To further improve in vitro models of the cornea, this study focused on the creation of a three-dimensional, stratified, curved epithelium; and the subsequent characterization and evaluation of its suitability as a model for biocompatibility testing.
Immortalized human corneal epithelial cells were grown to confluency on curved cellulose filters for seven days, and were then differentiated and stratified using an air-liquid interface for seven days before testing. Varying concentrations of a commercial ophthalmic solution containing benzalkonium chloride (BAK), a known cytotoxic agent, and two relevant ocular surfactants were tested on the model. A whole balafilcon A lens soaked in phosphate buffered saline (BA PBS) was also used to assess biocompatibility and verify the validity of the model. Viability assays as well as flow cytometry were performed on the cells to investigate changes in cell death and integrin expression.
The reconstructed curved corneal epithelium was composed of 3–5 layers of cells. Increasing concentrations of BAK showed dose-dependent decreased cell viability and increased integrin expression and cell death. No significant change in viability was observed in the presence of the surfactants. As expected, the BA PBS combination appeared to be very biocompatible with no adverse change in cell viability or integrin expression.
The stratified, curved, epithelial model proved to be sensitive to distinct changes in cytotoxicity and is suitable for continued assessment for biocompatibility testing of contact lenses. Our results showed that flow cytometry can provide a quantitative measure of the cell response to biomaterials or cytotoxic compounds for both the supernatant and adherent cell populations. As a specifically designed in vitro model of the corneal epithelium, this quantitative model for biocompatibility at the ocular surface may help improve our understanding of cell-material interactions and reduce the use of animal testing.
Citation: Postnikoff CK, Pintwala R, Williams S, Wright AM, Hileeto D, Gorbet MB (2014) Development of a Curved, Stratified, In Vitro Model to Assess Ocular Biocompatibility. PLoS ONE 9(5): e96448. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0096448
Editor: Christophe Egles, Université de Technologie de Compiègne, France
Received: July 27, 2013; Accepted: April 8, 2014; Published: May 16, 2014
Copyright: © 2014 Postnikoff et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by a Collaborative Research and Development grant from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Council (NSERC) of Canada and CIBA Vision (now known as Alcon). NSERC had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. A.M.W. from CIBA participated in the study design but did not have a decision role. CIBA Vision/Alcon had no role in data collection and analysis, decision to publish or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have read the journal’s policy and the following conflicts have been identified. In the past 4 years, Gorbet has received funding from CIBA Vision (now known as Alcon) and from Vistakon/Johnson & Johnson. Wright is currently an employee from Alcon (formerly CIBA Vision). This does not alter the authors’ adherence to all the PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
The cornea is comprised of three main cellular layers: the epithelium, stroma, and endothelium. The corneal epithelium is the first line of defence against many types of injury, trauma, and infection and contributes to maintenance of transparency and rigidity of the cornea –. The epithelium has also been shown to be the primary barrier against transcorneal permeation . As a result, to have simpler models than the entire cornea itself, many researchers have opted to develop alternative corneal epithelial models for the study of material interactions at the front of the eye.
Recently, in vitro ocular toxicity testing has experienced a major advancement with the development of multilayered corneal epithelial cultures. There has been much interest in developing in vitro models that have the potential to replace the in vivo Draize test. The Draize test was developed as an ocular toxicity test in 1944 and involves the placement of test solutions on the eyes of living animals . It became part of the United States Food and Drug Administration regulations in 1964 . The Draize test has since come under much criticism in terms of its performance and reliability –. As the corneal epithelium represents the major barrier of the eye, many in vitro epithelial models have since been developed and proposed as alternatives to the in vivo Draize test. Since the 1960s, monolayer cell cultures have been developed using primary and immortalized corneal epithelial cell lines of rabbit and canine origin; and starting in the 1990s, the use of human-derived cells has become more popular , .
Concurrent to the development of better cell lines was the improved understanding of multilayered cultures and the importance of the air-liquid interface. Combined, the research has led to many in vitro models of epithelial reconstruction – and the development of commercially available models such as HCE by SkinEthic, EpiOcular by MatTek, and Clonetics by Lonza. The majority of these in vitro models have been used for toxicity testing of different ophthalmic solutions and for drug permeation studies –, though presently none of these models have been validated or accepted for regulatory purposes. On the other hand, little research has been performed with these in vitro models in the area of contact lens interactions, possibly due to their limited surface area that would require the manufacture of smaller lenses or the use of trephined lens segments.
As part of regulatory testing, contact lenses are rigorously tested for their interactions with the ocular surface. Beyond the initial qualification of the contact lens material, the overall biocompatibility of a multipurpose contact lens disinfecting solution (MPS) with the contact lens material also needs to be defined. It is recognized that contact lens materials uptake and release some components of MPS, which may in turn affect ocular cell response –. Most notably, lens-solution interactions have been shown to be of critical importance in patterns of solution induced corneal staining as seen in both the StainingGrid and the IER Matrix Study , . Current in vitro toxicological evaluations have been mostly conducted using a monolayer of cells to investigate the effects of different MPS – (see Choy et al.  for a review of these studies). In line with Powell’s recent demonstration that lens material has an effect on uptake and release of biocides , our research group further showed that this difference in uptake and release can affect the response of corneal epithelial cells in vitro , . While monolayer cultures represent a rapid and simple model to investigate lens-solution interactions, these models are very sensitive as they solely consist of a single layer of cells and are static in nature. As a means to better characterize and understand lens-solution biocompatibility, we proposed the development of an in vitro reconstructed curved epithelium model that can better mimic interactions at the interface between the contact lens and corneal epithelial cells. To determine the sensitivity of the curved, stratified model, we chose to assess the response of our model to varying concentrations of benzalkonium chloride, a well-known cytotoxic agent , and compare that response to a silicone hydrogel lens soaked in phosphate buffered saline. As benzalkonium chloride is often found in a proprietary solution, common ophthalmic surfactants from the poloxamine family were also tested to ensure cytotoxicity was dependent on benzalkonium chloride.
To evaluate the response of the curved stratified epithelium, the MTT and luciferin-luciferase ADP/ATP assays were used to determine cellular metabolic activity and flow cytometry was performed to investigate changes in integrin expression and mechanism of cell death. To our knowledge, this current study reports the first in vitro stratified model developed specifically for studying contact lens-solution biocompatibility; this model may further prove useful for drug-delivery and cell-material interaction studies.
Reagents and Antibodies
Keratinocyte serum-free medium (KSFM), keratinocyte growth supplements (KGS), and penicillin/streptomycin (Pen/Strep) solution were purchased from ScienCell (Carlsbad, California). All other cell culture reagents, including Dulbecco’s Minimum Essential Medium (DMEM), 1∶1 DMEM in Ham’s F12 nutrient medium, fetal bovine serum (FBS), 0.25% Trypsin-EDTA, Hank’s based cell dissociation buffer, and TrypLE Express were purchased from Life Technologies (Burlington, Ontario, Canada). Phosphate buffered saline (PBS) was purchased from Lonza (Allendale, New Jersey).
Monoclonal antibodies to β1 integrin (CD29) and α3 integrin (CD49c) were fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) and R-phycoerythrin conjugated, respectively and were purchased from Becton Dickinson (Mountain View, CA, USA). Propidium iodide (PI) and the FLICA caspase kit were purchased from ImmunoChemistry Technologies, LLC (Bloomington, MN, USA). The FLICA kit uses the fluorescent probe FAM-VAD-FMK for caspase detection. The ADP/ATP Bioluminescent Cell Viability Kit II was purchased from PromoCell GmbH (Heidelberg, Germany). All chemicals used to prepare paraformaldehyde and HEPES Tyrode Buffer were of analytical or reagent grade.
Contact Lens and Ocular Solution
A daily-wear silicone hydrogel balafilcon A (BA; Bausch & Lomb, Rochester, NY, USA) was tested. Lenses were obtained in their original packaging from the manufacturer and had a curvature of 8.6 mm, diameter of 14.0 mm, and power of −3.00 dioptres. All lenses were used before their expiry date. Whole lenses were used and were not cut before placement on the cultures.
Phosphate buffered saline was used as a negative control lens solution, which was previously shown to be biocompatible . A sterile ophthalmic solution of benzalkonium chloride (BAK) was used as a positive control: the commercially available Moisture Eyes (ME; Bausch & Lomb, Rochester, NY, USA) has a BAK concentration of 0.01% w/v. Stratified cultures were exposed to undiluted and diluted Moisture Eyes at final BAK concentrations of 0.01% w/v (100% ME), 0.005% w/v (50% ME), and 0.002% w/v (20% ME).
As Moisture Eyes is a proprietary commercial source of BAK, it is possible that other ingredients within the solution may affect viability. To confirm that the cytotoxicity observed with our BAK source resulted mainly from BAK, two commonly used ocular surfactants from the poloxamine family, namely Tetronics 904 and 1304 (BASF, Ludwigshafen, Germany) were also investigated. Surfactants were tested at concentrations of 0.25% w/v and 1% w/v which are within a relevant range for ocular therapeutics , .
In vitro Cell Culture
HPV-immortalized human corneal epithelial cells gifted from Dr. May Griffith  were cultured in keratinocyte serum-free medium with keratinocyte growth supplements (bovine pituitary extract and recombinant epidermal growth factor) and Pen/Strep. Fresh medium was added every other day, and cells were grown to 90% confluency and were used before their eighteenth passage. Higher passage numbers were avoided in order to reduce the genomic variations that have been observed in other immortalized epithelial cells . Adherent cells were removed using TrypLE Express dissociation solution. Cells were routinely observed for any morphological changes.
Curved Multilayer Preparation
The curved multilayers were grown on a Millicell-HA (mixed cellulose esters, Millipore, Billerica, MA, USA) membrane with a 0.45 µm pore size. To deform the cell substrate with a curve that would mimic the curvature of the cornea, an aluminum mold/counter-mold was fabricated (Figure 1b). The 30 mm diameter filters were first deformed using the custom-shaped curved die. Silicone Press-to-Seal sheets with adhesive (Life Technologies, Burlington, Ontario, Canada) were punched into rings (inner diameter of 15 mm and an outer diameter of 22.5 mm) using a laboratory bench press (Figure 1a). Once cut, the rings were disinfected with 70% ethanol and placed on top of the curved filters to reduce the cell culture surface area to the curved filter. The entire process is depicted in Figure 1 where the initial cellulose filter (Figure 1c) is deformed into a curved shape (Figure 1d) and finally, the ring is placed on top (Figure 1e). The assembled inserts were then UV sterilized. After sterilization, inserts were coated with collagen type I (0.05 mg/mL –30 min at 37°C) and cells were seeded within 30 minutes of coating.
a) silicone rings and silicone ring die, b) top and bottom of eye form, c) cellulose insert before forming, d) final curved insert, e) final curved insert with one silicone ring.
The curved inserts were seeded with 5×105 cells per insert. The curved multilayers were fed with KSFM on each of the basal and apical sides of the curve for the first seven days, with medium being exchanged every other day. After seven days, cell differentiation was induced by exposing the monolayer to an air-liquid interface. Cells were fed only on the basal side with 2% FBS in 1∶1 DMEM/F12 and medium was exchanged daily. The cells grew under these conditions for seven days and were then ready for experimentation.
Consecutive sections constituting the entirety of the specimens were processed routinely for microscopic examination: after initial fixation in 10% neutral buffered formalin, the cellulose filters were processed, embedded in paraffin, serially sectioned in 5-µm-thick sections, and stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E). The histological slides were evaluated using bright field microscopy (Leica DM1000, Leica Microsystems Inc, Concord, ON).
In vitro Onlay Model
For the testing of solution soaked contact lenses, we adapted our monolayer onlay method to be used in a stratified and curved epithelial model. Contact lenses were incubated in 3 mL of PBS for 24 hours in a tissue-culture-polystyrene well. Prepared stratified multilayers were fed with KSFM on the basal side. Apically, KSFM was added to wet the surface and PBS-soaked lenses were placed gently on top of the multilayer, concave-side down, to fit the eye-shaped curve. An additional amount of KSFM was added on top of the lens to ensure moisture retention. For the BAK samples, 800 µL, 400 µL, and 160 µL of BAK solution were added to the multilayers for the 0.01%, 0.005%, and 0.002% BAK dilutions, respectively. KSFM was added, where necessary, for a total apical volume of 800 µL. Tetronics 904 and 1304 were dissolved in PBS to a concentration of 2% w/v and were further diluted with KSFM to final concentrations of 0.25% and 1% on top of the stratified cultures. Control cells were fed with 800 µL of KSFM. Upon placement of the lenses, surfactants, and BAK, the cells were returned to the humidified incubator at 37°C and 5% CO2 for either 6 or 24 hours.
After 6 and 24 hours incubation, lenses and medium were removed to quantify cellular viability using the MTT assay. The MTT assay was originally developed in 1983 by Mosmann et. al.  based upon the reduction of tetrazolium salts as originally discovered by Altman , . The assay was then redeveloped for multilayers by Doucet in 1996 , adapted again by Van Goethem in 2006 to improve accuracy , and finally reworked by Pauly to further improve apical sensitivity in 2009 . To allow the MTT assay to be used for our larger and curved stratified model, Pauly’s protocol was further modified as follows. Briefly, thiazoyl blue tetrazolium bromide (0.5 mg/mL, MTT, Sigma Aldrich, Oakville, ON, Canada) was added to the apical and basal sides of the cell culture insert and was incubated for 3 hours 37°C and 5% CO2. The MTT solution was then removed and isopropanol was added to both the apical and basal sides of the insert and plates were agitated for 2 hours. An aliquot was taken from both the apical and basal sides and the two remaining solutions in the apical and basal sides were then mixed together and a final aliquot of the mixed solution was taken. Samples were read in a UV-Vis spectrophotometer for optical density at 595 nm with a reference at 650 nm. All results are expressed as relative viability compared to control cells; cells incubated in KSFM and in the absence of a contact lens (no lens control). Cellular metabolic activity determined from the mixed solution is reported in the results section.
Cell Collection and Tissue Digestion
After lens incubation, the media on top of the well was used to gently wash the contact lens and the surface of the stratified cell culture. This population of cells and debris was collected and is referred to as the supernatant population. Upon removal of the supernatant population, DMEM/10% FBS was added to the supernatant cells and the samples were centrifuged. Supernatant cells were resuspended in DMEM/10% FBS and prepared for flow cytometry (see below).
Once the supernatant population and the contact lens were removed, the multilayers were digested. 0.25% Trypsin-EDTA was added to the basal side of the insert and to the top of the insert. Cell dissociation buffer was then added to the top of the insert and the cells were placed on a shaker at 120 rpm for 45 minutes in a 37°C and 5% CO2 environment. After 45 minutes, FBS was added to the inserts and cells were briefly resuspended via pipetting. The cells were returned to the shaker for another 45 minutes. Once the cells were removed, the cell-containing media from the top of the filter was transferred to polypropylene tubes containing DMEM/10% FBS. Cells were then centrifuged and resuspended in fresh media. This population is referred to as the adherent population.
Luciferin-luciferase ADP/ATP Assay
To further assess cellular viability, the Bioluminescent Cell Viability Kit II (ADP/ATP) was used for the determination of a viability ratio of ADP/ATP. The assay was performed as per manufacturer’s instructions. Briefly, ATP monitoring enzyme and nucleotide releasing buffer were mixed to form a “Reaction Mix”. 100 µL of the Reaction Mix was added to a 96-well plate. This sample was then read on a luminescence-capable spectrophotometer (FluoStar Optima, BLG Labtech, Ortenberg, Germany) to provide the background reading (Data A). Digested adherent cells were then diluted and 5×103 cells per 10 µL of medium were added to the 96-well plate. This cell solution was then read on the luminometer, twice (Data B and C) to measure the amount of ATP within the cells. Finally, 1 µL of ADP converting enzyme was added and the cell solution was read for a final time (Data D). To obtain the ratio of ADP to ATP, the following calculation was used:
All results are expressed as ratios relative to control cells: cells incubated in KSFM in the absence of a contact lens (no lens control).
After resuspension in DMEM/10% FBS, aliquots were transferred to flow cytometry tubes. Flow cytometry tubes contained one of two mixtures: (a) FITC-labeled anti-CD29 and PE-labeled anti-CD49c; or (b) FITC-VAD-FMK (pan caspase). Integrins were incubated in the dark at room temperature for 30 minutes. Integrin samples were then diluted in buffer and paraformaldehyde fixative (1% final concentration) and were analyzed by flow cytometry within five days. As per kit instructions , caspase samples were incubated at 37°C for 60 minutes. The samples were then washed and propidium iodide (PI) was added. All caspase samples were analyzed immediately on the flow cytometer.
Flow Cytometry Acquisition/Analysis
All integrin, caspase, and PI samples were acquired on a FACSVantage flow cytometer (Becton Dickinson, Mountain View, California) using CELLQuest Software. Appropriate isotype controls were used with each experiment. At least 5000 events were collected per sample. Analysis was also performed using FACSExpress post data acquisition.
All results are reported as means ± standard deviation. To evaluate the significance of the differences in cell viability and cell activation, an analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed, followed by multiple pairwise comparisons using the Tukey’s Honest Significant Difference using Statistical Analysis Software (SAS, Cary, NC, USA). Samples were compared to cells incubated without lens or solution (no lens control) as well as to cells exposed to a PBS-soaked BA lens (PBS-BA control). Significant differences between the compounds tested are also reported. A p value of less than 0.05 was required for statistical significance. The number of experiments was equal to or greater than three and experiments were performed on different days.
While a cellulose insert can be curved and hold its shape, one of its drawbacks is that it is not transparent, and thus difficult to image. To illustrate how cells cover the entire curved surface, pictures were taken after incubation with the metabolic dye thiazoyl blue tetrazolium bromide (MTT) (Figure 2).
Surface coverage by formazan indicates well stratified and viable cells.
Histopathologic evaluation revealed squamous epithelial cells arranged in 3 to 5 defined, relatively uniform horizontal layers, firmly attached to the underlying cellulose filter (Figure 3).
H&E, original magnification 63X.
Cellular Metabolic Activity
As shown in Figure 4, there was no difference in viability between the BA PBS (99±10% and 102±10% at 6 and 24 hours, respectively) and the no lens controls. All BAK concentrations significantly reduced viability when compared to the BA PBS control (p<0.001). Exposure to 0.01% BAK resulted in the largest reduction in viability with values of 16% and 12% at 6 hours and 24 hours, respectively. Time was not a significant factor (p = 0.74) suggesting that any of the tested concentration of BAK could be used as a positive control at either time point.
Cells were incubated for 6 and 24 hours with solutions of BAK or PBS-soaked contact lenses. Viability was measured by the MTT assay and is expressed as a percentage relative to cells grown in the absence of a contact lens (control). n = 5, *significantly different from BA PBS control, p<0.05. BA PBS: PBS-soaked balafilcon A lens.
Both surfactants tested showed a negligible reduction in viability at 6 hours (Figure 5). Only exposure to 1% Tetronic 1304 for 24 hours resulted in a significant decrease in viability (88±12%) when compared to the viability observed at 6 hours (107±14%) (p<0.05). However, this reduction in viability was not statistically significant when compared to the BA PBS control (p = 0.14).
Cells were incubated for 6 and 24 hours with solutions of different poloxamine surfactants at different concentrations. Viability was measured by the MTT assay and is expressed as a percentage relative to cells grown in the absence of a contact lens (control). n = 5, *significantly different from BA PBS control, #significantly different between 6 and 24 hours, p<0.05, T1304: Tetronic 1304, T904: Tetronic 904.
ADP/ATP Viability Ratio
With the luciferase assay, when compared to controls (BA PBS and no lens), an increase in the ratio of ADP/ATP was observed with increasing concentrations of BAK, except in the case of 0.01% BAK (Table 1). It is important to note that due to the damage incurred from exposure to the most toxic concentration of BAK (0.01%), cells from this sample may have oversaturated the signal, which resulted in a calculated ADP/ATP ratio that appeared to be non-significantly different from the controls (Personal communication, 2014, Jacqueline White, PromoCell).
To assess if exposure to BAK or to a PBS-soaked lens affected the cell adhesion phenotype, expression of the heterodimer α3β1 was investigated via its two integrin subunits α3 (CD49c) and β1 (CD29).
Two distinct populations of cells were studied. The supernatant population corresponds to the cells that were sloughed off of the multilayer during and after lens incubation or BAK exposure, and the adherent population refers to the tissue that was digested via trypsinization.
In the adherent cell population (Figure 6), when compared to both a PBS-soaked lens and control (no lens, no solution), upregulation in CD49c expression was observed with increasing concentrations of BAK. Exposure to 0.01% BAK for both 6 and 24 hours resulted in a significant upregulation of CD49c expression when compared to all other samples (p<0.001). At 24 hours, higher CD49c expression was also observed with 0.005% BAK (p<0.01). While for all BAK samples, increases in CD49c expression appeared to occur between 6 hours and 24 hours, these changes were not statistically significant (p>0.2).
Following exposure to stimuli after 6 or 24 hours, the curved, stratified cultures of corneal epithelial cells were digested with trypsin and EDTA to form the adherent cell population. CD49c and CD29 expression was measured by flow cytometry and is expressed as a ratio relative to its expression on cells incubated with no lens or BAK (control). n = 3 to 5, *significantly different from PBS-soaked lens, p<0.05. BA PBS: PBS-soaked balafilcon A lens.
CD29 expression on adherent cells, as shown in Figure 6, was also upregulated in the presence of BAK. Similar to CD49c expression, a significant upregulation could be observed following exposure to 0.01% BAK for 6 and 24 hours compared to BA PBS (p<0.001). No change in CD29 expression was observed for BA PBS. There was also no effect of time on the expression of CD29.
For cells in the supernatant, as shown in Table 2, no difference in CD49c expression could be observed amongst any of the concentrations of BAK versus the BA PBS and no lens controls. Incubation time also had no effect. Regardless of treatment, there was also little difference in CD29 expression on cells from the supernatant. Some downregulation (albeit not significant) was observed at 6 hours for both 0.005% BAK and 0.01% BAK. However, at 24 hours, for all samples, a significant upregulation in CD29 expression was observed compared to 6 hours (p<0.05).
Caspase Activation and Propidium Iodide Expression
To assess how the different conditions affected cell apoptosis and necrosis, caspase activation was detected by flow cytometry using the fluorescently-tagged pan caspase inhibitor FITC-VAD-FMK, which fluoresces most intensely in cells with active caspases. Dead cells were identified by propidium iodide staining.
For adherent cells, no difference in caspase activation was observed between BA PBS and the no lens control with ratios of 1.0±0.1 and 0.99±0.5 for 6 hours and 24 hours, respectively, as shown in Figure 7. The only formulation to induce significant caspase activation was 0.01% BAK at 6 hours (p<0.001). Caspase activation in cells from the 0.01% BAK sample at 6 hours was also significantly higher compared to the 24 hour time point, with ratios of 1.7±0.5 and 1.1±0.2, respectively.
Following exposure to stimuli after 6 or 24 hours, the curved, stratified cultures of corneal epithelial cells were digested with trypsin and EDTA. Caspase expression was measured by flow cytometry and is expressed as a ratio relative to its expression on cells incubated with no lens or BAK (control). n = 3 to 5, *significantly different from PBS-soaked lens, p<0.05. BA PBS: PBS-soaked balafilcon A lens.
For the supernatant cells, incubation with BA PBS led to caspase activation similar to the no lens control at both 6 hours and 24 hours (Figure 7). For 0.005% BAK and 0.01% BAK, a significant increase (p<0.001) in the level of caspase activation was observed in the supernatant cells for both 6 and 24 hours.
The fluorescent intensities of caspase activation for the control show that, when compared to adherent cells, the supernatant cell population exhibited a significantly higher level of caspase activation (p<0.001) at the 6 hour time point with values of 4.10±1.0 and 8.48±3.6, respectively. At 24 hours, minimal difference in caspase expression was observed between adherent and supernatant cell populations for all samples.
In the adherent cell population, as expected, exposure to BAK led to an increase in cell death as shown by the increase in PI staining. At both 6 and 24 hours, PI staining in cells exposed to 0.01% BAK was significantly higher (p<0.001) compared to all other treatments (Figure 8).
Following exposure to stimuli after 6 or 24 hours, the curved, stratified cultures of corneal epithelial cells were digested with Trypsin and EDTA. PI staining was measured by flow cytometry and is expressed as a ratio relative to its expression on cells incubated with no lens or BAK (control). n = 3–5, *significantly different from PBS-soaked lens, p<0.05.
In the supernatant cell population, following exposure to BAK, a difference in PI staining was present between the 6 and 24 hour time points (Figure 9). At 6 hours, 0.01% BAK was the only formulation that induced a significant level of cell death. At 24 hours, both 0.002% BAK and 0.005% BAK led to a significant increase in PI staining in supernatant cells (p<0.05). For cells exposed to 0.01% BAK, a reduction in PI staining was observed between 6 and 24 hours (p<0.001).
The histograms display PI staining in the supernatant (a) and adherent (b) cell population following 24 hour exposure to 0.01% BAK. The grey histogram represents cells from the no lens, no solution control; and the black histogram represents cells exposed to BAK. The positive peak for PI (>10 arbitrary fluorescent units) can be observed in both the control and BAK supernatant population, as cells slough off the stratified culture. A significant increase in cells staining positive for positive for PI can be observed following BAK exposure.
In comparing the adherent versus supernatant population of cells in our no lens control, levels of PI staining were found to be significantly higher in the supernatant population (p<0.001), as shown in Figure 9. The adherent population of cells appeared to have a very low necrotic population in control samples, but the overall profile changed dramatically in response to 0.01% BAK where there were significantly more PI positive cells. This is in agreement with the MTT viability data.
In vitro Model
Many other multilayered epithelial models exist, with the most popular commercial model being the SkinEthic Human Corneal Epithelial model that was developed in 2003 by Nguyen et al . There has since been much use of the SkinEthic model to investigate the toxicity potential of ophthalmic solutions , – including a pre-validation study by Van Goethem et al. in 2006 where the SkinEthic model was shown to be a useful alternative for the in vivo Draize test .
The previously reported multilayered models have been grown using other cell types and support membranes: immortalized human corneal epithelial cell lines CEPI 17 CL4 and SV40 immortalized cells have been grown on polyester/polycarbonate Transwell cell culture inserts – and human corneal limbal epithelial cells have been grown on polyethylene terephthalate (PET) membranes . Gipson  and Robertson  have also recently developed multilayered cultures. Finally, tissue reconstruction for corneal transplantation has given rise to many different multilayered models with cells grown on human amniotic membrane or silk fibroin –.
To the best of our knowledge, none of the prior models have been focused on the investigation of contact lens interactions on a curved multilayered epithelial substrate. A cellulose-based filter was chosen as the substrate upon which the cells would grow. These filters are capable of plastic deformation and are neither too rigid nor brittle for our purposes. Contact lenses also fit very well to the shape of the curve. The main disadvantage of using a cellulose support is its opacity, as this makes it very difficult to image. However, the MTT assay has shown to be a very useful indicator of cellular health as indicated by formazan coverage across the filter surface.
Two major implementations used in the development of the curved multilayered epithelium were the use of a collagen coating and the use of an air-liquid interface. The basement membrane, between the corneal stroma and epithelium, is a specialized extracellular matrix supporting the corneal epithelium. It is composed mainly of laminin, collagen type IV, and heparin sulphate proteoglycan (perlecan) . Human corneal epithelial cells grown on collagen gels are known to secrete all of the components of the basement membrane, as well as collagen type VII: a main component of anchoring fibrils which help epithelial cells attach to the stroma . The use of collagen as a matrix has been shown to support attachment, proliferation, and differentiation of corneal epithelial cells , –. Collagen has also been shown to have a very low antigenicity .
Since the in vivo epithelium is exposed to air, it is a logical assumption that the main parameter affecting multilayer stratification and growth is the culturing of cells using an air-liquid interface. It has been shown that the air-liquid interface not only promotes proliferation, stratification and differentiation of corneal epithelial cells , , but it is actually essential for growth of a properly stratified epithelium –. It is believed that the air-liquid interface promotes the shift of oxidative metabolism from the growth phase to the differentiation phase . Further, it has been shown that an air-liquid interface encourages the deposition of type VII collagen and laminin . The air-liquid interface thus provides a polarization effect that allows for proper stratification. Upon the introduction of an air-liquid interface, our HCEC were able to properly stratify on the curved cellulose filter.
Histological analysis confirmed that our cells were stratified to three to five layers. The curved multilayer model thus offers an in vitro model whereby cells can be exposed to an entire soaked lens as if the model “wears” the lens, providing a better approximation of material interaction as it occurs in vivo. It remains, however, limited in its ability to fully mimic the in vivo environment as it does not account for tear film interactions, blinking, and inflammation; all of which may affect material biocompatibility. This model also does not account for other clinical implications of toxicity such as corneal edema, blisters, corneal opacity, and neovascularization . In the current study, as a proof of concept and to ensure the reliability of the model, a PBS-soaked balafilcon A lens was used. As expected, the PBS-soaked lens proved to be very biocompatible with levels of cellular activity, integrin expression, and cell death, all comparable to a no lens control.
Previous work with stratified cultures has also focused on the viability and histology of the stratified corneal epithelium. To our knowledge, this is the first study that investigates differences in integrin expression and cell death in a stratified culture of corneal epithelial cells using flow cytometry. With the curved in vitro model, not only were the adherent cells that comprise the majority of the tissue characterized, but also the “shed” cells, which were collected from the culture media on the top of the filter prior to trypsinization. Digestion of in vivo corneal epithelial tissue for the purpose of flow cytometry has been done previously to study the necrotic population of cells . In vitro stratified cultures have also been digested to examine the apoptotic response of corneal epithelium to UVB through colorimetric and fluorometric analyses .
As previously described, the MTT assay is based on the reduction of tetrazolium salts. Mitochondrial, cytosolic, and microsomal enzymes are all capable of performing the reduction of MTT . MTT is endocytosed into the cells where it is reduced to formazan in the endosomal/lysosomal compartment . The formazan then accumulates in blue cytoplasmic granules and is exocytosed as needle-like aggregates on the cell surface , . We therefore describe the MTT assay as a viability assay, which lends itself to a belief that it is a relative number of living cells to those that are dead. However, it may be more descriptive to refer to it as an assay of cellular activity. With increasing concentrations of BAK, cellular activity is greatly reduced at both 6 and 24 hours. Cells exposed to concentrations of 0.01% and 0.005% BAK sustained significant damage and continuous exposure to this dose of BAK prevented cell repair and growth. However, cells exposed to 0.002% BAK, while having a reduced viability at 6 hours, appeared to have a somewhat increased viability at 24 hours which would suggest that the stratified cells were able to repair themselves from the damage caused by BAK.
Our MTT viability results with BAK are in agreement with previously reported toxic mechanisms in vitro, primarily with the use of the SkinEthic model in the work of Baudouin and Khoh-Reiter , , –. Consistently, increasing concentration and time exposure to BAK is shown to have an increasingly negative effect on the health of corneal epithelial cells. However, our curved model appears to be slightly more sensitive to cytotoxicity than what has been shown using the SkinEthic model : for similar levels of BAK exposure, approximately 20% to 60% viability was observed in our model compared to the SkinEthic model. These differences in viability may be due to differences in surface area, exposure time, BAK source, and other factors such as the different structure of the in vitro models.
The luciferase assay was originally developed using the biomimetic system found in fireflies . Briefly, luciferase acts as an enzyme to catalyze the reaction between ATP and luciferin to form light: this light can then be measured using a luminometer. ADP can also be measured through its conversion to ATP and its subsequent reaction with luciferase. The ratio of ADP/ATP has since been shown to correlate with apoptosis and necrosis and to provide measures of cellular viability , . Geerling et al  previously used a luciferin-based assay to assess the cytotoxicity of BAK using a monolayer model of primary corneal epithelial cells. The assay showed to be more sensitive than scanning electron microscopy evaluation of morphological changes as well as the live/dead calcein/ethidium homodimer fluorescence assay. Our luciferase results further confirmed our cellular viability findings as measured by MTT, namely an increase in cell death with increasing concentrations of BAK, demonstrating that the luciferase assay may also be used to detect cytotoxicity in stratified cultures.
Poloxamine Surfactant Cytotoxicity
Poloxamines represent a family of nonionic amphiphilic surfactants and have been reported to be relatively nontoxic by BASF, their manufacturer . Poloxamines are currently used in ophthalmology in contact lens cleaning solutions and eye drop formulations , , . In our model, these surfactants show a negligible decrease in viability which is in accordance with recent in vitro and ex vivo corneal assays that demonstrated the safety of these surfactants for the ocular surface . Poloxamers, similar to poloxamines but with a generally lower molecular weight, are also frequently used in ophthalmic preparations. While both families of surfactants have been shown previously to induce cytotoxicity in vitro , the study used a colony-forming assay of Chinese hamster lung fibroblasts V79 cells and a 6-day incubation. The long incubation time, the type of culture (isolated colonies versus stratified culture), and the cells used (V79), which may be more sensitive due to tissue and species variations, likely explain the difference in results. Overall, only 1% Tetronic 1304 showed a marginal decrease in viability (88±12% relative to control) as well as an increase in ADP/ATP relative to control, which may indicate some associated cell death. However, given the level of change observed compared to control, this concentration would likely not be considered cytotoxic.
Integrins are heterodimeric transmembrane glycoproteins that consist of an alpha and a beta chain, and are responsible for the interactions between epithelial cells and their extracellular matrix. Integrin chains α3 (CD49c) and β1 (CD29) form heterodimers that are known to have strong roles in epithelial adhesion and maintenance of cell-cell junctions; they have also been reported to play a role in cell spreading , . The heterodimer α3β1 is a receptor for fibronectin, laminin 5, laminin 10, and all major components of the corneal basement membrane  and α3β1 heterodimers are expressed in the basal or suprabasal layers of the corneal epithelium , . Higher levels of α3β1 are expressed on cells with higher proliferative properties , , . It has also been reported that β1 integrins can at least partially compensate for the loss of desmosomes and adherens junctions .
Integrin expression in supernatant cells appeared to be relatively consistent regardless of applied formulation and showed levels of expression similar to control cells. As the supernatant cells have been sloughed or worn off the multilayered tissue, it is likely that these cells no longer attempt to promote attachment. On the other hand, with increases in BAK concentration, the adherent cells showed a significant increase in CD49c (α3) and CD29 (β1) expression. This increase in integrin expression suggests that prolonged exposure to a cytotoxic stimulus such as BAK may lead the cells in the stratified tissue to enter a repair phase and consequently display a phenotype that increases their ability to proliferate and migrate.
Cell Death Mechanisms
Apoptosis is a programmed form of cell death and serves, among others, as a defense mechanism in the removal of damaged cells. Apoptosis is a highly regulated, programmed cell death pathway, mediated in part by the action of caspases . Caspases are cysteine aspartate proteases that act as mediators for initiating cellular disassembly and are normally found in the inactive, pro-caspase form , . Initiation of apoptosis occurs upon activation of initiator caspases by intrinsic or extrinsic factors, which can subsequently activate downstream effector caspases.
Alternatively, necrosis is a form of dysregulated cellular death. Necrotic cells that have an intact nuclear membrane are stained by propidium iodide, which intercalates with DNA and provides a strong fluorescent signal in its bound form. It is also possible that cells positive for PI staining may be the result of an apoptotic death pathway.
Fluorescent levels of caspase and PI were much higher in the supernatant overall as compared to the adherent populations. This agrees with Pauly’s previous findings that cell death was localized to the outer layers of the multilayer following exposure to BAK .
Similar trends in caspase expression were observed in both supernatant and adherent cells whereby increases in BAK concentration resulted in increased caspase activation at 6 hours; albeit by 24 hours, caspase levels were lower compared to 6 hours. This is likely due to the 24 hour time point being too late to observe caspase activation. Caspase activation is an initiator of apoptosis and activation may not be detectable at later time points depending on the type of death cycle the cells may have entered (secondary necrosis versus apoptosis). Interestingly, the response of the multilayer to a strong stimulus (0.01% BAK) was different from a weak stimulus (0.002% or 0.005% BAK), suggesting a dynamic cell death process within the stratified culture model. With the 0.01% BAK samples, the reduction in PI staining between 6 and 24 hours in the supernatant was paralleled by an increase in PI staining in the adherent population. Thus, prolonged exposure to BAK may cause cells in the supernatant to lose their nuclear membrane integrity and ability to stain with PI: these cells detached from the stratified culture and thus were potentially already damaged, making them more sensitive to cytolytic damage by BAK. Such a phenomenon does not appear to occur at lower BAK concentrations as an increase in PI staining in supernatant cells is observed for these treatments at 24 hours. The change in PI expression may be explained by the apoptotic cells in the supernatant population entering secondary necrosis, which has been previously observed , . The increase in PI staining at 24 hours for all BAK samples highlights the completion of the cell death cycle whereby a certain number of cells in the stratified culture were irreversibly damaged by exposure to BAK. The results from the 6 hour time point suggest that apoptosis played a role in the cell death observed at 24 hours. These results emphasize the importance of early time points when measuring cell death mechanisms. The PI staining results also correspond well with the observed reduction in viability as measured by MTT and the luciferase assay.
It is also worth discussing the overall lack of significant change observed with exposure to 0.002% BAK. While viability, as measured by MTT, decreased at both 6 and 24 hours, no significant upregulation of integrins or caspase expression occurred. PI staining increased in the supernatant cell population, but only after a 24 hour exposure. This was also noted for 0.002% BAK using the luciferase assay. This suggests that BAK may only be harmful at high concentrations: though cells may still be damaged, they may be able to withstand certain low concentrations of BAK, allowing the tissue to recover. These results are in accordance with the previous study by Pauly et al.  showing that cells exposed to lower concentrations of BAK did not see a continued decrease in reduction of viability following a 24 hour recovery period.
A healthy, reconstructed corneal epithelium in the shape of the regular human cornea in vitro was successfully grown. Our model appears to be well-stratified with three to five layers of cells. The overall suitability of our model for biocompatibility experiments was verified by exposure to the well-known cytotoxic compound benzalkonium chloride, which is currently used as a preservative in commercially-available eyedrop formulations. Surfactant cytotoxicity was also found to not be implicated in the cytotoxicity of BAK.
To assess cellular viability and cell phenotype via flow cytometry, new protocols were developed for the stratified curved models. Both supernatant cells, which had been sloughed off of the multilayer, and adherent cells, which had remained adherent as part of the stratified culture, were characterized. Cells in the supernatant were found to be significantly more caspase and PI positive. A dynamic cell death mechanism was observed across the varying concentrations of BAK, leading to the hypothesis that many cells die through apoptosis. An increase in integrin expression was also noted with increasing concentrations of BAK implying that the cells were attempting to repair the damaged tissue. Examination of cell phenotype via flow cytometry proved to be a very useful quantitative method for detecting sensitive changes in our curved, stratified corneal epithelium.
Overall, our model was able to detect differences in cytotoxicity over time. Furthermore, exposure of the curved stratified culture to a PBS-soaked lens did not have a significant effect on cells, suggesting that our in vitro model is suitable to investigate contact lens/solution interactions.
The authors would like to thank Christopher Amos for his advice and the fruitful discussion around the model. CP would like to thank Hanna Kazhamiaka and Fernando Camacho for their assistance in statistics as well as Vivian Xu for her help with the bioluminescent plate reader.
Conceived and designed the experiments: CKP RP SW ANW MBG. Performed the experiments: CKP RP SW DH. Analyzed the data: CKP RP SW ANW DH MBG. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: DH MBG. Wrote the paper: CKP MBG.
- 1. Barar J, Javadzadeh AR, Omidi Y (2008) Ocular novel drug delivery: impacts of membranes and barriers. Expert Opinion on Drug Delivery 5: 567–581.
- 2. Suzuki K, Saito J, Yanai R, Yamada N, Chikama T-I, et al. (2003) Cell-matrix and cell-cell interactions during corneal epithelial wound healing. Progress in Retinal and Eye Research 22: 113–133.
- 3. Reichl S, Kölln C, Hahne M, Verstraelen J (2011) In vitro cell culture models to study the corneal drug absorption. Expert Opinion on Drug Metabolism and Toxicology 7: 559–578.
- 4. Araie M, Maurice D (1987) The rate of diffusion of fluorophores through the corneal epithelium and stroma. Experimental Eye Research 44: 73–87.
- 5. Draize JH, Woodard G, Calvery HO (1944) Methods for the Study of Irritation and Toxicity of Substances Applied Topically to the Skin and Mucous Membranes. Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics 82: 377–390.
- 6. Castro-Muñozledo F (2008) Corneal Epithelial Cell Cultures as a Tool for Research, Drug Screening and Testing. Experimental Eye Research 86: 459–469.
- 7. York M, Steiling W (1998) A Critical Review of the Assessment of Eye Irritation Potential using the Draize Rabbit Eye Test. Journal of Applied Toxicology 18: 233–240.
- 8. Debbasch C, Ebenhahn C, Dami N, Pericoi M, Van den Berghe C, et al. (2005) Eye Irritation of Low-Irritant Cosmetic Formulations: Correlation of in vitro Results with Clinical Data and Product Composition. Food and Chemical Toxicology 43: 155–165.
- 9. Araki-Saskai K, Ohashi Y, Sasabe T, Hayashi K, Watanabe H, et al. (1995) An SV40-Immortalized Human Corneal Epithelial Cell Line and Its Characterization. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 36: 614–621.
- 10. Griffith M, Osborne R, Munger R, Xiong X, Doillon CJ, et al. (1999) Functional Human Corneal Equivalents Constructed from Cell Lines. Science 286: 2169–2172.
- 11. Robertson DM, Li L, Fisher S, Pearce VP, Shay JW, et al. (2005) Characterization of Growth and Differentiation in a Telomerase-Immortalized Human Corneal Epithelial Cell Line. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 46: 470–478.
- 12. Lim MJ, Hurst RK, Konyenbelt BJ, Ubels JL (2009) Cytotoxicity Testing of Multipurpose Contact Lens Solutions Using Monoloyer and Stratified Cultures of Human Corneal Epithelial Cells. Eye & Contact Lens 35: 287–296.
- 13. Gipson IK, Spurr-Michaud S, Argüeso P, Tisdale A, Ng TF, et al. (2003) Mucin Gene Expression in Immortalized Human Corneal-Limbal and Conjunctival Epithelial Cell Lines. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 44: 2496–2506.
- 14. Reichl S, Bednarz J, Müller-Goymann CC (2004) Human Corneal Equivalent as Cell Culture Model for in vitro Drug Permeation Studies. British Journal of Ophthalmology 88: 560–565.
- 15. Van Goethem F, Adriaens E, Alépée N, Straube F, De Wever B, et al. (2006) Prevalidation of a New in vitro Reconstituted Human Cornea Model to Assess the Eye Irritating Potential of Chemicals. Toxicology in Vitro 20: 1–17.
- 16. Xiang CD, Batugo M, Gale DC, Zhang T, Ye J, et al. (2009) Characterization of Human Corneal Epithelial Cell Model As a Surrogate for Corneal Permeability Assessment: Metabolism and Transport. Drug Metabolism and Disposition 37: 992–998.
- 17. Reichl S (2006) Comparison of the transepithelial permeability of the two commercially available reconstructed corneal epithelium models Epiocular (Mattek) and RHCE (Skinethic) Proceedings of the 5th World Meeting on Pharmaceutics, Biopharmaceutics and Pharmaceutical Technology, Geneva, Switzerland.
- 18. Hahne M, Zorn-Kruppa M, Guzman G, Brandner JM, Haltner-Ukomado E, et al. (2012) Prevalidation of a human cornea construct as an alternative to animal corneas for in vitro drug absorption studies. Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 101: 2976–2988.
- 19. Powell CH, Lally JM, Hoong LD, Huth SW (2010) Lipophilic Versus Hydrodynamic Modes of Uptake and Release by Contact Lenses of Active Entities Used in Multipurpose Solutions. Contact Lens and Anterior Eye 33: 9–18.
- 20. Gorbet M, Postnikoff C (2013) The Impact of Silicone Hydrogel-Solution Combinations on Corneal Epithelial Cells. Eye & Contact Lens 39: 42–47.
- 21. Jones L, Powell CH (2013) Uptake and Release Phenomena in Contact Lens Care by Silicone Hydrogel Lenses. Eye & Contact Lens 39: 29–36.
- 22. Andrasko G, Ryen K (2008) Corneal Staining and Comfort Observed with Traditional and Silicone Hydrogel Lenses and Multipurpose Solution Combinations. Optometry 79: 444–454.
- 23. Carnt N, Willcox MDP, Evans V, Naduvilath TJ, Tilia D, et al. (2007) Corneal Staining: The IER Matrix Study. Contact Lens Spectrum.
- 24. McCanna DJ, Harrington KL, Driot J-Y, Ward KW, Tchao R (2008) Use of a Human Corneal Epithelial Cell Line for Screening the Safety of Contact Lens Care Solution in Vitro. Eye & Contact Lens 34: 6–12.
- 25. Cavet ME, Harrington KL, VanDerMeid KR, Ward KW, Zhang J-Z (2009) Comparison of the Effect of Multipurpose Contact Lens Solutions on the Viability of Cultured Corneal Epithelial Cells. Contact Lens and Anterior Eye 32: 171–175.
- 26. Dutot M, Warnet J-M, Baudouin C, Rat P (2008) Cytotoxicity of Contact Lens Multipurpose Solutions: Role of Oxidative Stress, Mitochondrial Activity, and P2×7 Cell Death Receptor Activation. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 33: 138–145.
- 27. Choy CKM, Cho P, Boost MV (2012) Cytotoxicity and effects on metabolism of contact lens care solutions on human corneal epithelium cells. Clinical and Experimental Optometry 95: 198–206.
- 28. Gorbet MB, Tanti NC, Crockett B, Mansour L, Jones L (2011) Effect of contact lens material on cytotoxicity potential of multipurpose solutions using human corneal epithelial cells. Molecular Vision 17: 3458–3467.
- 29. Tanti NC, Jones L, Gorbet MB (2011) Impact of Multipurpose Solutions Released from Contact Lenses on Corneal Cells. Optometry & Vision Science 88: 483–492.
- 30. Noecker R (2001) Effects of Common Ophthalmic Preservatives on Ocular Health. Advances in Therapy 18: 205–215.
- 31. Gorbet MB, Tanti NC, Jones L, Sheardown H (2010) Corneal Epithelial Cell Biocompatibility to Silicone Hydrogel and Conventional Hydrogel Contact Lens Packaging Solutions. Molecular Vision 16: 272–282.
- 32. Glick R, Huth SW, Yu ZJ, Powell CH (2006) Compositions and methods using sub-PPM combinations of polyquaternium-1 and high molecular weight PHMB. Google Patents.
- 33. Owen GR, Brooks AC, Graff G (2006) Suspension formulations of nepafenac and other ophthalmic drugs for topical treatment of ophthalmic disorders.
- 34. Yamasaki K, Kawasaki S, Young RD, Fukuoka H, Tanioka H, et al. (2009) Genomic Aberrations and Cellular Heterogeneity in SV40-Immortalized Human Corneal Epithelial Cells. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 50: 604–613.
- 35. Mosmann T (1983) Rapid Colorimetric Assay for Cellular Growth and Survival: Application to Proliferation and Cytotoxicity Assays. Journal of Immunological Methods 65: 55–63.
- 36. Altman FP (1974) Studies on the Reduction of Tetrazolium Salts III. The Products of Chemical and Enzymic Reduction. Histochemistry 38: 155–171.
- 37. Altman FP (1976) Tetrazolium Salts and Formazans. Progress in Histochemistry and Cytochemistry 9: 1–56.
- 38. Doucet O, Robert C, Zastrow L (1996) Use of a serum-free reconstituted epidermis as a skin pharmacological model. Toxicology in Vitro 10: 305–313.
- 39. Pauly A, Melont M, Brignole-Baudouin F, Warnet J-M, Baudouin C (2009) Multiple Endpoint Analysis of the 3D–Reconstituted Corneal Epithelium after Treatment with Benzalkonium Chloride: Early Detection of Toxic Damage. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science 50: 1644–1652.
- 40. ImmunoChemistry Technologies, LLC (2012) FAM-FLICA in vitro Caspase Detection Kit.
- 41. Nguyen DH, Beuerman RW, DeWever B, Rosdy M (2003) Three-Dimensional Construct of the Human Corneal Epithelium for In Vitro Toxicology. In: Katz HSaS, editor. Alternative Toxicological Methods: CRC Press. 147–158.
- 42. Meloni M, Pauly A, Servi BD, Varlet BL, Baudouin C (2010) Occludin gene expression as an early in vitro sign for mild eye irritation assessment. Toxicology in Vitro 24: 276–285.
- 43. Meloni M, De Servi B, Marasco D, Del Prete S (2011) Molecular mechanism of ocular surface damage: Application to an in vitro dry eye model on human corneal epithelium. Molecular Vision 17: 113–126.
- 44. Doucet O, Lanvin M, Thillou C, Linossier C, Pupat C, et al. (2006) Reconstituted human corneal epithelium: A new alternative to the Draize eye test for the assessment of the eye irritation potential of chemicals and cosmetic products. Toxicology in Vitro 20: 499–512.
- 45. Liang H, Pauly A, Riancho L, Baudouin C, Brignole-Baudouin F (2011) Toxicological evaluation of preservative-containing and preservative-free topical prostaglandin analogues on a three-dimensional-reconstituted corneal epithelium system. British Journal of Ophthalmology 95: 869–875.
- 46. Pauly A, Brasnu E, Riancho L, Brignole-Baudouin F, Baudouin C (2011) Multiple endpoint analysis of BAC-preserved and unpreserved antiallergic eye drops on a 3D-reconstituted corneal epithelial model. Molecular Vision 17: 745–755.
- 47. Khoh-Reiter S, Jessen B (2009) Evaluation of the cytotoxic effects of ophthalmic solutions containing benzalkonium chloride on corneal epithelium using an organotypic 3-D model. BMC Ophthalmology 9: 5.
- 48. Reichl S, Döhring S, Bednarz J, Müller-Goymann CC (2005) Human cornea construct HCC–an alternative for in vitro permeation studies? A comparison with human donor corneas. European Journal of Pharmaceutics and Biopharmaceutics 60: 305–308.
- 49. Toropainen E, Ranta V-P, Vellonen K-S, Palmgrén J, Talvitie A, et al. (2003) Paracellular and passive transcellular permeability in immortalized human corneal epithelial cell culture model. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 20: 99–106.
- 50. Toropainen E, Ranta V-P, Talvitie A, Subonen P, Urtti A (2001) Culture Model of Human Corneal Epithelium for Prediction of Ocular Drug Absorption. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 42: 2942–2948.
- 51. Greco D, Vellonen K-S, Turner HC, HÃ¤kli M, Tervo T, et al. (2010) Gene expression analysis in SV-40 immortalized human corneal epithelial cells cultured with an air-liquid interface. Molecular Vision 16: 2109–2120.
- 52. Ban Y, Cooper LJ, Fullwood NJ, Nakamura T, Tsuzuki M, et al. (2003) Comparison of ultrastructure, tight junction-related protein expression and barrier function of human corneal epithelial cells cultivated on amniotic membrane with and without air-lifting. Experimental Eye Research 76: 735–743.
- 53. Nakamura T, Yoshitani M, Rigby H, Fullwood NJ, Ito W, et al. (2004) Sterilized, Freeze-Dried Amniotic Membrane: A Useful Substrate for Ocular Surface Reconstruction. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 45: 93–99.
- 54. Reichl S (2008) Cell Culture Models of the Human Cornea - A Comparative Evalutation of Their Usefulness to Determine Ocular Drug Absorption in-Vitro. Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology 60: 299–307.
- 55. Ohji M, SundarRaj N, Hassell JR, Thoft RA (1994) Basement membrane synthesis by human corneal epithelial cells in vitro. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 35: 479–485.
- 56. Minami Y, Sugihara H, Oono S (1993) Reconstruction of cornea in three-dimensional collagen gel matrix culture. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 34: 2316–2324.
- 57. Geggel HS, Friend J, Thoft RA (1985) Collagen gel for ocular surface. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 26: 901–905.
- 58. He Y-G, McCulley JP (1991) Growing human corneal epithelium on collagen shield and subsequent transfer to denuded cornea in vitro. Current Eye Research 10: 851–863.
- 59. Zieske JD, Mason VS, Wasson ME, Meunier SF, Nolte CJM, et al. (1994) Basement Membrane Assembly and Differentiation of Cultured Corneal Cells: Importance of Culture Environment and Endothelial Cell Interaction. Experimental Cell Research 214: 621–633.
- 60. Kondo M, Tamaoki J, Sakai A, Kameyama S, Kanoh S, et al. (1997) Increased oxidative metabolism in cow tracheal epithelial cells cultured at air-liquid interface. Am J Respir Cell Mol Biol 16: 62–68.
- 61. Johnson LG, Dickman KG, Moore KL, Mandel LJ, Boucher RC (1993) Enhanced Na+ transport in an air-liquid interface culture system. American Journal of Physiology Lung Cellular and Molecular Physiology 264: L560–L565.
- 62. Chang J-E, Basu S, Lee V (2000) Air-Interface Condition Promotes the Formation of Tight Corneal Epithelial Cell Layers for Drug Transport Studies. Pharmaceutical Research 17: 670–676.
- 63. Petrali JP, Dick EJ, Brozetti JJ, Hamilton TA, Finger AV (2000) Acute ocular effects of mustard gas: ultrastructural pathology and immunohistopathology of exposed rabbit cornea. Journal of Applied Toxicology 20: S173–S175.
- 64. Choy CKM, Cho P, Boost MV, Benzie IFF (2009) Do Multipurpose Solutions Damage Porcine Corneal Epithelial Cells? Optometry and Vision Science 86: E447–E453.
- 65. Schotanus MP, Koetje LR, Van Dyken RE, Ubels JL (2011) Stratified corneal limbal epithelial cells are protected from UVB-induced apoptosis by elevated extracellular K+. Experimental Eye Research 93: 735–740.
- 66. Gonzalez RJ, Tarloff JB (2001) Evalutation of Hepatic Subcellular Fractions for Alamar Blue and MTT Reductase Activity. Toxicology in Vitro 15: 257–259.
- 67. Molinari BL, Tasat DR, Palmieri MA, Cabrini RL (2005) Kinetics of MTT-Formazan Exocytosis in Phagocytic and Non-Phagocytic Cells. Micron 36: 177–183.
- 68. Diaz G, Melis M, Musinu A, Piludu M, Piras M, et al. (2007) Localization of MTT Formazan in Lipid Droplets. An Alternative Hypothesis About the Nature of Formazan Granules and Aggregates. European Journal of Histochemistry 51: 213–218.
- 69. John JBS (1970) Determination of ATP in chlorella with the luciferin-luciferase enzyme system. Analytical Biochemistry 37: 409–416.
- 70. Bradbury DA, Simmons TD, Slater KJ, Crouch SPM (2000) Measurement of the ADP: ATP ratio in human leukaemic cell lines can be used as an indicator of cell viability, necrosis and apoptosis. Journal of Immunological Methods 240: 79–92.
- 71. (2013) Bioluminescent Cell Viability Kit II (ADP/ATP). PromoCell GmbH.
- 72. Geerling G, Daniels JT, Dart JKG, Cree IA, Khaw PT (2001) Toxicity of Natural Tear Substitutes in a Fully Defined Culture Model of Human Corneal Epithelial Cells. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science 42: 948–956.
- 73. (2004) Tetronic 904 Block Copolymer Surfactant. BASF Technical Bulletin.
- 74. Santodomingo-Rubido J, Mori O, Kawaminami S (2006) Cytotoxicity and antimicrobial activity of six multipurpose soft contact lens disinfecting solutions1. Ophthalmic and Physiological Optics 26: 476–482.
- 75. Zhao M, Campolmi N, Thuret G, Piselli S, Acquart S, et al. (2012) Poloxamines for Deswelling of Organ-Cultured Corneas. Ophthalmic Research 48: 124–133.
- 76. Pereira HA, Ruan X, Gonzalez ML, Tsyshevskaya-Hoover I, Chodosh J (2004) Modulation of Corneal Epithelial Cell Functions by the Neutrophil-Derived Inflammatory Mediator CAP37. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 45: 4284–4292.
- 77. Stepp MA, Spurr-Michaud S, Gipson IK (1993) Integrins in the wounded and unwounded stratified squamous epithelium of the cornea. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 34: 1829–1844.
- 78. Päällysaho T, Tervo T, Virtanen I, Tervo K (1992) Integrins in the Normal and Healing Corneal Epithelium. Acta Ophthalmologica Scandinavica 70: 22–25.
- 79. Li D-Q, Chen Z, Song XJ, de Paiva CS, Kim H-S, et al. (2005) Partial enrichment of a population of human limbal epithelial cells with putative stem cell properties based on collagen type IV adhesiveness. Experimental Eye Research 80: 581–590.
- 80. Stepp MA, Zhu L (1997) Upregulation of α9 Integrin and Tenascin During Epithelial Regeneration After Debridement in the Cornea. Journal of Histochemistry and Cytochemistry 45: 189–201.
- 81. Budihardjo I, Oliver H, Lutter M, Luo X, Wang X (1999) Biochemical Pathways of Caspase Activation During Apoptosis. Annual Review of Cell and Developmental Biology 15: 269–290.
- 82. Cho SG, Choi EJ (2002) Apoptotic signaling pathways: caspases and stress-activated protein kinases. J Biochem Mol Biol 35: 24–27.
- 83. Luo L, Li D-Q, Pflugfelder SC (2007) Hyperosmolarity-Induced Apoptosis in Human Corneal Epithelial Cells Is Mediated by Cytochrome c and MAPK Pathways. Cornea 26: 452–460.
- 84. Pauly A, Roubeix C, Liang H, Brignole-Baudouin F, Baudouin C (2012) In Vitro and In Vivo Comparative Toxicological Study of a New Preservative-Free Latanoprost Formulation. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 53: 8172–8180.
- 85. Smolewski P, Grabarek J, Halicka HD, Darzynkiewicz Z (2002) Assay of caspase activation in situ combined with probing plasma membrane integrity to detect three distinct stages of apoptosis. Journal of Immunological Methods 265: 111–121.