The rock partridge, Alectoris graeca, is a polytypic species declining in Italy mostly due to anthropogenic causes, including the massive releases of the closely related allochthonous chukar partridge Alectoris chukar which produced the formation of hybrids. Molecular approaches are fundamental for the identification of evolutionary units in the perspective of conservation and management, and to correctly select individuals to be used in restocking campaigns. We analyzed a Cytochrome oxidase I (COI) fragment of contemporary and historical A. graeca and A. chukar samples, using duplicated analyses to confirm results and nuclear DNA microsatellites to exclude possible sample cross-contamination. In two contemporary specimens of A. graeca, collected from an anthropogenic hybrid zone, we found evidence of the presence of mtDNA heteroplasmy possibly associated to paternal leakage and suggesting hybridization with captive-bred exotic A. chukar. These results underline significant limitations in the reliability of mtDNA barcoding-based species identification and could have relevant evolutionary and ecological implications that should be accounted for when interpreting data aimed to support conservation actions.
Citation: Gandolfi A, Crestanello B, Fagotti A, Simoncelli F, Chiesa S, Girardi M, et al. (2017) New Evidences of Mitochondrial DNA Heteroplasmy by Putative Paternal Leakage between the Rock Partridge (Alectoris graeca) and the Chukar Partridge (Alectoris chukar). PLoS ONE12(1): e0170507. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0170507
Editor: Wolfgang Arthofer, University of Innsbruck, AUSTRIA
Received: October 27, 2016; Accepted: January 5, 2017; Published: January 23, 2017
Copyright: © 2017 Gandolfi et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are included in the paper.
Funding: The authors received no specific funding for this work.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The rock partridge Alectoris graeca, Meisner 1804, is a polytypic species included in “The IUCN (International Union for Conservation of Nature) Red List of Threatened Species” as “Near Threatened” on a global scale  and as “Vulnerable” in Italy , due to a trend of population decline. This decline is mostly associated with anthropogenic causes, including the massive release of captive-bred chukar partridge Alectoris chukar, Gray 1830, resulting in the formation of hybrids [3, 4, 5]. Genetic pollution and hybridization magnified the damages already caused by the decline of natural populations due to habitat loss and overhunting, and likely resulted from an uncertain morphological distinction between these species. This difficulty is almost entirely due to non-discrete characters, not easily applicable  and even less effective to detect hybrid individuals.
In recent years, molecular markers have been proved to represent an effective tool to support management of Alectoris populations [3, 4, 5, 7, 8]. As in most conservation-oriented genetic studies, both mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and nuclear DNA (nDNA) were used [3, 4, 5, 7], offering different and complementary information on the history of populations. While biparentally inherited nDNA markers can trace both the paternal and maternal contribution along generations, maternally inherited mtDNA is usually informative of matrilinear lineages only. The classical view of unilinear mode of inheritance, with no recombination, together with a relatively high mutation rate made mtDNA particularly appealing as a molecular tool in evolutionary and conservation biology, offering an informative and simpler system to model population history compared with nDNA . However, the general assumption of uniparentally transmitted, homoplasmic and non-recombining mitochondrial genomes is more and more contrasted by accumulating evidences of exceptions to the rule, with a growing list of taxa in which mtDNA biparental inheritance, heteroplasmy and recombination were demonstrated (reviewed in [10, 11, 12]).
Heteroplasmy has been observed in a range of eukaryotic taxa, in plants, fungi and animals . While point heteroplasmy, i.e. the within individual co-occurrence of different mtDNA haplotypes differing from each other at a single (or few) nucleotide position(s), can be a consequence of somatic or germline mutations, heteroplasmy can alternatively result through mitochondrial paternal leakage . Early studies detected heteroplasmy associated to paternal leakage substantially only in hybrid zones . Nevertheless, recent studies [14, 15] demonstrated that heteroplasmy can be common within single populations as well. In fact, on the one hand, when leakage occurs either between closely related populations, with no mitochondrial structure, or within single populations, with no mitochondrial variation, paternal mtDNA may simply not be detectable due to high similarity or identity between haplotypes ; on the other hand, the selective elimination of sperm mitochondria might not function properly when mtDNA divergence is elevated between parents [10, 16]. Studies of natural or anthropogenic hybrid zones, in which relatively different mitochondrial haplotypes come into contact, can thus provide an ideal experimental system to search for the evidence of paternal mitochondrial leakage .
Here we report on the observation of putative introgression-associated paternal leakage of mitochondrial haplotypes in two individuals from an anthropogenic hybrid zone of A. graeca and introduced A. chukar. We discuss the evolutionary and conservation implications of the observed evidence to our knowledge described here for the first time, in the endangered taxon of Galliformes, and their potential relevance in a conservation context.
Materials and Methods
The work performed during the analyses carried out for this manuscript is consistent with the National regulations and indications of the Ethics Committee of the University of Perugia (Italy). Approval by Ethics Committee was not necessary given the nature of the data collected (museum specimens, feathers) and the method of data recovery, without any animal suffering.
For museum specimens, each museum Direction agreed with this sampling campaign. Authorization of the CAMS’s Director and of the Morbegno’s museum were reported (S1 File). No specimen was sampled in absence of the museum’s staff.
A central, taxonomically informative, fragment of the mtDNA Cytochrome oxidase c subunit 1 (COI) in both putative A. graeca and A. chukar specimens was characterized. Investigations were performed on 44 either contemporary or historical samples of A. graeca and A. chukar (Table 1).
Details of analyzed specimens for each species: contemporary or historical samples, sample date, sampling location and geographic area of origin, number of analyzed samples (N) and Catalog number (for museum specimens).
For A. graeca, specimens were classified as “contemporary” if either alive or taxidermied after 1930, the date of the first documented introduction for chukar partridge in Italy . Museum specimens (“historical”), collected before the onset of stocking practices, may in facts represent the key to the recognition of A. graeca genetic makeup, thus avoiding misinterpretations. Both alive and museum specimens were morphologically assigned to either of the two species  and were sampled with a non-invasive method, collecting few feathers (from three to five).
DNA was extracted from a single feather  for each specimen in duplicate and subsequent PCR amplification and sequencing were performed according to previous published protocols [18, 19]. In particular, a first amplification with Bird-F1 and Bird-R1 primers  was done followed by a nested amplification with primers 5-NEST-F (GTAATCGTTACAGCCCATGC) and 3-NEST-R (gggtcgaaaaatgtggtgtt). All reactions were run using the following thermal cycle program: 5’ at 94°C followed by twenty-six cycles of 30” at 94°C, 45” at 52°C, and 45” at 72°C, followed by a final extension of 1’ at 72°C. The risk to amplify nuclear insertions of mtDNAs (nuclear mitochondrial DNA, NUMTs) was taken into account and prevented by the use of feathers as DNA source  and by a careful design of the COI nested primers . Specific features of NUMTs, possibly useful for their recognition [21, 23], were finally evaluated on the obtained sequences. PCR products were run on 2.5% agarose gel clearly showing a single band, with no evidence of smaller amplicons. Samples of different species were processed in different laboratories and by using dedicated laminar flow hoods to avoid cross-contamination between contemporary/museum samples.
To exclude sample contamination, a subset of seven individuals was also genotyped with ten microsatellite loci : six from the “ARU” series  and four from “MCW” series [4, 25]. The ten loci were analyzed following authors’ protocols [24, 26].
Results and Discussion
Sequences of 312 bp were aligned and screened for polymorphism, and the different haplotypes retrieved were deposited in GenBank (Accession Numbers KT180220-KT180226). Out of 312 bp, 41 sites were polymorphic in the alignment. Morphology based assignment of individuals to species was univocally confirmed in all cases but two. In two contemporary samples from Monte Fema (see Table 1) morphologically attributed to A. graeca, 19 polymorphic sites, all confirmed from duplicated independent analyses for each sample, clearly showed heteroplasmy (Fig 1a). The observed pattern of polymorphism suggested these two specimens to be derived from hybridization between A. graeca and A. chukar (see Fig 1b).
(a) Example of polymorphic site at position 212, clearly showing mtDNA COI heteroplasmy. (b) Heteroplasmic sites (GenBank KT180225) compared with polymorphisms discriminant in A. graeca (GenBank KT180224)/ A. chukar (GenBank KT180226) attribution.
The presence of NUMTs can be reasonably excluded in the present study. First, NUMTs are usually shorter than the corresponding mitochondrial gene . In the Alectoris genus NUMTs were described in A. chukar, where a 351bp NUMT was co-amplified with a 1143 bp-Cytb fragment (see Table 4 in , for a review of base count of mitochondrial genes vs NUMTs in ten Galliformes). Furthermore, NUMTs are usually recognizable ex post through analysis of reading frame and mutation positions. For example, in Gallus gallus identities between NUMTs and mitochondrial sequences are variable, ranging from 58.6 to 88.8% . Specifically, no amino acid variation, no stop codon insertion, nor sequence length variation, which can be found in NUMTS of coding regions , were observed in the present work.
The two haplotypes observed in each of the two individuals were easily reconstructed by phasing polymorphic sites through comparison with the other haplotypes observed in the sample set. The two resulting haplotypes, identical in the two individuals (GenBank KT180225), are too differentiated to be resulting from somatic mutations; at the same time, they are strictly related to one of the two species’ mitochondrial haplogroups—without presenting frame shifts or early stop codon mutations—to represent nuclear copies of the gene. In fact, the same sequences of the two haplotypes were observed in 5 individuals of A. graeca (GenBank KT180224, from Umbria and Abruzzo Regions, Central Italy) and in all the individuals of A. chukar (GenBank KT180226, Fig 1b).
In order to exclude that the observed heteroplasmic sequences might be due to sample contamination, ten microsatellite loci were screened on a subset of seven individuals, including the two heteroplasmic ones. The scored microsatellite allelic ranges were compatible with those already reported for the genus Alectoris, as showed in Table 2.
Specific locus, fluorochrome used, alleles range and number of alleles observed in the present work.
In both the heteroplasmic specimens, as well as in the other screened individuals, a clear homozygote or heterozygote biallelic signal was observed, referable to a single diploid individual, thus strongly rejecting the hypothesis of cross-sample contamination.
To our knowledge, this is the first record of heteroplasmy in A. graeca and the first record of a likely mitochondrial paternal leakage in Galliformes. In fact, the only case of mtDNA heteroplasmy from the literature for a congeneric was observed in the cytochrome b sequence of an A. chukar specimen from Cyprus . The two haplotypes observed in the heteroplasmic individual (Cyp27), both included in the A. chukar haplogroup and differing by a single nucleotide polymorphism, were shared by one (AM084572) and 15 (AM084573) different samples, respectively, in the same dataset. While the authors did not discuss the possible origin of the observed heteroplasmy, this could however represent another case of paternal leakage, occurred within species. Besides confirming our observation, this interpretation of the data  would also suggest that paternal leakage might be not so infrequent in this taxon. This would in turn have relevant evolutionary and ecological implications that should be accounted for when interpreting data generated in order to support conservation actions. As an example, in a survey of introgression patterns between rock and chukar partridge  no evidence of maternal introgression from the exotic species, i.e. the presence of chukar mtDNA haplotypes, was observed in 28 putative hybrid individuals determined by microsatellite analysis. The authors therefore concluded that captive-bred female partridges reproduced poorly in nature and introgression was therefore unidirectional, by backcrossing with native wild female rock partridges . This deduction might be reconsidered in the light of possible paternal leakage. Mitochondrial population bottlenecks (intra-individual genetic drift or vegetative sorting ), during the gametogenesis cell divisions, are supposed to quickly eliminate heteroplasmy, in a single or few generations [10, 30]. The expected unbalanced and relatively limited proportion of paternal mtDNA to maternal mtDNA makes the former more prone to loss by drift . However, heteroplasmy may persist through generations and become fixed, or alternatively maternal or paternal mtDNA may be lost due to either the forces of drift or selection . Thus, it’s possible that paternal leakage-associated hybridization might contribute to the mechanism through which genetically divergent mitochondrial genomes can meet and recombine, purging deleterious mutations and promoting the generation of new mitochondrial haplotypes, possibly contributing to increased fitness [10, 31]. Although Robison and colleagues  work on a parasite, having obviously a complete different biology than Alectoris, it is interesting what they argue for C. lectularius, the bed bugs. They hypothesize that paternal leakage may be really common and that its effects may be considered “long lasting”. Furthermore, they suggest a fascinating hypothesis circa the correlation between the insurgence of mitochondrial heteroplasmy and the re-union of historically allopatric lineages, that may simulate “hybridization-like” events . In the two Alectoris species, maybe a reproductive statement occurs similar to that hypothesized for allopatric lineages in which the molecular mechanisms preventing “transmission of paternal mtDNA to the oocyte may have been relaxed, leading to extensive paternal mtDNA leakage in inter-population hybrids” . This hypothesis should be evaluated in the future also in the light of the evolutive history of the Alectoris genus.
This paper documented, for the first time, the presence of mtDNA heteroplasmy in A. graeca / A. chukar. The observed heteroplasmy is reasonably associated with paternal leakage, following hybridization between the two species. This evidence confirms that paternal leakage should be taken into account in order to avoid erroneous reconstruction of population or species histories in mtDNA analyses, and—if frequent enough—might have possible far-reaching effects on the evolution and persistence of populations and species , acquiring relevant and fundamental importance for conservation purposes.
Authors would like to thank the Natural history museum of the University of Pisa, the Civic museum of Zoology of Rome, the Casalina’s Gallery of Natural History and the Civic Natural History museum of Morbegno.
- Conceptualization: AG LL SC IDR FS AF.
- Formal analysis: AG BC MG LL.
- Investigation: BC MG EG LL.
- Methodology: AG LL SC IDR FS AF.
- Project administration: AG LL.
- Resources: CM LL.
- Supervision: AG LL.
- Validation: AG LL BC MG EG.
- Visualization: AG LL SC.
- Writing – original draft: AG LL SC IDR FS AF.
- Writing – review & editing: AG LL SC IDR FS AF.
- 1. BirdLife International 2015. Alectoris graeca. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2015: e.T22678684A84626323. http://dx.doi.org/10.2305/IUCN.UK.2015.RLTS.T22678684A84626323.en.
- 2. Rondinini C, Battistoni A, Peronace V, Teofili C. Lista Rossa IUCN dei Vertebrati Italiani. Roma: Comitato Italiano IUCN e Ministero dell’Ambiente e della Tutela del Territorio e del Mare; 2013.
- 3. Barilani M, Bernard-Laurent A, Mucci N, Tabarroni C, Kark S, Perez Garrido JA, et al. Hybridisation with introduced chukars (Alectoris chukar) threatens the gene pool integrity of native rock (A. graeca) and red-legged (A. rufa) partridge populations. Biol Cons. 2007;137: 57–69.
- 4. Barilani M, Sfougaris A, Giannakopoulos A, Mucci N, Tabarroni C, Randi E. Detecting introgressive hybridization in rock partridge populations (Alectoris graeca) in Greece through Bayesian admixture analyses of multilocus genotypes. Conserv Genet. 2007;8: 343–354.
- 5. Negri A, Pellegrino I, Mucci N, Randi E, Tizzani P, Meneguz PG, et al. Mitochondrial DNA and microsatellite markers evidence a different pattern of hybridization in red-legged partridge (Alectoris rufa) populations from NW Italy. Eur J Wildl Res. 2013;57: 407–419.
- 6. Cramp S. Handbook of the Birds of Europe, the Middle East and North Africa. The Birds of the Western Palearctic, vol. II. Terns to Woodpeckers. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1985.
- 7. Barbanera F, Negro JJ, Di Giuseppe G, Bertoncini F, Cappelli F, Dini F. Analysis of the genetic structure of red-legged partridge (Alectoris rufa, Galliformes) populations by means of mitochondrial DNA and RAPD markers: a study from central Italy. Biol Cons. 2005;122: 275–287.
- 8. Randi E. Evolutionary and conservation genetics of the rock partridge, Alectoris graeca. Acta Zool Sinica 2006;52: 370–374.
- 9. White DJ, Wolff JN, Pierson M, Gemmell NJ. Revealing the hidden complexities of mtDNA inheritance. Mol Ecol. 2008;17: 4925–4942. pmid:19120984
- 10. Barr CM, Neiman M, Taylor DR. Inheritance and recombination of mitochondrial genomes in plants, fungi and animals. New Phytol. 2005;168: 39–50. pmid:16159319
- 11. Rokas A, Ladoukakis E, Zouros E. Animal mitochondrial DNA recombination revisited. Trends Ecol Evol. 2003; 18 411–417.
- 12. Tsaousis AD, Martin DP, Ladoukakis ED, Posada D, Zouros E. Widespread Recombination in Published Animal mtDNA Sequences. Mol Biol Evol. 2004;22: 925–933.
- 13. Kvist L, Martens J, Nazarenko AA, Orell M. Paternal Leakage of Mitochondrial DNA in the Great Tit (Parus major). Mol Biol Evol. 2003;20: 243–247. pmid:12598691
- 14. Nunes MDS, Dolezal M, Schlotterer C. Extensive paternal mtDNA leakage in natural populations of Drosophila melanogaster. Mol Ecol. 2013;22(8):2106–2117. pmid:23452233
- 15. Robison GA, Balvin O, Schal C, Vargo EL, Booth W. Extensive Mitochondrial Heteroplasmy in Natural Populations of a Resurging Human Pest, the Bed Bug (Hemiptera: Cimicidae). J Med Entomol. 2015;52, 734–738. pmid:26335484
- 16. Sutovsky P, Moreno RD, Ramalho-Santos J, Dominko T, Simerly D, Schatten G. Ubiquitin tag for sperm mitochondria. Nature 1999;402: 371–372. pmid:10586873
- 17. Lever C. Naturalised Birds of the World. London: T and AD Poyser; 2005.
- 18. Lucentini L, Gigliarelli L, Puletti ME, Volpi L, Panara F. Comparison of conservative DNA Extraction methods for two Galliformes: grey partridge (Perdix perdix Linnaeus 1758) and red-legged partridge (Alectoris rufa Linnaeus 1758). Conserv Gen Res. 2010;2: 381–384.
- 19. Lucentini L, Chiesa S, Giannetto D, Pompei L, Natali M, Sala P, et al. Integrative taxonomy does not support the occurrence of two species of the Squalius squalus complex (Actinopterygii, Cypriniformes, Cyprinidae) in Italy. Biochem Sys Ecol. 2014; 56: 281–288.
- 20. Kerr KCR, Stoeckle MY, Dove CJ, Weigt LA, Francis CM, Hebert PDN. Comprehensive DNA barcode coverage of North American birds. Mol Ecol Notes 2007; 7:535–543. pmid:18784793
- 21. Sorenson MD, Quinn TW. Numts: A Challenge for Avian Systematics and Population Biology. The Auk 1998;115: 214–221.
- 22. Xiang H, Gao J, Yu B, Zou H, Cai D, Zhang Y, et al. Early Holocene chicken domestication in northern China. PNAS 2014;111: 17564–17569. pmid:25422439
- 23. Sun J, Feng Z, Liu Y, Nucleotide Substitution Pattern in Mitochondrial Cytochrome b Pseudogenes of Ten Species in Galliformes. in Zhu E, Sambath S. Information Technology and Agricultural Engineering. USA: Springer; 2012.
- 24. Gonzalez EG, Castilla AM, Zardoya R. Novel polymorphic microsatellites for the red-legged partridge (Alectoris rufa) and cross-species amplification in Alectoris graeca. Mol Ecol Notes 2005;5: 449–451.
- 25. Amaral AJ, Silva AB, Grosso AR, Chikhi L, Bastos-Silveira C, Dias D. Detection of hybridization and species identification in domesticated and wild quails using genetic markers. Folia Zool. 2007;56: 285–300.
- 26. Barbanera F, Pergams ORW, Guerrini M, Forcina G, Panayides P, Dini F. Genetic consequences of intensive management in game birds. Biol Cons. 2010;143:1259–1268
- 27. Pereira L, Baker A. Low number of mitochondrial pseudogenes in the chicken (Gallus gallus) nuclear genome: implications for molecular inference of population history and phylogenetics. BMC Evol Biol. 2004;4:17. pmid:15219233
- 28. Guerrini M, Panayides P, Hadjigerou P, Taglioli L, Dini F, Barbanera F. Lack of genetic structure of Cypriot Alectoris chukar (Aves, Galliformes) populations as inferred from mtDNA sequencing data. Anim Biodiv Cons. 2007;30: 105–114.
- 29. McCauley DE, Olson MS. Do recent findings in plant mitochondrial and population genetics have implications for the study of gynodioecy and cytonuclear conflict? Evolution 2008;62: 1013–1025. pmid:18315572
- 30. Pearl SA, Welch ME, McCauley DE. Mitochondrial heteroplasmy and paternal leakage in natural populations of Silene vulgaris, a gynodioecious plant. Mol Biol Evol. 26;2009: 537–545. pmid:19033259
- 31. Gemmell NJ, Metcalf VJ, Allendorf FW. Mother's curse: the effect of mtDNA on individual fitness and population viability. Trends Ecol Evol. 2004;19: 238–244. pmid:16701262
- 32. Wolff JN, Nafisinia M, Sutovsky P, Ballar JWO. Paternal transmission of mitochondrial DNA as an integral part of mitochondrial inheritance in metapopulations of Drosophila simulans. Heredity 2013;110: 57–62. pmid:23010820