Advertisement
Browse Subject Areas
?

Click through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in your field.

For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click here.

  • Loading metrics

Pathoadaptive Mutations in Salmonella enterica Isolated after Serial Passage in Mice

  • Sanna Koskiniemi ,

    Contributed equally to this work with: Sanna Koskiniemi, Henry S. Gibbons

    Affiliation Department of Medical Biochemistry and Microbiology, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden

  • Henry S. Gibbons ,

    Contributed equally to this work with: Sanna Koskiniemi, Henry S. Gibbons

    Affiliation US Army Edgewood Chemical Biological Center, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Aberdeen, Maryland, United States of America

  • Linus Sandegren,

    Affiliation Department of Medical Biochemistry and Microbiology, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden

  • Naeem Anwar,

    Affiliation Department of Microbiology, Tumor and Cell Biology, Karolinska Institute, Solna, Sweden

  • Gary Ouellette,

    Affiliations US Army Edgewood Chemical Biological Center, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Aberdeen, Maryland, United States of America, Science Applications International Corporation, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Aberdeen, Maryland, United States of America

  • Stacey Broomall,

    Affiliation US Army Edgewood Chemical Biological Center, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Aberdeen, Maryland, United States of America

  • Mark Karavis,

    Affiliation US Army Edgewood Chemical Biological Center, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Aberdeen, Maryland, United States of America

  • Paul McGregor,

    Affiliations US Army Edgewood Chemical Biological Center, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Aberdeen, Maryland, United States of America, Science Applications International Corporation, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Aberdeen, Maryland, United States of America

  • Alvin Liem,

    Affiliation OptiMetrics, Inc., Abingdon, Maryland, United States of America

  • Ed Fochler,

    Affiliation OptiMetrics, Inc., Abingdon, Maryland, United States of America

  • Lauren McNew,

    Affiliation US Army Edgewood Chemical Biological Center, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Aberdeen, Maryland, United States of America

  • Carolyn Nicole Rosenzweig,

    Affiliation US Army Edgewood Chemical Biological Center, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Aberdeen, Maryland, United States of America

  • Mikael Rhen,

    Affiliation Department of Microbiology, Tumor and Cell Biology, Karolinska Institute, Solna, Sweden

  • Evan W. Skowronski,

    Affiliation US Army Edgewood Chemical Biological Center, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Aberdeen, Maryland, United States of America

  • Dan I. Andersson

    Dan.Andersson@imbim.uu.se

    Affiliation Department of Medical Biochemistry and Microbiology, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden

Pathoadaptive Mutations in Salmonella enterica Isolated after Serial Passage in Mice

  • Sanna Koskiniemi, 
  • Henry S. Gibbons, 
  • Linus Sandegren, 
  • Naeem Anwar, 
  • Gary Ouellette, 
  • Stacey Broomall, 
  • Mark Karavis, 
  • Paul McGregor, 
  • Alvin Liem, 
  • Ed Fochler
PLOS
x

Abstract

How pathogenic bacteria adapt and evolve in the complex and variable environment of the host remains a largely unresolved question. Here we have used whole genome sequencing of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium LT2 populations serially passaged in mice to identify mutations that adapt bacteria to systemic growth in mice. We found unique pathoadaptive mutations in two global regulators, phoQ and stpA, which increase the competitive indexes of the bacteria 3- to 5-fold. Also, all mouse-adapted lineages had changed the orientation of the hin invertable element, resulting in production of a FliC type of flagellum. Competition experiments in mice with locked flagellum mutants showed that strains expressing the FliC type of flagellum had a 5-fold increase in competitive index as compared to those expressing FljB type flagellum. Combination of the flagellum cassette inversion with the stpA mutation increased competitive indexes up to 20-fold. These experiments show that Salmonella can rapidly adapt to a mouse environment by acquiring a few mutations of moderate individual effect that when combined confer substantial increases in growth.

Introduction

Bacteria adapt genetically to changing environments and many studies show that bacteria possess a considerable potential to increase fitness during experimental evolution under constant laboratory conditions [1], [2]. However, less is known about how bacteria adapt to a more complex and variable environment, such as that encountered inside a host. Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (hereafter referred to as S. typhimurium) is a common facultative intracellular pathogen that can adhere to and invade gut epithelial cells. After invasion, bacteria that reach the submucosa can be internalized by macrophages and disseminate to systemic sites such as the lymph nodes and ultimately the spleen and liver [3]. To be able to survive and replicate in these various growth niches, S. typhimurium possesses an arsenal of virulence factors which, when properly regulated, provide an appropriate physiological response to the actual environment [4] In addition, upon growth inside a host, selection can benefit bacterial mutants with altered expression of virulence genes that better suit the environment of the host. These mutations can be considered pathoadaptive mutations. Most studies of virulence genes use mutants where potential genes involved in virulence are inactivated or altered, to confirm loss/increase of virulence [5], [6], [7] This does not however give any information to what actually happens during growth and adaptation in natural settings. Another approach to study pathoadaptive mutations is by comparative genomic or proteomic analyses, where the genomes of pathogenic bacteria can be compared to those that are avirulent to determine what changes might be responsible for that change [8], [9]. However, these studies rarely identify single mutations responsible for the increased virulence, which makes it hard to elucidate the exact gain of each mutation.

Here we study pathoadaptive mutations in S. typhimurium found after serial passage of bacteria in mice followed by whole genome sequencing of the adapted populations. Previous results from our laboratory show that S. typhimurium evolved experimentally by serial passage for <200 generations of growth in mice rapidly increased their growth rate as measured by an up to 50-fold increase in competitive index [10] Here we identify the mutations responsible for faster growth in mice using whole genome sequencing and verify their role in pathoadaptation by reconstructing the mutations in wild-type backgrounds. In recent years, microbial whole-genome sequencing has advanced from identifying the genomes of model-organisms, to be used as a tool in determining adaptive mutations and comparative analysis of pathogenic bacteria. This type of whole-genome sequencing has applications to the fields of bacterial pathogenesis and vaccine development [11] epidemiology [12] and microbial forensics [13], [14].

We find unique mutations in two global regulators of virulence associated genes, phoQ and stpA, that increase the expression of the spv (salmonella plasmid virulence) locus required for survival within macrophages. We also observed fixation of bacteria expressing one type of flagellum (FliC) rather than the other (FljB). Finally, we show that even though any of the mutations alone only give a relatively small increase in growth rates in mice (3- to 5-fold increase in competitive index (CI)), the combined effect of the mutations can result in a considerable increase in CI.

Materials and Methods

Preparation of Isolates/DNA for Sequencing

DNA was prepared from populations of cells after extraction from mice spleens and after few generations of growth in Luria Bertani (LB) broth. DNA was prepared with Qiagen genomic tip 500G kit (Qiagen) according to the manufacturer and tested for concentration and purity with a Nanodrop 1000 (Thermo Scientific). Only DNA with A260/A280 ratios larger than 1.8 were used for sequencing.

Whole Genome Sequencing

Shotgun libraries were prepared from genomic DNA isolated from the JB124 parent strain and from populations derived from each host-adapted lineage. DNA was sheared by nebulization and converted into shotgun libraries according to standard protocols for the Roche/454 procedure [15] Shotgun sequencing was performed on the Roche/454 GS-FLX instrument using the Titanium reagent package according to manufacturer’s protocols. Mean coverage for all isolates was between 20 and 35-fold. Datasets for each lineage have been deposited in the NCBI Short Read Archive (SRA) under the project submission ID SRA075312 with SRA accession numbers SRS418168-SRS418176.

Bioinformatic Analysis

Reads were assembled de novo using Newbler GSAssembler (version 2.3) to confirm the quality of raw sequence data. Reads from all strains were mapped to the published S. typhimurium LT2 reference sequence (NC_003197.1 and NC_003277.1 for the chromosome and pSLT1 virulence plasmid, respectively) using both GSMapper and CLC Genomic workbench v 5.1 (CLC Bio, Aarhus Denmark). Mutations present in the JB124 strain the LT2 reference strains were first identified to focus the search for adaptive mutations on those mutations that were unique to the adapted strains and absent from the parent strain. High-confidence differences (HCDiffs) were identified based on the neighborhood quality score algorithm in Newbler and the SNP and DIP mapping algorithms in CLC Genomic Workbench. SNPs and small insertion/deletion events in strain JB124 relative to the LT2 reference sequence were initially identified based on an 85% read-difference cut-off. In addition, structural variations called by GSMapper were identified as regions that exhibited rearrangements (deletions or inversions) with obvious and consistent join points. The latter class of variations presents as a collection of reads that map consistently to two places on the genome with common break points. All mutation calls and putative rearrangements were verified by manual inspection of the assembly files and by PCR analysis. The candidate mutations identified in JB124 were compared to all published Salmonella genomes to help screen out sequencing errors in the published sequence. Residual sequencing errors in the LT2 genome were identified by comparing the mutations identified by 454 sequencing of JB124 with differences between LT2 and 14028s using MAUVE [16]. The presence and relative amount of identified mutations was verified with colony PCR and subsequent sequencing with StpA and PhoQ primers.

Genetic Reconstruction of Adaptive Mutations

Possible pathoadaptive mutations identified were reconstructed in wild type background to analyze their contribution to the increased growth rates in mice. Resistance cassettes (cat) were inserted ∼5 kb from the identified mutation in genes with no known function (STM2804 and STM1236) with linear transformation as described previously [17]. In short, linear DNA was amplified using STM2804_cat_ins and STM1236_cat_ins primers with Phusion enzyme according to the manufacturer (Finnzymes) according to the following protocol in a Geneamp 9700 (Applied biosystems); 94°C 2 min, then 31 rounds of 94°C 30 s, annealing (68–72°C) 30 s, elongation 72°C (30 s-2 min) and a final elongation at 72°C for 7 min before cooling down to 4°C. As template for the cat gene the pKD3 plasmid prepared with E.Z.N.A plasmid mini kit (Omega-Bio-Tek) was used. The resistance marker from pKD3 inserted by linear transformation included FRT-recombination sites present on the template plasmids. PCR products of the right size were purified with Fermentas gel and PCR extraction kit (Fermentas) according to the instructions of the manufacturer and used for linear transformation as described previously [17]. Resistance cassettes were transferred to strains with mutations using P22 transductions [18]. The presence of the mutations were verified with PCR and subsequent sequencing before a new P22-lysate was made on strains now carrying a cat-resistance marker ∼5 kb from the mutation. The mutation was transferred to fresh wild type background with and without a selectively neutral cobI-24::MudJ mutation, using P22 transduction with the prepared lysates and isogenic strains carrying the mutation (wt) or not (cobI-24::MudJ) were saved for the mice competition experiments. Resistance markers were removed from strains using plasmid pCP20 carrying the FLP-recombinase under thermal induction control [17] for the flagellum fljBAON/fljBAOFF mutants. The original fljBAON/fljBAOFF mutants were a gift from Kelly T. Hughes [19] and the mutations were transferred into our mutant and wild type backgrounds by P22 transductions. Presence of the fljBAON/fljBAOFF mutations was verified with PCR and restriction cleavage with SacI, which cleaves the fljBOFF PCR product (to 419 bp +1329 bp) but not the fljBON product (1748 bp). Presence of the identified mutations was verified after fljBAON/fljBAOFF transductions with PCR and sequencing.

Competition Experiments in Mice

The competition experiments were performed in female 6–8 weeks old BALB/c mice. The mutants were competed against respective isogenic wild type strain (Table 1) in the following pairs DA18243/DA18336, DA18251/DA18344, DA18933/DA18938, DA18935/DA18938, DA18939/DA18942, DA18940/DA18942, DA21181/DA21184, DA21182/DA21184 and DA21179/DA21185. Five mice/group were infected intraperitoneally with a mixture of mutant and wild type bacteria at a ratio of 1∶1 and a final amount of ∼104 cfu. Mice were sacrificed on day 3–4 and the spleens from sacrificed mice were removed and homogenized in PBS before dilutions of the homogenates were plated on LA and LA plates supplemented with Kanamycin. The competition index was calculated after one cycle of growth in mice (∼10 generations) as the ratio of the mutant population divided by the population of the isogenic wild type strain as compared to the proportion of the mutant population relative to the wild type in the infection mixture. Selection coefficients (s) were estimated using the regression model s = [ln(R(t)/R(0))]/[t], as previously described [20], where R is the ratio of mutant to wild type and t the number of generations. The relative fitness (W) was calculated as 1-s.

Ethics Statement

Animal experiments were carried out at the animal facility at the Microbiology and Tumor Biology Centre, Karolinska Institute (Stockholm, Sweden), in compliance with EU, national and institutional guidelines (regulations DFS2004:4 and DFS2004:15 from Swedish Board of Agriculture). Animal experiments were approved by the Animal Experiments Committee, Stockholm North (ethical permits N345/08 and N491/11).

Quantitative Real-time PCR

Cells were grown overnight and diluted 1∶100 in fresh LB and grown to OD600 = 0.5. 1 ml of the culture was removed and RNA was prepared with the SV Total RNA Isolation System (Promega) according to the manufacturer. RNA was treated with turbo DNAse (Ambion) according to the instructions of the manufacturer to remove any remaining chromosomal DNA. RNA concentrations were measured with a Nanodrop 1000 (Thermo scientific) and 0.1- to 0.3 µg RNA was used for cDNA synthesis. mRNA was converted to cDNA using the iScript reverse transcription kit from BioRad according to the manufacturer. Quantitative real-time PCR technique based on the high affinity of SYBR Green dye for double-stranded DNA was used to measure relative mRNA levels with the CT-value method according to the manufacturer (Bio-Rad). The fluorescence signal was monitored on-line, using the iCycler real-time PCR system (Bio-Rad laboratories). The mRNA levels were calculated relative to dnaE mRNA in each individual RNA-sample, and normalized to expression of the same gene in wild type cells (DA6192). Primers for the real-time PCR are found in Table S4. RNA was prepared from 2 independent cultures and all quantitative real time PCR measurements were run in duplicates and at least 2 times for all samples.

Motility Testing

To test whether the motility of cells expressing fliC type of flagellum rather than fljB type flagellum was altered, we performed motility testing on motility agar plates as described previously [21]. Motility plates were made with 0.3% agar, 0.5% Tryptone, 0.25% Yeast extract and 0.25% Sodium chloride. In short, 5 fresh colonies (after growth over night on plate) were stabbed into fresh (less than 24 h old) motility agar plates with a toothpick. Motility was detected visually after 16 h of growth in 37°C as the spreading of the colony in the motility agar. Motility was given as a five grade scale; −, (+), +,++ and +++, where − stands for non-motile and +++ for fully motile.

Results

Serial Passage of Bacteria in Mice

In a previous study, 8 independent lineages of S. typhimurium were evolved by serial passage in BALB/c mice for approximately 130 generations [10]. All of these evolved bacteria (listed in Table 1) showed an increased growth rate in mice as measured by competition with the non-evolved parent strain. The competition indexes (CI) were calculated as the ratio of the evolved population per parent after 10 generations of growth in mice and varied between 2 and 57 for the different lineages (Fig. 1a). This corresponds to an increase in relative fitness varying from 10- to 40% for the different evolved populations (Fig. 1b).

Whole-genome Sequencing

The eight evolved lineages and their wild type ancestor JB124 were sequenced to between 25- and 42-fold mean sequence coverage. Based on the overall similarity in quality of each of the 9 datasets, we deemed it likely that the results of comparison of each dataset to the published reference sequence would be valid (Table S1). We identified 89 High-confidence differences (HCDiffs) between JB124 and the published sequence of S. typhimurium LT2 (Genbank ID NC003197) (Table S2). These differences can either be the result of sequencing errors in the published reference strains or accumulation of mutations since the separation of these isolates. Considering the number of changes observed we find the former explanation more likely. Screening of the HCDiffs against other complete S. typhimurium genomes in the non-redundant databases also support this and we find only 13 mutations that appear to be unique to JB124 (Table S3). Almost all of these mutations were also identified in adapted strains. Although coverage of the reference genome was consistently above 99% some regions of JB124 sequenced poorly and had some remaining apparent gaps. No lineage-specific mutations that might be candidates for pathoadaptive mutations were observed in those regions.

Identification of Pathoadaptive Mutations

After screening out differences between the published reference and the parent strain, we looked for both nucleotide substitutions and genomic rearrangements between JB124 and the evolved lineages. Each of the lineages examined contained at least one of each type of variation as described below. In typical sequencing projects, mutations in a sample derived from a pure, single-colony purified clone are identified on the basis of high consensus disagreement with the published reference sequence (>85% read-level consensus for all mutations; 100% for most). However, since our sequencing data for the adapted strains was derived from populations obtained from mouse serial passage instead of single clones, only mutations fixed in the population would meet the 85% consensus cut-off. No such high frequency variations were detected. With a lower cut-off criterion we identified 12 different high-confidence mutations that were present in 11- to 60% of the reads (Table 2). These mutations were lineage-specific, suggesting that they had been selected independently during repeated animal passage and possibly conferred an increased competitive ability in mice. Mutations mapping to homopolymer regions known to present problems in 454 sequences were ignored, as were candidate mutations mapping close to the ends of contigs, which can present assembly conflicts. The identified mutations were mostly substitutions, as well as few insertion/deletions. Among these 12 mutations, we chose to study further the mutations that had reached the highest level in the population, and that were expected to confer the most beneficial effect. Accordingly, the populations designated DA5810 and DA5816 contained point mutations in the stpA (60% of the population) and phoQ (57% of the population) genes (positions 2947501 and 1318652) respectively. Both of these genes are known regulators of virulence factors in Salmonella and were thus examined further.

We confirmed the presence of the stpA(E42delta) and phoQ(L13Q) alleles by sequencing PCR products from 10 single colonies of the populations. This analysis confirmed that both mutations were present in 50–60% of their respective population (6/10 and 5/10 respectively). StpA is a H-NS homologue and has no assigned function in Escherichia coli (E. coli) [22], [23]. However, in S. typhimurium StpA was recently shown to regulate expression of 5% of the genes in the Salmonella genome [24]. An important role of StpA in S. typhimurium is growth phase-specific regulation of gene expression. For example, during mid-exponential phase StpA prevents expression of the RpoS regulon whereas it is required for full expression of the CRP-cAMP regulon during late-exponential growth [24]. PhoQ is the sensory componant in the PhoQ/PhoP two-component regulatory system [25]. Inactivation of either phoP or phoQ has been shown to attenuate virulence of S. typhimurium in mice by compromising survival in mice macrophages [5], [26]. Thus, it is unlikely that the phoQ (L13Q) mutation found here is a loss of function mutation.

Alignment of PhoQ and StpA Protein Sequences

To ascertain whether any other genome sequences contained similar variant alleles of PhoQ and StpA, we conducted BLASTp searches and performed multiple alignments on protein sequences from other Salmonellae and related Enterobacteriaceae using the variant alleles (Fig. 2). No other Salmonella sequenced to date contained either variant. Furthermore, the L13 residue was conserved in Salmonella, E. coli,Yersinia pestis and Mycobacterium PhoQ homologs. Similarly, the E42 residue of StpA is part of a stretch of four glutamic acid residues that is conserved in the homologues found in Salmonella, E. coli and Shigella flexneri (Fig. 2). However, the StpA homologue H-NS shares sequence identity to StpA in this region but only contains three glutamic acid residues (like our E42delta mutant). According to the domain structure of StpA and H-NS the glutamic acid region is located in the N-terminal domain of the protein and in the region involved in dimerization of H-NS and StpA [27]. Dimers of StpA/H-NS are much more stable than oligomers which are rapidly degraded by Lon protease. Thus the deletion of amino acid E42 could result in increased stability of the StpA protein [14].

thumbnail
Figure 2. Pathoadaptive phoQ (L13Q) and stpA (E42delta) mutations are not found in previously sequenced strains.

Multiple alignment of PhoQ (top) and StpA and HNS (bottom) proteins from all published Salmonella sequences and other organisms as indicated.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070147.g002

Reconstruction of the Mutants and Growth Rates in Mice

The stpA (E42delta) mutation was found in 60% of the population by whole genome sequencing and the original population DA5810 had a competitive index of 57 and a 40% increase in relative fitness (W) (Fig. 1ab). When the mutation was moved to a wild type background the stpA (E42delta) mutant had a competitive index of 5 and a 17% increase in relative fitness (Fig. 1a–b). Likewise, the phoQ (L13Q) mutation was found in 57% of the population, and the original population DA5816 had a competitive index of 25 and a 32% increase in relative fitness (Fig. 1a–b). When the mutation was moved to a wild type background the phoQ (L13Q) mutant had a competitive index of 3 and a 11% increase in relative fitness (Fig. 1a–b). From these results we conclude that the stpA (E42delta) and phoQ (L13Q) are only partly responsible for the increased virulence seen in the evolved population in mice.

Regulation of Virulence-gene Expression

PhoQ and StpA are known regulators of virulence genes and both have been shown to affect expression of the RpoS regulon [24], [28]. In turn, RpoS regulates many genes required for virulence including the spvABCD gene operon essential for survival within macrophages [29]. To test whether the mutations in StpA and a PhoQ were affecting protein function positively or negatively, we tested how the reconstructed mutations affected expression of the RpoS regulated katE and the PhoQ regulated mgtA genes known to be regulated by StpA and PhoQ respectively [24], [30]. We also tested whether the mutations affected expression of the RpoS regulated spvABCD virulence gene operon (spv for Salmonella plasmid virulence) required for survival in macrophages.

Quantitative real-time PCR showed that both the reconstructed PhoQ(L13Q) and the StpA(E42Del) mutations resulted in a 10-fold decrease in expression of katE (Fig. 3). StpA is known to repress expression of the RpoS regulon (including katE) during exponential growth [24]. We observed a 10-fold decrease in katE expression in the StpA(E42Del) mutant indicating that the mutation enhances StpA activity. PhoQ stabilizes RpoS levels through increased expression of IraD, which in turn sequesters RssB protein thus preventing RssB from binding to RpoS and delivering it for ClpXP proteolysis [28]. We observed a 10-fold decrease in katE expression in the PhoQ mutant, indicating that the PhoQ(L13Q) mutation is affecting PhoQ function negatively. In addition, we tested how the PhoQ(L13Q) mutation affected expression of the mgtA gene, that is known to be positively regulated by PhoQ. The PhoQ(L13Q) mutation resulted in a 3-fold decrease in mgtA expression levels (Fig. 3) suggesting that the PhoQ(L13Q) mutation is affecting PhoQ function negatively. The StpA(E42Del) mutation did not affect mgtA expression as predicted (Fig. 3).

thumbnail
Figure 3. Expression levels of spvA (black bars), mgtA (light grey bars) and rpoS (dark grey bars) in the StpA(E42Del) and the PhoQ(L13Q) mutant relative to wild type levels.

All expression levels are relative to the dnaE mRNA levels in each RNA sample. Error-bars are SEM.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070147.g003

Importantly, both the StpA(E42Del) mutation and the PhoQ(L13Q) mutation resulted in an increased expression of spvA, 5- and 3-fold respectively (Fig. 3). Both StpA and PhoQ have been shown to affect expression of the RpoS regulon and RpoS is required for spv expression during stress conditions [31]. However, neither the phoQ nor the stpA mutation increased expression of the RpoS regulon suggesting that the increased spvA expression is mediated through another mechanism than increased levels of RpoS.

Flagellum Inversion in Adapted Strains

The fljB and fliC genes of S. typhimurium are divergently expressed, where a 931 bp invertible cassette that contains a single promoter controls the expression from both fljB and fliC loci in the following manner: when the hin-invertable element is located so that the fljBA promoter is in the ON-orientation this results in the expression of both the flagellar protein FljB and the FljA repressor protein. FljA represses expression of fliC loci post-transcriptionally, which results in a FljB type of flagellum [10], [24]. When the hin-invertable element is located so that the fljBA promoter is in the OFF-orientation, this represses expression of both the fljB and fljA genes. Since FljA no longer represses expression of fliC, this orientation of hin results in a FliC type of flagellum [10]. Strain JB124 had the hin region in the fljBON orientation and thus expressed the fljB type flagellum whereas all of the in vivo evolved strains had switched hin orientation and was in a fljBOFF state, and were with one exception non-motile (Fig. 4ab).

thumbnail
Figure 4. Motility testing on motility agar.

A) Illustrating how motility is scored on motility agar. Motility is scored on a 5 step scale where (−) is non-motile and+++is fully motile. B) Motility and phase variation of wild type and evolved Salmonella typhimurium strains. FljBAON cells expressing fljB type of flagellum and FljBAOFF cells expressing fliC type of flagellum. Percentage indicates the fraction of cells (based on whole-genome sequencing) in mouse-adapted population that were in FljBAON state.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070147.g004

Expression of FliC Flagellum Increases Competitive Ability in Mice

Previous results show that S. typhimurium mutants expressing FliC type of flagellum are more virulent in mice, at least when administered orally or intravenously [32]. In view of these results, it is possible that in addition to the phoQ and stpA mutations the switch from fljBON to fljBOFF contributed to the increased competitive ability of the evolved strains. Competition experiments (with bacteria injected intraperitoneally) with mutants genetically locked in either position (expressing fliC or fljB exclusively) in wild type background showed that with the flagellum in the fliC orientation (fljBAOFF, DA21179) the competition index was 5 and a 16% increase in relative fitness as compared to the wild type strain with the flagellum in fljB orientation (fljBAON, DA21185) (Fig. 1a–b). Furthermore, combination of the stpA(E42delta) with a fliC flagellum (fljBAOFF, DA18933) resulted in a competitive index of 19 and a 29% increase in relative fitness, to be compared with the original mouse-adapted population that had a competitive index of 57 and a 40% increase in relative fitness (Fig. 1a–b). Combination of the phoQ (L13Q) mutation with a fliC flagellum (fljBAOFF, DA18939) resulted in a competitive index of 4.4 and a 15% increase in relative fitness, to be compared with the original mouse-adapted population with a competitive index of 25 and a 32% increase in relative fitness (Fig. 1a–b). From these results, we conclude that the major part of the increased growth rate in mice seen in the original mouse-adapted population of DA5810 is due to the stpA (E42delta) mutation in combination with the hin-inversion (29- and 40% increase in relative fitness respectively). However, for the mouse-adapted population of DA5816, the phoQ (L13Q) and hin-inversion mutations accounted only for a minor part of the increased growth rate in mice (15 and 32% increase in relative fitness respectively). Since several low abundance mutations were found in the latter population, it is possible that these mutations also contribute to the faster growth, thus providing a possible explanation for the difference in virulence between the parental population and the reconstructed strain. It is also possible that several beneficial mutations are competing within the population, resulting in clonal interference and the lack of additive effects on fitness when combining the different mutations. Also, the increased virulence of lineages DA5828, DA5884, DA5894 and DA5915, can be attributed to the hin-inversion seen in all the adapted lineages, since this inversion alone should give a competitive index of ∼5 and a 16% increase in relative fitness (Fig. 1a–b).

Evolved Strains have Partly or Fully Lost their Motility on Motility Agar Plates

To test whether the motility of cells expressing fliC type of flagellum rather than fljB type flagellum was altered, we performed motility testing on motility agar plates as described previously [21]. All 8 evolved strains were tested, and interestingly, 7/8 strains expressing the fliC type of flagellum were non-motile on motility agar plates (Fig. 3a–b), implying that absence of motility increases bacterial growth in mice. The previous finding that Salmonella mutants that lack flagella grow significantly faster in BALB/c mice than the flagellated strains supports this hypothesis [7].

Discussion

Here we show that mutations in global regulators of virulence (stpA and phoQ) and mutations affecting the flagellum composition increase bacterial growth rates in mice and confer a pathoadaptive phenotype. StpA and PhoQ proteins govern master regulatory systems. PhoQ is the primary sensor kinase involved in regulation of a broad suite of virulence factors, including SPI-1, SPI-2 and various lipid A modifying genes [33]. The effect of the L13Q substitution on PhoQ activity is likely to be subtle, as mutations to PhoQ that result in constitutive activation or complete ablation also attenuate virulence [34]. While the sensor kinase domain at the C-terminus and the Mg2+ binding periplasmic loop are well-characterized [25], [30], [35], [36], little is known about the short N-terminal region (including amino acid 13) that precedes the first trans-membrane domain and is predicted to lie in the cytoplasm. This is the first evidence implicating the N-terminal trans-membrane region of PhoQ in any function. Increases in gene expression of members of the PhoP/Q regulon have been observed in hypervirulent strains following animal passage [37], although the transient increase in virulence in those strains suggest different mechanism(s) contributing to the infectivity of those strains.

StpA is a H-NS homologue that in S. typhimurium shares 52% amino acid identity with H-NS. Although no obvious phenotype of StpA inactivation could be detected in E. coli [38] a recent study showed that inactivation of StpA resulted in altered expression of 5% of the S. typhimurium genome [24]. Interestingly, StpA was shown to be a master regulator governing the stationary phase response along with RpoS. LT2 strains of Salmonella have a known defect in the RpoS response which is conferred by a mutation in the start codon resulting in the sub-optimal UUG start. This defect causes a significant decrease in virulence in mice relative to 14028s or SL1344 strains [39], [40]. In spite of the potential advantage of reversion to an AUG start codon, we did not observe any revertants of the rpoS gene to the parental allele in any of our evolved strains. However, both StpA and PhoQ have been shown to affect expression of the RpoS regulon in S.typhimurium, suggesting that suboptimal expression of the RpoS regulon could be a problem during infection.

RpoS is a stationary phase specific sigma factor that functions as a global regulator of gene expression under various stress conditions. During infection RpoS regulates a number of known virulence factors and is essential for Salmonella virulence in mice. For example, RpoS regulates the spv (Salmonella plasmid virulence) operon required for survival within macrophages. The spv locus is required for bacterial virulence in mice, as demonstrated by a several logs increase in LD50 dose in an spv defective mutant [41]. The spvABCD operon is expressed from a single promoter that is positively regulated by both RpoS and the SpvR regulatory protein [42], [43]. Surprisingly, both the StpA(E42Del) and the PhoQ(L13Q) mutations down-regulated expression of the RpoS regulon instead of resulting in an increase in RpoS regulated gene-expression. However, both mutations did increase expression of the spv virulence-gene operon specifically in an RpoS independent manner. H-NS, a SptA homologue, has been shown to affect spv expression independently of RpoS44. H-NS prevents recognition of the spvR promoter by a sigma70 containing RNA polymerase and by doing so, couples the expression of the spv operon to the cellular levels of sigmaS [44]. StpA is similar to H-NS in that it is able to bind and form a rigid filament along DNA [45]. Even though the DNA binding patterns of StpA and H-NS are similar in E.coli [46], major differences in effects on gene regulation are seen in S.typhimurium [24]. It is possible that stabilization of the StpA dimer by the StpA(E42Del) mutation allows StpA to increase spv-gene expression by changing the DNA curvature at the spv locus thus allowing expression of the spvR inducer that is normally repressed by H-NS. Increased levels of spvR would then lead to increased expression of the spvABCD operon as SpvR is essential for activation of the spvA promoter and is known to be able to induce RpoS-independent expression from the spvA promoter [31]. In conclusion, we have identified two new mutations that both increase expression of the spv virulence genes required for survival in macrophages, indicating that spv gene expression is limiting Salmonella typhimurium during infection and that any mutation that allows increased expression of these genes will increase cell survival. As Salmonella typhiumurium LT2 has lower levels of RpoS due to its suboptimal start codon and RpoS is required for full expression of the spv operon during stress, one could hypothesize that both the StpA(E42Del) and PhoQ(L13Q) mutations are compensating for the lack of RpoS during infection.

The biological significance of flagellar phase-variation for Salmonella typhimurium has been studied in murine infection models. Non-flagellated mutants of Salmonella typhimurium retain their virulence and their ability to infect BALB/c mice [46]. However, Salmonella mutants locked in the fljBON position are completely attenuated in a murine model whereas mutant locked in the fljBOFF position retain their virulence [32]. These experiments were performed as single infections and can therefore not be directly compared with our results obtained from competitions. Our data shows that the fljBOFF locked mutants have a 5-fold increase in competitive indexes in mice as compared to the fljBON state. Thus, for four of the eight sequenced lineages (DA5822, 5884, 5894, and 5915) the switch from fljBON to fljBOFF during evolution in mice can explain the increase in competitive ability. As flagellum switching is a frequent event, occurring at a frequency about 10−3 to 10−5 per cell per generation21, it is expected that the majority of cells in all lineages would be in the fljBOFF state. In contrast, the stpA and phoQ point mutations are much rarer and it will therefore take a longer time for these mutations to appear and become fixed in the population (note that these mutations were only fixed to about 60%).

The contributions to bacterial growth rates by these mutations alone were fairly moderate (11- and 17% increases in relative fitness). However, when two of the mutations (stpA and fljBAOFF) were combined in the same background this resulted in a synergistic increase in growth. In contrast, combination of the phoQ mutation with fljBAOFF resulted in a slightly antagonistic effect on growth, suggesting that the contribution of individual mutations to the fitness of a population is not simply additive. In addition, among the eight whole-genome sequenced lineages several other mutations were found. Thus, it is likely that the mouse-adapted populations contain, apart from the three identified mutations, other low-abundance variants that also contribute to the increased fitness in mice. Interestingly, two of these low abundance mutations were found in two separate lineages (Table 2), which might suggest a strong epistasis between the two mutations. Another possibility is that the strains were contaminated at some point during the evolution experiment. If this was the case, it must have been early during serial passage since both lineages have additional unshared mutations (Table 2).

As our previous report suggested [10], pathoadaptation of these isolates appears to have occurred sequentially, with the high-frequency hin inversion event governing flagellum biosynthesis and motility occurring early and in all of the adapted lineages, while lower-frequency point mutations swept the populations later if at all. Our observations are consistent with earlier reports of the requirement for multiple mouse passages of Burkholderia pseudomallei to obtain a highly pathogenic isolate [47] and with the rapid purification of virulent isolates from a less-virulent population by single rounds of animal passage [48]. The emergence of pathoadaptive mutations in nature is restricted by the mutation rate of the pathogen and its effective population size at multiple points in the infection cycle, especially the genetic bottlenecks associated with transmission between individuals and even within hosts [49], [50]. Our results show that the pathogen’s own evolved regulatory network itself provides an additional constraint on in vivo evolution that must be re-tuned to accommodate changes in host environments.

Supporting Information

Table S1.

Genome Sequencing Statistics by Strain.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070147.s001

(DOCX)

Table S2.

Sequence differences between strain JB124 and the published sequence of S. typhimurium LT2 (Genbank ID NC003197).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070147.s002

(XLSX)

Table S3.

Unique Mutations identified in JB124 relative to LT2.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0070147.s003

(DOCX)

Author Contributions

Conceived and designed the experiments: SK HG LS DIA. Performed the experiments: SK NA GO SB MK PM AL EF LM CNR ES. Analyzed the data: SK HG LS NA GO SB MK PM AL EF LM CNR MR ES DIA. Wrote the paper: SK HG LS MR DIA.

References

  1. 1. Lenski RE, Travisano M (1994) Dynamics of adaptation and diversification: a 10,000-generation experiment with bacterial populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 91 15: 6808–14.
  2. 2. Rainey PB, Buckling A, Kassen R, Travisano M (2000) The emergence and maintenance of diversity: insights from experimental bacterial populations. Trends Ecol Evol 15 6: 243–247.
  3. 3. Salcedo SP, Noursadeghi M, Cohen J, Holden DW (2001) Intracellular replication of Salmonella typhimurium strains in specific subsets of splenic macrophages in vivo. Cell Microbiol 3 9: 587–97.
  4. 4. Clements M, Eriksson S, Tezcan-Merdol D, Hinton JC, Rhen M (2001) Virulence gene regulation in Salmonella enterica. Ann Med 33 3: 178–85.
  5. 5. Miller SI, Kukral AM, Mekalanos JJ (1989) A two-component regulatory system (phoP phoQ) controls Salmonella typhimurium virulence. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 86 13: 5054–8.
  6. 6. Bianconi I, Milani A, Cigana C, Paroni M, Levesque RC, et al. (2011) Positive signature-tagged mutagenesis in Pseudomonas aeruginosa: tracking patho-adaptive mutations promoting airways chronic infection. PLoS Pathog 7 2: e1001270.
  7. 7. Vijay-Kumar M, Wu H, Jones R, Grant G, Babbin B, et al. (2006) Flagellin suppresses epithelial apoptosis and limits disease during enteric infection. Am J Pathol 169 5: 1686–700.
  8. 8. Haneda T, Sugimoto M, Yoshida-Ohta Y, Kodera Y, Oh-Ishi M, et al. (2010) Comparative proteomic analysis of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium ppGpp-deficient mutant to identify a novel virulence protein required for intracellular survival in macrophages. BMC Microbiol 10: 324.
  9. 9. Nash JH, Villegas A, Kropinski AM, Aguilar-Valenzuela R, Konczy P, et al. (2010) Genome sequence of adherent-invasive Escherichia coli and comparative genomic analysis with other E. coli pathotypes. BMC Genomics 11: 667.
  10. 10. Nilsson AI, Kugelberg E, Berg OG, Andersson DI (2004) Experimental adaptation of Salmonella typhimurium to mice. Genetics 168 3: 1119–30.
  11. 11. Tettelin H (2009) The bacterial pan-genome and reverse vaccinology. Genome Dynamics 6: 35–47.
  12. 12. Robins-Browne RM, Miliotis MD, Cianciosi S, Miller VL, Falkow S, et al. (1989) Evaluation of DNA colony hybridization and other techniques for detection of virulence in Yersinia species. J Clin Microbiol 27 4: 644–50.
  13. 13. Miller JF, Mekalanos JJ, Falkow S (1989) Coordinate regulation and sensory transduction in the control of bacterial virulence. Science 243 4893: 916–22.
  14. 14. Johansson J, Eriksson S, Sonden B, Wai SN, Uhlin BE (2001) Heteromeric interactions among nucleoid-associated bacterial proteins: localization of StpA-stabilizing regions in H-NS of Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol 183 7: 2343–7.
  15. 15. Margulies M, Egholm M, Altman WE, Attiya S, Bader JS, et al. (2005) Genome sequencing in microfabricated high-density picolitre reactors. Nature 437 7057: 376–80.
  16. 16. Darling AE, Treangen TJ, Messeguer X, Perna NT (2007) Analyzing patterns of microbial evolution using the mauve genome alignment system. Meth Mol Biol 396: 135–52.
  17. 17. Datsenko KA, Wanner BL (2000) One-step inactivation of chromosomal genes in Escherichia coli K-12 using PCR products. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 97 12: 6640–5.
  18. 18. Maloy SR, Cronan JE, Freifelder D (1994) Microbial Genetics 2nd ed: Jones and Barlett Publishers International.
  19. 19. Bonifield HR, Hughes KT (2003) Flagellar phase variation in Salmonella enterica is mediated by a posttranscriptional control mechanism. J Bacteriol 185 12: 3567–74.
  20. 20. DE D (1990) Experimental Studies of Natural Selection in Bacteria. Ann Rev Ecol Systemat 21: 373–398.
  21. 21. Gillen KL, Hughes KT (1991) Negative regulatory loci coupling flagellin synthesis to flagellar assembly in Salmonella typhimurium. J Bacteriol 173 7: 2301–10.
  22. 22. Muller CM, Dobrindt U, Nagy G, Emody L, Uhlin BE, et al. (2006) Role of histone-like proteins H-NS and StpA in expression of virulence determinants of uropathogenic Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol 188 15: 5428–38.
  23. 23. Zhang A, Rimsky S, Reaban ME, Buc H, Belfort M (1996) Escherichia coli protein analogs StpA and H-NS: regulatory loops, similar and disparate effects on nucleic acid dynamics. EMBO J 15 6: 1340–9.
  24. 24. Lucchini S, McDermott P, Thompson A, Hinton JC (2009) The H-NS-like protein StpA represses the RpoS (sigma 38) regulon during exponential growth of Salmonella Typhimurium. Mol Microbiol 74 5: 1169–86.
  25. 25. Vescovi EG, Ayala YM, Di Cera E, Groisman EA (1997) Characterization of the bacterial sensor protein PhoQ. Evidence for distinct binding sites for Mg2+ and Ca2+. J Biol Chem 272 3: 1440–3.
  26. 26. Fields PI, Swanson RV, Haidaris CG, Heffron F (1986) Mutants of Salmonella typhimurium that cannot survive within the macrophage are avirulent. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 83 14: 5189–93.
  27. 27. Cusick ME Belfort M (1998) Domain structure and RNA annealing activity of the Escherichia coli regulatory protein StpA. Mol Microbiol 28 4: 847–57.
  28. 28. Tu X, Latifi T, Bougdour A, Gottesman S, Groisman EA (2006) The PhoP/PhoQ two-component system stabilizes the alternative sigma factor RpoS in Salmonella enterica. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103 36: 13503–8.
  29. 29. Gulig PA, Danbara H, Guiney DG, Lax AJ, Norel F, et al. (1993) Molecular analysis of spv virulence genes of the Salmonella virulence plasmids. Mol Microbiol 7 6: 825–30.
  30. 30. Groisman EA (2001) The pleiotropic two-component regulatory system PhoP-PhoQ. J Bacteriol 183 6: 1835–42.
  31. 31. Chen CY, Buchmeier NA, Libby S, Fang FC, Krause M, et al. (1995) Central regulatory role for the RpoS sigma factor in expression of Salmonella dublin plasmid virulence genes. J Bacteriol 177 18: 5303–9.
  32. 32. Arico B, Miller JF, Roy C, Stibitz S, Monack D, et al. (1989) Sequences required for expression of Bordetella pertussis virulence factors share homology with prokaryotic signal transduction proteins. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 86 17: 6671–5.
  33. 33. Ernst RK, Guina T, Miller SI (1999) How intracellular bacteria survive: surface modifications that promote resistance to host innate immune responses. J Inf Dis 179 Suppl 2S326–30.
  34. 34. Miller SI, Mekalanos JJ (1990) Constitutive expression of the phoP regulon attenuates Salmonella virulence and survival within macrophages. J Bacteriol 172 5: 2485–90.
  35. 35. Cho US, Bader MW, Amaya MF, Daley ME, Klevit RE, et al. (2006) Metal bridges between the PhoQ sensor domain and the membrane regulate transmembrane signaling. J Mol Biol 356 5: 1193–206.
  36. 36. Castelli ME, Garcia Vescovi E, Soncini FC (2000) The phosphatase activity is the target for Mg2+ regulation of the sensor protein PhoQ in Salmonella. J Biol Chem 275 30: 22948–54.
  37. 37. Heithoff DM, Shimp WR, House JK, Xie Y, Weimer BC, et al. (2012) Intraspecies variation in the emergence of hyperinfectious bacterial strains in nature. PLoS Pathog 8 4: e1002647.
  38. 38. Bertin P, Hommais F, Krin E, Soutourina O, Tendeng C, et al. (2001) H-NS and H-NS-like proteins in Gram-negative bacteria and their multiple role in the regulation of bacterial metabolism. Biochimie 83 2: 235–41.
  39. 39. Swords WE, Cannon BM, Benjamin WH Jr (1997) Avirulence of LT2 strains of Salmonella typhimurium results from a defective rpoS gene. Infect Immun 65 6: 2451–3.
  40. 40. Wilmes-Riesenberg MR, Foster JW, Curtiss R 3rd (1997) An altered rpoS allele contributes to the avirulence of Salmonella typhimurium LT2. Infect Immun 65 1: 203–10.
  41. 41. Guiney DG, Fierer J (2011) The Role of the spv Genes in Salmonella Pathogenesis. Front Microbiol 2: 129.
  42. 42. Krause M, Fang FC, Guiney DG (1992) Regulation of plasmid virulence gene expression in Salmonella dublin involves an unusual operon structure. J Bacteriol 174 13: 4482–9.
  43. 43. Grob P, Guiney DG (1996) In vitro binding of the Salmonella dublin virulence plasmid regulatory protein SpvR to the promoter regions of spvA and spvR. J Bacteriol 178 7: 1813–20.
  44. 44. Robbe-Saule V, Schaeffer F, Kowarz L, Norel F (1997) Relationships between H-NS, sigma S, SpvR and growth phase in the control of spvR, the regulatory gene of the Salmonella plasmid virulence operon. Mol Gen Genet : MGG 256 4: 333–47.
  45. 45. Lim CJ, Whang YR, Kenney LJ, Yan J (2012) Gene silencing H-NS paralogue StpA forms a rigid protein filament along DNA that blocks DNA accessibility. Nucl Acids Res 40 8: 3316–28.
  46. 46. Miller JF, Roy CR, Falkow S (1989) Analysis of Bordetella pertussis virulence gene regulation by use of transcriptional fusions in Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol 171 11: 6345–8.
  47. 47. Nigg C, Ruch J, Scott E, Noble K (1956) Enhancement of virulence of Malleomyces pseudomallei. J Bacteriol 71 5: 530–41.
  48. 48. Jacobson MA, Falk IS (1927) Studies On Respiratory Diseases Xxix. The Influence Of Anti-Serum And Of Animal Passage Upon The Virulence And Electrophoresis Of Pneumococci. J Bacteriol 13 3: 191–201.
  49. 49. Plaut RD, Kelly VK, Lee GM, Stibitz S, Merkel TJ (2012) Dissemination bottleneck in a murine model of inhalational anthrax. Infect Imm 80 9: 3189–93.
  50. 50. Troy EB, Lin T, Gao L, Lazinski DW, Camilli A, et al. (2013) Understanding Barriers to Borrelia burgdorferi Dissemination during Infection Using Massively Parallel Sequencing. Infect Imm 81 7: 2347–57.