The smallest genomes of any photosynthetic organisms are found in a group of free-living marine cyanobacteria, Prochlorococcus. To determine the underlying evolutionary mechanisms, we developed a new method to reconstruct the steps leading to the Prochlorococcus genome reduction using 12 Prochlorococcus and 6 marine Synechococcus genomes. Our results reveal that small genome sizes within Prochlorococcus were largely determined shortly after the split of Prochlorococcus and Synechococcus (an early big shrink) and thus for the first time decouple the genome reduction from Prochlorococcus diversification. A maximum likelihood approach was then used to estimate changes of nucleotide substitution rate and selection strength along Prochlorococcus evolution in a phylogenetic framework. Strong genome wide purifying selection was associated with the loss of many genes in the early evolutionary stage. The deleted genes were distributed around the genome, participated in many different functional categories and in general had been under relaxed selection pressure. We propose that shortly after Prochlorococcus diverged from its common ancestor with marine Synechococcus, its population size increased quickly thus increasing efficacy of selection. Due to limited nutrients and a relatively constant environment, selection favored a streamlined genome for maximum economy. Strong genome wide selection subsequently caused the loss of genes with small functional effect including the loss of some DNA repair genes. In summary, genome reduction in Prochlorococcus resulted in genome features that are similar to symbiotic bacteria and pathogens, however, the small genome sizes resulted from an increase in genome wide selection rather than a consequence of a reduced ecological niche or relaxed selection due to genetic drift.
Citation: Sun Z, Blanchard JL (2014) Strong Genome-Wide Selection Early in the Evolution of Prochlorococcus Resulted in a Reduced Genome through the Loss of a Large Number of Small Effect Genes. PLoS ONE 9(3): e88837. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0088837
Editor: Art F. Y. Poon, British Columbia Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS, Canada
Received: June 18, 2013; Accepted: January 13, 2014; Published: March 3, 2014
Copyright: © 2014 Sun, Blanchard. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: We are grateful for funding from the UMass Healy Foundation (http://www.umass.edu/research/faculty-research-granthealey-endowment-grant) and USDA Hatch grants MAS00898 and MAS009582. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Genome sizes vary in bacteria, ranging from 160 kb in Carsonella ruddii  to 13,034 kb in Sorangium cellulosum . In general, bacterial genomes are tightly packed with coding genes and the gene length is similar across genomes , . Therefore, differences in the bacterial genome sizes are primarily the result of loss of existing genes and acquiring new genes through the processes of gene duplication and horizontal gene transfer.
There are three well-known examples of bacteria with reduced genomes: (1) pathogens (e.g., Mycoplasma genitalium  and Rickettsia ), (2) endosymbionts (e.g., Buchnera , Wigglesworthia  and Blochmannia ), and (3) marine microbes that play important ecological roles in oligotrophic environments (e.g., Pelagibacter ubique  and Prochlorococcus marinus ). Understanding genome reduction is important for understanding the evolution of human pathogens and agricultural pests. It also helps us to gain insights into global nutrient cycling and climate regulation.
Reduced genomes in obligate pathogens are associated with a change from a free-living to a host-dependent lifestyle . This lifestyle change rendered many genes unnecessary for the organisms' survival in the protected environments , . Moreover, due to the small effective population sizes and reduced recombination, the effect of genetic drift is larger. Genetic drift facilitates fixation of small effect deleterious mutations, formation of pseudogene, and subsequent gene deletions , . In the cases of endosymbiotic bacteria, the host environments restrict opportunities of gene gains through horizontal gene transfer –. Although pathogens can acquire genes via lateral gene transfers, it has been demonstrated that obligate parasite genomes are subject to far more extensive DNA loss due to inactivation of unnecessary genes and deletional bias , . It is suggested that genome degradation in obligate host-associated bacteria is so advanced that it has placed them on the path to extinction , .
The marine cyanobacteria in the Prochlorococcus genus are the most abundant known oxygenic phototrophs on earth, and contribute significantly to the primary productivity in the ocean . Prochlorococcus genomes are also among the smallest of all oxygen-evolving autotrophs. Most of the sequenced Prochlorococcus genomes, ranging in size from 1.6 to 2.7 Mega-base pairs (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/genome), are smaller than those of another major marine picocyanobacterial genus Synechococcus, which is the closest phylogenetic group to Prochlorococcus . These two groups differ in light-harvesting apparatus and nutrient utilization, and thus have quite different ecology performance . Although Prochlorococcus and Synechococcus commonly coexist, Prochlorococcus has wider vertical distribution in oceanic waters relative to Synechococcus and dominates in the oligotrophic regions of the ocean , . In contrast, Synechococcus is much more abundant in nutrient rich environments such as upwelling areas and coastal watersheds . Prochlorococcus isolates can be divided into two major ecotypes exhibiting distinct light and/or temperature optima: the high light-adapted (HL) and low light-adapted (LL) clades , . Aligned with the ecological distinction, genome sizes vary between the Prochlorococcus ecotypes that the HL genomes are smaller than most of the LL genomes . Previous studies have revealed evidence for genome reduction in Prochlorococcus , –. In contrast, no extensive genome streamlining has occurred during the evolution of marine Synechococcus .
Reduced Prochlorococcus genomes share many genomic characteristics with the aforementioned endosymbiotic bacteria such as an increase in AT content, loss of DNA repair genes and accelerated evolution , , . However, in sharp contrast to small population obligate host-associated bacteria, Prochlorococcus is possibly the most plentiful free-living bacterial genus on Earth, and the sizes of Prochlorococcus populations are vast , , , . Moreover, purifying selection is estimated to be much stronger in the present-day Prochlorococcus populations than in the marine Synechococcus . There is also evidence suggesting that Prochlorococcus has experienced a fair level of genetic exchange via interactions with different types of phages –. Therefore, the evolutionary forces that shaped the small genomes of Prochlorococcus are probably different from the forces that caused the genome reduction of endosymbionts and pathogens . It is also intriguing why a free-living, ecologically successful organism would become smaller.
Several hypotheses have been proposed to explain genome reduction in free-living bacteria. According to the genome-streamlining hypothesis , small size, therefore larger surface-to-volume ratio, gives the organisms a selective advantage in nutrient poor water. It's also possible that with deletions of non-essential genes, Prochlorococcus have adopted a more economical lifestyle to better cope with the nutrient limited environment . The “Black Queen Hypothesis” suggests that vital but costly genes could be deleted under strong purifying selection if co-occurring organisms can provide the lost functions . Alternatively, an accelerated protein evolution rate was observed in the small genomes of Prochlorococcus, and this led to the suggestion that an elevated genome-wide mutation rate is associated with genome reduction . Another study  demonstrated through mathematical modeling and computer simulation that a modest increase in mutation rate could lead to significant genome reduction even in an organism having a very large population size, thus creating the possibility that enhanced mutation rate, as a non-selective force, could be the driving force of genome reduction in free-living bacteria. However, no study has systemically examined the effects of natural selection and molecular evolution rate on the genome content of Prochlorococcus in the evolutionary history.
In this study, we analyzed the complete genome sequences of 12 Prochlorococcus isolates and 6 marine Synechococcus isolates to address the following questions: When and how did genome reduction occur in the evolutionary history of Prochlorococcus? Which genes were deleted from the Prochlorococcus genomes, and what are their functional effects? What role has natural selection played in Prochlorococcus genome evolution, particularly in the genome reduction? What is the driving force behind the reduced genomes of Prochlorococcus?
Reconstruct Phylogeny of Prochlorococcus and Synechococcus using concatenated protein alignments
Based on a published phylogeny of marine cyanobacteria , 12 Prochlorococcus isolates (P.MED4, P.MIT9515, P.AS901, P.MIT9301, P.MIT9215, P.MIT9312, P.NATL1A, P.NATL2A, P.SS120, P.MIT9215, P.MIT9313, P.MIT9303) formed a monophyletic group and 5 marine Synechococcus isolates (S.CC9605, S.CC9902, S.WH8102, S.CC9311, S.WH7803) are in the sister group to Prochlorococcus. We used the above 17 genomes as the primary study material and refer to them as in-group genomes. Synechococcus RCC307 was used as an out-group.
An accurate phylogeny is critical for ancestral gene content reconstruction. Therefore, the first thing we did was to reconstruct the phylogeny of the 17 in-group genomes based on a concatenated alignment containing 100 of the most conserved orthologs. In brief, we first identified 1102 consistent orthologs from the 17 in-group genomes (see Materials and Methods). We then calculated the synonymous and non-synonymous substitution rates for every ortholog pair. Orthologs that have low non-synonymous substitution rate to synonymous substitution rate ratios, i.e., dN/dS ratio, are considered evolutionary conserved genes. Therefore, we selected 100 genes that have the smallest mean dN/dS ratios and moderate synonymous substitution rates (in the range of the 1st and the 3rd quartiles). Their protein sequences were aligned individually, and the alignments were concatenated. Finally a maximum likelihood tree was built using the combined information of the 100 orthologous genes. Our tree (Fig. 1) has the same topology as the previously reported trees , , . In addition, it has higher bootstrap values for the internal nodes. Therefore, we are very confident that we have a reliable and robust phylogenetic framework for the analyses described below.
The phylogenetic relationship of 12 Prochlorococcus and 5 marine Synechococcus is reconstructed from concatenation of 100 conserved protein alignments using a maximum likelihood analysis with Tree-PUZZLE implemented in PHYLIP 3.6a. The branch length is defined as the expected number of amino acid substitutions per site. Support for the internal branches of the quartet puzzling tree topology is shown as a percentage. Genome size and gene count are reported beside each genome.
Ancestral gene content reconstruction suggests early genome reduction in Prochlorococcus evolution
The sizes of Prochlorococcus genomes are generally smaller than those of the marine Synechococcus except for MIT9303 and MIT9313 (Fig. 1). Regression analysis result indicates a strong correlation (R2 = 0.995) between the genome size and the gene number of Prochlorococcus and Synechococcus. Also, the gene length does not significantly differ between the Synechococcus group and the Prochlorococcus group (Mann-Whitney U test, P-value = 0.959). This confirms that reduced gene number is the major cause of genome size reduction in Prochlorococcus. Among Prochlorococcus, there exist several distinct genome size groups in some accordance with the phylogeny (Fig. 1). Members in the low-light-adapted (LL) P. MIT9303 clade (MIT9303 and MIT9313) have the largest genome sizes among all the Prochlorococcus and they were the first to diverge from the other Prochlorococcus isolates. In contrast, members in a more recent LL clade P. NATL clade (NATL1A and NATL2A) have smaller genome sizes. Moreover, all the members of the youngest Prochlorococcus clade, i.e., the high-light-adapted (HL) clade (MED4, MIT9515, AS9601, MIT9301, MIT9215 and MIT9312), have the smallest genome sizes of Prochlorococcus. Interestingly, two LL Prochlorococcus isolates SS120 and MIT9211, which are relatively deep in the tree, have small genome sizes that are comparable to the HL clade (Fig. 1).
The next question we address is when and how did genome reduction happen? More specifically, is it a progressive and ongoing process, or was it a historical event? To address this question, we reconstructed the ancestral gene content at every node of the tree using two methods: maximum parsimony and maximum likelihood (See Methods and Materials). The results of these two approaches have led to the same conclusion of Prochlorococcus genome size evolution, and hence we will only report the results of the parsimony reconstruction.
The reconstructed last common ancestor of the 17 in-group genomes contains a total of 2028 genes. We first calculated the net gene losses and gains in the individual genomes from the last common ancestor (Table 1). The t-statistic of a Student's t test shows that Prochlorococcus lost significantly more genes than the Synechococcus (P<10−6) on average. Even the two largest Prochlorococcus genomes (MIT9303 and MIT9313) have significantly greater gene loss than Synechococcus (P<0.001). In contrast, while relatively large Prochlorococcus genomes (e.g., the moderate-size LL P. NATL clade and the large-size P. MIT9303 clade) have gained considerably more genes than the small genomes in the HL clade, the difference in gene gains between the small genomes in the LL P. SS120 clade and the HL clade is insignificant (Table 1).
A more detailed investigation of gene loss and gene gain at every branch of the tree found that in spite of the fact that gene loss occurred at every stage of Prochlorococcus evolution, a significant amount of genes were deleted shortly after the split of Prochlorococcus and Synechococcus, and only a small number of genes were acquired during the same period (Fig. 2). Therefore, a reduced genome was established before the divergence of the HL clade and the LL clade. After the divergence from the other Prochlorococcus, both of the intermediate-size P. NATL clade and the large-size P. MIT9303 clade obtained a considerable number of genes, contributing significantly to their present-day relatively large genome sizes. Our results suggest that the observed distinct genome size groups within Prochlorococcus were shaped by a combination of an early and large genome reduction and clade-specific gene gains at late stages, instead of by progressive gene deletions.
Ancestral genome contents were reconstructed based on the phylogenetic tree in Figure 1 by maximum parsimony. Gene loss and gain events are summarized on the branches leading to the major clades of Prochlorococcus. The number in black is gene gain and the number in red is gene loss.
Intensified purifying selection associated with genome size reduction of Prochlorococcus
To determine the effects of natural selection on the genome evolution of Prochlorococcus, we carried out a maximum likelihood analysis to estimate the ratio of non-synonymous substitution rate to synonymous substitution rate, i.e., the dN/dS ratio, across the phylogenetic tree. The dN/dS ratio is used as an indicator of selective pressure acting on protein-coding genes. In this study, the substitutions rates were calculated from a concatenated alignment of 1102 consistent orthologs (see Materials and Methods). In addition to the 12 Prochlorococcus, 2 marine Synechococcus WH8102 and WH7803 each representing a Synechococcus clade, and an out-group marine Synechococcus RCC307 were used in the analysis.
Using the codeml program in the Phylogenetic Analysis by the Maximum Likelihood (PAML) package , we first applied a one-ratio model for the entire tree. This resulted in a log likelihood value of l1 = −9300717. We then fit a free-ratio model, which assumes a different ratio (ω = dN/dS) for each branch in the tree. This produced a log likelihood value of lf = −9239311. The likelihood ratio test showed that the free-ratio model fits the data significantly better than the one-ratio model (P<0.001 for a χ2 distribution with df = 23). This indicates that the dN/dS ratios are indeed significantly different at different evolutionary stages and among lineages.
Due to parameter rich nature of the free-ratio model, we obtained slightly different estimates of branch-specific dN/dS ratios between the replicate runs. Even so, they always show the same trend in ratio changes between the branches. Therefore, we designed a set of reduced branch-models and used a hypothesis testing strategy to verify the observed ratio changes across the tree. All the reduced models are described in Table 2 (the branch numbers refer to the labeled branches from the tree in Figure 3). The first two-ratio model (Model 2-1) assigns one ratio parameter to all the Synechococcus and one to all the Prochlorococcus. This model was compared with a one-ratio model to test whether Prochlorococcus has a significantly different ratio from Synechococcus. The second two-ratio model (Model 2-2) assumes that branch #1 (the ancestral branch of all the Prochlorococcus) has the same dN/dS ratio as Synechococcus, and it was compared with Model 2-1. If Model 2-1 has a higher likelihood value, then Prochlorococcus must have been under different selection pressure after its immediate split from Synechococcus. The first three-ratio model (Model 3-1) assigns a new ratio parameter for branch #2 (the ancestral branch of most Prochlorococcus after the split with the LL P. MIT9303 clade). Therefore, if it fits the data significantly better than the two-ratio models, branch #2 is most likely to have a distinct ratio from the other Prochlorococcus branches. The remaining two three-ratios models (Model 3-2, 3-3 and 3-4) are used to test if the descending branches have the same dN/dS ratio as branch #2 by comparing their likelihood values with Model 3-1. Both Model 4-1-1 & 4-1-2 are based on Model 3-1 but contain an extra parameter for either branch #4 that leads to the HL clade or for the entire HL clade and branch #4. They are designed to determine if branch #4 has a different ratio than other branches including its descending branches within the HL clade. Similarly, Model 4-2 contains an extra parameter for the P.MIT9303 clade based on Model 3-1. It is used to determine whether dN/dS ratios changed after the P.MIT9303 clade diversified from its Prochlorococcus ancestor.
The displayed phylogeny is an unrooted tree of 12 Prochlorococcus and 2 sister Synechococcus and an outgroup Synechococcus RCC307. The branches are drawn in proportion to their length. They are defined as the expected numbers of nucleotide substitutions per site, which is estimated from the concatenation of 100 conserved amino acid sequences by using the no-clock model. The tree topology, but not the branch lengths, is used to calculate the maximum likelihood dN/dS ratios. The ancestral branches are labeled below the branches (o: outgroup, 1–9). The maximum likelihood estimates of dN/dS ratios under a five-ratio-branch-model are reported on the corresponding branches. This model divides the tree into 5 ratio groups: ω0 = all Synechococcus branches; ω1 = branch #2; ω2 = branch #6 and P.MIT9303 clade; ω3 = branch #4; ω4 = Prochlorococcus background ratio (i.e., branch #1, branch #3, branch #7 and P.SS120 clade, branch #8 and P.NATL clade, branch #5, branch #9 and the entire Prochlorococcus HL clade). Branches for which no value is shown have the same ratios as their immediate ancestral branches.
We used both the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) approach and the likelihood ratio test for model selection (Table 3). The results confirm our previous observations from the free-ratio model and are demonstrated in a final five-ratio-branch-model (Model 5 in Table 2 and Fig. 3). In summary, our results show: (1) Prochlorococcus branches always have lower genome-wide dN/dS ratios than marine Synechococcus, suggesting purifying selection has imposed stronger constraints on amino acid sequence evolution in Prochlorococcus than in marine Synechococcus, (2) there are consecutive decreases in the dN/dS ratio on the early ancestral branches of Prochlorococcus (branch #1 and branch #2). It's the same period when Prochlorococcus experienced major genome shrinkage, implying an association between intensified efficacy of purifying selection and massive gene deletions, (3) after the major genome reduction period, dN/dS ratios increased as the Prochlorococcus diversified and have remained relatively constant to this day, except for a slight decrease at branch #4 that leads to the HL clade.
Prochlorococcus lost genes have higher dN/dS ratios than retained genes
In order to determine the role of selection in the process of gene deletions, we measured two selection-related parameters (dN/dS ratio and the Codon Adaptation Index) for the ancestor-derived genes that are retained in the Synechococcus genomes but are lost in the Prochlorococcus on every internal branch of the Prochlorococcus phylogeny. Among the 2028 genes in the last common ancestor genome, 1641 have orthologs in all of the 5 in-group Synechococcus genomes. Therefore, we refer to them as the Ancestor-derived Synechococcus Orthologs (ASO)(Fig. 4). We then divided the 1641 ASO genes into two groups (the Lost group and the Retained group) based on the absence and presence of the genes in the reconstructed ancestor genome at every ancestor node of the tree. The numbers of the Lost and the Retained genes are summarized in Table 4. The step-wise gene losses in the Prochlorococcus evolution are demonstrated in Figure 5.
A subset of 1641 ancestor-derived genes was identified from the 2028 genes in the reconstructed last common ancestor genome due to their presence in the 5 marine Synechococcus genomes. This subset is further divided into two groups: (1) the Lost group, which contains genes that are lost in the Prochlorococcus genomes; and (2) the Retained group, which contains genes that are kept in the Prochlorococcus genomes.
Step-wise Prochlorococcus gene loss (red numbers) in the context of the subset of Synechococcus ancestor-derived genes is reported on the ancestor branches. The branch labels (black values) are the same as in Figure 3.
We first compared the dN/dS ratios of the Lost genes and the Retained genes. Genes with low dN/dS ratios (<1) are considered to be evolving under strong functional constraints and subject to strong purifying selection. The Lost group consistently shows a higher average dN/dS ratio than the Retained group (Table 4). In particular, the differences are highly significant on branch #1 and branch #2 during the genome reduction period (Student's t-test, P-value<10−5). More remarkably, genes that were lost during the early genome reduction period have significantly higher dN/dS ratios than those that were deleted in the later stages (Table 4. One-sided Student's t-test: Total gene loss on branch #1 and branch #2 vs. the Lost on branch #4, P-value = 0.021; Total loss on branch #1 and branch #2 vs. the Lost on branch #7, P-value = 0.002; Total loss on branch #1 and branch #2 vs. the Lost on branch #8, P<0.001; the Lost on branch #1 vs. the Lost on branch #6, P-value = 0.003). This result indicates that genes with the smallest fitness values were discarded first. Figure 6 shows the distinct distributions of the lost genes during the main period of genome reduction (the Lost genes on branch #1 and branch #2 combined) and of the genes that are retained in all the extant Prochlorococcus genomes. It again demonstrates that in general, genes of higher dN/dS ratios (of those <1), which are probably under relaxed selection pressure, were deleted in Prochlorococcus during the genome reduction period.
The dN/dS ratios of a subset of the ancestral genes that are retained in the 12 extant Prochlorococcus and the 5 in-group marine Synechococcus genomes are shown in blue. The dN/dS ratios of a subset of the ancestral genes that are retained in the 5 in-group marine Synechococcus genomes, but were deleted in the Prochlorococcus during the early genome reduction period on branch #1 and branch #2 (branch numbers refer to the labeled branches in Fig. 3) are shown in red.
The Codon Adaptation Index (CAI) is useful for assessing how well genes are adapted to the local environment . Due to the assumption that differences in the degree of codon usage bias largely reflect the differences in selective pressure on synonymous codons, the Codon Adaptation Index (CAI) is often positively correlated with the strength of selection. CAI values for the 1641 ancestor-derived genes were calculated for each of the 5 in-group marine Synechococcus genomes in the context of its genome-specific codon usage. The Lost group has significantly lower average CAI values compared to the Retained group except for branch #8 (Table 5). This supports our previous finding that genes under less stringent selection in the extant Synechococcus genomes were discarded early in Prochlorococcus evolution.
Deleted gene functions do not suggest ecological specialization
We employed the Clusters of Orthologous Groups of proteins (COGs) annotation system  to predict gene functions and to assess the functional effect of gene loss in Prochlorococcus. 1269 out of 1641 ancestor-derived genes (77.33%) were assigned to at least one COG category. The distribution of annotated genes in this ancestor-derived gene set is very similar to those of the individual Synechococcus genomes (Fig. 7). Moreover, the distributions of small Prochlorococcus genomes also resemble that of the ancestor gene set (Fig. 7), suggesting reduction in gene content didn't alter the general functional composition of Prochlorococcus.
Functions were assigned to protein sequences that have significant hits to the Clusters of Orthologous Groups of proteins (COGs) annotation system in the Entrez Conserved Domain Database (CDD). A whole pie depicts the COG annotated gene pool of a genome. Each color represents a functional category of the COGs. The area under each color corresponds to the gene density in that COG category.
Among the 1269 COG annotated ancestor-derived genes, 259 were deleted during the early reduction period (on branch #1 and branch #2). These genes are distributed in all of the functional categories (Fig. 8A). Though some functional groups appear to have severer gene loss than the others, the deleted genes consistently have higher dN/dS ratio means and lower CAI means compared to the retained genes across all the function categories (Fig. 8B).
A. The maroon area indicates the percentage of the genes that were deleted during the early genome reduction period (branch #1 and branch #2 in Fig. 3) in the ancestor-derived Synechococcus orthologs set (ASO). The purple area shows the percentage of the retained genes. COG abbreviations: C: Energy production and conversion; E: Amino acid transport and metabolism; F: Nucleotide transport and metabolism; G: Carbohydrate transport and metabolism; H: Coenzyme metabolism; I: Lipid metabolism; J: Translation, ribosomal structure and biogenesis; K: Transcription; L: DNA replication, recombination and repair; M: Cell envelope biogenesis, outer membrane; O: Posttranslational modification, protein turnover, chaperones; P: Inorganic ion transport and metabolism; R: general function prediction only; S: Function unknown; T: Signal transduction mechanisms; U: Intracellular trafficking and secretion; V: Defense mechanism; NA: no defined COG annotation. B. Bar plot of the average dN/dS ratios of the Prochlorococcus lost genes and the retained genes across functional groups. A subset of the ASO genes whose orthologs were lost in the Prochlorococcus during the early genome reduction period are shown in maroon. A subset of the ASO genes whose orthologs were kept in the Prochlorococcus genomes immediately after the early genome reduction, are shown in purple.
We demonstrated that (1) the small Prochlorococcus genomes were largely shaped by massive gene loss shortly after the split of Prochlorococcus and marine Synechococcus, (2) strong purifying selection occurred in Prochlorococcus during the genome reduction period, and (3) most Prochlorococcus lost genes have small fitness effects and are from nearly all functional categories.
Our results separate out the reduction process from the current state, thus decoupling genome reduction from current ecological niches. The small size and reductive characteristics of present Prochlorococcus genomes have been shaped by ancestral conditions before the radiation of most Prochlorococcus lineages, including the HL and LL groups. The forces driving Prochlorococcus genome reduction may not still be present or as strong. We suggest dividing Prochlorococcus evolutionary history into 3 sub stages: genome reduction, genome diversification (radiation of Prochlorococcus) and ecological niche specialization.
Functional analysis of lost genes at both early and recent evolutionary stages found no clear relationship between gene loss and ecological niche specialization. In contrast, extensive comparative analysis of extant Prochlorococcus genomes have identified a number of genes that are responsible for important ecological and physiological properties that differentiate Prochlorococcus ecotypes from each other . Many of them are found to be concentrated in certain genomic regions called “genomic islands” . These genomic regions are highly variable and are hot spots for gene gains , . These observations suggest that horizontal gene transfer likely played a more important role than gene loss in ecological niche specialization and/or population diversification in Prochlorococcus. For instance, a group of phosphorus-uptake and metabolism genes have recently been found only in Atlantic Prochlorococcus populations where phosphorus concentrations are extremely low . The limitation of phosphorus has imposed an ecosystem-specific selective pressure that has driven divergence between Prochlorococcus populations . Again, the evolutionary forces responsible for recent Prochlorococcus diversification are probably not the same as what generated the reduced genomes at an earlier time.
Our results support the streamlining hypothesis , where selection for a more economical lifestyle has been the major driving force for genome reduction in Prochlorococcus. We are the first to estimate selection strength in a phylogenetic context and to demonstrate that the Prochlorococcus genome was subject to extremely strong purifying selection upon genome reduction. The genome-wide intensified selection was unlikely induced by changes of specific local environmental factors because altered environmental parameters usually only effect selection coefficients on a small subset of genes with particular functions. The Prochlorococcus genes that are lost during the early genome reduction period are from a variety of cellular processes spread across the genome and have higher dN/dS ratios (<1) regardless of function in Synechococcus. In spite of the large differences in gene content between Prochlorococcus and Synechococcus genomes, very few genes have been proposed to be responsible for ecological differences . Therefore, the most plausible explanation is that Prochlorococcus had a very large effective population size during this time period and it imposed a strong purifying selection on the entire genome and subsequently led to the deletion of genes with higher dN/dS ratios.
Small effect genes are not necessarily discarded in large populations unless deletion of these genes confers selective advantage over maintaining them. This is true when the metabolic cost of maintaining small effect genes outweighs their potential benefits for the cell (e.g. allowing the cell to cope better with unfavorable conditions or environmental fluctuations). This scenario is most likely to occur in relative stable environments where nutrients are scarce (e.g., oligotrophic oceans) and competition for nutrients is severe. Under these conditions, advantages of a small genome—such as economics in energy and material for cell growth, maintenance and division . increased surface area-to-volume ratios that improves nutrient uptake rate  and a reduction in self-shading  could be substantial enough that an economical lifestyle through genome reduction becomes a good strategy for ecological success.
It should be noted that not all deleted genes in the Prochlorococcus genome reduction are non-essential at individual levels, such as oxidative-stress genes, which are important for oxygen-producing marine cyanobacteria . It's still unclear why such genes were also discarded from Prochlorococcus. One of the possible explanations is based on the Black Queen Hypothesis . If coexisting organisms—e.g., marine Synechococcus –were capable of producing sufficient amounts of stress response enzymes to reduce reactive oxygen species to a level that was safe to all organisms in the community, then the related genes could become conditionally dispensable to Prochlorococcus.
Our results did not rule out the possibility that an elevated global mutation rate might also have accompanied the Prochlorococcus genome size reduction. We found several non-essential DNA repair genes (Table 6) such as 6-O-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase and DNA helicase RecQ that were deleted during the early genome reduction period and their loss could possibility cause a baseline mutation rate change. But the extremely low dN/dS ratio reveals that there was no accumulation of non-synonymous substitutions in comparison with synonymous substitutions. This is different than the case of the reduced endosymbiont genomes where an elevated mutation rate has been demonstrated to be responsible for the accumulation of deleterious mutations and subsequently led to exacerbated gene loss . The lack of non-synonymous substitutions also means the mutation-driven model proposed by Marais et. al. , which is conditioned on fixation of small effect deleterious mutations does not apply to Prochlorococcus genome reduction. An accelerated protein evolution rate in Prochlorococcus in comparison with Synechococcus was previously reported from analyses of a small number of genomes , . We also calculated the substitution rates at non-synonymous sites (dN) between individual in-group genomes to a common out-group genome Synechococcus RCC307. We found that the non-synonymous substitution rate not only increased from Synechococcus to Prochlorococcus but also significantly increased from low-light adapted to high-light adapted isolates within the Prochlorococcus group (Fig. 9). This indicates that the elevated protein evolution might not directly relate to genome reduction but rather associate with ecological niche specialization and diversification of Prochlorococcus.
All genomes were compared to an outgroup Synechococcus RCC307 to ensure the same divergence time. Red boxes: HL Prochlorococcus. Pink boxes: LL Prochlrococcus. Blue boxes: Synechococcus. The ends of the whiskers represent the lowest datum still within a 1.5 interquartile range (IQR) of the lower quartile, and the highest datum still within a 1.5 IQR of the upper quartile. A notch is drawn in each side of the boxes and non-overlapping notches of two plots indicate significantly different medians.
Prochlorococcus, as an abundant marine photosynthetic group, is a focal point of climate change research. Do Prochlorococcus genomes have the genetic/evolutionary potential to cope with varying environment parameters? The answer is probably just as much as other microbes. Because of the large population sizes and ability to exchange genetic material, these genomes are unlikely to be evolutionary dead-ends. The current abundance and wide vertical distribution of diverse Prochlorococcus ecotypes in oligotrophic oceans has already demonstrated their evolutionary capabilities even with a small genome size. The growing collection of complete genome sequences and metagenomic data will provide additional opportunities to understand the population dynamics of Prochlorococcus and provide further insights into the evolutionary and ecological potential of this group of organisms.
Materials and Methods
Genome sequence data, gene prediction and annotation
The complete bacterial genome data set of our study contains 17 in-group cyanobacterial genomes (12 Prochlorococcus: P.MED4, P.MIT9515, P.AS901, P.MIT9301, P.MIT9215, P.MIT9312, P.NATL1A, P.NATL2A, P.SS120, P.MIT9215, P.MIT9313, P.MIT9303 and 5 marine Synechococcus: S.CC9605, S.CC9902, S.WH8102, S.CC9311, S.WH7803) and 31 other published cyanobacterial genomes. The genome sequences were downloaded from the Genome Assembly/Annotation Projects section on NCBI ftp://ftp.ncbi.nih.gov/genomes/Bacteria. To ensure gene annotations are consistent and comparable between the isolates we re-annotated the 17 in-group genomes and an outgroup Synechococcus genome RCC307 using the same gene prediction program GeneMarkS . After translating DNA sequences to protein sequences, we determined gene function by searching predicted protein sequences against the Entrez Conserved Domain Database (CDD) of the Pfam  and Clusters of Orthologous Groups of proteins (COGs)  domain models using the Reverse Position-Specific BLAST algorithm (RPSBLAST) implemented in the NCBI BLAST search tool .
Ancestral Gene Content Reconstruction and Genome Flux Analyses
(1) Generate an integrated multi-genome gene relationship table and identify common orthologous genes
We first used the protein-protein BLAST (blastp) algorithm to find highly similar protein sequences among the in-group genomes. Every predicted protein sequence of an in-group genome was blasted against a database of 48 cyanobacterial genomes. The inclusion of a large set of other published cyanobacterial genomes during blastp allows a low bit score cutoff threshold (40) to be used to generate a “top hit list” for each query. This still gives us high confidence in finding the real orthologs from the in-group genomes because we require the scores of the members of the in-group to be superior to the scores of other cyanobacterial genomes. A query gene can have at most one ortholog from each of the other in-group genomes. We collected such orthologous gene sets for each of the 17 in-group genomes, and then compiled them into a comprehensive multi-genome gene relationship table. This integrated gene table consists of two types of orthologous gene sets. The first type includes 1102 consistent orthologous gene sets whose homologous relationships have been identified congruently in all of the genome-specific tables. There are cases where an inconsistent orthologous gene set shares one or more genes with a consistent ortholog set. In these cases, the non-overlapping genes in the set are possible paralogs resulting from gene duplications in a subset of the genomes. We validate a paralog set by two criteria: (1) the same gene set is reported at least twice, and (2) every paralog in the set is confirmed by the blastp result of individual genome. Once confirmed, the paralogs are added to the related consistent ortholog set. The second part of the integrated gene table consists of consensus ortholog sets that are resolved from inconsistent but related gene sets. The most represented genes are chosen as the consensus orthologs from the possible paralogs based on the majority rule. The other paralogs are validated by the blastp results. 84 consensus ortholog sets were resolved by this method. In total we have identified 1186 orthologous gene sets of the 17 in-group genomes.
(2) Reconstruct the phylogeny of Prochlorococcus and Synechococcus using concatenated alignments of conserved orthologs
The pairwise dN/dS ratios were calculated for the orthologous gene sets using the yn00 program implemented in the Phylogenetic Analysis by Maximum Likelihood (PAML) software  (see Maximum likelihood analysis of sequence evolution rate below). Based on the dN/dS results, we selected 100 orthologous gene sets that (1) have the smallest means of pairwise dN/dS ratios, and (2) have average synonymous substitution rates in the range between the 1st quartile (25%) and the 3rd quartile (75%). Protein sequences of the selected orthologs were aligned individually in ClustalW2 . The 100 alignments were then concatenated. The Gblocks  program was used to mask gapped and other noisy portions of the concatenated alignments, with a minimum block length of 10 amino acids and gaps allowed in any alignment position for no more than half of the sequences. Based on the concatenated alignment, we reconstructed a maximum likelihood tree using the Tree-PUZZLE program primed with a Neighbor-joining tree in the PHYLIP 3.6a . The Jones-Taylor-Thornton (JTT)  amino acid substitution model was employed and all model related parameters were estimated from the data.
(3) Reconstruct the history of gene content evolution on the phylogenetic tree
We converted the integrated multi-genome gene relationship table, which was generated in the first step, into a R(row)×17(column) character matrix of the gene state. In this matrix, each row is a homologous gene set and each column corresponds to an in-group genome. The value of every cell in the matrix indicates a genes current state and its copy number in one of the 17 in-group genomes. 0 means absent and any integer greater than 0 is the copy number. This character matrix was then mapped onto the phylogenetic tree, which we built in step 2. We applied two methods that are implemented in the Mesquite software  to reconstruct the ancestral gene states throughout the tree: (1) maximum parsimony, and (2) maximum likelihood. A single rate of changes between the states was assumed for both reconstruction methods. In the cases where a gene's state at the root cannot be unambiguously determined by the algorithms, we keep it in the last common ancestor only if this gene has at least one significant blastp hit from the out-group cyanobacteria. Genes with ambiguous predictions at the internal nodes are excluded from the downstream analyses. At each internal node a collection of genes with state N (N> = 1) were added to the ancestral genome at that evolutionary stage. Subsequently, a gene loss or gene gain event on an ancestral branch was determined by the change in quantity and direction of that gene's state between the two consecutive nodes.
Maximum likelihood analysis of sequence evolution rates and dN/dS ratio
Protein sequences of the orthologs were aligned in the software ClustalW2 . The corresponding nucleotide sequences were then mapped onto the protein alignment using custom Perl scripts to generate sets of aligned nucleotide sequences. Nucleotide substitution rates and dN/dS ratios were calculated using the maximum likelihood method as implemented in the Phylogenetic Analysis by Maximum Likelihood (PAML) software . Pairwise dN/dS ratios were calculated from the synonymous and non-synonymous substitution rates, which were estimated by the yn00 program based on the HKY85 substitution model . The codeml program was employed to compute branch-specific dN/dS ratios in a pre-determined phylogeny under different branch models. We used the topology of the concatenated gene tree. All model-related parameters (e.g., base frequencies and transition/transversion rate ratio) were estimated from the data. The likelihood value under each model was also reported by PAML. We then utilized the likelihood ratio test for model selection and hypothesis testing.
Calculation of Codon Adaptation Index
We collected all of the ribosomal protein genes from each of the genomes and used them as reference sets to create genome-specific codon usage tables by the “cusp” program of the EMBOSS package . The Codon Adaptation Index values were calculated by the “CAI” program of the EMBOSS package based on the codon usage tables.
We would like to thank Laura Katz, Adam Porter, Ben Normark and Jinghua Hu for constructive advice. We also thank Janine Borgaro for reading the manuscript and making helpful suggestions.
Conceived and designed the experiments: ZS JLB. Performed the experiments: ZS. Analyzed the data: ZS. Wrote the paper: ZS JLB.
- 1. Nakabachi A, Yamashita A, Toh H, Ishikawa H, Dunbar HE, et al. (2006) The 160-Kilobase Genome of the Bacterial Endosymbiont Carsonella. Science (80-) 314: 267. doi: 10.1126/science.1134196
- 2. Schneiker S, Perlova O, Kaiser O, Gerth K, Alici A, et al. (2007) Complete genome sequence of the myxobacterium Sorangium cellulosum. Nat Biotechnol 25: 1281–1289 Available: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17965706. Accessed 13 September 2010.
- 3. Lynch M (2006) Streamlining and simplification of microbial genome architecture. Annu Rev Microbiol 60: 327–349. doi: 10.1146/annurev.micro.60.080805.142300
- 4. Xu L, Chen H, Hu X, Zhang R, Zhang Z, et al. (2006) Average Gene Length Is Highly Conserved in Prokaryotes and Eukaryotes and Diverges Only Between the Two Kingdoms. Mol Biol Evol 23: 1107–1108. doi: 10.1093/molbev/msk019
- 5. Fraser CM, Gocayne JD, White O, Adams MD, Clayton RA, et al. (1995) The minimal gene complement of Mycoplasma genitalium. Science 270: 397–403. doi: 10.1126/science.270.5235.397
- 6. Andersson JO, Andersson SG (1999) Genome degradation is an ongoing process in Rickettsia. Mol Biol Evol 16: 1178–1191. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.molbev.a026208
- 7. Shigenobu S, Watanabe H, Hattori M, Sakaki Y, Ishikawa H (2000) Genome sequence of the endocellular bacterial symbiont of aphids Buchnera sp. APS. Nature 407: 81–86.
- 8. Akman L, Yamashita A, Watanabe H, Oshima K, Shiba T, et al. (2002) Genome sequence of the endocellular obligate symbiont of tsetse flies, Wigglesworthia glossinidia. Nat Genet 32: 402–407. doi: 10.1038/ng986
- 9. Gil R, Silva FJ, Zientz E, Delmotte F, Gonzalez-Candelas F, et al. (2003) The genome sequence of Blochmannia floridanus: Comparative analysis of reduced genomes. Proc Natl Acad Sci 100: 9388–9393. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1533499100
- 10. Giovannoni SJ, Tripp HJ, Givan S, Podar M, Vergin KL, et al. (2005) Genome streamlining in a cosmopolitan oceanic bacterium. Science 309: 1242–1245 Available: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16109880.
- 11. Dufresne A, Salanoubat M, Partensky F, Artiguenave F, Axmann IM, et al. (2003) Genome sequence of the cyanobacterium Prochlorococcus marinus SS120, a nearly minimal oxyphototrophic genome. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 100: 10020–10025. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1733211100
- 12. Moran NA (2002) Microbial minimalism: genome reduction in bacterial pathogens. Cell 108: 583–586. doi: 10.1016/s0092-8674(02)00665-7
- 13. Andersson JO, Andersson SGE (2001) Pseudogenes, Junk DNA, and the Dynamics of Rickettsia Genomes. Mol Biol Evol 18: 829–839. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.molbev.a003864
- 14. Gil R, Silva FJ, Pereto J, Moya A (2004) Determination of the core of a minimal bacterial gene set. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 68: 518–537. doi: 10.1128/mmbr.68.3.518-537.2004
- 15. Moran NA, Mira A (2001) The process of genome shrinkage in the obligate symbiont Buchnera aphidicola. Genome Biol 2: RESEARCH0054. doi: 10.1186/gb-2001-2-12-research0054
- 16. Degnan PH, Lazarus AB, Wernegreen JJ (2005) Genome sequence of Blochmannia pennsylvanicus indicates parallel evolutionary trends among bacterial mutualists of insects. Genome Res 15: 1023–1033. doi: 10.1101/gr.3771305
- 17. Tamas I, Klasson L, Canback B, Naslund AK, Eriksson AS, et al. (2002) 50 million years of genomic stasis in endosymbiotic bacteria. Science (80-) 296: 2376–2379. doi: 10.1126/science.1071278
- 18. Ham RCvan, Kamerbeek J, Palacios C, Rausell C, Abascal F, et al. (2003) Reductive genome evolution in Buchnera aphidicola. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 100: 581–586. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0235981100
- 19. Zinser ER, Schneider D, Blot M, Kolter R (2003) Bacterial evolution through the selective loss of beneficial Genes. Trade-offs in expression involving two loci. Genetics 164: 1271–1277.
- 20. Perez-Brocal V, Gil R, Ramos S, Lamelas A, Postigo M, et al. (2006) A Small Microbial Genome: The End of a Long Symbiotic Relationship? Science (80-) 314: 312–313. doi: 10.1126/science.1130441
- 21. Partensky F, Hess WR, Vaulot D (1999) Prochlorococcus, a marine photosynthetic prokaryote of global significance. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 63: 106–127.
- 22. Moore LR, Rocap G, Chisholm SW (1998) Physiology and molecular phylogeny of coexisting Prochlorococcus ecotypes. Nature 393: 464–467. doi: 10.1038/30965
- 23. Partensky F, Blanchot J, Vaulot D (1999) Differential distribution and ecology of Prochlorococcus and Synechococcus in oceanic waters: a review. Marine cyanobacteria, eds Charpy L, Larkum A (Musée Océanographique, Monaco) 19: 457–475.
- 24. Moore LR, Chisholm SW (1999) Photophysiology of the Marine Cyanobacterium Prochlorococcus: Ecotypic Differences among Cultured Isolates. Limnol Oceanogr 44: 628–638 Available: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2670673.
- 25. Johnson ZI, Zinser ER, Coe A, McNulty NP, Woodward EM, et al. (2006) Niche partitioning among Prochlorococcus ecotypes along ocean-scale environmental gradients. Science 311: 1737–1740. doi: 10.1126/science.1118052
- 26. Kettler GC, Martiny AC, Huang K, Zucker J, Coleman ML, et al. (2007) Patterns and implications of gene gain and loss in the evolution of Prochlorococcus. PLoS Genet 3: e231. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgen.0030231.eor
- 27. Dufresne A, Garczarek L, Partensky F (2005) Accelerated evolution associated with genome reduction in a free-living prokaryote. Genome Biol 6: R14. doi: 10.1186/gb-2005-6-2-r14
- 28. Luo H, Friedman R, Tang J, Hughes AL (2011) Genome reduction by deletion of paralogs in the marine cyanobacterium Prochlorococcus. Mol Biol Evol 28: 2751–2760. doi: 10.1093/molbev/msr081
- 29. Rocap G, Larimer FW, Lamerdin J, Malfatti S, Chain P, et al. (2003) Genome divergence in two Prochlorococcus ecotypes reflects oceanic niche differentiation. Nature 424: 1042–1047. doi: 10.1038/nature01947
- 30. Palenik B, Ren Q, Dupont CL, Myers GS, Heidelberg JF, et al. (2006) Genome sequence of Synechococcus CC9311: Insights into adaptation to a coastal environment. Proc Natl Acad Sci 103: 13555–13559. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0602963103
- 31. Dufresne A, Ostrowski M, Scanlan DJ, Garczarek L, Mazard S, et al. (2008) Unraveling the genomic mosaic of a ubiquitous genus of marine cyanobacteria. Genome Biol 9: R90. doi: 10.1186/gb-2008-9-5-r90
- 32. Hu J, Blanchard JL (2009) Environmental sequence data from the Sargasso Sea reveal that the characteristics of genome reduction in Prochlorococcus are not a harbinger for an escalation in genetic drift. Mol Biol Evol 26: 5–13. doi: 10.1093/molbev/msn217
- 33. Ahlgren NA, Rocap G, Chisholm SW (2006) Measurement of Prochlorococcus ecotypes using real-time polymerase chain reaction reveals different abundances of genotypes with similar light physiologies. Environ Microbiol 8: 441–454. doi: 10.1111/j.1462-2920.2005.00910.x
- 34. Sullivan MB, Waterbury JB, Chisholm SW (2003) Cyanophages infecting the oceanic cyanobacterium Prochlorococcus. Nature 424: 1047–1051. doi: 10.1038/nature01929
- 35. Sullivan MB, Coleman ML, Weigele P, Rohwer F, Chisholm SW (2005) Three Prochlorococcus cyanophage genomes: signature features and ecological interpretations. PLoS Biol 3: e144. doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.0030144
- 36. Coleman ML, Chisholm SW (2010) Ecosystem-specific selection pressures revealed through comparative population genomics. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 107: 18634–18639. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1009480107
- 37. Morris JJ, Lenski RE, Zinser ER (2012) The Black Queen Hypothesis: evolution of dependencies through adaptive gene loss. MBio 3: e00036–12–. doi: 10.1128/mbio.00036-12
- 38. Marais G, Calteau A, Tenaillon O (2008) Mutation rate and genome reduction in endosymbiotic and free-living bacteria. Genetica doi: 10.1007/s10709-007-9226-6
- 39. Yang Z (2007) PAML 4: phylogenetic analysis by maximum likelihood. Mol Biol Evol 24: 1586–1591. doi: 10.1093/molbev/msm088
- 40. Sharp PM, Li W-H (1987) The codon adaptation index-a measure of directional synonymous codon usage bias, and its potential applications. Nucleic Acids Res 15: 1281–1295. doi: 10.1093/nar/15.3.1281
- 41. Tatusov RL, Fedorova ND, Jackson JD, Jacobs AR, Kiryutin B, et al. (2003) The COG database: an updated version includes eukaryotes. BMC Bioinformatics 4: 41.
- 42. Coleman ML, Sullivan MB, Martiny AC, Steglich C, Barry K, et al. (2006) Genomic islands and the ecology and evolution of Prochlorococcus. Science 311: 1768–1770. doi: 10.1126/science.1122050
- 43. Scanlan DJ, Ostrowski M, Mazard S, Dufresne A, Garczarek L, et al. (2009) Ecological Genomics of Marine Picocyanobacteria. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 73: 249–299. doi: 10.1128/mmbr.00035-08
- 44. Moran NA, McLaughlin HJ, Sorek R (2009) The Dynamics and Time Scale of Ongoing Genomic Erosion in Symbiotic Bacteria. Science (80-) 323: 379–382. doi: 10.1126/science.1167140
- 45. Besemer J, Lomsadze A, Borodovsky M (2001) GeneMarkS: a self-training method for prediction of gene starts in microbial genomes. Implications for finding sequence motifs in regulatory regions. Nucleic Acids Res 29: 2607–2618. doi: 10.1093/nar/29.12.2607
- 46. Finn RD, Mistry J, Tate J, Coggill P, Heger A, et al. (2010) The Pfam protein families database. Nucleic Acids Res 38: D211–22. doi: 10.1093/nar/gkp985
- 47. Altschul SF, Gish W, Miller W, Myers EW, Lipman DJ (1990) Basic local alignment search tool. J Mol Biol 215: 403–410. doi: 10.1016/s0022-2836(05)80360-2
- 48. Larkin MA, Blackshields G, Brown NP, Chenna R, McGettigan PA, et al. (2007) Clustal W and Clustal X version 2.0. Bioinformatics 23: 2947–2948. doi: 10.1093/bioinformatics/btm404
- 49. Castresana J (2000) Selection of conserved blocks from multiple alignments for their use in phylogenetic analysis. Mol Biol Evol 17: 540–552. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.molbev.a026334
- 50. Felsenstein J (1989) PHYLIP - Phylogeny Inference Package (Version 3.2). Cladistics 5: 164–166.
- 51. Jones DT, Taylor WR, Thornton JM (1992) The rapid generation of mutation data matrices from protein sequences. Comput Appl Biosci 8: 275–282. doi: 10.1093/bioinformatics/8.3.275
- 52. Maddison WP, Maddison DR (2007) Mesquite: a modular system for evolutionary analysis. Version 2.0 http://mesquiteproject.org.
- 53. Hasegawa M, Kishino H, Yano T (1985) Dating of the human-ape splitting by a molecular clock of mitochondrial DNA. J Mol Evol 22: 160–174 Available: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF02101694.
- 54. Rice P, Longden I, Bleasby A (2000) EMBOSS: the European Molecular Biology Open Software Suite. Trends Genet 16: 276–277. doi: 10.1016/s0168-9525(00)02024-2