Small-quantity lipid-based nutrient supplements (SQ-LNS) are promising home fortification products, but the optimal zinc level needed to improve growth and reduce morbidity is uncertain. We aimed to assess the impact of providing SQ-LNS with varied amounts of zinc, along with illness treatment, on zinc-related outcomes compared with standard care. In a placebo-controlled, cluster-randomized trial, 34 communities were stratified to intervention (IC) or non-intervention cohorts (NIC). 2435 eligible IC children were randomly assigned to one of four groups:1) SQ-LNS without zinc, placebo tablet; 2) SQ-LNS containing 5mg zinc, placebo tablet; 3) SQ-LNS containing 10mg zinc, placebo tablet; or 4) SQ-LNS without zinc and 5mg zinc tablet from 9–18 months of age. During weekly morbidity surveillance, oral rehydration salts were provided for reported diarrhea and antimalarial therapy for confirmed malaria. Children in NIC (n = 785) did not receive SQ-LNS, tablets, illness surveillance or treatment. At 9 and 18 months, length, weight and hemoglobin were measured in all children. Reported adherence was 97±6% for SQ-LNS and tablets. Mean baseline hemoglobin was 89±15g/L. At 18 months, change in hemoglobin was greater in IC than NIC (+8 vs -1g/L, p<0.0001), but 79.1% of IC were still anemic (vs. 91.1% in NIC). Final plasma zinc concentration did not differ by group. During the 9-month observation period, the incidence of diarrhea was 1.10±1.03 and of malaria 0.54±0.50 episodes per 100 child-days, and did not differ by group. Length at 18 months was significantly greater in IC compared to NIC (77.7±3.0 vs. 76.9±3.4cm; p<0.001) and stunting prevalence was significantly lower in IC (29.3%) than NIC (39.3%; p<0.0001), but did not differ by intervention group within IC. Wasting prevalence was also significantly lower in IC (8.7%) than in NIC (13.5%; p = 0.0003). Providing SQ-LNS daily with or without zinc, along with malaria and diarrhea treatment, significantly increased growth and reduced stunting, wasting and anemia prevalence in young children.
Citation: Hess SY, Abbeddou S, Jimenez EY, Somé JW, Vosti SA, Ouédraogo ZP, et al. (2015) Small-Quantity Lipid-Based Nutrient Supplements, Regardless of Their Zinc Content, Increase Growth and Reduce the Prevalence of Stunting and Wasting in Young Burkinabe Children: A Cluster-Randomized Trial. PLoS ONE 10(3): e0122242. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0122242
Academic Editor: James G. Beeson, Burnet Institute, AUSTRALIA
Received: June 20, 2014; Accepted: February 12, 2015; Published: March 27, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Hess et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Data Availability: All files are available from the Figshare database (accession number http://dx.doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.1301239).
Funding: The project was funded by a grant from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation to the University of California, Davis. The funder had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: KHB has worked as a consultant and later as employee for the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. SA declares non-financial support from Nutriset SAS, outside the submitted work. None of the other authors have a conflict of interest to declare. This does not alter the authors’ adherence to PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Growth stunting in early life continues to be a critical public health concern in low-income countries [1,2]. Diarrhea and pneumonia are leading causes of morbidity and mortality among young children in low income countries and the case fatality for these illnesses is increased in undernourished children [3,4]. Although the global malaria burden has decreased in the past decade, it remains very high in sub-Saharan Africa . Supplemental zinc increases linear growth and weight gain and reduces the incidence of diarrhea and pneumonia among children under 5 years of age [6–10]. Small quantity lipid-based nutrient supplements (SQ-LNS) have been designed to prevent undernutrition and promote health and development . SQ-LNS provide ~20 g or ~110–120 kcal per day along with additional protein, essential fatty acids and 22 micronutrients, including zinc. Trials investigating the potential of SQ-LNS and medium-quantity LNS (MQ-LNS; at ~50 g or ~250–280 kcal per day) to prevent malnutrition and promote growth have yielded mixed results [12–17]. Only a few of these studies reported morbidity outcomes, and none detected any benefit of SQ-LNS [14,15]. Thus, the beneficial impact of zinc on growth and morbidity is less clear when provided mixed with food, such as point-of-use fortification of complementary foods with SQ-LNS or multiple micronutrient powders (MNP), possibly because of insufficient zinc content.
While there is strong evidence that providing 3–20 mg zinc supplements daily as syrup or tablets consistently results in significantly increased plasma zinc concentrations (pZn) in the zinc supplemented group compared to the placebo control group , findings from home fortification trials are inconsistent. Most, but not all, studies providing 5 mg zinc in a daily dose of SQ-LNS or MNP did not find increased pZn at the end of the study [19–21]. One study in young Iranian children who received 5 mg of zinc in MNP and one study in young Cambodian children who received 10 mg of zinc in MNP found a significantly increased pZn at the end of the study compared to a placebo control group and non-intervention group, respectively [22,23]. Possible explanations for this lack of response in biochemical and functional outcomes are: 1) the dose of zinc was inadequate because less zinc is absorbed from zinc-containing preparations that are provided with meals than from water-soluble zinc supplements provided between meals, 2) the study populations were not zinc deficient, so they did not respond functionally to additional zinc, and/or 3) zinc consumed with meals was taken up preferentially by non-metabolically active zinc pools.
The present study had two primary objectives: 1) To compare zinc-related functional responses among young Burkinabe children who received SQ-LNS containing 0, 5 or 10 mg of zinc and placebo tablet or SQ-LNS without added zinc, plus 5 mg zinc tablets along with treatment for diarrhea and malaria episodes; and 2) to compare the impact of the intervention package among children in intervention vs. non-intervention communities. Cluster-randomization at the level of the family compound (i.e. concession) in the intervention communities was used to prevent cross-contamination between intervention groups through food sharing. Major outcomes included physical growth, morbidity from common infections (specifically, diarrhea and malaria), and change in pZn.
Materials and Methods
Study Design and Participants
The study was designed as a partially masked, placebo-controlled, cluster-randomized intervention trial. The trial was conducted from April 2010 to July 2012 in rural communities of the Dandé Health District in southwestern Burkina Faso. Ethical approval for the study protocol and the consent procedure was provided by the Institutional Review Boards of the Centre Muraz in Bobo-Dioulasso (Burkina Faso) and the University of California Davis (USA). The study was registered as a clinical trial with the U.S. National Institutes of Health (NCT00944281;).
Nine-month old infants were identified by periodic censuses in the study area. Written, informed consent was obtained from one of the child’s primary caregivers (mother, father or legal guardian). In case the caregiver was illiterate, an impartial witness was present during the consent process, who confirmed that the information in the consent document was accurately explained to the participant, and that consent was freely given. Children were considered eligible if they were 8.8 to 9.9 months of age, resided permanently in the area, planned to be available during the study period and had written parental consent. Exclusion criteria were: hemoglobin (Hb) <50 g/L, weight-for-length <70% of the median of the National Center for Health Statistics/World Health Organization (NCHS/WHO) growth reference  presence of bipedal edema, other severe illness warranting hospital referral, congenital abnormalities potentially interfering with growth, chronic medical conditions requiring frequent medical attention, known HIV infection of infant or mother, history of allergy towards peanuts, history of anaphylaxis or serious allergic reaction to any substance requiring emergency medical care, and concurrent participation in any other clinical trial. Once enrolled, children were withdrawn from study participation when absent from the study for more than 3 weeks, although data collected until that time were retained.
The sample size estimates were based on the number of children needed in each group to detect (with a significance level of P<0.05 and power >0.80) effect sizes that are consistent with the magnitude of effects observed in previous zinc supplementation trials [6,25]. In particular, the sample sizes were based on an effect size of >0.22 for diarrhea incidence, malaria incidence, and physical growth; and 0.6 for change in pZn. The target sample size per intervention group for incidence of diarrhea and malaria and growth was n = 583 and for biochemical indicators of nutritional status n = 85. This included an assumed attrition rate of 15% for morbidity and growth outcomes and 20% for the biochemical outcomes. The estimated sample size for the NIC was increased for an assumed design effect of 1.5 due to the cluster sampling design.
Randomization and Masking
This trial included two levels of randomization: 1) the community and 2) the concession. Thirty-four communities that were accessible year-round were chosen. A statistician at the University of California Davis stratified individual communities by selected indicators (population size; proximity to road and Bobo-Dioulasso; and health clinic affiliation) and computer-generated an assignment within strata to participate in the intervention cohort (IC; 25 communities) or in the non-intervention cohort (NIC; 9 communities). The same statistician, who was blinded to the intervention, generated a random allocation sequence at the level of the concession for the enrollment of eligible infants in the IC. Eligible children meeting the inclusion criteria were allocated to one of four interventions from 9 to 18 months of age: 1) SQ-LNS without zinc, and placebo tablet (LNS-Zn0), 2) SQ-LNS with 5 mg zinc, and placebo tablet (LNS-Zn5), 3) SQ-LNS with 10 mg zinc, and placebo tablet (LNS-Zn10), or 4) SQ-LNS without zinc, and 5 mg zinc tablet (LNS-TabZn5). Children in the intervention groups received free treatment for diarrhea, malaria and fever, as described in more detail below. Children in the NIC did not receive SQ-LNS or tablets from 9 to 18 months of age, nor any illness treatment, but received SQ-LNS from 18 to 27 months after the data collection was finished. The trial was partially masked, as all participants, field staff and researchers remained blinded to the four intervention groups until data analyses were completed, but were aware which communities were assigned to IC and NIC.
The LNS products were developed for the iLiNS project  by Nutriset SAS (Malaunay, France) and tested for acceptability . A weekly ration of LNS was initially delivered to participating children in plastic cups containing 140 g (sufficient for one week) and later in seven sachets containing 20 g each. The child’s caregiver was advised to feed the day’s allotment (20 g = 2 spoonsful) mixed in food during two separate meal times. The LNS for each treatment group were identical, except for their zinc content. Besides zinc, a daily ration of LNS provided 118 kcal and 6 mg iron along with 20 other micronutrients . Table 1 shows the nutrient content of a daily ration of SQ-LNS compared with the Recommended Nutrient Intakes by WHO and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) [27,28]. Zinc tablets were provided as water-dispersible tablets produced by Nutriset SAS (Malaunay, France) containing 5 mg zinc or an identical placebo. The caregivers were advised to provide the tablet once daily, dissolved in water or breast milk, but not with other foods. SQ-LNS and packages of tablets were labeled with one of eight color codes (two colors per intervention group). Caregivers were given brief feeding advice at enrollment, which included the above-described instructions for SQ-LNS and tablets and recommendations to continue breastfeeding and to provide a variety of nutritious foods.
At the time of enrollment, children’s length, weight, mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC) and head circumference (HC) were measured in IC and NIC. Maternal height and weight, and information on the child’s dietary practices and family socio-economic status (SES) were also obtained for all children. The age of the participants was confirmed from health cards. A capillary sample was collected for onsite analyses of Hb concentration (Hemocue 201+, HemoCue AB, Ängelholm, Sweden) and a rapid diagnostic test (RDT) for malaria parasites, based on histidine-rich protein II (SD BIOLINE Malaria Ag P.F/Pan, Standard Diagnostics, INC., Kyonggi-do, Korea). Capillary blood (300 μL) was collected in microcuvettes containing lithium heparin (CB 300 LH, Sarstedt AG & Co, Nümbrecht, Germany) for assessment of zinc protoporphyrin (ZPP) concentration. In case of illness, all children screened received free medical treatment(s): in case of diarrhea oral rehydration salts (ORS) packets were provided, children with fever received paracetamol and children with a positive RDT received anti-malarial treatment (artesunate-amodiaquine combination therapy and paracetamol). Children with Hb <80 g/L received anthelmintic treatment (mebendazole 200 mg/day for 3 days) and iron supplements (2–6 mg iron/kg body weight for 30 days). Children with weight-for-length <70% of the median of the NCHS/WHO growth reference  or with malaria or diarrhea with complications or any other illness requiring medical follow up were referred to the health center. Enrollment continued until the target sample size was met. In the case of twins, both were enrolled in the study, but only one was randomly selected for inclusion in the data analysis.
Children in the IC were visited weekly for delivery of intervention products and morbidity surveillance using standardized data collection tools. During each visit, reported LNS and tablet consumption was recorded, and empty and unused packages were collected for assessment of adherence. At each visit, the field worker evaluated the child for the presence of clinical danger signs, and evidence of uncomplicated diarrhea, fever, or malaria, which were treated in the community, as described above. In case of reported fever on the day of or the day before the surveillance visit, the field worker performed an RDT and measured aural body temperature. Children with danger signs, and diarrhea, fever and malaria with complications and any other cases of severe illness were referred to the health center for evaluation and treatment. Surveillance field workers participated in regular training, and refresher sessions and were overseen by field supervisors and two study physicians. A randomly selected sub-sample of children participated in 12-hr home observations at 11 and 16 months of age, as described in more detail elsewhere .
The anthropometric measurements described above were repeated at 12 and 15 months in IC only. From the age of 9 to 18 months, children in NIC were not supplemented nor visited by study personnel; they relied on standard care provided by the family and health system. At 18 months, all children (IC and NIC) were invited for a final follow up examination, where anthropometric assessments were repeated, and Hb concentration was assessed. Children’s and mothers’ weights were measured to 50 g precision (Seca Model 383 and Seca Model 874) and children’s length (Seca Model 417), MUAC (26 cm Tri-Colored Single-Slotted Insertion Tape), HC (ShorrTape Measuring Tape), and mothers’ height (Seca Model 217) were measured to 0.1 cm precision. Four teams of two anthropometrists each completed measurements in both IC and NIC and were systematically restandardized. During 12 standardization sessions, the mean technical error of measurement (TEM) for length was 0.50 cm and ranged from 0.09 to 0.74 cm (N = 120) considering both intra- and inter-observer variability .
At enrollment, a subset of children in IC and NIC were randomly assigned to the “biochemistry sub-group” for a venous blood draw. To avoid intra-concession correlation in this sub-group, only one child was randomly selected per family compound. Final venous blood samples were obtained from the same sub-set of children at 18 months of age. On both occasions, children were free of symptoms of diarrhea and fever during the previous 48 hr, and 5 mL of blood was drawn 1–2 hr after the last breastfeeding episode from an antecubital or dorsal metacarpal vein. Blood was collected in evacuated, trace element-free polyethylene tubes containing lithium heparin (Sarstedt AG & Co, Nümbrecht, Germany), stored on ice and transported to the field laboratory, where ZPP was assessed in unwashed capillary whole blood by hematofluorometer (206D, AVIV Biomedical Inc., Lakewood, NJ, USA). Plasma was separated from heparinized venous blood by centrifuging at 2800 rpm for 10 min and stored at -20°C until shipped on dry ice to the respective laboratories for analysis. All blood collection and processing procedures conformed with recommendations by the International Zinc Nutrition Consultative Group (IZiNCG) . pZn was determined by inductively-coupled plasma atomic emission spectrometry following overnight digestion in 70% nitric acid at the Children’s Hospital Oakland Research Institute [32,33]. C-reactive protein (CRP) and α-1-acid glycoprotein (AGP) were analyzed by ELISA by DBS-Tech in Willstaett, Germany .
Length-for age (LAZ), weight-for-age (WAZ), and weight-for-length z-scores (WLZ) were calculated according to the World Health Organization 2006 growth standards . Stunting, underweight and wasting were defined as <-2 standard deviation (SD) LAZ, WAZ and WLZ, respectively. Diarrhea was defined as the presence of ≥3 loose or liquid stools per 24 hr. Reported fever was defined as any fever reported by the caregiver. Confirmed fever was defined as aural temperature >37.5°C. Any episode of reported or confirmed fever associated with a positive RDT was defined as malaria. A child was considered at risk for malaria if the child did not receive any antimalarial treatment within the previous 21 days. New episodes of diarrhea and fever were considered when at least 48 hr had elapsed since a previous episode. To assess food security, the Household Food Insecurity Access Scale (HFIAS ) was adjusted for season and year. Using principal components analysis, an asset index was computed from information on baseline ownership of a set of assets, lighting source, drinking water supply, sanitation facilities, and flooring materials . pZn and ZPP concentrations were adjusted for the presence of inflammation (elevated acute phase proteins categorically defined as CRP >5 mg/L, AGP >1 g/L, or both). Cut-offs used to define deficiency for each indicator were: pZn < 65 μg/dL; Hb < 110 g/L; ZPP >70 μmol/mol heme.
The primary outcomes were growth, incidence of diarrhea, incidence of malaria and pZn. All statistical analyses were completed with SAS System software for Windows release 9.2 (SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina, USA). Data are presented as means ± SD, unless otherwise noted. Treatment groups remained masked until all statistical analyses were completed and main conclusions were drawn.
Descriptive statistics were used to examine all variables. Because the method of allocating communities to the two cohorts did not result in equal probabilities of being selected for intervention, selected variables were compared between cohorts using linear mixed models for continuous variables, mixed logistic regression models for binary variables, including random effects of village and concession, and Chi-square tests accounting for community for non-binary categorical variables. Covariates and potential effect modifiers were defined prior to analyses. Linear mixed model ANCOVA (SAS MIXED procedure) was used to compare anthropometric outcomes, and Hb, pZn, AGP and CRP concentrations between the two cohorts, among the four intervention groups and among the five groups (four intervention groups and NIC) with adjustment for baseline value, age, other relevant variables and random effects (village, concession, if appropriate). Differences in the prevalence of stunting, underweight, and wasting at the end of the study were compared with mixed model logistic regression (SAS GLIMMIX procedure) adjusting for respective baseline z-score and other co-variates. Potential modifying effects with an interaction with the treatment group and/or cohort were considered significant if P<0.1. The modifying effects of baseline LAZ on the change in LAZ was examined by estimating adjusted means at the 10th, 50th and 90th percentile of baseline LAZ.
Morbidity outcomes were compared by using mixed effects logistic regression (SAS GLIMMIX procedure), including random effects of concession, and accounting for overdispersion. Treatment of diarrhea included treatments provided both by project field workers and health centers. For treatment of malaria, only the treatment provided by field workers was considered. Differences in mortality rates between enrollment and end of the study were compared with logistic regression including random effects of village and concession.
Of 3402 children screened for eligibility, 3220 were enrolled in the study (Fig. 1). Of these, 2435 were randomly assigned to one of the 4 treatment groups in the IC and 785 to the NIC. Among the four intervention groups, 19.5% dropped out by the final visit at 18 months. In the NIC, 15.2% were lost to anthropometric follow up at 18 months. Caregivers of 97.1% of children in the intervention groups provided morbidity surveillance information for at least 30 days and 78% provided information for at least 35 weeks, with no difference in participation rates among the four intervention groups.
Potential biases associated with loss to follow up were assessed. There were no differences in child, maternal, or household characteristics or SES between children who completed the study and those who dropped out, except for maternal age. Mothers of children who completed the study were slightly older than those of non-completers (27.0 ± 6.7 vs. 26.2 ± 6.7; P = 0.004).
At enrollment, children had a mean age of 9.4 ± 0.35 months, and almost all children (99.9%) were still breastfed. Most baseline child and maternal characteristics did not differ among the groups (Table 2). However, WAZ and WLZ of children in LNS-Zn10 were significantly lower than in children in the LNS-TabZn5 group at baseline. There was also a significant difference in maternal education and marital status/rank. More women in NIC had no education (67.6%) compared to women in the 4 intervention groups (56.2–60.8%). Although other SES characteristics were not significantly different between groups, there was a tendency towards lower SES in the NIC.
Caregivers reported high daily adherence to SQ-LNS (96.8% ± 6.5%) and to tablets (97.4% ± 6.4%). Disappearance rates of both products also indicated high weekly adherence . In contrast, during the 12-hr home observations only 62.6% and 54.1% of children at 11 and 16-months, respectively, were observed receiving SQ-LNS during the 12-hr observation periods and 32.0% and 27.1%, respectively, were observed receiving tablets.
Mean baseline Hb was 89 ± 15 g/L, and 91.1% of the children were anemic at enrollment. At 18 months of age, mean Hb concentration increased significantly in IC compared to NIC, with no difference among the four intervention groups (Table 3). This increase in Hb concentration resulted in a final anemia prevalence of 79.1% in IC, compared with 91.1% of children in NIC (P<0.0001). Mean baseline pZn was 69.0 ± 1.2 μg/dL and 35.2% of children had low pZn concentration at enrollment. There was no difference in final mean pZn among any of the study groups nor between IC and NIC. The intervention also did not have a significant impact on mean AGP and CRP concentrations at 18 months, nor on the prevalence of elevated AGP. However, significantly fewer IC children had elevated CRP at 18 months than NIC children (28.9% vs. 41.9%; P = 0.010).
At 18 months, adjusted mean length, weight, MUAC and HC were all significantly greater in IC children compared to NIC children (Table 4), but there were no differences among the 4 intervention groups in any of these outcomes. There was a significant modifying effect of initial length on the difference in growth between IC and NIC children (P = 0.023; Fig. 2). In particular, the change in length was significantly greater among IC children with the lowest 10th percentile of initial length compared to NIC children (P<0.0001). At baseline, mean LAZ, WAZ and WLZ were -1.21 ± 1.10, -1.42 ± 1.14, and -0.99 ± 1.05, respectively, in all five groups combined. These z-scores were significantly greater in IC children compared to NIC at 18 months, with no difference among the 4 intervention groups. The increase in length and weight in IC from 9 to 18 months resulted in a significantly lower prevalence of stunting, underweight and wasting in IC compared to NIC. At 18 months, 39.3% of NIC children were stunted compared to 29.3% of IC children (P<0.0001) and 13.5% of NIC children were wasted compared to 8.7% of IC children (P = 0.0003). The prevalence of stunting did not differ among the four intervention groups. However, the prevalence of underweight was marginally higher in children in the LNS-Zn10 group compared to children in the LNS-TabZn5 group (26.3% vs 15.2%, P = 0.089). Similarly, the prevalence of wasting in LNS-Zn10 (13.2%) was significantly higher than in LNS-TabZn5 (5.4%) and LNS-Zn0 (7.2%; P = 0.003). In the 5-group comparison of wasting prevalence, there was no difference between LNS-Zn10, LNS-Zn5 and NIC (P>0.05).
During the 9 months intervention period in the IC, the mean (95% confidence interval (CI)) prevalence of diarrhea in all four groups combined was 3.08% (2.94, 3.22) and the mean (± SD) diarrhea incidence was 1.10 ± 1.03 per 100 child-days. These did not differ among the four intervention groups (Table 5). The intra-cluster (i.e., concession) correlation for diarrhea incidence was ~0.16, resulting in a design effect of about 1.10 for diarrhea incidence. The proportion of all diarrhea episodes treated according to the study protocol ranged from 36.4% to 41.3% and did not differ by study group. At enrollment, the proportion of children with a positive RDT (61.4% overall) did not differ among groups. During the 9 months follow up, the overall mean malaria prevalence and mean malaria incidence did not differ by group. Almost all malaria episodes were treated (99.0%), and treatment rates did not differ by study group.
There were no significant differences in hospitalization (P = 0.394) or mortality (P = 0.125) rates among children in the four intervention groups. At 18 months, caregivers were asked whether they sought medical services for the study children, and retrospective reports were marginally higher in IC versus NIC (57% vs 54%, P = 0.083), but did not differ among all five study groups (P = 0.412). The mortality rate was significantly lower in IC than NIC (1.4% vs 3.2% P = 0.005). When all five study groups were compared, this difference was only significant between NIC and LNS-Zn5 (Fig. 1).
Provision of SQ-LNS along with simple feeding advice and treatment of confirmed cases of malaria and reported diarrhea resulted in significantly greater growth velocity and lower prevalence of stunting, wasting and anemia among children in the IC compared to children in the NIC. The growth effect was significantly greater among children whose initial length was below the 10th percentile of initial length of study participants, indicating that those with the greatest degree of initial growth restriction benefitted most. This reduction in stunting prevalence is of public health significance considering that stunting is associated with increased risk of morbidity and mortality, impaired cognition and educational performance, lower adult wages, and, when accompanied by excessive weight gain later in childhood, increased risk of nutrition-related chronic diseases [1,2].
Within the IC, there were no detectable differences in zinc-related outcomes, such as increased growth, morbidity reduction or change in pZn, regardless of the amount or form of supplemental zinc, implying that the different amounts of zinc provided in SQ-LNS or as dispersible tablet were neither protective nor harmful. Possible explanations for these findings are poor adherence to supplements, poor absorption of zinc from these supplements, deficiencies of other nutrients causing limited responses, or lack of zinc deficiency in the study population. Although reported adherence was very high, 12-hr home observations during home visits revealed that only 59% of children were offered SQ-LNS, and only 30% of the children received a tablet during the 12-hr home observation. Moreover, almost half of all children (46%) who were offered a tablet on the day of observation received the tablet less than 30 min after a meal . Thus, it is possible that adherence to the zinc tablets and/or absorption of zinc from the tablets were less than optimal. It is less likely that concurrent deficiencies of other nutrients limited responses since SQ-LNS provided all IC children with 21 micronutrients and essential fatty acids . Absence of zinc deficiency in the study population is also an unlikely explanation since 54% of children had low pZn at the end of the study.
Although there were no significant differences in mean WLZ among the four intervention groups at the end of the study, the wasting prevalence at 18 months was significantly higher in LNS-Zn10 (13.2%) compared to LNS-Zn0 (7.2%) and LNS-TabZn5 (5.4%; P = 0.003). It is unlikely that this higher wasting prevalence in the LNS-Zn10 group was due to an adverse effect of zinc. A meta-analysis of 22 studies of preventive zinc supplementation provided either as tablets or syrup, including 13 studies that provided 10 mg supplemental zinc, found a small, marginally significant, positive effect of zinc on change in weight-for-height z-score . A previous study found no differences in LNS acceptability or LNS consumption in relation to zinc content , so differences in LNS consumption is also an unlikely explanation. Rather, it seems that the difference in final wasting prevalence is a chance finding given that we found no other significant differences in any of the growth and morbidity outcomes among the intervention groups.
While larger quantity LNS has proven useful in the treatment of children with severe acute malnutrition , the potential of SQ-LNS to prevent malnutrition and improve health and nutrition status is only beginning to be explored. In the present study, the standardized mean difference of LAZ at the end of the study was 0.27 between the children in IC who received the intervention package compared to children in NIC. Similarly, Adu-Afarwuah and colleagues found a standardized mean difference of final LAZ of 0.26 between Ghanaian children who received SQ-LNS compared to children in a non-intervention group, although the difference in final LAZ at 12 months of age was not significant, probably due to the smaller sample size in the Ghana study . Over the 9-months intervention period we found an effect size in length of 0.48. In contrast, a smaller but also significant effect size of 0.11 was found for the longitudinal average monthly growth effect in Haiti . Possible explanations for these differences are the community-based provision of disease treatment and/or differences in initial LAZ of these study populations. Whereas treatment of diarrhea and malaria was provided by the field team in the present study, no treatment was provided in the studies in Ghana and Haiti. In addition, the mean baseline LAZ was much lower in the Burkinabe children (-1.21 ± 1.10) compared to the baseline LAZ of -0.20 ± 1.0 and -0.39 ± 1.20 in the studies in Ghana and Haiti, respectively. A fourth trial in young Malawian children with mean initial LAZ of -1.00 ± 0.77 found that infants with baseline LAZ below the median who received 50 g LNS gained more length than children who received a micronutrient-fortified maize-soy flour for 12 months . This is consistent with our findings that children with the greatest degree of growth restriction benefitted most.
Diarrhea is associated with a small decrease in linear growth over the long term , but findings from longitudinal studies investigating the impact of malaria on growth are inconsistent [40–43]. One study found that only Plasmodium vivax was a predictor of stunting and wasting and not Plasmodium falciparum ; the latter was the most common parasite type in our study. Because all children in the intervention groups received SQ-LNS along with simple feeding advice and illness treatment, it is uncertain what proportion of the growth impact in IC children can be attributed to SQ-LNS alone and how much was due to the malaria and/or diarrhea treatment. In the present study, the frequency of treated malaria episodes did not have an impact on average change in growth , and it is unlikely that the provision of ORS would have an impact on growth. Nevertheless, to explore the possible effects of illness treatment we compared the results of the present study with the outcomes of another zinc trial in a neighboring health district. In the neighboring study, zinc supplementation was provided only as dispersible zinc tablets along with community-based treatment of malaria and diarrhea, following the same treatment protocol. In that study, where no SQ-LNS was provided, zinc supplements and illness treatment did not increase the growth of young children compared to a non-intervention group , suggesting that SQ-LNS may have been the critical growth-promoting component of the current intervention package. However, other differences in the study designs prevent firm conclusions.
We found a significant reduction in anemia prevalence in the IC children. These findings are consistent with the study of SQ-LNS in Ghana, which also found a significant reduction in anemia prevalence in children receiving SQ-LNS from 6 to 12 months of age compared to a non-intervention group . Similarly, studies of MNP also consistently find a beneficial impact on anemia prevalence . However, 79% of all children in IC still had a Hb concentration <110 g/L at the end of the intervention, despite the daily provision of 6 mg iron, 400 μg retinol and B-vitamins in SQ-LNS, along with treatment for malaria and diarrhea. Thus, additional interventions would be needed to reduce the high anemia burden in this population.
Strengths of the current study include the large sample size, high participation rates, and regular training and rigorous supervision of field staff. All anthropometrists participated in regular standardization sessions as recommended by WHO . In addition, the present study included multiple strategies to assess adherence to the study products  and blood collection and plasma analyses followed procedures recommended by IZiNCG .
Several limitations in the present study also have to be considered. One limitation was the cluster assignment to intervention and non-intervention communities. To compensate for the cluster design, we enrolled a large number of communities (25 IC and 9 NIC villages) and included a design effect of 1.5 in calculating the NIC sample size. Also, adherence to the different study products could not be definitely ascertained despite the use of a variety of strategies to assess adherence . Another weakness of our study is related to the partially blind study design. While participants, field workers and investigators remained blinded to the intervention groups in IC during data collection, data analyses and result interpretation, the comparisons between IC and NIC could not be blinded. However, all final anthropometric indicators were consistently greater in IC and the stunting prevalence of 22.4% at 9 months in all children and 39.3% at 18 months of age in NIC are comparable to the national stunting prevalence in the same age range (25.1% in 9–11 months old children and 41.6% in children aged 18–23 months) in 2010 . Moreover, a similar study in a neighboring health district with weekly contact for morbidity surveillance and product distribution did not find a difference in growth between the intervention and non-intervention group . Thus, it is unlikely that the Hawthorne effect could explain the observed growth impact. Despite these considerations, the inclusion of the NIC in our trial strengthened the study design, as it allowed the comparison of the intervention package to the current standard care in rural southwestern Burkina Faso.
Because the trial was implemented in a malaria-endemic area, SQ-LNS and feeding recommendations for the iLiNS studies were designed to minimize possible risks of iron supplementation . In particular, the daily iron dose was half the recommended dose for MNP , and caregivers were advised to feed the daily ration in two separate servings to avoid consuming a large bolus of iron at a single meal. Moreover, treatment was provided for diagnosed cases of malaria and diarrhea. A recent trial of MNP conducted in Pakistan found an increase in reported diarrhea and chest in-drawing among 6 to 18 month old children who received MNP compared to a non-supplemented control group, although there was no difference in the rates of persistent diarrhea, fever, or hospitalizations . Because we did not collect continuous morbidity data in the NIC, so as not to interfere with current treatment practices, the present trial does not allow such a direct comparison of morbidity rates between IC and NIC. In an effort to assess potential risks of the intervention, we asked caregivers at the end of the study to report retrospectively any medical care seeking at local health centers and regional hospitals over the 9-months study period. These reports were marginally higher in the IC (57%) compared to the NIC (54%; P = 0.083), which was likely due to the fact that children in IC were referred to the health center by the morbidity surveillance worker for any illness other than uncomplicated diarrhea and malaria. At the same time, there was a significantly lower mortality rate in IC than NIC (1.4% vs 3.2%; P = 0.005). While our study was not powered to assess hospitalization and mortality rates, these findings together imply that providing SQ-LNS as prescribed in the current study, along with malaria and diarrhea treatment, was likely not harmful.
In summary, there were no differences in growth and morbidity outcomes among the four intervention groups. Thus, the optimal level of zinc to be added to SQ-LNS remains uncertain. Nevertheless, the provision of SQ-LNS along with brief feeding advice and illness treatment of diagnosed cases of malaria and diarrhea had a significant beneficial impact on stunting, wasting and anemia reduction. While we are not able to distinguish the impact of SQ-LNS from the impact of health services, provision of malaria and diarrhea treatment is unlikely the sole reason for the beneficial impact on growth. The findings of the present study suggest that provision of SQ-LNS is a promising strategy to reduce childhood stunting and wasting when coupled with greater access to health care, especially among children at greatest risk of stunting.
S1 CONSORT Checklist. CONSORT Checklist.
S1 Protocol. Trial Protocol.
We thank the entire study staff. Special thanks go to Lucien Bado and Faustin Ye (Institut de Recherche en Sciences de la Santé, Bobo-Dioulasso) for planning and coordinating blood sample collection, Antonio Perfecto (Children’s Hospital of Oakland Research Institute, USA) for pZn analyses, Janet Peerson (University of California Davis, USA) for assistance with the programming and statistical analyses and the iLiNS Project Steering Committee (www.ilins.org) and Mary Arimond (University of California Davis, USA) for technical support. Finally, we sincerely appreciate the support of the participating children and their parents, the local communities and the staff of the Health District of Dandé.
Conceived and designed the experiments: KHB SYH JBO. Performed the experiments: SA EYJ JWS ZPO RMG SYH KHB SAV JBO. Analyzed the data: SA JWS. Wrote the paper: KHB SA EYJ.
- 1. Black RE, Victora CG, Walker SP, Bhutta ZA, Christian P, de Onis M, et al. Maternal and child undernutrition and overweight in low-income and middle-income countries. Lancet. 2013;382: 427–451. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(13)60937-X. pmid:23746772
- 2. de Onis M, Dewey KG, Borghi E, Onyango AW, Blossner M, Daelmans B, et al. The World Health Organization's global target for reducing childhood stunting by 2025: rationale and proposed actions. Matern Child Nutr. 2013;9 Suppl 2: 6–26. doi: 10.1111/mcn.12075. pmid:24074315
- 3. Walker CL, Rudan I, Liu L, Nair H, Theodoratou E, Bhutta ZA, et al. Global burden of childhood pneumonia and diarrhoea. Lancet. 2013;381: 1405–1416. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(13)60222-6. pmid:23582727
- 4. Bhutta ZA, Das JK, Walker N, Rizvi A, Campbell H, Rudan I, et al. Interventions to address deaths from childhood pneumonia and diarrhoea equitably: what works and at what cost? Lancet. 2013;381: 1417–1429. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(13)60648-0. pmid:23582723
- 5. Murray CJ, Ortblad KF, Guinovart C, Lim SS, Wolock TM, Roberts DA, et al. Global, regional, and national incidence and mortality for HIV, tuberculosis, and malaria during 1990–2013: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2013. Lancet. 2014;384: 1005–1070. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(14)60844-8. pmid:25059949
- 6. Brown KH, Peerson JM, Baker SK, Hess SY. Preventive zinc supplementation among infants, preschoolers, and older prepubertal children. Food Nutr Bull. 2009;30: S12–40. pmid:19472600
- 7. Roth DE, Richard SA, Black RE. Zinc supplementation for the prevention of acute lower respiratory infection in children in developing countries: meta-analysis and meta-regression of randomized trials. Int J Epidemiol. 2010;39: 795–808. doi: 10.1093/ije/dyp391. pmid:20156999
- 8. Imdad A, Bhutta ZA. Effect of preventive zinc supplementation on linear growth in children under 5 years of age in developing countries: a meta-analysis of studies for input to the lives saved tool. BMC Public Health. 2011;11 Suppl 3: S22. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-11-S3-S22. pmid:21501440
- 9. Yakoob MY, Theodoratou E, Jabeen A, Imdad A, Eisele TP, Ferguson J, et al. Preventive zinc supplementation in developing countries: impact on mortality and morbidity due to diarrhea, pneumonia and malaria. BMC Public Health. 2011;11 Suppl 3: S23. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-11-S3-S23. pmid:21501441
- 10. Mayo-Wilson E, Junior JA, Imdad A, Dean S, Chan XH, Chan ES, et al. Zinc supplementation for preventing mortality, morbidity, and growth failure in children aged 6 months to 12 years of age. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2014;5: CD009384. doi: 10.1002/14651858.cd009384.pub2
- 11. Arimond M, Zeilani M, Jungjohann S, Brown KH, Ashorn P, Allen LH, et al. Considerations in developing lipid-based nutrient supplements for prevention of undernutrition: experience from the International Lipid-Based Nutrient Supplements (iLiNS) Project. Matern Child Nutr. 2013: [epub ahead of print]; doi: 10.1111/mcn.12049.
- 12. Kuusipalo H, Maleta K, Briend A, Manary M, Ashorn P. Growth and change in blood haemoglobin concentration among underweight Malawian infants receiving fortified spreads for 12 weeks: a preliminary trial. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. 2006;43: 525–532. pmid:17033530 doi: 10.1097/01.mpg.0000235981.26700.d3
- 13. Phuka JC, Maleta K, Thakwalakwa C, Cheung YB, Briend A, Manary MJ, et al. Complementary feeding with fortified spread and incidence of severe stunting in 6- to 18-month-old rural Malawians. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2008;162: 619–626. doi: 10.1001/archpedi.162.7.619. pmid:18606932
- 14. Adu-Afarwuah S, Lartey A, Brown KH, Zlotkin S, Briend A, Dewey KG. Randomized comparison of 3 types of micronutrient supplements for home fortification of complementary foods in Ghana: effects on growth and motor development. Am J Clin Nutr. 2007;86: 412–420. pmid:17684213
- 15. Iannotti LL, Dulience SJ, Green J, Joseph S, Francois J, Antenor ML, et al. Linear growth increased in young children in an urban slum of Haiti: a randomized controlled trial of a lipid-based nutrient supplement. Am J Clin Nutr. 2013;99: 198–208. doi: 10.3945/ajcn.113.063883. pmid:24225356
- 16. Mangani C, Maleta K, Phuka J, Cheung YB, Thakwalakwa C, Dewey K, et al. Effect of complementary feeding with lipid-based nutrient supplements and corn-soy blend on the incidence of stunting and linear growth among 6- to 18-month-old infants and children in rural Malawi. Matern Child Nutr. 2013: [e-pub ahead of print]; doi: 10.1111/mcn.12068.
- 17. Bisimwa G, Owino VO, Bahwere P, Dramaix M, Donnen P, Dibari F, et al. Randomized controlled trial of the effectiveness of a soybean-maize-sorghum-based ready-to-use complementary food paste on infant growth in South Kivu, Democratic Republic of Congo. Am J Clin Nutr. 2012;95: 1157–1164. doi: 10.3945/ajcn.111.028704. pmid:22492382
- 18. Hess SY, Peerson JM, King JC, Brown KH. Use of serum zinc concentration as an indicator of population zinc status. Food Nutr Bull. 2007;28: S403–429. pmid:17988005
- 19. Adu-Afarwuah S, Lartey A, Brown KH, Zlotkin S, Briend A, Dewey KG. Home fortification of complementary foods with micronutrient supplements is well accepted and has positive effects on infant iron status in Ghana. Am J Clin Nutr. 2008;87: 929–938. pmid:18400716
- 20. Zlotkin S, Arthur P, Schauer C, Antwi KY, Yeung G, Piekarz A. Home-fortification with iron and zinc sprinkles or iron sprinkles alone successfully treats anemia in infants and young children. J Nutr. 2003;133: 1075–1080. pmid:12672922
- 21. Troesch B, van Stuijvenberg ME, Smuts CM, Kruger HS, Biebinger R, Hurrell RF, et al. A micronutrient powder with low doses of highly absorbable iron and zinc reduces iron and zinc deficiency and improves weight-for-age Z-scores in South African children. J Nutr. 2011;141: 237–242. doi: 10.3945/jn.110.129247. pmid:21178093
- 22. Samadpour K, Long KZ, Hayatbakhsh R, Marks GC. Randomised comparison of the effects of Sprinkles and Foodlets with the currently recommended supplement (Drops) on micronutrient status and growth in Iranian children. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2011;65: 1287–1294. doi: 10.1038/ejcn.2011.124. pmid:21750564
- 23. Jack SJ, Ou K, Chea M, Chhin L, Devenish R, Dunbar M, et al. Effect of micronutrient sprinkles on reducing anemia: a cluster-randomized effectiveness trial. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2012;166: 842–850. doi: 10.1001/archpediatrics.2012.1003. pmid:22801933
- 24. World Health Organization Physical status: The use and interpretation of anthropometry. Technical Report Series No. 854. Geneva: World Health Organization. 1995.
- 25. Brown KH, Peerson JM, Rivera J, Allen LH. Effect of supplemental zinc on the growth and serum zinc concentrations of prepubertal children: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Am J Clin Nutr. 2002;75: 1062–1071. pmid:12036814
- 26. Hess SY, Bado L, Aaron GJ, Ouedraogo JB, Zeilani M, Brown KH. Acceptability of zinc-fortified, lipid-based nutrient supplements (LNS) prepared for young children in Burkina Faso. Matern Child Nutr. 2010;7: 357–367. doi: 10.1111/j.1740-8709.2010.00287.x. pmid:21159124
- 27. World Health Organization, Food and Agriculture Organization Vitamin and mineral requirements in human nutrition. Report of a joint FAO/WHO expert consultation. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization. 2004.
- 28. Food and Agriculture Organization Fats and fatty acids in human nutrition: Report of an expert consultation. Rome, Italy: Food and Agriculture Organization. 2010.
- 29. Abbeddou S, Hess SY, Yakes Jimenez E, Some JW, Vosti SA, Guissou RM, et al. Comparison of methods to assess adherence to small-quantity lipid-based nutrient supplements (SQ-LNS) and dispersible tablets among young Burkinabe children participating in a community-based intervention trial. Matern Child Nutr. 2014: Dec 17, doi: 10.1111/mcn.12162.
- 30. Ulijaszek SJ, Kerr DA. Anthropometric measurement error and the assessment of nutritional status. Br J Nutr. 1999;82: 165–177. pmid:10655963 doi: 10.1017/s0007114599001348
- 31. Brown KH, Rivera JA, Bhutta Z, Gibson RS, King JC, Lönnerdal B, et al. International Zinc Nutrition Consultative Group (IZiNCG) technical document #1. Assessment of the risk of zinc deficiency in populations and options for its control. Food Nutr Bull. 2004;25: S99–203. pmid:18046856
- 32. Wessells KR, Ouedraogo ZP, Rouamba N, Hess SY, Ouedraogo JB, Brown KH. Short-term zinc supplementation with dispersible tablets or zinc sulfate solution yields similar positive effects on plasma zinc concentration of young children in Burkina Faso: A randomized controlled trial. J Pediatr. 2011;160: 129–135. doi: 10.1016/j.jpeds.2011.06.051. pmid:21871635
- 33. Killilea DW, Ames BN. Magnesium deficiency accelerates cellular senescence in cultured human fibroblasts. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2008;105: 5768–5773. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0712401105. pmid:18391207
- 34. Erhardt JG, Estes JE, Pfeiffer CM, Biesalski HK, Craft NE. Combined measurement of ferritin, soluble transferrin receptor, retinol binding protein, and C-reactive protein by an inexpensive, sensitive, and simple sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay technique. J Nutr. 2004;134: 3127–3132. pmid:15514286
- 35. World Health Organization WHO growth standards: length/height-for-age, weight-for-age, weight-for-length, weight-for-height and body mass index-for-age: methods and development. Geneva: World Health Organization. 2006.
- 36. Coates J, Swindale A, Bilinsky P. Household Food Insecurity Access Scale (HFIAS) for measurement of food access: Indicator guide. Washington, DC: USAID. 2007.
- 37. Vyas S, Kumaranayake L. Constructing socio-economic status indices: how to use principal components analysis. Health Policy Plan. 2006;21: 459–468. pmid:17030551 doi: 10.1093/heapol/czl029
- 38. Lenters LM, Wazny K, Webb P, Ahmed T, Bhutta ZA. Treatment of severe and moderate acute malnutrition in low- and middle-income settings: a systematic review, meta-analysis and Delphi process. BMC Public Health. 2013;13 Suppl 3: S23. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-13-S3-S23. pmid:24564235
- 39. Richard SA, Black RE, Gilman RH, Guerrant RL, Kang G, Lanata CF, et al. Diarrhea in early childhood: short-term association with weight and long-term association with length. Am J Epidemiol. 2013;178: 1129–1138. doi: 10.1093/aje/kwt094. pmid:23966558
- 40. Nyakeriga AM, Troye-Blomberg M, Chemtai AK, Marsh K, Williams TN. Malaria and nutritional status in children living on the coast of Kenya. Am J Clin Nutr. 2004;80: 1604–1610. pmid:15585775 doi: 10.1111/j.0300-9475.2004.01423o.x
- 41. Padonou G, Le Port A, Cottrell G, Guerra J, Choudat I, Rachas A, et al. Prematurity, intrauterine growth retardation and low birth weight: risk factors in a malaria-endemic area in southern Benin. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2014;108: 77–83. doi: 10.1093/trstmh/trt099. pmid:24336697
- 42. Kang H, Kreuels B, Adjei O, Krumkamp R, May J, Small DS. The causal effect of malaria on stunting: a Mendelian randomization and matching approach. Int J Epidemiol. 2013;42: 1390–1398. doi: 10.1093/ije/dyt116. pmid:23925429
- 43. Lee G, Yori P, Olortegui MP, Pan W, Caulfield L, Gilman RH, et al. Comparative effects of vivax malaria, fever and diarrhoea on child growth. Int J Epidemiol. 2012;41: 531–539. doi: 10.1093/ije/dyr190. pmid:22258823
- 44. Williams TN, Maitland K, Phelps L, Bennett S, Peto TE, Viji J, et al. Plasmodium vivax: a cause of malnutrition in young children. QJM. 1997;90: 751–757. pmid:9536339 doi: 10.1093/qjmed/90.12.751
- 45. Somé JW, Abbeddou S, Yakes Jimenez E, Hess SY, Ouédraogo ZP, Guissou RM, et al. Treated malaria does not affect physical growth and hemoglobin concentration of young children in Burkina Faso Faseb J. 2015, in press.
- 46. Becquey E, Ouédraogo C, Hess SY, Rouamba N, Prince L, Vosti SA, et al. Comparison of preventive and therapeutic zinc supplementation programs for young children in Burkina Faso: a randomized, masked, community-based trial. Faseb J. 2013;27: 845.819. doi: 10.1096/fj.13-0301ufm. pmid:23450005
- 47. Salam RA, Macphail C, Das JK, Bhutta ZA. Effectiveness of Micronutrient Powders (MNP) in women and children. BMC Public Health. 2013;13 Suppl 3: S22. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-13-S3-S22. pmid:24564207
- 48. World Health Organization. Measuring change in nutritional status: Guidelines for assessing the nutritional impact of supplementary feeding programmes for vulnerable groups. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization. 1983.
- 49. Macro International Inc. MEASURE DHS STATcompiler. Available: http://www.measuredhs.com, Accessed 2014 January 20.
- 50. World Health Organization. Use of multiple micronutrient powders for home fortification of foods consumed by infants and children 6–23 months of age. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization. 2011.
- 51. Soofi S, Cousens S, Iqbal SP, Akhund T, Khan J, Ahmed I, et al. Effect of provision of daily zinc and iron with several micronutrients on growth and morbidity among young children in Pakistan: a cluster-randomised trial. Lancet. 2013;382: 29–40. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(13)60437-7. pmid:23602230