Advertisement
Browse Subject Areas
?

Click through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in your field.

For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click here.

  • Loading metrics

Morphology, Chemistry and Function of the Postpharyngeal Gland in the South American Digger Wasps Trachypus boharti and Trachypus elongatus

  • Gudrun Herzner ,

    gudrun.herzner@biologie.uni-regensburg.de

    Affiliation Evolutionary Ecology Group, Institute for Zoology, University of Regensburg, Regensburg, Germany

  • Martin Kaltenpoth,

    Affiliation Research Group Insect Symbiosis, Max Planck Institute for Chemical Ecology, Jena, Germany

  • Theodor Poettinger,

    Affiliation Evolutionary Ecology Group, Institute for Zoology, University of Regensburg, Regensburg, Germany

  • Katharina Weiss,

    Affiliation Evolutionary Ecology Group, Institute for Zoology, University of Regensburg, Regensburg, Germany

  • Dirk Koedam,

    Affiliation Department of Animal Sciences, Federal Rural University of the Semi-Arid Region, Mossoro, Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil

  • Johannes Kroiss,

    Affiliation Research Group Insect Symbiosis, Max Planck Institute for Chemical Ecology, Jena, Germany

  • Erhard Strohm

    Affiliation Evolutionary Ecology Group, Institute for Zoology, University of Regensburg, Regensburg, Germany

Morphology, Chemistry and Function of the Postpharyngeal Gland in the South American Digger Wasps Trachypus boharti and Trachypus elongatus

  • Gudrun Herzner, 
  • Martin Kaltenpoth, 
  • Theodor Poettinger, 
  • Katharina Weiss, 
  • Dirk Koedam, 
  • Johannes Kroiss, 
  • Erhard Strohm
PLOS
x

Abstract

Microbes pose severe threats to animals as competitors or pathogens and strongly affect the evolution of life history traits like parental care. Females of the European beewolf Philanthus triangulum, a solitary digger wasp, provision their offspring with paralyzed honeybees and embalm them with the secretion from large postpharyngeal glands (PPG) that contain mainly unsaturated hydrocarbons. This coating changes the physico-chemical properties of the prey surface, causes a reduction of water condensation and retards growth of mold fungi. Here we examined the closely related South American genus Trachypus, which shows a life-history similar to Philanthus. We investigated whether Trachypus spp. also possess PPGs and embalm larval provisions. Using histological methods and 3D reconstructions we show that Trachypus boharti and T. elongatus possess PPGs that are similar to P. triangulum but somewhat smaller. The ultrastructure of the gland epithelium suggests that the gland content is at least partly sequestered from the hemolymph. Chemical analyses using gas chromatography / mass spectrometry revealed that both the cuticle and PPGs of Trachypus contain mainly unsaturated long-chain hydrocarbons. The gland of T. boharti additionally contains long-chain ketones. The hydrocarbons from the PPG of T. elongatus occurred on prey bees excavated from nests in the field but not on conspecific control bees. While the embalming only slightly elevated the amount of hydrocarbons on prey bees, the proportion of unsaturated hydrocarbons, which is crucial for the antifungal effect, was significantly increased. The Trachypus species under study possess PPGs that are very similar to the PPG of P. triangulum with regard to morphology, ultrastructure and chemistry. Moreover, we provide clear evidence that T. elongatus females embalm their prey, presumably as a means of prey preservation. The observed differences among Trachypus and Philanthus in gland size and prey embalming may have evolved in response to divergent ecological conditions.

Introduction

Pathogenic and competing microbes prevail everywhere that animals live. This permanent threat has given rise to a remarkable diversity and complexity of animal adaptations to protect themselves, their offspring as well as their food against microbial attack [1-8].

A solitary digger wasp, the European beewolf Philanthus triangulum Fabricius (Hymenoptera, Crabronidae), for example shows several intriguing adaptations to such kinds of threats. Female beewolves provision brood cells with paralyzed honeybees (Apis mellifera, Hymenoptera, Apidae) as food for their offspring [9]. In the subterranean nests the prey bees and the developing brood are exposed to a multitude of biotic and abiotic threats. To protect the provisions and their brood against infestation by microbes, P. triangulum females embalm their prey with large amounts of hydrocarbons (HCs) [7,10-13]. This prey embalming considerably increases the total amount of HCs on the prey bee surface as well as the proportion of unsaturated and shorter-chain HCs [10-12]. Such a change in the chemical profile may reduce the melting point of the total hydrocarbon mixture on the prey bee surface [14,15], in that it becomes more or less liquid and forms an oily, hydrophobic layer [10]. As a result, water condensation on the bees is reduced so that the growth conditions for fungi are impaired and fungus growth is significantly retarded [7,10,13]. A second benefit of the thick layer of HCs caused by the embalming is a reduction of water loss from the prey bees that helps the beewolf larva to resist desiccation under hot and dry conditions [12].

The HCs used for embalming are secreted from a large head gland, the postpharyngeal gland (PPG) [16-18]. This type of gland has long been known only from ants [19-21], until it has recently been described in P. triangulum [16,22] as well as in the emerald cockroach wasp Ampulex compressa (Hymenoptera, Ampulicidae) [23]. In all these taxa, the PPG contains mostly HCs (but see 22,24) that show a high congruence with the respective epicuticular hydrocarbon profile [17,18,20,23,25]. In ants, several functions have been suggested for the PPG (for a review see 19), with the crucial role in nestmate recognition being the most prominent [26-28]. The PPG in A. compressa was proposed to function as a HC storing organ [23].

The simple yet ingenious physical mechanism of prey embalming to fight fungi and desiccation has so far only been described for P. triangulum, but preliminary analyses of other Philanthus species show that they also possess PPGs and embalm their prey (Herzner, Kaltenpoth and Strohm, unpublished). The embalming of prey with a PPG secretion thus seems to be common in the genus Philanthus, which comprises about 140 species with a distribution in Europe, Africa, North America, and Asia [29,30].

Published morphological phylogenies [31] as well as a molecular phylogeny of the subfamily Philanthinae that is under construction (Kaltenpoth, Strohm et al., unpublished) suggest that the most closely-related taxon to Philanthus is Trachypus, a genus that comprises about 30 species in Central and South America [29,30]. The life-history of Trachypus is similar to that of Philanthus, with females constructing nests in the soil and hunting hymenopteran prey (Figure 1) as provisions for their progeny [30,32-34]. Thus, it is likely that Trachypus, as the ‘neotropical ecological equivalent to Philanthus’ [35], faces similar threats with regard to pathogenic and competing microorganisms and desiccation.

thumbnail
Figure 1. Female T. boharti hunting males of the stingless bee Scaptotrigona postica in flight.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082780.g001

We already know that Philanthus and Trachypus share another antimicrobial defense mechanism. European beewolves have evolved a protective symbiosis with Streptomyces bacteria (‘Candidatus Streptomyces philanthi’) that are cultivated in the females' antennae, secreted into the brood cells, taken up by the larvae and integrated into the cocoon [6,36,37] where they produce a mixture of antibiotics that fight a multitude of microorganisms and secure the survival of the developing beewolf [6,37,38]. Closely related bacteria have been found in the antennae of 28 other species of the genus Philanthus [36]. Recently, it has been shown that Trachypus as well as another related genus, Philanthinus, also engage in protective symbiosis with Streptomyces bacteria [39,40].

The present study aims to elucidate whether females of Trachypus spp. also possess PPGs and embalm their prey. We investigated two species, Trachypus boharti (Rubio) and Trachypus elongatus (Fabricius), for the presence, morphology, and ultrastructure of the PPG by light microscopy, transmission electron microscopy and 3D-reconstruction of cephalic structures based on semi-thin sections. The contents of the PPGs of the two Trachypus species were analyzed by gas chromatography – mass spectrometry to assess whether they are dominated by HCs. In addition, the chemical profiles of the cuticles were analyzed and checked for chemical congruence with the PPG content. To assess whether the prey in the brood cells is embalmed, provisioned prey bees were excavated from T. elongatus nests in the field, and their chemistry was compared with both conspecific control bees caught in the field and the chemical profile of the PPG of T. elongatus females. The results provide new insights into the evolutionary history of the PPG and the distribution and variation of embalming behavior within the crabronid wasps.

Results

Morphology and ultrastructure of Trachypus PPGs

The histological investigations revealed that females of both T. boharti and T. elongatus possess large gland reservoirs that originate from the pharynx near the posterior part of the hypopharyngeal plate and can thus be called PPGs. The 3D-reconstructions illustrate that the PPG is located in the forehead in the upper two thirds of the head capsule and extends laterally to the anterior margins of the eyes (Figure 2). The PPGs of both species originate from the pharynx and comprise various tubular extensions. In T. elongatus, the gland has an overall ‘glove-like’ structure (Figure 2B) with 10-12 ‘fingers’ originating from a common root. The PPG of T. boharti, in contrast, has a more ‘comb-like’ overall structure (Figure 2A) with 10-12 ‘teeth’ originating from a common branch. In T. boharti, the 'teeth' of the reconstructed individual appear somehow collapsed. The PPG of T. elongatus has an additional sac-like extension ventrally to the pharynx. The calculated gland volumes were 0.27 µl for T. elongatus (3.6 mm head capsule width) and 0.1 µl for T. boharti (3.5 mm head capsule width).

thumbnail
Figure 2. 3D-reconstructions of the postpharyngeal glands of females.

(A) T. boharti, and (B) T. elongatus. Abbreviations: Br, brain; Oc, ocellus; Ph, pharynx; PPG, postpharyngeal gland. Head capsule widths of the depicted individuals were 3.52mm for T. boharti and 3.64mm for T. elongatus.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082780.g002

The histological investigations of the semithin sections revealed that in T. boharti the left and right ‘comb’ of the gland each have their own opening into the pharynx laterally near the suspensorium of the hypopharyngeal plate. In T. elongatus, in contrast, the roots of the two ‘gloves’ cohere and have one joint dorsal connection to the pharynx. In both species air sacs are located between the frontal cuticle and the PPG as well as between the PPG and the brain.

In both species the wall of the PPG is formed by a monolayered epithelium (Figure 3). The basal (outer) side of the epithelium is characterized by multiple constrictions and foldings that apparently enlarge the outer surface. The apical (inner) side of the epithelium bears numerous long hairs that extend into the lumen. These hairs become less abundant towards the outer parts of the gland. There are no class-III gland cells [41,42] with duct cells and secretory cells associated with the PPG. In some regions the epithelium borders a tissue of relatively large cells, some of which contain numerous large vesicles (Figure 3). While there are muscles attached to the cuticular extensions of the hypopharyngeal plate near the opening of the PPG in both species, no muscles are directly associated with the epithelium of the gland. In T. elongatus there is a circular muscle around the opening of the lower sac-like part of the PPG.

thumbnail
Figure 3. Semi-thin sections of the postpharyngeal glands of females.

(A) T. boharti, and (B) T. elongatus. All the features shown for one species could also be observed in the other, but may not appear in the respective picture. Abbreviations: As, air sac; Ep, epithelium of the PPG; H, hair; Lu, lumen of the PPG; N, nucleus; sC, surrounding cell; V, vesicle (scale bars = 50µm).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082780.g003

The transmission electron microscopic investigations of the ultrathin sections of T. boharti PPGs confirmed that the wall of the gland reservoir is formed by a monolayered epithelium (Figure 4A). The thickness of this epithelium is rather variable. The apical side of the epithelium is characterized by a well-developed microvillar fringe and is supported by an intima (cuticle) that resembles the intima of the pharynx. The basal side of the epithelium is bordered by a basal lamina that shows numerous conspicuous invaginations. The epithelial cells contain large nuclei, mitochondria, smooth and some rough endoplasmatic reticulum, and septate desmosomes. There are no extracellular cavities, pore canals, or ducts that are characteristic of class-III gland cells [41].

thumbnail
Figure 4. Transmission electron micrographs of the PPG epithelium of a female T. boharti.

(A) Epithelium of the PPG (scale bar = 2.5µm); (B) PPG and the surrounding cells (scale bar = 5µm). The surrounding cells are in direct contact with the PPG and with each other (white arrows). Abbreviations: Bl, basal lamina; Bin, basal invagination; Cu, cuticle; dC, dark cell; H, hair (cross-cut); lC, light cell; Lu, lumen; Mt, mitochondrium; Mv, microvilli; PPG, postpharyngeal gland; S, secretion; sER, smooth endoplasmatic reticulum; V, vesicle.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082780.g004

The cells bordering the PPG in T. boharti seem to comprise two different types (Figure 4B). One type appears lighter and contains mainly smooth endoplasmatic reticulum in high densities as well as mitochondria. The darker appearing cell type contains mainly rough endoplasmatic reticulum, mitochondria and various large electron translucent vesicles (Figure 4B). Both cell types are found in close proximity with each other and the epithelium of the PPG. The pronounced invaginations of the epithelium’s basal lamina at the contact sites between the PPG and these neighboring cells as well as at sites where the PPG is in direct contact to the hemocoel suggest an extensive transport of substances across this basal lamina.

Chemistry of Trachypus PPG and cuticle

In the PPG samples of T. boharti, we detected 51 substances with chain lengths of 21-31 carbon atoms (Table 1). The chemical profile was dominated by long-chain unsaturated HCs (on average 84.5±1.5% of the total amount of HCs) with 7-pentacosene being the most abundant compound. The PPGs of T. boharti also contained 14 long-chain unsaturated ketones ranging from C23 to C29. The structures of these alkenones were assigned by their mass spectra and the mass spectra of their DMDS adducts. The mass spectrum of the most abundant alkenone, 18-pentacosen-6-one, for example, was characterized by a molecular ion at m/z 364 [C5H11-CO-C19H37]+ and two diagnostic fragment ions at m/z 99 for [C5H11-CO]+ and at m/z 293 for [C19H37-CO]+, indicating that the carbonyl group is at position C6. The mass spectrum of the DMDS (molecular weight = 94) adduct showed a molecular ion at m/z 458 (364+94) and diagnostic fragment ions at m/z 145 and m/z 313, which clearly reflect a double bond at the C18 position in the original alkenone (see Table 1 and Figure S1 for the diagnostic ions of the ketones and their respective DMDS adducts and two exemplary mass spectra). The mass spectrum of 18-heptacosen-10-one was identical to that published by Yasui et al. [43]. 14-tricosen-6-one, 16-pentacosen-8-one, 18-heptacosen-10-one had previously been described for P. triangulum [17]. Mass spectra and retention times of these ketones found in T. boharti and P. triangulum (reanalyzed on our GC/MS set-up) were identical.

No.SubstanceLRIPresence on CuticleDiagnostic ions
B1Heneicosane2100+296
B29-Tricosene2272+322; DMDS: 173, 243, 416
B37-Tricosene2280+322; DMDS: 145, 271, 416
B4Tricosane2300+324
B59-Tetracosene2372+336; DMDS: 173, 257, 430
B67-Tetracosene2380+336; DMDS: 145, 285, 430
B7Tetracosane2400+338
B814-Tricosen-6-one2453-99, 181, 265, 336; DMDS: 99, 173, 257, 430
B914-Tricosen-4-one 2461-71, 153, 293, 336; DMDS: 71, 173, 257, 430
B10+ 16-Tricosen-6-one-99, 181, 265, 336; DMDS: 99, 145, 285, 430
B1116-Tricosen-4-one 2467-71, 153, 293, 336; DMDS: 71, 145, 285, 430
B12+ Pentacosadiene-348; DMDS: n.d.
B13+ 3-Methyltetracosane-57, 323
B149-Pentacosene2473+350; DMDS: 173, 271, 444
B157-Pentacosene2484+350; DMDS: 145, 299, 444
B165-Pentacosene2491+350; DMDS: 117, 327, 444
B17Pentacosane2500+352
B1813-Methylpentacosane 2533+196/197 (sym.)
B19+ 11-Methylpentacosane+168/169, 224/225
B205-Methylpentacosane2548-85, 308/309
B219-Hexacosene2573+364; DMDS: 173, 285, 458
B228-Hexacosene2577-364; DMDS: 159, 299, 458
B237-Hexacosene2582+364; DMDS: 145, 313, 458
B24Hexacosane2600+366
B2516-Pentacosen-8-one2654+127, 209, 265, 364; DMDS: 127, 173, 285, 458
B2616-Pentacosen-6-one2659+99, 181, 293, 364; DMDS: 99, 173, 285, 458
B2718-Pentacosen-8-one2663+127, 209, 265, 364; DMDS: 127, 145, 313, 458
B2818-Pentacosen-6-one2666+99, 181, 293, 364; DMDS: 99, 145, 313, 458
B296,9-Heptacosadiene2670+376; DMDS: 131, 155, 203, 299, 323, 371, 407, 455, 502
B309-Heptacosene2675+378; DMDS: 173, 299, 472
B313, 6, 9-Heptacosatriene2679+108, 135, 318, 345, 331, 374
B327-Heptacosene2684+378; DMDS: 145, 327, 472
B335-Heptacosene2693+378; DMDS: 117, 355, 472
B34Heptacosane2700+380
B357-Octacosene2784+392; DMDS: 145, 341, 486
B3618-Heptacosen-10-one2860-155, 237, 265, 392; DMDS: 155, 173, 313, 486
B37+ 18-Heptacosen-8-one-127, 209, 293, 392; DMDS: 127, 173, 313, 486
B3820-Heptacosen-10-one2864+155, 237, 265, 392; DMDS: 155, 145, 341, 486
B39+ 20-Heptacosen-8-one2867+127, 209, 293, 392; DMDS: 127, 145, 341, 486
B406,9-Nonacosadiene2873+404; DMDS: 131, 155, 203, 327, 351, 399, 435, 483, 530
B41 9-Nonacosene2876+406; DMDS: 173, 327, 500
B423, 6, 9-Nonacosatriene 2881+108, 135, 346, 359, 373, 402
B437-Nonacosene2884+406; DMDS: 145, 355, 500
B44Nonacosane2900+408
B457-Triacontene2986+420; DMDS: 145, 369, 514
B4622-Nonacosen-12-one3069-183, 265, 420; DMDS: 171, 145, 369, 514
B47+ 22-Nonacosen-10-one-155, 237, 293, 420; DMDS: 155, 145, 369, 514
B48Hentriacontadiene 3077+432; DMDS: n.d.
B49+ 9-Hentriacontene+434; DMDS: 173, 355, 528
B507-Hentriacontene3086+434; DMDS: 145, 383, 528
B51Hentriacontane3100+436

Table 1. Chemical composition of the postpharyngeal gland content and the cuticle of T. boharti females.

LRI = linear retention index (calculated in relation to n-alkanes) on the RH-5ms+ column;
+ = present;
- = absent;
sym = symmetric molecule, reduced number of diagnostic ions; DMDS = diagnostic ions of the respective DMDS adducts;n.d. = not detected.
CSV
Download CSV

The polar as well as non-polar fractions of pooled samples revealed the presence of additional compounds (mainly saturated and unsaturated ketones) which could not be detected in extracts from single individuals because of their low abundance and/or because they coeluted with the dominant HCs. For completeness, these additional compounds are given in Table S1.

The cuticle samples of T. boharti contained 39 substances of chain length C21 to C31 (Table 1). The overall chromatographic patterns of PPG and cuticle closely resembled each other. According to a major axis regression analysis (R=0.88, P=0.0003, see Figure S2), there was a direct proportionality in the proportions of components on the cuticle and in the PPG.

The average total amount of substances found in the PPG samples of T. boharti was 15.6 ± 6.4 µg, the average total amount of compounds on the cuticle was 8.2 ±3.1 µg and thus significantly less than in the PPG (paired t-test: t=-3.99, P=0.0032).

In T. elongatus, the PPG and head samples contained 35 substances with chain length C21 to C33 (Table 2 and Figure 5C) and were dominated by unsaturated HCs (67%). The cuticle samples contained the same substances, and the chromatographic pattern of the PPG showed high congruence with the cuticular chemistry (R=0.88, P=0.004, Figures 5C and D and Figure S3). The total amount of HCs was 47.5 µg for the PPG and 54.1µg for the corresponding cuticle sample.

No.SubstanceLRIPPGCuticleEBCBDiagnostic ions
1Heneicosene2072--++294
2Heneicosene2078---+294
3Heneicosane2100++++296
4Docosane2200++++310
5Tricosene2273--++322
6Tricosane2300++++324
73-Methyltricosane2372++++85, 309
8Tetracosane2400++++338
99-Pentacosene2473++++350; MS2: 306
107-Pentacosene2479++++350; MS2: 334
11Pentacosane2500++++352
125-Methylpentacosane2549+++-85, 308/309
133-Methylpentacosane2573++++57, 337
14Hexacosane2600++++366
1513-Heptacosene2666+---378; MS2: 278
1611-Heptacosene2669+---378; MS2: 306
179-Heptacosene2675++++378; MS2: 334
18Heptacosene2684--++378
19Heptacosane2700++++380
20Octacosane2800--++394
21Unidentified2811--++-
2213-Nonacosene2866+++-406; MS2: 306
2310-Nonacosene2873+++-406; MS2: 348
249-Nonacosene2876++++406; MS2: 362
258-Nonacosene2879+++-406; MS2: 376
26Nonacosane2900++++408
27Triacontane3000--+-422
289,19-Hentriacontadiene3041+++-432; MS2: 374, 332
29Hentriacontadiene3048+++-432
30Hentriacontadiene 3058+++-432
3115-Hentriacontene3066+++-434; MS2: 306
3212-Hentriacontene3069+++-434; MS2: 348
3310-Hentriacontene3075+++-434; MS2: 376
349-Hentriacontene3078+++-434; MS2: 390
35Hentriacontane3100++++436
36Dotriacontane3200--+-450
378,22-Tritriacontadiene3241+++-460; MS2: 416, 374
38Tritriacontadiene3250+++-460
39Tritriacontadiene3258+++-460
4016-Tritriacontene3262+++-462; MS2: 320
4114-Tritriacontene3264+++-462; MS2: 348
4212-Tritriacontene3271+++-462; MS2: 376
439-Tritriacontene3277+++-462; MS2: 418

Table 2. Comparison of the chemistry of T. elongatus with its provisioned prey and control bees.

Chemical composition of solvent extracts of the postpharyngeal gland (PPG) and cuticle (Cuticle) of a T. elongatus female, a T. hyalinata prey bee excavated from a T. elongatus nest (EB, embalmed bee) and a T. hyalinata control bee (CB, control bee).
LRI = linear retention index (calculated in relation to n-alkanes) on the RH-5ms+ column;
+ = the substance was detected in at least one of the samples;
- = not detected;
sym = symmetric molecule, reduced number of diagnostic ions;
MS2 = MS2 diagnostic ions (MS2 precursor ion for all compounds: [M+54]+).
CSV
Download CSV
thumbnail
Figure 5. Chromatographic evidence for prey embalming by T. elongatus females.

Total ion chromatograms of (A) a T. hyalinata control bee, (B) a provisioned T. hyalinata bee excavated from a T. elongatus nest, (C) the PPG content of a T. elongatus female and (D) the cuticle of the same T. elongatus female. The peaks of minor compounds are not always visible due to the magnification used. The numbers at the peaks correspond to the numbers in Table 2. Unlabelled peaks are contaminations.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082780.g005

Prey embalming in T. elongatus

Of the 31 excavated T. elongatus brood cells, three were freshly provisioned and contained 4, 3, and 3 Trigona hyalinata (Lepeletier) (Hymenoptera, Apidae, Meliponini) workers, respectively. Chemical analyses showed that T. hyalinata control bees that were caught in the vicinity of T. elongatus nests and directly from their nest entrance carried 21 HCs (Figure 5A and Table 2). The chemical analyses of the provisioned bees revealed that, in addition to the species specific cuticular HCs, they all carried the substances that we found in the samples of T. elongatus females (Figure 5B and Table 2).

If T. elongatus females add their characteristic HCs to the surface of their prey bees that already carry their own characteristic HCs, the chemical profile of provisioned bees is expected to be intermediate between the wasps and conspecific control bees. The multivariate statistical analyses revealed that this was actually the case (Figure 6). An ANOSIM analysis showed an overall significant difference between all three groups (R = 0.97, P = 0.0001) and significant differences in all pairwise comparisons (sequential Bonferroni correction; P < 0.01 for all comparisons; control bees vs. provisioned bees R = 0.96; control bees vs. T. elongatus R = 1; provisioned bees vs. T. elongatus R = 0.99). The substances contributing most to the difference between control bees and provisioned bees were the hentriacontenes (15% in the SIMPER analysis), which are the most abundant unsaturated compounds found in the PPG of T. elongatus females (see also Figure 5 and Table 2).

thumbnail
Figure 6. Statistical evidence for prey embalming by T. elongatus females.

Two-dimensional MDS representation of the chemical profiles of individual T. hyalinata control bees (squares), provisioned T. hyalinata bees (circles), and T. elongatus females (triangles) (stress value: 0.11). The ellipses depict the 95% confidence intervals.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082780.g006

Provisioned bees carried only slightly but not significantly more HCs than control bees (median ± median absolute deviation: 40.9 ± 2.2 µg vs. 38.7 ± 4.9 µg; exact P=0.77). Nonetheless, the proportion of unsaturated HCs was significantly higher on provisioned bees as compared to the controls (median ± median absolute deviation = 37.3 ± 7.0% vs. 18.3 ± 0.30%; exact P=0.0013).

Discussion

Morphology and ultrastructure of Trachypus PPGs

Females of T. boharti and T. elongatus possess large PPGs. The location and basic morphology are similar to the PPGs of female European beewolves, P. triangulum [16], as well as many ant species [19-21]. There are, however, some notable differences. While in T. boharti and P. triangulum the PPG consists of a pair of evaginations, each with its own connection to the pharynx, the two branches of the PPG of T. elongatus cohere at their base and possess only one joint connection to the pharynx. The lower, smaller part of the PPG with a separate opening to the pharynx that has been described for P. triangulum does not occur in the two Trachypus species. The more or less pronounced extension of the PPG ventrally to the pharynx in T. elongatus might be interpreted as an intermediate stage between P. triangulum and T. boharti. The estimated gland volume of P. triangulum is about ten times larger than that of T. elongatus. The gland volume of T. boharti was even smaller. However, the gland tubes of T. boharti appeared partly collapsed, so the actual gland volume is probably somewhat larger.

As in P. triangulum, the wall of the PPG in Trachypus is a monolayered epithelium, and the lumen of the gland is lined by a cuticular intima. The PPG thus belongs to the epithelial type. The long hairs that are formed by the cuticular intima and extend far into the lumen have also been described for the PPG of P. triangulum. Also as in P. triangulum, the PPG of Trachypus is partly bordered by two different types of cells and there are no muscles associated with the epithelium of the gland.

The ultrastructural investigations of T. boharti revealed that the cells bordering the epithelium of the PPG show a considerable density of smooth and rough endoplasmatic reticulum and thus appear to be synthetically very active. The cells of the PPG epithelium show comparatively few signs of synthetic activity. The pronounced invaginations of the basal lamina at the contact areas between the PPG and the neighboring cells as well as the hemolymph rather suggest that there is an intense transport of substances across the epithelium of the PPG. We therefore propose that the secretion that is stored in the PPG of Trachypus females is at least partly sequestered from the hemolymph and might be synthesized in the neighboring cells and in the fat body. Such a (at least partial) sequestration of compounds into the PPG has also been proposed for female P. triangulum [16,18] and the emerald cockroach wasp A. compressa [23] and has been shown in ants (see below) [20,44].

Chemistry of Trachypus PPG and cuticle

As in P. triangulum [17,18], A. compressa [23] and various ant species [20,25], the PPGs of T. boharti and T. elongatus contain mostly HCs. The chemistry of the two Trachypus species is dominated by long-chain unsaturated HCs, which is also true for P. triangulum [17]. The PPG of T. elongatus contains more doubly-unsaturated HCs than that of T. boharti and P. triangulum. In both T. boharti and P. triangulum the by far most prominent compound is pentacosene, while in T. elongatus the hentriacontenes and pentacosane are the most abundant compounds. Interestingly, the PPG of T. boharti additionally comprises long-chain ketones. 14-tricosen-6-one, pentacosan-8-one, heptacosan-10-one, 16-pentacosen-8-one, and 18-heptacosen-10-one have also been found in the PPG, on the cuticle and in the hemolymph of P. triangulum [17]. However, we did not find any ketones in T. elongatus. 18-heptacosen-10-one and heptacosan-10-one are part of the contact sex pheromone in the white-spotted longicorn beetle, Anoplophora malasiaca [43]. All other unsaturated ketones have, to our knowledge, not yet been described as natural products. Whether these ketones play a special role for the defense against microbes and why T. elongatus lacks these ketones is not yet known.

In ants, there is convincing evidence that the HCs are synthesized by oenocytes, released into the hemolymph, transported by lipophorin to the cuticle as well as to the PPG and continuously exchanged between these two sites [20,44]. Consequently, there is congruence of the HC profiles of the hemolymph, the PPG and the cuticle [20,25,45]. Such congruence was also shown in P. triangulum [18] and A. compressa [23]. In the two Trachypus species, we also found a high congruence between the chemical profiles of PPG and cuticle, suggesting a similar mode of synthesis and circulation of HCs.

The amount of HCs in the T. elongatus PPG was 48 µg. The PPGs of field caught T. boharti contained on average 15.6 µg HCs and varied considerably between 4.8 µg and 27.4 µg. The average amount of HCs found in the PPG of field caught P. triangulum females (330µg) was considerably higher [16]. This difference is only partly explained by the larger size of P. triangulum females (average head capsule width 4.25-4.5mm [46] as opposed to T. boharti (3.4±0.2mm; N=16) and T. elongatus females (3.6±0.1mm; N=3), making up for an approximately twofold difference in body volume. Thus, the comparatively smaller glands and lower amounts of secretion in the two Trachypus species under study must have different reasons (see below).

Prey embalming

The specific HCs from the PPG of T. elongatus were clearly present on provisioned T. hyalinata bees excavated from T. elongatus nests, but not on T. hyalinata control bees. Our chemical and statistical analyses revealed that T. elongatus females add enough long-chain unsaturated HCs from their PPGs to their prey bees to significantly change their chemical profile. Consequently, the surface chemistry of provisioned T. hyalinata bees was intermediate to the chemical profiles of T. hyalinata control bees and T. elongatus females. For the present study provisioned prey of T. boharti was not available. It is tempting to speculate, however, that this species, which preys exclusively on males of Scaptotrigona postica (Latreille) (Hymenoptera, Apidae, Meliponini) [32,33] embalms its prey with the secretion of its PPG.

In T. elongatus the embalming did not significantly elevate the total amount of HCs on the bees’ surface. This is in contrast to P. triangulum, where embalming results in a five to tenfold increase of HCs on the prey surface [10,11]. However, the quantity of secretion applied to the bees might not be the decisive factor for the adaptive significance of prey embalming in Trachypus. In P. triangulum the embalming not only changes the quantity but also the quality of HCs on the bees by increasing the proportion of unsaturated HCs about threefold (25.8±7.8% for control bees and 73.6±9.9% for provisioned bees; [10]). This alters the physicochemical properties of the bee surface and consequently causes a decrease in water condensation. The reduced availability of water on the bees in turn renders microclimatic conditions unfavorable for the growth of competing mold fungi. In P. triangulum already small amounts of HCs on the bees were sufficient to mediate this physical effect [10], indicating that the quality of secretion, namely its high degree of unsaturation, is probably more important than its quantity (see 13 for a more detailed discussion).

As in P. triangulum, the PPG secretions of both Trachypus species consist primarily of unsaturated long-chain HCs. Consequently, in T. elongatus the embalming of the provisioned bees with the PPG secretion significantly elevated the proportion of unsaturated compounds on their surface as compared to not embalmed control bees. Whether this doubling of the proportion of unsaturated HCs on the surface of the prey of T. elongatus is sufficient to mediate the effect of reduced water condensation and fungus growth is currently unclear. Assuming the same relationship between the proportion of unsaturated HCs and water gain as has been found in P. triangulum in the laboratory [10], an increase of unsaturation from 18 to 37% would cause a two-fold reduction in water condensation on T. elongatus prey bees. Furthermore, the excavated T. elongatus brood cells were found very deep in the soil (at 95, 100, and 115 cm below the surface), where temperature fluctuations that would favor excessive water condensation are expected to be negligible [47]. Together, these effects might be sufficient to effectively impair fungal growth.

The second benefit of prey embalming in P. triangulum, the reduction of evaporative water loss of the prey, increases with increasing amounts of HCs on the prey surface [12]. As the brood cells of T. elongatus were located deep in the soil and surrounded by rather moist sand, the desiccation of the prey might not be a problem for T. elongatus. Thus, also the second function of the embalming, the prevention of desiccation, would not select for large amounts of HCs as a water barrier as found in P. triangulum.

In addition to the benefits of prey embalming, the accompanying costs have to be considered. In P. triangulum, prey embalming has been shown to enhance offspring survival but also to entail costs with regard to a reduced future reproductive potential of the females [13]. In order to maximize their fitness returns, female P. triangulum hence might adjust the amount of secretion in response to the actual conditions. In general, the optimal amount of secretion applied to the prey bees might depend on various biotic and abiotic factors, i.e. the nesting site, temperature and humidity, the prey species, the number of prey items and the threat by pathogenic and competing microorganisms. The prevalent prey of Trachypus, stingless bees, are known to carry plant-derived resins on their cuticles [48,49], and these mostly terpenoid compounds are known to have antimicrobial activity [50]. In the present study we found indications that T. hyalinata likewise carries resins on its surface (As the incidence of these compounds was irregular and their analysis was beyond the scope of the study, we do not provide more details.). Such resins might decrease the susceptibility of T. hyalinata to mold fungi and Trachypus females might therefore invest less in prey embalming.

As most of the abiotic and biotic factors that may shape prey preservation are likely to differ among Philanthus and Trachypus species, each species can be expected to adjust to the level of embalming that maximizes its overall reproductive success over evolutionary times. It is therefore conceivable that the optimal embalming strategy may differ between the European beewolf P. triangulum and the South American beewolf T. elongatus. We thus propose that, despite the lower amounts of secretion applied, the prey embalming in Trachypus has evolved as a parental care strategy for the purpose of prey preservation.

Conclusions

The South American beewolves of the genus Trachypus, which show a very similar life-history to the closely related genus Philanthus, seem to deploy similar antimicrobial defense mechanisms like the protective symbiosis with bacteria and the embalming of the prey with long-chain unsaturated HCs. Despite the similarities in morphology and chemistry of the PPG as well as the prey embalming between P. triangulum and the two Trachypus species under study, our results show that there are also considerable differences. These are probably the result of diverging selection pressures with regard to biotic and abiotic conditions that have shaped these traits in the different species over evolutionary times. Further studies on the genera Philanthus and Trachypus, other members of the subfamiliy Philanthinae, and even more distantly related digger wasps will be necessary to further unravel the origin and evolutionary history of the PPG and the exceptional antifungal defense mechanism of prey embalming.

Methods

Ethics statement

Permits were issued by the Brazilian Ministry of the Environment: MMA/SISBIO/22861-1.

Specimens and nest excavations

Adult female Trachypus boharti and T. elongatus were collected in São Paulo State, Brazil. Of the collected T. boharti, five heads were fixed for histological investigations; six heads were dissected to remove the PPGs for ultrastructural investigations. Ten specimens were dissected to remove the PPGs for chemical analyses. The corresponding bodies (thorax and abdomen) were used for chemical analyses. A total of fiveT. elongatus females was collected. Three heads were fixed for histological investigations, one head was extracted in hexane for chemical analysis, and one head was dissected to remove the PPG for chemical analysis. Of the corresponding bodies four were extracted in hexane for chemical analyses. Nests of still active T. elongatus females were excavated to obtain prey bees from freshly provisioned brood cells. For comparison, individuals of the prey species of T. elongatus, the stingless bee Trigona hyalinata, were caught directly from their nest entrance.

Histological investigations

Histological investigations of T. boharti (N = 5) and T. elongatus (N = 3) heads were conducted using light microscopy following standard histological methods. Freshly caught Trachypus were cold-anaesthetized and decapitated. The heads were fixed immediately in formalin-ethanol-acetic acid fixative (Scheuring). Subsequently, they were rinsed in 80% ethanol and both eyes were cut off using razor blades to enable the embedding medium to soak into the head. The specimens were then dehydrated in a graded ethanol series and propylene oxide, and finally embedded in Epon 812 (Polysciences Europe GmbH, Eppelheim, Germany). Continuous series of semi-thin sections (4 µm) were cut on a microtome (Reichert Ultracut; Leica Microsystems AG, Wetzlar, Germany) equipped with a diamond knife and stained with toluidine blue [51]. Sections were examined under a compound microscope (Zeiss Axiophot) and photographs were taken using a Nikon digital camera (Nikon Digital Sight DS-2Mv) and Nikon NIS F 2.20 software (Nikon Corp., Tokyo, Japan).

3D-reconstruction

3D-reconstructions of one T. boharti and one T. elongatus female head based on the series of semi-thin sections were conducted using the 3D visualization software Reconstruct (SynapseWeb, Kristen M. Harris, PI, http://synapses.clm.utexas.edu/). The photographs of the series of head sections were loaded into the program and manually aligned. The structures of interest (postpharyngeal gland, pharynx, brain, ocelli) were manually marked in each picture and the 3D surfaces computed. The gland volumes were calculated by the Reconstruct software.

Transmission electron microscopy

Six T. boharti females were cold anaesthetized, decapitated and their heads dissected under a stereomicroscope to remove the PPGs as described previously for P. triangulum [22]. The PPGs were then fixed for transmission electron microscopy (TEM) in a modified Karnovsky’s prefixative solution (2.5% glutardialdehyde and 2 % paraformaldehyde in sodium dihydrogen orthophosphate buffer; pH 7.4) in a refrigerator at approximately 4 °C. After postfixation in 2% OsO4 in 0.1M sodium dihydrogen orthophosphate buffer (pH 7.4) on ice for 2 hrs, the specimens were dehydrated in a graded ethanol series. They were then embedded in Epon 812 (with acetone as the intermediary solution). Ultra-thin sections were made with a 45° diamond knife on a Reichert Ultracut E microtome (Leica Microsystems AG, Wetzlar, Germany). Sections were stained with 2% uranyl acetate and Reynolds’ lead citrate and examined with a Zeiss EM 10 at 80 kV. Micrographs were taken with a TRS slow scan CCD camera (type s-7899-v) and the software TRS Image Sys Prog (Version 1.1.1.65).

Chemical analyses

The solvent extracts of the cuticles and the PPGs of T. boharti and T. elongatus were analyzed by gas chromatography / mass spectrometry (GC/MS, see below) to identify and quantify the chemical compounds and to test for a possible chemical congruence. The PPGs were obtained as described above and transferred to hexane vials (one PPG per vial), where they remained until chemical analyses were conducted. The respective bodies (thoraces and abdomens) as well as the one head of T. elongatus were individually extracted in hexane for 10 min. The bees excavated from T. elongatus nests (N = 10) as well as control bees (N = 5) were individually extracted in hexane for 10 min. Octadecane was added as an internal standard for quantification of the HCs, the samples were reduced in volume to approximately 70µl under a gentle stream of nitrogen and 1µl of each sample was analyzed by GC/MS.

GC/MS analysis was performed with an Agilent 6890N Series gas chromatograph coupled to an Agilent 5973 inert mass selective detector (Agilent Technologies, Böblingen, Germany). The GC was fitted with an RH-5ms+ fused silica capillary column (30m×0.25mm ID; film thickness = 0.25µm; Capital Analytical Ltd., Leeds, England). The GC was programmed from 70 to 180 °C at 30 °C/min and then at 3°C/min to 300 °C, with a 1-min initial isothermal and a 5-min final isothermal hold. A split/splitless injector (250 °C) was used in the splitless mode, with the purge valve opened after 1min. Helium was the carrier gas at a constant flow rate of 1ml/min. Electron ionization mass spectra (EI-MS) were recorded at an ionization voltage of 70 eV, a source temperature of 230 °C, and an interface temperature of 315 °C. Data acquisition and storage were performed with the GC/MS software MSD ChemStation for Windows (Agilent Technologies, Palo Alto, CA, USA). Peak areas were obtained by manual integration using the GC software.

After they had been run individually on the GC/MS, the crude extracts of T. boharti were pooled and then fractionated by column chromatography on a silica gel column (Chromabond 100mg, Macherey and Nagel) with hexane and dichloromethane as the mobile phase to separate polar from non-polar compounds. An aliquot of 1µl of each fraction was analyzed by GC/MS. Hydrocarbons were identified as described previously [23]. Iodine-catalyzed methylthiolation using dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) [52,53] was performed to determine the positions of the double bonds in alkenes, alkadienes and alkenons. Double-bond positions in the alkatrienes were determined by their characteristic fragments, which, together with the molecular ion, allow the assignment of double bonds [54]. Details on the identification of polar compounds are given in the results section.

For T. elongatus, double bond positions of unsaturated HCs were determined by a chemical ionization (CI) tandem-mass spectrometry (MS/MS) in situ double bond derivatization method using acetonitrile (ACN) as the reagent gas [55]. As this technique does not result in a retention time shift of the derivatized compounds, double bond positions can also be determined for very long-chain HCs that are not amenable to DMDS derivatization. ACN-CI-MS/MS was performed using a Varian 240MS ion-trap mass detector coupled to a Varian 450GC. All analyses were done in the internal ionization configuration. A DB-WAXETR column (30m×0.25mm ID, 0.25μm df; Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA) was used for optimal separation of HC isomers. The split/splitless injector was operated at 250°C in the splitless mode. The GC oven temperature was programmed as follows: 80°C for 2min, 15°C/min to 240°C, hold 30min. Helium was used as the carrier gas at a constant flow rate of 1ml/min. CI spectra were recorded using acetonitrile (ACN) as the reagent gas with a mass range of m/z 60-500. CI-MS/MS experiments with the [M+54]+ adducts of unsaturated HCs as precursor ions were conducted with the resonant waveform type for precursor ion excitation, an isolation window of m/z = 3, and a maximum reaction time of 100ms. The automatic “q” calculator was used for the determination of precursor ion excitation energy and product ion mass range. All CI measurements were conducted with an ion-trap temperature of 220°C, a manifold temperature of 50°C, and a transfer line temperature of 240°C.

Linear retention indices (LRIs) of unsaturated HCs were determined on a DB-5ms column (30m×0.25mm ID, 0.25μm df; Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA) with the following GC oven temperatures: 150°C for 1min, 5°C/min to 300°C, hold 10min. All other settings were identical to the ones used for identification of HCs on the DB-WAXETR column. EI-MS and ACN-CI-MS/MS experiments were used to homologize peaks with those detected on the DB-WAXETR column. Data were analyzed using the MS Workstation software (version 6.9.3, Varian Inc., Palo Alto, CA, USA).

Data analysis

To test for a chemical congruency between the HCs found in the PPG and on the cuticle of T. boharti, a major axis regression analysis between the mean proportions of components in the PPG and on the cuticle was conducted (for further details see Figure S2). The total amounts of substances in the individual samples were calculated by use of the internal standard. For T. boharti the mean amounts in the PPG and on the cuticle were compared with a paired t-test. If not otherwise stated, data given are means ± standard deviation.

For T. elongatus females, we obtained chemical data of the PPG and cuticle of one individual, the head and cuticle of another individual and the cuticles of two further individuals. We checked for a chemical congruence of the PPG, head and cuticle samples by investigation of the chromatographic patterns, by regression analysis and by multivariate statistical analyses (see Figure S3 and Figure S4). The chromatographic patterns as well as the statistical analyses revealed 1) that the chemical profiles of the four individuals were very similar and 2) that there was a strong linear relationship between the PPG/head samples and the corresponding cuticle samples, as has been shown for T. boharti in the present study (see Results) as well as for the closely related P. triangulum [18] and the more distantly related A. compressa [23] in earlier studies. The chemical congruence of PPG and cuticle justifies the inclusion of the cuticle samples in our statistical analyses that test the hypothesis of prey embalming. All further statistical analysis were performed with the dataset containing one sample per T. elongatus individual (N=4 cuticle samples).

To assess whether T. elongatus females embalm their prey, we compared the chemical profiles of T. hyalinata control bees (N=5), the excavated provisioned T. hyalinata bees (N=10) and T. elongatus females (N=4) by investigation of the chromatographic patterns as well as by multivariate statistical analyses. As the different isomers of the alkadienes and alkenes were only partially resolved by chromatography, they were integrated together, which resulted in a total of 22 integrated peaks. The total peak area of each individual extract was standardized to 100% and the relative peak areas were calculated. We visualized differences in the chemical profiles between the groups by non-metric multidimensional scaling (nmMDS), based on Bray-Curtis similarity measures [56,57]. The significance of the differences between groups was assessed by one-way ANOSIM (ANalysis Of SIMilarity) and the chemical compounds primarily responsible for the observed differences between control and provisioned bees were identified using a SIMPER (SIMilarity PERcentage) analysis, both based on Bray-Curtis similarity indices.

The total amount of HCs as well as the proportion of unsaturated HCs on provisioned and control bees was calculated and compared with exact tests for independent samples. All statistical analyses were performed with the statistics software package PAST (Version 2.15, [58]).

Supporting Information

Figure S1.

Mass spectra for (A) 18-pentacosen-6-one and (B) its DMDS adduct.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082780.s001

(TIF)

Figure S2.

Congruence between PPG content and cuticle in T. boharti. The overall chromatographic patterns of PPG and cuticle closely resembled each other. All substances found on the cuticle were also present in the PPG. Twelve compounds were only detected in the PPG but not on the cuticle. As these substances are all minor compounds and the cuticle samples in general contained lower amounts of compounds, the twelve compounds were most probably below the detection limit in the cuticle samples. A major axis regression between the mean relative amounts of eleven selected peaks (representing 17 compounds) revealed a strong linear relationship between the compounds in the gland and the corresponding compounds on the cuticle (R=0.88, P=0.0003, N=10 individuals). Moreover, the linear regression was consistent with a direct proportionality in the proportions of components on the cuticle and in the PPG (y-intercept: -0.04 with 95% confidence interval of -0.30 to 0.35; slope: 1.02 with 95% confidence interval of 0.63 to 1.3).The labels of the data points correspond to the numbers in Table 1. For the regression analysis peak areas were obtained by manual integration using the GC/MS software. The peaks of some substances showed no base-line separation and were hence integrated together and treated as one peak. The total peak area of each individual extract was standardized to 100% and the relative peak areas of all peaks were calculated. Only those peaks that accounted for a mean of at least 1% of the total peak area were included in the analysis. The total peak areas of these remaining peaks were again standardized to 100%, the relative peak areas were calculated and the values normalized by log-transformation. The assumption of congruence requires direct proportionality between the samples, i.e. the slope of the regression line should not differ from 1 and the y-intercept should not differ from 0.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082780.s002

(TIF)

Figure S3.

Congruence between PPG/head and cuticle samples in T. elongatus. A major axis regression between the relative amounts (peak area transformed; Methods analogous to the analysis of T. boharti) of compounds in the PPG/head and on the cuticle of T. elongatus females based on the eight selected peaks revealed a strong linear relationship between the relative amounts of compounds in the PPG/head samples and on the cuticle (R=0.88, P=0.004; y-intercept: 0.058 with 95% confidence interval of -0.53 to 0.93; slope: 0.97 with 95% confidence interval of -0.53 to 2.25).The labels of the data points correspond to the numbers in Table 2.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082780.s003

(TIF)

Figure S4.

Prey embalming by T. elongatus females. Two-dimensional MDS representation of the chemical profiles of individual T. hyalinata control bees (squares), provisioned T. hyalinata bees (circles), and T. elongatus females (triangles) (stress value: 0.092). The ellipses depict the 95% confidence intervals. Of the five collected T. elongatus females we obtained chemical data of the PPG and cuticle of one individual, the head and cuticle of another individual and the cuticles of two further individuals. For a first multivariate data analysis we included all six T. elongatus samples into the data set. Note that the cuticle, PPG and head samples of T. elongatus group closely together. C, cuticle; PPG, postpharyngeal gland; H, head.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082780.s004

(TIF)

Table S1.

Chemical composition of the content of the postpharyngeal gland of T. boharti females with the additional compounds detected only in the pooled (N=10) and fractionated samples (highlighted in grey).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082780.s005

(PDF)

Acknowledgments

We wish to thank Margot Schilling, Agnes Paech and Margit Schimmel for technical assistance.

Author Contributions

Conceived and designed the experiments: GH. Performed the experiments: GH ES MK KW TP JK DK. Analyzed the data: GH. Wrote the manuscript: GH ES.

References

  1. 1. Herzner G, Schlecht A, Dollhofer V, Parzefall C, Harrar K et al. (2013) Larvae of the parasitoid wasp Ampulex compressa sanitize their host, the American cockroach, with a blend of antimicrobials. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 110: 1369-1374. doi:10.1073/pnas.1213384110. PubMed: 23297195.
  2. 2. Kudo S-I, Akagi Y, Hiraoka S, Tanabe T, Morimoto G (2011) Exclusive male egg care and determinants of brooding success in a millipede. Ethology 117: 19-27. doi:10.1111/j.1439-0310.2010.01851.x.
  3. 3. Cotter SC, Topham E, Price AJP, Kilner RM (2010) Fitness costs associated with mounting a social immune response. Ecol Lett 13: 1114-1123. doi:10.1111/j.1461-0248.2010.01500.x. PubMed: 20545735.
  4. 4. Gross J, Schumacher K, Schmidtberg H, Vilcinskas A (2008) Protected by fumigants: beetle perfumes in antimicrobial defense. J Chem Ecol 34: 179-188. doi:10.1007/s10886-007-9416-9. PubMed: 18236110.
  5. 5. Sadd BM, Schmid-Hempel P (2007) Facultative but persistent trans-generational immunity via the mother's eggs in bumblebees. Curr Biol 17: R1046-R1047. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2007.11.007. PubMed: 18088585.
  6. 6. Kaltenpoth M, Göttler W, Herzner G, Strohm E (2005) Symbiotic bacteria protect wasp larvae from fungal infestation. Curr Biol 15: 475-479. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2004.12.084. PubMed: 15753044.
  7. 7. Strohm E, Linsenmair KE (2001) Females of the European beewolf preserve their honeybee prey against competing fungi. Ecol Entomol 26: 198-203. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2311.2001.00300.x.
  8. 8. Hefetz A, Eickwort GC, Blum MS, Cane J, Bohart GE (1982) A comparative study of the exocrine products of cleptoparasitic bees (Holcopasites) and their hosts (Calliopsis) (Hymenoptera: Anthophoridae, Andrenidae). J Chem Ecol 8: 1389-1398. doi:10.1007/BF01403102.
  9. 9. Strohm E, Linsenmair KE (1997) Low resource availability causes extremely male-biased investment ratios in the European beewolf, Philanthus triangulum F. (Hymenoptera: Sphecidae). Proc Royal Soc of Lond B 264: 423-429. doi:10.1098/rspb.1997.0060.
  10. 10. Herzner G, Strohm E (2007) Fighting fungi with physics: food wrapping by a solitary wasp prevents water condensation. Curr Biol 17: R46-R47. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2006.11.060. PubMed: 17240324.
  11. 11. Herzner G, Schmitt T, Peschke K, Hilpert A, Strohm E (2007) Food wrapping with the postpharyngeal gland secretion by females of the European beewolf Philanthus triangulum. J Chem Ecol 33: 849-859. doi:10.1007/s10886-007-9263-8. PubMed: 17334918.
  12. 12. Herzner G, Strohm E (2008) Food wrapping by females of the European Beewolf, Philanthus triangulum, retards water loss of larval provisions. Physiol Entomol 33: 101-109. doi:10.1111/j.1365-3032.2007.00603.x.
  13. 13. Herzner G, Engl T, Strohm E (2011) Cryptic combat against competing microbes is a costly component of parental care in a digger wasp. Anim Behav 82: 321-328. doi:10.1016/j.anbehav.2011.05.006.
  14. 14. Gibbs A (1995) Physical properties of insect cuticular hydrocarbons: Model mixtures and lipid interactions. Comp Biochem Physiology B 112: 667-672. doi:10.1016/0305-0491(95)00119-0.
  15. 15. Gibbs A, Pomonis JG (1995) Physical properties of insect cuticular hydrocarbons: The effects of chain length, methyl-branching and unsaturation. Comp Biochem Physiology B 112: 243-249. doi:10.1016/0305-0491(95)00081-X.
  16. 16. Strohm E, Herzner G, Goettler W (2007) A 'social' gland in a solitary wasp? The postpharyngeal gland of female European beewolves (Hymenoptera, Crabronidae). Arthropod Struct Dev 36: 113-122. doi:10.1016/j.asd.2006.08.007. PubMed: 18089092.
  17. 17. Strohm E, Herzner G, Kaltenpoth M, Boland W, Schreier P et al. (2008) The chemistry of the postpharyngeal gland of female European Beewolves. J Chem Ecol 34: 575-583. doi:10.1007/s10886-008-9447-x. PubMed: 18415061.
  18. 18. Strohm E, Kaltenpoth M, Herzner G (2010) Is the postpharyngeal gland of a solitary digger wasp homologous to ants? Evidence from chemistry and physiology. Insect Soc 57: 285-291. doi:10.1007/s00040-010-0083-4.
  19. 19. Eelen D, Borgesen L, Billen J (2006) Functional morphology of the postpharyngeal gland of queens and workers of the ant Monomorium pharaonis (L.). Acta Zool. (Copenhagen) 87 101-111.
  20. 20. Lucas C, Pho D-B, Fresneau D, Jallon J-M (2004) Hydrocarbon circulation and colonial signature in Pachycondyla villosa. J Insect Physiol 50: 595-607. doi:10.1016/j.jinsphys.2004.04.006. PubMed: 15234620.
  21. 21. Soroker V, Hefetz A, Cojocaru M, Billen J, Franke S et al. (1995) Structural and chemical ontogeny of the postpharyngeal gland in the desert ant Cataglyphis niger. Physiol Entomol 20: 323-329. doi:10.1111/j.1365-3032.1995.tb00822.x.
  22. 22. Herzner G, Goettler W, Kroiss J, Purea A, Webb AG et al. (2007) Males of a solitary wasp possess a postpharyngeal gland. Arthropod Struct Dev 36: 123-133. doi:10.1016/j.asd.2006.08.006. PubMed: 18089093.
  23. 23. Herzner G, Ruther J, Goller S, Schulz S, Goettler W et al. (2011) Structure, chemical composition and putative function of the postpharyngeal gland of the emerald cockroach wasp, Ampulex compressa (Hymenoptera, Ampulicidae). Zoology (Jena) 114: 36-45. doi:10.1016/j.zool.2010.10.002. PubMed: 21256725.
  24. 24. Kroiss J, Schmitt T, Schreier P, Strohm E, Herzner G (2006) A selfish function of a "social" gland? A postpharyngeal gland functions as a sex pheromone reservoir in males of the solitary wasp Philanthus triangulum. J Chem Ecol 32: 2763-2776. doi:10.1007/s10886-006-9198-5. PubMed: 17131184.
  25. 25. Bagnères AG, Morgan ED (1991) The postpharyngeal glands and the cuticle of Formicidae contain the same characteristic hydrocarbons. Experientia 47: 106-111. doi:10.1007/BF02041269.
  26. 26. Soroker V, Vienne C, Nowbahari E, Hefetz A (1994) The postpharyngeal glands as a 'Gestalt' organ for nestmate recognition in the ant Cataglyphis niger. Naturwissenschaften 81: 510-513. doi:10.1007/BF01132686.
  27. 27. Hefetz A, Errard C, Chambris A, Le Negrate A (1996) Postpharyngeal gland secretion as a modifier of aggressive behavior in the myrmecine Ant Manica rubida. J Insect Behav 9: 709-717. doi:10.1007/BF02213551.
  28. 28. Lahav S, Soroker V, Hefetz A, Vander Meer RK (1999) Direct behavioral evidence for hydrocarbons as ant recognition discriminators. Naturwissenschaften 86: 246-249. doi:10.1007/s001140050609.
  29. 29. Pulawski WJ (2013) Catalog of Sphecidae. San Francisco, SA: California Academy of Sciences. Available: . http://research.calacademy.org/ent/catalog_sphecidae. Accessed 31 August 2013.
  30. 30. Bohart RM, Menke AS (1976) Sphecid wasps of the world. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. 695 pp.
  31. 31. Alexander BA (1992) A Cladistic Analysis Of The Subfamily Philanthinae Hymenoptera Sphecidae. Syst Entomol 17: 91-108. doi:10.1111/j.1365-3113.1992.tb00324.x.
  32. 32. Koedam D, Slaa EJ, Biesmeijer JC, Nogueira-Neto P (2009) Unsuccessful attacks dominate a drone-preying wasp’s hunting performance near stingless bee nests. Genet Mol Res 8: 690-702. doi:10.4238/vol8-2kerr032. PubMed: 19554768.
  33. 33. Koedam D, Morgan ED, Nunes TM, Patricio EDAFLRA, Imperatriz-Fonseca VL (2011) Selective preying of the sphecid wasp Trachypus boharti on the meliponine bee Scaptotrigona postica: potential involvement of caste-specific cuticular hydrocarbons. Physiol Entomol 36: 187-193. doi:10.1111/j.1365-3032.2010.00769.x.
  34. 34. Polidori C, Boesi R, Ruz L, Montalva J, Andrietti F (2009) Prey spectrum and predator-size relationship of the solitary wasp, Trachypus denticollis, in central Chile (Hymenoptera: Crabronidae). Stud Neotrop Fauna E 44: 55-60. doi:10.1080/01650520902861531.
  35. 35. Evans HE, O´Neill KM (1988) The natural history and behavior of North American beewolves. Ithaca and London: Comstock Publishing Associates. 278 pp.
  36. 36. Kaltenpoth M, Goettler W, Dale C, Stubblefield JW, Herzner G et al. (2006) 'Candidatus Streptomyces philanthi', an endosymbiotic streptomycete in the antennae of Philanthus digger wasps. Int J Syst Evol Micr 56: 1403-1411. doi:10.1099/ijs.0.64117-0.
  37. 37. Koehler S, Doubský J, Kaltenpoth M (2013) Dynamics of symbiont-mediated antibiotic production reveal efficient long-term protection for beewolf offspring. Front Zool 10: 3. doi:10.1186/1742-9994-10-3. PubMed: 23369509.
  38. 38. Kroiss J, Kaltenpoth M, Schneider B, Schwinger MG, Hertweck C et al. (2010) Symbiotic streptomycetes provide antibiotic combination prophylaxis for wasp offspring. Nat Chem Biol 6: 261-263. doi:10.1038/nchembio.331. PubMed: 20190763.
  39. 39. Kaltenpoth M, Schmitt T, Polidori C, Koedam D, Strohm E (2010) Symbiotic streptomycetes in antennal glands of the South American digger wasp genus Trachypus (Hymenoptera, Crabronidae). Physiol Entomol 35: 196-200. doi:10.1111/j.1365-3032.2010.00729.x.
  40. 40. Kaltenpoth M, Yildirim E, Gürbüz MF, Herzner G, Strohm E (2012) Refining the roots of the beewolf-Streptomyces symbiosis: Antennal symbionts in the rare genus Philanthinus (Hymenoptera, Crabronidae). Appl Environ Microbiol 78: 822-827. doi:10.1128/AEM.06809-11. PubMed: 22113914.
  41. 41. Noirot C, Quennedey A (1974) Fine structure of insect epidermal glands. Annu Rev Entomol 19: 61-80. doi:10.1146/annurev.en.19.010174.000425.
  42. 42. Quennedey A (1998) Insect Epidermal Gland Cells: Ultrastructure and Morphogenesis. In: F. HarrisonM. Locke. Microscopic Anatomy of Invertebrates. New York: Wiley-Liss, Inc.. pp. 177-207.
  43. 43. Yasui H, Akino T, Yasuda T, Fukaya M, Ono H et al. (2003) Ketone components in the contact sex pheromone of the white-spotted longicorn beetle, Anoplophora malasiaca, and pheromonal activity of synthetic ketones. Entomol Exp Appl 107: 167-176. doi:10.1046/j.1570-7458.2003.00053.x.
  44. 44. Soroker V, Hefetz A (2000) Hydrocarbon site of synthesis and circulation in the desert ant Cataglyphis niger. J Insect Physiol 46: 1097-1102. doi:10.1016/S0022-1910(99)00219-X. PubMed: 10817835.
  45. 45. Akino T, Yamamura K, Wakamura S, Yamaoka R (2004) Direct behavioral evidence for hydrocarbons as nestmate recognition cues in Formica japonica (Hymenoptera: Formicidae). Appl Entomol Zool 39: 381-387. doi:10.1303/aez.2004.381.
  46. 46. Strohm E, Linsenmair KE (1997) Female size affects provisioning and sex allocation in a digger wasp. Anim Behav 54: 23-34. doi:10.1006/anbe.1996.0431. PubMed: 9268432.
  47. 47. Schubert R (1984) Lehrbuch der Ökologie. Jena: VEB Gustav Fischer Verlag. 595p.
  48. 48. Patricio Eflra, Cruz-López L, Maile R, Tentschert J, Jones GR et al. (2002) The propolis of stingless bees: terpenes from the tibia of three Frieseomelitta species. J Insect Physiol 48: 249-254. doi:10.1016/S0022-1910(01)00170-6. PubMed: 12770125.
  49. 49. Leonhardt SD, Blüthgen N, Schmitt T (2009) Smelling like resin: terpenoids account for species-specific cuticular profiles in Southeast-Asian stingless bees. Insect Soc 56: 157-170. doi:10.1007/s00040-009-0007-3.
  50. 50. Gershenzon J, Dudareva N (2007) The function of terpene natural products in the natural world. Nat Chem Biol 3: 408-414. doi:10.1038/nchembio.2007.5. PubMed: 17576428.
  51. 51. Adam H, Czihak G (1964) Arbeitsmethoden der makroskopischen und mikroskopischen Anatomie. Stuttgart: Gustav Fischer Verlag. 583pp.
  52. 52. Francis GW, Veland K (1981) Alkylthiolation for the determination of double-bond positions in linear alkenes. J Chromatogr 219: 379-384.
  53. 53. Howard RW (1993) Cuticular hydrocarbons and chemical communication. In: DW Stanley-SamuelsonDR Nelson. Insect Lipids: Chemistry, biochemistry and biology. University of Nebraska Press. pp. 179-226.
  54. 54. Witte V, Foitzik S, Hashim R, Maschwitz U, Schulz S (2009) Fine tuning of social integration by two myrmecophiles of the ponerine army ant, Leptogenys distinguenda. J Chem Ecol 35: 355-367. doi:10.1007/s10886-009-9606-8. PubMed: 19234744.
  55. 55. Kroiss J, Svatoš A, Kaltenpoth M (2011) Rapid identification of insect cuticular hydrocarbons using gas chromatography - ion-trap mass spectrometry. J Chem Ecol 37: 420-427. doi:10.1007/s10886-011-9933-4. PubMed: 21431866.
  56. 56. Legendre P, Legendre L (1998) Numerical Ecology. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science B.V..
  57. 57. Clarke K, Green R (1988) Statistical design and analysis for a 'biological effects' study. Mar Ecol - Progress Ser 46: 213-226. doi:10.3354/meps046213.
  58. 58. Hammer Ø, Harper DAT, Ryan PD (2001) PAST: Paleontological statistics software package for education and data analysis. Paleontologia Electronica 4: Art. 4:: 9pp.