Natural populations are commonly exposed to complex stress scenarios, including anthropogenic contamination and their biological enemies (e.g., parasites). The study of the pollutant-parasite interplay is especially important, given the need for adequate regulations to promote improved ecosystem protection. In this study, a host-parasite model system (Daphnia spp. and the microparasitic yeast Metschnikowia bicuspidata) was used to explore the reciprocal effects of contamination by common agrochemical fungicides (copper sulphate and tebuconazole) and parasite challenge. We conducted 21-day life history experiments with two host clones exposed to copper (0.00, 25.0, 28.8 and 33.1 μg L-1) or tebuconazole (0.00, 154, 192 and 240 μg L-1), in the absence or presence of the parasite. For each contaminant, the experimental design consisted of 2 Daphnia clones × 4 contaminant concentrations × 2 parasite treatments × 20 replicates = 320 experimental units. Copper and tebuconazole decreased Daphnia survival or reproduction, respectively, whilst the parasite strongly reduced host survival. Most importantly, while copper and parasite effects were mostly independent, tebuconazole suppressed infection. In a follow-up experiment, we tested the effect of a lower range of tebuconazole concentrations (0.00, 6.25, 12.5, 25.0, 50.0 and 100 μg L-1) crossed with increasing parasite challenge (2 Daphnia clones × 6 contaminant concentrations × 2 parasite levels × 20 replicates = 480 experimental units). Suppression of infection was confirmed at environmentally relevant concentrations (> 6.25 μg L-1), irrespective of the numbers of parasite challenge. The ecological consequences of such a suppression of infection include interferences in host population dynamics and diversity, as well as community structure and energy flow across the food web, which could upscale to ecosystem level given the important role of parasites.
Citation: Cuco AP, Abrantes N, Gonçalves F, Wolinska J, Castro BB (2017) Interplay between fungicides and parasites: Tebuconazole, but not copper, suppresses infection in a Daphnia-Metschnikowia experimental model. PLoS ONE 12(2): e0172589. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172589
Editor: Pieter Spanoghe, Universiteit Gent, BELGIUM
Received: July 18, 2016; Accepted: February 7, 2017; Published: February 23, 2017
Copyright: © 2017 Cuco et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: Data available from the Dryad Digital Repository: http://dx.doi.org/10.5061/dryad.18gt9.
Funding: This work was supported by the strategic programs UID/AMB/50017/2013 (CESAM) and UID/BIA/04050/2013 (CBMA, POCI-01-0145-FEDER-007569), funded by national funds through the Portuguese Science Foundation (FCT I.P. - http://www.fct.pt/) and by the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF) through COMPETE2020 (http://www.poci-compete2020.pt/). APC and NA are recipients of, respectively, a PhD grant (SFRH/BD/81661/2011) and a researcher contract (IF/01198/2014) from FCT. This work is also part of the project VITAQUA (PTDC/AAC-AMB/112438/2009), which was funded by FEDER through COMPETE and by national funding from FCT. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
A multiple stressor framework is required to understand the effects of environmental change under an ecologically relevant perspective [1–3]. Given the need for adequate regulations for ecosystem protection, it is especially important to consider interaction scenarios involving anthropogenic contaminants. However, standard ecotoxicity tests determine the effects of single contaminants only, and may thus under- or overestimate hazards if interactive scenarios with other stress factors are not considered [2,4]. Contaminants that have no impact on organisms individually may be harmful when other stressors are present [4,5]. For instance, the sensitivity of organisms may be altered when they are simultaneously exposed to environmental changes , such as temperature increase [3,6,7] or reduced food availability [8,9]. Sensitivity to contaminants may also be altered by specific biotic agents, such as parasites or predators [2,10]. Within a risk assessment framework, it is therefore desirable to focus on multiple stress scenarios, because they can provide a more accurate and realistic prediction than individual stressor effects [4,9].
The impacts of agricultural activity are particularly relevant to the need for a multiple stressor framework to adequately assess the risks to non-target organisms and to protect ecosystem services. Extensive agricultural exploitation poses major environmental concerns due to the release of organic and inorganic contaminants into the environment [11,12]. Fungicides, which often account for the majority of pesticide application, are extensively used to fight fungal parasites, particularly in vineyards [12,13]. Copper-based and azole fungicides are some of the most commonly used compounds ; copper is a general biocide that can cause growth inhibition and interfere with several cellular processes , and azoles are a family of highly effective systemic fungicides that act by inhibiting ergosterol biosynthesis [14,16]. Their broad use and persistence results in their frequent detection in aquatic systems [12,14,17]. Fungicides reach superficial waters via runoff events, leaching or spray-drift, and may cause negative effects in natural populations and ecosystem processes, such as leaf litter breakdown . The ecological effects of copper and azole compounds must therefore be assessed when monitoring surface and groundwater quality of aquatic systems near agriculture activity .
Pesticides–and fungicides in particular–are designed to eliminate nuisance species (including parasites) that compromise agricultural yield. However, disease is an important natural stressor, and it is omnipresent in all types of ecosystems . Parasitism has an important role in modulating host population dynamics and community structure, via parasite-induced host mortality or reduced fecundity, as well as frequency-dependent selection . Furthermore, parasites are important drivers of genetic diversity in host populations, as demonstrated in experimental and field studies [20,21]. Host-parasite relationships are strongly dependent on environmental context , and their outcome can be altered by the presence of natural and anthropogenic stressors, including pesticides [2,23]. Interactive scenarios between parasites and pesticide exposure have been shown to be mostly synergistic, causing exacerbated impacts on the host´s sensitivity to the pollutant [5,24] or on their susceptibility to infection [25,26]. However, this may not always be the case [27,28]. Contaminants may either increase or decrease parasite fitness and transmission rates, the latter happening if parasites are more susceptible to pollutants than their hosts, or if pollutants negatively affect intermediate hosts or vectors (see rationale and examples in ).
Bearing in mind the putative reciprocal effect of disease and pollution, we investigated the interaction between parasitism and fungicides using a host (Daphnia spp.) × parasite (Metschnikowia bicuspidata) model system. Life history assays with this model system allow us to discriminate the relative contribution of contaminant exposure and parasite challenge to the outcome of the host-parasite relationship. Tebuconazole and copper sulphate were selected as contaminants due to their common use as fungicides in agriculture and frequent presence in superficial and runoff waters [12,30,31]. We performed two experiments: first, we tested the effect of each contaminant in the presence or absence of the parasite; second, we tested the effect of increasing parasite challenge (single vs. double challenge) on the response of the host-parasite system to the contaminant. Our null hypothesis (H0) assumed no contaminant × parasite interaction (i.e., independent effects). However, we predict the existence of interactive effects, via (H1) contaminant-induced reduction of host fitness or immunity, leading to increased parasite infectivity or virulence (we foresee this scenario for copper, given its generalist mode of action and high toxicity to Daphnia); or (H2) contaminant-induced reduction of parasite fitness leading to decreased parasite infectivity or virulence (we foresee this for tebuconazole, given its specific antifungal mode of action). In the presence of such interactions, we expect that an increase in the number of parasite challenges, as applied in the second (follow-up) experiment, would exacerbate the parasite effects (if H1 true) or offset the anti-parasitic effect of the contaminants (if H2 true).
Host-parasite system: Origin and maintenance
The water flea Daphnia spp. is a model organism in aquatic ecology, ecotoxicology and evolution, because of its life cycle characteristics convenient for experimental testing (short life cycle and cyclic parthenogenetic reproduction) and central position in aquatic food webs [32,33]. Two genotypes belonging to the Daphnia longispina species complex (clone AMM_12—D. galeata x longispina hybrid and clone AMM_47—D. galeata; hereafter designated as clone 12 and clone 47, respectively) were selected as model hosts, and maintained as single-cohort group cultures in the laboratory. These Daphnia genotypes were isolated from Lake Ammersee (Germany), and they are part of a collection of Daphnia clones that have been used in other studies [23,34]. The use of more than one genotype/taxon increases ecological relevance, but the use of numerous clones is often not logistically feasible. The use of two distinct taxonomical entities (clones 12 and 47) represents a compromise that allows a more robust assessment of the observed patterns. Daphnia cultures were reared in moderately hard reconstituted water (123 mg L-1 MgSO4·7H2O, 96 mg L-1 NaHCO3, 60 mg L-1 CaSO4·2H2O, 4 mg L-1 KCl) supplemented with a standard organic additive (algal extract) and vitamins (for a more detailed description, see  and ). Group cultures consisted of 30–40 individuals in 800 ml of culture medium, which were kept in a controlled temperature room (at 20 ± 1°C) with a 16hL:8hD photoperiod. Medium was renewed three times per week and, at each medium renewal, daphniids were fed with Raphidocelis subcapitata at a ration of 1.5 x 105 cells mL-1. Several synchronized group cultures per clone were used to warrant a sufficient number of juveniles for the experiments. To assure homogeneous quality and standardization, neonates (less than 24 h old) born between the 3rd and 5th broods were used to renew the cultures or to carry out the experiments.
The microparasite M. bicuspidata is a yeast that grows inside Daphnia´s body cavity and produces needle-like ascospores (S1 Fig) that are released from dead infected hosts, and then grazed upon by healthy Daphnia (horizontal transmission); in this process, the parasite reduces the host’s fecundity and lifespan . A logistical advantage of this model is that M. bicuspidata can be cultured inside its host, and spore suspensions can be obtained from infected Daphnia, allowing control of parasite transmission and spore load in infection experiments [34–36]. The endoparasitic yeast M. bicuspidata was also isolated from Lake Ammersee and was maintained in an infected Daphnia magna culture. Uninfected D. magna were added to infected cultures every other week to guarantee a continuous supply of hosts and to ensure parasite transmission.
Tebuconazole (Tebuconazol PESTANAL®, CAS nr. 107534-96-3) [(RS)-1-p-chlorophenyl)-4,4-dimethyl-3-(1H-1,2,4-triazol-1-ylmethyl)pentan-3-ol] and copper sulphate pentahydrate (CuSO4·5H2O, CAS nr. 7758-99-8) were obtained from Sigma Aldrich (Munich, Germany) and Merck (Darmstadt, Germany), respectively. Concentrated stock solutions were prepared in distilled water (for copper sulphate) or ethanol (for dissolving tebuconazole) and then diluted in reconstituted water to obtain final test solutions: 0.00, 154, 192 and 240 μg L-1 for tebuconazole and 0.00, 25.0, 28.8 and 33.1 μg L-1 for copper sulphate (expressed as μg of free Cu2+ ion per litre). Aqueous solutions of tebuconazole and copper are not easily degraded; tebuconazole has a half-life of 28–43 days whilst copper is considered a stable aqueous solution [37,38]. Our goal was to set a geometric series of non-lethal concentrations causing reproductive impairment in Daphnia spp., based on a previous study . For tebuconazole exposure, ethanol was also added in control replicates (0.00 μg L-1) at an equal volume to the one used in the tebuconazole concentrations (0.1 ml L-1).
In order to check the validity of the nominal concentrations tested, aliquots of the lowest and the highest tested concentrations of all experiments were collected at two random timings and sent to an independent analytical laboratory (certified according to ISO/IEC 17025:2005). Quantification of tebuconazole was performed by liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS), according to an internal method adapted from ISO 11369:1997. Copper (Cu) was analysed by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) after digestion with HNO3, according to ISO 17294–2:2003. Analytical data confirmed the validity of nominal concentrations in all experiments (see Experimental design and Follow-up experiment). Measured concentrations slightly overestimated nominal concentrations: 10–16% for copper and 1–18% for tebuconazole (S1 Table). Given this data, we assumed a good correspondence between nominal and measured concentrations.
Life history assays were conducted for 21 d with both Daphnia clones exposed to a range of tebuconazole or copper sulphate concentrations (see above) and the presence (“parasite”) or absence (“no-parasite”) of the parasite M. bicuspidata, in a fully crossed design. For logistical reasons, experiments were carried out separately for each contaminant. Thus, experimental design for each contaminant consisted of 2 Daphnia clones x 4 contaminant concentrations x 2 parasite treatments x 20 replicates = 320 experimental units. Each experiment was initiated by individually placing neonates in glass vessels with 50 mL of corresponding test solution. Assays were carried out under the same light and temperature conditions as the cultures. The medium was renewed every three days and daphniids were fed daily (with a R. subcapitata ration of 1.5 x 105 cells mL-1). With the necessary adaptations, test procedures followed OECD  recommendations. Individual Daphnia were infected on day 5 with an M. bicuspidata spore suspension (parasite treatment) or a placebo (no-parasite treatment), following the methodology described below.
Survival and reproductive parameters were recorded daily for each individual. Reproductive parameters included age at first reproduction (AFR), fecundity at day 14 (cumulative number of living offspring released per surviving female at day 14) and reproductive output at day 21 (cumulative number of living offspring released per female). Fecundity was estimated at day 14, because its calculation at day 21 was impacted by parasite-mediated mortality, which was not yet the case on day 14. Reproductive output (measured at day 21) considers the combined effects of stressors on both survivorship and fecundity [3,39]. For the calculation of reproductive output, we excluded replicates in which test organisms died before day 4, as this could be the result of accidental or natural early-age mortality. Individuals were visually inspected, under an Olympus CKX41 inverted microscope, for confirmation of infection (presence of spores inside body cavity–S1 Fig) at time of death or at the end of the assay (day 21). Infection percentages were calculated in each treatment. Survival and reproduction data at the end of the experiment (day 21) were used to determine the per capita intrinsic rate of population increase (r) from the Euler-Lotka equation: where r is the rate of population increase (day-1), x is the age class in days, lx is the probability of surviving to age x, and mx is the fecundity at age x. Replicate pseudo values for r were generated using the jack-knifing technique described by Meyer et al. .
Infected D. magna were crushed in distilled water to obtain a homogenized M. bicuspidata spore suspension, and spore concentration was determined using a Neubauer improved counting chamber. A placebo was obtained by crushing the same number of uninfected D. magna in distilled water; this allows the possible effects of bacteria or alarm cues from the crushed conspecifics to be controlled .
Parasite challenge was carried out between the 5th and 7th day of the experiments. On the first day of infection (day 5), test solution volume from all experimental units was reduced from 50 mL to 15 mL and organisms were not fed to ensure higher filtration rates and, thus, a higher spore encounter rate . Experimental units from parasite treatment were inoculated with a spore suspension aliquot (to obtain a final spore density of 700 spores mL-1 ) while experimental units from no-parasite treatment were given an equivalent placebo aliquot. On the following days, test solution volume was progressively increased to 30 mL (day 6) and 45 mL (day 7), by adding fresh medium. On day 6, daily feeding was resumed (1.5 x 105 algal cells mL-1) and, from day 8 onwards, the initial conditions were restored (50 mL of test solution, daily feeding, and medium renewal every three days).
An additional life history assay was carried out in order to further explore the effects of tebuconazole on the Daphnia-M. bicuspidata model system. This experiment was not carried out for copper, because no toxicant × parasite interaction was observed (see Results). Here, we tested the effect of lower tebuconazole concentrations (0.00, 6.25, 12.5, 25.0, 50.0 and 100.0 μg L-1) and two levels of parasite challenge (“single challenge” versus “double challenge”). In the single challenge treatment, experimental units were inoculated as previously; in the double challenge treatment, inoculation was performed twice–at day 3 and 5 –thus simulating a higher spore load in total . The experiment was conducted in a fully crossed design consisting of 2 Daphnia clones x 6 tebuconazole concentrations x 2 parasite levels x 20 replicates = 480 experimental units. All experimental procedures were similar to the previous assay, except for the parasite infection procedure. Also, we reduced the volume of test solutions, relative to the previous experiments, as a refinement step to minimize the amount of tebuconazole and spores required, as well as producing less toxicant waste. Test vessels were filled with 10 mL of corresponding test solution on day 0, and test solution volumes were progressively increased to 15 mL (day 6) and 25 mL (day 7). The experiment was terminated on day 21.
Two-way analyses of variance (ANOVA) were performed separately for each contaminant to assess the effects of parasite presence or number of parasite challenges (first and second experiment, respectively) and contaminant concentration (fixed factors) on life history parameters of Daphnia. Because we were expecting differences in the sensitivity of the tested clones to parasite and contaminant (see ), tests were conducted separately per clone. Hence, a necessary adjustment in the significance level was performed (α = 0.025) using the Dunn-Sidak procedure. Prior to analyses, plots of residuals were analysed to assess deviations from normality and homogeneity of variances; although minor deviations were sometimes found, we assumed ANOVA to be sufficiently robust to deal with them. However, AFR was ln-transformed to comply with more pronounced heterogeneous variances. All statistical analyses were conducted using R software, version 3.1.2 .
Infection rates in the controls (i.e. no contaminant) were 85–100% for both clones, demonstrating a successful infection procedure; no individuals became infected in the no-parasite treatment. High mortality levels were observed in parasite treatment, from day 14 onwards, concordant with high levels of infection (Figs 1 and 2). Infection with M. bicuspidata was mostly independent of copper exposure and infection rates were consistently high in all concentrations (> 89.5%), for both clones (Fig 1). Conversely, infection was suppressed by tebuconazole exposure from 153.6 μg L-1 upwards (Fig 2).
Two Daphnia clones (Clone 12 and Clone 47) were exposed to increasing copper concentrations in the absence (”no-parasite”) and presence (”parasite”) of spores of the microparasitic yeast M. bicuspidata. Host mortality and parasite infectivity are shown as the proportion of dead or infected hosts, respectively, at the end of the experiment (day 21). Fecundity (at day 14), reproductive output (at day 21), age at first reproduction and intrinsic rate of increase are shown as mean (circle) and respective 95% confidence intervals (error bars), based on 20 experimental units per treatment. Dotted lines between data points are used to facilitate visualization of the concentration-dependent response across parasite treatments.
Two Daphnia clones (Clone 12 and Clone 47) were exposed to increasing tebuconazole concentrations in the absence (”no-parasite”) and presence (”parasite”) of spores of the microparasitic yeast M. bicuspidata. Host mortality and parasite infectivity are shown as the proportion of dead or infected hosts, respectively, at the end of the experiment (day 21). Fecundity (at day 14), reproductive output (at day 21), age at first reproduction and intrinsic rate of increase are shown as mean (circle) and respective 95% confidence intervals (error bars), based on 20 experimental units per treatment. Dotted lines between data points are used to facilitate visualization of the concentration-dependent response across parasite treatments.
Copper x parasite
Parasite presence caused ca. 100% host mortality irrespective of copper concentration. In the absence of the parasite, copper caused slight mortality in the highest concentration (Fig 1). The effects of copper and parasite presence were mostly independent (see non-significant interaction terms in Table 1).
Neither copper nor parasite treatment had an influence on age of first reproduction (AFR), although the highest tested concentration of copper resulted in a slight delay, but only in clone 47 (Fig 1 and Table 1). Overall, copper exposure caused a slight stimulation in host reproduction (see increased fecundity and reproductive output at intermediate concentrations–Fig 1). However, the most substantial effect on Daphnia reproduction was caused by the parasite, which strongly reduced the host’s reproductive output in both tested clones (Fig 1 and Table 1). This effect was mainly due to parasite-induced mortality of hosts from day 14 onwards, because Daphnia fecundity was much less affected (compare the gap between parasite and no-parasite treatments in terms of fecundity and reproductive output–Fig 1). The per capita rate of increase confirmed the higher fitness of Daphnia in the no-parasite treatment. Although the effects of copper and parasite were mostly independent, a significant interaction between copper and parasite presence was found in clone 47, in terms of its reproductive output and rate of increase (Table 1). This was mostly due to a stronger decrease of these parameters in the no-parasite treatment in the highest copper concentration (see Fig 1).
Tebuconazole x parasite
Parasite presence caused ca. 80% host mortality in the negative control (0 μg L-1 tebuconazole) but tebuconazole completely suppressed infection, irrespective of the nominal concentration (Fig 2). As a consequence, the main effect observed in the life history parameters was caused by contaminant concentration alone.
Tebuconazole significantly delayed AFR and decreased fecundity, reproductive output, and rate of increase, demonstrating a clear dose-response relationship independent of parasite absence/presence (Fig 2 and Table 1). The differential infection success between negative control and tebuconazole concentrations in the parasite treatment lead to a significant concentration x parasite presence interaction in Daphnia reproductive output (Fig 2 and Table 1). This difference was not observed for fecundity, confirming that the main effect of the parasite is on host mortality. Per capita rate of increase and reproductive output were slightly lower in the parasite treatment, compared to no-parasite treatment (Fig 2 and Table 1).
In the follow-up experiment, the infection procedure was also successful, although infection rates in controls (i.e. no tebuconazole) varied according to clones and levels of parasite challenge: 85–95% for clone 12 and 55–60% for clone 47 (Fig 3). This experiment demonstrated an antiparasitic effect of tebuconazole at lower concentrations than the previous ones. At 6.25 μg L-1 (the lowest tested concentration), tebuconazole reduced infection rates in clone 12 to 20% and 30%, and in clone 47 to 0% and 20%, for single challenge and double challenge treatments, respectively. From 12.5 μg L-1 onwards, tebuconazole completely suppressed infection. Overall, while the increase in the number of parasite challenges caused a slightly higher parasite success (at 0 μg L-1 and 6.25 μg L-1), this higher spore load was unable to compensate the anti-M. bicuspidata effect of tebuconazole above 12.5 μg L-1.
Two Daphnia clones (Clone 12 and Clone 47) were exposed to increasing tebuconazole concentrations and two levels of parasite challenge (“single challenge” vs. “double challenge”) with spores of the microparasitic yeast M. bicuspidata. Host mortality and parasite infectivity are shown as the proportion of dead or infected hosts, respectively, at the end of the experiment (day 21). Fecundity (at day 14), reproductive output (at day 21), age at first reproduction and intrinsic rate of increase are shown as mean (circle) and respective 95% confidence intervals (error bars), based on 20 experimental units per treatment. Dotted lines between data points are used to facilitate visualization of the concentration-dependent response across parasite treatments.
Fecundity and reproductive output were significantly affected by tebuconazole exposure but also by the level of parasite challenge (Fig 3 and Table 2). Increasing concentrations of tebuconazole significantly reduced host fecundity. However, hosts from control treatments showed reduced reproductive output and per capita rate of increase, when compared to hosts from tebuconazole treatments, due to parasite-induced mortality. This was also the pattern for per capita rate of increase (Fig 3 and Table 2). Survival, fecundity and reproductive output were consistently lower in the double challenge treatment, which was more pronounced in Clone 12. This latter finding is paradoxical, given that there is no difference in the infection success between single challenge and double challenge treatments from 12.5 μg L-1 onwards.
Disease and pollution are two important stressors affecting natural populations. Interaction between these stressors can exacerbate or mitigate their otherwise independent effects . This study was motivated by the need for a clarification on how pesticide pollution affects the eventual spread of diseases [23,42]. Our major finding was that two common agrochemicals (fungicides) cause different outcomes in a host-parasite (Daphnia-M. bicuspidata) relationship, confirming that effects of pollution on host-parasite relationships depend on the particular stressor [22,29]. Particularly, infection by M. bicuspidata was independent of copper exposure, but was suppressed in the presence of the fungicide tebuconazole.
Tebuconazole and copper are commonly used in agriculture to fight fungal pests, particularly in vineyards, and are frequently detected in superficial and runoff waters [12,31]. Despite the fact that detected concentrations for both agricultural fungicides are usually low (below 10 μg L-1), higher levels have been recorded in extreme runoff events (up to 263 μg L-1 for copper and up to 200 μg L-1 for tebuconazole) [13,16]. At these concentrations, tebuconazole and copper were overall noxious to Daphnia, decreasing survival (especially copper), reproductive output and per capita rate of increase ( and this study). Regarding copper, Daphnia reproduction was only affected at the highest tested concentration (33.06 μg L-1) where organisms also started to show increasing mortality. This may be due to the fact that copper, unlike tebuconazole, is an essential element for physiological processes in low doses, above which it becomes toxic .
Successful infection by M. bicuspidata depends on needle-like ascospores entering the host (via filtration) and piercing the gut wall ; thus, the more spores enter the host, the more likely they will germinate in the host´s haemolymph and develop infection. In our study, the infection procedure was successful, given that infection was always high in the negative controls (i.e. without fungicide). Infected Daphnia were killed within 14 to 17 days, which agrees with the described timing for development of M. bicuspidata infection . Before being killed by the parasite, the fecundity of infected Daphnia was only slightly reduced, also in agreement with previous studies . For this reason, reproductive output was more informative than fecundity, reflecting the integration of reproduction and parasite-induced mortality.
Levels of parasite challenge were determinants of host fitness: the more severe exposure (double challenge) generally led to higher infection rates than single challenge exposure, confirming the findings of Ebert et al. . Also, Daphnia from the double challenge treatment suffered an overall stronger reduction in reproductive parameters and higher levels of mortality (Fig 3). This cannot simply be explained by a direct relationship between spore load and the strength of infection [44,45], because no visible symptoms of infection were observed under tebuconazole exposure. Possibly, mechanical damage caused by M. bicuspidata ascospores piercing the host´s gut wall  could explain the difference between the two levels of parasite challenge , even if infection was not successful.
When Daphnia were simultaneously exposed to copper and M. bicuspidata spores, infection was the major cause of negative effects on host reproduction due to early host death; this pattern was visible at all copper concentrations and in the negative control, confirming the independent action of both stressors. This means that copper is not toxic to the yeast; however, higher copper concentrations kill the host . Unlike tebuconazole (see below), copper does not have a specific cellular target in fungal cells, which may explain its higher toxicity to the host, since Daphnia are particularly sensitive to metals . Our results seem to contradict those of Civitello et al. , who demonstrated that sublethal levels of copper increased filtration rates in Daphnia dentifera, hence boosting M. bicuspidata spore consumption and, thus, parasite transmission. However, increased filtration rates may be less important for parasite transmission under high parasite load, such as in our case– 700 spores mL-1 in our study vs. 25–75 spores mL-1 in Civitello et al. . Also, in this previous study higher copper concentrations were tested (i.e. 50–200 μg L-1 in contrast to 25–33 μg L-1 in the present experiment), which could be partially explained by their choice of a synthetic medium with chelating properties (see ). This stimulatory effect of copper that indirectly benefited the parasite  was not observed in our study.
Under tebuconazole exposure, M. bicuspidata infection was completely suppressed above 12.5 μg L-1. Unlike copper, the parasite was more sensitive to tebuconazole than the host. Tebuconazole, along with other azoles, is considered a fungistatic agent capable of impairing growth and preventing sporulation, particularly in yeast ; including species from the genus Metschnikowia . Agricultural azole fungicides (e.g., propiconazole and tebuconazole), along with common pharmaceuticals to treat yeast infections (e.g., clotrimazole and fluconazole), have been detected in the environment, raising concerns about putative negative effects on non-target organisms [17,48] and in important microbe-mediated ecological processes [13,47]. In our case, increasing concentrations of tebuconazole significantly affected reproductive and demographic parameters in Daphnia, but the most striking result was that infection signs were suppressed at environmentally relevant concentrations (i.e. from 6.25 μg L-1 up). In fact, although tebuconazole concentrations up to 200 μg L-1 have been detected in the field (reviewed by Zubrod et al. [13,16]), typical concentrations in the aquatic environment are below 10 μg L-1 [12,31,49]. Thus, even low, environmentally-relevant concentrations of tebuconazole can cause the termination of parasite epidemics, with unknown ecological consequences.
Although there were no signs of infection in organisms exposed to tebuconazole, daphniids displayed slightly lower fitness under parasite challenge (see reproductive output data–Fig 2). It might be that M. bicuspidata growing inside the host’s body cavity could be causing injury or using Daphnia’s vital resources. Further research is needed to clarify whether this reduction in host fitness results from mechanical injury by spores piercing the gut wall (discussed above) or from the yeast’s parasitic action. Azole fungicides lead to a depletion in ergosterol necessary to membrane functioning, thus inhibiting fungal growth and eventually causing their death [50,51]. Possible fungicidal or fungistatic effects of tebuconazole could occur at multiple stages: a) suppression of initial spore germination (after being filtered by Daphnia); b) growth inhibition due to depletion of ergosterol; c) death of yeast cells that were able to germinate from initial spores; d) reproduction (i.e., sporulation) impairment. It is not clear whether these effects are reversible or not, as M. bicuspidata may have remained latent in the Daphnia body cavity during tebuconazole exposure, thus delaying the infection instead of suppressing it. This delay scenario could not be confirmed in our study due to the short duration of the assay, and further experiments need to be conducted to address that issue.
Antagonistic effects between fungicides and parasitism have been reported previously. Blanar et al.  showed that exposure to zinc and copper reduced survival and fecundity of a juvenile Atlantic salmon ectoparasite without affecting the host; Hanlon et al.  demonstrated that exposure of frog tadpoles to the fungicide thiophanate-methyl and a chytrid fungus resulted in a clear suppression of the infection. Such phenomena may be widespread, and should not be underestimated. Many antifungal formulations present in agrochemicals, pharmaceuticals and personal care products may affect non-target fungal parasites, which otherwise control natural populations of a variety of hosts, including cyanobacteria [53,54], protists [54,55], plants , invertebrates , fishes  and amphibians [52,59]. Also, parasites in general interfere with energy flow and are important drivers of genetic diversity . Thus, changes in the outcome of host-parasite relationships may upscale to population, community and ecosystem level [23,45,60]. While the suppression of infection (as detected in the tebuconazole treatment) may seem positive from the host´s point of view, the exact consequences of an antagonism between pollution and disease, as shown here, are still poorly understood. The growing needs of the human population and the challenges of climate change will increase the use of pesticides (including fungicides), which will likely cause deleterious effects in non-target fungi and bacteria, such as microparasites and decomposers. It is of primordial importance that such phenomena are not overlooked, and that protective measures are implemented to preserve important and diverse ecological processes that are mediated by these microbial communities.
S1 Table. Nominal and analytical concentrations (mean ± SD, n = 2) for copper (free ion, Cu2+) and tebuconazole.
S1 Fig. Stages of Metschnikowia bicuspidata infection in Daphnia galeata × longispina.
(A) healthy, uninfected female; (B) early development of infection signs–body becomes more opaque with the presence of ascospores (not all of them mature yet); (C) late development of infection signs–body cavity is filled with needle-like ascospores; (D) detail of ascospores released by dead hosts.
Authors thank Mark Phillipo for linguistic help and three anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments.
- Conceptualization: APC NA FG JW BBC.
- Formal analysis: APC BBC.
- Funding acquisition: NA FG BBC.
- Investigation: APC.
- Methodology: APC NA FG JW BBC.
- Project administration: BBC FG NA.
- Resources: NA FG JW BBC.
- Supervision: BBC.
- Visualization: APC BBC.
- Writing – original draft: APC BBC.
- Writing – review & editing: NA JW FG BBC.
- 1. Coors A, De Meester L. Synergistic, antagonistic and additive effects of multiple stressors: predation threat, parasitism and pesticide exposure in Daphnia magna. J Appl Ecol. 2008;45: 1820–1828.
- 2. Holmstrup M, Bindesbøl A-M, Oostingh GJ, Duschl A, Scheil V, Köhler H-R, et al. Interactions between effects of environmental chemicals and natural stressors: A review. Sci Total Environ. 2010;408: 3746–3762. pmid:19922980
- 3. Cuco AP, Abrantes N, Gonçalves F, Wolinska J, Castro BB. Toxicity of two fungicides in Daphnia: is it always temperature-dependent? Ecotoxicology. 2016;25: 1376–1389. pmid:27381036
- 4. Heugens EHW, Hendriks AJ, Dekker T, van Straalen NM, Admiraal W. A review of the effects of multiple stressors on aquatic organisms and analysis of uncertainty factors for use in risk assessment. Crit Rev Toxicol. 2001;31: 247–284. pmid:11405441
- 5. Buser CC, Jansen M, Pauwels K, De Meester L, Spaak P. Combined exposure to parasite and pesticide causes increased mortality in the water flea Daphnia. Aquat Ecol. 2012;46: 261–268.
- 6. Loureiro C, Cuco AP, Claro MT, Santos JI, Pedrosa MAA, Gonçalves F, et al. Progressive acclimation alters interaction between salinity and temperature in experimental Daphnia populations. Chemosphere. 2015;139: 126–132. pmid:26079923
- 7. Heugens EHW, Jager T, Creyghton R, Kraak MHS, Hendriks AJ, Van Straalen NM, et al. Temperature-dependent effects of cadmium on Daphnia magna: accumulation versus sensitivity. Environ Sci Technol. 2003;37: 2145–2151. pmid:12785520
- 8. Pereira JL, Gonçalves F. Effects of food availability on the acute and chronic toxicity of the insecticide methomyl to Daphnia spp. Sci Total Environ. 2007;386: 9–20. pmid:17727918
- 9. Stampfli NC, Knillmann S, Liess M, Beketov MA. Environmental context determines community sensitivity of freshwater zooplankton to a pesticide. Aquat Toxicol. 2011;104: 116–24. pmid:21561593
- 10. Hanazato T. Pesticide effects on freshwater zooplankton: an ecological perspective. Environ Pollut. 2001;112: 1–10. pmid:11202648
- 11. Hildebrandt A, Guillamón M, Lacorte S, Tauler R, Barceló D. Impact of pesticides used in agriculture and vineyards to surface and groundwater quality (North Spain). Water Res. 2008;42: 3315–26. pmid:18502469
- 12. Bereswill R, Golla B, Streloke M, Schulz R. Entry and toxicity of organic pesticides and copper in vineyard streams: Erosion rills jeopardise the efficiency of riparian buffer strips. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2012;146: 81–92.
- 13. Zubrod JP, Baudy P, Schulz R, Bundschuh M. Effects of current-use fungicides and their mixtures on the feeding and survival of the key shredder Gammarus fossarum. Aquat Toxicol. 2014;150: 133–143. pmid:24674876
- 14. Komárek M, Cadková E, Chrastný V, Bordas F, Bollinger J-C. Contamination of vineyard soils with fungicides: a review of environmental and toxicological aspects. Environ Int. 2010;36: 138–51. pmid:19913914
- 15. Devez A, Gomez E, Gilbin R, Elbaz-Poulichet F, Persin F, Andrieux P, et al. Assessment of copper bioavailability and toxicity in vineyard runoff waters by DPASV and algal bioassay. Sci Total Environ. 2005;348: 82–92. pmid:16162315
- 16. Zubrod JP, Bundschuh M, Schulz R. Effects of subchronic fungicide exposure on the energy processing of Gammarus fossarum (Crustacea; Amphipoda). Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. 2010;73: 1674–1680. pmid:20709394
- 17. Kahle M, Buerge IJ, Hauser A, Muüller MD, Poiger T. Azole Fungicides: Occurrence and Fate in Wastewater and Surface Waters. Environ Sci Technol. 2008;42: 7193–7200. pmid:18939546
- 18. Lafferty KD, Allesina S, Arim M, Briggs CJ, De Leo G, Dobson AP, et al. Parasites in food webs: the ultimate missing links. Ecol Lett. 2008;11: 533–546. pmid:18462196
- 19. Wolinska J, Lively CM, Spaak P. Parasites in hybridizing communities: the Red Queen again? Trends Parasitol. 2008;24: 121–126. pmid:18295542
- 20. Jokela J, Dybdahl MF, Lively CM. The maintenance of sex, clonal dynamics, and host-parasite coevolution in a mixed population of sexual and asexual Snails. Am Nat. 2009;174: S43–S53. pmid:19441961
- 21. Wolinska J, Spaak P. The cost of being common: evidence from natural Daphnia populations. Evolution (N Y). 2009;63: 1893–1901.
- 22. Wolinska J, King KC. Environment can alter selection in host-parasite interactions. Trends Parasitol. 2009;25: 236–244. pmid:19356982
- 23. Buser CC, Spaak P, Wolinska J. Disease and pollution alter Daphnia taxonomic and clonal structure in experimental assemblages. Freshw Biol. 2012;57: 1865–1874.
- 24. Kelly DW, Poulin R, Tompkins DM, Townsend CR. Synergistic effects of glyphosate formulation and parasite infection on fish malformations and survival. J Appl Ecol. 2010;47: 498–504.
- 25. Jansen M, Stoks R, Coors A, van Doorslaer W, de Meester L. Collateral damage: rapid exposure-induced evolution of pesticide resistance leads to increased susceptibility to parasites. Evolution (N Y). 2011;65: 2681–2691.
- 26. Coors A, Decaestecker E, Jansen M, De Meester L. Pesticide exposure strongly enhances parasite virulence in an invertebrate host model. Oikos. 2008;117: 1840–1846.
- 27. Civitello DJ, Forys P, Johnson AP, Hall SR. Chronic contamination decreases disease spread: a Daphnia-fungus-copper case study. Proc R Soc B Biol Sci. 2012;279: 3146–3153.
- 28. Blanar C a., MacLatchy DL, Kieffer JD, Munkittrick KR. Exposure to a mixture of zinc and copper decreases survival and fecundity of Discocotyle sagittata (Leuckart) parasitizing juvenile atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L. Bull Environ Contam Toxicol. 2010;84: 692–697. pmid:20473654
- 29. Lafferty KD, Kuris AM. How environmental stress affects the impacts of parasites. Limnol Oceanogr. 1999;44: 925–931.
- 30. Cerejeira M., Viana P, Batista S, Pereira T, Silva E, Valério M., et al. Pesticides in Portuguese surface and ground waters. Water Res. 2003;37: 1055–1063. pmid:12553980
- 31. Berenzen N, Lentzen-Godding A, Probst M, Schulz H, Schulz R, Liess M. A comparison of predicted and measured levels of runoff-related pesticide concentrations in small lowland streams on a landscape level. Chemosphere. 2005;58: 683–91. pmid:15620762
- 32. Loureiro C, Castro BB, Pereira JL, Gonçalves F. Performance of standard media in toxicological assessments with Daphnia magna: chelators and ionic composition versus metal toxicity. Ecotoxicology. 2011;20: 139–48. pmid:21080223
- 33. Ebert D. Ecology, epidemiology, and evolution of parasitism in Daphnia [Internet]. Bethesda (MD): National Library of Medicine (US), National Center for Biotechnology Information; 2005. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?db=Books
- 34. Yin M, Laforsch C, Lohr JN, Wolinska J. Predator-induced defense makes Daphnia more vulnerable to parasites. Evolution. 2011;65: 1482–8. pmid:21521197
- 35. Lohr JN, Yin M, Wolinska J. Prior residency does not always pay off—co-infections in Daphnia. Parasitology. 2010;137: 1493–1500. pmid:20444300
- 36. Hall SR, Sivars-Becker L, Becker C, Duffy MA, Tessier AJ, Cáceres CE. Eating yourself sick: Transmission of disease as a function of foraging ecology. Ecol Lett. 2007;10: 207–218. pmid:17305804
- 37. Kegley SE, Hill BR, Orme S, Choi AH. PAN Pesticide Database. In: Pesticide Action Network [Internet]. North America (Oakland, CA, 2014); 2014. http://www.pesticideinfo.org.
- 38. Lewis KA, Tzilivakis J, Warner DJ, Green A. An international database for pesticide risk assessments and management. Hum Ecol Risk Assess An Int J. 2016;7039.
- 39. OECD. Test No. 211: Daphnia magna Reproduction Test, OECD guidelines for the testing of chemicals, section 2. OECD.
- 40. Meyer JS, Ingersoll CG, McDonald LL, Boyce MS. Estimating uncertainty in population growth rates: Jacknife vs. Bootstrap techniques. Ecology. 1986;67: 1156.
- 41. R Core Team. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria [Internet]. 2014. http://www.r-project.org/.
- 42. Marcogliese DJ, Pietrock M. Combined effects of parasites and contaminants on animal health: parasites do matter. Trends Parasitol. 2011;27: 123–130. pmid:21144800
- 43. Auld SKJR, Hall SR, Duffy MA. Epidemiology of a Daphnia-multiparasite system and its implications for the Red Queen. PLoS One. 2012;7.
- 44. Ebert D, Zschokke-Rohringer CD, Carius HJ. Dose effects and density-dependent regulation of two microparasites of Daphnia magna. Oecologia. 2000;122: 200–209.
- 45. Dallas T, Drake JM. Nitrate enrichment alters a Daphnia-microparasite interaction through multiple pathways. Ecol Evol. 2014;4: 243–50. pmid:24558580
- 46. Manavathu EK, Cutright JL, Chandrasekar PH. Organism-dependent fungicidal activities of azoles. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 1998;42: 3018–21. Available: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9797246 pmid:9797246
- 47. Álvarez-Pérez S, de Vega C, Pozo MI, Lenaerts M, Van Assche A, Herrera CM, et al. Nectar yeasts of the Metschnikowia clade are highly susceptible to azole antifungals widely used in medicine and agriculture. FEMS Yeast Res. 2015;16: 1–15.
- 48. Fick J, Lindberg RH, Tysklind M, Larsson DGJ. Predicted critical environmental concentrations for 500 pharmaceuticals. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol. 2010;58: 516–523. pmid:20816909
- 49. Herrero-Hernández E, Andrades MS, Álvarez-Martín A, Pose-Juan E, Rodríguez-Cruz MS, Sánchez-Martín MJ. Occurrence of pesticides and some of their degradation products in waters in a Spanish wine region. J Hydrol. 2013;486: 234–245.
- 50. Ochoa-Acuña HG, Bialkowski W, Yale G, Hahn L. Toxicity of soybean rust fungicides to freshwater algae and Daphnia magna. Ecotoxicology. 2009;18: 440–6. pmid:19184419
- 51. Dijksterhuis J, van Doorn T, Samson R, Postma J. Effects of seven fungicides on non-target aquatic fungi. Water, Air, Soil Pollut. 2011;222: 421–425.
- 52. Hanlon SM, Kerby JL, Parris MJ. Unlikely remedy: Fungicide clears infection from pathogenic fungus in larval southern leopard frogs (Lithobates sphenocephalus). PLoS One. 2012;7: 1–8.
- 53. Agha R, Saebelfeld M, Manthey C, Rohrlack T, Wolinska J. Chytrid parasitism facilitates trophic transfer between bloom-forming cyanobacteria and zooplankton (Daphnia). Sci Rep. Nature Publishing Group; 2016;6: 35039.
- 54. Gleason FH, Jephcott TG, Küpper FC, Gerphagnon M, Sime-Ngando T, Karpov SA, et al. Potential roles for recently discovered chytrid parasites in the dynamics of harmful algal blooms. Fungal Biol Rev. 2015;29: 20–33.
- 55. Jephcott TG, Alves-de-Souza C, Gleason FH, van Ogtrop FF, Sime-Ngando T, Karpov SA, et al. Ecological impacts of parasitic chytrids, syndiniales and perkinsids on populations of marine photosynthetic dinoflagellates. Fungal Ecol. 2016;19: 47–58.
- 56. Dean R, Van Kan JAL, Pretorius ZA, Hammond-Kosack KE, Di Pietro A, Spanu PD, et al. The Top 10 fungal pathogens in molecular plant pathology. Mol Plant Pathol. 2012;13: 414–430. pmid:22471698
- 57. Hall SR, Becker CR, Duffy MA, Caceres CE. Epidemic size determines population-level effects of fungal parasites on Daphnia hosts. Oecologia. 2011;166: 833–842. pmid:21305322
- 58. Gozlan RE, Marshall WL, Lilje O, Jessop CN, Gleason FH, Andreou D. Current ecological understanding of fungal-like pathogens of fish: What lies beneath? Front Microbiol. 2014;5: 1–16.
- 59. Hanlon SM, Lynch KJ, Kerby JL, Parris MJ. The effects of a fungicide and chytrid fungus on anuran larvae in aquatic mesocosms. Environ Sci Pollut Res. 2015;22: 12929–12940.
- 60. Johnson PTJ, Chase JM, Dosch KL, Hartson RB, Gross J a, Larson DJ, et al. Aquatic eutrophication promotes pathogenic infection in amphibians. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2007;104: 15781–15786. pmid:17893332