma levels of DMG are associated with various pathophysiological conditions. Elevated DMG plasma levels are associated with atherosclerotic CVD [27] and mortality [28], impaired renal function [29] and CRP-related inflammation [27]. Because DMHDH catalyzes metabolism of DMG, it is likely that increased levels of DMG will be accompanied by increased expression of DMGDH. Our results will stimulate further studies to investigate whether DMGDH expression is correlated with DMG plasmalevels, and their potential role in the development of atherosclerosis.
SPARC and TGF/B signaling pathway.
SPARC encodes an extracellular matrix glycoprotein molecule that is involved in transduction of a plethora of cell signaling pathways, including TGF-beta pathway by interacting with TGF/B receptor II [30–32]. Other pathways regulated by SPARC include Wnt/beta-catenin and MAPK pathways [33, 34].
We found that SPARC expression was up-regulated in high LDL-C baboons and down-regulated in low LDL-C baboons. Our results corroborate with a previous study which indicated that ox-LDL-C influenced SPARC expression [35]. The mechanisms that link high LDL-C and SPARC expression are unclear, but it is likely high LDL-C may stimulate expression of SPARC in PBMCs. The subsequent secretion of SPARC proteins into circulation may trigger inflammation, vascular endothelial cell apoptosis, and vascular smooth cell proliferation to initiate atherosclerosis.
In other studies, elevated plasma concentrations of SPARC are associated with diabetes mellitus, inflammation and dyslipidemia [36] and obesity [37]—all risk factors for cardiovascular disease. These results correlate with findings that SPARC plasma concentrations are elevated in patients with coronary artery disease [38]. In ex-vivo, SPARC expression was up-regulated in both vascular endothelial cells and smooth muscle cells in atherosclerotic lesions in rhesus macaques (Macaca mulatta) [39]. Together,these findings suggest that SPARC plays a fundamental role in dyslipidemia and in the development of atherosclerosis.
Differentially expressed candidate miRNAs and their role in dyslipidemia
miR-545-3p.
miR-545 is encoded in a long noncoding RNA associated with the X-linked FTX gene (lnc-FTX). In our study, miR-545 had the greatest change in response to HCHF diet challenge with a 322-fold change in high LDL-C baboons comparing the HCHF diet to the baseline chow diet. This is the first study showing association of miR-545 expression with LDL-C concentrations. Our miRNA/mRNA prediction analysis indicated that miR-545 gene-targets include LDLRAP1, LDLRAD4, and VLDLR. Elsewhere, in a study comparing patients with CAD and controls, platelet-associated miR-545 was up-regulated in CAD patients compared to controls [40]. Future studies will validate the interaction of miR-545-3p with its gene-targets and molecular mechanisms underlying dyslipidemia in a baboon model of atherosclerosis.
miR-34.
We found discordant expression of miR-34a* (miR-34a-3p), whereby the miRNA is up-regulated in high LDL-C baboons but down-regulated in low LDL-C baboons. However, very little is known about the role of miR-34a-3p in lipid metabolism. It is plausible that miR-34a-3p plays an important role in lipid metabolism and atherosclerosis, especially because it is evidently involved in both progenitor and EC apoptosis in vitro [41, 42]. The pro-apoptosis nature of miR-34a parallels the LDL-C mediated endothelial cell senescence and may explain the up-regulation of miR-34a-3p in high LDL-C baboons. Hepatic miR- 34a was up-regulated in mice fed a high-fat diet, which led to down-regulation of PPARα and SIRT1 [43]. An increasing body of evidence shows that miR-34a, which is a transcriptional target of p53, has tumor suppressive properties mediating apoptosis, cell cycle arrest, and senescence by inhibiting multiple oncogenic pathways [44, 45]. In some cancers, miR-34a is silenced typically by hypermethylation of its regulatory promoter [46]. A miRNA mimic for miR-34 is currently in clinical trial for patients with advanced solid tumors [44]. Further studies will investigate whether the promoter that regulates mir-34a-3p transcription is differentially methylated between low and high LDL-C baboons.
miR-221/222.
miR-221/222 genes are located in close proximity on the X-chromosome (Xp11.3) and are regulated in a coordinated manner [47]. In our study, we observed that both miR-221 and miR-222 were down-regulated in high LDL-C baboons in response to HCHF diet in concordance with our previous findings for the hepatic microRNAome for the same animals [13].
Recent evidence suggests that both miR-221 and 222 are anti-apoptotic and silenced by high LDL-C concentrations. Both miR-221 and miR-222 were down-regulated in oxidized LDL-C-induced apoptotic EC in vitro [12], and exogenous inhibition of miR-221/221 led to enhanced EC apoptosis by up-regulating Est1 and p21 [11]. A contrasting report showed that miR-221/222 plays a pro-apoptotic role in EC in serum-deprived media [48]. Importantly, serum-deprived media may not accurately represent the in vivo physiological condition. In comparison, ox-LDL-C-induced EC morphological changes recapitulate similar events during atherosclerosis in vivo [49]. This discrepancy may suggest that the functional role of a miRNA depends on environmental context. Our data suggest that high LDL-C may influence the down-egulation of expression of miR-221/222 in PBMCs, most likely to antagonize the miRNA anti-apoptotic functional role, and to promote initialization of atherosclerosis, in concordance with findings in in-vitro experiments.
miR-148.
miR-148 is a promising candidate that plays an important role in regulating lipidemia [50, 51]. We observed a novel discordant expression of mature miR-148a/b-3p and complementary ‘star’ sequences (miR-148a/b-5p) in low and high LDL-C baboons. miR-148a/b-3p were up-regulated in low LDL-C while miR148a/b-5p were up-regulated in high LDL-C baboons. This is the first study to report discordant expression of mature miR-148 and complementary sequences. These findings suggest that miR-148 and its complementary sequences may play different roles in low and high LDL-C concentrations and are potential novel therapeutic targets for dyslipidemia and atherosclerosis.
Two recent studies have identified miR-148a as a negative regulator of LDLR expression and activity [51, 52]. In mice, repression of miR-148a increased clearance of circulating labeled LDL particles and decreased LDL-C levels [51]. In addition, miR-148a is a critical regulator of HDL biogenesis and cholesterol efflux by targeting ABCA1, which plays an important role in removal of excess cholesterol from peripheral cells, including macrophages in atherosclerotic plaques [50]. Thus, miR-148a may play a unique role of decreasing LDL-C and increasing HDL particles.
In conclusion, we have demonstrated molecular genetic differences in response to a HCHF diet; these responses are evident in expression levels of individual genes and miRNAs, as well as in expression of coordinated networks of genes and miRNAs. The miRNAs and miRNA gene-targets differentially expressed in baboon with low LDL response versus high LDL response to a HCHF diet are potential therapeutic targets for lowering LDL-C and alleviating atherosclerosis burden. Although existing therapies are effective in lowering LDL-C concentrations and reducing the progression of atherosclerotic plaques in many people, the risk factors and incidence of CVD are still alarmingly high, and for some patients, the treatments are either not effective or tolerable. The observed genetic differences may explain why current therapies are not effective in some individuals. Thus, there is a need for a continued search for novel therapies. Interestingly, miRNAs are being considered for treatment because of their specificity and reduced side effects [44, 53]. Further studies are necessary to understand the molecular mechanisms by which high LDL-C alters the expression of genes and miRNAs in PBMCs, and whether there is a link between the expression profiles and the initiation of atherosclerosis. Such initiatives will enable delivery of a cassette of miRNA mimics or inhibitors to facilitate fine-tuning of gene networks, rather than delivery of single candidate genes. While miRNA therapeutics raise concerns over potential off-target effects current work on miR-122 has demonstrated that these therapies may prove more effective than, or complement, existing treatment options for CVD. Because nonhuman primates and humans are phylogenetically close, and are similar in their physiology and genetics, the baboon findings will be directly translatable to humans.
Supporting information
S1 Table. Expressed genes in low and high LDL-C baboons v2.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0213494.s001
(XLSX)
S4 Table. Inversely correlated miRNAs-genes in low and high LDL-C baboons.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0213494.s004
(XLSX)
References
- 1. Benjamin EJ, Virani SS, Callaway CW, Chamberlain AM, Chang AR, Cheng S, et al. Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics-2018 Update: A Report From the American Heart Association. Circulation. 2018;137(12):e67–e492. Epub 2018/02/02. pmid:29386200.
- 2. Thom T, Haase N, Rosamond W, Howard VJ, Rumsfeld J, Manolio T, et al. Heart disease and statistics—2006 update: a report from the American Heart Association Statistics Committee and Stroke Statistics Subcommittee. Circulation. 2006;113(6):e85. pmid:16407573; CIRCULATIONAHA. 105.171600 [PII].
- 3. Amarenco P, Goldstein LB, Szarek M, Sillesen H, Rudolph AE, Callahan A 3rd, et al. Effectsof intense low-density lipoprotein cholesterol reduction in patients with stroke or transient ischemic attack: the Stroke Prevention by Aggressive Reduction in Cholesterol Levels (SPARCL) trial. Stroke; a journal of cerebral circulation. 2007;38(12):3198. pmid:17962589; STROKEAHA.107.493106 [pii].
- 4. Amarenco P, Labreuche J, Touboul PJ. High-density lipoprotein-cholesterol and risk of stroke and carotid atherosclerosis: a systematic review. Atherosclerosis. 2008;196(2):489. pmid:17923134; S0021-9150(07)00480-7 [pii].
- 5. Assmann G, Schulte H. Relation of high-density lipoprotein cholesterol and triglycerides to incidence of atherosclerotic coronary artery disease (the PROCAM experience). Prospective Cardiovascular Munster study. AmJCardiol. 1992;70(7):733. pmid:1519522.
- 6. McGill HC Jr., McMahan CA, Kruski AW, Mott GE. Relationship of lipoprotein cholesterol concentrations to experimental atherosclerosis in baboons. Arteriosclerosis (Dallas,Tex).1981;1(1):3.pmid:6945831.
- 7. Brown MS, Goldstein JL. Lipoprotein metabolism in the macrophage: implications for cholesterol deposition in atherosclerosis. Annu Rev Biochem.1983;52:223. pmid:6311077.
- 8. Harada-Shiba M, Kinoshita M, Kamido H, Shimokado K. Oxidized low density lipoprotein induces apoptosis in cultured human umbilical vein endothelial cells by common and unique mechanisms. JBiolChem. 1998;273(16):9681. pmid:9545302.
- 9. Li D, Yang B, Mehta JL. Ox-LDL induces apoptosis in human coronary artery endothelial cells: role of PKC, PTK, bcl-2, and Fas. AmJPhysiol. 1998;275(2 Pt 2):H568. pmid:9683446.
- 10. Napoli C, Quehenberger O, De Nigris F, Abete P, Glass CK, Palinski W. Mildly oxidized low density lipoprotein activates multiple apoptotic signaling pathways in human coronary cells. FASEB journal: official publication of the Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology.2000;14(13):1996. pmid:11023984.
- 11. Qin B, Cao Y, Yang H, Xiao B, Lu Z. MicroRNA-221/222 regulate ox-LDL-induced endothelial apoptosis via Ets-1/p21 inhibition. Mol Cell Biochem. 2015;405(1–2):115. pmid:25893733.
- 12. Qin B, Xiao B, Liang D, Xia J, Li Y, Yang H. MicroRNAs expression in ox-LDL treated HUVECs: MiR-365 modulates apoptosis and Bcl-2 expression. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2011;410(1):127. pmid:21640710; S0006-291X(11)00893-X [pii].
- 13. Karere GM, Glenn JP, Vandeberg JL, Cox LA. Differential microRNA response to a high cholesterol, high-fat diet in livers of low and high LDL-C baboons. BMC Genomics. 2012;13:320. pmid:22809019; 14712164–58413–320 [pii].
- 14. Kushwaha RS, McGill HC, Jr. Diet, plasma lipoproteins and experimental atherosclerosis in baboon sp.). Hum Reprod Update. 1998;4(4):420. pmid:9825856.
- 15. Cox LA, Mahaney MC, Vandeberg JL, Rogers J. A second-generation genetic linkage map of the baboon (Papio hamadryas) genome. Genomics. 2006;88(3):274. pmid:16697552; S0888-7543(06)00101-7 [pii].
- 16. Cox LA, Glenn J, Ascher S, Birnbaum S, VandeBerg JL. Integration of genetic and genomic methods for identification of genes and gene variants encoding QTLs in the nonhuman primate. Methods (San Diego, Calif). 2009;49(1):63. pmid:19596448; S1046-2023(09)00154-6 [pii].
- 17. Mahaney MC, Karere GM, Rainwater DL, Voruganti VS, Dick EJ Jr., Owston MA, et al. Diet induced early-stage atherosclerosis in baboons: Lipoproteins, atherogenesis, and arterial compliance. J Med Primatol. 2018;47(1):3–17. Epub 2017/06/18. pmid:28620920;PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPMC5839476.
- 18. Spradling KD, Glenn JP, Garcia R, Shade RE, Cox LA. The baboon kidney transcriptome: analysis of transcript sequence, splice variants, and abundance. PLoS One. 2013;8(4):e57563. pmid:23637735; 601 PONE-D-12-22718 [pii].
- 19. Bindea G, Mlecnik B, Hackl H, Charoentong P, Tosolini M, Kirilovsky A, et al. ClueGO: a Cytoscape plug-in to decipher functionally grouped gene ontology and pathway annotation networks. Bioinformatics (Oxford, England). 2009;25(8):1091. PubMed 605 pmid:19237447.
- 20. Zhu E, Zhao F, Xu G, Hou H, Zhou L, Li X, et al. mirTools: microRNA profiling and discovery based on high-throughput sequencing. Nucleic Acids Res. 2010;38(Web Server issue):W392. pmid:20478827; gkq393 [pii].
- 21.
McDonald J. Handbook of Biological Statistics. Third Edition ed. Baltimore. Maryland, USA: Sparky House publishing; 2014.
- 22. Aharon A, Tamari T, Brenner B. Monocyte-derived microparticles and exosomes induce procoagulant and apoptotic effects on endothelial cells. Thromb Haemost. 2008;100(5):878. 08110878 [pii]. pmid:18989533.
- 23. Tang N, Sun B, Gupta A, Rempel H, Pulliam L. Monocyte exosomes induce adhesion molecules and cytokines via activation of NF-kappaB in endothelial cells. FASEB journal: official publication of the 616 Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology. 2016;30(9):3097. pmid:27226520.
- 24. Berisha SZ, Hsu J, Robinet P, Smith JD. Transcriptome analysis of genes regulated by cholesterol loading in two strains of mouse macrophages associates lysosome pathway and ER stress response with atherosclerosis susceptibility. PLoS One. 2013;8(5):e65003. pmid:23705026.
- 25. Bruczko M, Wolanska M, Malkowski A, Sobolewski K, Kowalewski R. Evaluation of Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor and Its Receptors in Human Neointima. Pathobiology: journal ofimmunopathology, molecular and cellular biology. 2016;83(1):47. pmid:26890264.
- 26. Lever M, George PM, Dellow WJ, Scott RS, Chambers ST. Homocysteine, glycine betaine, and N,N-dimethylglycine in patients attending a lipid clinic. Metabolism 2005;54(1):1.Doi:S0026049504003014 [pii]. pmid:15562374.
- 27. Svingen GF, Ueland PM, Pedersen EK, Schartum-Hansen H, Seifert R, Ebbing M, et al. Plasma 630 dimethylglycine and risk of incident acute myocardial infarction in patients with stable angina pectoris. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2013;33(8):2041. PubMed 632 pmid:23723367.
- 28. Svingen GF, Schartum-Hansen H, Ueland PM, Pedersen ER, Seifert R, Ebbing M, et al. Elevated plasma dimethylglycine is a risk marker of mortality in patients with coronary heart disease.EurJPrevCardiol. 2015;22(6):743. pmid:24671904.
- 29. McGregor DO, Dellow WJ, Lever M, George PM, Robson RA, Chambers ST. Dimethylglycine accumulates in uremia and predicts elevated plasma homocysteine concentrations. Kidney Int.2001;59(6):2267. S0085-2538(15)47722-1 [pii]. pmid:11380830
- 30. Francki A, McClure TD, Brekken RA, Motamed K, Murri C, Wang T, et al. SPARC regulates TGF-beta1-dependent signaling in primary glomerular mesangial cells. J Cell Biochem. 2004;91(5):915. pmid:15034927.
- 31. Joseph C, Hunter MG, Sinclair KD, Robinson RS. The expression, regulation and function of secreted protein, acidic, cysteine-rich in the follicle-luteal transition. Reproduction. 2012;144(3):361. 6 pmid:22733805.
- 32. Toba H, de Castro Bras LE, Baicu CF, Zile MR, Lindsey ML, Bradshaw AD. IncreasedADAMTS1 mediates SPARC-dependent collagen deposition in the aging myocardium.AmJPhysiolEndocrinolMetab. 2016;310(11):E1027. pmid:27143554.
- 33. Nagaraju GP, Sharma D. Anti-cancer role of SPARC, an inhibitor of adipogenesis. Cancer Treat Rev. 2011;37(7):559. pmid:21237573.
- 34. Said N, Najwer I, Motamed K. Secreted protein acidic and rich in cysteine (SPARC) inhibits integrin-mediated adhesion and growth factor-dependent survival signaling in ovarian cancer. AmJPathol. 2007;170(3):1054. S0002-9440(10)60924-8 [pii]. pmid:17322388.
- 35. Farrokhi E, GhatrehSamani K, Hashemzadeh Chaleshtori M, Tabatabaiefar MA. Effect of Oxidized Low Density Lipoprotein on the Expression of Runx2 and SPARC Genes in Vascular Smooth Muscle Cells. IranBiomedJ. 2015;19(3):160. Pii-IBJ-A-10-1308-1 [pii]. pmid:26025968.
- 36. Xu L, Ping F, Yin J, Xiao X, Xiang H, Ballantyne CM, et al. Elevated plasma SPARC levels areassociate with insulin resistance, dyslipidemia, and inflammation in gestational diabetes mellitus.PLoS One.2013;8(12):e81615. pmid:24349098.
- 37. Kos K, Wilding JP. SPARC: a key player in the pathologies associated with obesity and diabetes. NatRevEndocrinol. 2010;6(4):225. pmid:20195270.
- 38. Takahashi M, Nagaretani H, Funahashi T, Nishizawa H, Maeda N, Kishida K, et al. The expression of SPARC in adipose tissue and its increased plasma concentration in patients with coronary artery disease. Obes Res. 2001;9(7):388. pmid:11445660.
- 39. Raines EW, Lane TF, Iruela-Arispe ML, Ross R, Sage EH. The extracellular glycoprotein SPARC interacts with platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF)-AB and -BB and inhibits the binding of PDGF to its receptors. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1992;89(4):1281. pmid:1311092.
- 40. Chen F, Zhao X, Peng J, Bo L, Fan B, Ma D. Integrated microRNA-mRNA analysis of coronary artery disease. Mol Biol Rep. 2014;41(8):5505. pmid:24913032.
- 41. Hill JM, Zalos G, Halcox JP, Schenke WH, Waclawiw MA, Quyyumi AA, et al. Circulating endothelial progenitor cells, vascular function, and cardiovascular risk. NEnglJMed. 2003;348(7):593. pmid:12584367.
- 42. Zhang C, Zheng H, Yu Q, Yang P, Li Y, Cheng F, et al. A practical method for quantifying atherosclerotic lesions in rabbits. J Comp Pathol. 2010;142(2–3):122. pmid:20031151; S0021-9975(09)00315-6 [pii].
- 43. Ding J, Li M, Wan X, Jin X, Chen S, Yu C, et al. Effect of miR-34a in regulating steatosis by targeting PPARalpha expression in nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. Sci Rep. 2015;5:13729. pmid:26330104.
- 44. Ling H, Li X, Yao CH, Hu B, Liao D, Feng S, et al. The physiological and pathophysiological roles of adipocyte miRNAs. BiochemCell Biol. 2013;91(4):195. pmid:23859012.
- 45. Schmid G, Notaro S, Reimer D, Abdel-Azim S, Duggan-Peer M, Holly J, et al. Expression and promotor hypermethylation of miR-34a in the various histological subtypes of ovarian cancer. BMC Cancer. 2016;16:102. pmid:26879132.
- 46. Xie K, Liu J, Chen J, Dong J, Ma H, Liu Y, et al. Methylation-associated silencing of microRNA- 34b in hepatocellular carcinoma cancer. Gene. 2014;543(1):101. pmid:24704024.
- 47. Altuvia Y, Landgraf P, Lithwick G, Elefant N, Pfeffer S, Aravin A, et al. Clustering and conservation patterns of human microRNAs. Nucleic Acids Res. 2005;33(8):2697. pmid:15891114; 33/8/2697 [pii].
- 48. Liu X, Cheng Y, Yang J, Xu L, Zhang C. Cell-specific effects of miR-221/222 in vessels: molecular mechanism and therapeutic application. J Mol Cell Cardiol. 2012;52(1):245. pmid:22138289; S0022-2828(11)00474-3 [pii].
- 49. Ross R, Agius L. The process of atherogenesis—cellular and molecular interaction: from experimental animal models to humans. Diabetologia. 1992;35 Suppl 2:S34. pmid:1478376.
- 50. Feinberg MW, Moore KJ. MicroRNA Regulation of Atherosclerosis. Circ Res. 2016;118(4):703. pmid:26892968.
- 51. Goedeke L, Rotllan N, Canfran-Duque A, Aranda JF, Ramirez CM, Araldi E, et al. MicroRNA- 148a regulates LDL receptor and ABCA1 expression to control circulating lipoprotein levels. Nat Med. 2015;21(11):1280. pmid:26437365.
- 52. Wagschal A, Najafi-Shoushtari SH, Wang L, Goedeke L, Sinha S, deLemos AS, et al. Genome-wide identification of microRNAs regulating cholesterol and triglyceride homeostasis. Nat Med.2015;21(11):1290. pmid:26501192.
- 53. Lanford RE, Hildebrandt-Eriksen ES, Petri A, Persson R, Lindow M, Munk ME, et al. Therapeutic silencing of microRNA-122 in primates with chronic hepatitis C virus infection. Science (New York, NY). 2010;327(5962):198. pmid:19965718;science.1178178 [pii].