To determine whether therapeutic hypothermia after hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy (HIE) in neonates increases the risk of cardiac arrhythmia during intervention.
A meta-analysis was conducted using a fixed-effect model. Risk ratios, risk differences, and 95% confidence intervals, were measured.
Studies identified from the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, MEDLINE, EMBASE, Google Scholar, previous reviews, and abstracts from onset to August, 2016.
Reports that compared therapeutic hypothermia with normal care for neonates with HIE and that included data on safety or cardiac arrhythmia, which is of interest to patients and clinicians, were selected.
We found seven trials, encompassing 1322 infants that included information on safety or cardiac arrhythmia during intervention. Therapeutic hypothermia considerably increased the combined rate of cardiac arrhythmia in the seven trials (risk ratio 2.42, 95% confidence interval 1.23 to 4.76. p = 0.01; risk difference 0.02, 95% CI 0.01 to 0.04) during intervention.
Citation: Zhang W, Lu M, Zhang C, Zhang R, Ou X, Zhou J, et al. (2017) Therapeutic hypothermia increases the risk of cardiac arrhythmia for perinatal hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy: A meta-analysis. PLoS ONE 12(3): e0173006. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0173006
Editor: Chiara Lazzeri, Azienda Ospedaliero Universitaria Careggi, ITALY
Received: November 5, 2016; Accepted: February 12, 2017; Published: March 8, 2017
Copyright: © 2017 Zhang et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: We received no specific funding for this study.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Perinatal hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy is the second leading cause of neonatal death, and it also globally accounts for the third major cause of childhood death . Studies showed that neural damage after hypoxic ischaemia is delayed in response to several hours of acute hypoxic ischaemia , and therapeutic hypothermia can be used in newborn infants with HIE to reduce the risk of death and neurological impairments . Currently, therapeutic hypothermia is the standard clinical care for moderate-to-severe perinatal HIE in high-income countries . Therefore, previous studies have focused on the efficacy of therapeutic hypothermia in infants with HIE, while adverse effects or complication data might be ignored by clinicians.
Among these unfavourable effects, cardiac arrhythmia is one of the most common complications during the intervention or in the hospital. Several clinical trials [5–11] reported some or all of the adverse effects, but the results of these trials are not conclusive. An updated systematic review issued by the Cochrane Library in 2013 reported that 72 hours of moderate hypothermia started within 6 hours of birth has a negative effect on cardiac arrhythmia during intervention or in the hospital  Thus, cardiac arrhythmia adverse events remain ambiguous and controversial when hypothermia is used in a patient with HIE.
We aimed to perform a meta-analysis of relative studies and recently available data from published studies that defines how much therapeutic hypothermia might increase the risk of cardiac arrhythmia after hypoxic ischaemia. We will also determine its adverse effects during intervention in infants who survive perinatal HIE, and consider whether the therapeutic measure of hypothermia is more carefully applied to infants with moderate-to-severe encephalopathy. In the future, we will search for precautions to reduce the risk of cardiac arrhythmia according to the outcomes of our study.
Materials and methods
Relevant studies were identified from MEDLINE (using the Mesh terms (“infant, newborn” AND “asphyxia and hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy”) and “hypothermia”), EMBASE, and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, previous reviews including abstracts, cross-references, conferences, expert informants, symposia proceedings, and via searching journals by hand. We updated this search in August, 2016, and did not include the additional unpublished data and unpublished studies. Studies were identified by our group of authors, and relevant studies were selected by consensus.
We included all randomised controlled studies comparing the use of therapeutic hypothermia with standard care (normothermia) for perinatal HIE. The methodological quality of the studies was assessed, we were advised by the Cochrane Collaboration neonatal review group, which relied on the use of randomisation and blinding to the intervention, and which was also based on completeness and blinding of follow-up . The study participants met the following criteria: 1. Newborn infants, 36 weeks gestation or greater; 2. Evidence of birth asphyxia, with each enrolled infant satisfying at least one of the following criteria: (i) Apgar score of 5 or less at 10 minutes; (ii) mechanical ventilation or resuscitation at 10 minutes; (iii) cord pH less than 7.1, or an arterial pH less than 7.1, or base deficit of 12 or more within 60 minutes of birth; 3. Evidence of encephalopathy according to the Sarnat staging (Sarnat 1976; Finer 1981) as follows: Stage 1 (mild): hyper-reflexia, hyper-alertness, dilated pupils, hypotonia with weak suck, Moro and seizures; Stage 2 (moderate): hyper-reflexia, lethargy, bradycardia, miosis, hypotonia with weak suck, miosis and seizures; Stage 3 (severe): flaccidity, stupor, decreased stretch reflexes, small to mid-position pupils that react poorly to light, hypothermia and absent Moro; 4. No major congenital abnormalities recognisable at birth. The requirement for intervention is determined when the following criteria are met: 1. Therapeutic hypothermia (whole body and/or selective cooling) initiated prior to 6 hours after birth versus no cooling (normothermia); 2. Cooling duration ranges from 48 to 72 hours or greater; and 3. Cooled body temperature ranges from 33 to 35°C (rectal temperature).
Data collection and analysis
In our studies, cardiac arrhythmia was regarded as the adverse event assessment primary outcome in infants with HIE. The follow-up time window for cardiac arrhythmia adverse effects was identified as during intervention or while the patient remained in the hospital (in-hospital). We selected reports that included data to analyse the effect of hypothermia on the rate of cardiac arrhythmia during intervention or in-hospital.
Meta-analysis was performed with the Review Manager software (RevMan Version 5.3; Nordic Cochrane Centre, Copenhagen, Denmark) using the Mantel-Haenszel method and a fixed-effect model. We calculated risk ratios (RR) and risk difference (RD) for dichotomous variables, with 95% confidence intervals (CI), which is the reciprocal of the risk difference, with 95% confidence intervals. Encephalopathy grade rated by amplitude integrated electroencephalography was considered to be equivalent to that of the clinical assessment . All statistical tests were two-sided and analyses were not corrected for multiple comparisons. A P value <0.05 was considered statistically significant. We examined heterogeneity among studies using the χ2 and the I2 tests.
Our literature search identified 909 unique records (Fig 1). We compiled a dataset of 1322 infants with HIE from 7 randomised controlled trials, which at least included cardiac arrhythmia data [5–11]. A summary of the trial characteristics is shown in Tables 1 and 2. These trials had similar inclusion criteria: evidence of birth asphyxia, at least 36 weeks gestation at recruitment, random allocation was completed by 6 hours after birth, a target rectal temperature range from 33.0~35.0°C, and temperature was maintained within that range for 48~72 hours. Cooling was induced using cooling blankets placed under the infants and/or achieved by circulating cooling fluid in a cap (systematic and/or selective cooling).
Seven randomised controlled trials were excluded for insufficient cooling depth [14–16], insufficient duration time , method of incomplete randomisation , randomised time more than 6 hours (up to 10 hours) , and study included criteria that do not meet the pre-defined definition of peripartum asphyxia .
Of the seven trials that reported the rate of cardiac arrhythmia during intervention, five had caregivers who were not blinded to the treatment assignment (Fig 2) [5–9]. The publication bias funnel plot for cardiac arrhythmia during intervention or in-hospital is shown in Fig 3. The methodological quality of the trials included in the assessment of cardiac arrhythmia was reported in a 2013 update Cochrane review . The two remaining studies used an appropriate methodology.
We identified seven trials including 1322 infants with HIE, and these trials contained information about cardiac arrhythmia during intervention. Therapeutic hypothermia significantly increased the rate of cardiac arrhythmia (risk ratio 2.42, 95% confidence interval 1.23 to 4.76, p = 0.01; risk difference 0.02, 95% CI 0.01 to 0.04) during intervention (Fig 4).
Hypothermia is among the most severe complications in critically ill patients with severe shock and multiple traumas, which comprises the death triangle when combined with coagulopathy and acidosis. Hypothermia is also widely used clinically because moderate hypothermia was shown to reduce brain metabolism and alleviate brain injury, and thus, it plays a protective role in encephalopathy or brain injury. However, in clinical, cardiac arrhythmia induced by therapeutic hypothermia in infants with HIE may be underestimated because of its low morbidity. In the above-mentioned studies, the focus was mostly on mortality and neurological outcomes, while there were few reports on adverse effects of cardiac arrhythmia. In some meta-analyses, there were no reports of cardiac arrhythmia in infants with HIE . In this study, we confirmed that therapeutic hypothermia increased the risk of cardiac arrhythmia in infants with HIE during the intervention. Recently, therapeutic hypothermia was shown to be ineffective, and even harmful, in children with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest  and in adults with traumatic brain injury  and infection/inflammation . Thus, we investigated the undesirable outcomes that are involved in the adverse effects or complications of therapeutic hypothermia.
Our research has several advantages. First, we have a well-defined goal so we selected only a single variable for performing the meta-analysis, to preclude confounding factors from other variables. Second, the variable of cardiac arrhythmia is easy to measure during the intervention in infants with HIE, which reduces the risk of dropout. Third, the outcome of our research is consistent with the advances in the present studies, which show that therapeutic hypothermia in infants with HIE should be taken into consideration by clinicians.
Limitations of study
Although moderate therapeutic hypothermia was shown to increase the risk of cardiac arrhythmia in infants with moderate-to-severe HIE compared with standard care, there were still some limitations. In the included seven randomised controlled trials, the rate of cardiac arrhythmia was reported, but it was not the primary outcome. Whereas, in our study, we regarded it as the primary outcome.
The sample size might still be restricted in a poor level due to the episodes were reported in few literatures. Therefore, in order to validate our conclusions, we need to design some high-quality clinical trials with a safety assessment that includes cardiac arrhythmia in patients undergoing moderate therapeutic hypothermia. This will help to search for the relevant precautions to prevent the adverse effect of cardiac arrhythmia.
Finally, there were lack of recent studies due to the clarified efficacy of reduction mortality and improving neurological outcomes on therapeutic hypothermia in infants with HIE. Moreover, cardiac arrhythmia is usually regarded as a secondary outcome in some studies, so that there are few studies related to this topic.
Although the morbidity is low on therapeutic hypothermia induced cardiac arrhythmia in infants with HIE, actually, the problem is still deserved to be focused by clinicians. Because the conclusions may provide a direction on medical study of pathobiological mechanism of hypothermia induced cardiac arrhythmia.
In infants with HIE, therapeutic hypothermia increases the risk of cardiac arrhythmia during intervention or in-hospital.
We thank the investigators of all the trials contained in the meta-analysis for providing the data. We also thank the patients in the 7 trials contained in the meta-analysis. Finally, we thank Li Ling, assistant researcher at the Chinese Cochrane Centre, Chengdu, China, for her help with the search strategy, literature search, and methodological guidance for the data analysis.
- Conceptualization: YK ML WZ.
- Data curation: CZ XO RZ.
- Formal analysis: WZ.
- Investigation: YK ML WZ.
- Methodology: YK WZ ML.
- Project administration: YK WZ.
- Resources: WZ CZ RZ XO.
- Software: CZ XO RZ.
- Supervision: ML JZ.
- Validation: YK WZ.
- Visualization: YK WZ.
- Writing – original draft: WZ.
- Writing – review & editing: WZ YL JZ.
- 1. Liu L, Oza S, Hogan D, Perin J, Rudan I, Lawn JE, et al. Global, regional, and national causes of child mortality in 2000–13, with projections to inform post-2015 priorities: an updated systematic analysis. Lancet. 2015;385(9966):430–40. pmid:25280870
- 2. Hassell KJ, Ezzati M, Alonso-Alconada D, Hausenloy DJ, Robertson NJ. New horizons for newborn brain protection: enhancing endogenous neuroprotection. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed. 2015;100(6):F541–52. pmid:26063194
- 3. Edwards AD, Brocklehurst P, Gunn AJ, Halliday H, Juszczak E, Levene M, et al. Neurological outcomes at 18 months of age after moderate hypothermia for perinatal hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy: synthesis and meta-analysis of trial data. Bmj. 2010;340:c363. pmid:20144981
- 4. Roka A, Azzopardi D. Therapeutic hypothermia for neonatal hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy. Early human development. 2010;86(6):361–7. pmid:20570448
- 5. Gluckman PD, Wyatt JS, Azzopardi D, Ballard R, Edwards AD, Ferriero DM, et al. Selective head cooling with mild systemic hypothermia after neonatal encephalopathy: multicentre randomised trial. Lancet. 2005;365(9460):663–70. pmid:15721471
- 6. Shankaran S, Laptook AR, Ehrenkranz RA, Tyson JE, McDonald SA, Donovan EF, et al. Whole-body hypothermia for neonates with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy. The New England journal of medicine. 2005;353(15):1574–84. pmid:16221780
- 7. Azzopardi DV, Strohm B, Edwards AD, Dyet L, Halliday HL, Juszczak E, et al. Moderate hypothermia to treat perinatal asphyxial encephalopathy. The New England journal of medicine. 2009;361(14):1349–58. pmid:19797281
- 8. Simbruner G, Mittal RA, Rohlmann F, Muche R, neo.n EnTP. Systemic hypothermia after neonatal encephalopathy: outcomes of neo.nEURO.network RCT. Pediatrics. 2010;126(4):e771–8. pmid:20855387
- 9. Zhou WH, Cheng GQ, Shao XM, Liu XZ, Shan RB, Zhuang DY, et al. Selective head cooling with mild systemic hypothermia after neonatal hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy: a multicenter randomized controlled trial in China. The Journal of pediatrics. 2010;157(3):367–72, 72 e1–3. pmid:20488453
- 10. Bharadwaj SK, Bhat BV. Therapeutic hypothermia using gel packs for term neonates with hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy in resource-limited settings: a randomized controlled trial. J Trop Pediatr. 2012;58(5):382–8. pmid:22396230
- 11. Joy R, Pournami F, Bethou A, Bhat VB, Bobby Z. Effect of therapeutic hypothermia on oxidative stress and outcome in term neonates with perinatal asphyxia: a randomized controlled trial. J Trop Pediatr. 2013;59(1):17–22. pmid:22907998
- 12. Jacobs SE, Berg M, Hunt R, Tarnow-Mordi WO, Inder TE, Davis PG. Cooling for newborns with hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy. The Cochrane database of systematic reviews. 2013;1:CD003311.
- 13. Al Faleh K, Al-Omran M. Reporting and methodologic quality of Cochrane Neonatal review group systematic reviews. BMC pediatrics. 2009;9:38. pmid:19534780
- 14. Gunn AJ, Gluckman PD, Gunn TR. Selective head cooling in newborn infants after perinatal asphyxia: a safety study. Pediatrics. 1998;102(4 Pt 1):885–92. pmid:9755260
- 15. Battin MR, Dezoete JA, Gunn TR, Gluckman PD, Gunn AJ. Neurodevelopmental outcome of infants treated with head cooling and mild hypothermia after perinatal asphyxia. Pediatrics. 2001;107(3):480–4. pmid:11230586
- 16. Akisu M, Huseyinov A, Yalaz M, Cetin H, Kultursay N. Selective head cooling with hypothermia suppresses the generation of platelet-activating factor in cerebrospinal fluid of newborn infants with perinatal asphyxia. Prostaglandins, leukotrienes, and essential fatty acids. 2003;69(1):45–50. pmid:12878450
- 17. Akula V, Joe P, Thusu K, Kim S, Shimotake T, Butler S, et al. A randomized clinicaltrial of therapeutic hypothermia during transport for hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy: Device servo-regulated cooling versus standard practice. Journal of investigative medicine. 2014;62(1):210.
- 18. Lin ZL, Yu HM, Lin J, Chen SQ, Liang ZQ, Zhang ZY. Mild hypothermia via selective head cooling as neuroprotective therapy in term neonates with perinatal asphyxia: an experience from a single neonatal intensive care unit. Journal of perinatology: official journal of the California Perinatal Association. 2006;26(3):180–4.
- 19. Li T, Xu F, Cheng X, Guo X, Ji L, Zhang Z, et al. Systemic hypothermia induced within 10 hours after birth improved neurological outcome in newborns with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy. Hospital practice (1995). 2009;37(1):147–52.
- 20. Robertson NJ, Nakakeeto M, Hagmann C, Cowan FM, Acolet D, Iwata O, et al. Therapeutic hypothermia for birth asphyxia in low-resource settings: a pilot randomised controlled trial. Lancet (London, England). 2008;372(9641):801–3.
- 21. Jacobs SE, Berg M, Hunt R, Tarnow-Mordi WO, Inder TE, Davis PG. Cooling for newborns with hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy. The Cochrane database of systematic reviews. 2013(1):CD003311. pmid:23440789
- 22. Moler FW, Silverstein FS, Holubkov R, Slomine BS, Christensen JR, Nadkarni VM, et al. Therapeutic hypothermia after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in children. The New England journal of medicine. 2015;372(20):1898–908. pmid:25913022
- 23. Andrews PJ, Sinclair HL, Rodriguez A, Harris BA, Battison CG, Rhodes JK, et al. Hypothermia for Intracranial Hypertension after Traumatic Brain Injury. The New England journal of medicine. 2015;373(25):2403–12. pmid:26444221
- 24. Mourvillier B, Tubach F, van de Beek D, Garot D, Pichon N, Georges H, et al. Induced hypothermia in severe bacterial meningitis: a randomized clinical trial. Jama. 2013;310(20):2174–83. pmid:24105303