Advertisement
Browse Subject Areas
?

Click through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in your field.

For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click here.

  • Loading metrics

Aluminium Accumulation and Intra-Tree Distribution Patterns in Three Arbor aluminosa (Symplocos) Species from Central Sulawesi

Aluminium Accumulation and Intra-Tree Distribution Patterns in Three Arbor aluminosa (Symplocos) Species from Central Sulawesi

  • Marco Schmitt, 
  • Sven Boras, 
  • Aiyen Tjoa, 
  • Toshihiro Watanabe, 
  • Steven Jansen
PLOS
x

Abstract

Accumulation of Aluminium (Al) at concentrations far above 1,000 mg kg-1 in aboveground plant tissues of Arbor aluminosa (Symplocos) species is the main reason why traditional Indonesian weavers rely on their leaves and bark as a mordant for dyeing textile. Recently, Symplocos species have become a flagship species for the conservation efforts of weaving communities due to their traditionally non-sustainable sampling and increasing demand for Symplocos plant material. Here we investigated Symplocos odoratissima, S. ophirensis and S. ambangensis at three montane rainforest sites in Central Sulawesi to measure Al levels in different tissues and organs. The highest Al concentrations were found in old leaves (24,180 ± 7,236 mg·kg-1 dry weight, mean ± SD), while young leaves had significantly lower Al levels (20,708 ± 7,025 mg·kg-1). Al accumulation was also lower in bark and wood tissue of the trunk (17,231 ± 8,356 mg·kg-1 and 5,181 ± 2,032 mg·kg-1, respectively). Two Al excluding species (Syzigium sp. and Lithocarpus sp.) contained only high Al levels in their roots. Moreover, no difference was found in soil pH (4.7 ± 0.61) and nutrient (K, Ca, Fe, Mg) availability at different soil levels and within or outside the crown of Symplocos trees, except for the upper soil layer. Furthermore, a positive and significant correlation between Al and Ca concentrations was found at the whole plant level for Symplocos, and at the leaf level for S. ophirensis and S. ambangensis, suggesting a potential role of Ca in Al uptake and/or detoxification within the plant. Our results provide evidence for strong Al accumulation in Symplocos species and illustrate that both Al accumulation and exclusion represent two co-occurring strategies of montane rainforest plants for dealing with Al toxicity. Indonesian weavers should be encouraged to harvest old leaves, which have the most efficient mordant capacity due to high Al concentrations.

Introduction

One of the first observations of plants containing high concentrations of alum may have been made by Georg Eberhard Rumphius, when he described the Arbor aluminosa (“aluminium tree”) [1]. This tree was later identified as a species of Symplocos (Symplocaceae) [2], which includes ca. 250 species native to Asia, Australia, and the Americas. Although aluminium (Al) had not been discovered yet during the time of Rumphius, the notion of high levels of alum in plants was based on the traditional use of plant material as a mordant for dyeing textile, a process that apparently also involved alum in India and South-East Asia [1,37]. The first chemical identification of Al salts in leaves of Symplocos was made by Driessen [8], and we refer to Hutchinson [9] for a historical overview.

Nowadays, traditional weaving communities across the Indonesian archipelago still rely on the supply of plant material, which includes several Symplocos species as a natural mordant and additional plants (e.g., Morinda citrifolia and Indigofera) for dyes and tannins [1012]. Although Al accumulation is found in a total of ca. 45 angiosperm families [5,6,13], the dyeing protocol of Indonesian weavers is based on the exclusive use of local species [12]. Symplocos species in Indonesia are found in remnant forests and communal forests on deeply weathered soils, but are becoming rare in various areas and hardly fulfil the increasing demand by Indonesian weavers. In fact, Symplocos has become a flagship species for the conservation efforts of ca. 13,000 women still working with traditional, natural dyes [12]. Since the traditional harvesting method for obtaining Symplocos plant material involves the collection of leaf and bark tissue from living forest trees, which commonly involves the cutting of entire trees, this destructive method frequently results in tree dieback. Moreover, cultivation of local Symplocos species has not been prompted yet, and efforts to promote forest sustainability currently focus on the collection of old, fallen leaves from the forest floor [12]. We lack, however, scientific evidence that old leaves contain the highest Al levels, which would also indicate that old leaves have the highest mordant capacity. As far as we know, the highest concentration of Al in aboveground plant tissue measured was 72,240 mg kg-1 in S. spicata Roxb. [4]. Modern chemical analyses of Al concentrations in Symplocos plant tissue, however, are limited and include only few tropical species from their natural environment [1416].

Although Al is the most abundant metal in the earth´s crust and heavily exploited by human activities [17], its availability increases exponentially in acidic soils because a low pH (< 5) changes Al from a crystalline structure into plant available forms, some of which are known to be phytotoxic [1820]. In fact, Al toxicity represents one of the most limiting factors for crop production in acidic soils [21]. While considerable research has been devoted on Al toxicity of crops, our understanding of Al accumulation in flowering plants is limited to a few Al accumulating species such as Camellia sinensis, Fagopyrum esculentum, Hydrangea macrophylla, and Melastoma malabathricum [2225]. The ecological and evolutionary aspects of how tropical plant species deal with Al toxicity remain poorly studied [13,15,26].

Two main strategies are distinguished with respect to Al3+ response mechanisms, namely exclusion and accumulation, which have also been applied to a wide range of other metals [27]. Al exclusion is considered to rely on an external (i.e., apoplastic) resistance mechanism, resulting in Al levels in aboveground tissue that are on average 200 mg kg-1, whereas accumulation involves detoxification via an internal (i.e., symplastic) mechanism [13,2830]. Al accumulators are typically defined as plants that show Al levels in aboveground tissue above 1,000 mg kg-1 [13]. How exactly Al is detoxified in aboveground plant tissues and in which chemical forms Al is present remains largely unclear [31]. There is some evidence suggesting that Al can bind to oxalate in the vacuoles of leaf cells and to citrate when being transported through the xylem [22,3234]. However, it is also clear that detoxification mechanisms can be taxon-specific [16]. Moreover, both the xylem loading, potential transport via phloem, and the ligand exchange are not fully understood [35,36].

It has been suggested that obligate Al accumulators, which typically show a beneficial effect of Al on plant growth [24,37,38], may show higher activity of antioxidant enzymes, reduction of iron toxicity, or other unknown metabolic advantages under acidic soils [39,40]. In a cerrado sensu strictu physiognomy, for instance, only five of the 38 tree species appeared to be Al accumulators, although these accounted for 30% of the total importance value in the community [41]. Also, the spatial distribution of Al accumulating trees in West Sumatra showed a positive correlation with the soil edaphic status [42]. These findings may suggest that there could be potential trade-offs in the costs and benefits of Al exclusion and accumulation that may provide evolutionary fitness advantages [43]. It has also been suggested that Al accumulation may provide a defence mechanism against herbivory or pathogens [31], similar to metals such as nickel (Ni) and selenium (Se) [44,45].

In this study, we aim to quantify Al accumulation across three Symplocos species from Central Sulawesi (Indonesia). Earlier observations from literature indicate that out of the 159 specimens of Symplocos tested, 158 individuals showed Al accumulation [5,7,15,46,47]. We therefore expect that Al accumulation is a common strategy in Symplocos. A second goal is to quantify the intra-tree variation in Al concentration by comparing various organsand plant tissues at different developmental stages. Based on evidence from Al accumulators in the cerrado [48,49] and Melastoma malabathricum [24,50], it is expected that the highest levels of Al are found in the leaves and bark tissue, with old leaves showing higher concentrations than younger leaves.

Furthermore, we want to test if Al accumulation in Symplocos species shows allelopathic effects on neighbouring species [43] and is associated with potential plant-soil interactions. Considering the high levels of foliar Al in accumulating plants, leaf shedding in the proximity of the stem and subsequent decomposition may have a local effect on the Al concentration and chemical composition in the soil, with potentially higher concentrations of soluble Al under the canopy of an Al accumulating tree than outside its canopy. If this hypothesis would be correct, the high availability of soluble Al could negatively affect the growth and performance of plants with low Al toxicity tolerance growing next to Al accumulators due to increased Al stress. The higher availability of soluble Al should therefore negatively affect the growth and abundance of potentially Al sensitive plants growing next to Al accumulators altering their environment. Therefore, soil samples are analysed at different levels of depth and at different proximities to the stems of Symplocos trees.

Finally, we aim to find out if high Al levels are correlated with other elements in aboveground tissues of Symplocos. In particular, we expected that Al levels are positively correlated with calcium (Ca) and magnesium (Mg), based on earlier findings of Al accumulating plants [26,42]. These goals are achieved by studying both Al accumulating species and non-accumulating plant species from three study sites in Central Sulawesi.

Materials and Methods

Study sites and species

Fieldwork was conducted in October and November 2013 at three different sites in the Lore Lindu National Park in Central Sulawesi. The sites were selected based on the relatively high abundance of Symplocos trees based on earlier observations [51], and represented primary montane rainforests with minor differences in altitude and climate (see Table 1 for details). For each site, a single species of Symplocos was sampled (Table 1).

thumbnail
Table 1. Field sites of montane rainforest selected in Central Sulawesi (Indonesia) with reference to the species studied, geographical information and climatea.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0149078.t001

Symplocos trees were represented as understorey plants, about 8 to 15 m tall with a diameter at breast height (DBH) from 5.4 to 25.7 cm. The vegetation showed a high abundance of rattan species (Arecaceae), Rubiaceae, Zingiberaceae and Melastomataceae, and the most prominent tree species were Fagaceae, Myrtaceae and Podocarpaceae. Besides Symplocos, a second plant species was sampled at each field-site, including Lithocarpus sp. (Fagaceae), Polyosma celebica Schulze-Menz (Escalloniaceae), and Syzygium sp. (Myrtaceae). The main criterion for selecting these species was their abundance at each field site. Moreover, these additional species represented one additional Al accumulating species (Polyosma celebica; [5,52]) and two Al-excluding species (Syzygium sp. and Lithocarpus sp.).

The soil at the three field sites was composed of undulating red to yellow podsoil with some areas showing alluvium and organosols.

Collection of plant material

Leaf samples were divided into three developmental stages (i.e., young, mature, and old), which were grouped based on their size and colour. Data on the leaf life span were not available. However, abscission was assumed to provide an additional and easy criterion for distinguishing the fully developed, mature leaves from old ones. Young (i.e., not fully developed) leaves had a light green colour compared to the larger, dark green, mature and fully developed leaves. The old leaves were typically yellowish green. Young and mature leaves were collected from branches. The old leaves were sampled by shaking a tree and picking up the fallen leaves. We also collected old leaves that could be found on the forest floor and did not show any signs of decomposition.

For each specimen, we collected five bulk samples. As for the leaves, one sample included three to ten leaves, depending on the leaf size. We aimed to collect ca. 15 leaf samples per tree. However, it was not always possible to collect five bulk samples of old leaves. Bark samples were taken from the trunk and branches, with five bulk samples per tree sampled (n = ca. 10 per tree). Wood samples were taken from branches only (n = 1 per tree). For the non-Symplocos species (Table 1), we collected bulk samples of mature leaves (n = 5 per tree), bark from the main trunk (n = 5), and one root sample per tree.

In order to measure the soil pH and the amount of soluble cations, soil samples were taken at three different depth levels (level 1 = 5–7 cm; level 2 = 30–32 cm; level 3 = 40–42 cm) and at three different distances from the trunk of a Symplocos tree (near = 0.15–0.45 m; middle = 0.50–2.25 m; far = 1.85–5.00 m). These places corresponded to the soil area close to the trunk of the tree sampled, half-way the radius of the tree crown, and outside the crown. The three arbitrary distances from the trunk thus depended on the crown width of the tree sampled. Each soil sample had a volume of 0.1 L and was taken with a standardized metallic cylinder. Therefore, we sampled nine soil samples per tree. Each time, we collected two volumes of soil samples: one for pH measurements, and one for elemental analyses. Root samples were taken after obtaining the soil samples from the first excavation hole, which was closest to the tree trunk, by following the main roots until fine root material was visible (n = 1 per tree).

Overall, we collected a total of 270 soil, 290 leaf, 224 bark, 30 root, and 14 wood samples. All samples were stored in plastic bags at ambient temperature for a maximum of five days before further treatments could be applied in the lab. At Tadulako University, leaves were washed with 3% (v/v) HCl, tap-water, and deionized water to clean the leaves and to avoid any potential contamination. Root material for chemical analysis was thoroughly washed with tap water and rinsed with deionized water to avoid soil contamination. All plant organs and tissues were then transferred into paper bags and oven-dried (OP150, LTE, United Kingdom) at 60°C for 48 hours. Soil samples for pH-measurements were air-dried for 48 hours. All samples were then shipped to Ulm University for further chemical analysis, covered by a Material Transfer Agreement. The research and collecting permit was granted by the National Ministry for Science and Technology of Indonesia (RISTEK) in Jakarta under the number 4306/FRP/SM/VIII/2013.

Soil pH measurements

We mixed 10 g of soil material with 25 mL of deionized water and homogenized the solution for 1 h. After sedimentation, the pHH2O (referred to as pH in this paper) was measured three times with a pH-meter (330i, WTW, Germany). Then, the suspension was filtered with a 595 filter paper (Schleicher & Schuell, Dassel, Germany) using a vacuum pump. The filtrates were stored in a fridge at 6°C prior to elemental analysis.

Elemental analysis

Leaf, bark, root, and wood samples were ground with a centrifuge mill (ZM1, Retsch, Germany). Root samples were not separated into wood and bark tissue for all species. We transferred 50 mg of the ground tissue into a PTFE-vessel before adding 2 mL of concentrated HNO3 and 0.5 mL of concentrated HCl. Samples were microwave digested (Mars 5 plus, CEM, Germany) at 200°C (1600 W) for 30 min (15 min Ramp time; 15 min Holding time).The digestions were diluted to 50 mL with a 0.25% (w/v) CsNO3-solution as ionic buffer. The filtrate of the soil samples was diluted 1:10 with the same ionic buffer for analysis. The concentrations of Al, Fe, Mg, Ca and K were measured using microwave-plasma atomic emission spectrometry (MP-AES, Agilent 4100, Agilent Technologies, Australia). Calibration ranged from 1–60 mg/L, depending on the elemental concentration of the digestions.

Statistical analyses

Statistical analyses were computed with RStudio (Version 0.98.1091, RStudio Inc., Boston, USA). Significant differences between mean values were represented using OneWay-ANOVA with Tukey´s Honestly Significant Difference (HSD) for normal distribution and Wilcoxon´s rank sum test for non-normally distributed data. Correlations were calculated with a Spearman´s rank correlation coefficient. Unless mentioned otherwise, the significance level was P < 0.05. The entire dataset including all measurements was provided in the Supporting Information (S1 Dataset).

Results

Interspecific variation of Al concentrations

Al concentrations for the three species of Symplocos and Polyosma celebica were far above 1,000 mg·kg-1 dry weight in all tissues and organs measured. Al levels in P. celebica varied from 6,250 (± 1,487) mg·kg-1 (mean value ± SD) to 7,535 (± 1,528) mg·kg-1 in bark and leaf tissue, respectively (Table 2). Al levels in Symplocos were up to four times higher, ranging from 16,719 (± 1,120) mg·kg-1 to 23,383 (± 9,593) mg·kg-1 in leaves of S. ambangensis and S. odoratissima, respectively, while bark tissue included slightly lower levels of Al, from 7,034 (± 1,978) mg·kg-1 in S. odoratissima to 20,257 (± 5,305) mg·kg-1 in S. ambangensis. The highest Al concentration measured was 49,100 mg·kg-1 in old leaves of S. odoratissima.

thumbnail
Table 2. Summary of the elemental concentrations (mean value ± SD) of various plant tissues from three Symplocos species and dominant neighbouring plant species collected at tropical montane forest sites in Central Sulawesi.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0149078.t002

Much lower Al concentrations were reported for the Al excluding species, with values ranging from 34 (± 13) mg·kg-1 (mean ± SD) in leaf tissue of Syzygium sp. to 176 (± 140) mg·kg-1 in leaves of Lithocarpus sp. At the root level, Al concentrations between Al excluders and accumulators were less variable: Lithocarpus sp. showed similar mean Al concentrations in its roots than Symplocos odoratissima. Also, Syzygium showed a relatively high mean Al concentration of 986 (± 677) mg·kg-1 in its roots.

Intra-tree variation of Al accumulation in Symplocos

We found significant differences in Al concentration between different organs and plant tissues for the three Symplocos species studied (Fig 1). The lowest Al concentrations were measured in wood samples (on average 5,181 ± 2,032 mg·kg-1) and the highest values in old leaves (24,180 ± 7,236 mg·kg-1; S1 Table). Although the roots had a higher mean Al concentration (11,272 ± 4,792 mg·kg-1) than the wood, no significant difference was found between these organs. There was also no significant difference between bark tissue from the main trunk and small branches (Fig 1). Al levels in the bark of the main trunk were similar to those in young and mature leaves (Fig 1). Therefore, young and mature leaves did not show a significant difference (P = 0.615, Fig 1), but a significantly higher Al concentration was found for the old leaves compared to younger leaf ages for all three species (P < 0.01, Fig 1).

thumbnail
Fig 1. Aluminium (Al) concentrations in various plant tissues for three Symplocos species from Central Sulawesi (mg·kg-1 dry mass).

For each species, five individual trees were measured, with ca. five large samples per tree for leaf and bark material, and one root and wood sample per tree. Leaves were classified according to three developmental stages (young, mature, and old). Different letters indicate significant differences between mean values (Wilcoxon Rank Sum Test, P < 0.05). Boxes show the median, 25th and 75th percentiles, error bars show 10th and 90th percentiles, and individual points show outliers.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0149078.g001

When analysing the three Symplocos species separately, no significant difference between mature and young leaves could be found for S. odoratissima and S. ophirensis (Fig 2), but significant differences between the three developmental leaf stages were found for S. ambangensis. For the three Symplocos species studied, old leaves showed significantly higher Al concentrations than younger developmental leaf stages.

thumbnail
Fig 2. Boxplots showing aluminium (Al) concentrations (mg·kg-1 dry mass) in leaves for three species of Symplocos, showing the median, 25th and 75th percentiles, 10th and 90th percentiles as error bars, and outliers as individual points.

Leaves were grouped into three different developmental stages (young, mature, and old). Different letters indicate significant differences between mean values (Wilcoxon Rank-Sum Test, P < 0.05).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0149078.g002

Soil characteristics

The soil pH values measured varied from 2.2 to 6.3. With an average value of 4.7 (± 0.61) the soil at the three sites was acidic. Furthermore, the mean soil pH at the Rorekautimbu site was 4.1 (± 0.52), which was significantly lower than in Dali and Nokilalaki (P < 0.001). The pH values showed a homogeneous pattern, regardless of the relative distance between the main trunk and the tree crown (Fig 3). However, at all sites we found a significantly lower pH-value in the top-soil layer compared to deeper soil layers (P < 0.001 Fig 3). No correlation was found between the amount of soluble soil ions (Ca, K, Mg, Fe) and the pH values measured (Table 3).

thumbnail
Fig 3. pHH2O values of soil samples (n = 135) from the surface soil layer of Symplocos trees in Central Sulawesi.

Five individual trees per species were sampled for three species at three field sites (D = Dali, N = Nokilalaki, R = Rorekautimbu). The pH values are shown in relation to 1) the distance from the tree trunk, 2) the soil depth, and 3) the sampling site. Distances from the tree trunk depended on the tree crown width (near = at 0.15 to 0.45 m from the trunk; middle = at 0.50 to 0.25 m from the trunk, i.e. half the radius of the tree crown; far = 1.85–5.00 m, i.e. outside the tree crown). Depth classes 1, 2, and 3 were at 5 to 7 cm, 30 to 32 cm, and 40 to 42 cm, respectively. The box plots show the median, 25th and 75th percentiles, error bars show 10th and 90th percentiles, and individual points show outliers. Different letters indicate significant differences between mean values (Wilcoxon Rank-Sum Test, P < 0.05).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0149078.g003

thumbnail
Table 3. Elemental concentration of water extracted soluble ionsa in soil samples from three montane rainforest field sites in central Sulawesi.

The values represent mean values (± SD) for three depth classes near five Symplocos trees sampled per site. For each tree, nine soil samples were taken.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0149078.t003

In general, the uppermost layer had a higher concentration of soluble ions, compared to the middle and bottom layer. The highest concentration of soluble Al was found in the soil layers at the site in Rorekautimbu with 235.16 (± 289.53) mg·kg-1 in the uppermost soil layer (Table 3), while soluble Al concentrations did not exceed 50 mg·kg-1 at the two other field sites. Ca concentrations were highest in Dali with 139.83 (± 220.01) mg·kg-1and low in Nokilalaki and Rorekautimbu. The concentration of soluble Fe was higher in Nokilalaki (822.66 ± 1426.07 mg·kg-1) and Rorekautimbu (383.33 ± 497.90 mg·kg-1) than in Dali (6.16 ± 4.41 mg·kg-1).

The soil elemental concentrations did not differ significantly along the three distances of the tree crown (data not shown). No correlation between the soil soluble elements was found.

Al concentrations in relation to other elements

No correlation was found between Al and the other elements measured, including Fe, Mg and K. The Al concentration in the three Symplocos species was positively correlated with the concentration of calcium (Ca), both at the leaf level and the entire plant level (Fig 4). At the whole plant level, the correlation was significant for S. odoratissima (R2 = 0.064, P = 0.02), S. ophirensis (R2 = 0.269, P < 0.01), and S. ambangensis (R2 = 0.432, P < 0.01). At the leaf level the Al-Ca correlation was strongest for S. ambangensis (R2 = 0.537, P < 0.01), significant for S. ophirensis (R2 = 0.133; P < 0.01), but weak and non-significant (R2 = 0.087; P = 0.33) for S. odoratissima (data not shown). The leaf Ca concentration was significantly lower in both Syzygium sp. and Lithocarpus sp. compared to the Symplocos species. Leaf Ca concentration in P. celebica similar as the mean Ca levels in S. ophirensis and S. ambangensis.

thumbnail
Fig 4. Correlation between aluminium (Al) and calcium (Ca) concentrations in three Symplocos species from Central Sulawesi.

Five trees were sampled for each species. Different symbols represent different plant tissues and organs. The solid line represents the regression line. S. odoratissima: P = 0.02, n = 124; S. ophirensis: P < 0.01, n = 134; S. ambangensis: P < 0.01, n = 135.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0149078.g004

Leaf age had a considerable effect on Ca concentration, with the concentration in the young leaves significantly lower than in old leaves (P = 0.0078, data not shown). However, there was no significant difference in the amount of Ca between young and mature, and between mature and old leaves for the four Al accumulating species. There is a significant, age dependent increase in the Ca concentration for S. ophirensis and S. ambangensis, but not for S. odoratissima (data not shown).

No correlation was found between Al and the other elements measured, including Fe, Mg and K.

Discussion

Al accumulators and excluders

Our chemical analyses clearly indicate that the genus Symplocos includes strong Al-accumulating species in Indonesia. Therefore, our data support the old, pre-Linnean name given by Rumphius (Arbor aluminosa) to these Al accumulating trees, although the values measured are not as high as the 72,240 mg·kg-1 recorded for S. spicata [4]. Mean Al levels measured in S. crassipes from Brunei included 33,883 mg·kg-1 [15], which is slightly higher than the values obtained for S. odoratissima. Temperate to subtropical species of Symplocos, however, appear to show slightly lower levels of Al accumulation, with a mean value of 8,872 mg·kg-1 for five Japanese species [14] and an average concentration of 8,309 (± 282) mg·kg-1 for S. chinensis grown in a standard nutrient solution with 0.5 mmol·L-1 Al [16]. Differences in soil acidity and/or leaf longevity could explain the lower Al levels in temperate species of Symplocos compared to tropical species. Al values of more than 10,000 mg·kg-1 were also reported for tea (Camellia sinensis) plants growing in their natural environment [53], which supports the close phylogenetic relationship between Symplocaceae and Theaceae.

Lithocarpus and Syzygium show Al concentrations that are characteristic of Al excluders growing in tropical, acidic soils, while Al accumulation is supported for Polyosma [5]. With casparian stripes blocking apoplastic transport around the central, vascular bundle in roots [54], it can be suggested that symplastic pathways between Al accumulators and excluders are likely different, probably through channels that either promote or block the uptake of Al [34]. The relatively low Al concentration in root samples of Syzygium (986 ± 677 mg·kg-1) seems to suggest that this genus may have a mechanism that prevents Al uptake into its root tissue. Representatives of the Myrtaceae family (Melaleuca leucadendra, Melaleuca cajuputi and Eucalyptus camaldulensis) that were exposed to Al (0.5 mmol to 4 mmol) showed various Al tolerance mechanisms (e.g., alteration of the pH at the root level) in addition to the exudation of organic compounds and phosphate to alleviate Al toxicity [55]. Besides the genera Eugenia and Xanthostemon, Al accumulation has not been reported in Myrtaceae [56]. However, the physiological explanation for the relatively low concentration of Al in the root tissue of Syzygium requires further research.

Al concentrations between various tissues of Symplocos

Earlier findings suggest that the xylem tissue represents the major transport pathway for Al between the roots and the leaves of Al accumulating tea plants [53]. Therefore, the concentration of Al can be expected to increase in leaves by the transpiration stream. Since the old leaves were found to show the highest Al concentrations, immobility of Al within the leaf tissue can be suggested and is in line with earlier findings of Al storage in leaf epidermal tissue and xylem [16,24,38]. The evidence that old leaves of Symplocos show the highest Al levels is important for the traditional weavers in Indonesia because a lower amount of Symplocos material will be required to obtain a similar dye efficiency for a given amount of textile. Moreover, harvesting of old leaves from the forest floor is unlikely to result in tree death, unlike cutting aboveground stems and trunks.

High aluminium concentrations in the bark may also suggest transport via the phloem, which was found for instance in Camellia oleifera and C. sinensis [57,58]. It is unclear, however, if transport via the phloem mainly follows an axial direction via the phloem sieve tubes, or whether Al shows possible interactions between xylem and phloem tissues, with both axial and radial transport via ray cells. Regardless of the transport pathways, we found high levels of Al in the ray parenchyma and phloem of the plants sampled in Indonesia (M.S., unpublished data) based on Al specific staining techniques.

The elemental allelopathy hypothesis and soil properties

As expected, the highest concentrations of soluble cations are found in the top layer of the soil, and can be explained by decomposition of organic matter, which makes various nutrients available for recycling [7,59]. Furthermore, the degradation of organic material lowers the pH through bacterial synthesis of carbonic acids in the top layer. This also promotes the availability of soluble cations through exchange of protons in the substrate [60].

The soil pH and the soluble nutrients did not show any correlation. Thus, a lower pH does not account for a degradation of substrates to make nutrients soluble, but will shift their chemical forms (i.e., a shift from aluminium hydroxide forms to Al3+) [19,30,61].

The elemental allelopathy hypothesis for Al could not be confirmed because no difference in the amount of soluble Al in the soil and in the soil pH could be found between the different proximities to the stem. Active acidification through release of protons at the root zone level was not tested. Even if such an acidification mechanism would be applied by Symplocos trees to facilitate Al accumulation, it could be expected that a low pH value may occur in the proximity of the stem [24]. Because our pH values were measured at a relatively large (macroscopic) scale, it is possible that pH gradients may occur at a local scale close to the fine roots, which could then account for a higher solubility of Al species in the soil.

Interestingly, Al accumulating representatives of various families (e.g., Melastomataceae, Rubiaceae, Theaceae, Escalloniaceae) were growing in close proximity to members of Al excluding families (e.g., Zingiberaceae, Arecaceae, Myrtaceae, Moraceae). Although we did not conduct any detailed measurements on growth rate, reproductive success, vegetation density, life span, etc., Al accumulators and excluders appear not to show any obvious ecological advantage or benefit for dealing with Al toxicity in acidic soils.

Our observations of vertebrate and/or invertebrate herbivory in the Symplocos species studied suggest that Al accumulation does not result in an enhanced defence mechanism. However, it was not clear whether the herbivores attacking the Symplocos leaves were specialists or generalists, and whether Al accumulation provides higher resistance to pathogens than Al excluding plants. Sika deer in Japan were reported to avoid bark stripping for Symplocos coreana and neotropical leaf cutting ants were shown to have a low appetite for leaves of the Al accumulating Coussarea hydrangeifolia (Rubiaceae) [62,63]. Observation of leaves from our three Symplocos species frequently showed signs of herbivory (S1 Fig).

Al accumulation in plants differs considerably from accumulators of transition metals or arsenic (As) [6467]. For instance, Al accumulation frequently characterises large taxonomic groups at the genus and (sub)family level, unlike heavy metal accumulators [13,14]. Therefore, it can be suggested that Al accumulation conveys a selective advantage in a wider range of ecological contexts than heavy metal accumulators. While heavy metals are restricted to metalliferous soils and to active or abandoned mining sites, Al is omnipresent in all soil types, but the amount of soluble Al strongly depends on soil pH [68]. As far as we know, distinct soil patches that represent “geochemical islands” with higher levels of available aluminium have only been investigated for the Al tolerant species Plantago almogravensis [69]. The distribution density of this species was linked with the realized niche concept [70] and high Al tolerance was found to provide a successful strategy for P. almogravensis to grow on acidic and Al rich spots whereas it would be outcompeted on habitats with reduced Al toxicity. To what extent Al exclusion and accumulation may have an effect on tropical forest dynamics remains unclear and would require detailed observations at the population level [71,72].

Correlation between Al and other elements

Compared to data from Masunaga et al. [42], the Ca values for leaves and bark of Al accumulators are rather low, especially in Polyosma celebica. Based on a global dataset on foliar elemental concentrations, the values for Mg, K and Ca concentrations in Symplocos are similar to our data [14,15].

As expected, our data show that Ca levels are correlated with Al, both at the whole plant level, and to a lesser degree at the leaf level (Fig 4). This finding is strengthened by the lack of a correlation of soluble ions in the soil and is thus only found in the plant body. The positive correlation between Ca and Al confirms previous studies that showed an increase in Ca uptake with enhanced Al levels [42,73], and a Ca-Al correlation was also found in the sister family Theaceae [74], which may provide evidence for a genetic disposition of the mechanisms underlying the uptake of Ca in the presence of Al. At the leaf level, there is a clear difference between the excluding species and the accumulators. The genus Symplocos is known to have calcium oxalate crystals stored in its leaf tissue [16,75]. This could contribute to the higher foliar concentrations in Symplocos when compared to the neighbouring plants, at least in case of Syzygium and Lithocarpus. No calcium oxalate crystals were reported for S. ophirensis [75], which could explain the lower concentrations of foliar Ca when compared to the other two Symplocos species studied. However, as the correlation at the leaf level is not as strong as at the whole-plant level, these crystals cannot be the only explanation. Oxalate can bind to both Ca and Al and could therefore act as a regulating molecule for the accumulation of both elements. The formation of crystals with metal inclusion and subsequent storage in the vacuole is also hypothesized to be a possible mechanism to reduce the toxic effect of Al and other metals [76]. The correlation between Al and Ca concentrations also provides evidence for the relative immobility of both elements once they are taken up by leaf tissue, where Ca is known for its immobilization from old to young leaves, even under stressful conditions [77].

The lower concentration of Fe in the root tissue of S. odoratissima could be explained by low soluble Fe concentrations in the soil (Table 3), whereas both S. ophirensis and P. celebica showed higher root Fe concentrations because of higher Fe levels in the soil. Adsorption at the root level does not affect the potential uptake into the aboveground tissues. Furthermore, our experimental setup did not account for desorption of adsorbed metals in the root tissue, which is why the root elemental concentrations are not useful to discuss uptake in the aboveground plant tissues. However, any given difference between accumulators and excluders could still suggest the potential exudation of chelating agents that may affect Al uptake into the root tissue and subsequently uptake into aboveground tissues [78]. Whether both Fe and Al are bound to the symplast or apoplast was not addressed in this study.

Conclusion

Our finding that the highest Al levels occur in the oldest leaves should provide important information for Indonesian weavers to achieve sustainable harvesting of Symplocos plant material for their traditional dying techniques [12]. The results indicate that there are transport pathways for Al within the different tissues of Al accumulators, whereas non-accumulators seem to possess mechanisms that actively block the uptake of Al at the root level. No ecological advantage or disadvantage was found with respect to the elemental allelopathy hypothesis in the case of Al. Al excluders were growing in close proximity to accumulating species, suggesting that both accumulation and exclusion seem to be equally successful strategies to deal with Al toxicity. Furthermore, calcium is suggested to play a role in Al accumulation of Symplocos species.

Supporting Information

S1 Dataset. The dataset including all elemental concentrations measured with microwave-plasm atomic emission spectrometry (MP-AES) and soil pH values at three montane rainforest sites in Central Sulawesi.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0149078.s001

(XLSX)

S1 Fig. Leaves of Symplocos odoratissima showing signs of herbivory in a montane rainforest at the Dali field site in Central Sulawesi.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0149078.s002

(TIFF)

S1 Table. Elemental concentrations of different organs and developmental stages of leaves for three Symplocos species from three montane rainforest sites in Central Sulawesi.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0149078.s003

(DOCX)

Acknowledgments

Bernhard Schuldt and Fabian Brambach (University of Göttingen) are acknowledged for useful advice and information about the field sites. We also thank colleagues from Tadulako University, especially Firdaus Daeng Mattata, Rickson Tiranda and Nur Ainun for support with field and lab work. We greatly appreciate information and helpful discussions from Jean Howe, William Ingram, I Made Maduarta, and Tony Cunningham. Jakob Gerber, Nadine Buchsteiner, Hans Malchus, Gaby Wiest-Danner, and Ellen Salzer are acknowledged for technical support at Ulm University. Finally, we thank the Ministry of Research and Technology of Indonesia (RISTEK) and the Lore Lindu National Park in Central Sulawesi for the research opportunity.

Author Contributions

Conceived and designed the experiments: MS SJ. Performed the experiments: MS SB SJ. Analyzed the data: MS SB SJ. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: MS SB AT SJ. Wrote the paper: MS AT TW SJ. Obtained permission for field work and research permits: MS AT.

References

  1. 1. Hutchinson GE. The biogeochemistry of aluminum and of certain related elements. Q Rev Biol. 1943;18: 1–29.
  2. 2. Radlkofer L. Über Tonerdekörper in Pflanzenzellen. Ber Dtsch Bot Ges. 1904;22: 216–24.
  3. 3. Hutchinson GE. Aluminum in soils, plants and animals. Soil Sci. 1945;60: 29–40.
  4. 4. Von Faber FC. Untersuchungen über die Physiologie der javanischen Solfataren-Pflanzen. Flora. 1925;118: 89–110.
  5. 5. Chenery EM. Aluminium in the plant world—Part I. General survey in dicotyledons. Kew Bull. 1948;2: 173–83.
  6. 6. Chenery EM. Aluminium in the plant world—Part II. Monocotyledons and gymnosperms. Kew Bull. 1949;4: 463–73.
  7. 7. Webb LJ. Aluminium accumulation in the Australian-New Guinea flora. Aust J Bot. 1954;2: 176–97.
  8. 8. Driessen F. Étude sur le rouge Turc (Ancien procédé). Rev Gén Mat Color. 1902;6: 252–9.
  9. 9. Hutchinson GE, Wollack A. Biological accumulators of aluminum. Trans Conn Acad Arts Sci. 1943;35: 73–128.
  10. 10. Burkill IH. A dictionary of the economic products of the Malay Peninsula Vols. I and II. Kuala Lumpur: Minstry of Agriculture Malaysia; 2002.
  11. 11. Lemmens RHMJ, Wulijarni-Soetijipto N, editors. Dye and tannin-producing plants (Prosea 3): No 3 (PROSEA—plant ressources of South East Asia). Kerkwerve, The Netherlands: Backhuys Publishers; 1992.
  12. 12. Cunningham AB, Maduarta IM, Howe J, Ingram W, Jansen S. Hanging by a thread: Natural metallic mordant processes in traditional Indonesian textiles. Econ Bot. 2011;65: 241–59.
  13. 13. Jansen S, Broadley MR, Robbrecht E, Smets E. Aluminum hyperaccumulation in angiosperms: A review of its phylogenetic significance. Bot Rev. 2002;68: 235–69.
  14. 14. Watanabe T, Broadley MR, Jansen S, White PJ, Takada J, Satake K, et al. Evolutionary control of leaf element composition in plants. New Phytol. 2007; 174: 516–23. pmid:17447908
  15. 15. Metali F, Salim KA, Burslem DFRP. Evidence of foliar aluminium accumulation in local, regional and global datasets of wild plants. New Phytol. 2012;139: 637–49.
  16. 16. Maejima E, Hiradate S, Jansen S, Osaki M, Watanabe T. Comparative analysis of aluminum accumulation in leaves of three angiosperm species. Botany. 2014;92: 327–31.
  17. 17. Pogue AI, Lukiw WJ. The mobilization of aluminum into the biosphere. Front Neurol. 2014;5: 1–4.
  18. 18. Kochian LV, Piñeros MA, Hoekenga OA. The physiology, genetics and molecular biology of plant aluminum resistance and toxicity. Plant Soil. 2005;274: 175–95.
  19. 19. Kinraide TB. Identity of the rhizotoxic aluminium species. Plant Soil. 1991;134: 167–78.
  20. 20. Kinraide TB. Reconsidering the rhizotoxicity of hydroxyl, sulphate, and fluoride complexes of aluminium. J Exp Bot. 1997;48: 1115–24.
  21. 21. Von Uexküll HR, Mutert E. Global extent, development and economic impact of acid soils. Plant Soil. 1995;171: 1–15.
  22. 22. Ma JF, Hiradate S, Nomoto K, Iwashita T, Matsumoto H. Internal detoxification mechanism of Al in Hydrangea. Plant Physiol. 1997;113: 1033–9. pmid:12223659
  23. 23. Ma JF, Zheng SJ, Matsumoto H. Detoxifying aluminium with buckwheat. Nature. 1997;390: 569–70.
  24. 24. Watanabe T, Osaki M, Yoshihara T, Tadano T. Distribution and chemical speciation of aluminum in the Al accumulator plant, Melastoma malabathricum L. Plant Soil. 1998;201: 165–73.
  25. 25. Watanabe T, Misawa S, Osaki M. Aluminum accumulation in the roots of Melastoma malabathricum, an aluminum-accumulating plant. Can J Bot. 2005;83: 1518–22.
  26. 26. Metali F, Salim KA, Tennakoon K, Burslem DFRP. Controls on foliar nutrient and aluminium concentrations in a tropical tree flora: phylogeny, soil chemistry and interactions among elements. New Phytol. 2014;205: 280–92. pmid:25138655
  27. 27. Baker AJM. Accumulators and excluders—Strategies in the response of plants to heavy metals. J Plant Nutr. 1981;3: 643–54.
  28. 28. Poschenrieder C, Benet G, Corrales I, Barcelo J. A glance into aluminum toxicity and resistance in plants. Sci Total Environ. 2008;400: 356–68. pmid:18657304
  29. 29. Brunner I, Sperisen C. Aluminum exclusion and aluminum tolerance in woody plants. Front Plant Sci. 2013;4: 1–12.
  30. 30. Kochian LV, Piñeros MA, Liu J, Magalhaes J V. Plant adaptation to acid soils: The molecular basis for crop aluminum resistance. Annu Rev Plant Biol. 2015;66: 571–98. pmid:25621514
  31. 31. Grevenstuk T, Romano A. Aluminium speciation and internal detoxification mechanisms in plants: where do we stand? Metallomics. 2013;5: 1584–94. pmid:24185904
  32. 32. Ma JF, Ryan PR, Delhaize E. Aluminium tolerance in plants and the complexing role of organic acids. Trends Plant Sci. 2001;6: 273–8. pmid:11378470
  33. 33. Watanabe T, Osaki M. Influence of aluminum and phosphorus on growth and xylem sap composition in Melastoma malabathricum L. Plant Soil. 2001;237: 63–70.
  34. 34. Klug B, Horst WJ. Oxalate exudation into the root-tip water free space confers protection from aluminum toxicity and allows aluminum accumulation in the symplast in buckwheat (Fagopyrum esculentum). New Phytol. 2010;187: 380–91. pmid:20487309
  35. 35. Ma JF, Hiradate S, Matsumoto H. High aluminum resistance in buckwheat II. Oxalic acid detoxifies aluminum internally. Plant Physiol. 1998;117: 753–9. pmid:9662518
  36. 36. Ma JF, Hiradate S. Form of aluminium for uptake and translocation in buckwheat (Fagopyrum esculentum Moench). Planta. 2000;211: 355–60. pmid:10987553
  37. 37. Watanabe T, Jansen S, Osaki M. The beneficial effect of aluminium and the role of citrate in Al accumulation in Melastoma malabathricum. New Phytol. 2005;165: 773–80. pmid:15720688
  38. 38. Haridasan M. Nutritional adaptations of native plants of the cerrado biome in acid soils. Braz J Plant Physiol. 2008;20: 183–95.
  39. 39. Ma JF. Syndrome of aluminum toxicity and diversity of aluminum resistance in higher plants. Int Rev Cytol. 2007;264: 225–52 pmid:17964924
  40. 40. Watanabe T, Jansen S, Osaki M. Al–Fe interactions and growth enhancement in Melastoma malabathricum and Miscanthus sinensis dominating acid sulphate soils. Plant Cell Environ. 2006;29: 2124–33. pmid:17081246
  41. 41. Haridasan M. Distribution and mineral nutrition of aluminium-accumulating species in different plant communities of the cerrado region of central Brazil. In: San José JJ, Montes R, editors. La Capacidad Bioproductiva de Sabanas. I.V.I.C., Caracas, Venezuela; 1987. pp. 309–48.
  42. 42. Masunaga T, Kubota D, Hotta M, Wakatsuki T. Nutritional characteristics of mineral elements in leaves of tree species in tropical rain forest, West Sumatra, Indonesia. Soil Sci Plant Nutr. 1998;44: 315–29.
  43. 43. Boyd RS. The defense hypothesis of elemental hyperaccumulation: status, challenges and new directions. Plant Soil. 2007;293: 153–76.
  44. 44. Martens SN, Boyd RS. The defensive role of Ni hyperaccumulation by plants: A field experiment. Am J Bot. 2002;89: 998–1003. pmid:21665699
  45. 45. Freeman JL, Quinn CF, Lindblom SD, Klamper EM, Pilon-Smits EAH. Selenium protects the hyperaccumulator Stanleya pinnata against black-tailed prairie dog herbivory in native seleniferous habitats. Am J Bot. 2009;96: 1075–85. pmid:21628258
  46. 46. Jansen S, Watanabe T, Caris P, Geuten K, Lens F, Pyck N, et al. The distribution and phylogeny of aluminium accumulating plants in the Ericales. Plant Biol. 2004;6: 498–505. pmid:15248133
  47. 47. Yoshii Y, Jimbo T. Mikrochemischer Nachweis von Aluminium und sein Vorkommen im Pflanzenreiche. Sci Rep Tôhoku Imp Univ. 1932;7: 65–77.
  48. 48. Medina E, Silva JF. Savannas of northern South America: a steady state regulated by water-fire interactions on a background of low nutrient availability. J Biogeogr. 1990;17: 403–13.
  49. 49. Medeiros RA de, Haridasan M. Seasonal variations in the foliar concentrations of nutrients in some aluminium accumulating and non-accumulating species of the cerrado region of central Brazil. Plant Soil. 1985;88: 433–6.
  50. 50. Watanabe T, Osaki M, Tadano T. Aluminum-induced growth stimulation in relation to calcium, magnesium, and silicate nutrition in Melastoma malabathricum L. Soil Sci Plant Nutr. 1997;43: 827–37.
  51. 51. Culmsee H, Pitopang R, Mangopo H, Sabir S. Tree diversity and phytogeographical patterns of tropical high mountain rain forests in Central Sulawesi, Indonesia. Biodivers Conserv. 2011;20: 1103–23.
  52. 52. Culmsee H, Pitopang R. Tree diversity in sub-montane and lower montane primary rain forests in Central Sulawesi. Blumea. 2009;54: 119–23.
  53. 53. Matsumoto H, Hirasawa E, Morimura S, Takahashi E. Localization of aluminium in tea leaves. Plant Cell Physiol. 1976;17: 627–31.
  54. 54. Barberon M, Geldner N. Radial transport of nutrients: The plant root as a polarized epithelium. Plant Physiol. 2014;166: 528–37. pmid:25136061
  55. 55. Nguyen NT, Nakabayashi K, Thompson J, Fujita K. Role of exudation of organic acids and phosphate in aluminum tolerance of four tropical woody species. Tree Physiol. 2003;23: 1041–50. pmid:12975128
  56. 56. Jansen S. Aluminium accumulation in leaves of 127 species in Melastomataceae, with comments on the order Myrtales. Ann Bot. 2002;90: 53–64. pmid:12125773
  57. 57. Zeng QL, Chen RF, Zhao XQ, Shen RF, Noguchi A, Shinmachi F, et al. Aluminum could be transported via phloem in Camellia oleifera Abel. Tree Physiol. 2013;33: 96–105. pmid:23192975
  58. 58. Tolrà R, Vogel-Mikuš K, Hajiboland R, Kump P, Pongrac P, Kaulich B, et al. Localization of aluminium in tea (Camellia sinensis) leaves using low energy X-ray fluorescence spectro-microscopy. J Plant Res. 2011;124: 165–72. pmid:20422247
  59. 59. Marschner H, Romheld V, Cakmak I. Root-induced changes of nutrient availability in the rhizosphere. J Plant Nutr. 1987;10: 1175–84.
  60. 60. Rengel Z. Availability of Mn, Zn and Fe in the rhizosphere. J Soil Sci Plant Nutr. 2015;15: 397–409.
  61. 61. Kochian LV, Hoekenga O a, Pineros M a. How do crop plants tolerate acid soils? Mechanisms of aluminum tolerance and phosphorous efficiency. Ann Rev Plant Biol. 2004;55: 459–93.
  62. 62. Mundim FM, Costa AN, Vasconcelos HL. Leaf nutrient content and host plant selection by leaf-cutter ants, Atta laevigata, in a neotropical savanna. Entomol Exp Appl. 2009;130: 47–54.
  63. 63. Akashi N, Nakashizuka T. Effects of bark-stripping by Sika deer (Cervus nippon) on population dynamics of a mixed forest in Japan. For Ecol Manage. 1999;113: 75–82.
  64. 64. Baker AJM, McGrath SP, Reeves RD, Smith JAC. Metal hyperaccumulator plants: A review of the ecology and physiology of a biological resource for phytoremediation of metal-polluted soils. In: Terry N, Banuelos G, editors. Phytoremediation of contaminated soil and water. Boca Raton, FL, USA: Lewis Publishers; 2000. pp. 85–107.
  65. 65. Reeves RD, Baker AJM. Metal-accumulating plants. In: Raskin I, Ensley BD, editors. Phytoremediation of Toxic Metals: Using Plants to Clean Up the Environment. New York, NY, USA: John Wiley; 1999. pp. 193–229.
  66. 66. Meharg AA. Arsenic and old plants. New Phytol. 2002;156: 1–8.
  67. 67. Meharg AA. Variation in arsenic accumulation–Hyperaccumulation in ferns and their allies. New Phytol. 2003;157: 25–31.
  68. 68. Kochian LV, Pence NS, Letham DLD, Pineros MA, Jurandir V, Hoekenga OA, et al. Mechanisms of metal resistance in plants : Aluminum and heavy metals. Plant Soil. 2002;247: 109–19.
  69. 69. Serrano HC, Antunes C, Pinto MJ, Maguas C, Martins-Loucao MA, Branquinho C. The ecological performance of metallophyte plants thriving in geochemical islands is explained by the Inclusive Niche Hypothesis. J Plant Ecol. 2014;8: 41–50.
  70. 70. Colwell RK, Rangel TF. Hutchinson‘s duality : The once and future niche. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009;106: 19651–8. pmid:19805163
  71. 71. Haridasan M, Monteiro de Araújo G. Aluminium-accumulating species in two forest communities in the cerrado region of central Brazil. For Ecol Manage. 1988;24: 15–26.
  72. 72. Rehmus A, Bigalke M, Valarezo C, Castillo JM, Wilcke W. Aluminum toxicity to tropical montane forest tree seedlings in southern Ecuador: response of biomass and plant morphology to elevated Al concentrations. Plant Soil. 2014;382: 301–15.
  73. 73. Huang JW, Grunes DL, Kochian L V. Aluminum effects on the kinetics of calcium uptake into cells of the wheat root apex. Planta. 1992;188: 414–21. pmid:24178332
  74. 74. Fung KF, Carr HP, Zhang J, Wong MH. Growth and nutrient uptake of tea under different aluminium concentrations. J Sci Food Agric. 2008;88: 1582–91.
  75. 75. Wehnert A. Anatomisch-systematische Untersuchung der Blätter der Gattung “Symplocos.”Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München; 1906.
  76. 76. Mazen AMA. Calcium oxalate deposits in leaves of Corchorus olitorius as related to accumulation of toxic metals. Russ J Plant Physiol. 2004;51: 281–5.
  77. 77. Kirkby EA, Pilbeam DJ. Calcium as a plant nutrient. Plant Cell Environ. 1984;7: 397–405.
  78. 78. Barceló J, Poschenrieder C. Fast root growth responses, root exudates, and internal detoxification as clues to the mechanisms of aluminium toxicity and resistance: a review. Environ Exp Bot. 2002;48: 75–92.