Understanding the temporal dynamics of present thermal and pH exposure on coral reefs is crucial for elucidating reef response to future global change. Diel ranges in temperature and carbonate chemistry parameters coupled with seasonal changes in the mean conditions define periods during the year when a reef habitat is exposed to anomalous thermal and/or pH exposure. Anomalous conditions are defined as values that exceed an empirically estimated threshold for each variable. We present a 200-day time series from June through December 2010 of carbonate chemistry and environmental parameters measured on the Heron Island reef flat. These data reveal that aragonite saturation state, pH, and pCO2 were primarily modulated by biologically-driven changes in dissolved organic carbon (DIC) and total alkalinity (TA), rather than salinity and temperature. The largest diel temperature ranges occurred in austral spring, in October (1.5 – 6.6°C) and lowest diel ranges (0.9 – 3.2°C) were observed in July, at the peak of winter. We observed large diel total pH variability, with a maximum range of 7.7 – 8.5 total pH units, with minimum diel average pH values occurring during spring and maximum during fall. As with many other reefs, the nighttime pH minima on the reef flat were far lower than pH values predicted for the open ocean by 2100. DIC and TA both increased from June (end of Fall) to December (end of Spring). Using this high-resolution dataset, we developed exposure metrics of pH and temperature individually for intensity, duration, and severity of low pH and high temperature events, as well as a combined metric. Periods of anomalous temperature and pH exposure were asynchronous on the Heron Island reef flat, which underlines the importance of understanding the dynamics of co-occurrence of multiple stressors on coastal ecosystems.
Citation: Kline DI, Teneva L, Hauri C, Schneider K, Miard T, Chai A, et al. (2015) Six Month In Situ High-Resolution Carbonate Chemistry and Temperature Study on a Coral Reef Flat Reveals Asynchronous pH and Temperature Anomalies. PLoS ONE10(6): e0127648. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0127648
Academic Editor: Sebastian C. A. Ferse, Leibniz Center for Tropical Marine Ecology, GERMANY
Received: April 24, 2014; Accepted: April 17, 2015; Published: June 3, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Kline et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Data Availability: Data used in the analyses for this paper have been deposited with the NOAA National Oceanographic Data Center (NODC) under NODC Accession Number 0127256. The doi assigned to this data set is 10.7289/V55M63MF. The link to the metadata page of the data set is at (http://www.nodc.noaa.gov/oceanacidification/data/0127256.xml).
Funding: This research was funded by the Australian Research Council (ARC) Linkage Infrastructure Equipment and Facilities grant #LE0989608 (OHG, DK, SD), ARC Linkage grant #LP0775303 (OHG, SD), ARC Centre of Excellence grant #CE0561435 (OHG, SD), a Queensland Government Smart State Premier's Fellowship to OHG, National Science Foundation grants (NSF OCE-0729236, to RBD; and NSF ATM-0941760 to BGM), and the Pacific Blue Foundation (DK). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
By 2100, tropical surface seawater temperatures are projected to rise by 2–3°C  and open ocean pH levels are projected to decline by 0.3–0.4 units . Ocean warming can lead to thermal physiological stress in corals known as coral bleaching . Increasing CO2 content in surface seawater leads to ocean acidification (OA) which can reduce skeleton- and shell-building ability in many marine organisms [4–7] and possibly even hamper reef ecosystem calcification for many reefs globally [8, 9]. The relevance of carbonate chemistry variability (pH, dissolved inorganic carbon [DIC], and total alkalinity [TA]) to coral physiology, reef ecology and susceptibility to OA is increasingly appreciated [10–13]. Current models predict a 60% decline in reef coral coverage within the next few decades due to warming, and a 10–50% drop in coral calcification and even a shift towards net reef dissolution by the end of this century due to OA [3, 14–17].
Compared to environmental variability in the open ocean, coral reefs are dynamic coastal ecosystems, with large diel and seasonal temperature and pH variability. Daily temperature swings are largely driven by cloud cover, currents, turbidity, tides and solar heating , and can range from 4.0 to 8.0°C (e.g., [11, 19]). Several studies suggest that the mean monthly and seasonal temperatures, as well as diel temperature changes or the short term thermal history, are important for determining coral bleaching temperature stress thresholds [11, 20]. It has also been suggested that daily exposure of corals to potentially stressful thermal conditions that persist long enough to induce acclimation but not to cause mortality may increase corals’ bleaching resistance . Diel pH variability can be as large as 0.5–0.6 pH units, greater than the pH decline predicted by 2100 for the open ocean [21–23]. Such large diel ranges are driven by reef metabolism processes of photosynthesis/respiration and calcification/dissolution as well as physical controls on the local seawater residence time at the site [24, 25]. Seasonal pH ranges can also be substantial, up to 0.7–0.8 pH units, especially on isolated reef flats with long seawater residence time . Seasons can substantively influence other environmental variables on reefs, such as temperature, light, and precipitation, while longer term inter-annual variation can be due to processes such as El Niño/La Niña events . Furthermore, carbonate chemistry variability on reefs may have large implications in a high CO2 future due to predicted amplification of the variability .
A better grasp of potential variation in OA impacts across different reef zones and communities requires detailed characterization of their natural diel and seasonal range in carbonate chemistry (pH, pCO2, DIC, TA, and aragonite saturation state [ΩAR]). We use an accepted model of vulnerability in this study, wherein we consider the relative vulnerability of reefs to be a function of exposure to a hazard or risk and of sensitivity to such hazards or risks [27, 28]. A significant knowledge gap in our understanding of OA impacts on coral reefs lies in understanding the exposure of reefs to natural variability in OA-relevant parameters on different time-scales. This study aims to provide a high-resolution dataset, which delineates different patterns of natural variability in environmental parameters over 6 months on a coral reef. An upcoming publication will depict a study that tests both exposure and sensitivity to exposure in an OA experiment .
Most previous studies of carbonate chemistry dynamics on shallow coral reef environments have monitored the environment either long-term (months to years) with in situ pH sensors but often with few discrete measurements, or short-term (days) yet at high-resolution (>3–4 measurements per day) and sometimes repeated in different seasons (e.g., [22, 30, 31–33]). Several studies are attempting to determine the complex interaction between environmental factors (light, wave energy, temperature, ecological community composition, etc.), carbonate chemistry and reef function [25, 34] but often field and logistical challenges constrain such studies to short-term (several days) data collections of anomalously high-frequency carbonate system measurements (e.g. ).
This study presents one of the most high-resolution environmental data suites for a coral reef environment in a 6-month period, including 10-s water depth data, 10-s water velocity data, 10-s temperature data, 10-s salinity data, 10-s PAR, 10-s pH, and daily to hourly DIC and total alkalinity. Phosphate and nitrate data were also collected for 150 samples at nearly daily resolution during the 6 months of the study. This large dataset library for Heron Island provides valuable detail of environmental variability on various time-scales. This paper contributes: 1) documentation, in as high detail as logistically feasible, of the environmental variability on Heron reef flat with a specific focus on carbon system parameters and temperature; 2) an assessment of relative contributions to the natural variation in pH, aragonite saturation state, and pCO2 from thermodynamic and biological processes; and 3) development of a set of empirically derived pH and temperature metrics for a better understanding of reef environmental exposure over time. Periods of anomalous temperature and pH exposure were asynchronous on the Heron Island reef flat, which may have implications for overall reef habitat sensitivity and biological responses to future global ocean changes (see Methods section on how we have defined ‘anomalous’ within this dataset for each variable). This study suggests that high-resolution data sets in near shore environments are critical for understanding the dynamics of co-occurrence of multiple stressors on coastal ecosystems.
Materials and Methods
Permits from the Department of Environment and Resource Management (#CSCE00874010) and the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (#G09/29996.1) were provided to conduct this research.
This study was conducted on the Heron Island reef flat (23° 27’ S, 151° 55’ E), a coral cay that is part of the Capricorn-Bunker Group of reefs at the southern end of the Great Barrier Reef (GBR, Fig 1). Corals of the Acropora and Porites genera cover >20% of the Heron Island reef flat . The Heron Island reef flat has semi-diurnal tidal cycles, with a spring tidal range of 2.3 m, a neap tidal range of 1.1 m  and depths between 0.3–1 m in the shallowest reef flat areas at low tides when the reef flat is isolated by the emergent reef rim . The Heron Island algal reef rim on the southwest side of the island was dredged to allow passage of boats  (Fig 1). This modification has altered the hydrodynamics of the reef flat waters resulting in continual flushing of reef waters through the dredged channel even at low tide. December through February, or austral summer, has the highest rainfall, whereas austral winter (June to September) is the driest season . According to temperature data from the Heron Island weather station (ID 39122, Australian Bureau of Meteorology) for the 1962–2006 period, the air temperature has been warmest in January, at 29.7 ± 0.9°C (+/- STD), and coldest in July at 21.5 ± 0.8°C. Sea-surface temperatures available from the Australian Institute of Marine Sciences for 2008–2013 and derived from sensors across the Heron lagoon show similar trends to air temperature: January has the annual maximum of 29.4 ± 0.7°C and July has the minimum temperatures with an average of 23.3 ± 0.75°C . Rainfall and wind data were also obtained from the Australian Bureau of Meteorology for the duration of the study .
(a) Map of Australia with a black rectangle representing the Capricorn Bunker group of reefs at the southernmost end of the Great Barrier Reef with a circle for Heron Island. (b) Aerial photograph of Heron Island with the reef flat study site shown as a star, the Heron Island Research Station aquarium system as a black rectangle and the channel cut in the reef flat as a white arrow.
The instrumentation array included a Monterey Bay Area Research Institute (MBARI) modified Sea-Bird 18 digital pH sensor sampling every second (1-second resolution, manufacturer’s reported precision of ± 0.001 pH units; field precision of approximately ± 0.01 pH units, Nido Instruments, USA), a Vector acoustic velocimeter (2-minute resolution; Nortek, Norway), and a Conductivity, Temperature, Depth (CTD) instrument (10-second resolution, SBE-16plusV2, Sea-Bird Electronics, USA) with a Satlantic Photosynthetically Active Radiation (PAR) sensor (Sea-Bird Scientific, USA). The instruments were attached to cinder blocks with PVC clips on the Heron Island reef flat (23°27’S, 151°55’E) in front of the research station approximately 50 m from shore at a submerged location, which ranged in tidal depth from 0.3 m to 2.5 m (Fig 1). The instrument array was connected to a waterproof CompacRIO computer pod (National Instruments, USA) and a 12V power supply (details of the instrumentation array can be found in [40, 41]). The pH sensors were swapped out with freshly calibrated sensors every 48–72 hours and cleaned daily. The pH sensors were calibrated to the seawater scale using a Denver pH meter (UB-10, Denver Instruments, NY, USA) with NBS standards and then used to prepare pH 6.00 and 8.20 filtered seawater standards. The mV readings of the pH sensors in the freshly prepared seawater standards were then used for sensor calibration to the seawater pH scale using a spreadsheet developed by MBARI. A powerful tropical storm in November 2010 disabled many of the field instruments and limited access to the site, resulting in a data gap in November.
Discrete samples for DIC, TA, and pH were collected at variable frequencies throughout the study. In June and December, availability of personnel allowed for the capture of the full diel cycle in DIC and TA through 3–4 hour interval sampling on the reef flat. During the winter and early spring months, we were constrained to sampling once or twice a day, typically at noon and at the daytime low tide, due to lack of personnel. DIC samples were measured with a LI-COR 7000 H2O:CO2 analyzer (LI-COR, Lincoln) coupled to an automated DIC sample introduction unit built by Stanford University’s Stable Isotope Laboratory. DIC precision ranged between ± 1–2 μmol kg-1, and the accuracy was determined with certified reference materials (CRMs) from A.G. Dickson (Scripps Institution of Oceanography, Oceanic Carbon Dioxide Quality Control). 226 DIC samples and 216 TA discrete samples were collected over the course of the study. TA was measured via potentiometric titrations in accordance with Gran titration procedures , using a T50 titrator with a small-volume DGi101-SC pH sensor (Mettler Toledo, Switzerland). All TA samples were corrected based on the offset between the measured and certified value of the CRM; TA precision was ± 3 μmol kg-1. DIC, TA, temperature and salinity were used to compute pCO2 and ΩAR, using CO2SYS . K1 and K2 dissociation constants used were from Mehrbach et al. (1973) , as refitted by Dickson and Millero (1987) , and the constant for sulfate, KSO4, was from . Monte Carlo simulations (5000 runs) provide error sensitivities of ± 3.5 ppm for pCO2, an error of ± 0.03 units for ΩAR, and ± 0.01 units for pH. We tested the sensitivities of outputs to input pairs and this analysis demonstrated that the derived values of TA are most sensitive to salinity changes. DIC and TA values were normalized to the 6-month average salinity of 35.2 psu and presented as nDIC and nTA. Non-normalized DIC and TA values were used with CO2SYS to compute aragonite saturation state and pCO2. Otherwise, we display salinity-normalized values for the 6-month period in order to remove the effects of rainfall and evaporation on the DIC and TA values and observe the effects of the benthos on the water column chemistry.
Thermodynamic vs. Biological Controls on pH and ΩAR
Variability in pH and ΩAR is driven by temperature and salinity as well as the relative concentrations of DIC and TA. Separately from the thermodynamic controls of temperature and salinity, the biological processes of net ecosystem calcification (NEC) and net ecosystem production (NEP) affect the TA/DIC ratio, which in turn affects the seawater pH and ΩAR at the site [22, 47]. To understand the relative contribution of these different drivers on pH and ΩAR variability, we performed a simple decomposition, previously described in [12, 48]: (1) (2) In each of these equations, the partial derivative accounting for the contribution of temperature, salinity, DIC, or TA was calculated by holding the other three components constant. The temperature, salinity, DIC, and TA values used in this were not hypothetical end-member values, but the data collected from Heron Island reef flat during December 2010 when there was a relatively high sampling resolution of 3–4 hours. This approach produces a time series of pH, ΩAR, and pCO2 along with relative contributions from temperature, salinity, DIC, and TA for the site.
Environmental Exposure Metrics
The environmental exposure metrics of intensity, duration, and severity of events were computed for the pH and temperature data following Hauri et al. (2013) . We use pH rather than ΩAR values for the development of a carbonate system metric because the pH data was sampled at much higher resolution (10 s), whereas the ΩAR values have been derived from relatively fewer discrete samples of DIC and TA over the duration of our study. While ΩAR provides much useful, biologically relevant information, in this case, the high-resolution pH dataset is more suitable for intensity and severity analyses on different time-scales. We also developed a new combined exposure metric for intensity, duration, and severity that incorporated both pH and thermal exposure. Anomalous pH and temperature events were recorded as intensity events, which we determined by observing when, to what extent, and for how long values exceeded a predetermined threshold (Table 1). We used a pH threshold of 8.1, based on the 2010 mean global open ocean pH , and a temperature threshold based on the mean monthly maximum temperatures measured by the Australian Institute of Marine Science from 2008–2013 with sensors distributed across the Heron Island lagoon (S1 Table). The duration of the thus-defined anomalous event was estimated as the amount of time passed until 15-minute mean values of pH or temperature returned to the threshold levels after exceedence. The severity of each event (either a low-pH or high-temperature event) was calculated as the product of intensity and duration (total pH unit•hr, °C•hr, respectively). Therefore, each month had a number of low-pH as well as a number of high-temperature events.
A combined exposure metric, containing information on both pH and temperature exposure, required a rescaling of the intensity, duration, and severity values for each variable. For example, within a given month, pH intensity, duration, and severity values were separately divided by the maximum intensity, duration, or severity, respectively, to normalize values for every month on a 0–1 scale. The same scaling was applied for the temperature variable. Then, the scaled intensity, duration, and severity were each averaged per month, for both pH and temperature (see Table 1 for equations). The composite metrics for intensity (total pH unit•°C), duration (hr), and severity (total pH unit•°C•hr) for a given month were computed by adding the mean monthly scaled pH exposure intensity to the mean monthly scaled thermal exposure intensity.
All statistical analyses were done on a MatLab platform. Pearson’s correlation was used to test correlations between datasets. The Kruskal-Wallis test was used to test for significant difference across seasons for the same environmental variable. Kruskal-Wallis is the non-parametric version of one-way analysis of variance and does not assume normal distribution of datasets; therefore, this test is better suited for the task at hand.
Variability in Environmental Parameters
As expected, diel average temperatures had winter minima and increased during the spring (Fig 2A). The largest diel temperature ranges were in the spring, in October (1.5–6.6°C), and lowest diel averages were observed in July (0.9–3.2°C; Fig 2A). Diel composites of temperature variability for an average 24-hr period for each month reveal consistent thermal maxima around noon to shortly afternoon, and minima around 02:00, as well as an increase in the mean temperature with progression through winter and spring (Fig 2D). In this study, the highest diel temperature maxima of 26.3 ± 1.2°C were observed in December, towards the end of austral spring. The mean monthly seawater temperatures ranged from 22.0 ± 0.7°C in June to 25.1 ± 0.6°C in December 2010 (Tables 2 and 3). Temperature varied across seasons in a statistically significant way, as evidenced by Kruskal-Wallis tests (Table 4).
(a) Box plots of temperature, (b) light and (c) water depth data with hourly resolution. The edges of the box are the mid-range (25–75th percentile), the lines extend to the most anomalous data points not considered outliers, and outliers are plotted individually. (d) Diel composites shown for each month for temperature, (e) light and (f) water depth.
PAR data showed a general increase in intensity from the fall to the end of spring (Fig 2B and 2E), with a small decline during the month of October likely due to cloudiness at the beginning of the rainy season (Table 2). Seasonal PAR increased steadily during this study period (Table 3), and differences across the seasons were statistically significant (Table 4).
Water depth measurements reveal a semi-diurnal tidal cycle with a tidal range between 0.5–2.5 m during spring tides and 0.5–1.5 m during neap tides (Fig 2C). Monthly averages of water depth reveal the variability of the time of day of spring and neap tides every month (Fig 2F). Three-hour averages for pH and water depth show a small but statistically significant correlation (r = 0.07, p = 0.04). Pearson’s correlation analysis reveals there is a similarly small yet statistically significant correlation (r = 0.22, p = 0.016) between water depth and total alkalinity.
Salinity levels on the reef flat had a mean of 35.3 ± 0.3 psu from June through the end of October, with occasional punctuated drops in the 33.0–33.5 psu range due to rain events. Mean salinity in December was lower at 33.9 ± 0.5 psu following a sustained period of rain in November (Fig 3A and 3B).
(a) Environmental data included salinity, (b) rainfall, (c) wind speed and (d) current velocity. The salinity and current velocity data were measured as part of this study while the rainfall and wind speed data are from the Australian Bureau of Meteorology (http://www.bom.gov.au/).
Water Depth, Rainfall, Wind and Current Velocities.
The spring had more regular rainy periods and higher average and maximum wind speeds (vmax >12 m s-1) in October 2010 (Fig 3B and 3C). The average rainfall was higher in the spring compared to winter, although there was one major rain event in mid-August. Southeasterly trade winds dominate this area, with westerly winds developing in the wintertime (Fig 3C). Currents on the reef flat were slowest on average in the fall and late spring with fastest along-shore velocities during these periods of around 2 cm s-1 to the SE and 5 cm s-1 to the NW, toward the harbor. In the winter, the velocities ranged from 10 cm s-1 to the SE to 15 cm s-1 to the NW (Fig 3D).
Nitrate values measured sporadically throughout the study period (n = 148) had a mean value of 0.3 ± 0.4 μmol/L while phosphate values had a mean value of 0.21 ± 0.14 μmol/L (S2 Table). The nitrate and phosphate levels are comparable to those routinely measured on oligotrophic coral reefs .
Variability in Carbonate Chemistry
The highest daytime pH values occurred in the fall with a decline in pH from the fall to the winter and a rise in pH in the spring (Table 2; Fig 4A and 4F). Seasonal trends were statistically significant (Table 4), with the mean pH declining from 8.24 ± 0.1 in the fall, to 8.12 ± 0.14 in the winter to 8.04 ± 0.14 in the spring (Tables 3 and 4). The greatest diel range was observed in the winter when the average minimum and maximum pH were 7.57 and 8.61, respectively (Table 3). Periods of lowest pH occurred in the winter during the night, which is expected considering the higher CO2 solubility at colder water temperatures in winter and potentially greater rates of respiration at night during those times (Fig 5B and 5H).
(a) Hourly resolution data for pH in total pH units, (b) salinity normalized dissolved inorganic carbon (nDIC) in μmol kg-1, (c) salinity normalized total alkalinity (nTA) in μmol kg-1, (d) the partial pressure of CO2 (pCO2) in μatm and (e) the aragonite saturation state (ΩARG). The edges of the box are the mid-range (25–75th percentile), the lines extend to the most anomalous data points not considered outliers, and outliers are plotted individually. (f) Diel composites of the data are shown for each month for pH, (g) nDIC, (h) nTA, (i) pCO2 and (j) ΩAR.
(a) The data for June 7–22, austral fall, is shown for water depth in m, (b) pH in total pH units, (c) salinity normalized dissolved inorganic carbon (nDIC) in μmol kg-1, (d) salinity normalized total alkalinity (nTA) in μmol kg-1, (e) the partial pressure of CO2 (pCO2) in μatm and (f) the aragonite saturation state (ΩARG). (g) Data for Nov. 29—Dec 13, austral spring, for water depth, (h) pH, (i) nDIC, (j) nTA, (k) pCO2, and (i) ΩAR. During these periods, discrete samples of DIC and TA were taken at least two times per day and in some cases every 3 hours.
nDIC and nTA samples were taken once to twice daily, typically at noon and at the daytime low tide, throughout most of the research period because of logistical constraints, thus what we report here are observed rather than true minima and maxima (Tables 3 and 4; Fig 4B and 4G). High-frequency sampling occurred in June and during a brief period in July and in December, which allowed for the full capture of diel cycles and thus reliable comparisons between late fall and late spring conditions (Fig 5).
December had a larger diel range in nDIC values compared to June (Fig 5C and 5I; Table 2). The lowest average monthly nDIC was in mid-winter, in August, and the highest in December (Table 2). The mean seasonal nDIC increased from fall to spring with the highest seasonal maximum occurring in spring (Table 3). No statistically significant difference emerged across seasons; however, that is likely to be caused by a low number of total samples collected (Table 4).
nTA followed similar trends as nDIC (Fig 4C and 4H; Tables 2 and 3), with higher diel averages, minima, and maxima observed in December compared to June. The higher values and greater variability in nTA were clearly seen when comparing data from June and December (Fig 5). Mean monthly nTA values increased from late fall to spring (Table 2). The greatest and smallest diel range in nTA occurred in the spring and the fall, respectively (Table 3). The seasonal trends were statistically significant, and the seasonal means in nTA increased steadily during the study period from fall to spring (Tables 3 and 4).
A comparison of the June to the December values shows more variability in pCO2 in December with higher daily values that peak at almost 900 μatm (Fig 5E and 5K). The lowest calculated pCO2 value was in August, as was the lowest monthly maximum (Table 2). The seasonal pCO2 trends were not statistically significant throughout the study period. This was also likely an artifact of the reduced discrete sampling during most of the winter and spring (Tables 3 and 4).
As expected, opposite trends to the pCO2 data were observed for ΩAR, with the smallest average diel means and minima observed in June (Fig 4E and 4J). A comparison of ΩAR values in June vs. December show that in June there was less variation around the mean 3.6 ± 0.3, while in December there was a greater range of values with high values of 5.5 and lows of 2.0 and a mean of 3.8 ± 0.7 (Fig 5F and 5I; Table 2). ΩAR seasonal means were all around 3.6 with no significant differences between fall, winter or spring (Table 4) that is also likely an artifact of the reduced discrete sampling during most of the winter and spring.
Thermodynamic vs. biological controls on pH and ΩAR.
We find that temperature and salinity have minimal contributions to pH and ΩAR variability, often an order of magnitude smaller than those driven by DIC and TA changes (Fig 6A–6C). TA and DIC have predictably opposing contributions, e.g., at night increasing DIC leads to a drop in pH and ΩAR and increase in pCO2, whereas the nighttime rise in TA counteracts the dropping pH and ΩAR and rise in pCO2 due to reintroduction of carbonate ions. Conversely, during the day at both sites, DIC decreases due to photosynthesis and calcification leads to a rise in pH and ΩAR and drop in pCO2, while TA consumption during calcification results in a decreased availability of carbonate ions and, hence, lowers pH and ΩAR and increases pCO2.
(a) Contributions of salinity, temperature, total alkalinity and DIC to changes in pH, (b) aragonite saturation state (ΩAR) and (c) pCO2. The complete sampling suite #s are times throughout the December 2010 study period when all of the parameters (S, T, pH, DIC, TA) were measured. The sign of percentage change (positive vs. negative) keeps track of the overall directionality of change in the pH, pCO2, or ΩAR value.
Thermal and pH exposure metrics of intensity, duration, and severity.
The pH data suggest that there were anomalous pH conditions in September and December based on the pH 8.1 mean open ocean threshold chosen, although we had data for only part of December. There were more low-pH events in September (60 events, Table 5) than in any other month. In June we only recorded 22 of these events, of which 80% had intensities ≤ 0.05 total pH units (Fig 7A, Table 5). The highest intensities were recorded in December, with 60% of the intensities ≥ 0.15 total pH units. This was largely due to two punctuated events of high intensity values. The low pH events in June were shortest, with 80% lasting 2 hours or less, while 40% and 60% of the low pH events in September and December respectively, lasted 10 hours or longer (Fig 7B). As a function of duration and intensity, September and December were the two months with the highest low-pH event severity during the study, while June had the lowest severity (Fig 7C).
(a) Frequency distribution of the mean intensity events, in total pH units, for each of the months in this study was plotted, while the duration of the events in hours was plotted in (b) and the mean severity in total ph units•hours in (c). The pH threshold (Th) was defined as 8.1 to represent the 2010 mean global open ocean pH. A similar procedure was used for the temperature data, but the mean monthly maximum temperature thresholds for each month (June-December) were determined based on temperature monitoring data available from 2008-present (Australian Institute for Marine Science, http://data.aims.gov.au/aimsrtds/station.xhtml?station=130). (d) The relative frequency distributions of monthly mean intensity of the high temperature events in °C, (e) the duration of these events in hours and (f) the mean monthly severity of these high temperature events in °C•hours. (g) The composite intensity including the mean monthly scaled pH and temperature intensity values, (h) combined duration including the mean monthly scaled pH and temperature duration values and (i) the combined severity.
The temperature conditions were arguably most anomalous in July, August and October (Table 5, Fig 7). The temperature data reveal that October had the greatest number of intense high-temperature events with approximately 40% of the exposure events with a mean intensity ≥1.2°C and 60% with a mean intensity ≥0.8°C. In December, 60% of the high-temperature events had a mean intensity between 0.8–1.2°C, while in October 40% were between 0.8–2.0°C (Fig 7D). The longest duration events occurred in the austral winter, June—August, with 60% of the temperature events lasting 4–8 hours in July and 80% in June lasting 3–4 hours (Fig 7E). In spring, high-temperature events were generally more intense but lasted only two hours or less in September and December. The most severe high-temperature events were in October, August and July, respectively (Fig 7F).
The combined environmental intensity, including values for both pH and temperature, increased from June to December with the highest combined intensity events in December, followed by October and September. The late fall (June) and winter months (July, August) had the lowest combined intensities (Fig 7G, Table 5). There was no seasonal pattern in the combined duration and severity of events (Fig 7H and 7I). The combined duration of events was longest in July, followed by October, largely driven by long-lived thermal exposure events. June exhibited the shortest combined duration of events. Even without the combined exposure metric, it was clear that the periods of highest intensity and severity of pH exposure events (September and December) corresponded to times of least intense and least severe thermal exposure events, and vice versa.
We contribute two rigorous analytical approaches with this paper: 1) the assessment of relative contribution of thermodynamic and biological drivers to variability in pH, aragonite saturation state, and pCO2, which provides further evidence that not only do reefs modulate their own reef water carbon chemistry, but they also effectively play a role in determining the exposure, and 2) the development of metrics for exposure to pH and temperature, which are two factors known to play an important role in physiological and ecological processes.
Relative Contribution of Thermodynamic and Biological Drivers
The biologically driven DIC and TA variability is a stronger driver of pH, ΩAR, and pCO2 than salinity and temperature, at this location (Fig 6). Since DIC and TA are driven primarily by reef metabolism processes, their influence on the variability of pH, ΩAR, and pCO2 suggests that changes in NEC and NEP would have a significant biogeochemical feedback on the diel variability and average diel values for pH and ΩAR on the reef in the future. Salinity-based reconstructions of carbonate system parameters, which are routinely used to calculate alkalinity in the open ocean (e.g., ), would not produce accurate representations of the environmental variability in aragonite saturation state or other carbonate system parameters in coral reefs.
Environmental Exposure Metrics for pH and Thermal Stress
Long-term observations such as these presented here from the Heron reef flat, as well as others, for example for various reef zones from Palmyra Atoll , raise the question what environmental metrics, for pH, temperature, and other variables, are most relevant to the physiological and ecological processes on reefs that may be affected by continued OA. Price et al. (2012)  provide estimates for duration of pH conditions above a certain threshold by using the metric of number of hours when pH stays above a site-specific climatological seasonal low (CSL) value. The authors find that net calcification rate and percent cover usually increase as the number of hours of pH exposure above the CSL increase . Our approach presented here used exposure in a different way, investigating intensity and duration of exceedence of a pH minimum threshold as well as temperature maximum threshold, thus adding one more way to examine pH variability on reefs as it may relate to vital ecological processes in these settings.
We used metrics of intensity, duration and severity developed for coral bleaching temperature data  and adapted it for carbonate chemistry data  for both pH and temperature stress alone and for a combined metric to try to better determine which months were likely more physiologically stressful during the 6-month study period. This analysis suggests that highly intense events of high severity generally do not occur simultaneously for high temperature and low pH exposure, especially at the end of fall (June) and end of spring (December) at Heron Island. This could have both positive and negative implications for the vulnerability of reef flats to climate changes as asynchronous impacts may allow reef organisms time to recover from low pH or high temperature exposure and possibly minimize synergistic impacts. However, the potential negative impacts could be that with asynchronous exposure there is less time during the year when the reef organisms are not exposed to potential stressful environmental conditions increasing the possibility that a sensitive life stage event such as reproduction or settlement occur under challenging environmental conditions.
Environmental exposure analysis can provide context with respect to how different reef habitats are conditioned by their environment. While a combined pH and thermal exposure metric has not been developed before, we view this study as an important effort to understand coupled environmental pressures associated with global change, and we recognize the limitations of the approach used here. The results are sensitive to the threshold values chosen, as was seen in , and we used a pH threshold of 8.1, based on the 2010 mean global open ocean pH , as a conservative first approach. In the future, a pH threshold based on long-term pH data for the site would be more appropriate for determining internal thresholds similarly to the way temperature thresholds were determined in this study. It will also be important to integrate additional environmental parameters such as PAR, additional carbonate chemistry parameters and nutrients into the combined exposure metrics. Furthermore, the combined metric assumes that the interactive effects between temperature and pH stress are additive but it is also possible that they could be synergistic with variable contributions, antagonistic or even have no interaction [54–56]. It is clear that more studies will be needed to determine the appropriate method to determine a combined metric for pH and temperature. Future studies, likely site-by-site and species-by-species, will further elucidate the distinctly different weight of pH and thermal stress contributions to organisms’ sensitivity and resistance to global change. Such future work will enable improved estimates for a combined exposure metric that will be useful for predicting and managing times with high environmental exposure severity.
The life-stage, energy reserve status and acclimation strategies of reef flat organisms will largely determine the respective physiological and ecological importance of the temperature and pH exposure events. For example, key life-stage events for reef flat corals include timing of mass spawning events, larval recruitment and settlement, as well as allocation of energy to reproductive output. Studies have shown that coral species experience energy trade-offs between different physiological processes (e.g., calcification, reproduction, etc.) when exposed to environmental stress [57, 58]. Coral spawning research at the Heron Island Research Station suggests that corals at this location typically spawn between November and January [59, 60]. Using coral and crustose coralline algae species found on Heron reef, research has shown that coral recruitment can be significantly hampered under future predicted OA conditions (pH 7.6–7.8) . If lowered pH conditions on the Heron reef occur during a critical part of the coral reproductive cycle, it is possible that corals could sacrifice calcification rate in order to maintain reproductive success. This could potentially lead to corals directing energy away from reproduction in order to maintain calcification under OA conditions or potentially shifting the timing of their spawning events. Our data show that during November-December the alkalinity is higher than the rest of the sampling period, which may be indicative of lower calcification rates. Lower calcification rates may be due to coral spawning events during this period, but could also be due to high cloud cover associated with decreasing light-enhanced calcification rates. Combined low pH, high temperature events will likely become more frequent in a high-CO2 future and as both the severity and duration of these stressful conditions increase, their potential impact may grow. However, there is emerging evidence that some coral reef environments (e.g., reef flats in Ofu, American Samoa) have been able to survive under conditions previously classified as severe exposure . Emerging research shows that biogeochemical feedback from declining calcification and increased photosynthesis on reefs may actually counteract expected pH declines in the future to some extent, yet at significant cost to coral reef health and ecosystem function .
Comparison of Seasonal Variability in Carbon Biogeochemistry
To provide more context for the seasonality we observe in this study, we compare our results from Heron Island in 2010 with studies from Media Luna reef, Puerto Rico in 2007–2008 ; Lady Elliott Reef flat, Great Barrier Reef from 2009–2010 ; and the Lower, Middle, and Upper Keys of the Florida Reef Tract from 2009–2010  (Table 6). Seasonal differences in carbon system parameters are assumed to be driven by the combination of the biogeochemical signature of incoming offshore waters, seasonality in key reef biological processes that influence the local carbonate chemistry including calcification/dissolution and photosynthesis/respiration, and changes in reef hydrodynamics and residence time . Comparing the results from the 4 reef studies confirms that Lady Elliott Island (LEI), a similar reef flat site on the GBR, had similar seasonal ranges in environmental variables to the Heron Island study as expected (Table 6). The temperature ranges are similar for these two GBR locations, but the absolute temperatures are generally lower at Heron Island than LEI, except in the winter, when the temperatures are quite similar at both sites. The salinity ranges for Heron Island and LEI are also similar to each other across the seasons: greater in the winter and spring, smaller in the summer and fall. The pH ranges for Heron Island and LEI are very similar, and the Heron Island pH seasonal average is greater than the Media Luna reef average during every season, but winter was characterized by the highest diel pH maxima in both GBR sites as well as at Media Luna.
Seasonal ranges in TA for the Florida Reef Tract (FRT) were an order of magnitude smaller than those for the GBR sites regardless of the season and could be due to a number of factors including a shorter seawater residence time, less coral coverage leading to less calcification, and increased dissolution along the FRT or a combination of these and other factors. The alkalinity ranges for LEI, however, were much greater than those for Heron Island, suggesting greater calcification/dissolution rates and/or greater residence time of LEI waters. The pCO2 maxima and the seasonal ranges are much higher for the GBR sites compared to the FRT, which correspond to the smaller ranges in the DIC and TA, suggesting that this may be an effect of the different reef characteristics and the chemical environment of the surrounding seawater feeding the reefs. The lowest seasonal averages for pCO2 in all sites were observed in the winter (Table 6). Lastly, the ΩAR ranges were greater across all seasons for the GBR sites compared to the FRT and the Puerto Rico sites, with LEI having the greatest ranges and the lowest minima. While ΩAR values are greater than 3.3 all the time for the FRT and most of the time for the Puerto Rico reef at Media Luna, the ΩAR values for the reef flats of the GBR reached minima close to an aragonite saturation state value of 1 quite frequently at night during every season, most markedly during the fall for LEI and the winter for Heron Island. These comparisons demonstrate that seawater chemical properties differ by reef location, reef type, residence time, ecological community composition, as well as calcification/dissolution and photosynthesis/respiration rates for the reef community.
Future Research Directions
This study found similar diel and seasonal trends as those observed on other reef flats and contributes to a number of such field studies [22, 23, 33, 62, 63, 65]. This 6-month high-resolution data set from the Heron Island reef flat reveals that there were large daily, weekly, monthly and seasonal variations in the environmental conditions measured.
Coral reefs are among the ecosystems most sensitive to OA impacts , yet the diel variability in carbonate chemistry on shallow reef zones often exceeds levels predicted for 2100 in the open ocean [12, 31], and coral calcification rates have already been observed to be sensitive to carbonate chemistry in much smaller pH ranges than those expected for the end of the century [7, 67]. High-frequency carbon system field studies are needed over longer time scales across different reef zones to help improve projections for future reef conditions in warmer and acidifying seas and help elucidate reef zone vulnerability. The urgent need for targeted reef biogeochemical monitoring efforts have been recognized as an ecosystem-based management priority  and will require a combination of CO2 buoy networks, autonomous instrumentation platforms that monitor at least two carbonate chemistry parameters autonomously, typically pH and pCO2, as well as regular discrete sampling for DIC and TA. Recent studies have also demonstrated the importance of combining high-resolution biogeochemical measurements with hydrodynamic characterization in order to best quantify the drivers of carbonate chemistry variability and the modulators of biological activity, reef metabolism and ecological community composition [25, 33]. Future studies should focus on temporal and spatial variability of carbonate chemistry and physiological responses of corals to document the heterogeneity of reef environments and to provide a better understanding of controls on carbon cycling, reef calcification, and aspects of reef resilience [69, 70].
Furthermore, high-resolution carbonate data is necessary to ground-truth, force and evaluate regional biogeochemical models, which could be used as an additional tool to analyze the drivers and magnitude of carbonate chemistry variability and to project how ocean acidification and climate change may affect the biogeochemical conditions in the future . With more, long-term high-resolution carbonate chemistry data it will become possible to incorporate it into a reef health model such as NOAA’s Coral Reef Watch  so that a combined thermal and pH stress predictive model could be developed.
Ocean acidification, warming and other multi-stressor experimental studies should attempt to incorporate the natural diel and seasonal variability in their controls and treatments as it will likely have a major impact on the results. A recent study on Heron Island  incorporated the natural reef variability by reproducing values of temperature and pCO2 measured from a reef buoy as their control treatments, and performed all pre-industrial and future treatments as an offset from these measured natural reef conditions. Additionally, recent field, in situ experimental studies have started incorporating natural variability in key ecosystem variables . Such work indicates natural environmental variability needs to be closely replicated in experimental design since tracking environmental variability will likely impact coral reef physiological and ecological responses, will ensure more biologically-relevant results, and will be critical to understanding the impacts of local and global stressors in a high CO2 future.
Quantifying the temporal dynamics in temperature, pH, and other variables on diel, monthly, and seasonal scales can indicate times where the coral reef community experiences potentially anomalous events such as low pH or high temperature conditions. Future research pairing such exposure information involving intensity, duration, and severity of events with information on physiological processes on reefs and their ecological community composition can provide crucial insights into how environmental dynamics confer or hinder resilience to a coral reef community in future warming and acidifying seas. We provide a method to create exposure metrics individually for pH and temperature as well as a combined additive exposure metric. Future work should be focused on improving environmental exposure metrics and demonstrate site-specific approaches to quantifying variable contributions from different variables, most importantly, the relationship between global stressors, e.g. pH and temperature, and local stressors, e.g. nutrient loading and sedimentation. While temperature is an exogenous environmental variable, a physical variable that coral reef organisms are passively subjected to, pH is a variable that has not only physical drivers but is also modulated by the coral reef ecosystem calcification processes as well.
In essence, to a large extent reefs modulate their own exposure to pH, especially in back-reef zones that are sometimes isolated from open ocean water. Reefs are both experiencing pH diel cycles, but they are also contributing to the actual range of the diel cycle. Studying the dynamics of diel cycles for long periods of time on coral reefs can help us better understand how different reefs can modulate their carbon system environment in different ways and how these modulations may interact to produce variable rates of ocean acidification on different reefs.
S1 Table. Sea-surface temperature (SST) monitoring data available from 2008-present for 11 sensors at various locations on the Heron Island lagoon and reef flat (Australian Institute for Marine Science, http://data.aims.gov.au/aimsrtds/station.xhtml?station=130).
From each of the 11 sensors, the maximum temperature was extracted for each month and then averaged across the 11 sensors to get a single maximum sea surface temperature (SST) for Heron Island reef representative of each month of each year. Then, a Mean Monthly Maximum (MMM) time series of 12 values was calculated based on the temperature data from 2008–2013.
We wish to thank the staff of the Heron Island Research station especially Matt Roy, Steve Venn, Kyra Hay, and Liz Perkins for all of their support throughout this project.
Conceived and designed the experiments: DIK LT KS TM AC MM RD KC SD OHG. Performed the experiments: DIK LT KS TM AC MM RD KC SD OHG. Analyzed the data: DIK LT KS CH. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: DIK RD KC BGM SD OHG. Wrote the paper: DIK LT KS CH TM AC MM RD KC BL TR BGM SD OHG.
- 1. Stocker T, Qin D, Plattner G, Tignor M, Allen S, Boschung J, et al. (2013) IPCC, 2013: climate change 2013: the physical science basis. Contribution of working group I to the fifth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change.
- 2. Cao L, Caldeira K (2008) Atmospheric CO2 stabilization and ocean acidification. Geophys Res Lett 35. pmid:24347740
- 3. Hoegh-Guldberg O (1999) Climate change, coral bleaching and the future of the world's coral reefs. Marine Freshwater Research 50: 839–866.
- 4. Erez J, Reynaud S, Silverman J, Schneider K, Allemand D (2011) Coral calcification under ocean acidification and global change. In: Dubinsky Z. and Stambler N., editors. Coral Reefs: An Ecosystem in Transition. Netherlands: Springer. pp. 151–176.
- 5. Doney SC, Fabry VJ, Feely RA, Kleypas JA (2009) Ocean Acidification: The Other CO2 Problem. Ann Rev Mar Sci 1: 169–192. pmid:21141034
- 6. Kleypas JA, Yates KK (2009) Coral Reefs and Ocean Acidification. Oceanography 22: 108–117.
- 7. Schneider K, Erez J (2006) The effect of carbonate chemistry on calcification and photosynthesis in the hermatypic coral Acropora eurystoma. Limnol Oceanogr 51: 1284–1293.
- 8. Ricke K, Orr J, Schneider K, Caldeira K (2013) Risks to coral reefs from ocean carbonate chemistry changes in recent earth system model projections. Environ Res Lett 8: 034003.
- 9. Silverman J, Lazar B, Cao L, Caldeira K, Erez J (2009) Coral reefs may start dissolving when atmospheric CO2 doubles. Geophys Res Lett 36.
- 10. Schneider K, Levy O, Dubinsky Z, Erez J (2009) In situ diel cycles of photosynthesis and calcification in hermatypic corals. Limnol Oceanogr 54: 1995–2002.
- 11. Putnam HM, Edmunds PJ (2011) The physiological response of reef corals to diel fluctuations in seawater temperature. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 396: 216–223.
- 12. Shaw EC, Mcneil BI, Tilbrook B, Matear R, Bates ML (2013) Anthropogenic changes to seawater buffer capacity combined with natural reef metabolism induce extreme future coral reef CO2 conditions. Global Change Biol 19: 1632–1641. pmid:23505026
- 13. Dufault AM, Cumbo VR, Fan TY, Edmunds PJ (2012) Effects of diurnally oscillating pCO2 on the calcification and survival of coral recruits. Proc R Soc B 279: 2951–2958. pmid:22513858
- 14. Hughes TP, Baird AH, Bellwood DR, Card M, Connolly SR, Folke C, et al. (2003) Climate change, human impacts, and the resilience of coral reefs. Science 301: 929–933. pmid:12920289
- 15. Kennedy EV, Perry CT, Halloran PR, Iglesias-Prieto R, Schönberg CH, Wisshak M, et al. (2013) Avoiding coral reef functional collapse requires local and global action. Curr Biol 23: 912–918. pmid:23664976
- 16. Hoegh-Guldberg O, Mumby PJ, Hooten AJ, Steneck RS, Greenfield P, Gomez E, et al. (2007) Coral Reefs Under Rapid Climate Change and Ocean Acidification. Science 318: 1737–1742. pmid:18079392
- 17. Dove SG, Kline DI, Pantos O, Angly FE, Tyson GW, Hoegh-Guldberg O (2013) Future reef decalcification under a business-as-usual CO2 emission scenario. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 110: 15342–15347. pmid:24003127
- 18. Crabbe MJC (2008) Climate change, global warming and coral reefs: Modelling the effects of temperature. Comput Biol Chem 32: 311–314. pmid:18565794
- 19. Oliver T, Palumbi S (2011) Do fluctuating temperature environments elevate coral thermal tolerance? Coral Reefs 30: 429–440.
- 20. Middlebrook R, Hoegh-Guldberg O, Leggat W (2008) The effect of thermal history on the susceptibility of reef-building corals to thermal stress. J Exp Biol 211: 1050–1056. pmid:18344478
- 21. Ohde S, van Woesik R (1999) Carbon dioxide flux and metabolic processes of a coral reef, Okinawa. Bull Mar Sci 65: 559–576.
- 22. Shaw EC, McNeil BI, Tilbrook B (2012) Impacts of ocean acidification in naturally variable coral reef flat ecosystems. Journal of Geophysical Research-Oceans 117.
- 23. Silverman J, Kline DI, Johnson L, Rivlin T, Schneider K, Erez J, et al. (2012) Carbon turnover rates in the One Tree Island reef: A 40-year perspective. Journal of Geophysical Research-Biogeosciences 117.
- 24. Anthony K, A Kleypas J, Gattuso JP (2011) Coral reefs modify their seawater carbon chemistry—implications for impacts of ocean acidification. Global Change Biol 17: 3655–3666.
- 25. Falter JL, Lowe RJ, Zhang Z, McCulloch M (2013) Physical and biological controls on the carbonate chemistry of coral reef waters: effects of metabolism, wave forcing, sea level, and geomorphology. PLoS One 8: e53303. pmid:23326411
- 26. Tudhope AW, Chilcott CP, McCulloch MT, Cook ER, Chappell J, Ellam RM, et al. (2001) Variability in the El Niño-Southern Oscillation through a glacial-interglacial cycle. Science 291: 1511–1517. pmid:11222850
- 27. Boylan P, Kleypas J (2008) New insights into the exposure and sensitivity of coral reefs to ocean warming. Proc 11th Int Coral Reef Symp. pp. 854–858.
- 28. Turner BL, Kasperson RE, Matson PA, McCarthy JJ, Corell RW, Christensen L, et al. (2003) A framework for vulnerability analysis in sustainability science. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 100: 8074–8079. pmid:12792023
- 29. Kline DI, Teneva L, Schneider K, Miard T, Chai A, Marker M, et al. (2014) 200 day in situ experiment reveals that the coral reef matrix may begin dissolving under high CO2. In Prep.
- 30. Frankignoulle M, Gattuso JP, Biondo R, Bourge I, CopinMontegut G, Pichon M (1996) Carbon fluxes in coral reefs. II. Eulerian study of inorganic carbon dynamics and measurement of air-sea CO2 exchanges. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 145: 123–132.
- 31. Hofmann GE, Smith JE, Johnson KS, Send U, Levin LA, Micheli F, et al. (2011) High-frequency dynamics of ocean pH: A multi-ecosystem comparison. PloS one 6: e28983. pmid:22205986
- 32. Gattuso JP, Frankignoulle M, Smith SV (1999) Measurement of community metabolism and significance in the coral reef CO2 source-sink debate. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96: 13017–13022. pmid:10557265
- 33. Teneva L, Dunbar R, Mucciarone D, Dunckley J, Koseff J (2013) High-resolution carbon budgets on a Palau back-reef modulated by interactions between hydrodynamics and reef metabolism. Limnol Oceanogr 58: 1851–1870.
- 34. Gove JM, Williams GJ, McManus MA, Heron SF, Sandin SA, Vetter OJ, et al. (2013) Quantifying Climatological Ranges and Anomalies for Pacific Coral Reef Ecosystems. PloS one 8: e61974. pmid:23637939
- 35. Santos IR, Glud RN, Maher D, Erler D, Eyre BD (2011) Diel coral reef acidification driven by porewater advection in permeable carbonate sands, Heron Island, Great Barrier Reef. Geophys Res Lett 38.
- 36. McGowan HA, Sturman AP, MacKellar MC, Wiebe AH, Neil DT (2010) Measurements of the local energy balance over a coral reef flat, Heron Island, southern Great Barrier Reef, Australia. J Geophys Res Atmos 115.
- 37. Chen D, Krol A (1997) Hydrology of Heron Island, Great Barrier Reef. In: Vacher H. L. and Quinn T. M., editors. Geology and Hydrogeology of Carbonate Islands. Amsterdam: Elsevier. pp. 867–884.
- 38. Gourlay MR, Jell JS (1993) Heron Island spoil dump. Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority.
- 39. Australian Bureau of Meteorology. Australian Institute of Marine Science.
- 40. Marker M, Kline DI, Kirkwood B, Headley K, Brewer P, Peltzer E, et al. (2010) The Coral Proto Free Ocean Carbon Enrichment System (CP-FOCE): Engineering and development. OCEANS 2010 IEEE. Sydney pp. 1–10. pmid:22639723
- 41. Kline DI, Teneva L, Schneider K, Miard T, Chai A, Marker M, et al. (2012) A short-term in situ CO2 enrichment experiment on Heron Island (GBR) accurately manipulates carbonate chemistry and causes variable physiological response in coral, crustose coralline algae and sediments. Sci Rep 2: 1–9. pmid:22629482
- 42. Dickson AG, Afghan JD, Anderson GC (2003) Reference materials for oceanic CO2 analysis: a method for the certification of total alkalinity. Mar Chem 80: 185–197.
- 43. Van Heuven S, Pierrot D, Lewis E, Wallace D (2009) MATLAB Program developed for CO2 system calculations. Oak Ridge National Laboratory Rep ORNL/CDIAC-105b.
- 44. Mehrbach C, Culberson CH, Hawley JE, Pytkowicz RM (1973) Measurement of the Apparent Dissociation Constants of Carbonic Acid in Seawater at Atmospheric Pressure. Limnol Oceanogr 18: 897–907.
- 45. Dickson A, Millero F (1987) A comparison of the equilibrium constants for the dissociation of carbonic acid in seawater media. Deep Sea Res A 34: 1733–1743.
- 46. Dickson AG (1990) Standard potential of the reaction: AgCl(s) + 1/2 H2(g) = Ag(s) + HCl(aq), and the standard acidity constant of the ion HSO−4 in synthetic seawater from 273.15 to 318.15 K. J Chem Thermodyn 22: 113–127.
- 47. Andersson AJ, Gledhill D (2013) Ocean Acidification and Coral Reefs: Effects on Breakdown, Dissolution, and Net Ecosystem Calcification. Annual Review of Marine Science, Vol 5 5: 321–348. pmid:22881351
- 48. Hauri C, Gruber N, Vogt M, Doney SC, Feely RA, Lachkar Z, et al. (2013) Spatiotemporal variability and long-term trends of ocean acidification in the California Current System. Biogeosciences 10. pmid:24839448
- 49. Hauri C, Gruber N, McDonnell A, Vogt M (2013) The intensity, duration, and severity of low aragonite saturation state events on the California continental shelf. Geophys Res Lett 40. pmid:24587563
- 50. Bell P (1992) Eutrophication and coral reefs—some examples in the Great Barrier Reef lagoon. Water Res 26: 553–568.
- 51. Lee K, Tong LT, Millero FJ, Sabine CL, Dickson AG, Goyet C, et al. (2006) Global relationships of total alkalinity with salinity and temperature in surface waters of the world's oceans. Geophys Res Lett 33. pmid:19122778
- 52. Price NN, Martz TR, Brainard RE, Smith JE (2012) Diel variability in seawater pH relates to calcification and benthic community structure on coral reefs. PloS one 7: e43843. pmid:22952785
- 53. Donner SD, Knutson TR, Oppenheimer M (2007) Model-based assessment of the role of human-induced climate change in the 2005 Caribbean coral bleaching event. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104: 5483–5488. pmid:17360373
- 54. Brown CJ, Saunders MI, Possingham HP, Richardson AJ (2013) Managing for interactions between local and global stressors of ecosystems. PloS one 8: e65765. pmid:23776542
- 55. Hofmann GE, Barry JP, Edmunds PJ, Gates RD, Hutchins DA, Klinger T, et al. (2010) The effect of ocean acidification on calcifying organisms in marine ecosystems: an organism-to-ecosystem perspective. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 41: 127–147.
- 56. Ban SS, Graham NA, Connolly SR (2014) Evidence for multiple stressor interactions and effects on coral reefs. Global Change Biol 20: 681–697. pmid:24166756
- 57. Anthony K, Connolly SR, Willis BL (2002) Comparative analysis of energy allocation to tissue and skeletal growth in corals. Limnol Oceanogr 47: 1417–1429.
- 58. Schoepf V, Grottoli A, Warner M, Cai W, Melman T, Hoadley K, et al. (2013) Coral Energy Reserves and Calcification in a High-CO2 World at Two Temperatures. PloS one 8: e75049. pmid:24146747
- 59. Ward S, Harrison P, Hoegh-Guldberg O (2002) Coral bleaching reduces reproduction of scleractinian corals and increases susceptibility to future stress. Proceedings of the Ninth International Coral Reef Symposium, Bali, 23–27 October 2000. pp. 1123–1128. pmid:11185398
- 60. Doropoulos C, Ward S, Diaz-Pulido G, Hoegh-Guldberg O, Mumby PJ (2012) Ocean acidification reduces coral recruitment by disrupting intimate larval-algal settlement interactions. Ecol Lett 15: 338–346.
- 61. Palumbi SR, Barshis DJ, Traylor-Knowles N, Bay RA (2014) Mechanisms of reef coral resistance to future climate change. Science 344: 895–898. pmid:24762535
- 62. Gray SEC, DeGrandpre MD, Langdon C, Corredor JE (2012) Short-term and seasonal pH, pCO2 and saturation state variability in a coral-reef ecosystem. Global Biogeochem Cycles 26.
- 63. Manzello DP, Enochs IC, Melo N, Gledhill DK, Johns EM (2012) Ocean acidification refugia of the Florida reef tract. PloS one 7: e41715. pmid:22848575
- 64. Bates N, Amat A, Andersson A (2010) Feedbacks and responses of coral calcification on the Bermuda reef system to seasonal changes in biological processes and ocean acidification. Biogeosciences 7: 2509–2530.
- 65. Shamberger K, Feely R, Sabine C, Atkinson M, DeCarlo E, Mackenzie F, et al. (2011) Calcification and organic production on a Hawaiian coral reef. Mar Chem 127: 64–75.
- 66. Hoegh-Guldberg O, Bruno JF (2010) The Impact of Climate Change on the World's Marine Ecosystems. Science 328: 1523–1528. pmid:20558709
- 67. de Putron S, McCorkle D, Cohen A, Dillon A (2011) The impact of seawater saturation state and bicarbonate ion concentration on calcification by new recruits of two Atlantic corals. Coral Reefs 30: 321–328.
- 68. McLeod E, Green A, Game E, Anthony K, Cinner J, Heron S, et al. (2012) Integrating Climate and Ocean Change Vulnerability into Conservation Planning. Coast Manage 40: 651–672.
- 69. Guadayol Ò, Silbiger NJ, Donahue MJ, Thomas FI (2014) Patterns in temporal variability of temperature, oxygen and pH along an environmental gradient in a coral reef. PloS one 9: e85213. pmid:24416364
- 70. Koweek D, Dunbar RB, Rogers JS, Williams GJ, Price N, Mucciarone D, et al. (2014) Environmental and ecological controls of coral community metabolism on Palmyra Atoll. Coral Reefs: 1–13.
- 71. Liu G, Matrosova L, Penland C, Gledhill D, Eakin C, Webb R, et al. (2008) NOAA Coral Reef Watch coral bleaching outlook system. Proceedings of the 11th International Coral Reef Symposium. Ft. Lauderdale, Florida.
- 72. Sabine CL, Mackenzie FT, Winn C, Karl DM (1995) Geochemistry of carbon dioxide in seawater at the Hawaii Ocean Time series station, ALOHA. Global Biogeochem Cycles 9: 637–651.