A nematophagous fungus, Esteya vermicola, is recorded as the first endoparasitic fungus of pine wood nematode (PWN), Bursaphelenchus xylophilus, in last century. E. vermicola exhibited high infectivity toward PWN in the laboratory conditions and conidia spraying of this fungus on Japanese red pine, Pinus densiflora, seedlings in the field protected the pine trees from pine wilt disease to some extent, indicating that it is a potential bio-control agent against PWN. Previous research had demonstrated that the living fungal mycelia of E. vermicola continuously produced certain volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which were responsible for the PWN attraction. However, identity of these VOCs remains unknown.
In this study, we report the identification of α-pinene, β-pinene, and camphor produced by living mycelia of E. vermicola, the same volatile compounds emitted from PWN host pine tree, as the major VOCs for PWN attraction using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS). In addition, we also confirmed the host deception behavior of E. vermicola to PWN by using synthetic VOCs in a straightforward laboratory bioassay.
This research result has demonstrated that the endoparasitic nematophagous fungus, E. vermicola, mimics the scent of PWN host pine tree to entice PWN for the nutrient. The identification of the attractive VOCs emitted from the fungus E. vermicola is of significance in better understanding parasitic mechanism of the fungus and the co-evolution in the two organisms and will aid management of the pine wilt disease.
Citation: Lin F, Ye J, Wang H, Zhang A, Zhao B (2013) Host Deception: Predaceous Fungus, Esteya vermicola, Entices Pine Wood Nematode by Mimicking the Scent of Pine Tree for Nutrient. PLoS ONE8(8): e71676. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0071676
Editor: Michael Hendricks, Harvard University, United States of America
Received: February 4, 2013; Accepted: July 2, 2013; Published: August 19, 2013
Copyright: © 2013 Lin et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by a project from the Chinese Ministry of Forestry (2010) No. 201004003. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Esteya vermicola was recorded as the first endoparasitic fungus of the pine wood nematode (PWN), Bursaphelenchus xylophilus , and exhibited high infectivity in vitro , . The lunate conidia of E. vermicola are adhesive and can adhere to the cuticle of PWN, causing subsequent infection. This predaceous fungus consumes the contents of the infected nematode’s body, grows out from its cadaver, and then produces new lunate conidia for the next infection cycle . During a survey of nematophagous fungi in Korea, a novel endoparasitic fungal strain, CNU 120806, was isolated from infected nematodes in forest soil and identified as a rare hyphomycete. Results of taxonomy and molecular phylogenetic analyses showed that CNU120806 was a new strain of E. vermicola . E. vermicola CNU 120806 also exhibited high infectivity toward PWN in the laboratory conditions. Conidia spraying of E. vermicola onto four-year-old Pinus densiflora seedlings in the field showed promising potential to be used as a bio-control agent against PWN , . Wang et al. demonstrated that the living mycelia and exudative substances of E. vermicola were attractive to PWN . Further experiments revealed that the attractive substances from E. vermicola consisted of volatile and non-volatile compounds . We hypothesized that these attractive volatile compounds should be related to the PWN hosts. Present research was focused on the identification of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that were responsible for PWN attraction from E. vermicola CNU 120806 using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS).
Materials and Methods
PWNs were cultured on Botrytis cinerea and isolated by Baermann funnel technique . The harvested PWNs were rinsed 3 times with distilled water and then prepared as an aqueous suspension for further experiments.
Esteya vermicola CNU 120806  was a present given by Dr. Chang-Keun Sung and Dr. Chun-yan Wang, Chungnam National University, Korea. The fungus was cultured on potato sucrose agar (PSA: potato exudate 200 g, sucrose 20 g and agar 15 g in 1 liter water) in Petri plates (7 cm diam.) at 26°C for 8 days.
The chemicals used in GC-MS analyses and silicone tube method (STM) bioassays include α-pinene (98%, J&K Scientific Ltd.), β-pinene (98%, J&K Scientific Ltd.), camphor (95%, J&K Scientific Ltd.), dichloromethane (99%, Aladdin Chemistry Co., Ltd.), and ethanol absolute (99.8%, Aladdin Chemistry Co., Ltd.).
VOCs Collection, Fractionation, and Analysis
VOCs from E. vermicola were collected using the super Q absorbent (80–100 mesh, Alltech Associates Inc., Deerfield, IL, USA), fractionized by GC, and analyzed by GC-MS , , . The fungus E. vermicola was cultured on 200 ml PSA medium in glass tube (30 cm long, 6 cm inner diam.) at 26°C for 10 d. An absorbent glass tube (external and inner diam. were 6 mm and 4 mm respectively) containing 50 mg of Super Q was connected to the outlet of the fungus tube by a Teflon tube. Charcoal-purified air was drawn over the fungus and absorbent tubes at a rate of 300 ml/min by a vacuum pump (Nanjing Rongshide Trade, Nanjing, P. R. China). VOCs were collected for 1 h and then eluted with 150 µl of dichloromethane from Super Q tube into individual 2 ml vial (CNW technology GmbH, Germany) and the resulting extracts were stored at - 20°C until use , . VOCs from PSA medium were also collected using the same method as above, but without E. vermicola.
Volatile collections from the fungus and PSA medium were repeated three times. Extracts were combined separately, and then concentrated to ∼10 µl with nitrogen stream. One microliter of each extract was analyzed by an Agilent 7890A GC or by an Agilent 7890A connected to an Agilent 5973C mass spectrometer. A 30 m HP-5 ms (0.25 mm internal diam., 0.25 µm film thickness for GC-MS and 0.32 mm internal diam., 0.25 µm film thickness for GC) capillary column (Agilent Technologies Inc., CA, USA) was used with splitless mode. The oven temperature was programmed from an initial temperature of 40°C, and then increased to 280°C at a rate of 5°C/min, held for 10 min.
The setup for the GC fractionation is similar to GC-electroantennogram. The end of capillary column was split by a deactivated Y splitter (Agilent Technologies Inc., CA, USA) with its one end to the GC flame ionization detector and the other end as a outlet to the outside using the same type of the column segments (Figure 1). After injecting 6 µl extract from E. vermicola, VOCs components were collected during certain retention time periods from GC outlet using glass capillary tubes (20 cm long, 1 mm internal diam.). Each fraction was rinsed with 10 µl of dichloromethane from capillary tube into a small vial and stored at - 20°C until use. Components of interested compounds from extracts were identified by GC-MS based on comparison of mass spectra with the NIST 08 MS library ,  and retention times of synthetic standards. Quantification of α-pinene, β-pinene, and camphor was performed by GC using external standard method.
In order to evaluate the activity of VOCs collected from E. vermicola, a simple bioassay method that we refer as silicone tube method (STM) was developed (Figure 2). Advantage of STM is that the small internal space in STM greatly increases the concentration of VOCs treatment comparing with Petri dish method that is usually used to study attractive VOCs from microbes to nematodes by most researchers , resulting in enhanced sensitivity of bioassay.
The main part of bioassay apparatus was consisted of a 5 cm long transparent silicone tube (6 mm external diam., 3 mm internal diam., TOGOHK International Industrial Co., Ltd). Filter paper of the suitable size was rolled into a 3 cm long rod, gently put into the silicon tube, and kept at the middle of the tube with rooms of 1 cm for samples in the both ends. The paper rod was moistened with 140 µl distilled water. An apical hole (∼0.6 mm diam.) was made in the middle of the silicone tube (Figure 2A), allowing a suspension of mixed aged nematode to be introduced into the filter paper rod inside.
A small filter paper disc (3 mm diam.) containing one microliter of fungal volatile extract, one microliter of volatile extract from PSA medium, one microliter of volatile extract from different fungal GC fractions, or certain amounts of individual synthetic compound or blend (α-pinene, β-pinene, and camphor) was placed into one end of the silicone tube, and the control disc containing dichloromethane solvent was placed into the other end. Two ends of the tube were sealed with parafilm tape (Pechiney Plastic Packaging Company), and the tube was incubated in the dark at 26°C for 0.5 h to establish a concentration gradient of VOCs. After 10 µl of nematode suspension (∼200 mixed aged individuals) was applied to the central opening of the tube then tube was kept horizontally for 10 h in the dark at 26°C. Six replicates were prepared for each treatment. The silicone tube was cut into three segments (left: 2 cm, middle: 1 cm, right: 2 cm, Figure 2B). The nematodes in the two 2 cm segments for the treatment and control were isolated with the Baermann funnel technique  respectively and the numbers of the nematode in both of the treatment and control segments were counted and recorded respectively.
To reduce the deviation of nematodes added in the tubes, the nematode numbers obtained from two segments of the treatment and the control were transferred to percentage to perform the statistical analyses. All of the bioassay data were analyzed by independent samples group t test with SPSS 13.0 software.
Bioassay of the VOCs from E. vermicola Mycelium
The VOCs collected from E. vermicola and PSA medium were bioassayed by STM. The result showed that the VOCs collected from E. vermicola were significantly attracted more nematodes than the control (p<0.01). However, VOCs from PSA medium did not show attractive activity to attract nematodes (p = 0.126) (Table 1). This indicates that active components to attract PWNs are only associated with the VOCs collected from mycelium of E. vermicola.
GC Fractionations of the VOCs from E. vermicola Mycelium and Activity Bioassay
VOCs collected from E. vermicola mycelium were fractionized by GC and four fractions were collected at different retention time periods, which were subsequently bioassayed with the nematodes using STM. Bioassay results showed that the potentially active components appeared in middle fractions with retention time from 4–5.7 min (p<0.01) and 5.7–10 min (p<0.05). Other fractions with retention times from 2.6–4 min (p = 0.102), and 10–18 min (p>0.05) did not show significantly attracting activities comparing with solvent control (Table 2).
GC-MS Analyses of the VOCs from E. vermicola and the PSA Medium
GC-MS analyses of the VOCs from E. vermicola and the PSA medium indicated that three compounds were only associated with E. vermicola in an approximate ratio of 28: 12: 1 (Figure 3). They were identified as α-pinene, β-pinene, and camphor by comparison of mass spectra with the GC-MS library (Table 3). The identity of these three compounds was also confirmed by GC retention times with synthetic standards.
Identification of peaks: 1, α-pinene; 2, β-pinene; and 3, camphor.
Bioassays of the Synthetic Compounds
Synthetic α-pinene, β-pinene, and camphor, as well as a blend of the three chemicals were bioassayed with different doses using STM. Our results indicated that three individual compounds and a blend at natural ratio (28: 12: 1) significantly attracted the PWN at appropriate doses (Table 4). The minimum doses to attract PWN for α-pinene, β-pinene, camphor, and blend were 50 ng, 12 ng, 1.6 ng, and 41 ng respectively (p<0.05). No significant synergistic effect was observed when a three component blend was bioassayed at tested concentrations.
Our research results demonstrated that the nematophagous fungus, E. vermicola, emitted VOCs to entice PWN (Table 1 and 2), confirming that E. vermicola living mycelia produced volatile compounds for PWN attraction . The active compounds from E. vermicola VOCs (common pine volatiles: two monoterpenes, α-pinene, β-pinene; and one terpenoid, camphor) were identified (Figure 3, Table 3). The activity of identified compounds has been confirmed by STM bioassay using synthetic compounds (Table 4). To reduce the bioassay time, the middle 1 cm of the tube was cut off and only nematodes in other two segments were counted. That is reason why the numbers of nematodes in the treatment and control were relatively low comparing with total loading. Although it is also possible that the doses of individual synthetic compound and blend used may not be enough to elicit maximal attractive activity and some minor active component may be missing, the synthetic individual and blend tested resulted in up to 71% PWN attraction in our STM bioassay. It supports our hypothesis that attractive volatile compounds from E. vermicola should be related to the PWN hosts.
The compounds, α-pinene and β-pinene, have been reported as VOCs components from the larvae and adult of PWN vector beetle M. alternatus and its host pine trees, P. massoniana and dying P. thunbergii, to attract PWN , , , . Yun et al. reported that α-pinene, β-pinene, and camphor were highly attractive to PWN and camphor showed significantly higher attractiveness to the PWNs among the three chemicals in the PWN-infected pine tree log bioassay . More interestingly, our research results demonstrated that E. vermicola resorted to host deception, in which this living predaceous fungus enticed PWN by producing VOCs (α-pinene, β-pinene, and camphor) that mimicked the scent of PWN host pine tree for nutrient.
The nematophagous fungi are natural enemies of nematodes because they can trap living nematodes and the attraction intensity increased with increasing dependence of the fungi on nematodes for nutrients . The ability to use nematodes as an additional nutrient source provides nematophagous fungi with a nutritional advantage, therefore, they have been recently used to control the animal-parasitic nematodes in livestock , , , ,  as biological agents. Zhen Wang et al. found that E. vermicola survived in resin and other chemicals secreted by pine trees, and reproduced with new lunate conidia to parasitize other migratory PWNs in host trees . Our findings are of significances in better understanding parasitic mechanism of the fungus and the co-evolution in the two organisms and will aid management of the pine wilt disease.
To date, the most researchers use Petri dish method to study attractive VOCs to nematodes from microbes , . The STM bioassay provides a simple and effective way to assist identification of attractive VOCs to nematodes from microbes. New STM not only enables us to identify attractive compounds to the PWN from VOCs of E. vermicola, but also provides a more sensitive and efficient bioassay method in studying the behavior of nematodes. Further work to identify the non-volatile compounds from E. vermicola is under way.
We thank Dr. Chang-Keun Sung and Dr. Chun-yan Wang, Chungnam National University, Korea gave us the fungus, Esteya vermicola CNU 120806, as a present.
Conceived and designed the experiments: BGZ AJZ. Performed the experiments: FL JLY BGZ HGW. Analyzed the data: JLY FL. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: BGZ FL JLY. Wrote the paper: BGZ AJZ JLY.
- 1. Liou JY, Shih JY, Tzean SS (1999) Esteya, a new nematophagous genus from Taiwan, attacking the pinewood nematode (Bursaphelenchus xylophilus). Mycological Research 103: 242–248.
- 2. Wang CY, Fang ZM, Wang Z, Zhang DL, Gu LJ, et al. (2011) Biological control of the pinewood nematode Bursaphelenchus xylophilus by application of the endoparasitic fungus Esteya vermicola. Biocontrol (dordrecht) 56: 91–100.
- 3. Wang CY, Fang ZM, Sun BS, Gu LJ, Zhang KQ, et al. (2008) High infectivity of an endoparasitic fungus strain, Esteya vermicola, against nematodes. Journal of Microbiology 46: 380–389.
- 4. Wang C, Wang Z, Fang Z, Zhang D, Gu L, et al. (2010) Attraction of pinewood nematode to endoparasitic nematophagous fungus Esteya vermicola. Current Microbiology 60: 387–392.
- 5. Southey JF. (1986). Laboratory methods for working with plants and soil nematodes. London, UK, Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, HMSO, 202 pp.
- 6. Zhao LL, Wei W, Kang L, Sun JH (2007) Chemotaxis of the pinewood nematode, Bursaphelenchus xylophilus, to volatiles associated with host pine, Pinus massoniana, and its vector Monochamus alternatus. Journal of Chemical Ecology 33: 1207–1216.
- 7. Kaplan I, Sardanelli S, Denno RF, Halitschke R, Kessler A (2008) Constitutive and induced defenses to herbivory in above- and belowground plant tissues. Ecology 89: 392–406.
- 8. Nichols Jr WJ, Cossé AA, Bartelt RJ, King BH (2010) Methyl 6-methylsalicylate: a female-produced pheromone component of the parasitoid wasp Spalangia endius. Journal of Chemical Ecology 36: 1140–1147.
- 9. Fan J, Sun J, Shi J (2007) Attraction of the Japanese pine sawyer, Monochamus alternatus, to volatiles from stressed host in China. Annals of Forest Science 64: 67–71.
- 10. Aikawa T (2008) Transmission biology of Bursaphelenchus xylophilus inrelation to its insect vector. In: Zhao BG, Futai K, Sutherland JR, Takeuchi Y, editors. Pine Wilt Disease. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer Science 123–138.
- 11. Takeuchi Y, Kanzaki N, Futai K (2006) Volatile compounds in pine stands suffering from pine wilt disease: qualitative and quantitative evaluation. Nematology 8: 869–879.
- 12. Yun JE, Kim J, Park CG (2012) Rapid diagnosis of the infection of pine tree with pine wood nematode (Bursaphelenchus xylophilus) by use of host-tree volatiles. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 60: 7392–7397.
- 13. Jansson H, Nordbring-hertz B (1979) Attraction of nematodes to living mycelium of nematophagous fungi. Journal of General Microbiology 112: 89–94.
- 14. Gronvold J, Wolstrup J, Nansen P, Henriksen SA (1993) Nematode-trapping fungi against parasitic cattle nematodes. Parasitology Today 9: 137–140.
- 15. Nordbring-Hertz B, Jansson H-Br, Tunlid A (2006) Nematophagous fungi. Encyclopedia of Life Sciences: doi: 10.1038/npg.els.0004293.
- 16. Gronvold J, Wolstrup J, Nansen P, Henriksen SA, Larsen M, et al. (1993) Biological control of nematode parasites in cattle with nematode-trapping fungi: a survey of Danish studies. Veterinary Parasitology 48: 311–325.
- 17. Gomes AP, Araujo JV, Ribeiro RC (1999) Differential in vitro pathogenicity of predatory fungi of the genus Monacrosporium for phytonematodes, free-living nematodes and parasitic nematodes of cattle. Brazilian Journal of Medical and Biological Research 32: 79–83.
- 18. Assis RC, Luns FD, Araujo JV, Braga FR (2012) Biological control of trichostrongyles in beef cattle by the nematophagous fungus Duddingtonia flagrans in tropical southeastern Brazil. Experimental Parasitology 132: 373–377.
- 19. Wang Z, Wang CY, Yang ZH, Fang ZM (2011) Viability and pathogenicity of Esteya vermicola in pine trees. Biocontrol Science and Technology 21: 387–393.