Carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning can be fatal but is preventable. From October 2010 to February 2011, Anshan Prefecture reported 57 cases of non-occupational CO poisoning in District A, with two deaths. We conducted an investigation to identify risk factors and recommend preventive measures.
We defined a possible case of non-occupational CO poisoning as onset of at least two of the following symptoms: fatigue, headache, dizziness, nausea, vomiting, cyanosis, loss of consciousness, coma, and shock from October 1, 2010, to February 28, 2011, in a resident of Anshan Prefecture with non-occupational exposure to CO poisoning. We defined a probable case as onset of at least one of the following symptoms: cyanosis, loss of consciousness, coma and shock, plus at least one of the following symptoms: fatigue, headache, dizziness, nausea, vomiting, among possible cases. A confirmed CO poisoning case was a possible case or probable case plus hemoglobin (Hb) CO higher than 10%. We searched for cases by reviewing medical records and records of hyperbaric oxygen tank usage. In a case-control investigation, we compared home heating practices of 30 case-persons and 120 control-persons who were individually matched to each case by neighborhood.
Overall, 56% (39/70) of case-patients’ households burned coal for home-heating. In the case-control investigation, 40% (12/30) of case-persons’ households compared with 5.8% (7/120) of control-persons’ households placed stoves in bedrooms (Mantel-Haenszel odds ratio [ORM-H] = 11, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 3.0–41); 53% (16/30) of case-patients’ households and 33% (40/120) of control-patients’ households did not extinguish the fire before sleeping (ORM-H = 3.6, 95% CI = 1.1–12); 13% (4/30) of case-patients’ households and 3% (4/120) of control-patients’ households had not installed the ventilation pipe vertically (ORM-H = 7.3, 95% CI = 1.0–56). Overall, 77% (23/30) of case-patients’ households and 39% (47/120) of control-patients’ households had at least one of those three risk factors (ORM-H = 10, 95% CI = 2.5–40; population attributable risk percentage: 78%).
Dangerous practices with coal-burning stoves inside the home accounted for the majority of CO poisoning incidents. Community health centers should provide instruction to and supervision of residents on proper installation and use of home heating stoves as well as inspection of installation.
Citation: Lu Q, Lv W, Tian J, Zhang L, Zhu B (2015) Risk Factors for Non-Occupational Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: Anshan Prefecture, Liaoning Province, China, 2011–2012. PLoS ONE 10(6): e0129121. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0129121
Academic Editor: William Durante, University of Missouri, UNITED STATES
Received: January 23, 2015; Accepted: May 5, 2015; Published: June 12, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Lu et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper.
Funding: The authors have no support or funding to report.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Carbon monoxide (CO) is a colorless, odorless, tasteless, and nonirritating toxic gas produced by incomplete combustion of organic compounds . Symptoms of CO poisoning are nonspecific. Mild exposures result in headache, myalgia, dizziness, or neuropsychological impairment . Severe exposures result in confusion, loss of consciousness, or death . Improperly installed heaters, motor vehicles, appliances that use carbon fuels, and most importantly household fires are the main sources for CO gas .
In China, CO poisoning cases are reported through the emergency public health event reporting system. In Anshan Prefecture, located in northeastern China where winters are bitterly cold, some residents that live in bungalows burn coal in stoves for home heating. From October 2010 to February 2011, the emergency public health event reporting system in Anshan Prefecture reported 57 non-occupational cases of carbon monoxide poisoning in District A, including two death (attack rate: 19/100000). In 91% of cases CO poisoning occurred as a result of household CO sources. The detailed causes included leakage of CO from coal-burning stoves, forgetting to turn off the natural gas valve, leaking gas cylinder used for cooking, and leaking gas-powered water-heater in the home. We conducted this investigation to identify risk factors for household sources of CO poisoning and recommend preventive measures.
Materials and Methods
The study was approved by the Ethic Review Committee of Liaoning Center for Disease Control and Prevention. All study objects had signed an informed consent document prior to participation. All data analyzed were anonymized.
We defined a possible case of non-occupational CO poisoning as onset of at least two of the following symptoms: fatigue, headache, dizziness, nausea, vomiting, cyanosis, loss of consciousness, coma, and shock from October 1, 2010, to February 28, 2011, in a resident of Anshan Prefecture with non-occupational exposure to CO poisoning. We defined a probable case as onset of at least one of the following symptoms: cyanosis, loss of consciousness, coma, and shock, plus at least one of the following symptoms: fatigue, headache, dizziness, nausea, vomiting, among possible cases. A confirmed CO poisoning case was a possible case or probable case plus hemoglobin (Hb) CO higher than 10% (normal concentration: 2% for non-smokers and 5–9% for smokers ).
We searched for cases in all three hospitals designated to treat CO poisoning in Anshan Prefecture by reviewing the outpatient records, inpatient records, usage records of the hyperbaric equipment, and laboratory records. We also reviewed records in the emergency public health event reporting system to identify reported CO poisoning cases or events. We interviewed the case-patients about all sources of CO they were exposed to both inside and outside the home.
We conducted a case-control study to identify risk factors for CO poisoning among residents living in bungalows who used coal-burning stoves for heating in the winter. Because this investigation focused on household-level risk factors, if a household had multiple case-patients, we selected only one. For each case-patient, we randomly selected four individually-matched neighborhood controls from households without any suspected cases; one control was selected in each household. We interviewed the case-persons and control-persons or their family members to collect information regarding home heating practices, e.g., type of stove used, type of fuel used (e.g., block coal, powdered coal, charcoal), design of the chimney, location of the stove in the household, how frequently the ventilation pipes was cleaned, how the ventilation pipe was installed, and whether the stove fire was extinguished before sleeping.
We used univariate conditional logistic regression to estimate the matched odds ratios (ORmatch) and 95% confidence intervals (CI) associated with various risk factors, and multivariable conditional logistic regression to control for confounding and to calculate the adjusted odds ratios (ORadj). We used the ORadj and the exposure percent in the control group associated with each risk factor to calculate the population attributable risk percent (PARP) for each risk factor.
In total, we identified 72 cases (54 possible, 12 probable and 6 confirmed) in 67 households; 62 of the 67 households had one case and five had two cases. The median age of the case-patients was 47 years (range: 12–83 years); 56% (40/72) of the case-patients were males. Cases occurred in three out of four districts in Anshan Prefecture; 97% (70/72) of the cases occurred in District A where the bungalows were concentrated; District B and C each had one case. Therefore, we focused our investigation on cases in District A.
Of the 70 case-patients in District A, the clinical symptoms included fatigue (43%), dizziness (39%), headache (37%), nausea or vomiting (33%), confusion (14%), and coma (11%). Two of the case-patients died (case-fatality rate: 2.9%). Interviews of the case-persons revealed that the majority of the CO poisoning incidents (56%, 39/70) were caused by leakage of CO from coal-burning stoves used for home heating (Table 1).
The 39 case-patients whose cause of CO poisoning was the use of coal-burning stoves inside the home lived in 36 bungalows. We enrolled 30 case-patients (from 30 different households) in our investigation; the other six households had either moved away at the time of our investigation or could not be reached due to lack of detailed contact information.
The 30 households all used coal-burning stoves for home-heating. None of the 30 case-patients’ households had installed CO detectors. None of the 120 control households had installed CO detectors. The case-control investigation showed that 40% (12/30) of case-patients’ households installed a stove in the bedrooms compared to 5.8% (7/120) of control-persons’ households (ORmatch = 11, 95% CI = 3.5–37); 97% (29/30) of case-patients’ household and 76% (91/120) of control-persons’ households burned block coal (ORmatch = 9.3, 95% CI = 1.2–72); 13% (4/30) of case-patients’ households and 3.3% (4/120) of control-persons’ households installed non-vertical ventilation pipe (ORmatch = 7.0, 95% CI = 1.1–34); 80% (24/30) of case-patients’ household and 67% (80/120) of the control-persons’ households never cleaned the ventilation pipes (ORmatch = 4.2, 95% CI = 1.0–22); 53% (16/30) of case-patients’ households and 33% (40/120) of control-persons’ households did not extinguish the fire before sleeping (ORmatch = 2.7, 95% CI = 1.1 = 6.9). The multivariable analysis showed that placing the stove in the bedroom (ORadj = 11, 95% CI = 2.0–41), installing non-vertical ventilation pipes (ORadj = 7.3, 95% CI = 1.0–56), and not extinguishing the fire before sleeping (ORadj = 3.6, 95% CI = 1.1–12) were significant risk factors for CO poisoning (Table 2). Other factors, including ventilation pipes without joints, ventilation pipes made of brick, sealing off the chinks around the windows to prevent the wind from blowing in, lack of a ventilation fan, and using brick stoves, were not significantly associated with CO poisoning.
The population attributable risk percentages (PARP) were 37% for installing a stove in the bedrooms, 17% for having a non-vertical ventilation pipe, and 46% for not extinguishing the fire before sleeping. When we examined those three risk factors combined, 77% of the case-patients’ households compared with 39% of the control-persons’ households had at least one of the three risk factors (ORM-H = 10, 95% CI = 2.5–40), yielding a PARP of 78%.
About half of the world’s households depend on biomass and coal for cooking and heating; most of these are found in developing countries, where poor households generally use open fires or inadequately vented stoves [6–7]. In Anshan Prefecture, China, residents who live in the bungalows mainly use stoves for home heating in winter. Of the 70 case-patients in District A, the majority of the CO poisoning incidents (56%) were caused by leakage of CO from coal-burning stoves used for home heating. That means CO poisoning could be greatly decreased if the stoves were installed and used correctly. So, we conducted a case-control study to identify the risk factors for CO poisoning among the residents who used coal-burning stoves for heating. We identified three preventable risk factors involved in the installation and use of coal-burning stoves for home heating. Previous literature in China had shown that use of a stove could increase the risk of CO poisoning , but in our investigation, in addition to the placement of stoves in the bedroom that had previously been shown to be a risk factor, we also found having a non-vertical chimneys and not extinguishing the fire before sleeping were risk factors for CO poisoning. In this prefecture, this problem would continue to exist if not identified and resolved. The results of this study could be applied not only in this prefecture but also anywhere in the world where stoves were used to greatly reduce CO poisoning caused by coal-burning stove. In our case, CO poisoning is a significant, yet completely preventable, cause of death and severe illness in northern China. However, applied research on locality-specific risk factors had rarely been conducted. Therefore, our study raised the awareness of this important public health, identified risk factors in this area and informed public health actions.
Previous investigations also showed that keeping windows closed is a risk factor for CO poisoning [8, 9]. However, we were unable to investigate this factor because, with average winter temperate of -10°C in Anshan Prefecture, doors and windows in the bungalows are universally closed at night in the winter. In this region, people usually seal windows which means sealing off the chinks around the windows when the windows were closed to prevent wind from blowing in through the chinks to maintain warmth in the room. Yet sealing the windows was not shown as a risk factor in this study. Use of mud stoves for home heating had been found to be a risk factor for CO poisoning in Hunan Province in southern China . The mud stoves had no chimneys. When they are used in the bedrooms, CO gas can easily leak out of the top and bottom of the stove, causing CO poisoning . In Anshan Prefecture, although mud stoves were used, they usually had chimneys. But if the chimneys were installed non-vertically, the risk of CO poisoning was increased. The gas in chimneys that are installed horizontally usually discharges slowly compared to the gas in chimneys that are installed vertically out of the room.
Many residents in Anshan Prefecture used stoves for home heating, especially those living in bungalows. Our studies showed that factors related to improper installation and use of those stoves accounted for over 78% of all CO poisoning cases, and these factors are all preventable.
The main limitation of this study was that several case-patients had moved away or their contact information was not available, resulting in the small study size.
The CDC definition for CO poisoning is: A case was defined as two or more symptoms consistent with CO poisoning (i.e., headache, nausea, diarrhea, dizziness, dry mouth, drowsiness, or vomiting) or CO poisoning diagnosed by a physician and a carboxyhemoglobin (COHb) level greater than 10% (normal concentration: less than 2% for nonsmokers, 5–9% for smokers) . In our study, we formulated the case definition based on the symptoms of reported CO poisoning patients. Our case definition is similar to the CDC definition.
In conclusion, we identified three preventable risk factors involving the installation and use of coal-burning stoves for home heating, which accounted for over three-quarters of CO poisoning cases.
Based on the findings of this study, we suggest that the local government should conduct health education for local residents about the risk factors of CO poisoning, and provide instructions to the residents on the correct installation and use of home heating stoves. The local government should also consider providing free CO detectors to people living in bungalows and teaching them how to correctly install and use the detectors. The local government should also conduct periodic inspections of households living in bungalows before winter comes, and a few more times during the winter.
We thank the staff at Anshan Center for Disease Control and Prevention for their assistance during this investigation. The authors also thank Dr. Robert E. Fontaine, U.S. CDC, who provided many valuable suggestions.
Conceived and designed the experiments: QL LZ. Performed the experiments: QL WL JT. Analyzed the data: LZ BZ. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: LZ BZ. Wrote the paper: QL LZ.
- 1. Mustafa K, Eyup K, Sumeyya A, Kantarci MN, Kaya M, Akyol O. Forensic and clinical carbon monoxide (CO) poisonings in Turkey: A detailed analysis. J Forensic Leg Med. 2013; 20: 95–101. doi: 10.1016/j.jflm.2012.04.031. pmid:23357394
- 2. Ernst A, Zibrak JD. Carbon monoxide poisoning. N Engl J Med. 1998;339: 1603–8. pmid:9828249 doi: 10.1056/nejm199811263392206
- 3. Amitai Y, Zlotogorski Z, Golan-Katzav V, Wexler A, Gross D. Neuropsychological impairment from acute low-level exposure to carbon monoxide. Arch Neurol. 1998; 55: 845–8. pmid:9626776 doi: 10.1001/archneur.55.6.845
- 4. Unintentional carbon monoxide poisonings in residential settings—Connecticut, November 1993–March 1994. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 1995; 44(41):765–7. pmid:7565559 doi: 10.1001/jama.1995.03530200015014
- 5. Miquel P. A dictionary of Epidemiology. Fifth Edition, Oxford University Press. 2008.
- 6. McCracken JP, Smith KR, Díaz A, Mittleman MA, Schwartz J. Chimney stove intervention to reduce long-term wood smoke exposure lowers blood pressure among Guatemalan women. Environ Health Perspect. 2007;115: 996–1001. pmid:17637912 doi: 10.1289/ehp.9888
- 7. Smith KR, Mehta S, Maeusezahl-Feuz M. Indoor air pollution from household use of solid fuels. In: Ezzati M, Lopez AD, Rodgers A, Murray CJL,editors. Comparative quantification of health risks: global and regional burden of diseases attributable to selected major risk factors. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2004. p. 1435–93.
- 8. Li C, Ma H. Risk factors of non-occupational carbon monoxide poisoning during the 2008 ice storm in Guiyang ciunty, Hunan province, China. Public health reports;125: 605–610. pmid:20597461
- 9. Chen XH, Zhao XC, Qiao ZY. Investigation of 2 cases of nonoccupational CO poisoning. Occup Health. 2008; 24: 498–5.
- 10. Unintentional Carbon Monoxide Poisonings in Residential Settings—Connecticut, November 1993-March 1994. MMWR. 1995; 44:765–7. pmid:7565559 doi: 10.1001/jama.1995.03530200015014