Tuberculosis is a major human and animal disease of major importance worldwide. Genetically, the closely related strains within the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex which cause disease are well-characterized but there is an urgent need better to understand their phenotypes. To search rapidly for metabolic differences, a working method using Biolog Phenotype MicroArray analysis was developed. Of 380 substrates surveyed, 71 permitted tetrazolium dye reduction, the readout over 7 days in the method. By looking for ≥5-fold differences in dye reduction, 12 substrates differentiated M. tuberculosis H37Rv and Mycobacterium bovis AF2122/97. H37Rv and a Beijing strain of M. tuberculosis could also be distinguished in this way, as could field strains of M. bovis; even pairs of strains within one spoligotype could be distinguished by 2 to 3 substrates. Cluster analysis gave three clear groups: H37Rv, Beijing, and all the M. bovis strains. The substrates used agreed well with prior knowledge, though an unexpected finding that AF2122/97 gave greater dye reduction than H37Rv with hexoses was investigated further, in culture flasks, revealing that hexoses and Tween 80 were synergistic for growth and used simultaneously rather than in a diauxic fashion. Potential new substrates for growth media were revealed, too, most promisingly N-acetyl glucosamine. Osmotic and pH arrays divided the mycobacteria into two groups with different salt tolerance, though in contrast to the substrate arrays the groups did not entirely correlate with taxonomic differences. More interestingly, these arrays suggested differences between the amines used by the M. tuberculosis complex and enteric bacteria in acid tolerance, with some hydrophobic amino acids being highly effective. In contrast, γ-aminobutyrate, used in the enteric bacteria, had no effect in the mycobacteria. This study proved principle that Phenotype MicroArrays can be used with slow-growing pathogenic mycobacteria and already has generated interesting data worthy of further investigation.
Citation: Khatri B, Fielder M, Jones G, Newell W, Abu-Oun M, Wheeler PR (2013) High Throughput Phenotypic Analysis of Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Mycobacterium bovis Strains' Metabolism Using Biolog Phenotype Microarrays. PLoS ONE 8(1): e52673. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0052673
Editor: Riccardo Manganelli, University of Padova, Medical School, Italy
Received: August 3, 2012; Accepted: November 19, 2012; Published: January 10, 2013
Copyright: © 2013 Khatri et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Funding for this work was provided though the AHVLA's (http://ahvlaintranet/) Seedcorn programme, SC0205. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Pathogenic, slow-growing mycobacteria include the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex, of major importance as human and animal pathogens. While Mycobacterium tuberculosis causes death and disease in humans, leading to 2 million fatalities a year, Mycobacterium bovis (which is 99.95% similar at the nucleotide level) causes financial devastation with losses of $3 billion a year to agriculture .
At a genetic level, these organisms are well characterised: several strains have had their whole genome sequenced (http://www.sanger.ac.uk/resources/downloads/bacteria/mycobacterium.html; http://genolist.pasteur.fr/TubercuList/ and links therein). Intriguing links between their molecular typing and biology have been deduced. For example, a Beijing lineage has been identified as an increasing cause of disease, particularly in Asia, and is associated with outbreaks of drug-resistance elsewhere . Gene chip technology has allowed polymorphisms to be studied across a worldwide distribution, giving deep insights into the population biology of M. tuberculosis . This work suggested that M. tuberculosis strains evolve to adapt to local human populations. In the case of M. bovis, molecular typing of strains is used in surveillance of bovine tuberculosis in cattle and wildlife in the UK. One notable finding of the spacer-oligonucleotide typing (spoligotyping) done in the UK is that around 60% of the cattle are infected by just two spoligotypes of M. bovis, types 9 and 17. Type 17 represents an emerging microepidemic, increasing at a rate significantly faster than all other field strains of M. bovis .
Though molecular tracing helps us to identify emerging strains, it does not readily provide any information about their phenotypes. This is a substantial gap in our knowledge since it is the phenotype which is selectable and must relate to the apparent evolutionary advantage of one strain over another. Encouragingly, principal component analysis of metabolites clustered M. bovis strains with their spoligotypes  showing a link between molecular type and phenotype, without identifying the individual metabolites. A key metabolite was implicated in the Beijing strains that are hypervirulent in mice. They produce an immunomodulatory phenolic glycolipid located on the bacterial surface which, within this lineage, has been associated with virulence . However, this glycolipid likely has to act in concert with other phenotypic characteristics , perhaps including those arising from constitutive expression of the dosR regulon  with its effects on global regulation of metabolism. A direct indication that differences in the utilisation of substrates may be important came from a study to reveal the nature of the phenotypic differences between the emerging type 17 strains and other M. bovis strains. While their lipid composition was indistinguishable, differences in the rates of incorporation of propionate and acetate into straight chain fatty acids and pyruvate was clearly evident . Together, these data suggest differences in metabolism, and in metabolites produced, could be important in understanding the emergence of new strains and pathogens in the M. tuberculosis complex.
The targeted approaches outlined thus far have been slow and painstaking. Therefore, the use of a commercially available Phenotype MicroArray™ (Biolog) in which twenty-five 96-well plates in which nearly every well had different metabolites, substrates or conditions was assessed as a way of generating phenotypic data rapidly. This technology is based on bacteria producing NADH from which electrons reduce a tetrazolium dye in a redox reaction, resulting in irreversible formation of a purple colour. The rate of electron flow through the respiratory chain, and thus dye reduction, depends upon the conditions in each individual well of a microtitre plate. Biolog OmniLog instrumentation is used to read and record the colour change every 15 min so this provides quantitative and kinetic information about the response of bacteria to each condition in the Phenotype MicroArray (PM) . This appeared a promising approach because the reduction of tetrazolium salts to formazan dyes has been used previously to detect mycobacterial respiration, viability and growth . Moreover, tetrazolium dye reduction gave a perfect match with the original BACTEC method , which was used routinely in diagnostic work involving mycobacteria. For our work, we used Biolog plates PM1 to PM4, giving 190 carbon sources, 95 nitrogen sources, 59 phosphorous sources and 35 sulphur sources and the PM9 and PM10 plates giving 192 tests of environmental conditions such as pH and salt concentrations in a rich culture medium (Table S1 gives the conditions in each well of the PM1 to PM10 plates). Our experimental design involved using a low inoculum so that it needed growth to occur in a well for the density of bacteria to become high enough for clear dye reduction to be observed. However, it is a property of PM technology that if a high enough inoculum is used, growth is not necessary for the dye reduction to occur, and we cannot exclude the possibility of high respiration rates with minimal growth resulting in dye reduction in some wells.
In this paper, both the range of nutrients tested, and the use of tetrazolium dye reduction to indicate their use, is novel for the slow-growing Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex of pathogens.
Bacterial Strains and routinely used PM Conditions
Mycobacterial strains used in this study are described in Table 1. PM plates PM1, 2A, 3B, 4, 9 and 10, Inoculating Fluid-0a (IF-0a) and Dyes D and G (proprietary dye mixes) were obtained from Technopath, UK, and were bona fide Biolog™ (Hayward CA) materials. Middlebrook growth media and enrichment and yeast extract were obtained from Difco, all other chemicals were obtained from Sigma-Aldrich or VWR Merck.
Development work leading to the routinely used PM protocol is summarised briefly, with the conclusions, in Text S1.
To prepare the inoculum for PM plates, bacteria were grown in Middlebrook 7H9 medium containing 10% (v/v) albumin-dextrose-catalase (ADC) enrichment, 0.42% sodium pyruvate and 0.05% (v/v) Tween 80. Bacteria were harvested at mid-logarithmic stage (OD600 nm = 0.30 to 0.60), washed twice with 20 mM phosphate buffer (pH 6.8) containing 0.025% (v/v) tyloxapol and incubated in IF-0a GN/GP for 24 h at 25°C as a starvation step. Then the turbidity was adjusted to OD600 nm = 0.60 (0.18 mg dry weight/ml) . PM additive solutions for each plate were made according to Table S2. For plates PM1 to PM4, PM plates were inoculated with 100 µl of the mixture made up with the following volumes per plate: IF-0a GN/GP at 1.2×(10 ml), Dye mix G at 100×(0.12 ml), PM additive appropriate to the plate (Table S2) at 12×(1 ml) and bacteria in IF-0a GN/GP at 13.64×(0.88 ml). The strength (e.g.100×) is calculated in according to the manufacturer's specifications. For plates PM9 and PM10, PM plates were inoculated with 100 µl of the mixture made up with the following volumes per plate: Middlebrook 7H9 broth (Difco) at 1.2×(10 ml), Dye mix G at 100×(0.12 ml), PM additive appropriate to the plate (table S2) at 12×(1 ml) and bacteria in IF-0a GN/GP at 13.64×(0.88 ml). For each plate, the final volume of mixture was 12 ml with OD600 nm = 0.044. After plate inoculation, each plate was sealed with transparent film and the lid was placed on the sealed plate. The plate lid was securely taped around with transparent sealing tape, sprayed with 70% aq ethanol, transferred to an OmniLog (Biolog, Inc.) incubator and incubated at 37°C for 7 days. Taping likely helped to negate edge well effects as the volume of edge wells was the same as non edge wells after 7 days' incubation. Each inoculum was used to inoculate one of each type of plate; replicates were with separate inocula, and therefore biological replicates. Assays were performed in triplicate or quadruplicate plates, though in cases where plates could not be used (e.g. due to contamination), fewer replicates may be presented in the Results.
Contents of PM plates
The content of every PM plate from PM1 to PM10, is given in Table S1. As alphabetical order of substrates/conditions and order on the PM plate do not correspond, wells are referred to after the substrate/condition name as the PM plate followed by the well identifier in the form (plate, well), for example (PM1, B9) where required for clarity in the text.
PM Data handling and statistical analysis of data from PM1 to PM4 plates
The Biolog OmniLog PM software in Parametric module exported the data for each run into CSV files, these file contained measurements related to dye reduction at discrete time points (every 15 minutes) throughout the run (up to 168 h), and a final AUC (Area Under the Curve) figure for the entire run. Data sets were labelled to show the strains and spoligotypes that were represented within.
To check whether kinetic curves corresponded to growth, and resultant dye reduction, kinetic growth curves for strains within each well were also produced- in SAS using a GPLOT procedure (Statistical Analytical Software, Medmenham, Marlow, Buckinghamshire: http://www.sas.com/offices/europe/uk/index.html) - and used to judge the criteria used to accept or reject data (below). All the kinetic curves of PM data are presented as supplementary data (figures S1, S2, S3, S4, S5). Note, in some of these figures, data from “unstarved” bacteria are included. This data is not presented elsewhere in this paper and was not used in any of the analyses reported here.
Inspection of the kinetic curves revealed that the AUC values were often misleading, for example in wells where the baseline was >0, or if abiotic or unsustained dye reduction had occurred but then ceased. Using the PM software Parametric module, it was evident that any abiotic or unsustained dye reduction had ceased by 48 h. Therefore, instead of using AUC values, CSV files were copied into Excel spreadsheets. The dye reduction values at 0 h, 48 h and 165 h (the final time point in all sets of data) were used to calculate mean values, standard deviation (SD) and standard error of the mean (SEM) values for dye reduction (i) throughout the 165 h, calculated by subtracting the 0 h value from the 165 h value for each data set, and (ii) for “sustained dye reduction” which was calculated from the 165 h value minus the 48 h for each set of data. The units are referred to as “Omnilog units” and are generated by the Biolog OmniLog PM software from readings of colour intensity. Essentially, these are photographic readings: OD or absorbance reading were not taken. All these mean, SD and SEM values are shown in Table S3. Statistical significance for differences between strains were determined for each well by performing pairwise 2-tailed t- tests on values for each strain across the spreadsheet using Excel statistical functions. Thus, the P values from these t- tests are also all in Table S3.
PM Data handling and statistical analysis of data from PM9 and PM10 plates
Dye reduction in PM9 and PM10 strains varied with strain, thus in nearly all the wells, dye reduction was higher for H37Rv and AF2122/97. Using such raw data gave highly significant differences between these two strains for ∼70 wells. Given that the objective of these plates is to compare the effects of different environmental conditions- pH, salt, osmolytes on strains, using raw data was unsuitable and it had to be converted to relative dye reduction values. A control well with no condition being tested, only the standard culture medium being present, was established as PM9, G1. This is suitable as a control well, as it reflects the pH and phosphate concentration in the Middlebrook (7H9) medium used in these plates. Next, given that t = 0 h values were not always baseline, we subtracted the starting dye reduction (t = 0 h) value for each incubation from every value for that incubation to give generated dye reduction values in each well during the incubation period. We cannot be sure why the baseline was sometimes high in PM9 and PM10 plates, but it is notable that a rich culture medium is used in these plates, while the basal medium used for PM1 to PM4 plates gave little dye reduction on its own. Next, the issue of the different rates of dye reduction for each strain was addressed by dividing every generated dye reduction value for each incubation by the final generated dye reduction value for the control- PM9, G1- (Figure 1a) well to give relative dye reduction values. Final time point (165 h) replicates (shown in Table S4) available in all incubations were used for statistical analysis and performing 2-tailed t-tests using Excel statistical functions (i) to investigate whether there were any significant differences (P<0.05) between strains, then (ii) to determine if any agents had a statistically significant effect on restoring activity lost in wells at pH 4.5, pH 9.5 and with 6% NaCl. Note that the 165 h reading is the last available readout in all plates, though in some incubations up to eight more readings- over 2 h- were made.
Omnilog units (arbitrary colour units due to dye reduction) were plotted against time (0 to 168 h). A. The well (PM9, G1) used as a control well, with 20 mM potassium phosphate is shown as representative of >70 wells on the PM9 plate in that they all had more rapid dye reduction with H37Rv (plots in pink and black) than AF2122/97 (plots: other colours). The other traces can be viewed in Figures S1, S2, S3, S4, S5 B. Dye reduction in the presence of 6% NaCl (PM9, A7) was similar with H37Rv and AF2122/97.
Criteria to accept data for analysis- confirmation that dye reduction related to growth and metabolism
Regardless of the statistical analysis used, dye reduction due to the slow-growing mycobacteria was confirmed by inspecting kinetic curves. The following criteria were applied:
- Wells with abiotic dye reduction, that occurred in wells without bacteria (Text S2), were discarded. Abiotic dye reduction was obvious even in plates with bacteria as it was observable within 4 h, while dye reduction due to bacteria was barely apparent until 48 h.
- Wells in which dye reduction was observed at 0 h and essentially gave a flat line against time were discarded.
- Wells where rapid dye reduction occurred, followed by a flat line or lag phase (blue and green lines in Figure 2), were discarded, as this suggested contamination, likely with a more rapidly growing microbe. Our experiments were planned with the size of the inocula low so that growth had to occur to get good dye reduction by the bacteria. With their mean generation time of 20 h or more, a straight line or slight exponential increase in dye reduction against time (up to 167 h) was seen (lines other than blue or green in Figure 2b). Experimental evidence for rapid dye reduction followed by a flat line or lag phase corresponding to contamination was obtained in wells with L-alanine and Tween 40 with M. bovis type 17 (Figure 2). L-alanine is not a substrate for M. bovis (Figure 2a) while we showed Tween 40 to be one. Thus, in figure 2b, the Tween 40 reveals all the suspensions to contain viable M. bovis but the curves obtained on 10 (blue) and 26 Sep (green) with both substrates must indicate contamination. On the basis of the curves generated in this project, any with a slope of ≥30 Omnilog units/10 h were rejected. This criterion applies to the current work: if, for instance, a higher inoculum is used this cut-off would not be applicable.
These criteria may eliminate a few true positive wells but given the large amount of data generated a conservative approach, attempting to eliminate false positives, was taken. These criteria excluded 23 of the 390 wells in PM 1 to PM4 plates (390 wells), including all pentoses as they gave abiotic dye reduction.
- Wells in which <3 Omnilog units dye reduction occurred between 48 h and 165 h. This low value was chosen as it was the median value for strains in PM1 well A3, N- acetyl D-glucosamine, a substrate which was shown to support growth in culture medium as well as permit dye reduction (the culture experiment is described in the Results section).
Omnilog units (arbitrary colour units due to dye reduction) were plotted against time (0 to 168 h). Colour coding for replicates is the same in both plots; blue and green plots were of data considered to be from contaminated inocula.
The PM1 to PM4 plate data for all 28 incubations were clustered based on their phenotypic kinetic profiles according to the following procedure. For each incubation, all the measured profiles (one profile per measured test) were concatenated into a single vector of floating-point numbers. Where data were not available (e.g. data from an incubation was not measured for one or more of the plates), the missing values were flagged. A symmetrical 28×28 distance matrix was then constructed by calculating the Euclidean distance between each pair of incubations using the concatenated profile data for each incubation. Where data from one or both incubations were flagged as missing, data points were skipped and did not contribute to the distance measure. Optimal coordinates in 2 and 3 dimensions were then calculated from the distance matrix using the technique of Distance Geometry, as previously developed for the construction of genetic maps from a genetic distance matrix (Newell, W., personal communication). Incubations with similar profiles occur close to each other in this representation; incubations with very different kinetic profiles are far apart.
Incubations were colour-coded according to known genetic similarities of the bacteria in each incubation, and the coding is tabulated in Table 1. Replicate incubations, where available, are numbered 1 up to 4 after the code for the strain.
Growth experiments in culture bottles to test hypotheses about substrates generated by our PM data
Dye reduction in PM wells suggests substrates in those wells as possible candidates for culture of mycobacteria. To test these, we inoculated selected strains in 10 ml culture medium in square-bottom 30 ml bottles, shaking them once a day. Sauton base or Roisins base were used for the media. Sauton base contained (per litre) 4 g of L-asparagine, 2 g of citric acid, 0.5 g of K2HPO4, 0.5 g of MgSO4·7H2O, and 0.05 g of ferric ammonium citrate, adjusted to pH 7.2 with KOH. Roisin's base  was essentially ammonium chloride with salts (Table S5). Individual carbon sources to be tested were added to a final concentration of 2 g/l in Sauton base or 5 g/l in Roisins base except for Tweens which were added to 2 ml/l. When Tweens were not added, 0.025% (v/v) of tyloxapol (not itself a carbon source) was added as a detergent. Experiments in which both Tween 80 and hexoses were added to culture media are described in full in the results.
Wells with dye reduction in any strain
Effects of substrates- plates PM1 to PM4.
Sustained dye reduction by two strains of M. tuberculosis and four strains of M. bovis is shown in greyscale in the heatmaps (Figures 3 and 4). The more intense the dye reduction, the darker the grey. These data established the starting point for this study, that dye reduction occurred with the M. tuberculosis complex strains and was equally demonstrable in field strains as laboratory strains. Essentially these data represent dye reduction from 48 h to 165 h of incubation, due to bacteria using the substrate added to each well. We regarded this as a reliable measure as we noted that glycerol (PM1, B03) allowed dye reduction between 0 h and 48 h in some M. bovis strains, even though they cannot grow on glycerol as a sole carbon source. This dye reduction by M. bovis was not sustained much after 48 h, while a steady, exponential increase occurred in wells with M. tuberculosis throughout the 7 days' incubation. The kinetic curves for the glycerol well, and indeed for every well, can be viewed in figures S1, S2, S3, S4, S5. Actual values in Omnilog dye reduction units from 48 h to 165 h are given in Table S6, together with notes on the application of criteria for acceptance or rejection described in the methods. Dye reduction values from t = 0 h to 165 h are shown in Table S7.
n = Number of incubations (from separate pre-cultures). Code (corresponds with Table 1): Rvp = H37Rv (AHVLA); Bj = Bj 5208; 9a = type 9 61/0038/01; 9b = type 9 AF2122/97; 17c = type 17 21/7917/05; 35a = type 35 61/1307/01. Cut off for +ve is 3, the median value for well PM01, A03, since we confirmed substrate use as a C-source by growing in culture flasks using it.
n = Number of incubations (from separate pre-cultures). Code (corresponds with Table 1): Rvp = H37Rv (AHVLA); Bj = Bj 5208; 9a = type 9 61/0038/01; 9b = type 9 AF2122/97; 17c = type 17 21/7917/05; 35a = type 35 61/1307/01. Cut off for +ve is 3, the median value for well PM01, A03, since we confirmed substrate use as a C-source by growing in culture flasks using it. a3-O-β-D-Galactopyranosyl-D-Arabinose. Not rejected, but there's a risk the D-ara is released and abiotic dye reduction follows; baccepted, possible trace in a single strain.
Differences in substrate use between M. tuberculosis and M. bovis
In the heatmaps, significantly higher dye reduction is shown in red for M. bovis and green for M. tuberculosis H37Rv (Figures 3 and 4). First, the originally sequenced strains were compared- H37Rv  and M. bovis (spoligotype 9, AF2122/97: ). There were 21 substrates that gave significantly different dye reduction and at least a 2-fold difference in the dye reduction values. However, some substrates for which there were differences gave good dye reduction by both strains, for example D-serine and L-glutamic acid, while others such as methionyl-alanine (Met-Ala) and DL-lipoamide gave barely above trace dye reduction (pale grey in heatmaps). Therefore, the more stringent comparison where dye reduction was ≥10 Omnilog units and the difference was ≥5-fold is used routinely: these are indicated by darker greys and deep colours respectively in the heatmaps. Thus, when we compared every strain of M. bovis (“bovis” in the heatmap strains titles) used in this study against M. tuberculosis H37Rv, the differences in substrates that gave dye reduction were very similar to when AF2122/97 and H37Rv were compared. Just one substrate, Tween 20, which gave no dye reduction with M. tuberculosis but 38.4 Omnilog units (mean for 48 h to 165 h) with M. bovis, was added to the major differences as P<0.05 when all the M. bovis data were taken into account (Figure 3). Detailed statistical analysis is given in Table S8.
Differences in substrates supporting dye reduction between M. tuberculosis H37Rv and a Beijing strain, Bj5208
Bj5208 gave by far the highest dye reduction (Figure 4) of the strains in this study with gentiobiose and 2,3-butanedione, neither of which gave dye reduction with H37Rv. The substrates (shown in green) that gave significantly higher dye reduction with H37Rv than Bj5208, but did not distinguish H37Rv and M. bovis, were citrate and lactate, though the differences were <5-fold (Figure 3). Other substrates that gave wells with dye reduction that distinguished these two human strains were similar to those that distinguished M. tuberculosis and M. bovis as shown in Figures 3 and 4.
Dye reduction with caproic acid was notably high and like butyric (where it just failed to meet the 2-fold criterion- see Table S9), gave significantly higher dye reduction with Bj5208. The difference in dye reduction with these two short chain fatty acids between H37Rv and other strains, including Bj5208, was due to the long lag phase before dye reduction commenced only in the case of H37Rv (Figure S1).
Differences in substrates supporting dye reduction between M. bovis strains
Not surprisingly, metabolic diversity between the closely related M .bovis strains (Table 2) was less than between M. tuberculosis and M. bovis. Notable differences appeared to be due to AF2122/97 (strain 9b) being more metabolically active, perhaps even to some extent laboratory adapted with its higher dye reduction in wells with glycerol and Tween 80 which are standard culture media constituents. Consistent with this, there were no differences between the type 9 strains less often used in the laboratory, 9a and 9c. The impression from Table 2 is that 35a was the least metabolically active, though actually 35a is the only strain for which dye reduction could be detected- albeit at trace activities which are not presented in Table 2 - with α- amino-N-valeric acid (PM3, G12) and thiosulphate (PM4, F3) (Figure 4). Strain 17c appeared to give dye reduction with a wider range of nitrogen sources than 17b, with D-glucosamine (PM3, B10) and ethylenediamine (PM3, D10) distinguishing only these strains (Table 2). Full detail is presented separately for between- spoligotype (Table S10) and within - spoligotype (Table S11) comparisons of strains.
Clustering of M. tuberculosis complex strains based on their substrate use
Results of the clustering procedure are shown in Figure S6 (2D) and Figure 5 (3D). The members of the M. tuberculosis H37Rv (blue) cluster relatively close to one another, as do the members of M. bovis clusters for type 9 (orange) and type 17 (red). All the M. bovis types co-cluster, including type 35 (brown) and form a separate cluster from the human strains. The two Beijing strain replicates (green) occur close to each other and apparently with some separation from H37Rv (blue). The Bangladeshi strains, Tb 12 and Tb 30, could be investigated by cluster analysis. They had no replicates for at least some of the PM plates but this is acceptable as in cluster analysis each point is generated from a single set of data. They appeared to be in an extended M. tuberculosis cluster on one edge of the H37Rv cluster (Figure 5).
Investigation of unexpected PM data on glycolysis substrates with a growth experiment
PM technology is essentially a first pass screening procedure, generating findings and hypotheses to be tested. One unexpected finding, given the lesion in glycolysis of an inactive pyruvate kinase  in M. bovis, was dye reduction with the hexoses glucose and mannose by M. bovis. This suggested a hypothesis that glycolytic substrates stimulate the use of other substrates. In the PM plates, Tween 80 could be such a substrate. It is a source of oleic and some other fatty acids and gave good dye reduction in its E2 well (Figure 3). In the rest of the wells, Tween 80 is at a suboptimal concentration of 0.1 ml/l. We tested the above hypothesis by performing growth experiments in 10 ml culture media. Tween 80, at 0.1 ml/l, was added to culture media with and without D-glucose and D-mannose. On its own, this concentration of Tween 80 was enough to give only very low growth yields (Table 3). As the results with mannose were almost identical to glucose, only the glucose data are shown (Table 3). Although glucose alone did not support growth of M. bovis, it stimulated growth in 0.1 ml/l Tween 80 four-fold (Table 3). The effect was confirmed in Roisins base in which there is no other carbon source (Table 3). These findings could explain the positive wells in PM1 plates inoculated with M. bovis (Figure 3) as in the short incubations of the high-throughput PM method very little growth is needed to get good dye reduction.
Growth of strains of M. tuberculosis and M. bovis on substrates that allowed dye reduction in PM plates
One of the advantages of the PM approach is that data output might suggest new substrates for culture and diagnostics of bacteria. In this work, a few carbon sources suggested for growth by their dye reduction in PM plate wells were tested to prove principle. N-acetylglucosamine, methyl-succinate and acetic acid supported growth, though to obtain good yields or get growth of M. bovis, Sauton base had to be used. Propionic acid did not support growth in these experiments (Table S12). Like the yeast extract and Tween 80 in the PM plate wells, Sauton base contains additional carbon and nitrogen sources that appear to stimulate growth, though they did not allow growth on their own in the period of the experiments reported in Table S12.
Our PM data suggested differential growth might be obtained with Tween 20. In fact, Tween 20, like Tween 40 and Tween 80 supported growth of all strains tested (Table S12). However, the H37Rv growth was highly flocculent, while M. bovis strains gave more dispersed growth. This difference may be related to the lack of dye reduction with Tween 20 (PM1, C5) by H37Rv, in contrast to M. bovis strains which reduced dye in the C5 well (Figure 3).
Effect of osmotic conditions and pH on growth in rich medium- PM9 and 10 plates
M. bovis strains and M. tuberculosis Tb12 were clearly shown to be more salt-tolerant than M. tuberculosis H37Rv and Bj5208 (Figure 6). Similar effects were seen with NaCl (Figure 6), KCl (PM9, wells D1 to D4) and sodium formate (PM9, wells E1 to E6) (Table S4, wells are along top row). Statistical analysis shows the above-mentioned differences were significant- this is compelling as P<0.05 at a range of concentrations for each agent (Table S4). There was no obvious differential effect of pH: the optimum pH of 6 or 7 and the shape of the relative dye reduction vs. pH plot were similar for all strains (Figure S7), though dye reduction values varied between strains.
Mean ± SEM relative dye reduction values for 2 to 4 experiments are shown for each strain. Incubations were in the wells of PM9 plates.
PM9 plates also screen for osmolytes by including a range of compounds in wells with 6% NaCl. Only glycerol restored dye reduction statistically significantly, and then in only M. bovis AF2122/97 and M. bovis 61/1307/01 (Figure 7). Osmolytes restore activity and enable salt tolerance. However, in very few wells was even one-third of the relative dye activity restored compared with controls without NaCl (well G1). Note, although there is no “0% NaCl” well in the plate, dye reduction in the presence of 1% NaCl (well A1) is not notably different from in the control well (Figure 6). The effects of all osmolytes tested are shown in Table S13. Glutathione appeared to have an effect but this was probably due to abiotic dye reduction (Text S2).
Mean ± SEM relative dye reduction values for 2 to 4 experiments are shown for each strain for a range of candidate osmolytes. The relative dye reduction with no NaCl was always 1.0 or very close to 1.0 (0.98 to 1.02: actual values are for PM9, G1; given in Table S1).
PM10 plates also screen for amines that act as protectants against acidic and alkaline (pH 4.5 and pH 9.5) conditions. At pH 4.5, isoleucine (well B10) fully restored dye reduction in all M. bovis strains and leucine (well B11) fully restored dye reduction in all the bacteria studied (Figure 8). Anthranillic acid (well D1) and L-norleucine (well D2) also restored dye activity to some extent in all the bacteria studied (Figure 8). The effects at pH 9.5 were less clear cut- some kinetic curves fell with time, for others such as when cadaverine (well G5) was added, all the stimulation of dye reduction occurred in the initial ∼6 h (figures S1, S2, S3, S4, S5). Those data had to be rejected but L- tryptophan (well F6) restored dye reduction in all strains, L-tyrosine had a similar effect (well F7) while L-valine (well F8) restored dye reduction in M. bovis types 9 and 35 and in M. tuberculosis Tb12 (Figure 9). Interpretation of the statistical significance of the differential effects of amines on strains is complicated by the relative dye reduction values being due to both the effect of pH and of the amine but clearly significant differences (P<0.021) in the above mentioned wells in PM10 plates, between M. tuberculosis H37Rv and M. bovis were obtained with norleucine (D2 well) and L-valine (F8 well). In contrast, for well F6, P>0.23 in pairwise comparisons between strains, consistent with L-tryptophan being equally effective for all strains (Table S14).
Mean ± SEM relative dye reduction values for 2 to 4 experiments are shown for each strain for a range of amines. The bars in green show relative dye reduction values at pH 7 to enable interpretation of the degree of restoration of dye reduction in wells in PM10 plates with the amines at pH 4.5. The basal dye reduction, in wells at pH 4.5 with no addition, is shown in orange.
Mean ± SEM relative dye reduction values for 2 to 4 experiments are shown for each strain for a range of amines. The bars in green show relative dye reduction values at pH 7 to enable interpretation of the degree of restoration of dye reduction in wells in PM10 plates with the amines at pH 9.5. The basal dye reduction, in wells at pH 9.5 with no addition, is shown in violet.
Rapid, high throughput methods for diagnosis and phenotypic analysis of slow growing, pathogenic mycobacteria are highly desirable, for two reasons in particular. The first is the slow growth of these bacteria and consequent long time to culture using traditional diagnostic methods. More intriguingly, genetic diversity is revealed by molecular typing of the M. tuberculosis complex but it is barely understood if there are corresponding phenotypic differences. Such methods have been hitherto elusive, but we have achieved proof of principle that a Phenotype MicroArray (PM) method, developed by Biolog, gives signals and differentiates strains of the M. tuberculosis complex.
Slow-growing mycobacteria give dye reduction signals in PM
Overall, 71 of 390 wells in the array gave dye reduction- the signal- in at least one of the strains of the M. tuberculosis complex that we tested. The highest signals were 130–140 Omnilog dye reduction units- for glycerol, monomethyl-succinate and butyric acid. Glycerol only supported this level of dye reduction with M. tuberculosis, not M. bovis, in agreement with it not supporting growth of M. bovis in culture medium . Well-known substrates used in culture media generally gave good dye reduction (Figure 3), including Tween 80 and pyruvate as carbon sources. The best nitrogen source across all strains was L-glutamatic acid, notably this is the main nitrogen source in the classic Middlebrook media which are optimal for the culture of the entire M. tuberculosis complex.
Generally, fewer wells in the PM3B plate to test nitrogen sources gave dye reduction than expected. For instance, ammonia and aspartic acid can be used in culture media  but they gave no, or trace dye reduction depending upon the strain. It may be that they would give better dye reduction if they were used in the pre-culture to prepare the inocula for the PM plates. Amino acids that are known to be taken up but not used as sole nitrogen sources did not give dye reduction either. These included (PM3B plate wells given in brackets) histidine (B3), isoleucine (B4), leucine (B5), lysine (B6), methionine (B7), proline (B9), tryptophan (B12) and valine (C2), for which auxotrophs have been constructed , , , . Interestingly, evidence for the uptake and utilisation of leucine, tryptophan and valine was obtained in PM10 plates as these amino acids ameliorated the inhibitory effect of acid and alkaline conditions on dye reduction.
Of the 71 positive wells, 28 gave <10 Omnilog units in any strain, essentially trace dye reduction. This could be due to respiration without growth, but it is notable that N-acetyl D-glucosamine, which gave 6 Omnilog units or below in all but one strain, supported growth when it was tried as a carbon source in culture media.
Some substrates were used in some, but not all, of the biological replicates. These are indicated by high standard error values in Table S6. This finding was similar to the discovery of “low confidence” substrates, defined as giving dye reduction in 3 to 5 out of 8 replicates, during a genome-scale reconstruction of Bacillus subtilis based on PM data, . These represent substrates that the bacteria can use, but are clearly not always used in apparently subtly different experimental conditions.
A way of increasing the number of wells giving dye reduction for mycobacteria may be to have more wells with lipids and fatty acids, given that they are preferred carbon source for mycobacteria , . In this work the Tweens, fatty acid esters of sorbitan, gave good dye reduction. In early work, leading up to the development of BACTEC, mycobacterial species were distinguished by using a range of 14C -labelled fatty acids and 14C -labelled amino acids , ,  and monitoring 14CO2 evolution. Given that the 14CO2 evolution was related to respiration, this suggests that similar substrates might permit dye reduction, also a correlate of respiration, in PM plates. Further development with lipid substrates is a realistic prospect as there is a lipid plate currently in development (B. Bochner, personal communication).
Using PM to show phenotypic differences between strains
As well as detecting metabolism, PM also distinguished between strains' use of substrates. Using a simple t-test of statistical significance, and for substrates where P<0.05 applying a cut-off of at least a 5-fold difference in dye reduction, pairwise comparisons revealed that 12 substrates differentiated from species level between M. bovis and M. tuberculosis and even to 3 between strain level within one spoligotype of M. bovis, where up to 3 substrates were discriminatory. The diagnostic potential of PM technology was further illustrated by cluster analysis of the data, which gave compelling clusters for M. bovis and M. tuberculosis. M. tuberculosis appeared to separate into two clusters- one for the Beijing strain and one for all other strains. This cluster analysis essentially gives a visual representation of the similarities between a set of samples, and is an exploratory data analysis tool. Although this analysis was based on substrate utilisation it was comparable with clustering based on principal component analysis of metabolic products (‘fingerprints’) , though the fingerprint analysis better separated M. bovis spoligotypes.
Agreement of PM data with prior knowledge and unexpected findings
Many of the differences between M. bovis and M. tuberculosis were expected and corresponded with known genetic differences. For instance, lesions in alanine dehydrogenase and pyruvate kinase  that prevent M. bovis from using alanine as a sole nitrogen or carbon source, or glycerol as a sole carbon source were reflected in PM data with M. tuberculosis but not M. bovis, giving sustained dye reduction (Figure 3). For nitrogen sources, glutamine and asparagine gave very good dye reduction with M. tuberculosis, but were considerably lower with M. bovis strains (Figure 4). This apparent loss of metabolic capability may reflect the loss of genetic material as M. bovis strains have descended from a progenitor close to M. tuberculosis by reductive evolution .
Though much of the PM data agreed with previous knowledge, there were some apparent discrepancies. Some could be due to differences in methodology, for example PM additives are not the same as culture medium supplements. We argue in the results section that glycolytic intermediates may stimulate utilisation of PM additives and show this to be the case with Tween 80 when we tested it in an experiment, measuring growth yield instead of dye reduction. Independently, tracer experiments with labelled glucose and acetate showed simultaneous use of these substrates even in M. tuberculosis, which is able to use glucose as a sole carbon source for growth . These experiments raise fundamental issues in questioning how, if at all, feedback repression occurs in slow-growing mycobacteria.
Low dye reduction with glucose by M. tuberculosis H37Rv may seem surprising given that glucose is a constituent of pre-culture medium in which we grew the inocula for PM plates. However, pre-culture medium was supplemented with pyruvate and Tween 80. We found H37Rv from the preculture inoculated into Roisin medium with glucose as the sole carbon source took 3 weeks to start growing, while H37Rv grew with a lag phase of a few days in standard Roisin medium including glycerol and Tween 80 (unpublished data). Thus, both Roisins and PM data may reflect the limited sugar transporters in M. tuberculosis  and tight regulation of glucose metabolism . It was puzzling that the Beijing strain used in this study did not give dye reduction with glycerol. This could be due to the toxic methylglyoxal building up from glycerol in this strain , . It is also possible that genetic lesions may develop in widely used strains. One of the H37Rv isolates (Rvv) we obtained gave no dye reduction with L-alanine, amongst some other nitrogen sources (Table S3). The natural null mutation of the gene for alanine dehydrogenase  in M. bovis gave a similar result in PM so, although we did not characterise the gene in Rvv, we speculate a similar lesion may have happened in Rvv. This shows the potential of PM technology to analyse and characterise mutants.
New ideas and future questions
Essentially, PM is a scanning technology, generating hypotheses to be followed up. We proved this principle by showing the suitability of some new carbon sources for growth that were suggested by their permitting dye reduction in PM plate wells. This is encouraging for following up intriguing findings on metabolism revealed by PM in this work, for instance the better use of short-chain fatty acids by the Beijing strain than the H37Rv strain of M. tuberculosis as well as between spoligotype 35 and spoligotype 17 of M. bovis.
Further new ideas were generated from the environmental PM9 and PM10 plates. Though they did not characterize strains, they divided the M. tuberculosis complex into two groups based on their salt-tolerance in some strains. Interestingly, a classical osmolyte- betaine  had no effect on salt-tolerance though glycerol ,  and possibly trehalose did give some salt tolerance. Similarly, γ- aminobutyrate, classically involved in acid resistance in enteric bacteria ,  had no effect in the M. tuberculosis complex. Instead some hydrophobic amino acids gave full protection against the effects of incubation at pH 4.5. Thus far, data suggest phosphoinsoitol- based signalling systems  and induction of membrane proteins in acid and salt stress  but this is the first suggestion that osmoadaptation or pH tolerance through amines occur in these mycobacteria  and suggest distinctive mechanisms and agents might be involved. The few leucine decarboxylases found in nature have a wide substrate specificity ,  so could provide a mechanism for the effect of this range of hydrophobic amino acids. This enzyme has not been annotated in the M. tuberculosis genome but there are several un-annotated proteins with pyridoxal phosphate predicted binding sites that could be candidates .
Although we describe the method we present here as a working method, we have established procedures that will have to be incorporated into any PM protocol. These include the use of liquid preculture rather than harvesting colonies from solid medium and the starvation of bacteria for 24 h, which was needed to minimise background well dye reduction (Text S1). However, the PM technology readily permits adaptation and modification. One change that could be investigated in future could be whether the Tween 80 added at suboptimal level to stimulate metabolism in PM wells should be replaced by a non-metabolizable detergent. This would take the methodology closer to revealing sole carbon sources and should avoid the “false positives” where hexoses gave high reduction by M. bovis, which lacks the final enzyme in the glycolytic pathway. It is important to emphasise that although the substrate in each well is needed for dye reduction, there are other additives in each well. Thus, to test for use of a substrate truly as a sole carbon source, dye reduction in buffer, or growth in a minimal medium such as our modified Roisin's medium without Tween 80 ( a carbon source for mycobacteria) would have to be done.
Potentially, the incubations could be made shorter by increasing the inoculum. Indeed a high inoculum might enable dye reduction to be read without growth, extending the method to the uncultivable species Mycobacterium leprae . Indeed, PM has already been used to analyse metabolism of the Coxiella burnetti without growth  in work that led to its axenic cultivation for the first time. However, we found it useful in this study to view kinetic curves (figures S1, S2, S3, S4, S5) to recognise readily increase in dye reduction related to growth. One major point that arose from inspecting kinetic curves was that dye reduction sustained through from 48 h to 165 h best gave data that matched the properties of the mycobacteria in this study- their growth rate, strain differences and known metabolism. In some curves, rapid early dye reduction was abiotic or evidently due to contamination. A consequence of this point is that if PM plates were to be used without a Biolog OmniLog incubator, dye intensity should be read at 0, 48 and 165 h and positives only recorded where the 165 h reading is >48 h reading. Readings without a Biolog OmniLog incubator would be better done as pixels than as OD values since the bacterial suspension contributes to the OD value as well as the dye.
In conclusion, this publication should encourage and stimulate attempts to tailor PMs to address specific questions and develop robust methodologies for the use of phenotype arrays with this difficult, but hugely important group of bacteria.
Kinetic curves for all PM plates with Mycobacterium tuberculosis H37Rv and Bj5208 strains.
Kinetic curves for all PM plates with M. tuberculosis H37Rv from two separate laboratories.
Kinetic curves for all PM plates with Mycobacterium bovis Type 9 strains.
Kinetic curves for all PM plates with M. bovis Type 17 strains.
Kinetic curves for all PM plates with M. bovis Type 35 strains. Figures S1 to S5 were generated in SAS using a GPLOT procedure, as described in the methods. Each figure is a Zip file containing plots of Omnilog units (due to dye reduction) against time (0 to 168 h) for all wells of each of the six 96 well plates. Each well is identified by (plate, well) and a list of the contents of wells is in Supplementary Table S1.
Clustering of strains from PM1 to PM4 data, in 2 dimensions. An aspect of the 3D clustering is presented in main paper and the key is in Table 1
pH optima of strains. Mean ± SEM relative dye reduction values for 2 to 4 experiments are shown for each strain.
Method development for preparing suspensions of the M. tuberculosis complex to inoculate PM plates
List of all the conditions/substrates in PM wells for plates PM1 to PM10.
Preparation and concentration of PM additives for PM plates used in this study.
Means, SD and SEM and t-tests and ratios for dye reduction data from plates PM1 to PM4. Pairwise t-tests were done for all 384 wells and the actual P values are given in this spreadsheet. The data used in the tests are Omnilog units (dye reduction). Notes and colour coding are explained on the spreadsheet.
Differences between strains deduced from data from PM9 and PM10 wells. Pairwise t-tests were done for all 192 wells. The data used in the tests are relative dye reduction values (defined in full in the methods section). As they are relative to (PM9, G1) the relative dye reduction value for that well is, perforce, always 1 or very close to 1. t-Tests performed are described in the first column and highlighted in yellow and the P values are along the row, corresponding to each well. Where P<0.05, the result is highlighted in red where the ratios of mean relative dye reduction values between the strains are >1.5; where they are <1.5 so the difference is slight, although statistically significant, they are highlighted in pink. Where there is almost no difference between the mean relative dye reduction values or when there is a negative value, yet the difference statistically significant, they are highlighted in pink with the P value in white .The ratios of mean relative dye reduction values are in rows highlighted in blue.
Plates PM1 to PM4: Sustained dye reduction, from 48 h reading to end (165 h). There is one row for every well in the PM1 to PM4 plates including means and SDs for strains coded (in Table 1): Rvp, Bj, 9b,9a,17c and 35a along with all the pairwise t-tests summarised in Tables S7 to S11 that gave P<0.05.
Plates PM1 to PM4: Dye reduction, from 0 h reading to end (165 h). There is one row for every well in the PM1 to PM4 plates including means and SDs for strains coded (in Table 1): Rvp, Bj, 9b,9a,17c and 35a
Plates PM1 to PM4: Wells with significantly different dye reduction between M .tuberculosis H37Rv and M. bovis. Data for wells for which P<0.05, there are at least 2-fold differences, and at least one strain has a mean value of at least 3 Omnilog units are summarised here.
Plates PM1 to PM4: Wells with significantly different dye reduction between M .tuberculosis H37Rv and a Beijing strain. Data for wells for which P<0.05, there are at least 2-fold differences, and at least one strain has a mean value of at least 3 Omnilog units are summarised here.
Plate PM1 to PM4: Wells with significantly different dye reduction between M .bovis spoligotypes. Data for wells for which P<0.05, there are at least 2-fold differences, and at least one strain has a mean value of at least 3 Omnilog units are summarised here.
Plates PM1 to PM4: Wells with significantly different dye reduction within M .bovis spoligotypes. Data for wells for which P<0.05, there are at least 2-fold differences, and at least one strain has a mean value of at least 3 Omnilog units are summarised here.
Investigation of substrates that gave dye reduction in PM plates as growth substrates in culture medium.
Effect of osmolytes using t-tests to show those having a significant effect at 6% NaCl concentration. Pairwise t-tests were performed for the 23 wells in plate PM9 with additions to wells with 6% NaCl. Colour coding (explained in the spreadsheet notes) is used to show the degree of restoration of relative dye reduction where P<0.05: the key is at the foot of the spreadsheet.
Effect of amines using t-tests to show those having a significant effect at pH 4.5 and pH 9.5. Pairwise t-tests were performed for the 70 wells in plate PM10 with additions to wells at pH 4.5 and pH 9.5. Colour coding (explained in the spreadsheet notes) is used to show the degree of restoration of relative dye reduction where P<0.05: the key is at the foot of the spreadsheet.
Whelan, A., Coad, M., Jahans, K. and Vordermeier, M. for encouraging Bhagwati Khatri and allowing her the time and laboratory space to do her MSc by research.
Hewinson, R.G. for encouragement to participate in the Seeedcorn programme and Biolog work in particular
Barry Bochner, the Biolog CEO, for following the work with interest, helpful advice, and encouraging publication.
Khatri, B., Jones, G., Newell, W., Abu-Oun, M. and Wheeler, P.R (corresponding author) are British Civil Servants and as such Crown Copyright applies to all their work.
Conceived and designed the experiments: PRW BK MF. Performed the experiments: BK PRW. Analyzed the data: GJ WN MA-O PRW. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: PRW MF. Wrote the paper: PRW BK WN.
- 1. Garnier T, Eiglmeier K, Camus JC, Medina N, Mansoor H, et al. (2003) The complete genome sequence of Mycobacterium bovis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 100: 7877–7882.
- 2. Glynn JR, Whiteley J, Bifani PJ, Kremer K, van Soolingen D (2002) Worldwide occurrence of Beijing/W strains of Mycobacterium tuberculosis: a systematic review. Emerg Infect Dis 8: 843–849.
- 3. Gagneux S, DeRiemer K, Van T, Kato-Maeda M, de Jong BC, et al. (2006) Variable host-pathogen compatibility in Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103: 2869–2873.
- 4. Smith NH, Dale J, Inwald J, Palmer S, Gordon SV, et al. (2003) The population structure of Mycobacterium bovis in Great Britain: clonal expansion. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 100: 15271–15275.
- 5. Winder CL, Gordon SV, Dale J, Hewinson RG, Goodacre R (2006) Metabolic fingerprints of Mycobacterium bovis cluster with molecular type: implications for genotype-phenotype links. Microbiology 152: 2757–2765.
- 6. Reed MB, Domenech P, Manca C, Su H, Barczak AK, et al. (2004) A glycolipid of hypervirulent tuberculosis strains that inhibits the innate immune response. Nature 431: 84–87.
- 7. Sinsimer D, Huet G, Manca C, Tsenova L, Koo MS, et al. (2008) The phenolic glycolipid of Mycobacterium tuberculosis differentially modulates the early host cytokine response but does not in itself confer hypervirulence. Infect Immun 76: 3027–3036.
- 8. Reed MB, Gagneux S, Deriemer K, Small PM, Barry CE 3rd (2007) The W-Beijing lineage of Mycobacterium tuberculosis overproduces triglycerides and has the DosR dormancy regulon constitutively upregulated. J Bacteriol 189: 2583–2589.
- 9. Wheeler PR, Brosch R, Coldham NG, Inwald JK, Hewinson RG, et al. (2008) Functional analysis of a clonal deletion in an epidemic strain of Mycobacterium bovis reveals a role in lipid metabolism. Microbiology 154: 3731–3742.
- 10. Bochner BR, Gadzinski P, Panomitros E (2001) Phenotype microarrays for high-throughput phenotypic testing and assay of gene function. Genome Res 11: 1246–1255.
- 11. Kairo SK, Bedwell J, Tyler PC, Carter A, Corbel MJ (1999) Development of a tetrazolium salt assay for rapid determination of viability of BCG vaccines. Vaccine 17: 2423–2428.
- 12. Abate G, Mshana RN, Miorner H (1998) Evaluation of a colorimetric assay based on 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyl tetrazolium bromide (MTT) for rapid detection of rifampicin resistance in Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2: 1011–1016.
- 13. Beste DJ, Peters J, Hooper T, Avignone-Rossa C, Bushell ME, et al. (2005) Compiling a molecular inventory for Mycobacterium bovis BCG at two growth rates: evidence for growth rate-mediated regulation of ribosome biosynthesis and lipid metabolism. J Bacteriol 187: 1677–1684.
- 14. Cole ST, Brosch R, Parkhill J, Garnier T, Churcher C, et al. (1998) Deciphering the biology of Mycobacterium tuberculosis from the complete genome sequence [see comments] [published erratum appears in Nature 1998 Nov 12;396(6707):190]. Nature 393: 537–544.
- 15. Keating LA, Wheeler PR, Mansoor H, Inwald JK, Dale J, et al. (2005) The pyruvate requirement of some members of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex is due to an inactive pyruvate kinase: implications for in vivo growth. Mol Microbiol 56: 163–174.
- 16. Ratledge C (1982) Nutrition, growth and metabolism. In: Ratledge C, Stanford J, editors. The Biology of the Mycobacteria. London: Academic Press. pp. 186–272.
- 17. Hondalus MK, Bardarov S, Russell R, Chan J, Jacobs WR Jr, et al. (2000) Attenuation of and protection induced by a leucine auxotroph of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Infect Immun 68: 2888–2898.
- 18. Parish T, Gordhan BG, McAdam RA, Duncan K, Mizrahi V, et al. (1999) Production of mutants in amino acid biosynthesis genes of Mycobacterium tuberculosis by homologous recombination. Microbiology 145 (Pt 12): 3497–3503.
- 19. Smith DA, Parish T, Stoker NG, Bancroft GJ (2001) Characterization of auxotrophic mutants of Mycobacterium tuberculosis and their potential as vaccine candidates. Infect Immun 69: 1142–1150.
- 20. Lee S, Jeon BY, Bardarov S, Chen M, Morris SL, et al. (2006) Protection elicited by two glutamine auxotrophs of Mycobacterium tuberculosis and in vivo growth phenotypes of the four unique glutamine synthetase mutants in a murine model. Infect Immun 74: 6491–6495.
- 21. Oh YK, Palsson BO, Park SM, Schilling CH, Mahadevan R (2007) Genome-scale reconstruction of metabolic network in Bacillus subtilis based on high-throughput phenotyping and gene essentiality data. J Biol Chem 282: 28791–28799.
- 22. Wheeler PR, Blanchard JS (2005) General metabolism and Biochemical pathways of tubercle bacilli. In: Cole ST, Eisenach KD, McMurray DN, Jacobs WR, Jr., editors. Tuberculosis and the tubercle bacillus. Washington DC: ASM Press. pp. 309–339.
- 23. Munoz-Elias EJ, Upton AM, Cherian J, McKinney JD (2006) Role of the methylcitrate cycle in Mycobacterium tuberculosis metabolism, intracellular growth, and virulence. Mol Microbiol 60: 1109–1122.
- 24. Siddiqi SH, Hwangbo CC, Silcox V, Good RC, Snider DE Jr, et al. (1984) Rapid radiometric methods to detect and differentiate Mycobacterium tuberculosis/M. bovis from other mycobacterial species. Am Rev Respir Dis 130: 634–640.
- 25. Camargo EE, Wagner HN Jr (1987) Radiometric studies on the oxidation of [1-14C]fatty acids and [U-14C]L-amino acids by mycobacteria. Int J Rad Appl Instrum B 14: 43–49.
- 26. Camargo EE, Kertcher JA, Larson SM, Tepper BS, Wagner HN Jr (1982) Radiometric measurement of differential metabolism of fatty acid by mycobacteria. Int J Lepr Other Mycobact Dis 50: 200–204.
- 27. Brosch R, Gordon SV, Marmiesse M, Brodin P, Buchrieser C, et al. (2002) A new evolutionary scenario for the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 99: 3684–3689.
- 28. de Carvalho LP, Fischer SM, Marrero J, Nathan C, Ehrt S, et al. (2010) Metabolomics of Mycobacterium tuberculosis reveals compartmentalized co-catabolism of carbon substrates. Chem Biol 17: 1122–1131.
- 29. Titgemeyer F, Amon J, Parche S, Mahfoud M, Bail J, et al. (2007) A genomic view of sugar transport in Mycobacterium smegmatis and Mycobacterium tuberculosis. J Bacteriol 189: 5903–5915.
- 30. Deol P, Vohra R, Saini AK, Singh A, Chandra H, et al. (2005) Role of Mycobacterium tuberculosis Ser/Thr kinase PknF: implications in glucose transport and cell division. J Bacteriol 187: 3415–3420.
- 31. Berney M, Weimar MR, Heikal A, Cook GM (2012) Regulation of proline metabolism in mycobacteria and its role in carbon metabolism under hypoxia. Mol Microbiol 84: 664–681.
- 32. Pethe K, Sequeira PC, Agarwalla S, Rhee K, Kuhen K, et al. (2010) A chemical genetic screen in Mycobacterium tuberculosis identifies carbon-source-dependent growth inhibitors devoid of in vivo efficacy. Nat Commun 1: 57.
- 33. Sleator RD, Hill C (2002) Bacterial osmoadaptation: the role of osmolytes in bacterial stress and virulence. FEMS Microbiol Rev 26: 49–71.
- 34. Blomberg A (2000) Metabolic surprises in Saccharomyces cerevisiae during adaptation to saline conditions: questions, some answers and a model. FEMS Microbiol Lett 182: 1–8.
- 35. Richard HT, Foster JW (2003) Acid resistance in Escherichia coli. Adv Appl Microbiol 52: 167–186.
- 36. Morita YS, Yamaryo-Botte Y, Miyanagi K, Callaghan JM, Patterson JH, et al. (2010) Stress-induced synthesis of phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate in mycobacteria. J Biol Chem 285: 16643–16650.
- 37. Vandal OH, Nathan CF, Ehrt S (2009) Acid resistance in Mycobacterium tuberculosis. J Bacteriol 191: 4714–4721.
- 38. Hartmann T (1972) Leucin-carboxylase aus marinen Rhodophyceae: Vorkommen, Verbreitung und einige Eigenschaften. Phytochemistry 11: 1327–1336.
- 39. Sutton CR, King HK (1962) Inhibition of leucine decarboxylase by thiol-binding reagents. Arch Biochem Biophys 96: 360–370.
- 40. Cole ST, Eiglmeier K, Parkhill J, James KD, Thomson NR, et al. (2001) Massive gene decay in the leprosy bacillus. Nature 409: 1007–1011.
- 41. Omsland A, Cockrell DC, Howe D, Fischer ER, Virtaneva K, et al. (2009) Host cell-free growth of the Q fever bacterium Coxiella burnetii. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 106: 4430–4434.
- 42. Banu S, Gordon SV, Palmer S, Islam MR, Ahmed S, et al. (2004) Genotypic analysis of Mycobacterium tuberculosis in Bangladesh and prevalence of the Beijing strain. J Clin Microbiol 42: 674–682.
- 43. Martinez-Gamboa A, Ponce-de-Leon A, Galindo-Fraga A, Bobadilla-del-Valle M, Kato-Maeda M, et al. (2008) Molecular analysis of Mycobacterium tuberculosis strains with an intact pks15/1 gene in a rural community of Mexico. Arch Med Res 39: 809–814.