Advertisement
Browse Subject Areas
?

Click through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in your field.

For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click here.

  • Loading metrics

Comparative Transcriptome Analysis Reveals Cool Virulence Factors of Ralstonia solanacearum Race 3 Biovar 2

  • Fanhong Meng,

    Current address: Department of Plant Pathology and Microbiology, Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas, 77843, United States of America

    Affiliation Department of Plant Pathology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, 53706, United States of America

  • Lavanya Babujee,

    Current address: Genome Center of Wisconsin, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, 53706, United States of America

    Affiliation Department of Plant Pathology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, 53706, United States of America

  • Jonathan M. Jacobs,

    Current address: Institut de Recherche pour le Développement, 34394, Montpellier, France

    Affiliation Department of Plant Pathology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, 53706, United States of America

  • Caitilyn Allen

    cza@plantpath.wisc.edu

    Current address: Department of Plant Pathology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, 53706, United States of America

    Affiliation Department of Plant Pathology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, 53706, United States of America

Comparative Transcriptome Analysis Reveals Cool Virulence Factors of Ralstonia solanacearum Race 3 Biovar 2

  • Fanhong Meng, 
  • Lavanya Babujee, 
  • Jonathan M. Jacobs, 
  • Caitilyn Allen
PLOS
x

Abstract

While most strains of the plant pathogenic bacterium Ralstonia solanacearum are tropical, the race 3 biovar 2 (R3bv2) subgroup attacks plants in cooler climates. To identify mechanisms underlying this trait, we compared the transcriptional profiles of R. solanacearum R3bv2 strain UW551 and tropical strain GMI1000 at 20°C and 28°C, both in culture and during tomato pathogenesis. 4.2% of the ORFs in the UW551 genome and 7.9% of the GMI1000 ORFs were differentially expressed by temperature in planta. The two strains had distinct transcriptional responses to temperature change. GMI1000 up-regulated several stress response genes at 20°C, apparently struggling to cope with plant defenses. At the cooler temperature, R3bv2 strain UW551 up-regulated a cluster encoding a mannose-fucose binding lectin, LecM; a quorum sensing-dependent protein, AidA; and a related hypothetical protein, AidC. The last two genes are absent from the GMI1000 genome. In UW551, all three genes were positively regulated by the adjacent SolI/R quorum sensing system. These temperature-responsive genes were required for full virulence in R3bv2. Mutants lacking lecM, aidA, or aidC were each significantly more reduced in virulence on tomato at 20°C than at 28°C in both a naturalistic soil soak inoculation assay and when they were inoculated directly into tomato stems. The lecM and aidC mutants also survived poorly in potato tubers at the seed tuber storage temperature of 4°C, and the lecM mutant was defective in biofilm formation in vitro. Together, these results suggest novel mechanisms, including a lectin, are involved in the unique temperate epidemiology of R3bv2.

Introduction

Ralstonia solanacearum is a soil-borne pathogen that causes bacterial wilt disease on more than 200 plant species, including important crops such as potato, tomato, eggplant, pepper, tobacco and banana [1]. The bacterium normally invades plant roots from the soil and spreads up into the stem and leaves through the host vascular system. It multiplies rapidly in the xylem vessels, reaching cell densities >109 cfu g−1 of host tissue. Bacterial wilt is considered the single most destructive bacterial plant disease because of its aggressiveness, wide geographic distribution, and unusually broad host range [2]. Many virulence factors contribute to wilt disease development, including plant cell wall-degrading enzymes, bacterial extracellular polysaccharide (EPS), and a consortium of type III-secreted effectors [3]. These are regulated by a complex cascade that responds to unknown plant signal(s) and to cell density or confinement [4]. The role of temperature and other environmental signals in regulation of virulence factors has not been studied in R. solanacearum.

Most R. solanacearum strains cause disease in tropical to warm temperate environments, but a phenotypically and genetically homogenous subgroup of phylotype IIB, historically and for regulatory purposes known as Race 3 biovar 2 (R3bv2), is adapted to cooler environments and causes brown rot of potatoes in the highland tropics [5]. Brown rot is a major constraint to potato production in cool temperate climates worldwide, causing an estimated $950 million in losses each year [6]. R3bv2 can also infect tomato, geranium, and many weeds and wild plants [5]. Extensive field research documents that R3bv2 can cause disease at much cooler temperatures than tropical or subtropical R. solanacearum strains [7,8]. However, the mechanisms underlying this distinctive ecological trait are not understood.

R3bv2 and tropical strains have similar growth rates in culture at 20°C and 28°C and survive in comparable numbers in water at 4°C [9]. However, R3bv2 strain UW551 does survive longer in potato tubers at 4°C and is much more virulent on tomato at 20°C than tropical strains such as GMI1000 [9]. This suggests that the success of R3bv2 in temperate climates is mediated by interaction with host plants.

R3bv2 strains apparently originated in the cool Andean highlands [10,11]. R3bv2 has been accidentally introduced to North America and Europe via infected geranium cuttings imported from highland tropical areas, where the pathogen is endemic [1215]. To date, R3bv2 is not established in North America. However, R3bv2 strains have survived for years in temperate European waterways in the weed host Solanum dulcamara, which sheds pathogen cells into surface water, triggering potato brown rot outbreaks [1619]. Because of fears that R3bv2 may be able to overwinter and become established in American potato-growing regions, R3bv2 is listed as a U.S. Select Agent pathogen [20]. However, history suggests that quarantines often eventually fail [2123]. Insights into the mechanisms of cool virulence in R3bv2 are needed to shape rational disease mitigation strategies.

R. solanacearum strains form a heterogenous species complex. Several strains have been sequenced, including GMI1000, a tropical strain belonging to the Asian phylotype I, sequevar 18 [24], and UW551, a typical cool virulent R3bv2 strain that belongs to American phylotype IIB, sequevar 1 [25]. Although both cause bacterial wilt disease of tomato, these two strains are quite evolutionarily divergent, with an average nucleotide identity around 91% [26]. Nonetheless, the synteny between the UW551 and GMI1000 genomes is 71%, and genes encoding most known bacterial wilt virulence determinants and regulators are highly conserved [25,27]. Comparison of the UW551 and GMI1000 genome sequences did not identify any differences in gene repertoire obviously linked to cold tolerance [25]. This suggested that the phenotypic differences in cold adaptation between R3bv2 and non-R3bv2 strains could be caused by genes of unknown function, or by differential regulation of orthologous genes [25].

To further explore this phenomenon, we used comparative transcriptome analysis to identify molecular mechanisms potentially involved in the cool virulence of R3bv2. We found that a small set of genes was differentially expressed by temperature in UW551 and GMI1000 during pathogenesis. There was little overlap between the temperature-responsive genesets in the two strains, suggesting that they have distinct responses to temperature. Mutational analysis revealed that several genes differentially expressed by temperature contributed significantly to the cool virulence of R3bv2, including a mannose-fucose binding lectin and two quorum sensing-regulated genes of unknown function.

Results

To better understand the cool virulence mechanisms of R. solanacearum R3bv2, we profiled the transcriptomes of two biologically distinct strains of this pathogen, tropical strain GMI1000 and R3bv2 strain UW551, during pathogenesis of tomato plants at tropical (28°C) and temperate (20°C) temperatures. We also profiled the transcriptomes of both strains during growth in culture at the two temperatures. Because quorum sensing affects expression of several R. solanacearum virulence factors, we extracted RNA from bacteria at the same cell density under all conditions, ~6x108 CFU g−1 or ml−1, when the bacterium’s quorum sensing systems should be active [28]. Four biological replicates of each strain were assayed for each of the four conditions, using whole genome microarray chips custom-designed for each strain. The experiments were highly reproducible, with average correlation coefficients across the in planta biological replicates of 0.978 and 0.933 for UW551 at 20°C and 28°C, and 0.96 and 0.948 for GMI1000 at 20°C and 28°C.

Overview of genes differentially expressed (DE) by temperature

Temperature did not affect the expression of most genes in the two strains (Fig 1). Scatter plots showing mean signal intensities of all genes in UW551 and GMI1000 at 20°C and 28°C in planta had very high correlation coefficients (0.93 for UW551 and 0.91 for GMI1000) (S1 Fig). The in culture transcriptomes of both strains were also highly correlated at the two temperatures (data not shown). We used an EB-LNN critical threshold of 0.01 and a two-fold difference in expression to define differentially expressed (DE) genes. The differential expression of selected genes was confirmed with qPCR analysis of the same RNA samples used for the microarray analysis (S1 Table). In planta, tropical strain GMI1000 had more genes DE by temperature than temperate strain UW551. Overall, 4.2% of UW551 genes (181 of 4318) were DE by temperature in planta (S2 Table), and 3.2% (137 genes) were DE in culture (S3 Table). In strain GMI1000, 7.9% of genes (398 of 5061) were DE by temperature in planta (S4 Table), and 1.8% (89 genes) were DE in culture (S5 Table). There was little overlap between the GMI1000 and UW551 genesets that were DE by temperature in planta and in culture (S2 Fig), indicating that the tropical and temperate strains had distinct transcriptional responses to low temperature under the two experimental conditions. A COG analysis did not identify any noteworthy patterns, with the majority of DE genes in the ‘unassigned’ or ‘unknown function’ categories in all four conditions. Since responses in the host plant environment are most relevant to R. solanacearum biology, the following analysis focuses on the in planta data, unless otherwise noted.

thumbnail
Fig 1. Scatter plot of log2 expression ratio for orthologous genes at 20°C compared to 28°C in planta.

The orthologs shared between UW551 and GMI1000 were divided into five groups based on expression pattern. Gray dots in the middle represent orthologs not differentially expressed by temperature in either strain; symbols in colors represent orthologs differentially expressed in at least one strain. Each symbol represents one ortholog.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.g001

Genomes of UW551 and GMI1000 share 3477 orthologous genes, and there are 816 strain-specific genes in UW551 and 1381 strain-specific genes in GMI1000 [29]. Most of the orthologs were not DE by temperature: only 3.3% (115 genes) in UW551 and 7.5% (263 genes) in GMI1000. There was minimal overlap between orthologs that were DE in both strains at low temperature, including 36 genes with congruent expression patterns and 3 genes with divergent expression patterns. These common DE genes included 24 from the R. solanacearum species complex Core Genome, as defined by analyses of 18 strains from all four phylotypes [27]. Genes encoding known bacterial wilt virulence factors like EPS, pectinases, and swimming and twitching motility were not DE by temperature in either strain, although several genes involved in Type 3 secretion were slightly upregulated at 20°C in both strains. Among the strain-specific genes, 66 (8.1%) were differentially expressed in UW551 and 135 (9.8%) were differentially expressed in GMI1000. In both strains, strain-specific genes were more often differentially expressed than orthologs in response to cool temperature, suggesting that UW551 and GMI1000 have fundamentally different responses to temperate conditions. This divergence could reflect distinct, independently evolved responses to chilling, and may offer useful clues to understanding the cool virulence trait of R3bv2 strains.

Several stress and defense-related pathways were up-regulated at cool temperatures in tropical strain GMI1000

The R. solanacearum nag gene cluster, which putatively encodes degradation of the potent plant defense signal molecule salicylic acid, was also up-regulated in GMI1000 at 20°C (S6 Table). In addition, at the lower temperature GMI1000 had 3- to 6-fold higher expression of the genes encoding degradation of plant phenolic hydroxycinnamic acids (S3 Fig). Finally, several genes putatively or known to be involved in toxin efflux were more highly expressed in tropical strain GMI1000 during pathogenesis at 20°C than at 28°C (S7 Table). Collectively, this expression profile suggests that infecting a plant at cool temperatures is stressful for this tropical pathogen.

R3bv2 genes induced by cool temperature

Genes encoding the SolI/R quorum sensing system were differentially up-regulated at 20°C relative to 28°C in temperate strain UW551 in culture, indicating that their expression is responsive to low temperature (Fig 2). An adjacent gene cluster, which was upregulated at 20°C both in culture and in planta, encodes LecM, a mannose-fucose binding lectin, and AidA and AidC, two proteins of unknown function. The GMI1000 genome does not contain either aidA or aidC, and GMI1000’s lecM homolog was not differentially expressed by temperature. We confirmed the microarray expression results for lecM, aidA, and aidC by measuring their expression in culture at both temperatures using quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR). For each gene, the expression trend was consistent between microarray and qPCR, although qPCR indicated a higher fold-induction (S1 Table), probably due to the higher sensitivity of the method. These results suggested that this region could be involved in cool virulence and thus warranted further study.

thumbnail
Fig 2. A cluster of genes adjacent to those encoding the SolI/R quorum sensing system were up-regulated in R. solanacearum strain UW551 at 20°C, in culture.

Some were also upregulated in planta. Arrows represent open reading frames. The numbers above the arrows indicate the expression fold-change for each gene at 20°C compared to 28°C, in culture/in planta, determined by whole-genome microarray analysis as described in the text. The arrangement and expression levels of the corresponding genes in strain GMI1000 are also shown.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.g002

Mutation of lecM, aidA, or aidC differentially reduced UW551 virulence at 20°C

To test the hypothesis that genes in the lectin region contribute to the cool virulence of UW551, we generated deletion mutant strains UW551ΔlecM, UW551ΔaidA, and UW551ΔaidC, as well as a UW551ΔsolI mutant. qPCR analysis of cDNA from the mutants confirmed that there was no detectable expression of the deleted gene in each mutant. All the mutants grew indistinguishably from wild type in rich broth culture and in tomato leaves at both 20°C and 28°C, indicating that their phenotypes were not the result of a growth defect in culture or in planta. We measured the virulence of mutants on tomato plants using a biologically representative soil-soak inoculation that requires bacteria to actively find and invade unwounded host plant roots from the soil. At 28°C, UW551ΔlecM was almost as virulent as its wild type parent, while UW551ΔaidA and UW551ΔaidC had slight virulence defects. In contrast, at 20°C, all three mutants were significantly reduced in virulence relative to wild type (Fig 3). We quantified this differential virulence by comparing the area under the disease progress curve (AUDPC) for each strain at both temperatures to that of wild type. Strains lacking lecM, aidA, or aidC caused significantly less disease under temperate conditions (P<0.01). For example, at 28°C the AUDPC of UW551ΔlecM was 96% of wild type, but it was only 72% of wild type at 20°C (Fig 3E). All three mutants were also significantly reduced in virulence when they were inoculated directly into the tomato xylem via a cut leaf petiole (Fig 3F, P< 0.01, repeated measures ANOVA), indicating that R3bv2 strain UW551 requires lecM, aidA, and aidC for mid-stage bacterial wilt disease virulence, and not only for early infection. Together, these results demonstrate that lecM, aidA, and aidC encode functions necessary for cool virulence of UW551.

thumbnail
Fig 3. Mutation of R. solanacearum strain UW551 lecM, aidA, or aidC but not solI differentially reduced bacterial virulence at 20°C.

Virulence was measured on wilt-susceptible tomato plants at 20°C and 28°C via soil soak inoculation (A-E) or at 20°C via cut petiole inoculation (F). Each point represents the mean of three biological replicates, each containing 16 plants per strain per temperature. The area under disease progress curve (AUDPC) was measured for each strain in A-C and each mutant’s AUDPC relative to wild type is shown (E). Asterisks indicate that virulence of wild type and mutant strains were significantly different (* P< 0.05, ** P< 0.01, ANOVA). Each mutant was also significantly reduced in virulence (P< 0.01, repeated measures ANOVA) compared to the wild type following cut petiole inoculation (F).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.g003

Lectin-specific sugars inhibited R. solanacearum attachment to tomato roots

Lectins, which are carbohydrate-binding proteins, play important roles in cell–cell interactions, including microbial pathogenesis [30]. To test the hypothesis that LecM contributes to R. solanacearum adhesion to plants, we compared the ability of UW551 and the UW551ΔlecM mutant to attach to tomato seedling roots at 20°C, both separately and in a 1:1 competition assay. The lecM-deficient strain had no measurable defect in attachment in either condition. This could be the result of functional redundancy between LecM and LecX, the other mannose-fucose binding lectin encoded by the UW551 genome, especially since lecX was also strongly up-regulated in planta compared to its expression in CPG culture at the same temperature (Table 1).

thumbnail
Table 1. Expression of lectin genes in R. solanacearum strains GMI1000 and UW551 under various conditions.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.t001

LecM is 70% identical to LecB of the opportunistic human pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa; LecB contributes to P. aeruginosa virulence via involvement in biofilm formation, adhesion, host recognition, and inhibition of host defenses [31] [3234]. Patients infected by P. aeruginosa have been successfully treated with a solution of sugars specifically bound by its two lectins, LecA and LecB [35,36]. The sugars compete for and block the lectin sugar-binding sites, thus inhibiting bacterial attachment to host cells.

To determine if lectins have a similar function in R. solanacearum, we incubated strain UW551 in a solution of sugars that bind to its two lectins (LecM and LecX) to see if this would affect its ability to attach to plant roots. UW551 cells pre-incubated with 10 mM D-mannose and 10 mM L-fucose were significantly reduced in attachment to tomato roots compared with the untreated bacteria (1.5x107 cfu/g root as compared to 2.2x106 cfu/g root, P<0.01, t-test). Exposure to the sugar solution did not affect bacterial viability and a control treatment with 10 mM glucose had no effect on bacterial attachment.

LecM was required for biofilm formation in vitro

R. solanacearum forms biofilms on PVC plastic plates and biofilm-like aggregations on tomato seedling roots, although the biological significance of biofilms in this species is not known [37,38]. P. aeruginosa LecB specifically binds to cells in biofilms and contributes to biofilm formation. Exopolysaccharides are key components of microbial biofilms, and mannose, which is preferentially bound by both LecB and LecM, is a primary constituent of EPS from both P. aeruginosa and R. solanacearum [3941]. We therefore tested the hypothesis that LecM is involved in biofilm formation. On PVC microtiter plates, UW551ΔlecM formed 9.15-fold less biofilm than its wild type parent (P<0.01). Together, these results suggest that LecM may function both in attaching bacteria to host plant cells (adhesion), and in bacterial cell–cell binding in biofilms (cohesion).

LecM was required for normal host colonization

To measure the effect of LecM on bacterial success inside host plants, after the adhesion and entry stages, we quantified R. solanacearum population growth in stems of tomato inoculated directly into the xylem via a cut petiole with either UW551 or UW551ΔlecM and incubated at 20°C. Two days after inoculation, plants inoculated with wild type and UW551ΔlecM contained similar numbers of bacteria, with mean population sizes just over 1×106 cfu g−1. However, eight days after inoculation, the mean population size of UW551 in tomato stem was 2.83×1011 cfu g−1, more than 50-fold larger than that of UW551ΔlecM, which was 5x109 cfu g−1 (P<0.01). This result indicated that lecM contributes to xylem colonization by UW551. The colonization defect at day 8 corresponds to the difference in time of disease onset between wild type and UW551ΔlecM in the cut-petiole virulence assay (Fig 3F).

UW551ΔlecM and UW551ΔaidC survived poorly in potato tubers at 4°C

We previously found that R3bv2 strain UW551 survived much longer than non-R3bv2 strains in tubers of potato, a socioeconomically important natural host, at the common seed tuber storage temperature of 4°C [9]. We inoculated potato tubers with lecM and aidC mutants and measured their population sizes over time. As previously observed, tropical strain GMI1000 survived poorly in potato tubers at 4°C compared to UW551. At 6, 9 and 12 weeks after inoculation, the population sizes of UW551ΔlecM and UW551ΔaidC in tubers were around 5-fold lower than those of the wild type parent strain (Fig 4, P<0.05), indicating that LecM and AidC contribute to cold survival of UW551 as well as to temperate virulence.

thumbnail
Fig 4. UW551ΔlecM and UW551ΔaidC had reduced survival in potato tubers at 4°C.

Potato tubers were injected with different R. solanacearum strains, and bacterial cell numbers were counted by grinding and dilution plating tubers at different times after inoculation. The experiment was repeated three times, with three tubers per strain per time point. At 6, 9 and 12 weeks after inoculation, the population sizes of UW551ΔlecM and UW551ΔaidC in tubers were significantly lower than those of the wild type parent strain (P<0.05, ANOVA).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.g004

Adding the UW551 lectin region to GMI1000 did not confer cool virulence on GMI1000

Since aidA and aidC are not present in GMI1000 and there is some sequence variation between the two strains in this region, we tested the hypothesis that inserting the UW551 lecM cluster into a neutral site in the GMI1000 chromosome would increase its virulence in temperate conditions. However, neither a fragment containing the UW551 lecM, aidA, and aidC ORFs (plus 753 bp of upstream sequence) nor a larger fragment containing the UW551 lecM, aidA, aidC, soIR, and solI ORFs increased the virulence of GMI1000 at 20°C. This negative result suggests that either the necessary UW551-typical regulation of these genes did not occur in GMI1000, or that additional elements are required to confer cool virulence on non-R3bv2 strains.

LecM, AidA, and AidC are required for cool virulence in other R3bv2 strains

We attempted to complement each of these three mutations, first in trans on a low-copy number plasmid and then by insertion of single copies into the selectively neutral chromosomal att site. In all cases the merodiploid strains had pleiotropic phenotypes: they were hypermotile and several overproduced an acylhomoserine lactone quorum sensing signal molecule. We therefore used an alternative method to confirm that the insertions in the target genes were responsible for the cool virulence phenotypes we observed, and to demonstrate that this result was not unique to UW551. We independently recreated the lecM, aidA, and aidC mutations in two additional R3bv2 strains of R. solanacearum, UW553 and UW560. The resulting mutants did not have the pleiotropic phenotypes observed in the merodiploid “complemented” strains, nor did they have any growth defect compared to the wild type strains. We tested the virulence of these mutants at 20°C via soil-soak inoculation. Consistent with the findings in UW551, strain UW553 and UW560 mutants lacking lecM, aidA, or aidC had similarly reduced virulence at 20°C compared to their respective wild type parents (S4 Fig, P< 0.01, repeated measures ANOVA). These results confirmed that each of these genes is important for the temperate virulence of R3bv2 strains.

The lecM region is regulated by the SolI/R quorum sensing system

Since the lecM gene cluster is adjacent to the solI/R acyl-homoserine lactone (AHL) quorum sensing (QS) system, and aidA is controlled by solI/R [28], we used qRT-PCR to determine if other genes in this region were also regulated by SolI/R. When solI was deleted, transcription in culture of lecM, aidA, and aidC were all lower than in a wild-type background, although to differing degrees. Expression of lecM was 54.7-fold lower in UW551ΔsolI, while aidA expression was 31-fold lower and aidC was 2.2-fold lower. These results demonstrate that, at least in culture, lecM, aidA, and aidC are all positively regulated by the SolI/R QS system.

Discussion

We compared the transcriptional profiles of two ecologically distinct strains of a high-impact plant pathogen at different temperatures in culture and during disease in a natural host. There was only minimal overlap between the differentially expressed gene sets in culture and in planta for both temperate R3bv2 strain UW551 and tropical strain GMI1000, confirming our previous finding that R. solanacearum regulates gene expression very differently in vitro and in planta [29]. These results offer further evidence that data from in vitro studies do not reliably reflect pathogen behavior in vivo and therefore should be used and interpreted with caution [42].

This in planta comparative analysis yielded insights into ways that temperature has shaped two related pathogens. Changing the temperature of pathogenesis from a tropical 28°C to a cool temperate 20°C altered expression of relatively few genes in both R. solanacearum strains. Nonetheless, almost twice as many genes were differentially expressed at the lower temperature in GMI1000 than in UW551, and the number of genes up-regulated at 20°C in GMI1000 was almost three times greater than the number up-regulated in UW551. This was not unexpected, since UW551 is a successful pathogen at both temperate and tropical temperatures, and is thus well adapted to broad environmental parameters. When UW551 causes disease at 20°C, it alters expression of less than 5% of its genome relative to when it wilts tomato plants at 28°C. In contrast, tropical strain GMI1000 had a more significant transcriptional response to cool temperatures, including up-regulating diverse stress-related functions, possibly because it is not adapted to this condition.

The transcriptional response of prokaryotes to subtle yet physiologically relevant temperature changes is largely unexplored even for well-studied model organisms. Essentially nothing is known about traits required by phytopathogenic bacteria for successful pathogenesis at lower temperatures. Studies of bacterial adaptation to extreme low temperatures typically identify genes encoding cold shock proteins, membrane lipid desaturases, and molecular chaperones that stabilize proteins at near-freezing temperatures [4346]. However, none of these genes were differentially expressed by temperature in either R. solanacearum strain, possibly because our experiment did not expose bacteria to a sudden change in temperature. It is also likely that 20°C was not low enough to induce cold shock.

R. solanacearum strain GMI1000 is only weakly virulent on tomato at 20°C [9]. At this cool temperature, the tropical strain increased expression of diverse self-protective functions that were not up-regulated in temperate strain UW551 under the same condition. Like most bacteria, R. solanacearum strains have multiple toxin efflux pumps that confer tolerance of deleterious compounds and are often up-regulated as part of a generalized stress response [47,48]. We previously found that AcrAB, an RND family efflux pump, contributes to bacterial wilt virulence by protecting R. solanacearum from host antimicrobial compounds [49]. Genes encoding six toxin efflux pumps, including AcrAB, were differentially up-regulated during GMI1000 pathogenesis of tomato at 20°C, suggesting that this tropical R. solanacearum strain confronts toxic plant defenses in temperate conditions.

The nag genes, which encode degradation of the plant signaling molecule salicylic acid (SA) were also differentially up-regulated at 20°C in GMI1000. The SA defense pathway is activated during tomato resistance to R. solanacearum [50], and SA itself can directly reduce bacterial fitness and virulence factor production [51]. Elevated nag cluster expression may reflect a bacterial response to high SA levels in tomato plants infected by GMI1000 at 20°C. We previously found that at 28°C, GMI1000-infected tomato plants expressed SA defense genes faster and to a greater degree than plants infected with UW551 [52]. At 28°C, both GMI1000 and UW551 can successfully overcome SA-dependent defenses in tomato, and UW551 is still able to do this at 20°C. GMI1000 may increase expression of its SA degradation pathway at 20°C in an unsuccessful attempt to overcome SA-triggered plant defenses.

Finally, during pathogenesis at 20°C, GMI1000 differentially upregulated genes encoding degradation of hydroxycinnamic acids, which are major plant cell wall-reinforcing phenolic compounds that also have direct antimicrobial properties [5358]. R. solanacearum elicits production of cell-wall-bound phenolic compounds in tomato, and increased phenolic levels correlated with lower R. solanacearum population sizes [59,60]. Furthermore, we recently found that the ability to degrade hydroxycinnamic acids is required for full virulence of GMI1000 at 28°C [61]. The increased expression of the hydroxycinnamic acid degradation pathway at 20°C suggests that GMI1000 may confront higher levels of phenolics at cool temperatures, where it struggles to cause disease. Consistent with this idea, we observed that tomato plants infected by GMI1000 at 20°C exhibit extensive vascular browning, which is indicative of plant phenolic production. We speculate that, like resistant plants, tomatoes infected with GMI1000 at 20°C produce more phenolic compounds. This may help explain the strain’s weak virulence at this temperature.

Taken together, this expression profile suggests that GMI1000 confronts significant stress in tomato plants at 20°C, and it may up-regulate toxin efflux pumps and enzymes that degrade SA and phenolic compounds in an ineffectual attempt to overcome host defenses. Alternatively, GMI1000 and UW551 may experience similar levels of host defense under these conditions, but UW551 is better able to tolerate them.

A recent study that compared the proteomes of tropical and cool virulent R. solanacearum strains at 18°C and 30°C identified 101 proteins that were differentially expressed by temperature [62]. This proteomic analysis found that Type 3 secretion system structural protein HrcC is more abundant in cool virulent strains at the lower temperature, in agreement with our findings. However, the list of differentially expressed proteins did not generally correspond to the genes identified by our transcriptional analysis. This may reflect the slightly different temperatures used in the two studies (20/28°C vs. 18/30°C) or the differences between levels of protein and mRNA. It is more likely that the contrasting results of these two studies can be explained by their very different experimental designs. The proteomic analysis quantified proteins extracted from bacteria co-cultured with tomato seedlings in static liquid MS medium, whereas the transcriptomic study measured mRNA from bacteria extracted from the xylem vessels of diseased whole tomato plants. Thus, both the R. solanacearum strains and their host plants experienced significantly different physiological conditions in these two studies.

A separate study found that cool virulent strains exhibited reduced twitching motility, which is required for bacterial wilt virulence [63]. However, no known twitching motility genes were DE by temperature in either the cool virulent R3bv2 strain or tropical strain GMI1000. Again, the experimental conditions were not comparable; cool virulent strains may use twitching motility on solid surfaces like agar plates (or plant roots) but not in shaking broth culture or in tomato xylem, which were the two conditions we assayed here.

Three genes in a cluster that was up-regulated at 20°C in R3bv2 strain UW551 contributed significantly to cool virulence on tomato plants and to survival in potato tubers at 4°C. To our knowledge lecM, aidA, and aidC are the first genes known to be involved in temperature adaptation in plant pathogenic bacteria. However, their exact mechanisms of action remain to be determined. Our data suggest that the mannose/fucose binding lectin LecM increases pathogen attachment to other bacteria during biofilm formation. Pre-treatment of the bacterium with a solution of mannose and fucose reduced root attachment, which is indirect evidence that that lectins may also help R. solanacearum attach to host surfaces.

Binding affinities and crystal structures have been determined for three lectins from R. solanacearum, originally named RSL, RS-IIL, and RS20L, but their biological functions remain unknown. LecF (RSL), which is not present in UW551, preferably binds L-fucose [6466]. LecX (RS20L) binds L-fucose, D-mannose and D-xylose [67]. LecM (RS-IIL), which was significantly induced in UW551 at 20°C, binds D-mannose, L-fructose, L-fucose and D-arabinose [65]. These sugars are common constituents of plant cell wall polysaccharides [68,69].

Interestingly, all lectin genes from both strains were highly expressed under all conditions tested, although with differing expression patterns. Specifically, lecF and lecX were consistently highly expressed in GMI1000; indeed, their expression levels were so high that the chip may have been saturated, preventing detection of expression differences across conditions. In UW551, lecX was up-regulated in planta, but was not differentially expressed by temperature, and lecM was up-regulated in response to both growth in planta and low temperature. lecM was also induced in planta in GMI1000, though not by low temperature. The high expression levels of all lectin genes suggest these proteins are important for R. solanacearum fitness in planta. It would be interesting to determine the virulence of a triple mutant lacking all three lectin structural genes.

Plant lectins play important diverse roles in plant-microbe interactions [7073], but to our knowledge this is the first indication that bacterial lectins may contribute to pathogen attachment to plants. Our finding that lectin-specific sugars could inhibit attachment of UW551 cells to tomato roots is consistent with a novel role for R. solanacearum lectins in bacterial adherence to plant cells. Because the UW551ΔlecM mutant was significantly reduced in virulence even when it was introduced directly into the tomato xylem through a cut petiole, this lectin apparently also functions inside the plant, not only during initial root attachment.

The regulation of R. solanacearum lecM may resemble that of its P. aeruginosa homolog, lecB. Like lecM, lecB is controlled by quorum sensing, but lecB is additionally regulated by the alternative sigma factor RpoS [74]. Expression of R. solanacearum SolI/R depends on RpoS [75], so lecM may also be indirectly regulated by RpoS via quorum sensing. In addition, an in vitro microarray study found that in GMI1000 lecM is regulated by the global virulence transcriptional regulator HrpG [76]. The fact that lecM expression is controlled by several regulators suggests the importance of this protein to bacterial fitness.

AidA and AidC were previously wholly cryptic, but this work demonstrated that they both play significant roles in bacterial wilt virulence, contributing disproportionately at low temperatures. They are not, however, unique to cool-temperate R3bv2 strains of R. solanacearum. Although aidA and aidC are absent from African (phylotype III) and Asian (phylotype I) strains, they are present in tropical Indonesian phylotype IV strains and in tropical and warm-temperate phylotype II strains from North and South America, suggesting that their function extends beyond cool virulence [26]. The lecM-aidA-aidC gene order is retained in Burkholderia cenocepacia and Pseudomonas entomophila, although the gene sequences are not well conserved. The aidA gene was originally identified in R. solanacearum strain AW1 because it is regulated by the SolIR quorum sensing system [28]. An AidA homolog in Burkholderia cenocepacia contributes to slow killing of nematodes [77]. However, R. solanacearum AidA is not necessary for slow killing of nematodes and its function remains unknown [78]. AidC is about 24% identical to AidA at the amino acid level and its function is also unknown; aidC is located directly downstream of aidA in all R. solanacearum genomes that contain aidA.

The SolI/R quorum sensing system regulated expression of lecM, aidA, and aidC at 20°C in strain UW551. Consistent with a previous study of a solI mutant in R. solanacearum strain AW1 [28], we found that the UW551ΔsolI mutant had no virulence defect at either 20°C or 28°C. This might seem counterintuitive, since SolI/R positively regulates expression of lecM, aidA, and aidC, which were all required for virulence, especially at 20°C. Our microarrays and qPCR assays measured the transcription of R. solanacearum cells at densities higher than 1x108 cfu g−1, which is above the threshold for activation of the SolI/R regulatory system. However, expression of these genes was induced not only by quorum sensing but also by low temperature and by a condition or signal present in plants, so it is possible that lecM, aidA, and aidC are expressed in planta even in the absence of solIR. We and others previously showed that virulence traits controlled by another quorum sensing regulator, PhcA, are regulated very differently in culture and in planta [29,79]. It is also possible that inactivation of solIR did not affect virulence because of redundancy between the virulence-regulating quorum sensing systems in R. solanacearum. The AHL-responsive SolI/R autoinduction system in R. solanacearum is part of a more complex autoregulatory hierarchy. Expression of solR and solI requires PhcA, which is itself controlled by a second quorum sensing system that responds to 3-OH-PAME [28]. As mentioned above, solIR expression is additionally dependent on the alternate sigma factor RpoS [75].

Overall, these studies reveal that cool virulence is a complex multigenic trait in R. solanacearum. Unexpectedly, we found that a bacterial lectin contributes differentially to bacterial wilt virulence at lower temperatures. Our results generated diverse testable hypotheses for further laboratory and field studies and also identified biochemical pathways that plant breeders may be able to manipulate in tomato varieties to restrict growth of vascular pathogens and generate disease-resistant crops.

Materials and Methods

Bacterial strains and culture conditions

The bacterial strains used in this study are listed in S8 Table. R. solanacearum strains were grown at 28°C either in casamino acids-peptone-glucose (CPG) rich broth or on tetrazolium chloride (TZC) plates, as previously described [80]. Escherichia coli strains were grown in Luria-Bertani medium [81] at 37°C. Antibiotics were added when needed at the following concentrations: ampicillin, 50 mg l−1; kanamycin, 25 mg l−1; tetracycline, 12.5 mg l−1, and rifampin, 25 mg l−1. Unless otherwise noted, medium components were purchased from Difco Laboratories (Detroit, MI) and other chemicals were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (St. Louis, MO).

RNA extraction

For the in culture samples, RNA was extracted from 30 ml cultures of strains UW551 and GMI1000 grown in rich CPG broth to log phase (~6x108 cfu ml−1), using a modified hot-phenol extraction followed by four DNase treatments [82]. For the in planta samples, wilt-susceptible Bonny Best tomatoes were soil-soak inoculated at 28°C and 20°C with strain UW551 or strain GMI1000 as described for the virulence assay below. Before inoculation, roots of plants inoculated with GMI1000 at 20°C were disturbed by gently lifting the plant stem a few mm to increase numbers of symptomatic plants at this non-conducive temperature. Bacterial RNA was harvested from plants showing early wilting symptoms (disease index = 1, as described below). Since xylem vessels are the primary habitat of R. solanacearum during pathogenesis, we harvested bacteria from infected plants by centrifuging 7 cm sections of infected tomato stems at 13,500 g for 5 min in 15 ml conical tubes containing 3 ml transcriptional stop solution (95% ethanol, 5% phenol). The resulting bacterial pellet was stored at -80°C until the bacterial population size in the stem was confirmed by dilution plating a ground stem section. Pellets from stems colonized with 1x108 cfu g−1 to 1x109 cfu g−1 were pooled for RNA extraction by the hot phenol method. Absence of genomic DNA contamination in RNA was confirmed by PCR with R. solanacearum universal primers 759/760 [10]. Quality of RNA samples was assessed using Nanodrop and the Agilent Bioanalyzer 2100 nanochip system (Agilent Technologies). RNA samples with A260/A280 >2.0, A260/A230 >2.0, and RNA Integrity Number (RIN) >8 were used for microarray and qPCR analysis. We did four biological replicates for each condition of the microarray experiment.

Transcriptome analysis with microarrays

The custom-designed DNA microarrays used for transcriptional analysis of strains GMI1000 and UW551 were previously described [29]. Synthesis of cDNA, labeling, hybridization, and scanning were conducted as previously described [29]. NimbleScan 2.4 software was used to extract the raw data from the scanned images and compute expression values (gene calls) according to the Robust Multichip Average (RMA) algorithm [83]. Signals from the four biological replicates of each experiment were normalized using quantile normalization [84] with the RMA procedure in NimbleScan 2.4. To identify genes differentially expressed between 28°C and 20°C in each strain, an empirical Bayes analysis, EBArrays [85], was executed within the R statistical analysis software package and Bioconductor v2.1 [86]. In culture and in planta growth conditions from each strain's dataset were used to define two patterns: equivalent (1111,1111) and differential (1111,2222) expression. The posterior probability for each pattern was calculated using a hierarchical log-normal normal expression model with the conditional false discovery rate (cFDR) at 0.01 to determine the appropriate threshold (cFD(τ)). The critical thresholds for the datasets were: 0.937 and 0.927 for comparison of strain GMI1000 expression between the two temperatures in culture and in planta, respectively; and 0.944 and 0.941 for comparison of UW551 expression between the two temperatures in culture and in planta, respectively. Data were imported into a custom MicroSoft Access database and further analyzed using Microsoft Excel; scatter plots were generated using ArrayStar to visualize expression data within and across treatments. The raw microarray data and MIAME information are available as Accession E-GEOD–33662 on the EMBL European Bioinformatics Institute ArrayExpress Archive (http://www.ebi.ac.uk/arrayexpress/).

Quantitative RT-PCR (qPCR)

qPCR was performed as described [52] using an ABI PRISM 7300 Real-Time PCR System (Applied Biosystems, Foster, CA) with SYBR-Green chemistry. Based on observed stable expression in the microarrays under all conditions, three R. solanacearum genes, oxyR, rplM, and serC, were selected to normalize expression values for all other genes. The qPCR primer sequences are listed in S9 Table. Reaction parameters for qPCR were: 10 min polymerase activation, followed by 40 cycles of 95°C for 15 sec and 57°C for 1 min.

Comparative genomics

Orthologous (homologous) proteins between genomes were identified using BLAST-based methods. Orthologs were assigned to genes whose similarity scores and percent identity fell within cutoff values of >70% for pair-wise BLASTP searches. Whole genome alignments using Mauve v2.1 [87] allowed us to use gene context as an arbiter in cases where multiple paralogs were possible and to designate orthologs with improved specificity and precision. When true orthology was critical, downstream analyses were limited to high confidence datasets.

DNA manipulations

Cloning, restriction digestion, sequencing, and PCR were performed using standard methods [88]. R. solanacearum and E. coli were transformed by electroporation as previously described [89]. DNA sequencing and oligonucleotide synthesis were performed at the University of Wisconsin-Madison Biotechnology Center. DNA sequence was analyzed using the DNASTAR software package (DNASTAR, Inc., Madison, WI, U.S.A.). Unless otherwise noted, molecular biology reagents and kits were purchased from Promega (Madison, WI).

Mutant strain construction

Splicing by overlap extension PCR (SOE-PCR) was used to create in-frame deletion constructs using primers listed in S9 Table [90]. Deletion constructs were introduced into the chromosome of wild-type R. solanacearum strain UW551 by double homologous recombination as previously described [38] to create UW551ΔlecM, UW551ΔaidA, UW551ΔaidC and UW551ΔsolI, respectively. The correct allelic replacement in each mutant was confirmed by PCR and sequencing analyses. To generate GMI1000 strains carrying the putative cool virulence region from UW551, the 2,534-bp DNA fragment containing the lecM-aidA-aidC region plus 753bp of upstream of lecM or a 4,149-bp fragment containing the lecM-aidA-aidC-solR-solI region were amplified from UW551 genomic DNA using the PCR primer pairs Up lecM_ F/Com aidC _R and ComWhole _F/ComWhole _R, respectively, and cloned into the SmaI site of pUC18-mini-Tn7T-Gm [91]. The resulting products were introduced into strain GMI1000 at the selectively neutral attTn7 site 25bp downstream of the glmS gene [92] as described [93] and the correct integration was confirmed with PCR.

Natural transformation of R. solanacearum strains

Natural transformation was used to make mutants in strains UW551Rif, UW553 and UW560 as previously described [94] with some modifications. Briefly, recipient strains were grown to mid-log phase in CPG, pelleted, washed and resuspended in sterile water. Fifty microliters of competent bacterial cells were incubated for 24h with 500 ng of genomic DNA from donor strains carrying the desired mutations, and transformants were selected on CPG plates containing the appropriate antibiotics. The mutants were confirmed by PCR and sequencing analyses.

Virulence assays

To compare the virulence of R. solanacearum strains at different temperatures, we used a naturalistic soil soak inoculation and a more direct petiole inoculation of the wilt-susceptible tomato cv. Bonny Best, as previously described [95], except that half the plants were moved from 28°C to 20°C growth chambers one day after transplanting. For the soil soak assay, a bacterial suspension was poured onto the soil of pots that each contained an unwounded 16-day-old tomato plant to a final density of approximately 1x108 cfu g−1 soil. For the petiole inoculation, 2x103 bacteria in a 2μL volume were placed onto the freshly cut petiole of the first true leaf of a 21-day-old tomato plant. Plants were monitored daily for disease progress by a rater blind to treatment identity, and symptoms were scored on a 0-to–4 disease index, where 0 indicates no disease, 1 indicates 1 to 25% of leaves wilted, 2 indicates 26 to 50% of leaves wilted, 3 indicates 51 to 75% of leaves wilted, and 4 indicates 76 to 100% of leaves wilted. Each experiment contained a minimum of 16 plants per strain at each temperature, and experiments were repeated at least three times. The disease index for each day is the average of 48 plants from three experiments.

Multiplication of R. solanacearum strains in tomato leaves

To ensure that mutant strains had not lost the ability to multiply in the host, we measured growth of strains uniformly infused into tomato leaves. R. solanacearum cells grown overnight in CPG were collected by centrifugation, resuspended in water, adjusted to OD600 = 0.01, and infiltrated into fully expanded tomato leaves with a syringe. Plants were incubated at either 28°C or 20°C. Every 12 hours for three days, leaves were sampled with a #5 cork borer, three leaf discs were pooled, ground, and dilution plated on TZC medium to enumerate colony forming units cm−2 leaf tissue. The experiment was repeated three times, with at least six plants per strain per temperature.

Colonization of tomato stems by R. solanacearum strains

To measure bacterial colonization of tomato stems at 20°C, plants were inoculated with either the wild-type strain or the mutant using the cut petiole method as described above. Population sizes of each strain in tomato plants were quantified as described [38]. Briefly, at different time points after inoculation, five plants inoculated with each strain were randomly chosen and a 1 cm stem segment spanning the inoculation site was collected, weighed, and ground in 1 ml sterile deionized water. The resulting homogenate was dilution plated on TZC plates supplemented with 100 mg l−1 cycloheximide and appropriate antibiotics. R. solanacearum population sizes were determined as cfu g−1 of plant tissue. All experiments were repeated three times.

Measuring bacterial attachment to tomato roots

Attachment of R. solanacearum cells to tomato seedling roots was quantified as described [80]. Briefly, susceptible tomato cv. ‘Bonny Best’ seedlings were grown axenically on Murashige and Skoog medium with vitamins (Caisson Laboratories, North Logan, UT) for 2 weeks, when secondary roots were well developed. These were incubated with R. solanacearum cell suspensions in water (OD600 = 0.01) at 20°C for 1h. For competition studies, wild type and mutant cell suspensions were combined in a 1:1 ratio. Seedling roots were then rinsed with sterile water, blotted lightly on absorbent paper, excised, weighed, ground in sterile water and dilution plated on TZC to quantify total bacteria adhering to roots. Cell numbers were normalized to seedling root fresh weight. All experiments were repeated three times, with each replicate containing at least 10 roots per treatment. For the sugar inhibition attachment assay, R. solanacearum cells were prepared as described above, except they were resuspended either in sterile water or water containing 0.01M D-mannose and 0.01M L-fucose, or 0.01M glucose as a control, and incubated at room temperature for half an hour. The bacterial suspensions were then incubated with sterile tomato seedlings at 20°C for an hour as described above.

Biofilm assays

Production of biofilms by R. solanacearum strains was measured in vitro using a minor modification of the polyvinylchloride (PVC) microtiter plate assay [96]. Briefly, 5 μL overnight cultures of R. solanacearum adjusted to OD600 = 0.1 were used to inoculate 95 μL of CPG broth in wells of a PVC microtiter plate and incubated without shaking for 24h at 28°C. Biofilms were quantified by absorbance at 600nm following crystal violet staining.

Survival in potato tubers

We measured the survival of R. solanacearum strains in susceptible 15 to 17 mm potato minitubers (cv. ‘Russet Norkotah’, Sklarczyk Seed Farm, Johannesburg, MI) at the typical seed potato storage temperature of 4°C as previously described [9]. Briefly, both ends of each potato tuber were injected with 2 μL of 1x109 cfu ml−1 bacterial suspensions. Tubers were stored in the dark at 4°C and sampled at intervals. Tissue was weighed, ground, and dilution plated to determine cfu g−1. Survival rates were calculated based on triplicate experiments using two to three individual tubers per sampling time point. The detection limit was 1 log cfu g−1 potato tissue and a value of 1 log cfu g−1 was also used to report samples below the detection limit. Experiments were performed with rifampicin-resistant R. solanacearum strains to facilitate pathogen detection in the natural microbial background.

Supporting Information

S1 Fig. Scatter plots of expression levels of all R. solanacearum UW551 and GMI1000 at 20°C and 28°C during tomato pathogenesis.

Within each strain, gene expression was highly correlated at temperate and tropical temperatures. Scatter plots showing in planta mean signal intensities of genes in the genomes of UW551 (A) and GMI1000 (B) at 20°C and 28°C, as determined by whole-genome microarray analysis. Each dot represents a gene, and the log2 signal intensity for each gene shown is the average of four biological replicates.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s001

(PDF)

S2 Fig. Venn diagrams of R. solanacearum UW551 and GMI1000 genes differentially expressed by temperature in culture and during tomato pathogenesis.

A small number of genes were differentially expressed (DE) at 20°C compared to 28°C, with minimal overlap between those DE in culture and in planta. The numbers in the circles indicate the number of genes DE under different conditions (>2-fold difference in expression by EBArray analysis with the false discovery rate set at 0.01).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s002

(PDF)

S3 Fig. The R. solanacearum hydroxycinnamic acid degradation pathway and effect of cool temperature on its expression.

The hydroxycinnamic acid degradation pathway was up-regulated in R. solanacearum strain GMI1000 during tomato pathogenesis at 20°C. Above each arrow is shown the gene(s) encoding each enzyme, together with their expression level fold-changes at 20°C compared to 28°C in planta are shown above the arrows.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s003

(PDF)

S4 Fig. Virulence effects of mutating lecM, aidA, and aidC in two additional R3bv2 R. solanacearum strains.

Mutation of lecM, aidA, or aidA in R. solanacearum R3bv2 strains UW553 (A) and UW560 (B) resulted in significantly lower bacterial wilt virulence than the corresponding wild-type parent strain at 20°C (P< 0.01 by repeated measures ANOVA). Virulence was measured on wilt-susceptible tomato plants at 20°C via soil soak inoculation. The experiment was repeated twice, each replicate containing 16 plants per treatment per strain. Results from a representative experiment are shown.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s004

(PDF)

S1 Table. qPCR validation of expression levels for some R. solanacearum strain UW551 genes differentially expressed in the microarray analysis.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s005

(PDF)

S2 Table. R. solanacearum strain UW551 genes differentially expressed in planta at 20°C compared to 28°C.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s006

(PDF)

S3 Table. R. solanacearum strain UW551 genes differentially expressed in rich culture medium (CPG) at 20°C compared to 28°C.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s007

(PDF)

S4 Table. R. solanacearum strain GMI1000 genes differentially expressed in planta at 20°C compared to 28°C.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s008

(PDF)

S5 Table. R. solanacearum strain GMI1000 genes differentially expressed in rich culture medium (CPG) at 20°C compared to 28°C.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s009

(PDF)

S6 Table. Genes involved in the salicylic acid degradation pathway were selectively up-regulated in R. solanacearum strain GMI1000 during tomato pathogenesis at 20°C.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s010

(PDF)

S7 Table. Genes involved in multidrug efflux were up-regulated in R. solanacearum strain GMI1000 during tomato pathogenesis at 20°C.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s011

(PDF)

S8 Table. Bacterial strains used in this study.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s012

(PDF)

S9 Table. Sequences of PCR primers used in this study.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139090.s013

(PDF)

Acknowledgments

The authors gratefully acknowledge Philippe Prior and Benoît Remenant for the R. solanacearum Core Genome list and useful discussions; Timothy Denny, Freddy Monteiro and Marc Valls for sharing data and useful discussions; and Donald Waller for statistical advice. This research was supported by the University of Wisconsin College of Agricultural and Life Sciences, USDA Plant Biosecurity project 2006–04560, the USDA-ARS Floral and Nursery Crops Research Initiative, and by a Storkan-Hanes-McCaslin Scholarship Award to F. Meng.

Author Contributions

Conceived and designed the experiments: FM LB JMJ CA. Performed the experiments: FM JMJ. Analyzed the data: FM LB JMJ CA. Wrote the paper: FM LB JMJ CA.

References

  1. 1. Hayward AC (1991) Biology and epidemiology of bacterial wilt caused by Pseudomonas solanacearum. Annu Rev Phytopathol 29: 65–87. pmid:18479193
  2. 2. Allen C, Prior P, Hayward AC, editors (2005) Bacterial Wilt Disease and the Ralstonia solanacearum species complex. St Paul: APS Press. 510 p.
  3. 3. Genin S, Denny TP (2012) Pathogenomics of the Ralstonia solanacearum species complex. Annu Rev Phytopathol 50: 67–89. pmid:22559068
  4. 4. Schell MA (2000) Control of virulence and pathogenicity genes of Ralstonia solanacearum by an elaborate sensory network. Annu Rev Phytopathol 38: 263–292. pmid:11701844
  5. 5. Champoiseau P, Jones J, Allen C (2009) Ralstonia solanacearum Race 3 biovar 2 causes tropical losses and temperate anxieties. Plant Health Progress.
  6. 6. Elphinstone JG (2005) The current bacterial wilt situation: A global overview. In: Allen C, Prior P, Hayward AC, editors. Bacterial Wilt: The Disease and the Ralstonia solanacearum Species Complex. St Paul: American Phytopathological Society Press. pp. 9–28.
  7. 7. Ciampi L, Sequeira L (1980) Influence of temperature on virulence of Race 3 strains of Pseudomonas solanacearum. Am Potato J 57: 307–317.
  8. 8. Tung PX, Rasco ET, VanderZaag P, Schmiediche P (1990) Resistance to Pseudomonas solanacearum in the potato: II. Aspects of host-pathogen-environment interaction. Euphytica 45: 211–215.
  9. 9. Milling A, Meng F, Denny TP, Allen C (2009) Interactions with hosts at cool temperatures, not cold tolerance, explain the unique epidemiology of Ralstonia solanacearum Race 3 biovar 2. Phytopathology 99: 1127–1134. pmid:19740025
  10. 10. Fegan M, Prior P (2005) How complex is the "Ralstonia solanacearum species complex"? In: Allen C, Prior P, Hayward AC, editors. Bacterial Wilt Disease and the Ralstonia solanacearum species complex. St. Paul: APS Press. pp. 449–461.
  11. 11. Poussier S, Trigalet-Demery D, Vandewalle P, Goffinet B, Luisetti J, Trigalet A (2000) Genetic diversity of Ralstonia solanacearum as assessed by PCR-RFLP of the hrp gene region, AFLP and 16S rRNA sequence analysis, and identification of an African subdivision. Microbiology 146: 1679–1692. pmid:10878132
  12. 12. Janse JD, van den Beld HE, Elphinstone J, Simpkins S, Tjou-Tam-Sin NAA, van Vaerenbergh J (2004) Introduction to Europe of Ralstonia solanacearum biovar 2, race 3 in Pelargonium zonale cuttings. J Plant Pathol 86: 147–155.
  13. 13. Kim SH, Olson TN, Schaad NW, Moorman GW (2003) Ralstonia solanacearum Race 3, biovar 2, the causual agent of brown rot of potato, identified in geranium in Pennsylvania, Delaware, and Connecticut. Plant Dis 87: 450.
  14. 14. Swanson J, Montes L, Mejia L, Allen C (2007) Detection of latent infections of Ralstonia solanacearum Race 3 biovar 2 in geranium. Plant Disease 91: 828–834.
  15. 15. Williamson L, Kazuhiro N, Hudelson B, Allen C (2002) Ralstonia solanacearum Race 3, Biovar 2 strains isolated from geranium are pathogenic on potato. Plant Disease 86: 987–991.
  16. 16. Elphinstone J (1996) Survival and possibilities for extinction of Pseudomonas solanacearum (Smith) in cool climates. Potato Res 39: 403–410.
  17. 17. Elphinstone J, Stanford HM, Stead D (1998) Detection of Ralstonia solanacearum in potato tubers, Solanum dulcamara, and associated irrigation water. In: Prior P, Allen C, Elphinstone J, editors. Bacterial wilt disease: Molecular and ecological aspects. Berlin, Germany: Springer. pp. 133–139.
  18. 18. van Elsas JD, Kastelein P, van Bekkum P, van der Wolf JM, de Vries PM, van Overbeek L S (2000) Survival of Ralstonia solanacearum biovar 2, the causative agent of potato brown rot, in field and microcosm soils in temperate climates. Phytopathology 90: 1358–1366. pmid:18943377
  19. 19. van Elsas JD, Kastelein P, de Vries PM, van Overbeek LS (2001) Effects of ecological factors on the survival and physiology of Ralstonia solanacearum bv. 2 in irrigation water. Can J Microbiol 47: 842–854. pmid:11683466
  20. 20. Lambert CD (2002) Agricultural bioterrorism protection act: possesion, use, and transfer of biological; agents and toxins; interim and final rule. (7 CFR Psrt 331). Federal Register 67: 76908–76938.
  21. 21. Agrios GN (2005) Plant Pathology. Amsterdam: Elsevier Academic Press.
  22. 22. Large EC (1940) The Advance of the Fungi. New York: Henry Holt and Co.
  23. 23. Schumann G, D'Arcy C (2012) Hungry Plant: Stories of Plant Diseases. St. Paul: APS Press.
  24. 24. Salanoubat M, Genin S, Artiguenave F, Gouzy J, Mangenot S, Arlat M, et al. (2002) Genome sequence of the plant pathogen Ralstonia solanacearum. Nature 415: 497–502. pmid:11823852
  25. 25. Gabriel DW, Allen C, Schell M, Denny TP, Greenberg JT, Duan YP, et al. (2006) Identification of open reading frames unique to a select agent: Ralstonia solanacearum Race 3 Biovar 2. Mol Plant-Microbe Interact 19: 69–79. pmid:16404955
  26. 26. Remenant B, Cambiaire J-CD, Cellier G, Barbe V, Medigue C, Jacobs JM, et al. (2011) Phylotype IV strains of Ralstonia solanacearum, R. syzygii and the Blood Disease Bacterium form a single genomic species despite their divergent life-styles. PLoS One 6: e24356.
  27. 27. Guidot A, Prior P, Schoenfeld J, Carrere S, Genin S, Boucher C (2007) Genomic structure and phylogeny of the plant pathogen Ralstonia solanacearum inferred from gene distribution analysis. J Bacteriol 189: 377–387. pmid:17085551
  28. 28. Flavier AB, Ganova-Raeva LM, Schell MA, Denny TP (1997) Hierarchical autoinduction in Ralstonia solancearum: control of acyl-homoserine lactone production by a novel autoregulatory system responsive to 3-hydroxypalmitic acid methyl ester. Journal of Bacteriology 179: 7089–7097. pmid:9371457
  29. 29. Jacobs JM, Babujee L, Meng F, Milling A, Allen C (2012) The in planta transcriptome of Ralstonia solanacearum: conserved physiological and virulence strategies during bacterial wilt of tomato. mBio 3: e00114–00112. pmid:22807564
  30. 30. Gabius HJ, Andre S, Kaltner H, Siebert HC (2002) The sugar code: functional lectinomics. Biochim Biophys Acta 1572: 165–177. pmid:12223267
  31. 31. Tielker D, Hacker S, Loris R, Strathmann M, Wingender J, Wilhelm S, et al. (2005) Pseudomonas aeruginosa lectin LecB is located in the outer membrane and is involved in biofilm formation. Microbiology 151: 1313–1323. pmid:15870442
  32. 32. Gilboa-Garber N, Sudakevitz D, Sheffi M, Sela R, Levene C (1994) PA-I and PA-II lectin interactions with the ABO(H) and P blood group glycosphingolipid antigens may contribute to the broad spectrum adherence of Pseudomonas aeruginosa to human tissues in secondary infections. Glycoconj J 11: 414–417. pmid:7696845
  33. 33. Imberty A, wimmerova M, Mitchell EP, Gilboa-Garber N (2004) Structures of the lectins from Pseudomonas aeruginosa: insight into the molecular basis for host glycan recognition. Microbes Infect 6: 221–228. pmid:15049333
  34. 34. Adam EC, Mitchell BS, Schumacher DU, Grant G, Schumacher U (1997) Pseudomonas aeruginosa II lectin stops human ciliary beating: therapeutic implications of fucose. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 155: 2102–2104. pmid:9196121
  35. 35. von Bismarck P, Schneppenheim R, Schumacher U (2001) Successful treatment of Pseudomonas aeruginosa respiratory tract infection with a sugar solution–-a case report on a lectin based therapeutic principle. Klin Padiatr 213: 285–287. pmid:11582527
  36. 36. Hauber HP, Schulz M, Pforte A, Mack D, Zabel P, Schumacher U (2008) Inhalation with fucose and galactose for treatment of Pseudomonas aeruginosa in cystic fibrosis patients. Int J Med Sci 5: 371–376. pmid:19043609
  37. 37. Kang Y, Liu H, Genin S, Schell MA, Denny TP (2002) Ralstonia solanacearum requires type–4 pili to adhere to multiple surfaces and for natural transformation and virulence. Mol Microbiol 46: 427–437. pmid:12406219
  38. 38. Yao J, Allen C (2006) Chemotaxis is required for virulence and competitive fitness of the bacterial wilt pathogen Ralstonia solanacearum. J Bacteriol 188: 3697–3708. pmid:16672623
  39. 39. Ma L, Lu H, Sprinkle A, Parsek MR, Wozniak DJ (2007) Pseudomonas aeruginosa Psl is a galactose- and mannose-rich exopolysaccharide. J Bacteriol 189: 8353–8356. pmid:17631634
  40. 40. Orgambide G, Montrozier H, Servin P, Roussel J, Trigalet-Demery D, Trigalet A (1991) High heterogeneity of the exopolysaccharides of Pseuodomonas solanacearum strain GMI1000 and the complete structure of major polysaccharide. J Biol Chem 266: 8312–8321. pmid:2022648
  41. 41. Wozniak DJ, Wyckoff TJ, Starkey M, Keyser R, Azadi P, O'Toole GA, et al. (2003) Alginate is not a significant component of the extracellular polysaccharide matrix of PA14 and PAO1 Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilms. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 100: 7907–7912. pmid:12810959
  42. 42. Mobley HLT (2015) Measuring bacterial gene expression and metabolism during infections provides a more comprehensive view of virulence in action. Microbe 10:239–246.
  43. 43. Beckering CL, Steil L, Weber MH, Volker U, Marahiel MA (2002) Genomewide transcriptional analysis of the cold shock response in Bacillus subtilis. J Bacteriol 184: 6395–6402. pmid:12399512
  44. 44. Goldstein J, Pollitt NS, Inouye M (1990) Major cold shock protein of Escherichia coli. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 87: 283–287. pmid:2404279
  45. 45. Phadtare S (2004) Recent developments in bacterial cold-shock response. Curr Issues Mol Biol 6: 125–136. pmid:15119823
  46. 46. Phadtare S, Alsina J, Inouye M (1999) Cold-shock response and cold-shock proteins. Curr Opin Microbiol 2: 175–180. pmid:10322168
  47. 47. Martinez JL, Sanchez MB, Martınez-Solano L, Hernandez A, Garmendia L, Fajardo A, et al. (2008) Functional role of bacterial multidrug efflux pumps in microbial natural ecosystems. FEMS Microbiol Rev 33: 430–449.
  48. 48. Ma D, Alberti M, Lynch C, Nikaido H, Hearst J. E. (1996) The local repressor AcrR plays a modulating role in the regulation of acrAB genes of Escherichia coli by global stress signals. Mol Microbiol 19: 101–112. pmid:8821940
  49. 49. Brown DG, Swanson JK, Allen C (2007) Two host-induced Ralstonia solanacearum genes, acrA and dinF, encode multidrug efflux pumps and contribute to bacterial wilt virulence. Appl Environ Microbiol 73: 2777–2786. pmid:17337552
  50. 50. Chen YY, Lin YM, Chao TC, Wang J-F, Liu AC, Ho FI, et al. (2009) Virus-induced gene silencing reveals the involvement of ethylene-, salicylic acid- and mitogen-activated protein kinase-related defense pathways in the resistance of tomato to bacterial wilt. Physiol Plantarum 136: 324–335.
  51. 51. Prithiviraj B, Bais HP, Weir T, Suresh B, Najarro EH, Dayaker BV, et al. (2005) Down regulation of virulence factors of Pseudomonas aeruginosa by salicylic acid attenuates its virulence on Arabidopsis thaliana and Caenorhabditis elegans. Infect Immun 73: 5319–5328. pmid:16113247
  52. 52. Milling AS, Babujee L, Allen C (2011) Ralstonia solanacearum extracellular polysaccharide is a specific elicitor of defense responses in wilt-resistant tomato plants. PLoS One 6: e15853. pmid:21253019
  53. 53. Fry SC (1982) Phenolic components of the primary cell wall. Feruloylated disaccharides of D-galactose and L-arabinose from spinach polysaccharide. Biochem J 203: 493–504. pmid:7115300
  54. 54. Carnachan SM, Harris PJ (2000) Ferulic acid is bound to the primary cell walls of all gymnosperm families. Biochem Syst Ecol 28: 865–879. pmid:10913848
  55. 55. Mathew S, Abraham TE (2004) Ferulic acid: an antioxidant found naturally in plant cell walls and feruloyl esterases involved in its release and their applications. Crit Rev Biotechnol 24: 59–83. pmid:15493526
  56. 56. Smith BG, Harris PJ (2001) Ferulic acid is esterified to glucuronoarabinoxylans in pineapple cell walls. Phytochemistry 56: 513–519. pmid:11261585
  57. 57. Harris V, Jiranek V, Ford CM, Grbin PR Inhibitory effect of hydroxycinnamic acids on Dekkera spp. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 86: 721–729. pmid:19957080
  58. 58. Nicholson RL H R (1992) Phenolic compounds and their role in disease resistance. Annual Review of Phytopathology 30: 369–389.
  59. 59. Mandal S, Mitra A, Mallick N (2009) Time course study on accumulation of cell wall-bound phenolics and activities of defense enzymes in tomato roots in relation to Fusarium wilt. World J Microbiol Biotech 25: 795–802.
  60. 60. Zhu HH, Yao Q (2004) Localized and systemic increase of phenols in tomato roots induced by Glomus versiforme inhibits Ralstonia solancearum. J Phytopathol 152: 537–542.
  61. 61. Lowe TM, Ailloud F, Allen C (2015) Hydroxycinnamic acid degradation, a broadly conserved trait, protects Ralstonia solanacearum from chemical plant defenses and contributes to root colonization and virulence. Mol Plant-Microbe Interact 28: 286–297. pmid:25423265
  62. 62. Bocsanczy AM, Achenbach UCM, Mangravita-Novo A, Chow M, Norman DJ (2014) Proteomic comparison of Ralstonia solanacearum strains reveals temperature dependent virulence factors. BMC Genomics 15: 280. pmid:24725348
  63. 63. Bocsanczy AM, Achenbach UCM, Mangravita-Novo A, Yuen J, Norman DJ (2012) Comparative effect of low temperature on virulence and twitching motility of Ralstonia solanacearum strains present in Florida. Phytopathology 102: 185–194. pmid:21936660
  64. 64. Sudakevitz D, Imberty A, Gilboa-Garber N (2002) Production, properties and specificity of a new bacterial L-fucose- and D-arabinose-binding lectin of the plant aggressive pathogen Ralstonia solanacearum, and its comparison to related plant and microbial lectins. J Biochem 132: 353–358. pmid:12153735
  65. 65. Sudakevitz D, Kostlanova N, Blatman-Jan G, Mitchell EP, Lerrer B, Wimmerová M, et al. (2004) A new Ralstonia solanacearum high-affinity mannose-binding lectin RS-IIL structurally resembling the Pseudomonas aeruginosa fucose-specific lectin PA-IIL. Mol Microbiol 52: 691–700. pmid:15101976
  66. 66. Arnaud J, Claudinon J, Tröndle K, Trovaslet M, Larson G, Thomas A, et al. (2013) Reduction of lectin valency drastically changes glycolipid dynamics in membranes but not surface avidity. ACS Chemical Biology 8: 1918–1924. pmid:23855446
  67. 67. Šulák O, Kostlánová N., Adam J., Mitchell E., Imberty A., and Wimmerová M (2007) Bacterial lectin RS20L from Ralstonia solanacearum: corelation between structure and function. XI Setkání biochemiků a molekulrních biologů. Brno: Masarykova Univerzita. pp. 37–38
  68. 68. Carpita NC, Gibeaut DM (1993) Structural models of primary cell walls in flowering plants: consistency of molecular structure with the physical properties of the walls during growth. Plant J 3: 1–30. pmid:8401598
  69. 69. Somerville C, Bauer S, Brininstool G, Facette M, Hamann T, Milne J, et al. (2004) Toward a systems approach to understanding plant cell walls. Science 306: 2206–2211. pmid:15618507
  70. 70. Schmidt EL (1979) Initiation of plant root-microbe interactions. Annu Rev Microbiol 33: 355–376. pmid:386926
  71. 71. Halverson LJ, Stacey G (1986) Signal exchange in plant-microbe interactions. Microbiol Rev 50: 193–225. pmid:3523189
  72. 72. Hirsch AM (1999) Role of lectins (and rhizobial exopolysaccharides) in legume nodulation. Curr Opin Plant Biol 2: 320–326. pmid:10458994
  73. 73. Peumans WJ, van Damme EJ (1995) The role of lectins in plant defence. Histochem J 27: 253–271. pmid:7635758
  74. 74. Winzer K, Falconer C, Garber NC, Diggle SP, Camara M, Williams P (2000) The Pseudomonas aeruginosa lectins PA-IL and PA-IIL are controlled by quorum sensing and by RpoS. J Bacteriol 182: 6401–6411. pmid:11053384
  75. 75. Flavier AB, Schell MA, Denny TP (1998) An RpoS (sigmaS) homologue regulates acylhomoserine lactone-dependent autoinduction in Ralstonia solanacearum. Mol Microbiol 28: 475–486. pmid:9632252
  76. 76. Valls M, Genin S, Boucher C (2006) Integrated regulation of the type III secretion system and other virulence determinants in Ralstonia solanacearum. PLoS Pathog 2: 798–807.
  77. 77. Huber B, Feldmann F, Kothe M, Vandamme P, Wopperer J, Reidel K, et al. (2004) Identification of a novel virulence factor in Burkholderia cenocepacia H111 required for efficient slow killing of Caenorhabditis elegans. Infect Immun 72: 7220–7230. pmid:15557647
  78. 78. Lynch N, Denny T. P. (2009) Ralstonia solanacearum Phc confinement-sensing system is required for slow-killing of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Phytopathology 99: S78
  79. 79. Monteiro F, Genin S, vanDijk I, Valls M (2012) A luminescent reporter evidences active expression of Ralstonia solanacearum type III secretion system genes throughout plant infection. Microbiology 158: 2107–2116. pmid:22609750
  80. 80. Meng F, Yao J, Allen C (2011) A MotN mutant of Ralstonia solanacearum is hypermotile and has reduced virulence. J Bacteriol 193: 2477–2486. pmid:21421761
  81. 81. Miller JH (1992) A short course in bacterial genetics: a laboratory manual and handbook for Escherichia coli and related bacteria. Cold Spring Harbor, NY: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press.
  82. 82. Jahn CE, Charkowski AO, Willis DK (2008) Evaluation of isolation methods and RNA integrity for bacterial RNA quantification. J Microbiol Meth 75: 318–324.
  83. 83. Irizarry RA, Hobbs B, Collin F, Beazer-Barclay YD, Antonellis KJ, et al. (2003) Exploration, normalization, and summaries of high density oligonucleotide array probe level data. Biostatistics 4: 249–264. pmid:12925520
  84. 84. Bolstad BM, Irizarry RA, Astrand M, Speed TP (2003) A Comparison of normalization methods for high density oligonucleotide array data based on bias and variance. Bioinformatics 19: 185–193. pmid:12538238
  85. 85. Efron B, Tibshirani R (2002) Empirical Bayes methods and false discovery rates for microarrays. Genet Epidemiol 23: 70–86. pmid:12112249
  86. 86. Reimers M, Carey VJ (2006) Bioconductor: an open source framework for bioinformatics and computational biology. Methods Enzymol 411: 119–134. pmid:16939789
  87. 87. Darling AC, Mau B, Blattner FR, Perna NT (2004) Mauve: multiple alignment of conserved genomic sequence with rearrangements. Genome Res 14: 1394–1403. pmid:15231754
  88. 88. Ausubel F, Brent R, Kingston R, Moore D, Seidman J, et al. (1995) Short Protocols in Molecular Biology. New York: John Wiley and Sons.
  89. 89. Allen C, Huang Y, Sequeira L (1991) Cloning of genes affecting polygalacturonase production in Pseudomonas solanacearum. Mol Plant-Microbe Interact 4: 147–154.
  90. 90. Horton RM, Hund HD, Ho SN, Ullen JK, Pease LR (1989) Engineering hybrid genes without the use of restriction enzymes; gene splicing by overlap extension. Gene 77: 61–68. pmid:2744488
  91. 91. Choi KH, Schweizer HP (2006) Mini-Tn7 insertion in bacteria with single attTn7 sites: the example of Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Nat Protoc 1: 153–161. pmid:17406227
  92. 92. Choi K-H, Gaynor JB, White KG, Lopez C, Bosio CM, Karkhoff-Schweizer RR et al. (2005) A Tn7-based broad-range bacterial cloning and expression system. Nat Methods 2: 443–448. pmid:15908923
  93. 93. Yao J, Allen C (2007) The plant pathogen Ralstonia solanacearum needs aerotaxis for normal biofilm formation and interactions with its tomato host. J Bacteriol 189: 6415–6424. pmid:17601784
  94. 94. Bertolla F, Van Gijsegem F, Nesme X, Simonet P (1997) Conditions for natural transformation of Ralstonia solanacearum. J Bacteriol 180: 27–34.
  95. 95. Tans-Kersten J, Huang H., and Allen C. (2001) Ralstonia solancearum needs motility for invasive virulence on tomato. J Bacteriol 183: 3597–3605. pmid:11371523
  96. 96. O'Toole GA, Kolter R (1998) Initiation of biofilm formation in Pseudomonas fluorescens WCS365 proceeds via multiple, convergent signalling pathways: a genetic analysis. Mol Microbiol 28: 449–461. pmid:9632250