Browse Subject Areas

Click through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in your field.

For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click here.

  • Loading metrics

Identification of Ochratoxin A Producing Fungi Associated with Fresh and Dry Liquorice

  • Amanda Juan Chen,

    Affiliation Institute of Medicinal Plant Development, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, P.R. China

  • Dan Tang,

    Affiliation Institute of Medicinal Plant Development, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, P.R. China

  • Ying Qun Zhou,

    Affiliation China National Corporation of Traditional & Herbal Medicine, Beijing, P.R. China

  • Bing Da Sun,

    Affiliation China General Microbiological Culture Collection Center, Institute of Microbiology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, P.R. China

  • Xiao Jin Li,

    Affiliation Xinjiang Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine and Ethnicdrug, Urumchi, P.R. China

  • Li Zhi Wang,

    Affiliation Institute of Medicinal Plant Development, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, P.R. China

  • Wei Wei Gao

    Affiliation Institute of Medicinal Plant Development, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, P.R. China

Identification of Ochratoxin A Producing Fungi Associated with Fresh and Dry Liquorice

  • Amanda Juan Chen, 
  • Dan Tang, 
  • Ying Qun Zhou, 
  • Bing Da Sun, 
  • Xiao Jin Li, 
  • Li Zhi Wang, 
  • Wei Wei Gao


The presence of fungi on liquorice could contaminate the crop and result in elevated levels of mycotoxin. In this study, the mycobiota associated with fresh and dry liquorice was investigated in 3 producing regions of China. Potential toxigenic fungi were tested for ochratoxin A (OTA) and aflatoxin B1 (AFB1) production using liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry/mass spectrometry. Based on a polyphasic approach using morphological characters, β-tubulin and RNA polymerase II second largest subunit gene phylogeny, a total of 9 genera consisting of 22 fungal species were identified, including two new Penicillium species (Penicillium glycyrrhizacola sp. nov. and Penicillium xingjiangense sp. nov.). The similarity of fungal communities associated with fresh and dry liquorice was low. Nineteen species belonging to 8 genera were detected from fresh liquorice with populations affiliated with P. glycyrrhizacola, P. chrysogenum and Aspergillus insuetus comprising the majority (78.74%, 33.33% and 47.06% of total) of the community from Gansu, Ningxia and Xinjiang samples, respectively. In contrast, ten species belonging to 4 genera were detected from dry liquorice with populations affiliated with P. chrysogenum, P. crustosum and Aspergillus terreus comprising the majority (64.00%, 52.38% and 90.91% of total) of the community from Gansu, Ningxia and Xinjiang samples, respectively. Subsequent LC/MS/MS analysis indicated that 5 fungal species were able to synthesize OTA in vitro including P. chrysogenum, P. glycyrrhizacola, P. polonicum, Aspergillus ochraceus and A. westerdijkiae, the OTA concentration varied from 12.99 to 39.03 µg/kg. AFB1 was absent in all tested strains. These results demonstrate the presence of OTA producing fungi on fresh liquorice and suggest that these fungi could survive on dry liquorice after traditional sun drying. Penicillium chrysogenum derived from surrounding environments is likely to be a stable contributor to high OTA level in liquorice. The harvesting and processing procedure needs to be monitored in order to keep liquorice free of toxigenic fungi.


Liquorice, the root of the leguminous Glycyrrhiza plant species (Glycyrrhiza uralensis Fisch., Glycyrrhiza inflate Bat. and Glycyrrhiza glabra L.), is a popular botanical with a long history of cultivation and use in China. In Traditional Chinese Medicine, liquorice is one of the most frequently used herbs, which exerts antitussive, expectorant and antipyrotic functions and is often used to treat cough, pharyngitis, bronchitis and bronchial asthma [1]. In addition, liquorice is a common dietary supplement and its derivatives have been given Generally Recognized as Safe (GRAS) status in the USA in 1985 [2]. Likewise, liquorice and its derivatives are used as flavoring and sweetening agents in confectionery and other food products, such as beverages and chewing gum [3,4]. China is one of the largest liquorice producing regions. According to customs statistics in 2011, 3300 tons of liquorices were exported to Japan, Korea, Germany and the United States, among other countries. The wild plants of liquorice (G. uralensis, G. inflate and G. glabra) are primarily distributed in arid desert and grassland areas in Gansu, Ningxia, Xinjiang and Inner Mongolia in northwest China, among which G. uralensis is the most widely distributed variety [5].

Ochratoxin A (OTA) and Aflatoxin B1 (AFB1) are mycotoxins that cause adverse health effects in animals including teratogenicity, immunotoxicity, genotoxicity and mutagenicity [6,7]. The presence of ochratoxin A in liquorice was first reported in Germany by Bresch et al. and Majerus et al. [8,9]. Consequent studies confirmed widespread and high contamination of OTA in foods containing liquorice, sometimes with values exceeding 200 µg/kg [10,11]. In Spain, analysis of 30 samples of liquorice root, liquorice confectionery, liquorice block, and liquorice extract indicated that all samples contained OTA; the dry roots contained the highest OTA at levels of 1.4-252.8 µg/kg [12]. In China, 5 moldy liquorice samples were found to be contaminated with OTA at levels ranging 1.3-84.4 µg/kg [13]. Although liquorice and its derivatives were not main contributors to dietary intake of OTA, it cannot be excluded that liquorice confectionery may contribute to the level of exposure in consumers, in particular in children. In a worst case scenario, children with elevated intake of liquorice confectionary could reach the 8.94% tolerable weekly intake (TWI) [10]. In comparison with OTA, aflatoxin contamination of liquorice was found to be very low [14], the reason of this difference was still unknown.

OTA is mainly produced by several Penicillium and Aspergillus species, notably Penicillium verrucosum and Aspergillus ochraceus, but also A. carbonarius and A. niger species [15]. In a series of recent reviews and papers, more than 25 species of Penicillium were listed as OTA producers [16-18]. However Frisvad et al. [19] excluded most of them, and only accepted P. verrucosum and P. nordicum as major OTA producer in the Penicillia. With respect to liquorice, Chen et al. [20,21] found that P. polonicum and P. chrysogenum were the primary OTA contributors in moldy liquorice in China. However, the distribution pattern of these toxigenic fungi in regularly consumed liquorice is still unknown. In this study, both fresh and dry liquorice were collected from the major producing regions in China. The distribution of OTA producing fungi in Chinese liquorice and their pollution ways were studied in detail.

Materials and Methods

Sample collection

Samples of fresh liquorice (G. uralensis) were collected from Gansu province (N 38°38’18’’, E 103°05’25’’, permitted by The Forestry Department of Gansu province), Ningxia province (N 37°46’55’’, E 107°24’18’’, permitted by The Forestry Department of Ningxia province) and Xinjiang province (N 42°17’59’’, E 86°24’18’’, permitted by The Forestry Department of Xinjiang province) in China. Twenty to 30 healthy wild liquorice roots were dug out carefully at each site and were gently shaken to remove superficial soil. Cleaned roots were then placed into sterile paper bags. Dry liquorice roots were collected from relevant local markets in Gansu, Ningxia and Xinjiang province. For each site, about 1 kg roots were collected from 5 different herbal stores and put into sterile paper bags. Samples from Gansu and Ningxia were whole dry roots which were dried in the sun at each respective locality while those from Xinjiang were herbal slices of roots, which were made from whole dry roots in the local processing factory. The temperatures of each sampling sites were 21.7°C, 20.0 °C, 17.1°C, and relative humidity 14%, 13%, 15% in Gansu, Ningxia and Xinjiang, respectively. All paper bags containing liquorice samples were transported to the lab in Beijing within 3 days of collection.

Isolation of fungi

Entire liquorice roots were cut into pieces with sterile scissors; herbal slices of roots were directly used for fungal isolation. Ten g of each sample was added to 90 ml sterile water and mixed. This mixture was then shaken on a rotary shaker for approximately 30 min and subjected to a series of ten-fold serial dilution to a final concentration of 10-3. Aliquots consisting of 1 ml of each dilution were spread (in quadruplicate) on Rose Bengal Chloramphenicol Agar (RBCA). One of the three sets of dilutions that averaged between 10 and 60 colonies per plate was selected for enumeration. The results of quadruplicate plating were expressed as the average CFU/g. All of the plates were incubated at 25 °C for 7 to 10 days and were subsequently stored at 4 °C for future colony isolation and identification.

Identification of fungi

Followed by preliminary morphological identification, every fungal colony was transferred and re-streaked onto Malt Extract Agar (MEA). With respect to new Penicillium species, colonies on Czapek Yeast Autolysate Agar (CYA) and Yeast Extract Sucrose Agar (YES) cultivated at 25 °C for 7 days were also compared and described. Colony colour was assessed according to The Methuen Handbook of Colour by Kornerup and Wanscher [22]. Other macroscopical and microscopic morphological observations (eg. colony texture, conidiophore and conidia characteristics) were made according to proper guides [23-26]. To verify the results of morphological characterization and identification of fungi, the β-tubulin gene and the second largest RNA polymerase II subunit (RPBII) gene were PCR amplified and sequenced. In total, 126 isolates affiliated with Aspergillus and Penicillium were subjected to PCR amplification of the β-tubulin gene using the primer pair Bt2a 5'-GGTAACCAAATCGGTGCTGCTTTC-3' and Bt2b 5'-ACCCTCA GTGTAG TGACCCTTGGC-3' [27]. A part of RPBII gene were amplified from these strains with the primer pair RPB2-5F_Pc 5’- GATGACCGTGACCACTTCGG-3’ and RPB2-7CR_Pc 7CR 5’-CCCATGGCTTGTTTGCCCAT-3’ [28]. With respect to fungal species other than Penicillium and Aspergillus spp., ITS gene was amplified by using the primers ITS4 5'- TCCTCCGCTTATTGATATGC -3' and ITS5 5'- GGAAGTAAAAGTCGTAACAAGG -3' [29]. Basic Local Alignment Search Tool (BLAST) was used to identify the closest affiliated sequence in the GenBank/NCBI dataset.

Phylogenetic tree construction

Phylogenetic analyses were conducted in order to better understand the evolutionary history of isolates using the obtained partial β-tubulin and RPBII genes. Sequences of selected strains along with reference sequences obtained from GenBank (Table 1) were aligned using Clustal X [30]. Alignment was manually trimmed at the N and C terminals to delete non-overlapping alignment regions with the MEGA5 program [31]. Phylogenetic analyses using the neighbor-joining method [32] was performed with the same program. The neighbor-joining tree was constructed specifying 1) the Kimura 2-parameter model, 2) transitions and transversions and 3) with pairwise deletion of gaps. The phylogeny was subjected to 1000 bootstrap replicates. All phylograms were rooted with gene sequences from A. westerdijkiae.

Taxon nameCollection No.OriginGenBank Accession number
Penicillium aethiopicumCBS484.84 TGrain, EthiopiaAY495983 JF909940
P. aurantiogriseumCBS 324.89 TUnknownAY674296JN406573
CBS 792.95Apple juice production plant, DenmarkAY674298JN985381
CBS 642.95 Chicken feed, DenmarkAY674297JN985380
P. chrysogenum CBS 306.48 TCheese, USAAY495981JF909937
NRRL 807 TCheese, USAJF909943JF909925
CBS 355.48 TDecaying branch, NorwayJF909948JF909930
CGMCC3.15262(G1433)Liquorice, China, GansuKF021541 KF021564
CGMCC3.15263(G3311)Liquorice, China, GansuKF021539 KF021552
CGMCC3.15266(G6523)Liquorice, China, GansuKF021542KF021551
CGMCC3.15265(ND3341)Liquorice, China, NingxiaKF021545 KF021565
P. confertumCBS171.87 TCheek pouch, USAAY674373JF909934
P. cyclopiumCBS 144.45 TFruit, NorwayAY674310JN985388
CBS 477.84Grain, DenmarkAY674309JN985393
CBS 101136Harness, Saudi Arabia AY674308JN985383
P. dipodomyisCBS110412 TCheek pouch, USAAY495991JF909932
CBS 170.87Cheek pouch, USAAY495989JX996707
P. flavigenumCBS 419.89 TFlour, DenmarkAY495993JF909939
CBS110411Barley, CanadaJX996830JX996694
P. freii CBS 794.95Chicken feed (cereal), DenmarkAY674290JN985430
CBS 112292Barley, DenmarkAY674292JN985397
P. gladioliCBS 332.48 TCorm of Gladiolus sp., USAAY674287JN406567
CBS815.70Corm of Gladiolus sp., IndiaAY674289
P. glycyrrhizacola sp. nov.CGMCC3.15271(G4432) TLiquorice, China, GansuKF021538KF021554
CGMCC3.15269(G1411)Liquorice, China, GansuKF021540 KF021556
CGMCC3.15273(74212) TLiquorice, China, XingjiangKF021543 KF021553
CGMCC3.15270(G2312)Liquorice, China, GansuKF021546 KF021555
P. melanoconidiumCBS 640.95Panicum miliaceum imported to DenmarkAY674303JN985431
CBS 218.90 Hordeum vulgare, DenmarkAY674302JN985404
P. mononematosumCBS172.87 THeavily moulded seed, USAAY495997JF909935
P. nalgiovenseCBS 352.48 TEllischauer cheese, CzechoslovakiaAY495999JF909938
CBS 109610UnknownJX996825JX996689
P. neoechinulatumCBS 101135 TCheek pouch, USAAY674299JN985406
CBS 110343Seed cache, USAAY674300JN985409
P. nordicumCBS 109538Fish feed, DenmarkAY674314
CBS 109537Jam, JapanAY674315
CBS 109541Lumpsucker, DenmarkAY674316
CBS 112573Salami, ItalyAY674317
CBS 110770Sausage, GermanyAY674318
P. persicinumCBS 111235 TSoil, ChinaAY495982 JF909933
P. polonicumCBS 222.28 TSoil, PolandAY674305JN406609
CBS 101479 Foods, BulgariaAY674306JN985410
CGMCC3.15264(G3323)Liquorice, China, GansuKF021548 KF021558
CGMCC3.15272(G5314)Liquorice, China, GansuKF021549KF021559
CGMCC3.15221(16524)Liquorice, China, JiangxiHM347088KF021562
CGMCC3.15222(23226)Liquorice, China, HenanHM347089KF021563
P. tricolorCBS635.93 TTriticum aestivum, CanadaAY674313JN985422
CBS 637.93Triticum aestivum, CanadaAY674312JN985423
P. verrucosum CBS 603.74Unknown, BelgiumAY674323JN121539
CBS 115508UnknownAY674324
P. viridicatumCBS 390.48 TAir, USAAY674295JN985429
CBS 109826Cereal, BulgariaAY674294JN985426
P. xingjiangense sp. nov.CGMCC3.15274(84513)Liquorice, China, XingjiangKF021544 KF021557
Aspergillus ochraceusCGMCC3.15267(74124)Liquorice, China, XingjiangKF021560
A. westerdijkiaeCGMCC3.15268(84424)Liquorice, China, XingjiangKF021547KF021561

Table 1. Strains used in phylogenetic analysis.

Download CSV


The electronic version of this article in Portable Document Format (PDF) in a work with an ISSN or ISBN will represent a published work according to the International Code of Nomenclature for algae, fungi, and plants, and hence the new names contained in the electronic publication of a PLOS ONE article are effectively published under that Code from the electronic edition alone, so there is no longer any need to provide printed copies. In addition, new names contained in this work have been submitted to MycoBank from where they will be made available to the Global Names Index. The unique MycoBank number MB804682 and MB804683 can be resolved and the associated information viewed through any standard web browser by appending the MycoBank number contained in this publication to the prefix The online version of this work is archived and available from the following digital repositories: PubMed Central, LOCKSS etc.

OTA and AFB1 determination of fungal strains by liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry/mass spectrometry (LC/MS/MS)

Fungal strains were grown on sterile rice media (20 g rice; 20 ml water, sterilize for 30 min) for 30 days at 25 °C. After incubation, all cultures were treated at 60 °C for three days to dry the mycelial mat and then finely grounded using a grinder. About 20 g mat material and 100 ml methanol-water (80/20) was mixted and extracted using ultrasonography for 45 min and filtered. The filtrate was purified by solid phase extraction (SPE) (NERCB-SPE, 100 mg/3 ml, Beijing, China). LC/MS/MS analysis was performed with an Agilent 1200 series high-performance liquid chromatograph (HPLC) (Palo Alto, CA, USA) interfaced to a 3200Q Trap triple-quadrupole linear ion-trap MS/MS system (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA). The sample was separated using a XbridgeTM C18 column (150 × 2.1 mm, 3.5 µm) (Waters, Milford, Massachusetts, USA) with acetonitrile- water containing 5 mM ammonium acetate. OTA and AFB1 were detected with ESI in positive mode. The collision energy (CE) was 40.0 V. The MRM model was used for quantitative calculation. The ion pairs at m/z 404/358 and m/z 313/285 were employed to analyze OTA and AFB1, respectively. The limits of detection (LOD) and the limits of quantification (LOQ) were less than 0.024 and 0.095 µg/kg, respectively [33].

Statistical analysis

Isolation frequency was determined as the number of isolates of one species divided by the total number of isolates obtained. The species diversity was estimated using the Shannon-Wiener index (H´) according to the formula: H'=-i=1nPi1nPi[34], where Pi is the proportion of the ith species and n is the number of species at the site. The Bray-Curtis similarity coefficient (C) was used to estimate the similarity of fungal communities as C = 2w/(a+b) [35], where w is the sum of the lesser counts of each species common to both sites, a and b were the sum of all isolates obtained in each site.

The software SPSS 15.0 was used for the statistical data analysis. Analyses were made of fungal colony counts of different regions by standard χ2 tests. Multiple pairwise comparisons were performed using the Table procedure of SPSS software and the Bonferroni method was used to adjust P-values.


Phylogeny and Taxonomy of Fungal Species

All fungal strains were identified according to morphological and molecular characteristics. With respect to confusing species and potential toxigenic species, twelve β-tubulin and 15 RPBII sequences were included in the analysis. In addition, forty-one and 32 sequences recovered from GenBank that were associated with Penicillium subgenus Penicillium sect. Viridicata and sect. Chrysogena, respectively, were included as references. Figure 1 indicates that members of the sect. Viridicata and Chrysogena formed two separate clades. Penicillium polonicum strain CGMCC3.15272 (G5314) clustered with type species CBS 222.28. Penicillium polonicum strain CGMCC3.15264 (G3323) was excluded from this clade, but subsequent morphological observations (blue green conidia on CYA and YES) suggests that it should be included in this lineage. In clade Chrysogena, described P. chrysogenum strains formed an independent lineage that clustered with type species CBS 306.48. Two new branches were separated from other known species with rather high bootstrap value. Combined with detailed morphological observation, they were identified as two new species, namely Penicillium glycyrrhizacola sp. nov. and Penicillium xingjiangense sp. nov.. The phylogenetic position of isolates when the RPBII sequence was used is in full agreement with that when β-tubulin sequence was used. (Figure 2)

Figure 1. Neighbor-joining tree inferred from partial β-tubulin genes showing the relationships among members of Penicillium subgenus Penicillium sect.

Viridicata and sect. Chrysogena. The tree is rooted with the β -tubulin gene from Aspergillus westerdijkiae.

Figure 2. Neighbor-joining tree inferred from partial RPBII genes showing the relationships among members of Penicillium subgenus Penicillium sect.

Viridicata and sect. Chrysogena. The tree is rooted with the RPBII gene from Aspergillus westerdijkiae.

Penicillium glycyrrhizacola Chen, Sun & Gao, sp. nov. Figure 3.

Figure 3. Penicillium glycyrrhizacola sp. nov. A-C. 7-day old colonies on A. CYA, B. MEA, C. YES, D-F.

Conidiophores. G. Conidia. Scale bar = 10 µm.

Mycobank no.: MB804682

Colonies on CYA at 25°C reaching 23-34 mm diam. in 7 d, floccose, radially furrowed; mycelium white to grayish green (25B3), exudates rarely present, clear, reverse grayish yellow (33C) to white at center.

Colonies on MEA at 25°C reaching 23-34 mm diam. in 7 d, floccose to velutinous; mycelium grayish green (25B3); sporulation heavy on entire surface of colonies, reverse white.

Colonies on YES at 25°C reaching 31-38 mm diam. in 7 d, velvety, crater-like or convoluted at center, radially furrowed, mycelium white to grayish green (25C3), reverse grayish yellow (33C) to white.

Conidiophores borne from surface or subsurface hyphae, stipes commonly 150-300 ×2.5-3.5 µm, ter- and quarter verticillate, divergent rami born from aerial and subsurface hyphae; rami 13-20×3.0-4.0 µm; metulae in verticals of 3-5, short and appressed, 9-12×2.5-3.5 µm, phialides 4-7 per vertical, ampilliform 8-10×2.5-3 µm. Conidia ellipsoidal to subspheroidal, smooth walled, 2.2-2.6 × 2.5-3.2 µm.

Habitat: Liquorice, China

Holotype: China, Gansu, from liquorice, CGMCC3.15271 (G4432), specimen deposited in Herbarium Mycologicum Academiae Sinicae HMAS 244707; Paratype: China, Xingjiang, from liquorice, CGMCC3.15273 (74212), HMAS 244708.

Distinguishing characteristics: Penicillium glycyrrhizacola shares many characters in common with P. chrysogenum, but differs by the grayish green colony on CYA and MEA, rarely present clear exudates and absent soluble pigment.

Penicillium xingjiangense Chen, Sun & Gao, sp. nov. Figure 4.

Figure 4. Penicillium xingjiangense sp. nov. A-C. 7-day old colonies on A. CYA, B. MEA, C. YES, D-F.

Conidiophores. G. Conidia. Scale bar = 10 µm.

Mycobank no.: MB804683

Colonies on CYA at 25°C reaching 29-32 mm diam. in 7 d, floccose, radially furrowed; mycelium white to pale yellow (4A3), exudates clear, reverse grayish yellow (3C3).

Colonies on MEA at 25°C reaching 20-24 mm diam. in 7 d, floccose to velutinous; mycelium grayish green (4B3) at centre, turquoise white (24A2) towards white at margin; sporulation heavy on entire surface of colonies, reverse white.

Colonies on YES at 25°C reaching 39-45 mm diam. in 7 d, velvety, radially furrowed, mycelium orange grey (6B2), reverse pale yellow (1A3).

Conidiophores borne from surface or subsurface hyphae, stipes commonly 100-300 ×3.0-3.2 µm, ter- and quarter verticillate, divergent rami born from aerial and subsurface hyphae; rami 21-30×3.0-3.2 µm; metulae in verticals of 2-5, thin and appressed, 9-13×2.0-3.0 µm, phialides 5-7 per vertical, ampilliform 8-10×2-3 µm. Conidia mostly globose, smooth walled, 2.0-2.2 × 2.8-3.2 µm.

Habitat: Liquorice, China

Holotype: China, Xingjiang, from liquorice, CGMCC3.15274 (84513), specimen deposited in Herbarium Mycologicum Academiae Sinicae, HMAS 244709.

Distinguishing characteristics: Penicillium xingjiangense is closely relate to P. confertum and P. mononematosum, but differs by the white to pale yellow colony on CYA and thin metulae.

Comparison of fungal community on fresh and dry liquorice

Total fungal counts ranged from 300 to 3400 CFU/g on fresh liquorice sampled from 3 production areas; nineteen species of fungi belonging to 8 genera were detected among these CFUs (Table 2). The fungal community associated with fresh liquorice showed high species diversity with the Shannon-Weiner index (H’) of 1.971. Penicillium and Aspergillus were the two most predominant genera detected in association with fresh liquorice, representing 49.57% and 24.98% of the total CFUs respectively. Penicillium glycyrrhizacola, P. chrysogenum and A. insuetus were the most common species on fresh liquorice from Gansu, Ningxia and Xinjiang province; Penicillium chrysogenum was the only species which was detected from all three of the production areas. In contrast, a total of 2200 to 9375 CFU were obtained per g dry liquorice. Among these CFUs, ten species belonging to 4 genera were detected. The fungal community associated with dry liquorice showed low species diversity as evinced by a Shannon-Weiner index (H’) as 1.755 when compared to 1.971 associated with the fresh liquorice. Like fresh liquorice, Penicillium and Aspergillus were the two most abundant genera detected, representing 73.54% and 14.26% of the CFUs. P. chrysogenum was the most common species on dry liquorice from Gansu and could be detected in both Ningxia and Xinjiang samples while with relative low frequency. Seven fungal species could be detected in association with both fresh and dry liquorice which including A. westerdijkiae, Eurotium amstelodami, Penicillium aurantiogriseum, P. chrysogenum, P. crustosum, P. glycyrrhizacola and P. polonicum. The similarity of fungal communities between fresh and dry liquorice was 22% (Bray-Curtis index). Among the three production areas examined, the most similar dry and fresh liquorice fungal communities were found in Gansu, with a Bray-Curtis index of 31.78%, followed by Ningxia (Bray-Curtis index = 6.67%) and Xinjiang (Bray-Curtis index = 4.46%).

Fungal speciesfresh liquorice dry liquorice
Gansu   Ningxia   XinjiangGansu   Ningxia   Xinjiang
Acremonium kiliense0.74
Actinomucor elegans0.74
Aspergillus dimorphicus9.56
Aspergillus insuetus47.06
Aspergillus ochraceus1.33
Aspergillus terreus90.91
Aspergillus westerdijkiae7.35 1.33
Cladosporium cladosporioides1.47
Eurotium amstelodami33.33 1.33
Eurotium repens0.92 22.79
Metarhizium anisopliae0.18
Mucor racemosus42.86
Penicillium aurantiogriseum0.18 4.00
Penicillium chrysogenum 7.58 33.33 3.68 64.00 4.76 9.09
Penicillium citrinum 3.68
Penicillium coprophilum0.74
Penicillium crustosum5.36 16.67 52.38
Penicillium glycyrrhizacola78.74 1.47 16.00
Penicillium griseofulvum1.11
Penicillium polonicum 5.91 12.00
Penicillium xingjiangense 0.74
Talaromyces flavus16.67
Total counts (CFU/g)2705 300 3400 9375 4200 2200

Table 2. Frequency (%) of fungi associated with fresh and dry liquorice of 3 production areas in China.

Download CSV

OTA and AFB1 production by selected strains

Among the 21 fungal species obtained in this study, 5 species (P. polonicum, P. chrysogenum, P. crustosum, A. ochraceus and A. westerdijkiae) were classified as potentially being toxigenic [1618,21]. Accordingly, 21 strains belonging to these five species and 2 new species P. glycyrrhizacola and P. xingjiangense were screened for OTA and AFB1 production. OTA could be detected in 6 strains belong to 5 species (Table 3). A chromatogram with the mass spectrum from an OTA positive sample is depicted in Figure 5. As shown in Table 3, P. chrysogenum, P. glycyrrhizacola, P. polonicum, A. ochraceus and A. westerdijkiae could produce OTA. The OTA concentration varied among the isolates from 12.99 to 39.03 µg/kg. AFB1 was absent in all tested strains.

Sample No.Taxon nameStrain No.SubstratumOriginOTA(µg/kg)AFB1(µg/kg)
1Penicillium chrysogenumCGMCC3.15262(G1433)fresh liquoriceGansu province, Chinan.d.n.d.
2CGMCC3.15263(G3311)fresh liquoriceGansu province, Chinan.d.n.d.
3CGMCC3.15265(ND3341)fresh liquoriceNingxia province, China26.62n.d.
4CGMCC3.15266(G6523)dry liquoriceGansu province, Chinan.d.n.d.
5P. glycyrrhizacolaCGMCC3.15271(G4432) Tfresh liquoriceGansu province, Chinan.d.n.d.
6CGMCC3.15269(G1411)fresh liquoriceGansu province, Chinan.d.n.d.
7CGMCC3.15270(G2312)fresh liquoriceGansu province, Chinan.d.n.d.
8CGMCC3.15273(74212) Tfresh liquoriceXinjiang province, China 30.44 n.d.
9P. polonicumCGMCC3.15264(G3323)fresh liquoriceGansu province, China12.99n.d.
10CGMCC3.15272(G5314)dry liquoriceGansu province, China39.03n.d.
11Aspergillus ochraceusCGMCC3.15267(74124)fresh liquoriceXinjiang province, China 26.48n.d.
12A. westerdijkiaeCGMCC3.15268(84424)fresh liquoriceXinjiang province, China 17.26n.d.

Table 3. OTA and AFB1 production by fungal species*.

*Only OTA positive species were listed here
Download CSV
Figure 5. LC-MS/MS chromatography for OTA positive strain CGMCC3.15268 (84424) with Q1 mode.

Ions at m/z 404 and m/z 358 were selected as characteristic signals of OTA, while the ion at m/z 406 containing 37Cl was a reference.


This study provides the first comprehensive evidence for the presence of OTA producing fungi on fresh and dry liquorice from China and provides a comprehensive assessment of the associated communities. Two new Penicillium species (Penicillium glycyrrhizacola sp. nov. and Penicillium xingjiangense sp. nov.) were identified and characterized genetically and morphologically. Importantly, one of these species, P. glycyrrhizacola, was the dominant fungus detected on fresh liquorice sampled from Gansu province.

Fungal contamination on dry liquorice has been the subject of many investigations [36,37], however OTA producing fungi on liquorice has rarely been reported. Chen et al. [21] investigated toxigenic fungi associated with OTA contaminated and moldy liquorice. According to their finding, the predominant fungal species differed based on the location of liquorice sampling; only P. polonicum and P. chrysogenum contributed to high OTA levels in the moldy liquorice samples that were tested. Moldy liquorice resulting from improper storage will not be processed or sold to customers under normal circumstances. Thus, identifying OTA producing fungi associated with healthy dry liquorice was the focus of this study. Here, we report that P. chrysogenum was the most common species associated with dry liquorice sampled from 3 production regions in China and subsequent LC/MS/MS analysis proved the ability of this strain to produce OTA. Since P. chrysogenum was detected in association with both healthy dry and OTA positive moldy liquorice, we suggest that P. chrysogenum is a stable contaminant on liquorice and is one of main contributors of OTA contamination.

In addition to P. chrysogenum, other OTA producing fungi associated with liquorice contained P. glycyrrhizacola, P. polonicum, A. ochraceus and A. westerdijkiae which account for 18.22% of total fungal species on dry liquorice. The OTA producing ability of P. glycyrrhizacola was reported for the first time in this study. Penicillium polonicum has previously been reported as an OTA producer that is associated with moldy liquorice [21]. Aspergillus ochraceus and A. westerdijkiae were responsible for OTA in feeds, bee pollen, cocoa and smoked red pepper [38-41]. Although the quantity of these OTA producing fungi was lower than that of P. chrysogenum on dry liquorice, they could become predominant under proper environmental conditions, and thus may be responsible for the high OTA level in liquorice. It’s worth noting that the OTA producing abilities of P. chrysogenum and P. polonicum were questioned by some researchers, only P. verrucosum and P. nordicum were accepted as OTA producers among the Penicillia [19]. Penicillium verrucosum and P. nordicum are mainly distributed in cereal and meat [42-44] and have never been detected in association with liquorice [20,21,36,37]. This study verified that a proportion of the tested P. chrysogenum strains (one of four tested strains) could produce OTA. In comparison, none of the isolated fungi were found to produce AFB1 in this study.

Low fungal community similarity was found between fresh and dry liquorice, Penicillium spp. and Aspergillus spp. were the dominant fungi encountered. Similarly, Efuntoye [45] reported remarkable differences between the mycobiota obtained on fresh and dry plant parts; however, Rhizopus stolonifer, Absidia corymbifera, Helminthosporium sp., Pichia fermentans and Trichosporon sp. were found to be associated primarily with the fresh plant while Aspergillus, Penicillium, Fusarium, Rhizopus and Mucor were found to be more commonly associated with dry plant samples. The possible reason for this observation is that the fresh plant parts used in his research included seeds, leaves, fruits and stem barks; the normal mycobiota associated with fresh plant was unlikely to be able to exist after it was sun dried. With respect to liquorice, fresh roots were dug up from soil and it is hard to remove the Penicillium and Aspergillus fungal spores along with soil by traditional washing methods. These kinds of fungi may survive for a long period of time after drying [46,47]. So liquorice may be more easily contaminated by fungi and mycotoxins due to the part of the plant that is utilized and the rough way in which it is processed.

Fewer fungal species were found in association with dry liquorice from Xinjiang, species of Penicillium were rarely detected and A. terreus was predominant. Meanwhile the lowest fungal community similarity was found between fresh and dry liquorice sampled from Xinjiang. This partly because the dry liquorices from Gansu and Ningxia were whole roots, which were dried directly after harvest while samples from Xinjiang were liquorice slices, which were made from whole dry roots in the local processing factory. The normal processing procedure included washing, cutting and drying. Importantly, it is possible that the primary mycobiota present on raw roots may have been removed and replaced by fungi present in the processing factory. Compared with whole liquorice roots, slices of liquorice are more often used in hospital and pharmacy settings. According to our data, liquorice slices appear to be less contaminated by fungi and thus may support the continued use of this liquorice processing technique over liquorice roots in these settings.

From this study it can be concluded that fungal contamination constitutes a potential health hazard in consumption of liquorice. Ariño et al. [48] indicated that the OTA in licorice and derived products was unaffected by sorting or washing, whereas peeling the roots significantly reduced OTA contents by more than 50%. However, this method of processing is typically viewed as being cost-prohibitive. According to our findings, P. chrysogenum, P. glycyrrhizacola, P. polonicum and A. westerdijkiae present on fresh liquorice could survive after primary sun drying and were main OTA contributors on dry liquorice. The information determined in this study will further efforts to identify more targeted fungicidal methods to help keep liquorice crops free from these toxigenic fungi.


Thanks are given to Dr. Long Wang for help in Penicillium identification.

Author Contributions

Conceived and designed the experiments: AJC WWG. Performed the experiments: AJC DT LZW. Analyzed the data: BDS. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: YQZ XJL. Wrote the manuscript: AJC.


  1. 1. Chinese Pharmacopoeia Council (2005) Chinese Pharmacopoeia. China, Beijing: Chemical Industry Press. 846 pp.
  2. 2. (1985) 21 CFR Parts 182 and 184 GRAS status of licorice, (Glycyrrhiza), ammoniated glycyrrhizin and monoammonium glycyrrhizinate. Fed Regist 50: 21043-21044.
  3. 3. Gabriele D, Curcio S, Cindia B (2001) Optimal design of single-screw extruder for liquorice candy production: a rheology based approach. J Food Eng 48: 33-44. doi:
  4. 4. Carmines EL, Lemus R, Gaworski CL (2005) Toxicologic evaluation of licorice extract as a cigarette ingredient. Food Chem Toxicol 43: 1303-1322. doi: PubMed: 15878225.
  5. 5. Wang YQ, Zhu M (2002) Investigation and analysis on the resource of Glycyrrhiza uralensis Fisch. in China. J . Shanxi Agric Univ 22(4): 366-369.
  6. 6. Creppy EE (1999) Human ochratoxicoses. J Toxicol - Toxin Rev 18: 273-293.
  7. 7. O’Brien E, Dietrich DR (2005) Ochratoxin A: The continuing enigma. Crit Rev Toxicol 35(1): 33-60. doi: PubMed: 15742902.
  8. 8. Bresch H, Urbanek M, Nusser M (2000) Ochratoxin A in food containing liquorice. Nahrung 44: 276-278. doi: PubMed: 10996904.
  9. 9. Majerus P, Max M, Klaffke H, Palavinskas R (2000) Ochratoxin A in Sübholz, Lakritze und daraus hergestellten. Erzeugnissen Deustche Lebensm - Rundschau 96: 451-454.
  10. 10. Herrera M, Herrera A, Ariño A (2009) Estimation of dietary intake of ochratoxin A from liquorice confectionery. Food Chem Toxicol 47: 2002-2006. doi: PubMed: 19450650.
  11. 11. Kabelitz L, Sievers H (2004) Contaminants of medicinal and food herbs with a view to EU regulations. Innovations. Food Technol 1: 25-27.
  12. 12. Ariño A, Herrera M, Estopañan G, Juan T (2007) High levels of ochratoxin A in licorice and derived products. Int J Microbiol 114: 366-369. PubMed: 17107730.
  13. 13. Yang L, Wang LN, Pan JY, Xiang L, Yang MH et al. (2010) Determination of ochratoxin A in traditional Chinese medicinal plants by HPLC-FLD. Food Addit Contam 27: 989-997. doi: PubMed: 20432098.
  14. 14. Pietri A, Rastelli S, Bertuzzi T (2010) Ochratoxin A and Aflatoxins in liquorice products. Toxins 2: 758-770. doi: PubMed: 22069608.
  15. 15. Esteban A, Abarca ML, Bragulat MR, Cabañes FJ (2006) Effect of water activity on ochratoxin A production by Aspergillus niger aggregate species. Int J Microbiol 108: 188-195. PubMed: 16443301.
  16. 16. Czerwiecki L, Czajkowska D, Witkowska-Gwiazdowska A (2002) On ochratoxin A and fungal flora in Polish cereals from conventional and ecological farms. Part 1: Occurrence of ochratoxin A and fungi in cereals in 1997. Food Addit Contam 19: 470-477. doi: PubMed: 12028646.
  17. 17. Czerwiecki L, Czajkowska D, Witkowska-Gwiazdowska A (2002) On ochratoxin A and fungal flora in Polish cereals from conventional and ecological farms. Part 1: Occurrence of ochratoxin A and fungi in cereals in 1998. Food Addit Contam 19: 1051-1057. doi: PubMed: 12456276.
  18. 18. Varga J, Rigó K, Terén J, Mesterházy A (2001) Recent advances in ochratoxin research. I. Production, detection and occurrence of ochratoxins. Cereal Res Commun 29: 85-92.
  19. 19. Frisvad JC, Nielsen KF, Samson RA (2006) Recommendations concerning the chronic problem of misidentification of mycotoxigenic fungi associated with foods and feeds. Adv Exp Med Biol 571: 33-46. doi: PubMed: 16408592.
  20. 20. Chen AJ, Yang L, Cai F, Yang MH, Gao WW (2010) Fungi associated with moldy medicinal materials of Glycyrrhiza uralensis and their capability of mycotoxin production. Mycosystema 29 (2): 335-339.
  21. 21. Chen AJ, Huang LF, Wang LZ, Tang D, Cai F et al. (2011) Occurrence of toxigenic fungi in ochratoxin A contaminated liquorice root. Food Addit Contam 28(8): 1091-1097. doi: PubMed: 21790488.
  22. 22. Kornerup A, Wanscher JH (1978) Methuen Handbook of Colour. 3r edn.: Eyrn. London: Methuen. p. 252.
  23. 23. Pitt JI (1979) The genus Penicillium and its teleomorphic states Eupenicillium and Talaromyces, 1st edn; Lodon Academic Press. 634 p.
  24. 24. Carmichael JW, Kendrick WB, Conners IL, Sigler L (1980) Genera of Hyphomycetes. Canada: The University of Alberta Press. 386 pp.
  25. 25. Klich MA, Pitt JI (1988) A laboratory guide to common Aspergillus species and their teleomorphs. 1st edn. . CSIRO Ryde, NSW, Australia: Division of Food Science and Technology, North. 116 p.
  26. 26. Samson RA, Frisvad JC (2004) Penicillium subgenus Penicillium: new taxonomic schemes, mycotoxins and other extrolites. Stud Mycol 49: 1-253.
  27. 27. Glass NL, Donaldson GC (1995) Development of primer sets designed for use with the PCR to amplify conserved genes from filamentous Ascomycetes. Appl Environ Microbiol 61: 1323-1330. PubMed: 7747954.
  28. 28. Houbraken J, Samson RA (2011) Phylogeny of Penicillium and the segregation of Trichocomaceae into three families. Stud Mycol 70: 1-51. doi: PubMed: 22308045.
  29. 29. White TJ, Bruns T, Lee S, Taylor J (1990) Amplification and direct sequencing of fungal ribosomal RNA genes for phylogenetics. In: MA InnisDH GelfandJJ SninskyTJ White. PCR protocols: A Guide to Methods and Applications. New York: Academic Press. pp. 315-322.
  30. 30. Thompson JD, Gibson TJ, Plewniak F, Jeanmougin F, Higgins DG (1997) The Clustal X windows interface: Flexible strategies for multiple sequence alignment aided by quality analysis tools. Nucleic Acids Res 25: 4876-4882. doi: PubMed: 9396791.
  31. 31. Tamura K, Peterson D, Peterson N, Stecher G, Nei M et al. (2011) MEGA5: molecular evolutionary genetics analysis using maximum likelihood, evolutionary distance, and maximum parsimony methods. Mol Biol Evol 28(10): 2731-2739. doi: PubMed: 21546353.
  32. 32. Saitou N, Nei M (1987) The neighbour-joining method: a new method for reconstructing phylogenetic trees. Mol Biol Evol 4: 406-425. PubMed: 3447015.
  33. 33. Wang LZ, Wang Z, Gao WW, Chen J, Yang MH et al. (2013) Simultaneous determination of aflatoxin B1 and ochratoxin A in licorice roots and fritillary bulbs by solid-phase extraction coupled with high-performance liquid chromatography - tandem mass spectrometry. Food Chem 138: 1048-1054. doi: PubMed: 23411213.
  34. 34. Pielou EC (1975) Ecological Diversity, 1st edn. New York: Wiley Interscience Publication. 165 pp.
  35. 35. Bannister P (1968) An evaluation of some procedures used in simple ordinations. J Ecol 56: 27-34. doi:
  36. 36. Hitokoto H, Morozumi S, Wauke T, Sakai S, Kurata H (1978) Fungal contamination and mycotoxin detection of powdered herbal drugs. Appl Environ Microbiol 36: 252-256. PubMed: 697361.
  37. 37. Singh P, Srivastava B, Kumar A, Dubey NK (2008) Fungal contamination of raw materials of some herbal drugs and recommendation of Cinnamomum camphora oil as herbal fungitoxicant. Microb Ecol 56: 555-560. doi: PubMed: 18322727.
  38. 38. Accensi F, Abarca ML, Cabañes FJ (2004) Occurrence of Aspergillus species in mixed feeds and component raw materials and their ability to produce ochratoxin A. Food Microbiol 21: 623-627. doi:
  39. 39. González G, Hinojo MJ, Mateo R, Medina A, Jiménez M (2005) Occurrence of mycotoxin producing fungi in bee pollen. Int J Microbiol 105: 1-9. PubMed: 16009441.
  40. 40. Copetti MV, Pereira JL, Iamanaka BT, Pitt JI, Taniwaki MH (2010) Ochratoxigenic fungi and ochratoxin A in cocoa during farm processing. Int J Microbiol 143: 67-70. PubMed: 20709419.
  41. 41. Gil-Serna J, Vázquez C, Sardiñas N, González-jaén MT, Patiño B (2011) Revision of ochratoxin A production capacity by the main species of Aspergillus section Circumdati. Aspergillus steynii revealed as the main risk of OTA contamination. Food Control 22: 343-345. doi:
  42. 42. Frisvad JC, Filtenborg O (1983) Classification of terverticillate Penicillia based on profiles of mycotoxins and other secondary metabolites. Appl Environ Microbiol 46: 1301-1310. PubMed: 6660869.
  43. 43. Frisvad JC (1985) Classification of asymmetric Penicillia using expressions of differentiation. In Samson RA, Pitt JI, editors. Advances in Penicillium and Aspergillus systematics. . New York: Plenum Press. pp. 327-333.
  44. 44. Pitt JI (1987) Penicillium viridicatum, P. Verrucosum, and the production of ochratoxin A. Appl Environ Microbiol 53: 266-269. PubMed: 3566267.
  45. 45. Efuntoye MO (1996) Fungi associated with herbal drug plants during storage. Mycopathologia 136: 115-118. doi: PubMed: 9208479.
  46. 46. Sanders TH, Cole RJ, Blankenship PD, Dorner JW (1993) Aflatoxin contamination of peanuts from plants drought stressed in pod or root zones. Peanut Sci 20: 5-8. doi:
  47. 47. Müller P, Basedow T (2007) Aflatoxin contamination of pods of Indian Cassia senna. p. L. (Caesalpinaceae) before harvest, during drying and in storage: Reasons and possible methods of reduction. J Stored Prod Res 43 (4): 323-329.
  48. 48. Ariño A, Herrera M, Langa E, Raso J, Herrera A (2007) Ochratoxin A in licorice as affected by processing methods. Food Addit Contam 24(9): 987-992. doi: PubMed: 17691012.