The effectiveness of a vaccine is determined not only by the immunogenicity of its components, but especially by how widely it covers the disease-causing strains circulating in a given region. Because vaccine coverage varies over time, this study aimed to detect possible changes that could affect vaccine protection during a specific period in a southern European region. The 4CMenB vaccine is licensed for use in Europe, Canada, and Australia and is mainly directed against Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B. This vaccine contains four main immunogenic components: three recombinant proteins, FHbp, Nhba and NadA, and an outer membrane vesicle [PorA P1.4]. The allelic distribution of FHbp, Nhba, NadA, and PorA antigens in 82 invasive isolates (B and non-B serogroups) isolated from January 2008 to December 2013 were analyzed. 4CMenB was likely protective against 61.8% and 50% of serogroup B and non-B meningococci, respectively, in the entire period, but between 2012 and 2013, the predicted protection fell below 45% (42.1% for serogroup B isolates).The observed decreasing trend in the predicted protection during the 6 years of the study (Χ2 for trend = 4.68, p = 0.03) coincided with a progressive decrease of several clonal complexes (e.g., cc11, cc32 and cc41/44), which had one or more antigens against which the vaccine would offer protection.
Citation: Pérez-Trallero E, Esnal O, Marimón JM (2014) Progressive Decrease in the Potential Usefulness of Meningococcal Serogroup B Vaccine (4CMenB, Bexsero®) in Gipuzkoa, Northern Spain. PLoS ONE 9(12): e116024. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0116024
Editor: Jodie McVernon, Melbourne School of Population Health, Australia
Received: September 19, 2014; Accepted: December 1, 2014; Published: December 26, 2014
Copyright: © 2014 Pérez-Trallero et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: The authors confirm that all data underlying the findings are fully available without restriction. All relevant data are within the paper.
Funding: This work was supported by a grant from the Education Department of the Basque Country Government to the UPV/EHU (IT656-13). The funder had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Neisseria meningitidis is the first cause of bacterial meningitis and a frequent cause of severe sepsis worldwide. Of the 12 meningococcal serogroups described so far, six are mostly related to human invasive disease (A, B, C, X, W-135 and Y), serogroup B being the most common in developed countries .
Nowadays, there are effective polysaccharide conjugate vaccines against serogroups A, C, W-135 and Y, both as monovalent and as tetravalent vaccines (ACWY) but there is no conjugate vaccine against serogroup B. This is due to the similarity of the polysaccharide structure of serogroup B with the polysialic acid present in human glycoproteins, this similarity making the polysaccharide poorly immunogenic. However, for N. meningitidis serogroup B, there are vaccines that specifically target porin A (PorA), one of the major outer-membrane proteins. Although these vaccines have been effective in outbreaks , , they are not universal as they only target specific PorA types .
New technologies such as reverse vaccinology ,  have facilitated the discovery of novel N. meningitidis antigens with high antigenic value, including factor H binding protein (FHbp), heparin binding Neisserial antigen (Nhba), and Neisserial adhesin A (NadA). The Bexsero (4CMenB) vaccine is licensed for use in Europe, Canada, and Australia and contains four main immunogenic components: three recombinant proteins FHbp, Nhba, and NadA and an outer membrane vesicle [PorA P1.4]. Although mainly directed at serogroup B meningococci, this vaccine can also protect against infections caused by isolates of other serogroups expressing one or more of the antigens included in the vaccine , . The peptide variants included in this vaccine are B1.1 for FHbp, subvariant 2 for Nhba, variant 3 for NadA, and P1.4 for PorA. The B1.1 component of FHbp is highly immunologically cross-reactive with other B1 subvariants .
The effectiveness of a vaccine is not only determined by the immunogenicity of its components, but especially by how widely it covers disease-causing strains circulating in a particular region. Therefore, the aim of this study was to analyze the allelic distribution of FHbp, Nhba, NadA, and PorA antigens in invasive isolates (of serogroup B and of other serogroups) from a region of southern Europe in order to assess the potential coverage of the Bexsero vaccine against meningococcal disease within this region.
Material and Methods
All isolates causing invasive meningococcal disease in the province of Gipuzkoa from January 2008 to December 2013 were included in the study. Only one isolate per patient was included. Gipuzkoa has about 700,000 inhabitants and is located in the north of Spain (Basque Country), bordered by the Bay of Biscay and France to the north.
The capsular serogroup was identified by latex agglutination with group-specific antibodies against capsular polysaccharides of serogroups A, B, C, W135, X, Y and Z (Murex Biotech Ltd., Dartford, England). Non-serogroupable isolates were genogrouped using a specific real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using primers specific for the siaD and orfA genes . Multilocus sequence typing (MLST) and identification of clonal complexes (cc) were carried out according to the N. meningitidis MLST database (http://pubmlst.org/neisseria/).
The allelic distribution of vaccine antigens in the meningococcal isolates was deduced from the translated sequence of their encoding genes. In this work we assumed that if 4CMenB genes encoding for vaccine antigens (GEVA) were detected in an isolate, they always expressed the antigenic proteins.
fHbp, nhba, and nadA typing was performed as previously proposed and described , . The sequencing and subsequent comparison of the deduced amino acid sequences for fHbp, nhba, nadA, and porA was carried out according to the above-mentioned N. meningitidis MLST database. The PorA-type was determined through amplification of two fragments of the porA coding for the VR1 and VR2 regions  and subsequent comparison of the deduced amino acid sequence with PorA types available at the NM PorA variable region database (http://pubmlst.org/neisseria/).
The Χ2 test for trends was used to compare the distribution of isolates with vaccine antigens during the 6 years of the study (2008–2013).
In the present study, no human experimentation was conducted, with all studies carried out on microorganisms obtained from samples that had previously been sent to our laboratory for routine diagnosis. The data discussed in this study were associated with N. meningitidis strains, and no patient information was used other than age, gender, and outcome. Conjugated vaccine against serogroup C meningococci was included in Gipuzkoa in 2000 for children at 2, 4 and 6 months of age. In 2005, the vaccine was also introduced for people between 11 and 20 years old, reaching coverage of 84.6% in this population group. Publication of these results was approved by the Ethics Committee for Clinical Research of the Gipuzkoa health region.
Between January 2008 and December 2013, meningococcal isolates from 82 patients with invasive disease were available for phenotypic and genotypic characterization. Total confirmed cases in Gipuzkoa included 91 episodes, 9.9% of them diagnosed only by PCR without culture isolation (3 serogroup B, 2 serogroup C, 1 serogroup W-135 and 3 non serogrouped). Most cases were observed in the cool months, 68.3% between November and May and especially between January and March, that comprised 50% of the cases. As in most series, the higher annual incidence rates were observed in children younger than 5 years of age (mean 18.2 cases per 100,000, range 11–27.6).
In the past two decades, Gipuzkoa has changed from being a high to moderate endemic region (rates >5×100,000 inhabitants in the early 2000s) to a moderate to low endemic region (rates ≤2×100,000 inhabitants from 2010 on) (Fig. 1). Only 6 cases of meningococcal serogroup C disease were detected in the 6 years study period (2008–2013) as compared with 64 cases occurred in the 6 years previous to the introduction of meningococcal serogroup C conjugate vaccine (1994–1999). From 2008 to 2013, annual distribution of cases corresponded to a low to moderate endemic region, without outbreaks or clusters worthy of mention.
Forty-one isolates were collected from blood-cultures, 33 from cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), and the remaining eight isolates were isolated both in the blood and CSF of the same patient.
Of the 82 patients, 45 (55%) were female and 37 (45%) male. More than half of the isolates were collected from patients younger than 10 years old (N = 43, 52%), while the second age group with the highest number of isolates consisted of people aged ≥65 years old (N = 13, 15.8%). Six patients (7.3%) died from meningococcal infection, all of them with sepsis: 1 children aged 4 years without previous disease, 2 teenagers 15 and 16 years old (both immunosuppressed), one young adult 27 years old (paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria) and two elderly patients aged 83 years old.
Most of the 82 isolates belonged to serogroup B (N = 68, 83%), although serogroups C (N = 4, 5%), Y (N = 6, 7%), X (N = 2, 2.5%), and W-135 (N = 2, 2.5%) were also present.
Analysis of the genes encoding the antigens included in the 4CMenB vaccine (GEVA)
fHbp could be characterized in all 82 isolates included in the study, with 50% (N = 41) belonging to sub-family/variant B1, 30.5% (N = 25) to sub-family/variant A2 and 19.5% (N = 16) to sub-family/variant A3. The analysis of GEVA demonstrated that 41 isolates showed potential vaccine coverage for the FHbp antigen (41 variant B1 isolates, 50%), of which 36 were serogroup B (36/68, 52.9%). Only three of the 41 fHbp variant B1 isolates showed subvariant B1.1.
Among the 36 serogroup B isolates with the fHbp variant B1, 21 were collected in 2008–2009, nine in 2010–2011, and six in 2012–2013 (Table 1).
nhba was also present in all 82 isolates, but only four of them (all serogroup B isolates) had Nhba subvariant 2, the antigen included in the 4CMenB vaccine, for which the potential coverage was 4.9% (4/82) for all meningococcal invasive isolates and 5.9% (4/68) for serogroup B isolates.
Amplification of nadA failed in 71% (58/82) of isolates. Of the 24 isolates with this antigen, only two isolates from 2009 and 2012 had variant 3 (included in the vaccine) or variants 1 and 2 (which cross-react with variant 3).The potential coverage of the NadA antigen was 2.4% (2/82) for all meningococcal invasive isolates and 1.5% (1/68) for serogroup B isolates.
porA was detected in all N. meningitidis isolates, with only four isolates (three serogroup B) coding for the VR2 4 region, which determines the P1.4 antigen included in the vaccine. One isolate with the porA coding for the VR2 4-1 region was not included because this antigen does not react with P1.4 monoclonal antibody . The potential coverage of the 4CMenB vaccine for the P1.4 antigen was 4.9% for all serogroups and was 4.4% for serogroup B invasive isolates.
Two isolates had two GEVA: one had the fHbp variant B1 plus porA VR2 4 and the other the fHbp variant B1 plus nhba2 genes (Table 1).
Overall, the potential coverage of the 4CMenB vaccine was 59.8% for all meningococcal invasive isolates but progressively decreased during the study period. Coverage significantly decreased from 72.2% in 2008–2009, to 56.5% in 2010–2011, and to 43.5% in 2012–2013, revealing an annual decreasing trend during the 6 years of the study (Χ2 for trend = 4.68, p = 0.03).
When only serogroup B isolates were analyzed, 69.7% were theoretically covered by the vaccine in 2008–2009, but this percentage decreased to 42.1% in 2012–2013 (p = 0.051). This decreased coverage coincided with a progressive decline in our region of several cc with GEVA (especially cc11 and cc41/44).
Relationship between vaccine antigens and clonal complexes
Genotyping showed the presence of 15 different cc described in the N. meningitidis MLST data base (http://neisseria.org/nm/typing/mlst/). Five isolates could not be included in any cc (ST6421, ST7306 and another 3 new STs) and one isolate (serogroup B, ST4954) was included in a new e-Burst group defined by us  but without formal cc inclusion to date. The most frequent cc were 213 (N = 14), 269 (N = 12), 11 (N = 10), and 60 (N = 9) (Table 2). The distribution of the cc between 2008 and 2013 was uneven both in time and age groups and no cc was related to higher mortality. Only cc269 was present throughout the study period (Table 2). The largest cluster of cases caused by a single clone occurred in 2009, with five ST11 meningococci: 4 serogroup B (in 2 young adults, 1 child of six years and an elderly patient) and one serogroup C (in a 9 years old child) with no apparent epidemiological relation. Also in 2009, six cc213 isolates were detected, but only three of them had the same ST (3 ST3496, and 1 each ST4224, ST8756 and ST10121).
The presence of GEVA among isolates of a specific cc was diverse (Table 2). In some cc (cc11, cc60, cc32, cc41/44, cc103, cc162, and cc1117), ≥90% of isolates were theoretically covered by the 4CMenB vaccine. No isolates of cc167, cc35, cc750 or cc22 showed GEVA.
Recent publications have reported the potential coverage of the 4CMenB vaccine for Spain and other European countries , –. Because the coverage in a specific region can vary over time due to distinct clonal circulation, this study aimed to detect possible changes that could affect vaccine protection during a specific period. Studies evaluating this protective effect have been performed using the MATS (Meningococcal Antigen Typing System) ELISA provided by Novartis or, as in the present study, by analyzing the allelic distribution of the four main antigens included in the 4CMenB vaccine. We assumed that the presence of fHbp B1, nhba2, nadA 1,2/3 and porA VR2 4, once expressed, is a prerequisite for the protective immune response induced by vaccination. Although the immune response to the 4CMenB vaccine is not limited to the immunogenicity of its four major antigens, these are the main inductors of protection.
The FHbp and Nhba antigens are present in virtually all N. meningitidis, although their expression level may vary among isolates – and not all their variants were included in the vaccine. In the present study, fHbp and nhba were detected in all 82 invasive isolates, but the variant predicted to confer protection (FHbp B1 and Nhba 2) was detected in only half and less than 5% of isolates, respectively. Some authors suggested that Nhba variants 3, 20, 21 and 113 could also confer protection, due to cross-reactivity with Nhba variant 2 (16,17). Taking into account this latter criterion, only one more isolate, having Nhba variant 21 and isolated in 2012, would have been included. nadA was absent in most isolates, a fairly common occurrence, especially in some CCs  and, in the present study, only two isolates had the vaccine antigenic variants 1, 2, and 3. Finally, only four isolates codified the PorA VR2 4 region that produces the P1.4 antigen included in the vaccine.
Given that the presence of each of the four antigens would stimulate the immune response of vaccinated patients, almost 60% of patients could have been protected by 4cMenB vaccination (61% including the Nhba variant 21). However, the theoretical protection between 2012 and 2013 fell below 45% (48% including the Nhba variant 21).
Percentages of theoretical protection greater than 75% have been reported for Europe as a whole and for some other European countries , –. A different theoretical coverage could have been obtained, depending on the study period. In a European study , lower protective figures were obtained for Spain and the Czech Republic, the only two countries with isolates obtained after 2008. Our strains were not included in the study of Vogel et al (17) but showed the same distribution of serogroups, cc and theoretic 4CMenB protection figures as the Spanish meningococcal isolates collected between 2008 and 2010 of that study. N. meningitidis is very prone to the exchange of genetic material and it is unsurprising that the meningococcal population changes over time . The reduction in 4CMenB vaccine protection could have been due to decreased circulation of clones harboring GEVA or to changes in GEVA in some isolates of the same clone. The most frequently found serogroup B meningococcal clones during the previous decade in our region  and in other European countries  were cc in which most of the isolates had GEVA (e.g., cc41/44, cc32, cc11). The decreasing trend in the potential 4CMenB vaccine protection observed during the 6 years of the present study was influenced by the decrease in the circulation of CC whose isolates possessed GEVA (cc60 complex, cc32 complex ET-5, cc11 complex and cc41/44 complex), although the fact of belonging to a certain cc is insufficient to predict antigenic profile. Nine of the 10 cc11 isolates belonged to the ST11 hypervirulent clone and all had the FHbp B1 antigen against which the vaccine would confer protection. cc269 was highly prevalent in Europe and some of its STs, such as ST269, have been reported to possess vaccine antigens in all or almost all isolates , . However, in the present study, most cc269 isolates were ST1163 and they lacked GEVA. Over time, changes are common in both the circulation of clones and in the genetic information within a single clone.
The incidence of meningococcal disease in our region has substantially declined in the last decade, and most recent circulating isolates lacked antigens against which vaccinated people would have been protected. In the current situation, and considering the high incidence of fever from the vaccine , the introduction of the 4CMenB vaccine in our community does not seem to achieve the necessary priority to be recommended. If an outbreak caused by a hypervirulent clone were to occur, especially if the clone was the ST11 clone, the vaccine would be extremely useful.
Conceived and designed the experiments: EPT OE. Performed the experiments: OE JMM. Analyzed the data: EPT OE JMM. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: EPT OE JMM. Wrote the paper: EPT OE.
- 1. Harrison LH, Trotter CL, Ramsay ME (2009) Global epidemiology of meningococcal disease. Vaccine 27 (Suppl 2): B51–63
- 2. Galloway Y, Stehr-Green P, McNicholas A, O'Hallahan J (2009) Use of an observational cohort study to estimate the effectiveness of the New Zealand group B meningococcal vaccine in children aged under 5 years. Int J Epidemiol 38:413–418
- 3. Rodriguez AP, Dickinson F, Baly A, Martinez R (1999) The epidemiological impact of antimeningococcal B vaccination in Cuba. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz 94:433–440 http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/S0074-02761999000400002.
- 4. Vicente D, Esnal O, López de Goicoechea MJ, Cisterna R, Pérez-Trallero E (2009) Influence of two vaccination campaigns on genetic diversity of invasive Neisseria meningitidis isolates in northern Spain (1997–2008). PLoS One 4:e8501
- 5. Rappuoli R (2000) Reverse vaccinology. Curr Opin Microbiol 3:445–450
- 6. Pizza M, Scarlato V, Masignani V, Giuliani MM, Aricò B, et al. (2000) Identification of vaccine candidates against serogroup B meningococcus by whole-genome sequencing. Science 287:1816–1820
- 7. Serruto D, Bottomley MJ, Ram S, Giuliani MM, Rappuoli R (2012) The new multicomponent vaccine against meningococcal serogroup B, 4CMenB: immunological, functional and structural characterization of the antigens. Vaccine 30 (Suppl 2): B87–97
- 8. Hong E, Giuliani MM, Deghmane AE, Comanducci M, Brunelli B, et al. (2013) Could the multicomponent meningococcal serogroup B vaccine (4CMenB) control Neisseria meningitidis capsular group X outbreaks in Africa? Vaccine 31:1113–1116
- 9. Lucidarme J, Comanducci M, Findlow J, Gray SJ, Kaczmarski EB, et al. (2010) Characterization of fHbp, nhba (gna2132), nadA, porA, and sequence type in group B meningococcal case isolates collected in England and Wales during January 2008 and potential coverage of an investigational group B meningococcal vaccine. Clin Vaccine Immunol 17:919–929
- 10. Taha MK (2000) Simultaneous approach for nonculture PCR-based identification and serogroup prediction of Neisseria meningitidis. J Clin Microbiol 38:855–857.
- 11. Comanducci M, Bambini S, Caugant DA, Mora M, Brunelli B, et al. (2004) NadA diversity and carriage in Neisseria meningitidis. Infect Immun 72:4217–4223
- 12. Jacobsson S, Thulin S, Mölling P, Unemo M, Comanducci M, et al. (2006) Sequence constancies and variations in genes encoding three new meningococcal vaccine candidate antigens. Vaccine 24:2161–2168
- 13. Sacchi CT, Lemos AP, Brandt ME, Whitney AM, Melles CE, et al. (1998) Proposed standardization of Neisseria meningitidis PorA variable-region typing nomenclature. Clin Diagn Lab Immunol 5:845–855.
- 14. PubMLST databases. Neisseria PorA Variable Region2. Available: http://pubmlst.org/neisseria/PorA/vr2.shtml
- 15. Tzanakaki G, Hong E, Kesanopoulos K, Xirogianni A, Bambini S, et al. (2014) Diversity of greek meningococcal serogroup B isolates and estimated coverage of the 4CMenB meningococcal vaccine. BMC Microbiol 14:111
- 16. Holst J, Comanducci M, Bambini S, Muzzi A, Comandi S, et al. (2014) Variability of genes encoding surface proteins used as vaccine antigens in meningococcal endemic and epidemic strain panels from Norway. Vaccine 32:2722–31
- 17. Vogel U, Taha MK, Vazquez JA, Findlow J, Claus H, et al. (2013) Predicted strain coverage of a meningococcal multicomponent vaccine (4CMenB) in Europe: a qualitative and quantitative assessment. Lancet Infect Dis 13:416–425
- 18. McNeil LK, Zagursky RJ, Lin SL, Murphy E, Zlotnick GW, et al. (2013) Role of factor H binding protein in Neisseria meningitidis virulence and its potential as a vaccine candidate to broadly protect against meningococcal disease. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 77:234–252
- 19. Donnelly J, Medini D, Boccadifuoco G, Biolchi A, Ward J, et al. (2010) Qualitative and quantitative assessment of meningococcal antigens to evaluate the potential strain coverage of protein-based vaccines. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 107:19490–19495
- 20. Giuliani MM, Biolchi A, Serruto D, Ferlicca F, Vienken K, et al. (2010) Measuring antigen-specific bactericidal responses to a multicomponent vaccine against serogroup B meningococcus. Vaccine 28:5023–5030
- 21. Bambini S, De Chiara M, Muzzi A, Mora M, Lucidarme J, et al. (2014) Neisseria adhesin A variation and revised nomenclature scheme. Clin Vaccine Immunol 21:966–971
- 22. Bambini S, Piet J, Muzzi A, Keijzers W, Comandi S, et al. (2013) An analysis of the sequence variability of meningococcal fHbp, NadA and NHBA over a 50-year period in the Netherlands. PLoS One 8:e65043
- 23. EU-IBIS meningococcal data. Clonal complexes associated with Serogroups B and C. Available: http://www.hpa-bioinformatics.org.uk/euibis/php/meningo_pie_chart.php.
- 24. Bettinger JA, Scheifele DW, Halperin SA, Vaudry W, Findlow J, et al. (2013) Diversity of Canadian meningococcal serogroup B isolates and estimated coverage by an investigational meningococcal serogroup B vaccine (4CMenB).Vaccine. 32:124–130
- 25. Lucidarme J, Comanducci M, Findlow J, Gray SJ, Kaczmarski EB, et al. (2009) Characterization of fHbp, nhba (gna2132), nadA, porA, sequence type (ST), and genomic presence of IS1301 in group B meningococcal ST269 clonal complex isolates from England and Wales. J Clin Microbiol 47:3577–3585
- 26. Anonymous (2014) Meningococcal B vaccine. An immunogenic vaccine possibly useful during outbreaks. Prescrire Int 23:201–204